Latest / Herbert Smith Freehills Kramer Podcasts / The Construction Law Shortcast: EP2 Delay, Float and Extensions of Time
Transcript
- 0:11Noe Minamikata: Welcome to another episode of the Construction Law Shortcast series where we'll be deconstructing fundamental principles of English construction law.
- 0:19Noe Minamikata: All in just five minutes or thereabouts.
- 0:22Noe Minamikata: I'm Noe Minamikata from the London Construction and Infrastructure Disputes Team here at HSF Kramer.
- 0:29Xavier Milne: And I'm Xavier Milne, also from HSF Kramer's London Construction and Infrastructure Disputes Team.
- 0:36Noe Minamikata: In this episode, we'll be focusing on three related concepts which frequently come up in construction disputes.
- 0:43Noe Minamikata: Delay, float, and extensions of time.
- 0:46Noe Minamikata: To start us off, Xavier, can you walk us through the concept of delay and what it means in a construction context?
- 0:53Xavier Milne: Sure.
- 0:54Xavier Milne: Under most construction contracts, the contractor needs to complete the works by a fixed date specified in the contract.
- 1:02Xavier Milne: This is often referred to as a scheduled completion date.
- 1:07Xavier Milne: When we talk about delay in a construction context, what we usually mean is delay that impacts the scheduled completion date.
- 1:15Xavier Milne: This is known as critical delay, because it involves delay to the critical path to completion.
- 1:23Noe Minamikata: So if the contractor's progress is delayed but the scheduled completion date isn't impacted, this doesn't qualify as critical delay, is that right?
- 1:32Xavier Milne: That's right.
- 1:33Xavier Milne: Most construction contracts also contain, or should contain, a mechanism for addressing critical delay.
- 1:41Xavier Milne: This includes allocating the risk of delay to either the contractor or the employer.
- 1:47Noe Minamikata: Okay, and how do construction contracts tend to allocate risk?
- 1:52Xavier Milne: That really depends on the contract.
- 1:54Xavier Milne: But typically, the contractor assumes the risk of delay if it was caused by the contractor or a contractor risk event.
- 2:03Xavier Milne: Likewise, the employer assumes the risk of delay if it was caused by the employer or an employer risk event.
- 2:12Noe Minamikata: That seems very sensible.
- 2:14Noe Minamikata: And we mentioned at the outset that delay is related to the concept of float.
- 2:19Noe Minamikata: Can you explain what we mean here by float?
- 2:22Xavier Milne: When we talk about float, we usually mean the amount of time that an activity can be delayed without impacting activities that immediately follow or the scheduled completion date.
- 2:35Xavier Milne: It's a form of contingency that's built into the program to allow for unforeseen issues.
- 2:42Noe Minamikata: So what happens where a project is delayed but the delay can't be absorbed in that float?
- 2:49Xavier Milne: If the employer or an employer risk event caused the delay, the contractor can usually claim an extension of time under the contract.
- 2:58Xavier Milne: But if it was the contractor or a contractor risk event that caused the delay, the contractor usually won't be able to be entitled to an extension of time.
- 3:10Noe Minamikata: And are there any instances where delay is caused by both the contractor and the employer in almost equal measure?
- 3:18Xavier Milne: Yes, but it's rare.
- 3:20Xavier Milne: This scenario is what we call concurrent delay.
- 3:24Xavier Milne: There's some debate around the precise requirements, but it's often said that for concurrent delay to exist, each event has to be an effective cause of delay to completion.
- 3:37Xavier Milne: It rarely occurs in practice, but when it does, it can present legal and factual challenges.
- 3:44Xavier Milne: Some construction contracts specifically address the risk of concurrent delay.
- 3:50Xavier Milne: But where the contract is silent, the general English law rule is that the contractor is entitled to an extension of time but no loss and expense claim.
- 4:03Xavier Milne: An extension of time usually refers to an adjustment to the scheduled completion date to reflect the period of delay.
- 4:19Xavier Milne: That's critical delay caused by the employer or an employer risk event.
- 4:25Xavier Milne: Where a contractor is entitled to an extension of time, it might also be entitled to claim loss and expense.
- 4:34Xavier Milne: Although this isn't always the case and will depend on contract terms.
- 4:41Noe Minamikata: And that's a key point to remember, isn't it?
- 4:43Noe Minamikata: Are there any other points that parties should be alive to when claiming an extension of time or assessing an extension of time claim?
- 4:52Xavier Milne: There are.
- 4:53Xavier Milne: Sure.
- 5:26Xavier Milne: So to sum up, I'd say the key points are when we talk about delay, what we mean is critical delay that can't be absorbed by any float and impacts the scheduled completion date.
- 5:40Xavier Milne: Which party bears the risk of delay depends on the cause, and finally, if a contractor considers it is entitled to an extension of time, it needs to properly follow the contractual process for making a claim.
- 5:55Xavier Milne: Likewise, an employer assessing a contractor's claim should check that it has strictly complied with the contractual process.
- 6:04Noe Minamikata: Thanks, Evia, and that brings us to the end of this episode of the Construction Law Shortcast series.
- 6:10Noe Minamikata: Thanks for listening, and please join us in our next episode where we'll be discussing the concept of disruption.