Latest / The So What? / 40 Days That Changed the World
Transcript
- 0:00Hello and welcome to the So What podcast, in which political economic analyst JP Landman
- 0:11discusses the issues uppermost in the minds of South Africans. You can find a written
- 0:16version of this content on JP's website, jplantman.co.za. I am Ruda Landman and I am your host.
- 0:25Hello and as always a very warm welcome to this conversation. This one accompanies JP's
- 0:33research note dated the 7th of March 2025 under the title 40 Days That Changed the World.
- 0:40It's now been a little bit more than 40 days since Donald Trump became the American President
- 0:46and the world has changed. Yes, whether it's 40 days or 48 days in that
- 0:51period, it really changed the world in ways that very, very few people have foreseen.
- 0:58That's the reality that we're living with. For better or for worse?
- 1:03For better or for worse, I think definitely for worse, not for better. And then I want
- 1:09to start off by saying Henry Kissinger that used to be the American Secretary of State
- 1:15and probably the most important diplomat in America in the second half of the previous
- 1:19century said to be an enemy of America is dangerous, but to be a friend is fatal. And
- 1:27that is what we're seeing happening, whether it's Mexico and Canada, loyal neighbors of
- 1:32America, whether it's Ukraine, whether it's Europe, all over its friends that are getting
- 1:37the same bad treatment from Trump. And it's really a question of it is fatal to be a friend
- 1:44of America. And then I'm not even talking about the people, many hundreds of thousands
- 1:51who live from the word that USAID used to do, not only, but particularly on HIV AIDS,
- 1:58but also on food programs, helping people suffering from hunger. And all of that, of
- 2:04course, is now out of the window. And that just proves the point. It is fatal to be a
- 2:10friend of America. But how can he do it?
- 2:14He's tearing up agreements, going back on treaties. There should be a law, surely.
- 2:23No, the fact is he is doing it. It boggles the mind. It goes completely beyond what one
- 2:31can call rational behavior or legitimate behavior in the international order.
- 2:36There used to be a rules-based order, no longer.
- 2:39Yeah, I think that's the simple reality. Outside and inside America, Trump is on record
- 2:45as saying that judges that rule against him should be impeached. So that's inside and
- 2:50outside America, the rules-based order has been thrown out. So that's the reality.
- 2:57You know, I want to challenge listeners to send me the coordinates of one square meter
- 3:03of land in this country that was grabbed by the state. Yet he wants to grab Panama, Greenland,
- 3:09Canada, and Gaza. It is simply astonishing. Yet he's complaining about non-existent land
- 3:15grabs here. No, the reality is that after this first couple of weeks of behavior, not
- 3:22of just talking, but of actual behavior and actual decisions that have been announced,
- 3:27I think one can only come to the conclusion America is no longer a serious country.
- 3:33You quote the FT who had a headline recently, the Financial Times, America is now an enemy
- 3:40of the West.
- 3:43Think about that. You know, the Financial Times is a middle-of-the-road newspaper and
- 3:47that is their conclusion that America is now an enemy of the West. It's an astonishing
- 3:52headline but I think a very apt one. It describes what is going on.
- 3:56But Trump is actually also withdrawing America from the world.
- 4:02Yes, and that's very important to note. There's nothing exceptional about South Africa. Trump
- 4:07has basically declared war on all his friends except on Putin and Russia, but for the rest
- 4:13war all over. Maybe not warfare.
- 4:17And Israel.
- 4:18And Israel, yeah, absolutely. But for the rest, he's bullying his friends. That's the
- 4:28reality. Now the question is how must one react to that? And I think we can learn something
- 4:33from his first term. In 2017 when he was inaugurated as president the first time, on his first
- 4:40day in the Oval Office, he withdrew America from the TPP. The TPP is the then was the
- 4:46Trans-Pacific Partnership, 12 countries on the Pacific who over a space of more than
- 4:52a decade negotiated a very sophisticated gold standard trade agreement. There was protection
- 4:59for labor rights, protection for environmental rights, protection for intellectual property
- 5:04rights. It was really the gold standard of agreements. And the Obama administration in
- 5:09their time put a lot of effort into it.
- 5:12On his first day in office, he withdrew America from the TPP. It had a shocking effect and
- 5:19a sort of numbing effect on the remaining 11 members. In fact, I think it was the Minister
- 5:26of Foreign Affairs of Japan said they cannot really carry on with the TPP without America.
- 5:33That is not the way it turned out. After a couple of months, the countries pulled themselves
- 5:37together. They renegotiated the agreement, this time without the intellectual property
- 5:42protections that the United States fought very hard for. That's the irony of it.
- 5:49And they reestablished the TPP under a new name. Today, China, South Korea, the other
- 5:56kingdom are all lining up to become members of this renewed TPP. So the world carried
- 6:02on without America. And that is what we will have to do. He's now, as we know, he's withdrawn
- 6:08the US from the World Health Organization, although it will take time to take effect.
- 6:13He's withdrawn the US from the Paris Climate Agreement. He's withdrawn the US from the
- 6:18trade agreement in North America. He clearly wants to withdraw the US from support for
- 6:24Ukraine, which is not an agreement, but it was.
- 6:27And probably the G20.
- 6:29And probably the G20, if you look at the way that these people behaved towards the meeting
- 6:33being held in South Africa. So the reality is he's withdrawing America from the world
- 6:38and the rest of us must adapt to that.
- 6:41Where does this leave South Africa?
- 6:44In 2012, that's now 13 years ago, the first National Planning Commission under the chairmanship
- 6:51of then Minister Trevor Emmanuel developed the South African and published the South
- 6:57African National Development Plan. And that plan made two points amongst a lot of others.
- 7:03The one is that power was shifting from the West to the East. And secondly, South Africa
- 7:09must adjust to that by diversifying its relationships and have relationships with all in the world.
- 7:16To put it in ordinary English, maintain your old relationships, but build new ones. Maintain
- 7:21that which you have, but develop new relationships for trade and exports.
- 7:25And it looks, if we look at our export figures, it looks as if that is precisely what has
- 7:29happened in the 13 years since that National Development Plan was published. We quoted
- 7:36in the note, but let me just repeat it. Today, our biggest export share, 35%, goes to China,
- 7:44India, and what is called the Asian nations. Basically Asia. That's where it's going.
- 7:4935% biggest portion of our exports. Second biggest is to Africa, largely Sotheg, 25%.
- 7:57And tying with them in the second place is Europe, also taking 25% of our exports. So
- 8:02between them, you're looking at 85% of South African exports. And then North America, which
- 8:08includes Canada and the US, 8%, Middle East, 4%, South America, 3%. So our exports have
- 8:15already diversified quite substantially towards the East and away from what we can call the
- 8:22US. That has happened.
- 8:23Can I just ask something in between? Many people are very worried about the AGOA and
- 8:29we will probably lose that. But North America, Canada and the US only take 8% of our total
- 8:37exports. Will it have that much of an effect?
- 8:39Yes, it will have an effect because think of a wine farmer in the Western Cape that's
- 8:44exporting to America. It'll affect them. I think the sectors that will be particularly
- 8:49influenced will be motor car, automotive exports. We export a lot of that to America. And the
- 8:55AGOA, that'll be affected. And if in general, Trump decides to levy South African exports
- 9:02to the US, which is what I think he will do, it'll obviously make our products more expensive
- 9:07and less competitive and we could lose some trade from that. So yes, it will have an impact.
- 9:13Okay. But you were saying that we have actually already, if I may borrow a word from the,
- 9:21I think the Obama administration, pivoted towards the East, that Asia already takes
- 9:2735% of our exports. Yes.
- 9:30So this makes nonsense of the idea that South Africa must choose between the US and China.
- 9:35Yeah, absolutely. A lot of people want to sort of almost, if I can use the word, threaten
- 9:42one by saying, oh, you must choose this side or that side. And that's exactly what the
- 9:46National Development Plan 13 years ago said you shouldn't do. US developed relations were
- 9:51with everybody. Now, if America doesn't want to have relations with you, well, fine. You
- 9:55can't force them to have relations with you. From your side, keep it open, try and keep
- 9:59it going. And if that doesn't work, then it doesn't work. Then you've got to develop
- 10:05other possibilities. Now, the one big possibility that is beginning to become available is the
- 10:12African Free Trade Agreement, which effectively only started last year in terms of physical
- 10:18exports going into Africa. That's an obvious market. And for the rest, one must develop
- 10:24other markets. There's the Middle East, I think is a big potential agricultural market.
- 10:30Recently, for the first time in a long time, we could start selling fruit to, I think,
- 10:36Vietnam again. So yeah, there are possibilities elsewhere in the world, and that'll have to
- 10:41be exploited.
- 10:42Do we know, do we have an idea, a feel for how bad the impact will be if Trump goes all
- 10:49the way with his tariffs and levies?
- 10:51Yes, in South Africa, the work has been done by Elna Mulman, who, as you know, is the top
- 10:56rated economist. And she's run the numbers on what would happen if there's a 10% levy
- 11:02by America on its trade partners, and all the trade partners also reciprocate with 10%.
- 11:08So 10% both ways. And basically what she said is that in the first year, world GDP will
- 11:14be half a percent lower. And then the second year, the cumulative effect will be GDP will
- 11:19be 0.8% lower. For the United States alone, it'll be 1.1% lower in the first year and
- 11:261.3% lower in the second year. For South Africa, it'll be 0.1% lower in the first year and
- 11:33cumulatively 0.2% in the second year. But these are, of course, all theoretical exercises.
- 11:39You know, one doesn't know, will it be 10%, will it be 20%? We don't know how it'll play
- 11:44out. But it gives you more or less a feel for how things can pan out.
- 11:49But we are hit badly when it comes to aid rather than trade.
- 11:54Yes, absolutely. So aid, not trade. It's a reversal of the normal story. South Africa
- 11:59in 2024-25 was supposed to receive from the United States aid to the value of $439 million
- 12:08US dollars. Now, if you multiply that with an exchange rate of 18.50, then that will
- 12:14come to 7.2 billion rand. Now, in the context of the South African economy, it's small.
- 12:19It's only 0.1%. But of course, it has a direct impact on specific selected sectors. So you
- 12:28cannot just dismiss it. A lot of the pain of that 7.2 billion rand not coming our way
- 12:36will fall on health programs, specifically HIV AIDS treatment. As you know, George Bush
- 12:41in 2003, that's already, what is it, 22 years ago, started PEPFAR, the President's Program
- 12:50Emergency Plan for AIDS Relief. That will come to an end, has come to an end already.
- 12:54The letters have been sent, clinics have closed, nurses and doctors have been laid off. And
- 12:59obviously patients are not getting, they are not getting their medicine and their treatment.
- 13:04And that makes very real the point that Kissinger made, to be a friend of America is fatal.
- 13:09These people may now die, probably will die. I mean, that is the fatality of being a friend
- 13:15of America. How do you see South Africa's reaction up to now? Was it good, bad, indifferent?
- 13:22Well so far, there's been a remarkable, what is called the strategic silence. The only
- 13:27person who made one comment was Minister Gwede Mantash, who said we should then withhold
- 13:33mineral exports. And after that he went quiet. So clearly some collective discipline was
- 13:38imposed on him. I think the South African government has been very disciplined in not
- 13:44talking and feeding the flames. The problem that we have in South Africa is that there
- 13:49are two groups. The one is sort of coming from the liberal side of our political spectrum,
- 13:54not the left, but the liberals. And then the far right in the form of referendum and solidarity
- 13:59are feeding a lot of narratives that South Africa should go out to the US and do what
- 14:08they want and so on and so forth. And that is not going to happen. A lot of these people
- 14:15hope that with Trump's help they can achieve things, or with American pressure they can
- 14:20achieve things domestically, which they can't achieve through normal political processes.
- 14:25I'm afraid they will be disappointed. And the reason I say they will be disappointed
- 14:29is there is such a thing as a reaction or a backlash. And we're seeing it playing out
- 14:35in Canada right now at this moment. In Canada, the government of Justin Trudeau, the prime
- 14:40minister, was in so much trouble that he resigned as leader of the party and as prime minister.
- 14:45He's just in acting capacity now while his party is looking for a successor. But they
- 14:51were supposed to lose completely in the coming election in Canada and the opposition was
- 14:56supposed to be a shoe in. Since Trump has started insulting the Canadians, that has
- 15:02changed around completely. Now that doesn't mean that's how the election will end.
- 15:07Why are the conservatives in Canada, if I can put it that way, on Trump's side?
- 15:13They perceive to be that, yes. And all that what the liberals, the governing party, has
- 15:19done is to just have a lot of clips of the opposition leaders saying friendly things
- 15:24about Trump and broadcasting this to the nation. And there's clearly a reaction there. And
- 15:31I want to stress that this is not a uniquely Canadian thing. It is standard politics that
- 15:35you find an enemy outside the country and you mobilize against the enemy and that's
- 15:40how you build your support base. Then people don't vote on internal issues. They vote
- 15:44on this external enemy. Trump himself has done it with the immigration issue. He's really
- 15:49blown that up enormously and that made him president of the US. So it's a standard technique,
- 15:55but we're seeing it playing out in a moderate, polite country like Canada.
- 15:59Now what is the danger for South Africa? The danger for South Africa is that if that kind
- 16:04of Canadian reaction takes hold here, it is not inconceivable that the ANC goes back to
- 16:0950%. People will just say, we haven't had enough of this. And if it is sort of right-wing
- 16:16far right-wing whites who are seen to be flaming the fires here, then it may very well affect
- 16:23the distribution of political support for parties.
- 16:26The question comes up, whose side are you on?
- 16:29Simple as that.
- 16:30So what, to summarize, the accepted world order has changed.
- 16:36And that's very difficult for, I think, particularly white people in South Africa to accept. We
- 16:41grew up under the Pax Americana. Pax Americana is no more.
- 16:44When we grow up, we want to be like America, no longer.
- 16:47No longer, absolutely no longer. And we have to accept that and we must adjust to that
- 16:53reality. It's no good trying to pretend it's not happening.
- 16:56The second, so what is the idea that South Africa has to choose between America and China
- 17:01is very misguided. And the export numbers tell us that. Our further salvation will not
- 17:07lie with the Americans. It would lie with other nations. If the Americans levy us and
- 17:13put 25% import tariffs, you know, how on earth will you go to exports there? You probably
- 17:19won't.
- 17:20The third, so what I think is an important one, and that is the chainsaw that Trump has
- 17:24taken to United States-Europe relations, United States-EU relations, I think could very well
- 17:32provide or create an opportunity for South Africa. And I was thinking, why did Mr. Ramaphosa
- 17:37invite Zelensky on a state visit here? You know, it's an interesting kind of almost
- 17:43anomaly in terms of recent behavior. And all I can think is, Zelensky is now clearly the
- 17:49one man who Europe wants to protect. Europe wants to be seen to stand by him and effectively
- 17:56stand by him. By inviting me here for a state visit, one can capitalize on the rupture between
- 18:02the US and EU.
- 18:05And it's not just South Africa?
- 18:08I think that's a very important point to note. USAID has been dismantled worldwide, whether
- 18:12it's Pakistan or Indonesia or South Africa or Lesotho. It's a worldwide thing. Tariffs
- 18:19are being levied left, right and center on friends, not on Russia, interestingly, but
- 18:24on friends. So yes, it is not just a South African thing. And we must get over the feeling
- 18:30that it's our fault. It is not our fault. We're dealing with a very particular individual
- 18:35on the other side.
- 18:37Your last bullet point under the sow. What's losing US support will force South Africa
- 18:42to get its house in order. We must display a greater sense of urgency in doing what we
- 18:47must do. What do you mean?
- 18:49We know that we have to fix energy. We know that we have to particularly transmission.
- 18:53The generation, I think, is busy being fixed, but we have to do more on transmission side,
- 19:00electricity transmission. We clearly have to fix railways. We clearly have to fix the
- 19:04ports. We clearly have to fix water. These are the basic things that we must get right.
- 19:10And it is at the moment just taking too long. It is simply just taking too long. This development
- 19:15of America, it brings an urgency to our domestic agenda, which we must grab hands on and deal
- 19:23with and get it behind us.
- 19:26Because we are in a certain sense now on our own.
- 19:29We are on our own.
- 19:31We have to grow up and do it ourselves.
- 19:35We've got to pay the aids bill ourselves. We've got to find that money in the budget. If the
- 19:39money is not in the budget, we must grow the economy so that the budget can be there, so
- 19:44that we can look after all our aids patients.
- 19:48I must just point out that 83% of aid spending comes from South Africa anyway, but 17% doesn't.
- 19:55That used to come from the Americans. And that 17% cannot just be left to die. We must
- 20:01deal with that. So I think we must have a greater sense of urgency in fixing our problems
- 20:08and getting our own show on the road.
- 20:10Thank you very much.
- 20:11Thank you.
- 20:12Until next time, goodbye.