Latest / Public Health Review Morning Edition / 1045: Bringing Island Voices Into the Data: Inside the First PHWINS Territories Survey
Transcript
- 0:01This is Public Health Review MORNING Edition for Thursday,
- 0:04December 18th, 2025. I'm John Sheehan with news from
- 0:07the Association of State and Territorial Health Officials.
- 0:11Today we hear about newly collected data concerning the
- 0:14needs, challenges and demographics of public health
- 0:17workers from all eight US territories and freely
- 0:20associated states. The information was collected as
- 0:23a pilot program of the pH WINS, the Public Health Workers
- 0:27Interests and Needs Survey, which is run jointly every three
- 0:31years by the de Beaumont Foundation and ASTO.
- 0:34The survey hadn't included US public health workforces in
- 0:37island territories until now. Puerto Rico and the US Virgin
- 0:42Islands in the Atlantic. In the Pacific we have American
- 0:46Samoa, the Commonwealth of the Northern Mariana Islands and
- 0:50Guam, and then we have 3 freely associated States, the Federated
- 0:55States of Micronesia, the Republic of the Marshall
- 0:58Islands, and the Republic of Palau.
- 1:01This is Rachel Herr Bork, director of pH Wins for the De
- 1:04Beaumont Foundation. I am so excited that all of the
- 1:10eight US territories and freely associated states participated
- 1:15in some shape or form on our pH WINS Islands pilot.
- 1:20We sent the survey to almost 9000 individuals working in
- 1:26government public health and it had a response rate of 28% among
- 1:32eligible employees, which is something that we are really
- 1:36excited about. And how?
- 1:38Did you get such a high? Participation rate.
- 1:41We worked really hard in conjunction with ASTO and the
- 1:47Pacific Island Health Officers Association, PIHOA, to really
- 1:53explain the survey. We did a lot of travel,
- 1:56attending national meetings, going out to these specific
- 2:00islands to meet with leaders, explaining to them what the
- 2:04survey is, what the survey is not.
- 2:07We also worked with them to adjust some of the questions so
- 2:12that the survey did match the unique context of the island.
- 2:17And it's some pretty far-flung places.
- 2:20Yeah, I have a lot of air Miles. No doubt this is the first time
- 2:24this survey has taken data from these territories.
- 2:29Yes. It was something that we always
- 2:31had wanted to do, but we're never able to.
- 2:35And we're really fortunate that we got financial support from
- 2:39CDC to make this happen. And we're thrilled that now
- 2:45these islands have a voice. And it's really great that since
- 2:49the islands participated, we now have data that expresses how
- 2:54they are similar to the rest of the country and also their
- 2:58unique characteristics. That's great.
- 3:01So what were some results? Yeah.
- 3:02So we found some really interesting things when we ran
- 3:07the survey, places in which these islands are really similar
- 3:11to the mainland United States and places where they are a bit
- 3:15different. So one area that we really
- 3:18focused on in the survey is understanding the workforce that
- 3:23is 35 years old or younger. And what we see is that the
- 3:27islands have a much younger workforce than the mainland of
- 3:31the United States. So here in the mainland, 25% of
- 3:35our workforce, about one in four folks are going to say that they
- 3:38are 35 years old and under. In the islands as a whole, that
- 3:43number goes up to 32%. And when you just look at the
- 3:46Pacific Islands, it's 36%. So that cuts both ways.
- 3:52On the one hand, it's really great to have young people with
- 3:54fresh ideas entering the workforce.
- 3:58At the same time, they may lack institutional knowledge and they
- 4:03may in some places lack training.
- 4:06And this is another interesting finding.
- 4:08So within the mainland, it's actually 36% of those who are 35
- 4:13and under have a degree in public health.
- 4:16That's compared to 17% of older folks in the mainland United
- 4:21States. In the islands, it is reversed.
- 4:25So on the islands as a whole, only 30% of that younger
- 4:29population has a degree in public health.
- 4:32And in the Pacific, it's really low.
- 4:35It's only 12% of people who are 35 and under have a degree in
- 4:41public health, which shows that there needs to be more
- 4:45opportunities for education and training for the younger islands
- 4:50workforce because they don't have it at the same levels as
- 4:53their peers in the mainland. And did you find that this these
- 5:01survey results were surprising to to the territorial
- 5:05leadership? Yes and no.
- 5:08I think in a lot of times pH Wins gives you the numbers of
- 5:12things that you kind of already know, but that and that is
- 5:15powerful, right, to be able to go to leaders with those
- 5:19numbers. I think in the Pacific, they
- 5:23know it is an issue. They have training programs that
- 5:28they're really proud of that they're working to expand.
- 5:30I think the number itself maybe was a little jarring exactly how
- 5:35low it is. And I also think it's really
- 5:39powerful and this is about pH wins in general, is that the
- 5:43survey allows you to compare to so that they can now go to
- 5:47leadership and say, hey, we have a real training problem.
- 5:50Only 12% of our USAPI under 35 workforce have a degree in
- 5:56public health. We are behind the rest of the
- 5:59islands and we are way behind the mainland.
- 6:01And that is, I think, a really powerful narrative that leaders
- 6:05can use that they couldn't say before they participated in pH
- 6:10ones. Yeah.
- 6:11Is that an example of one of the directions, maybe one of the the
- 6:15takeaways that leadership can can bring from the data results?
- 6:21Yeah, I think a lot of the leaders have talked about using
- 6:25this data to go to territorial leadership or freely associated
- 6:30state leadership to say, hey, we need more money for public
- 6:33health in our island. And here are findings that show
- 6:38kind of the, the extent of our need, what our workforce is
- 6:41saying they need, how the skill level or lack thereof of our
- 6:47workforce. Because at the end of the day,
- 6:50they're fighting with lots of other issue areas to get a piece
- 6:53of the pie as as happening in states across our country,
- 6:56right? So I think the fact that they
- 6:58have this pH wins data is a really powerful advocacy tool
- 7:03that public health leaders now have to try and get more
- 7:08resources for public health in their islands.
- 7:12Yeah, Is the hope that it will influence the national
- 7:14conversation as well, now that you can sort of compare data
- 7:18from the Pacific islands to the continental US?
- 7:21Yeah, exactly. I think it'll be really powerful
- 7:24that they are now part of the narrative.
- 7:26And this was a criticism that we got in previous cycles of pH
- 7:30wins. That was fair that islands
- 7:33weren't counted, and if you're not counted then you can't be
- 7:36part of the story. And finally, so this was a pilot
- 7:41program, is the intention for it to continue?
- 7:44That is our hope. CDC funded this pilot and we
- 7:48were really grateful for their support and we are having
- 7:53conversations with them about continuing this work because one
- 7:57of the most powerful things about pH wins is that it is a
- 8:00survey that is taken over time. So in, you know, for ASTO
- 8:05members, right, those that have participated can look at how
- 8:08their data has changed over time.
- 8:11This PH1's islands pilot gives us a baseline for the islands,
- 8:15but of course we'd love to run it on the same cadence of about
- 8:19every three years so that these islands can track their progress
- 8:23across these metrics. Rachel Herr Bork is the director
- 8:28of research and impact at the de Beaumont Foundation and holds a
- 8:31pH. D in Politics and Education from
- 8:33Teachers College, Columbia University.
- 8:36Oh, and one more thing. For those folks who are
- 8:38interested in learning more, we really encourage you to go to
- 8:42our website, phwins.org. There's a drop down menu there
- 8:47and under 2024 findings you'll see another tab that says pH
- 8:52Wins Islands Pilot. There you'll find tons of data,
- 8:56infographic reports, and of course, all of the data is
- 9:00publicly available on our dashboards.
- 9:03We hope interested individuals will take a look at the data and
- 9:07explore on their own. Join Manisha Juthani, MD,
- 9:12Commissioner, Connecticut Department of Public Health and
- 9:15ASTO President, and John Auerbach, MBA, Senior Vice
- 9:18President for Public Health, ICF, for a webinar that examines
- 9:22how clear, purposeful leadership strengthens both internal and
- 9:25external trust. Through insights and reflection,
- 9:28we will examine how leaders embody steadiness amid
- 9:31uncertainty, set a sustainable pace, and provide calm direction
- 9:35that builds trust and drives performance.
- 9:38This conversation aims to inspire participants to
- 9:40recognize their composure and capacity not as a personal
- 9:44indulgence, but as a fundamental leadership function that shapes
- 9:47the overall tone, focus, and confidence of their
- 9:50organizations. Stay current on all ASTO news by
- 9:54subscribing to Public Health Weekly and Legislative Alerts
- 9:57for updates, analysis, resources and events on pressing issues in
- 10:01state and territorial public. Health.
- 10:03You can find it all at asto.org or the link in the show notes.
- 10:08This has been Public Health Review MORNING Edition.
- 10:11I'm John Sheehan for the Association of State and
- 10:14Territorial Health Officials.