Latest / WonkyFolk / Vol 3 – The Amnesia Episode
Transcript
- 0:00Jed: Hey Andy.
- 0:01Andy: Hey Jed.
- 0:02How are you?
- 0:02Jed: I'm doing really well.
- 0:04It was great to see a fish pic at the top of EduWonk here last week.
- 0:08I've been missing those.
- 0:10Andy: Thanks.
- 0:10Yeah, I've got a backlog of them.
- 0:13And so I need to continue to get them out.
- 0:15I really have a lot of them piled up and I'm also dealing
- 0:18with problems with spam filters.
- 0:20So I'm trying to sort out how to actually get the ones out, the ones
- 0:25that are appropriately fish porn, get them out, but without having them
- 0:29always get caught in people's spam filters and teachers complain they can't
- 0:32access them from school and so forth.
- 0:34But enough about that.
- 0:35I've been concerned about you.
- 0:36Do we need to have a moment of silence for the Kings or are you really doing okay?
- 0:40Are you in denial?
- 0:41What's going on?
- 0:43Jed: The beam was extinguished this week and yeah, we are still regretting that.
- 0:49It's interesting: it was my birthday and so we ended up going to the game.
- 0:55But the only reason we went to the game was because the first birthday
- 1:00plan we had was to be in Yosemite.
- 1:02And we were all set for an incredible weekend there, but you probably heard
- 1:06Yosemite closed because of the excess melt and the flooding and all that.
- 1:12So, it was a complicated weekend here and all I know is that when I saw
- 1:17your fish pic I just, we've talked a lot about, hey, we have a shared
- 1:22love of the American West, right?
- 1:24And we've talked about going to the Bob Marshall a lot.
- 1:26So we have to figure out a way to record a WonkyFolk in the Bob Marshall someday.
- 1:31Andy: We could, and there's some education folks, Terry Ryan's out there.
- 1:35I know Steve Farcus likes to go out there and go backpacking.
- 1:37There's some good education folks around.
- 1:39So we could actually, we could do, we could probably get some good guest folks.
- 1:42And some of the folks in Idaho education are super interesting.
- 1:46There's some, some really great folks out there.
- 1:48Jed: I agree with you.
- 1:49Terry had me up there for an event a couple years ago, and I was really
- 1:52very impressed by the breadth of reform efforts that were going there.
- 1:56Hey, as far as developments this week goes, I am going to maybe lead
- 2:00off with just some thoughts about, Nation At Risk, its 40th anniversary.
- 2:05MInd if I riff on that to start off?
- 2:07Andy: Yeah.
- 2:07Go.
- 2:08I know you've got some thoughts and I think we both read some of
- 2:10the same articles this past week.
- 2:12Jed: Yeah, Valerie Strauss at the Washington Post comes out with a just
- 2:16complete hit piece, just trying to recast the entire history Nation At
- 2:21Risk as having been huge mistake.
- 2:24And in fact, the frame for that was somebody looking at some of the greatest
- 2:28historical mistakes have ever happened, including, Napoleon's invasion of Russia.
- 2:36And somehow or another that gets to be the frame for considering
- 2:39what the impact Nation At Risk was.
- 2:42Of course we see, Diane Ravich the very next day, saying similar things.
- 2:47My own sense is that, look, attack it for being too political, we can attack
- 2:52it for various procedural challenges, but I think it is just a milestone where
- 2:59like Sputnik, Sputnik was, okay, we have to get our acts together on math and
- 3:03science instruction during Cold War.
- 3:06And then Coleman report was really like, "Hey, we gotta understand just how big the
- 3:11gap is between black students and white students and what is really causing that."
- 3:17But I think that Nation At Risk was this moment where just like across the entire
- 3:21range of educational activity for the first time we saw that the wellbeing
- 3:25of the country is dependent upon how good our public education efforts are.
- 3:30And I thought it was really interesting.
- 3:31The Economist came out with this very unexpected publication about a
- 3:36week ago or two weeks ago, about the success of the American economy and
- 3:41how it's really actually done very well over the last 25 or 30 years.
- 3:45And one of the things that it cites there is our higher ed excellence.
- 3:49But they continue to cite our K through 12 problems as being something that's a drag.
- 3:55And I think that, Nation At Risk was probably the first place that really
- 3:59made us focus on the fact that overall, our K-12 efforts are in fact a drag.
- 4:04Andy: Yeah, and what you raise there, one of the critiques you often
- 4:09hear about Nation At Risk is this idea that the schools are actually
- 4:14pretty good, except they're just not good for certain groups of kids.
- 4:17And you hear that a lot and, weirdly, you hear it a lot from self-identified
- 4:20progressives who are basically saying the schools are actually pretty
- 4:24good if you don't count the poor kids, or you don't count the black
- 4:26kids, you don't count the Hispanic kids, which is a crazy thing to say.
- 4:30It's racist and yet it's a sentiment you hear from the left sometimes and it ties
- 4:35to this idea about the American economy.
- 4:37The American economy has been able to persist despite problems in education
- 4:41and not just recent, problems in the Nation Risk era, but even longer because
- 4:46for a while we had a strong back economy and so not a strong mind economy.
- 4:50And so if you had a good work ethic and you could do work, you
- 4:53could have a middle class lifestyle and educational achievement,
- 4:56didn't have to be part of that.
- 4:58That is changed.
- 4:59And then second, it's just a numbers' game.
- 5:00People used to talk about sure, "German engineers are better than
- 5:03American engineers, but we can put four engineers on the same problem."
- 5:07And that really was, we won a numbers game during the 20th century.
- 5:10You can't beat China and India and countries like that
- 5:13economically with numbers.
- 5:15We've got to beat them with educational quality.
- 5:18And so that, that critique I've heard for a long time and it
- 5:21has never sat right with me.
- 5:22Not only just ethically and from an equity standpoint, but just
- 5:26practically, it's it doesn't matter.
- 5:27And my own view, and I've written about this as is that our future talent is all
- 5:31these kids who are underserving right now.
- 5:34If you want more engineers, some of those kids are your future
- 5:37engineers, but you have to put them in a position to be able to do that
- 5:40and have those kinds of choices.
- 5:42And I agree with you, it was seminal in terms of the
- 5:44moment and what it kicked off.
- 5:46And I think you can quibble with aspects of it, it was a political
- 5:48document, interestingly, there's this whole view of it is like this gigantic
- 5:53conspiracy, but I would highly recommend Luke Cannon's biography of Reagan.
- 5:58He wrote about Reagan when he was a governor and then covered him at the
- 6:01White House, and they talk about Nation.
- 6:03There's a couple pages in there about Nation At Risk and it talks about how
- 6:07this was a throwaway thing for them.
- 6:09They didn't expect this to take on the life it did and so forth.
- 6:13They fell into it less than it was this elaborate, orchestrated effort
- 6:17and as in general, most people who have conspiracy theories, but all
- 6:21these things government is doing have never actually worked in government.
- 6:24It's on a good day, it's a lot.
- 6:26And anyway he talks about it.
- 6:27He just fell into this.
- 6:28I think it's good reading in these sort of sinister things.
- 6:31The one thing with that article though that Strauss republished, and look,
- 6:34if I suspect the Venn diagram between people who get their education news
- 6:38from Valerie Strauss and people who listen to our podcast, I don't think
- 6:41there's a whole lot of overlap there.
- 6:43That's just not a particularly good place to get your news.
- 6:45But it made a really good point though.
- 6:47I think the standards movement, it's been a big push.
- 6:51It's had, it's actually accomplished a lot of good things.
- 6:53We need to figure out, you know what now, and you and I talk about that some,
- 6:56but it did result in the minimizing of career and technical education.
- 7:01And I think there is a place for that.
- 7:03And we need to think about what does CTE look like.
- 7:05I think a lot of CTE advocates and a lot of people, there's a lot to
- 7:09answer for there in terms of tracking and there's some reasons that people
- 7:13are skeptical of CTE, but we do have to have a conversation there.
- 7:16And I thought that was a point the article made as a potential downside
- 7:19that was worth engaging with it.
- 7:21And charter schools, there's some of them that are trying to focus
- 7:23on that and people are trying to figure out what are ways to do CTE
- 7:27that don't just become tracking.
- 7:29Jed: Yeah, I think also like overlay of the Nation at Risk timeframe and
- 7:36the broader changes in the economy, really been looking at some of this.
- 7:41Is it called the Meritocracy trap?
- 7:43Is that the book from a couple years ago that really went after
- 7:46the notion of American meritocracy?
- 7:49And really talking about how the affluent got so great at educating their own
- 7:56kids to perpetuate their special benefit that, it has created a very compelling
- 8:03argument against meritocracy broadly.
- 8:05And are we as a society getting to the point where we're going to focus
- 8:09so much of our collective investment in a very narrow slice of kids,
- 8:14and feel like the economy is going to be able to be okay for that?
- 8:17Or, are we going to finally figure out a broader investment in all kids?
- 8:22And those that attack a Nation At Risk I think risk undercutting an
- 8:28argument that even more investment, that's broad, for the 99% is central to
- 8:34what we should all be thinking about.
- 8:36Andy: Yeah.
- 8:36A few years ago the EDTrust had some data out and it basically shown-- I'm
- 8:40going to get this a little wrong-- but directionally, that basically kids who
- 8:44got As and Bs in the lowest quintile, lowest two quintiles were going to
- 8:48college at the same rate as kids in the upper income quintile who got As and Bs.
- 8:53And that was one way you see systemic problems in the American
- 8:57education system, in the data.
- 8:58And so to your point, one thing you, you look at that and you say, okay, then this
- 9:02is all bullshit and we should get rid of it, but another thing you could look at
- 9:05that and say, and this is obviously how I look at it, is there's a real return
- 9:09to college, especially for poor kids, so what do we need to do to make sure those
- 9:12kids in the lowest quintile, particularly those really hyper talented kids are
- 9:16getting the opportunities they need?
- 9:18That's the thing we need to fix.
- 9:20But and we have had this push in the last few years at our college, it's
- 9:23all a waste and so forth, and the data don't show that for starters.
- 9:28And second, it's weird because it's pretty much everybody's saying it are
- 9:30people who went to higher ed and have benefited from that and are now running
- 9:34around saying, "oh no there's something there that's a little un unsettling."
- 9:39But the equity push on how do we get those students, those lower income students,
- 9:43like that seems like that's the work that, I think that's the reason a lot
- 9:46of people come to work, because they do think that's our future talent pipeline.
- 9:50That's our future talent pool that's not engaged as fully as it could be right now.
- 9:55Jed: And as far as education policy goes, I think we suffer from societal amnesia.
- 10:01And so when something like education, when Nation At Risk comes up,
- 10:04we're talking about four decades ago and the opportunities to write
- 10:08whatever the heck you want to, because of our amnesia, are ripe.
- 10:14But if we look just at what happened two or three years ago we really saw
- 10:18this come out with Randy Winegarten and being put under the microscope right now
- 10:23for what was her role in during Covid and opening and keeping things closed.
- 10:28I have some thoughts about that as well.
- 10:29But where do you get us started on this topic?
- 10:31Andy: No, we can do it.
- 10:32I know you have some thoughts and I've got some thoughts.
- 10:33The one thing I'll say: something you said that was just embedded in there, we
- 10:35should surface The Economists' coverage of education lately has been really good.
- 10:40Jed: I agree.
- 10:41Totally agree with you.
- 10:42Andy: Yeah, really strong mainstream coverage and not just like this recent
- 10:46stuff, but just, over the last year or so, they've just been like doing some
- 10:50really smart stuff that's worth reading.
- 10:52Yeah, I think we can, I think we can tie off the Nation At Risk.
- 10:55I do.
- 10:55It's appropriate.
- 10:56I just heard the news this morning.
- 10:57I suspect by the time this podcast comes out, it'll be more widely around, Marshall
- 11:02Smith, Mike Smith, who was under Secretary of Education, the Clinton Administration,
- 11:06Dean of Stanford out your way among a number of other roles at Hewlett in
- 11:11California as well, passed away this morning, and just you think about the
- 11:16standards movement, you think about the progress that's been made since Nation At
- 11:19Risk, like Mike was pretty instrumental in some of that work was super thoughtful,
- 11:24a real big thinker but a real big thinker who was open to other ideas.
- 11:28One of the things that impressed me about him a lot when I first got to
- 11:31know him is how willing he was to engage with perspectives he didn't agree with.
- 11:35He wasn't a tribalist.
- 11:37And and so we should as we talk about, so the Nation At Risk and
- 11:40that progress, we should certainly call attention to that because he
- 11:42certainly made his contribution.
- 11:44Jed: I thank you for recognizing him because that is a big moment.
- 11:47He was definitely a pivotal figure.
- 11:49But tell me what do you make of this...
- 11:51I mean, well It's interesting because like Nation At Risk, I went back
- 11:54and I looked at Terrell Bell when he was being interviewed by the
- 11:58Senate Education Committee before his appointments were approved because he
- 12:01was Secretary of Education under Reagan.
- 12:04It was just such a deep and thoughtful discussion.
- 12:09And Oren Hatch and Kennedy are there and they were respectful of each
- 12:14other and they actually talked about some depth of issues and I think
- 12:18Mike Smith was there at a moment when that kind of depth was possible.
- 12:21And then you contrast that against, Winegarden, in Congress
- 12:25last week with Green Taylor.
- 12:26Oh my gosh.
- 12:27It's just a completely different environment.
- 12:30Andy: Yeah, I mean that, I didn't watch a lot of that hearing because it was
- 12:34just a circus and I thought what Marjorie Taylor Green said was way over the line.
- 12:38And which would it see if she wasn't clearly insinuating something she
- 12:41should have made that clear or apologized for it so way over the line.
- 12:45But at the same time, like everyone wants to talk about that and not talk about
- 12:50there's a lot of historically amnesia, and this was only a couple of years ago.
- 12:53We're not talking about Nation At Risk, we're talking about 2021 and 2022.
- 12:57And so it was it was one of these things, and I find so many of these things these
- 13:00days, everybody wants to find good guys and bad guys, and you're just, instead
- 13:03you're like, yeah, I don't like any of this like your answer's rather than a
- 13:06rooting interest your answer's just, yeah.
- 13:08No, thanks.
- 13:10Jed: I've started investing more at charter folk in some of the
- 13:13archival newspapers so that we can see what were people saying about
- 13:18New Jersey charter schools in 1997?
- 13:20What were they saying about public schools in general in 1993?
- 13:24What were they saying in Washington DC before charter schools came along?
- 13:27Just to try and set the record straight.
- 13:29Cause I think it's really very important and when we have an amnesia from a
- 13:34societal standpoint on education issues.
- 13:36When people can't remember, they don't want to remember the past, then
- 13:40people can just say charter schools are actually, creators of problems
- 13:43that we're actually responses to.
- 13:45But that's broader.
- 13:46That's over a 30 year timeframe.
- 13:48Andy: But I think you're putting your finger on the problem that Randy's
- 13:51running into her ammo over the years has always been just say whatever
- 13:55you need to say in the moment.
- 13:57And that worked for a long time longer than I think a lot of people
- 14:01thought it was going to work.
- 14:02The problem she's bumping into now is everything's recorded.
- 14:04Everything's digitized, and people can reach out.
- 14:08And so you saw like her account, like Terry McCullough, like that New York Times
- 14:12article, Terry McCullough wouldn't even confirm some of the stuff she was saying.
- 14:16So yeah, no, that didn't happen.
- 14:17And then Lori Lightfoot on the closing stuff came out today and was like,
- 14:21yeah, no, that's not how it went down.
- 14:23I think that there's a increasingly short half-life to that strategy and
- 14:27it's catching up with Randy on this issue cuz you don't need to do archival
- 14:31deep digs or go to dusty libraries.
- 14:34Anyone with Google can do it.
- 14:36Jed: And the other thing that she really tries to, just attach herself
- 14:40to for justification is, "oh, the polling said, and all the parents
- 14:45in our schools said at some moment."
- 14:47Now, first of all, I don't think she's crisp on what polling there existed when.
- 14:52And so she's really able to like, try and have some more
- 14:54flexibility along those lines.
- 14:56But the other thing she just absolutely does not take responsibility for is
- 14:59in terms of forming public opinion and forming parental opinion.
- 15:04What your union and your teachers are saying over and over again is
- 15:08changing the views of the electorate.
- 15:10And when you have clear stories in country, after country in Europe,
- 15:14where they were able to open up the schools in that following spring and
- 15:17had virtually no health problems.
- 15:20It just goes to show that, a set of organizations like Randy's on top of
- 15:26just pushing out some stuff that's just fundamentally not accurate, actually
- 15:31does in fact sway opinion in very big ways that I think she ultimately
- 15:37should take much more responsibility for than she's willing to do right now.
- 15:40For sure.
- 15:41Andy: Yeah, look, I think my general thing, you have to get
- 15:44the spring of 2020 was crazy.
- 15:46Nobody knew.
- 15:47We didn't know how this thing was spread.
- 15:49I was actually moonlighting as an EMT during that time and like we were
- 15:53getting, nobody knew what was going on.
- 15:54We're getting conflicting guidance on how this thing was trans...
- 15:57I mean, that was a confusing time.
- 15:59And it was, so it was confusing for everybody, whatever
- 16:02your distance from it was.
- 16:03But to me, the problem became like when you started to like, I remember I wrote a
- 16:07piece later in the spring saying we need to have open air summer schools and we
- 16:11need to start thinking creatively about this, and I got attacked for like that I
- 16:15wanted teachers to die and all this stuff.
- 16:17And and that's when you could start to see, okay, this is getting away
- 16:20from us, it's getting tribal and we're going to need some leadership, and
- 16:23obviously the White House was no help.
- 16:26And you cannot help but run the counterfactual here of, if we had
- 16:29actually had steady leadership at the White House instead of just that circus
- 16:36show we had, if you'd actually had steady leadership, would that have helped lower
- 16:40the temperature on some of this stuff?
- 16:42Not that you could have solved this from Washington, but you would've
- 16:44just had clearer direction so forth.
- 16:45That's unknowable, but that's something I wonder about.
- 16:48But the interesting thing with the polling that you raised Jed, one
- 16:52of the things we saw, as soon as schools would open in communities,
- 16:56the polling would start to shift about whether or not they should be open.
- 17:00And I think there's no way to know for sure, but my sense on that is partly what
- 17:03we are seeing was despite everything, people still trusted their health
- 17:08officials, their local health authorities, their schools, and so they figured if the
- 17:12schools were closed, there was probably a good reason that the schools were closed,
- 17:16so they supported keeping them closed.
- 17:18And then when they opened, they conversely assumed well that they're
- 17:21saying it's okay to go back to school, it's probably okay to go back to school.
- 17:24And you saw public opinion change.
- 17:26It was very hinged on this question of whether or not the
- 17:29schools actually were open or not.
- 17:31And I think that..
- 17:32so I do think you can point to the polling and say some parents didn't want to, and
- 17:35I think some parents clearly did not want to, even when schools were open, and one
- 17:40of the things that states, some states did a good job, some states did a lousy
- 17:43job, is what kind of virtual options and other options were you continuing
- 17:47to provide for families who weren't comfortable or who couldn't be comfortable
- 17:50because of medical conditions, either with kids or in their household or whatever.
- 17:54And then that, again, that was a very mixed job, but I think the polling, it's
- 17:57a misreading that it was just nobody wanted this to happen, it was done against
- 18:01their will, it was more fluid than that.
- 18:03And because, again, people were looking for leadership, they were
- 18:05looking for guidance, and despite all the missteps, they still hope they
- 18:10trusted public health authorities to try to tell them what to do.
- 18:13Jed: It's why one of the most damning moments from the testimony, or at
- 18:16least from the articles I've seen characterizing, because I didn't watch
- 18:19the whole thing myself either, was the focus on whether Winegarten was
- 18:23using her influence to push the CDC to change what it was recommending.
- 18:28That is really a foundational issue and she should really be held accountable
- 18:33for trying to behind close doors.
- 18:36Andy: Yeah.
- 18:36And how they were using like different language so it wouldn't look like
- 18:39they were doing that cause they were focusing on certain teachers.
- 18:41There's a lot of slight at hand here.
- 18:44But again, there's a record and I think people are super frustrated.
- 18:48And you're starting to see that come up and you're seeing more and more and not
- 18:53just in conservative media, you're seeing more and more just questioning about this.
- 18:58But we do have to sound, I don't know if you want to move on from it.
- 19:00I'm not the only one who's thought this, I think a lot of people thought this and
- 19:03I've seen a few people, it does take, just, we should pause and just honor.
- 19:07It takes a certain kind of I don't know what you would even call it.
- 19:10Not political skill, something to make Randy look sympathetic
- 19:15in this whole thing.
- 19:16It takes a certain kind of something that apparently only Marjorie Taylor Green
- 19:20can muster and has, that you were, wow.
- 19:23You can make her, you make her look completely sympathetic
- 19:25cuz you're over the line.
- 19:26And I just don't think we can leave without just pausing on
- 19:28that superpower that Marjorie Taylor Greene apparently has.
- 19:32Jed: Yeah, that was a very unfortunate part of this whole thing, for all sorts
- 19:36of reasons, I think where I would, go next or where I would extend it as it
- 19:40relates to like topics we want to get to, is this recurring question of did
- 19:44Weingarten and did the unions in general, quote unquote overplay their hands?
- 19:49And we saw a lot of people that were saying that they overplayed their hands.
- 19:55And I basically argued against that.
- 19:59I did not see any evidence that the unions themselves believed that they
- 20:04were overplaying their hands, if anything, they were just doubling down.
- 20:08But I do think it's, as I think more about it, it depends on which
- 20:13poker game you're talking about.
- 20:15If you're talking about politics in urban settings and deep blue, there's
- 20:21no there's no overplaying there.
- 20:24They can do whatever they want to do.
- 20:25The only place you can really overplay it is if you're basically in a 50/50
- 20:31red/blue political context where the union can be so extreme that they
- 20:37actually will take some of those blue or they'll influence the independence.
- 20:41And so I think that like the place I would well, Virginia's certainly one
- 20:45of these places, but New York was one as well, where I think like Hochul
- 20:48felt as though this race turned out to be way closer than she was thinking.
- 20:54And so she made a commitment during the campaign that she would
- 20:58lift the cap on charter schools.
- 21:00I don't think she really wanted to do that.
- 21:02She uttered one single word saying that she supported lifting the cap.
- 21:06But now everyone after the fact has been holding her to the fact that
- 21:11she needs to deliver on her promise.
- 21:14And this week we see that there's going to be some number of schools
- 21:19that are going to be able to open.
- 21:21For me the irony I wrote about this week at CharterFolk was that the one place in
- 21:26New York that would not be allowed for a new charter school is Harlem because
- 21:30they have more than 55% of their kids in public schools already attending charters.
- 21:34But just the irony of all the places, of all the places where charter
- 21:37schools have done incredibly great work and we would want more, and where
- 21:41historical inequity, and just system dysfunction has been more pronounced
- 21:45than anywhere, that is the one place in the state of New York where apparently
- 21:49we're not going to be able to open up charter for the next couple of years.
- 21:52Andy: Yeah, I know you follow that more closely.
- 21:54The New York stuff to me is always slightly impenetrable, just the
- 21:58politics up there are like, it's checkers, chess, and like five other
- 22:02games going on at the same time.
- 22:04I actually just have a few people I call when I actually need
- 22:06someone to explain it to me.
- 22:08And I used to be on the board of the New York State Charter Association.
- 22:10I should know this more, but it is like, pick your various metaphors.
- 22:15It is complicated.
- 22:16Jed: Can I ask you, Andy, just from a blue perspective, what we find that
- 22:21democratic governors in purplely states, they can't stand on a straight support or
- 22:30defense of the public education system.
- 22:32Murphy in New Jersey, he waffles and there's going to be a
- 22:35lot of charter school growth.
- 22:36And we see, that Hochul had to do this.
- 22:38We see that in Rhode Island.
- 22:39We got new supports in Pennsylvania.
- 22:41We got a governor that's that Democratic, but these tend to be in these places
- 22:45where it's red or blue or where there's a mix of red and blue, do you think in
- 22:51places like Chicago and in San Francisco and in Los Angeles where it's just
- 22:55absolute blue, are politicians going to be able to stand on a defense of the
- 23:00public education system, or are they too ultimately gonna waffle and say some
- 23:04kind of reform needs to happen here too?
- 23:06Andy: Yeah, that's a great question.
- 23:08Look, they're, everyone's cross pressured right now.
- 23:10I think one piece of context, we don't talk about the unions and what poker game
- 23:13they're in, the big poker game they're in is the post Janus poker game where
- 23:17their membership is declining and so they need to figure out ways to engage their
- 23:21members and this seems weird to talk about in these terms, but strikes and all
- 23:25this stuff, they are member engagement strategies, they get people fired up and
- 23:30to some extent, They don't, you don't necessarily the merits of it matter less
- 23:35and you'll talk to people, they'll be like, "yeah, but this isn't really about
- 23:37the merits this is about activating the membership, activating the base."
- 23:40And so they're trying to figure out like how do they survive in a
- 23:44world where people thought, Janice I think like you, you talked a lot.
- 23:47People they thought The unions will go out of business in a year because of it.
- 23:50And so it is, it must have had no effect, but it's not like that.
- 23:53It's a slow glide.
- 23:54It's going to take some time, but you're really starting to see the impact on them.
- 23:57And so they, they understand and that's why they're so like invested
- 24:01in who the next labor secretary is and who the next administration is.
- 24:05They're facing an existential threat, and that's the poker game
- 24:08that they are really playing.
- 24:10I've thought for a long time, "yes, they're going to overplay their hand.
- 24:13Yes, they're going to overplay their hand" and people have
- 24:14short memories and it comes back.
- 24:17And I think to your point on Glenn Youngkin, it depends what's on offer.
- 24:20Youngkin was able to win because he was reasonable, he was
- 24:24appealing to people and so forth.
- 24:26And If you think of like, if you look at like 2022 and you look at a lot of
- 24:29the candidates that the Republicans put on the ballot, they wouldn't have been
- 24:32able to succeed in that environment.
- 24:34So Youngkin was a perfect storm of a ripe electoral environment and the right
- 24:38candidate that the Republicans ran.
- 24:40So I don't think it's as straightforward as that, that they're going to
- 24:44overplay their, that they're going to overplay their hand.
- 24:46And what that means in these cities is I think people will get dragged
- 24:50kicking and screaming to this.
- 24:51But it's going to take a while.
- 24:53And there's going to be a lot of collateral damage in the interim, but
- 24:57if there's nothing good on offer, you're not, the Democratic coalition will
- 25:00not split over questions like this.
- 25:02Like you, you need an environment of real political competitiveness,
- 25:06both inside the Democratic Party and across across party lines.
- 25:09And we just, in this climate room, we, you don't have that
- 25:12competitiveness in a lot of places.
- 25:15Glenn Youngkin's at 58% now, I think something like that, like you hear all
- 25:19this noise and so forth, but like he's generally within the state reasonably
- 25:23popular particularly in the context of a, of 2023 and closely divided politics.
- 25:28And so I just, that, that looks to me to be a little bit of an
- 25:31outlier case relative to how this stuff's going in most places.
- 25:35Jed: You were telling me about the new content standards that were adopted in
- 25:39Virginia and how it might relate to some of these red/blue wars, culture wars.
- 25:44Educate me a little bit here.
- 25:46Andy: You want my PTSD, I should probably be talking to your
- 25:50wife about this on the couch.
- 25:52It was, it was quite an experience.
- 25:54This is my second go around with standard setting in Virginia
- 25:57and it has changed a lot.
- 25:58It was highly political actually.
- 25:59What we were talking about, you would talk to some people and you'd be like, "what
- 26:02you're saying isn't true" and they would say, "yeah we gotta engage the members."
- 26:05And it became just very red on blue and just stop yanking.
- 26:09And there were some mistakes.
- 26:10The administration there, there was clear the, the first set of standards
- 26:13that were put forward, the board rejected them eight to nothing.
- 26:16So it's not like there weren't mistakes.
- 26:18But this final set of standards we passed is actually pretty good.
- 26:21It's actually got some California stuff in it, as a matter of fact.
- 26:24But the rhetoric around it is just deranged.
- 26:26It's starting to slow down as people, some people are actually reading at the
- 26:29Washington Post and editorial where they allowed that a lot of the criticisms
- 26:33being leveled against them were just in factually inaccurate and so forth.
- 26:37But it was illustrative to me, Jed, just the time we're living in.
- 26:41It's hard to have nice things, right?
- 26:43Like the end of the day the product we ended up with was pretty good.
- 26:47The board adopted the standards themselves unanimously.
- 26:50Including Anne Holton who's, you're not a Virginian, but her family's history here
- 26:54in Virginia around issues of integration and issues of addressing historical
- 26:59discrimination, racism in our state.
- 27:00She's on the board and was like, these are standards are, they're
- 27:03pretty good on how we teach about that, and they're a real step forward.
- 27:06So it was like a good moment and the board worked hard collaboratively to
- 27:10get there, and yet the atmospherics were just terrible and the sort
- 27:14of just the conflict narrative and the conflict entrepreneurism.
- 27:17And it was just for me, just illustrative of like why we, why it's hard to get
- 27:22anything done right now in this climate.
- 27:24And so to your earlier question, to move things forward in some of these
- 27:26places, we need people to come together.
- 27:28And that's just not happening.
- 27:31It's all about a conflict narrative and stirring up differences rather than
- 27:34figure out how to bring people together.
- 27:37Jed: I think there are so many different kinds of content,
- 27:41standards and content standards to be thinking about, that it might be
- 27:44worth a conversation at some point.
- 27:45I just think it's fascinating how much difficulty we're having adopting
- 27:51these things and we tend to argue about what is the single point
- 27:55of view we want to get to on this issue or that issue, or this issue.
- 28:00And yet what we know we want students to learn is how to grapple
- 28:06with multiple points of view.
- 28:07And it doesn't make, I just don't understand why the standards
- 28:11that we attempt to adopt are arguing about a spectrum of ideas.
- 28:16I think there's some ideas that can be Just beyond the pale, don't
- 28:19include them, they are just extreme.
- 28:21But we want to like share a range of opinions on these kinds of things and
- 28:27come forward with tools for kids to figure out how to grapple with that range.
- 28:33And there's just, we don't model that for kids at all.
- 28:36Andy: No.
- 28:36And both sides have things that they dearly held things that they
- 28:42think are just matters that are not open to varying points of view.
- 28:45But among all the normies, like the other 80% of people are like, yeah, those are
- 28:49open to, those are open to contention.
- 28:53And so it's not it's not about whether or not you should teach about reparations.
- 28:56It's whether should you only teach about them one way or should you
- 28:58teach the case for and against.
- 29:00And should you teach that in a really nuanced way because
- 29:03among African Americans, there's differing views on that, right?
- 29:07It is not should not....
- 29:08So you don't teach in some sort of reductionist way, teach it with all
- 29:11the nuance and complexity there.
- 29:13One of the things I'm very pleased about the Virginia standards is Zor
- 29:16Neal Hurston is in there, who to me, is like representative of somebody
- 29:20who was not easy to pigeonhole clearly thought for herself, was
- 29:24actually censored during her lifetime.
- 29:26And so like, complicated people like that I think help with what you're getting at.
- 29:31But the other big issue is simply do we even teach content or do you just
- 29:35teach inquiry and skills or very little content and mostly inquiry and skills.
- 29:41And that's an interesting dynamic for the charter sector I think,
- 29:44because my personal view is I like a more content rich education.
- 29:50And I think there's a lot of evidence that shows that know a knowledge
- 29:52rich education, you get better outcomes, better literacy, all of it.
- 29:56That knowledge is essential.
- 29:57And then once you have thing that, that knowledge, then you teach
- 30:00people to think critically in the things we were talking about.
- 30:03But it's not a sort of both.
- 30:05It's a, you need content and then you learn to think about it.
- 30:08But within the charter school context, obviously there's schools that are all
- 30:11over the place from core knowledge charter schools that are very content focused to
- 30:16very progressive, purely inquiry based schools that are very light on, you
- 30:22know, on an emphasis on content, very project based, all of that, and they can
- 30:26all live kind of in the charter world.
- 30:30And I do think you can't, you just, you said it earlier, you, there's
- 30:33stuff that's gotta be off the table.
- 30:35You can't just be like anything's good.
- 30:36Societies have to make choices and you can't dodges.
- 30:39And I think people in the choice community, you think choice will solve
- 30:42that are, I think that's wrong, but you can have more sort of, if you
- 30:46have a more choice driven system, you can have more on these sort of
- 30:49emphasis on pedagogy and themes.
- 30:51And it does create more space for that.
- 30:54Jed: Yeah I'd love to come back to this topic of how to teach across a broader
- 30:59content and a range of perspectives.
- 31:02I would say that some of my favorite moments in teaching were those when I
- 31:07actually think I did it pretty well.
- 31:09There were times I did it wrong again and again and again.
- 31:12But by my seventh year, I was better at it than I was in my first year.
- 31:17And I was also, just starting to learn how to balance.
- 31:20If I never shared what my perspective, my personal perspective
- 31:24was with my kids, they got bored.
- 31:26And they were genuinely very curious and they felt like they were being messed
- 31:30with, if they never knew what their teacher actually thought about an issue.
- 31:35On the other hand, if it was the teacher's opinion all the time,
- 31:39so I tended to give it like once every 20 days, once every 20 issues.
- 31:45But every once in a while I was going to give it, and they were,
- 31:48it would help them stay with the lesson all the way to the very end.
- 31:52But I just think these ideas about how we teach a range of perspectives and
- 31:56how we also try to get kids to move away from extremes to being able to see
- 32:01on both sides of issues, is something that we should really get better at, but
- 32:07we never, at least from my perspective as it relates to content standard
- 32:10adoptions, find that to be a priority.
- 32:14Andy: Yeah, and we're actually talking in Virginia about how do we, what kind
- 32:18of tools and training do you provide to teachers to help them teach these things?
- 32:22There's a couple of problems.
- 32:23One, a lot of teach teaching programs and teachers on education, they
- 32:26don't get the content on this.
- 32:28And part of some of the craziness in the last few years when you scratch meet
- 32:31the surface, it's not, curriculum coming out of sort of state governments or even
- 32:35school districts as teachers freelancing.
- 32:37They're just finding stuff on Google or Pinterest or whatever it is.
- 32:41And so you have to provide good materials and all that.
- 32:44And then you have to provide training becuse you don't just wake up in
- 32:46the morning knowing how to do this and sensitive stuff can come up.
- 32:51I used to do a lesson where I would take kids to to the Superior Court to see, and
- 32:56you could usually count on there'd be drug cases and those are the public defenders,
- 33:00generally fourth Amendment defenses.
- 33:01So it was how I taught the Fourth Amendment.
- 33:04And but that would also like you go to court on any given day, you're gonna
- 33:07see stuff that's gonna raise a whole bunch of questions about society for
- 33:11kids and different questions about different things, including obviously,
- 33:14power, race, things like that.
- 33:16And so like you, you don't just wake up knowing how to do that.
- 33:19You've got to, you need training and so forth.
- 33:21How to navigate those conversations in ways that people hear feel heard,
- 33:26regardless of different points of view on, on what are often contested questions.
- 33:30Jed: Yeah.
- 33:31You brought up to me this week the core knowledge study, we'll wrap on this issue.
- 33:36Andy: But leave on a good note.
- 33:37Jed: I think it's, it's fascinating, first of all, to see some kind
- 33:41of research that would suggest that core knowledge is generating
- 33:44such positive results with kids.
- 33:46The thing that's hard for me to separate there is that all of the research
- 33:52was in Denver charter schools, and you know, already I'm a fan of Denver
- 33:58Charter schools and I just know that a lot of the successes that we find
- 34:03within charter schools are so context specific, are so organizational specific.
- 34:08It's very difficult to extrapolate out.
- 34:11And I wonder whether or not this same set of organizations, should
- 34:14they have chosen something different than a core knowledge approach,
- 34:18probably would've been successful with that other approach as well.
- 34:22But there's clearly something within this that we should dive into further,
- 34:26which is what are the real value adds coming from the core knowledge approach.
- 34:31Andy: Yeah.
- 34:31Just one thing you raised there that I found interesting about this study is I
- 34:34do think we haven't done enough to think about sort of what are the compounding.
- 34:38I was always like the Teach for America studies would keep coming out, but I
- 34:41was always particularly interested.
- 34:43How do Teacher for America teachers perform in really high performing schools?
- 34:46Do we see a different effect and a more powerful effect there you saw with
- 34:50America teachers, you see a sort of, not insignificant, a modest effect that on
- 34:55average they're better than peer teachers?
- 34:57But it's not a huge effect.
- 34:59But you're like, that's across all schools.
- 35:00What happens if you put them in a really high, do you get
- 35:03a compounding effect there?
- 35:04This study, I was interested, so what happens if you take and you put in
- 35:07good high functioning schools, a really strong knowledge rich curriculum, and
- 35:12as it turns out you, you see a fairly substantial effect, the size of which
- 35:16we don't usually see with interventions.
- 35:18It's very significant.
- 35:19The study we should back up, I don't know, are we doing show notes yet?
- 35:22That's only our third show, the study is by a number of people, including
- 35:26a couple University of Virginia professors Dan Wellingham, David Grismer
- 35:30and so I would urge people, it's on my blog https://www.eduwonk.com/.
- 35:34You can find it.
- 35:35Jed: We'll get it referenced in the show in the show notes.
- 35:37Andy: Perfect.
- 35:38Anyway, so the study, it shows pretty significant effects.
- 35:41And it was a lottery study, which I like.
- 35:43It's basically a natural experiment that not, over-enrolled schools
- 35:46create, which over-enrolled schools is not an ideal circumstance, but it
- 35:50does create good opportunities to do studies and I think it's significant
- 35:53for the reasons we talked about.
- 35:54And just, again, it shows a knowledge rich curriculum.
- 35:57And this was always Don Hirsch's thing.
- 35:59It shows how crazy education politics are.
- 36:01He's always been considered a conservative, and in part cause
- 36:04maybe because the timing when his book came out the same time as
- 36:07Alan Bloom's book and so forth.
- 36:08But Don is anything but a conservative.
- 36:11He's extremely progressive in his politics and he believes one of the most sort of
- 36:17egalitarian things you can do is give everybody equal access to knowledge,
- 36:20and we don't do that, that's why his curriculum is structured the way it is.
- 36:24And to see results like this, I think it's significant and it's the kind
- 36:27of thing that if we had a healthier politics, I think we'd talk about more.
- 36:31I was trying to figure out what would be the analogy of a medical
- 36:33study with these kinds of results.
- 36:35But it is significant and you would think we would be talking
- 36:38about it like substantially more than the attention it's gotten.
- 36:42Jed: I speak about charter schools can sometimes warp these results cuz you
- 36:45don't know if it's unique to the context and whether it can be extrapolated out.
- 36:49But another thing I think is valuable from the charter school world just generally
- 36:52is we have organizations where studies like this can occur and and they can
- 36:57really start to inform conversations.
- 36:59So on this as well as on a number of other issues, I think the
- 37:03existence of the charter school space there is doing what we want
- 37:05it to do from a societal standpoint.
- 37:08But hey, great to check in as always.
- 37:09Andy: Good to see you.
- 37:11We'll get on to, we'll get fully onto baseball season now for the next one,
- 37:14but great to see you and fun to catch up.
- 37:17Jed: All right, you take care.
- 37:18Until next time.
- 37:19Andy: See you, Jed.
- 37:19Jed: Okay, bye Andy.