Latest / Surrounded / Gen Z and The American Dream | Surrounded Follow Up w/Maxwell Frost
Transcript
- 0:00Very worried
- 0:01that we're becoming an America where people owe
- 0:04more than they own.
- 0:05The American dream is just fundamentally so out of reach for so many people,
- 0:08we gotta do something about it.
- 0:09But
- 0:10why am I gonna trust you to do it?
- 0:12Number one,
- 0:12I gotta say,
- 0:13looking back at this,
- 0:14I'm glad that my curls are popping because I worked very hard on it that morning.
- 0:18So I just gotta say that's,
- 0:19that's the main thing.
- 0:20They looked great.
- 0:20They looked great.
- 0:21Thank you.
- 0:22The American dream.
- 0:22is supposed to be and what it was when they were
- 0:25our age was being able to succeed and get ahead.
- 0:29All right,
- 0:30well,
- 0:30hello,
- 0:30hello,
- 0:31Maxwell.
- 0:32How are you doing?
- 0:33Doing
- 0:33well,
- 0:34thank you.
- 0:34How are you doing?
- 0:35Good.
- 0:36It's good to see you again,
- 0:37you know,
- 0:37thank you for jumping into the circle to debate 20
- 0:40boomers and thank you for joining our surrounded podcast.
- 0:43Yeah,
- 0:43I know it was a lot of fun,
- 0:44honestly.
- 0:45It was a good time and I think,
- 0:46yeah,
- 0:47it was great.
- 0:48What made you interested in
- 0:49doing the show?
- 0:50Have you ever done anything like this before?
- 0:52Not really.
- 0:53I've,
- 0:54yeah,
- 0:54it was definitely a very unique experience,
- 0:56um,
- 0:57but
- 0:57it felt very familiar,
- 0:58you know,
- 0:59I'm,
- 0:59I'm a progressive Democrat who
- 1:01represents a district in the middle of Florida,
- 1:04right?
- 1:04I was born and raised in Florida.
- 1:06I spent a lot of time in
- 1:08Kind of non-traditional spaces.
- 1:10I spent a lot of time with people who have
- 1:12big disagree with big disagreements with me on issues,
- 1:14and so these kind of like
- 1:16debates were going back and forth,
- 1:17but in good faith,
- 1:18um,
- 1:19and trying to find common ground is just something I'm
- 1:21used to my whole life as a coalition builder,
- 1:23as an organizer.
- 1:23So,
- 1:24the format and the whole thing of it was like unique and new,
- 1:27but like the actual conversations
- 1:29were very familiar to me.
- 1:31Yeah,
- 1:31you kept your calm.
- 1:32I felt like no one seemed to get you rattled,
- 1:34so it was a really good debate.
- 1:36Yeah,
- 1:36it was a good time.
- 1:37I mean,
- 1:37I try,
- 1:38it takes a lot to get me rattled,
- 1:40especially working in Congress.
- 1:42I thought it was great and um
- 1:44for,
- 1:44you know,
- 1:44for the most part,
- 1:45I think everyone was there
- 1:46in good faith and just to have a good conversation and,
- 1:49you know,
- 1:49it was cool.
- 1:49I know at the end we were able to
- 1:50find some common ground on different like broad issues of
- 1:53Corruption and money out of politics and things like that,
- 1:56and I really truly believe that
- 1:58these are the sources of the biggest problems we have in our political system is that
- 2:02there are
- 2:03people who want to rig our democracy so they can rig our
- 2:05economy and it doesn't matter if you're a Republican or Democrat.
- 2:08Like if you're a working person,
- 2:10they are out for you and out for us,
- 2:11and I try
- 2:12to get people to really understand that as much as they can.
- 2:15Yeah,
- 2:16find some common ground.
- 2:17Well,
- 2:18I know you haven't seen the episode yet.
- 2:21So I,
- 2:21uh,
- 2:22I want to get into some of our clips from the,
- 2:25the show.
- 2:26Um,
- 2:27yeah,
- 2:27all right.
- 2:28So I want to start with one of your claims saying that
- 2:30Gen Z is the most politically active generation in American history.
- 2:35So I'm gonna play a clip from an interaction you had with Emilio.
- 2:38So I would say
- 2:40Gen Z,
- 2:41I,
- 2:41I want them to be more politically active.
- 2:44I think that's
- 2:45great the highest numbers young people have ever voted.
- 2:47Also
- 2:48have some humility.
- 2:50That's my main thing.
- 2:51Don't,
- 2:52don't be like the boomers
- 2:53and claim you're the best generation and then go out there and mess everything up,
- 2:57OK.
- 2:58Be the best generation.
- 2:59So a more politically active generation that comes to mind
- 3:02is the GI generation.
- 3:04That was my dad's generation.
- 3:06They went and fought World War II.
- 3:08They lived through the Depression.
- 3:10Another great generation
- 3:11is
- 3:12Alexander Hamilton's and Thomas Jefferson's.
- 3:15Look,
- 3:15look,
- 3:15mine,
- 3:16mine,
- 3:16mine isn't about saying that other generations
- 3:18weren't politically active or everyone else sucks.
- 3:21Like I don't believe that.
- 3:22I'm just saying that,
- 3:23you know,
- 3:24part of America is that we're always trying
- 3:25to do better than the last generation did.
- 3:27And for me it's exciting that the highest youth
- 3:30voter turnout we've ever had is very recent.
- 3:33Which means,
- 3:33of course,
- 3:34we always have work to do.
- 3:35And I've spent most of my professional career as an organizer
- 3:38fighting to get young people out to vote.
- 3:40I'm always thinking about how can we get young people out to
- 3:42vote and we have to do way better than we're doing now.
- 3:44All right.
- 3:46So,
- 3:47when you call Gen Z the most politically active generation,
- 3:50what's the metric?
- 3:52You know,
- 3:52how do you compare today's voting,
- 3:54protesting,
- 3:55and organizing to generations that fought wars or
- 3:58led movements like the Civil rights movement.
- 4:00It's really about looking at the totality of political engagement,
- 4:04right?
- 4:04So it's number one,
- 4:06Gen Z's had the highest youth voter turnout we've seen,
- 4:09right,
- 4:09in 2020,
- 4:10and then in 2018,
- 4:11and even these last election cycles.
- 4:13But it's the fact that we're looking beyond that as well.
- 4:15It's not just voting,
- 4:17it's also protesting,
- 4:18right?
- 4:18You see
- 4:19some of the largest social movements we've seen
- 4:21from young people like March for Our Lives,
- 4:22right,
- 4:23was the largest student-led demonstration
- 4:25in the history of our country that came from my
- 4:27State of Florida
- 4:28of a lot of young Gen Zers who after a shooting happened said we call BS,
- 4:32but
- 4:32it didn't end there,
- 4:33right?
- 4:33The shooting of Trayvon Martin happened before that
- 4:36and the movement that came after that,
- 4:37the Black Lives Matter uprising,
- 4:39the anti-war protests we see going on right now.
- 4:42And so it's,
- 4:43it's real,
- 4:43it's really interesting because in most generations we can usually identify
- 4:47one
- 4:48predominant
- 4:50social movement
- 4:51that you identify with that whole generation,
- 4:53right?
- 4:54Civil rights movement or this movement or that movement.
- 4:56But the interesting thing about Gen Z
- 4:58is we can identify multiple
- 5:00that have really taken over the country.
- 5:02And,
- 5:03um,
- 5:03and I think that alongside the highest youth voter turnout numbers,
- 5:07alongside us running for office at very uh
- 5:09high rates
- 5:10is why I say Gen Z is the most
- 5:12politically active young generation in the history of our country,
- 5:15which is exciting and like,
- 5:16and honestly,
- 5:17that's the way it's supposed to be.
- 5:19Like I said in that clip,
- 5:20like we want.
- 5:21The next generation to do better.
- 5:23So my hope is that Gen Alpha
- 5:24will blow us out of the water,
- 5:26have even better
- 5:27voting records,
- 5:28do even more to help move this country forward.
- 5:30And I think
- 5:31the more that young people are involved,
- 5:32the better.
- 5:33Now,
- 5:33the interesting thing,
- 5:34and I brought up this point somewhere in the debate,
- 5:36baby boomers are actually a lot
- 5:39like Gen Z and Gen Z is a lot like baby boomers during our youth and during,
- 5:42um,
- 5:43you know,
- 5:43our adolescence.
- 5:44The last generation to hit the kind of voting
- 5:46numbers we're hitting now or even get close,
- 5:48were the baby boomers.
- 5:50And so I think it just goes to show there's
- 5:52a lot of things that like bring our generations together.
- 5:55This fight and bickering on young people being lazy and this and that
- 5:58is just a trope
- 5:59that's very old.
- 6:00But what's very new is young people like
- 6:03being involved at the highest numbers we've seen,
- 6:05and that's really exciting to me.
- 6:07Well,
- 6:07do you think there's a fair criticism
- 6:10that,
- 6:10you know,
- 6:11Gen Z is more politically expressive,
- 6:13um,
- 6:14than politically effective?
- 6:15You know,
- 6:15they're very willing to protest and speak out online,
- 6:19but it's not always turning that energy into lasting political change.
- 6:23I disagree with that.
- 6:24Um,
- 6:24we see that young people have really been
- 6:26the margin that really mattered in many races.
- 6:28I mean,
- 6:29you look at the special elections in Georgia Senate
- 6:31that happened when two Democrats.
- 6:33Became US senators in the
- 6:35deep South in Georgia.
- 6:36When you look at that,
- 6:37it was really young voters were the group of voters that weren't expected to turn
- 6:41out that actually turned out and got both Jon Ossoff and Raphael Warnock elected.
- 6:46I mean,
- 6:46you look at my election,
- 6:47right?
- 6:47I'm the first Gen Z in Congress.
- 6:50I was elected right at 25 years old,
- 6:51right when we were old enough to run.
- 6:53We ran and been elected across the country.
- 6:55And to be honest,
- 6:56it's,
- 6:57it's kind of hard to answer the question too because
- 6:59We still need more time to go by and see how
- 7:01many more young people get elected and what impacts they have.
- 7:04I would argue
- 7:05that without the March for Our Lives movement,
- 7:07the Safer Communities Act that was passed,
- 7:09the first piece of gun violence legislation passed in nearly 30 years,
- 7:13wouldn't have been passed if it wasn't for that youth-led movement.
- 7:15Again,
- 7:16it's not just because of Gen Z that this stuff happened,
- 7:19cause it was signed into law by our oldest president,
- 7:21Joe Biden.
- 7:21So it just goes to show like it's a
- 7:23multi-generational fight.
- 7:25But like many times in history,
- 7:27oftentimes young people are the,
- 7:28the,
- 7:28the conscious of the country and kind of figuratively shake the country to say,
- 7:32hey,
- 7:32let's do something about this.
- 7:34And you might not see the impact the day after
- 7:37or the year after,
- 7:38but years down the road,
- 7:39you see that it starts a domino effect that,
- 7:42you know,
- 7:42creates a situation where the world has changed,
- 7:44where the country has changed.
- 7:45And so,
- 7:46is there more we need to do like that guy said in the clip,
- 7:49there's a lot more we need to do,
- 7:50and I agree.
- 7:51I'm not saying,
- 7:52yo,
- 7:52we're good,
- 7:52Gen Z is good,
- 7:53we have the best voting numbers,
- 7:54that's it.
- 7:55No,
- 7:55we have the highest youth voter turnout in the history of our country,
- 7:58but
- 7:58it still isn't great.
- 8:00Like we still need to get young people out to vote,
- 8:02but it's not
- 8:04because young people don't care about issues.
- 8:05There's a lot we need to do,
- 8:07including making voting more accessible for young people as well.
- 8:10So there's,
- 8:10there's a lot that's a part of this and
- 8:12I've
- 8:13really spent my life focusing on trying to get young people to get out and vote,
- 8:18um,
- 8:19and to,
- 8:19and to be a part of this and see that voting is,
- 8:22you know,
- 8:23how we can help,
- 8:24uh,
- 8:24decide who's gonna run our country,
- 8:26and I think that's,
- 8:26you know,
- 8:27an important thing.
- 8:27So there's a lot more work we need to do.
- 8:29We're nowhere near where we should be,
- 8:31but
- 8:32it gives me hope that
- 8:33we're making a difference and we're actually moving forward.
- 8:36Yeah,
- 8:37I like that you're not adding fuel to the the generational war,
- 8:40fire going on right now.
- 8:42There's a huge battle between generations and it really doesn't need to exist.
- 8:45You stressed that Gen Z should also have humility though,
- 8:49and not just say older generations screwed everything up and now we have to fix it.
- 8:53So,
- 8:54what do you think Gen Z gets wrong politically and
- 8:57what could they actually learn from boomers or older generations?
- 9:00There's so much to learn and the fact of
- 9:02the matter is previous generations had to fight.
- 9:05Um,
- 9:06huge battles
- 9:08with less,
- 9:09right?
- 9:10With,
- 9:10with a lot of less resources without social media.
- 9:14Um,
- 9:14and different tools that we have now,
- 9:17and I think there's so much to learn from their resiliency.
- 9:20Um,
- 9:20and from their organizing because we wouldn't be here without them.
- 9:23Like I wouldn't be a member of a congress right now if it wasn't for
- 9:26the civil rights movement,
- 9:27if it wasn't for
- 9:29the people who put their lives on the line
- 9:31for us to be where we're at right now.
- 9:32And so
- 9:33my claim is less about we're better than other people.
- 9:36It's actually
- 9:37kind of the,
- 9:38it's kind of the opposite,
- 9:39right?
- 9:39It's like
- 9:40we actually wouldn't be here without you and we're here because of you,
- 9:43and that's an exciting thing.
- 9:45And,
- 9:46and the,
- 9:46you know,
- 9:46the lesson for Gen Z is
- 9:48history has so much to teach us and those who
- 9:50are older than us and older generations have fought.
- 9:54Wars,
- 9:54uh,
- 9:55or not wars have fought like struggles,
- 9:57um,
- 9:57that
- 9:58have helped us
- 9:59get into the position we're in
- 10:01now.
- 10:02What we're trying to do is make sure that our country
- 10:04actually lives up to the promises that they fought for,
- 10:07um,
- 10:07and we know that there's many political forces
- 10:10and corporate forces that want us to go back
- 10:12and undo the work that they did.
- 10:13And what we're saying is
- 10:15we don't want to.
- 10:16Do the work that they did.
- 10:16And we also don't need to stifle our ability to,
- 10:18to move forward
- 10:20and do better and move that bar of excellence up and up and up,
- 10:22which is what America is all about.
- 10:24And so I think,
- 10:25you know,
- 10:25for Gen Zers who think
- 10:27older generations have nothing to offer us in
- 10:29terms of history or how we move forward,
- 10:31that's false,
- 10:31right?
- 10:32Like
- 10:32we all have a lot to learn together.
- 10:34It's a multi-generational movement that's gonna build the country that we want.
- 10:38Um,
- 10:39my,
- 10:40my claim is more that
- 10:41they were successful in helping us get to a good point.
- 10:43We're very politically active now.
- 10:44Let's do even better because we have a lot of work to do
- 10:47and there are unique challenges that didn't exist before that exist now,
- 10:50um,
- 10:51that we have to work on,
- 10:52and that's not to make anyone feel bad.
- 10:54It's just so we have,
- 10:55we're clear-eyed about where we're going and,
- 10:57and how we get there.
- 10:58As it should be.
- 10:59Once you know better,
- 11:00you do better.
- 11:00So,
- 11:01I just really think every generation wants to feel
- 11:04appreciated and that their contributions were understood.
- 11:07I think that's,
- 11:08that's a main issue.
- 11:09Well,
- 11:09I kind of want to pivot into our next clip
- 11:12from your claim that boomers lived the American dream.
- 11:15He can only
- 11:16read it because I think it ties into nicely to what we're talking about here.
- 11:19So I'm just gonna play that for you now.
- 11:21You're on Medicare,
- 11:22I assume.
- 11:22No,
- 11:23I have insurance.
- 11:24I have insurance.
- 11:25Is anyone here on Medicare?
- 11:26My mother was
- 11:28on
- 11:28your mother was on Medicare.
- 11:29Do you know when Medicare was proposed?
- 11:31Do you know the things that they said about it?
- 11:33Well,
- 11:34they said the government needs to get out of our way.
- 11:36We don't need this.
- 11:36It's a crazy radical thing and now it's a fact of life.
- 11:39Well,
- 11:39let's,
- 11:40let's,
- 11:40let's talk Social Security.
- 11:41Same thing with Social Security.
- 11:42They said
- 11:43Congress has been stealing it.
- 11:45The Congress has been stealing money radical thing and now it's
- 11:48supposed to be a savings account.
- 11:50It's gone
- 11:51because Congress and young people are worried that it might not even be there for us.
- 11:54Congress.
- 11:55That's why.
- 11:56That's why the American,
- 11:57that's why the American,
- 11:58that's who I claim.
- 11:59That's the heart of my claim.
- 12:00So go after the waste,
- 12:01fraud and abuse in the Congress that is stolen from the American.
- 12:05I agree there's a lot of we can agree there's a lot of waste,
- 12:07fraud,
- 12:07and abuse,
- 12:08absolutely,
- 12:08um,
- 12:09but it gets to the heart of my claim is that the American dream is just
- 12:12fundamentally so out of reach for so many people we gotta do something about it.
- 12:15But
- 12:16why am I gonna trust you to do it?
- 12:18I'm
- 12:19like,
- 12:19like I wanna work with you.
- 12:21I wanna see you succeed.
- 12:22I am very proud of you.
- 12:24At 25 years old,
- 12:25your family must be thrilled.
- 12:27I'm serious.
- 12:28It is such an accomplishment.
- 12:30But you know what?
- 12:32These kids can't go through
- 12:34my
- 12:35the time has run out.
- 12:37I do want to talk.
- 12:40All right,
- 12:40so you say the heart of your argument
- 12:43is that the American dream is becoming out of reach.
- 12:45So what specifically feels less attainable for Gen Z than it did for previous?
- 12:50generations.
- 12:50Number one,
- 12:51I gotta say,
- 12:52looking back at this,
- 12:53I'm glad that my curls are popping because I worked very hard on it that morning.
- 12:57So I just gotta say that's,
- 12:58that's the main thing.
- 12:59It looks great.
- 13:00Thank you.
- 13:01The second thing though is
- 13:03what I got from this,
- 13:04this
- 13:05kind of debate and this conversation.
- 13:07And,
- 13:08and beyond just her,
- 13:09everybody,
- 13:10is that
- 13:11people are changing
- 13:13what they believe the American dream is,
- 13:15and like the American dream is not
- 13:17having enough resources to get by.
- 13:20That's not what it is.
- 13:21The American dream is supposed to be,
- 13:23and what it was
- 13:24when they were our age,
- 13:26was
- 13:27being able to succeed and get ahead,
- 13:29to build wealth,
- 13:31right?
- 13:31To be able to do better than your parents did.
- 13:33That's the American,
- 13:34it's not like,
- 13:34oh,
- 13:34I have enough money,
- 13:35like I'm just getting by.
- 13:36Part of what I got from this conversation is
- 13:39we're number one,
- 13:40changing what the American dream is to fit the horrible economy that we're in.
- 13:45And that in and of itself proves my point is that
- 13:48when we live in a country where more and more people are unable to own a home,
- 13:52where rent is insanely high,
- 13:54where the cost of healthcare is insanely high,
- 13:57where people are choosing between medicine and food,
- 14:00where people have crushing student debt,
- 14:02where people are working
- 14:04as hard as they've ever worked,
- 14:05productivity in this country is high.
- 14:07The American people are producing and they're working.
- 14:09I brought up this statistic a bunch.
- 14:1157% of Gen Z has a side hustle
- 14:14or a second job.
- 14:15Is it because they want to have a second job?
- 14:17No,
- 14:17it's because they need more money to be able to pay their bills.
- 14:21And what's happening is
- 14:24Before,
- 14:24when they were our age,
- 14:25you would be able to work at a restaurant.
- 14:27You'd be able to work.
- 14:29Um,
- 14:29at a retail store or one job
- 14:32and be able to support your family and buy a home
- 14:35and
- 14:36save money
- 14:37and get ahead and build the life that you wanna build,
- 14:39which is great.
- 14:40I'm glad that
- 14:41a lot of them,
- 14:41not everybody,
- 14:42you know,
- 14:43things were different for a lot of people,
- 14:45but generally,
- 14:46I'm glad that that was something people were able to do.
- 14:48Nowadays,
- 14:49that is a fantasy.
- 14:50I mean,
- 14:50if you work at a retail store,
- 14:52you work at a restaurant,
- 14:53you are not gonna be able to
- 14:55put in,
- 14:56put away enough.
- 14:57Money
- 14:57to buy a home and be able to build wealth and get ahead.
- 15:02You're gonna be struggling to get by,
- 15:04and that's the heart of my claim,
- 15:05and
- 15:06that's the difference,
- 15:07and it,
- 15:07it has nothing to do with like,
- 15:09oh,
- 15:09Gen Z is more lazy,
- 15:10that's why they can't,
- 15:11or no,
- 15:11Gen Z doesn't have,
- 15:13they don't know how to manage their money enough for this.
- 15:15Of course,
- 15:16we always want,
- 15:17you know,
- 15:17more training on financial responsibility and how to,
- 15:20you know,
- 15:20balance your budget and all that is really important.
- 15:23I'm not saying it's not important.
- 15:25But there's bigger issues at hand,
- 15:27and
- 15:28the powers that be that have essentially
- 15:30pushed this country to a place where they are sucking up all the wealth,
- 15:33they're owning everything,
- 15:34and all the middle class and working class are just fighting for crumbs.
- 15:37They benefit when we're having these debates about,
- 15:40oh,
- 15:41the reason you can't afford a house is because you're buying
- 15:43too many lattes or avocado toast or whatever the hell,
- 15:46right?
- 15:46There's bigger problems at play here,
- 15:49and
- 15:50my argument is that
- 15:51The American dream is just so out of reach
- 15:54that
- 15:54most Gen Zers can read about it,
- 15:56um,
- 15:56but it's not something that they're actually getting right now,
- 15:59um,
- 16:00and that they're able to obtain
- 16:01with just purely hard work,
- 16:03and I think that's a shame,
- 16:04and I think the government.
- 16:06Has a role in
- 16:07fixing that
- 16:08and putting us in a place where one job is enough,
- 16:11not just to get by,
- 16:12but to get ahead and to be able to build wealth
- 16:14and again
- 16:15have a life where you own more than you owe
- 16:18and that's not
- 16:19the country we live in right now.
- 16:20Well,
- 16:20Laurie,
- 16:21the woman in the clip,
- 16:22she was asking you
- 16:24why should she trust you to fix it?
- 16:26Because given how little trust,
- 16:28you know,
- 16:28many Americans have in Congress,
- 16:30you know,
- 16:30why should young people or anyone for that matter,
- 16:33really believe in government
- 16:34and believe that they can actually make the American dream more attainable?
- 16:38And this is a great question.
- 16:39I know the time ran out,
- 16:40right,
- 16:40right when she asked me that.
- 16:42Well,
- 16:42number one,
- 16:42we see that in our country's history,
- 16:45when we have huge problems and the people come together,
- 16:48right,
- 16:49with leaders who are valuing people over profit,
- 16:52and the money over the money.
- 16:54We're actually able to do things
- 16:55and have big ideas that help us move forward,
- 16:58right?
- 16:58And that help working people.
- 17:00And I brought up Social Security and I brought up Medicare.
- 17:03I think a lot of times Americans generally
- 17:05can become
- 17:06take things for granted.
- 17:08And take struggles for granted.
- 17:10Like there was a time in this country's history
- 17:12where the vast majority of seniors lived in abject poverty
- 17:15because they weren't able to work anymore because they had gotten much older.
- 17:19They didn't really have that much savings and they were living in poverty.
- 17:21And you know what?
- 17:23Leaders and activists and organizers in our country said no.
- 17:26Government has something to do about this.
- 17:28We need to make sure we have a program
- 17:30where our seniors can retire with dignity.
- 17:32Social Security was proposed.
- 17:34It was called socialism,
- 17:35communism,
- 17:36a slippery slope,
- 17:37a crazy radical thing,
- 17:39and now it is a fact of life
- 17:41and enjoys,
- 17:43you know,
- 17:43bipartisanship,
- 17:44right?
- 17:44Everybody loves Social Security.
- 17:46Same thing with Medicare.
- 17:47We said.
- 17:47When our seniors retire,
- 17:49we want to make sure
- 17:49that if they need to go to a doctor,
- 17:51that they see a doctor.
- 17:52Medicare is the most popular government program in our country.
- 17:55It was called radical.
- 17:56It was called crazy,
- 17:57and now it's a fact of life.
- 17:59I get where people are coming from.
- 18:00They're like,
- 18:01what's government gonna do for me?
- 18:03Because for so long,
- 18:04corporations have bought off politicians really in both parties,
- 18:08I would say.
- 18:09And have
- 18:10uh created a political system where we are passing
- 18:13laws to benefit the wealthiest people and the biggest corporations
- 18:16and not working class Americans.
- 18:18But I encourage people,
- 18:20like if you look in the history,
- 18:21we can see that there have been times
- 18:23where government has actually been able to do something for us.
- 18:26I believe in getting back to that,
- 18:27and I believe we can do that.
- 18:29And
- 18:29for me specifically,
- 18:30this is why I don't accept corporate PAC money.
- 18:33It's not because I don't talk to
- 18:35companies and corporations.
- 18:36I'll talk to anyone.
- 18:37But the fact of the matter is my primary concern
- 18:40is helping the working class people in my district because I believe when we do that,
- 18:44everybody gets helped and we create a better country.
- 18:46And that's why I would say people can
- 18:48trust me,
- 18:49but also people like me.
- 18:50I'm not the only one.
- 18:51There's a lot of people
- 18:53coming into Congress,
- 18:54coming to office who are saying enough is enough.
- 18:56We need to have a country and a
- 18:57government that answers to the People and that's unafraid
- 19:01to move forward big ideas
- 19:03to make this country work for us.
- 19:05And uh
- 19:06that's why I ran for office.
- 19:07That's why I'm here.
- 19:07I do want to play you another clip from an interaction you had with uh the boomer
- 19:12and it's about student debt.
- 19:13Your claim was the United States
- 19:15should cancel all student debt.
- 19:17How would you feel that burden?
- 19:18You're saying that,
- 19:20yeah,
- 19:20you're saying that tomorrow if the United States forgave student debt,
- 19:23right,
- 19:23which isn't,
- 19:24we're not sending it.
- 19:25Check to to people to buy things we're
- 19:27we're saying we're forgiving you your outstanding balance.
- 19:30How would you feel that the day after the year after?
- 19:33I would feel it in the economy and the fact that
- 19:35there's a whole bunch of more imaginary money that showed up.
- 19:39That that's not what it is.
- 19:40That's exactly what happened during COVID.
- 19:41A bunch of imaginary money showed up,
- 19:43but you're confusing inflation went up,
- 19:45but canceling student debt isn't the Federal Reserve printing more money.
- 19:48It is forgiving an outstanding balance.
- 19:50And you're right,
- 19:51you would feel it in the economy
- 19:52because an entire generation of people
- 19:54would have more income
- 19:56to be able to use to buy a home,
- 19:57to start a family,
- 19:58to buy more goods,
- 19:59and it would actually help our economy.
- 20:01But it is not canceling canceling student debt is not printing money.
- 20:05It's not
- 20:06forgiving
- 20:07or it's not printing money.
- 20:07It is just forgiving.
- 20:09It's writing off something.
- 20:11It's taking a ledger
- 20:12and writing it off.
- 20:13How would you,
- 20:14and so my question to you is,
- 20:15how would you feel that?
- 20:17I would feel it because there's,
- 20:19there's like numbers on a ledge,
- 20:20but how would you feel it in your life?
- 20:22How would I feel it in my life?
- 20:23How would you feel it?
- 20:24Uh,
- 20:24well,
- 20:25I will tell you my wife's debt actually got totally,
- 20:27uh,
- 20:28relieved by Joe Biden.
- 20:30How did that,
- 20:30did that help you guys?
- 20:31It did.
- 20:32What were you able to do with the extra money?
- 20:34Wait,
- 20:34wait,
- 20:34wait,
- 20:34what were you guys saying?
- 20:35We weren't paying,
- 20:36we weren't paying that.
- 20:37You weren't paying it.
- 20:38No,
- 20:38she was on in a forever she was on a forever,
- 20:42uh,
- 20:42deferment deal,
- 20:43and we were carrying that.
- 20:45It was great to have the relief,
- 20:46but here's the deal.
- 20:47Well then,
- 20:47you guys had your own debt relief,
- 20:48so how can you sit here and say we shouldn't do it for others?
- 20:53Because
- 20:54it's not,
- 20:54oh I,
- 20:55I got a benefit and now everybody gets to have it.
- 20:58No,
- 20:58no,
- 20:58no,
- 20:58no,
- 20:58no,
- 20:58that's not how I,
- 20:59it's like the COVID checks.
- 21:01When the COVID checks for you but
- 21:03no no no no no no.
- 21:05All right,
- 21:05so your argument is that canceling student debt isn't printing money,
- 21:10it's writing off a balance.
- 21:12But if borrowers er suddenly have more disposable income,
- 21:15couldn't that still create inflationary pressure?
- 21:18No,
- 21:19absolutely not.
- 21:19What,
- 21:20what,
- 21:20what creates inflationary pressures when we're printing money
- 21:24and adding more money into the US,
- 21:26um,
- 21:26economy,
- 21:27and
- 21:28what this would do is actually help our economy because it means
- 21:31working people are gonna be able to spend their money in their communities
- 21:34so that way they can get to a place where they own more than they owe.
- 21:39Which should,
- 21:39which is,
- 21:40you know,
- 21:40is
- 21:41the goal,
- 21:41right?
- 21:42Is my goal as elected officials,
- 21:43I want to make sure our people have more money in their pockets.
- 21:45And I think this was a perfect interaction because
- 21:48he brought up the fact that number one,
- 21:49he,
- 21:50his wife,
- 21:51they got their own student debt canceled.
- 21:53And then he went on to say,
- 21:54yeah,
- 21:54it was a huge relief.
- 21:55And it was a big help to my life.
- 21:57I was trying to get him to understand is
- 21:59the argument that people use is they say,
- 22:02well,
- 22:02I don't want it,
- 22:03right?
- 22:04Because it's going to be bad for the economy.
- 22:06But no one can seem to answer the question on how would you actually feel it.
- 22:09Like how would it harm your life
- 22:11if your next door neighbor
- 22:13got their student debt
- 22:15canceled.
- 22:16And they're usually not able to answer this.
- 22:17And the next question is a lot of the folks
- 22:19in the room agreed with the big beautiful bill,
- 22:21which did the same thing
- 22:24for billionaires and mega corporations
- 22:26by giving them a huge tax giveaway.
- 22:27And what's a tax giveaway?
- 22:29Writing off a ledger and saying,
- 22:30hey,
- 22:30you owe less now.
- 22:32You don't have to
- 22:33contribute as much to our government for the services that we all use.
- 22:37But there's no complaints about that.
- 22:39And so,
- 22:39you know,
- 22:39a part of this is saying if we're gonna be in the Business of providing relief
- 22:43by way of tax breaks or writing off ledgers,
- 22:47we need to focus that relief on working class people
- 22:50and not the richest folks in this country,
- 22:52and that's actually gonna help our economy.
- 22:54Most of what powers our economy are consumers buying things.
- 22:58It's the vast majority of what keeps our economy afloat
- 23:01and so it's not,
- 23:02it's not only good economic practice for our country
- 23:05to do this and unshackle a whole generation.
- 23:07which by the way,
- 23:08isn't just young people,
- 23:09there's a lot of older folks who have crushing
- 23:11student debt that they've been paying off for decades.
- 23:14Um,
- 23:14it's just better for us to,
- 23:15to center relief for working people
- 23:18rather than billionaires or mega corporations.
- 23:20And that's really what I was trying to get people to
- 23:22understand is we can have the fairness argument on one side,
- 23:25which I agree it's not fair that people
- 23:26have crushing student debt in the first place.
- 23:28But on the other hand,
- 23:29this argument that it's bad for me.
- 23:32They,
- 23:33no one can seem to answer,
- 23:34how is it bad for you?
- 23:36How,
- 23:36how would you actually feel that tomorrow?
- 23:38And
- 23:39part of my counterarguments actually it would be
- 23:41good for you because more of your neighbors
- 23:42would have more income to go and build the life that they want to build,
- 23:46which is better for our nation.
- 23:47Now,
- 23:47does canceling existing student debt solve the underlying problem?
- 23:51You know,
- 23:52what stops the next generation
- 23:54from ending up with the same massive student loan uh burden?
- 23:58It doesn't,
- 23:58and this is part of the reason I think we brought this up in the
- 24:01In the debate that it's not just canceled student debt,
- 24:05you know,
- 24:05obviously I don't want my claim to be like 3 sentences long,
- 24:08but
- 24:09we,
- 24:09we should cancel student debt,
- 24:10which is like putting a band-aid on like a
- 24:13gashing wound,
- 24:14right?
- 24:14We need to put the band-aid on because it's important
- 24:16because we're in a cost of living crisis right now.
- 24:19But we also need to make sure that we,
- 24:21uh,
- 24:22ensure higher education
- 24:23is deeply affordable and
- 24:26That we put tons of resources into job training programs and the trade programs,
- 24:30um,
- 24:31and building trade programs and apprenticeships
- 24:33so that way after high school our young people
- 24:35have a plan and their plan doesn't involve them
- 24:38leaving high school and just immediately going into insane amounts of debt.
- 24:42The cost of higher education is insane,
- 24:45but
- 24:45part of what I brought up to a lot of
- 24:47the folks in the rooms because they were baby boomers
- 24:50is that when they went to college,
- 24:51if they did go to college,
- 24:53the government subsidized way more of their education
- 24:56than it does for young people nowadays.
- 24:58In fact,
- 24:58I think the numbers,
- 24:59they were responsible for about 20% of their education
- 25:02versus nowadays it's much more for young people,
- 25:05so.
- 25:06In a way,
- 25:07they kind of got their,
- 25:08you know,
- 25:09education covered before they graduated because the government
- 25:12put way more money into their education.
- 25:15Now what we're doing nowadays is we ask young
- 25:17people to carry that burden at a much higher percentage
- 25:20than
- 25:21baby boomers did,
- 25:22and that's part of the reason why people might have a hard time understanding
- 25:25what this is about.
- 25:26It's just our government puts way less money in terms of percentage.
- 25:30Into subsidizing education and so young people,
- 25:32they pay more,
- 25:33a larger percent of their education than baby boomers did as well.
- 25:37And it's this compounding problem that creates this issue where young people
- 25:41did what they were told to do.
- 25:43They were told to go to college,
- 25:44they were told,
- 25:45get student debt,
- 25:46it's fine,
- 25:46you'll be able to pay it off,
- 25:47you'll get a good job.
- 25:48They get a job afterwards,
- 25:49maybe,
- 25:50and it doesn't pay enough money to
- 25:52do,
- 25:53to pay off their,
- 25:54their,
- 25:54you know,
- 25:55insane rent,
- 25:56insane healthcare costs,
- 25:58uh,
- 25:59credit card debt.
- 26:00And student loan debt and all this stuff and so
- 26:03this is just a band-aid to help us,
- 26:04but you're 100% right.
- 26:05If we do it in 10 years we'll be in the same situation and so it's not just the band-aid,
- 26:09it's put the band-aid on,
- 26:10but we have to pass
- 26:12massive legislation to bring down the cost
- 26:14of higher education and make sure we have.
- 26:16routes as well.
- 26:17The last thing I'll say is I brought up in the debate
- 26:20that everyone says,
- 26:21oh,
- 26:21it's unfair,
- 26:22it's unfair.
- 26:23The people that technically would be most unfair to would be young people
- 26:26who actually didn't go to college and they don't have a degree,
- 26:30and I don't have a degree.
- 26:31Right,
- 26:32I don't have student debt.
- 26:33And so
- 26:34people who already paid off their student loans,
- 26:36I think that's
- 26:37the people who already,
- 26:37yeah,
- 26:38exactly.
- 26:39I didn't finish my,
- 26:40my degree and a part of it was because I didn't want to take up a bunch of student debt,
- 26:43but I still see the value in canceling student debt
- 26:47and making sure we solve this issue because it's better
- 26:49for our economy,
- 26:50it's better for America.
- 26:52And that's what I want.
- 26:53And it's a very,
- 26:54I believe,
- 26:54and I brought this up and some of them laughed.
- 26:56I believe it's a very patriotic thing
- 26:58to want our neighbors
- 27:00to be able to build wealth and build the life that they want.
- 27:03We have an
- 27:04ownership crisis in this country and I'm very worried
- 27:07that we're becoming an America where people owe more than they own.
- 27:11And that will be the new norm if we do do something about it.
- 27:14Yeah.
- 27:15Well,
- 27:15one of my final questions is,
- 27:17how do you distinguish between Between real structural barriers facing Gen Z
- 27:21and then the possibility that some young people may simply have
- 27:24different expectations of what the American dream should look like.
- 27:28That's part of the problem,
- 27:29right,
- 27:29is that the definition of the American dream has
- 27:32been watered down and watered down so much,
- 27:34and the reason why is because our country has been captured and captured by
- 27:39special
- 27:39interest corporations and uh the richest people in the country.
- 27:44And that's a problem.
- 27:45I'm not here to say
- 27:47there isn't,
- 27:48you know,
- 27:48that individual responsibility isn't important.
- 27:51I think it's very important.
- 27:52I think there's a lot we need to do
- 27:53to make sure young people understand financial health,
- 27:56that they're doing what they can given the circumstances
- 27:59to build the life that they want to live.
- 28:01Like that's all really important stuff.
- 28:04But part of what I'm saying as an elected official is I find it quite lazy
- 28:09and I,
- 28:09and I,
- 28:09and I believe in uh kind of
- 28:11putting aside my job.
- 28:14If I were to sit here and say,
- 28:15yeah,
- 28:15I'm not gonna go to Congress and and work on big ideas because
- 28:19it's your fault
- 28:20and you need to go fix it.
- 28:22I,
- 28:22I just,
- 28:23I don't see the American people as the problem.
- 28:25I see them as the hero in this pro in this story.
- 28:28And part of the issue
- 28:29is that we have big structural things.
- 28:32And you know,
- 28:32who really wants me to sit here and say the big problem is just the individual
- 28:36are the corporations that essentially have bought and,
- 28:39and are running this country.
- 28:40They want me to sit here and say,
- 28:41I'm not gonna work on big ideas
- 28:43because it's your.
- 28:44Individual fault that you bought too many lattes
- 28:46and when you stop buying too many lattes,
- 28:48maybe you'll be able to afford a house
- 28:50when that's BS.
- 28:51Individual responsibility is important,
- 28:53but there's big
- 28:55problems
- 28:56and there are people who have essentially rigged this economy to work for them.
- 29:00I'm gonna fight against that
- 29:02and it's gonna require big ideas and it's gonna require real work.
- 29:05It is easy and.
- 29:06Lazy for a politician to sit here
- 29:08and lecture the American people on how they need to do better,
- 29:12but the problem is we need politicians to do better,
- 29:14and we need politicians to actually pass laws
- 29:16to fix the problems.
- 29:18And so that's why I ran for Congress.
- 29:20I didn't come here to lecture people about what they need to do.
- 29:23I came here to build a government to actually help fix the big
- 29:27systemic problems we have,
- 29:29and that's what,
- 29:30you know,
- 29:31I hope people pull away from the debate.
- 29:33Again,
- 29:33I'm not trying to shy away from individual responsibility.
- 29:36But I just find too many politicians use that as a crutch to not do their damn job
- 29:40and focus on the big ideas that we need to get past
- 29:42to help move our country forward.
- 29:44And no one's saying it should be a walk in the park to build the life you want to live.
- 29:48But when you look at the numbers,
- 29:50everything is the most expensive it's ever been.
- 29:52Our people are still working hard
- 29:54and they're having trouble making ends,
- 29:55making ends meet.
- 29:56And it's not just young people,
- 29:57it's people of all ages.
- 29:5960% of this country lives paycheck to paycheck.
- 30:02Are we really gonna sit here and say 60% of this country is lazy?
- 30:05No,
- 30:06the American people aren't the problem,
- 30:07they're the hero.
- 30:08The problem are politicians
- 30:10and uh corporations
- 30:12that have
- 30:13essentially built this country to be,
- 30:15you can work really hard and you still might not
- 30:17be able to build the life you want to build.
- 30:19I want to make sure we fix that.
- 30:20Representative,
- 30:21that was a bar right there.
- 30:23American people are not the problem.
- 30:25They're the hero.
- 30:26I love that.
- 30:27Thank you for watching and thank you,
- 30:29Representative Maxwell for joining us today.
- 30:31Make sure to like,
- 30:32subscribe,
- 30:33and follow us wherever you watch your podcasts.
- 30:35We'll see you later.