Latest / The Voice of Corporate Governance / Pre-IPO Compensation Costs with Sven Riethmueller
Transcript
- 0:11SPEAKER_02: Welcome everyone.
- 0:12SPEAKER_02: Thank you for listening to the Council of Institutional Investors Voice of Corporate Governance, the number one corporate governance podcast for 2026, as determined by Million Podcasts.
- 0:22SPEAKER_02: I'm your host, Jeff Mahoney, General Counsel of CII.
- 0:26SPEAKER_02: Our topic for this episode is pre-IPO compensation costs.
- 0:30SPEAKER_02: And my special guest today is Sven Reitmueller, Clinical Professor of Law at Yale Law School and Director of the Entrepreneurship and Innovation Clinic at Yale Law School.
- 0:42SPEAKER_02: Professor Reit Mueller is the author of a recent research paper entitled Beatles with Ballooning Burdens: Pushing Out Pre-IPO compensation costs until the RSU Reckoning.
- 0:57SPEAKER_02: Welcome back to the program, Professor.
- 0:59SPEAKER_02: Thank you.
- 1:00SPEAKER_02: Thank you for having me.
- 1:01SPEAKER_02: Professor, your new research paper scrutinizes the stock-based compensation practices of pre-IPO unicorns in the United States.
- 1:12SPEAKER_02: Before we discuss your research findings and recommendations, can you begin by explaining the title of your paper, including the reference to Beetles, and what is meant by RSU?
- 1:24SPEAKER_00: Sure.
- 1:25SPEAKER_00: So I wanted to provide readers with a illustration of what I'm talking about in the paper, since it is somewhat dry when it comes to some accounting rules and compensation expenses and SEC filings.
- 1:39SPEAKER_00: So a beetle with a burden is a description in a folk tale out of Ghana, West Africa, for a dung beetle.
- 1:50SPEAKER_00: So a beetle with a burden, it's a it's a tale about a dung beetle pushing a ball of dung, uh, which I felt was a very apt comparison or illustration of what is going on here with the stock-based compensation practices involving so-called RSUs.
- 2:11SPEAKER_00: And so what is an RSU?
- 2:13SPEAKER_00: An RSU is a restricted stock unit.
- 2:17SPEAKER_00: It should not be confused with restricted stock.
- 2:20SPEAKER_00: Restricted stock is where an employee receives actual shares of capital stock, typically common stock, which is subject to certain types of contractual restrictions.
- 2:33SPEAKER_00: An RSU, by comparison, does not make the recipient, typically an employee or an executive, the owner of shares of stock yet.
- 2:44SPEAKER_00: It gives them a contractual right, a promise by the company that if certain vesting conditions are satisfied, they will automatically receive those shares, typically shares of common stock.
- 2:59SPEAKER_00: The process of when they receive them is called the settlement.
- 3:02SPEAKER_00: And they don't have to pay anything for those shares.
- 3:05SPEAKER_00: They have to satisfy the vesting conditions, which typically involve performing services, but not necessarily.
- 3:12SPEAKER_00: And once these vesting conditions are satisfied, the company will deliver the shares to them, and they do not have to pay cash for those shares or for the right to receive them, which makes them also very different from a stock option, where you typically have to purchase the shares by exercising your option and then paying for the shares at the preset exercise price or strike price that is provided in the option grant to the employee.
- 3:46SPEAKER_02: So, Professor, your paper concludes that many large pre-IPO companies, particularly those in the software and IT services industry, utilize stock-based compensation practices that overstate the pre-IPO financial performance of the company and thereby exposing post-IPO investors to a high risk of loss in shareholder value.
- 4:11SPEAKER_02: So, can you explain to our listeners the type of stock compensation practices that you believe harm post-IPO investors?
- 4:18SPEAKER_02: And why are those practices so popular with software and IT services companies?
- 4:24SPEAKER_00: Sure.
- 4:24SPEAKER_00: So I'm going to, given the time constraints and uh the format here of a podcast, I will simplify a few concepts and generalize them.
- 4:33SPEAKER_00: Um they are available in my paper.
- 4:36SPEAKER_00: My paper is available publicly on SSRN.
- 4:38SPEAKER_00: If you choose, if you search for my name and Beatles with ballooning burdens, you will certainly find them relatively easily.
- 4:46SPEAKER_00: So I conducted an empirical investigation uh that spent more than 10 years, basically spent the beginning of what I call the unicorn era until 2024.
- 4:59SPEAKER_00: The unicorn era, by my estimate or by the way the way that I view it, it started in 2014.
- 5:06SPEAKER_00: There was the uh article written in late 2013 that termed came up with the term unicorn, unicorn being a privately held company that has a post-money valuation out of the most recent financing round of at least a billion dollars.
- 5:23SPEAKER_00: So I looked at all unicorns that went public during this time period.
- 5:29SPEAKER_00: So went public in a regular IPO, so no direct listings or spec transactions, but a classic firmly underwritten IPO.
- 5:38SPEAKER_00: That covered 91 unicorns.
- 5:40SPEAKER_00: Um, there's some other criteria to make sure these are genuine unicorns, not recently inflated valuations and so on, which I explain in the paper.
- 5:48SPEAKER_00: So you have 91 unicorns that went public during the period from 2014 until 2024.
- 5:56SPEAKER_00: One of the things that's quite interesting is how they compensated their employees and executives.
- 6:03SPEAKER_00: RSUs, a particular type of RSU called a double trigger RSU, has become the predominant or at least very, very popular form of stock compensation for unicorns.
- 6:19SPEAKER_00: 60 out of the 91 unicorns offered double trigger RSUs.
- 6:24SPEAKER_00: Now, if I want to be more specific, 51 of those 91 unicorns offered RSUs that generated significant compensation expense, and I'll explain that in a moment.
- 6:34SPEAKER_00: But basically, over time, RSUs have become a very significant component of the compensation of employees and executives.
- 6:44SPEAKER_00: And it's not limited to just uh executives, this is for employees in general.
- 6:49SPEAKER_00: Why did they do this?
- 6:51SPEAKER_00: There are a number of reasons, but part of this is because as these companies, since they're unicorns, they have high valuations, options start becoming unattractive.
- 7:02SPEAKER_00: The reason is partly tax-driven.
- 7:05SPEAKER_00: Options, when they are granted, the exercise price of the option has to equal, at a minimum, the fair market value of the underlying stock at the time of grant.
- 7:16SPEAKER_00: And as these unicorns, by their name, are high value, the stock is also valued fairly highly, even when it's common stock and they are, you know, there's a stack of investor rights that have preferred stock.
- 7:31SPEAKER_00: Nonetheless, for late-stage companies that are mature unicorns or not early startups, these exercise prices are high.
- 7:41SPEAKER_00: That makes them unattractive to employees in many respects because employees feel like they're leaving a lot on the table.
- 7:49SPEAKER_00: There's not as much upside.
- 7:51SPEAKER_00: Airbnb, for example, granted options in 2017 at$52.50 a share exercise price per share.
- 8:00SPEAKER_00: Airbnb went public three years later in December 2020.
- 8:04SPEAKER_00: Its IPO was priced at$68 a share.
- 8:07SPEAKER_00: First day of public trading closed at$144 a share.
- 8:12SPEAKER_00: If I'm an employee, that$52.50 per share exercise price is what I'm leaving on the table.
- 8:21SPEAKER_00: So I am not getting the full value.
- 8:24SPEAKER_00: There are lots of other considerations, but the option becomes rather unattractive at a high-valued unicorn.
- 8:31SPEAKER_00: At the same time, publicly traded companies have started using RSUs because for reasons, again, relating to accounting a lot.
- 8:40SPEAKER_00: Also, again, because the upside, they don't have to worry about the upside, because again, if you grant somebody an RSU, they receive the full value, whatever it is.
- 8:50SPEAKER_00: So publicly traded companies, software companies in particular, IT companies, those kinds of companies started offering RSUs to their employees.
- 9:00SPEAKER_00: Now, unicorns are competing with those.
- 9:03SPEAKER_00: So they had to answer, but they can't offer attractive stock options.
- 9:08SPEAKER_00: So they devised their own type of RSU, which is called the double trigger RSU.
- 9:13SPEAKER_00: And in that one, the actual delivery of the shares is not just tied to services.
- 9:18SPEAKER_00: So for a publicly traded company, you receive an RSU as an employee, you perform services over time.
- 9:25SPEAKER_00: Once you perform the services, the company will deliver the shares to you.
- 9:29SPEAKER_00: This is highly attractive because A, as I mentioned, you don't pay for that.
- 9:33SPEAKER_00: The shares are liquid.
- 9:34SPEAKER_00: You can sell them in the open market, you can cover your taxes, you will have shares without any cash outlays uh up front.
- 9:42SPEAKER_00: Unicorns can't offer that because they're not publicly traded, their stock is illiquid.
- 9:46SPEAKER_00: So they offer double trigger RSUs.
- 9:48SPEAKER_00: So double trigger RSUs, the one trigger is again the performance of services.
- 9:52SPEAKER_00: But at the same time, we will not deliver the shares to you when the services are performed.
- 9:57SPEAKER_00: We will only deliver the shares to you when we have an IPO.
- 10:02SPEAKER_00: So when we have an IPO or another exit, like the company sale, at that point you receive the shares.
- 10:08SPEAKER_00: And that's the second trigger.
- 10:09SPEAKER_00: Part of this is tax driven.
- 10:11SPEAKER_00: But another really attractive feature of this structure is that companies who offer double trigger RSUs are not even allowed to, under the accounting rules, to recognize the compensation expenses associated with those RSUs until the second trigger becomes probable.
- 10:36SPEAKER_00: So, in other words, I grant RSUs to my employees, and they have the two triggers.
- 10:43SPEAKER_00: The employees have performed all the services, they've been there for four years, two years, whatever.
- 10:48SPEAKER_00: They've earned these RSUs by performing services, they don't receive them, and the company that's issuing them does not have to report to recognize in their financial statements the associated compensation expenses until the IPO or other liquidity event, like an exit or sale of the company, becomes probable.
- 11:12SPEAKER_00: So your compensation expenses omitted from the financial statements during the time that the IPO, in this case, is not probable.
- 11:24SPEAKER_00: That means that you have very low, if any, compensation expenses during this time period.
- 11:30SPEAKER_00: So that is quite a nice way of managing your expenses because compensation expenses are part of operating expenses.
- 11:40SPEAKER_00: Very few get capitalized.
- 11:42SPEAKER_00: So they would ordinarily hit your operating expenses.
- 11:46SPEAKER_00: That is the principle under the accounting rules in general.
- 11:49SPEAKER_00: The idea basically being that you're supposed to recognize expenses as the services are performed.
- 11:56SPEAKER_00: So in a typical stock option, you earn the stock option by performing services.
- 12:02SPEAKER_00: The company has to recognize the value of that stock option as an expense.
- 12:08SPEAKER_00: RSUs are more expensive because while an option is valued based on the value of the option, typically calculate like shoals or similar method, option pricing method, an RSU is basically measured as equal to the value of the underlying stock at grand.
- 12:27SPEAKER_00: So if you have a already high value for your stock, your RSUs are expensive.
- 12:33SPEAKER_00: But if you don't have to report them and recognize them on your financials, it makes them very attractive as a compensation tool.
- 12:41SPEAKER_00: So when do you have to recognize them?
- 12:43SPEAKER_00: You have to recognize them when the IPO becomes probable.
- 12:48SPEAKER_00: Well, that may be inconvenient because an IPO may become probable as you're preparing for an IPO.
- 12:56SPEAKER_00: However, the practice in the industry right now is that an IPO is never probable until it actually occurs.
- 13:05SPEAKER_00: Therefore, these compensation expenses are deferred or basically not recognized until the IPO has occurred, or until the registration statement for the IPO has been filed, depending on the way the companies draft their this liquidity condition.
- 13:27SPEAKER_00: So in that case, all these expenses which have accumulated over time will now hit the quarter in which the IPO occurs.
- 13:38SPEAKER_00: And they will all of a sudden all be recognized.
- 13:42SPEAKER_00: And that is a very large expense if the company has been very active in awarding RSUs to their employees and executives.
- 13:53SPEAKER_00: There are a number of other aggravating factors.
- 13:56SPEAKER_00: So one is that these RSUs are typically structured such that when the employee has performed the minimum required services for earning the underlying shares, they don't have to continue working at the company anymore, but they don't lose the right to receive those shares in the future.
- 14:17SPEAKER_00: So let's say you have four years of services.
- 14:20SPEAKER_00: Every year you earn 25%.
- 14:23SPEAKER_00: After one year, you leave, you will have at least received or secured 25% of your total award that cannot be taken away from you as long as the company goes public or otherwise has an exit during the rather lengthy term of your RSU award, which is typically seven to ten years.
- 14:44SPEAKER_00: So as long as the company goes public during this time period, you will eventually receive one quarter of your award, which also means that the expenses associated with that award, at least with that quarter, will have to be accumulated, will continue to accumulate and will ultimately be recognized.
- 15:05SPEAKER_00: On top of that, the accounting rules require that the company use something called accelerated attribution, which is front loading the expenses into the quarter when they get when these accumulated expenses get recognized.
- 15:23SPEAKER_00: This is a little bit complicated and it is not widely known and explained.
- 15:28SPEAKER_00: But what it does effectively, let's assume you have an employee award.
- 15:37SPEAKER_00: Each RSU is equal to one share, and they're earning them over two years.
- 15:42SPEAKER_00: Okay, so in a normal way that if these were options, they would be recognized every quarter, let's say, right?
- 15:51SPEAKER_00: Every month, every quarter.
- 15:52SPEAKER_00: So relatively, you know, manageable, right?
- 15:56SPEAKER_00: So you have, let's say, the the option is worth$10,000 for$24,000.
- 16:02SPEAKER_00: You basically have$240,000 total expenses for this award.
- 16:08SPEAKER_00: So you would recognize this award if you did it on a straight line basis every quarter, right?
- 16:14SPEAKER_00: So you would every quarter you would recognize these expenses, and so your quarter would very evenly look very basic.
- 16:22SPEAKER_00: So$30,000 per quarter is what you would recognize.
- 16:26SPEAKER_00: After one year, you would have recognized$120,000.
- 16:31SPEAKER_00: After two years, you would have recognized a total of$240,000.
- 16:34SPEAKER_00: But every quarter you're recognizing$30,000.
- 16:37SPEAKER_00: If you're using RSUs, double-trigger RSUs, you don't recognize any expenses until the IPO becomes probable.
- 16:45SPEAKER_00: Let's assume you're following the rule that IPO is never probable.
- 16:48SPEAKER_00: Not the rule, but the assumption here made IPO is never probable until the IPO actually occurs.
- 16:54SPEAKER_00: The IPO occurs at the end of the first year.
- 16:56SPEAKER_00: Now you would be assuming you recognize$120,000 in that quarter.
- 17:02SPEAKER_00: In reality, you're recognizing$200,000 under accelerate attribution, because you have to, under the accounting rules here, pull in, so to speak, prospective expenses for the future periods that you're assuming that employee who has to still be employed as of the IPO is going to continue performing services.
- 17:24SPEAKER_00: So that award,$240,000 total expenses, now gets recognized in the IPO quarter for$200,000, even though only 50% of the services have been performed.
- 17:37SPEAKER_00: So as you can see, this creates an enormous expense.
- 17:42SPEAKER_00: There are other factors, modification of the awards, all these things will start accumulating enormous expenses, all of which the company then recognizes in the quarter in which it completes its IPO.
- 17:58SPEAKER_00: So all of a sudden, a company goes from very few expenses to a lot of expenses.
- 18:05SPEAKER_00: So I give you one example, Uber, a long time ago, went public in May 2019.
- 18:10SPEAKER_00: And in that quarter, it recognized 3.6 billion in accumulated but previously deferred stock-based compensation expenses.
- 18:21SPEAKER_00: And all of these are from its pre-IPO award activity.
- 18:24SPEAKER_00: So 3.6 billion.
- 18:25SPEAKER_00: This is not even adjusted for inflation.
- 18:28SPEAKER_00: In the year before it had recognized any of these expenses, Uber had reported 172 million in stock-based compensation.
- 18:37SPEAKER_00: So relating to our stock options and other types of incentive instruments.
- 18:41SPEAKER_00: So it went from 172 at the end, you know, for the year end of 2018 to just a quarter in expenses, 3.6 billion.
- 18:52SPEAKER_00: So these expenses can accumulate and they can grow quite dramatically.
- 18:57SPEAKER_00: So you don't see them on your financials.
- 19:00SPEAKER_00: The companies, when they go public, when they present their financials, they will not show these expenses, which have been deferred, and they will only hit the financial results after the company's gone public.
- 19:12SPEAKER_00: And only when it reports the earnings or the financial results for the quarter in which the IPO occurs.
- 19:21SPEAKER_00: This is the fundamental issue that is associated with double trigger RSUs.
- 19:27SPEAKER_00: Now, it is not just a one-time expense.
- 19:29SPEAKER_00: This is called the catch-up expense.
- 19:31SPEAKER_00: You're catching up from all of these expenses that you have accumulated but deferred over time and that you bring in for future periods because of accelerated attribution.
- 19:43SPEAKER_00: But because companies engage in intensifying RSU award activity before the IPO, these expenses will continue to haunt the financial results for periods after the IPO quarter.
- 20:01SPEAKER_00: So for the earnings or results of the IPO quarter, this is not a one-time non-recurring expense.
- 20:09SPEAKER_00: I can show my paper that these are actually only about 50% or so, and you know, on average, but that for a lot of companies, these continue to haunt them, continue to have an impact on their financials for the immediate periods following the IPO.
- 20:27SPEAKER_00: I have a very nice illustration of Robin Hood, which had continued to deal with enormous expenses from its pre-IPO award activity for periods after the IPO quarter, which they then had to recognize.
- 20:41SPEAKER_00: All of this from pre-IPO ward activity because these companies increased their ward activity or engaged in double-trigger RCU award activity and then intensified that activity ahead of the IPO.
- 20:54SPEAKER_00: That's the other aspect.
- 20:56SPEAKER_00: This is not a one-time issue.
- 20:57SPEAKER_00: It is all of a sudden a fundamental change in how companies are reporting their stock-based compensation.
- 21:04SPEAKER_02: So, Professor, let's say I'm an institutional investor and I'm looking at a current or an upcoming IPO.
- 21:11SPEAKER_02: How do I use your research to have better insight as to whether I should invest in a current or a future IPO?
- 21:18SPEAKER_00: So there are two aspects here that are really important to understand.
- 21:22SPEAKER_00: So I looked at this from a statistical perspective as well, whether this makes a difference.
- 21:28SPEAKER_00: So you see companies who have utilized double trigger RSUs extensively.
- 21:35SPEAKER_00: And when they report, they typically report adjusted earnings, which excludes these expenses, with the argument that these are paper expenses.
- 21:44SPEAKER_00: Well, they are real expenses, right?
- 21:46SPEAKER_00: I mean, this really impacts the costs.
- 21:48SPEAKER_00: So I wanted to see what the market does with that.
- 21:51SPEAKER_00: Because the argument seems to be that don't look this way, look the other way, ignore what's here, only focus on adjusted D Bita because they Yeah, these were expenses from when we were young or whatever.
- 22:03SPEAKER_00: They they don't really matter.
- 22:04SPEAKER_00: Well, the market unfortunately feels different.
- 22:08SPEAKER_00: So I did an analysis using something called threshold uh analysis, statistical models that are based on actually biomedical research, where you're trying to distinguish at what point is a dose harmful or you know a condition harmful to a group of patients.
- 22:29SPEAKER_00: So I used a concept called MACstat or Maximally Selective Statistics, which basically identifies if there is a statistically relevant threshold at which these expenses have an impact on stock performance.
- 22:46SPEAKER_00: And around$100 million, this is on inflation adjusted numbers, 100 million, and specifically 107 million in stock-based compensation catch up expenses that are reported for that IPO quarter after the IPO, there is an 83% chance of a risk-adjusted stock decline of the stock.
- 23:10SPEAKER_00: When you compare the performance of the stock before the earnings are released for that IPO quarter compared to what the stock price looks like on a risk-adjusted basis after the earnings are reported.
- 23:25SPEAKER_00: So I looked at two periods, 10 trading days and 20 trading days before the earnings release date, and then 10 and 20 days after.
- 23:34SPEAKER_00: So only if the stock declined over both periods, so from 20 trading days pre-earnings announcement to 20 trading days after, and 10 trading days pre to 10 trading days post-earnings announcement.
- 23:52SPEAKER_00: If in both cases there was a stock decline, I treated that as a decline, so very conservative.
- 23:58SPEAKER_00: And it was 83% of companies who had reported more than 100 million, 107 million, at least 107 million or more, had an 83% risk of stock decline versus the companies who did not have those expenses, you know, catch-up expense of 107 million or more, or had none of them.
- 24:21SPEAKER_00: In that case, the decline was basically 50-50.
- 24:25SPEAKER_00: It was 47.8% risk of decline.
- 24:29SPEAKER_00: And this statistically relevant, there's a paper contains, and there's also an appendix, and numerous um statistical analyses, validation tests to show this.
- 24:38SPEAKER_00: This is a real risk.
- 24:40SPEAKER_00: This is what the RSU reckoning is about.
- 24:42SPEAKER_00: There is a real risk that if you invest before the earnings announcement, so 10, 20 trading days before the earnings announcement, that 10 or 20 days after the earnings announcement, the stock will have declined if the company reported RSU expenses, catch-up expenses of 107 million or more.
- 25:06SPEAKER_00: So that was something we showed that.
- 25:08SPEAKER_00: I showed that in a number of different uh scenarios.
- 25:12SPEAKER_00: And you know, we did all I did a lot of stress testing on this, but that's one of the outcomes.
- 25:17SPEAKER_00: Now, this is different if you're an IPO investor.
- 25:19SPEAKER_00: So this is very important to understand.
- 25:21SPEAKER_00: If you're an IPO investor, you benefit from underpricing.
- 25:24SPEAKER_00: You basically have a much, it's about 50-50.
- 25:29SPEAKER_00: If you measure from the IPO price to the performance of the stock 10 or 20 days after the earnings announcement, 10 or 20 trading days on a risk, uh risk adjusted basis, you have a much higher chance of still coming out okay.
- 25:45SPEAKER_00: And you have the benefit as an IPO investor.
- 25:48SPEAKER_00: So somebody buys at the IPO price at the IPO, you have the benefit of selling before the earnings announcement.
- 25:55SPEAKER_00: And you would make money statistically in my research.
- 25:58SPEAKER_00: So this benefits IPO investors.
- 26:01SPEAKER_00: They could be much better off if these accounting rules were not there and these expenses were recognized appropriately over time, but they are shielded compared to secondary market investors.
- 26:12SPEAKER_00: So whether you're a fund who decides they want to invest after the IPO, but before the earnings announcement, or you're a retail investor, you couldn't even participate in the earnings in the IPO, but now you feel you want to invest, you need to beware of the risks associated with the earnings release for the IPO quarter if that earnings release now reports significant stock-based compensation expenses associated with these double-trig RSUs that basically resulted from pre-IPO awards and that had been deferred until the IPO.
- 26:47SPEAKER_02: Professor, your paper indicates that the big four accounting firms may have some responsibility for the promotion of the practice of pre-IPO companies awarding restricted stock units as compensation.
- 26:59SPEAKER_02: So, could you explain the role of the large accounting firms with respect to restricted stock units and their popularity?
- 27:08SPEAKER_00: So this goes way all the way back to when these instruments were first introduced as a type of compensation expense.
- 27:15SPEAKER_00: And this is before the dawn of the unicorn era.
- 27:18SPEAKER_00: This involved Zynga, Facebook, and Twitter, the early kind of the three earliest companies that started using RSUs and that went public.
- 27:28SPEAKER_00: So 2011, 2012, and 2013, if I recall correctly, yes.
- 27:33SPEAKER_00: So these companies basically decided to adopt RSUs for various reasons.
- 27:39SPEAKER_00: Don't need to go into them here now, but uh Zynga was the first one that actually, even though Facebook was the first one that came up with the RSU structure, Zynga actually was the first one to go public.
- 27:51SPEAKER_00: And so the SEC inquired during the IPO, you know, uh registration statement review process very aggressively and and in detail of why Zynga thinks that it can defer these compensation expenses.
- 28:04SPEAKER_00: And these were you know, these were significant expenses at the time, even on a adjusted basis.
- 28:10SPEAKER_00: Zynga had deferred recognition of$510 million in 2011, and so that would have been$707 million.
- 28:20SPEAKER_00: Now they had a they the the expenses were a little bit less at the time of the reporting period that were included in the financial statements, but not that much less.
- 28:31SPEAKER_00: I believe it was Zynga had 393 million deferred, and so the SEC said, Well, why are you not recognizing them?
- 28:40SPEAKER_00: And Zynga basically said effectively made the argument together as auditors that the position that the accounting profession is taking is that an IPO is never probable until it actually occurs.
- 28:54SPEAKER_00: Because the rules are quite specific.
- 28:56SPEAKER_00: The rules say that are promulgated, adopted, codified by FASB here in Connecticut, that these are performance conditions.
- 29:07SPEAKER_00: So you need to evaluate at the end of every quarter whether the IPO condition here in our case is probable.
- 29:17SPEAKER_00: And probable means likely to occur.
- 29:19SPEAKER_00: If it is likely to occur, you are supposed to now recognize all of this catch-up expense.
- 29:25SPEAKER_00: That's the rule.
- 29:26SPEAKER_00: Nevertheless, the accounting, the leading representatives of the accounting profession that are involved in IPOs, and in this case, of the companies that deferred, of the unicorns in my sample that had deferred significant RSU-based compensation expenses, all of them were represented by a member of the Big Four, except the one that was Grant Thornton.
- 29:51SPEAKER_00: Not represented, but had their auditors, their auditors as one of the big four or Grant Thornton.
- 29:57SPEAKER_00: They all take the position that an IPO, regardless of what these rules say, an IPO is never probable until it actually occurs.
- 30:05SPEAKER_00: And that's the position that they argued to the SECs.
- 30:08SPEAKER_00: They didn't argue that, hey, the IPO is not probable, which would have required an actual analysis, right?
- 30:14SPEAKER_00: And questions like that.
- 30:16SPEAKER_00: No, they just they basically took the position, citing the other big four accounting firms and so on, to the SEC in during the review process that that Zinger's IPO would never be probable until it actually occurred.
- 30:31SPEAKER_00: And that is the rule when it comes to an IPO.
- 30:33SPEAKER_00: And the SEC caved in the end.
- 30:35SPEAKER_00: And that is the position that you will find in the published guidance literature, however you want to call it, you know, that the big four and firms like Grant Thornton basically state that IPOs should not be viewed as requiring an IP, you know, IPO, a probability, uh likely to occur analysis at the end of each quarter.
- 31:00SPEAKER_00: They are simply never probable until they occur.
- 31:04SPEAKER_00: So, and depends on how you define the liquidity conditions.
- 31:07SPEAKER_00: Maybe you can say, you know, when the registration statement for the IPO is declared effective.
- 31:12SPEAKER_00: Okay, so you basically say then it's never likely that the registration statement will be declared effective by the SEC until it is declared effective by the SEC.
- 31:24SPEAKER_00: So that's the problem.
- 31:25SPEAKER_00: Now, of course, this would be very inconvenient, right?
- 31:28SPEAKER_00: I mean, you're basically preparing for the IPO, and the chances are that the IPO is going to happen, you know, likely to occur.
- 31:36SPEAKER_00: This is not beyond a reasonable doubt, right?
- 31:38SPEAKER_00: This is not, you know, when we're not here at the enormously high standard, although the accounting firms typically say something like, I believe Ernst and Young has said it's more than 70%.
- 31:50SPEAKER_00: Um, so 71% is likely to occur.
- 31:53SPEAKER_00: But again, their view is that an IPO is never likely until it actually has occurred.
- 32:00SPEAKER_00: And you will see that stated in the registration statements as an accounting principle.
- 32:06SPEAKER_00: And it's really remarkable.
- 32:07SPEAKER_00: I mean, I then looked in my paper, what are the actual distances between the last, the most recent quarter before the IPO and then the actual IPO?
- 32:19SPEAKER_00: And so if you look from pricing, it is uh it's quite remarkable.
- 32:23SPEAKER_00: You will find that um that there are companies who took the position that that the IPO was not probable, even though the quarter ended.
- 32:32SPEAKER_00: Remember, at the end of the quarter, you're supposed to make that assessment, probable or not.
- 32:37SPEAKER_00: And they made the conclusion that, you know, they did not have to uh include these numbers, even though their IPO was 15 days or less from being priced.
- 32:48SPEAKER_00: Pinterest 17 days before the IPO priced, they took the position that they did not have to include the catch-up expenses, which were close to a billion dollars and over a billion in uh inflation-adjusted amounts in their financials for that quarter.
- 33:06SPEAKER_00: So this is quite remarkable.
- 33:08SPEAKER_00: And they will state it as I don't have to report it until the IPO actually occurs.
- 33:15SPEAKER_00: It is remarkable that the auditors are not taking a more conservative view of this, given how much money is at stake.
- 33:22SPEAKER_02: Well, Professor, your paper recommends several regulatory reforms, including requiring IPO candidates to provide full disclosure of their stock-based compensation deferral practices and the consequences arising from those practices.
- 33:38SPEAKER_02: As you're aware, uh Securities Exchange Commission chair Paul Atkins has signaled a shift toward a leaner, more principle-based disclosure framework, one that would recalibrate what companies are expected to disclose about compensation, including stock-based compensation.
- 33:55SPEAKER_02: So, what specifically is your recommendation to the SEC regarding disclosure of RSUs?
- 34:04SPEAKER_02: And how do you square your recommendation with your Atkins' views on compensation disclosures generally?
- 34:10SPEAKER_00: Before I answer that, let me just make one statement, but it's really shocking to me, is when you look at the quality of the disclosure that you see in for these large, prominent unicorns, right?
- 34:22SPEAKER_00: When it comes to the deferred, unrecognized compensation expenses that they know they will incur as soon as the IPO ends, right, by their measure, right?
- 34:35SPEAKER_00: They're saying, hey, these expenses will be recognized if and when the IPO occurs, right?
- 34:41SPEAKER_00: Not when it's probable, because maybe that would have been even earlier, but certainly when the IPO occurs, even by their view, they know these expenses are coming.
- 34:53SPEAKER_00: They also know which ones are coming after the IPO quarter because of the accelerated attribution method.
- 35:00SPEAKER_00: Because they're pulling in expenses for future services, they also know what those future expenses are going to be.
- 35:07SPEAKER_00: Nevertheless, the disclosures are very inadequate.
- 35:12SPEAKER_00: And I make you know an argument in my paper quite in detail that they do not comply with item 303 with the MDA MDNA requirements regarding these kind of future expenses, especially since they you know arguably relate to cost of labor and the increases.
- 35:30SPEAKER_00: And I give numerous examples.
- 35:32SPEAKER_00: I am very surprised that this has not been the subject of litigation.
- 35:37SPEAKER_00: I think part of this is or enforcement actions by the SEC.
- 35:40SPEAKER_00: I think part of this is because it's relatively complex.
- 35:43SPEAKER_00: This is not easy to understand, and again, these are presented as one-time expenses a lot of the times, which is not really uh the case.
- 35:53SPEAKER_00: So that was already a surprise.
- 35:55SPEAKER_00: I mean, even under the existing rules, under item 303, there need there should be a lot more disclosure, uh, a lot more detail.
- 36:04SPEAKER_00: You're supposed to analyze what is the impact.
- 36:06SPEAKER_00: I show some really interesting examples of the kind of things that companies engage in.
- 36:12SPEAKER_00: They don't disclose, they may disclose the catch-up expense somewhere, maybe even under a different heading, but then they don't disclose the future time period, you know, the expenses over the immediately following time periods, which remarkably the early companies, so Facebook, Zynga, and Twitter, they did that.
- 36:30SPEAKER_00: They took the view that item three or three required not only disclosing the catch up expense, but hey, just so you know, for the next quarter, for the next year, we're still gonna have these expenses, we're gonna have these expenses.
- 36:43SPEAKER_00: I mean, if you look at the Robin Hood expenses, they are remarkable how many, uh, how many more or the extent, the magnitude of these expenses following the IPO quarter, uh, which was already enormous, a million, uh, a billion dollars, uh, recognized catch up expenses, but then in future periods after the IPO quarter, what those expenses look like.
- 37:06SPEAKER_00: And Robin Hood did not disclose that in the IPO prospectus, even though they knew what they would be.
- 37:11SPEAKER_00: They disclosed them arguably.
- 37:13SPEAKER_00: I'm making the argument here, but they did disclose them in the 10K uh when they first filed at 10K and uh put that in the footnotes.
- 37:20SPEAKER_00: So these expenses are not easy to follow and to understand.
- 37:26SPEAKER_00: And companies really are playing a dangerous game, uh, not informing investors what the magnitude of these expenses are.
- 37:34SPEAKER_00: I give numerous examples where they effectively are downplaying, to my mind, the actual expense, the magnitude of these expenses, and when these expenses will be incurred.
- 37:45SPEAKER_00: And it's really difficult for investors to understand.
- 37:48SPEAKER_00: And then don't be surprised when the market reacts when all of a sudden you see these expenses.
- 37:54SPEAKER_00: So the SEC chair's proposal make me nervous because I mean, so we want to distinguish between disclosure regarding compensation and disclosure regarding compensation expenses.
- 38:06SPEAKER_00: But here's the issue, right?
- 38:07SPEAKER_00: At the IPO stage, these expenses are not recognized.
- 38:12SPEAKER_00: And so now it is the company's decision as to how much do we need to disclose in the financials, you know, the notes to the financials, or in the mDNA.
- 38:22SPEAKER_00: And if you're talking about simplifying the disclosures or whatever, it is going to be quite challenging to reconcile that with the existing inadequate to me in my paper, as I argue and show my paper, inadequate disclosure practices relating to these future expenses that are already known to companies, and then to see how that is going to impact how that would be treated under this proposed new approach, it would be even less prominent, is what I fear.
- 38:53SPEAKER_02: Professor, as you know, in May, the Securities Exchange Commission issued a proposed rule that would give public companies the option of switching from quarterly reporting to semi-annual reporting.
- 39:05SPEAKER_02: So, based on your research, do you support the SEC proposal?
- 39:10SPEAKER_02: Why or why not?
- 39:12SPEAKER_00: No.
- 39:13SPEAKER_00: And I actually give an example in my paper on this.
- 39:16SPEAKER_00: Again, remember, they don't show the expenses before the IPO and their financials.
- 39:22SPEAKER_00: They accumulate them off the book.
- 39:24SPEAKER_00: So depending on the timing, now if you're an investor, you may only see all these expenses that have now accumulated from pre-IPO awards when you do your you know full year or half-year reporting.
- 39:39SPEAKER_00: And that, you know, again, the earnings release will take even longer, right?
- 39:43SPEAKER_00: So I have a footnote in the paper showing about Robinhood.
- 39:45SPEAKER_00: This would have delayed Robinhood's disclosures by I think another three months or so if quarter reporting had already been abandoned at Robinhood's IPO, for example, right?
- 39:54SPEAKER_00: So so this is this is really, really challenging.
- 39:57SPEAKER_00: And by then, these expenses, remember, they continue to accrue and they continue to for all the pre-IPO awards, because they were all double trigger, doesn't matter that the IPOs now happened, they still have to be recognized on an accelerated attribution basis.
- 40:12SPEAKER_00: And you continue to award now RSUs to employees once you're public.
- 40:16SPEAKER_00: So these expenses will just continue to grow.
- 40:20SPEAKER_00: I don't understand why this is of interest to any IPO company that they would want this, because the expenses will be even greater, likely, because you know, more time has passed and the reporting period is longer so that the costs will have accumulated that will then be reported.
- 40:40SPEAKER_00: It would be more interesting and more in line, uh, more more, I would say, palatable and more in line with current practices to have quarterly reporting so that uh you get these expenses be done with them uh as quickly as possible, right?
- 40:56SPEAKER_00: This catch-up expense.
- 40:57SPEAKER_00: For investors, they will have again talking about the poor disclosure practices that, as I argue in my paper, this would mean they're even more in the dark.
- 41:08SPEAKER_00: And all of a sudden they see these expenses.
- 41:10SPEAKER_00: And and remember, these expenses they may be viewed as paper, but they are directly impacting the bottom line, right?
- 41:17SPEAKER_00: They're directly impacting the financial results.
- 41:20SPEAKER_00: So to make up for them, you need to grow revenue, you need to actually grow quite dramatically, and even if you do, the financial results will may only show you know some growth, maybe none, because you're countering the effect that these accumulated expenses are now having on your financial results.
- 41:41SPEAKER_00: And this is in nobody's interest.
- 41:44SPEAKER_00: That's why I argue that they should be these expenses should be recognized just like a traditional time-based option.
- 41:51SPEAKER_00: Recognize them over time because that's what this is for.
- 41:55SPEAKER_00: This whole idea of, you know, we're tying it to an IPO is simply a deferral mechanism.
- 42:01SPEAKER_00: It is simply a deferral mechanism.
- 42:03SPEAKER_00: It makes everybody look bad, it doesn't help investors.
- 42:08SPEAKER_00: Investors don't see the full picture.
- 42:10SPEAKER_00: It's still, even if you treat it that way, will not solve the whole problem because these companies do engage in intensifying, as I mentioned, intensifying award activity prior to the IPO.
- 42:24SPEAKER_00: And so there will be some increase in expense, but it will already go a long way to managing these expenses properly and for investors to understand, you know, the scope of you know what awaits them when they uh attend the earnings conference or or or see the earnings results.
- 42:40SPEAKER_00: Because right now they're they're basically uh kind of left in the dark.
- 42:43SPEAKER_00: And as I also mentioned, um, so my paper provides now empirical support for the fact that having these high compensation expenses is a risk factor, a risk factor of stock decline, and that companies should include those in their IPO prospectus.
- 43:01SPEAKER_00: But I, as I show my paper, almost very few companies do that effectively, if at all, and they don't even quantify what these expenses are as part of the risk factors.
- 43:12SPEAKER_02: That concludes our podcast episode on behalf of the Council of Institutional Investors.
- 43:16SPEAKER_02: I want to thank my special guest, this is Ven Reitmueller, Clinical Professor of Law at Yale Law School, and director of the Entrepreneurship and Innovation Clinic, also at Yale Law School.
- 43:26SPEAKER_02: If you have any questions or comments regarding this podcast, please feel free to contact me at Jeff.
- 43:31SPEAKER_02: That's J E F F at C I dot O-R-T.
- 43:34SPEAKER_02: Until next time, I'm Jeff Mahoney.
- 43:36SPEAKER_02: Thanks again for listening to the voice of corporate governance.
- 43:47SPEAKER_01: Thank you for listening to this episode of The Voice of Corporate Governance, brought to you by the Council of Institutional Investors.
- 43:54SPEAKER_01: The Voice of Corporate Governance is a free, non-sponsored podcast that highlights critical developments in corporate governance and other important issues affecting institutional investors.
- 44:04SPEAKER_01: The views expressed by those interviewed on the podcast do not necessarily reflect the views of CII or its members.
- 44:11SPEAKER_01: For more information on CII and its policies on corporate governance, please visit our website at www.cii.org.