Latest / Elsies Little Pickles’s Podcast / Arguing With My Son: The Free Speech Showdown
Transcript
- 0:00I am James Madison. I want to thank you all for assisting me today with the
- 0:05historic task of drafting our first ten amendments for our new Constitution.
- 0:11The first amendment that I would recommend would be this one.
- 0:15It's pretty straightforward. It's freedom of religion, freedom of speech,
- 0:20freedom of the press, freedom to assemble.
- 0:24I love it. It's not bad, I guess.
- 0:28Great. Moving along then, Second Amendment is, yes, Tim.
- 0:34This whole freedom of speech thing, how exactly would that work?
- 0:39A free people should be able to think and speak freely without the government stopping it.
- 0:48Now, moving on to the second amendment.
- 0:53Yes, Tim. Like, what if someone says something that you disagree with?
- 0:56Or what if someone says something that hurts you feel?
- 0:59It's like if someone said James Madison is an oafish Galumpus who needs to shut
- 1:03his potato trap mouth if he knows what's good for him.
- 1:05Would that be projected to be? That would be very hurtful. But yes,
- 1:09it's not the government's job to come in and tell its citizenry whether or not
- 1:13it can and can't say something.
- 1:14If somebody decided to insult me, you know, I'm a man.
- 1:18I can take it. So the ability to insult anyone will be a guaranteed right.
- 1:24I love America. Wait, wait, wait, wait, wait. No, let's slow this down.
- 1:29If people can say whatever they want, we're going to need to provide for spaces
- 1:34that are safe from free speech. No, that defeats the whole purpose.
- 1:39We must be able to use the words we wish without fear of prosecution.
- 1:44I don't know about that, chief. Words can be violence, you know No,
- 1:48words are quite literally not violence Violence is violence and words are words
- 1:53You can't just go around changing definitions all the time All willy-nilly See,
- 1:58I don't like that you just said that I am naming this section of the table here My safe space,
- 2:06Tim, that's ridiculous. Ah! You are in my safe space. You can't say that, okay?
- 2:13So, with this whole free speech thing, what happens if someone says something that's untrue?
- 2:19We're going to need a team of fact-checkers funded by the government to identify misinformation.
- 2:23The government would never fund fact-checkers against its own citizenry,
- 2:27not if the First Amendment has anything to say about it.
- 2:30I'd give it 250 years. Yeah, don't be a gullible, ignorant rube.
- 2:34Okay, moving on to the Second Amendment. Not so fast. What about cyberbullying?
- 2:40What about misgendering?
- 2:42What about jokes that punch down on marginalized communities?
- 2:46What about hate speech? What is hate speech?
- 2:50I think it's something like, I hate you, you scurvy knave. You have the wits
- 2:54of a damn... Turn it up, James Madison!
- 2:56You can't commit hate speech against him.
- 2:59He's a cis white male. You can only commit it against minorities and those on the fringes of society.
- 3:04Are you suggesting that we only protect speech that we agree with? Perfect.
- 3:11Congress shall make no law abridging speech that we agree with. Simple fix.
- 3:18Glad we worked that out. No, no, no. That undermines the whole purpose.
- 3:21We must protect all speech or no speech is safe. I like where you're going with
- 3:27that, but okay, hear me out.
- 3:29What if we only protected some speech?
- 3:33And who exactly would decide what speech is protected and what is not? I'll volunteer to do it.
- 3:40Problem solved. Are we done here? No, we are not.
- 3:44We're obviously going to go in circles on this, okay? So why don't we just put
- 3:48a pin in the First Amendment and move on to the Second?
- 3:52And what would that one be? The right to keep and bear arms.
- 3:57But if everyone has guns, how am I going to stop them from saying things I don't like?
- 4:34Your pickles elsie's icebreaker mission even
- 4:39if it's just a couple of bucks we could really appreciate that
- 4:42thanks and just off of that that
- 4:45intro intro clip i already feel
- 4:48my hair turning blue i i i'm living out over here that was that was we i got
- 4:55that from babylon b i want to thank them for for putting that together they
- 5:00it was online i grabbed it i thought it was perfect for this particular discussion.
- 5:04This is going to be a little bit of a different episode.
- 5:06This episode, we're... The much-awaited. Yeah, it's the airing of grievances.
- 5:14It's the big debate.
- 5:16It's something that Colton and I have been arguing over for about two years, right?
- 5:21Oh, longer than that. But Kiefer's been privy to it.
- 5:26Kiefer's been privy to this argument for the last two years.
- 5:30We've had iterations of this argument probably
- 5:33since what 2017 2018
- 5:37yeah in some form or fashion whenever
- 5:41that first chappelle special came out where he was talking about trans people
- 5:45i think that's where it originated anyways so what we're going to do is something
- 5:50you know i actually watched that the other night again just to reaffirm how
- 5:54i felt about it oh yeah yeah and Well, in that case,
- 5:59I'm glad we're not getting into individuals on, on this conversation.
- 6:03I, I, I still think it was very beautiful and poetic.
- 6:07Like just the way I, I heard him, the way I could read between the lines and
- 6:14then his last two sentences, I think were the most powerful,
- 6:18which is they were a beautiful person, whether or not you agree with them.
- 6:24But yeah, I mean, I kind of came on, that was my takeaway too.
- 6:28But a lot of people got upset about it.
- 6:31Colton, I don't want to speak for Colton, but Colton thought it was punching
- 6:36down, thought he could do better.
- 6:37And everyone's entitled to their own opinion. But what this show is about is
- 6:43we're getting deep into the argument. It's the final airing.
- 6:48It's the final airing of grievances between Colton and I. You and I both know that's not the case.
- 6:54Yeah, probably not. But we figured we'd bring our family argument to the Pickle Pod community.
- 6:59We'll give the definitive roadmap and then we can come back as needed. Yeah.
- 7:05So, Keith, I'll let you, since you're going to be the moderator in this debate,
- 7:10I'll let you kind of lay down what's going on here.
- 7:15Well, you know what? for over two years now,
- 7:20I've had to listen to these knuckleheads
- 7:23and two years of pickle-powered necroboxing on a ghost horse. Yeah.
- 7:33It's time for a final debate. If we were on pay-per-view, this would be like squiggly line porn.
- 7:42Now, I just have to point out, I take issue with the characterization of me
- 7:47as a knucklehead. I actually identify as a ne'er-do-weller.
- 7:52Duly noted. I'm just an instigator. I'm just an idiot with opinions. That's all I am.
- 8:01The knucklehead versus the ne'er-do-weller. Yeah. What the monkey considers
- 8:06business, the horse considers play.
- 8:10Again, as the great James Cornett says, hey, you're the one fucking the dog.
- 8:16I'm just the one holding its head.
- 8:18So not to get into it, but the rules are pretty simple. Each one of us will
- 8:24have opening statements.
- 8:26And then you will ask us a series of questions.
- 8:30Each of those questions is worth a point. And yes, both of us as master debaters
- 8:37have to keep their point to that particular question.
- 8:42We want to keep our answers short because there's going to be a fair amount
- 8:45of questions and a bunch of rebuttals.
- 8:48And each one of us is allowed one rebuttal per question.
- 8:51If you're bored with the answer, Kiefer, you get to basically end that particular
- 8:58conversation, and you get to say, shut your pie hole to whoever it is that's
- 9:04boring you in that particular conversation.
- 9:07Which will be noted by the...
- 9:10At the end, whoever has the most checks for shut your pie hole is the loser,
- 9:16and the one with the least checks is the winner.
- 9:19And if you're ready, I'm ready. Oh, and the last-minute rule on any counterpoint
- 9:26or rebuttal, Kiefer can also ask for elaboration, and that does not result in a strike. Correct.
- 9:35I think I'm also going to add a stipulation that you have two minutes to answer the question.
- 9:41I think that that should be relatively easy.
- 9:45Yeah, that's plenty. Yeah, that's plenty. I'll be looking at my clock here. Oh, I know you will.
- 9:50As long as it's not two minutes between us, we'll be okay. Yeah. No. Yeah.
- 9:56For each answer. And with that, I guess we just get started, right?
- 10:01Are you ready? Yeah, I suppose so. Let me, let me grab my scotch.
- 10:07So grab some no-dos. Let me get the straight. We flipped a coin. I can mix them.
- 10:12We flipped a coin before the show and I get opening statements.
- 10:17So I get to go first in opening statements and then Colton gets to go first
- 10:20in answering your round of questions. Fair enough.
- 10:25Cool. And with that, I will begin my opening statements.
- 10:29He wants parallel park to cargo ship on land.
- 10:35He once won an argument with a GPS.
- 10:42He once delivered a punchline so sharp the microphone filed a complaint.
- 10:48He is the most interesting Steve in America.
- 10:52Stay informed, my friends. He once got a tattoo of a butt on a butt on his butt.
- 11:03You got to tell everyone what kind of an ass I am. All right.
- 11:08So mine is less of an opening statement and more of a definition because I think
- 11:13a lot of people don't realize how many different views there are when it comes to freedom of speech.
- 11:17So I just want to go through them as quickly as possible. First and foremost,
- 11:21the one that most people are familiar with is absolutism.
- 11:23The core idea of speech should never be restricted because of its content, period.
- 11:29It's a classic. Free speech means free speech position.
- 11:32However, I tend to lean that way, but I don't think anyone can be an absolutist.
- 11:38Absolutely. I think that there's always carve-outs that are made.
- 11:42Absolutists usually believe government should not push ideas,
- 11:45even offensive, hateful, false, or should not punish ideas, even if they're
- 11:49offensive, hateful, false, or dangerous ones.
- 11:53The cure for bad speech is more speech, not censorship.
- 11:56Once the government gets the power to decide, bad ideas will abuse it.
- 12:00The strength is that it's a clean, principled, easy-to-defend position,
- 12:05very resistant to any government abuses.
- 12:08The weakness, though, is that almost nobody is a true absolutist in practice.
- 12:13Even hardcore absolutists will usually still carve out true threats,
- 12:18fraud, blackmail, perjury, conspiracy, and incitement.
- 12:22So then you have the near absolutism, which is the strong presumption for free speech.
- 12:28The core idea of that is speech gets the strongest possible protection,
- 12:32but a tiny set of exceptions are allowed.
- 12:35Probably the most common serious pro-free speech position in the U.S.
- 12:40Belief, start with speech, is protected Only allow narrow exceptions Such as
- 12:47direct threats, incitement, defamation, fraud, obscenity.
- 12:51Though legally allowed, though, and criminal solicitation.
- 12:55It's more realistic than absolutism. Still very speech protective.
- 12:59The weakness, everyone fights over what counts as an exception.
- 13:03Governments love turning narrow exceptions into broad censorship.
- 13:07Then there's the marketplace of ideas. The core idea behind this,
- 13:12free speech is valuable because the truth emerges from open competition between ideas.
- 13:18Now, I do like that, okay?
- 13:21But I don't think that you, like, it's a great idea in concept,
- 13:26but the problem with it is not always the best ideas win, okay?
- 13:31Just like the free market. Yeah, it's just like the free market.
- 13:34Not always the best product makes it to number one.
- 13:37So basically, humans are fallible. Today's obvious truth can be tomorrow's stupidity.
- 13:42False ideas can still help the truth by forcing us to defend what we believe,
- 13:47let ideas fight in public.
- 13:49So its strength is strong epistemic argument, how societies discover truth.
- 13:56It's great defense against orthodoxy and moral panic. The weakness,
- 14:00it assumes that the best idea will win.
- 14:02In real life, lies often beat the truth if they are louder, richer,
- 14:06simpler, or, you know, in the algorithm.
- 14:09Critics say it ignores power, propaganda, and media manipulation,
- 14:13and I would agree with that. Thank you.
- 14:15Then you have democratic self-government. Core idea, speech matters most because
- 14:20democracy requires an informed citizenry.
- 14:23The belief, the core purpose of free speech is self-government.
- 14:28Citizens can't rule themselves if they can't criticize power,
- 14:31hear dissent, debate policy, access information.
- 14:35Political speech gets the highest protection.
- 14:37Now, I'm very fond of that, but I don't think that that fucking really works either.
- 14:42The strengths are it's a very powerful constitutional argument. That's why I do like it.
- 14:47It explains why political speech is often treated as sacred.
- 14:51Again, I do agree with that. The weakness, it doesn't cover art,
- 14:56sex, comedy, religion, culture, personal expression, and it can imply some speech
- 15:03matters less if it's not political.
- 15:05Then you have individual autonomy or self-expression. the core idea,
- 15:11speech is protected because expressing yourself is part of being a free human being.
- 15:16This is the free speech as human dignity type argument.
- 15:21The belief is basically speaking is not just about truth or politics.
- 15:25It's about identity, conscience, creativity, personhood, moral agency.
- 15:29Silencing someone is not just censoring words. It is dominating the person.
- 15:34I do agree with a lot of that, but I don't think that's a solution either. Okay?
- 15:40It's strengths. It does protect art, identity, weirdness, blasphemy,
- 15:47offensive comedy, personal expression. That's why I like it,
- 15:50because it does protect those things.
- 15:53It explains why speech matters beyond elections. Again, I like that.
- 15:58The weakness, it's harder to draw the lines when expression collides with harm.
- 16:02Critics say it can overprotect harmful expression. I disagree with that.
- 16:07Then you have dignity, which is basically equality limiting view, right?
- 16:13So the core idea, some speech undermines the equal standing of other people
- 16:17so badly that restricting it can be justified.
- 16:20This is the strong anti-abolitionist liberal take, right?
- 16:26The belief free speech matters, but so do equality and dignity.
- 16:31Some forms of speech, especially hate speech, do more than offend.
- 16:36They degrade, intimidate, exclude, subordinate, make targeted groups less secure in public life.
- 16:42Therefore, some restrictions are consistent with liberal democracy.
- 16:46Sorry, I just want to double check. What was that strain called?
- 16:50Because so far, that has my vote.
- 16:54Dignity, equality, limiting view.
- 16:58So the strengths are it takes real-world power and social harm seriously.
- 17:02Explains why many democracies ban hate speech.
- 17:05The weakness, it's easy to abuse. Protecting dignity can become protecting people from discomfort.
- 17:12Governments can redefine dissent as harmful or destabilizing.
- 17:16I don't agree with that one.
- 17:18I don't. Because I'm sorry, when it comes to freedom of speech,
- 17:24Yes, you want to make sure people don't feel like they're going to get harmed,
- 17:29but there are laws that prevent people from getting fucking harmed.
- 17:33I can't hold your hand through every part of your day and make sure you feel
- 17:37comfortable with your life.
- 17:39That's not my job. That's no one's job. That's your job. So, but we'll get to that.
- 17:44Then you have a harm principle, right?
- 17:47The core idea, speech should be free unless it causes or directly risks real harm to others.
- 17:54Belief, mere offensiveness is not enough. Hurt feelings are not enough. Real harm matters.
- 18:00Threats, targeted harassment, incitement, fraud, defamation,
- 18:04panic-inducing falsehoods in the right context.
- 18:07The key question is, is this speech causing wrongful harm? Now I can get behind
- 18:11that far more than I can get behind the previous one, which you were getting behind.
- 18:16The strengths, it's very intuitive,
- 18:18protects robust speech while allowing intervention in serious cases.
- 18:23The weakness, harm is slippery.
- 18:25Activists and governments constantly expand the word until everything becomes harm.
- 18:30Emotional injury versus legal harm becomes the battlefield.
- 18:34And that's where I have a problem with that. I don't think just because you
- 18:39were offended or you had your feelings hurt that that should limit my right
- 18:44to offend you or hurt your feelings.
- 18:47I'm not going to do it on purpose because I'm not an asshole,
- 18:49but there are some assholes out there that will do that.
- 18:53Again, life is tough. Wear a helmet.
- 18:56Balancing and proportionality. The core idea of free speech is important,
- 19:01but it must be weighted against competing rights and interests.
- 19:04This is the dominant framework in Europe, Canada, and international rights law
- 19:11The belief, speech is a right, but not an unlimited trump card Courts ask,
- 19:17what interest is the government protecting?
- 19:19Is the restriction narrowly tailored?
- 19:22Is there a less restrictive alternative?
- 19:25Is the burden on speech proportionate? The strength is it's flexible,
- 19:30can adapt to modern problems handles edge cases better than rigid absolutism.
- 19:35The weakness, balancing can become about vibes.
- 19:40It can become available to judicial subjectivity, ideological laundering.
- 19:47Critics say it gives government too much room.
- 19:50Consequentialist social stability, public order.
- 19:53The core idea, speech is protected or restricted based on what produces the
- 19:58best overall social outcome.
- 20:00This is the oldest and frankly most dangerous when unchecked.
- 20:03Belief, if speech threatens public order, war effort, institutional legitimacy,
- 20:12social cohesion, safety, anti-radicalism goals, then it can be restricted.
- 20:18I absolutely disagree with this one.
- 20:22The strength, governments love it because it's practical. The weakness,
- 20:26this is the engine of most censorship regimes.
- 20:30Public order becomes code for shut the fuck up, don't embarrass us,
- 20:35don't destable the power.
- 20:37So, then you got number 10, bad tendency test.
- 20:42Core idea, speech can be restricted if it merely has a tendency to lead to harmful outcomes.
- 20:49So an example that would be, if speech might encourage disorder,
- 20:54radicalism, or law-breaking, governments can act.
- 20:56Why that matters? It's extremely broad, historically used to crush dissent,
- 21:01one of the least speech-protective approaches.
- 21:05Clear and present danger is another one. Speech can be restricted when it creates
- 21:09a clear and immediate danger of serious harm. Why it matters?
- 21:13This is a major U.S. doctrine in the early to mid-20th century.
- 21:18Strength, more protective than bad tendency The weakness, still manipulable,
- 21:24historically used inconsistently 12.
- 21:27Imminent lawless action Core idea, speech advocating lawbreaking is protected
- 21:34unless it is intended to incite lawless action and likely to produce it and
- 21:40the lawless action is imminent So the strength is very protective,
- 21:44stops government from criminalizing abstract radical talk The weakness makes
- 21:49it harder to stop some dangerous rhetoric until it gets very close to action.
- 21:54Thirteen, preferred position doctrine. The core idea, speech gets special status among rights.
- 22:01Not all constitutional rights are treated equally. Free speech sits near the top.
- 22:05Why it matters, it explains why courts apply harsher scrutiny to speech restrictions. Okay?
- 22:12Content neutrality viewpoint. Governments may regulate how speech happens more
- 22:17easily than what it says.
- 22:19The distinction, content-based restriction, no discussion of abortion.
- 22:24Viewpoint-based restriction, only pro-life speech is allowed.
- 22:28Content, neutral rule, no amplified sound after midnight. So you can see right
- 22:34in there how that's just foolishness.
- 22:37Then you got categorical exclusions or low-value speech.
- 22:41Some speech is either not really protected at all or protected less.
- 22:46Common examples, true threats, fraud, defamation,
- 22:50perjury, blackmail, extortion criminal solicitation some obscenity some child
- 22:55sexual abuse material not protected as speech in the usual sense of freedom
- 22:59of speech i mean like there's some things that i agree with there but not not a fucking ton you know.
- 23:08So I guess really what it boils down to for me is I want people to have free speech,
- 23:16but my carve-outs are not to do with hurting your feelings.
- 23:24If it can actually cause harm to you, their speech, you know,
- 23:27libel and stuff like that, like it's causing a legitimate, provable harm that
- 23:33has nothing to do with whether or not you just don't like the way somebody said something to you.
- 23:38I'm kind of on board with that you know what I mean we're kind of on board even
- 23:43with the point of and this gets to political speech even when January 6th happened,
- 23:51while I disagreed with Trump being pulled off of social media like Twitter and
- 23:57Facebook on constitutional grounds I recognized that those companies had the
- 24:04right to do it because they're a corporation And there's terms of service.
- 24:09And he violated those terms of service. But the reason I didn't like it is because,
- 24:15ah, A, political speech.
- 24:18B, now we have corporations calling balls and strikes.
- 24:23And these are the same corporations, right, that have been sitting next to Trump
- 24:29in his second term, writing out checks for whatever he asks,
- 24:33giving him fake peace prize awards.
- 24:38And essentially are manipulating the president now.
- 24:44Or maybe you could say the president's manipulating them. I guess it's kind
- 24:47of both ways. But that's where I think...
- 24:50You need freedom of speech and you need to be able to call out this administration.
- 24:54We've already seen them try to take out Jimmy Kimmel.
- 24:58We've already seen them try to take out, you know, all kinds of different things.
- 25:02And then on top of it, they're in charge of huge mergers where one of the fucking
- 25:05companies is CNN that would would go over to the Ellisons who are huge MAGA heads.
- 25:13Now, maybe they're just huge MAGA heads because Trump's in office and they know that they can,
- 25:18you know, between donations and slobbing on his knob, that they can somehow
- 25:24or another get what it is they're looking for. Maybe that's what it is.
- 25:30But at the end of the day, I think political speech and artistic speech are
- 25:37our most important speech to protect. Yeah.
- 25:40And I'm going to drop out of my opening with this from Ricky Gervais.
- 25:45Free speech. They only want free
- 25:47speech so they can go around saying awful things, which just isn't true.
- 25:50And even if it was, the good thing about free speech is people can say awful
- 25:55things back. It's a really good system.
- 25:57And you can't say anything under the laws of free speech. That's a total misconception.
- 26:01There are loads of caveats to free speech, all of which I agree with.
- 26:05Actually, you can't incite violence.
- 26:08Good rule. You can't slander people. good rule you can't libel people you know
- 26:12fascinating fact about libel law you can't libel the dead so i could stand here
- 26:19and say gandy used to take it up the eye if i wanted.
- 26:25Which i do i do but free speech is the most important human right there is and
- 26:33i agree with that free speech is the most important human right there is because
- 26:36without that nothing else comes forward.
- 26:38If you can't speak truth to power or you can't speak the truth that you see,
- 26:43you cannot make society better.
- 26:46And I would even go so far as to argue that the person who seems the most ridiculous
- 26:53is the person you need to let speak the most so they can get it out of their
- 26:58system and have to defend that idea.
- 27:01Now, if they are able to defend that idea, great. But if not,
- 27:05well, that maybe they'll learn something.
- 27:08And I mean this across the board. Okay. I mean this literally across the board.
- 27:13If somebody says that intelligent design is the way things happened, not evolution.
- 27:19Okay. Make your point.
- 27:21Okay. Because I at least have the right to hear it.
- 27:25And I don't think anyone should be denied the right to hear a ridiculous opinion.
- 27:31Yep. Now, did you want to introduce Colton or shall I? Oh, go right ahead. All right.
- 27:48His silence is considered a form of
- 27:51constructive criticism he is
- 27:54the most interesting colton in america stay informed my friends now it's all
- 28:02you buddy all right well i i want to start by saying i'm glad that you went
- 28:06through that list of different iterations of free speech because is it goes to show two things to me.
- 28:15One, free speech is a spectrum. It's not a yes or no.
- 28:19I agreed. Yeah, there are degrees of freedom of speech.
- 28:24And there is not, I mean, I could go into the woods and say whatever the fuck I want, you know?
- 28:31I could have the freest speech in the world, and we'll get there, we'll get there.
- 28:36But the second thing, it shows me that we are a lot closer than either of us
- 28:41would like to admit on this issue.
- 28:43Really, to me, well, you know what? Fucking, I'll get there too.
- 28:48So, just to start, the constitutional definition of freedom of speech is that
- 28:54individuals are protected from governmental restriction on expression of thought
- 28:58through speech, writing, symbols, and symbolic gestures.
- 29:01What that means is the government cannot arrest, punish, or censor individuals
- 29:06on the basis of free expression, except for some narrow circumstances,
- 29:12which you definitely went into.
- 29:14But those existing exceptions, just the biggest ones off the top of my head,
- 29:19defamation and slander, incitement of unlawful action, specific and actionable
- 29:24threats of violence, particularly against public figures, but technically also
- 29:29against everyone. Yeah.
- 29:31And then harassment and hate speech in an effort to protect human rights of marginalized groups.
- 29:38Now, hate speech laws are not some oppressive thing.
- 29:43It's just a simple recognition that some people are fucking assholes and make
- 29:48other people so uncomfortable that they are not okay going out into their own community.
- 29:54That's all it is to me. Now you can argue, yeah, you know, life's tough wear
- 29:59a helmet and I get where you're coming from. I do.
- 30:02But at the same time, when you have, let's take black people in America,
- 30:07over 400 years of lynchings, violence, slavery, rape, all of these things.
- 30:16And only in the last what 1965 we're talking 61 years right,
- 30:25yeah there's still gonna be some crossover there Jim Crow didn't end until the
- 30:30fucking 80s in some places,
- 30:33you know there are still sundown towns in America there are still places where
- 30:37if you are black and you are there when the sun goes down you will be harassed
- 30:41or assaulted or worse you know So hate speech laws,
- 30:47yes, you could make the reductive argument, make society feel more comfortable.
- 30:54I've been to two of those cities. Oh, yeah?
- 30:58In arkansas yeah well i mean fuck what is it
- 31:01howell michigan is the kkk capital of michigan
- 31:04yep that's still
- 31:06an established fact that means if you're black
- 31:09and you're crossing through howell you're probably going to get harassed not
- 31:13a guarantee of course but you could and let's be honest the law if you take
- 31:19away hate speech laws the laws designed to protect against physical harassment,
- 31:28physical assault, physical violence.
- 31:30What does that do in the moment? What exactly does that do in the moment?
- 31:34Now, I'm not saying that hate speech laws are much better, but at least it establishes
- 31:38a clear delineation that like, OK, if this guy's a known KKK member and he's
- 31:44also the prime suspect in a lynching,
- 31:46you know, like we can put two and two together here, you know.
- 31:51So moving forward, I think that the main difference between my point of view
- 31:57and Steve's is the extent to
- 31:58which we agree with social consequences to someone's use of free speech.
- 32:04So what are some examples of social consequences to free speech?
- 32:09Private companies choosing not to host you because of the volatility of your speech.
- 32:14I'm sorry, as much as we like to believe Twitter is the town square,
- 32:18it's fucking not. It's a private company.
- 32:20Now, I have my own disagreements with Twitter and the way it's run or YouTube
- 32:25and the way it's run or, you know, name your platform.
- 32:28I have my disagreements, but it's not a fucking town square.
- 32:32It's simply not. It is a private company, they have terms of service,
- 32:36and if they choose not to host your content, then that's that. I agree with you on that.
- 32:41Someone getting offended by your speech and using their free speech to voice that.
- 32:45Not saying that anyone has the right not to be offended by other people,
- 32:49but people do get offended sometimes.
- 32:51There's nothing we can do to change that, and that's just a social consequence.
- 32:57That's all it is. if you if you call me an asshole and i get offended and then
- 33:03i start calling you an asshole,
- 33:05that's a social consequence baby again i know i agree with that next people
- 33:10choosing not to engage with your speech i.e.
- 33:13Canceling the big scary cancel culture i don't agree with that that is a social
- 33:19consequence if i choose not to engage with call call it dave chappelle Well,
- 33:24if I choose not to engage with his use of free speech, well,
- 33:28that is a social consequence.
- 33:29All right. I don't want to interrupt you, but we can swing back to that. OK.
- 33:33I mean, as as free of speech as one person may have, I have equal equal freedom
- 33:41not to engage with that speech.
- 33:44And don't buy the fucking ticket. Yeah. Yeah, I don't have a problem with people
- 33:48not buying the fucking ticket.
- 33:50And I don't have a problem with an event being canceled because there's no ticket sales.
- 33:55I have a problem with colleges, as an example, canceling a controversial speaker
- 34:01because, you know, a student group got a bug up their ass and they don't want to hear it.
- 34:09Because what they're doing is they're... Well, not wanting to hear it and knowing
- 34:13what's going to be said, two different things.
- 34:16Well, even if you— We can deliberate. We can deliberate. We can deliberate.
- 34:20But look, cancellation has always been a right-wing thing, generally speaking.
- 34:25So I'll get there in a second, but I do think cancel culture is stupid,
- 34:31whether the left is doing it or the right is doing it.
- 34:34But the simple fact is if enough people have a bug up their ass about someone,
- 34:39about what they're going to say, about whatever the program is,
- 34:43that's a social consequence.
- 34:45It's awesome. You can argue that it's misplaced. You can argue that it's not right.
- 34:50You can argue all these things, but it is a social consequence. All right.
- 34:54I have to speak up on that one. I would buy that argument.
- 34:59If everyone who was doing the canceling was familiar with the product and knew
- 35:04what it was, instead of just being, you know what?
- 35:08I think that this is the right side of the argument, even though I don't know
- 35:12what the argument is. Right.
- 35:14Cancel culture to me is a very right wing coded thing.
- 35:17And I don't, make apologies for it when the left wing does it.
- 35:21I think it's stupid, generally.
- 35:24Okay. Now, in narrow situations, which I'll get to in a moment,
- 35:28I think that it has its place.
- 35:30But generally speaking, it's a right wing coded thing.
- 35:33It's an authoritarian coded thing. And I disagree with cancel culture broadly. Okay.
- 35:39Now, I'm going to get into the crux of my argument, my five main points with this.
- 35:46The first is that social consequences to one's use of free speech are a necessary
- 35:51guardrail for freedom of speech as a concept.
- 35:54Now, what I mean by this is that there are people that would use their freedom
- 35:59of speech to suppress the free speech of others. Okay.
- 36:03And without social consequence to that action,
- 36:08produces a chilling effect on freedom of speech as a whole, for everyone,
- 36:11except for those that have the platform, that have the power,
- 36:15that have the microphone.
- 36:16So would an example of that, just so I'm clear, would an example of that be, let's say, a president?
- 36:23Well, we've had freedom of speech since the founding of the United States as
- 36:29a country. But it didn't really come into play. It didn't really do much until the late 50s, early 60s.
- 36:36Well, hear me out on this. And since then, we've had a lot of debate almost yearly on what it means.
- 36:43We've had freedom of speech since the founding 1776 of the United States of America.
- 36:49And before 1865, that only applied— I think it was actually 1779 is when it went into effect.
- 36:59Maybe, because that's the Confederacy versus the federal government.
- 37:04Yeah, well, 1779 was also where they, I believe, ratified the Constitution.
- 37:13Sure. Since the earliest days of the Constitution being the law of the land,
- 37:17let's say it that way, we've had freedom of speech.
- 37:21But it took until 1865 for that to technically apply to anyone other than white
- 37:27Anglo-Saxon Protestants.
- 37:28They used their freedom of speech to suppress that of others.
- 37:32They used their freedom of speech to pass laws, such as the Fugitive Slave Act.
- 37:36They used that freedom of speech to incite violence against slave uprisings.
- 37:44Okay, that's what I mean by that. And then you fast forward enough,
- 37:47you get to, I guess this would have been the 30s through the 50s, roughly.
- 37:53You get the most prescient example of this point, the chilling effect on freedom
- 38:00of speech, George Lincoln Rockwell. He was the.
- 38:04Fucking president of the United States, the American Nazi party,
- 38:09he would if he would have had his way, he would have suppressed the speech of
- 38:13everyone that didn't agree with him.
- 38:15That's my point. Now, he didn't win. And we know that. But the Nazis never really
- 38:20went away. We also know that.
- 38:22OK, so my second point, people hiding from social consequences of their speech
- 38:29behind the Oh, it's my free speech. That's bitch-made behavior.
- 38:33That's bitch-made behavior, especially because definitionally their freedom
- 38:37of speech is not being infringed.
- 38:39Only a government can do that, whether local, state, or federal.
- 38:44Definitionally, the freedom of speech means that the government will not censor
- 38:48you or suppress your freedom of speech or attack you with the law due to your freedom of speech.
- 38:54Says nothing about private corporations, says nothing about private citizens.
- 39:00If you're going to say something that might offend some people,
- 39:03whether it's a racial comment, whether it's, you know, a joke,
- 39:07a really iffy joke, whatever it is, have the sack at least to stand 10 toes down on it.
- 39:15Okay okay three i agree
- 39:18that cancel culture is stupid as hell not only
- 39:21because it's a right-wing coded thing that the left tried
- 39:24their hand at but because all it does is make
- 39:27the canceled person and their followers dig in their
- 39:30heels on bad points i agree
- 39:33there yeah some people do deserve
- 39:36to be canceled by society at large and the
- 39:39private platforms that host them in an effort to limit the
- 39:42growth of their malignant beliefs to this
- 39:45i would point to fuentes i would point to kanye west
- 39:48i would point to the me too movement the
- 39:51cancellation of harvey weinstein there are people that are so malignant alex
- 39:56jones there are people that are so malignant that the suppression of their speech
- 40:03specifically does benefit society at large and keeps speech freer for everyone else Question.
- 40:10As, as, as a little added bonus, have either of you seen Alex Jones the last two days, three days?
- 40:18Oh, he's spiraling. He's spiraling.
- 40:20He's doing a lot. You know it's bad when a crazy person is saying that Trump is crazy. Yeah. Mm-hmm.
- 40:26And doing it from his car. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah.
- 40:30I've not seen anything other than Alex Jones in his car lately.
- 40:33So I don't know if that's all he's got left as a studio.
- 40:36I've seen a couple in, in a, in a new studio, but yeah, he's spiraling.
- 40:40He can't handle, he can't handle the fact that he begged for the Epstein files
- 40:45to get released. And all of his friends are in them. Yeah. Yeah.
- 40:50I digress go ahead my fourth point is it's all oh go ahead go back to that last
- 40:56one again and just refresh me on that last one just real quick i agree that
- 41:00cancel culture is stupid,
- 41:01but you were saying all it does is it makes people dig in
- 41:05their heels but there are limited circumstances in which
- 41:08the suppression of any individual's speech when
- 41:11you get maximizes free speech for other people when
- 41:14you were talking that goes back that goes back to the the chilling effect
- 41:17that i was talking about earlier yeah okay but when you were talking about fuentes
- 41:20and and and kanye west and
- 41:23harvey weinstein although for him it wasn't speech he was
- 41:26actually a sex pest yeah so you can't really count him in
- 41:29into my particular question here alex jones
- 41:33fuentes i mean yeah i was just i
- 41:35was just talking about cancel culture as as the overarching like
- 41:39okay but my question is the umbrella yeah who gets
- 41:43to decide to cancel them society at
- 41:45large and how does that come about if there
- 41:49is enough popular sentiment to where clearly
- 41:52this person is ruffling the wrong feathers
- 41:55because it's one thing it's one thing to be shaking things
- 41:58up it's one thing to have a spicy take yeah
- 42:02but that's a very fucking fine line and somebody starts
- 42:06that and i'm of the opinion that the person who
- 42:09usually starts it is just a fucking lunatic.
- 42:13Who gets offended easily and decides that they have to
- 42:16leave a bad yelp review or bad google review
- 42:19on every opportunity you know every opportunity
- 42:22they get sure that's sure and that person very well
- 42:24could be the case but doesn't it make my point doesn't it
- 42:27make more sense is it's it's not like it's some it's not like it's some like
- 42:33secret cabal deciding to cancel these people right no but you're saying that
- 42:37it will have to be a group effort and society's got to step up and decide this
- 42:43together. And that's where I get into the argument.
- 42:45It's not even a conscious decision. I mean, look...
- 42:48I don't engage with Nick Fuentes outside of, like, there's a clip that someone
- 42:54that I watch is covering because he says something ridiculous in the clip. Right. Yeah.
- 42:59Again, chimp clipping.
- 43:03Not chimp. Not chimp clipping. All right. But let's say it's a serious point, right?
- 43:09And it's just one that you disagree with. It's ridiculous.
- 43:14Well, no one's forcing you to agree with it. And no one's forcing you to watch it.
- 43:18No one's forcing you to go to that to Nick Fuentes channel and watch. Exactly.
- 43:24And my point is cancellation isn't just there's this large movement that says,
- 43:30fuck this guy in particular.
- 43:33Cancellation is also I'm choosing not to engage with this person's use of their
- 43:39free speech because it is my enacting of a social consequence.
- 43:45And if enough people do that, you might call that a cancellation.
- 43:48Okay, I'll let that go for now, but I think that that's something we'll have to circle back at later.
- 43:54My fourth point, it's all jokes until it's not anymore.
- 43:59While comedy is a very important check on power, strong potential for social
- 44:05consequences to free speech ensures that speech remains free.
- 44:10If no one is allowed to express a negative opinion of a comedian or public person
- 44:16or politician or so on, that causes a chilling effect on free speech as a whole as well.
- 44:22Beyond this, if someone is constantly punching down and not just like here and
- 44:28there, not just like, oh, you know, but hiding behind it's just comedy or it's
- 44:34my free speech and you can't stop me.
- 44:36What happens when it clearly is not just jokes anymore? And I have two examples on this.
- 44:44Sneeko, are either of you familiar with Sneeko? Mm-mm.
- 44:47He is like a C-tier, Andrew Tate, orbiter, manosphere kind of guy, okay?
- 44:56Mm-mm. He's a far-right streamer. He's constantly joking about hating women
- 45:01and calling them inferior and making anti-Semitic comments and so on, right?
- 45:05Whether he's joking or not is kind of immaterial because he has a following,
- 45:10and that following takes his word as gospel.
- 45:14He has released videos multiple times,
- 45:17but one in particular where he is at some kind of like streamer convention and
- 45:23two teenage boys representative of much of his audience approach him and start
- 45:29spewing all of this hateful, misogynistic,
- 45:31racist shit at him. And they're not joking.
- 45:35And he looks shocked that they're saying it.
- 45:39Motherfucker, where do you think they heard it from? Yeah, well.
- 45:42Right. and this isn't a protect the kids argument necessarily
- 45:45this is just a simple fact like you can call you
- 45:48can say oh it's it's it's just jokes it's just jokes it's just jokes but look
- 45:53here's the other thing imagine here's my second example imagine i meet a friend
- 45:58and i've given you this example before steve imagine i meet a new friend and
- 46:03he seems nice enough you meet him he's a cool guy you know whatever Ever.
- 46:09More I hang out with them, the
- 46:10more you kind of start to notice there are some changes in my behavior.
- 46:14Now, keep in mind, I'm not so weak willed and impressionable as to do this.
- 46:20But just for the sake of example, you start noticing some little behavioral changes, right?
- 46:27At first, it's just like every so often here and there, there's a there's a Jew joke.
- 46:32Okay, well, you know, it was just a joke. Clearly, it was just a joke.
- 46:36It was funny. So it slides, whatever, right?
- 46:39Just a Jew joke here and there. Just a Muslim joke here and there.
- 46:44Just a black joke here and there. Right.
- 46:47Then it kind of evolves into it could still be a bit.
- 46:52But now I'm like questioning whether Jews rule the world and whether or not
- 46:57they're in cahoots with American blacks to rape all the white women. Right.
- 47:03Could still just be for the bit. so maybe you'll let it slide.
- 47:07Maybe you talk to me, maybe you'll let it slide.
- 47:09But it's still like an odd change in behavior.
- 47:12Next, you see someone who you're pretty sure is me on a video at a neo-Nazi
- 47:18rally. And it's unclear whether I'm participating.
- 47:21If it is me, it's unclear whether I'm participating or if I'm just a bystander at this event.
- 47:28Okay, but that kind of crosses a line. You talk to me and you find out that
- 47:33it was me But, oh, I was just there as a joke.
- 47:37It was just a joke. I was just it was for it was for the bit. Right.
- 47:42Before you know it, I have a shaved head and swastika tattoos.
- 47:45I'm goose stepping and chanting our bite mocked fry.
- 47:48At what point was it no longer just jokes?
- 47:52Well, first off, it depends on how funny the jokes are.
- 47:56You know, you know, you've spoken like a true, true comedian.
- 48:00Yeah. But I mean, what was the rule that you had to follow in this house?
- 48:05Funny is funny. But again, my point being, at what point was it no longer just jokes?
- 48:10When it stopped becoming funny or as a parent, when I realized that you were
- 48:17telling jokes that were inappropriate for your age.
- 48:21So even if it was a funny joke, but it was totally inappropriate for you to
- 48:25say that joke at your age, that's when I step in and I go, buddy, that's funny.
- 48:30I give you credit for funny, but it's completely inappropriate for you at this
- 48:36age to tell that joke. I never want to hear anything like that out of you. And again.
- 48:41You've fallen into my trap because what is that but a social consequence?
- 48:45Yeah, no, but that's being, there's a difference. There's a difference between
- 48:48the social consequences, the difference between getting canceled and having
- 48:52your parent go, not in my fucking house.
- 48:55There is a difference. Clearly, there's a difference. But is that not if you
- 48:59boil both of them down just a social consequence? And at what point in that
- 49:03in that stream of occurrences would a social consequence have helped to deter me from that bullshit?
- 49:09Well, again, that's my point. So, well, here's here's the opposite kind of side of not a cancer.
- 49:17Consolation in this situation, just a, Hey, look, you know, sure. Funny is funny.
- 49:23That was a horrible joke. And I'm worried about what that says about where your mind is. Yeah.
- 49:30Well, that's a social consequence.
- 49:32No, that's, that's a, that's a familial consequence. That's a family consequence.
- 49:38That is because I'll tell you why I'm going to, I'm going to defer to Keith around this.
- 49:42All right, well, we will, but let me finish my explanation of that.
- 49:45But that happened, if that were to happen, where does it happen?
- 49:49Within the four walls of my house? Mm-hmm.
- 49:53Sure, sure. All right. And do I then go hop online and tell everyone my son
- 50:00told this horrific fucking joke?
- 50:03You're conflating two different social consequences here. I'm just saying that
- 50:06there's a degree. It's a conflation of two different things.
- 50:09Well, that's what I think you're doing because I would argue.
- 50:12That is not what I'm doing.
- 50:13I would argue that a personal interaction between a father and a son or a father
- 50:19and a daughter or a mother and a son or a mother and a daughter,
- 50:23that's family now you can call that
- 50:26a social consequence but that's a family consequence let's
- 50:29take it out let's take family out of
- 50:31it let's say you were my best friend josh is that not then a social consequence
- 50:37even if i concede that that's a familial consequence if it happens with you
- 50:40which i do not concede well i think you do not concede incorrectly but with
- 50:45it with josh i would agree that would
- 50:46be a social consequence because your relationship with josh is friend,
- 50:51Friends are social. Parents aren't social.
- 50:55Well, you're not. No, fuck no, I'm not.
- 50:58Okay, so I'm going to defer to Kiefer on this.
- 51:01Yeah, let's defer to Kiefer on this. You're getting to start early.
- 51:05And I only have one more point, but it is a long one. Okay.
- 51:08So the difference being is that I think it's being conflated a personal relationship
- 51:14and a social relationship.
- 51:17Social gets its wording from society. your
- 51:21family is not society your school would
- 51:24be society this is a relative a
- 51:28parent so it would be personal my point
- 51:32in saying if you boil both of them down to their core it's a social consequence
- 51:37is because it's between two people who are part of society and one of them is
- 51:43clearly recognizing this is not acceptable within a societal structure and the other one is not,
- 51:49That's why I'm saying, and then as far as like. I would still say that's iffy
- 51:53because, you know, what is it, the Mormons, they tend to stick to themselves.
- 51:58They're not a part of society.
- 52:01Scientologists? I guess my perspective, my perspective on it does come from
- 52:07Frederick Engels, who asserts that the family is the basic unit of society.
- 52:12Not the individual, it's the family is the basic unit of society.
- 52:16That's a little more philosophical than. Sure.
- 52:20But then on the other hand, with cancel culture, if you boil it down to its
- 52:24core component, it's a social consequence.
- 52:26I don't I don't disagree with you on that. I think that cancel culture is a social consequence.
- 52:32But to your art or to your philosophical point that the family is society.
- 52:39No, that's it's no more the truth than no. No, not family is society.
- 52:44Family is the building, the building block, the basic unit of society. Right. Okay.
- 52:50And maybe... Because you have to be social with a group, a small group,
- 52:56before you can be social with a larger, more organized group.
- 53:00But by the same token, you know, calling the nucleus an atom does not mean that
- 53:06the nucleus is an atom any more than it means the proton or neutron is an atom.
- 53:10It takes a proton, a neutron, and a nucleus to make an atom.
- 53:15Okay. Fair enough. That's, I mean, if we're going to split hairs,
- 53:18that's where I'm splitting mine on the atomic level.
- 53:22Then let's, let's revise, let's revise the example and take family out of it.
- 53:27You're a friend and I meet a new friend.
- 53:29And that's, yeah, that would be a totally different thing. I want to add that,
- 53:31uh, technically, Steve, you are also half right, half wrong with that Adam,
- 53:37because it could also take a God to make an Adam. Well, that's true.
- 53:43Okay. So my final point before we go to the Q&A.
- 53:49Comedy has always served as a check on the powers that be.
- 53:53From court jesters and Shakespeare to Carlin and Hicks, comedy has always served
- 53:59as a widely accessible embodiment of the fifth estate, which is non-mainstream
- 54:03media countercultural figures and so on.
- 54:06When any given comedian routinely, and I emphasize routinely.
- 54:12Punches down instead of up, punches down on marginalized groups,
- 54:16it's not only incredibly lazy
- 54:18comedy, but it is actively against the main point of comedy as a concept.
- 54:23That's not to say that observations about a person or a community isn't allowed in comedy.
- 54:29You're allowed to do anything in comedy. Okay.
- 54:32But sorry, I lost my spot here. They're encouraged, but regularly have having
- 54:38the punchline being and the criminal was black or and the woman deserved it
- 54:43is just lazy and defeats the point of comedy.
- 54:45Right. Again, cancel culture is dumb as hell, but it's no wonder why marginalized,
- 54:52often left-leaning, because when you're talking about a marginalized group,
- 54:55they're typically left-leaning,
- 54:57groups would take issue with certain comedians on that basis.
- 55:01See Bill Maher's Islamophobia, particularly in the context of the genocide of the Palestinians,
- 55:07saying every war Israel has ever fought in was a self-defensive war when literally
- 55:13not one of them has been, saying Palestinians are at fault for the unrest when
- 55:17Israel has given them no other option, and so on.
- 55:21And the pro-Palestine crowd took issue with that. Big surprise.
- 55:25Or take Chappelle's perceived transphobia. Real or not,
- 55:31trans people and allies largely took offense to it, and actual transphobes defended
- 55:36Dave Chappelle for what they saw as allyship in transphobia.
- 55:41Now, again, perceived transphobia.
- 55:45And again, cancel culture is dumb. Let me just say this real quick,
- 55:49because I hate interrupting you in this.
- 55:52No, go ahead. But I think if I don't, I'm going to forget this.
- 55:55Bill Maher being wrong with facts and being pro-Israel, considering he's half
- 56:02Jew, even though he's anti-religious and calls himself an atheist,
- 56:07which I don't doubt that— Which is why he should be anti-Zionist.
- 56:10I agree with you there, but having bad information just shows laziness in your preparation.
- 56:18Yeah. Okay. So I'm not going to defend laziness in the preparation of the material
- 56:23anymore than I'm going to- Punching down constantly on marginalized communities
- 56:28is lazy and defeats the point of comedy.
- 56:31Well, I do have a point of contention on that to a degree. Okay.
- 56:35And I'll get there in a second.
- 56:37I don't want to interrupt you if you got if you got more to this
- 56:40that you want to throw in there but that's i'll leave it right there you
- 56:43can go ahead okay so i'm not going
- 56:46to defend and then run my clip yeah i
- 56:49will i'll run you clip i'm not going to defend laziness in comedy i'm not going
- 56:57to defend poor writing in comedy so if somebody's got a bad punchline and people
- 57:04are offended by of that punchline.
- 57:06My first question is, why aren't you just offended that it's a bad punchline?
- 57:12You paid 20 bucks to get in.
- 57:14That's just lazy preparation.
- 57:17Be upset about that, definitely. Okay?
- 57:21But understand that no comic who is worth their salt, who's got 10 years plus
- 57:26in, is ever going to step on stage intentionally trying to quote-unquote punch down or...
- 57:35People that's just not not intentionally not intentionally
- 57:38happening but you learn that as
- 57:41a comic you do that joke once and it
- 57:44lands let's say it lands great so you do
- 57:46it two three four five more times if that joke
- 57:49continuously lands and gets you a
- 57:52big laugh it's probably going to stay in the show but
- 57:55if you do that joke once and it lands and
- 57:59you get big laughs and then you do it two three four five times more
- 58:02you don't get the laugh in fact you get people going
- 58:05on people are going to go boo fuck you
- 58:08right yeah which if some
- 58:11if people were to say that on mass let's
- 58:14say it does get the laugh that time let me be perfectly
- 58:17honest with you because i've been there i've this
- 58:20is i've seen it and i've had it happen to me a joke
- 58:24lands you think okay great i'll just do that
- 58:27joke it's funny right you don't think you're punching down
- 58:30you don't think you're you know going after
- 58:33marginalized people then you hit it on the wrong crowd but you hit that same
- 58:37joke on the wrong crowd all of a sudden you go oh what the fuck is that well
- 58:41then i'm as a non-lazy performer going to go through and try to figure out how
- 58:47this is going right one show and wrong the next And if it goes wrong,
- 58:52two shows in a row, fuck you. That's out.
- 58:55And I would then add.
- 58:58You have to then refer back to my second point, which is hiding behind free
- 59:02speech as as a Trump card is bitch made.
- 59:05Oh, I agree with you there. But if you're a lazy comic who's constantly punching
- 59:12down, defeating the purpose of comedy as an institution, if we can call it that.
- 59:17And then when people get offended at your jokes, you're going to hide behind free speech.
- 59:21Well, that's bitch made. First off, even if people get upset with a joke of
- 59:25mine, and they have, but I stand behind it because I think it's a good joke and I disagree.
- 59:31I'll keep doing it. Okay.
- 59:33Now, the reason is, is I learned early on. In fact, I learned this in high school. All right.
- 59:39People in general, no matter who they are, want to be accepted into the group.
- 59:45They want to be part of the crowd. Right.
- 59:48So I would at the end of one of my classes, because we had handicapped kids
- 59:54that that would sit in on regular classes.
- 59:56Right. And this one kid, Mark, was a buddy of mine.
- 1:00:00And I ended up sitting next to him quite often because his last name started with a B.
- 1:00:05So did mine. So we ended up close to each other in a lot of classes over the
- 1:00:09course of three, four years. Right.
- 1:00:12Totally kick-ass cool dude. Right. And he went from having a regular rolling wheelchair.
- 1:00:18He ended up getting an electric.
- 1:00:23Now, because of that relationship, I also became friends with a young girl who
- 1:00:28was also handicapped severely could barely talk,
- 1:00:34had the old, all, you know, the, the limbs were pulled up and, and, and, you know,
- 1:00:41She was in bad shape. She wanted to be part of the group. That's all she wanted.
- 1:00:46So one day she saw me pushing Mark when he had his old wheelchair.
- 1:00:54And I would like hop on the back of it and ride it a little bit.
- 1:00:57And then he got the new electric one and it was like, you know,
- 1:01:00it was like fucking little hot rod.
- 1:01:03Yeah. So I said to him, because I would walk next to him, but his chair was
- 1:01:09going so fast. I go, motherfucker, either slow down or let me hop on.
- 1:01:13Goes, well, hop on. I'll drop you at the doors for lunch. Well,
- 1:01:18I fucking hopped on at his request.
- 1:01:21And then she got offended about it? No, she wanted it. She wanted me to ride
- 1:01:26on the back of her chair, too.
- 1:01:28And those two started getting into little arguments about who was going to let
- 1:01:33who was going to ride me to the doors at lunchtime.
- 1:01:37Now, mind you, these two thought it was great because they were being included
- 1:01:42in regular fucking society.
- 1:01:44Right. They loved it.
- 1:01:47That made them feel so fucking normal. But boy, did I catch shit from a bunch of people.
- 1:01:54For including them in regular society. For including them. And that's my point.
- 1:01:58I think I know where you're going and correct me if I'm wrong,
- 1:02:02I'm not saying that a cheap shot is illegal.
- 1:02:07That's not what I'm saying. And it shouldn't be because it's often
- 1:02:10misunderstood so i got a ton of shit because after
- 1:02:13about three weeks of me zipping through the hallways on
- 1:02:16the back of fucking wheelchairs and then getting
- 1:02:19like if i saw them during the the
- 1:02:22course of the day and i was running late for class i'd be like hey can
- 1:02:24i get a ride to 402 yep boom and i
- 1:02:27was there on time i had one at one
- 1:02:30point at one point they would they were hanging out at the
- 1:02:33smoking doors waiting for me to finish my cigarette so they could zip
- 1:02:35my ass over to the next class because they never got
- 1:02:38late for being or in trouble for being late right so
- 1:02:41they just it was a mutually beneficial thing
- 1:02:44right a cheap inclusive shot is
- 1:02:47not what i'm talking about well here's my point though here's my
- 1:02:50comedy in the world in the
- 1:02:53world that we all participate in i don't
- 1:02:57know anyone that doesn't want to feel like part of a group if not the group
- 1:03:02we are social animals and by and by the definition of being social animals at
- 1:03:10our base everyone should be able to take a fucking joke.
- 1:03:16Especially if it's not meant with any venom. Now, again, I'm not going to defend
- 1:03:22somebody that says something shitty and thinks it's funny.
- 1:03:25OK, that's just a cunt being a cunt.
- 1:03:29Yeah. Like, I mean, if we take it again, I don't want to get bogged down in individuals.
- 1:03:34But if we take it back to the difference between Chappelle and the difference between Bill Maher.
- 1:03:39It sounded like that was like the first iteration of an Uber.
- 1:03:44Yeah. You could have called it wobble wagon. Wobble wagon.
- 1:03:49So if we take it back to the examples of Chappelle and Marr,
- 1:03:53Chappelle, I have not seen explicitly dehumanizing trans people. Yes.
- 1:03:59Trans people got up in arms about his comments, but that's, I mean that Marr
- 1:04:06you're talking, no, no, no, Chappelle. Okay. Chappelle.
- 1:04:09So, I have not personally heard him dehumanizing. In fact, Kiefer,
- 1:04:13you said that you rewatched the first one that really kicked off the whole drama.
- 1:04:20And the finalized, the end point of the routine is very humanizing and very
- 1:04:27beautiful. It's beautiful, yeah. Yeah.
- 1:04:30So, again, when I'm talking about Trappell in this point, I'm only talking about
- 1:04:36the perceived transphobia. Okay. Mm-hmm.
- 1:04:39Now, when we're talking about Marr, I've heard him dehumanize Palestinians.
- 1:04:43I've heard him dehumanize everyone.
- 1:04:47I mean, if there's one thing, look. That's a menace to society as far as I'm
- 1:04:52concerned. And I'm not going to disagree with you.
- 1:04:54He has become older, has become much more.
- 1:04:57Again, is he an old school Democrat? Yes.
- 1:05:00Does he take it too far as
- 1:05:03far as like his snottyness and his his smarmy way of i'm so much smarter than
- 1:05:10you yeah absolutely and because his whole thing is the holier than thou which
- 1:05:15doesn't help and because of that even if it was meant in jest in good nature he doesn't know how
- 1:05:22to smile big enough to take the sting out of what the attitude says. Okay. Yeah.
- 1:05:30He did not learn from Darwin Hines. And no, he did not. He did not learn from Darwin Hines. Yeah.
- 1:05:36You know what I respect him for, though, is he'll take shots at people, but he'll do it to them.
- 1:05:44I'll give him credit for that. Yep. Yeah. So he's got the balls to say it to
- 1:05:50your face. There's no two ways about that. You got to give him credit where credit's due.
- 1:05:53I don't remember what he said, but he took a shot at John Mellencamp, to John Mellencamp.
- 1:06:00And it was something that I went, oh, I don't know if I would have said that.
- 1:06:04Mellencamp just laughed like hard and that's
- 1:06:08the thing because Mellencamp has a sense of humor about himself
- 1:06:11and even if he didn't he was smart enough to realize if I
- 1:06:13laugh this off it goes away if
- 1:06:16I make a big deal about it I become the story I don't want to become the story
- 1:06:20now Steve I sent you a clip that I think in a relatively brief but incomplete
- 1:06:27manner kind of sums up my perspective on the conversation on free speech as
- 1:06:34a whole. Yep. Now play it now.
- 1:06:36Perspective, I think, in the broader free speech thing. On one hand,
- 1:06:38I'd like to consider myself a pretty big fan of free speech in a practical sense.
- 1:06:42I think it's really important as a society to preserve it. I've come down really
- 1:06:45hard on systems that don't have it, even in like England, where they have much
- 1:06:49stricter laws for liability to slander.
- 1:06:52I think stuff like that can be really, really bad all the way up to like China or whatever else.
- 1:06:55But at the same time, I feel like an advocacy for free speech is often kind
- 1:07:00of not a dog whistle, but it's, it's often invoked as a defense against the
- 1:07:05idea that there should be consequences for engaging in bad political behavior.
- 1:07:10You know, so, so like a kid will say something like, uh, you know,
- 1:07:12all lives matter, you know, the black people, blah, blah, and people will,
- 1:07:16will push back against that.
- 1:07:17And the response would be like free speech. I agree with you.
- 1:07:19I don't think a person who says all lives matter should be instantly treated
- 1:07:22like some kind of clan member, you know, but there are of course people who do worse things.
- 1:07:26And sometimes like when you push back against that, it's really hard to find
- 1:07:28that line. Because again, if there are no consequences to speech,
- 1:07:31then it's not meaningfully free.
- 1:07:34I can get behind a lot of what he said there. You know, I can.
- 1:07:38That very succinctly, though, and completely sums up kind of my perspective
- 1:07:43on it. All right. I can appreciate that.
- 1:07:46Okay. I guess we're ready to jump into the actual debate.
- 1:07:50So. Yeah. The longest opening in any debate. Yeah.
- 1:07:55And the shortest fucking debate. Right. The judge already objects.
- 1:08:02Well, too bad. Because guess what? Oh, go ahead.
- 1:08:05I just wanted to say the nature of our disagreement isn't about the governmental
- 1:08:11aspect of freedom of speech, I don't think.
- 1:08:14It's the social consequences. That's where the line is.
- 1:08:18And I know your perspective is
- 1:08:21whenever it comes to anything artistic that there is no valid limitation.
- 1:08:28And generally I agree with you on a governmental level.
- 1:08:32But what is valid is social consequences
- 1:08:35to well but see that's the
- 1:08:38thing is is i believe that when it comes to the art okay no one's forcing you
- 1:08:43to look at it no one's forcing you to read it no one's forcing you to watch
- 1:08:46it no one's forcing you out of your house and getting a babysitter going to
- 1:08:50dinner and then going seeing a stand-up comic but the so the the social contract
- 1:08:55that's made specifically,
- 1:08:57specifically with standup comedy is this room is a safe space where some outlandish
- 1:09:05shit is going to be said in an effort to elicit laughter,
- 1:09:10which is the working person's opium.
- 1:09:15Laughter is, is it doesn't matter how rich or poor you are.
- 1:09:19You have access to fucking humor.
- 1:09:24And if you're going to be upset by it, don't go.
- 1:09:30Don't listen. But you don't have to fucking complain. But also,
- 1:09:34in the modern era, and I'll leave it here on this, but in the modern era,
- 1:09:39you don't have to buy a ticket to see a comedy show. You don't have to click on.
- 1:09:43That's my point exactly. But what you shouldn't do is hop online and fucking
- 1:09:48put your opinion out there about a particular piece of art.
- 1:09:52Is that not a chilling on the freedom of speech? No, it's not a chilling on the freedom of speech.
- 1:09:57It's it's well, I'll explain how no one fucking cares if you had a bad experience at a restaurant.
- 1:10:03Wasting your time well those people are
- 1:10:06just like them people and they great get
- 1:10:09your little fucking workshop and your little fucking facebook group
- 1:10:13and complain all you want but leave us the fuck out of it you're you're constant
- 1:10:18bitching and complaining about this that or the other thing yes that's your
- 1:10:23right to do so but i also have a right to not hear it and and at the end of
- 1:10:29the and I could turn that exactly back on you.
- 1:10:32It's ticket sales. Well, no, at the end of the day, it's ticket sales.
- 1:10:35It's book sales. There is a type of person in this world that you could walk
- 1:10:41up to and be like, hey, you just won $1,000.
- 1:10:45Here's $1,000. And they would complain about how you handed it to them.
- 1:10:51There are just some people that you cannot ever fucking, hopefully,
- 1:10:55or that you could never hope to please.
- 1:10:58And that's the thing about stand-up comedy is different
- 1:11:01senses of humor but I guarantee you no matter what your
- 1:11:04sense of humor is there is a comedian on
- 1:11:07stage somewhere in the United States if not in the
- 1:11:10world and maybe multiple that represent
- 1:11:13that type of humor for you and you'll
- 1:11:16be perfectly happy with them but like I don't
- 1:11:19go to a movie and hate the movie and
- 1:11:22immediately hop on social media to tell
- 1:11:25everyone how much I fucking hated the movie right but
- 1:11:28you're also not terminally online person but
- 1:11:31that's that's the problem that's a separate issue
- 1:11:34that i think that that's the problem everyone thinks
- 1:11:37that they need to report on everything it's a complete surveillance society
- 1:11:45by society no one honestly let me tell you something i could give a fuck less
- 1:11:50what the guy at the gas station thinks about you know a book or a movie or fucking meal.
- 1:11:57I'm not interested in your fucking opinion.
- 1:12:01I have friends, I know a ton of people, who go on and on about what a fantastic movie Fight Club was.
- 1:12:10I'm one of them. I loved it. I wanted that time of my life back.
- 1:12:16And that's fair. I thought it was, quite honestly, one of the worst concepts,
- 1:12:21even the execution of the movie.
- 1:12:24I stood up in the first 20 minutes to walk out and realized, my wife is here.
- 1:12:30And so I sat back down. And you're entitled to that opinion.
- 1:12:35Yeah. And I, but see, that's the thing is I'll defend that. She did not know
- 1:12:39that I stood up, but had she known that I was about to leave, she would have left.
- 1:12:45Cause she too thought that it was a horrible piece of stuff.
- 1:12:49But see, that's the thing is, but where's one of those movies where I felt like
- 1:12:55I was dumber for having watched it.
- 1:12:57But you're entitled to that opinion you're entitled to have shared that opinion,
- 1:13:01I don't usually offer that information because I don't care if people know I'm
- 1:13:08sure people don't care if I share that information I don't usually bring it
- 1:13:12up unless someone says you know remember this in Fight Club that was such a great movie.
- 1:13:19Well, see, where my biggest argument is, okay, and we'll use Chappelle.
- 1:13:21If you ask me, I'll tell you, but it's just one of those things where I never
- 1:13:25miss it because I never watch it.
- 1:13:27So I'll tell you where I think maybe I haven't been clear, and we'll use Chappelle as the example, okay?
- 1:13:36I know for a fact, okay, so let me put it in this perspective.
- 1:13:41I don't care if you are offended. I don't care if you want to voice your offense,
- 1:13:51even all of it where I have a problem with it.
- 1:13:55And this is where we are in society is it's all about 30 second, two minute clips.
- 1:14:04It out of context you don't know necessarily but more often than not you don't
- 1:14:10know the full arc of so let's say for example with chappelle people heard one
- 1:14:15or two or three parts of that bit.
- 1:14:18Okay but they didn't hear the full bit they didn't
- 1:14:21hear it in context and they didn't hear the end because you know what if i'm
- 1:14:24trying to make a point about what a piece of shit dave chappelle is for talking
- 1:14:27about trans i'm not going to put the heart touching part on the end of that
- 1:14:32bit I'm not going to put the part that takes all of the sting out of it by explaining,
- 1:14:40oh, I learned something, and I learned that this person was a wonderful human being.
- 1:14:46Because sometimes in a joke, you have to build the tension, and you have to
- 1:14:51be the bad guy until you can show how you were taught differently.
- 1:14:56It's called making yourself you are not gonna get an argument out of me that americans are,
- 1:15:03not media literate no they're
- 1:15:06not you're not gonna get an argument out of me on that and when you
- 1:15:09have a uh uprising of people who did not see the show weren't at the show but
- 1:15:18saw clips of the show making a determination on whether or not they're gonna
- 1:15:22join a protest to try to make this motherfucker not have a career,
- 1:15:27yeah, I got a fucking problem with that free speech. I do have a problem with that.
- 1:15:30Because ultimately, it's the comics, in my opinion, but also the authors,
- 1:15:38the screenwriters, the directors,
- 1:15:41the poets, the songwriters, the musicians.
- 1:15:47We're the ones that are supposed to hold up the mirror to society.
- 1:15:50It's not our fault if you don't like what you see.
- 1:15:54If you don't like what you see, clean your fucking mirror. But don't blame me.
- 1:15:58All right, moving on. And now it's time for Kiefer.
- 1:16:02He once sipped tea so perfectly that Parliament applauded.
- 1:16:08He once rage quit a video game and the game apologized.
- 1:16:14He once stared down a blizzard until it snowed somewhere else,
- 1:16:20He is the most interesting Kiefer in America Stay informed, my friends,
- 1:16:28You can speak Russian fluently and French All right, so what are we getting into here?
- 1:16:37Well, I'm going to ask some questions and then I'm going to let you guys take
- 1:16:44two to two and a half minutes to discuss.
- 1:16:47All right. And I.
- 1:16:58Hit us. Is there any speech you believe should be protected,
- 1:17:03even if it is offensive, hateful, or false?
- 1:17:07I would say political speech does have a specific place, whether you want to
- 1:17:15call it a pedestal or not.
- 1:17:16But even in political speech, there is the potential for speech that is violence.
- 1:17:25In the sense of like if you
- 1:17:28go back to what was his fucking name the guy that
- 1:17:31that worked for nixon and then ended up working for reagan where
- 1:17:35he was like well back in back in the 50s you could say the n-word but now now
- 1:17:39you're now you can't that's that's not politically that's not politically expedient
- 1:17:43now you have to talk about you know you're getting so abstract uh you're talking
- 1:17:48about forced busing you're talking about all these things yeah the guy that
- 1:17:51was in the uh iran Contra scandal.
- 1:17:54That's who you're talking about. Not Ollie North. It wasn't Ollie?
- 1:17:58No, no. It was some political consultant cretin.
- 1:18:05Like that that's the point you know
- 1:18:08to me where it's like yes i think political speech
- 1:18:11does deserve extra protections
- 1:18:16but even within those extra protections there is still the capacity for political
- 1:18:22speech to be bad not only for society but just generally like not not good speech,
- 1:18:33hateful, regressive.
- 1:18:35I mean, Trump's speech before January 6th didn't directly incite violence,
- 1:18:41but indirectly incited violence.
- 1:18:44You know, like that's that's an area where, like, yeah, he should be punished
- 1:18:49for that. He was going to.
- 1:18:51But Merrick Garland dragged his fucking ass. Well, I agree and I disagree with you.
- 1:18:55I agree that, unfortunately, with Trump and that speech,
- 1:19:01he was able to manipulate the circumstance to make it political speech simply by being—.
- 1:19:15Political speech and that office have been beyond reproach until that point.
- 1:19:22It was a new thing for us to have to try to understand how it fit,
- 1:19:27whether it was political speech or whether he was inciting violence.
- 1:19:30I think we all knew where that was going to end up, but he never actually said
- 1:19:35commit violence that I recall.
- 1:19:37No, he didn't. He just said, we're going to march on the Capitol.
- 1:19:41And for what it's worth, I would put the arts in that same position where it
- 1:19:45does deserve extra protection, but that doesn't excuse the most obscene.
- 1:19:51And by obscene, I don't mean like the traditional definition of like,
- 1:19:55oh, he said fuck on stage.
- 1:19:56Yeah, I get I get where you're going. But I would I would actually say that
- 1:20:00in general, I agree with you on this on this evaluation or this assessment.
- 1:20:05I would add into that pornography.
- 1:20:09Pornography is an artistic expression.
- 1:20:12However, we do have the carve out, not child pornography.
- 1:20:16So I can see where you're coming from and I can make a correlation with that
- 1:20:20to try to find revenge porn.
- 1:20:22No, I can't define what pornography is, but I know when I see it. Yeah, exactly.
- 1:20:28And revenge porn, well, that's a party being subject to something that they did not agree to.
- 1:20:35Yeah, it's a non-consensual release. So, you know, exactly.
- 1:20:38It's non-consensual, A. B, any pornography that is, quote-unquote,
- 1:20:44professional pornography or published professional pornography,
- 1:20:48there's fucking, or there should be at least, you know, copies of driver's licenses,
- 1:20:54copies of consent forms, copies of what you will do and what you won't do. You know what I mean?
- 1:21:00Like, there's all those things that are in place so that the performer has...
- 1:21:06To make an educated decision on what it is that they are exposing themselves,
- 1:21:12not only to, but to what degree they're exposing themselves.
- 1:21:17Part of me is, as the judge, I'm going to Google pornography.
- 1:21:27All right, so no points deducted yet.
- 1:21:30Next question. Who should decide the limits of speech?
- 1:21:35I think when you're talking about deciding the limits of speech,
- 1:21:42it's difficult to say that the government should be the arbiter because that
- 1:21:49goes against the freedom of speech.
- 1:21:51But we have kind of de facto delegated that responsibility to the courts.
- 1:21:56Yeah. And I don't think that there's really a correct answer on this.
- 1:22:03I don't either because there's no one that I trust to be in charge of.
- 1:22:09Dictating what is allowed speech and what is not allowed speech.
- 1:22:13However, when it does go through the court system, at least it goes through several court systems.
- 1:22:18And eventually, if the argument is worthy, ends up at the Supreme Court.
- 1:22:23And while I don't like the makeup of the
- 1:22:25Supreme Court, I think it's not representative of not only the country,
- 1:22:32but it doesn't even cover fairly one Supreme Court justice for every circuit court.
- 1:22:39Right. So so I think it should represent one Supreme Court justice for every
- 1:22:44circuit court, first off, because that will give better representation to the
- 1:22:49people and they should be elected and have term limits.
- 1:22:53They should have that term limits as well. Exactly. They should have term limits.
- 1:22:56It shouldn't be for life. It may be your last job.
- 1:22:59And if look, if we have to just like we do with politicians and I'm sure we
- 1:23:04do with with Supreme Court justices, even after they retire,
- 1:23:07they still get a fucking paycheck. So this isn't a paycheck issue.
- 1:23:10This isn't a financial issue. And it shouldn't be because you do.
- 1:23:13No, it's a representation. It's a representation issue.
- 1:23:15And I, in the end, I do believe in, you know, equal representation.
- 1:23:19I do believe that you need to have an odd number because otherwise.
- 1:23:26Yeah, no ties. You can't have ties.
- 1:23:28And ultimately, look, when it comes to that argument of, you know,
- 1:23:35is there anything that you would or would not defend?
- 1:23:39So I absolutely abhor...
- 1:23:44KKK and neo-Nazis. But I would die on that hill to protect their right to speak the way they do.
- 1:23:54I wouldn't because they have proven themselves time and time again to be a terrorist organization.
- 1:24:00Now, yes, I understand that the counter to that is, well, tomorrow,
- 1:24:06any organization that you're a part of could be designated a terrorist organization. I get that.
- 1:24:11But the simple fact is the KKK arose
- 1:24:15because we didn't do enough during reconstruction after the civil war.
- 1:24:20Again, I'm not going to disagree with you with that. And I'm not going to disagree
- 1:24:23with you that they've been labeled this or labeled that or whatever,
- 1:24:26and that they proven that time and time again, I'm not, I'm not defending their behavior.
- 1:24:32I'm defending their right with the KKK, because now I have to be careful when
- 1:24:37I dress up on Halloween as a ghost and get the whole costume just perfect so
- 1:24:42that I'm not misconstrued.
- 1:24:45No red and no points. Yeah, that's pretty.
- 1:24:48But yeah, I mean, to me, adding the KKK into the conversation,
- 1:24:55I don't think that their speech should be protected or valid because they have
- 1:25:00acted in terroristic ways via their speech.
- 1:25:04And their speech has informed other terrorist activities.
- 1:25:09I understand that's a fragile argument, but it's kind of the best we got.
- 1:25:13As far as the question that we were just discussing, there isn't really a correct
- 1:25:17answer as to who should be the arbiter of what is allowed speech and what is not.
- 1:25:23The best I can really offer is, you know, we've delegated it to the Supreme, to the court system.
- 1:25:32It should probably just stay that way unless, you know, we end up with a grand
- 1:25:38speech poobah. No, see, that's the thing.
- 1:25:40I don't want some fucking speech czar or some fucking, you know, judicial committee.
- 1:25:44I will not take them seriously unless they have a fun hat.
- 1:25:50Like I said, I abhor everything that they represent, everything that they stand
- 1:25:56for, and I abhor everything that they want to say.
- 1:25:59But I would die on that hill protecting their right to say it. I would not.
- 1:26:04Fair enough. Next question. Mm-hmm.
- 1:26:08Private platforms have the same free speech obligations as governments if they
- 1:26:12function as the modern public square.
- 1:26:16No. Well, as I discussed earlier, I reject the idea that private platforms are
- 1:26:22a public square. I'm in the same boat.
- 1:26:25If it's your business, if it's your company, if it's your corporation,
- 1:26:31and it's an online, specifically, you know, social media. That's not to say
- 1:26:35that I don't have issues with how they handle certain things.
- 1:26:38Oh, I fucking can't stand a lot of it, but.
- 1:26:40I do have issues with how they handle certain things, but the simple fact of
- 1:26:43the matter is we live in a country that is hundreds of private companies stacked
- 1:26:49on top of each other, wearing a trench coat, calling themselves a country. Right. Yeah.
- 1:26:53So thank you, Citizens United, which, by the way, Citizens United,
- 1:26:59for those who don't know, is a decision that came down from the Supreme Court,
- 1:27:03which I thought was a horrible choice on their part.
- 1:27:06But I live with it. Everyone thinks that. OK, that says corporations are people
- 1:27:11and because they're people, they can spend their money accordingly how they
- 1:27:15want to regarding politics.
- 1:27:19Yeah, because that's free speech. Now, on a very, very micro level,
- 1:27:24I can understand how they came to that conclusion. I just think it's a bad conclusion. Yeah.
- 1:27:30So, yeah, to me, I reject the idea that that private streaming or social media sites or whatever,
- 1:27:38I reject the idea that that's a the modern town square or public square. As do I. Simply not.
- 1:27:46And I think that they have every right to reject service to whoever they choose.
- 1:27:52And for whatever reason. And I would I would add to that, that this idea that
- 1:27:58Elon says Twitter is the public square.
- 1:28:00I amend what I just said, not for whatever reason. You're not rejecting someone
- 1:28:05just because they're black or whatever.
- 1:28:08You get what I'm saying? Yeah, we get what you're saying. I would amend it with
- 1:28:12the public square thing.
- 1:28:13I think Elon saying that Twitter is the public square.
- 1:28:17I think that that is bullshit. I think that that's a poorly thought out manipulation.
- 1:28:23Especially because he can ban whoever he wants from that public square. At any time.
- 1:28:27So don't tell me it's the public square because if it's truly the public square,
- 1:28:31everyone is allowed to say whatever they want.
- 1:28:34That's a public square. And if you can decide that you don't like that,
- 1:28:39whether that's through kicking them off, suspending them, or shadow bans,
- 1:28:44it's not a public square.
- 1:28:47By definition, it's not a public square. Yeah.
- 1:28:50You got to love anybody that's going to unmute the president and then mute Don Lemon. Yeah.
- 1:28:57Getting to the next question. But that's because he didn't like the questions
- 1:29:00Don Lemon asked him when he did the interview with Don Lemon.
- 1:29:03Yeah. Exactly. Exactly.
- 1:29:05At what point does targeted harassment stop being protected speech and become conduct?
- 1:29:11I think as soon as it's targeted. Well, see, here's the thing is,
- 1:29:16is there, there was actually a case that's, that's, I don't know if it's gone
- 1:29:20in front of the courts or not, but this guy was, I forget who it was.
- 1:29:24It was a musician or something, I think like a country artist or something like that.
- 1:29:29And this guy was stalking her.
- 1:29:32Right. But he's made the argument, no, it was free speech.
- 1:29:37I didn't know that it was making her uncomfortable. I was just letting her know how much I was into her.
- 1:29:42And the fucking judge that heard that was like, well, I've said things like
- 1:29:46this because he was reading the tweets or the messages or whatever.
- 1:29:51Well, I've said things like this in the past. And, oh, well,
- 1:29:54that doesn't seem so bad to me.
- 1:29:56But no, no, no, no. Sad commentary. That's a sad commentary because clearly,
- 1:30:02clearly, after being told by this artist, please, no more.
- 1:30:10And he had found out where she lived and found out, you know,
- 1:30:13like all kinds of things about once the person being harassed says, please stop.
- 1:30:18I think that's when it's, I think that that's exactly when it becomes harassment.
- 1:30:23Yeah. And, or, and harassment and, or stalking.
- 1:30:27Yeah. And I don't think that that should be viable, viable for litigation at that point.
- 1:30:31At the bare minimum. As the judge, I say, correct.
- 1:30:35My God, we've made it through what? Three questions and not one shut your fucking pie hole.
- 1:30:41Can a society truly protect vulnerable groups without restricting some forms of expression?
- 1:30:49No, no. I think if we go back to our KKK example, you are infringing on,
- 1:30:58to some degree, their freedom of speech in the broadest sense.
- 1:31:03If you were to say, look, KKK is illegal now. Sorry.
- 1:31:08Germany, it's illegal to be,
- 1:31:13a Nazi in Germany. Okay. So that is, that is technically an infringement on,
- 1:31:18on freedom, but what it does is secure freedom and maximize freedom for the broad majority.
- 1:31:25All right. The needs of the many away the needs of the few. Yeah.
- 1:31:29All right. So I have a little bit of a problem with that. Just a little bit,
- 1:31:33right? Specifically the Germany example. All right.
- 1:31:36So, and going to the next question.
- 1:31:43While you do have flat earthers
- 1:31:46and you do have people who who don't
- 1:31:50think the holocaust happened okay which are harmful ideas in one respect or
- 1:31:56another are they though yes well here hear me out before you you quickly jump
- 1:32:02to yes all right i just want to point out that there are flat earthers all around the world.
- 1:32:07Yes, they are. Now, I'm not saying that I agree with either of these.
- 1:32:12Okay, so let me be clear. I'm not saying that I agree with a Holocaust denial,
- 1:32:16and I'm not saying that I agree with flat earthers.
- 1:32:19Okay? But what I am saying is, if they have a good enough argument that they've
- 1:32:25put enough time into that is actually worth my time to listen,
- 1:32:30I would like to hear their argument.
- 1:32:32Because the winners write history, but the losers usually have a few nuggets of fucking truth.
- 1:32:41Not necessarily the winners. It's the survivors. Well, survivors.
- 1:32:45That write history. Yeah, all right. And the survivors are not necessarily the winners.
- 1:32:50No, not necessarily, but oftentimes the winner is the one who writes history.
- 1:32:56That's pretty much common knowledge.
- 1:32:58You know what I mean? Like, so when you've been taught this,
- 1:33:01again, you've been taught evolution
- 1:33:04is the way of the world and somebody comes along and says, no. No.
- 1:33:12Fascinationism or no, you know, divine intervention, whatever,
- 1:33:17right? Whatever their theory is.
- 1:33:20I'm curious enough to want to be able to, should I choose to hear that argument?
- 1:33:27And I think that that law in Germany stifles that ability for people to hear that other side.
- 1:33:36I don't say- But at this point, does it though?
- 1:33:38And the reason I say at this, in the Germany example specifically at this point
- 1:33:43does it though because how many living nazis are there still,
- 1:33:48know and how many of those living nazis were high enough up to actually know
- 1:33:53what was happening again i don't know i've heard in in this arena that goebbels
- 1:34:01book was actually far more.
- 1:34:05Enlightening when it came to what was actually going on in germany during that
- 1:34:09time than any of the history books might have been i've not heard that so i'm
- 1:34:14curious to read that book but But if that book is not allowed to exist.
- 1:34:19That's not the German law. The German law is just you can't be in public with
- 1:34:24a swastika, siegheiling, spouting anti-Semitic shit.
- 1:34:29So shit like that, okay, fine. You can't be in public doing Nazi shit. That's the law. Okay.
- 1:34:35But does that law allow for somebody to go, I don't think that the Holocaust
- 1:34:41happened, and here are my reasons why, and here are the receipts I bring to the table.
- 1:34:46It does not allow for that. That's where I think it goes wrong.
- 1:34:48Because who the fuck else would have the records?
- 1:34:53I don't think that's... If not the Germans, who the fuck else would have the
- 1:34:56records of the Holocaust having happened? I still don't think that that is a
- 1:35:01valid reason for that conversation not to be allowed, or that freedom of speech
- 1:35:06to be allowed. And that's just my opinion.
- 1:35:08Every time I heard Germans, I just hear Mr. Burns in my head. Oh no, not Germans.
- 1:35:18I don't know if you guys are familiar with that. Oh yeah. That's funny. Question.
- 1:35:24Should comedians, artistes, and satirists receive broader protection than ordinary
- 1:35:32speakers because exaggeration and offense are built into the form?
- 1:35:37And the judge has said it like that because it tickles the court.
- 1:35:42I don't think that necessarily entertainers or artists should receive broader
- 1:35:50protections over any individual on a legal basis or on a social basis.
- 1:35:59Like, quite honestly, if it hasn't been clear at this point,
- 1:36:02I don't think anyone is above social consequence for making a lazy joke,
- 1:36:09making a joke in poor taste,
- 1:36:12holding holding dog shit opinions.
- 1:36:14You're subject to social consequences. That being said, on a legal basis,
- 1:36:20I don't think that anyone should necessarily be arrested for,
- 1:36:25not even necessarily, I don't think anyone should be arrested for, you know,
- 1:36:31saying a joke that didn't land.
- 1:36:33And, you know, I don't think that a painter painting something so,
- 1:36:39what would you say, like, adversive to society? Subversive.
- 1:36:44Subversive. I don't think that that person should be arrested,
- 1:36:47but they are subject to social consequence.
- 1:36:50I think that the only social consequence is, are there asses in the seat?
- 1:36:55Are the books being sold?
- 1:36:57Are people overall coming to the event?
- 1:37:02And I disagree because let's take a book, for example, if I read a book and I'm like, man.
- 1:37:08Yes, this is written well, the story is cohesive, but it holds up a really dogshit
- 1:37:15and regressive narrative of society.
- 1:37:18I'm going to go tell people about
- 1:37:21this book and how dogshit and regressive the message of this book is.
- 1:37:25That's a social consequence. But you're not going to get a party together and
- 1:37:28burn copies of those books.
- 1:37:32No, I'm obviously not going to do that.
- 1:37:35But if enough people also feel that this book has a dog shit regressive message
- 1:37:42and say, we don't like this book.
- 1:37:45We're getting rid of this book and we're not buying any more books from this author.
- 1:37:51That's a social consequence. It is a social consequence, but like I said,
- 1:37:55at the end of the day, at the end of the day, I don't care, and I'm going to use comedy.
- 1:38:01If the comic is putting asses in seats, that's all that matters.
- 1:38:07To the comic specifically and to the club specifically
- 1:38:10no no no yes yes to the art because
- 1:38:14people still want to see that and if people don't
- 1:38:17want to see the particular art that is being presented by that particular performer
- 1:38:21there will be no asses in the seats that's the social consequence that's the
- 1:38:25only social consequence that matters that's it that's the only one that matters
- 1:38:29because at the end of the day if you don't have comics who have always always
- 1:38:33always has been on the forefront,
- 1:38:35the bleeding edge of what free speech is.
- 1:38:39If you don't have them, you have no free speech.
- 1:38:42And I would say the same about authors. I would say the same about writers and producers of movies.
- 1:38:50I would say the same of poets. I would say the same of musicians.
- 1:38:54I would disagree strongly. Well, tell me why.
- 1:38:57Because as I was alluding to earlier, I can walk out into the middle of the
- 1:39:01woods and say whatever the hell I want. and I have the freest speech that anyone has had free speech.
- 1:39:08Does not factor in when you're talking about the social construct of being in
- 1:39:14society. Okay, and I can do the same thing.
- 1:39:17With that being said, I'm not saying that asses in seats, tickets sold doesn't
- 1:39:23matter as a social consequence. It does.
- 1:39:26Because that's that comic's livelihood or that artist's livelihood.
- 1:39:30That's that club's livelihood.
- 1:39:32I'm not saying that that doesn't matter. What I'm saying is,
- 1:39:35if you piss people off enough to Where you're not getting asses in the seats
- 1:39:39and you have a boycott outside.
- 1:39:41That's a social consequence. And it fucking matters. I want a boycott outside.
- 1:39:46I'll have more asses in the seats.
- 1:39:48That's exactly what the fuck I want. I want people protesting my show because
- 1:39:53it's too filthy or it's too this or it's too that.
- 1:39:56And I'll tell you another thing. As far as being standing out in the middle of the fucking woods.
- 1:39:59Yeah, great. I'm standing in the middle of the woods. I'm standing on a stump
- 1:40:02and I'm screaming at the top of my lungs. everything that I wanted to say as a comedian.
- 1:40:08I've got somebody that just happens to hear me in the distance and him and his
- 1:40:12friends, they come up and they decide to sit on a couple more stumps.
- 1:40:15Well, guess what? The next people to come, I'm charging fucking admission for.
- 1:40:19And now I'm in the middle of the woods doing a stand up show for people that
- 1:40:22have shown up because they've chosen to walk into the woods.
- 1:40:26Do I still have the same level of freedom of
- 1:40:29speech because I have an audience that I
- 1:40:31had when I didn't have an audience no it's the
- 1:40:34same freedom of speech people have chosen
- 1:40:37to trust the performer to take them on
- 1:40:40a ride and the social contract when you
- 1:40:43do stand-up comedy is this i understand
- 1:40:46as the performer that people are this might
- 1:40:49be it this might be their entertainment budget for the fucking month i
- 1:40:53don't want to piss them off these people have worked 40 hours
- 1:40:56a week or more they're dealing with kids and getting them
- 1:40:59to their fucking sporting events or getting them to their fucking cub
- 1:41:01scouts or their girl scouts or their brownies or whatever the fuck else
- 1:41:04they're dealing with having to take care of a house and
- 1:41:07maybe maybe just fucking maybe this one
- 1:41:10fucking weekend this one night this one show they've had enough opportunity
- 1:41:16over the last three months to save up enough to not only buy the tickets to
- 1:41:21see the show have a few drinks maybe have dinner out and pay for a fucking babysitter
- 1:41:26why would i want to piss them off but i don't know them.
- 1:41:31I'm not saying you're trying to piss them off.
- 1:41:33No, I know, but this is my point. This is my point. I don't know them.
- 1:41:36Now, maybe I tell a joke about my father or my grandfather, and it hits a sour
- 1:41:43note for them because they identify something in that joke that upsets them.
- 1:41:49Well, I didn't know they were fucking coming, and I didn't know that they had
- 1:41:52that story in their background.
- 1:41:54Don't get fucking shitty with me as an audience member when I didn't know you were fucking coming.
- 1:42:00You should have taken the time to investigate me because you're spending your money on me.
- 1:42:07And if you're offended by something I say, don't ask for your fucking money back.
- 1:42:13You didn't do your homework. Go fuck yourself. That's my opinion.
- 1:42:18First off, you mentioned into the woods. And I wanted to say into the woods
- 1:42:23and out of the woods and now we're getting sued.
- 1:42:28But there was a fantastic book written by one Eric Bischoff.
- 1:42:33I know neither of you probably know who Eric Bischoff is.
- 1:42:36He's a TV producer and wrote and produced WCW Wrestling.
- 1:42:41Though was called controversy creates cash
- 1:42:44and he lays it all
- 1:42:47out there you want to get an audience you want to put butts
- 1:42:50in seats start creating controversy shocks
- 1:42:53some people yeah it's the easiest and best and
- 1:42:56smartest way to get the attention that you
- 1:42:59need and in the course of doing that you're going to offend some people and
- 1:43:02you know what you got to be okay with that because at the end of the day everybody is
- 1:43:06offended by something different and you have no idea
- 1:43:09as a performer what that is and if you start as a
- 1:43:12performer whether that's a as a writer
- 1:43:15a musician a comic whatever right
- 1:43:19if you start to wonder and worry and concern yourself how is this going to land
- 1:43:24how is everyone going to take this how is the person who's a recluse going to
- 1:43:28take this how's the person who's a trans going to take this how's the person
- 1:43:32who's lgbt how's this person How about the person who is on the spectrum?
- 1:43:37Well, you're never going to be able to write, perform,
- 1:43:41or do anything because now you are paralyzed by a fear that you're going to
- 1:43:49be ostracized by society for an unintentional fucking offense.
- 1:43:55And to clarify, to clarify again, I am not saying that anyone has the right not to be offended.
- 1:44:02What I am saying is people do get offended, whether we like it or not.
- 1:44:07And that is a social consequence of the use of freedom.
- 1:44:11Okay, so really what you're getting at is it's just the number of people that
- 1:44:14are offended that qualifies whether or not you are a bad person,
- 1:44:21a bad comic, a bad musician, a bad writer.
- 1:44:25No, but I mean, isn't that essentially what it gets down to?
- 1:44:28If one person is offended and complains, but no one gives a fuck,
- 1:44:33that's not a social consequence. Yes, it is.
- 1:44:37One I'd give a fuck about. Definitionally, it is. Not one anyone would give
- 1:44:40a fuck about, as an example.
- 1:44:42I'm not saying you have to give a fuck about anyone or any amount of people being offended.
- 1:44:47My point is that people do get offended.
- 1:44:51That is a social consequence to your use of freedom of speech. Right.
- 1:44:56However. You don't have to care about that. However. But the simple fact is,
- 1:44:59if enough people are pissed off about your use of freedom of speech,
- 1:45:03and they choose not to engage with your content and choose not to buy your tickets
- 1:45:09and choose not to support you, that's a social consequence.
- 1:45:12And that's that. But you as the performer should not give a fuck as much as
- 1:45:18if it's one person or if it's 10,000 people. That's my point.
- 1:45:22I think, honestly, in the vast majority of things, and I'll use,
- 1:45:26again, I hate to, but Chappelle is the example.
- 1:45:28He came out and he was like, no, I'm not going to fucking back down.
- 1:45:31I'm not going to back down because I don't think I did anything wrong.
- 1:45:34And I'm going to keep doing these jokes to show you that I did nothing wrong.
- 1:45:39And he stood on business, and I give him credit for that. I do too.
- 1:45:41I think that that was the bravest fucking thing he could do because at the end
- 1:45:45of the day, I... He did not hide behind freedom of speech as an excuse to get
- 1:45:50out of social consequence.
- 1:45:51No, he continued with his freedom of speech to justify why he was right and they were wrong.
- 1:45:58And he came out on top. My problem is, is that you have this mob mentality,
- 1:46:03often uninformed with the actual context of the thing that they're complaining about.
- 1:46:09And it goes to the point where that lady came up to me in South Bend,
- 1:46:13Indiana and said, you're a chauvinist. I'm like, what the fuck are you talking about?
- 1:46:17You clearly did not hear my show.
- 1:46:20You heard one line and that one line offended you and you stopped listening.
- 1:46:27But had you kept listening, you would have seen that that line was a setup to
- 1:46:33make me look like an idiot so that you could laugh at a man making a mistake.
- 1:46:40That's all it was. Yeah. So fuck you, lady. All I'm saying is that's- Fuck you, lady.
- 1:46:46Her coming up to you is a social consequence. Yeah, and the consequence was
- 1:46:50me calling her a fucking cunt and telling her to get the fuck out of the club.
- 1:46:53Which was a social consequence of her actions and her freedom of speech. Fair enough.
- 1:46:59Well, you've all answered the next few questions in that one question,
- 1:47:03so I'm going to have to skip ahead.
- 1:47:05All right, and we're creeping up on two hours, I think, or something fucking
- 1:47:09ridiculous, so. Let's hit like five more. Yeah.
- 1:47:14Is punching down a moral critique or should it become a basis for restricting speech?
- 1:47:21This is where you and I are going to disagree, but I don't, I don't,
- 1:47:25I don't think that it's a basis for restricting speech for what it's worth,
- 1:47:30but I think doing it is lazy routine.
- 1:47:34But I, what I mean is routinely punching down, not like, Oh,
- 1:47:38quick little jab or like, Oh, quick little observation about this community.
- 1:47:43That's not what I'm talking about. Even if that could be perceived by that community as punching down.
- 1:47:48When I think punching down, I think a pattern, a routine of this community or
- 1:47:55this type of person is the butt of the joke.
- 1:47:58Okay, can I ask a question real quick?
- 1:48:01Let's say it's a segment. Let's say it's a chunk of material.
- 1:48:05Okay. And let's say it's three to five minutes.
- 1:48:08It's a three to five minute bit. It's not a huge chunk, but it's a chunk.
- 1:48:12My first question is, because I agree, lazy writing is lazy writing.
- 1:48:18And I don't have, I will never defend lazy writing. I'm just not going to do that.
- 1:48:23Okay. I'm not going to defend lazy punchlines. I'm not going to do that.
- 1:48:28I'm not going to defend people picking on people when it's clear that it's just,
- 1:48:35there's no joke there. You're just being an asshole.
- 1:48:38Yeah. And that's what I mean by punching down. Okay,
- 1:48:42that's what I wanted to get clear on, because I hate the term punching down,
- 1:48:46because I don't think that that's actually a legitimate term for what most people
- 1:48:52think when it comes to picking on, let's say.
- 1:48:58Any ethnic group, right? You can pick on every ethnic group.
- 1:49:02I don't think it's... I don't have a problem with a jab. I'm going even for,
- 1:49:07you know, you can't joke about that. The fuck I can't?
- 1:49:10Well, you can't joke about rape. Carlin proved that you could. Yeah.
- 1:49:16That's what I'm talking about. I don't like when people say,
- 1:49:19I'm offended by what you said because I think you're punching down.
- 1:49:25Well, you need to define what punching down is pretty fucking clearly.
- 1:49:29To me, when I hear punching down, I think a routine and habitual pattern of bullying.
- 1:49:36A specific person, group.
- 1:49:39But that's the thing is no professional comedian is
- 1:49:42going to make it past 10 years and be able to
- 1:49:45make a living punching down bill mar
- 1:49:48did no he didn't no he
- 1:49:51what do you call his comments on palestine then his routine recent
- 1:49:54comments i call them recent i call them
- 1:49:57yeah sure i mean sure recent in the sense of
- 1:50:00he didn't he didn't even know palestine fucking existed until
- 1:50:03october 7th 2023 again i
- 1:50:05would disagree and and like i said i i'm not defending
- 1:50:08his ignorance i'm not defending his poor
- 1:50:12or his his his character change
- 1:50:16as far as it goes for him being a snarky asshole
- 1:50:20okay i've seen to one degree or another he's always been let's be honest yeah
- 1:50:25he has to a degree okay he has to a degree always been a snarky asshole but
- 1:50:29i've seen him perform live I've seen his specials and that's different than
- 1:50:35what he does on his TV show.
- 1:50:38Yeah. So I'm not going to. That HBO money went to his head a little is what you're telling me.
- 1:50:43I'm sure it did, but that's not even the point that I'm making.
- 1:50:48The point I'm making is every comedian evolves differently.
- 1:50:53Loses some audience members and gains more or replaces them with different audience
- 1:50:58members over the course of a fucking 35, 40 year career or whatever he's got right now.
- 1:51:03He's got to have like, he's got, well, he's what?
- 1:51:06I think he's 65 or something like that.
- 1:51:09I don't know. I think I know he's over 60, 70. Well, I know he's over 60 and
- 1:51:14I know he's been doing comedy basically since college. So whatever that is,
- 1:51:19let's call it 40 years. Okay.
- 1:51:21You're not the same person comedically in your 20s as you are in your 30s,
- 1:51:26as you are in your 40s, as you are in your 50s, as you are in your 60s,
- 1:51:29as you are in your 70s. You're going to change.
- 1:51:33And maybe some of those changes are good and some of them are bad.
- 1:51:38And sometimes you're going to. All right. So, like.
- 1:51:41You can tell what drug Carlin was doing in any given decade. You can.
- 1:51:46But there are people who only like early Carlin. Some people only like 80s Carlin.
- 1:51:51Some people only like 90s Carlin.
- 1:51:53Some only like, you know, 2000s until he died Carlin.
- 1:51:56Same thing goes for Dave Chappelle. There are people that only like early Dave
- 1:52:01Chappelle and some people like late Dave Chappelle.
- 1:52:04And if you go back and you listen to early Dave Chappelle, okay,
- 1:52:08again, you might get offended, but it's kind of fucking brilliant and it's definitely hysterical.
- 1:52:15But who he was as a comedian In the 90s Is not the same person he is In 2026,
- 1:52:24And I can say that because I literally Sat in a comedy condo,
- 1:52:31wiley's comedy club which was his home club when he was in ohio until he got his own fucking town.
- 1:52:39Right and after the show we
- 1:52:42were sitting in the condo smoking a joint and talking like normal fucking human
- 1:52:47beings it's one of the kindest gentlest and most compassionate people i have
- 1:52:55ever come across and i would say the same thing for carrot top and i would say the same thing,
- 1:53:00not for bill maher he was a bit of an asshole but yeah
- 1:53:04but i called very short i literally said that
- 1:53:07to him i said he said to me why don't you buy
- 1:53:10me a beer after the show i go motherfucker i didn't get paid tonight
- 1:53:13because you only let females open for you and
- 1:53:16you just got picked up by abc off of
- 1:53:19comedy central money why don't you buy me
- 1:53:22a fucking beer yeah and he appreciated that he laughed at that long story short
- 1:53:28i i don't believe in 99 of the time i don't believe in restriction of speech
- 1:53:35so that's that's kind of my answer on that let's move on next question,
- 1:53:43if we begin censoring offensive humor who gets to decide where comedy ends and harm begins.
- 1:53:51I hate to do it again, but I, I defer, I defer to the court system.
- 1:53:56Not that it's a perfect system, not that it's even a good system,
- 1:53:59but you know, if someone's marching up on, on,
- 1:54:04on stage as a comedian and spewing Nazi shit and finishes their set with,
- 1:54:12and yeah, let's kill all the Jews. Good night, everyone. Thanks for coming out.
- 1:54:16Yeah. That's, that's not okay.
- 1:54:20All right. And should probably go through the court system. I would argue that
- 1:54:25if it was done in parody and it was funny, it should be allowed.
- 1:54:31And I will cite Mel Brooks.
- 1:54:34Thank you. I was about to go there. As the judge, I was going to bring up springtime
- 1:54:39for Hitler, which is one of the funniest things that I have ever witnessed.
- 1:54:45Again, with this question, it's such a shaky kind of...
- 1:54:51I'm not even I'm not even necessarily comfortable saying Supreme Court should
- 1:54:55decide what's comedy and what's harmful.
- 1:54:57You know, like I would argue, buddy, I would argue that under parody law,
- 1:55:04under comedic law, comedians learn that there's a difference between breaking
- 1:55:09the law and bending the rules.
- 1:55:11And if you actually make
- 1:55:14it to the point where that's your living as a
- 1:55:17comedian and you're able to sustain and
- 1:55:20support yourself by telling jokes you know what the lines are what the laws
- 1:55:28are and what the rules are by 10 years in and it takes that long and anyone
- 1:55:34that makes it past 10 years that continuously is failing.
- 1:55:38They're failing because they're not writing good enough material.
- 1:55:42And sooner or later, they will realize that.
- 1:55:49Unfortunately, due to technical difficulties, I can fucking talk.
- 1:55:55Technical difficulties.
- 1:55:58Unfortunately, one Colton's Wi-Fi has apparently dropped out.
- 1:56:03Completely and totally. So I'm going to have to make a ruling based on this,
- 1:56:07which is nobody wins. We all lose with censorship.
- 1:56:11Remember that comedy, music, art is subjective. it.
- 1:56:16It's always up to us how we interpret everything. And for that,
- 1:56:21I want to thank myself and no one but myself because I can't as judge.
- 1:56:28You all have to listen to what I say. You're such an ass.
- 1:56:32I would, I would say that I agree with you. No one wins when you censor.
- 1:56:36Like it's, it's, it's the most ridiculous thing in the world.
- 1:56:40And, and to, uh. And sometimes I enjoy when people try to do that because it
- 1:56:46just pushes that person, that art form to another stratosphere,
- 1:56:51as in it did for a while with,
- 1:56:54oh gosh, Andrew Dice Clay. Yeah.
- 1:56:56Yeah, that's a good example. For a while, he became crazy popular because he was offending people.
- 1:57:02And some people who have a certain personality think that's funny,
- 1:57:08such as me. You have people like Don Rickles who made an entire career of offending
- 1:57:14people because it was funny.
- 1:57:15The way nobody was safe.
- 1:57:18Nobody. Right.
- 1:57:21Made it wonderful i mean they literally called him mr warm
- 1:57:24yep i would add one
- 1:57:28thing that bothers me more than anything is
- 1:57:30when people disrespect the social contract between
- 1:57:34the audience and the performer when
- 1:57:37it comes to stand-up comedy if you're offended
- 1:57:40by something a comedian says hold your
- 1:57:43breath for two seconds and wait
- 1:57:46for the next fucking joke bite your tongue don't
- 1:57:49get offended just let it roll off your back that that
- 1:57:52joke wasn't for me but let's see
- 1:57:55jerking off without coming yeah so just
- 1:57:59just wait just just wait a moment and i guarantee you there's another joke coming
- 1:58:05that you will like and to kind of lead us out of this here's christopher hitchens
- 1:58:11fire fire fire fire now you've heard it not shouted in a cloudy theater admittedly.
- 1:58:19As I realize I seem now to have shouted it in the Hogwarts dining room.
- 1:58:25But the point is made. Everyone knows the fatuous verdict of the greatly overpraised
- 1:58:30Justice Oliver Wendell Holmes, who asked for an actual example of when it would
- 1:58:35be proper to limit speech or define it as an action,
- 1:58:38gave that of shouting fire in a crowded theater.
- 1:58:41It's very often forgotten what he was doing in that case, was sending to prison
- 1:58:46a group of Yiddish-speaking socialists,
- 1:58:49whose literature was printed in a language most Americans couldn't read,
- 1:58:53opposing President Wilson's participation in the First World War and the dragging
- 1:58:58of the United States into this sanguinary conflict which the Yiddish-speaking
- 1:59:02socialists had fled from Russia to escape.
- 1:59:04In fact, it could be just as plausibly argued that the.
- 1:59:08Speaking socialists who were jailed by the excellent and overpraised Char-Joyver
- 1:59:12Wendell Holmes were the real firefighters, were the ones who were shouting fire
- 1:59:16when there really was fire in a very crowded theater.
- 1:59:20Indeed. And who is to decide? Well, keep that question if you would,
- 1:59:25ladies and gentlemen, brothers and sisters, I hope I may say comrades and friends, before your minds.
- 1:59:30I exempt myself from the speaker's kind offer of protection that was so generously
- 1:59:36proffered at the opening of this evening.
- 1:59:38Anyone who wants to say anything abusive about or to me is quite free to do
- 1:59:43so, and welcome, in fact, at their own risk.
- 1:59:48But before they do that, they must have taken, as I'm sure we all should,
- 1:59:53a short refresher course in the classic texts on this matter,
- 1:59:57which are John Milton's Areopagitica, Areopagitica being the great hill of Athens
- 2:00:01for discussion and free expression.
- 2:00:04Paine's introduction to the age of reason, and I would say a John Stuart Mill's
- 2:00:08essay on liberty, in which it is variously said,
- 2:00:11I'll be very daring and summarize all three of these great gentlemen of the
- 2:00:17great tradition of especially English liberty, in one go.
- 2:00:21What they say is, it's not just the right of the person who speaks to be heard.
- 2:00:26It is the right of everyone in the audience to listen and to hear.
- 2:00:30And every time you silence somebody, you make yourself a prisoner of your own
- 2:00:34action because you deny yourself the right to hear something.
- 2:00:37In other words, your own right to hear and be exposed is as much involved in
- 2:00:42all these cases as is the right of the other to voice his or her view.
- 2:00:49Indeed, as John Stuart Mill said, if all in society were agreed on the truth
- 2:00:53and beauty and value of one proposition, all except one person,
- 2:00:57It would be most important,
- 2:00:59in fact, it would become even more important that that one heretic be heard,
- 2:01:05because we would still benefit from his perhaps outrageous or appalling view in more modern times.
- 2:01:12This has been put, I think, best by a personal heroine of mine,
- 2:01:17Rosa Luxemburg, who said that the freedom of speech is meaningless unless it
- 2:01:20means the freedom of the person who thinks differently.
- 2:01:25My great friend john o'sullivan former editor of the national review and my
- 2:01:30i think probably my most conservative and reactionary catholic friend once said
- 2:01:35it's a tiny thought experiment he says if you hear the pope saying he believes
- 2:01:39in god you think well the pope's doing his job again today,
- 2:01:44if you hear the pope saying he's really begun to doubt the existence of god
- 2:01:47you begin to think he might be on to something and that is my point and my final
- 2:01:53point and with that that's another Elsie's.
- 2:02:44Say that I should hate this person. So I'm going to hate this person,
- 2:02:46but I don't know fucking nothing about that person.