Latest / TheThinkingAtheist / Nanny Software: Surveilling People "Straight"
Transcript
- 0:00We understand the thinking atheist. It's not a person, it's a symbol,
- 0:09an idea. The population of atheists this country is going through the rule,
- 0:14rejecting faith, pursuing knowledge, challenging the sacred. If I tell the truth,
- 0:20it's because I tell the truth, not because I put my hand on
- 0:23a book and made a wish and working together for a more rational world.
- 0:29Take the risk of thinking. Feel so much more happiness. Truth Usian wisdom
- 0:33will come to you that way. Assume nothing, question everything, and start
- 0:40thinking. This is the Thinking Atheist podcast hosted by Seth Andrews. If you
- 0:57are anywhere near Springfield, Missouri, on the fifteenth of November, I Am
- 1:02going to be hosted by Springfield Freethinkers to come out and give a presentation.
- 1:07This is brand new, by the way. It's called Seth Andrews versus God?
- 1:12Who is the better intelligent Designer? And I've got some ideas I'm just
- 1:19saying. So if you want to come out, it's going to be a
- 1:21great night's all are welcome. For tickets and information, you can just define
- 1:26the link on my website Seth Andrews dot com slash events. Here is just
- 1:37a tiny window into what my life was like in a Puritan family. It
- 1:42was nineteen eighty six, nineteen eighty seven, the film Children of a Lesser
- 1:49God had just released. This is a wonderful movie starring William Hurt and Marley
- 1:53Mattlin. And her character is deaf. She works like a janitorial job at
- 2:01a school. She is a broken person. She has been tremendously traumatized in
- 2:07her life, partially because of her disability and how she was treated. And
- 2:12there's a scene in the film where after hours, she goes into where the
- 2:17pool is. There's a swimming pool, and she strips off her clothes and
- 2:21she submerges herself in the water. And this is symbolism, right. She
- 2:27is a person who is raw, she is exposed, and she is essentially
- 2:31to a degree, living in a world without sound. So the scene has
- 2:36real power in so many ways. And I'm home, I am watching this.
- 2:43Mom and dadd are in the room, and that scene happens on the
- 2:47television. There is Marlee Matlin's bare ass underwater in the pool, and my
- 2:57father was beside himself the TV. He was immediately shut off. And I
- 3:01get the sermon, you get this is new to you can't show that.
- 3:06My father used to say it like this. He'd say she was in the
- 3:09buff, which I guess in the buff means you're nude or naked. But
- 3:15this was like sinful material. There was no beauty in it. There was
- 3:21no deeper meaning to be learned about, sort of the raw nature of the
- 3:25exposed human self. None of that. No, no, no, he
- 3:29just saw skin. He flipped out, and he didn't want that video in
- 3:32his house. Oh, I'm sure he had wished for a filter. We're
- 3:38going to talk about a bunch of that kind of thing today. We're going
- 3:43to talk a lot about sex. That's how my mother used to say the
- 3:47word fox. Her face would just sort of contort like it was painful.
- 3:53And Natalie's always ribbing me because I'm one of five kids, and so Natalie's
- 4:02like, well, you're one of five, so your parents were getting it
- 4:06on somewhere. I'm like, nah, no, nan la la la la
- 4:10la. Don't talk about that. But I mean, I guess it happened
- 4:16unless I was born in a tube or a lab or whatever. But my
- 4:20parents were not affectionate. They didn't express any physical affection. They were intellectual
- 4:28partners. And this sort of fed into a sense of shame about physicality,
- 4:34about sensuality, about sexuality. That was part of the temperature of my home,
- 4:42and it's also part of the temperature of many Puritan cultures, high control
- 4:46religions, especially. So we're going to talk about what my friend, doctor
- 4:50Darryl Ray calls nanny software. We're going to talk about pornography, sex addiction.
- 4:58I'm going to bring in a clinical psychologist and sex expert to get into
- 5:02that. We're just gonna we're going to do some stuff that would have definitely
- 5:08had my father reaching for the off button on the television. I had some
- 5:15experience with this kind of nanny software back in the early days. This was
- 5:19back in the nineteen nineties. I was a Christian radio host and I was
- 5:26asked to endorse a client. This client was pitching a service, a filter,
- 5:30a morality filter, designed to help you navigate the wild west of this
- 5:36new thing called the World Wide Web. The service I was endorsing was called
- 5:42Integrity Online, and the commercials I did for the service were what you might
- 5:47expect, this wonderful software or I don't know if it was a browser filter.
- 5:53It's been so long, but this will block out violent material, filthy
- 5:58language, and certainly the most important thing, it will lock out porn.
- 6:03Now did this service work? And the real question I know you want to
- 6:10ask me is did you ever test it to make sure it worked? Hell?
- 6:15No, I didn't test it, not because I was mister clean,
- 6:19but because I was terrified that if I tested it by typing something naughty into
- 6:27a search engine, it would set off an alarm at the client. They
- 6:30would notify my employer, who would in turn thank me for my years of
- 6:35service and escort me out of my career. We had just had a guy
- 6:41who worked at one of our sisters stations in a different state and they found
- 6:46porn that was downloaded to his office computer and they fired him on the spot.
- 6:53I mean they found out and they said sorry, you are terminated.
- 6:57And he cried and he apologized and prayed and he begged, please don't fire
- 7:01me, but boom, he was gone, just like that. So the
- 7:05whole point of filtering and monitoring and screening and even reporting was to keep this
- 7:13kind of thing from happening. The problem was Integrity Online was horrible at knowing
- 7:18the difference between what would have been considered an evil site and a legitimate site.
- 7:25We got complaints across the board, and Integrity Online blocked me at almost
- 7:31every turn I would try to go to a mainstream news page, access denied,
- 7:38lifestyle and entertainment online access denied, trivia and game sites access denied.
- 7:48I'm sure even decades later, this kind of thing is a problem now,
- 7:54and I think it's because these developers simply can't keep up with the massively complicated
- 8:00nuances of the web. Software code has no idea about context. It didn't
- 8:05understand intent. That couldn't know the difference between a kink in somebody's armor or
- 8:13a kink in somebody's bedroom. But the whole concept just roots in moral panic
- 8:20about the temptations of the outside world. James One talks about tempted people.
- 8:26They're dragged away by their own evil desire and enticed Luke twenty two forty.
- 8:33Pray that you will not fall into temptation, Matthew chapter six, verse thirteen,
- 8:39and lead us not into temptation, but deliver us from the evil one.
- 8:46I find it interesting a lot of religious people think that temptation or being
- 8:50tempted is a sin, like the temptation. I am tempted then I've sinned.
- 8:56And here's what I mean. Let's say that I am not married,
- 9:01I am outside of wedlock, as they like to say. But I've got
- 9:07a girlfriend, and my girlfriend and I are alone in the house. We're
- 9:11both tempted to have sex. We don't have sex, but we are tempted,
- 9:18and then we resist the temptation. However, before we both separate in
- 9:24our holiness and then go home for a cold shower in some prayer time,
- 9:28we had just for a second really been considering it. We'd thought about it.
- 9:33Wouldn't that be something if we could have sex? Had we still not
- 9:39sinned? Hadn't I sinned? Matthew five? Anyone who looks at a woman
- 9:45with lust has already committed adultery with her in his heart. I had looked
- 9:52at her with lust. But wait a minute, I resisted the temptation.
- 9:58I got out of there, didn't have sex, but I was still a
- 10:01sinner. I didn't commit adultery, but I was still an adulterer. Does
- 10:05that mean temptation? Being tempted considering the temptation is itself a sin? The
- 10:13Book of Hebrews says that Christ himself was tempted in all things did he just
- 10:20express no desire to give in? Or did he take a moment and say,
- 10:24hmm, what if? Right? I mean, he was one hundred
- 10:28percent God, but he was also somehow one hundred percent man. Christ tempted
- 10:35in all things. The Bible says, flee temptation, but Christ stayed there.
- 10:41So was he a sinner? Jesus seemed awfully prone to surrounding himself with
- 10:48forbidden fruit. Did his eyes ever wander? Did he ever fantasize? Was
- 10:54he sitting at his ancient web browser wondering what might happen to him if he
- 10:58typed the words hot harlot. All he had to do would be to pull
- 11:03up his ancient search engine Jerusaleugal and then click download photo. Download speeds for
- 11:11naked pictures would have been really slow back then, but he's Jesus, so
- 11:16he could have sped that up. So tempting. Jesus was tempted in all
- 11:22things, just as we are tempted with all that carnality today, and lo
- 11:30and behold, accountability software is here to save the day. The website for
- 11:37Accountable to you, it is a marital aid, if you'll pardon the expression,
- 11:43It is a preventative dongle for your fondle. Okay, let me play
- 11:48you just a little bit of the website video about how accountable to You works.
- 11:56So what can you do to help encourage your family's purity in this digital
- 11:58aid? Introducing accountable to You software for all of the major operating systems that
- 12:05facilitates openness, transparency, and integrity between individuals and families through comprehensive, easy
- 12:11to read reporting. How does it work? Simply install accountable to You on
- 12:18your laptops, desktops, and mobile devices, then set an accountability partner for
- 12:22each device. For example, you might want to be the accountability partner for
- 12:26your kids while setting your devices to report to your spouse or someone in your
- 12:31church. Accountability partners will then receive daily or weekly reports on device activity.
- 12:39Our sophisticated system can also send instant text alerts if something objectionable is detected,
- 12:43so partners can check in immediately. Okay, beyond the fact that these people
- 12:50need a sound engineer, somebody who knows how to properly mix sound so that
- 12:54the music doesn't drown out the narrator, what do we take away from the
- 12:58c But I'm not going to focus on children. I think that's a different
- 13:01conversation right now. I'm talking about the age of consent. Crowd. We
- 13:07choose an accountability partner. Accountable to you says it will link your spouse to
- 13:16everything you do online, because nothing says relational trust like being monitored twenty four
- 13:24to seven quick digression. I actually knew a couple where the wife would do
- 13:33this to her husband. They would sit down at dinner. I heard about
- 13:37this from their kids, by the way, their grown children, who were
- 13:39kind of like, oh my god. But they would sit down at dinner
- 13:45and she would hold out her hand and he would be expected to hand over
- 13:50his phone, and she would just go through it, checking all of his
- 13:54text who's talking to him? Checking all of his photographs, checking his browser
- 13:58history. I guess, And I thought to myself, you know, I
- 14:03really appreciate the idea of openness and transparency. Right. We don't want we
- 14:09don't want people who live secret, second or even third lives. But is
- 14:16this how a healthy relationship works? Now? I'm not talking about somebody who
- 14:22sees a lot of red flags. You know, you have genuine, sincere
- 14:28suspicion that there may be infidelity going on or there's there are lies being told,
- 14:35abuses being covered up in some way, abuses of trust. I think
- 14:39that's a different conversation. You know, this is I'm not talking about the
- 14:41CSI where you are having to do some real digging, and maybe that does
- 14:48include private conversations that have been kept out of your view. I think that's
- 14:52different. I'm talking about a relationship that is defined by distrust. You sit
- 14:56down and they say, give me your phone, I'm going to go through
- 15:00everything. Give me all your passwords. I'm going to go through everything.
- 15:05Is that a healthy thing? Like a manual version of accountable to You,
- 15:11which sends out reports daily and weekly to the surveillance team, your accountability partners.
- 15:20Oh, you want to try to browse the web anonymously in incognito mode.
- 15:26You try to modify the software, uninstalled the service? Uh uh alarm
- 15:31bells go off? Big brother knows and I think, most ironically, at
- 15:37the bottom of the features page of this surveillance service website, they have the
- 15:43words committed to your freedom. Accountable to You. That'll cost you about one
- 15:50hundred and fifty dollars a year. Here's another one, ever, accountable same
- 15:58stuff. Lead me Not is another one. It lets you actually note what
- 16:06your specific temptations are. What do you struggle with, what's your inclination,
- 16:11your desire, your lust, your focus, your fetish, and lead me
- 16:17Not gives you extra material for those specific temptations and triggers. Do you feel
- 16:22triggered to sin? There's a button on the website. I'm triggered and this
- 16:30is a bad signal to your accountability partner, whoever that person is. They
- 16:34see this thing. Ah, Bob's being triggered, Kate is being triggered.
- 16:41Holy shit, I need to jump in and save the day. If you
- 16:45don't have an accountability partner, lead me Not, We'll find a person for
- 16:52you. And I am not making this up. The website says it might
- 16:55even be Jason Matthew, the founder of the company. If you're more self
- 17:03sustaining, if you trust yourself just a little bit more, here's a service,
- 17:07a self control service called Plucky p luck Y. The default setting on
- 17:18Plucky blocks all images and all videos on all websites, no media, no
- 17:30media can get through. And then wouldn't this be a joy. You have
- 17:36to go in and you have to specifically designate and allow each image or video
- 17:45I guess this may keep you too busy to stream Quentin Tarmantino films and pictures
- 17:52of bear boobs. You just don't have the time. You're busy allowing the
- 17:55good content. Covenant Eyes, I think maybe the most popular service of this
- 18:00kind. Covenant Eye says it as one point five million users and for just
- 18:07sixteen ninety nine a month, you can experience quote victory over porn, and
- 18:15that's the main focus for Covenant Eyes. Porn. The homepage says porn creates
- 18:22shame, shame fuels porn usage. And I think this is hugely interesting because
- 18:30Covenant Eyes does not mention what the source of the shame is. Right,
- 18:34they want to install the software, but who installed the shame. Now,
- 18:40let me play you a clip from three geniuses who were pitching Covenant Eyes on
- 18:45their show The Authentic Christian Podcast. This is on YouTube. The hosts are
- 18:52Aaron Gallagher, Scott Ingram and Tucker Wallace. So they were talking about purity
- 18:57software account of bild the option sexual purbity, especially against porn. Here is
- 19:04a quote unquote solution to keep yourself from having sex outside of marriage. Check
- 19:14out this advice. One thing that's that I want to bring some encouragement.
- 19:18Is that I said, I know sometimes when you look for look forward to
- 19:21marriage, especially in college, you're like, I'll watch porn for a while,
- 19:23then I quit it. So what I'm saying is that God designed those
- 19:29sexual desires for marriage, and and like sometimes we think that God's going to
- 19:33take away from me. He's the one that designs sex and the enjoyment for
- 19:37marriage, and so the people in the world are twisting it. Wait for
- 19:41your wife or your husband, and just a summary of five Proverbs five eighteen
- 19:47through nineteen's just like, let your found me blessed and rejoice with the wife's
- 19:51of your youth as a loving deer and a graceful doe. Let her breast
- 19:55satisfy you all times, and always be enraptured with her love and wooden versions
- 19:57as intoxicated. Say all that to say that there is like all that stuff
- 20:03that's been twisted. You can fully enjoy your marriage with sex like it's there's
- 20:07a place for it. And guess what I mean, I'm gonna say,
- 20:11you don't have to be thirty. I think our culture is really I'm I
- 20:15personally think the devil one in this way too, where he basically makes people
- 20:18think that you shouldn't get married till you're thirty, because if you get married,
- 20:21you know you want to wait, you to live your life, you
- 20:22want to go to high school, you want to go to college, you
- 20:25want to show you're while to I think it's stupid. I mean, yeah,
- 20:27my wife and I didn't get married till later. That's because it didn't
- 20:30meet her till later. But like my advice would be me too, Yeah,
- 20:33that's that's better. My advice would be, don't wait till you're twenty
- 20:37five, thirty forty to get married if you have it, if you don't
- 20:40have to, because you understand commitment in what the relationship requires, and it's
- 20:45a godly, godly in marriage. That's it. Yeah, I mean absolutely.
- 20:48I mean that's why we wonder why people are struggling with pornography. And
- 20:52you're like, well, yeah, you want a guy to wait till he's
- 20:53twenty eight to be married. What do you expect? Okay, am I
- 20:57the only one who brain went to that place when he read the verse let
- 21:03your fountain be blessed? Is that what that means? I never thought about
- 21:08it before this moment. Let your fountain be blessed sounds like, I mean's
- 21:15it sounds like? Doesn't it? Is that what it means? I don't
- 21:18know. Am I the only one? I guess I just need validation.
- 21:22I also thought it was ironic that this guy was chiding people for waiting till
- 21:27they were almost thirty to get married, and then he said that he had
- 21:32been older when he got married. Someone explained this to me. Anyway,
- 21:38I sent a message out to the Thinking Atheist Facebook community asking if anybody had
- 21:44ever had their own experiences with this type of software. I had a guy
- 21:48named David. He said, my employer has a really good one, but
- 21:53it's less aimed at morality and more at protecting their computer network and keeping their
- 22:00employees from wasting company time watching movies or playing video games. So that's kind
- 22:06of a different animal. Danny said, I used an app once I forget
- 22:11the name from the website xxxchurch dot com. Now I have not clicked that
- 22:19link. I'm not recommending you click that link. I don't know what that
- 22:23link is. I'm just reading. I'm just reading what it is. It
- 22:27monitored sites you visit in the background, and every two or four weeks,
- 22:32depending on your preference, it would email a list of the questionable sites you
- 22:37visit to an accountability partner you designate. The problem was that the software parameters
- 22:44of what was bad were so loose it was adding lots of harmless sites to
- 22:48the list that made it worthless to use. Laurie said, Utah is full
- 22:55of crap like this. There used to be a company, I think,
- 22:59clean Flicks, that would edit out all the swearing, violence or sex in
- 23:03a movie. Well, I just did a quick Google search and Laurie is
- 23:08absolutely right. The company Clean Flicks founded in Utah back in two thousand.
- 23:17They rented and sold commercially released DVDs and VHS tapes from which they edited content
- 23:26they considered inappropriate. Now this is a copyright nightmare. They're grabbing Hollywood movies
- 23:33without permission. They just grabbed them, and they edited those films and then
- 23:38released them on their own site for rental and for sale. And of course
- 23:44major film studios were pissed and they sued Clean Flicks in two thousand and two.
- 23:51They were closed by court order in two thousand and six, but they
- 23:56reopened the next year with a website called Movies you Can Trust. They no
- 24:03longer offered edited movies. I guess it was more of a list of tens
- 24:07of thousands of films that they had reviewed, and then they compiled a database
- 24:14of a thousand films that they felt met their family friendly criteria clean flicks,
- 24:21which became movies you can trust. Andrea sent an email she said, when
- 24:27I was a kid, my parents got a TV guardian. It would automatically
- 24:33mute the sound whenever a bad word was on the screen via closed captions,
- 24:40and it would show the words on the screen so you could read it,
- 24:42replacing the bad word with a good word. So I used to watch the
- 24:48old Pride and Prejudice BBC series, and it would change sex as in talking
- 24:55about gender to hugs, and watching it would change Puss in boots to whimp
- 25:03in boots. It was a bloody nightmare, but at the time I thought
- 25:08it was wonderful because I was completely brainwashed. In this same house, my
- 25:14stepdad would also cover the screen with a book whenever a scantily clad woman was
- 25:19on the screen for himself, apparently because it was just me and my mom
- 25:26at the time. I want to talk about sex addiction. I was interested
- 25:33to learn that the diagnostic and statistical Manual of Mental Disorders does not list or
- 25:40recognize sex addiction as a real disorder, and that sounds counterintuitive to me.
- 25:48I mean, you see people who are they're obsessed in an unhealthy way,
- 25:52or they're checking out of their own relationships because they're over here watching porn or
- 25:57whatever, and I wanted to talk about that. I have an actual clinical
- 26:02psychologist and sex therapist. His name is doctor David Lay, and he's going
- 26:07to talk to us about sex addiction, the use of pornography by both men
- 26:11and women, and we're going to talk about nanny software that's coming up next.
- 26:25Glad you're here. Thank you so much for listening, and thank you
- 26:27so much for your support of this show on Paytreon. I see we are
- 26:33at around seven hundred patrons right now, and I've been working to try to
- 26:37get this show back to where we were pre covid, which was a little
- 26:41over nine hundred, and if you'd like to support the show, paytreon dot
- 26:47com slash Seth Andrews. I want to talk a little bit about sex addiction,
- 26:56especially in the church. There's so much content video, lectures, conferences,
- 27:02certainly books that talk about breaking sex addiction. I want to talk to
- 27:07someone who is a clinical psychologist, a certified sex therapist, supervisor, an
- 27:12author, and a guy who has talked about these claims regarding sex addiction.
- 27:18Doctor David le thanks for coming man, good to talk to you. Thanks
- 27:22for having me, Seth. May I call you, David? Call you?
- 27:26Yeah? Okay, I want to respect the title. Okay. Yeah.
- 27:30There's so many people who call me bad words that just call me David
- 27:33is good to go. I'm sure you're an agent of debauchery and immorality,
- 27:40lust sin. You know, you're a sort of a crusader for the carnal.
- 27:45Have you had these types of interactions out there? Yeah? I mean
- 27:48my favorite are the people that say, simply by virtue of me challenging the
- 27:53validity of the concept of sex addiction, I must therefore be a sex addict
- 27:59myself. Oh thou dost protest too much of tours of course? Yeah.
- 28:04The fact that there's legitimate scientific and clinical concerns here, that doesn't matter.
- 28:11And interestingly, the reverse also doesn't matter, because it turns out that religious
- 28:17therapists are far more likely to diagnose sex addiction than lay therapists, and the
- 28:22overwhelming majority of self identified sex addiction therapists are themselves self identified sex addicts.
- 28:30Neither of those issues apparently seem to matter in terms of the validity of sex
- 28:36addiction. But me not believing in sex addiction clearly means I'm just a proverb.
- 28:41Well, before I do my due diligence as a host and give you
- 28:45some pushback or play Devil's advocate, I'm going to ask the questions I wonder
- 28:49if some of our audience members and I have about all this, Why is
- 28:55sex addiction not a thing? Well, for a variety of reasons. The
- 29:03research at this point is really really clear that people who self identify as sex
- 29:07addicts or people who get labeled as sex addicts, don't actually have more sex
- 29:11than anybody else, but they feel worse about it now. The reason that
- 29:15they feel worse about it is overwhelmingly due to a moral incongruence, typically religiously
- 29:22based. These are people who grew up with pretty strict religious sexual values around,
- 29:29for instance, heterosexuality, monogamy, not masturbating. Now as adults,
- 29:34they find themselves interested in sex and sexual behaviors that they were taught made them
- 29:40a bad person. They feel bad about it. They engage in the behaviors,
- 29:44and that afterwards they feel guilt and shame, and because they are struggling
- 29:49to prevent themselves from engaging in these behaviors, they feel like they are out
- 29:55of control. But the feeling of being out of control is different from actually
- 29:59being out of control. So the reason that the concept of sex addiction is
- 30:03just not a good scientific or clinical label is that it points us at the
- 30:10wrong target. It points us at the target of the sexual behavior. You're
- 30:15a sex addict, you need to stop having so much sex. Well,
- 30:18wait a minute, if this guy isn't having that much sex, and the
- 30:22problem is the moral conflict, we need to deal with and examine that moral
- 30:26conflict. The label of sex addiction is what I call a sexy shiny object.
- 30:33It distracts us, unfortunately, from dealing with and addressing the real conflicts
- 30:37are going on here. Well, let's say there's a partnership, a romantic
- 30:44couple, and one of the two is always thinking about sex. They are
- 30:52masturbating, how many times a day, they've got pornography on the computer.
- 30:57They seem compulsive, they're obsessed with sex in that way, and the partner,
- 31:03their partner has real concern like this doesn't feel healthy? Would that not
- 31:08be a sex addiction of some kind? First and foremost, it is what
- 31:14we call a desired discrepancy. It is one individual being in a relationship with
- 31:18somebody who does not share their level of sexual interest. So I've treated that
- 31:23couple multiple times, and oftentimes, as one partner becomes less and less interested
- 31:30in sex, more and more resistant to engaging in sex, the other partner
- 31:37paradoxically increases their focus on sex because it's not what they're getting. Because as
- 31:41they run into the brick wall of getting their sexual needs fulfilled or affirmed,
- 31:48they want it more and more and more, And we end up in this
- 31:51situation where the two partners in the couple are battling with each other over sexuality,
- 31:56when really this is coming out of the the unfortunate situation that many people
- 32:02get married and commit to monogamous relationships without ever really contemplating the fact that they
- 32:10may end up with different sexual desires or interests in their partner. And how
- 32:15are they going to deal with that? Well, if I can jump in,
- 32:19doctor lay quickly, what would you say to somebody who countered that this
- 32:22sounds like partner blaming? You know, you're not giving me what I need,
- 32:25So I'm going to go over here, and hell, it might even
- 32:30result in extramarital activities and fidelity, etc. What would you say to that
- 32:35sexuality occurs within a system, and the match between partners on these sexual variables
- 32:43impacts how the sexuality is experienced by both partners. So, for instance,
- 32:49couples that watch pornography together have healthier sexual lives and more satisfying sexual relationships.
- 32:57But couples where one partner is watchingnography in secret from the other partner, or
- 33:01where one partner is watching more pornography than the other partner tend to be relationships
- 33:07with a sexual mismatch that are sexually unsatisfied and sexually unhappy. But the pornography
- 33:14is an expression of unmet sexual need that the couple typically is not effectively negotiating
- 33:22or discussing figuring out how they're going to address this discrepancy between them. I'm
- 33:29going to continue my church lady questions for just a second, because I hear
- 33:32them so often. Pornography distorts notions of healthy sexuality. I mean, you
- 33:38see all kinds of stuff play outs in porn videos, porn movies, porn
- 33:45in prints, and there are many concerns inside and outside of religion that porn
- 33:52creates unhealthy notions of what sex is, of what consent is, etc.
- 33:59Does porn stort healthy sex? You know? I mean the biggest problem with
- 34:02pornography is that it presents an unrealistic idea of how quickly the plumber is going
- 34:07to show up when you have I mean, in porn, you know,
- 34:13the sync breaks and five minutes later the plumber is there. I mean,
- 34:16holy crap. Yeah, But I mean one of the concerns is is that
- 34:21how do everyday people compete with the perfectly shapely, sexy, red hot porn
- 34:28star. You know, how does how does real life compete with that?
- 34:31Yeah? Pornography is fantasy, and we all have to be clear about that.
- 34:36The problem and the challenge is that the people most affected negatively by pornography
- 34:42are the people who believe that it is a realistic depiction of sex. So
- 34:45people who are inadequately educated around sexuality look at pornography and think that's how real
- 34:52sex works. They don't understand that pornography doesn't show the negotiation, the aftercare,
- 34:59the prep, the lube, the discussions, the sex education that performers
- 35:05have in order to engage in these behaviors. They think, oh, you
- 35:08know, you just jump in and pound away. But good sex takes a
- 35:13lot more than that. But pornography is a fantasy that we watch to relieve
- 35:20and escape from some of the burden of real world sex. Real world sex
- 35:24takes work. The same thing is true of romance novels, for instance.
- 35:30They depict a fantasy world where people engage in behaviors and relationships are not possible
- 35:37in the real world. The same is true in Hollywood, I mean the
- 35:42X Men movies. These are fantasies and we watch them to escape from reality
- 35:47for a little while. The problem, again is when people are watching pornography
- 35:55and thinking that they can translate those elements into the real world without all of
- 36:02those components like negotiation, preparation, discussion, integrities, respect, et cetera.
- 36:08We can mitigate the potential harms of pornography on relationships and on young people
- 36:15by effectively addressing sex education. Unfortunately, our country has engaged in grossly,
- 36:22frankly, in my opinion, criminal neglect of sexual education. And then when
- 36:28people go to pornography and learn lessons that we don't that are unhealthy. We
- 36:32blame pornography. Pornography was never intended to be sex education. It became that
- 36:37way because we allowed a gap to exist, and then we, ohso conveniently
- 36:45blame pornography instead of taking responsibility for our failure to address these critical issues.
- 36:51I remember being a teenager my parents, you know, hardcore Bible believing Puritan
- 36:55types, and you know, sex was a dirty word. And if it
- 36:59had not been for cinemax, I mean, you know, just like,
- 37:01oh, well, that's what that looks like. I mean, now,
- 37:05is that typical? Dude? I want to get into these accountability services nanny
- 37:08software type stuff in just a second. But I'm just fascinated that the very
- 37:14puritan United States, especially the churched portion of it, seems to want to
- 37:19rush people into marriage because only in the marriage bed is sex legitimate. So
- 37:24you know, we just mentioned that verse out of First Corinthians, Right,
- 37:28don't burn with passion, You've got to get married. And this breeds a
- 37:30whole new level of dysfunction. You want to speak to that. Yeah,
- 37:35there's a couple of really important things here. First, the religious states in
- 37:38the country do view internet pornography as a threat and an assault on their way
- 37:45of life. I get it. And Utah, which was the first state
- 37:49in the country to pass legislation identifying pornography as a public health crisis, they
- 37:53explicitly identified in that legislation that pornography led to young people wanting to get married
- 38:00and they can't keep this material out as they allow the internet in and in
- 38:06the modern world beneath the Internet, and so they are seeing young people adopt
- 38:10sexual values that they don't embrace or agree with. Now, the interesting thing
- 38:15is, as people watch pornography, they become less religious, and they become
- 38:19more accepting of sexual diversity. And so there really is there really is a
- 38:23fact here that you know, pornography does lead to changes in the values and
- 38:30beliefs of young people watching it that are discrepant from those of religious communities.
- 38:36But interestingly, a colleague of mine, Sam Perry, who's in Oklahoma,
- 38:39he has done fascinating research looking at all these issues. And he did this
- 38:44one study where he looked at men who watch pornography and is it the case
- 38:50that because pornography is cheap and accessible, that men are more likely to watch
- 38:54pornography rather than want to get married and have sex. And in fact,
- 38:58he found the opposite, found that men who watch pornography are actually more likely
- 39:02to express desire to get married because men who watch pornography are men who value
- 39:07sex and libido. They want to have real sex. They're watching pornography as
- 39:12a filler, as an alternative to the sex that they're not getting to have.
- 39:17Is it true that the Bible Belt states, I mean you mentioned Utah.
- 39:21I remember reading this was years ago that Utah was like in the top
- 39:24three for peorn usage. It just feels like the more they try to restrict
- 39:30it, the more people find a way. Oh your experience. Yeah,
- 39:34So absolutely, this has been studied a couple of different times, a couple
- 39:37of different ways, and consistently, more religious, more sexually conservative states consume
- 39:44more pornography, both historically in magazine subscriptions and currently in internet searches for pornography.
- 39:52Now, I will say there is some question, there's some conflict here
- 39:57because religious people overall want less pornography. So then why would it be the
- 40:02case that religious states are drawing or watching more pornography. And what we think
- 40:09is is two things. One is the less religious people in those states are
- 40:15experiencing the sexual suppression in that community and seeking pornography as outlet. And then
- 40:21secondly, the highly sexual people that are in the religious community and keeping their
- 40:27sexuality secret are using pornography as an outlet to pursue the sexual experiences that they
- 40:36can't get in real life because of the religious suppression. Talking here with clinical
- 40:40psychologists and certified sex therapist doctor David lay one more before the accountability software,
- 40:49is it true that men gravitate more to pictures while women gravitate more to literature
- 40:55when it comes to getting turned on in fiction? Yes and no. In
- 41:00fact, research suggests that women actually may have a stronger physiological sexual response to
- 41:07visual images than men. However, women are more likely to experience psychological distress
- 41:17or lack of arousal to those same images, particularly when they a feeling of
- 41:22disgust comes up. Women are more likely to read, for instance, as
- 41:29I mentioned, romance novels because it feels less challenging and threatening than visual images.
- 41:37You know, when Tumblr banned pornography on that site, it had a
- 41:42disproportionate impact on women who were using Tumblr to watch curated pornography. What we
- 41:50think is going on there is that again, when a woman encounters something in
- 41:54a pornographic video that they find, you know, unarousing, you know,
- 42:00a big hairy guy, somebody engages in a violent or humiliating behavior. The
- 42:05woman is more likely to experience that as a turn off and they lose their
- 42:08mojo and they don't want to keep having sex or masturbating. Men appear to
- 42:14maintain sexual arousal through that get over that hump, so to speak, a
- 42:17little more easily. This is one reason why we think that women tend to
- 42:22be a little less likely to watch pornography than men. However, when women
- 42:27watch pornography, they watch pretty much the same kinds of pornography that men do.
- 42:31Covenant Eyes is an accountability software, a surveillance program reporting to spouses.
- 42:40Maybe I don't know children, parents, friends, Sunday school teachers, pastors,
- 42:45et cetera. Someone installs this on their computer to try to block out
- 42:50temptation. What's your thoughts on that? Uhhh So, over the past couple
- 42:53of years, we've actually learned a lot about these these programs, and it's
- 42:58not good. Wired magazine has an expose about the incredible security problems in these
- 43:04softwares that they open up your computer and your Internet usage to almost anybody.
- 43:09They create significant vulnerabilities for hacking and for viruses. Secondly, they typically recommend
- 43:19that you not have your spouse as your quote accountability partner, that is,
- 43:23seeing all of the pornography or all of the sites you may go to on
- 43:28your computer. However, when people use their pastor, for instance, as
- 43:34their accountability partner, there's a lot of evidence that religious leaders are using this
- 43:38software to enforce heteronormative and socially conservative values. So even if you don't go
- 43:46to a gay porn site, but you go to a site, for instance,
- 43:51about gay sexual health, there are lots of examples of pastors coming to
- 43:57the person and expressing concern that they are, you know, homosexual or experiencing
- 44:04homosexual urges, and that they should stop them. Interesting that the culture encourages
- 44:08people to give over the keys to their most private spaces, like I have
- 44:13to submit to an authority with a capital A to monitor me. It seems
- 44:17like a violation to me. It is. Now I'm telling you another violation
- 44:22that I'm actually more concerned about, and that is that these softwares are overwhelmingly
- 44:27created and supported by moral and religious and spiritually based organizations, and yet there
- 44:32are parole and probation officers and judges across the country that are ordering sex offenders
- 44:38to have these softwarees installed on their sites. I'm concerned that this is number
- 44:43one, you know, a violation of church and state, but number two,
- 44:46these authorities have unrealistic ideas for the reliability and effectiveness of this software.
- 44:52They are thinking that this software helps the public to stay safe, and there's
- 44:58no evidence of Thatjosh Dugger is a really good example. Josh Shugger actually had
- 45:02Covenant Eyes installed on his computer. Josh Juger from that reality team Kids and
- 45:09Counting, Yeah, Yeah, and he was convicted of child sexual abuse.
- 45:14Then he had this software installed on his computer. He created a partition so
- 45:17that he could use the other part of the computer to look at and download
- 45:21child pornography, criminal child sexual abuse material. His wife was his accountability partner.
- 45:27She had no idea that he was still looking allegedly. He had no
- 45:30idea. She had no idea he was still looking at this material, and
- 45:32then the FBI tracked him down. That software did nothing but allow him to
- 45:38manipulate people into thinking that he was not engaging in criminal and immoral behavior,
- 45:45when in fact he was. It was like a shell company. Yeah.
- 45:50One final question. You've been very generous with your time here. So if
- 45:53we see someone who has let's say they're thinking about sex and acting out on
- 45:58impulses regarding section NonStop. If this is not sex addiction, would you say
- 46:02this is another type of issue and sex is just a symptom of it.
- 46:08Absolutely, I mean that's what I say all the time. Sex and porn
- 46:13related problems are never really about sex. They are about moral conflict and shame
- 46:20about your sexual desires. They're about unregulated anxiety and people using masturbation and sexual
- 46:25fantasy as a way to manage anxiety. They're about depression, They're about desired
- 46:30discrepancy within the relationship. The problem with the sex addiction or porn addiction label
- 46:37again is that it leads us to say the answer here is to stop having
- 46:42or wanting sex. But that's not going to fix the problem that the sexual
- 46:45behaviors or desires are actually being used to try to manage or regularly. We
- 46:51need to help people with the real problems rather than blaming sex. You have
- 46:59written a book called well, the Myth of Sex Addiction. I'd be curious
- 47:02to read that, sucker. You were recommended to me by a buddy,
- 47:06doctor Daryl Ray, who is the author of Sex and God and host the
- 47:09Secular Sexuality podcast. But this has been an interesting conversation Doctor David jay Ley
- 47:15l e y you you've been terrific. Thanks for talking to us today.
- 47:20I appreciate you. Thanks for having me Seth. I appreciate what you're doing.
- 47:22This is important. I hope you found the show today interesting, compelling,
- 47:32educational, whatever. Leave your comments in the comments section and I will
- 47:37see you back here next week. Follow The Thinking Atheist on Facebook and Twitter
- 47:44for a complete archive of podcasts and videos, products like mugs and t shirts
- 47:47featuring the Thinking Atheist logo, links to atheist pages and resources, and details
- 47:52on upcoming free thought events and conventions. Log onto our website, The Thinkingatheist
- 47:59dot com.