Latest / Credit Union Exam Solutions Presents With Flying Colors / Why Your CAMEL Code Is Even More Important Now
Transcript
- 0:06Hey everyone, this is Mark TriCal with another episode of With Flying Colors.
- 0:11I hope you had a wonderful Memorial Day weekend and thanked your favorite
- 0:16veterans in your family or that you happen to meet during the day.
- 0:20I.
- 0:20It's a, an important holiday and it's good to remind those people how much
- 0:25we appreciate what they did for us.
- 0:28Typically, I do a new episode on Tuesday followed by a evergreen or a
- 0:33hot topic from a, the past on Thursdays.
- 0:36But because we finally had a little bit of good weather, I switched that
- 0:40and did a evergreen podcast on Tuesday.
- 0:44And today is Wednesday.
- 0:45I'm recording a podcast on NCOs insurance briefing, but most particularly, I'm going
- 0:50to focus on camels and what they revealed about camels and why your camel code right
- 0:56now could be more important than ever.
- 0:59And I'll get to that at the end.
- 1:01You should see on the screen here if you are watching via YouTube.
- 1:06If you're not watching and you're on a podcast app or on my website,
- 1:10I'll describe what we're seeing here.
- 1:11But NCA retooled their PowerPoint and you can still download the
- 1:15PowerPoint, but they turned it into more of a database from their end.
- 1:19You have this top line, the percentage of insured shares by Camel ratings
- 1:25and it shows code ones and twos.
- 1:26While they do their presentation, they can hover over these dots and
- 1:31tell you more specifics, although they actually spoke last about camel.
- 1:35At this meeting they had in a while, which is surprising from one perspective because
- 1:40Camel readings actually got better.
- 1:42You thought they might have highlighted that.
- 1:43Particularly since Todd Harper, former board member relative to his
- 1:49lawsuit has said the sky is falling in camel codes are gonna get worse.
- 1:53So I thought they might have.
- 1:55Tried to point out that Camel Codes got better, but it's really
- 1:59within the line so flat here.
- 2:00It's hard to see anything other than the line is flat, and this page doesn't
- 2:06show, in my opinion, as much as it used to until they get that Interoperative
- 2:10version of it out for everybody else.
- 2:12So hopefully they said that's what they're gonna do, but
- 2:14with their cutbacks, who knows?
- 2:17But the big takeaway here is the blue Camel codes.
- 2:22Camel threes declined from the fourth quarter of 2024 from 715 to 679.
- 2:31Code fours and fives declined from 135 to 129.
- 2:36That six plus 21, 27, 37, 42, a reduction of 42.
- 2:41Now, some of those are mergers, right?
- 2:42So it's not a true net reduction from improvement, although those assets are
- 2:47improved because they're into a different bucket of camel codes, which would be
- 2:51the code one and code two category.
- 2:55This basket shows you a little bit more.
- 2:58This is the second.
- 3:00Slide that they do on Camel codes.
- 3:02And you can see there actually is one area where camel codes got worse and that is
- 3:08over on the left of the screen on code fours and code fives over $500 million.
- 3:15So there, last quarter there were nine complex credit unions, and again,
- 3:21NCA defines complex credit unions as credit unions over $500 million.
- 3:27There were nine credit unions coded four or five that increased to 11.
- 3:33And excuse me.
- 3:35The assets went from 13 billion to just over 13 billion.
- 3:4013.2
- 3:41billion to 15 billion.
- 3:43So there were two units that went in at 1.8
- 3:46billion net, and it's possible that three went in and one went out.
- 3:49But in any event, I.
- 3:51The trend there is negative.
- 3:52There are WA was an aggressive stance taken in at least two credit
- 3:57unions over $500 million, coding them in a code four and a code five.
- 4:02Now, historically, code four means you're gonna be visited by NCUA every 120 days.
- 4:08Versus a code three, which is 180 days versus a code one or a two, which gets
- 4:14you into the regular exam cycle, and they've provided some relief there,
- 4:18which by the way is why your camel code could never be more important.
- 4:22I.
- 4:24But again, I'll get into a little bit more details on that.
- 4:27The a hundred million to $500 million category.
- 4:30There also was a slight increase in Campbell Code fours.
- 4:35They went from eight units to nine units.
- 4:37They went from 1.2
- 4:39billion to 1.4
- 4:41billion.
- 4:42You could argue that you could look and see.
- 4:45All things being equal.
- 4:46If those are the same eight that there was one that went up, you could go
- 4:49try and find a $200 million credit union that might fit that category.
- 4:53But it's also possible that there were moving parts in there and
- 4:56that you can't reverse engineer by the way, they used to have a.
- 5:00Four categories.
- 5:01They had the 500 million and I believe they had a $10 billion category.
- 5:06But as Camel Code started ter deteriorate, they figured out you
- 5:10could actually reverse engineer that.
- 5:12So they collapsed.
- 5:13I.
- 5:14The biggest category into one category, which is the 500 million above also
- 5:18known as complex credit unions.
- 5:20So the smaller credit unions, less than a hundred million.
- 5:23The code fours declined from one 18 to 1 0 9, so a decline of nine,
- 5:27and they declined by 200 billion.
- 5:31Excuse me, $200 million in assets.
- 5:33A little bit of deterioration in two of the categories on code fours and the
- 5:37smaller credit unions actually got better.
- 5:40So what happened in code threes during the quarter the previous quarter, there
- 5:44were 69 complex credit unions, over $500 million, and that decreased to 64.
- 5:50So four of those five, five of those shifted.
- 5:53However, a couple of those probably shifted to the, to.
- 5:57A couple of those were probably the credit unions that shifted
- 6:00from a code four or code five.
- 6:02'cause you can go from a two to a four.
- 6:04It happens, you can go from a two to a five, but the most logical.
- 6:08Pivot would be from going from a three to a four.
- 6:11So I'm guessing that two of these went the wrong direction and went
- 6:14to the code fours and code fives and three of them actually improved.
- 6:19And there was roughly, let's see, $12 billion, $11.3
- 6:24billion in insured shares improvement in that category right here now in
- 6:30the a hundred million to $500 million category, if you fall into that.
- 6:32There was a slight deterioration, a slight meaning an increase of 1
- 6:3792 credit union code threes last quarter, 93 this quarter, and about
- 6:43a hundred million dollars increase.
- 6:44So again, you could theoretically reverse engineer, but who has the time to do that,
- 6:49particularly since it's a small unit?
- 6:52Alright, code three is under a hundred million dollars, 10.3
- 6:55billion in assets previous quarter and this quarter, 9.5
- 7:00billion.
- 7:01So that's an improvement of 800 million and an improvement
- 7:05of from 554 units to 522.
- 7:09That's 32.
- 7:10It looks like NCUA.
- 7:12Is getting nicer in the small credit unions on camel codes.
- 7:16Could that be related to the fact that they had some we just wanna
- 7:20watch 'em so we can go back in.
- 7:22Maybe the regional directors warned them saying, Hey, I don't need you.
- 7:25Being on the small credit unions, let's be a little bit nicer.
- 7:29And on the big credit unions where our risk are we'll keep the game the same.
- 7:32Who knows?
- 7:33But that's what the you could.
- 7:36Paint that narrative.
- 7:37I'm not sure that narrative is exactly correct.
- 7:40Getting back to why your camel code is more important than ever,
- 7:44if you've listened to any of my recent podcasts or read anything
- 7:48in the press recently about NCUA in response to the Trump initiatives to.
- 7:54Decreased federal agencies sizes.
- 7:58We know that NCUA is going to shrink by about 25%.
- 8:02We know that NCUA is under a hiring freeze.
- 8:04We know that they're losing a lot of really talented people.
- 8:07We know that they only have one board member Republican Kyle Halman
- 8:10serving as chair, and we know that they're going to be pressed
- 8:14to get their things done on time.
- 8:16They previously had.
- 8:18Problems getting their camel threes and fours done on time this year.
- 8:22They allowed some relief to that early on in January before Trump came in.
- 8:28President Trump that is, and they elongated their cycle,
- 8:32allowing billion dollar plus credit unions to participate in.
- 8:36The longer exam cycle.
- 8:38Previously, if you were over a billion dollars, you had
- 8:41to have a calendar exam done.
- 8:42Every year, they changed those rules so that if you are a code one and code two
- 8:47with stable management, stable meaning you've been there for a while, I.
- 8:51That you could have that elongated.
- 8:53They did that, in my opinion, like the airlines do their thing
- 8:56to, when they added 30 minutes to every flight, they wanted to
- 8:59make sure that they were on time.
- 9:00I think that's what NCA did.
- 9:02But then under the proverbial Mike Tyson quote, they were punched in the face
- 9:06and told that they needed to shrink.
- 9:08So they've since tweaked that even further allowing a longer cycle for.
- 9:14For every type of credit union, even the ones credit unions now can have a
- 9:18little bit more time based on what they said at the board meeting last week.
- 9:22Which gets me back to if you're a code one and you're a code two and
- 9:25you're in good shape, NCUA is gonna be scrambling to get things done.
- 9:29They don't have time to focus on, on, on.
- 9:32Bank purchases, they don't have time to focus on things that are
- 9:37not examination related, and they don't have time, in my opinion.
- 9:40Once all these people start leaving and you have people that are
- 9:43leaving at the end of the year, you have people that already left.
- 9:47But NCA is a little bit in, in a shocked triage type statement.
- 9:51Type condition right now.
- 9:53And because of that, if you're a good credit union, a code
- 9:56one or code two, you're gonna get ignored a little bit more.
- 9:58And if you know what you're doing and legitimately are code one and code
- 10:02two and 99% of you pick a number, 98% actually should be coded at two that
- 10:07are a one that are coded at one or two.
- 10:09You're gonna get a lot of leeway and that NCOA is just not gonna show up.
- 10:12They're not gonna have time for you.
- 10:14However, if you are a code three or a code four or a code five, you will.
- 10:19Get most of the same level of attention.
- 10:22However, they're not gonna have all the resources that they need.
- 10:25They're losing a lot of regional lending specialists.
- 10:27They're losing a lot of information specialists.
- 10:29They're losing a lot of pcos.
- 10:31They're losing a lot of supervisory examiners.
- 10:33You have supervisory examiners on the West Coast in particular do doing double
- 10:37duty, so they're gonna be stretched.
- 10:40They're gonna be stressed.
- 10:41And because of that, when you're negotiating with them as a code three,
- 10:44code four, or code five, they might they will, they possibly could be a little less
- 10:50willing to be friendly because they're pissed off that their friends left.
- 10:54They're pissed off that they have to do all the work.
- 10:57They're frustrated because they have more put on their plate a as
- 11:01whether they decided to stay and were eligible or whether they were.
- 11:05Six months short of being eligible for retirement or six months short of being
- 11:10eligible for the early retirement.
- 11:14There are folks there I know who wanted to leave, but they fell short.
- 11:17And they even mentioned in their board meeting that there were
- 11:20people who applied to leave that didn't meet the requirements.
- 11:23If you're in good shape and you're a code one and code two,
- 11:25you want to keep it that way.
- 11:27So NCUA.
- 11:28While they're having all this turmoil it doesn't bother you.
- 11:31And if you're a code three, code four, code five, it's gonna be extra important
- 11:34that you communicate with them well.
- 11:37Extra important that you get the information to them that they ask.
- 11:41Put it in a format that makes it easy for them.
- 11:44Try and make their job as efficient as possible so that they see.
- 11:48That you are a good code three that might be moving to a code two but
- 11:53getting their attention is going to be substantially more difficult.
- 11:56I will tell you that.
- 11:58Sadly, in a lot of my clients, in a lot of my conversations, I hear
- 12:02conversations like the specialist was there for only a week.
- 12:06And they didn't look at what we provided.
- 12:07And then when we asked them to look at it, they were already gone.
- 12:10And when they looked at it, they said, Hey, I don't have time to look at it.
- 12:13'cause I'm three jobs on from now.
- 12:15That's only gonna get worse.
- 12:16Making your communication efforts while they are there.
- 12:20Extremely critical.
- 12:21So have a good communication plan when they come in.
- 12:25Have a good communication plan as far as corralling the conversations
- 12:29that happen in your credit union.
- 12:31And we have different podcasts that talk about that.
- 12:34I'm gonna hit one more topic here for the day before I go enjoy the sun outside.
- 12:40And that is this.
- 12:41At the end of the board meeting I was very curious what Kyle
- 12:46Helpmann might say or not say.
- 12:48And I'm reminded a little bit of a Van Morrison song with a, with the line in it.
- 12:53What's the sound of one hand clapping?
- 12:56There's one board member.
- 12:57They have stated publicly via a leaked email from the executive director that
- 13:03the board member can act on anything.
- 13:07He's not yet acted on anything public.
- 13:10He's done two briefings.
- 13:11Briefings are not actions.
- 13:12They established under the Dennis dollar era when I was the deputy
- 13:16executive director and Dennis Dollar was the chair, the only board
- 13:19member that you could do briefings.
- 13:21They put in place a delegation of authority saying back then to resolve
- 13:25that saying or to address that, saying that the NCUA board, if there's only
- 13:30one, could take essential actions.
- 13:32They've publicly said that one, if there's only one board member,
- 13:36one board member equals a quorum.
- 13:38Todd Harper, Tony, Tanya Ska in their lawsuits have indicated
- 13:42that they believe otherwise.
- 13:44Ultimately, this may be decided in court, and there are some things that came
- 13:47out from the Supreme Court indicating that Trump does have broader authority
- 13:51to fire at some other agencies that possibly could impact the cases that
- 13:57Harper and Ska believe that they have.
- 14:00We're gonna have to watch that closely.
- 14:01But in any event, what wasn't said.
- 14:04Was remain calm.
- 14:06I have the ability to take the actions that I need.
- 14:09They did not reiterate it at the table.
- 14:11Why they could have just thought it wasn't appropriate, or they don't wanna
- 14:15touch that third rail because I don't believe that they really believe that
- 14:19a board of one can change regulations, that a board of one can approve a budget.
- 14:24The good thing is NCUA back when I was there, we put in place a two year budget.
- 14:29So there is a budget for 2026.
- 14:32They just need to and those purse strings can be controlled by a one one
- 14:37board member and the executive director.
- 14:39And the reality is, I don't think that they think they can actually take those
- 14:43other actions and that there could be lawsuits that would challenge it.
- 14:46However, the plus is republicans tend to want less regulation, therefore credit
- 14:51unions will likely not sue if actions are taken, although some consumer group might.
- 14:57So we're gonna have to watch.
- 14:59For what happens there.
- 15:00I'm curious what happens there.
- 15:02And with that I will have one additional podcast.
- 15:06Most likely.
- 15:07I teed it up last week about what the future state of NCUA will be.
- 15:12I've got some thoughts on how they may collapse some of the organizations
- 15:17with NCUA to be more efficient.
- 15:21Alright, that's it.
- 15:22I appreciate you listening as always.
- 15:25I hope you'll listen again soon.
- 15:27We're on YouTube, we're on your favorite podcast app.
- 15:30If you like the show, if you could go out and give us a five star rating,
- 15:33we would really appreciate that.
- 15:35Or better yet share the podcast link with some folks at your credit union or some
- 15:41of your friends in other credit unions.
- 15:43I, again, appreciate you listening, and this is Mark TriCal
- 15:46signing off with flying colors.