Latest / MBA Training Marketing / Diversifying paid acquisition beyond Google and Meta: a practical playbook
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome to the Leaders Insights Podcast.
- 0:08Today's episode, Diversifying Paid Acquisition Beyond Google and Meta, a practical playbook.
- 0:14Everyone says diversify your ad spend, then puts 90% back into Google and Meta anyway.
- 0:19So let me be blunt.
- 0:21Is channel diversification just a thing marketers talk about to sound sophisticated?
- 0:25Mostly, yes.
- 0:27It's the marketing equivalent of saying you'll start running in January.
- 0:31The intent is real.
- 0:32The follow through is a rounding error.
- 0:34Then why should anyone bother if the two giants still deliver?
- 0:38Because deliver is doing a lot of lifting.
- 0:40When one auction sets your entire cost per acquisition, the price you pay to land one paying customer,
- 0:47you don't have a strategy, you have a landlord.
- 0:49And that landlord raised rent again.
- 0:52Meta's average costs climbed roughly 10% year over year through 2025, per their own reporting,
- 0:58which is not exactly a neutral source.
- 1:00Fine, but concentration is efficient.
- 1:03Isn't spreading budget across 10 channels just a slower way to waste money?
- 1:07That's the mistake everyone makes.
- 1:09What?
- 1:12They think diversification means dilution.
- 1:15It doesn't.
- 1:16You don't move 30% of budget on day one.
- 1:19You carve out a test cell, 5% to 10% of spend, ring-fenced so it can't touch your baseline performance.
- 1:26You're buying information, not chasing volume.
- 1:29Buying information sounds like the thing people say right before they lose a quarter.
- 1:33Only if you can't read the meter.
- 1:35Here's the discipline.
- 1:37Every new channel gets a fixed test budget.
- 1:39A fixed window, say six weeks.
- 1:42And one question.
- 1:44Can it hit within 130% of your blended acquisition cost at meaningful volume?
- 1:49If not, you kill it.
- 1:51No sentiment, no.
- 1:53Let's give it another month.
- 1:55Give me a channel that actually cleared that bar.
- 1:57Names.
- 1:58Reddit.
- 1:59Everyone treated it as a joke until around 2024, then a wave of direct-to-consumer brands
- 2:05found intent there that Meta had priced out of reach.
- 2:08Ramp.
- 2:09The corporate card company has talked openly about pushing beyond the duopoly into places
- 2:15like Reddit and podcasts because the incremental customer was simply cheaper.
- 2:20TikTok, obviously.
- 2:22Though the U.S. ownership drama has made planners nervous, and rightly so.
- 2:26So the answer is just go where it's cheap?
- 2:28No.
- 2:29Go where your customer's attention is underpriced relative to their intent.
- 2:34Those are different things.
- 2:36Retail media is the sharpest example.
- 2:38Amazon, Instacart, even Uber's ad business.
- 2:43You're catching people with a wallet already open.
- 2:46Amazon's ad revenue ran north of $50 billion in 2024.
- 2:51And that's not vanity spend.
- 2:53That's performance marketers voting with budget.
- 2:55Here's the uncomfortable one.
- 2:57Most of these channels can't measure themselves properly.
- 3:00How do you defend spend you can't cleanly attribute?
- 3:03You stop pretending Google and Meta measure themselves cleanly either.
- 3:07They mark their own homework and grade generously.
- 3:11The honest tool is a holdout test.
- 3:13You switch a channel off in one region, leave it on in another, and watch what actually
- 3:17happens to sales.
- 3:19Painful, slow, unglamorous, and the only thing that tells you the truth.
- 3:28Then they deserve the platform dependency they've got.
- 3:31Look.
- 3:32Finance Chief, who won't fund a $50,000 holdout test, is the same one who will happily sign
- 3:38an eight-figure check to a channel he's never once verified.
- 3:42That's not prudence.
- 3:43That's Stockholm Syndrome with a spreadsheet.
- 3:46What breaks most often when brands finally try this?
- 3:49Creative.
- 3:50They take the exact meta video, drop it into TikTok or a podcast read, and conclude
- 3:55the channel doesn't work.
- 3:57The channel works fine.
- 3:58Yunn, the ad is a tourist.
- 4:01Each surface needs native creative, which is a cost people forget to budget.
- 4:05So the test fails for a reason that has nothing to do with the channel.
- 4:09So the failure gets blamed on the wrong thing and diversification dies for the wrong reason.
- 4:14Every time.
- 4:15And then they crawl back to the duopoly and call it discipline.
- 4:18Give me the one thing a listener does Monday morning.
- 4:21Pull your last quarter's spend by channel.
- 4:24If any single platform is above 70% of paid budget, ring fence 5% this week for
- 4:29one test channel with a native ad and a six-week kill date.
- 4:33Not a strategy deck.
- 4:34A live experiment.
- 4:36That's the whole move.
- 4:38That's it.
- 4:39The CMO Decision Tools are live at MBA-training.com.