Latest / Unexplained : True Tales of Unexplained Mysteries with Bestselling Author Steph Young / Hunted in the Woods - the true story of Heath & David
Transcript
- 0:12It was late in the night when David Smith became separated from his friend Heath
- 0:17Bullard. They'd been running frantically in blind panic in the dark, and when
- 0:21they reached the creek, Heath couldn't go any further. He couldn't swim,
- 0:25and maybe David didn't notice, but David plunged headlong into the water, and
- 0:30their separation for a descent into surreal horror began. It was August the ninth,
- 0:35nineteen ninety four, be some days before Heath and David would be reunited,
- 0:40but the space in between would see them changed beyond all recognition from their
- 0:45former selves. They had all begun when David Smith, aged twenty five,
- 0:49and Heath Bullard, twenty three, had set out on August the eighth,
- 0:53nineteen ninety four, in a loaded pickup truck from their homes in Carbon County,
- 0:58Pennsylvania, on a roacho. They were bound for a Native American reservation
- 1:02in Arizona. David was a painter and Heath was a trainee teacher enrolled at
- 1:07Cuttertown University, and he was heading for Cayunta Indian Reservation in Monument Valley to
- 1:11take up a student teaching role. David was along for the ride and would
- 1:15fly back on the coming Friday to return to his job. What began as
- 1:19an innocent drive on the highway soon turned into something so surreal and inexplicable it's
- 1:26hard to fathom to this day. The Morning Call at Pennsylvania did a lot
- 1:30of reporting on what happened to them. Is really one of the only newspapers
- 1:34that kind of picked up on this story. For The Morning Call says a
- 1:38convoy of twenty to thirty cars and tractor trailers began chasing the bare Tuesday as
- 1:42they drove through Arkansas on Interstate forty, said Heath Bullard. I was going
- 1:48seventy five to eighty miles an hour. It began, it would seem when
- 1:52the boys picked up on one vehicle. We constantly had a car on us,
- 1:56said he That was Tuesday. Later afternoon said he and Smith did nothing
- 2:00to provoke their pursuers. He said, I think it was the Pennsylvania tags.
- 2:06When asked what caused the pursuit, Heath's possessions were wrapped in plastic and
- 2:10packed in the bed of the pickup truck. He assumed cars following him were
- 2:15full of drug enforcement agents who suspected Heath believed that he was transporting drugs.
- 2:23In fact, in recent correspondence between myself and Heath, he confirms this scenario
- 2:30and his opinion that he was being pursued by what he believed had to be
- 2:35the DEA. And yet also at the same time hot on their heels were
- 2:39a convoy of trucks and tractor trailers too. Heath claimed the license plates of
- 2:46these vehicles were Texas, Arkansas, and Tennessee. In one of the Morning
- 2:52Call reports, they say They're claimed encounter easily earns them the Most Bizarre Experience
- 2:57Award for nineteen ninety four. We'd had all the elements of a made for
- 3:00TV thriller. Abductions, imprisonment, eighty mile an hour chases by thirty vehicle
- 3:07convoys over the border. A chillingly detailed account ran yesterday Smith and Ballard were
- 3:12kidnapped by dozens of people. But that's not the half of it, they
- 3:15said. Soon one of Heath and David would be confronted with human heads hanging
- 3:20from a tree. And six months later, The Morning Cars reported that Heath's
- 3:24stint in a mental hospital and therapy sessions have driven thoughts of suicide from his
- 3:30head. His fiancee, Stacy Elmore, had committed David to a mental health
- 3:35unit at Gnadam Houghton Hospital in Leyton, Pennsylvania, apparently because his behavior had
- 3:39deteriorated since his ordeal last fall. When Heath and David had noticed that the
- 3:45car on the highway that previous August seemed to be following them. The pair
- 3:50traveling cross country in Ballard's pickup truck, also said that a convoy of twenty
- 3:54to thirty cars and tractor trailers began chasing them too. The people chasing them,
- 3:59they said, were both men and women, also children, and black
- 4:02and white. Smith said he took pictures of some of the vehicles, but
- 4:05his camera, along with all of Billard's possessions, were inside the truck,
- 4:09which wasn't recovered. This was at a time, he said the Morning Call,
- 4:13when people in Arkansas are still reeling from the murders of three little boys
- 4:16on the conviction of two teens, at least one of whom was linked to
- 4:19a Satanic cult. They're referring to the highly controversial case of the West Memphis
- 4:25three. They say the triple murders of the eight year old boys occurred in
- 4:28ninety three in West Memphis, which is separated by the Mississippi River. The
- 4:31alleged mastermind of the crimes, Damian Eccles nineteen, was ordered executed for his
- 4:35role in the slayings. Well, of course, decades later, the West
- 4:40Memphis three would be freed on an authored appeal, with opinions highly divided on
- 4:44their continued guilt or complete innocence, although that the slaughtering of the little boys
- 4:47happened cannot be denied by whoever the perpetrator was. Meanwhile, back on the
- 4:53highway, disconcerted by what the two men believed were government agency employees following them,
- 4:59they said, they pulled into rest area, said he about fifteen vehicles
- 5:01followed us. About five of them pretended to be working on a truck,
- 5:05but I could tell they were watching me. He called his attorney, Barry
- 5:09Shabbock of Palmerton, Pennsylvania, presumably by public phone in the rest area.
- 5:14Heath said. Shabbick told him to confront these men, and Heath says he
- 5:17did. I said to them, this is against the law. They said
- 5:20they didn't know what I was talking about. Heath and David drove on into
- 5:25the tiny town of Prescott in Nevada County, Arkansas, where Heath said he
- 5:30talked to the sheriff about what was going on. You must be high,
- 5:32Heath claimed. The sheriff's response was, Sheriff's the ghosts that are following you.
- 5:38Heath pointed to a car parked across the street. The sheriff replied,
- 5:42the men in that car are locals and told Heathan David to go away.
- 5:46Subsequently, after the end of the ordeal, which we're going to go into,
- 5:48the morning car contacted the county sheriff of Prescott, Eb Norman, who
- 5:53laughed and denied it never heard of them. Oh, this is news to
- 5:56me. I don't know one thing about it, which might seem he doth
- 6:00protest too much. When asked again six months later by the Morning Call,
- 6:04they reported, Sheriff ab Mormon denied during a telephone interview that the men had
- 6:10been to his office. Prescott is more than two hundred and sixty miles from
- 6:14where Heath and David would eventually end up. They left Prescott and kept driving.
- 6:18On and on They drove until they came to the Texas border. They
- 6:21tried to enter Texas, but apparently, says he three tractor trailers boxed us
- 6:28in and forced our pickup truck onto an exit ramp where a car was parked
- 6:31across the exit. We were trapped, said Heath, and they had no
- 6:35choice but to drive back into Arkansas. A little while later, they parked
- 6:40along the burm of the highway and popped the hood, pretending that they had
- 6:44engine trouble. When Arkansas State troopers spotted them and pulled over. He laughed,
- 6:48said Heath, and said he can't help us. The pair took off
- 6:53once more, still on Highway forty, this time crossing into Tennessee. They
- 6:58were now driving in the exact opposite direction to the one they needed to be
- 7:01heading in. They wound out more than two hundred and fifty miles to the
- 7:05east of the Boonies north of Memphis, apparently still being chased by this crazed
- 7:12cult convoy of caravans, tractor trailers, and trucks. It was getting late
- 7:16now and they were running out of gas, so they drove into the small
- 7:19town of Covington, Tennessee, northeast of Memphis and about four hours from Prescott.
- 7:26They were looking for a gas station, but said they could not find
- 7:29one. Then things got strange again, said he Two cars, they looked
- 7:32like cop cars, unmarked, chased us into a field. We don't have
- 7:36any mention of the tractor trailers, so I'm not quite sure where they were
- 7:41at the time, but it sounds a little bit like a wrestling tag team.
- 7:44The boys pickup truck got stuck in the mud in the field, and
- 7:46Heath and David took off on foot, running, leaving the truck and all
- 7:50their possessions behind. It was a wooded swampy area. They ran into the
- 7:56woods until they reached the creek. David jumped in. Heath couldn't swim.
- 8:00We got to the creek, he said, I had no water. I
- 8:03started puking. Dave swam, I couldn't. I hid. The next thing
- 8:07was I was being chased in the swamp and I had to take my shoes
- 8:09off. They were making too much noise. I was hiding. I was
- 8:13in the swamp the whole night and part of the next day. The sun
- 8:16rose. I had to get something to drink. I couldn't walk any more.
- 8:20My stomach was crumping. Heath said. He walked for miles and miles
- 8:24and miles until he came upon a farm. He said, I sat in
- 8:28front of the house. No one came out. I wasn't sure who to
- 8:31trust. Then a woman came to the door, presumably from inside, and
- 8:35she offered him food and drink, a shower, and a change of clothes.
- 8:39She let him call his grandfather in Ashfield, who wired money via Western
- 8:43Union. The woman then went to pick up the money, and she then
- 8:48had friends drive Heath to Memphis Airport, where he took a flight to Allentown
- 8:52Bethleem Eastern Airport. It's so complex, said Heath Friday. Nobody wanted to
- 8:58help well. As of his friend David, he would be in the swamp
- 9:01much longer. The slight confusion over the number of nights he spent in the
- 9:05swamp, but he was eventually taken to a hospital in Pennsylvania, where he
- 9:09could barely speak above a whisper on the thirteenth of August. We do know
- 9:13that, according to David, at one point he was floating down the creek
- 9:18clinging to two logs when he was shut out for sport. He was surrounded
- 9:22by a crazed group of people, and he saw human heads in trees,
- 9:28said the Morning Call. Smith said that he was pursued, captured, released,
- 9:33and recaptured by a religious cult whose members included men, women, and
- 9:37children, blacks and whites, all wearing two emblems, one emblazoned with an
- 9:43a, the other with a witch. He said that the members of this
- 9:48group were wearing two white patches on their shirts. He said he floated down
- 9:54a river on a log, refusing help offered by a man in a motor
- 9:58boat. He said he did know who to trust at this point. Smith
- 10:01said he was at one point surrounded by cult members. They surrounded him in
- 10:07a circle, and he was forced to watch as they poured blood from sheep
- 10:11and pigs on a woolen blanket and rolled in the mess. He said he
- 10:16saw decomposing human heads hanging from trees. Later, he said, a woman
- 10:22gave him permission to hide in a shed on her property, then fired a
- 10:26gun at him. Eventually, he said, he came upon a church near
- 10:30which were lighted poles from which emblems matching those worn by the people chasing him
- 10:35were posted. He said he stayed at the church for a while, thinking
- 10:41they wouldn't come looking for him there, then walked on and at an estimated
- 10:45mile from the church, he found a house which he broke into. This
- 10:50was in Tipton County. Inside the house, he used the telephone to call
- 10:54his fiancee in Pennsylvania. He'd found the address of the house from some male
- 10:58inside. His fiancee then called the Tipson County Sheriff's Department to summon help.
- 11:05Unfortunately for David, the house had broken into, unbeknown to him, was
- 11:09owned by a highway patrol officer. Both Highway Patrol and a Lieutenant John Fletcher
- 11:16of the Tipton County Sheriff's Department arrived at the house shortly after. David said,
- 11:20I sat in the house with a butcher knife. A policeman pulled up
- 11:24in the morning call say. This was Lieutenant John Fletcher, who, when
- 11:28called about this, laughed when asked about Smith's ordeal, Well, said David,
- 11:33the house I broke into was the house of a highway patrolman. I
- 11:37was taken to the police department. They shackled me and put me in a
- 11:41cell. They took me to a hospital. They had three psychiatrists look at
- 11:45me. They told me they were going to take me to a mental hospital.
- 11:48I was afraid to say too much because I think the police were involved.
- 11:52They gave me an IV in the hospital because I was dehydrated. A
- 11:56nurse gave me a phone and I called home relative back in Pennsylvania. Phoned
- 12:01the woman that Heath Bullard identified as having helped him, and this lady showed
- 12:07up at the hospital and told the nurse she was his cousin. Wonder why
- 12:11she would do that anyway, he said, I was allowed to see her
- 12:15in a hallway. I pulled out the IV and put on the clothes she
- 12:18brought me. I had nothing with me. The lady took me to her
- 12:20house and hid me, and then she got me on a flight. I
- 12:24missed the flight and hid in the bathroom at the Memphis Airport until later.
- 12:28A nurse in the hospital told me they actually used their own family members as
- 12:33sacrifices sometimes well. At the hospital. During his brief say, his blood
- 12:39and urine were tested for drugs and alcohol. The tests showed no traces or
- 12:43either substance. Oddly, the hospital later denied having had David there, and
- 12:50the sheriff. Sheriff Yoakum would later say tell them ten bucks a day for
- 12:54storage to get their abandoned pick up truck back. Smith said his vision is
- 13:01poor when he's not wearing corrective lenses, but he has. He said he
- 13:05could still tell the man by the car was holding a gun, so he
- 13:07dropped to his knees and dropped the knife. The man with the girl was
- 13:11Lieutenant Fletcher of the Tipton County Sheriff's Office, and eventually David Smith would go
- 13:16on to be charged and extradited back to Tennessee, much against his will and
- 13:22with great fear. Well, David describes a little bit more about his time
- 13:28in the swamp in the Lost Nights, events which include being shot at with
- 13:33paint pellets, hearing bird calls, communicating with each other, and seeing at
- 13:37least two separate groups chasing him, and a man who tried to convince an
- 13:39eight year old boy to shoot him. He said, for the first night,
- 13:43Tuesday, I hid in the water underbrush. I could hear them calling.
- 13:46They were using bird calls. The next morning, Wednesday, I got
- 13:50out of the swamp and they started shooting at me. I ran as long
- 13:54as I could until I fell over. I'd say I ran a mile and
- 13:58a half, maybe two miles. Then I came to another swamp and went
- 14:01in, and they were still shooting at me. They were shooting me with
- 14:05paint pellets. I really couldn't tell how many there were at the time.
- 14:09I saw maybe ten different people running through the woods. Then I went back
- 14:13in the swamp again and hid under brush. Then I was back on land
- 14:18and they chased me around. They circled me using the bird calls. Again.
- 14:22I ran into a man and a little boy. The boy was about
- 14:26eight years old. I suppose he was part of the chase. The man
- 14:30gave the kid a gun. It was a rifle. As far as I
- 14:33know, there were shells in it. The man wanted the boy to shoot
- 14:35me. I said to the boy, I have a son about your age
- 14:39at home. How would you like it if I sent my son here to
- 14:41shoot your dad. The boy dropped the rifle and started to cry. I
- 14:46ran. The older man picked up the gun and fired at me. I
- 14:48got back into another creek, grabbed a log and floated. Then I got
- 14:52another log. I had one on each shoulder. They were shooting at me.
- 14:56I went around a bend. There was a guy in a motor boat
- 14:58and he asked if I needed to help, but I didn't know who to
- 15:01trust. I went on down stream, further and the logs got caught,
- 15:05and I was back on land. I crawled into the woods and went under
- 15:07some brush and tried to sleep, but the bugs kept biting me. The
- 15:11next morning, Thursday, I jumped back into the creek again and nearly drowned.
- 15:16The people. They were the people who were chasing me, who teiled
- 15:20a tree branch and pulled me out. They were playing with me. They
- 15:22laid me down on the bank. I must have passed out. I woke
- 15:26up two more shots and started running again. They caught me. The people
- 15:33wore emblems, a big round circle with an a in the mill, and
- 15:35a smaller circle with a witch under the big emblem. There were about twenty
- 15:41of them there. They had a big piece of wool like a blanket,
- 15:45and they were cutting up sheep and pigs and putting blood on the blanket.
- 15:48They surrounded me, circled like they had me in an arena. They rolled
- 15:54around in the blood. I saw three heads. They were decomposed. They
- 15:56were human, hanging from a tree. I started running again. I ran
- 16:02into another creek, into a swamp. I was thirsty. I drank the
- 16:04swamp water. I think I started hallucinating. I thought I was home.
- 16:08I woke up again and I went up a little stream that led to a
- 16:11bigger creek. It came to a drain pipe and crawled in to the other
- 16:15side. I heard a woman and child screaming. I started running through the
- 16:19fields. It got light out. Friday morning had arrived. I took a
- 16:25nap. Then when I woke up again, I came to a church.
- 16:27The emblems like what the people wore were on poles lighted poles at the church.
- 16:33I stayed at the church for a while. I thought they wouldn't look
- 16:37for me there. Then I took off again to a house. A woman
- 16:41there said, go hide in her shed. I did. Then she came
- 16:45after me with a gun. Nith says that they were driving along Route forty
- 16:49I made, a road recommended by the American Automobile Association. He believes what
- 16:55happened to them has happened to other out of state drivers. I wonder,
- 17:00he said, how many missing people were abducted. If no one was looking
- 17:03for a person, no one would ever know. He frequently cried in his
- 17:10interviews with the newspapers. While as for David, his girlfriend had him committed
- 17:15to a mental hospital when they got back to Pennsylvania. The investigation into what
- 17:19happened to the two young men was oddly conflicting. Afterwards, Lieutenant John Fletcher
- 17:25of the Tipton County Sheriff Department confirmed that Smith was safe when he was apprehended
- 17:30outside the police officer's house, but he snickered when told that Smith reported to
- 17:36his girlfriend he'd been kidnapped. As for Sheriff Yoakum, he said that he
- 17:41had found no other tiremarks that would indicate any other vehicles had been in that
- 17:45field, nor any tracks from people. The sheriff said it was so muddy
- 17:51no other vehicles could have got down there. He also said that David Smith
- 17:55did not escape from a hospital he was released. I don't know what he
- 17:59told you, he said. He has no earthly idea about this, he
- 18:03told the Morning Call. I can't figure a case that involves thirty vehicles at
- 18:07one time. It's unreasonable to believe a thirty car chase for that many miles.
- 18:11It doesn't make a whole lot of sense. Asked about the colt,
- 18:15he said, I ain't nothing like that around here. That sounds kind of
- 18:18crazy. We've had a little touch of colts, just reports you know,
- 18:22and gang stuff, spray painting and stuff, but that's just crazy. Asked
- 18:26about David smith claim that a woman fired a gun at him, the sheriff
- 18:30laughed and said, sounds like a good move to me. He said it
- 18:33was not a call from Stacy Almoor, the fiance of David Smith's, that
- 18:37led to David being rescued from a policeman's house. He said, no,
- 18:41no residents out there kept calling. They said there was someone around, something
- 18:45on the loose, something strange. I don't know anything about a fiance.
- 18:48We had three or four different people who were talking about either seeing somebody or
- 18:52coming to their door or whatever. Lieutenant Fletcher finally found him while he was
- 18:57doing an area search. Hospital meanwhile, said they had no record of David
- 19:03Smith. They were being admitted. David Smith, of course, said he
- 19:06believed police are involved in all of this from the beginning. But the sheriff
- 19:10did confirm parts of Heath and David's story in that he said there was a
- 19:15church about one mile from the house David had broken into. However, he
- 19:18said it's just a church. This is an extremely rural area. They don't
- 19:22know the denomination. It's a church. That's predominantly black. It's just a
- 19:26little, old, small country church. Of their story about a crazed religious
- 19:32cult, he said, it's not plausible, possible, anything's possible. Still,
- 19:37it's not reasonable and it's certainly not plausible. I hardly have any consideration
- 19:41for a claim in which these men say they were chased from Tennessee to Arkansas
- 19:47and back by thirty cars, and he said that no lucid person would tell
- 19:51such a tale. He believed that Heath and David probably misread the events and
- 19:56thought they were being chased, but added, I suspect there's more to this
- 20:00whole thing than we know at this point. Local state, and federal authorities
- 20:04when The Morning Call tried to chase up on this story, really just added
- 20:07to the confusion, they said. Numerous telephone interviews revealed that apparently no one
- 20:12was looking into the matter. Well. Mark Roy, chief criminal investigator for
- 20:17Lorderdale County, did take things slightly more seriously. He said he was aware
- 20:22of the West Memphis three the triple murder. However, he said because of
- 20:26the ages of the people involved, and presumably he means in the West Memphis
- 20:30case, he said, they're not going to have this kind of following,
- 20:33I don't imagine. In other words, I think he meant he did not
- 20:37think that a huge cult could span the breadth from West Memphis up to Lorderdale
- 20:41County, nor have sufficient members. He did, however, want to get
- 20:45the FBI involved. He told The Morning Call that he was trying to enlist
- 20:49the help of the FBI. He said he also needs Ballard and Smith on
- 20:55hand to point out the areas of the alleged incidents. He said, Lorderdale
- 20:59County is nearly five hundred square miles and he's the only investigator. He said,
- 21:03I'm sure I could come up with some sort of conclusion, but I
- 21:07need them to help me. I can't do an investigation if I don't have
- 21:10someone to take me to the crime scene. Well, things got progressively more
- 21:14muddy. Fletcher said that he was not investigating, then said he was,
- 21:18then said Allentown Office of the FBI was in charge, and Dennis Buckley of
- 21:23the FBI in Allentown said the investigation was in the hands of the State Police
- 21:26at Bethlem. State Police at Bethlom hadn't heard about the case. Meanwhile,
- 21:32every hospitals the Morning Call reported, including Baptist's Memorial Hospital in Tipton and Lorderdale
- 21:38Baptist in Ripley has no record of a David Smith, and Covington police said
- 21:45they had no record of either men. We know that someone did investigate,
- 21:48though, because David would find himself unable to fight an ext edition eventually well
- 21:55in the immediate aftermath of the rather traumatic road trip. When David arrived moved
- 22:00back in Allentown Bethlehem Eastern Airport on August thirteenth, it was greeted by sobbing
- 22:06relatives. Under wheelchair, David could not speak above a whisper and appeared dazed
- 22:11and confused. His exposed arms and legs were covered in scratches and cuts.
- 22:15He embraced his mother, fiancee, and Ballard before leaving for Palmerton Hospital.
- 22:21Heath, who cried frequently during interviews yesterday and today, said that after hours
- 22:26of being chased by a group of cars and tractor trailers, he hid in
- 22:29a swamp. He said, I think it was a cult. He still
- 22:33wore the same muddy sneakers he'd worn in the swamp. Spritey didn't change.
- 22:37The pennsylvani new newspaper reported Smith's fiancee Stacy Elmore, said Smith called Thursday morning
- 22:45to report that he had fled his captors, who left him unattended in a
- 22:49house in Covington. Smith has steadfastly maintained he did not make up his story.
- 22:56He said he was drug and alcohol free throughout the journey and was taken
- 23:00only over the counter caffeine pills to keep awake during the drive. When he
- 23:04returned from Tennessee Sheriff Yoakum had said he would not face prosecution for breaking into
- 23:11the policeman's house. He'd also cut the phone wire, Joacumb said the more
- 23:15serious violation is the wild tale he told us. Nevertheless, in a secret
- 23:21grand jury indictment handed down later in November, Smith was charged with aggravated burglary
- 23:27and aggravated assault, even though he'd been in contact with the Tennessee authorities numerous
- 23:33times after the incident, and he was told that he was not facing charges,
- 23:37but now he was being listed as a fugitive and a governor's warrant had
- 23:41been issued. Then. In January nineteen ninety five, six months after their
- 23:48ordeal in the swamps, Smith said that he vowed to kill himself if forced
- 23:52to go back to Tennessee. He said, I did nothing wrong. I
- 23:56wrote a letter to the policeman who owns the house and apologized. I told
- 24:00him I didn't want to interfere with his life, and I offered to pay
- 24:03for the banana and cookies and milk, and I didn't assault Lieutenant Fletcher.
- 24:07I called the police down there, and I have the phone bills to prove
- 24:10it, and they have my telephone number all along. Upon David's return to
- 24:14Pennsylvania, at first, he just didn't want to talk about it, he
- 24:18said, I didn't say anything about it. I just wanted to forget it,
- 24:21but I couldn't. Things got bad. I was drinking a lot.
- 24:23Things got bad between me and Stacy. I just sort of exploded, but
- 24:27I did it the wrong way. His fiance, unfortunately, had to have
- 24:30him committed to a mental hospital. Fast forward six months later in January,
- 24:34and David's worst and nightmares come to life, the local paper said, as
- 24:38he left a hospital mental ward, David William Smith, a Carbon County man
- 24:42who said he was abducted by a Southern cult last fall, was arrested on
- 24:45a warrant from Tennessee. Carbon County detective Joseph Pampinin had picked up Smith as
- 24:52he and Elmore walked out of the mental ward. When the call asked Tipson
- 24:56County why this was happening, the sheriff, Buddy Lewis replied, there is
- 25:00such a thing as a secret indictment in the state of Tennessee. Asked if
- 25:06Smith's arrest had been done under a secret indictment, Lewis had then said,
- 25:11that's not what I said, then hung up. Since the morning call,
- 25:14David Smith's girlfriend said he's a changed person since returning from Tennessee. He's just
- 25:18not the same anymore. He's angry, he wants to forget what ever happened.
- 25:22He just keeps saying, I can't go back there. I can't go
- 25:25back there. Taken to the office of District Justice Edward Lewis for an arraignment,
- 25:29Smith lost it. His fiance said he banged his head on the table
- 25:33and said he would kill himself before going back there. Well. Unfortunately for
- 25:37David, he was taken to Carbon County Prison awaiting his extradition. In there,
- 25:41David said local ministers from several churches go in to see him. I
- 25:47never read the Bible before, but now I read it every day. His
- 25:49mother said, he seems like to be in shock. He just seems like
- 25:52he has blank stairs in his eyes. He asked if I could help him.
- 25:56He said he couldn't go back down there. He said he'd kill himself.
- 25:59He said that four times. I do believe him. There's no reason
- 26:03for him to come back with a tale like this. He was absolutely not
- 26:06going to gain from something like this. What would he gain. He'd only
- 26:08be hurting himself and his friends and family. She said, our son never
- 26:11revealed all the details of what happened to him in Tennessee. He's scared,
- 26:15She said. There's something that he saw, There's something wrong. He won't
- 26:19tell the whole thing. As far as heath, he went through a lot,
- 26:23but not as much as David. He was a very strong person before
- 26:27he could do anything. He always had a very good outlook. He could
- 26:30overcome anything. He was never afraid. Now he seems so afraid. He
- 26:34seems so scared. There's something he's so afraid of, but I don't know
- 26:38what it is. In late March, after David had been held in prison
- 26:44in Carbon County for many weeks, he was finally taken back to Tennessee,
- 26:49although he was then released on bail. In May, David was taking back
- 26:55again to Tennessee. His lawyer managed to get a no contest place on reduced
- 27:00charges. David said they should be investigating what happened to me, not what
- 27:06I did, and he added that his story did not differ to his best
- 27:10friend's account, despite the fact that they had been separated for much of their
- 27:15encounters with the cult. He said, if two people become paranoid or delirious
- 27:19or sleep deprived, you'll get two different stories. What we saw is what
- 27:25we saw. We did not misinterpret what went down well. In the end,
- 27:30David was acquitted of the assault charge and found guilty only of trespass,
- 27:36for which he was deemed to have already served his time in jail four so
- 27:40he paid a small fine and was able to return home without going back to
- 27:44jail again. They still cannot believe what happened to them, they said they
- 27:48were looking for answers and that they'll keep looking until the mystery is solved.
- 27:52He staid. He plans to contact the federal government, starting with US Representative
- 27:56Paul Kanjorski. I want someone to listen to this, said he If it
- 28:00happened to us, it could happen to anybody. What David said you couldn't
- 28:04understand was why he had been investigated and charged when no one else was.
- 28:10Why was his story not taken seriously? Was he completely insane and his best
- 28:15friend also completely insane too? Why did they never change their story or drop
- 28:19it or admit having made it up? And he'd said, all that time
- 28:25ago, who else has gone missing? Who else has this happened to