Latest / Onramp Bitcoin Media / The Last Trade E044: Bitcoin Mining’s Next Epoch with Bob Burnett
Transcript
- 0:00Before we get into the episode, a quick reminder that this
- 0:02podcast is for informational and entertainment purposes only and
- 0:06nothing should be construed as investment or legal advice.
- 0:10If you are enjoying On RAMP media content, please like
- 0:13subscribe and share as it goes a long way in helping others find
- 0:17the signal through the noise. Now for a word from on RAMP.
- 0:20On RAMP is a Bitcoin asset management platform built on
- 0:23multi institution custody leveraging our partnership with
- 0:26Bit Go and their 10 plus year track record in securing assets
- 0:29and Coincover, the premier digital asset risk mitigation
- 0:32company on ramps. Multi institution custody is a
- 0:35segregated institutional grade vault requiring two of three
- 0:39institutions at any point in time to sign once a client's
- 0:43unique permissions have been met at on RAMP we understand that
- 0:47your Bitcoin journey is a multi generational pursuit catalyzed
- 0:50by the ideals of perseverance, aspiration and legacy.
- 0:54That's why we're proud to introduce on RAMP Heritage, a
- 0:57suite of private client services dedicated to ensuring your
- 1:00Bitcoin legacy is preserved and passed on, embodying the true
- 1:04essence of wealth that goes beyond mere numbers.
- 1:07If you would like to learn more, please schedule a consultation
- 1:10as we prepare for the Bitcoin having and the next wave of
- 1:13global adoption of this nascent and growing asset class.
- 1:16We are having all annual maintenance fees for clients
- 1:19that secure their wealth before the next Bitcoin epoch.
- 1:23What you're telling me is that music is about to stop and we're
- 1:27going to be left holding the biggest bag of odorous excrement
- 1:31ever assembled in the history of doctors 1974198792972000.
- 1:41And whatever we're going to call this, it's all just the same
- 1:43thing over and over. We can't help ourselves.
- 1:46I say when we sell. Hey, I.
- 1:51Say. When?
- 1:56We sell Woo. Gentlemen, Bob Burnett, welcome
- 1:59to the show. Thanks for having me.
- 2:02Great to see you guys. I'm a little I Rd. dogged it
- 2:07hard yesterday to and from Houston up at 5:00 AM, in the
- 2:10car by 5:45, Houston by 9, back in Austin by 7:15 at night.
- 2:17That one will take it out of you.
- 2:18We did me and Cam did that a few months ago and you go there in
- 2:20the morning and you get back. It's nice to be home, but it's
- 2:22also, it's just rough just being in a car for like 6 hours in the
- 2:27day and then meetings in between it.
- 2:29Was rough when it was energizing the empower.
- 2:32Yeah. Conference is good.
- 2:34I like these guys. Do you feel?
- 2:39Empowered. Yeah.
- 2:40I feel energized. It was good.
- 2:41I got to see Steve Barber. Whenever you get to see Steve
- 2:43Barber, it's a good day. Oh yeah, that's one of my
- 2:46favourites. You know what I always liked
- 2:48though? I miss it.
- 2:49When I was younger I I lived in Chicago and I had an hour and a
- 2:53half commute every each way, every day.
- 2:55I did that for seven years. It's a horrible way to live, by
- 2:58the way, Horrible way to live. But what I will say is it it
- 3:02really gave me a lot of time to think you know And so I I I
- 3:06always found the drive time to like to be good for mental
- 3:10clarity and and I don't do it very much anymore although I I
- 3:13live in Naples FL now and and much like between Houston and
- 3:18Austin you know it's it's roughly a similar distance from
- 3:21where I live to Miami and I have to go to Miami a lot for you
- 3:25know Bitcoin related stuff. And that that drive, there's a
- 3:29place called Alligator Alley in Florida, it connects the
- 3:32southern, you know the southern part, there's nothing there,
- 3:35right. So, so I always just kind of
- 3:37zone out and I have a lot of lot of mental clarity comes to me
- 3:42through Alligator Alley. And there a sound, Jesse.
- 3:46It's between Houston and Austin when you get to the ranch, the
- 3:50the stretch of Rd. that's just a bunch of ranches, hundreds of
- 3:54cattle, wildflowers blooming. It's a beautiful ride home.
- 3:58Yeah, and the Alligator Alley. They've got the alligator farms
- 4:01and and fan boat tours and stuff like that, huh?
- 4:05Oh, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah.
- 4:07Those I don't have. I have them right in my
- 4:09backyard, though. I have my.
- 4:10House you're not in Alligator. Yeah, well, I I'm still
- 4:15fascinated by them. When you when you get up close
- 4:19to an alligator, I mean there's something just kind of
- 4:21mesmerizing about it, 'cause they are just, you know, we have
- 4:25a couple. So I live, it's in a golf course
- 4:28community, but I have a lake right behind the house and we
- 4:31have several alligators living in there.
- 4:32One's about an 11 footer and whenever that bad boy comes out
- 4:37and he's kind of just takes command, he just lays on the
- 4:40bank and it's it's just awesome like the the the power of those
- 4:47things and. It's drastic.
- 4:50It reminds me of when I used when I used to live in
- 4:52Charleston, SC. We used to have Gators all
- 4:54throughout our development and we were bad kids.
- 4:56We used to go fishing. If we got bored fishing, we'd
- 4:59pull out the slingshot and shoot rocks at the Gators.
- 5:01It was bad. Just to irritate them up, yeah.
- 5:08You got to be glad that was a one way interaction there Marty.
- 5:12Well, you learn. You learn quick.
- 5:13You run in zig zags, Yeah, yeah. If the Gators come at you, they
- 5:17can't turn, so you gotta you just you get horizontal.
- 5:21It's the it's very Darwinian too, like, so you know, only
- 5:27only the quick and smart survive.
- 5:32That's a great segue into the topic of this conversation,
- 5:34which is mining only Only the quick and smart survive.
- 5:39You know what? That that is great.
- 5:41That is a great segue. Yeah, that is a great segue I
- 5:45think. Yeah, building on where I came
- 5:47from yesterday, the Empower conference thrown by digital
- 5:49outcatters who are doing really cool things in the energy sector
- 5:53and they're attuned to what's going on in Bitcoin mining.
- 5:55So they throw this conference annually.
- 5:57I think this was the 3rd annual Empower conference trying to get
- 6:00the energy sector and the Bitcoin mining sector together
- 6:03to cross pollinate some ideas and give updates on where
- 6:07everybody is. And I think I was only there for
- 6:10one day out of the two day conference yesterday.
- 6:12And I think that was one of the the larger themes is that we're
- 6:17heading into a new paradigm for the mining industry,
- 6:21particularly the publicly traded miners where historically
- 6:25they've been able to raise money by ASICS announced PRS that they
- 6:31have more ASICS that are going to grow their hash rate and
- 6:34their stock price has appreciated from that.
- 6:36It seems that now that the market has other options and the
- 6:40equity in the equities markets to get proxy Bitcoin exposure
- 6:45that that strategy is probably not going to be as successful as
- 6:49it has been in the past. Especially when you consider how
- 6:52competitive the market's gotten. That we have another halving on
- 6:55the way. And that equity analysts are
- 6:59becoming more Privy to the actual economics of of mining
- 7:02operations and the fact that just raising money, buying ASIC
- 7:07futures orders and announcing that may not be the best
- 7:10strategy from from a profitability standpoint.
- 7:13So with that in mind, Bob, what are your thoughts on, on where
- 7:19we are now in the mining sector, particularly for the publicly
- 7:22traded miners? Yeah.
- 7:24Well, to your point Marty, I think all you have to do is look
- 7:29back at the last handful of years and you look at the big,
- 7:33the financial performance of the bigger companies, you know Riot,
- 7:37Marathon, Clean Spark, that class of minor.
- 7:42And what you'll just see is all these companies bleeding red
- 7:46year after year, but they even in the best time.
- 7:49So if you look at like 2021 which should have been just an
- 7:56absolute bonanza, you still see red in terms of operating
- 8:00profit. And you know, as you said, I
- 8:02think it was it was a game of leveraging access to cat capital
- 8:09for them and then getting this insane market reaction to any
- 8:16news that they put out because they were acting somewhat as a a
- 8:21proxy for Bitcoin for those who who maybe couldn't get in in
- 8:27other ways. And the EF TS changed that.
- 8:29So I think this focus to like hey businesses are are are meant
- 8:34to make money whether you measure that in Fiat or you
- 8:36measure that in Bitcoin, they they have to do something
- 8:39positive and they haven't been doing something positive.
- 8:43And I think part of that is we were, we were kind of joking,
- 8:46we're talking about being fast and smart.
- 8:48Well, I remember going back in that time period because my, my
- 8:53company Barefoot Mining, we've been doing this since 2017 and I
- 8:56remember having that that philosophical discussion with
- 9:04myself and some members of my team and some of my close
- 9:07friends like you know should we consider going public.
- 9:09And for those of you who don't know my background, I was at
- 9:13Gateway, the personal computer company.
- 9:15I was the Chief Technology Officer there and I helped take
- 9:19Gateway public. You know we became a Fortune 200
- 9:22company. And so I know what it's like to
- 9:25sit in the C-Suite of a of a big public company and I just
- 9:30personally didn't want to do that anymore.
- 9:32It's a terrible place to be and it incites or incense behaviors
- 9:44that I don't think you can get away from that force you into
- 9:48this high time preference mode of operation that goes
- 9:55completely against the ethos of Bitcoin, right?
- 10:00You know, so, and you might say it might be easy for an
- 10:03individual to say that no, they're real bitcoiners, they're
- 10:08Bitcoin, Maxi, whatever. But the truth of the matter is
- 10:11they signed in blood to adhere to a different ethos, which is
- 10:16they have to serve their shareholders and they get very
- 10:19beholden to 90 daytime cycles and what analysts think and not
- 10:24what's. And that was really best for for
- 10:26the long term of their company or the long term of Bitcoin.
- 10:30And I kind of operate from the ethos like, hey, I'll I'll do
- 10:34what's best for Bitcoin in the long run in the belief that it
- 10:40ultimately comes back to me. So you know, we talk about a
- 10:44lot, a lot about economic incentives in Bitcoin and how it
- 10:47has those, but I think the the time horizon is also part of it.
- 10:51So you know I do what I think is best for the long run and I'm
- 10:55willing to forgo the short run for the long run.
- 10:57And that's true for me and it's true for the company.
- 11:03But this thing about being fast and smart, I I think the the big
- 11:07miners also have a problem. And and the problem is that if
- 11:15if we were going to go put up a new site and say we had our, we
- 11:17had our choice of doing 1100 MW site, are we going to try to do
- 11:23let's say 52 MW sites? Most people would say, well
- 11:28let's just go about build the 100 MW site, the one site more
- 11:34efficient, you know, blah blah blah.
- 11:36But doing so means you're probably looking at maybe a 12
- 11:44to 18 month horizon to get something like that done
- 11:46between, you know, finding the energy, raising the capital, all
- 11:49the all the approvals, acquiring all the the Transformers and the
- 11:55servers and all that other stuff that that's a lot to put
- 11:58together. And so you raise all this money
- 12:03and then the return on the money doesn't come for a long time and
- 12:09the Bitcoin world can change dramatically over that time
- 12:12period. So what I'm about for, for
- 12:16barefoot is we decided that doing small things quickly is a
- 12:20much better approach than trying to do big things slowly.
- 12:25And so, you know, we're we're all about like, hey, if we find
- 12:29an advantageous energy situation and it's 300 kilowatts, bam,
- 12:33we'll go do it. You know, 'cause we probably can
- 12:35do it in a matter of weeks. If it's a MW or two megawatts
- 12:38like that's our sweet spot like do do do small things quickly
- 12:44where we can get money into play.
- 12:47We can start generating Bitcoin quickly for the investors.
- 12:50We start creating returns quickly and by the way we are
- 12:54forced to be cash flow positive and profitable almost from the
- 12:58beginning. By definition, because we don't
- 13:00have the, we don't have the big bags from an IPO or or or a new
- 13:07stock issuance or something like that.
- 13:10That's really. Just to jump in, like Bob and I
- 13:15were catching up early in the week and he was telling me the
- 13:17story and I was like, hey, I think we knew it.
- 13:19We had the luxury by not being close to mining but being close
- 13:22to you and the gigas of the world and understanding this
- 13:25natural order of congruence with with everything is you have to
- 13:29generate cash flow, you have to have a natural order of growth
- 13:33from a first principles perspective.
- 13:35And Bob, you made the point of it's from a long term Bitcoin
- 13:40like altruistic. And I think a lot of people
- 13:42align with that in the sense of if you do good in the space, it
- 13:44comes back to you. But then it's also from like a
- 13:46first principles to get to that other side, you have to be
- 13:49thinking in the short order of like how do you do good for for
- 13:52yourself as well. And Bitcoin in the sense of you
- 13:54have to produce value at a lower cost in the markets returning it
- 13:58to you so you can stay around. And so then I think there's
- 14:02something to, and I'm glad you talked about the gateway
- 14:05background and seeing that because that alludes or
- 14:08signifies you. You know it was looking at your
- 14:11LinkedIn, I think 1991 to 2004 like there's a lot of learnings
- 14:14from the, the the older markets and traditional tech and the
- 14:17growth that was seen there that I think you're bringing to what
- 14:20you're explaining because what you're describing doesn't get
- 14:22told to the general pop populace of the market from a larger
- 14:26perspective. And just like that, they're not
- 14:28naturally organic fundamental driven businesses on the large
- 14:32scale miners. And so I think there's a lot of
- 14:34your background that you're bringing to this that is
- 14:36important to discuss. And also just like from people
- 14:39building, whether it's minors or just like anything financial
- 14:41services custody, it's like this notion of you got to kind of
- 14:44produce value at a lower cost in the market.
- 14:46We'll give you because of that, that cost of capital changes,
- 14:49we've seen it change. If you're caught offsides, that
- 14:53liquidity dries up and now you're looking at effectively
- 14:56unit economics that don't make sense.
- 14:57And this is like the tail of the past 20 years when you look at
- 14:59we work all the way down. Yep.
- 15:04Yeah. And I think the small scale,
- 15:09quick deployment approach, I think it's becoming very
- 15:13apparent in the Bitcoin mining world that not maybe it's not
- 15:16very apparent. It's apparent to me at least
- 15:17that this is advantageous because when you think about it,
- 15:20when you deploy the capital, whether that's the get a six or
- 15:23get infrastructure, that's when the clock starts ticking on the
- 15:26opportunity costs 'cause you could deploy that capital into
- 15:29Bitcoin directly. And when that talk, that clock's
- 15:32ticking at the price is going up.
- 15:34If difficulties going up, if hash rate's going up, you are
- 15:36missing out on the the opportunity cost is increasing
- 15:41throughout that time. So the the name of the game is
- 15:44to shorten the amount of time between that capital being
- 15:46deployed and those ASICS being up and hashing.
- 15:51Absolutely, absolutely 'cause you guys all well know, but you
- 15:55know comparing what I can mine today versus what I can mine six
- 16:01months from now, almost by definition today is more
- 16:05valuable than the day six months from now, right.
- 16:08So like we use typically a four year cycle in our models as
- 16:14we're looking at it, but we also.
- 16:16So in other words if we're if we're doing a new site and we
- 16:19basically always believe in investing in new technology.
- 16:24So you know like over the last six months or so everything we
- 16:29bought has been an S19K Pro, I'll use the bit main models,
- 16:34but an S19K Pro or better like up to S 21200, it's like you
- 16:42know everything's been in that range.
- 16:44We don't, we don't you know and we're expecting three to five
- 16:48years of operation out of those machines and then you know with
- 16:53the expectation of about four. But the best day is the first
- 16:59day we turn it on typically, right.
- 17:01So that's the most profitable day and certainly dealing with
- 17:05the having that's been a big rush to get in front of in front
- 17:08of the having you know the the other thing about small too that
- 17:13I that I didn't mention is I think a lot of people probably
- 17:18perceive that only only people doing big things can get the
- 17:26great deals on energy you're talking about empower and you
- 17:29know all that and obviously the energy the relationship between
- 17:32the energy sector and and the Bitcoin miners is very
- 17:35important. But there are a lot of small
- 17:38opportunities out there that I understand that Riot or Marathon
- 17:42probably wouldn't even think about.
- 17:45But like I'll give you an example.
- 17:47I've talked about this one publicly before is our home base
- 17:51is in South Dakota. We know that area really well.
- 17:54About a year and a half ago, we were aware of a company leaving
- 18:01a building in an industrial park and it was a, it was a building
- 18:06that had a lot of refrigeration in it.
- 18:09So a new company moved in and then the new company ironically
- 18:14was a burrito company. So they were making burritos,
- 18:18the ones that you get like in 7-11 like that you throw in the
- 18:21microwave, right. They they the guys that make
- 18:23those. So we we suspected that they
- 18:29were going to use less power than the previous tenant.
- 18:32And so we went and talked to the landlord and it was true talked
- 18:35to the landlord and the burrito guys and they had about two 2.2
- 18:40megawatts of excess power there. So he said, hey, how how about
- 18:46we drop a couple containers on the backside of your building?
- 18:50You won't even know they're there.
- 18:53And you know this is by the way energy in the, we'll just say 4
- 19:00cent range, right? So decent, decent price per kWh
- 19:06and you know we were able to to work that deal.
- 19:10We've been mining there for a a year and a half and nobody knows
- 19:15we're there. We're we're adding value kind of
- 19:18to the industrial park and that that local area and it's it's
- 19:24probably something that most all the big mining companies would
- 19:29just ignore that sort of thing, right.
- 19:30But for us that's almost the ideal thing.
- 19:34We go in, we deploy quick, quickly, no one really even
- 19:37knows we're there. I don't know if you've ever
- 19:40heard me talk about what I call horse class sites, but that's
- 19:44what I I call those are kind of these small to medium sized
- 19:46commercial sites, horse class sites, because they're they're
- 19:53they're still big and powerful but we're still mobile.
- 19:57Like if there's ever a problem, we can get it up and go without
- 20:01without too much trouble. Versus an elephant site, which
- 20:04is what I would call a you know, a A50, a hundred.
- 20:09Several 100 MW site, you know they're big and powerful but
- 20:12they take forever to to grow and they're they're also easy to
- 20:16hunt. And you know I I think that when
- 20:20you look at like the the Biden tax proposal which which came
- 20:23back if if I assume you guys are aware of that in the 2025 budget
- 20:27they're trying to put that that 30% tax in.
- 20:30You know you're very exposed to you know community activism eco
- 20:38eco activism and terrorism. There's a lot of different
- 20:41vectors I think, upon which those, those bigger sites are
- 20:44going to have to fend and protect themselves that the
- 20:48smaller guys won't have to worry about.
- 20:52Yeah. The energy arbitrage opportunity
- 20:56that is out there, if you're willing to do it, because I
- 20:59think that's the problem that the elephant sites don't want to
- 21:03solve, is it's really a logistics problem because that's
- 21:06what my personal miners are in a hash Hut on a stranded natural
- 21:10gas well that's producing like 21 MCFD, it's a 600 kilowatt
- 21:16hash Hut or 300 kilowatt hash Hut.
- 21:18It's even smaller and it just sits in the middle of Appalachia
- 21:22mining Bitcoin using generator, using a generator that's
- 21:27converting the natural gas to electricity.
- 21:30And we simply like that is one example of an opportunity where
- 21:35there's hundreds of thousands of stranded natural gas wells out
- 21:37there and there's people that have liabilities on these wells
- 21:43where they need to maintain them.
- 21:44And if they don't maintain them, they get dinged by the EPA.
- 21:47So we're able to come in and say, hey, we'll maintain our
- 21:49well for you if you just let us use the gas for free.
- 21:51Maybe we'll pay your land lease for the year which is very cheap
- 21:54and and is very low cost energy and allows us to mine and a
- 22:00small scale in a remote area. But if you were trying to scale
- 22:05that operation up, it's just a logistics problem.
- 22:07How can you if you're doing many of those types of operations?
- 22:11It just comes down to how can you maintain all the generators
- 22:14and work the geographic distribution of your of your
- 22:18operations. Yeah, that that's that's the
- 22:22downside I should say the downside, but that's the that's
- 22:26the trade off. The trade off, yeah that's the
- 22:29probably the right way to do it. And by the way we're we're
- 22:31looking you know right now I've got a deal I think we're very
- 22:34close to initiating in Pennsylvania about an hour and a
- 22:39half out of Pittsburgh doing the same thing.
- 22:41It's about 600 kilowatt project. We'll throw a couple upstream
- 22:48hash huts with the, with the, with the, with the generators
- 22:53and you know off we'll go and you know we're looking at
- 22:57something a little bigger in Alberta right now too that's a
- 23:00couple megawatts. And as I said there, there are
- 23:03thousands and thousands and thousands and I think to a
- 23:06certain degree it's a lot easier like for instance Ryan was was a
- 23:11a public thing this week. They they were.
- 23:14They were I don't forgot the name of the county but you know
- 23:16they were trying to do a bigger project and got rejected by the
- 23:21the county commissioners and they had had a lot of pushback
- 23:23from the local community and I don't know where they'll go from
- 23:27there. Maybe they can overcome it.
- 23:28I certainly I'm not wishing I'll on anybody but those are those
- 23:32are hard problems right. You know when you keep trying to
- 23:35build these elephants and and now the miners you know for for
- 23:42the last couple years I think we were pretty much the only game
- 23:46in town out searching for big energy.
- 23:50Well now like we're we're running into it like even in
- 23:55South Dakota right now we're talking to this is on our on
- 23:58grid side we're talking to the energy company that we work with
- 24:01a lot mid American energy and you know they're seeing massive
- 24:07massive requests from the AI community for for you know
- 24:15double digit to several 100 MW requests but they don't have by
- 24:21the way they they're they don't have that laying around but now
- 24:25the now the Bitcoin community is going to have to fight the AI
- 24:28folks and also probably all the EV charging stations and all
- 24:32that there's going to be a lot of competition for this energy.
- 24:36So I think only the we would go back to that.
- 24:39You know, if you're if you're fast and you're smart then, and
- 24:43you're willing to do these small ones, then then I think you'll
- 24:48still find plenty of places to be successful, but it's going to
- 24:51be harder and harder to chase the big ones.
- 24:57It's it's interesting to me that, well, first of all, Marty,
- 25:01I love that somehow the way you framed what you were talking,
- 25:04you know, your Hut and Appalachia just sort of reminded
- 25:07me that like, we've done this before.
- 25:08This is, this is like moonshiners with copper stills
- 25:12in wherever they're wherever. It makes sense to have a small
- 25:15time operation. Like there's a model for this
- 25:18that has worked in the past. Granted it was for different
- 25:20reasons, but it's kind of funny to think about and and Bob as
- 25:24you're talking about like the you know the advantages of small
- 25:27scale versus just going like the monolithic route.
- 25:31I was thinking, I was trying to think about like what are the
- 25:35the IT seems to me that that mining will ultimately is
- 25:40ultimately A barbell sort of outcome where you have just pure
- 25:44economies of scale on on the large scale side, the monolithic
- 25:48riots of the world. But then there's also advantages
- 25:53or or reasons why someone might do very small scale mining and
- 25:57small to medium scale mining. Whether that's somebody who's
- 26:01set up like a, you know a couple miners in their in their garage
- 26:06either for ideological purposes because they want to contribute
- 26:10or because they're going to heat their home with it.
- 26:13And and so the heating applications in particular I
- 26:16think are very exciting on on that other end of the the
- 26:19barbell, the smaller scale because you can when you're
- 26:24adding the the economics of you know getting two birds for one
- 26:28stone of being able to heat something like you know growing
- 26:31flowers in a in a greenhouse or something like that while also
- 26:35mining Bitcoin in in getting that use out of the same energy.
- 26:41That makes it possible for the economics to make sense on the
- 26:44small side when in any other industry like larger wins out
- 26:49because of economies of scale and there's no sort of two
- 26:52birds, one stone phenomenon that's possible.
- 26:55I guess first of all, do you see that as as one of the advantages
- 26:58for smaller scale mining? Do you guys think about or or
- 27:02will you start thinking about how to you know get a heating
- 27:06applications out of your installations as well or maybe
- 27:09it just doesn't make sense? And then are there any other
- 27:13advantages that you see to small scale mining that make it so
- 27:17that you know the barbell will happen?
- 27:211st, in terms of the multi use, yeah, I think that'll be very,
- 27:28very important and very, very common.
- 27:31I think in this next cycle it will become a lot more common
- 27:36certainly. But I think by the end of this
- 27:37one and we start looking at the next having right that that that
- 27:43those the market will drive some of those efficiencies.
- 27:47We've done a little of it already.
- 27:48For instance we have we worked with a a greenhouse in Northern
- 27:53Florida, a commercial grower and what we did is we we worked with
- 28:00him because he has he's just far enough N where he needs on
- 28:07occasion either heat or dry air and and So what we did is we
- 28:16worked with him. We've got some what we talked
- 28:20about Steve, I don't think maybe that was before I started, but
- 28:22Steve Barber, you know we had a, we've got some of his black
- 28:26boxes scattered around the outside of this guy's greenhouse
- 28:33and then he has the choice of you know either venting them
- 28:36into the atmosphere or venting them into the greenhouse
- 28:40depending on his condition. And so he's mining all the time.
- 28:43He's got a little little bit of solar and a little bit of on
- 28:46grid and kind of mixes those together to create the energy
- 28:50and then we vent in. So you know the economics of
- 28:54running there even though in that case the on grid parts a
- 28:57little bit more expensive than you'd normally see.
- 29:00He doesn't view it that way, right.
- 29:02He's, he's growing flowers. I think he's the biggest
- 29:05provider of poinsettias like French with Easter coming up,
- 29:09biggest provider of poinsettias to like Target and Publix and
- 29:14things like that. And so if you see one of those
- 29:16in a Target, there's probably a little bit of Bitcoin in that
- 29:20poinsettia, right, because because of that a little.
- 29:25Bit of Bitcoin error. Yeah, yeah, help make that
- 29:28poinsettia happen. And I I think those are, that's
- 29:30a cool little story, right? But you know we're you know
- 29:34we've talked to people and and we'll see if these come
- 29:37together. The guy that we're we're
- 29:38potentially working on the stranded gas up in Alberta with
- 29:42is also a grower he he grows a lot of the Peppers and tomatoes
- 29:47and things like that for a lot of the grocery stores in in
- 29:50Canada. But you know there are people
- 29:52like car washes in northern climates the the using mining to
- 30:04warm the the water you know inside the car washes before you
- 30:11know at at the start of the car wash cement water.
- 30:16I I don't know a lot about cement but you know I've talked
- 30:18to some people said yeah we need, we need warm water as part
- 30:22of the cement mixing process. So these sort of things are like
- 30:27coming to the forefront and like things I haven't been involved
- 30:31with in the past, but are pretty cool, right?
- 30:33I think I think the topic of a lot of this for individuals, and
- 30:36I'd personally never been too like fascinating because it's
- 30:38such a whole rabbit hole in itself as the mining is just a
- 30:41decentralized component of it, right?
- 30:43I think like this Nate, this similar Riot reminds me of
- 30:47almost like a Coinbase in the world.
- 30:49It's like a huge target for a lot of reasons and that are also
- 30:53not naturally organic whether it's Coinbase because of SVB and
- 30:56the banking situation or however they got to their size that
- 30:59eventually they'll start to look at themselves and like man, I
- 31:02don't really like being this big for a number of reasons similar
- 31:05to Bob what you just described whether it's via the target on
- 31:09the back from the tax perspective, government
- 31:11perspective, drone attacks, whatever it is, it's just a a
- 31:15not natural organic way. I think long term we'll look
- 31:18back similar to custody and and minors that are this size and
- 31:23scale and probably wouldn't, won't make sense.
- 31:26And just purely from a Bitcoin perspective and the
- 31:28decentralized component of hash rate being further out onto the
- 31:32edges is healthier for the industry.
- 31:36And like kind of on that thread, Bob, what's fascinating, I'm
- 31:40curious that I have no idea is like your background seeing the
- 31:44tech boom and growing gateway. Do you see any similarities or
- 31:47things that have either helped you, like as you navigate this
- 31:50whole field, like not just mining, but just Bitcoin in
- 31:52general and the maturation of the industry?
- 31:56So I'm just always fascinated with how, like, I think what
- 31:58happened in the 90s is there's similar corollaries to what
- 32:01we're seeing here and we can learn from them and kind of not
- 32:04either make the same mistakes or actually like, you know, expand
- 32:07on what the first versions of things were built in the early
- 32:1090s. And I think there's just like a
- 32:13lot to learn from. There's a book called EE Boys
- 32:16that talks a lot about the very first iterations of technology
- 32:20companies that you can kind of see if you squint like similar
- 32:23concepts that have happened here in Bitcoin.
- 32:25I'm curious if you thought about it in that way.
- 32:28Yeah, absolutely. The first thing that comes to
- 32:32mind is the cyclic nature and how companies respond to the
- 32:37cycles. So little little history.
- 32:42So in the PC market, if you go back to let's say the the the
- 32:47early 90s, we could kind of as an industry see that this thing
- 32:57was about to skyrocket. You know the, the exponential
- 33:00part of the curve was starting to lift.
- 33:03You could just feel it, right. So what happened though was it
- 33:09ended up being the point where a whole bunch of PC companies got
- 33:12wrecked. Why did they get wrecked?
- 33:16Well, they got wrecked because let's just say as an example, I
- 33:20don't, I don't have the exact number, but it's something like
- 33:22this previous year, let's say it was 199470 million PCs were sold
- 33:31globally and the next year we're expecting 90 million.
- 33:38And now if you look at the, the a lot of the major companies in
- 33:44the world, they all saw that we we all had a good feel that this
- 33:49was going to happen. But almost every company
- 33:53perceived that not only would the industry grow, but that
- 33:56their market share would also grow.
- 33:59So they start sending signals into the supply base that
- 34:07they're going to, they're they're they're ordering memory
- 34:10and hard drives and CPUs and these things like that which
- 34:13have fairly long lead times not unlike you know buying a new bit
- 34:17my machine or something like that in scale, right, that hey,
- 34:21I was, I was 8% of 70 million but now I'm going to be 10% of
- 34:2690, right. But this is happening almost at
- 34:31every single company, every company deciding they're going
- 34:34to grow 1234 percent market share on a on 20% growth.
- 34:39Well, what ends up happening is the the supply base sees signals
- 34:47actually more for like 100 million and of course maybe we
- 34:52get to the the 90 million but but we don't get to 100.
- 34:59And so this massive saturation of supply came in and a lot of
- 35:05companies even in this bull run got wrecked because they were
- 35:12stuck with this massively overvalued industry.
- 35:15It's very similar if you think about, you know, what happened
- 35:19to our world. Well, in our world the
- 35:26especially the public, public miners especially filled with
- 35:29all of this cash from the the public markets went and way
- 35:34overbought the supply and they got wrecked at core, core
- 35:40actually literally going bankrupt and a few others going
- 35:43bankrupt, you know, through the same thing.
- 35:46So it's funny, but I've had this talk with my my team.
- 35:50One of the things I've said is we have to be very careful once
- 35:57the bull run really starts, once investors start contacting us
- 36:05and try start trying to throw money at us, that might be the
- 36:09point when we have to pull back a little bit.
- 36:11We have to really watch the price of the mining equipment
- 36:16and make sure that we don't get caught up in it and start
- 36:19chasing high prices. We may have to, In other words,
- 36:23we may have to pause and just write out what we have at the
- 36:28point that the market seems the best counterintuitive.
- 36:33But it's another reason it's hard, I think, for the public
- 36:35guys because they're getting shareholder pressure and analyst
- 36:41pressure if they're not expanding in the middle of the
- 36:44bull run, which is actually probably the worst time to be
- 36:50really expanding. It's so profound.
- 36:53It's because it's a tail all the time.
- 36:54Liquidity drowns companies and I think about it like which you
- 36:58just mentioned in a similar vein is almost like Lightning
- 37:02companies and that there's something there.
- 37:04But then when the market takes off, if you take on too much
- 37:06money or you deploy too much in the Lightning, it's like is the
- 37:09infrastructure or is it really ready for adoption.
- 37:12So you take that money, you hire the people and then you look
- 37:14around, you're like, wait, I don't know if the market was
- 37:15ready to start using this yet. How do we figure it out versus
- 37:18like the slow and steady and staying around owning more of
- 37:22your company? And that's just one example.
- 37:23I think you know, AI is another application, but like these
- 37:25cycles continue. Like railroads was a good
- 37:27example of it, right? They've laid a bunch of tracks,
- 37:30didn't know what they were going to use.
- 37:31And then the infrastructure gets picked up by the second and
- 37:33third people through the door that it's already been laid and
- 37:35now you can see all the best practices.
- 37:37And really fascinating. That's exactly what happened
- 37:40last cycle. I mean he I mean in the peak of
- 37:432021 bull madness I think a six were selling for $140.00 a
- 37:48terahash. At their peak they fell all the
- 37:51way to $12.00 a terahash over the course of the preceding 2
- 37:56years. And the other like Bob the other
- 37:59comment like these publicly traded miners are pressured to
- 38:03expand at the top of the bull market.
- 38:04If they're not doing that, the analyst sting them and then on
- 38:06top of that when it would be advantageous for them to lock in
- 38:10some profits on the Bitcoin treasury, maybe sell some to to
- 38:13bolster their cash balances, They can't do that either and
- 38:16like Core is a perfect example, They had I think 30,000 Bitcoin
- 38:19and they were forced to liquidate half of it at 25,000
- 38:23or 21,000 instead of tipping off half of that at 6065 and.
- 38:30It's fascinating. 'Cause it's in the.
- 38:31Bob, the pain and that we're saying they're completely like
- 38:35controversial or not said. And they're so rooted in
- 38:37pragmatism and prudence that it's that's how far we've gotten
- 38:40away from, like, fundamentals. Yeah, I think some people don't
- 38:45want to hear it. I think, you know and you know
- 38:49one of the things I say is like, hey, you know, one of the
- 38:52beauties of Bitcoin is it's free, right?
- 38:54And it's, it's a freedom based thing.
- 38:57So if you want to own stock in a public miner, then own stock in
- 39:01a public miner, that's that's not for me to say, but I will
- 39:05say this, you know, ask your, if you're a bitcoiner, ask yourself
- 39:09whether or not they are a net positive or negative for the
- 39:16ecosystem as a whole. You make your own decision.
- 39:18I have, I have my opinion, you make your decision.
- 39:21But Core, like Core is a great example and I've done a little
- 39:25bit on this. But you know the highlights of
- 39:27Core are they went public in January of 2022, they raised
- 39:33$200 million, 11 and and as they went public they were, they were
- 39:40essentially the biggest miner in the world.
- 39:42Eleven months later they were bankrupt with a billion, almost
- 39:47a billion and 1/2 in debt. So you know that that's probably
- 39:54the like the gross, I mean that exemplifies probably just the
- 40:02the gross mismanagement and and gross I I don't even know what
- 40:07to call it like it, it's just so catastrophic.
- 40:11But it it also tells us that you were asking Mike about the like
- 40:17lessons. Well, in the early 90s there
- 40:21were probably 150 legitimate personal computer companies.
- 40:26As we as we left and went into the next decade, there were only
- 40:30like 6 that mattered, like the and and they weren't even, some
- 40:35of them weren't even the ones that started like.
- 40:37So again, I don't wish it all on anybody.
- 40:42I don't want to come off that way, but don't be shocked if
- 40:48Riot or Marathon or Clean Spark or, you know, pick your big one.
- 40:53Some of those or many of them don't exist a couple years from
- 40:56now. Don't be shocked because that's
- 41:00true in like almost any market like this.
- 41:03That's technology driven that requires very a lot of
- 41:10nimbleness. It requires, you know, continual
- 41:12improvement, like those sort of things.
- 41:15Those industries turn over quickly and they become, it's
- 41:18very Darwinian. I'd be interested to get your
- 41:22perspective on this because it seems that it's becoming
- 41:25abundantly clear as time goes on and the competition within the
- 41:30mining industry becomes even more fierce, margins become more
- 41:33compressed, that vertical integration and optionality in
- 41:37terms of revenue stream becomes way more important for larger
- 41:41scale miners. And that's been the big question
- 41:44that's been thrown out there for many years.
- 41:46I remember we were talking about this at Great American Mining is
- 41:49what happens first. Do do miners become energy
- 41:51companies or do energy companies become miners?
- 41:54Because the end state of this is getting the mining operation to
- 41:59the lowest cost possible, and the only way to do that is to
- 42:01actually own and vertically integrate from the molecule to
- 42:06the hashes that you're sending to the pool.
- 42:10Yeah, I I, I agree with that make a comment on it and then
- 42:16I'll say one thing that I want to throw one caveat though to
- 42:20what you've said. And so I I what what I built for
- 42:25our company which I mean we're not massive.
- 42:28I mean we're we're, I guess we're we're big enough to not be
- 42:31small, but you know not big enough to be big right.
- 42:34We're kind of that way but but this vertical integration thing
- 42:37I think is is critical. So I've I've built something to
- 42:42call it the minor stack and it starts with energy as you said.
- 42:47The bottom part of the stack is like I want to as much as
- 42:49possible I want to own the energy access or at least have
- 42:53control of it, right. That that we're we're working
- 42:58toward trying to be self sovereign as well, not only to
- 43:02be efficient but also to be self sovereign so that we're not
- 43:05permissioned in anything that we do because that I think that's
- 43:09that's very important too. So like in our example, the one
- 43:13that I'll I'll talk about publicly, I've talked a little
- 43:15about some of the things we're trying to do with like stranded
- 43:17gas, but we own a hydro, a small hydroelectric facility in South
- 43:20Carolina that we rehabbed and we we actually cut the cord back to
- 43:26the grid. So we we don't even have the
- 43:31ability to push excess energy back to the grid and that was a
- 43:36choice that we made because we wanted that level of sovereignty
- 43:41and independence, right. It probably cost us a little bit
- 43:44of money at times when we produce more than we have hash
- 43:47for, but you know, so be it. So owning, owning that energy at
- 43:54a minimum being not permission. The second one is ASIC and by
- 43:59ASIC I mean the chip. And so I'm, I'll be talking more
- 44:05about this publicly, but I'm I'm on the board of advisors and I'm
- 44:08working closely with a group of ex Samsung and Intel people to
- 44:12design our own ASIC and you'll probably see that in 2025 and my
- 44:21background I I, I build systems, right that's that's really what
- 44:25I do like I starting in 1986 that's that's what I've done.
- 44:30I've designed laptops and desktops and servers.
- 44:32And so our intention is once we have access to our own chip to
- 44:36build our own systems both for our own consumption as well As
- 44:40for the general market, Then there's so this is kind of the
- 44:45stack, right, the energy, the ASIC, the system.
- 44:49Then there's kind of the operational excellence, you know
- 44:52can can you, can you manage it, keep high up times, keep the
- 44:57machines operating at the highest efficiency possible, all
- 45:01that sort of stuff. I think a lot of lot of quote UN
- 45:04quote mining companies which are really hashing companies, we'll
- 45:06talk about that later, but they that's really where their focus
- 45:11is. Then the next one is block
- 45:16template creation. And I guess this leads to that
- 45:19you are not a miner until you create a block template.
- 45:21And because if you're just a hasher, you're connecting to a
- 45:25pool that creates the template for you.
- 45:29You're not even connected to the network.
- 45:32You're you're a hired gun, basically selling your hash to
- 45:38the pool, right. And then the last part is the
- 45:41pool. And I'm on the board of
- 45:43Directors. There's an investor in Ocean in,
- 45:47in part because of all that, right.
- 45:49So there's these six pieces of the stack, and my intention is
- 45:53to have at least some ownership or control over each of the six
- 45:59pieces of the stack. Both because I think I can save
- 46:04money, but also I don't have to get.
- 46:07If I do it right, I don't have to get anybody's permission to
- 46:12to be a minor. But before Barty jumps like I
- 46:16really wanted him to, I wanted him to hear the part about like
- 46:19the block space template creation you referred to because
- 46:22he he was alluding to energy producers and miners.
- 46:26But our previous discussion was sharing on like how financial
- 46:29institutions start to compete and maybe starting with like
- 46:32block space getting scarcer sooner than most people think
- 46:34about. Sure.
- 46:37Yeah. So I think there's you alluded
- 46:41to it Marty, the the, there's this certainly relationship
- 46:46between the energy companies and the miners.
- 46:48I, I, I, I, I do not mean to make that insignificant and
- 46:54certainly like you were just at the Empower conference, I had
- 46:57one of my guys there. It's very, very important.
- 47:00However, there's a second end of so you're you're looking at that
- 47:03end. The bottom of the stack I just
- 47:05talked about, well the top of the stack is important too.
- 47:09So and it's it's that if we look at block space, block space is
- 47:19absolutely scarce in any time window.
- 47:23So if you, if you do the math right, what you'll find is that
- 47:26there are about 53,000 blocks per year.
- 47:30There's basically nothing we can ever do to change that.
- 47:35And so that's what we're going to produce and each one has four
- 47:39million weight units and if you translate that, it's about 4000
- 47:42transactions. So what that tells us is that
- 47:47the network at the base layer has about four or 200 million
- 47:51base layer resolutions and I don't believe some others
- 47:58believe it's slightly differently.
- 47:59I don't believe that that will materially change.
- 48:02I think if you go into you know whether it's CTV or some of
- 48:06these other things, I don't believe they materially change
- 48:09the transaction capability of the network.
- 48:14We're still stuck with the 4 million and I don't think they
- 48:17can actually strip the transaction size in a in a way
- 48:22that materially changes that output.
- 48:26So given that if we just use that 200 million a year number,
- 48:34I I believe those should be thought of as virtual real
- 48:37estate or a commodity. And that over the course of the
- 48:43next few years we're going to find that that is ungodly
- 48:49valuable, precious beyond belief and that there will be a massive
- 48:54fight for control over that. Right now block template
- 49:02creation is done at the pool level pretty much basically
- 49:07across the whole the whole world and six companies for Chinese
- 49:11companies you know which would include like and pool and F2
- 49:14pool plus Luxor and Foundry on the US side.
- 49:21Those six control roughly 90% of all blocked template creation.
- 49:25I think that's very dangerous and bad for the industry.
- 49:28And I I mentioned I'm an investor in Ocean and and on the
- 49:32board. So I don't want to turn this
- 49:33into a pitch for them because I want this in lots of pools.
- 49:37But what we're really about, I think we've gotten caught up in
- 49:41a lot of the ordinals debate and there's a reason for that.
- 49:46But what Ocean's really about is moving block template creation
- 49:49back to the minor. I would say moving that that's
- 49:52really the most important thing. And so I'll just use a simple
- 49:55example. If I if I create the block
- 49:59template, if I'm a minor and I create the block template and I
- 50:04own 1% of the world's hash rate, then I will make the choices on
- 50:112 million of the 200 million transactions annually.
- 50:16And that's a very, very powerful position.
- 50:22I believe that financial institutions Swan actually being
- 50:26at the front of the line right now who've who've come out of
- 50:28nowhere to have literally 1% of the world's global hash, I think
- 50:32are understanding this. I think they will be followed by
- 50:36the black rocks and fidelities and I know that's a cringe
- 50:39statement, but I believe they are all going to chase block
- 50:44template control and the only way to control block templates
- 50:48is by owning miners. And so I believe that those that
- 50:53sector is going to aggressively move into mining.
- 50:57They will and and I believe they will look at it when they really
- 51:03start thinking about it, they will realize it's existential to
- 51:07their existence that if they don't control the block
- 51:11template, they do not control the priority, they do not
- 51:16control the cost structure. And so it's my belief that we're
- 51:23going to, well we'll see certainly see some energy
- 51:25companies trying to merge and move in and associate with
- 51:29mining companies. But I think it's going to be the
- 51:31financial services companies that really come in fast and
- 51:35hard and start buying up the miners public and private.
- 51:40Thanks for tuning in. If you're interested in
- 51:43exploring any of these topics further, or want to learn more
- 51:45about how we can help you secure a new or existing Bitcoin
- 51:49allocation, get in touch with our team at on rampbitcoin.com.
- 51:53We look forward to supporting you on your Bitcoin journey.
- 51:57And one other because I talked about this at Empower yesterday.
- 52:00One other thing we need to figure out too.
- 52:01It's not only block template, because that's been the big meme
- 52:04with Stratum V2, it's like, oh, the individual miners will be
- 52:07able to construct their own block templates, which is good,
- 52:09which is a net positive. But even in that scenario is
- 52:13Stratum V2. If it were to be massively
- 52:16adopted and individual miners were able to construct their own
- 52:19blocks transactions, somebody needs to broadcast that
- 52:22transaction. In the stratum V2 world, the
- 52:25pool still has power over that broadcast.
- 52:26So you can give individual miners the ability to construct
- 52:31their own blocks by the end of the day.
- 52:32That could get audited by the by the pool that has to broadcast
- 52:38transaction and they can make a decision like actually I don't
- 52:41want to broadcast this because it has some transactions that I
- 52:45don't like in it. Of course that has economic
- 52:47repercussions, but that I think is like the the weak point of
- 52:51the stratum V2 model is the transaction broadcast.
- 52:55Then I'll top and just to build on what you said about the
- 52:59financial institutions before, I have to hop off here.
- 53:01But yeah, that is something that everybody should be wary of.
- 53:05And I wonder you can go back to like first principles of why
- 53:10these institutions exist in the 1st place.
- 53:12They're an immagulation of the Fiat world where people can't
- 53:16save their money, so they're forced to interact with the
- 53:20black rocks, the vanguards, all these financial institutions, so
- 53:23that they can beat inflation. I just like, is it a race to
- 53:30hyper bitcoinize as fast as possible to destroy their
- 53:33business models because you you don't need them.
- 53:36If people can save in Bitcoin so that we they don't have as much
- 53:40power in the long run, I don't know the answer but.
- 53:46It's certainly part of it and and I guess you know only time
- 53:50will tell, but it's very clear that within the Bitcoin world,
- 53:57right, we have companies like Swan that are public and now
- 54:01have over 1% of the world's hash is is with you know, I guess, I
- 54:06guess you could at least call them one of the good guys,
- 54:07right. And and I do know them well, I
- 54:10don't want to, I don't want to disclose anything that's not
- 54:15public. But I can say this like if
- 54:18you're Swan and part of your business model is that you let
- 54:24people buy Bitcoin and you encourage them to self custody
- 54:27and you offer that service for free in a world where Bitcoin
- 54:31fees become ungodly, then that model breaks, right.
- 54:38So you could look at it potentially as existential to
- 54:42them in the way that they do business to be able to control
- 54:45the block template. Because then they could
- 54:48theoretically look at it like, hey, for people that buy Bitcoin
- 54:52from us, we can offer the ability to move Bitcoin into
- 54:56self custody at a more modest fee.
- 55:00Because we, you know, we can control the blocks in which that
- 55:04happens, right, 'cause they'll control at 1% of the world's
- 55:06hash, they're gonna control 1 1/2 ish blocks per day.
- 55:11Right. Do you think that's why they
- 55:12they do it though? Because I would say that's a
- 55:14flawed assumption if that's why they're getting into mining like
- 55:18the fact that that if you were think forward thinking people
- 55:20are gonna take delivery of the Bitcoin from a scalable
- 55:22perspective like it's from a theory, it's.
- 55:25No, I I think it's it's just an example, yeah, that the, the
- 55:30power of that position is much greater.
- 55:34Well, one, I mean, I'm assuming they're doing it right, they're
- 55:38making money right now, right. So I mean we'll start with that.
- 55:42I think that's the number one reason.
- 55:43But it gives them, it gives them also the, the ability to control
- 55:53this block space in the long run.
- 55:55That would be, I gave you an example of I think a small, a
- 56:00small piece of the decision, but I do believe this and I think we
- 56:05talked about this a little privately, Michael, and and
- 56:08that's that if we look at the block reward right now, OK, so
- 56:15we sit here today 4 minors, the block reward is 6 and a quarter
- 56:20of subsidy plus fees. The last year, those fees have
- 56:25averaged right around .4, OK. So we're at like six, we'll call
- 56:33it 6/6, and 2/3 is the average reward.
- 56:38We're 23 days away from that changing to 3.125 plus most
- 56:46likely in the short term still the .4, right?
- 56:49So the having changed one part of the equation but not the
- 56:54other, it means that the minor revenue, the mining company's
- 57:01revenues go from what would that be maybe 6% of 7?
- 57:098. Percent the you know and and so
- 57:13so you have you basically have the fees doubling So what I'm
- 57:16gonna say will be controversial but it's I I have some models
- 57:22that I've developed I'm I'm probably wrong but I hopefully I
- 57:25I'm not wrong by any order of magnitude.
- 57:27I believe as we exit the next cycle and we're staring at the
- 57:30next halving, we will have reached parity.
- 57:34Interesting. So, so, so if I'm right or close
- 57:39to right, what does that mean? That means that interestingly,
- 57:44as measured in Bitcoin, we exit the next halving at almost the
- 57:51same rate we we we entered this one, right?
- 57:58So, so in other words, because we we'd be at over six, right?
- 58:01That would be over six Bitcoin per block.
- 58:06If I'm right, it also means that in the next in the cycle that
- 58:10follows, because the 3.125 would drop to 1.56.
- 58:17Two, what would that be? Whatever that is right now we're
- 58:21at 2/3, right? So now we'd go into the next
- 58:25cycle at 2/3 fees. OK, so, so let's think about
- 58:31what happens in that world. One ramification of that is that
- 58:40as measured in Bitcoin minor revenue starts getting much more
- 58:44variable. So today we basically have a
- 58:48very fixed Bitcoin output. OK, so there's really not when,
- 58:53when, when we're running our models when we're thinking about
- 58:56the future, we don't we don't have a lot of variance in the
- 59:00Bitcoin output. But but you know we could see
- 59:03great variance block to block or day-to-day in the future.
- 59:10Right now if you're, if you're if you're in a situation where
- 59:18your revenue starts having great variance, what do you do you
- 59:23want to moderate that sum, right.
- 59:27So I think that's going back to the blockspace thing that we
- 59:31were talking about. I think what that leads to is a
- 59:35futures marketplace for blockspace where the miners,
- 59:41let's say me again, will pretend I have 1% if I have 1% of the
- 59:46world's hash rate. I don't, by the way, I'm not
- 59:48that big, but if I had 1% of the world's hash rate and I have 200
- 59:52million transactions per year that that I will choose in my
- 59:58block templates, then that's like 180,000 a month.
- 1:00:04So think of me as a farmer now. So that's no different than
- 1:00:09maybe a farmer who produces. A certain amount of corn every
- 1:00:13month or something like that. Well, if if, if as I'm looking
- 1:00:18at sitting here in March and I'm looking at August, let's say,
- 1:00:26you know, would I be willing to sell 25% of my August output at
- 1:00:33a known price that is fair and profitable to me?
- 1:00:38Yes, I would to lock that in, right.
- 1:00:42So I think that's what's actually going to happen.
- 1:00:45And then the then there's a, there's a counterparty to that,
- 1:00:47the other side of that, which is the users of the block space.
- 1:00:52So if you were a company or potentially even an individual
- 1:00:56and you knew that in August you were going to have a lot of
- 1:00:59Unchained activity, would you like to just wait to see what
- 1:01:04the market offers you in August or would you like to lock in a
- 1:01:09known and fair price now I think for some percentage of the
- 1:01:12market they will want to do that.
- 1:01:14So and I'm I'm working on this by the way I I've mentioned
- 1:01:19mentioned this a few times before, but I'm working on that
- 1:01:21right now and we're going to, we're going to bring a futures
- 1:01:24marketplace for block space to market.
- 1:01:27It will happen this year and with with by the way all all
- 1:01:31contracts on the Lightning Network.
- 1:01:33So we're going to use the Lightning Network as the for the
- 1:01:39marketplace and for all the contracts.
- 1:01:42This makes, I'm glad Jesse's here hearing this because we had
- 1:01:45this conversation and I think there's gonna be a lot to
- 1:01:47discuss on this. But one thing Bob, I think it
- 1:01:50tracks, I think also the the idea of derivatives for it.
- 1:01:54Like I think generally it's been talked about from a hash rate
- 1:01:57perspective but not block space and block space makes a lot more
- 1:02:00sense. The one thing that so from the
- 1:02:04financial service perspective it's, it is to your point
- 1:02:08existential or their whole business model, our business
- 1:02:11model, anybody's business model. If you're moving around UTXOS,
- 1:02:14you have to pay those fees and so to get in the middle or
- 1:02:18figure that part out is important.
- 1:02:20The thing that I'm curious on how you make the leap, because I
- 1:02:23didn't think of it at the time, but now as you work through This
- 1:02:25is why would a financial service or institution get to make the
- 1:02:30leap from the block template simply from what would change
- 1:02:36now to then in the sense of like it's not their core competency
- 1:02:39and the bidding situation or how people they bid is effectively
- 1:02:45how they get, how we get UTX OS by paying the fees into the
- 1:02:49block. Why would it change in the
- 1:02:51future? Because everybody's competing
- 1:02:53for those UTX or competing for those fees.
- 1:02:57I'm I'm struggling to understand that leap and why the
- 1:03:00institutions would start to mine and do something that's not core
- 1:03:03to their business model from just like their competency, not
- 1:03:05execution around it. Does that make sense?
- 1:03:13Or not. I think I got your question.
- 1:03:14I'm I'm gonna try to answer it if I if I answer the wrong
- 1:03:16question let me know. But so if I'm, if I'm a
- 1:03:21financial, so, so if I'm a financial institution and I I
- 1:03:28want to, I want to make sure that all of my transactions are
- 1:03:40with a predictable time window and a predictable price, then I
- 1:03:50have two options. One is to own the mining
- 1:03:54operation or the 2nd is to own and participate in this
- 1:04:00derivative marketplace. OK.
- 1:04:02So if I'm a smaller guy, I'm probably going to pick the
- 1:04:08derivative marketplace. But if I'm a bigger guy, if I'm
- 1:04:14BlackRock or I'm Swan or I'm some some organization like
- 1:04:19that, I'm I, I believe we're going to see them wanting more
- 1:04:26absolute control over this. Now, I do want to point out
- 1:04:30something because some people might be afraid.
- 1:04:32What I view is that some people might say, well, are you going
- 1:04:36to disrupt the mem pool? Are you going to, you know, do?
- 1:04:39Is this going to make it harder to really see what's going on?
- 1:04:44And I've been vocal about it, like I think everything has to
- 1:04:47be transparent. We have to have transparency in
- 1:04:49all these things. Well, the more I thought about
- 1:04:53it and the reason, part of the reasons I support this is that
- 1:04:58today we know the present situation of the mempool and
- 1:05:04based on the transaction sitting in the mempool we can get a
- 1:05:08future look. But the future look is maybe
- 1:05:10hours, right? You can see hours ahead of what
- 1:05:13what might be out there. This is going to give us
- 1:05:16visibility days ahead and you know our our marketplace will
- 1:05:22make sure that that all the fees end up in the blocks and it's
- 1:05:29part of the Coinbase #1 and #2. You know that that it all is
- 1:05:34fully visible and you can separate those transactions that
- 1:05:38are part of the futures marketplace from those that are
- 1:05:40part of more the real time marketplace, which I got off of
- 1:05:44on a tangent there. I have no idea if I covered the
- 1:05:46question that you asked. No, it makes sense.
- 1:05:49I think that covers. It's like it's giving more
- 1:05:51control. At the end of the day, you still
- 1:05:52have the natural mechanism of the bed for block space via just
- 1:05:56fees, right, Like somebody will be able to because somebody's
- 1:05:59going to mind that that transaction if you pay a higher
- 1:06:02fee. So that's always exists no
- 1:06:04matter who, who who's out there. It's just that the financial
- 1:06:06institution, if they want better clarity or if they want to hedge
- 1:06:09out those fees, then they'll be able to participate in what
- 1:06:13you're describing just to have better clarity of their business
- 1:06:16model. Yeah.
- 1:06:19And you know and this part, this is the part that you know, I
- 1:06:28think we we probably all get a little uncomfortable with too is
- 1:06:31you know if if Black Rock goes and buys 10% of the world's
- 1:06:37mining capacity or control of it, they're going to control you
- 1:06:42know, 220,000,000 of the transactions annually.
- 1:06:48And you know what did they do with them?
- 1:06:52Are they, is it OFAC, is it You know, I mean there's a lot of
- 1:06:56that sort of stuff going on and you know we need, we need lots
- 1:07:00of pools. Like Marty, Marty talked about
- 1:07:02one issue which is you know could could you have situations
- 1:07:06where pools, even though you have a lot of hundreds or
- 1:07:11thousands of block template creators which we need, could
- 1:07:14you get in a situation where individual pools are enforcing
- 1:07:21OFAC compliance, rejecting block templates that are coming from
- 1:07:26theirs? I guess the only good thing
- 1:07:29would be that the there would at least be visibility to the miner
- 1:07:33that the pool was rejecting them and hopefully they could find
- 1:07:37another pool that they could work with that that wouldn't
- 1:07:41block them. I think we need pools in lots of
- 1:07:45jurisdictions around the world by the way I mean having having
- 1:07:49the top six be comprised of only US and China is not good.
- 1:07:54You know you know you know we've got what is the one there's one
- 1:08:01out of Japan in the top ten brains is obviously out of
- 1:08:05central Europe volcanoes trying to come up in El Salvador.
- 1:08:10But we need, we need these and you know I I think you know for
- 1:08:15those of us at Ocean, you know we, I'll just say we think about
- 1:08:19that a lot and making sure that you know we we keep a path so
- 1:08:25that that sort of stuff never happens to us too that you know.
- 1:08:30Yeah, we're it seems like there's a lot of, there's a lot
- 1:08:34of ambiguity and risks further out there.
- 1:08:36But I guess one of the things you you were pointing out Bob,
- 1:08:41that that actually gives me some comfort, gives me a fair bit of
- 1:08:46comfort is you walk through how the percentage of fees is
- 1:08:52growing relative to this block subsidy and and that's already
- 1:08:56happening and that will that that's pretty certain at this
- 1:09:00point like that we shift into a a fee a fee dominant incentive
- 1:09:07model for minors. It's already underway like and
- 1:09:15and that's good because you know one of the one of the classic
- 1:09:18FUD tropes that people always brought out is you know how how
- 1:09:24will Bitcoin survive when the block subsidy is gone.
- 1:09:28You know there's no evidence of a E market developing.
- 1:09:31Well there's an evidence it's right here if if actually I
- 1:09:35don't I don't know if you know this off the top of your head,
- 1:09:37Bob, but you you pointed out the the key data point of averaging
- 1:09:41.4 Bitcoin per block in fees and I wonder what that number was
- 1:09:47four years ago. I would guess I.
- 1:09:50Do know it. I do know it.
- 1:09:53It's actually interesting. Yeah.
- 1:09:55So I the all time number from the very if you take the average
- 1:09:59from the very beginning it's .335.
- 1:10:02OK. In the first half of 2023 it was
- 1:10:13it was .335. The we averaged in 2023.4.
- 1:10:20So we did. The second-half of 2023 lifted
- 1:10:23the overall average off of the base.
- 1:10:27However, remember that the this is what's interesting.
- 1:10:30The .335, it's been pretty consistent for 15 years.
- 1:10:36So even though the subsidy went fifty 2512 1/2, right that it
- 1:10:41stayed 3.335 for that in basically for that entire time.
- 1:10:48So we're seeing this lift now for the first time, and I can
- 1:10:53the reason isn't directly ordinals and inscriptions, but I
- 1:10:58think you had a question there or comment.
- 1:10:59Just I was going to point out that like the the math there
- 1:11:04means that even if it was to stay at .335 like and then that
- 1:11:0815 year trend was just to continue going forward
- 1:11:12eventually the growth of of the total value of Bitcoin.
- 1:11:17All you need is a 20X in order for that .335 to now equal the
- 1:11:23current block subsidy in terms of economic value and that that
- 1:11:30means getting to $1,000,000 for Bitcoin.
- 1:11:33And there's pretty clear line of sight I think to do that based
- 1:11:36on you know, the current tailwinds and and demand
- 1:11:41dynamics playing out over the next 8 or whatever.
- 1:11:45So anyway I think that it's it's interesting that you know this
- 1:11:49conversation about what happens to mempool and how pools operate
- 1:12:00comes with like a lot of new questions and a lot of new
- 1:12:03ambiguities. But in that we're also you're
- 1:12:07sort of pointing out that the fee market is proving out and
- 1:12:11that's like that's such a huge win that that we check off one
- 1:12:16major box and then granted introduces some other big
- 1:12:20questions. But then you kind of have to
- 1:12:22fall back to the the assumption that free market will win out
- 1:12:27and that the incentives are sound and and will cause
- 1:12:33decentralization and you know, a lack of capture of of the market
- 1:12:40by you know BlackRock and OFAC or whatever was to you know sort
- 1:12:44of try to hijack it. Yeah, you know what's
- 1:12:49interesting? I'm glad you brought up the
- 1:12:52whole point about you know bringing this up again like what
- 1:12:56were the historical fees because like I'm I'm making a guess it's
- 1:13:00my my highest probability guess that we will exit that that
- 1:13:06we're going to see essentially like a what would that be like
- 1:13:09A78X jump in the fee structure between now and the end of the
- 1:13:14next having which by by the. It's not a massive stretch, by
- 1:13:18the way, because we've already seen in 2023 several periods
- 1:13:22where. Or it's jumped up like a preview
- 1:13:25of what's possible when the blocks are are fully.
- 1:13:28Pull right and and well here here's the thing OK the the
- 1:13:35issue is not actually blocks being full exactly because
- 1:13:39here's another stat I have AI have a a little team we we do we
- 1:13:46pull a lot of block metrics we we do it ourselves and because
- 1:13:52we we're looking for a couple metrics that that aren't
- 1:13:55available like glass and old for instance and all that they're
- 1:13:57they're great services but there's a couple things we look
- 1:13:59for that they don't have and like one of them or one one
- 1:14:06piece I can tell you is that in 2023 every single block was
- 1:14:14full. There were.
- 1:14:16I happened to know. It's off the top of my head.
- 1:14:17There were 147 empty blocks, which are, you know, a part of
- 1:14:25the mining process. If you want to dive in there, we
- 1:14:28can talk about that a little bit.
- 1:14:29But but you know, outside of those, every single block was
- 1:14:32full. It was like 3.98 million weight
- 1:14:36units average on the rest of the blocks.
- 1:14:40So there's like no space. Every single block was full.
- 1:14:43Whether the ordinals and inscription people were active
- 1:14:46or not, they were always full. And remember too, that the
- 1:14:53mempool is kicking out a whole bunch of transactions, right
- 1:14:58that that it's they're too long, they don't have the right fees,
- 1:15:04they're getting kicked out. And then there's a whole bunch
- 1:15:06of people who wanted to do things but would look at the
- 1:15:09market and say, hey, it's not, I'm not even going to try right
- 1:15:13now because it's too expensive. So the mempool is not truly a
- 1:15:19reflection of total demand. Total demand is always much
- 1:15:22higher than whatever the men pool reflects.
- 1:15:27So the question is not demand, but also the urgency of the
- 1:15:33demand. Right, yes.
- 1:15:36So we're at a point where the we're already already full.
- 1:15:42So now it's just the component of OK, you know how many
- 1:15:48transactions now reach that point of I can't wait, I have
- 1:15:52to, I have to do it like I had one I did earlier this week
- 1:15:57where it was we have different companies right.
- 1:16:00And I had AI had a move, I don't know, it was like 500,000 SAT's
- 1:16:06from one company to another company.
- 1:16:11Very non urgent, you know, I threw it in there at 4 SAT's for
- 1:16:15BV byte and the very lower end of the threshold.
- 1:16:19If it happens in a week, fine, I don't really care.
- 1:16:23That money is going to sit there for a long time.
- 1:16:25Yeah, there's, you know, but I have other things.
- 1:16:28Excuse me? No, sorry.
- 1:16:29I was I was going to say this is basically the beauty of the fee
- 1:16:31market and all the things we've discussed get solved literally
- 1:16:34because if there's if scarce and it's valuable then whoever takes
- 1:16:38you know OFAC and BlackRock and have 20% but the other 80% will
- 1:16:41get bid up to take those transactions.
- 1:16:43They can go to 50% of the hash rates blocked but eventually
- 1:16:47like that's where I'm it's less concerned.
- 1:16:49It's still concerning, but it's if six out of seven of the pools
- 1:16:52are not taking the transactions, another pool, just by definition
- 1:16:56of the pool, makes money by the the hashing and all the things
- 1:17:00associated with it. Another pool would step in to to
- 1:17:02mine or construct the blocks to take those transactions because
- 1:17:05the fees. Would, yeah.
- 1:17:07Yeah, that's true. But you know we, we, we really
- 1:17:11don't want like there are, there are there are 6 pools that doing
- 1:17:16about 90% and there's another about 9:00 that are that are
- 1:17:23active, they have enough hash rate, they win a block every
- 1:17:26week or two, right. So that's what we're dealing
- 1:17:29with today. That's not enough or it it's
- 1:17:32it's certainly not enough if the block template creation is not
- 1:17:35occurring at the minor level and the pool, the pool is just
- 1:17:39acting as the pool, not the cause.
- 1:17:43In reality the pool is the minor, right.
- 1:17:45On a technical basis, the pool looks to the network like the
- 1:17:49minor and the the miners that we call miners are just hashers who
- 1:17:54are giving their hash rate over to the pool and it's the
- 1:18:01discretion of the pool how to use it and they get compensated.
- 1:18:06And you know, I I'm not trying to say anything too alarming,
- 1:18:10but as a hasher you really don't even know what they're giving
- 1:18:15you. Like, they they could be giving
- 1:18:17you Bitcoin Cash or Bitcoin SV. I'm not saying that they are,
- 1:18:22but you really don't know what it is they're giving you, right?
- 1:18:25They they could give you any set of work.
- 1:18:28They could only send you empty blocks.
- 1:18:30They could, they could send you blocks full of stuff that you
- 1:18:35don't agree with philosophically and you really have no way of
- 1:18:40knowing what's what's in there, right.
- 1:18:43So, but that changes dramatically at the point you
- 1:18:45create the block template, which I'm very passionate about.
- 1:18:49Bob, one of the things but or go ahead.
- 1:18:51No, no, go ahead, I. Was going to go back to what
- 1:18:54what Jess is kind of the fees and some of those sort of
- 1:18:57things. So if you had a question there.
- 1:19:01No, no, no. It's more related to scarcity
- 1:19:05and block space. But we'll cover that and then
- 1:19:07oh, OK. So, well, yeah just kind of back
- 1:19:10on the fees. So I I'm, I'm probably at the
- 1:19:15the most aggressive edge of people predicting these sort of
- 1:19:20things in terms of where fees will go.
- 1:19:24But I want to just you know where where where Jesse was
- 1:19:26going was. If we look at it, we're we're
- 1:19:29we're at the having of we'll call it we're already in the
- 1:19:323.125 era. We'll be at 1.5 something.
- 1:19:38We'll be at .75. Well then we're going to be at
- 1:19:41.37. OK.
- 1:19:44So, so the question is not whether I'm right or wrong.
- 1:19:52Even in the worst case I believe we're only those would that be
- 1:19:56three more, three more halvings. So the question is whether it's
- 1:19:59a four year window or like a 15 year window, but that's that's
- 1:20:03basically what we're saying in terms of this period.
- 1:20:06Yeah, right. So, so I just want to like you
- 1:20:10like you said, you know, dispel the.
- 1:20:13Spell the FUD first of all, about security.
- 1:20:16Not a problem. Do not lose sleep over it #1 #2
- 1:20:21This problem of the minor income becoming highly variable right
- 1:20:31is eminent as well, right? That's also there.
- 1:20:34So that is a very interesting like I've never thought about
- 1:20:38that that how that ambiguity is going to come up it's going to
- 1:20:41turn into it's quite frankly it's going to turn into a major
- 1:20:44new arena of Fudd. And and the debate of
- 1:20:49considerable debate I'm sure of is this is this a a mortal
- 1:20:55threat to Bitcoin If we have the these incentives at work that
- 1:21:02could cause the the fracturing of of the mempool.
- 1:21:06And you know like the the swan example of they could try to
- 1:21:11have habits so that they're pushing through in the 1% of
- 1:21:15blocks you know discounted rate for swan customers doing on
- 1:21:21chain transactions. And then would they want that to
- 1:21:24be visit with those transactions to be sitting visibly in a in a
- 1:21:27mempool or would they want their own mempool that they you know
- 1:21:30feed directly into the box that they're mining.
- 1:21:33You start to see the the potential for the fracturing of
- 1:21:37of the mempool as we know it, which is probably inevitable.
- 1:21:41But then it turns into just like kind of a higher level, the next
- 1:21:45level up of competition between not just competition but in the
- 1:21:50existing singular mem pool between transactions, but
- 1:21:54competition between mem pools and philosophies that ultimately
- 1:21:59are still competing and and settled on block space via the
- 1:22:04existing infrastructure of mining and the and the
- 1:22:06competition that plays out there.
- 1:22:08So it it'll be a very interesting like new debate and
- 1:22:14arena of Fudd. It's going to be the new hot
- 1:22:17topic as that starts to become, you know, clear that that's
- 1:22:22what's happening in Bob. I think you're just seeing
- 1:22:24around the corner four, maybe eight years earlier than
- 1:22:28everybody else. Yeah.
- 1:22:29And Bob, I think where this ties in, it's really fascinating that
- 1:22:33we're having a conversation about unpopular opinions.
- 1:22:34And one of them was just referencing what Jesse described
- 1:22:37in Block Space from UTXOS and everybody holding their keys and
- 1:22:41how it's just like not feasibly possible and working from a
- 1:22:44first principles perspective. I think you said like 10,000
- 1:22:46SATS or whatever the number was and you try to send them out to
- 1:22:49every person on planet Earth, it would take 40 years.
- 1:22:52But just curious of like sharing kind of like that, like working
- 1:22:55through that logic, how you think about like what you just
- 1:22:58described the scalability of Bitcoin and how you know the
- 1:23:00different things that are coming to market play into that?
- 1:23:04Sure. Well, yeah, let's just, it's not
- 1:23:07an opinion, it's just the fundamental structure of what we
- 1:23:11have. And and by the way, I think it
- 1:23:14is the right structure and it promotes this layered approach.
- 1:23:19But let's talk about the base layer.
- 1:23:21So we've already established that there's 200 million
- 1:23:25transaction capacity annually. Well, there's 8 billion people
- 1:23:31in the world and there's 330 million companies in the world.
- 1:23:36So those entities all have to share that base layer.
- 1:23:41So one way to look at it is if every company in the world
- 1:23:45wanted to do one base layer transaction annually, we
- 1:23:50couldn't handle it. They we we only have room for
- 1:23:54one every roughly 2 years for every company.
- 1:23:58So that's number one. Number two, as you mentioned, if
- 1:24:02I want to send some Bitcoin to every person in the world, so
- 1:24:07everybody owns some Bitcoin, 8 billion / 200 million is 4040
- 1:24:16years to accomplish that. So it's completely unrealistic
- 1:24:23to think that everybody's going to hold their own keys and it's
- 1:24:30just like literally impossible, right?
- 1:24:33And by the way, we're not even counting the fact that people
- 1:24:35are dying and being born over that 40 year period, right?
- 1:24:39So you wouldn't even get there in the 40 years.
- 1:24:41So it's it's not it's just not going to happen.
- 1:24:48The another way to look at it I I saw this stack some somebody
- 1:24:53else on on Twitter had done this one.
- 1:24:55But I I liked it too. Another way to look at it would
- 1:24:57be to say in the lifetime of each individual's if we exclude
- 1:25:04the companies there's about one KB of block space for every
- 1:25:09person existing in the world today in their lifetime.
- 1:25:13That's another way to another way to look at it again,
- 1:25:16assuming no companies participated and no nobody died
- 1:25:22or and was born like like you know so so you know it just
- 1:25:27means that that there's just not enough number one, everybody
- 1:25:31can't hold their own keys. I I talk about scarcity too.
- 1:25:35I think people sometimes don't understand scarcity, especially
- 1:25:40absolute scarcity. You know, we we talk about it
- 1:25:43with Bitcoin and how it it will ultimately drive this
- 1:25:49exponential growth in the price of Bitcoin.
- 1:25:52Well, it's going to have the same effect on block space.
- 1:25:57And I give an example that I think kind of visualizes it for
- 1:26:02people pretty well. And say if if I have an apple
- 1:26:04tree and it's the only apple tree in the world, and I produce
- 1:26:08100 apples a day, if demand for apples is 95 apples per day, the
- 1:26:15price of apples is really cheap. I'm throwing 5 away every day.
- 1:26:19The moment 101 people want apples, price of apples really
- 1:26:24spikes. When 120 or 150 people per day
- 1:26:28want apples, it gets insanely expensive.
- 1:26:31When thousand people want it, only the the elite can afford
- 1:26:36apples. Well, I that's that's what's
- 1:26:39going to happen to block space will be the same way and you
- 1:26:44know it it I think it illustrates what will really
- 1:26:48happen at the at the base level and and you know Satoshi did
- 1:26:52something kind of interesting. So actually did more than one
- 1:26:57thing interesting, but so if you look at the very terminology of
- 1:27:01the block reward, the block reward is the subsidy plus fees,
- 1:27:04right. And I think most people think of
- 1:27:06the subsidy as this reward to the miners to keep them incented
- 1:27:11to mine early on. It's partially true, but I also
- 1:27:15believe it was to create user adoption.
- 1:27:21And so you could think of it as kind of like a free introductory
- 1:27:24period for users of Bitcoin. And we've had 15 years of this
- 1:27:29introductory period of access to essentially instantaneous access
- 1:27:34for free to the world's most powerful network, right.
- 1:27:38And the subsidy is going down. I think we're reaching that
- 1:27:43point where the free period is over.
- 1:27:46It's like, hey, you know, at a, at a health club, January is
- 1:27:50free, but you know, you got to pay starting in February, right.
- 1:27:55The health clubs always do that sort of thing, right?
- 1:27:57Or it's a dollar the first month in January, but not then it's 29
- 1:28:01a month after that. Well that's where we are and and
- 1:28:04I think some people have have the mistaken impression that
- 1:28:08this free instantaneous access to the base layer is something
- 1:28:14that should be there forever. Well we're we're in year 15 of
- 1:28:20what I believe to be the next thousand years of money.
- 1:28:23So you know it's it's it's just this little period and and and
- 1:28:28we're witnessing this flip. It's such a beautiful Next.
- 1:28:33Yeah, sorry. It's just such a beautiful
- 1:28:35mental model to flip and in invert effectively because when
- 1:28:38Jesse was alluding to the block, besides like, I agree, I think
- 1:28:41everybody here agrees from fees. But like you know certain people
- 1:28:44believe that the fees won't get there.
- 1:28:45We have telemission all the crap that goes along with it and
- 1:28:48they're literally looking at it the wrong.
- 1:28:50Like the lens is completely opposite of what you just
- 1:28:52described. This is it.
- 1:28:54It's not the. It's not the de facto protocol
- 1:28:57for it to consistently be this block as the majority of value.
- 1:29:01It was to get to a certain place for them the transactions to
- 1:29:05make up the the majority of the value.
- 1:29:08Right. And it's literally called
- 1:29:09subsidy. Like I think that's lost on
- 1:29:11people. It is literally called subsidy.
- 1:29:14Yeah. And to talk about beauty from
- 1:29:17from Satoshi, that one in particular smacks me over the
- 1:29:21head every now and then of like what talk about two birds with
- 1:29:25one stone. How many birds did Satoshi get
- 1:29:27with that that design of the halving of of the subsidy
- 1:29:32because in one in one go he managed to to bootstrap proof of
- 1:29:38work and distribute coins fairly while introducing increasing
- 1:29:45scarcity as a mechanic for like for to to drive bitcoins
- 1:29:50monetization into the future where you know if you save now
- 1:29:53it gets more valuable in the future because they're making
- 1:29:56less of it in the future. So he's he's bootstrapped an
- 1:29:59entire incentive model for saving and holding and and as
- 1:30:04you point out it's a it's an introductory model to an
- 1:30:10eventual fee market development. So he managed to create this
- 1:30:13like, all right, here's a trial phase and then slowly transition
- 1:30:17into a fee market. And like all those things are
- 1:30:20packaged into this super elegant, oh, we're just going to
- 1:30:23cut the block subsidy in half every every four years.
- 1:30:26It's unbelievable how many birds with one stone that that
- 1:30:29accomplished. Yep, Yep.
- 1:30:31It it is. Like I said I'm, I'm continually
- 1:30:35impressed and I've been involved in this for since 2017 and you
- 1:30:42know these revelations still come at me.
- 1:30:48You know this this long like the beauty of that, the depth of
- 1:30:51that. You know I'm sure in the coming
- 1:30:54year something else will come and you know what I want.
- 1:30:57I want to say one thing not not to correct you Jesse, just say
- 1:31:01one thing. I think that you use the word
- 1:31:04slowly in the fee market. I this is this is where I differ
- 1:31:08from a lot of people but I just want to kind of go back to the
- 1:31:11the Apple example I gave. I I believe it's more like an
- 1:31:15exponential thing that fees will be exponential and that we sit
- 1:31:21on the cusp of this this massive explosion.
- 1:31:28And in fact, this is an interesting thing too.
- 1:31:32If you think about what a minor does or the product of a minor,
- 1:31:37right, Companies produce things. For the last 15 years, we have
- 1:31:46as a mining industry or community, we have produced a
- 1:31:50Bitcoin. And I mean that in the literal
- 1:31:53sense like we were, we were producing the Coinbase, which
- 1:31:58you talked about that, right. That's part of the whole thing
- 1:32:01was to produce the Coinbase. Well, that's almost over.
- 1:32:05I mean, I think you can, you can make an argument that it almost
- 1:32:09is like where, where do you want to draw that point?
- 1:32:11Is it this having the next one? But you say, but in essence it's
- 1:32:16over. So what do we produce now?
- 1:32:21Well, we produce block space. That's that's what miners do.
- 1:32:25Miners are in the transition of going from producing Bitcoin to
- 1:32:30Coinbase to producing block space and being compensated for
- 1:32:35that. So again, there's another
- 1:32:38fundamental Yep. Right.
- 1:32:40And to bring it, to bring it back to your to your apple
- 1:32:43analogy like you're right, it's so I say slowly but
- 1:32:47exponentially is probably more right.
- 1:32:49But then it's also kind of binary and I think you're you're
- 1:32:54pointing out how like we've lived in a world where there's
- 1:32:57been more apple supply than demand if you know if we make
- 1:33:02that parallel to block space. And now like the last couple
- 1:33:06year or two really we've lived in a in a world where there's
- 1:33:11101 apples being demanded and 100 being supplied.
- 1:33:16And so it's been, it's it's sort of binary ultimately like
- 1:33:20there's, there's the the last 15 years where it's been more
- 1:33:23supply than demand and now looking forward there's probably
- 1:33:28more demand and supply and those are just they're night and day.
- 1:33:33It's it's a pretty binary situation where like what
- 1:33:36happens to the value of block space in a world where there's
- 1:33:40more supply than demand versus more demand and supply.
- 1:33:43It's a a light switch. Yeah, I was just saying we'll go
- 1:33:51ahead and finish that thought. And then I had one more before
- 1:33:53conscious of time, but wanted to ask something before.
- 1:33:56Yeah, I'm OK. By the way, don't don't worry
- 1:33:58about time for me. If you guys got to go, that's
- 1:34:00fine, but I'm fine. You know, we with this ETF, a
- 1:34:03lot of these, a lot of people talk about the multiplier effect
- 1:34:06on the ETF. You know, a dollar or you know,
- 1:34:09a dollar into the ecosystem has multiplier effect.
- 1:34:14I don't have any science behind this, but I would suspect
- 1:34:17there's something like that same thing that will occur as demand
- 1:34:24for block space goes up, that that each incremental unit of
- 1:34:30demand for block space has an inordinate impact on the fees
- 1:34:37associated with it. Yep.
- 1:34:40Interesting. Yeah, that that makes sense,
- 1:34:43Bob. I know this is like reverse
- 1:34:45order, but before we wrap, I'm curious, it's so fascinating how
- 1:34:48you think about it. Like, how did you get into
- 1:34:50Bitcoin? And then what made you choose
- 1:34:52mining? Because you seem very
- 1:34:54multidisciplinary. You come at it from different
- 1:34:55angles, like there's a lot of ways you could have had an
- 1:34:58impact. How did mining be the like area,
- 1:35:01the angle you attack it from? Well it it starts a little shit
- 1:35:08coin. Y like a lot of people but in a
- 1:35:12in a strange way didn't even start shit coining what what
- 1:35:15happened was I had somebody call me one day and he said he's he
- 1:35:21was an old gateway person had spoken to him for over a decade
- 1:35:24but he called me up out of the blue and he said Bob, I've got a
- 1:35:29group 2017 by the way 2017 he said Bob, I have a group we are
- 1:35:36putting up a large Ethereum mining farm.
- 1:35:40Can you? But problem is I can't.
- 1:35:44I can't get a professionally built system and I can't get the
- 1:35:48NVIDIA chips, you know. So would you be able to help me?
- 1:35:55So I looked at it as a system person, a computer person right.
- 1:35:59Except you know can can we design a professional Ethereum
- 1:36:03server not knowing much about it and it just so happens from way
- 1:36:10back in the gateway days me. So I was the CTO at at Gateway
- 1:36:16and Keith Thomas, who's the President at Barefoot, he was
- 1:36:19the head of Desktop engineering Gateway.
- 1:36:21Well, turns out we have pretty good relationships with NVIDIA.
- 1:36:24So we we called up NVIDIA and said hey if we build these
- 1:36:29systems will you give us chips because we needed 881070 or 1080
- 1:36:36chips and everyone which at the time was kind of the pinnacle of
- 1:36:40the GPU world and they said yes. So we we ended up with an order
- 1:36:48for like 800 of these at was it like $6800 or something like
- 1:36:52that. It was like a $6 million PO.
- 1:36:54We just started a company that you would now know as barefoot
- 1:36:57mining to build these and these systems for this guy.
- 1:37:02So we did and we shipped them to him.
- 1:37:04We did pretty well on it. So then we said, well, we have
- 1:37:08this design. I wonder if anybody else would
- 1:37:10want to buy them, right, so we could get more chips.
- 1:37:12So we found a pretty decent market for those.
- 1:37:16But most of the people that we were that were interested in it
- 1:37:19were somebody that wanted five of them or three of them or you
- 1:37:22know, ten of them or something like that.
- 1:37:24And almost all of them said, hey, I'll buy them from you, I'm
- 1:37:29interested, but I don't have anywhere to put them.
- 1:37:34Can you host them for me? So that forced us to open a
- 1:37:40hosting operation and then we kind of saw how well these were
- 1:37:45doing vary Fiat looking at that moment, right?
- 1:37:48It's like, right, these are making a lot of money.
- 1:37:50Maybe we should take all the profits, pour it into our own
- 1:37:53equipment, which we did and started mining Ethereum for
- 1:37:57ourselves. So then after kind of going
- 1:38:02through several months of kind of getting all that in order and
- 1:38:05we're doing really well, I started to sit back and 1st I
- 1:38:09started looking at Ethereum, you know what is this thing really
- 1:38:13And I started to have concerns. I saw a massively complex
- 1:38:20system. I saw highly centralized
- 1:38:23signals. I saw this.
- 1:38:27They had already signaled that they were going to move to proof
- 1:38:30of or stake at some point. So I saw all these things that I
- 1:38:36didn't, I didn't like just again, more of a technical lens
- 1:38:39like this. This doesn't look good to me.
- 1:38:43And then in parallel started looking harder at Bitcoin and
- 1:38:48Silent. I have AI, have a economics
- 1:38:51background as well. I studied economics and and
- 1:38:54found Independent School as well as my engineering degree and and
- 1:38:58then I also in the early 2000s found Austrian economics just
- 1:39:02coincidentally. So I started looking at Bitcoin
- 1:39:06and you know the just the sound technical foundation and some of
- 1:39:10the early revelations of the beauty of the way that Satoshi
- 1:39:14had architected this thing started to appeal to me.
- 1:39:17And then I saw the Austrian principles kind of coming
- 1:39:20through all this and so we started pivot the company and
- 1:39:26away from Ethereum and to Bitcoin.
- 1:39:30So, so that was that was the the point for me of you know,
- 1:39:35getting involved and and ultimately landing, you know
- 1:39:40more firmly in the Bitcoin side of the equation.
- 1:39:43That's awesome. Yeah, that's.
- 1:39:46I think that's an interesting coming into altcoin story
- 1:39:50because I know Jesse shares his and everybody has their their
- 1:39:52own. But generally it's like they
- 1:39:54kind of stopped from there and then obviously like went to
- 1:39:57Bitcoin. But you could literally were
- 1:39:59like mining or helping to support and then realize it's
- 1:40:01like, oh, I found like this niche and understand how to
- 1:40:04build these systems, but I'm just building the wrong building
- 1:40:06the wrong circuit set up, yeah. Yeah.
- 1:40:12I can't help but find it interesting too that like you
- 1:40:14know you and and Wozniak you know are are both like earlier
- 1:40:21computer infrastructure engineering guys who both see
- 1:40:26the beauty of this this system of engineered money And and
- 1:40:31there's there's something to that that you know I I guess
- 1:40:34anybody who's early to computers has a pattern recognition or
- 1:40:40like a style of thinking where you just see things see the
- 1:40:44future playing out and lo and behold with Bitcoin we we see
- 1:40:48it. Quite a few folks like yourself
- 1:40:51who have seen this movie before and and are excited about this
- 1:40:55one too, you know? And and that that says a lot.
- 1:41:00Yeah, absolutely. I appreciate you putting me and
- 1:41:03Wozniak in the same sentence. That's how I praise.
- 1:41:05I, I appreciate that, but I'm not sure it's applicable.
- 1:41:09But what I will say is this that to the degree I have some vision
- 1:41:16or or ability to to to kind of you know see how technology is
- 1:41:23going to evolve and how it's going to impact society.
- 1:41:25I mean that was really my job when I was the Chief Technology
- 1:41:28Officer at Gateway that was what I was chartered with right.
- 1:41:31My my job was to direct where we were going to go with technology
- 1:41:36and and that meant trying to see where how how would people adapt
- 1:41:44how would business adapt like like so and it and you know it
- 1:41:47forces me and going back to my early days to like as an
- 1:41:51engineer. Yeah how how will this all come
- 1:41:54together. It's like when I was at gateway
- 1:41:59like I'll tell you a little story may find interesting.
- 1:42:01I have, I have a bunch of patents and my my favorite
- 1:42:07patent is a very simple patent and the patent was because it
- 1:42:14was roughly 2000, 2001 and probably people don't remember
- 1:42:21this. But Gateway wasn't just APC
- 1:42:22company. We we were the number one maker
- 1:42:24of plasma TV's in America in 2002 for instance.
- 1:42:29We had like like we we had we sold more plasma TV's than
- 1:42:33anybody in America in 2002 under our own brand that my team
- 1:42:37developed. So I'm real proud of that.
- 1:42:39But we also did digital cameras, we did MP3 players, all kinds of
- 1:42:44other consumer electronics devices.
- 1:42:47And so one of the products we were developing was a an early
- 1:42:53MP3 player and this is a a Ledger, but you know it was like
- 1:42:57this size, right. So it was ausb stick, MP3 player
- 1:43:03and we had got the first prototype developed.
- 1:43:08And I guess to to say that, you know, so we could see like what
- 1:43:11was happening with like like that music was moving from the
- 1:43:15CD. We had seen what Napster and you
- 1:43:18know, some Limewire. And if you're old enough to
- 1:43:21remember, like how music distribution was changing and
- 1:43:25that, you know, the future was people carrying around their
- 1:43:28music, thousands and thousands of songs and picking their own
- 1:43:31playlists and like all that, we, you know, that was part of what
- 1:43:35what we envisioned. And Apple hadn't come up with
- 1:43:38the iPod yet. So we were we were trying to
- 1:43:42scramble ultimately with the goal of hopefully having had the
- 1:43:45success of the iPod, which we didn't have.
- 1:43:47But But anyway, so we're we're developing this little USB stick
- 1:43:51device. And in the first prototype it,
- 1:43:55it only had, it had a play pause button so it could start and
- 1:44:01stop. And it has a button that would
- 1:44:04reverse you to the beginning of the track or a forward button
- 1:44:08that would take you to the next track.
- 1:44:10This is all I had, right? It doesn't.
- 1:44:12It didn't even have a display on it.
- 1:44:14OK, so so anyway, I'm out for a run and I had downloaded an
- 1:44:24audiobook in MP3 form to this this device I'm run.
- 1:44:32So I'm, I'm at a really good part of the book and I'm running
- 1:44:35along and I have a wired earbud in and my elbow catches the the
- 1:44:42cable and it rips the the, the device out of my hand.
- 1:44:48It goes flying, you know, tumbling down the sidewalk and
- 1:44:52the earbuds go another way. And I have to reassemble the
- 1:44:56whole thing, right? And I put it in and like shit
- 1:45:00the the audio book has kept playing the whole the whole time
- 1:45:06right. And and I missed like 90 seconds
- 1:45:08of this book. And remember I only have two
- 1:45:11options which were this is an MP3 rip of the whole book.
- 1:45:15My choices are go back to the beginning of the book or skip to
- 1:45:20the end of the book. I have no other options.
- 1:45:23I'm like shit, so I'm sitting there on the sidewalk and I go,
- 1:45:28I'm an engineer I I should have the force.
- 1:45:34I should have had the foresight to understand that the moment
- 1:45:37that the earbud pulled out of the device, I should have
- 1:45:42stopped the audio track. So it's so by the way.
- 1:45:51So if you have like earbuds and you're listening to music and
- 1:45:54you know when you take them out and the music stops and you put
- 1:45:56it in and it starts again, that's my patent.
- 1:46:00And so which by the reason I'm proud of it, I think I have, I
- 1:46:06have much more technical, much more intricate patents.
- 1:46:11But I'm really proud of this one patent because there are
- 1:46:16billions of people who have devices that get to use
- 1:46:20something that I invented every day, right.
- 1:46:24And so that's a kind of a cool thing when I even when I'm, when
- 1:46:27I'm on an airplane or in a restaurant or you know,
- 1:46:28whatever, and I see somebody listening to something and they
- 1:46:31take it out, I think, oh, you know, a little piece of my work
- 1:46:35kind of went into that. So and there's a very long
- 1:46:38winded, kind of tangential way of saying I think that there are
- 1:46:43people and like like Wozniak is is great and Jobs is great and
- 1:46:49Elon Musk is great. And you know, for me to even be
- 1:46:52in the same room as those guys are in the same class, you know,
- 1:46:57that's that's high praise. But I but I do think that there
- 1:47:01are people that can do that, that that have that ability to
- 1:47:05say I I can think of the 2nd order, the 3rd order, the 4th
- 1:47:09order, the 5th order. Effects of these things remove
- 1:47:14themselves from the present and bring it.
- 1:47:18Satoshi was absolutely marvelous at.
- 1:47:22It may have been the greatest of all time.
- 1:47:26I mean, I agree. Yeah and yeah.
- 1:47:31It's it's a perfect way to to wrap in the sense of like Bob
- 1:47:36that story is I think anyway I'm glad we met and hope to be able
- 1:47:40to get your guidance on how we think about our business
- 1:47:42building and feedback. But then in general, what
- 1:47:44personally really excited for this next epoch is mainly from
- 1:47:48like the operational execution and talent coming into the space
- 1:47:52with backgrounds that were experts in their own field found
- 1:47:55Bitcoin and now bringing all of that second, third or third
- 1:47:58order thinking and vision into this world that we kind of
- 1:48:01haven't seen yet. And so, yeah, that encapsulates
- 1:48:05it very well as hopefully there's other people coming in
- 1:48:07with very significant patents and things they've done that
- 1:48:09will port that over to Bitcoin. Yeah we we need it You know I
- 1:48:16maybe I'll I'll say one last thing which is you know I think
- 1:48:18we all have to be vigilant like like there's if we enter a bull
- 1:48:21run probably my greatest fear is complacency like that that you
- 1:48:27know we have to we have to innovate just because you know
- 1:48:32we shouldn't ever think that we won like we we you know I I I
- 1:48:37mentioned this earlier I think about Bitcoin from 1000 year
- 1:48:40perspective and I I may at times overreact to something that may
- 1:48:49seem like a trivial issue And the reason I I might react that
- 1:48:56way is that over time over 1000 year window there are going to
- 1:49:01be a lot of attacks and it it may be that we fend them all off
- 1:49:09but it may also be that a small one that we ignored that we
- 1:49:15didn't think was significant ends up being the one that
- 1:49:18defeats us. Just like Bitcoin got its very
- 1:49:23existence because the existing financial system and power
- 1:49:27system of the world ignored us for too long right.
- 1:49:31And then it came in and we now we attacked them.
- 1:49:33And we're now we're we're we're too big and too powerful to fend
- 1:49:37off. Well, let's not fall victim to
- 1:49:39the same thing that brought us our success.
- 1:49:42Perfectly said. Anywhere to share where people
- 1:49:46can find you. Sure, Barefoot Mining is our our
- 1:49:52company website. Boomer BTC Under score BTC at on
- 1:49:59Twitter I have a podcast called Old Man yells on.
- 1:50:02You find it on YouTube and Spotify and things like that,
- 1:50:05which is just me ranting about various things.
- 1:50:08Awesome. And then you'll be at Biblock
- 1:50:10Bib this year, right? I will be, yeah.
- 1:50:12I will be at Biblock Boom this year.
- 1:50:14I will be in Prague as well. If anybody's in Europe, I'll be
- 1:50:18in Prague in June. Awesome.
- 1:50:20That's where you can find Bob and then the Bitcoin.
- 1:50:23John meet up this Monday in Philadelphia with Lynn Alden.
- 1:50:26We're have some of our team down there and I guess it's up to
- 1:50:29over 100 people now are going to attend of RSVP.
- 1:50:33The the most I think was 30 to 40.
- 1:50:35So if you still want to attend, sign up.
- 1:50:38Yep, that's cool. Awesome.
- 1:50:42All right. Thanks guys.
- 1:50:44Thank you guys.