Latest / Star Wars Alliance / From A Certain Point Of View Return of the Jedi Review Star Wars Alliance
Transcript
- 0:00The Foss will be with you always. Hello and welcome back to another episode
- 0:22of Star Wars Alliance. Of course, I'm your host Clay, and with
- 0:26me this Saturday afternoon, Sunday Sunday, Oh my gosh, Sunday Sunday Sunday
- 0:35afternoon is Katie. This is a special episode, guys. Of course we
- 0:42have been telling you guys, and we've had our weekly book club of from
- 0:48a certain point of view, return of the Jedi. But of course Katie
- 0:53is with me. Katie, how have you been this weekend? Well,
- 0:57everything is still chaos, but you know, happy times are coming. Happy
- 1:03times. We're gonna take deep breaths. I have learned how to meditate more
- 1:07and just like breathe through it. Everything's gonna be fine. How do you
- 1:12know? I am doing pretty well. I'm pretty sure. I can't remember
- 1:19if I told you guys in the gua chat, but I recently went back
- 1:25to the doctor and they were like, hey, because unfortunately I just found
- 1:32out that my regular doctor is going through chemotherapy and that's why she has like
- 1:38just disappeared and I have a new doctor now. But I found out that
- 1:41was the reason why. But this new doctor was just snooping around my file
- 1:45because of course she's my new doctor. And she's like, hey, I
- 1:49noticed that your blood sugar is really high and all of these other things.
- 1:53Have you ever considered a diet? And I'm like no, but so I
- 2:01had to go do some blood work this week. I got the results.
- 2:06It's all gibberish to me because I don't know anything as far as you know,
- 2:09autonomy, science and whatnot. So she will tell me all about that
- 2:16stuff in a couple of weeks and I will possibly have to go through hell
- 2:21learning how to quote unquote eat healthy. That's gonna be welcome to my life.
- 2:27I can send you, like all the recipe books my contritionist has given
- 2:30me. They're actually quite tasty. Okay, they're actually quite tasty. I
- 2:36see. That's I always go. I always flip through these videos on TikTok
- 2:39where it's like eating healthy does not have to be gross, and it has
- 2:45like a huge, like juicy hamburger, and I'm just like, why are
- 2:47you doing this to me? Like why are you like waving this in my
- 2:52face right now when I know that I probably shouldn't be eating that, but
- 2:57hopefully I can still eat somewhat of like tasteful things. That's that's the big
- 3:04thing for me. But of course this isn't a nutrition or food podcast.
- 3:07This is a Star Wars podcast, And like I said, this is one
- 3:13of our special episodes. This is not a regular news show. This is
- 3:15only a book review. This book is coming out in a week, two
- 3:23days todays, yes, two days as of the time we are recording this.
- 3:28So by the time you were listening to this, uh, the book
- 3:30is already out. You may not have finished it yet. It is a
- 3:35whopping forty stories, close to four hundred and thirty something odd pages. We
- 3:42were so graciously given the digital copy of this book, which, by the
- 3:46way, it actually helped me. I found out on the uh net Galley
- 3:53app that, uh, you can turn your pages into scroll. You don't
- 4:01have to swipe, you can you can make every chapter just a scroll.
- 4:06And so I just continuously scroll through the entire chapter, because I'm the type
- 4:13of person that's always like, okay, let's count how many pages it is.
- 4:15Is it worth reading right now? Or should I go to bed or
- 4:18whatnot? And scrolling just seems a lot easier. It's just like it's all
- 4:21continuous, it's all one page and then boom, I'm done. But yes,
- 4:29it's forty pages. I mean forty pages, forty stories, four hundred
- 4:31and something odd pages. We were also given the audio book closer to the
- 4:39end or the beginning of this week. I have week I have finished that.
- 4:43I will go ahead and spoil this for you. Sam Whitwer has one
- 4:47of the most awesome dialogues in this audio book, Like, it is great,
- 4:56and I will mention it when we get there, because today we're going
- 4:59to be talking about our five top stories of the forty and getting a three
- 5:05honorable mentions eight, which is a problem because I finished this book, y'all,
- 5:12and like, I love these books, but they are also like a
- 5:15monster to finish because you're like, okay, short story, short story,
- 5:19but then it's like, oh wait, I have to read forty short stories.
- 5:23So I have finished this twenty minutes before we were supposed to start,
- 5:28and I didn't even get a chance to listen to the audiobook. So I
- 5:30just quickly what Clay was talking, wrote like top top in like my places,
- 5:35because I showed Clay I have a table. I have a forty row
- 5:41table, so I just added like a little rank column. I have seven
- 5:45top stories and three honorable mentions, so I have to whittle this down really
- 5:49quickly. I'm kind of going through the same thing in my head because I
- 5:56also finished the audio book probably about two hours ago so, and we just
- 6:02came up with the idea of honorable mentions and top fives right before we started
- 6:08recording. So it's it's it's going to be a little bit of fun and
- 6:12we're just gonna go with the flow here. But uh, this book overall,
- 6:18uh, you guys have heard it before. When I had the opportunity
- 6:25to read from a certain point of view, a new hope, I nearly
- 6:30despised it because there was just so many stories in there that I had no
- 6:38care about whatsoever. And I will always go to that Aunt Brerew story talking
- 6:45about churning cheese and baking cookies and all of this stuff. It's like I
- 6:49don't care, Like I'm sorry. It just didn't Uh, it didn't make
- 6:55any sense to me. But what I did say, if you guys go
- 6:59back to the book club from a couple of weeks ago when we started Return
- 7:04of the Jedi, from a certain point of view, there has been some
- 7:10stories of characters that are a blink and you miss it part of the actual
- 7:15movie Return of the Jedi, and these writers have created an entire world behind
- 7:24these characters, and it is amazing. I absolutely love some of these stories
- 7:30in this book. And I will say there is a little bit of a
- 7:38tease for future books. I don't know what it means. I don't know
- 7:45how it's gonna go, but we'll talk about that when we get there,
- 7:49because I think it's at least on one of my lists. So, Katie,
- 7:54do you want to go from your most favorite or your least favorite at
- 8:00first? Like? Are we going from five to one? Are we going
- 8:01one to five? Okay? So I'm just gonna say it. I love
- 8:07all these stories so much. They're just top five. Yeah, they're not
- 8:11like a particular order. Okay, Okay, okay, I can agree with
- 8:16because it's really hard for me to go from like, well, I don't
- 8:22want to say it because I don't want to spoil my list, but like
- 8:24one story to another, Like one story is on here specifically because like it's
- 8:31like one of my favorite characters, but it's also like a really well done
- 8:33story. So yeah, okay, so go ahead and give me your first
- 8:41one. Then all right, So I'm gonna go. I guess I'm gonna
- 8:46go chronologically. Here's what we're gonna do. I'm gonna go chronologically. Okay,
- 8:50Okay, So we have talked about the story already, but I just
- 8:54I have to put this up here. June Seas of June Sea, Songs
- 9:01of Salt and Moonlight by Oh my gosh, I we forgot to look up
- 9:05how to pronounce some of these author's names. Theo Guanzan And it's about Jess
- 9:11And it's the one where she is a singer in job As Palace. And
- 9:16it's like a short little romance tale, like pure perfection, and like the
- 9:20little interludes on how to kill a hut just make me laugh, like it's
- 9:24just such a good story. It is. And this is also on my
- 9:28top five. We both gushed about it on the book Club. This was
- 9:35This was one of the longer short stories within from a certain point of view
- 9:41Returned the Jedi or from a certain point of view return however you want name
- 9:45it. This was one of the longer ones, but it, like I
- 9:48said, built an entire world behind this character. This character has a sick
- 9:54father, a long lost lover that returns Uh, it's it's so good.
- 10:03Uh. You know, there's this idea that she is just stuck under the
- 10:07thumb of Jabah and big for Tuna, and you're rooting for these for this
- 10:13character the entire time. Uh, Like I hope something comes out of this.
- 10:18I hope something comes out of this. Uh. And it's it's so
- 10:22good. I know. Uh, Katie is as well as I. We're
- 10:26a sucker for romance novels uh and just the genre of romance uh as a
- 10:33whole. And so this one really stuck to me as soon as I finished
- 10:37tread h for sure. Like, and Jess does get mentioned in a later
- 10:43story that we're going to talk about, Like if this is not, if
- 10:48this next, if the one that I'm thinking of that I'm trying not to
- 10:52spoil isn't on your list, Clay, I will be her friendously surprised.
- 10:56But anyways, so what is the next one on your list? So the
- 11:03next one, if we're going chronologically, we just did Dunecy Songs of Salt
- 11:09and Moonlights. I think my next favorite, as silly as it sounds,
- 11:20would have to be my mouth never closes. Yes, this is, of
- 11:28course the snarlac Pit slack p starlack Pit Yeah, sorry starlack Pit. Uh,
- 11:37this was really really fun and they give him a really funny accent and
- 11:46uh in the audiobook, so I highly recommend it. But is this the
- 11:52Scott one? This? I think it might be? Okay? Uh,
- 11:58which, oh, by the way, since it's it's passing this one or
- 12:03it's before this one, and I don't know if it's on yours whatsoever.
- 12:07But reputation the uh the Bubba Fett Yeah, is John Hamm? Yeah,
- 12:15he's done all three, all three stories for Bubba fet I don't remember him
- 12:20in a New Hope, but hearing it, I was like, Okay,
- 12:26I can dig this. I want to know if made like was uh Morrison
- 12:33like not available or so was it like a budget thing? Because I feel
- 12:39like John Hamm would be more expensive than Morrison. So when did that one
- 12:46come out? Was that twenty twenty? No, that was twenty seventeen.
- 12:52So it was like in the beginning of like everybody kind of a bunch of
- 12:58authors kind of getting authors, actors getting into like audiobooks and stuff like Andy
- 13:05Serkis was getting into doing them and everything. I think this was like when
- 13:09The Sandman first came out, and so like with a lot of from a
- 13:16certain point of view, it actually has a wide cast. So Jonathan Davis,
- 13:20Mark Thompson, January Lavoy are all a part of it. But you
- 13:24also have John hamp you have Neil Patrick, Harris, Ashley x stein Uh
- 13:33does narration for one of them. So it was like a really big thing.
- 13:37And then from a certain point of view, strikes back. That was
- 13:43the first time San Whitwer was involved. But John Ham did returned for that
- 13:46one, So yeah, okay, I was thinking there was more celebrities involved
- 13:54in the first one, but there really wasn't. But going back to this
- 13:56one, my mouth never closes. Getting this perspective was shouldn't have been surprising
- 14:05to me because of course, the one thing that I remember from a New
- 14:09Hope is the trash Compactor monster and getting their whole backstory and like having this
- 14:18whole background of like possibly even being for sensitive and like all of this stuff,
- 14:22And I thought it was really really cool giving the Starlac pit a a
- 14:30background where like it what the origin wasn't even in tattooing, Like there was
- 14:37a whole school of them, like a pack, and he landed in a
- 14:43jungle tattooing. That was wild to me. That tattooing at one point was
- 14:52green and beautiful and had all of these creatures in it. And then he
- 14:58slept for like ten thous in years and woke up to a dry desert.
- 15:03Uh. Absolutely wild. He absolutely hates the taste of human flesh. He's
- 15:11a vegetarian, and everybody's forced feeding him flesh. I thought was absolutely hilarious,
- 15:20but also it kind of got really dark when C three Po fell in
- 15:24and he was like, stay with me. You can stay with me forever.
- 15:30You don't have to be a servant to anyone, and we could live
- 15:33together forever and we'll be best friends. And three I like how it like
- 15:39almost seems like C. Three Po is like kind of like contemplating it,
- 15:43and he's like yeah, no, no, no no, I'm gonna wave
- 15:48down my master and we're gonna go okay bye. Yeah. And the starlet
- 15:54pick uses sign language, which I thought was really interesting, like all the
- 15:56tentacles waving around like they incorporate did that into the character. So like,
- 16:03Charlie Jane Anders did an incredible job with this one. This one is one
- 16:07of my honorable mentions so well, Okay, I still have six honorable mentions,
- 16:14but we'll just see what happens. I can't. It's hard, Okay,
- 16:19it's it's a good story. And like I said, it's going to
- 16:23be hard. There's forty stories in here, guys, forty that Again,
- 16:30I didn't think I was going to like as many as I did, and
- 16:33I thoroughly appreciated these. So, Katie, what would be your number three?
- 16:41So this next one should not be a surprise relate to anyone, but
- 16:47it is from a certain point of view by Alex Jennings h And it is
- 16:51about obi Wan Canoe and uh. For me, this one is so good.
- 16:56It's so well articulated, and all of the connections to the different shows
- 17:03and everything. It's just perfect. And like, I think the biggest thing
- 17:07for me is Jennings being able to capture obi Wan, realizing that Anakin's not
- 17:12truly gone and that those best parts of Anakin and of course Padme live on
- 17:18in Luke and Leia, which means he could come back because the good parts
- 17:22of him are rooted in Luke and Leia. It was just such an incredible
- 17:26story and I just I loved it. This one was really, really good
- 17:34because we need to remember that from a certain point of view, Obi one
- 17:42almost felt like a failure to Anakin because of what happened, and to get
- 17:51this revelation of like, oh, that good part is still here living residing
- 17:57in his son Luke sky Walker. And there's even a moment within the story
- 18:03where like he can even see like the struggle Luke is having. H but
- 18:10there's there's a moment instead of like, uh, he expected him to say
- 18:15I can't do this, I can't do this, but instead he says I
- 18:19can't kill my father. And that really surprised Obi Wan Kenobi. He's like
- 18:29he couldn't comprehend it. And I just really love the heart behind this.
- 18:37And if anybody, of course is a Star Wars fan, you take into
- 18:41account the journey that Obi Wan Kenobi has taken from the moment he met Anakin
- 18:48to now this holds so much weight and that's what I love about it.
- 18:53Yeah, yeah, was this on your top list? Or this was on
- 18:57my This was on my top list? Yeah? Okay, all right,
- 19:03So which one is next? For you? The next one for me?
- 19:10See here? Uh? I oh shoot, what was it? No?
- 19:18Hold on which one? H it was? Oh? Shoot, I can't
- 19:26remember. Oh you know what twenty and out. This is about the uh,
- 19:37one of the operators for the Desk Star, Yeah, is about to
- 19:42go into retirement. Uh. This whole story is about him kind of like,
- 19:49oh, just I just need to do this one more thing and then
- 19:53I'm out, Like I'm twenty years and I'm out, and then I can
- 19:57like the idea. I love this also because it's so stupid and silly.
- 20:03Is he has this genius idea, a billion credit idea, and all of
- 20:12his other co workers are like, all right, tell us and he's like,
- 20:15no, I'm not gonna tell you. If I tell you, then
- 20:18you're gonna tell somebody else and then they're gonna do it. And I'm not
- 20:21gonna make my billion Like no, this is my idea. And they're like,
- 20:23come on, dude, we're not gonna tell anybody. You're gonna be
- 20:26the first one out of here anyway. Just tell us. She's like,
- 20:29okay, guys, listen, listen, this genius genius idea handrails and he
- 20:38just like I can just imagine the circle in the break room handrails, and
- 20:42he just like sits back and he kind of looks at everybody, and everybody
- 20:48just starts laughing at him, and they're like, what are you talking about.
- 20:51He's like, no, no, no, listen, listen, listen,
- 20:52listen, listen. What is the number one cause of death for stormtroopers?
- 21:00One guy was like rebels. He's like, okay, yeah, you're
- 21:03right, but no, no, what's the second most common reason of death
- 21:08for stormtroopers? And they're like, I don't know. He's like, well,
- 21:12it's falling off ledges, Like we're always falling for some stupid reason,
- 21:18so if we get handrails, there's no reason for us to fall. And
- 21:23they're like, I guess, I don't know. He's liked, just wait,
- 21:29I'm gonna make my billion. I'm gonna make my billion. I swear,
- 21:32I swear. And I think it's so funny because this is, of
- 21:34course, at the exact same time of the attack on the Death Star two,
- 21:41and he legit is literally about to fall because of the like the death
- 21:48Star actually starts to shake and him and his co pilot for the for the
- 21:56operation of the Death Star, it shakes and they both topple over, but
- 22:02they don't fall to their deaths. They're able to like grab on, they
- 22:04pull themselves up and they start walking away, and like, after the whole
- 22:08scene is done, they're like, yeah, so Guardrails, Like I think,
- 22:11I think you're gonna do great man, Like this is gonna be wonderful.
- 22:18Yeah. Lamar Gyles did a really good job with this one. This
- 22:22is when I struggled. I was like, do I put it in my
- 22:25honorable mentions or do I have an now? So it did not. It's
- 22:27not ultimately on my list, but this one was still a really good one.
- 22:30It's short, very well written, and it's to the point having that
- 22:37funny element of hand rails, which is also a very legitimate thing. But
- 22:42while the guys trying to retire and he's like, yeah, just one more
- 22:45week, and he has this little veteran voice speaking in the back of his
- 22:49head. In the way they just talk back and forth to each other.
- 22:52I just imagined like a little devil on his shoulder and it was just it
- 22:56was great. Yeah. Uh so uh what would be your your next one?
- 23:06So my next one actually scrolls back in the timeline. It is no
- 23:11contingency by fran Wilde, and it is about modern mathma going to get Yes,
- 23:19yes, I did forget about this one, So this one was on
- 23:22my top list as well. Yes, uh Wild did such an incredible job
- 23:30with this, Like I was literally crying after reading the story. It's just
- 23:37so good. It had me on the edge of my seat the entire time.
- 23:41We don't get to see enough about mon Monthma, like going into the
- 23:47field or doing anything. So to get to see her do that while she
- 23:51reflects on her life and reflects them the loss of the offense, like just
- 23:57it adds so much depth to that, to the briefing on Home one in
- 24:03Return of the Jedi, It's incredible. So yeah, there's also a higher
- 24:08republic connection with the ex droid, Yes there is, And with this one.
- 24:15You know, you said we don't get enough of her in the field,
- 24:18but every single time we have seen on Mathma, she looks just like
- 24:25this pen and proper individual that doesn't get her hands dirty. And in here
- 24:32she says, I have to do it. I'm the only one that can
- 24:36do it. This idea that she put in this like safe safety measure on
- 24:45this droid, and if it doesn't get back to it, like it has
- 24:48important information and if this droid does not get back to them, it's going
- 24:52to self destruct. And then we're going to lose that information and so we
- 24:56need to get it. And like I think it's her representatives are like okay,
- 25:02but like what are we supposed to say If anybody tries to like find
- 25:06you there, She's like, then stall them, do something. I have
- 25:10to get going. And it is so intense, to the point where there's
- 25:15like she is basically holding a bomb at one point and then she just like
- 25:22throws it out with the droid. It is absolutely insane, and then like
- 25:29at the very end of the book, it's like nothing happened. She's just
- 25:30like, Okay, bring akbar to attention, and I'm just gonna blend into
- 25:37the background and that's where I'm supposed to be, and you never know that
- 25:40she is just such a badass for this, Yep, the whole bomb thing,
- 25:45and like her opening the droid and like seeing like a written note with
- 25:51like blood on it, like that just shows you the battle that the book,
- 25:55that the book fans went through to get the information. It's just this
- 26:00was such a good story. Like I've got a couple authors on this list
- 26:04who I'm like, Okay, I need to go pick up one of their
- 26:07books and like read it. And this is one of them. Yeah,
- 26:12very nice. Uh my next one, which would be my number five.
- 26:18This could very easily be my number one if I were to legit number them
- 26:26from best to to least favor or whatever. Just because as soon as uh,
- 26:33like in the middle of the story, I knew exactly which character this
- 26:37was actually talking about. And this is the Ballad of nante Uh. This
- 26:45is about the storyteller of the Ewoks, and this ewalk does not really know
- 26:56their place, but they like to go on adventure, they like to tell
- 27:00stories and all of these other things. And the chief of the Ewoks are
- 27:03like, so there's not really a position for this anymore, but every once
- 27:11in a while we give this title to somebody. It's basically like, yeah,
- 27:15you know what you could feel important to just go do? This is
- 27:18basically what they're doing. But he takes it so seriously and I love it.
- 27:22He becomes the storyteller and the ballad writer for the Ewoks, and so
- 27:30he is writing all these things and he finds this tree where he's writing all
- 27:34of it. He's etching all of his stories into this tree. Now,
- 27:40the reason why I felt I knew who this character was was because I was
- 27:45getting so attached to this character. In the middle of the story, I
- 27:48was like, Okay, something bad is going to happen to this character.
- 27:52So I thought, back, okay, what bad happens to ewoks? And
- 27:56there's a scene we're trying of the jet where an e Walk gets blasted at
- 28:04and like another ewalk runs to him, and then, like you you find
- 28:08out it's like one of the saddest scenes in Return the General. You see
- 28:14the death of an Ewalk and this is like, as an audience member,
- 28:17that's like the first time you're supposed to be like, oh, like this
- 28:19is really affecting more people than just the rebels yep. And as soon as
- 28:25I thought that, I was like, oh no, oh no. And
- 28:30so it goes on to like they're about to go into battle. Nanta is
- 28:34like, I'm not a warrior, but this other warrior Ewok, is like
- 28:38it's okay, just follow me, do as I do, and we'll be
- 28:41just fine. And it gets to a point where even Nanta is like feeling
- 28:48confident and he's like we're gonna do this, We're gonna win. It's gonna
- 28:51be awesome. And they get blasted and Nanta tells this other warriors like I
- 28:59am the storyteller and I have stories to tell, and he just dies,
- 29:04and so he passes on the title to this Ewok and at the very end,
- 29:11he starts edging these things into the tree, not writing his own stories,
- 29:15only adding to what Nanta had added. And you find out that the
- 29:19song that they all sing at the very end of the movie is the Ballad
- 29:23of Nanta. I. So this does not make my list, but it
- 29:32did affect me because and I didn't. I was like, when did this
- 29:34elok die? And so you you talking about the scene. I was like,
- 29:40oh my gosh, that's totally what it was, and like that just
- 29:44like, uh, this this Ewok in the movie has no significance whatsoever.
- 29:48It's just again another blink and you miss it like it's it lingers. The
- 29:52scene lingers because it's supposed to affect you as the audience member. Yep.
- 29:56But for them, them as in uh Sarah kun too literally just be like,
- 30:04hey, I'm gonna rip everybody's heart and half writing this story. Uh
- 30:10it's so good. I love this story. Sarah Coun wrote the Doctor Afra
- 30:17audio drama, and she didn't. They did a really good job with that
- 30:19one. I need to I need to go and see if I can get
- 30:23that one, because this was great. I love this book. It was
- 30:29it was so good. The next one on my list. All right,
- 30:33y'all, we are going to hit our first ad break and we will be
- 30:34right back in three two one, which is number four for me. Again,
- 30:41not ranked in any order, but it's Ali Hazelwoods. The Last Flights
- 30:48about Sila Cott there is like, and I got the romance I was expecting
- 30:55from Ali, but and I I kind of figured this one was going to
- 31:02break my heart, but I didn't know how bad it was going to break
- 31:06my heart. Because Sila goes through and she is basically like mortal enemies with
- 31:12this girl, and then one day they kind of meet and then they're friendly,
- 31:18like, oh, this utter hatred I have for you was actually fatal
- 31:22attraction. And so Sila and her start seeing each other and then they go
- 31:30on a date and the Imperial facility that the girlfriend works at actually fired and
- 31:37mis hits in quotation marks a ship that had Sila Kott's whole family on it.
- 31:45Yeah, I was immediately like, I'm leaving, I've got to go.
- 31:48And the girl is like what if I never see you again, like
- 31:52it was just an accident. So long story short, Sila gets there and
- 31:56she's she's a great pilot. That's how her and the girlfriend kind of like
- 32:01fell in line, fell in love together, which her piloting for the girlfriend's
- 32:06test, but Silo refuses to pilot a fighter jet. She wants to fly
- 32:13cargo missions and everything, and so the girlfriend right before, like I think
- 32:21it's like a week before the Death Star happens, the girlfriend sends a message
- 32:27into the rebellion and she has become a rebellion informant and is taking down the
- 32:32Imperial facility, and the girlfriend's like, you know what, I hope I
- 32:37see you soon, but make it a surprise. And Syla is one of
- 32:44the X Wing fighter pilots attacking the Death Star and she leads people off of
- 32:50her squad and is like, I hope you're ready for your surprise, like
- 32:54because she knew the girlfriend was dead because the place exploded. But like I
- 33:00like kind of threw my book down and was like no, no, no,
- 33:05no. So yeah, I really enjoyed this one. It didn't make
- 33:14any of my lists, but I did really enjoy it. Like I said,
- 33:16this is this is a hard list to make, but yours is actually
- 33:23it's so funny. Ours are very close together. You did Last Flight,
- 33:28I did twenty and Out. I did the Ballad of Nanta. My next
- 33:32one is literally right after that, then Fall Sidious by Olivier Blake. So
- 33:39this is this is your start of your honorable mentions. Yes, this is
- 33:44the start of my honorable mentions. This is narrated by Sam Whitwor and he
- 33:50does almost a perfect sidious. It is awesome. This story is just like,
- 34:04uh, oh man, it's just so so good talking about like the
- 34:08fact that uh, the idea of you know, wanting to bring Luke into
- 34:16the dark side and you know, having oh so confident, all this confidence
- 34:22with Vader at his side, and all of these other things. I really
- 34:28enjoyed this one. I may just love it for the fact that I was
- 34:31actually able to listen to it in audio form, and Sam, we're just
- 34:37like, it's just so good. It's like this one. It may you
- 34:44may just want to listen to this in audio form, but it was really
- 34:47really good to me. So Sam actually did Mike Trends of Disturbance, and
- 34:52from a certain point of view, strikes back which is about Palpatine as well.
- 34:58Highly recommend that one. For me. I was not a fan of
- 35:02a structure on this one, like it was was it just like chounting down
- 35:07like the seconds because it's got like the ten nine eight mm hmm. I
- 35:14was just not a fan. And like, I feel like, if you're
- 35:15going to try and attempt like oh seconds kind of feel, then the sections
- 35:22need to be shorter, because some of them were like two or three pages
- 35:27and yeah, and you're like, it's it. It's it's the it's the
- 35:30thing about movies where it's movie time right where one minute is actually five minutes,
- 35:37and like three seconds is actually two minutes. It's so weird, uh,
- 35:42but I can understand that. I I it's also a little poetic in
- 35:47a sense. Uh, just kind of thinking that you know, as he
- 35:52is literally dying, he's looking back at all this stuff. But it's it.
- 35:59This is why. Honestly, it's part of my honorable mentions and not
- 36:01one of my favorites. Potanchio. All right, so my last part of
- 36:07my top five is the one that I was talking about that I'm very surprised
- 36:12not on your list of being in the top five, but it is the
- 36:15chronicler by Daniel Page, and this is basically the story keeper of the rebellion.
- 36:23She has a perfect memory. We kind of get some of her history
- 36:29with mon Mathma, and then we go to like the day of the briefing
- 36:35about Death Star two and she's interviewing our main trio Plando. Yes, this
- 36:45is this is part of my honorable mentions. This is part of my own
- 36:47honorable mentions. I think I enjoyed the other ones a little bit more,
- 36:52but I really enjoyed this one. But keep going, keep I want you
- 36:57to explain it. And so she goes through interviewing all these people, and
- 37:00her main question kind of lies and do Han and Leia have a relationship?
- 37:07And she interviews Han, and then she interviews Luke, and then it's Wando
- 37:12and then finally she gets talked Leia and she's always kind of looked up to
- 37:15Leo, Like we get a lot of that in her history. But she
- 37:19asks Leia all these questions and Leia's like, why are you focusing on me?
- 37:23Why are you not focusing on jess on Ulah, Like these are the
- 37:30people that matter, the little rebellions that matter every single day in that survival
- 37:35of trying to make sure that other people are taken care of, and like
- 37:40it's like this is one again where I'm like, I need to go find
- 37:45what else Daniel Page has written, because like everybody has complained so much about
- 37:52Star Wars Cannon recently, like just being about the little people, why aren't
- 37:58we getting the big things? And well, in a sense, I do
- 38:00agree, this is what it's about, Like like five stars perfection. This
- 38:09would be number one on my list because it's just that good and the emotions
- 38:15built within it just out out of this world. I really enjoyed this one
- 38:24because there let me try to find the actual quote. She is talking to
- 38:30Lando at one moment and all she asks him or yeah, she asks him
- 38:39something about Han and he's like, you mean, who's he's sleeping with?
- 38:45And she's like she is like she cannot speak. I love these things,
- 38:55Like even when she's talking to Luke, and Luke is just like, oh,
- 39:00Leiah has this like guiding light for the rebellion, and she is like
- 39:05awesome and perfect in all of these things, and he even gets lost and
- 39:08like her awe. I really enjoyed this one. And if you guys remember
- 39:15the Chronicler was on my most anticipated This actually did blow my mind. And
- 39:27I even like at the very end where she goes to mon mom Ba and
- 39:30she's like, here you go, I'm a failure. I suck. I
- 39:35hate this and she's like, this is your best work ever. I don't
- 39:39know what you're talking about. I really like this one. It was so
- 39:45good, all right? So okay, So since I have so many Honorable
- 39:52Mentions, I'm just kind of good to go down the list and you tell
- 39:55me which one you want to hear me talk about, because I've already talked
- 40:00about the Star lac Pit, so that would be one. So I have
- 40:01two more, okay, So I have Ending Protocol by Hannah Witten and it
- 40:07is about Riz, and then I have The Emperor's Red Guards by Gloria Chow,
- 40:16Wolf Trap by A. Lissa Wong about Hoyle, when fire Marked the
- 40:22Sky by Emma Mieko Kanden and it's about what gentillies. And then I have
- 40:28The Veteran by Adam blance Garcia about Dexter Jetster. Well, Dexter story was
- 40:36on my Honorable Mentions, So let's go ahead and talk about that one real
- 40:38quick. Hey, do you want to start it off me first. Okay,
- 40:46so this story kind of goes into decks being on Corscant he's basically lost
- 40:53everything. He lives in the little apartment. The diner is no longer open.
- 40:59It closed about four years after a Revenge of the Sith, and it
- 41:05just kind of tells the story of the first night on Corucent after the death
- 41:10start to explode it and so he basically kind of goes around, like he
- 41:16tells his little neighbor who he takes a knife from that he wants to check
- 41:22the wind and ends up saving this stormtrooper, this little girl, and gets
- 41:29her out and they kind of agree to build this rebellion. And it's just
- 41:34such a history on decks, kind of all those little moments about like living
- 41:39for so long because and he even goes on to talk about that like the
- 41:43Besselists live a long life, but not as long as other species, so
- 41:49Adam didn't have to put a timespan on how long's best. But you also
- 41:52can look at the life that he has led, like we've seen him in
- 41:59the High Repel, look, we've seen him in the prequel trilogy, and
- 42:05to know that he's hiding in the original trilogy. That's awesome, Like,
- 42:10and I love the conversation between him and the little girl. She's like,
- 42:15I chose to save this man. You can't tell me that's wrong because it
- 42:19was a Stormtrooper and you know everything was going to shit and he knows.
- 42:24He's like, there's a side that knows that they won, and there's a
- 42:30side that just fails to recognize that they lost, or they just don't know
- 42:35that they lost, and so there's just chaos everywhere. It does talk a
- 42:42lot about his experience, like because we met Decks in Star Wars Cannon as
- 42:49just some guy at a diner, and then there was just so much history
- 42:52brought into him about how much he knows and his connection and all of these
- 43:00other things. This guy knows a thing or two, and so having the
- 43:07title the veteran is so relevant to who he is as an individual within the
- 43:14Star Wars universe. Yep, for sure. I think Adam for his first
- 43:20entry into Star Wars section, I think this was a great entry. Okay,
- 43:25so I'm not gonna talk about I'm not gonna go into detail on wolf
- 43:30Trap, but I just have to say a Lissa Wong, what the fuck
- 43:34did I just read. Okay, remind me because because I was scrolling the
- 43:38table of contents and I found wolf Trap, but I can't remember what it
- 43:43was about. So it's about a stormtrooper that gets captured by the Ewoks and
- 43:49he runs into the squad that was captured by the Ewoks like a week previously,
- 43:54and they're all like captured together. They're not fed, and so he
- 43:59basically starts to lucinating like back on his home planet yea, and how like
- 44:04his I guess his boyfriend wanted him to like they wanted to like just get
- 44:09off the planet. And he was like, well, I can get off
- 44:12the planet, go make money and send it back to you, but I
- 44:15can also be a rebel spy and like this whole time, like and like
- 44:21at the end, like he cuts his hand off or he cut part of
- 44:25his hand off, and I was like, like, I just I could
- 44:32not like and I said, I wasn't gonna talk like that much about it,
- 44:36but I just I just had to say it, like what the fuck?
- 44:40It was a wild story. Yeah, all right, Okay, I
- 44:52think the one that I went to claim as my third and final honorable mention
- 44:57is actually ending protocol about h Riz, and it is a Riz is one
- 45:01of the first Imperial surrenders to the rebellion after the Death Star explodes, and
- 45:08I just have to wonder what happened to her. Like it's it's a more
- 45:13lengthy story. It goes into a London detail, but it's just very well
- 45:17written. It's full of heart. I think Whitten did an incredible job here.
- 45:22Oh so this correct me if I'm wrong, because I could be thinking
- 45:25of another story. This is the stormtrooper that inevitably walked into the celebration and
- 45:36gave herself up right. Yep, Okay, she was afraid of She's basically
- 45:42afraid of blasters because like the arms dealer person in the beginning of the story
- 45:46took her blaster and shot her commanding officer. Yes, that that was.
- 45:52It kind of gave like a little bit of like a PTST type of story,
- 45:58which when you were reading, I will say this, I highly recommend
- 46:02if you were not used to reading a story or reading a book in general
- 46:07at like two am. I don't recommend it because your eyes get all fuzzy
- 46:14and you start to like lose memory and stuff. I highly don't recommend this.
- 46:19But because of the way the flashback took place, it kind of felt
- 46:24like it just happened, and I was like, what the Like I had
- 46:28to scroll back and then read it again, but I could see that.
- 46:31But even like her like being so like not she she goes through this like
- 46:40wave because she's on a patrol and with her partner and then they come upon
- 46:47like Han trying to get into the facility to take down the shields and the
- 46:52partner goes to shoot point blank at Leia and she actually trips him, so
- 46:59the shot hits Leia and shoulder. Yeah, and she does like the whole
- 47:05like fake being knocked out kind of thing because Leiah shoots the soldier when Hank
- 47:09goes, I love you, and she goes, I know, and then
- 47:12she pulls lightsaberd shoots the trooper yeah, like and they're like faking like being
- 47:17dead, like she she fakes it like she's just's dead. She's yeah,
- 47:22she's faking yeah, just so that way she could survive. Uh yeah,
- 47:25really really good story. But Katie, I will say this, because you
- 47:30cheated, I'm gonna cheat. I'm gonna bring up one more story. Uh.
- 47:35And plus we need to we need to expand some time for this to
- 47:37actually be up on the podcast feed anyway, but gone to the Winner's Circle
- 47:43by Patricia A. Jackson. This was a surprising treat that ended oh so
- 47:53tragically this individual. I kind of liked these stories because, again we talked
- 48:06about, especially in the Inquisitor book The Red Blade, that sometimes our point
- 48:15of view of the protagonist, that being the Jedi, we enjoyed the idea
- 48:24of seeing it from a different perspective. Here, seeing the Stormtrooper, we
- 48:30learn that the whole entire reason why he is even doing the job that he
- 48:37does is because the Rebellion decided to shoot down a basically I can't remember the
- 48:49exact thing what it was, but it was basically wrong information that the rebellion
- 48:54got and they thought they were destroying something for themire or destroying something that the
- 49:01Empire had, but they didn't, and in doing so, they had killed
- 49:08this individual's lover, and so he's like, I'm done with this, Like
- 49:17the Rebellion is going to get what they deserve. And this individual character is
- 49:24the one on the speeder at Indoor where you get that scene where they're going
- 49:30through the trees and everything else. You learn that he's a racer and that's
- 49:35why he was so like cool on the speeder. Following Luke and Leia,
- 49:42now we know how this story ends. Luke Skywalker what the lightsaber? He
- 49:49spins out of control and crashes into a tree. The ending of this book,
- 49:58like he is so call confidite and the way that he is like doing
- 50:02everything to the point where he like he basically says f off to his commanding
- 50:07officer. He's like, I can do this, just like just wait and
- 50:10see. And it's just like the way it ends, He's like, oh,
- 50:16I've crashed, like it all hurts, but at the same time,
- 50:20there's no pain whatsoever. I'm engulfed in flames like it is very like graphic
- 50:27but also poetic in a sense. This one really surprised me. But I
- 50:31think again, the reason why I liked it is because if you're gonna tell
- 50:36me a story of the bad guy or a a section of this empire,
- 50:44and you're wanting me to feel sorry for him, give me a good enough
- 50:47story too, And this one did. I feel like. This one was
- 50:52like, okay, there is there is a good enough reason why he would
- 50:57be angry at the rebellion, Like he I couldn't even tell you necessarily if
- 51:02he was like, yeah, I'm all for the empire, or if he
- 51:06was more so I hate the rebellion more, you know, so I really
- 51:12do enjoy that. Where's this what almost? Yeah? I love like the
- 51:19connection to speederbag racing. I think it again just brings in like that little
- 51:24known attribute in the Star Wars. I think he's an interesting trooper and one
- 51:32who am I just fighting the good fight is not without those casualties of mistakes.
- 51:37So yeah, I thought it was good. I did enjoy that one.
- 51:42But that is all of our honorable mentions. But I will say I
- 51:50did say at the very beginning of this that there was some sort of teas
- 51:53for the future. At the very end, we have the return of the
- 51:59Wills, And I really enjoyed this story just because it's so silly. They
- 52:07even talk about at the very very end that uh that there is more,
- 52:15there is another, and so like us as the readers, you're like,
- 52:22okay, what does that mean? Are we are? Are we moving forward?
- 52:23Are we moving back? And they teased both they said, oh yea,
- 52:28there is another, talking about there's gonna be something afterward or on the
- 52:31Jedi. But then the other other Wills was like, oh, but we
- 52:36could also go back. You know, I still can't forgive you for what
- 52:39you did to Darth Maul, Like I I really really want after this one.
- 52:49And I don't know if you saw it. In our Star Wars Alliance
- 52:52chat when I was letting everybody know that the audiobook was available soon, Travis
- 53:02was like, Oh, I'm not ready for this. I'm not ready for
- 53:05this because he doesn't like these stories. The reason why he doesn't like these
- 53:08stories is the idea of like kind of how the conversation we're having in the
- 53:15gua about Rebel move, Well, if you're not going to tell the whole
- 53:17story, why do you need a whole another movie for it, Like,
- 53:20just tell the whole story. He's the same way. It's like he doesn't
- 53:23get the Oh, well, if you're gonna have this little nugget of information,
- 53:30you could have just told that story within the movie. It's like,
- 53:31Hey, we say this all the time in Star Wars. The story wasn't
- 53:35there to begin with, so we had to make up the story for it
- 53:37to makes sense. The birthplace. I'm just gonna defend my Rebel moon point
- 53:42because I don't want anybody to say anything about it. I think this is
- 53:45completely different because it's a celebration of the story. It's not trying to like
- 53:52add like retell the movie. It's literally just opening up these characters. And
- 53:57no, a moviegoer's not going to care about any of these characters. Heck,
- 54:00like all like I told Matt about like the R five story in a
- 54:07New Hope, and he's like, why do I care? He doesn't care,
- 54:12and like so it's just it's yeah, it's completely different. I think
- 54:19then because a book is different, and people give novelization shit all the time.
- 54:23Yeah, like why do I need a novel to understand a movie?
- 54:25I should not need seven hours of a movie to understand the movie. And
- 54:32you're right this book. You don't need this book to understand Returnd the Jedi.
- 54:37I want to reiterate that for everybody, this is a celebration, but
- 54:43I am excited for the teas it means that we could possibly be getting more.
- 54:47Of course, I think, just like any other piece of media,
- 54:53is if it does well, they'll continue. If it doesn't do well,
- 54:59then they won't continue. And because we as Star Wars fans are crazy and
- 55:05will always buy anything Star Wars. I think it will do well, but
- 55:09of course I'm pretty sure Katie has already said it. We will be interviewing
- 55:19we talk about it last week. Yes, we will be interviewing the editor
- 55:23of this book, of course, Tom. We are very excited. We
- 55:27already have a handful of questions and we will be releasing that soon. We
- 55:34haven't interviewed him yet. We are actually going to be interviewing him after this
- 55:37review, so live, so come join the five. Granted this one is
- 55:44coming out before the interview yourself. I was gonna say this is coming out
- 55:46on the same day it's the interview, So if you have listened to this
- 55:51and not seen or heard the regular quote unquote news show, there is not
- 55:57gonna be any news, We're gonna jump right into the review. I'm sorry
- 56:00interview, so go check that out as well. But of course, thank
- 56:07you guys so much for being here. Of course you can always find me
- 56:10at a fanboy, play on Twitter, in any other social media. Recently
- 56:15I have been streaming live on Twitch playing Marvel Snap. I want to thank
- 56:22Dylan, s Bubs and Andrew for showing up the other day. It was
- 56:25very, very fun. But Katie, where can everybody find you. See,
- 56:31I'll find me on any social media. I just had a sip of
- 56:35my water, so nothing came out right, y'all can find me on any
- 56:39social media platform. It's at Katie. This show you can find on Twitter.
- 56:45It's at Star Wars Lines up. The A and the War is very
- 56:46important. Don't forget it. When Clay or I get an invite code to
- 56:52pop up, it'll go on Blue Sky. That's the next task, because
- 56:55that's where everybody's probably going to end up, I would think. So.
- 57:01Yeah, if social media explodes and nothing comes after Twitter, then you can
- 57:08go to my personal website, Slice of Katie dot com and you can find
- 57:13everything about the show where it'll be, etc. Remember, y'all, you
- 57:17can email us get Star Wars lances at the eight in The War is very
- 57:21important. To forget it, as well as our phone number where you can
- 57:25send us text messages and voice memos and mails that we will pre screen before
- 57:32sharing on the podcast about from a certain point of view returns a sooca at
- 57:39anything you want to ask us, any comments you have, we will happily
- 57:43take it all. All you have to do is call or text eight three
- 57:47zero five three eight four eight to eight. So with that, I want
- 57:52to wish everyone a great day or night, whatever, whatever time of day
- 57:58you are listening, and we will see you all next time. May the
- 58:00Four spee with you.