Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / Using ADR to Resolve Social Media Disputes: Neutral Strategies for a Digital World
Transcript
- 0:02Hello, everyone, and welcome to today's program,
- 0:06Using ADR to Resolve Social Media Disputes, Neutral
- 0:09Strategies for a Digital World. I'm Alla Policastro,
- 0:13Director of Education and Professional Development
- 0:15at Beverly Hills Bar Association, and I'm delighted
- 0:18to introduce today's speaker, Ellie Horizadeh
- 0:21of Jam's ADR Services. Ellie is a mediator, arbitrator,
- 0:26court -appointed neutral, and neutral evaluator
- 0:28with more than 25 years of experience resolving
- 0:30high stakes disputes across the United States
- 0:33and internationally. She delivers efficient,
- 0:36fair, and creative resolutions across countless
- 0:38practice areas, including disputes that arise
- 0:41or relate to social media, such as intellectual
- 0:44property, technology, artificial intelligence,
- 0:46and entertainment. She has served as a mediator
- 0:50for the Central District of California and Los
- 0:52Angeles Superior Court since 2019, and previously
- 0:56as a temporary judge for the Los Angeles Superior
- 0:58Court, and was repeatedly recognized as a preeminent
- 1:01litigator in Los Angeles by super lawyers. She
- 1:05also brings significant international experience
- 1:07having represented clients in cross -border disputes
- 1:10through Europe, Asia, and the Americas. We can't
- 1:13wait to hear what she has to share with us today,
- 1:15so I'm going to turn it over to her. Good afternoon.
- 1:17I'm Ellie Herizadeh, and as just previously stated,
- 1:21I'm a mediator and arbitrator with Jams. I specialize
- 1:24in cases arising from all types of social media
- 1:26posts, defamation claims, influencer brand conflicts,
- 1:30privacy breaches, and other claims arising and
- 1:32relating to contracts related to social media.
- 1:36In this session, we'll explore how counsel can
- 1:40use mediation not as a fallback, but as an advocacy
- 1:43tool to control the narrative of the dispute.
- 1:46to manage reputational exposure and reach enforceable
- 1:50practical outcomes. We will also explore what
- 1:53arbitration provisions in social mediating social
- 1:57media agreements should include. I'm going to
- 2:00go ahead and share my screen with you. Mediation
- 2:05gives counsel a controlled confidential forum
- 2:08to address what may otherwise be a very public
- 2:11dispute. This is crucial because public litigation
- 2:14fuels reputational harm and reputational harm
- 2:18fuels social media disputes. Mediation can help
- 2:22shape the outcome through the process design,
- 2:25through mediator selection, and through tailored
- 2:27remedies. Mediation offers advantages like evidentiary
- 2:31flexibility and confidentiality, and it allows
- 2:34the parties to craft non -monetary remedies.
- 2:38Mediation can also help preserve client relationships
- 2:41so that the relationships can recover and possibly
- 2:44continue beyond mediation. Sometimes, when presented
- 2:49with the suggestion to attend mediation, clients
- 2:51view mediation as a waste of time, or worse,
- 2:54as a showing of weakness. As counsel, it may
- 2:58be helpful for you to frame mediation as a proactive
- 3:01risk management tool instead of a concession.
- 3:04You may want to try to explain to your clients
- 3:07that speed equals value in digital disputes.
- 3:11Any delay will likely compound the harm, the
- 3:14reputational damage, and the emotional association,
- 3:17and thus make it more difficult to resolve and
- 3:20more costly to litigate. Social media takes on
- 3:26a life of its own as soon as it's posted, and
- 3:28as a result, social media disputes escalate quickly,
- 3:33much faster than court timelines. Since the court
- 3:36system is always lagging behind, it is unable
- 3:39to afford either party the immediate relief that
- 3:42they seek, even in the case of temporary restraining
- 3:45orders or preliminary injunctions. Mediation
- 3:48and arbitration, on the other hand, allow for
- 3:51faster technology -informed resolutions before
- 3:54the viral amplification of the issue at hand.
- 3:58And if the arbitration provision allows the arbitrator
- 4:03to issue preliminary action, like a takedown
- 4:06order, then the parties can get immediate relief
- 4:09while the dispute is being adjudicated. This
- 4:12can significantly reduce the potential harm and
- 4:15thus the damages. Digital disputes also often
- 4:19involve jurisdictional ambiguity in different
- 4:22social media platforms, each with its own rules
- 4:25and litigation requirements. This can further
- 4:28delay a final resolution and make it more difficult
- 4:32for the courts to be able to get all the necessary
- 4:34parties before that. We will discuss how these
- 4:38issues can be addressed by ADOT. As you know,
- 4:43mediation is a confidential process that protects
- 4:46what is said at mediation. Mediation can also
- 4:49provide an arena for the parties to discuss and
- 4:52craft things like a joint statement to preserve
- 4:55each party's social media perception. This is
- 4:58important because in social media, perception
- 5:01and reputational management is risk management.
- 5:05Reputation management is integral to resolution
- 5:08of these types of cases, and mediation gives
- 5:11you and your client an opportunity to control
- 5:14the narrative and prevent a winner -loser outcome.
- 5:20With the right mediator, parties can construct
- 5:22resolutions that are more creative. For example,
- 5:26settlements can include content modification,
- 5:29joint statements, restorative language, or carefully
- 5:32crafted correction. Council and parties can and
- 5:36should use their mediator both as a sounding
- 5:39board for public facing language and as a means
- 5:42to craft with the other side a controlled narrative.
- 5:48Through the process of mediation, each party
- 5:50can participate in the joint outcome, which leads
- 5:53to more success, more compliance, and more likely
- 5:58that the parties may continue to do business
- 6:00after. In order for mediation to be successful,
- 6:06you as counsel must prepare your clients for
- 6:09the day of mediation. Preparing your client for
- 6:12mediation involves more than going over strategy.
- 6:15You need to help your client understand that
- 6:18mediation is a process. It takes time and patience
- 6:22and explain to them that they will spend not
- 6:26an insignificant amount of time without the mediator
- 6:29in their room. There will be times when it seems
- 6:32that mediation is impossible and settlement is
- 6:35just out of sight, but you need to speak to your
- 6:40client and convince them to continue to be engaged
- 6:43during the process. Counsel should treat mediation
- 6:46prep like witness prep, anticipate emotional
- 6:49reactions, and have candid conversations about
- 6:52what it is that their client is really seeking
- 6:55to get out of the litigation. Remind your clients
- 6:59that mediation isn't about surrender. It's about
- 7:02taking control of the outcome. Use mediation
- 7:05as an opportunity to allow your client to advocate
- 7:08for themselves so that they can feel that they've
- 7:11been given the opportunity to air their grievances
- 7:13and explain their side directly to the mediator.
- 7:18There are at least nine areas of consideration
- 7:21for counsel before and at mediation. First, you
- 7:26must determine what contract is an issue. In
- 7:29social media disputes, there are often multiple
- 7:32overlapping agreements. There's the written agreement
- 7:35between the party, whether it be an influencer
- 7:37agreement, a brand ambassador contract, or a
- 7:40content agreement. There's also the platform,
- 7:44Instagram, TikTok, X, YouTube, and the terms
- 7:48of that platform, which may restrict data scraping,
- 7:52affect ownership, to the content or the account
- 7:55and limit the party's ability to modify or remove
- 7:58content. And there are often side agreements.
- 8:03In DMs, emails, or informal, we'll pay you if
- 8:07you post. All of these need to be taken into
- 8:10consideration. And in mediation, all of these
- 8:13should be on the table so that everyone is working
- 8:16from the same understanding of obligation and
- 8:18limitations. Second, Social media disputes are
- 8:23highly evidence -driven and the evidence is fragile.
- 8:27The evidence that drives social media disputes,
- 8:30whether in mediation, arbitration, or court,
- 8:34includes metadata and analytics. For disputes
- 8:38about performance or payment, it is imperative
- 8:41that you have access to and gather reach, impression,
- 8:47and engagement stats. follower counts over time,
- 8:51click -throughs, conversions, or promo code usage.
- 8:55It's important to have screenshots, but it's
- 8:58also important to understand that screenshots
- 9:00can be edited. You need to gather posts or comments
- 9:05or stories, but remember that each of these may
- 9:08have been deleted or edited after posting or
- 9:11limited in visibility either at the time of posting
- 9:14or subsequently by blocking users or restricting
- 9:18the close friends list. All of this evidence
- 9:21is important and can be lost if it is not immediately
- 9:24preserved. Mediation can be an opportunity to
- 9:28share and gather information without formal discovery
- 9:32requests. You can ask the mediator for information
- 9:36from the other party that you need to make a
- 9:38decision or access the other party's offer. You
- 9:42should gather as much of the metadata evidence
- 9:45as quickly as possible and have it available
- 9:48to support your argument for or against damages.
- 9:53The metadata helps anchor the value of your claim
- 9:56or any offer or counteroffer you may present.
- 10:00During mediation, at the very least, the party
- 10:03should discuss and hopefully agree on how to
- 10:06preserve the metadata evidence during the course
- 10:09of the dispute. even if the parties don't raise
- 10:11a resolution on the day of mediation. Third,
- 10:16social media contracts often blur ownership.
- 10:20Before attending mediation, you should think
- 10:22about who owns the content. Does the creator
- 10:25retain the copyright and grant a license? Does
- 10:28the brand own the content? Is it a work for hire?
- 10:32Are there right of publicity issues outside of
- 10:35the social media contract? Is there a use of
- 10:39the brand logos or trademarks, and are these
- 10:41within the contract guidelines? In mediation,
- 10:45you'll want to have explicit discussions of what
- 10:48happens to the existing account, whether any
- 10:51content must be edited, removed, or recaptured,
- 10:54and whether any licenses are revoked, modified,
- 10:59or clarified going forward. Fourth, Social media
- 11:05often involves collection and sharing of personal
- 11:08or customer data, such things as email lists,
- 11:12customer lists, or DMs. If the alleged breach
- 11:15involves sharing or misusing of personal or customer
- 11:20data, during mediation, you want to discuss and
- 11:24consider the deletion or return of the data,
- 11:27or at the very least, cessation of use of that
- 11:30data during the course of litigation. Five, before
- 11:36attending mediation, review the terms of use
- 11:39for the social media platform. Even if the parties
- 11:42reach settlement and mediation, the platform
- 11:45policies might limit what's possible. You need
- 11:49to know who controls the login or administrative
- 11:52rights for the pages at issue. If the settlement
- 11:55includes transfer of ownership of a page or an
- 11:58account, can ownership be transferred under the
- 12:01platform rules? If an account has been banned
- 12:04or shadow banned by the platform, can this account
- 12:07be restored? My suggestion is that any settlement
- 12:12should focus on what's actually within the party's
- 12:15control, including promises that depend on the
- 12:18platform doing something may result in the undoing
- 12:22of your settlement. Six, breach and social media
- 12:27context often centers on performance or payments.
- 12:30When you think about a breach, consider whether
- 12:34the breach is the result of performance issues
- 12:37that actually arose outside of the parties at
- 12:41issue. Is the breach due to outside factors like
- 12:44algorithm changes, seasonality, or platform issues?
- 12:49You want to consider and vet these issues before
- 12:52mediation and certainly before any litigation
- 12:55is initiated. In mediation, you'll want concrete
- 12:59numbers. you'll need to have the actual audience
- 13:02metrics or user metrics, the metadata that I
- 13:05just discussed. Some of this information has
- 13:09to be gathered from the platform, so you'll have
- 13:12to think about this in advance of mediation.
- 13:15It is important that this information is available
- 13:18to support your argument for or against damages
- 13:22and to anchor any offer or counter offer you
- 13:25present at mediation. or to use it to undermine
- 13:29the other party's position. Seven, if mediation
- 13:34results in an agreement, you want that agreement
- 13:37to be practical in a digital context. It needs
- 13:41to clearly and explicitly state which posts will
- 13:45be taken down or left up or edited and when,
- 13:49a specific timeframe, 72 hours. Second, you'll
- 13:55want and needs to verify compliance. How will
- 13:58the parties confirm that the screenshot or link
- 14:02has been taken down? Third, what is the process
- 14:06if a new harmful post surfaces later or if the
- 14:09same harmful post resurfaces? Are the parties
- 14:13obligated to attend renewed mediation before
- 14:16initiating litigation? Eight, if you're unable
- 14:21to reach your full resolution at mediation, try
- 14:24to reach an agreement on some very important
- 14:27preliminary points, like metadata retention,
- 14:31confidentiality of the mediation so there's no
- 14:33leak or post by either party, a joint statement
- 14:37about the dispute, or an agreement not to post
- 14:40further about the dispute until a final adjudication.
- 14:44Finally, social media relationships often involve
- 14:49cross borders. Parties may be in different states
- 14:52or countries which raise questions about which
- 14:55law applies and whether the dispute will be heard
- 15:00if mediation fails. What is the forum for the
- 15:04dispute? At mediation, you won't decide these
- 15:07legal issues definitively, but you and your client
- 15:10do need enough clarity in order to shape a settlement
- 15:13that's likely to be enforceable where it matters.
- 15:16and understand the risk exposure if mediation
- 15:19does not result in a settlement. Since social
- 15:25media relationships and disputes involve parties
- 15:28in different states or countries, online dispute
- 15:31resolution has become a more frequently used
- 15:34method for mediation and arbitration. ODR is
- 15:38simply mediation or arbitration that happens
- 15:41in a virtual setting. There are many options
- 15:44for ODR. I caution you to ensure that whatever
- 15:47company you choose as your online platform has
- 15:52sufficient security and data storage standards
- 15:55to protect your client's information. Data privacy
- 15:59implications under the California Consumer Privacy
- 16:02Act and the EU GDRP are important and required,
- 16:07especially when evidence includes personal data.
- 16:10you need to make sure that these concerns are
- 16:13addressed by the platform you use for online
- 16:17dispute resolution. If you're using jams, you
- 16:20don't need to worry about this, as all of these
- 16:23have been addressed by jams. In addition to security
- 16:29and storage issues, it is important to remain
- 16:32aware that sometimes virtual interactions can
- 16:36lead to tone, misunderstanding, and miscommunications.
- 16:40especially in a virtual session that involves
- 16:42people of different countries and cultures. For
- 16:45this reason, it is important to select a mutual
- 16:48with experience in social media matters and reputational
- 16:51management, as well as someone who has experience
- 16:55in global matters. I suggest that you treat your
- 16:59ODR like an in -person mediation. Control the
- 17:03lighting, the tone, the background. Optics affect
- 17:07credibility. You may also consider testing the
- 17:10platform with your client to ensure that your
- 17:13client is comfortable with such things as screen
- 17:16sharing and breakout rooms before the actual
- 17:19mediation or arbitration. I'm going to switch
- 17:24gears now to arbitration. More and more contracts
- 17:28include arbitration clauses. This is equally
- 17:31true for digital contracts, license agreements,
- 17:34brand and influencer deals. Whether you are drafting
- 17:38an arbitration agreement or reviewing a social
- 17:41media agreement for your client that includes
- 17:43an arbitration provision, you should ensure that
- 17:46the arbitration clause is comprehensive and not
- 17:49simply a boilerplate arbitration agreement. You
- 17:52may want to consider including a mediation arbitration
- 17:55alternative. The mediation arbitration alternative
- 17:59includes mandatory mediation at the outset of
- 18:02the dispute, which can result in lowering the
- 18:05temperature of the dispute. Initial mediation
- 18:08before arbitration can result in a preliminary
- 18:11agreement to take down or not post further, and
- 18:15it can allow the parties to exchange information
- 18:17at an early stage. There are nine key things
- 18:23to consider when drafting or reviewing an arbitration
- 18:26provision in a social media contract. First,
- 18:30the scope. The arbitration clause needs to clearly
- 18:34state that it relates to all claims arising out
- 18:37of or related to the digital conduct or the conduct
- 18:41contemplated by the agreement, not just the contract
- 18:45terms. Otherwise, if either side asserts a claim
- 18:49that is anything other than a breach of contract,
- 18:52you'll be forced to litigate the case in two
- 18:54separate forums. The contract terms will be forced
- 18:58into arbitration pursued to the arbitration provision,
- 19:01and all the other claims will be subject to court.
- 19:04If you don't want to be litigating in two forms,
- 19:07ensure that the scope of your arbitration provision
- 19:10is broad enough to include all claims arising
- 19:13out of or related to the digital conduct or the
- 19:17conduct contemplated by the agreement. Second,
- 19:22the arbitration provision should identify the
- 19:24forum of the arbitration. Otherwise, it will
- 19:27become a form selection race by the first party
- 19:29to file. Is the arbitration going to proceed
- 19:32in JAM, AAA, or another third party? It should
- 19:36be identified in the arbitration agreement. Third,
- 19:41the arbitration provision should include any
- 19:44requirements for the mediator or arbitrator.
- 19:47The mediator requirements only necessary if you
- 19:50opt for a mediator or arbitrator provision. Otherwise,
- 19:55you only need to include the requirements for
- 19:57the arbitrator. But the requirement should state,
- 20:00does the neutral have to have experience mediating
- 20:03or arbitrating social media disputes? Do you
- 20:06want a retired judge? Is there a certain industry
- 20:09or specialization that's required? Whether you
- 20:13want specific requirements for your mediator
- 20:16or arbitrator, those should be delineated in
- 20:19the arbitration provision. Four. Which rules
- 20:23is the arbitration going to be conducted in accordance
- 20:25to? Is it the Jams Comprehensive Rules, the Jams
- 20:29Streamliner Rules, the Federal Rules of Civil
- 20:32Procedure, the Federal Arbitration Act? Whichever
- 20:35rules you intend the arbitration to be governed
- 20:38by should be stated in the arbitration provision.
- 20:42Five, what is a controlling law? As we have discussed,
- 20:46social media involves parties and performance.
- 20:49They're national and sometimes international.
- 20:52Identifying the controlling law of the contract
- 20:54is one thing. Identifying the controlling law
- 20:57of the arbitration agreement is also necessary.
- 21:00You need to identify if the arbitration will
- 21:03be governed by California, another state, the
- 21:07federal rules, that needs to be included in your
- 21:09arbitration provision. Six, do you want your
- 21:14arbitration proceedings to be confidential? Many
- 21:17people mistakenly believe that arbitration proceedings
- 21:21are inherently confidential. They are not. If
- 21:26you want your arbitration proceeding to be confidential,
- 21:29you should state so in the arbitration provision.
- 21:33Seven, preliminary relief. Is the arbitrator
- 21:38permitted to issue take -down injections pending
- 21:42the completion of the arbitration? Is the arbitrator
- 21:45limited? Excuse me, is the arbitrator have the
- 21:50ability to limit either side from making further
- 21:53social media posts or limit their social media
- 21:56conduct during the arbitration. If you want the
- 21:59arbitrator to be able to grant immediate relief
- 22:04at the outset of the arbitration, this needs
- 22:06to be stated in the arbitration provision. Eight,
- 22:12what type of relief can the arbitrator award
- 22:15at the end as part of the final award? Is the
- 22:20arbitrator permitted to issue an injunctive relief,
- 22:23a takedown order? Can the arbitrator prohibit
- 22:27a party from further postings? Can the arbitrator
- 22:30transfer an account, terminate the agreement,
- 22:33or award attorney's fees? We may also want to
- 22:37consider whether the arbitrator can add reputational
- 22:42remedies. If you want to have a limitation, on
- 22:47what reputational remedies are available to the
- 22:50arbitrator, these should be set forth in the
- 22:52arbitration provision. And finally, the arbitration
- 22:56provision must address what happens if there's
- 23:00a conflict between arbitration provision in your
- 23:03contract and the arbitration provision in the
- 23:06platform terms of use. As we previously discussed,
- 23:11it's important as counsel to review the terms
- 23:14of use of the platform. But even if your contract
- 23:18arbitration provision is in line with the arbitration
- 23:22provision of the platform at the time the contract
- 23:24is drafted, there's nothing to say that the platform
- 23:28won't change its terms of use and its arbitration
- 23:31provision sometime before the dispute arises.
- 23:34Therefore, it's important for you to include
- 23:37a provision in the arbitration agreement that
- 23:40states that in the event of a dispute, the provisions
- 23:43of the arbitration provision of the contract
- 23:46should prevail. I'd like to turn to a case study
- 23:53for a recent case about a brand influencer dispute
- 23:56that was resolved through mediation. The case
- 24:00involved an influencer with a brand promotion
- 24:03contract. The influencer was accused of breaching
- 24:06the agreement after posting unapproved content
- 24:09which the brand alleged damaged the brand's image.
- 24:12The contract had a mediation arbitration provision
- 24:16and council invoked the mediation clause for
- 24:20mediation within 30 days. Attending mediation
- 24:23de -escalated the dispute and allowed the parties
- 24:26to air out their grievances and ultimately resolve
- 24:29their dispute. The settlement included a joint
- 24:33clarification post a clarification of the contract
- 24:36terms that had led to the dispute at issue, very
- 24:41limited compensation, and an NDA on the disputed
- 24:44claims. The early mediation preserved the party's
- 24:49relationship and prevented a defamation counterclaim
- 24:52and online fallout between the parties. For this
- 24:57reason, the mediation and arbitration provision
- 24:59helped preserve the party's relationship and
- 25:02allowed the partnership to continue to move forward
- 25:05despite the disagreement. Courts now expect ADR
- 25:13provision in online contracts and social media
- 25:16platform user agreements. Platform user agreements
- 25:20are becoming more and more central to social
- 25:23media disputes. you need to take the arbitration
- 25:26provisions of the platform user agreements into
- 25:29account when drafting a social media agreement.
- 25:33A few recent noteworthy cases in this area are
- 25:38the Doe versus TikTok, where the court confirmed
- 25:42the enforceability of a click wrap agreement.
- 25:45And a click wrap agreement is where there is
- 25:50an arbitration provision in the terms of use.
- 25:53and the user is deemed to accept the terms of
- 25:56use simply by continuing to use the platform.
- 26:00There is no affirmative action by the user other
- 26:03than the continued use of the platform. Now,
- 26:06I will tell you that the current state of click
- 26:08wrap agreements is in flux, but many courts have
- 26:12upheld the click wrap agreements and thus held
- 26:15that users are subject to the arbitration provisions
- 26:18of the terms of use of the social media platform.
- 26:24Miller v. Meta Platforms Inc. The court upheld
- 26:28the mediation requirements before class action
- 26:30lawsuits and the parties were asked to attend
- 26:34mediation where ultimately the case was resolved.
- 26:38Smith v. Twitter. The plaintiff sought injunctive
- 26:41relief in court, but the court upheld the arbitration
- 26:44clause in the terms of the use for then Twitter
- 26:48and declined to allow the plaintiff to proceed.
- 26:51with its request for injunctive relief. Instead,
- 26:55the court ordered the parties to attend arbitration.
- 26:58The arbitration provision, however, did not provide
- 27:00for injunctive relief by the arbitrator, and
- 27:03as a result, the parties were foreclosed from
- 27:06seeking immediate injunctive relief. Many judges,
- 27:14especially those in the Central District of California,
- 27:18now build mediation deadlines into their scheduling
- 27:21orders. Mediation should be a consideration at
- 27:25the outset of any dispute. Like anything in litigation,
- 27:29the timing of mediation is important. In standard
- 27:32litigation, attending mediation before discovery
- 27:36opens or before discovery closes or before the
- 27:40court issues an order on an important motion
- 27:43like a summary judgment can all be impactful.
- 27:46But in social media contacts, The sooner the
- 27:49parties attend mediation, the more powerful it
- 27:52will be on minimizing reputational harm and avoiding
- 27:56an online public dispute. It will also help the
- 28:00parties gather and preserve critical audience
- 28:03metrics. Social media is global, and as a result,
- 28:11disputes arising from social media contracts
- 28:14or social media posts trigger cross -border data
- 28:18privacy and enforcement challenges. There are
- 28:22various international forms and procedures for
- 28:25data removal and enforcement. To avoid having
- 28:29to become proficient in foreign laws or having
- 28:32to litigate all or a portion of a dispute under
- 28:36the laws of another country, I highly suggest
- 28:39adding a choice of law and the ability for the
- 28:42arbitrator to order initial takedown to your
- 28:46arbitration clauses in your social media contracts.
- 28:53Some practical takeaways. Draft arbitration clauses
- 28:57that anticipate digital harm. Think about a breach.
- 29:03Think about what it is that your client would
- 29:06want to protect his or her reputation and include
- 29:10those in the arbitration clause. Select neutrals
- 29:14that are fluent in online dynamics and digital
- 29:17evidence. In the case of a mediator, the mediator
- 29:20can assist the parties in identifying, sharing,
- 29:24and evaluating the audience metrics that may
- 29:27serve as the basis for the damages. In the case
- 29:30of an arbitrator, an arbitrator well versed in
- 29:33online dynamics and digital evidence will better
- 29:36understand the party's arguments and evidence.
- 29:40Gather your digital evidence as soon as the breach
- 29:43occurs. Even if your party is not the party that
- 29:47is alleged to have breached the contract, it
- 29:50is imperative for you and your client to immediately
- 29:53gather as much evidence as possible to defend
- 29:57against the claim that you believe may be asserted.
- 30:02Prepare your client to prioritize closure and
- 30:05control over public vindication. And as part
- 30:10of the settlement, include monitoring compliance,
- 30:15schedule periodic check -ins, take down verifications,
- 30:18or other methods. Now, I know I went over a lot
- 30:23of things and probably too quickly. So I'd like
- 30:27to just recap by going through and summarizing
- 30:31the nine things that should be considered before
- 30:34mediation. and the nine things to consider to
- 30:38put in your arbitration provisions. So I'll list
- 30:42them in without all of the explanations as we've
- 30:46already discussed. So for the nine things to
- 30:48consider before mediation is identify the contracts,
- 30:52and they may not all be the contracts at issue
- 30:55that you're thinking of. Two, gather the metadata
- 31:00and analytics as soon as possible, and that may
- 31:03involve getting information from the social media
- 31:07platform. Three, identify the ownership of the
- 31:10content, the pages, the posts. Four, the data
- 31:16management. Consider whether the breach involves
- 31:20misusing of personal or customer data and how
- 31:24you can prevent further breach or disclosure
- 31:28of that data. Five, Review the social media platform
- 31:32terms of use and rules so that you know what
- 31:35is permissible and what can be accomplished in
- 31:38mediation. Six, consider whether the breach arose
- 31:43as a result of something other than a bad actor,
- 31:46like algorithm changes, and vet those with the
- 31:49platform before mediation. Seven, if mediation
- 31:53results in settlement have clear obligations,
- 31:57a means to verify and a process if there is the
- 32:00same or a similar harmful post. Eight, settle
- 32:06as much as possible, even if not the entire dispute,
- 32:10at mediation. Consider metadata retention, confidentiality,
- 32:16joint statements, agreement not to post any further.
- 32:20And nine, shape a settlement that's likely to
- 32:23be enforceable where it matters, or if the matter
- 32:26doesn't settle, Understand the choice of law
- 32:29issues and the jurisdictional issues so you know
- 32:34how to proceed immediately. And the nine things
- 32:39to consider when drafting an arbitration provision
- 32:43that we discussed was the scope. Make sure that
- 32:46the scope is wide enough that it relates to Claims
- 32:53arising out of or related to the digital conduct
- 32:56or the conduct contemplated by the agreement.
- 32:59Include the forum, Jams, AAA, or another third
- 33:03party. Include the mediator arbitrator requirements.
- 33:09Number four, what rules will govern the arbitration
- 33:12proceeding? Five, what is the controlling law
- 33:16of the contract and the arbitration? Six, do
- 33:23you want your arbitration proceeding to be confidential?
- 33:26And if so, state so in the arbitration agreement.
- 33:30Seven, is the arbitrator permitted to grant preliminary
- 33:37relief? Eight, what is the arbitrator permitted
- 33:41to grant as part of its final order? And nine,
- 33:47If there is a dispute between an arbitration
- 33:50provision in the contract and some other arbitration
- 33:52provision, which one prevails? These are the
- 34:01case references. I hope that you found today's
- 34:06presentation helpful. I am happy to take any
- 34:09questions. All right, so it looks like we have
- 34:14a, let's see. Question from Jack asking if you
- 34:19ever acted as a mediator and then an arbitrator
- 34:22in the same case. Let's see. I'm happy to answer
- 34:28that. Yes, so I have acted as a mediator and
- 34:36an arbitrator in the same case. There is a disclosure
- 34:40requirement that Jams has the party sign, but
- 34:45the arbitrator can serve as a mediator in the
- 34:49case if the parties agreed to do so. In the case
- 34:53that I served as the mediator for a case where
- 34:57I was selected as the arbitrator, the parties
- 34:59ultimately settled in mediation and so we didn't
- 35:01go back to arbitration. And so that case was
- 35:06resolved in mediation. But yes, the arbitrator
- 35:10can serve as a mediator under the jams rules.
- 35:13I don't know whether or not that's true for AAA
- 35:18or any other organization, but I can only speak
- 35:21as to the jams rules. All right, so it looks
- 35:25like we have some questions through email. I
- 35:28guess we can attend to those while we wait for
- 35:32our audience. How do you persuade a client who
- 35:35wants public vindication that ADR is actually
- 35:38the better strategic move? That's a great question.
- 35:43Oftentimes, it takes a lot of persuasion and
- 35:46a lot of discussion with the client of if you
- 35:49want online vindication, you have to remind your
- 35:53client that the online vindication will happen
- 35:55on both sides. So unfortunately, it's not just
- 35:59your client that's going to be posting and messages
- 36:03on social media, but it will be the other side
- 36:06as well. And then there's a whole comment section
- 36:09that takes on a life of its own. My suggestion
- 36:12would be perhaps have an example of something
- 36:16that's already happened for your client with
- 36:18regards to dispute. And it often happens in a
- 36:21chat or the DMs and try and have your client
- 36:26imagine a world where that takes on a life of
- 36:29its own. And you can explain to your client that
- 36:33once the genie is out of the bottle, it's very
- 36:35hard to put that genie back in the bottle. and
- 36:38to regain reputational damage that was lost as
- 36:41a result of a dispute that takes place in the
- 36:44public forum. All right. Then I have another
- 36:49question. In your experience, what kinds of non
- 36:51-monetary remedies, for example, joint statements,
- 36:55content edits, retraction language, are most
- 36:58effective, and which ones tend to backfire? Well,
- 37:03in my experience, I find that um, joint statements
- 37:07or things that are done together between the
- 37:09parties are the most effective. So where the
- 37:12parties work together and come to a settlement
- 37:16and by settlement, I mean, each party has to
- 37:18give on what they want. If the parties can come
- 37:21to a joint statement or a joint concession on
- 37:25what is stated, those are the ones that are most
- 37:29likely to result in compliance and resolution.
- 37:33The ones where the parties say, OK, we'll each
- 37:36issue our own statement, are the ones that usually
- 37:39result in more discourse between the parties.
- 37:43Once the parties come to a joint statement, they
- 37:46have more incentive to comply and to reinforce
- 37:50the joint message that has been put forth. So
- 37:55I always advocate for something that's joint.
- 37:57And even if each side is going to issue their
- 38:00own statements, I often advise that they compare
- 38:04or share their joint statement with the other
- 38:07side before posting to avoid further escalation
- 38:10of the dispute by unintended consequences of
- 38:14what is meant to be a cooperative statement that
- 38:18isn't interpreted as such by the other party.
- 38:27How would you prepare a client who is emotionally
- 38:30charged because the dispute played out publicly
- 38:32online? I would actually not try and disengage
- 38:41the client from the emotion. I would advise that
- 38:44counsel let that client that is emotionally charged
- 38:47be present at mediation and have the client present
- 38:51the case in their view with all of their emotion
- 38:54to the mediator. I think part of moving a case
- 38:58forward, be it in mediation or ultimate resolution
- 39:02in arbitration or court, requires the parties
- 39:05sign on. And in order for a party to sign on,
- 39:08they need to be able to be heard. And sometimes
- 39:11the only place that a party can be heard is at
- 39:14mediation with the mediator. So bring your client
- 39:17that's charged, emotionally charged, to mediation
- 39:21and allow your client to speak directly to the
- 39:24mediator. and allow the media to validate and
- 39:27vindicate the client in your private caucus with
- 39:30respect to how your client is feeling and how
- 39:34your client feels it has been wronged. Alrighty,
- 39:39and another question. What specific language
- 39:42do you recommend to ensure the clause, an ADR
- 39:46clause I'm assuming, covers tort claims arising
- 39:49out of digital conduct? So the language that
- 39:54I found through my own practice and through ADR
- 39:59and through court review is if the language includes
- 40:03language that says arising out of or related
- 40:07to the digital conduct or the conduct contemplated
- 40:12by this agreement, usually that is broad enough
- 40:15to include tort claims. You can of course say,
- 40:19including but not limited to any tort claims
- 40:22that arise from or related to claims arising
- 40:26from this contract, to be overly inclusive. But
- 40:31I think it's important and it would be in your
- 40:36client's best interest to include more words
- 40:38and to be broader in the scope of your arbitration
- 40:41agreement than to be forced to litigate in two
- 40:43separate forums. All right, and let's see. When
- 40:53drafting clauses that allow arbitrators to order
- 40:55content removal or correction, how do you avoid
- 40:58running a foul of platforms own policies or technical
- 41:01limitations? So the arbitrator is going to look
- 41:05to counsel for that. I mean, any good arbitrator
- 41:08is also going to look at the platform rules.
- 41:11But when counsel is seeking to have a either
- 41:15a provisional remedy at the outset of arbitration
- 41:19or as final remedy, part of counsel's job is
- 41:23to ensure that whatever remedy they're asking
- 41:25the arbitrator to provide is in compliance with
- 41:28the platform's rules and it's in compliance with
- 41:31the then effective platform rules. So the arbitrator
- 41:35will look at the platform rules, but it's really
- 41:37counsel's obligation to make sure that whatever
- 41:39they're asking for is something that the platform
- 41:44will allow the parties to do. So even if the
- 41:48arbitrator issues a final award or a remedial
- 41:56award at the outset to say, take down X, Y, or
- 42:00Z, even if the courts go to court and have the
- 42:02court enforce that order, if it does not comply
- 42:05with the platform rules, the platform doesn't
- 42:07have to do it. So make sure that whatever you're
- 42:10asking for from the arbitrator, the mediator,
- 42:13or the other side, or court, it conforms to the
- 42:18rules of the platform. So study the rules of
- 42:22the platform. See what it is that they, in terms
- 42:25of ownership, in terms of litigation, and in
- 42:28terms of what can be done as remedial effects
- 42:36for an arbitration or remedial remedies, make
- 42:39sure that whatever you're asking for conforms
- 42:41to what the platform will allow. All right. And
- 42:49so it looks like we have another set of questions.
- 42:52When using mediation middle litigation to test
- 42:55a damages model, what makes that process most
- 42:58productive for the mediator? So if you want to
- 43:04test your damages model in mediation, the best
- 43:07way to do that is to test it with the mediator.
- 43:10So present your damages to the mediator as if
- 43:13they were the judge rendering and decision in
- 43:16your case. The mediator will walk through the
- 43:18damages calculations with you, and a good mediator
- 43:23will be able to identify to you and for you the
- 43:28areas of your damages calculations or damages
- 43:31strategy that are not likely to be successful.
- 43:35So you can use your damages to first have the
- 43:38conversation with the mediator. And once you
- 43:40have tailored your damages, strategy and your
- 43:45damages claim more narrowly so that it fits within
- 43:50the law and within your claims and has a more
- 43:53likelihood of a success, then you can present
- 43:56that via the mediator to the opposing party at
- 43:59mediation. But you should flush out your damages
- 44:02strategy with the mediator first. All right.
- 44:11And let's see. What are the best practices for
- 44:15drafting mediation briefs that both support settlement
- 44:18and preserve the litigation narrative if mediation
- 44:20fails? That's an excellent question. So I strongly
- 44:25suggest that mediation briefs not be like a court
- 44:30pleading. Your mediation brief should set the
- 44:35tone for mediation, both with opposing party,
- 44:38if you're going to share, and with the mediator.
- 44:40So The mediator is going to know, and obviously
- 44:44the opposing party knows all of your claims and
- 44:47knows the law. You don't need to spend a bunch
- 44:50of time reiterating what the law is. You can
- 44:53identify the claims and then identify the facts
- 44:56that you believe support your claim or defense.
- 45:01Then use the rest of the mediation brief to explain
- 45:04to the mediator what happened. and the personalities
- 45:09that are going to be present and what has prevented
- 45:13the parties from reaching a resolution absent
- 45:15mediation. Those are the things that help the
- 45:18mediator help you reach a resolution. Now, if
- 45:21you're going to share your mediation brief or
- 45:24a portion of your mediation brief with your opposing
- 45:27side, which can be helpful, then the tone of
- 45:30your mediation brief can set the tone for mediation
- 45:33with the other party. You can use your mediation
- 45:36brief to explain away something that may be misunderstood
- 45:41or an inadvertent mistake and set the tone with
- 45:45the other party to try and explain your position
- 45:49without being adversarial. Right, so let's see.
- 45:57In high reputation risk cases, how do you balance
- 45:59zealous advocacy with the ethical risk of inadvertently
- 46:03disclosing sensitive information that could be
- 46:05leaked or misinterpreted? That is a difficult
- 46:11tightrope to walk. In mediation, you want to
- 46:17ask the mediators to re -emphasize at each time
- 46:21they go into each room that the information that's
- 46:24being disclosed is confidential. Now, council
- 46:27knows that, but parties who have not been in
- 46:31mediation before often forget that. And so that
- 46:34needs to be reiterated at every stage of the
- 46:37mediation so that the parties are constantly
- 46:40reminded that whatever is being said today cannot
- 46:42be used, weaponized, or posted later. Second
- 46:47of all, if you are producing paperwork to the
- 46:50other side that includes highly confidential
- 46:52information, keep track of whatever it is that
- 46:55you're giving to the mediator to share with the
- 46:57other side. Make sure you get all of your paper
- 47:00back. Now, I understand that the other side can
- 47:03take a picture, so it doesn't foreclose absolutely
- 47:07the disclosure. But if you're keeping track of
- 47:09the paper that's being disclosed, you can avoid
- 47:12the inadvertent disclosure later by someone who
- 47:17retains the piece of paper that has the information
- 47:19and later forgets that that was produced in mediation.
- 47:22So you have to be really vigilant in the disclosure,
- 47:27keeping track, and Also, making sure that the
- 47:30mediator reiterates repeatedly that the information,
- 47:34whatever is being disclosed, is confidential
- 47:36and cannot be used by either party outside of
- 47:39the confines of mediation. Are there any recurring
- 47:47ethical issues you see when lawyers negotiate
- 47:50non -disparagement or joint messaging provisions?
- 47:56I don't see it as reoccurring ethical when they
- 47:59do joint statements, but I do see ethical issues
- 48:04when people are zealously advocating on behalf
- 48:09of their clients. So there is a fine ethical
- 48:13line between being deceptive and doing puffery.
- 48:22So you need to be able to walk the fine line
- 48:26of being able to zealously advocate for your
- 48:30client and puffing when necessary to try and
- 48:33get the best settlement for your client versus
- 48:37being deceptive, excuse me, and not disclosing
- 48:41something that the other side doesn't know or
- 48:44has no reason to know but is in the knowledge
- 48:47of your client. Something that later will come
- 48:49up and cause the other party to undermine the
- 48:55settlement or to allege fraud. All right. So
- 49:04let's see. How do you approach a mediation where
- 49:07the narrative the client wants to preserve is
- 49:09factually inaccurate or self -serving and managing
- 49:12that narrative itself becomes a barrier to resolution?
- 49:16That's a great question. So I would do it in
- 49:19two ways. I would include, if your client insists
- 49:22on including its version of the narrative in
- 49:25your mediation brief, then do so. Put it in the
- 49:28mediation brief. I would caution that perhaps
- 49:31you don't share with the other side because that
- 49:33will set a bad tone for mediation if the other
- 49:37side gets a mediation brief that is inflammatory
- 49:41or contains facts that aren't true. But I understand
- 49:45your position in having to set forth the facts
- 49:47that your client wants to set forth, even if
- 49:50not true. My suggestion is have a confidential
- 49:54brief that you're just sending to the mediator
- 49:57that sets forth the facts as your client wants.
- 50:01I would subsequently also submit a further confidential
- 50:05statement to the mediator that explains the personalities
- 50:09and suggests the mediator that some of the facts
- 50:12are subject to interpretation. A good mediator
- 50:17will know the difference, and the good mediator
- 50:19will come to mediation, spend some time with
- 50:21your client, and ascertain the true fact by questioning
- 50:25your client in a non -aggressive manner to try
- 50:30and understand what the true facts are. The mediator
- 50:33can serve as the person who will question and
- 50:38put doubts in your client. facts so that your
- 50:42client can come and reach more certainty and
- 50:46reality with respect to the facts of the case.
- 51:02What do you see as the practical limits of enforceability
- 51:06when a remedy depends on cooperation of social
- 51:09media platforms or the dynamics of algorithmic
- 51:12spread? That's a great question. It is very difficult
- 51:18to come up with, to arrange for settlements that
- 51:24require social media platform compliance or to
- 51:30do something with their algorithm. And with that,
- 51:35I imagine you're talking about banning or shadow
- 51:37banning. It is very difficult, and we've had
- 51:41very little success in getting the platforms
- 51:44to do something simply because the party's settlement
- 51:47agreement requires it. The best thing I can suggest
- 51:52is to reach out to the platform by council ahead
- 51:56of time. You can subpoena their their rules and
- 52:01they have an internal set of rules or I think
- 52:07some of them call it dispute resolution and some
- 52:12of the platforms, I know that TikTok does not,
- 52:16but I know that some of the other social media
- 52:19platforms have something that they sent to council
- 52:22that will outline what it is that the parameters
- 52:25of what they will or will not agree to do. You
- 52:29can ask for that. It's important to reach out
- 52:32to the platform sometimes through general counsel
- 52:35and find out what are the limitations of what
- 52:38the platform will allow and has allowed in the
- 52:42past. And you can use that as kind of a guideline.
- 52:45Otherwise, it's kind of like shooting in the
- 52:47dark and hoping that the platform will agree
- 52:50to what the parties agree in settlement. And
- 52:54so that's why it's important that the parties
- 52:56try and agree to things that are within their
- 52:59within their rights and abilities outside of
- 53:04the social network platform itself. All right,
- 53:13so it looks a little bit kind of going backward
- 53:17in terms of emotion. What is your view on whether
- 53:21mediation risks becoming to data -driven and
- 53:24reputational cases? And how do you balance hard
- 53:27metrics with human impact, emotion, or apology
- 53:30dynamics? So I think I forgot the first part
- 53:35of the question, so I'll have you repeat that
- 53:37in a moment. But I think balancing of the metrics
- 53:41versus the reputational harm and the emotional
- 53:44harm that people feel is much easier in mediation
- 53:49than in any other forum. Mediation allows the
- 53:53parties to, for example, apologize. And I had
- 53:58a mediation where the apology went a long way
- 54:01in resolving the social media dispute. Mediation
- 54:06is the only forum that allows for that personal
- 54:09touch. Now, while you may spend a lot of time
- 54:12in separate rooms in mediation, A good mediator
- 54:15will know when it is appropriate to have the
- 54:18parties in the same room. A mediator can take
- 54:21the apology to the other side and say, are you
- 54:25open to this? Would you be willing to accept
- 54:27an apology, to hear an apology from the other
- 54:30side? Because that's important. I think diffusing
- 54:33of the emotional baggage that comes with litigation
- 54:36is important and can only be done in mediation.
- 54:40And that needs to be done before any of the metrics
- 54:42or anything else can really come into play. So
- 54:46I think that's an important part, and I'm glad
- 54:49that the audience is recognizing that. If you
- 54:53don't mind reading back the first part of that
- 54:55question so I can answer that. Yeah, it was.
- 54:57What is your view on whether mediation risk becoming
- 55:01too data driven and reputational cases? I don't
- 55:05think mediation is too data driven. In any of
- 55:09the cases, I think mediation primarily is about
- 55:14people and what they're feeling and the emotions.
- 55:17And then once we get past that stage, then we
- 55:21can drill down on the numbers and talk about
- 55:23the reputation on the meta data and how we address
- 55:26that reputational harm that's happened in the
- 55:28numbers. Like in social media, things are moving
- 55:32so quickly that the numbers often by the time
- 55:36you reached mediation and certainly by the time
- 55:39you reach arbitration or court have already become
- 55:43moot. And so it is the personal feeling and association
- 55:49that matters in both more at mediation than the
- 55:53metadata at this point. All right. And it looks
- 56:04like I have one last question here. How do you
- 56:08identify and correct for a power imbalance where
- 56:11one party is technologically sophisticated and
- 56:15the other is not, especially when digital literacy
- 56:20itself is part of the dispute. That is a more
- 56:25difficult bridge to cross. However, my suggestion
- 56:32is in anticipation of litigation, become As counsel
- 56:37and for your client, become as proficient as
- 56:40possible on the social media platform that's
- 56:42at issue or on whatever the technology is that
- 56:49is at issue. Become as proficient as you can.
- 56:52Use AI to learn about it, to learn about what
- 56:56can be done on the platform, what could have
- 56:58been done differently to avoid the dispute. And
- 57:01then at mediation, ask the mediator to have the
- 57:05other side help you understand the technological
- 57:11issues that you feel there is an imbalance or
- 57:15is becoming an impediment for you to reach a
- 57:19resolution or to reach a decision. There is nothing
- 57:22wrong with you asking the other side to educate
- 57:25you during mediation. But that's really the only
- 57:28forum where the other side has the ability and
- 57:31the opportunity to educate you without it being
- 57:35adversarial. All right, perfect. So that looks
- 57:42like that's our questions for today. Thank you
- 57:44so much, Ellie, for a fantastic presentation.
- 57:47And I'd also love to thank our audience for joining
- 57:49us this afternoon. Have a great day, everybody.
- 57:52Thank you.