Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / Advising Clients on California's Privacy Laws and the Latest Developments
Transcript
- 0:03Welcome to Advising Clients on California Privacy
- 0:06Laws and the Latest Developments. And for those
- 0:08of you in Southern California, I hope you're
- 0:10staying. At the beginning, I wanted to express
- 0:13our thanks to Jeffrey Mangels and Mitchell for
- 0:16the fabulous materials that are being presented
- 0:18today. And they were put together by Matt and
- 0:21Mike's team today. And we're very fortunate to
- 0:24have back two great speakers. One is Matthew
- 0:27Kenefick, some of you may have met before. Matt
- 0:29is extensive. An extensive practice includes
- 0:32litigation, real estate, and compliance matters.
- 0:35Matt represents a variety of industries, including
- 0:37manufacturers, financial institutions, retailers,
- 0:40real estate developers, wineries, and hotel industry,
- 0:42among others. Matthew is the hiring partner for
- 0:45J &M's San Francisco office, and Matt also has
- 0:48the distinction of having one of the biggest
- 0:51verdicts for 2022. Equally as impressive is another
- 0:55partner at Jeffer Maggleton Mitchell. which is
- 0:59my goal. My counsel's clients in a wide variety
- 1:02of matters including information security and
- 1:05privacy compliance, supply chain and outstanding
- 1:07security issues, AI implementation and governance,
- 1:10data breach responses and investigations, regulatory
- 1:14matters, crisis management and technology contracts.
- 1:17He is a partner as well as the chair of the cyber
- 1:19security and privacy group at Jack R. Merrybos
- 1:22and Mitchell Allen B. Mike and Matt, thank you
- 1:24so much for being here today and I'm going to
- 1:26let you guys get to it because I know that we
- 1:27have a lot of information to cover. For those
- 1:30who are wondering, if you have any questions,
- 1:32feel free to put them in the chat and we will
- 1:34save them towards the end. And if it goes longer,
- 1:36VHBA is willing to extend time and adjust your
- 1:40credits so you will get credit for all of your
- 1:42time today. Thank you. Well, thank you so much,
- 1:46Hillary, and good afternoon, everybody. As Hillary
- 1:49mentioned, we do have a robust slideshow. It's
- 1:53not our goal to go over line by line with you.
- 1:56We intended to have a large amount of materials
- 1:59that you could use for internal reference after
- 2:01the presentation. We're just going to hit some
- 2:04of the highlights. So let me go ahead and load
- 2:08up our slideshow. So here we are. And as you
- 2:13can see, this starts off with the name of the
- 2:18presentation. Let me move my zoom around here
- 2:20so we can see everything. And here you'll see,
- 2:23here's just the basic agenda. We're just going
- 2:26to talk about this. We're going to focus on California.
- 2:30Obviously, we're California lawyers. This is
- 2:32the Beverly Hills Bar Association. So we're going
- 2:34to talk about the California Invasion of Privacy
- 2:36Act very timely. There has been some recent amendments
- 2:39as of this week. We're going to talk about that,
- 2:42what precipitated that, and what follows now
- 2:46that we're through that. So let's talk about
- 2:49the California Invasion of Privacy Act, or we
- 2:53hear it SIPA. SIPA resides in the penal code.
- 3:01It came in in 1967, primarily trying to target
- 3:06wiretapping, eavesdropping, and the recordation
- 3:11of telephone calls. It predates the internet
- 3:17and digital tracking. We have seen that it...
- 3:23It was extended in 2015 to pen, register, and
- 3:28track and trace, which is the focus of part of
- 3:31today's presentation. And that came in in 2015.
- 3:34And if you look at the legislative history on
- 3:36that, the idea was that under the federal statute,
- 3:44if you were able to obtain a search warrant or
- 3:49a law enforcement agency was able to obtain a
- 3:52search warrant, for a pen register or trap and
- 3:55trace. And at that time, that was being regularly
- 3:58applied to internet applications. So the idea
- 4:02was to extend that to California, that type of
- 4:07search warrant capability to California laws.
- 4:09That's what the legislative history extends to,
- 4:13and it makes it very clear. And we'll talk about
- 4:17pen registers and trap and traces, but now we
- 4:21see that it's been applied for many years to
- 4:24digital marketing methodologies. Section 6, the
- 4:28key provisions, 631, which goes to wiretapping.
- 4:32We'll talk about each one of these in detail.
- 4:34632 goes to confidential recordings. 63851, the
- 4:39pen registers, trap and trace. And the 637 .2,
- 4:45with these for all the penal code, goes to private
- 4:47right of action. A pen register talks about where
- 4:58communications go out. Trap and trace talks about
- 5:02when communications come in. Traditionally, what
- 5:05this was was telephones. So the easy way to track
- 5:12calls that came in and calls that went out was
- 5:14either a pen register device or trap and trace.
- 5:17The idea, of course, is that could be critical
- 5:21evidence. If by way of example, Just think of
- 5:25the mythical mobster, makes a phone call to the
- 5:28hitman, and then five minutes later, the hitman
- 5:30does something bad. You have the record of that
- 5:33call, circumstantial evidence. And that was the
- 5:38historical use of that. But of course, we're
- 5:43now in a digital age and we're talking about
- 5:45websites and internet traffic and email. So the
- 5:51SIPA litigation weight. We started seeing some
- 5:56SIPA cases, primarily under Section 631 in 2003.
- 6:01Strike that, 2023. I'm dating myself. We saw
- 6:05about 200 of those in California, but it ballooned.
- 6:09They took off. They were lucrative. They were
- 6:12able to survive some judicial scrutiny, although
- 6:15the chatbot cases kind of fell apart. But then
- 6:19we saw in 2024, it exploded. about 4 ,000 cases.
- 6:24And as of mid -2026, we were out about the same.
- 6:28So Mike, what did you see in the form of the
- 6:34rise of these simple litigations? How did you
- 6:37see that manifest through your practice? Well,
- 6:42number one, I think it was almost inevitable.
- 6:45Given the relative ease with which we could file
- 6:50um these these these these complaints but also
- 6:55a fact that that kind of gets overlooked or mixed
- 6:58up in the in the debate about this the narrative
- 7:00about this and that is that this is one of those
- 7:04unusual laws that most organizations did not
- 7:08think they were violating and that came as a
- 7:14big shock to people you know when we first began
- 7:16representing organizations and defending these
- 7:19lawsuits i mean now You know most companies we
- 7:23deal with know about this stuff. They've read
- 7:24about it. They've heard about it They've got
- 7:26it, you know their own daily information feeds,
- 7:28but you know, you'll you'll recall you'll recall
- 7:32Matt back in the beginning You know people would
- 7:35inquire about these kinds of claims and they
- 7:38would be absolutely baffled And why they're being
- 7:42subject to prosecution under a criminal statute
- 7:45especially the organizations that felt that they
- 7:49were in compliance with California privacy law
- 7:51Right. Especially those. Yeah, it makes sense.
- 7:56Right. You're counseling people on cookies and
- 7:59banners, and then they get hit with this. You
- 8:01know, one of the things that, you know, I think
- 8:03is was it makes it inevitable to Mike's point
- 8:06is that we have a very strong consumer protection
- 8:09bar in California, and they're very good at creating
- 8:14novel theories. And you have to applaud them
- 8:16because some of the theories that they come up
- 8:18with are just very novel, cutting edge stuff.
- 8:22And so I think it was, I agree with Mike, it
- 8:25was inevitable that this would be extended. We've
- 8:28seen it extended a lot to the platforms, right?
- 8:31Where we see the big cases go against the Facebooks,
- 8:34the Googles, the larger platforms. But these
- 8:40cases were not going after the platforms. They're
- 8:43going against the end user websites, the people
- 8:47who use some of the platform. digital marketing
- 8:51tools. And that was one of the more interesting
- 8:54components of this. And they would show up in
- 8:56the form, and we've seen it, they still go to
- 8:58this day. I mean, I get two or three of them
- 8:59a day. We see them in the form of demand letters,
- 9:03arbitrations, mass arbitrations, and certainly
- 9:09lawsuits. For a while, they were all being filed
- 9:12in federal, and then a lot of the plaintiffs'
- 9:15attorneys try to plead out of federal. because
- 9:19they were trying to get them into a state court
- 9:26where there would be a lesser chance of creating
- 9:28adverse precedent. The master arms, we've all
- 9:34heard about that, and that can be very problematic
- 9:37because of the arbitration fees. And equally,
- 9:41this should be mentioned because this comes as
- 9:45an enormous shock. to all but the most sophisticated
- 9:49organizations we represent, that there are all
- 9:52kinds of tools available now that permit the
- 9:54plaintiff's lawyers to go on websites and find
- 9:57out what's actually going on as opposed to what
- 10:00the organization targeted by the claim thinks
- 10:03is going on, which are very often two very different
- 10:06things. Yeah, that's a very good point. And then
- 10:10there's the third component. A lot of people
- 10:13do not know what's going on even behind the scene
- 10:17because the platform technology, some of it is
- 10:20proprietary and black box. But you definitely
- 10:23see that we have, and I believe about one third
- 10:28of all commercial websites are built on a Shopify
- 10:31platform. So a lot of that Shopify stuff is done
- 10:36with software development kits and a lot of the
- 10:40digital marketing comes from that. comes with
- 10:43default settings and default plugins that a lot
- 10:46of the smaller businesses, and some larger ones
- 10:49just don't know what's going on. So let's talk
- 10:52about pen register claims. So this is something
- 10:56that came up. It was initially, I think, at least
- 11:00from my conversations with the plaintiff's attorneys
- 11:02that... really launched the claims. It was an
- 11:05add -on theory. It really wasn't their primary
- 11:07theory. It just, to their shock, survived emotion
- 11:11dismiss, and then it became the playing field.
- 11:16And the idea is it primarily targeted pixel technology
- 11:22or pixel beacons. So what a pixel beacon is,
- 11:26and I'm not a computer programmer, but I understand.
- 11:31what Google tells me about it, and our experts,
- 11:34of course. Pixel Beacon is a tracker. It's a
- 11:39small little image or code on a website or sometimes
- 11:42in an email. And when you load that website,
- 11:47it immediately initiates a transfer of data between
- 11:58your browser and an advertising server and also
- 12:04with the host website. And the data that it tracks,
- 12:12you would think is pretty benign. And some courts
- 12:14have held some of this is benign. We'll talk
- 12:16about that in a little bit. But it could be like
- 12:18your IP address, the time you opened it, the
- 12:22type of browser you're using, maybe some type
- 12:26of information about your device, such as a unique
- 12:33a unique ID. Now, a lot of that sounds very benign.
- 12:37The argument is that with certain types of technology
- 12:43enabled, especially like with the TikTok pixel,
- 12:50the platform has the ability to reverse append
- 12:54that information it collects with other information
- 12:58is collected about you. and connect and create
- 13:01a very large marketing picture, either about
- 13:04you specifically as the end user or about an
- 13:07anonymous user that they have associated with
- 13:10you. And that information is being targeted as
- 13:17being improperly collected. So the pen register
- 13:22claim, you go to the website, the IP address
- 13:27is a very common thing. that's captured, pixels,
- 13:31cookies, software development kits, or other
- 13:33chat widgets. We'll collect that IP address,
- 13:36the addressing information, and we'll talk about
- 13:38the addressing information a bit. Again, we talked
- 13:42about this being for a search warrant, so you're
- 13:44not supposed to be doing this under 63851 without
- 13:47a court order. And the technologies that it's
- 13:50going after, like I said, the tracking pixels,
- 13:55cookies, session replay, session replay is basically
- 13:57a process that tracks what's going on on your
- 14:02website visit, like I said, the chat widgets,
- 14:07the analytical tools, et cetera. One of the things
- 14:10that's really interesting is the contents of
- 14:14the communication is expressly excluded from
- 14:17a PEN register claim. A PEN register claim targets
- 14:20the DRESS, the dialing, routing, addressing,
- 14:23and signaling information. The contents of the
- 14:27communication itself, what is being said, That's
- 14:29covered under other sections of SIPA. So we talk
- 14:35about exposure. Five grand per violation potentially
- 14:41can be more under SIPA, that is. Most settlement
- 14:46demands range between 20 and 50k. So the plaintiff's
- 14:52bar is very precise in figuring out just how
- 14:56much it costs to defend these cases. And then
- 14:59they make a settlement demand just below that
- 15:02cost. So you could either pay Matt or Mike to
- 15:05defend the case and get the chance of being exonerated,
- 15:08or you could pay a little bit less than that
- 15:10to the plaintiff's attorney, and they go away.
- 15:13Estimated demand letters over $1 billion. State
- 15:16-wide costs in the legislature for Senate Bill
- 15:23690, which we'll talk about. You know, in the
- 15:27legislative history, the LA Times defined it
- 15:30as an extinction level threat for the, for publishers
- 15:34content. And you'll see it hits everybody. Hospitals,
- 15:38yeah. Mike, you were going to add? Well, I think
- 15:41it's important to add here that the plaintiff's
- 15:48law firms that are prosecuting these claims have
- 15:50already made the moral judgment that it really
- 15:52doesn't make any difference what kind of organization
- 15:53they're going after. So it could be a hospital.
- 15:57it could be a philanthropy, could be a 5013C.
- 16:02It really doesn't make any difference. If you're
- 16:05an organization with a website that is actually
- 16:09operating as a website, and it doesn't make any
- 16:13difference if you're compliant with the California
- 16:14Consumer Privacy Act, you probably have committed
- 16:18some potential violations of these laws that
- 16:21were never intended to cover that kind of conduct.
- 16:24Or, despite what the courts say, really never
- 16:27intended to cover this kind of technology. Yeah,
- 16:30a true legislative lag, because this legislation
- 16:33came out long before the, the technology was
- 16:38in its current use. And we've seen even business
- 16:40to business websites targeted. You know, it's,
- 16:43you know, and usually. Like most consumer protection
- 16:46lawsuits, the smaller the business, the more
- 16:48they pay. If you don't have the money to pay
- 16:50a big defense, you're probably going to pay a
- 16:53little bit less. But we'll talk about some of
- 16:56the more successful defenses. But those were
- 16:58asserted by some bigger law firms and bigger
- 17:02defendants. The Variety Media case, by way of
- 17:04example, was defended by Gibson Dunn. That's
- 17:10a defendant who could protect itself. But we
- 17:14don't always see that. So one of the things that
- 17:17fuels these types of lawsuits and these types
- 17:20of claims is uncertainty. We have courts all
- 17:25over the place. We'll see a lot of federal courts
- 17:29allowing them. State courts, you know, not so
- 17:33much. So we'll talk about it. Here's some of
- 17:35the one of the original cases, Greenleaf versus
- 17:37Kachava, basically saying that the fingerprinting
- 17:41software can constitute a pen register through
- 17:46that reverse appending. And we go through this.
- 17:48We'll see a lot of these cases where they say
- 17:52that pen registers do extend to computers and
- 17:56software, not just telephonic devices. The IP
- 18:01collection, a lot of federal cases have held
- 18:02that IP collection does constitute a violation
- 18:08of the pen register statute. Whereas we see in
- 18:12state court, Well, we've seen some pretty good
- 18:16results from a defense perspective, where they
- 18:20said IP address alone just is not sufficient
- 18:23for a pen register. There's no expectation of
- 18:28privacy in an IP address. IP addresses are just
- 18:30how the internet works. And if you wanted to
- 18:36shut down the exchange of IP collection, you
- 18:40might end up shutting down the entire internet
- 18:42as a whole. So we've seen that. So we mentioned
- 18:48the variety media. So we have a tentative ruling.
- 18:52We don't have a final ruling. But variety media
- 18:55was the first real appellate decision to apply
- 19:00to 638 .51. And that's the Trap and Trace statute
- 19:06in California under SIPA. And so the tentative
- 19:11ruling, the Court of Appeals said, look, Pen
- 19:15register, under SIPA, is the same as under ECPA.
- 19:20It reaches the internet. It's not just limited
- 19:22to telephones. So that defense was rejected.
- 19:28There was an argument that it was in conflict
- 19:31with the CCPA. The Variety Media Court said,
- 19:35no, it's complimentary. There's a rule of leniency
- 19:38that we were arguing that basically, or that
- 19:43was being argued rather, and we argue all the
- 19:45time, it looks penal code, it needs to be construed
- 19:47narrowly, not broadly. The court said, well,
- 19:50because it's being applied in a civil context,
- 19:54even though it's a penal code, you don't get
- 19:56that. But what it did rule that was very helpful
- 20:01says, you know, collecting IP addresses, you
- 20:05know, on itself as pledged. This was a Demer
- 20:08case, by the way. did not state a claim. So you
- 20:14needed more for the drafts, for the dialing,
- 20:16routing, addressing, signaling, than just collecting
- 20:18IP addresses and using it in the way that was
- 20:21being pled. But because it was raised on reply,
- 20:30not in the moving papers on Demer, the Court
- 20:33of Appeals' tentative ruling was to reverse the
- 20:39denial of the overruling, I guess, of the demurrer,
- 20:43sustain it with leave to amend to give the plaintiff
- 20:46an opportunity to try to plead something else
- 20:50other than IP address or change the allegations
- 20:54about how IP addresses would go to that. But
- 20:59this may very well be moot given what happened
- 21:02this week. And I'm sure everybody on this call
- 21:05knows about Senate Bill 690. So Senate Bill 690
- 21:09was unanimously passed through the California
- 21:13legislature. And this week on September 30th,
- 21:17it was signed by Gavin Newsom into law. And in
- 21:22his letter accompanying this, he was protecting
- 21:27small businesses from overzealous lawsuits and
- 21:30urged the legislature to address these decades
- 21:33old statutes and SIPA over the next year. So
- 21:37what does 690 do? So Senate Bill 690, the first
- 21:42thing is, is it eliminates a private right of
- 21:44action under 638 .51 for pen register claims
- 21:50and obviously trap and trace for websites and
- 21:55applications. AG, the DOJ AG can enforce it,
- 22:00but private plaintiffs lose standing. The interesting
- 22:03thing is, is, you know, these have one year statutes
- 22:05and limitations. Obviously, people try to get
- 22:08further back under 17200, but they have a one
- 22:12-year statute of limitations. And they're making
- 22:16this retroactive to January 1st, 2025. It's effective
- 22:21January 1st, 2026, but they're going to make
- 22:23it retroactive to January 1st, 2025. So obviously,
- 22:29it reaches five lawsuits. The interesting thing
- 22:31about this is that does make it subject to a
- 22:36challenge. Some of the more prominent plaintiff's
- 22:42firms in the space have said they're going to
- 22:43challenge constitutionality of it. And there's
- 22:46a separability clause that talks about, hey,
- 22:51look, if this is part of it is invalidated, the
- 22:55rest stays. Go ahead, Mike. Yeah, one of the
- 22:59interesting things about 690, and we'll talk
- 23:02further about its implications, is that It's
- 23:06probably the first initiative we've seen in a
- 23:08long time that may go someplace that actually
- 23:13acknowledges that the California Consumer Privacy
- 23:15Act and SIPA are not complimentary. And in fact,
- 23:19my view, and I'm speaking for myself as a lawyer
- 23:22in this area, they are inherently not complimentary.
- 23:29The California Consumer Privacy Act is an opt
- 23:33-out regime. And in order to be compliant with
- 23:38SIPA, you've effectively got to have deployed
- 23:42in your environment, on your website, a GDPR
- 23:46opt -in regime. You can't have both. So, and
- 23:52we'll, you know, Matt and I will get into takeaways
- 23:55and things that people need to do or should at
- 23:57least think about doing. But as you go through
- 24:01this, you may have the sense that somebody's
- 24:04missing something. And somebody is missing something,
- 24:07but you also need to understand that there is
- 24:13an inherent tension running through these initiatives
- 24:15composed of two things. One, the more or less
- 24:21profound lack of understanding of how the internet
- 24:25works and in particular how pixels and trackers
- 24:27work. And at the same time, a very broad -based
- 24:31concern. that human beings who use the internet
- 24:35are in fact the product. And the product is being
- 24:40abused typically by the large platforms, but
- 24:45the large platforms are not the low hanging fruit
- 24:47as Matt has pointed out, right? So where the
- 24:50plaintiff's lawyers go in the first instance
- 24:51is typically smaller organizations that understand
- 24:54that they can get out for a $5 ,000 or a $10
- 24:57,000 payment. avoid hundreds of thousands of
- 25:01dollars in litigation expenses, and get in front
- 25:03of a judge who may not care about their size
- 25:07or their compliance otherwise with California
- 25:10law. Yeah, absolutely. Some other states have
- 25:16tried to scale back. Again, we're trying to balance
- 25:19the climate of protecting consumers and their
- 25:22privacy rights. We certainly want that. But at
- 25:26the same time, we don't want predatory lawsuits
- 25:29from overzealous plaintiffs who are really just
- 25:33taking advantage of technical nuances that have
- 25:36no adverse impacts on the consumers. But we have
- 25:40seen that some other states, such as Tennessee,
- 25:43New Hampshire, and Alaska, did pass some statutory
- 25:46amendments to exclude some standard commercial
- 25:49tools like cookies and tracking pixels from their
- 25:53state wiretapping definitions. But this is really
- 25:56the first one that we've seen. big climate like
- 26:00California where we've seen this. It doesn't
- 26:04mean it completely goes away. There's plenty
- 26:06of other theories. We've already seen them, and
- 26:08Florida has a pretty robust statute on it as
- 26:11well. Florida's statute actually predates California,
- 26:16the Florida Security of Communications Act, and
- 26:20it has a trap and trace provision. But going
- 26:22back to the 690, so 690 does not affect the 631,
- 26:27632 wiretapping and recording provisions. And
- 26:31those still have those violations, the statutory
- 26:34penalties. It does not create a safe harbor,
- 26:41still prohibits pen registers. It just changes
- 26:43who may enforce. And California does have a lot
- 26:51of consumer protection going on in its enforcement
- 26:54agencies. So I would not be surprised if we see
- 26:56a lot of that. And we do know, of course, that
- 27:01a retroactivity component of that might be contested.
- 27:05It probably will be. We'll see how that plays
- 27:07out. There were some companion bills, Senate
- 27:10Bill 923 and Assembly Bill 1542 that did not
- 27:15go through. So now that 630 8 .51 is going away,
- 27:22what's happening? Well, we've already seen it.
- 27:24People anticipated that, and claims have changed.
- 27:29So we've seen a lot of people going after the
- 27:35wiretapping. It needs the contents of the communication,
- 27:41which is not the dialing, routing, addressing,
- 27:43or signaling. Matt, I might point out in the
- 27:47more recent letters, It's funny, the 631, that's
- 27:50like the last demand right now. It's no longer
- 27:54the first demand. Yeah. Well, 631 is somewhat
- 27:59co -extensive with the ECPA. But we'll see. Those
- 28:05were the original claims. That was the chat bot
- 28:07claims. It was a 631. And the thing is, it needs
- 28:10to be a contemporaneous. Exchange of information
- 28:15or, you know, so we'll talk about how you get
- 28:17around the 631 with the server side technology
- 28:20also needs to be shared with the 3rd party and
- 28:23there's ways dealing with that with that data
- 28:26privacy agreement. And there, but there are more
- 28:30defenses to that, but 631 there 632 is just California
- 28:34has a. Is it to party consent for recording,
- 28:39but it's for confidential. uh recordings right
- 28:43so that's be a reasonable expectation of confidentiality
- 28:46and there's a question as to whether or not um
- 28:50you know an exchange on internet or just merely
- 28:52browsing the internet um you know going to a
- 28:55website what portions of that is confidential
- 28:58is your mouse activity what you hover over what
- 29:02you scroll what you add to your uh your cart
- 29:05is that confidential some courts say yes some
- 29:08courts say no um is the Are the fields you fill
- 29:12in on the website, is that confidential? Obviously,
- 29:17some courts say yes, some courts say no. The
- 29:19federal statute, the ECPA, that still subsists.
- 29:24Now, that's a one -party consent statute. But
- 29:30as we'll talk about a little bit, people are
- 29:33trying to, plaintiffs are trying to get around
- 29:34that one -party consent using the crime tort
- 29:37exception, saying that you're using it for tortious
- 29:39purposes. And then the other one, which we see
- 29:42is common law claims in the video privacy protection
- 29:45act. We'll talk about that. One of the legitimate
- 29:52concerns that has been expressed by plaintiff's
- 29:56lawyers and by a lot of commentators is that,
- 29:59let's call it generically, internet technology
- 30:02has gotten to the point. at advertising advanced
- 30:05emerging advertising technology, especially with
- 30:08the introduction of AI has gotten to a point
- 30:11where it doesn't need many personal data points
- 30:14to create critical mass to start making inferences
- 30:19or help organizations make inference or to develop
- 30:24and initiate very significant ad campaigns. It's
- 30:28one of the reasons why privacy proponents, and
- 30:33in a way, I think we're all privacy proponents,
- 30:35are looking at things that people never used
- 30:37to look at, which is what are your mouse movements
- 30:40being tracked? Or if a field is being filled
- 30:44out and it doesn't even have your name or address,
- 30:47is there nonetheless enough information and view
- 30:49of existing and emerging technology for that
- 30:52to be taken and used to identify you? Yeah, no,
- 30:58absolutely. And that's That's really the crux
- 31:03of it, right? And so we'll see that there are,
- 31:06there's a lot of theories that keep happening
- 31:08on this. So some of the defense teams that we're
- 31:11seeing, you know, we're talking about for 631,
- 31:14you know, the data being delivered to server
- 31:17before tracking. And that's just the server side
- 31:21theory. And basically what the idea is, is you
- 31:25eliminate the contemporaneous component by having
- 31:29the data first go to your server, then it goes
- 31:35to the third party. And that breaks the contemporaneous
- 31:42interception, because you cannot eavesdrop on
- 31:45your own conversation. And you certainly can
- 31:48share information with third parties. It's just
- 31:50the simultaneous unauthorized third party interception
- 31:57is what people target as. as aiding and abetting
- 32:01wiretapping. So we talk about that. Consent,
- 32:05well, the ultimate defense is consent. That can
- 32:08be through a cookie batter, terms of service,
- 32:11privacy policies. But we see a lot of challenges
- 32:14on the enforceability of that, which also goes
- 32:17with the arbitration slash class action waivers.
- 32:22Certainly, a browse wrap is not going to be enforced
- 32:25in almost any jurisdiction, whereas scroll wrap
- 32:28or a click wrap will, and that means something
- 32:31that actually forces a consumer to affirmatively
- 32:36click through and show that they actually are
- 32:39looking at and reading your terms of service
- 32:42and agreeing to it. One of the things we talk
- 32:44about, the arbitration, we have batch arbitration
- 32:47provisions under JAMS and AAA. It's a great way
- 32:51of getting around the mass ARBs. Mass ARBs can
- 32:56be very scary because you get the demand from
- 32:59the plaintiff and they say, look, through our
- 33:02Reddit groups or whatever we're doing to collect
- 33:05a group of plaintiffs, whether they're real or
- 33:08not, we have 10 ,000 people signed up and they
- 33:12all want money from you. And if you don't pay
- 33:17us what we're asking, we will go ahead and process
- 33:20these all as ARB demands because they're consumer
- 33:23ARBs. You've got to pay the fees. And then if
- 33:27you say, no, I don't think I'm going to do that,
- 33:30then the first thing you get is they push through
- 33:35maybe 100 of them. After you get done paying
- 33:37$100 ,000 in ARD fees, so you're ready yet. And
- 33:41if you say no, then they push through another
- 33:4350 of them. This was at AAA, was actually sued,
- 33:47same with the law firm out east. I believe it
- 33:50was Jersey Mike's who's the plaintiff over this
- 33:52process. Like I said, the batch ARD rules try
- 33:56to fix that, but you got to have the clause and
- 33:59people have to agree to it. The vendor as an
- 34:02extension, I talked about that. The vendor, you
- 34:05have a data use agreement or data privacy agreement.
- 34:08You can make the vendor as basically an extension
- 34:11of your company and they're not going to be,
- 34:15it's not going to be a transmittal to a third
- 34:18party. Matt, now you're going to get into this
- 34:21in a little bit more detail in a few minutes.
- 34:24But one of the themes that emerges throughout
- 34:27all of this, I mean, it's a through line from
- 34:30start to finish, is that the typical organization
- 34:33does not know what's going on on or behind its
- 34:37website. They just don't. And very often, very
- 34:42often, it can be a significant organization who
- 34:44is using a third party contractor to design and
- 34:47manage the website. And the third party contractor
- 34:51is making decisions about what pixels, trackers,
- 34:54and beacons are being used. Or even worse, because
- 34:58all of these technologies have control mechanisms,
- 35:01they either ignore the control mechanisms or
- 35:03they don't know how to use the control mechanisms
- 35:06or don't realize that even if you switch something
- 35:10off, the default to that technology is that it
- 35:13goes back on automatically in like six months.
- 35:16And if you're not changing it periodically, so.
- 35:18The plaintiff's bar understands the leverage
- 35:22of the $5 ,000 per violation claim. They understand
- 35:26how batch arbitrations and mass arbitrations
- 35:29work. But they will very often come to the fore
- 35:32with a demand where there's just an asymmetry
- 35:35of relevant information about what happened,
- 35:37what they say happened. They've got a lot of
- 35:39information because the technology they've used
- 35:42is pretty freely available on the web. and the
- 35:46victimized organization simply does not know.
- 35:50Yeah, absolutely. One of the things that we see
- 35:52a lot, talk about the default settings, they
- 35:55do revert, advance matching, you know, that fingerprinting
- 35:58we're talking about, that reverts sometimes,
- 36:01and that's a challenge. You know, the privacy
- 36:04policy disclosure, you know, where you tell people
- 36:06what you're actually doing, you got to, Mike
- 36:08says, you have to know what you're really telling
- 36:09them. Because if you tell people that you're
- 36:12doing one thing, Can you do it in a nether? That's
- 36:15a whole nether. That gives you rise to a whole
- 36:17nether claim. And we talked about that with the
- 36:20consent mechanisms that we have. We'll talk about
- 36:22that towards the end of that, because that's
- 36:24one of the new waves of theories. And another
- 36:27interesting thing is often the plaintiffs, they
- 36:31do get it wrong. They look and they see what
- 36:34information is being requested by the platform
- 36:37or third party data marketing agency. versus
- 36:42what is actually being set. And next thing you
- 36:46know, you're fighting, you're paying somebody,
- 36:48you know, as an attorney, a lot of money to fight
- 36:50over what's actually been done and what's not
- 36:53being done with experts. And that's an expensive
- 36:56and ugly fight. So you're, you know, so obviously
- 36:58a meaningful disclosure, meaningful consent could
- 37:03prevent protect that. Certainly, you know, that
- 37:07is a business decision that has to be done by
- 37:10by clients and they have to weigh that because
- 37:13some of the consent mechanisms, they can impact
- 37:18adversely conversion rates. So businesses have
- 37:21to look at that and what works and track it throughout
- 37:25their whole enterprise. So we talk about, okay,
- 37:29so California shut down 638 .51. What about these
- 37:34other states? Well, Like I said, Florida, it
- 37:36is ground zero. The FSCA has the Trap and Trace
- 37:41Pen Register going strong. There's a lot of litigation
- 37:47back and forth on that. Some courts hold certain
- 37:50things. But look, I'm not a Florida lawyer. But
- 37:52I have clients who do business in Florida. And
- 37:54we do see these claims. Basically, that is still
- 38:00a viable claim, even though it's less, it's lesser,
- 38:04it's $1 ,000 per violation. We actually see those
- 38:07claims come through on small claims court, so
- 38:11it's interesting. And some of the other states
- 38:14have similar statutes. So let's look at some
- 38:19of the theories that we've been seeing, that
- 38:22you're probably seeing as well, and you're probably
- 38:24going to see more of them. as time goes on. So
- 38:31first, like I said, we talked about 631. That's
- 38:37back on the rise. We talked about this contents
- 38:42of the communication being shared contemporaneously
- 38:45with the third party. Same damages, 5 ,000 per
- 38:50violation or treble actual damages of greater.
- 38:53I've had some plaintiffs argue actual damages.
- 38:55I think it's I think it's hard to state a claim
- 39:01to quantify actual damages for a privacy invasion,
- 39:07just like this. But either way, we see that.
- 39:11And then, obviously, injunctive relief, which
- 39:13is scary from a class action component. The last
- 39:17thing you want to do is have some plaintiff come
- 39:20in seeking a big load star saying, look, we got
- 39:22this great injunctive relief. You got to pay
- 39:24our fees. 632, we're talking about this. This
- 39:30is the confidential communication recordation.
- 39:35Again, we'll see this for chats and other types
- 39:41of messaging or communications. The key is, is
- 39:48there really a confidential communication going
- 39:50on? Consent's obviously a big defense, but one
- 39:55of the many ones that work. we're getting. Then
- 40:01we go on to see, again, people are circling right
- 40:04back to the ECPA. I think we mentioned this before.
- 40:11They're trying to vitiate the theory of one -party
- 40:14consent by saying that as a company, you have
- 40:20somehow engaged in a tortious or criminal act.
- 40:24And they'll try to use a SIPA violation, including
- 40:26638 .51. They say, look, even if 638 .51 doesn't
- 40:30have a prior right of action, it still vitiates
- 40:32the ECPA. We have common law claims and claims
- 40:43under the California Constitution for right of
- 40:45privacy. Not going to go over all this. We've
- 40:48all seen this in many different contexts. But
- 40:50these are coming back at us. Intrusion upon.
- 40:54seclusion of the common law tort, CADAFA, California
- 40:59data and what is the acronym actually go for?
- 41:06Mike, do you remember the exact acronym for that?
- 41:09I know it on an episodic basis, but not otherwise.
- 41:13Yeah, it's a computer data access and fraud act.
- 41:18We always call it CADAFA. It's actually it's
- 41:20an analog to the computer fraud and abuse act.
- 41:22Okay. Yeah, yeah, exactly. And basically does
- 41:26have a private right of action. We've seen a
- 41:28lot of it's basically like, you know, data theft,
- 41:32you know, hacking, you see it like with a former
- 41:35employee stealing company data or trade secrets.
- 41:39But they're trying to say that, that, you know,
- 41:44sometimes somehow using, you know, a pen register,
- 41:52or other type of digital marketing constitutes
- 41:55an unauthorized access to the computer device.
- 42:00The big challenge or one of the big challenges
- 42:03with all of this is that from the time that the
- 42:08internet was first commercialized in a significant
- 42:10way up until let's say 2022, 2023, all of this
- 42:15stuff that people are now getting claims for
- 42:17being sued for, this was part and parcel of doing
- 42:21business on the web. You couldn't do business
- 42:24on the web if you didn't engage in these kinds
- 42:26of intrusions. By the way, that's still the case.
- 42:30The way it's dealt with in the European Union
- 42:32and in the UK is that's OK as long as you give
- 42:37us your consent beforehand. And even then, there
- 42:40are going to be some limitations. The United
- 42:43States has been a completely different paradigm.
- 42:48California probably comes as close as anybody
- 42:51in this, as any jurisdiction of the country to
- 42:53the European Union regime. But essentially what's
- 42:58happening is that plaintiffs and government authorities
- 43:03are going after conduct that has been absolutely
- 43:06essential for purposes of monetizing web commerce.
- 43:11Yeah, and this circles back to a core fundamental
- 43:15component, right? What is really happening here?
- 43:20digital marketing. And certainly, as Mike pointed
- 43:22out, the consumers are really the product, right?
- 43:27When you go and get access to the Gmail account
- 43:33without paying anything, it costs Google a lot
- 43:39of money to run that platform. When you use WhatsApp,
- 43:41which from what I understand, one out of five
- 43:44people on the planet use WhatsApp. Cost WhatsApp
- 43:48a lot of money to run that platform, but they're
- 43:50not charging you. So there certainly is a monetization
- 43:54on that. And the monetization, of course, is
- 43:57marketing data and information. But how is that
- 44:01used? When I was in law school about 25 years
- 44:04ago, I had the pleasure of having a professor.
- 44:08He was Milton Friedman's son. So the guy who
- 44:12invented income tax was a professor in my law
- 44:14school. And he said, we took this one class.
- 44:18It was really interesting. The guy was great.
- 44:20And it was the future of law and technology.
- 44:24And it was kind of like a science fiction class
- 44:27combined with law. But one of the things he said,
- 44:32he said, look, why is spam spam? If you go back,
- 44:37spam is the Monty Python skit, rather, where
- 44:40you can have anything as long as it's spam. But
- 44:44spam email or spam marketing is something you
- 44:47don't want, right? I may not want XYZ product,
- 44:53but I have to read through that in my email anyway.
- 44:56Fortunately, we have spam filters that move that
- 44:58to the side. But for the most part, that's unsolicited
- 45:02email. But what about something I really want?
- 45:05What about if I'm looking for a fantastic gift
- 45:08for my wife's birthday and I just can't think
- 45:11of it? and I have it presented to me on a silver
- 45:13platter? Or what if I'm a car collector and I'm
- 45:16looking for this one really obscure part from
- 45:19my car and I can't find it anywhere? I spent
- 45:22hours on the day looking on the internet and
- 45:24boom, there shows up in my inbox. Or whatever,
- 45:27pick whatever thing you were looking for as a
- 45:30consumer or an internet user. If that digital
- 45:33marketing puts that directly in front of you,
- 45:35there is utility to that. And so there's certainly
- 45:39a tension between that And certainly the legislature
- 45:46needs to catch up with that. And they're going
- 45:50to have to. They're going to have to balance
- 45:51those interests. And they're also going to have
- 45:52to balance the fact that people are getting these
- 45:55services for free. But at the very end, consent,
- 46:00I think, is, at least from a personal perspective,
- 46:02I think consent is a silver bullet. I think everybody
- 46:05has a right to know what's happening to their
- 46:07personal information. And that is the defense.
- 46:11that we always see. So we have, going on to the
- 46:14claims we're seeing, the CLRA, the 17200, we
- 46:21see those. That's standard. The VPPA, that's
- 46:27the Bork law, if you guys remember that, where
- 46:31it was intended to go after people who were disclosing
- 46:36Bork's videotape renting history from Blockbuster
- 46:42or whatever. And they said, look, you can't do
- 46:45that. Well, now, trying to disclose private video
- 46:48activity, whether or not there's a lot of tension
- 46:52on that. But we see those claims. The next one
- 46:59is more of a BNP tutus. five, seven, five. I
- 47:04think that's more of a Mike issue. Mike probably
- 47:07encounters that a lot. But that's something we,
- 47:11it's a truth and privacy policy situation. Trespass,
- 47:18we see that. Wire fraud, we see those claims.
- 47:22We've created for you a little bit of summary
- 47:24of some of the statutes, the damages, and the
- 47:29defenses. And we've gone over all this. But you'll
- 47:32see at the bottom. What's the common defense?
- 47:36Consent. But again, to really get that consent,
- 47:39you need to know just what your data is doing.
- 47:44That data flow needs to be mapped out. And that's
- 47:47sometimes not so easy. A lot of clients don't
- 47:51know that, what they're doing. So here's a theory
- 47:54that Mike and I have been seeing a lot of. And
- 47:57that is the fraudulent consent banner. Mike,
- 48:01do you want to take this on or do you want me
- 48:02to? Yeah, well, I'll take it on just because
- 48:05I've had a couple of interesting experience with
- 48:08with high -end organizations who have assured
- 48:10me that their banners work So let's start with
- 48:15the with the unit unifying theory the website
- 48:17displays a consent banner promising visitors
- 48:20can reject tracking, right? This is what both
- 48:22Matt and I hear all the time. We have a banner
- 48:25It's really accessible. It's right in your face.
- 48:29You can press a button online and you're gone
- 48:32Not a problem, right? And the banner designed
- 48:34as a defensive tool becomes affirmative evidence
- 48:36of it knowing where you get down to on this is
- 48:40that a lot of these banner technologies do not
- 48:43work. And here's the interesting thing. If they
- 48:47do not work, it kind of doesn't make any difference
- 48:50if you the organization were aware they didn't
- 48:52work or not. OK, the problem is that it is such
- 48:57a big deal in the state of California, such a
- 49:00big deal. that the mere fact that you were displaying
- 49:03it on a publicly accessible website, the implication
- 49:07is that it works. It gave you a sense of safety
- 49:11as a consumer, a sense of security, a sense of
- 49:14respect for the retailer, and it didn't work.
- 49:16Not only didn't it work, but if it didn't work,
- 49:19all kinds of personal information is going to
- 49:22third parties as a result of your interaction
- 49:24with that website. And so if you're a defense
- 49:27lawyer, it's really problematic. And the causes
- 49:31of action are fraud, which may not be terribly
- 49:34difficult to prove. The burden of proof might
- 49:38be a little harder, but the fact that a misrepresentation
- 49:42was made to thousands, if not millions of consumers,
- 49:46that all you got to do is click here and you're
- 49:48safe. Your data is safe with us. Unjust enrichment.
- 49:52There's no question that if you push the button
- 49:56and thought that the manipulation of your data
- 50:00and the sale and transfer of it to third parties
- 50:02for monetary gain was not happening. But in fact,
- 50:05it was happening. There was an unjust enrichment.
- 50:07And then there's digital fingerprinting, which
- 50:10can get really technical. Here's the bottom line.
- 50:14I've said this before. And the plaintiff's lawyers
- 50:18know this very well. A lot of lawyers who defend
- 50:23an organization's engaged to defend these claims
- 50:25do not know this. But it's something that has
- 50:28to be known. and that is the typical organization
- 50:31does not know what's going on in connection with
- 50:34its website. When Matt and I first started doing
- 50:37this, we were kind of surprised by that. We would
- 50:40ask, okay, so could you give us a, you know,
- 50:43a pixel audit? Like, what's that? Or you tell,
- 50:48can you, who's in control of your pixels and
- 50:50trackers? We'll get back to you on that. Or what
- 50:55we often hear and see and experience is that
- 51:00We'll ask the question. The company representative
- 51:03will say, not a problem. We'll get back to you
- 51:04with the information. And they'll get back to
- 51:07us after a lot of prodding, basically telling
- 51:10us that their third party ad technology people,
- 51:13advertising technology people are really offended
- 51:16by the kind of deep probing we're doing and the
- 51:21pesky questions we're asking. Matt said a few
- 51:25moments ago that it could be kind of expensive.
- 51:27to figure out what's going on on your website.
- 51:30We can tell you that looking at a pretty robust
- 51:35e -commerce website, an audit to determine what's
- 51:39going on that's actually effective in the sense
- 51:42of constituting proof, it's about $25 ,000 at
- 51:45a minimum. And it goes up from there. Yeah. And
- 51:50the problem is this consent banner. Some of the
- 51:53claims that we've seen have been very, very high
- 51:56value. And some of the firms are going after
- 51:59them. The Bursar firm, which was the one on the
- 52:02variety media, I believe they go after them.
- 52:06And then we also see that what it does is it
- 52:11fits hand in glove with existing claims. So you
- 52:15want to go to an ECPA claim. Now you argue that,
- 52:20well, we get rid of the one -party consent. because
- 52:24you committed fraud with your consent banner.
- 52:27So now they can go after that. So that's a problem.
- 52:31One of the things that we see is some interesting
- 52:37data points about the technology. What we see
- 52:41in the evidence is often before the consumer
- 52:48has the opportunity to opt in or opt out, immediately
- 52:52upon landing on the website, there are a variety
- 52:56of pixels and cookies that are launched. Now,
- 53:00there is essential versus non -essential. And
- 53:02that's certainly something that we see under
- 53:04the EU model and might go on for that all day
- 53:09long about that. But the issue is that happens
- 53:12before people have any opportunity to opt in
- 53:15or out. It happens in a nanosecond. And as one
- 53:19of the other many slides in here says, your information
- 53:24could be sent to over 100 third -party destinations
- 53:27before you even get to the consent stuff. Yeah.
- 53:32And obviously, that's just a field day for a
- 53:38plaintiff's lawyer. The tracking that goes on
- 53:43even after post -op, we see that. and it can
- 53:47be all kinds of information. Again, we talked
- 53:50about this advanced matching technology, screen
- 53:54resolution, CPU, browser. Again, why would you
- 53:59care about that? Well, as a consumer, that information
- 54:02is being used to create a fingerprint to be able
- 54:06to reverse append and identify who you are for
- 54:10marketing purposes. Kind of interesting here.
- 54:14Pardon the interruption. What we're seeing now
- 54:17with some of the more advanced technology is
- 54:19that even when a site is what we call it obfuscating
- 54:23or anonymizing the information, there are some
- 54:27instances we've seen where as few as seven data
- 54:32points can be used to identify a specific individual
- 54:37someplace in the United States. That's that's
- 54:41what we have seen. So, you know, Viewed from
- 54:45one perspective, the kinds of complaints against
- 54:48organizations that we're seeing have a lot of
- 54:51validity in the sense that they are engaging
- 54:55in some very intrusive practices. But again,
- 54:58and I know I probably sound repetitive. To me,
- 55:01the real issue is that a lot of these organizations
- 55:03don't even know that a lot of them do. But a
- 55:05lot of these organizations don't even know the
- 55:07totality of what's going on. And when they think
- 55:09they're taking remedial action, they're not.
- 55:13It's just not effective. It's like, well, we've
- 55:16kind of fit. We put multi -factor authentication
- 55:18on 75 % of the devices in ours, so we're safe,
- 55:21right? Or we plugged 18 of the 25 holes in the
- 55:27dike, so we're safe from the flood, right? That's
- 55:30really what it amounts to. And we see that over
- 55:32and over and over again. Yeah, absolutely. So
- 55:36let's move on. We're running out of time here,
- 55:37and we appreciate everybody sticking with us.
- 55:41So practical advice. So let's talk about that.
- 55:44So Senate Bill 690 is now the law. You're going
- 55:48to have to look at the impact on your client's
- 55:51existing claims. Certainly, you're going to have
- 55:56to look at matters that are going to be expiring
- 55:59or barred pretty soon. Whether or not you're
- 56:02going to do a motion to stay, motion dismissed,
- 56:05whatever you're going to do. We talked about
- 56:07auditing website tracking technologies. You really
- 56:11should have a data map. It's the easiest way
- 56:13to know what's happening. what you're exposed
- 56:15for, how to tailor a consent mechanism, which
- 56:21obviously is next. And then you should really
- 56:27look at the other theories, because that is what
- 56:32is coming around. And we can look at the way
- 56:35we deal with that. The vendor contracts, we talked
- 56:38about the data privacy agreements. You know,
- 56:44make sure that you get those in place so that
- 56:46the third parties who are processing, you know,
- 56:49your downstream data processors are not using
- 56:53that data for anything other than the purposes
- 56:56for which they're engaged and are keeping it
- 56:58confidential. Last thing you want to do is find
- 57:00out that they're selling it to some data broker.
- 57:03You know, prepare for regulatory scrutiny. Look,
- 57:06I'm sure everybody here has seen it. You get
- 57:09a letter from the AG DOJ. You know, they send,
- 57:13you know, hey, you have two weeks, give us all
- 57:15this information. You should be prepared to be
- 57:17able to respond to it. Some of my clients, you
- 57:19know, prophylactically will have a nice binder
- 57:22of all their information ready to go because
- 57:26last thing you want to do is be scrambling when
- 57:29you get those inquiries. It also is a good way
- 57:32to prepare yourself for a litigation defense.
- 57:36You know, litigation playbook, you know, look,
- 57:38depends on your clients. Some clients have A
- 57:41lot higher litigation risks are more prominent.
- 57:45They are. You should think about a standardized
- 57:48response because, look, if you have a standardized
- 57:51program that you're always responding to, you're
- 57:53doing the same practice, you can, of course,
- 57:57as a defense attorney or as a company, you can
- 58:02reduce your litigation spend. Another thing is
- 58:04you've got to figure out what you're going to
- 58:05do. Some companies, they get a lot of demands.
- 58:09What they need to do is they need to make themselves
- 58:12not be a soft target anymore. That is a very
- 58:15viable defense strategy. You need to let the
- 58:17plaintiff's bar know, if you come to us, we're
- 58:19going to make you earn your money. And likewise,
- 58:23and for those who come in with a really low demand,
- 58:26you reward them. Look, if you want 2 ,500 bucks
- 58:30maybe, then maybe we'll... We'll give it to you
- 58:34and go away with a notice and cure, et cetera,
- 58:37enterprise by release, all the things to protect
- 58:39your client. But if you come in higher than that,
- 58:43you'll see us at appellate level. You might be
- 58:46worth pointing out something that you said previously,
- 58:49and that is, and we see this all the time. There's
- 58:54a lot you can do and a lot you can't do, but
- 58:55there's one thing that's almost completely within
- 58:58your control. and that is the content of your
- 59:01privacy policy in your terms of use. That's one
- 59:05of the first things that a plaintiff's lawyer
- 59:06or regulator is gonna look at, what you say to
- 59:09people you do and don't do in your privacy policy
- 59:12in terms of use. If you can substantiate that
- 59:15those two documents accurately portray your privacy
- 59:18and security practices, you will be viewed certainly
- 59:22by regulators as a solution and not a problem.
- 59:26you will very often be viewed by a plaintiff's
- 59:29lawyer as, you know, we thought this was gonna
- 59:32be easier. Why don't we try to get rid of this
- 59:36one very quickly and move on to some lower hanging
- 59:38fruit, right? But again, see, and Matt can chime
- 59:44in here is we'll look at a privacy policy and
- 59:47it's simply not consistent with what we're seeing
- 59:49on the website. Yeah, so privacy policies certainly
- 59:53need to be updated. We all know that websites
- 59:55are updated daily, if not hourly, for some people,
- 1:00:00or some websites. And one of the issues that
- 1:00:02we often see as well is some of the larger enterprises
- 1:00:05use template websites. So you may have 10, 15,
- 1:00:10maybe even 20 brands all using the same template
- 1:00:12website. So they use the same forms, the same
- 1:00:14privacy policy. But the websites may operate
- 1:00:17differently. So that's important. And again,
- 1:00:20we're talking, there's websites, they go to multiple
- 1:00:25states. So you got to watch out for that. That
- 1:00:30is a challenge, especially for California lawyers,
- 1:00:33but a lot of firms either partner up with other
- 1:00:35states or have offices. Key takeaways, 690 is
- 1:00:41a... is a carve out. It's not a reset. We know
- 1:00:45that there will still be other litigation. The
- 1:00:47retroactivity will be litigated and we definitely
- 1:00:51know that consent is the disclosure and consent
- 1:00:56are great defenses. But not too far off on our
- 1:01:03time estimates. I'm very proud of that. Looks
- 1:01:06like we have a couple of questions here. Hilary,
- 1:01:10do you want to read us the questions? I'm still
- 1:01:13scrolling down. If you want to read them, I do
- 1:01:15see them. I'm trying to scroll down to that page.
- 1:01:17If you, Matt, I apologize. I had a couple of
- 1:01:20questions, too, if you'd like to. Okay, yeah.
- 1:01:22Go ahead. So you want to hit us with your questions?
- 1:01:30Yeah, I do. To give our audience an idea of how
- 1:01:33common, you know, there's always the impulse
- 1:01:38to say, These guys are so smart with both of
- 1:01:42you are, and they're dealing with these major
- 1:01:44companies. And how many of these claims are you
- 1:01:47actually getting? It's like, man, I know we've
- 1:01:48talked about this in terms of ADA defense. Mike,
- 1:01:51we've had conversations about AI and other presentations.
- 1:01:55Can you let our, I mean, is it just the Kmart's
- 1:01:58and the Kraft's and the Johnson and Johnson are
- 1:02:01getting these claims? How does this affect the
- 1:02:03everyday, small to mid -sized business and putting
- 1:02:07them at risk? Because that's what a lot of our
- 1:02:08clients are. But it really depends on the claimant.
- 1:02:13For a while, there was a particular pro se litigant
- 1:02:17who was very prolific. He was ultimately declared
- 1:02:19a vexatious litigant. And he did have a checkered
- 1:02:23background. And he was hitting everybody. One
- 1:02:28plaintiff's attorney estimated that this pro
- 1:02:33se litigant had made $10 ,000. demand letters
- 1:02:38in one month alone. And so certainly we see that.
- 1:02:42I mean, we see a lot, we see a lot. I would say,
- 1:02:48when I say three to five a day coming through
- 1:02:50our firm, I think that's down, that's understating
- 1:02:53it. We get them all the time. Some of them, there
- 1:02:58are so many coming from some of these firms that
- 1:03:00when we contact them, they can't even keep track.
- 1:03:04of which demand or claim they've made on our
- 1:03:07clients. Some of them, they lose the claims because
- 1:03:10they're just that busy. They're spamming everybody.
- 1:03:13It's a little bit ironic that they're spamming
- 1:03:16people for privacy claims. But they're very common.
- 1:03:21Again, I think the smaller the defendant, the
- 1:03:24higher the risk, because again, they know. There's
- 1:03:31a whole section of the of the plaintiff's bar
- 1:03:33and obviously I do not disparage the plaintiff's
- 1:03:36bar. I do a lot of plaintiff's work myself and
- 1:03:39they do a very important role and they're definitely
- 1:03:45there but there's some good and bad in every
- 1:03:48group and some of them will go after smaller
- 1:03:51businesses just because They have a harder time
- 1:03:54defending themselves. And I've had some where
- 1:03:56I've had some very small businesses who really
- 1:03:58can't even afford to hire us. But we took on
- 1:04:01the engagement for a limited matter. And we showed
- 1:04:03them, look, this is an elderly couple. They're
- 1:04:09in their 80s. They really don't do business anymore.
- 1:04:12This website's just about some sweaters or scarves
- 1:04:16that The wife knits every now and they don't
- 1:04:24have that they're on a fixed income. They're
- 1:04:25not doing any sales and you'll hear you'll hear
- 1:04:28back from the plaintiff's attorney. Well, if
- 1:04:30they don't have any money, they can't certainly
- 1:04:32can't pay you to defend themselves. We'll take
- 1:04:34a payment plan secured by a deed of trust, you
- 1:04:36know, that type of stuff. So so certainly small
- 1:04:40businesses and small companies are absolutely
- 1:04:43not. Well, that's why in the LA Times, it was
- 1:04:49called the potential existential threat. For
- 1:04:50a lot of small organizations, the margins are
- 1:04:53so small that $5 ,000 or $10 ,000, do we want
- 1:04:59to stay in business? Do we not want to stay in
- 1:05:01business? A lot of the plaintiff's firms do not
- 1:05:03care. Look, I do plaintiff's privacy work myself.
- 1:05:07I have a lot of respect for people to do this
- 1:05:08the right way for the right reasons. Some of
- 1:05:11this is abusive. There's no question about it.
- 1:05:12But on the other hand, interestingly enough,
- 1:05:16all of this is made possible by practices deployed
- 1:05:19by the big platforms. I mean, without them, none
- 1:05:24of this stuff would happen. And you know, no
- 1:05:27offense to them. I mean, I like some some kinds
- 1:05:30of targeted ads myself. It can be very difficult
- 1:05:32dealing with them. in terms of your own efforts
- 1:05:35as an organization to control your privacy risk
- 1:05:38service. They're very opaque when it comes to
- 1:05:42providing information, even information they've
- 1:05:44actually collected from your own website. And
- 1:05:48a footnote to my last comments. There are some
- 1:05:51plaintiff's attorneys who are very honorable
- 1:05:53who, by way of example, who I have settled with.
- 1:05:58I settle a case with them. And then like a month
- 1:06:01later, we'll get another demand letter from the
- 1:06:03same firm and I'll say, hey, guys, we just settled
- 1:06:06with you. What's going on here? And they'll say,
- 1:06:10oh, you know what? We're sorry. We'll withdraw
- 1:06:14that claim. We had a deal. We're going to give
- 1:06:17you some time to fix your practices. And we'll
- 1:06:20come back later and see how you guys are doing.
- 1:06:23So there are some firms that are very honorable.
- 1:06:25And obviously, other firms who are not. Same
- 1:06:29thing on both sides of the bar. Are you starting
- 1:06:33to see, I know we've discussed it in other contexts,
- 1:06:36what courts are saying, hey, we've had it with
- 1:06:37you guys. You know, if we're going to be abusing
- 1:06:39the process. I don't mean the vexatious, I mean
- 1:06:41the attorneys that are representing these people
- 1:06:44knowing that, you know, and again, there's good
- 1:06:47reason for these laws, I understand, but. And
- 1:06:50are you seeing contribution and indemnity? Because
- 1:06:52I've represented companies like in what Mike
- 1:06:56is talking about, and they usually have long
- 1:06:58terms of things like that that limit their liability.
- 1:07:02But does it really? Well, I'd say you raised
- 1:07:05two good points. So judicial attitude, I think
- 1:07:08it depends on the lawyer. I've certainly seen
- 1:07:10lawyers who have worn out their welcome with
- 1:07:12judges. This morning I was at a hearing over
- 1:07:16sanctions and a vexatious litigant. declaration,
- 1:07:21two separate motions. And we did actually achieve
- 1:07:24an award of sanctions against the other side
- 1:07:27for 128 .5 violation. But it depends on the lawyer,
- 1:07:32right? I mean, if a lawyer is going to make valid
- 1:07:36arguments and litigate in a way that's appropriate
- 1:07:40within the confines of the rules, I think every
- 1:07:43judge allows people to have their day in court.
- 1:07:45I mean, it's constitutional right. to position
- 1:07:48your grievances. So I don't think there's anything
- 1:07:50wrong with that, and I think a lot of judges
- 1:07:52recognize that. But if you're coming in and you're
- 1:07:55making frivolous arguments, you're doing oppressive
- 1:07:57or abusive tactics, you're challenging rulings
- 1:08:01that you shouldn't be, you're taking positions
- 1:08:04that are really strained or unsupported, yeah,
- 1:08:06then that's going to catch up with you. And your
- 1:08:08reputation is going to be not so great with the
- 1:08:11judges. I'm not a judge, but I presume that Judges
- 1:08:17talk about their work with each other. I talk
- 1:08:19with my work with my coworkers around the proverbial
- 1:08:22water cooler. I'm sure if somebody's going in
- 1:08:24and making bad arguments all day long, the other
- 1:08:28judges probably know about it. And I've definitely
- 1:08:32seen some lawyers who come in to court, and they
- 1:08:35get all the deference in the world from the judges,
- 1:08:37because the judges know, hey, look, I've seen
- 1:08:39this person 100 times, and they're honorable,
- 1:08:41and they're a great lawyer. And I've seen other
- 1:08:43lawyers who come in, and I don't have to say
- 1:08:45anything. I can sit back and watch the judges
- 1:08:47tear them apart, because they've made one too
- 1:08:51many frivolous arguments. On indemnity, boy,
- 1:08:55Hillary, get the nail on the head. These contracts.
- 1:08:58have usually huge limitations on liability, all
- 1:09:03kinds of exculpatory clauses. And some of them
- 1:09:08are, especially if it's with a larger platform,
- 1:09:12who needs who more, right? So a small business
- 1:09:16needs their digital and app marketing a lot more
- 1:09:19than maybe the platform. Cameras and privacy
- 1:09:26there and other privacy areas. And so they have
- 1:09:28these link to the, and then they update the terms
- 1:09:31of use. So you sign it 3 or 4 years ago and they
- 1:09:33update it continually without any kind of notification.
- 1:09:36We might what are your thoughts? Well, I've run
- 1:09:39into that all the time and. At a recent program,
- 1:09:43I told people, by the way, it's not just the
- 1:09:46contract, it's the, it's the 8 links in the contract
- 1:09:49to other elements of the contract. that are constantly
- 1:09:53in play, right? And here's the issue. If you're
- 1:09:59running a Pilati studio, you are not an expert
- 1:10:03in digital contracts. You're just not, right?
- 1:10:07And the problem is one of asymmetry. The problem
- 1:10:11is that I'm a business owner or I'm operating
- 1:10:14a business. I need this service. I don't have
- 1:10:17time to read this stuff. And by the way, and
- 1:10:20I've been... I've been hearing this one since
- 1:10:23the very first time I ever did one of these cases.
- 1:10:25Why would anybody be interested in targeting
- 1:10:28us, quote, unquote? If they only knew, right?
- 1:10:33The last thing not mentioned in the deck but
- 1:10:36should is that there is some possibility of insurance
- 1:10:40to cover these claims and it's not terribly expensive.
- 1:10:45Well, it depends on the company and the policies.
- 1:10:49I have some clients who do have insurance for
- 1:10:52this, but they have a huge SIR, like a $5 million
- 1:10:55SIR. It's like earthquake insurance, right? Why
- 1:11:00am I buying this? Well, you're buying it for
- 1:11:03that one chance, right? Something goes really
- 1:11:05bad. That happened with cyber security, too.
- 1:11:08I used to have a pretty cheap policy for the
- 1:11:10firm. And then they became a big area, as you
- 1:11:15both know, particularly Mike. And now they're
- 1:11:17like, yeah, they don't sell the small businesses,
- 1:11:19small firms anymore because they're too expensive.
- 1:11:22You were getting too good a deal. the rates have
- 1:11:25really gone up once they realized all these claims
- 1:11:27were coming in. So one of the one of the issues
- 1:11:30and there are some new carriers who have sprung
- 1:11:32up who are willing to take these greater risks.
- 1:11:33But one of the problems with a smaller organization,
- 1:11:36if you're looking at one of the big carriers,
- 1:11:39you will never be able to complete their application
- 1:11:43questionnaire to their satisfaction. The application
- 1:11:47questionnaires have gotten very, very lengthy,
- 1:11:49very substantive because the underwriters even
- 1:11:54with the privacy claims, the underwriters completely
- 1:11:57missed this in 2023, 2024. It's taken them several
- 1:12:03years to catch up and we're all paying for it
- 1:12:06right now. But that doesn't mean that it's not
- 1:12:08something people shouldn't think about, right?
- 1:12:11Yeah, it is a writer or something or some sort
- 1:12:14of coverage. Of course, as the other one, if
- 1:12:16these companies are springing up, we've probably
- 1:12:19all had this, the insurance company that goes
- 1:12:21out of business. I had this actually, I have
- 1:12:24two clients and they go, it was a cheaper deal.
- 1:12:28I thought it'd be, they're not around anymore.
- 1:12:31Sorry. Yeah, the California Insurance Quaranty
- 1:12:34Association, right? SIGA, make a claim to that.
- 1:12:37One of the things that Matt and I are, with some
- 1:12:40frequency, telling our clients is that if you're
- 1:12:42not going to read anything, read the Google Analytics
- 1:12:46terms of service. It doesn't say what you think
- 1:12:51it says. or what your broker says it says, right?
- 1:12:55Yeah, I mean, a lot of organizations simply misunderstand
- 1:12:59how to control Google Analytics. Yes, a great
- 1:13:03deal of it is very benign, but for purposes of
- 1:13:06California law privacy compliance, a great deal
- 1:13:08of it is not benign. And if you do not understand
- 1:13:12how it works, and part of it is just reading
- 1:13:15it and talking to the people who actually have
- 1:13:19their hands on the on and off switches. I'm licensed
- 1:13:23in Montana and they actually have there. I was
- 1:13:26really, I was going, I went to an MCA last, I
- 1:13:27didn't know. If the endorsements and everything
- 1:13:29specifically aren't attached, you don't have
- 1:13:31coverage. You have to have, I don't, I'm not
- 1:13:35saying it's okay, but like, so if you think you
- 1:13:37bought this and you don't have it, the certified
- 1:13:40endorsements, it's not covered. I mean, it's
- 1:13:43an evolving area, but it's like, you know, you
- 1:13:45think you're paying for something, you are paying
- 1:13:46for something, you don't have the paperwork,
- 1:13:48it's too late. So it's. It doesn't exactly, it's
- 1:13:52still confidence, I would say. Yeah, absolutely.
- 1:13:55So in the chat, we have a couple of written questions.
- 1:14:00So the first one talks about AI tools and transcription
- 1:14:05and privacy. Mike will probably be giving at
- 1:14:09Beverly Hills Bar Association a AI privacy talk.
- 1:14:14Not to commit him to that yet, but he's in the
- 1:14:16process of exploring that to address. to address
- 1:14:20that issue about whether or not an AI transcription
- 1:14:27of a call, et cetera, constitutes any violation
- 1:14:32of privacy. I don't know if Mike's prepared to
- 1:14:35address that at this time. I can't address it.
- 1:14:39It may or may not. It may or may not, depending
- 1:14:43upon the disclosure. I mean, if you look at the
- 1:14:49law, right? You can read it very easily to make
- 1:14:55it, I think, fairly clear that if you figure,
- 1:14:58hey, nobody's going to care, so I'm not going
- 1:15:00to mention it to anybody and there's no banner
- 1:15:02any place, I'm just going to have AI. And by
- 1:15:05the way, we've all had situations where you look
- 1:15:07at your phone and you realize that it's like
- 1:15:10the entire conversation is being transcribed
- 1:15:13because you forgot to turn a control off or a
- 1:15:16control was triggered without your knowledge,
- 1:15:18which is probably the more likely scenario. But
- 1:15:20yeah, that is a potential, and by the way, that's
- 1:15:24a potential national security risk. That's where
- 1:15:26that kind of stuff is arising with some frequency.
- 1:15:30Yeah. Yeah, and potential waivers of certain
- 1:15:34types of confidentiality as well. Absolutely,
- 1:15:37yeah. Yeah. And then so Jeffrey Titus asks us,
- 1:15:42what is the definition of violation demand letter
- 1:15:44seen to multiple, I think it means multiply,
- 1:15:48the number of trackers times 5 ,000? What if
- 1:15:53a single visit to a website? And that's a very
- 1:15:55good question, right? Because they say, look,
- 1:15:58you have 20 trackers on your website. I've never
- 1:16:01really seen 20 trackers. I usually see five to
- 1:16:0310 at the most. But if 20 trackers, I want five
- 1:16:07grand, each give me 100 grand. Or my client visits
- 1:16:09your website, your client's website, five times
- 1:16:12a day. I want $5 ,000 per time. The violation,
- 1:16:19that's not clearly defined. It's obviously something
- 1:16:22we argue about quite a bit. And again, it's one
- 1:16:27of these areas where you'll never get the plaintiffs
- 1:16:29to agree. Hillary mentioned ADA. We have a violation
- 1:16:35required, some statutory clarification, under
- 1:16:38the Honorary Civil Rights Act on that. And they
- 1:16:41gave us some great clarification on what that
- 1:16:44is. I would think that somebody visits a website,
- 1:16:52at least my position is, if you visit a website,
- 1:16:56if there's five trackers or one tracker, it's
- 1:17:00still the same. You don't get to multiply it
- 1:17:02by how many. pixel beacons are there or how many
- 1:17:05cookies are being deployed. I mean, that's my
- 1:17:07interpretation of it. Mike, do you agree? Yeah,
- 1:17:10it's mine as well. And then you have the other
- 1:17:16issue. And that is, how do you calculate the
- 1:17:20number of instances in a way that's rational?
- 1:17:22Because if you actually do a robust assessment
- 1:17:27of what actually happened in a particular visit,
- 1:17:30you're going to see things that under a certain
- 1:17:34viewpoint could equate to multiple thousands
- 1:17:38and thousands and thousands of dollars. At that
- 1:17:41point, you're getting into some very interesting
- 1:17:43issues of potential estoppels. That's when somebody
- 1:17:46comes back to a website three or four times,
- 1:17:48knowing that there's going to be a violation.
- 1:17:50That plaintiff probably may have an issue. The
- 1:17:55doctrine of lenity, in other words, it's a criminal
- 1:17:57statute and therefore has to be more narrowly
- 1:17:59construed, may have more significance in that
- 1:18:02context where where it literally is existential.
- 1:18:06I mean, there's simply not enough money in your
- 1:18:10world to pay for it. But again, Matt points out
- 1:18:14something that I think should not be overlooked
- 1:18:18and that is quite a few of the lawyers we work
- 1:18:20with, they're very good lawyers. They're top
- 1:18:24flight, ethical, plaintiffs, lawyers. many of
- 1:18:28them doing good work. And then as he also points
- 1:18:31out, and we've all run into them, they're the
- 1:18:34bad people on that bunch as well. And they're
- 1:18:36very, very difficult to deal with. I think that
- 1:18:40my big takeaway is that if your MTA is civil
- 1:18:45litigation and you don't know anything about
- 1:18:46digital advertising or what goes on in websites,
- 1:18:50please do not undertake one of these. without
- 1:18:54at least going online and doing a little research
- 1:18:56because it is seriously complex technology. Yeah,
- 1:19:02absolutely. The next one corrects question is
- 1:19:05on the front end, what measures can consumers
- 1:19:08or sole lawyers take to reduce their exposure
- 1:19:11to surveillance systems like these? I mean, your
- 1:19:14website browser has settings. You can absolutely
- 1:19:17change your digital marketing and settings. There's
- 1:19:20a lot of privacy settings in your browser. Can
- 1:19:24I add something to that? Absolutely, please.
- 1:19:26So this is kind of important from an operational
- 1:19:28perspective. Matt, I know hears this all the
- 1:19:32time. I hear this all the time. Talk to my ad
- 1:19:34tech people. They said we were good. That's meaningless
- 1:19:37to us as lawyers and should be meaningless to
- 1:19:41an operator as well because the ad tech people
- 1:19:44do not view this digital information for purposes
- 1:19:48of valuing its for purpose of its value in the
- 1:19:53context of a legal claim, right? So they're missing
- 1:19:56all kinds of, so this is no slap against them.
- 1:19:59They're capable, but many of them are very capable
- 1:20:01people. They're simply not looking at this as
- 1:20:05some of Matt's and my technical colleagues are
- 1:20:07looking at this stuff like, okay, here's a potential
- 1:20:10claim, here's a potential claim, here's a potential
- 1:20:12claim, right? And so it's critical to... when
- 1:20:19you're having this dialogue to know enough about
- 1:20:22what's going on so that you can get beyond, okay,
- 1:20:25so when you say we're good, that means that we
- 1:20:29are only collecting metadata for purposes of
- 1:20:32enabling the session, right? Oh, well, you didn't
- 1:20:35ask. I gotta go back and look at that one. I
- 1:20:38mean, that's because that, and that happens all
- 1:20:40the time. It's that follow -up question that
- 1:20:44you need to be in a position to ask. And so the
- 1:20:48last question is, can I use AI to help protect
- 1:20:52against a CIPA claim or an ADA website access
- 1:21:03claim? I mean, certainly you can. You may not
- 1:21:07be very good at it, but you could use it. I mean,
- 1:21:11AI is only as good as... is the prompts and directions.
- 1:21:15And you really have to understand both issues.
- 1:21:17Look, AI gets better and better by the day, but
- 1:21:20it has to be used very carefully. There are companies
- 1:21:24out there, kind of a cottage industry, so to
- 1:21:27say, who have recognized the large amount of
- 1:21:32these claims. And what they have done is they
- 1:21:36have marketed themselves as being in the compliance
- 1:21:39space to try to help you overcome these issues.
- 1:21:43Certainly, there's a couple of things. Certainly,
- 1:21:45you can do that with counsel. And certainly,
- 1:21:51there are ways of properly engaging those people
- 1:21:54to protect their work and their analysis as work
- 1:21:58product, or even attorney -client privilege,
- 1:22:01if you do it properly, in case you get some really
- 1:22:05bad news. But a lot of these statutes are somewhat
- 1:22:06strict liability. So it doesn't really matter
- 1:22:09what you know. if you're out of compliance. But
- 1:22:13nevertheless, there are companies out there that
- 1:22:16specialize in this. A lot of our clients work
- 1:22:19with that. But additionally, when I first started
- 1:22:24doing website access 20 -something years ago,
- 1:22:31maybe even more, website access wasn't even looked
- 1:22:35at under ADA. There were companies out there
- 1:22:39who were very, very, very expensive who would
- 1:22:42act as website access consultants. And these
- 1:22:46were programmers with very specialized expertise
- 1:22:50that nobody else had. Well, now, just about any
- 1:22:56competent website programmer or developer knows
- 1:23:00how to make a website accessible. There's lots
- 1:23:03of software out there to test it, lots of things
- 1:23:05to help you figure out how to do that and a lot
- 1:23:10of guidelines. Also, the regulations are very
- 1:23:12clear. They're suggested, not formally at the
- 1:23:16WCAG, and they help you figure out what are some
- 1:23:19of the concepts you're going to try to develop
- 1:23:22towards. I think similar situation is developing
- 1:23:28for SIPA as well. where the knowledge is being
- 1:23:35instituted throughout the development database,
- 1:23:39or marketplace rather, where more and more people
- 1:23:41are learning how to, people in the development
- 1:23:46side and the digital marketing, learning how
- 1:23:49to be able to change the settings and the functionality
- 1:23:53of your digital marketing. Of course, council
- 1:23:58needs to work with them to make sure that the
- 1:24:01right types of information are either being disclosed
- 1:24:06or consented to if you're collecting them or
- 1:24:10turned off, and making sure that those types
- 1:24:15of data, the default settings don't go back in
- 1:24:18place. So I hope that helps. Yeah. I think that
- 1:24:26without professional assistance, there's quite
- 1:24:29a bit you can do as a business operator. But
- 1:24:33there's a limit to something because of the nature
- 1:24:35of the technology involved, right? I mean, so
- 1:24:37if you're one of those people who goes on to
- 1:24:40Reddit and sees here are the seven things you
- 1:24:42need to do, that's not going to be terribly efficacious
- 1:24:45because the challenge with all these technologies,
- 1:24:47all these environments is you have to be able
- 1:24:50to operationalize this stuff. Operationalizing
- 1:24:53privacy is where the rubber hits the road. There
- 1:24:56are a lot of platitudes, a lot of aphorisms,
- 1:24:59a lot of smooth sounding sayings about how easy
- 1:25:02it is. It's not that easy. It's not that easy
- 1:25:05because there's a lot of stuff going on that
- 1:25:08neither you nor your website administrator are
- 1:25:11seeing on a daily basis, but it is doable. Great.
- 1:25:18All right. Well, I think we're pretty much out
- 1:25:21of time. I know I have a 3 .30, so I'd like to
- 1:25:24thank everybody so much for all your time. And
- 1:25:29for attendance to this, I checked and I saw that
- 1:25:32there were quite a few attendees and it's very
- 1:25:35flattering. Thank you both of you for coming.
- 1:25:38Mike, I hope you'll attend other ones. Matt,
- 1:25:40I'm sure we'll see you at others. Thank both
- 1:25:42of you for your time and your expertise. We really
- 1:25:45appreciate it, particularly on a Friday afternoon.
- 1:25:47And as you may know, you're up in the Bay or
- 1:25:48in the LA heat wave. My temperature says 100.
- 1:25:51So all of you, thank you and have a great weekend.
- 1:25:54Happy fall. Thank you very much. Take care. Thank
- 1:25:56you, everybody.