Latest / Onramp Bitcoin Media / Scarce Assets E015: The Undeniable Societal Benefits of Bitcoin with Troy Cross
Transcript
- 0:00Let's be clear, Bitcoin is an international asset.
- 0:04We are spending like drunken sailors.
- 0:08Bitcoin is the only economic entity where the supply is
- 0:12unaffected by the demand if you want to preserve.
- 0:16Your wealth. You have to.
- 0:17Convert that currency into an asset that's scarce, desirable,
- 0:22portable, durable, and maintainable.
- 0:31Hello, my name is Andy Edstrom and I'm happy to welcome you to
- 0:34the 15th episode of Scarce Assets, a show that examined
- 0:38scarcity, the most fundamental driver of economics and markets
- 0:41and the scarcest asset of all, which is Bitcoin.
- 0:44I'm delighted to be here with my Co host, Jesse Myers as always,
- 0:47and our guest, Troy Cross. A Troy is professor of
- 0:51philosophy and Humanities at Reed College.
- 0:54Prior to coming to Read, he held positions at Yale and Oxford,
- 0:58and Troy's philosophical research interests center around
- 1:02foundational issues in metaphysics and epistemology.
- 1:06But he's also been involved in Bitcoin for over a decade.
- 1:09And in my personal view, he has been instrumental, perhaps more
- 1:14so than anyone, certainly more than anyone I know, in examining
- 1:18and really impacting the narrative in a positive way
- 1:22around Bitcoin mining's environmental impact and energy
- 1:26usage of Bitcoin as well. So I'm very excited to talk with
- 1:30Troy about this topic and others.
- 1:33So, Troy, thank you for coming on Scarce Assets.
- 1:36How are you? I'm good, I'm good.
- 1:39Thank you for having me on. That was quite, quite an
- 1:42introduction. It's really it's great to be
- 1:44here. Well, it's awesome that you're
- 1:47here with us. And I want to start this
- 1:50conversation with a quick anecdote.
- 1:52Couple months ago, I flew to flew to Portland for the Bitcoin
- 1:56is for Everyone conference. It was a fantastic event.
- 1:59Hats off to Eddie and Julia and Eric and everyone who pitched in
- 2:04for it, including a bunch of great local Bitcoiners,
- 2:09obviously including you since that's your home territory.
- 2:13And there was a speakers dinner, and Troy and I were seated
- 2:15across from each other, and we got to compare notes on creating
- 2:19and managing paper wallets. Now, this concept probably
- 2:24sounds ridiculous today, but it made a lot of sense to us, I
- 2:27guess, seven or eight years ago. And I was wondering if you'd be
- 2:30willing to comment on that particular era in Bitcoin either
- 2:35in general or specifically for you?
- 2:38Yeah, yeah, I've never talked about this on a podcast before
- 2:44or publicly, but I I made, I've made a lot of mistakes with my
- 2:50Bitcoin. The alpaca stocks is just like
- 2:52the tip of the mistake. Mountain, iceberg, whatever.
- 2:59Yeah, in the early days of Bitcoin, you know, you just use
- 3:04your Bitcoin QT wallet. And that was, that was like just
- 3:12just fine, except you had this wallet dot DAT file sitting on
- 3:16your computer waiting to be stolen.
- 3:18And people got really paranoid about their computers being
- 3:23hacked because we were, you know, they're just normal
- 3:25machines online. And it's very easy to search for
- 3:29this file if you have access to the machine.
- 3:30So yeah, we started making paper wallets, which is basically just
- 3:35a pair of a public key and a private key.
- 3:38And so you, you print, you, you generate this, you generate a a
- 3:46private key, drive a wallet from it and, and then send funds to
- 3:52the wallet. And then you have a print out
- 3:55with both of these numbers and the QR code.
- 3:57And there was some code that you could use to generate these
- 4:00numbers. And there are different sites
- 4:04that you could use to do it. I, I used to use
- 4:06blockchain.info. Now blockchain.com as my kind of
- 4:10like launching point. That's what I used for just to,
- 4:13to, to browse the blockchain itself.
- 4:16And they had a link to a, a, a wallet generator, paper wallet
- 4:22generator. What was it called was.
- 4:24It bit was it bitaddress.org? I believe that was it.
- 4:27I think that was it there. There was another like Bitcoin
- 4:30paper wallet generator.com or something long name like that
- 4:32too. But you could go to the site,
- 4:37you could check that the code was from the site, you know,
- 4:41matched the repositories code you could generate, you could
- 4:46generate some randomness through cursor movements on your screen.
- 4:50And so you weren't just relying on a on an algorithm to generate
- 4:54the number. By the way, cursor, cursor
- 4:59movements, in case anyone's wondering, and in case anyone's
- 5:02watching video right now, it meant taking your mouse and your
- 5:04hand and going like this really fast, waving your mouse.
- 5:08That's it. Yeah.
- 5:10Wow. It's weird.
- 5:11It's been so long since I did this, right?
- 5:13But yeah, this was state-of-the-art, you know,
- 5:17security, print a paper wallet, print a couple copies, do it on
- 5:20a printer that is a, a dumb printer.
- 5:24Even so, don't trust the dumb printer and destroy it if
- 5:28necessary or certainly just make sure nobody gets access to it or
- 5:31it's never, you know, connected to anything online.
- 5:37And and then guard those paper wallets, you know, and it
- 5:41worked. It worked fine.
- 5:43You can still, you can still recover funds from paper
- 5:46wallets, but it, it, it wasn't as good as a, as a, as a
- 5:54dedicated hardware wallet in many respects.
- 5:56We just didn't have those back then.
- 5:58You know, you, yeah, you didn't have an ex pub that then
- 6:02generated a bunch of public wallets.
- 6:04You just had like pairs of public and private wallets,
- 6:07public and private keys. But there are multiple ways in
- 6:12which the system failed. One is is just very easy to lose
- 6:17a piece of paper. Sure.
- 6:19Especially if you have kids and that happened to me once.
- 6:24I won't, I won't say the amount that I lost is too painful.
- 6:29The other thing that can happen and this did happen was that the
- 6:31site that held the code was like purchased and then that random
- 6:39number generator that that code was code was Co opted and the
- 6:45code it was replaced with like produced only like 10 different
- 6:50public. It corresponded to like 10
- 6:52different keys. And every once in a while,
- 6:56someone would lose money from from this because they wisely to
- 7:00keep the scam going, only scan for wallets that held large
- 7:04amounts. And then we just occasionally
- 7:07spend from one of these wallets. And yeah, a very sophisticated
- 7:12attack. I did not thankfully lose any
- 7:15Bitcoin to that attack. But yeah, the the, the kind of
- 7:23responsibility that Bitcoin teaches you, it's new to the to
- 7:30the modern. It's kind of mind blowing.
- 7:31To the modern man, I'm losing your.
- 7:33Signal, by the way, you cut out for a SEC.
- 7:36Oh, sorry, sorry. We you cut out for a second
- 7:39there Troy. I, I was just going to augment
- 7:40that under score that. So first of all, amazing the
- 7:43long con, right? Whoever was running that, that
- 7:46site, you know, first it worked and then they disabled or
- 7:50crippled it and then, as you said, they only, you know,
- 7:52occasionally picked off unsuspecting, you know,
- 7:56unsuspecting users. Yeah, I I haven't heard about
- 7:58that at all. Is that is that like a well
- 8:00publicized attack that or is that kept it really small?
- 8:05I don't have it like documented, but I when I was having paper
- 8:09wallet issues, it was on the the Reddit, the subreddit or
- 8:14Bitcoin. That's where it was discussed.
- 8:17I think probably multiple times. People losing money to the to
- 8:21that, yeah. I mean.
- 8:25Very clever. Yeah, so I'll, I'll add my two
- 8:27sets, my personal experience with Paperwalt, so
- 8:29bidaddress.org. So what I did is I I read this
- 8:33somewhere, I downloaded, loaded the HTML so and then I took a
- 8:38virgin computer. It was running Windows.
- 8:42So then I had the file, it was not Internet connected, did the
- 8:44key generation, as you said, you know, hooked up the the printer
- 8:48which is not Internet connected and then and generated keys.
- 8:52And then, yeah, the, the first time my son saw the inside of a
- 8:57printer was when I tore down that printer.
- 9:00And he got to wield the hammer and crush everything, you know,
- 9:05every piece of hardware in that computer, in that printer that
- 9:09looked like a memory chip, you know, including the, you know,
- 9:12any screen, any screen elements. And then and then we did the
- 9:16same with the PC. So he got to see all the inside
- 9:20parts of a of a PC as we disassembled it and crushed
- 9:25every piece of possible memory in it.
- 9:28Good times. I think, I mean you took more
- 9:30steps than I did, I think I just booted from AUSB stick on my
- 9:35regular computer, ran the code in there.
- 9:39I had a dumb, I had a very, very old printer.
- 9:42I wasn't super worried about the printer barely worked and but it
- 9:47was, it was a really tremendous level of responsibility.
- 9:50And I can't say that I passed the test either, but it taught
- 9:54me something, right? Like the one way you learn is by
- 9:56like actually screwing up and losing money or making mistakes
- 10:00and freaking out. It's like the only way to really
- 10:03learn for me anyway. Maybe other people can learn
- 10:06from my mistakes, but I had to learn from my own mistakes and
- 10:11and do what you just did, Andy, like think through all the
- 10:14possibilities. It's part of what the appeal of
- 10:17Bitcoin is like that radical responsibility that you don't
- 10:21really face in many other areas of life.
- 10:23You have to compare it to something like having kids, you
- 10:25know, you come home for the hospital, you're like, that's
- 10:28total responsibility. And you feel something similar
- 10:30when you take your coin off exchanges.
- 10:34And it's it's, it's totally on you.
- 10:38It is. It absolutely.
- 10:40It absolutely is. Did you ever, ever do any paper
- 10:42walls? Jesse, you want to admit?
- 10:45Yeah, I played around with, with some of that stuff.
- 10:48You know, back back when you guys were doing that, I was
- 10:51juggling, you know, different altcoins and trying to figure
- 10:53out the best way to do paper wallets for different altcoins.
- 10:56You know, 'cause that's, that's the path I was on then, you
- 11:00know, took a few years before I figured out that all that was
- 11:03hooey. That's another level.
- 11:05Well, I was also messing around with altcoins.
- 11:08I just wasn't dedicated enough to figure out a paper wallet
- 11:11method for the altcoins. I think those just sat on
- 11:13exchange for me at that time. Yeah, yeah, there there were
- 11:17some that made it easy ish and then some that were not so easy.
- 11:20And so, you know, I had like a weird system of like, OK, here
- 11:24are the here are the ones that I have material amounts and then
- 11:27I've taken them offline and paper wallets and here's the
- 11:29ones that I don't. It was a mess and a lot simpler
- 11:34with with just Bitcoin. But then still, I mean, to the,
- 11:37to the problem you guys are sort of trying to solve, like no, no,
- 11:41Bitcoin self custody solution is entirely comfortable, right?
- 11:45Because like you, you have this, you know, radical responsibility
- 11:50in, in one basket. You know, for, for most
- 11:53Bitcoiners, they've, they've taken self custody into, into
- 11:56one basket that they've set up a certain method.
- 11:58And, and that that is part of, you know, why we, we started on
- 12:03ramp to create a method of, of custody that allows for the user
- 12:08to retain total control while having a, a, a method that
- 12:13doesn't involve having to set up your own self custody and set up
- 12:16your own keys and maintain perfect security of them.
- 12:19So you can, so you can have a world where you have yourself
- 12:21custody basket and this other multi institution custody basket
- 12:25and have two different, your eggs in two different baskets.
- 12:28That actually was kind of the the big step for me to start to
- 12:31really feel more comfortable with my Bitcoin custody solution
- 12:35because you know until that time that the radical responsibility
- 12:38and having it all, all your eggs in one basket is quite scary.
- 12:44At Onramp, we believe that Bitcoin is the most important
- 12:47asset of the 21st century. The hard part is securing it
- 12:50right. There are shortcomings with
- 12:52keeping your coins on an exchange, but also with setting
- 12:55up your own self custody arrangement.
- 12:58Onramp solves for these concerns.
- 13:00Our multi institution custody solution maximizes security and
- 13:04minimizes counterparty risk, ensuring that your Bitcoin
- 13:07remains securely in your possession and provides built in
- 13:10inheritance planning to ensure your family is protected as
- 13:13well. On Ramp provides Peace of Mind
- 13:16for your Bitcoin journey, whether for your whole stack or
- 13:19for part of it as a compliment to your existing self custody
- 13:22set up. For more information, check us
- 13:24out at on rampbitcoin.com. Yeah, and I've had problems on
- 13:30the custodial side as well, like pretty much anybody who's been
- 13:33here long enough, right, so. You third party custody or yeah.
- 13:38Yeah, yeah, the block blockchain.info where I got the
- 13:44link to the Bitcoin paper wallet generator also used to give out
- 13:50like vouchers. You could send people Bitcoin,
- 13:52but sending them Bitcoin was like actually a voucher from you
- 13:58would send Bitcoin to blockchain.info and they would
- 14:00send somebody an e-mail with like a, a, a, a link which they
- 14:05could use to then set up a wallet and send themselves
- 14:09Bitcoin. Those links I, I sent to my
- 14:12colleagues at the college I teach at still in 2013, I sent
- 14:17all the economists all, you know, like, you know, .1 Bitcoin
- 14:23or something like that. And, and some of my, some of my
- 14:28other colleagues, but especially the Economist, because we had
- 14:30debates about it back then. And you know, during the spike a
- 14:35couple years ago, you know, bitcoins like hitting 50,000 or
- 14:38whatever. I got these emails from some of
- 14:40them like, hey, Troy, I don't know how to get that Bitcoin
- 14:44that you sent me like, you know, nine years ago, like how do I do
- 14:49that? And I was like, well, you should
- 14:51just click on the link, you know, and there the, the link is
- 14:544/04 it goes to no, it goes nowhere.
- 14:56Wow. I contact blockchain.info and
- 14:59they're like, they're, they don't exist anymore, right?
- 15:00It's blockchain.com. Those URLs don't exist.
- 15:03They're like, you have an e-mail.
- 15:05We don't know. That's from us, you know, So it
- 15:07was all just gone. Wow, so I went so.
- 15:10So I want to get philosophical now, because this is your.
- 15:13This. Is your area of no, no, no, this
- 15:15is your area of expertise. I'm gonna, I'm gonna tie this
- 15:17together. So one of the ways to think
- 15:20about Bitcoin custody or holding Bitcoin right is in some sense
- 15:25probabilistic, right? So, you know, it's like, yes, I
- 15:29know I had the coins or I was sure I had the coins, you know,
- 15:32nine years ago. Now I may be less sure.
- 15:35And when I go to test it, oh, turns out, you know, turns out
- 15:40it wasn't there after all. Now I know you, you are
- 15:44knowledgeable on epistemology. Some of that analysis tries,
- 15:49tries to focus on certainty, but some things are not certain,
- 15:52including do you have control over your particular Bitcoin
- 15:57private keys? Is that a topic that's that
- 16:00you've thought much about as it within that philosophical
- 16:04framework? I have actually, you know, that
- 16:07just somebody made this point on Twitter recently and it was
- 16:10exactly the, the way I formulated it.
- 16:12But, you know, you don't really own Bitcoin or have Bitcoin.
- 16:18I mean, you can legally be entitled to it, but the
- 16:22fundamental mechanism is control.
- 16:24It's the word you used. It's like, do you have control
- 16:27over and it over a given address?
- 16:32Like that's the question. Do you have will the, will the
- 16:35Bitcoin network recognize your commands to, to transact?
- 16:42Will they recognize your signature and do what you want
- 16:45them to do like all of those nodes?
- 16:47And, and that's a new model. That's not how other kinds of
- 16:51ownership or control work. And it's not just that, but it's
- 16:54like solo control. Like if other people have your
- 16:57keys, but they haven't spent it yet, like maybe you printed a
- 16:59Bitcoin paper wallet, you put some money there.
- 17:02You didn't realize that that those keys are actually
- 17:04controlled by somebody else. You also have control of the
- 17:06keys. You know, that's a weird new
- 17:08status. It's like somebody else has the
- 17:10keys to your car. You have them too, but it's kind
- 17:14of, but it's just whoever gets in the car drives off first, can
- 17:17send it to a new location and then own it solo, right?
- 17:20That's that's very new. And I think, I think the
- 17:23difficulty of wrapping your head around that is part like what
- 17:27stands in the way of people adopting Bitcoin.
- 17:29They're not comfortable with the uncertainty about whether they
- 17:32have control and like having to check and they're not
- 17:35comfortable with that model. They want to like, they want to
- 17:38possess something like a like a rock like gold or they want
- 17:42somebody to owe them like a bank that they can trust and they
- 17:45don't have to deal with that, right.
- 17:47I mean, if you think about it really, I mean, I am an
- 17:49epistemologist. Like nothing is certain.
- 17:51You think the banks are certain? You think your ownership of gold
- 17:53is certain? Like.
- 17:55No. Anything, anything can be taken
- 17:59from you when you think you have it, you know, like it can be
- 18:02seized because you don't pay taxes or the institutions can
- 18:05collapse or, you know, natural disasters can happen, whatever
- 18:09like. So I don't think there's any
- 18:12more inherent uncertainty around Bitcoin.
- 18:14In fact, I think Bitcoin ownership and control, once you
- 18:18know what you're doing is probably as certain as anything,
- 18:21or if not more certain, it's just less familiar, right?
- 18:25So you can't have perfect certainty, but like you can
- 18:29check pretty easily see whether this private key actually
- 18:34controls the Bitcoin in that public address.
- 18:37And that's easier than figuring out whether there is a banking
- 18:41crisis that is going to like make the local bank that you
- 18:44have funds in full and whether FDIC is going to handle the
- 18:48strain when banks start collapsing.
- 18:50Like, I can't know that stuff as easily as checking whether my
- 18:54Bitcoin is actually under my control.
- 18:56So it it's seems foreign and unfamiliar, but it's actually
- 18:59this new epistemic paradigm which once you get there, is
- 19:04peak certainty for for human beings and property.
- 19:09Pretty amazing, pretty amazing situation.
- 19:12I have to confess, I've been thinking more recently, Tori,
- 19:16about one of the one of the things I think about with
- 19:19respect to investments and just for a second, what's called
- 19:22Bitcoin and investment. Humor me.
- 19:25You know, what's the rank ordering of my certainty of
- 19:29property rights in a given investment.
- 19:32And when I think about the value of the investment, I think
- 19:34about, oh, it's the in the future, what is the value of
- 19:38that investment? And perhaps it's multiplied by
- 19:40my percentage certainty out of 100% that I actually will
- 19:44possess it at that future date. And so I've been focusing, most
- 19:49investors, I think focus more on the valuation, right, The first
- 19:52part of the, of the, of the multiplier.
- 19:56But I've been thinking more lately about the second part of
- 19:58the multiplier, which is yeah, the the certainty.
- 20:01Of ownership and possession and I've been thinking in terms of
- 20:04Bitcoin for me, as you just stated, is probably at the top
- 20:07if properly secured. And then below that probably is
- 20:10maybe my house that I'm literally living in and can
- 20:13defend. You know, below that maybe is
- 20:15stocks and bonds, if I'm AUS citizen and those are domestic
- 20:20assets, you know foreign assets may might depend on the
- 20:23jurisdiction, etcetera, etcetera.
- 20:26And yeah, I think it's something that that we all, all investors
- 20:31need to think about and all, you know, people who have any
- 20:35interest or exposure to Bitcoin need to think about.
- 20:39Yeah. So much of our ownership is
- 20:40mediated by institutions and your certainty depends on your
- 20:44faith in those institutions. Right now, faith in institutions
- 20:48across the board. Is that like an all time low and
- 20:51it's collapsing. And I don't think that's just
- 20:54collective hallucination. I think we are picking up on
- 20:57some underlying vibe that our institutions are actually
- 21:01fragile in a way that we we didn't think they were.
- 21:07And so, yeah, I like your calculation.
- 21:09I think it's going to become like we're going to have risk in
- 21:12terms of asset pricing risk and we're going to have custody
- 21:16control risk as a separate dimension of risk and both will
- 21:20have to be multiplied through the expected value.
- 21:27I wonder if there's like is an impediment to adoption because
- 21:31people have to wrestle with this reality that you, that you need
- 21:36to figure out certainty and how comfortable you are.
- 21:40Whereas with the, the assets that Andy listed off, you know,
- 21:43they're all those are obfuscated away from the end.
- 21:48And so we just don't think about it.
- 21:51And you know, obviously with Bitcoin, you have to think about
- 21:54it. You have to make a conscious
- 21:56decision about how you're going to hold this asset and, and
- 21:58choose your path. Whereas, you know, with
- 22:01everything else, it's, it's just taken care of for you behind the
- 22:04scenes. I was wondering if there's,
- 22:06there's maybe there's an irony there of like possibly to make
- 22:09it through deeper into the bell curve of adopters, you have to
- 22:16reach a, a simpler format, a like more obfuscated norms of
- 22:21how Bitcoin custody is handled so that people aren't, you know,
- 22:26creating the their, their, their own red flags, their own hang
- 22:30ups, their own impediments as they worry about how to choose
- 22:34the right path for custody and, and, and and improve their
- 22:38certainty. Yeah, totally.
- 22:40And, and I think, you know, that's how I think of the ETFs
- 22:44and, and the custody solutions that are better custody than,
- 22:49you know, trusting Mount G Ox or Quadriga or whatever we've had
- 22:53thus far, right. And it's like, well, at least if
- 22:56we get like, if we get to the top of the kind of trust food
- 22:59chain, that's, that's, you know, that's much better than than fly
- 23:04by night operations. When I, when I checked, I think
- 23:08we said this that evening too, Andy, when I checked back in on
- 23:11my old like accounts on some of the early exchanges, they were
- 23:16all gone. They just didn't exist anymore.
- 23:19I went through my password manager, like anybody who had
- 23:23money on, you know, BTCE or whatever, it's poof or many of
- 23:28these changes have gone. So it, it's, I think, I think
- 23:33the, the ETFs obviously pose risks is too much of Bitcoin
- 23:38gets custody and they're not really crossing the chasm of
- 23:40self custody, but it, it maybe it's a step for a lot of people.
- 23:48It's like, well, I have I have somebody else hold it that I
- 23:50trust and meantime I can read up on what what to trustless
- 23:54solutions look like and and take some that way too and then
- 23:57comfortably like shift it over like on ramp type solutions.
- 24:02Yeah. It raises this question of a bit
- 24:05of a existential one really of like will the like local
- 24:09optimum, you know, of ETFs, will that be good enough for long
- 24:15enough that it ingests too much and possibly still have an
- 24:20Achilles heel that is then manifested and and creates a
- 24:25calamity? Or is that solution actually
- 24:29going to go the distance And you know, that local optimum turns
- 24:32out to be a, a global, you know, optimum it, I guess that becomes
- 24:38like it, it becomes a philosophical question of, you
- 24:41know, have we gotten to good enough institutional custody
- 24:45yet? Big question.
- 24:49We'll see, right? Time will tell.
- 24:51Time will tell. So yeah, so let's, I don't know,
- 24:53let's stay in the philosophical realm here a little bit.
- 24:57So the we talked about philosophical elements of of
- 25:01property rights and where and where Bitcoin fits in.
- 25:05And we talked about uncertainty, I guess.
- 25:10What about information asymmetry as a are there elements there
- 25:17that interest you with respect to how Bitcoin gets adopted or
- 25:23frankly any elements within Bitcoin?
- 25:25I mean, I could argue the information asymmetry has been
- 25:28the situation that you've been attacking with respect to energy
- 25:32usage and the grid, but any thoughts come to mind there?
- 25:38Yeah, well, I mean, I'm reminded of Jesse's amazing essay, which
- 25:45I I told Andy I've on multiple occasions, started writing this
- 25:50thing and then realized that I it was already written.
- 25:54You know, I was like, oh, yeah, that's already been done.
- 25:56I I think it's Andrew Bailey who told me that first.
- 25:59So I was like, I had this essay idea and I'd started writing it
- 26:02already. And he's like, have you read
- 26:04this piece by a Creasus about the yuppie elite and why they
- 26:08don't get Bitcoin? And it's like, Oh yeah, oh,
- 26:11yeah. So it's not somewhere deep in my
- 26:14subconscious, that whole piece, but that is the epistemic
- 26:18asymmetry across all issues having to do with Bitcoin.
- 26:21The yuppie elite doesn't need it.
- 26:24They're served very well by the existing system.
- 26:26And then you watch what happens is this amazing opportunity
- 26:31basically for everybody who's not that elite to flip the
- 26:35script. Suddenly we have this massive
- 26:37advantage. They're blinded by their lack of
- 26:41a need for good money, so they don't care to learn about it.
- 26:45They're served by the current system, so you can get ahead of
- 26:48all of them. And that's like such a wild
- 26:52opportunity. I mean, it's really is why I'm
- 26:55in the space. Like, that's why I in public,
- 26:57like, say everything. Seeing this, seeing me say
- 27:00asymmetry. Craig Warnke has like a ladder,
- 27:03the prestige ladder, where the higher you go on the prestige
- 27:07ladder, the less you know and the more lower you go, the more
- 27:10you know about Bitcoin. Love it.
- 27:13And it's like time and again it proves out it's the Midwest meme
- 27:17too. I mean, this has all been done
- 27:18on Twitter and being theory, right?
- 27:20Like it's the Midwest meme too. The the vast realm of Midwest
- 27:25that don't get it. And and the problem is that the
- 27:28Midwest rule the world. So we we so did the uppie elite,
- 27:32right? So we have like policy and
- 27:34education and media controlled by people who are on the wrong
- 27:40side of the asymmetry, but they're the ones who are
- 27:42supposed to educate people about emerging technology and issues
- 27:46facing the broader public. So it's like a global epistemic
- 27:50disaster when the people who don't get it are the people who
- 27:55everybody else trusts for their information.
- 27:57And we've had to build this alternative epistemic web
- 28:02basically through institutions like this podcast, like your
- 28:06essays, like, you know, Bitcoin, Twitter, the conference's scene,
- 28:10like this whole thing is an alternative epistemic mechanism
- 28:13of trust and information. You know, that that we that
- 28:19we've had to build it would this wouldn't exist if everybody were
- 28:22doing their jobs. You know what I mean?
- 28:24This whole world wouldn't exist. You'd just have like the same
- 28:27people who teach finance would be teaching Bitcoin.
- 28:30You know, that they they would, they would, they wouldn't be
- 28:31this separate Bitcoin world. And I suspect that that, you
- 28:35know, at some point in the future, I don't know when 1020
- 28:38years, that's what it'll be. You'll just like Bitcoin will
- 28:42just be incorporated into the curriculum of, of energy, of
- 28:45finance, of whatever. You just get all this Bitcoin
- 28:48specific stuff will go away, just like you know, Internet
- 28:52specific stuff or electricity specific stuff like nobody has
- 28:56electricity like conferences where like yay electricity, like
- 29:01everybody is down with electricity, right?
- 29:03That's what happened. So we're in this moment right
- 29:05now of an information asymmetry. All of us are, are, are just
- 29:11blessed to be here, both like financially and more more
- 29:16importantly, we, we have a service to provide for everybody
- 29:21else. It's like, you know, you, you,
- 29:24you know something, it's cool. People don't understand it.
- 29:27I'm a teacher. Like that's what we live for.
- 29:29Like that's the classroom, That's, that's the opportunity
- 29:32to educate. So this is the biggest asymmetry
- 29:34I've ever encountered, you know, And even within the Bitcoin
- 29:39stuff on the energy side, especially when I first started
- 29:42talking about it like three years ago, the what I was seeing
- 29:47talking to people who do it and also just reading people like
- 29:51Nick Carter and Lynn Alden who are writing awesome stuff at the
- 29:54time was so radically different from anything you read in the
- 29:59press or anything anybody said with a degree or any politician
- 30:03said or even any energy person was saying.
- 30:06They were like radically different.
- 30:07One was saying Bitcoin is this unique consumer of energy.
- 30:10It's flexible, It's it's time agnostic, location agnostic,
- 30:13portable, scalable. It's going to clean up waste
- 30:17methane and pair with renewables and go over all all over the
- 30:22world and incentivize electrical infrastructure through being a
- 30:26buyer of first and last resort. That was like the Bitcoin
- 30:29narrative outside the Bitcoin narrative.
- 30:30It was like, there's this terrifying consumer of energy
- 30:33that's going to consume all the world's energy and take us fast
- 30:352°C global warming just all on its own from pre industrial
- 30:40times. And it's really bad and we have
- 30:43to end it or it ends us. And those were like the two
- 30:46existing narratives, like talk of somebody had to be right,
- 30:49somebody had to be wrong. And it became clearer and
- 30:52clearer that everything Nick and Lynn were saying were was true
- 30:56and everything and, and the fear mongering was, was massively
- 31:01overblown and bogus. And now that is a lot clearer,
- 31:05right. That epistemic asymmetry is far
- 31:07from closed, but it has massively begun to close.
- 31:12And I think on the financial side, too, we've seen, you know,
- 31:15the the ETFs for for better, for worse are a recognition that
- 31:19that gap between the yuppie elite and the plebs is narrowed
- 31:24significantly. We had Larry Fink saying flight
- 31:27to quality about Bitcoin, like, OK, the the delta there is not
- 31:31what it used to be epistemically right.
- 31:34And I do think that some point that closes it.
- 31:37And you, you know what I mean? There's nothing more for us to
- 31:39do except just like what whatever we were doing
- 31:43beforehand or you know what I mean?
- 31:44But like make the world better in some other way.
- 31:47But right now there's still the gap.
- 31:49We're still closing. Yeah, totally.
- 31:51It, it, it, it always comes back for me to, you know, like the
- 31:57the founding father sort of call to action that, you know, that
- 32:01the Bitcoin presents this sort of Greenfield opportunity to
- 32:04really carve out like a, a a stance intellectually and be
- 32:13totally in the minority and feel very passionately about like,
- 32:17no, this is the future and This is why.
- 32:19And here are the things that are valuable and then manifest that
- 32:22make that happen through, you know, through the viral efforts
- 32:29of Bitcoin educators in the same way that, you know, independence
- 32:33minded thought leaders, I guess of, of, of that era would have
- 32:38done. And you know that then, you
- 32:41know, when you put in that kind of context and perspective, it,
- 32:44it's the calling of a lifetime to participate in, in taking
- 32:49this thing that is not well understood and has such
- 32:52incredible potential for helping the common man.
- 32:56And also, you know, civilizational development.
- 33:01It's crazy. Everything, everything that you
- 33:04hope for in in the Western school of thought of like what
- 33:07you know, what the world can be Bitcoin AIDS and, and yet it, it
- 33:12needs champions and it needs that viral coefficient to drive
- 33:17it to fruition. And so it's, you know, creates
- 33:20this opportunity for for folks like us to step aside from what
- 33:25we were doing to participate in the revolution just enough to to
- 33:30help the cause. All right, that's really well
- 33:33said. And, and yeah, it, it, it's
- 33:35weird being a philosopher and being in this space because I,
- 33:41I've never my, my philosophical work, like Andy said, it's in
- 33:44metaphysics and epistemology. It's been very limited to my,
- 33:50you know, my personal effects on students and how they think and
- 33:56also my professional colleagues in my, in my fields of study,
- 34:01right? That's been my sphere of
- 34:02influence. And the amount that I influence
- 34:06people in the ways in which I influence people, it's, it's
- 34:08very modest. That's not to say it's not
- 34:10worthwhile. It can be very rewarding.
- 34:13And I owe a lot to my own teachers for putting themselves
- 34:16into their work with me. But Bitcoin is like, the reason
- 34:20I can't walk away from it. It's like, like you said, a
- 34:25civilizational shift, which you could be a part of and help
- 34:30shape and bring about and understand and lead in.
- 34:35And it it does, it does promise to, yeah.
- 34:40Democratize, for lack of a better word, the power over
- 34:46value storage and transfer. And that is like democratizing
- 34:52information or democratizing other forms of power, like
- 34:56political power. And that that is immense in its
- 35:01impact. And yeah, you have an
- 35:05opportunity to to be there early and lead in it.
- 35:10It's kind of crazy, actually. It's kind of crazy that we have
- 35:15that opportunity. I mean, it's really hard, even
- 35:18though having read your essay, it, it, it's hard for me to
- 35:22understand not seeing this thing for what it is.
- 35:26And it gets harder with time. Like, OK, in, in, in 2011, I
- 35:31remember Gavin saying, you know, we'd probably fail, but it's a
- 35:35worthwhile experience and experiment.
- 35:36And it has like this incredible upside.
- 35:38I think that was a rational position in 2011.
- 35:41It was a tiny project. But it's so weird when you hear
- 35:462011 style objections in 2024 and people who are really well
- 35:51equipped otherwise to to get in on this conceptually and
- 35:57socially. Like just just this morning, the
- 36:00other philosophers and I were talking about political science
- 36:04and Andrew's looking up in the leading political science
- 36:07journals, how many like articles have been written about Bitcoin
- 36:11In the leading 2, there's one article about Bitcoin.
- 36:15Well, and it's not even really like focused directly on
- 36:18Bitcoin, but like here's this phenomenon.
- 36:20It's been here since 2009. It has already radically changed
- 36:23our world. The leading political science
- 36:25journals have shut it out entirely as a topic
- 36:28conversation. And when they do talk about it
- 36:30informally, it's about how Bitcoin, people who are into
- 36:33Bitcoin are like psychopaths. They're, you know, the dark
- 36:36tetrad, whatever they it's just like they're bad people.
- 36:40What an amazing opportunity for anybody in that field to step in
- 36:45and, and, and define the how Bitcoin changes politics.
- 36:49They don't like. I, I think about that sometimes.
- 36:53I, I wonder if the, you know, the gospel of, of what people
- 36:56believe political action can and should look like is sort of, you
- 37:01know, Occupy Wall Street style, like protests.
- 37:06And here is this alternative model that's basically
- 37:10intransigent of like, OK, fine, we'll build our own system and
- 37:12it's going to be better. And then eventually everybody's
- 37:15going to use that system because it's better.
- 37:17Fuck you. Like that's, that's the core of
- 37:20Bitcoin. And that is so counter to, I
- 37:24guess, like the the 1960s sort of distilled essence of what
- 37:30political action can and should look like in, you know, liberal
- 37:34society. And I wonder if that is the
- 37:37impediment there. Yep.
- 37:39Is political action like demanding better from our
- 37:43leaders? That's like one model, right?
- 37:45Like go to mom and dad. Mom and Dad give us something.
- 37:49Better. Yeah, exactly that.
- 37:52Once you have that in mind, just like demand better.
- 37:54And then your achievement is actually when they capitulate
- 37:57and give you what you want, that's like, oh, job, mission
- 38:00accomplished. We're done here as opposed to,
- 38:04you know, an engineering model of action where we we know we
- 38:09are actually, we're not going to delegate.
- 38:12We're not going to demand a solution to a problem and
- 38:15delegate the creation of that solution.
- 38:17We are going to solve it like, you know, with our own, with our
- 38:22own. And then we're going to make it
- 38:23a voluntary system that you can join or not join.
- 38:25We're not going to force it on you.
- 38:26So when it's just working entirely outside the political
- 38:29realm. And yeah, I think that's a big
- 38:30part of why why, you know, political science maybe hasn't,
- 38:37hasn't, you know, taken it up seriously.
- 38:40And similar for for econ. It's just outside it.
- 38:45It's it wasn't invented by an economist.
- 38:47It it backtracks in their moral arc of history, you know, back
- 38:51to the barbarous relic. Like we passed that money is
- 38:54dead. Come on, we like we cut the
- 38:55tide. Like, how could you be going
- 38:57backwards? So it where it, it's so weird in
- 39:02the Academy, we should be way out in front on this stuff.
- 39:07Like think about it. We have the best university
- 39:10system in the world in America, we have, we pour billions and
- 39:14billions of dollars into the knowledge economy.
- 39:17And what we want to do is like precisely to stay out in front
- 39:21of changes in society, understand them before they're
- 39:24happening or as they're happening, right?
- 39:26And, and to inform the public and lawmakers on, on what they
- 39:30mean and how best to deal with it, right?
- 39:32That's our job. And, and instead we're like a
- 39:35trailing indicator for true revolutionary changes.
- 39:39And we're trailing pretty far. Like on the energy stuff, when
- 39:43you talk to academics, they're much farther behind than the
- 39:45people who are in the energy world, right?
- 39:47And the people in the energy world are behind the people who
- 39:49are like actually doing the Bitcoin stuff.
- 39:51So once you start investigating this, it's really weird.
- 39:53It's like people want peer reviewed sources.
- 39:57Well, there aren't any peer reviewed sources or there
- 39:59weren't. There are some now because the,
- 40:02the people doing the reviewing and the people doing the
- 40:04studying are detached from what's actually what's actually
- 40:07happening instead of, instead of leading it right.
- 40:10And it's so it's, it's, it's really educated me about the lag
- 40:15in the Academy itself and the fundamentally conservative
- 40:19nature of science where you are protecting an existing paradigm.
- 40:24From threats to it, rather than jumping on anomalies as an
- 40:29opportunity for revolutionary science, what can we call
- 40:32revolutionary science, right? You see you see you see an
- 40:35anomaly in physics, something you didn't expect in the
- 40:38Collider, like something you really didn't expect.
- 40:40You think, OK, my Collider is probably like my data is off
- 40:43because my something's broken and and I should go and check my
- 40:46equipment. If you check your equipment, you
- 40:48run the experiments again, and you're still getting stuff that
- 40:51you wouldn't predict given the best theories, you get really
- 40:55excited. That means fundamental physics
- 40:58is wrong. And you, you are the the cost of
- 41:01discovering the truth about fundamental physics.
- 41:05But when economists see an anomaly that lasts well over a
- 41:10decade and keeps defying their theory, that's not their
- 41:13response. The response isn't like, oh,
- 41:15we're we're wrong. Let's, that's awesome.
- 41:17We're discovering how value actually works.
- 41:20No, no, it's like just double down.
- 41:21I mean, like maybe we, if we say enough bad things about it, we
- 41:25can tell it and then we will have been right all along.
- 41:28It's so weird. Which is the difference between
- 41:31physical science and social science?
- 41:33We must, we must acknowledge as it's a it's a lot easier to
- 41:36falsify and and prove things in, in physical science.
- 41:39But I got to tell you, Troy, one of the things that gives me hope
- 41:42about the Academy, including the social sciences, is you as a
- 41:46case study. Because you are a good example
- 41:49of someone who probably had quite a bit to lose
- 41:53reputationally for being wrong and for also fighting the
- 41:58narrative. Like as wrong as the narrative
- 42:00about the environmental and energy usage elements with
- 42:04Bitcoin was at the time. It probably was the proper, I'm
- 42:08guessing it was the, you know, it was the popular narrative,
- 42:12perhaps especially in the Pacific Northwest, where you
- 42:15where you ply your trade. And so, you know, my hat's off
- 42:18to you for going in the opposite direction hard and, you know,
- 42:25surviving to tell the tale. I think that's a good sign for
- 42:29the long run for, you know, academics, acceptance and
- 42:34willingness to explore Bitcoin. But you know, you're, you're
- 42:38clearly on the on the bleeding edge and clearly the herd has
- 42:41not caught up with you. So maybe it won't for a while.
- 42:45Yeah, I appreciate that, Andy. And I'll say, you know, I
- 42:48suffered some blowback. I've been cancelled by a lot of
- 42:51environmentalists, but my colleagues at my college have
- 42:56been extremely open minded and gracious.
- 42:59And it reminds you when you have these experiences that you know,
- 43:04behind the polarization and the tribal politics, people are
- 43:08people. Like people are people.
- 43:11That goes for students, that goes for colleagues,
- 43:13administrators. We get caught up in political
- 43:16games that pit US against each other.
- 43:18But fundamentally, people want to know the truth.
- 43:20Like people want to understand stuff.
- 43:22And if you build relationships, I was lucky to be I was lucky to
- 43:27be at read a while before I started talking all the crazy
- 43:29Bitcoin talk. And so I had friendships and
- 43:33relationships. And like when your friend starts
- 43:35telling you something that they you know, understand or know or
- 43:39are working through, you deal with them as a person.
- 43:42And ultimately, that's how this information asymmetry gets
- 43:46closed. Like person by person, you get
- 43:50somebody saying, yeah, I thought this was nuts, but actually I
- 43:53just didn't get it. And it goes, you know,
- 43:55relationship by relationship until takes over.
- 43:58And, and, and yeah, easy. It's really easy to stand
- 44:02outside the Academy and say they're caught, caught up in.
- 44:06And I guess I just did say that we're caught up in defending old
- 44:08paradigms, but science is science, and like, scientists
- 44:13want to get at the truth. Ultimately, they're driven by
- 44:16curiosity and the joy of discovery, and you just have to
- 44:19find a way to tap that. Does your Bitcoin custody setup
- 44:23keep you up at night? Maybe you still have coins
- 44:26sitting on an exchange worried about hackers.
- 44:28Or maybe you've set up your own self custody, but don't feel
- 44:30safe with your Bitcoin savings stashed on a little plastic
- 44:33device in your desk drawer. Gain Peace of Mind with On Ramp
- 44:38and our multi institution custody solution.
- 44:41Here's how it works. Onramp creates a dedicated multi
- 44:43sig vault just for you. 3 separate institutions each hold
- 44:47a key, Onramp bit go and coin cover, but none can move funds
- 44:52unilaterally. Instead only you have control
- 44:55over your coins. With Onramp's multi Institution
- 44:58custody, you'll sleep better at night knowing your Bitcoin is
- 45:01stored with best in class security on chain with fault
- 45:04tolerant multi sig. If you believe your Bitcoin is
- 45:08going to be worth a lot someday, don't jeopardize that future by
- 45:11exposing your coins to hackers on exchanges, $5 wrench attacks
- 45:15in the real world, or perhaps most importantly, the risk that
- 45:19you might screw something up with a highly technical self
- 45:21custody set up on ramps. Multi institution custody
- 45:25eliminates single points of failure, reduces your personal
- 45:28attack surface and technical burden, and provides access to
- 45:32financial services that allow you to confidently secure your
- 45:35Bitcoin, including inheritance planning, insurance backed
- 45:38warranties for all balances and transactions, low cost trading
- 45:41and more. Bitcoin is a once in a species
- 45:45asset, secure it right. Learn more at onrampbitcoin.com.
- 45:50Also credit to to Reed College. Reed has always for me had a
- 45:55reputation of, of being very unconventional, very smart
- 45:59people doing extremely unconventional approaches to, to
- 46:02education. And, you know, I had a few high
- 46:06school friends go to read and, and they kind of fit that mold,
- 46:10you know, super sharp and very unconventional.
- 46:12And, you know, this is, this is a great feather in the cap of,
- 46:16of Reed College of like that model works here for enabling
- 46:20you to think unconventionally and approach this stuff
- 46:24unconventionally. And I'm very interested to see
- 46:26like which institutions get to run up the score with Bitcoin
- 46:30thought leadership and, and attaching their name to like,
- 46:33you know what, we were right early about Bitcoin.
- 46:36And when every, when Harvard and everybody else was saying this
- 46:39was bullshit, we were right early.
- 46:42And, and you know, let's, let's put that on the scoreboard.
- 46:45And so I hope, I hope Reed gets a, a good, a good chunk of those
- 46:48accolades over the coming decades.
- 46:51I'd love to do that. And I, I think University of
- 46:54Wyoming's going to run it up. I think they're, I think
- 46:57they're, I think Texas A&M is running it up.
- 47:01To some extent MIT, although they've made they've made some
- 47:04good and some bad moves, you know, but so many places,
- 47:08because I've been around to different schools doing this,
- 47:11giving little talks and stuff. They are sponsored by the shift
- 47:16coins and like we, we don't have a budget in Bitcoin for any of
- 47:22this stuff, but these other protocols have treasuries of of
- 47:29their own shit coins to sell and spend on sponsoring events and
- 47:36and institutions and, and, and I've I've run into that in real
- 47:39life. You know, I've run into that in
- 47:41real life. I'll.
- 47:42I'll say that there was a, a professor at, at, at Stanford
- 47:46GSB, the Business School that is on the board at Ripple.
- 47:51And so that was the, the, that was the full extent of informed
- 47:56crypto education that we received in 2014 to 2016 that
- 48:02the GSB, well, if you hey, Ripple's pretty good.
- 48:05If you look at Cornell, where we do have some awesome Bitcoiner
- 48:09action and including, you know, Sarah Kreps, who's another
- 48:13fellow at the Bitcoin Policy Institute and we've got an
- 48:19amazing student group led by Ella Hoff that so she she's
- 48:24writing a thesis on on Bitcoin. So we've got a little action
- 48:28there. But if you look at their actual
- 48:31crypto stuff, they've got Ari Jewel who is the chief scientist
- 48:35for chain link, who teaches there in the computer science
- 48:37department. And we've got Emin Gunserer who
- 48:41created Avalanche and they're of course sponsored by Avalabs.
- 48:47That's a big funder, right? So just that's just one school.
- 48:49We could dig it elsewhere, but like, you realize,
- 48:52institutionally there's millions of dollars.
- 48:55I mean, Emin is probably, I don't know how rich he is, but,
- 48:57you know, the protocol has generated tremendous amount of
- 49:00wealth. So I don't know what he's even.
- 49:04Yeah, I don't know what the post even means at this point.
- 49:07You know, he's like, probably a billionaire.
- 49:09So. But how?
- 49:12How can you? Yeah, yeah.
- 49:14Bitcoins journey through academia is stymied on by two
- 49:19things. One is the traditional world.
- 49:21That's just like this stuff is crap.
- 49:23It's it's not pure because it's involved with money.
- 49:27That's what I've run into in some computerized departments.
- 49:29It's like, what are you talking about?
- 49:31We just want to talk about the abstract problem of distributed
- 49:35databases. Why are you bringing money into
- 49:37it? Like, well, how do you think
- 49:39you're going to secure that? You're going to need incentives.
- 49:42OK, but on the other side or, or it's just traditional finance or
- 49:46just, you know, just tradition. On the other hand, we have shit
- 49:50coins dumping money in and buying up the institutions and
- 49:54Bitcoin is caught uncomfortably in the middle.
- 49:56And also computer science wise, it's like the first chapter of
- 49:59the blockchain textbook. You know, the people are just
- 50:01like it's boring, like we want to go and build new stuff.
- 50:04So there are real challenges to the closing the epistemic
- 50:07asymmetry in the Academy. And I think again, rather than
- 50:10just like being 1st and putting points up on the board, there's
- 50:13also being wise. And some of this shit coinery
- 50:16stuff is going to look ridiculous 10 years from now.
- 50:20And those institutions that are careful about how they who they
- 50:24take money from and how and what sorts of programs they develop,
- 50:29that care will also pay off in the future.
- 50:32They won't look, you know what I mean?
- 50:33You have that ridiculous feeling when you know, you, you, you
- 50:37basically were sponsored by a, a rug.
- 50:39You know, you don't want. Yeah, I, I do know about an
- 50:43institution that like cancelled an invitation to Sam Bankman
- 50:48freed like to speak at their, you know, university right after
- 50:53he was, you know, arrested. But like if that had just
- 50:56happened a little bit later, they would have had SPF as their
- 50:59their headliner. Better late than never.
- 51:04Better late than never. Well, let the record show.
- 51:07Let the record show, Troy, that Bitcoin can be a professor coin.
- 51:12Your your case in point. And yeah, secondly, I too am
- 51:16optimistic. My alma mater, Williams, I
- 51:20actually got well, I've approached the institution at a
- 51:24couple levels, not with much success.
- 51:27I did have an econ professor reach out to me and let me know
- 51:31that he had given a copy of my book Why Buy Bitcoin to his
- 51:34student? This was about a year ago, so
- 51:37that was cool, but but also, I'm not going to mention his name
- 51:40because I think he, you know, had some concern about, you know
- 51:44what basically what that would look like.
- 51:45So anyway, hats off to you unknown Williams professor.
- 51:50You know, someday, someday I'll I'll be able to say your name
- 51:54without any concern for blowback for your, for your career.
- 51:59I I have friends. I have friends who I wish they
- 52:03could be public. They say some great stuff about
- 52:05Bitcoin, but they can't. Yeah, Yeah, that's reality.
- 52:08OK, well, let's switch gears a little bit here, Troy.
- 52:13I do want to talk about energy and Bitcoin and you know, you're
- 52:18free to sort of set the table in a general way if you'd like.
- 52:21But I, but I would actually like to you know, throw the throw the
- 52:26extra bit of salt in the mix, which is recent developments in
- 52:30AI compute capacity and your thoughts as that relates to to
- 52:37Bitcoin compute as well. Yeah, well, thanks for asking
- 52:43about that, Mark Margo Paez, my colleague at Bitcoin Policy is
- 52:48to. Margo and I shout out to Margo a
- 52:52good a good Los Angeles Bitcoiner.
- 52:54By the way, sorry, I interrupted.
- 52:56You no Margo and I are finishing up a report on Bitcoin mining
- 53:03and AI, and the primary focus of our report is Bitcoin mining.
- 53:10Nice. But it's also about Bitcoin
- 53:12mining in relation to AI. The title of the report is the
- 53:18locust and the Dung Beetle. The locust is AI compute.
- 53:22The dung beetle is Bitcoin compute.
- 53:25Love that image and. We're trying to illustrate with
- 53:29data the difference between these two forms of compute.
- 53:32Now they both have caught the public imagination with very
- 53:36high rates of growth. AI already consumes more power
- 53:43than Bitcoin mining. It's hard to say exactly how
- 53:46much AI compute is consuming, how much energy because they
- 53:51don't have a public blockchain that they're publishing to with
- 53:56a difficulty adjustment that's public.
- 54:00So we have to rely on on, on indirect measurements of how
- 54:05many GPUs are being sold and corporate reports and that sort
- 54:08of thing. But AI is already outpacing
- 54:13Bitcoin mining in, in, in energy use and its growth rates
- 54:17projected are insane. There's a, there's a rush right
- 54:22now to capitalize on to, to get leadership in the AI space and
- 54:27then get network effects. And so companies are willing to
- 54:31pay a premium to get ahead of the pack.
- 54:34And there's a shortage of power to meet those demands.
- 54:40And AI, unlike Bitcoin mining, it's very constrained in how and
- 54:45when it uses power. It it has to be in the US for
- 54:50the most part because companies don't want to keep their data
- 54:53overseas. It needs to be near major
- 54:55metropolitan areas to keep latency very low.
- 54:58It has to have very fast interconnect connections and
- 55:01they need 99.995% up time. That may change in the future,
- 55:07but that's where they're at now. So these data centers are
- 55:13opening up on grids in specific areas along the Eastern seaboard
- 55:16or in central Ohio, and they are overwhelming those grids.
- 55:22They are adding to peak demand. And that's freaking out a lot of
- 55:27utilities and regulators because it looks like they're going to
- 55:32push up prices of power. It simply can't meet the demands
- 55:38for power. And that's the kind of
- 55:41environment of fear that surrounded Bitcoin like two
- 55:44years ago. Oh my.
- 55:47And in fact, it's it's like Alex Devries, who is one of our main
- 55:51haters in Bitcoin mining space work for the Central Bank of the
- 55:56Netherlands, is a master's PhD student now.
- 56:03He he switched from flooding Bitcoin mining to flooding AI.
- 56:10Smart, Good, but it's a better opportunity for him.
- 56:14It's it's much better. I think he saw the way that the,
- 56:17that the rhetoric was going around Bitcoin and that way that
- 56:20Bitcoin, he was losing that that battle.
- 56:22And he saw a much bigger market around AI, Margo.
- 56:26And I think that the power demands from AI can be met if we
- 56:32get our act together and build the grid properly.
- 56:35Like the queues for adding power to the grid are immense.
- 56:39There's more power waiting to be added to the grid than there's
- 56:41power on the grid. And the wait times are like 5-6
- 56:44years, whereas the AI data centers want to connect like
- 56:49tomorrow for the next couple years.
- 56:51So we think that those demands can be met, but they are serious
- 56:56and they are local and concentrated and they are they
- 57:01exist at all times. What what we found in the
- 57:06report, we contrasted Bitcoin mining's use of power and we
- 57:11surveyed 10 different companies and got detailed data of their
- 57:16power usage, when they use power and what substation they're
- 57:20drawing from and how much power they use.
- 57:21When they turn down, how much did they turn down, how often do
- 57:24they turn down? We found up times ranging
- 57:29between 69.5% and 95%, you know, meeting 31% of the time some
- 57:37miners are off or 5% of the time some miners are off.
- 57:41And those up times or down times depended on like what kind of
- 57:43grid they were in. If they had just like steady
- 57:46hydroelectric power in these long term contracts, they would
- 57:48just run almost all the time unless there was some kind of
- 57:51emergency on the grid. If they had dynamic pricing in
- 57:54a, in a transparent market, they could respond to price signals
- 57:59quickly. They would be down a lot.
- 58:01But that's a lot of flexibility relative to, you know, a is
- 58:0499.995% uptime. And we also found that they
- 58:08turned down during severe weather events.
- 58:10You know, in times of grid stress, they just turn off
- 58:13completely. So we then used that data
- 58:19together with grid emissions factors, local grid emissions
- 58:22factors, to calculate the emissions that were avoided
- 58:27during the times that they were down.
- 58:30So, so basically comparing a constant uptime data center and
- 58:33the emissions associated with that to a data center that turns
- 58:37down at specific times when the grid is stressed and electricity
- 58:41prices are high. And, and what we found there
- 58:44was, I don't remember the exact numbers off the top of my head
- 58:48for our sample, but when we generalize that to the network
- 58:51as a whole, as a whole, it'd be the equivalent of taking 20
- 58:53million cars off the road. That difference between a
- 58:58constant uptime and the behavior that we saw from Bitcoin mining
- 59:01data centers and that flexibility and the carbon
- 59:05emissions reduction associated with it has been ignored by
- 59:08every previous estimation of Bitcoins emissions.
- 59:12You know, they just treat it like a constant uptime data
- 59:14center. And so this report really shows
- 59:18like, no, it's really nothing like that.
- 59:20It emits far less. It makes far fewer demands on
- 59:23electrical infrastructure. It doesn't push up prices at the
- 59:26top end of the market. So it's really much more benign
- 59:31as consumer of energy. That's the dung beetle nature of
- 59:35the consumer. And then if I can't just finish
- 59:38up here, like a quick caveat on that one is that we see the
- 59:43locust of AI eventually becoming a dung beetle too.
- 59:47We think that we think that we'll find ways to shift
- 59:52computational load around to where energy is cheapest.
- 59:55It's just a matter of time. That's just not how they behave
- 59:58now because of basically the rush to get ahead of the market
- 1:00:03and the value of these GPU's. The other caveat is that during
- 1:00:08periods of explosive growth in Bitcoin's price and supply chain
- 1:00:13constraints and maybe, you know, local conditions like China
- 1:00:18banning Bitcoin mining, Bitcoin can act like a locust too.
- 1:00:22There are times when it it it mines 100% of the time and it
- 1:00:27can mine on the most expensive electricity in the world and
- 1:00:30still be profitable. Those periods are short lived
- 1:00:34because we just make enough ASICS that the profit margins
- 1:00:39drop for mining. And once again, mining finds the
- 1:00:43cheapest energy only and is not profitable and expensive energy.
- 1:00:46But basically, yeah, we have the potential for AI to be a dung
- 1:00:52beetle, and we have the potential for Bitcoin to morph
- 1:00:55into a, a, a locust. But right now, and by and large,
- 1:01:02the Bitcoin miners are harmless stung beetles, and the AI data
- 1:01:06centers are swarming hordes of locusts.
- 1:01:10And that's what lawmakers need to understand rather than just
- 1:01:14being like, oh, I see 200 MW data centers that both want to
- 1:01:17drop into our location. You know, they're exactly the
- 1:01:20same. No, they are nothing like,
- 1:01:22nothing alike. At this point, I want to try out
- 1:01:25a narrative on you. Troy Bitcoin.
- 1:01:30Uses. Energy on a flexible basis to
- 1:01:33balance the load and makes you rich while the locust AI data
- 1:01:39centers make you poor by killing your jobs.
- 1:01:42What do you what do you think? I think that the media probably
- 1:01:48only heard. Bitcoin uses energy.
- 1:01:51The the very first part of that, I love it.
- 1:01:55I love it. I mean the the.
- 1:01:58Truth is, I think AI is probably overhyped.
- 1:02:01It will probably collapse. There will probably be a lot of
- 1:02:04like, there's going to be a lot of like excess infrastructure
- 1:02:09and stakes made and the equivalent of like the compute,
- 1:02:12compute N bankruptcy, the core scientific bankruptcy, we'll
- 1:02:15have the equivalent of that in the AI world probably at some
- 1:02:17point, right? Because that's how these things
- 1:02:19work. It's weird.
- 1:02:20You have this crystal ball. It's another information
- 1:02:22asymmetry as a bitcoiner, you see this happen in Bitcoin,
- 1:02:26right? We, we had our locust like
- 1:02:28period and you could see that's not sustainable.
- 1:02:31Eventually, eventually you, you can't you, you can't just keep
- 1:02:37you can't continue to have massive margins in a business
- 1:02:41with no barrier to entry. That's not going to last And and
- 1:02:45you can you can see the hype that came along with it.
- 1:02:48People just throwing money with anything with Bitcoin in the
- 1:02:50name, right? Bitcoin miners took public
- 1:02:52investment and over invested essentially, and they made bad
- 1:02:57power contracts because they didn't think the price of power
- 1:02:59mattered. They just wanted to be first and
- 1:03:01mine while the mining was hot before the difficulty adjustment
- 1:03:04went up. So they they made stupid
- 1:03:06decisions, overextended themselves, went into debt, you
- 1:03:09know, and they paid for all of that on the backside.
- 1:03:11And now you're like seeing the same thing As for sure going to
- 1:03:14happen in AI because that's just human nature and that we're
- 1:03:17going to like AI next big thing, throw tons of money at a borrow
- 1:03:20anything, any power you can hook up to dude, don't care about the
- 1:03:23contract you're signing. Just sign it, man, get power.
- 1:03:26And then eventually you're going to have, you know, just we're
- 1:03:29going to make enough graphics cards and they're going to
- 1:03:32deploy it enough places in the world that people are going to
- 1:03:34be like, you know, this power deal.
- 1:03:37It's actually like now it's a millstone around my neck and I'm
- 1:03:40paying the price for it, right? It's going to explode.
- 1:03:42We need to learn how to distribute this and send it out
- 1:03:44to to the cheaper forms of energy when and where they are
- 1:03:48that it's so weird to see that all ahead of you because it's in
- 1:03:53your past. It it's another great advantage
- 1:03:58of being a being a Bitcoiner and and then also the questions
- 1:04:03about AI is goodness and usefulness, right.
- 1:04:07It's like another human technology like Bitcoin.
- 1:04:09Yes, it's a mixed bag. People also do bad things with
- 1:04:14Bitcoin. It's a technology.
- 1:04:17It will serve the human good. We will make it serve the human
- 1:04:19good and it will it will earn its right to that energy by
- 1:04:24bidding on it and providing services for our lives.
- 1:04:27And so let's just stop the discussion about whether we
- 1:04:29should be spending energy on AI. And let's set up a market that
- 1:04:33allows people to bid on energy and this instead just decide
- 1:04:38whether or not we want to use AI and whether it actually is
- 1:04:41useful. And that will determine whether
- 1:04:43it deserves our energy. So, you know, I feel there's a,
- 1:04:48there's a competition between Bitcoin and AI in some sense,
- 1:04:50but they're both technologies that are energy intensive that
- 1:04:53people are willing to trade stuff for fundamentally.
- 1:04:57That's what ultimate, you know, should shape the way we think
- 1:04:59about their power usage. Yeah.
- 1:05:02And that demand? That demand will.
- 1:05:04Be there undoubtedly and the complementarity I mean there is
- 1:05:08no escaping the points you cited, which is one of these
- 1:05:12users of electricity in the data center needs 99 or 4 nines, you
- 1:05:17know uptime and the other doesn't care at all.
- 1:05:19So it's a compliment there and then likewise the need for low
- 1:05:23latency on on the AI applications.
- 1:05:26I guess we'll see how true that is in the long run.
- 1:05:30Obviously you need it for for querying the system, you need
- 1:05:34low latency inference. Yeah, maybe not so much for
- 1:05:37training, but it, it's just going to be, it's going to be
- 1:05:40fascinating to watch. Yeah, we're, we're going to
- 1:05:42separate it out like. Exactly when you need low
- 1:05:45latency and how low latency you need, and we're going to send
- 1:05:49the compute that needs the lowest latency to the very edge
- 1:05:52of the grid nearest to the user, right?
- 1:05:53There'll probably be degrees of like, how much time can this
- 1:05:56take? And if it can take a lot of
- 1:05:58time, we might. And is it secure information or
- 1:06:00doesn't need to be secured? Like all of this is going to be
- 1:06:04segmented in the marketplace for compute eventually and it'll all
- 1:06:09be optimized. You know, right now it's just
- 1:06:11kind of like one thing. Yeah, yeah, the the free market
- 1:06:14forces will. Optimize it over time and I'm
- 1:06:17reminded of Brandon Kiddum's Bitcoin is a pioneer species
- 1:06:23thought of when it comes to energy side of it.
- 1:06:25It's sort of symbiotic with with any other form of high compute
- 1:06:30demand. It is use case what Bitcoin can
- 1:06:35can can colonize undeveloped energy sources and then the the
- 1:06:41different use cases can follow once the infrastructure is
- 1:06:45robust enough for their needs. I mean it's wild.
- 1:06:48I mean, that's what's that's what's happened already with AI
- 1:06:51we. Have Margo and I have compiled a
- 1:06:54list of all of the Bitcoin mining companies that are now
- 1:06:56integrating AI. You know, core weave has now
- 1:07:00signed this huge contract with core scientific Iris energy has
- 1:07:05been doing AI for a while. Terra Wolf is doing it like
- 1:07:08we've got like a dozen companies that are already like
- 1:07:13integrating. So here's this power
- 1:07:15infrastructure. It's already there.
- 1:07:17All you have to do is build a a, a world class data center.
- 1:07:22It's very different kind of data Center for your AI, but you've
- 1:07:25got the power infrastructure there, the Foreman, which is the
- 1:07:28control software for for Bitcoin miners that, you know, turns
- 1:07:31them off and on in response to red demands and price signals.
- 1:07:35Foreman is developing the software to curtail and shift
- 1:07:40around AI loads. And I've just been reading stuff
- 1:07:42on that, right. So it's it's pioneer species.
- 1:07:46In action, that's another. Evergreen article, Jesse like
- 1:07:49yours, it's it's pioneer species in action.
- 1:07:52And it's not just that. It's like, you know, Harry
- 1:07:54Suddick talks about the power supplies being optimized for
- 1:07:58price. Like there's a tremendous amount
- 1:08:00of technical innovation that happens around the periphery of
- 1:08:04the ASIC itself. And a lot of that is impactful
- 1:08:09for other forms of compute, even though the total setting is
- 1:08:13different. Yeah.
- 1:08:16I mean, it's so wild. What happened was China bans
- 1:08:20Bitcoin mining, right, in order to power the rest of their
- 1:08:24industrial machine and also to, you know, just get rid of the
- 1:08:28threat to their power. Bitcoin mining floods to
- 1:08:32Kazakhstan and it floods to the US, to the Rust Belt where we
- 1:08:35just abandoned a bunch of power infrastructure and manufacturing
- 1:08:38infrastructure, which led to China, right?
- 1:08:40So it like left this and then we rebuild and rework that for,
- 1:08:45for, for, for Bitcoin mining, right?
- 1:08:46And then and then AI comes in and pushes out that the Bitcoin
- 1:08:53miner within that same infrastructure, which is now,
- 1:08:56you know, revitalized. So it's a really cool, like
- 1:09:00ecological thing. You know what I mean?
- 1:09:04It really, Brandon is exactly right.
- 1:09:06And you, you find this in nature, like where one thing
- 1:09:09makes a home for the next thing and then it gets pushed out.
- 1:09:11You know, it's like the, the food chain or whatever, the,
- 1:09:14the, the, the, the life of a carcass on the Serengeti or
- 1:09:17whatever, you know, like it is amazing.
- 1:09:20Bitcoin miners are marginal profit on a on a unit of energy
- 1:09:25is between 115th and 125th of a is right now.
- 1:09:30Now there's much more CapEx requirement for AI, but but if
- 1:09:35you're looking at units of energy, the margins are immense.
- 1:09:39So anywhere these two are like head to head and you have
- 1:09:43constant power and you have a contract for constant power,
- 1:09:46you'd be foolish to mine Bitcoin on that power.
- 1:09:49You should just set up and start doing AI as quickly as possible,
- 1:09:51right? So it's going to push AI is
- 1:09:54going to push Bitcoin mining into these crevices of available
- 1:09:59power which don't have low latency, which don't have
- 1:10:03constant up time, which do have ultra cheap power, right?
- 1:10:07It's kind of a beautiful thing to to, to watch this, you know,
- 1:10:12nature red and tooth and claw. Just do it, do its thing.
- 1:10:16Yeah. And, and importantly, it's.
- 1:10:18It's accretive. Too it, it builds an ecosystem
- 1:10:21rather than being like a 0 sum game, kind of like circle of
- 1:10:25life, like energy, you know, the carcass gets picked apart and
- 1:10:28absolutely instead it, it's building a whole jungle, you
- 1:10:32know, in fact, it's incentivizing.
- 1:10:35Yeah. It it's incentivizing, it's no,
- 1:10:40it's. Percent incentivizing.
- 1:10:41Renewables, you know, it's providing demand for solar.
- 1:10:45You know, whether that's good or bad, people can debate.
- 1:10:49It actually is topical to one of your prior concepts.
- 1:10:53I want to mention Jake Sibley wanted to revisit this question.
- 1:10:59So you had an A notion which was if you're a Bitcoiner and you're
- 1:11:04concerned about carbon emissions for your Bitcoin, you know, just
- 1:11:09go buy some or install some mining capacity and do it on
- 1:11:13renewable, you know, generation. I guess I wonder does that does
- 1:11:19that thesis or that idea, does that mesh with this much more
- 1:11:24interrelated, you know, ecosystem notion with Bitcoin
- 1:11:28mining interacting and being, you know, a pioneer species?
- 1:11:32Do those two jive still? I think so.
- 1:11:37I I. Yeah, Jake asked what happened
- 1:11:40to this idea. The the idea lives, but there's
- 1:11:44no like nobody who has developed a product around it.
- 1:11:48I've pitched it to like basically everyone, but I think
- 1:11:53it's the time is different now than it was then.
- 1:11:56Like this general trend of Bitcoin mining has in some ways
- 1:12:01obviated the need to do the thing that I'm talking about.
- 1:12:04Like Bitcoin mining is rushing in the direction that you would
- 1:12:08be incentivizing it to go anyway just due to these natural
- 1:12:13forces. Maybe this would be what your
- 1:12:14questions about. Like in a way, I was beaten to
- 1:12:18the punch by the natural dynamics of bitcoins pricing,
- 1:12:25But I still think that I I have yet to find to hear an objection
- 1:12:29that made me rethink the soundness of the causal claim
- 1:12:34that if you mine Bitcoin in proportion to your holdings,
- 1:12:42meaning if you have X percent of Bitcoin, you do X percent of
- 1:12:47mining in a in a low carbon way, then you don't incentivize any
- 1:12:52carbon emissions at all, directly or indirectly, because
- 1:12:57your impact on everybody else mining is twofold.
- 1:13:03By buying and holding Bitcoin, you make it more attractive for
- 1:13:07them to mine. And maybe they're mining on a
- 1:13:09whatever coal mine or something, they've got coal-fired plant,
- 1:13:13but you're doing something else that hurts their business, which
- 1:13:16is driving up the hash rate and driving up the difficulty
- 1:13:20adjustment. And if you do those two things
- 1:13:23in equal measure, the net effect on them will be zero.
- 1:13:28You won't be incentivizing them to mine and you won't be
- 1:13:30disincentivizing them to mine. And therefore you're not
- 1:13:33responsible in any extended sense of responsibility for
- 1:13:38their emissions. You're only responsible for the
- 1:13:41emissions of the mining that you do yourself.
- 1:13:45And if you mine in a low carbon way, then you're not responsible
- 1:13:49for any. So I still think that's a good
- 1:13:53formula. I still think that if I were at
- 1:13:56a financial institution where my clients were concerned about the
- 1:14:03mining, the emissions associated with mining and we should say
- 1:14:07here that, you know, mining has no scope one emissions, it has
- 1:14:12no direct emissions. Its emissions are scope 2 and
- 1:14:15indirect. And if you're concerned about
- 1:14:18that, you can do something to hold Bitcoin in a carbon neutral
- 1:14:24way that does not involve any funky carbon accounting.
- 1:14:27It doesn't involve any carbon credits, which are mostly a
- 1:14:30joke, and it doesn't really cost you anything because mining is
- 1:14:36kind of a neutral investment. I would say if you invest in
- 1:14:40some mining on on on low carbon mining, it's kind of like your
- 1:14:45expected profit is zero, I would say.
- 1:14:50Is a good bet. You know it's not going to be,
- 1:14:53you're not going to be profitable.
- 1:14:55You got. No scale, so you're not going to
- 1:14:56be profitable, but you probably also won't lose your shirt.
- 1:14:59Probably, yeah. You might lose a little.
- 1:15:02Bit but you, you're not just throwing money away at a carbon
- 1:15:04credit. You, you, you actually there's a
- 1:15:06scenario in which you make money and that scenario is where
- 1:15:10Bitcoin's price rips and hash rate cannot catch up to price
- 1:15:14and suddenly you are printing money with that very same
- 1:15:17investment. So it kind of diversifies your
- 1:15:19risk profile a little bit. There's also another scenario
- 1:15:22too where. You're using the the waste heat
- 1:15:25to heat your pool and then you get two birds with one stone,
- 1:15:29whereas this at scale miners can't do that because there's no
- 1:15:33use case for that. What if I don't have a pool?
- 1:15:35Do I have to factor? In the capital cost of my new
- 1:15:37pool, Jesse does that Does that complicates the?
- 1:15:42Business case I also think of. Sorry, I was, I also think.
- 1:15:47Of rights. Rights law, right, which is the
- 1:15:49more units of any given technology that get installed,
- 1:15:53you know, the lower the, the next, the lower the cost
- 1:15:57basically to to produce further units.
- 1:16:00And so if you're at the margin buying, you know, or installing
- 1:16:04renewable generation capacity, that should, you know, push down
- 1:16:08the cost curve in the long run, you know, for the whole
- 1:16:10industry. Not that it'll make a much
- 1:16:12difference if you do a few, you know, put in a few ASICS, but
- 1:16:16it's very true. Andy and and.
- 1:16:18And actually one of the companies that I advise, I can
- 1:16:21advise a half dozen companies in this space and they are
- 1:16:25installing, they're over. Provisioning.
- 1:16:27Solar on rooftops in San Diego and they are then sticking a
- 1:16:31miner in the garage and using that miner to basically they're
- 1:16:38using the miner to monetize that excess electricity in as a kind
- 1:16:42of pioneer species in the hopes that the house will eventually,
- 1:16:46the household will eventually electrify more of their, their
- 1:16:49life, either with, you know, heat pumps or electric vehicles
- 1:16:54or induction stoves or whatever. So it, it, it, it is that when
- 1:17:00you're on a rooftop and you're installing solar panels, like
- 1:17:03those next few panels don't cost a lot.
- 1:17:05Most of the cost of your installation is actually, you
- 1:17:07know, selling yourself as an installer.
- 1:17:09But after that, it's like the labor to install it.
- 1:17:11It's the panels are really, really cheap right now.
- 1:17:15And then, and then, yes, that additional, I mean what you
- 1:17:18described is what has driven down the cost of solar.
- 1:17:21We've installed so much solar than while, while the panels
- 1:17:23have gotten more efficient and that has been dramatic, much
- 1:17:26more dramatic the the economies of scale and manufacturing.
- 1:17:32Yeah. It, it, it, it's, as I see it,
- 1:17:35the need for heat and also is, is is.
- 1:17:39Very distributed that. Will never scale right.
- 1:17:41We never need a, a GW of, of, of, of heat like so that's an
- 1:17:49advantage for small miners over large miners.
- 1:17:52And there are also pockets of like free and excess electricity
- 1:17:55which are also distributed and cannot be eliminated.
- 1:17:58And that's an advantage for distributed mining.
- 1:18:01So we have kind of a big war between the economies of scale.
- 1:18:05If you're at the Winstone facility in Riot, you know, like
- 1:18:08maintenance is easy. You just like slide a ladder
- 1:18:10down or something and you know, walk up and pull the machine out
- 1:18:13and you've got a whole center there to work on it.
- 1:18:15If you're this distributed solar in households, you got to like
- 1:18:19send a truck out to a house, you know, to pull the miner and then
- 1:18:22bring it back. Your, your, your, your miners
- 1:18:25are spread all over San Diego or whatever.
- 1:18:27So or, or if it's the oil field, you know, you're out there in
- 1:18:30these little hash huts. It it's similarly you got to fix
- 1:18:34like an engine out there. You got to fix some ASICS out in
- 1:18:37the desert, you know, send somebody out there who knows how
- 1:18:40to do it and do it. You give economies of you have
- 1:18:43economies of scale for operating a mine.
- 1:18:46And then you have these dis economies of scale because you
- 1:18:49can't reuse the heat, because you can't take advantage of
- 1:18:51these little pockets of stranded energy.
- 1:18:53And what we're seeing in the in the, you know, Serengeti of the
- 1:18:57energy world is like those two forces play, play out, see which
- 1:19:02was greater. And I think it's an open
- 1:19:04question and a dynamic one. What is going to happen?
- 1:19:07And I'm just like, I don't know, place your bets.
- 1:19:09It's going to be fun. Enjoy the show.
- 1:19:12Well, we'll, I'll be watching. We'll.
- 1:19:14I'll be watching. It's going to be a wild, wild
- 1:19:17show. As what?
- 1:19:18As wild as any part of the evolution of Bitcoin over time.
- 1:19:22Yeah. Well, Speaking of overtime,
- 1:19:24we're overtime on our on our recording here.
- 1:19:27Thank you so much, Troy. This has been tremendous.
- 1:19:30I'm looking forward to reading your upcoming report on the
- 1:19:35locust and the dung beetle. As people know, your natural
- 1:19:41habitat is not actually Portland, OR it's Twitter slash
- 1:19:45X, so people should definitely follow you there if they aren't
- 1:19:49already. But are there any closing words
- 1:19:52you want to leave us with or anywhere else people should know
- 1:19:56about finding your work? No, I think.
- 1:19:59That's right, I'm at the. Trocro on Twitter.
- 1:20:02You can follow me there. I'm trying to cut down, but I do
- 1:20:07a lot of my thinking out loud on Twitter.
- 1:20:14Yeah, that's kind of that's where I live.
- 1:20:16And you can see me get things wrong and learn in public.
- 1:20:21I've done a lot of that and I will continue to do that.
- 1:20:24Yeah. Thanks for having me on, guys.
- 1:20:26This was a great conversation. Painful.
- 1:20:30The first part was painful, but then once we got beyond the
- 1:20:33paper wall, it losses. It's good stuff.
- 1:20:37Always good to not think about those things.
- 1:20:39But. Yeah, I loved riffing with you.
- 1:20:40It was great. Thank you so much, Troy.
- 1:20:43This is it's. Been a real pleasure and this
- 1:20:45has been scarce assets. Thanks for.
- 1:20:48Listening to this week's episode of the show.
- 1:20:51If you found the information valuable, please share the
- 1:20:53episode with a friend or leave a rating on your favorite podcast
- 1:20:55app. All the links we discussed in
- 1:20:57today's show will be in the show notes inside your podcast app.
- 1:21:00Before we finish, a quick reminder that On Rat Media is
- 1:21:03for informational and entertainment purposes only, and
- 1:21:05nothing should be construed as investment or legal advice.
- 1:21:09Regardless of where you are on your Bitcoin journey, we'd love
- 1:21:11to hear from you. Visit onrampbitcoin.com contact
- 1:21:15to schedule a consultation with one of our private client
- 1:21:17advisors.