Latest / Psychology In Seattle Podcast / DSM Corruption, Children Abusing Parents, and Chronic Pain
Transcript
- 0:00Hey, Deserve listeners. I thought I would answer your patren emails. This
- 0:04first email is from middle tier patron doctor Joel. He sent me a link
- 0:10for an article and he says the following. This article shows that the panel
- 0:17members for the DSM five, so the panel members meaning the folks that put
- 0:22together the DSM, the panel members for the DSM five received more than fourteen
- 0:29million dollars in industry funding. One psychologist commented that this is why quote unquote
- 0:36chemical imbalance it is still in the DSM five although there is no scientific basis
- 0:43for the concept of a chemical in balance the drug company's rule end of email.
- 0:50Yeah, so I read the article. It is on Medscape and it
- 0:55is about this fourteen million dollars in industry funding to the panel members of DSM
- 1:00five, written by Kelly Whitlock Burton in early twenty twenty four. So I
- 1:07thought I would pull some quotes here. This first quote, so you know,
- 1:12you first hear this, it sounds really horrible, and it can be
- 1:17really horrible, but it's more nuanced than just automatically being horrible. In the
- 1:23article quote, most payments were for food, beverages, travel, and consulting
- 1:29fees. So just chiming in here. What I think, what I imagine
- 1:33that this is highlighting is that you have pharmaceutical companies and perhaps other companies,
- 1:40but I think it's mainly pharmaceutical companies that are giving money to the panel members
- 1:46of the DSM five. And what the pharmaceutical companies will often do as a
- 1:51way of trying to ingratiate themselves on the leaders in psychiatry. And this happens
- 1:56in the medical field as well, of course, to a much larger degree.
- 2:00And so the pharmaceutical companies will find out that the panel members are meeting
- 2:06in Chicago, for example, and what the pharmaceutical companies will do is they
- 2:10will say, Hey, how about we pay for food and beverages and maybe
- 2:15even for travel, so y'all can get together in Chicago and talk about how
- 2:20you're going to author the DSM five. And what the panel members will say
- 2:25is like, well, you know, sure, actually that'll save us a
- 2:29lot of money on those costs, and maybe they can pass those savings on
- 2:34to the buyers of the DSM five. I don't know. I don't know
- 2:38exactly how the money trail works exactly, but they'll do that, and then
- 2:42there will be an expectation of advertising, right that they'll be a banner or
- 2:47a bunch of pens, or maybe even someone that comes in for a half
- 2:53an hour during and talks about a particular do drug or research or something.
- 2:58And as a panel member, you show up at this conference for DSM five
- 3:04and it's announced and there's all these banners around saying food and beverages and travel
- 3:09provided by Peiser, for example. And on one level that sounds gross,
- 3:15but on another level it might not be. It might be gross. It
- 3:20might be influencing them to emphasize things that can increase profit for Pfizer or whoever,
- 3:28while ignoring the needs of the patient, which I'll get into in a
- 3:30second. They also accept payments for consulting fees, meaning that the pharmaceutical companies
- 3:38will hire these psychiatrists to come to their company and consult about whatever they need
- 3:45consulting around how to design the drug or what sort of issues need to be
- 3:52researched or developed regarding new compounds, or maybe even marketing strategies, which again
- 4:00you could consider to be gross. But you know that's the way capitalism works.
- 4:03And how do we manage that as a society, Well, we have
- 4:08checks and balances is the issue. You know, we don't point our like
- 4:12a lot of people will yell at Amazon for doing a lot of horrible things
- 4:16to their workers, to the environment, to small businesses, and yeah,
- 4:24we have ways of dealing with that. We've had laws and agencies established for
- 4:30over one hundred years in this country that manage monopolies, that manage labor,
- 4:36laws that manage labor satisfaction or labor safety or labor rights, and we just
- 4:44need to use those agencies or make them more powerful or fund them better.
- 4:49It's it's all the time. It's you know, like with the FDA or
- 4:53other kinds of agencies. When you just allow the capitalistic system operate on what
- 5:00it's designed to do, which is to maximize profit, then they're going to
- 5:05exploit labor and they're going to not really care about the consumer. They're only
- 5:11going to care about profit. That's where the government comes in. When the
- 5:15government comes in, it protects us and makes everyone happy because the corporations can
- 5:20still make money. They just make less money than they would otherwise. But
- 5:25ultimately you could say that they're more sustainable because they don't kill off the customer
- 5:30base or destroy the economy and the process. You know, that's why you
- 5:35need banks following certain rules. So when it comes to pharmaceutical companies doing this,
- 5:42the way that I understand economics and policy is that it's fine that they
- 5:46do it, but we just have to have oversight. We just need to
- 5:49have powerful agencies that can make sure that the psychiatrists are not being pressured or
- 5:58over influenced or lied to, or you don't have leadership within the psychiatric community
- 6:03that are fraudulently telling their members to do something and they have agencies in place
- 6:12to actually do that. And from my understanding they do work some of the
- 6:15time, but they need to have more funding and more power and more legislation
- 6:19anyway. So going on with this quote, most payments were for food and
- 6:25beverages, travel, and consulting fees, but more than one third of contributors
- 6:30received compensation for services other than consulting, such as serving on a pharmaceutical company
- 6:35speakers Bureau, which medical ethicists say is particularly problematic. End of quote.
- 6:41Yeah, it's basically saying that you have these very influential panel members for the
- 6:46DSM five who it could be argued that are either being heavily influenced by these
- 6:53companies or are being maybe even directly paid off to do something back I don't
- 7:00know if you can back channel deals or handshake deals where you say, hey,
- 7:06i'll hire you to do this very lucrative speaking circuit where you could make
- 7:13millions of dollars if you make sure that the language regarding major depression retains that
- 7:23phrase chemical imbalance. I don't know if that's where chemical imbalance is in the
- 7:27DSM, but and therefore that will further our goals as profit makers to sell
- 7:34to psychiatrists in general, not just the people you're directly influencing, but all
- 7:40psychiatry perhaps around the world. And yeah, that is problematic, and you
- 7:46know, we could say, hey, you know what, let's not have
- 7:48panel members receive any money from companies. That's too much of a wide open
- 7:55door to corruption. You know. It's the same reason why we have at
- 8:00least expectations that Supreme Court justices US Supreme Court justices will not receive money and
- 8:07favors from corporations like what Clarence Thomas did, because when you do that,
- 8:16you could either be influenced and or making a backchannel deal where you're saying I
- 8:22will rule in this way that will be favorable to your profit. And as
- 8:26long as you give me this vacation in the Bahamas or something, and you
- 8:31know, I think that that's a worthy thing to think about anyway. So
- 8:35the other thing is that when it comes to consulting or speaking, it's not
- 8:41necessarily a bad thing. It can be a good thing. Actually, when
- 8:45you live in this world. And maybe doctor Drel knows all this stuff,
- 8:48I'm sure he does. Like imagine that you are a pharmaceutical company and you
- 8:52have a new drug, a new line of drugs that you have done a
- 8:58lot of research around. You've tested the efficacy, you've tested the safety,
- 9:03you've ran the trials, and you want to at the very least make the
- 9:09psychiatric community aware of this brand new compound. And since ninety eight percent of
- 9:16practicing psychiatrists have not been in graduate school in a long time and might not
- 9:24really pay attention to the trades in terms of the journal articles that are being
- 9:31sent out, or those journal articles are not very interesting in terms of grabbing
- 9:35your attention. Then what you might do is a pharmaceutical companies, you would
- 9:39hire a prominent figure that is respected within the psychiatric community. Maybe even a
- 9:45panel member of the DSM five, because they often are prominent figures in our
- 9:48field or the field of psychiatry, or if I say our field, meaning
- 9:52mental health in general. And you have this individual who has paid a lot
- 9:58of money, because it's a lot, it's a big pain in the ass
- 10:01to travel the country and do all these different talks at various different conventions and
- 10:05stuff. And this individual will look into the drug themselves independently, right as
- 10:15a paid contractor this prominent figure, and will give a presentation, and these
- 10:20presentations are very dry. They get up in front of you know, I've
- 10:26been to these presentations, and they get up in front they say, by
- 10:30the way, I'm being paid by I'm being paid by Pfizer to talk about
- 10:33this thing, and this new compound has been found to blah blah blah.
- 10:39Here's the research. Let me show you some graphs. Here are the reports,
- 10:43and here is something you might want to think about in terms of helping
- 10:48your patients. And the psychiatrists in the audience are really happy that they have
- 10:54learned about this thing, because they wouldn't have learned in detail otherwise. Right,
- 11:01So that can be a good thing. And then you could have patients
- 11:03that actually can benefit from this prescription, from this compound, so it can
- 11:09be a good thing. But of course, if you have nefarious actors,
- 11:13or a lack of critical thinking, or a lack of checks and balances,
- 11:18then of course you can have a pharmaceutical company who ultimately doesn't really care about
- 11:24the community because they're for profit, right, and they pay someone who for
- 11:30themselves, they might think, well, I'm not quite so sure about this
- 11:33drug. I'm not sure about the safety, I'm not sure about the efficacy,
- 11:37and I don't know, but they're paying me millions of dollars, So
- 11:41screw it. I'll sell myself out and i will ignore the downside and I'll
- 11:46promote the good side, and I'll speak to that at the conference. And
- 11:50then you have all these psychiatrists who don't know that that's what's happening to you,
- 11:56And then you'd rinse and repeat this over and over again. Have a
- 12:00problem, and you know this happens. We have very well documented cases where
- 12:05this will spin out of control, like with the over prescription of opiates.
- 12:11We're still dealing with the downstream effects of that capitalistic, corrupted process. You
- 12:20know, there's whole documentaries about it, and it's a problem, but that's
- 12:24what companies are going to do. And we live in a country where they're
- 12:28supposed to be free speech. Right, You're supposed to be able to speak
- 12:33with your dollars where you are saying I would like to hire this person,
- 12:37So we don't just shut that down. In my way of thinking about how
- 12:41to form a society for the benefit of the people, what we do is
- 12:45we just have government oversight that is well powered and funded and has enough staff
- 12:54and isn't bogged down by politicians that are trying to undermine everything. You know,
- 13:00you have a system that keeps that all in check. Right. But
- 13:03anyway, getting back to the DSM in and of itself, Yeah, there's
- 13:09always been a criticism that the DSM quote unquote medicalizes psychological issues, and if
- 13:15the pharmaceutical companies are heavily influencing, if not doing these back channel deals with
- 13:22the panel members of the DSM, then that medicalization of the DSM language could
- 13:28be furthered right. And this is a very complicated issue, but essentially the
- 13:33argument, which I agree with, is that it doesn't adequately emphasize socio cultural
- 13:37factors and it also frames everything behaviorally, and I talk about this occasionally.
- 13:43It's not something that I came up with. It's just an understood thing in
- 13:46our field that the dsm its purpose is to try to be as quote unquote
- 13:52medical or as behavioral or scientific or concrete as possible, and it's hard to
- 13:58do that when we're talking about psychological issues, like, for example, with
- 14:03depression. If you actually talk to someone who suffers from depression and just say,
- 14:07hey, describe what it's like, you're going to hear a lot of
- 14:11detail, and there's going to be a lot of subjective experiences. They'll,
- 14:16you know, they'll say, I don't know. I just feel like I
- 14:20can't really get up in the morning. And I know that there have been
- 14:24times when I didn't feel this way, but I just feel this way.
- 14:26I feel like I just can't get my brain to move. I just stare
- 14:31at the wall. And I know that I could get up and do something
- 14:35or work out or even just take a shower, but I just can't.
- 14:41I just can't seem to motivate my It's like I just don't want to.
- 14:43It just feels like I can't, you know. Okay, So that's one
- 14:48version. That's one particular profile of someone with depression, and how do you
- 14:54concretize that narrative. Well, in the DSM, they try to concretize it
- 15:00by saying, there has there been a change in appetite? Has there been
- 15:03a change in your sleep sleep pattern? You know, meaning you're sleeping more
- 15:09or sleeping less? Does the person find that things that used to be pleasurable
- 15:13are no longer pleasurable? Those kinds of language, and it tries to make
- 15:20it concrete because if you have a lot of criteria that are just like,
- 15:24well they might kind of feel this way or that way, or they might
- 15:28give a vibe blah blah like, it's harder to lock that down. And
- 15:31I appreciate the DSM actually doing this, But if we, as clinicians,
- 15:37and particularly I guess the public as well, consider the DSM to be the
- 15:43only way to describe something, then you're missing what most believed to be ninety
- 15:48percent of what the condition is. Right, things like schemas and trauma and
- 15:56emotion, these are not captured in that language because you can't see it.
- 16:02You can't see an emotion. You can see affect, you can see a
- 16:04display of emotion, right, but you can't see a subjective experience. You
- 16:08can't observe that, And I think that it's great that the DSM tries to
- 16:15make it as concrete as possible, but clinicians and everyone need to understand that
- 16:19the condition is way beyond what the DSM is trying to describe, Like with
- 16:26borderline personality sort of for example, they'll talk about, you know, I'll
- 16:30just quote from the DSM. They'll say, a pattern of unstable and intense
- 16:36interpersonal relationships characterized by alternating between extremes of idealization and devaluation. So a pattern
- 16:44of unstable and intense interpersonal relationships. What does that mean exactly? But that's
- 16:51the observation, right, and that's a pretty good description. But I would
- 16:56also, as y'all know, would include a discussion of distortions and schemas and
- 17:02lenses, you know, interpreting the data coming in through a particular lens and
- 17:07imagined betrayals. Right from the outside, it will look like, Wow,
- 17:12that person has a lot of unstable and intense relationships. But that's just what
- 17:18you see from the outside, and it's confusing if that's as far as you
- 17:22understand borderline to be, which a lot of clinicians. Unfortunately, that's as
- 17:26deep as they'll go for me. That's how I understood borderline for a long
- 17:30time. Once I started treating people with borderline, I suddenly saw the light.
- 17:34I was like, Oh, there's this whole other thing that generates all
- 17:41of those symptoms that are listed in the DSM. Like another DSM criterion is
- 17:47impulsivity. They'll say, you know, as one of the criteria for borderline
- 17:52person disorder is that the person is impulsive. And that doesn't make any sense
- 17:57to me. I've talked about this before, but people with borderline aren't impulsive.
- 18:03That's not the word. But when you understand what might look to be
- 18:08impulsive, you wouldn't understand where it comes from. Then you understand the behavior.
- 18:12When someone has tremendous betrayal and abandonment trauma and you don't text them back,
- 18:21or you hang out with a friend a little longer after work or something,
- 18:26I'm gonna sneeze, that was impulsive. So when you have someone with
- 18:41massive betrayal trauma and abandonment trauma and their spouse stays a little long after work
- 18:48with someone that could be interpreted as a target of romantic or sexual energy from
- 18:56you know what I'm saying, Like, you have a guy who has borderline
- 19:00and his partner, who's also a guy, is hanging out with another gay
- 19:04guy at work, and for the borderline guy, he can be triggered right
- 19:10by that, and so he might inul quoquote unquote, impulsively decide to binge
- 19:15drink even though he doesn't typically do that. Or he might impulsively decide to
- 19:22drive recklessly one night while he's driving with his partner because he's really angry or
- 19:27something from the outside that's labeled by the DSM as impulsive. But that's not
- 19:33the it's not generating from just a drive to be impulsive or what you would
- 19:41call people with ADHD being impulsive. Right, It's not an impulsivity problem.
- 19:45It's a triggering problem. It's sort of like saying that when people that have
- 19:51PTSD, like say someone has a trauma regarding a car accident and they are
- 19:57being asked to get back in a car a week later or a month later,
- 20:03a year later, and they say, I can't do this, you
- 20:06know, even though they had agreed that they were going to do it.
- 20:10And then from the outside you would say that's impulsive because they suddenly decided that
- 20:14they're not going to get in the car. No, they're not getting the
- 20:15car because their trauma's being triggered for the individual that is binge drinking. And
- 20:22they say they don't even normally drink at all. And you say, oh,
- 20:26that's impulsive. No, it's not impulsive. It's a trauma problem,
- 20:30you know. So, yeah, the DSM, it's there, and it's
- 20:33fine, but it's not the end all a way to understand these disorders.
- 20:40But getting to the allegation or the worry that the DSM is worded in a
- 20:47way that's pro pharmaceutical company, it doesn't really do that. I actually picked
- 20:53up the DSM just to make sure, and I was looking. I was
- 20:59really looking for evidence of corruption, and you know, I didn't read the
- 21:02whole thing again, but it's languaged in a way that is pretty consistent and
- 21:08is in line with a lot of the independent research language. You know,
- 21:12For each of the disorders in the DSM, there are a number of prominent
- 21:18groups of researchers that will spend their entire career, basically their entire working life.
- 21:23They will spend researching, researching, and writing about that one disorder,
- 21:30like you have Robert Hare who developed his criteria for psychopathy. He spent his
- 21:36entire career from the nineteen sixties until today researching and writing and talking and thinking
- 21:42and treating people who have psychopathic personalities. Or that's how people get ahead in
- 21:48our field is by hyper focusing. And so these individuals are so into their
- 21:55work that for a pharmaceutical company to come along and try to inflac's them,
- 22:00I just don't see that being an easy task. Plus, a lot of
- 22:06these folks have a lot of integrity. You know. The people don't go
- 22:10into this field because they want to make a billion dollars, you know.
- 22:15That's why when you look at things like other industries where it is typically attractive
- 22:23to people that want to make a quick buck, like banking and finance or
- 22:26real estate or something, then yeah, you're going to get a higher rate
- 22:32of fraud in my field. Is their fraud, Absolutely, but it's just
- 22:37not as much of a problem that I personally worry about. It is a
- 22:42problem, and we need to do what we can. But another protective cultural
- 22:49factor is consensus. Consensus is a very strong force in our field. Most
- 22:56of the time, that's a good thing. Some of the time. It's
- 22:59a bad thing, but it keeps people in check that when you have a
- 23:04researcher, like say you had a pharmaceutical company that managed to influence or coerce
- 23:11a prominent figure in our field to start going down a road that basically said,
- 23:17you know, I don't know. That's an example like the only treatment
- 23:19for ADHD is medication, for example, or even a specific medication like the
- 23:26SNRIs that are at least in my anecdotal experience, not as widely used as
- 23:33this as the stimulants are. So let's say you have one of the DSM
- 23:38panel members who is the prominent figure in ADHD research in psychiatry, and the
- 23:47SNRI manufacturer manages to get under their skin and they start giving talks or writing
- 23:52papers or maybe even inserting language into the DSM that the primary treement is SNRI
- 24:00or they're emphasizing it as an up and coming thing, and they're emphasizing it
- 24:06as equally as effective as psychostumas or something. Well, the consensus in our
- 24:11field would come down so hard, and that happens that happens in our field,
- 24:15they would come down so hard on them because there's so many independent university
- 24:21researchers that are outside of that money stream from pharmacology and have a lot of
- 24:29integrity and are very noticing of unethical kinds of things. Again, are there
- 24:37problems, Yeah, there are, absolutely, But overall there's a lot of
- 24:44positive things in our culture that I think are working against it. Having said
- 24:48all that, it is a problem that you have leading figures and a culture
- 24:55within psychiatry that, in my opinion, and there's to support this, and
- 25:00of course anecdote to support it, that you have an overall culture of over
- 25:07prescribing and an overall culture of downplaying non medical treatments like psychotherapy, for example,
- 25:15or exercise and diet. It is a well understood phenomenon. Do you
- 25:21have psychiatrists that are holistic around this, Absolutely, you have it. But
- 25:26when money is on the table and people are worried about paying their mortgages or
- 25:33paying for that vacation that they're wanting to go on later in the year,
- 25:37then people start to brainwash themselves, and that needs to be kept in check,
- 25:42and that is a problem. It has been a problem. I don't
- 25:45know to what degree. The psychiatrists that I talk to are pretty cognizant of
- 25:52that and are very caring about their patients and are very careful about overprescribing and
- 25:57try to remember not to consider everything a nail when they have a hammer,
- 26:04you know what I mean that because they have one tool, or often they
- 26:10consider it themselves having only one tool, which is medications, then all problems
- 26:15look like they can be solved with medication, you know. The psychiatrist said,
- 26:19I know, try to keep that in check, but you know,
- 26:22it's a thing and it's similar in my field right that for me, I
- 26:25can't provide prescriptions, right, and so when people come to me, I'm
- 26:30going to be in that world of psychotherapy, and I might ignore the obvious
- 26:37possibility that client might benefit from a psychiatric consultation or even a medical consultation.
- 26:42It's a well known thing in my field that you need to make sure that
- 26:48you know what you don't know, and that you recommend and refer a client
- 26:53to another provider, like a medical provider, if they show signs that there
- 27:00might be some issue there, you know, like someone comes in with even
- 27:03depression, right, they come in and they have or like with humberdo he
- 27:10when he was suffering from his thyroid disease, it looked like he was suffering
- 27:15from a lot of anxiety panic, and a lot of people were framing it
- 27:19that way. But for him, he kept going back to the drawing board
- 27:26because he was telling himself and others it just it didn't feel like straight up
- 27:33anxiety. He has a lot of anxiety, or he has had anxiety.
- 27:36But he kept saying this, this isn't the same, this isn't the same,
- 27:38and they kept saying, that's just anxiety. You're okay, and he
- 27:42just kept he had to fight for him, fight and fight and fight,
- 27:45and eventually they did more tests and said, oh, actually, yeah,
- 27:48your thyroid is like completely haywire, and he had it removed and he's been
- 27:55recovering ever since. But he's doing a lot better. So this, you
- 28:00know, having blinders on is a problem in a variety of ways. In
- 28:03this instance, you had medical providers that were ignoring the medical possibilities and we're
- 28:11telling him that he needs to go to a therapist. So it's kind of
- 28:14the opposite, right, But it's a general problem when you have blinders on,
- 28:18you know. So another thing to think about is, Okay, what
- 28:22are the ongoing solutions? And I've already been over some of them, but
- 28:26just to be specific, I think we just need to raise awareness. Like
- 28:30having this article that's read by a lot of people, I think that it
- 28:36helps. I think raising awareness can influence the culture and influence the panel members.
- 28:42I imagine that most of the panel members are trying to do an ethical
- 28:48job, and they might have to be reminded. Like with me, I
- 28:52sometimes have to be reminded. Don't see every problem as a problem that can
- 28:57be solved by psychotherapy. Be that reminder? Will it helps me? I
- 29:03need that reminder, like I don't know, every six months or something,
- 29:06so that I don't go down a road where I ignore that. You know,
- 29:11it's like on the list of things that I pay attention to when I'm
- 29:14working with clients, And if I go too long without that reminder, then
- 29:18I might overlook something. Right, So these kinds of reminders help us clinicians.
- 29:25Also, you might want to we might want to have an independent organization
- 29:32oversee this panel to make sure that there aren't undue influences. That kind of
- 29:37thing. And the other thing is that we already have a major measure that
- 29:45is helping the situation. The fact that this article even exists is because of
- 29:51Obamacare. The Affordable Care Act. A part of Obamacare was the establishment of
- 29:56the Open Payments Database. This database collects these people. They collect and publish
- 30:04data regarding how the medical providers and other entities how money goes between them,
- 30:12like pharmaceutical companies. You know the fact that this journalist can even report that
- 30:18the panel members received fourteen million dollars. The only reason why that journalist knows
- 30:23that and can report on that is because of Obamacare. And so this is
- 30:27legislation. This is federal government oversight by a government agency that is funded,
- 30:34that has power. You know, just like how the government agency that shut
- 30:40down their nose with Elizabeth Holmes because her and her colleagues were committing fraud and
- 30:45harming patients with their lives and their bad test results. Right, they are
- 30:49so lying to investors. And the agency that came forward, I think it
- 30:56was like a Medicaid agency after so many people tried to shut their nose down
- 31:00and look into it. It's depicted well in the drop out the TV show.
- 31:06This like unassuming, very polite inspector comes in with and I'm sure this
- 31:12is dramatized to a large extent, but this guy comes in who has a
- 31:17pencil protector in his glasses and he's like, I'm here to inspect the machines.
- 31:22And he has that power because of legislation and because of laws and because
- 31:29of funding. You could argue that this inspector should have been on site years
- 31:34before, and probably would have been if the government funded this agency to a
- 31:41greater degree. And once that investigation began, pretty I think immediately, at
- 31:47least in the TV show, for my memory, that day, after people
- 31:51have been trying to shut down their nose for years, that day the guy
- 31:55shuts down their nose because he is not satisfied with the safety and the claims
- 32:02that were being made. You know, all the shit. You gotta watch
- 32:05the TV show. But the Elizabeth Holmes and I think his name is Bowani,
- 32:09they were just very good at bullying and obscuring and throwing up smoke screens.
- 32:15And so you have a government agency that shut this down. Elizabeth Holmes
- 32:20would probably still be committing fraud and harming patients, maybe to a much larger
- 32:24degree if that government agency and that agency worker didn't exist. So these things
- 32:32can be made more robust to keep psychiatrists and check not because all psychiatrists are
- 32:38corrupt, but the few that might be can be punished and stripped of their
- 32:45license or influenced or threatened with some kind of action so that they stay in
- 32:52line, you know. So anyway, let's go on to another email.
- 32:57But first let's take a break. All right, we're back from the break.
- 33:02Let's do an opp These people became patrons all the way back in twenty
- 33:06twenty one and are still patrons. We have Ashley from Flushing, New York,
- 33:10who is at the mug level. Then we have a bunch of middle
- 33:15tier patrons here. We have Andrea from North Sydney, Australia. We have
- 33:22Michelle from Shell Harbor, Australia. We have Taru from Helsinki, Finland.
- 33:29We have Latitia from columb columb Is that Columbus? What is that? It
- 33:36says fr That seems like it'd be France. Don't you think as a country
- 33:39country code? Yeah, it is France. So Columbus France, Columbus France.
- 33:46Interesting, Sayaka from Paris, France, TK from Amsterdam, Holland,
- 33:53Netherlands. We have Ashiana from New York, New York. Lisa from Sun
- 33:58City, California, from Revere, Massachusetts. Journey. What a great name.
- 34:04Journey Willow from Philo, math Oregon. Phila, math Oregon. I've
- 34:09never heard of Phila, math Oregon. Shannon from Irvine, California. I've
- 34:14heard that my uncle Usa there. Christina from Chicago, Illinois. Princess from
- 34:19Portland. That's an a great name. You got a journey and a princess.
- 34:23Hillary from Alameda, California. Elliott Smith has a song called Alameda.
- 34:30You walk down Alameda shuffle linga saso dosa no noa o God. Alexandra from
- 34:49Towaco, New Jersey. Mac from Decatur, Illinois and from Seattle. I
- 34:52know that place. Annette from Paulsbow I know where that is in Washington.
- 34:57She Rot from Seattle, uh Ta from Decatur, Georgia, Doris from Indianapolis,
- 35:04Joy from Floresville, Texas, Terry from Saint Paul, Minnesota, McKenzie
- 35:08from Bothel, Washington, and Bailey from Bothel. We got Mackenzie and Bailey
- 35:13both from Bothel, Sarah from Palmyra, Virginia, Amanda from Roseville, California,
- 35:19Shelby from Phoenix, Dominic from Dallas and from god knows where we have
- 35:23dot Don and Tiffany. Thank you so much for becoming a patron and staying
- 35:27a patron this whole time. You are the wind beneath my wings, truly.
- 35:32The sext email is from anonymous middle tier patron. She says, Hi
- 35:36dk H, Doctor Corcatta. I have a co worker who frequently complains about
- 35:42ailments and feeling sick. I have a co worker who frequently complains about ailments
- 35:46and feeling sick. She also has a son who has autistic and becomes violent.
- 35:53She often discloses when he hurts her physically. There have been lots of
- 35:59emergence she visits, and two major surgeries. Wow, She's a son who's
- 36:04autistic and is violent. She often discloses that when he is violent with her
- 36:09and to her to an anonymous military patron, and she has said that she's
- 36:16gone to lots of times to the mercy room because of this violence. And
- 36:22also there have been two major surgeries. My goodness, she sometimes considered this.
- 36:28This coworker sometimes considers hiring a support worker or putting him in a home,
- 36:32but she often changes her mind, or she's worried that he'll get mad
- 36:37or that she will feel guilty for it. I have increased my support from
- 36:43listening at first to her, and then I started to provide light suggestions eventually,
- 36:49and then I was later telling her that she really needs to seek out
- 36:52help because I got scared that he was going to kill her. Yeah,
- 36:55so just Jim, mean, you're saying that. At first, you're like,
- 36:59oh wow, and you're being emotionally supportive, and then you start saying,
- 37:04you know, you might want to think about this or that, and
- 37:06then now you're telling her she really needs to seek help. Going out with
- 37:10your email, could you talk a bit about elder abuse? How can you
- 37:15support someone who doesn't want to make a change. How do I deal with
- 37:20the fear of her getting hurt and of email? Yeah, this is a
- 37:22tough situation. So this is what we would call in the broad sense,
- 37:28domestic violence, and that you have within the home, you have either a
- 37:32family member or someone that you're living with that is being violent with you.
- 37:36And it does happen. Children can be violent, domestically violent with their parents,
- 37:42and I've treated families like this. You don't get a lot of support
- 37:45for it online because for a lot of people they just figure, well,
- 37:50you must have done something to that kid to cause that kid to be violent
- 37:53with you, and certainly that can be the case, but it's hard for
- 37:59me to know so obviously, because I enter I would go into the home
- 38:01for a lot of these families, and when I would enter the home,
- 38:06I of course wouldn't know what had happened previously. But for some of these
- 38:09families, it did look like there was something else going on other than the
- 38:14parents influencing the child to be this way. There can be a lot of
- 38:17roads to anger, and you know, when you think about it more broadly,
- 38:22a lot of kids when they're young can be violent at times, even
- 38:27though you haven't shown them that way of dealing with their anger. You know,
- 38:30it's not uncommon to have a frustrated three year old or a frustrated six
- 38:35year old throw something at you or try to take a swipe at you with
- 38:38their hand. Not all kids do this, but many kids do. It's
- 38:43a natural instinct of I don't like what's happening right now, and I want
- 38:45you to stop. And we wouldn't say that just because a six year old
- 38:51takes a swipe at a parent, we wouldn't automatically assume that the parent had
- 38:54modeled that behavior or abused the child to cause that child to do that.
- 39:00You know, some kids they just do that. Again, not all the
- 39:01kids, but some kids. In the same way, you can have a
- 39:05teenager or an adult child who, without being influenced by the parents or harmed
- 39:10by the parents, can manifest their anger with a lot of violence towards the
- 39:19parents. You know, we could look towards other vectors, like bullying at
- 39:21school, or their own frustration, or their own mental health, that kind
- 39:24of thing as well. But anyway, to answer your question, how can
- 39:28you support someone who doesn't want to make a change. Yeah, I think
- 39:31that's the core of what your question is is that at first, your co
- 39:36worker is telling you about this very difficult situation at home, and at first
- 39:40you're just like, oh wow, and you're probably thinking, well, you
- 39:44know, eventually she'll figure out a solution there, because that doesn't sound sustainable.
- 39:47And then you notice that she doesn't do anything, and it seems to
- 39:52be staying the same or getting worse, and you're like, have you thought
- 39:55about this or that and maybe get a a little bit of traction. And
- 40:00then a month or two later, you see that the problem is still just
- 40:06as big as it ever was, and you're thinking, why isn't she doing
- 40:09anything to help herself. Why does she live with this? Why is she
- 40:13just letting this happen? Or how come she hasn't reached out to anyone.
- 40:17In your longer email, you were telling me that you basically know that she
- 40:24doesn't really talk about with other people, or if other people are alerted,
- 40:29they don't really do anything about it. So you're just watching her suffer.
- 40:34And basically, one could say using you as an emotional crutch. Right.
- 40:39I wouldn't say that, but I think some people would. And then eventually
- 40:43you start getting frustrated with her. I think a lot of people can relate
- 40:46to this, right. I think of our common story is you have a
- 40:49friend that isn't what we might call a toxic relationship, or they will frequently
- 40:55engage themselves with abusive partners, and you keep trying to help them, and
- 41:01you care, and they keep saying that they're going to do something about it,
- 41:06and they never do, and yet they still come to you and vent.
- 41:09And I get that question a lot. And what I say is that
- 41:15there's a tendency for some people being triangulated into this to take on their responsibility.
- 41:22And this is something that I'm very familiar with. Both as a therapist
- 41:24and as a professor. Something that I have to go over with my trainees
- 41:30all the time that if you don't watch it, you'll start taking on the
- 41:34responsibility of other people's problems and it'll destroy you, or it'll destroy the relationship,
- 41:38and it'll destroy your ability to be a positive force in this person's life
- 41:44because you'll either start yelling at them or rejecting them, or it'll destroy you
- 41:50emotionally. And so this is where differentiation comes in, where you have to
- 41:52notice that and take measures to distance yourself to some extent that you can be
- 42:00there in a way that you want to be there. And so for you
- 42:05anonymous military patron, one option, and again there's many, but just try
- 42:09it on for size. This is what I would be considering doing based on
- 42:13your description is two when I'm not with her, to just kind of take
- 42:20a step back and look at the big picture and look at what I want
- 42:22to do given the situation. And what I would want to do is I
- 42:27would want to be there for her because I care about her, and I
- 42:30would also have an urge to save her. But I would know, based
- 42:36on your description that even if I took measures like I don't know, I
- 42:39called the police or something. She would have to follow through with those things,
- 42:43and she apparently is not ready for that. Now she might be abused.
- 42:49So the other factor, the other way to look at this, is
- 42:51that she is an abused victim and she is being brainwashed and beaten down and
- 42:57isolated, and she has maybe even been kind of gas lit by her her
- 43:02child. And that's another angle here that could inform the sort of things you
- 43:08recommend, like that she might benefit by consulting with a dev advocate, an
- 43:15intimate partner, violence advocate, someone that would be able to speak with her
- 43:19in a way that would elucidate that possibility so that they could see so she
- 43:23could start to extract herself from the mindset of demoralized victim, you know what
- 43:30I mean, a person that doesn't have any control when she does have some
- 43:36power, you know, and could gain more power, and she deserves to
- 43:40have that power, because if she's going into the hospital multiple times and has
- 43:45had two major surgeries, and you know, and that's just the violence that's
- 43:49resulted in those kinds of things being necessary, all of the times where she's
- 43:54been harmed physically, all the times that she's been intimidated all the time she's
- 44:00been yelled at. It's got to just be really high up there, you
- 44:04know. And so what I would do is I would, as a friend
- 44:09listen and I might even say something like, hey, I let me tell
- 44:15you my journey that I've gone on with you at first and overall, I
- 44:20want to say that I love you, and I care about you, and
- 44:21I worry about you. And when you first started telling me about this,
- 44:24I thought, Wow, this sounds really horrible, and I felt really bad
- 44:29for you, and I didn't know what to do. But I figured since
- 44:31you were aware of it, that you would do something to change it.
- 44:37And I don't know what it is that you can do to change it,
- 44:38but it just seemed like you. You know, it'd sort of be like
- 44:43if you were telling me that you had a toothache, I would have figured
- 44:45that you would call the dentist, you know. So as time went on,
- 44:51I noticed that you weren't calling the dentist. Or again, I'm not
- 44:53I don't know what you're supposed to do. I just feel like there should
- 44:57be something. But so I started rung out some suggestions and I was really
- 45:04hoping that I don't know either you would take those suggestions or find another set
- 45:07of solutions, because I worry about you and it kills me to see you
- 45:14go through stuff like this. And then on bunch time went by even further
- 45:17and it seemed like it was just getting worse, and I just felt so
- 45:21bad, and so I just felt like I needed to do something about it.
- 45:25So I would really insist that you do something because I'm over here feeling
- 45:30powerless over the harm that you're going through, and I care because I care
- 45:36about you, and I don't know what to do, and it pains me
- 45:40to watch you go through this, and so for me, for my sanity,
- 45:45I have to figure out how I'm going to deal with this personally.
- 45:52It's not anything close to what you're dealing with, but it is hard for
- 45:55me. And so what I decided is that I'm going to listen to you,
- 45:59but I have to kind of keep you at a distance when it comes
- 46:02to this, because if I get too involved, I won't be able to
- 46:07sleep at night. So you know, feel free to talk with me about
- 46:10it, but just know that I'm listening and I care, but I'm also
- 46:15actively trying to resist their urge to get involved because I just don't see that
- 46:21being of any use. And if you want me to help you, I
- 46:25would gladly do something if you want me to look into something or if you
- 46:30need help, if you want if you want to go together to a thing,
- 46:35I could do that. You know, if you want to do that
- 46:37a military patent. But but aside from that, I think I have to
- 46:45calm down a little bit when I'm listening to you. And I feel bad
- 46:49about that because it feels like I'm giving up or it feels like I don't
- 46:52care, but I do care. And because I care, I have to
- 46:58do this because if I let this caring spin out of control for me,
- 47:04it'll cause me to not want to even talk with you because it will be
- 47:07overwhelming for me. So because I care about you, I am kind of
- 47:14drawing a boundary around that. Again, you can talk with me about it,
- 47:16but just know that I'm not going to get as emotionally involved as I
- 47:21was. End of role play. For some people in her position the coworker,
- 47:27she might actually appreciate that. She might say, you know what,
- 47:30thank you, because I don't want this to harm you. I want to
- 47:34be able to vent about this. But I was noticing it was causing you
- 47:38to be agitated and that was kind of bumming me out. So it would
- 47:43help if you did that. And I'm glad you're telling me that, and
- 47:46thank you for not rejecting me or judging me or anything. You know who
- 47:51knows, and that applies, you know, if you have a partner that
- 47:54is in an abusive relationship or they keep dating abusive people or whatever, it's
- 48:00the same thing now. Now maybe for you, regardless of the situation,
- 48:05that isn't the goal and that role play isn't fitting to your overall goal.
- 48:09For some people, they might say I'm going to double down on trying to
- 48:14help them, or I'm just going to distance myself from the person and tell
- 48:16you know, because you know, slowly back myself out of the door,
- 48:20or even just tell them I can't really be your friend because it's too painful.
- 48:22You know, those are options too, but you want to think about
- 48:27what you want to do and how you want to protect yourself. Really,
- 48:30all right, it's take a break, all right, it's do another opp
- 48:37I'm sorry for doing so many opps. I just feel like I need to
- 48:40catch up. These people became patrons toward the end of twenty twenty one and
- 48:45are still patrons. And this is a long list, but I hope you'll
- 48:50indulge me. Because they're all from other countries besides the US. I sort
- 48:53of grouped them together. So we have Samara from ah Oh, this has
- 49:04got to be Australia, right toon Gobby Toon, Gobby Toon. Gobby is
- 49:10a city in Australia. Yeah, that sounds fun to Gobby. Vicky from
- 49:15the Junction in Australia, Sonia from Joslyn, Australia, Zoe from Melbourne,
- 49:23Australia, Emma from all these people are Australia. We have Emma from Ballarat,
- 49:30East Australia, Sarah from Melbourne and Rachel from June Dallup, June Dallup,
- 49:37Australia. All right, these people are all from Canada. We have
- 49:40Page from Edmonton, Nancy from Memberton, Aaron from Memberton, Teresa from Calgary,
- 49:45Amanda from BC, Victoria BC, good old scene, Nick Victoria,
- 49:51Sam from Vancouver, BC, Alexandra from Lanceville, BC, Kate from New
- 49:55Brunswick and Danny from Toronto. All right, and these people are all from
- 50:01Switzerland. We have Isabelle, Linda and Bettina Isabelle and Linda are from Zurich
- 50:07and Bettina is from ocon And we have someone from Costa Rica. We have
- 50:14Eileen from San Jose, Costa Rica. And these are all people from Germany.
- 50:20We have Vincent, Lisa, Eve Peden and Sarah Vincent from greb Benstein,
- 50:28Lisa from Hamburg, Eve from Hamburg, Peden from Achen, and Sarah
- 50:32from I don't like there's too many. There's like a there's a there's a
- 50:38pie. You know the symbol for pie or for paragraph. No, this
- 50:42symbol for paragraph isn't this same anyway? I don't know how to pronounce that.
- 50:45And then we have these people are all from Great Britain. We have
- 50:51Ellie from Balden, Souhanna from a Bournemouth Bornemouth looks like bourne Mouth, but
- 51:00I'm guessing it's Bornemuth. Jane from Leads. I went down a kind of
- 51:05a rabbit hole regarding the accent from Leads. What was I watching? I
- 51:09think I was watching the Crown maybe and someone had an accent and I thought,
- 51:15oh, that accent is really cool, and I looked up where that
- 51:22person was from. Well, first off, I was like, I bet
- 51:24you anything that's like northern England, a North England accent, because it sounded
- 51:30a little bit more Scottish to me, like in between. And I looked
- 51:34it up where the actor was from and boom leads, which is exactly between.
- 51:39You know, it's like North England close Anyway. I don't know if
- 51:43any of that is true, but it let me down a rabbit hole of
- 51:45watching a lot of YouTube videos of people doing accents from that area, and
- 51:52apparently to a lot of English folks that accent is kind of funny to them
- 51:58or something. Anyway, challenge from Klee Thorpe's Cleethorpe's awe tig from tad Caster
- 52:07tad Caster. Tad Caster sounds like a guitar, you know, like telecaster
- 52:13or stratocaster, the tad and there's that band tad anyway, Chris from London,
- 52:19go to London, all right. These people are from a country with
- 52:22a country code gr which is Greece. We have Elena from I can't read
- 52:28that. It's like wingedings, honestly, and then Maria from Athens. I've
- 52:34been there, actually, it's really good. We have Ella from Israel from
- 52:37Tel Aviv. We have Guya from Italy, and we have a bunch of
- 52:44people from Netherlands. Here we have Sushi Moose. Sushi Moose from Amsterdam,
- 52:52juiced from nord Holland, look maybe like North Holland. Tom from Augst Geeste,
- 53:00that's terrible, and See from the Hague. And then these people are
- 53:05all from Norway. We have Kittiel, Taren and Helene, and then we
- 53:10have Anna from Poland. Thank you so much for being a patron all the
- 53:16way across the world in various different, far flung, exotic, cool sounding
- 53:22places, and thank you for indulging me everybody. While I powered my way
- 53:28through that, All right, let's move on to another email. I'm very
- 53:32excited to announce that I have answered all of the upper tier and middle tier
- 53:38patron emails, so we're now getting to the basic patrons and YouTube members.
- 53:46I always start with middle and upper tier folks and work my way down,
- 53:52and I'm now in the Google doc that is for the standard patrons, and
- 53:58that means I'm on the right. This doc is over two hundred pages,
- 54:04so I'll have to pick and choose, but this question is pretty easy to
- 54:07answer pretty quickly. This is from anonymous patron and YouTube member she says,
- 54:15Hi, doctor Honda, I have a question about love bombing. I've listened
- 54:19to your content on narcissistic personality and big ed big ed from Idea Fancy,
- 54:24and I was wondering whether it is possible for love bombing to be associated with
- 54:29other relational traumas or to be a variation of normal, or is it always
- 54:34associated with narcisstic personality disorder. I'm asking because in all of my past experience,
- 54:39men who have loved bombed ended up becoming controlling and having signs of narcissistic
- 54:45personality. But I'm wondering if that is always a case, or if it
- 54:47could just be that the person is just very eager to be in a relationship
- 54:52end of female. Yeah, if you listen to my deep dive on love
- 54:54bombing, or really anytime I talk about it, I am clear. I
- 55:00believe that love bombing is something that well, first off, if someone's just
- 55:07eager to be in a relationship and they don't have the underpinnings that would result
- 55:13in love bombing, then it's not love bombing. You could be very very
- 55:16in love with someone and really want to be with them and praise them and
- 55:22admire them, and maybe want to move fast in the relationship. But if
- 55:27you get pushback from the other person and you adjust, then that's not love
- 55:31bombing. That's just being in love. But for those who will react poorly
- 55:37to push back, to slow down or whatever, then we would call that
- 55:43love bombing. And for those individuals, most of them are not suffering from
- 55:52well, I would say usually what I'm delineating is a volitional love bombing with
- 56:00people with psychopathy, you know, con artists who are purposely and knowingly deceiving
- 56:07you by showering you with admiration. That's a rare individual. That's usually how
- 56:13love bombing is characterized. And honestly, I can't tell from your question,
- 56:16but I'm guessing that well, I don't know, but on the Internet,
- 56:21if you just googled narcissism and love bombing or especially like on TikTok or something,
- 56:29the vast majority of content, at least to me, it looks like
- 56:32what they're describing is psychopathy, not narcissism. So there's that plus people with
- 56:39narcissism. They're not the folks that would tend to love bomb, they can
- 56:45for sure, But the people that know the non psychopathic love bombers tend to
- 56:51be borderline or preoccupied or histrionic. They can be narcissistic, but that's rare
- 56:58because narcissistic people, generally speaking, are pathologically and pendent and are oriented towards
- 57:05themselves and not towards other people, and are convincing themselves that they don't need
- 57:09anybody, whereas people with borderline are very much oriented towards others and are desperate
- 57:15for closeness. Narcissistic people are too as well, and can manifest their desperation
- 57:22in the form of love bombing. Absolutely, and there's other I guess conditions,
- 57:29because you know, people avoidantly attached could love bomb potentially for the same
- 57:34you know, I always say, underneath every narcissistic person, and underneath every
- 57:37avoidant person is a preoccupied person or a borderline person, and or at least
- 57:43the traits of it. It's just manifesting in a different way, meaning that
- 57:46avoidant and narcisstic people are just as desperate for closeness, if not more to
- 57:53some extent, because they've not only been denied that growing up, but they
- 57:58also have denied their themselves the opportunity to ever pursue it. So love bombing
- 58:06typically comes from some form of trauma and is not on purpose. Now,
- 58:14to be clear, just because it's not on purpose does not mean that it's
- 58:16not harmful. It can be very very very very harmful and abusive. So
- 58:22I just want to be clear about that. And really this points to a
- 58:24larger issue that this association between abuse and narcissism or psychopathy needs to be divorced.
- 58:34We need to separate those two. There's event diagram, but most abusive
- 58:39people in my experience, and I think research shows this most abusive people,
- 58:45well, of course it does, because you know people with antisocial personality,
- 58:49people with psychopathy, they're a rare bunch. But there are a lot of
- 58:52abusive people. A lot of people have been through abusive relationships, so by
- 58:59definition, they can't all be psychopaths, and only a small percentage of them
- 59:04can be psychopaths. There's probably a greater rate among abusive people regarding psychopathy and
- 59:08any social but it's by no means like even a large minority. It's probably
- 59:14a Instead of being one percent of the population or two percent, it's probably
- 59:17like five or seven percent or something of abusive people suffer from any social or
- 59:22psychopathy. I don't know the exact number, but the point is is that
- 59:27we need to recognize that. Well, let me put it to you this
- 59:30way, when you thinking of an abusive person, what I would hope,
- 59:34after listening to me yam or about this so often both on the audio podcast
- 59:38and in the reaction videos, that when you think of an abusive person,
- 59:44please if it's a quintessential abusive person, do not think of a con artist
- 59:51or a psychopath or someone lacking an empathy. What I want you to think
- 59:55about is someone that actually has empathy. They have the capacity for compassion and
- 1:00:00love and remorse and feeling bad about their abuse. But they either suppress that
- 1:00:09or avoid it or deny it so that they don't feel bad. That's the
- 1:00:15issue, and that I guess I understand why people would think about those people
- 1:00:20as being psychopaths, because how could they continue to do something harmful to other
- 1:00:22people without stopping themselves, without trying to work on it right, or even
- 1:00:29with blaming the victim. But abusive people will well people in general, we
- 1:00:34do all sorts of things to justify our actions and to help us get through
- 1:00:38the day, and for abusive people, they'll do that. Plus what generates
- 1:00:45the abuse is a massive distortion of what's happening before them anyway, Right,
- 1:00:49you have someone a partner who well, like that previous example I gave where
- 1:00:55you have a gay couple and the partner stays long at work, and let's
- 1:01:01say that the preoccupied person at home is or I guess I was saying earlier,
- 1:01:07borderline, So let's go with that. So you have the person suffering
- 1:01:09for borderline and they haven't been through treatment, and they're not aware, they
- 1:01:12don't have any insight into what's going on with them, and they also had
- 1:01:15violence model to them when they were children, when they were a child,
- 1:01:21And so when his partner comes home, he will become very upset at his
- 1:01:28partner for staying late and for making him feel bad, and will punish him
- 1:01:34and say I can't believe and berate him. You know, you're a slut
- 1:01:37or you probably got together with him, didn't you. You're disgusting to me.
- 1:01:40I mean, just look at you. It's just like it's just like
- 1:01:44that thing you did to me before. I mean, I can't even believe
- 1:01:46that I'm with you know, just berating, berating, maybe hitting, But
- 1:01:49you know, you can get a lot of abuse done with just your mouth,
- 1:01:52and so that individual who suffers from borderline they have empathy, they care,
- 1:02:00they deeply care, and they have the capacity for remorse. But what
- 1:02:07they believe is happening is that their partner is massively mistreating them. That's how
- 1:02:13it feels to them. That's how it's being interpreted, maybe even distorted into
- 1:02:16that they might convince themselves that they did have sex with this other person at
- 1:02:22work, their partner did cheat on them, and therefore it's within their rights
- 1:02:27to be upset and to express that right. So that is abusive in the
- 1:02:31way that I described it. And it's not someone that is what the Internet
- 1:02:37would call a narcissist or what I would call someone that lacks empathy like with
- 1:02:40antisocial or psychopathy. It's sexs emails from patron and YouTube member Sierra from South
- 1:02:46Dakota. She says, Hello, doctor Honda, I would like to recommend
- 1:02:50that you watch Blue Eye Samurai on Netflix for your own enjoyment and possibly for
- 1:02:55a reaction video series on YouTube. End of email. Yeah. Absolutely,
- 1:03:00this has been on my list for a variety of reasons. I think I
- 1:03:04saw someone that I respect online saying how great it was, and I want
- 1:03:08to watch it. I do Blue White Samurai. Yeah, all right.
- 1:03:13The sext email is from Patron Taylor from Ben Rgan. She says, I
- 1:03:17have lived a life of chronic pain and fatigue from the beginning of puberty as
- 1:03:22a young teenager. I have lived a life of chronic pain and fatigue.
- 1:03:28I have never known a moment of my adult life that wasn't affected by some
- 1:03:32kind of pain or exhaustion. I sometimes feel so much pain that I have
- 1:03:37to sit down or else I might fall down. I can't be independent.
- 1:03:42To have independence is to choose pain. I can't pursue any passion, like
- 1:03:47a skill or a career, because to pursue any passion is to choose pain.
- 1:03:54But to not choose a passion feels like giving up. I'm talking with
- 1:03:59account about how to change how I think about things, but it's very challenging.
- 1:04:02I feel like I was born into the most opposing body for how my
- 1:04:06mind works. I want to do things to contribute to my people and my
- 1:04:11tribe, and to not feel free to do so makes me feel like I
- 1:04:15don't get to be a full person. Can you think of any unique tools
- 1:04:20that could help with this? End? Of email. Well, first off,
- 1:04:25Taylor, I'm so so sorry. I have no idea what that would
- 1:04:30feel like. I have had very minor glimpses into how that might feel.
- 1:04:38I went through a period of time when I had stabbing pain in my back
- 1:04:43at varying degrees throughout the day. It was never horrible, though, but
- 1:04:48it could be demoralizing, even at a low grade level. It just feels
- 1:04:55like, really because usually when pain happens for us, there's there's relief at
- 1:05:01some point, right Like you bang your arm and you have a bruise.
- 1:05:06Usually it's like, Okay, this hurts, but eventually it won't hurt anymore.
- 1:05:12But when you are dealing with any kind of chronic pain, even if
- 1:05:15it's at a low degree, it can be very demoralizing. It just feels
- 1:05:18like for the rest of my life and it could get worse. And that's
- 1:05:23what it was really scary to me, was like I would hear these horrible
- 1:05:28cases of people in their back pain, and the problem is is I have
- 1:05:31a football injury in my lower back. I think it's a football injury.
- 1:05:34It's unclear exactly when it happened, but pretty sure it happened playing football and
- 1:05:39I have a broken bone in my back, in my spine, and it
- 1:05:44makes it so that the vertebrae are pushed forward and I think two vertebrae are
- 1:05:49actually touching at the back and it'll you know, put stress on certain nerves
- 1:05:57and that'll cause a lot of pain, that sort of thing, and so
- 1:06:00there's nothing. There's only so much you can do. You can for that
- 1:06:03kind of problem, like working on your core strength or stretching or taking it
- 1:06:09easy on your back. But the kind of problem that I have, it's
- 1:06:13just it just is the way that it is. And apparently that's after talking
- 1:06:16to multiple specialists, and in all likelihood it's just going to get worse over
- 1:06:21time, and you just have to hope and pray, and you know,
- 1:06:27at first something, well, isn't there some sort of surgery we can do?
- 1:06:31And what they'll say is, you know, research shows that doing surgery
- 1:06:35is an option of last resort because you can actually make it worse with surgery.
- 1:06:43It isn't guaranteed to work. And that you know, you said,
- 1:06:46well, isn't aren't there medications And what they'll say is, well, yeah,
- 1:06:50but you will become tolerant of those medication such that they will no longer
- 1:06:56work, and you'll need more and more of the medication and eventually you'll be
- 1:07:00taking so much that you're basically suffering from well you know, it just can
- 1:07:06spin out of control and harm you. And so for a lot of people
- 1:07:11today who deal with chronic pain, there is no solution. And it just
- 1:07:15seems like of all the things that medical science could have solved by now,
- 1:07:20you would have thought that this could be one of those things. And of
- 1:07:24course pain has a lot of sources, but it just seems like, isn't
- 1:07:28there something you can do, some kind of thing that you can do to
- 1:07:33the nerves, or something you can do to the brain, or I don't
- 1:07:36know. It just it's such a tragedy and I'm so sorry that you're going
- 1:07:40through this. Tailor. It just and for me, my back pain went
- 1:07:43away without really any reason. I did all the things and nothing seemed to
- 1:07:49work, and then at some point years into it, it just it just
- 1:07:55disappeared like, well, thank god, you know, so in that moment
- 1:08:00I had a glimpse into that. I can't imagine what you're going through.
- 1:08:02It. Yeah, I'm just so sorry, and I very much doubt that
- 1:08:08I have any unique tools to give you, because I'm sure that you've heard
- 1:08:13them all and thought about them all. But the only thing I can offer,
- 1:08:20and I'm sure you know this, but I do hear from people who
- 1:08:25suffer from chronic pain that there's a third option. You lay out two options.
- 1:08:30One is to pursue your interests and choose to double your pain or triple
- 1:08:39your pain or something, or you give up and do nothing and have less
- 1:08:45pain but still chronic pain. Well, for these folks, I'll hear them
- 1:08:48talk about a third option, and the way that they talk about it,
- 1:08:53it's metaphorical and it's not easily adopted from the outside. The way that they
- 1:09:00talk, there'll be things like that they'll lean into the pain, or that
- 1:09:04they'll use the pain, or they'll find meaning while pursuing things while having the
- 1:09:12pain at their side, or something. It ends up being like that,
- 1:09:18you know, in terms of the solution. There's some kind of wisdom that
- 1:09:26I think these people will develop, and it's horrible that they have to develop
- 1:09:31these sorts of wisdoms. And I'm sure that these wisdoms are at the pinnacle
- 1:09:36of human abilities, you know. I think it takes a very rare individual
- 1:09:43to be able to find that place. And maybe it's a bit of random
- 1:09:47chance as well, but I think it's a lot to ask of somebody,
- 1:09:51right. There's also the possibility of pursuing things that are easy to pursue,
- 1:10:01you know, things that cause less chronic pain. I don't know, but
- 1:10:06again I'm quite positive you've thought about that at the very least, Taylor.
- 1:10:13What you deserve is love and care and compassion and attention and help. Reminds
- 1:10:21this reminds me of what's her name? Is her name? Science Girl?
- 1:10:27I have to google it science girl? Physics Girl? Sorry, physics girl,
- 1:10:35So physics girl. If you know her, you know her. But
- 1:10:40I've been seeing her videos for a very very long time. She's a science
- 1:10:45educator, very smart, very charming, and makes great videos, has made
- 1:10:51great content for many many years. Well, she had COVID and then she
- 1:10:57got long COVID and now she is in so much pain and she has so
- 1:11:03much fatigue and her brain isn't working hardly at all that she just I mean,
- 1:11:11I'm not describing it well, but I've watched a lot of footage about
- 1:11:16her having to have a very particular kind of diet and she basically just lays
- 1:11:21in bed and she can't even think. She can't watch TV, she can't
- 1:11:28read, she can't talk. It's painful, it's hard, it's cloudy.
- 1:11:33She's suffering on such a high level. I mean, it sounds miserable.
- 1:11:41And for so many of us fans of hers Physics Girl, to see her
- 1:11:47go from this energetic, intelligent, charismatic fun and you know she just brightens
- 1:11:57your day. To go from that, I mean it just makes me cry.
- 1:12:00And so to think about you, Taylor, going through that something like
- 1:12:03that, it just it just destroys me. And you know that line that
- 1:12:08you say here, which is that you say that you feel like you were
- 1:12:13born into the most opposing body for how your mind works, that feeling that
- 1:12:19your body is opposing you, your body is against you. If you could,
- 1:12:25if you could just free your mind from your body, downloaded into some
- 1:12:30other thing or body or machine, it just be free of the pain.
- 1:12:35It's really just so sad and aggravating to me that you're going through this.
- 1:12:45It's so unfair. It's just so unfair. I'm sorry. All right,
- 1:12:53Well, let's end the episode there. Everybody, take care of yourself and
- 1:12:59take care of others as we all deserve that we really really do