Latest / Office Hours with Fexingo: Daily Career Q&A, Workplace Questions, and Professional Advice / How to Ask for a Job Title Change Without a Promotion
Transcript
- Lucas: So here's a question that came in from a listener named Priya in Chicago, and I think it hits a nerve for a lot of people. Priya has been a marketing coordinator at her company for about three years. For the last year and a half, she's been doing the exact same work as the senior marketing coordinators on her team — managing campaigns, presenting to clients, mentoring newer hires — but her official title never changed. Luna: Right, so she's doing the senior job without the senior title. Classic scenario. Lucas: Exactly. And Priya's manager has told her that there's no budget for a promotion this year, no salary increase available. But she's wondering: can I at least get the title changed? Even if the money isn't there yet. Luna: That's a great question because a lot of people think title and money are locked together. But they're really two separate negotiations. Lucas: They are. And I think Priya is smart to separate them. Because if you wait for the budget to appear, you might be waiting forever. Meanwhile, your resume and LinkedIn still say 'coordinator' when you're functioning at a senior level. That hurts you if you want to leave. Luna: So what's the play here? How do you ask for a title change without making it sound like you're demanding a promotion? Lucas: The key is to frame it as an administrative correction. Not a reward. You want to say, 'Look, my responsibilities have evolved to match the senior role. The title is just out of sync with reality. Can we update it to reflect what I'm actually doing?' That's a much easier ask for a manager to say yes to, because it doesn't cost anything. Luna: And if the manager pushes back, saying HR policy requires a job level change or a compensation adjustment, then you've at least opened the conversation. Lucas: Right. And you can come back with a specific documented list of duties that match the senior job description. Priya should write down the key responsibilities from the company's own senior coordinator posting — or even better, from a coworker who has that title — and map her actual work to each bullet point. That makes it hard to argue. Luna: I love that. It turns it from a subjective request into an objective mismatch. 'Here's the job description for senior coordinator. Here's what I do. They're the same. Please fix the title.' Lucas: Exactly. And if the manager still says no, you've got a signal. Either the company has a rigid policy that won't bend, or they're not willing to advocate for you. Either way, you have useful information for your next career move. Luna: Speaking of useful information — if today's episode helped you think about your own title situation, honestly, if it was worth a coffee to you, there's a link. It's buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. That kind of listener support is what keeps this show ad-free and focused on real questions like Priya's. Lucas: Yeah, we really appreciate that. And it keeps us from having to do ad reads about mattress companies. So, back to Priya — one thing she should also consider is the timing. If her company is in a hiring freeze, or if her manager is swamped with year-end reviews, she might want to wait for a calmer moment. Luna: Good point. You don't want to catch someone when they're stressed about something else. The ask is more likely to land if you schedule a quick 15-minute meeting specifically about your role and responsibilities. Lucas: And write a short email in advance that previews the agenda. Something like, 'I'd like to discuss how my role has evolved and talk about aligning my title with my current duties.' That way, the manager isn't blindsided. Luna: So let's say Priya gets a yes. What happens next? Does HR just flip a switch? Lucas: Not always. Sometimes HR requires a formal job reclassification, which might involve a compensation review. But if the company has a policy that allows title changes without salary changes — some do, especially for roles like 'coordinator' to 'senior coordinator' — then it's just a system update. Priya should ask her manager to check with HR first before she goes through the full exercise. Luna: That's a smart pre-work step. Find out if it's even possible before you build your case. Lucas: Exactly. And if it turns out the company can't do a title change without a promotion, then Priya has a choice. She can accept that and decide whether to stay, or she can start looking externally where her experience will be valued at the senior level. The title might not matter to a future employer if she can describe her work convincingly, but it's definitely easier if the resume says 'senior'. Luna: And I think there's a psychological benefit too. Having the title you've earned changes how you see yourself. It's not just about external perception. Lucas: Totally. Priya has been doing the senior job for 18 months. She deserves the recognition. And asking for it — even if it's just a title — is a form of self-advocacy that builds confidence for bigger asks down the road. Luna: One last thing: if she does get the title change, she should update LinkedIn and her resume immediately. And she should also ask for a written confirmation or an updated offer letter, just in case the HR record doesn't get updated properly. Lucas: Great advice. And if she doesn't get it, she should ask for a timeline. 'Can we revisit this in six months?' That keeps the conversation alive and sets a clear expectation. Luna: Alright, so to summarize for Priya and anyone else in the same boat: separate title from money, frame it as an administrative correction, document your duties, and check HR policy first. Oh, and timing matters. Lucas: That's the playbook. And if you have your own career question you'd like us to tackle, send it to us. We read every one.