Latest / The Vegan Report / Who the Heck Should I Vote For? With Joel Matthews | Ep. 45
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome to The Vegan Report.
- 0:02My name is Ryan and have you ever been disappointed by our political class thinking that our dearly
- 0:10held values of compassion as vegans were simply not represented?
- 0:16Feeling politically homeless?
- 0:18Well, today let's confront those sentiments.
- 0:22Let's have an open conversation on the left, the right, and the place of veganism in that
- 0:27political theatre.
- 0:29To discuss this topic, I have with me Joel Matthews.
- 0:33Joel is a writer and academic preparing to publish a book called Human Supremacy, which
- 0:39is a fascinating reflection on the role of religion and Western culture in our exploitation
- 0:45of animals.
- 0:47He has thought deeply about society and often shares his insights on social media.
- 0:53Visit the link in the description below to connect with him.
- 0:57Thank you Joel Matthews for being here.
- 0:59Welcome to the show.
- 1:01I was truly looking forward to this conversation.
- 1:05I'm curious to know how you identify on the political spectrum and in preparation for
- 1:11this interview, I decided to take the political compass test.
- 1:16I think it's an online test everyone can take and it's very interesting because they show
- 1:22you where you are on the political spectrum in terms of the left and the right.
- 1:28And then they also have another indicator which is the authoritative left or right and
- 1:35then the liberal or libertarian left and right.
- 1:40And when I did the test, I was pretty surprised with the results because I was shown to be
- 1:47more on the left and more on the libertarian left, but not that far from the center.
- 1:53So I was wondering, where do you locate yourself on the political spectrum, landscape, all
- 2:02of that?
- 2:04This is a really good question.
- 2:07I've always described myself as someone who is politically on the left and very liberal.
- 2:19And writing this book and talking about and thinking about the treatment of animals and
- 2:28others in general, it kind of reaffirms my commitment to others and helping and supporting
- 2:39others.
- 2:40And on the basis that I don't live and no one lives in a vacuum, we're all fundamentally
- 2:52connected, interrelated, and the product of others and other systems and fortunate enough
- 3:01to have opportunities based on existing systems and society.
- 3:11And so I don't exist in a vacuum.
- 3:19The opportunities that I've been given in education are the product of my parents, their
- 3:26socioeconomic background, society's treatment of them and how it's affected me.
- 3:37And so I have a very close relationship with society and contributing to society.
- 3:51And so in that sense, I would describe myself as someone who's on the left.
- 4:01To be honest, I don't know how this would feed into liberalism.
- 4:08I understand that libertarianism is much more prominent in North America.
- 4:17It's not really not often discussed or it's not discussed in the UK.
- 4:24It doesn't feature in our political discourse.
- 4:29I think maybe because of the geography of the UK, we are literally, physically always
- 4:40close to government, close to London.
- 4:45I was in the United States.
- 4:48I have got friends who I visited several years ago in Kansas and they are physically, geographically
- 4:56very, very far away from Washington, DC.
- 4:59And I think that that does have an ideological or psychological impact on individuals' relationship
- 5:09with government.
- 5:10But in the UK, we're always close to London.
- 5:17You can't get that far away.
- 5:19And so the political discourse is either left or right.
- 5:25And so to answer your question, I would say on the left.
- 5:32That's a good point you're bringing because, yes, my audience is pretty much international.
- 5:40I would say I have more American listeners than anything else.
- 5:48And it's weird how left and right are adapted to those different cultures.
- 5:58So for instance, when I think about conservatives, Canadian conservatives, they're nothing like
- 6:05American conservatives.
- 6:07Like in Canada, for instance, the debate on abortion, that has been closed for a few years
- 6:14now, actually maybe a decade or more.
- 6:19But it is still an open debate in the US and you still have conservatives in the US who
- 6:26oppose it, who oppose the pro-choice argument.
- 6:35And same thing with gay marriage in Canada has been legal since, I think, 2005.
- 6:43So it's weird how there are those different definitions of the left and right.
- 6:50It's not truly universal, which makes me a bit not suspicious, but distrustful a bit
- 6:58of that political compass.
- 7:00I don't know if they take into account the country or your culture, but it's truly not.
- 7:06I don't feel it's a universal, there's a universality to this left and right paradigm.
- 7:19When you bring up the United States, the United States is the introduction of the kind of
- 7:27conflation between the political realm and the religious theological realm.
- 7:37Maybe I would suggest that the political left and right is us human beings as citizens and
- 7:45our relationship to society and government.
- 7:50I do have an explanation for the United States and their relationship with things like abortion.
- 8:01I think that stems from the United States origin of the movement of the Puritans having
- 8:16an extremely potent religious views.
- 8:23On paper, of course, 200 years later, there were secular founding fathers who wrote in
- 8:32the Constitution separating church from state.
- 8:36But I have a very good metaphor for the strange situation in the United States, because of
- 8:47course on paper, it is secular, and yet in reality, it is very religious.
- 8:56The metaphor I have is that when cars were introduced into the UK, legally it was written
- 9:08into our law that to flash our headlights in a car in the UK, that meant I'm here and
- 9:22I'm going to move forward, and be careful because I'm about to move forward.
- 9:30However, when cars were introduced, drivers decided, and still to this day this is how
- 9:38we operate, when we flash our lights, it does not mean watch out, I'm about to move forward.
- 9:48It's the opposite.
- 9:50It means you go first.
- 9:53In other words, the public have collectively rejected what's in the law, and we've just
- 10:03changed it.
- 10:04I think that's what's happened in the United States.
- 10:09Written in the Constitution, there is a separation of church and state.
- 10:18Let's go down to the Carolinas, and I don't think there will be many people who will acknowledge
- 10:24that.
- 10:29The potency of the church, still in the 21st century, is the main reason that is offered,
- 10:42and your explanation for that is because unlike the UK, in which the church is written into
- 10:50our constitution and governance, in America it has been separated, and so in a sense religion
- 11:02is fighting for its life, whereas in the UK we don't have to.
- 11:07In the UK we are surrounded by churches, it's a fundamental part of our culture, we have
- 11:14religious kings and queens.
- 11:20If you're religious in the UK, in England, Scotland, Ireland and Wales, there's no problem.
- 11:26We've got religion forever in a sense, whereas in America there's this constant threat that
- 11:31it's going to disappear, it has to continually advertise itself.
- 11:36And so that produces the kind of paradoxical situation in which you've got a secular America
- 11:47which is more religious than a religious England.
- 11:51That's fascinating, that is truly fascinating.
- 11:54I love your analysis of the situation.
- 11:59Let me go back to my first question.
- 12:03So you identify as being on the left, which is pretty typical in the vegan community.
- 12:12And I want to ask you, why is it the case?
- 12:15Why are most vegans on the left?
- 12:21Because they have an underlying acknowledgement of the interconnection of all others that
- 12:34can suffer in the world.
- 12:38And that awareness and connection is one of compassion.
- 12:44I would suggest, and I know this may be very contentious and controversial, but the political
- 12:53right to be conservative, an English conservative, that political view is fundamentally uncivilised.
- 13:11As I said, no one exists in a vacuum, whether you're a billionaire or a well-heeled right-wing
- 13:29politician, you are the product of some very fortunate conditions, circumstances that has
- 13:41allowed you to occupy the space that you're in.
- 13:50And yeah, I think that's my explanation.
- 13:57I think the contentious view that I have is that the political right is fundamentally
- 14:07uncivilised.
- 14:10But wait, the word uncivilised, I usually hear it from right-wing pundits.
- 14:17They're the ones using most this word, civilised, or the civilised world.
- 14:25So how can you associate this word, and actually its opposite, uncivilised, with those same
- 14:34right-wing people?
- 14:38Because it's just simply not true.
- 14:40I can't state that heavily enough.
- 14:50It's not true because it's inaccurate.
- 14:56To be civilised is to cooperate productively with each other, whether it's a small community,
- 15:08whether it's a tribal community in sub-Saharan Western Africa or in Western secular societies,
- 15:18just cooperating and acknowledging that we're all interconnected.
- 15:24And of course, right-wing pundits in North America, they would like to categorise left-wing
- 15:31movements as being uncivilised.
- 15:35But when you just have to just a cursory look at these movements, show us to be the opposite.
- 15:47Let me phrase that, or give another perspective to this question of why do most vegans identify
- 16:03on being on the left, or at least being liberal, not being conservative.
- 16:09Why aren't more conservatives adopting the vegan philosophy?
- 16:16What are the obstacles, mind obstacles that stop them from considering seriously the vegan
- 16:23argument?
- 16:24Yeah, that's a very good question.
- 16:28I think it would go back to their relationship with society and others.
- 16:36In a political perspective, we're of course talking about human beings.
- 16:48Obviously the vegan conversation is broader than that.
- 16:53But I would say that this demonstrates the depth or awareness or the intellectual depth
- 17:06of the vegan conversation because it acknowledges the very latest insight and understanding
- 17:14of the natural world, which is that human beings are part of all life on Earth.
- 17:23We have all emerged and evolved on this planet together.
- 17:31The human race, human beings, we're not aliens.
- 17:35We haven't appeared.
- 17:37We've all emerged together.
- 17:43So human beings are animals.
- 17:47The very notion of species is fluid.
- 17:51And vegans, I don't know whether you'd call more sort of intellectual vegan people, we
- 18:06know this, we're very aware of this.
- 18:14Whereas people on the right, forgetting all non-human animals, people on the political
- 18:22right, they almost by definition in the UK at the very least, don't care about all other
- 18:31human beings and society to begin with.
- 18:37To this day, the political discussion is anchored to particular ideologues, most notably Margaret
- 18:49Thatcher in the 1970s, who famously said that there's no such thing as society.
- 18:58So there you have it.
- 19:02There it is almost in black and white in a sense.
- 19:07There is just a fundamental rejection of the very notion of society, which is a, you know,
- 19:17you can have that view.
- 19:19But let's see if you still have that view, if you have a broken leg or a pregnant partner
- 19:25and you're in urgent need of health care or the police, at some point you will be relying
- 19:34upon community, friends, family, social services.
- 19:42And yeah, and I think in the largest possible scale, these particular ideologies aren't
- 19:53sustainable, this selfish, uncivilized approach and attitude towards the world is unsustainable
- 20:04and will contribute to the end of the species, but that's only the biggest possible scale.
- 20:13You recognized how religion was a big chunk of the identity of the typical conservative
- 20:23person.
- 20:25And I wonder if religion is playing a role here in stopping people from considering again
- 20:33the vegan argument.
- 20:36And there's a piece of news that I absolutely I'm obsessed with it.
- 20:41This is from the US.
- 20:44So in 2023, there's the I think they're called the Temple of Satan, something like that.
- 20:51They decided to expose to put a behemoth statue inside the Iowa State Capitol.
- 21:00A satanic temple has set up a display inside the Iowa State House.
- 21:05It's the holiday season and even secular government buildings display decorations for holidays
- 21:10that are rooted in religion like Christmas trees and menorahs for 14 days.
- 21:16The satanic temple has erected a display alongside these major religious symbols inside the rotunda
- 21:21of the Iowa State Capitol.
- 21:23Lucien Greaves, co-founder of the satanic temple, spoke to KCCI.
- 21:28We're going to really relish the opportunity to be represented in a public forum.
- 21:33We don't have a church on every street corner.
- 21:36Though the temple went through the correct administrative channels to present in the
- 21:40rotunda, the display is getting pushback.
- 21:42One, I hope people realize spiritual warfare is real, that there are evil satanic forces
- 21:50that are trying to infiltrate our state.
- 21:53And for those of you who don't know, you know, that is like the head, like a satanic head,
- 21:59you know, it's a clear symbol of satanism and, you know, clear anti-Christianism.
- 22:09Anti-Christian sentiment.
- 22:12And of course they did that in the name of freedom of speech.
- 22:21So you are allowed to be explicitly religious in our, you know, political spaces.
- 22:32So we're doing the same.
- 22:34And you should not be offended by our religion, you know, as we are also tolerant of yours.
- 22:42So that was the exercise, an exercise in free speech.
- 22:45But I read the situation like, you know, I found it so fascinating that so many, you
- 22:53know, Christian Americans and conservatives, you know, Republicans were deeply offended
- 22:59by that Bahamian statute.
- 23:02That if you present them with an Iowa, you know, slaughterhouse footage and you show
- 23:10them the evil of what is being done to cows, pigs and the rest, they still eat their bacon
- 23:22and they'll still, you know, sleep well at night.
- 23:26Yet the statute itself, the symbol, that's what's offensive.
- 23:30That's what's, you know, evil, not what's happening in the slaughterhouses.
- 23:36So what is the role played by religion in all of this?
- 23:43So I would begin with how human beings or any individual engages with the world.
- 24:01And after 2,000 or 3,000 years of human philosophy, there are two clear schools of thought.
- 24:09There are two ways, two ways, possible ways in which human beings engage with the world.
- 24:19The first is through the senses in a naturalistic, physicalistic way, direct, quote unquote,
- 24:32direct engagement with the world, and it's through the senses that we acquire information,
- 24:44data, and we put that together and interpret the world.
- 24:49The other is through thinking or the rational self, but thinking, contemplating alone, and
- 25:03we can build up a picture of the world through our thoughts and ideas.
- 25:12I stated in my book, and I have often stated that I don't know, I don't know which is the
- 25:21best method, but I have a lot of evidence which I would suggest it is the, a natural,
- 25:36honest, empirical engagement with the world that presents us with the best chance of survival
- 25:45in the world and the most ethical engagement with it and others that can suffer.
- 25:59And so the problem and the challenge that religion has is that by definition it is fundamentally
- 26:08rooted in revelation and individual, individual's ideas about the world.
- 26:19So when we talk about North American Christians, the origin of North American Christianity
- 26:30is with Abraham, and Abraham was walking in the desert and he has been recorded as stating
- 26:43that he had some kind of engagement with God that presented him with a particular covenant
- 26:51protecting his immediate family and grouping.
- 26:56And so immediately we have exclusivity, we have moral exclusivity.
- 27:05He's only interested in his immediate family or close grouping.
- 27:14And so the problem, the problems stem from there.
- 27:18I propose that we engage with the world with what I describe as a natural attitude, a naturalistic
- 27:27way, an honest, ideally unbiased engagement with others that are suffering.
- 27:40And so we're now in the 21st century and we see Christians in Iowa who cannot, their compassion
- 27:54for non-human animals has been catastrophically damaged.
- 28:01Their ability to engage with these animals has been entirely distorted by these particular
- 28:09religious ideas of humanity, the human species being fundamentally unique with this special
- 28:19wall surrounding it.
- 28:23And as I said, I don't have the fundamental answers, but I am suggesting that as a catastrophic
- 28:35moral oversight to have these particular ideas and allow all these animals to be killed entirely
- 28:44unnecessarily.
- 28:47And so on balance, it's a religious approach to the world is, has fundamental flaws and
- 29:01far greater than a naturalistic approach.
- 29:06I can crystallize this in quite simply.
- 29:14Since the scientific revolution, we now know that the earth, our planet, disregarding the
- 29:26climate crisis, that the earth has a limited lifetime because of the lifetime of our sun.
- 29:37We know that because of science, in other words, a naturalistic engagement with the
- 29:42world.
- 29:45If it wasn't for that naturalistic engagement and the insights that we've gleaned about
- 29:50the world, we would still have people of religious faith or more broadly an idealistic approach
- 30:01to the world, which is this thought-orientated engagement with the world, contemplating and
- 30:11discussing things, and the earth would die, including all these religious people of faith.
- 30:20It is the scientific naturalistic engagement, which at the very least is now shows us the
- 30:26finitude of planet earth.
- 30:30And already in the 1960s has demonstrated that we have the ability to leave this planet.
- 30:39And so on that basis, I rest my case.
- 30:42We're talking about Christianity here, but would you feel comfortable putting that same
- 30:52analysis applying it to other Abrahamic religions like Judaism and Islam?
- 30:58Absolutely.
- 31:00They are fundamentally morally exclusive, and I would respectfully say that they are
- 31:11on that basis, they are morally reprehensible.
- 31:15As someone who is interested and has a commitment to the alleviation or ideally the abolition
- 31:24of suffering in the world.
- 31:26You either, so I ask people of faith, whether they're a Muslim, a Jew or Christian, are
- 31:35you interested in the suffering of others and the alleviation of that?
- 31:41You either are or you're not.
- 31:45And I suggest that whether it's Christians, Muslims or Jews, they are not engaging and
- 31:57receptive to the experience of the gay community, the trans community, or indeed women.
- 32:09If you listen carefully, you'll hear the experiences of people who are excluded and depressed and
- 32:19their civil rights have been withdrawn.
- 32:26I have, I'm not interested in their particular ideas about the world.
- 32:30What I am interested in is the suffering of others and others, of course, includes anyone
- 32:39that can suffer and that includes non-human animals.
- 32:44Having said all of that, you know, having truly shed light on the problem with the right,
- 32:51I still accept the fact that there are strong arguments out there for adopting a vegan diet
- 32:58and lifestyle that could be presented to a right-wing person.
- 33:05For instance, the place of government, the power of the government and how limiting that
- 33:17is a vegan argument because we don't want the government to give subsidies to private
- 33:23companies.
- 33:25That should be a right-wing thinking, you know?
- 33:29So do you also accept that there is a strong right-wing argument for veganism?
- 33:38And I think the best one who represents that is Matthew Scully.
- 33:44Actually, he wrote an entire article about that.
- 33:49I should have prepared better and gave the title, but it's something like the right-wing
- 33:58for veganism, something like that.
- 34:01He published that a few years ago and he goes in depth in details on what would be convincing
- 34:09for a conservative person.
- 34:13So do you accept that there is a good argument to be made and directed to right-wing people?
- 34:21Yes.
- 34:23I'm probably not the best person to...
- 34:27Or maybe I am, I'd have to practice, but I would have to privately translate my ethical
- 34:39language to cater to what I would consider an uncivilized right-wing political outlook.
- 34:51And I think you're absolutely right.
- 34:57Even the ethics aside, we now know that the main contributor to the climate crisis is
- 35:04animal agriculture.
- 35:07And if there is one thing that defines the political right, it's arguably conservation
- 35:17tradition.
- 35:19And I would say the underlying sort of existential motivations for that, which are expressed
- 35:23in these political adjectives, are the maintenance of an individual's family and legacy and power.
- 35:39And so, of course, if we have a climate crisis and we have no climate, these right-wing family
- 35:51legacies cannot exist.
- 35:55And so I would suggest that you're absolutely right.
- 36:01Maybe vegans have to translate or kind of reduce down the scope, the ethical scope,
- 36:14maybe even taking ethics out of the equation and showing them that the right-wing people
- 36:23will not be able to maintain their family legacy and power in society if the climate
- 36:34is under experiencing a crisis.
- 36:38And so we should encourage them to eat.
- 36:42I personally would say, kill no and harm no animals.
- 36:50But maybe if we're trying to communicate to people on the right, we should be taking a
- 36:58more, a welfarist position.
- 37:02But it's extraordinary that, I mean, I've actually said that because I'm passionately
- 37:10an abolitionist.
- 37:13But the reason why I suppose I now found myself talking about a welfarist position is because
- 37:20I'm aware that I'm engaging people who, from the outset, say that they don't care about
- 37:26society and that's human society.
- 37:30But, I mean, reflecting on what I'm saying in the moment, I do have faith in humanity
- 37:38and I, with my book and my approach to people and the world, I have great hope and I personally
- 37:50am aiming and targeting young people who are not being, having, being entrenched in these
- 38:01particular exclusive ideologies.
- 38:10And so, yeah, if we can, if we can focus on young politically right orientated people,
- 38:22maybe we can, maybe we can talk to them about ethics and compassion, but maybe the older
- 38:27generation, we have to talk about climates and a welfarist scope, if that makes sense.
- 38:38It does.
- 38:39And I am of the opinion that our priority should be animals, non-human animals, their
- 38:51well-being.
- 38:52So, although it might make some of us uncomfortable with adopting that stance and trying to build
- 39:03that bridge with people who are not on the same political side as we are, we should be
- 39:12reminded of that, that animals are the priority here, that we're doing this for them, not
- 39:18for us.
- 39:20Yeah, yeah, I completely agree.
- 39:24Yeah, it's not, it's not, it's not a diet.
- 39:27It's not, it actually, it isn't about climate, climate in itself.
- 39:38I have a lot of good friends who are climate activists and I say to them, you know, what,
- 39:47the first question is which climates are we talking about?
- 39:50Are you interested in the climate?
- 39:52When you say climates, are you talking about the climates on the moon?
- 39:56And of course they're not, they're talking about the climates on Earth.
- 39:59So I say, well, that's very interesting.
- 40:01What is it about us and Earth's climate that makes, that warrants us to be so concerned?
- 40:08And of course, we're back to animals.
- 40:12So the climate, ironically, just like the Earth's atmosphere is a, the climate protesters,
- 40:21their main subject is a thin veneer.
- 40:24You only have to ask two or three questions and we're back to others that have the ability
- 40:30to suffer.
- 40:33Exactly.
- 40:34So there are always, we're in summer here, except for, I think Australia and on the Southern
- 40:44hemisphere.
- 40:45But there are, there have been lots of wildfires here in America where I am, I bet in parts
- 40:55of Europe, in the few forests that you have left.
- 41:00And the thing is every time there's a wildfire, I look at the news and they're talking about
- 41:09how it's horrible that it's linked to climate change, that it's putting pressure on all
- 41:17sorts of communities, that it's, you know, polluting the air and the air quality, but
- 41:25they never, never, they never talk about the animal, the non-human animal victims who are
- 41:32being, you know, they're burned alive in those horrifying fires.
- 41:38And they meet their end in the most horrifying way.
- 41:45And what, you know, they're not even worth mentioning, not even quickly how many animals
- 41:54have died in that forest fire.
- 41:56Yeah.
- 41:57Is this reporting in, as you said, is this in Australia or in the Southern hemisphere?
- 42:03Well, I, well, it's general, you know, general, like for instance, right now, as we're talking,
- 42:14it's August and there are lots of news coming from British Columbia here in Canada and they
- 42:23have lots of wildfires and no mention, absolutely none about, you know, the animal lives cost
- 42:33of those natural disasters.
- 42:36Yeah.
- 42:37Yeah.
- 42:38No, it is strange.
- 42:40I don't, I don't, I don't have an explanation for that.
- 42:44I mean, I am aware that the climate crisis has a, or the environment in general has a
- 42:54PR problem in that we can't, it's not tangible.
- 43:01We can't immediately see it.
- 43:03I mean, it's on the, on a quite a large scale.
- 43:10And currently journalists and the media, they're not doing a great job at bringing it closer
- 43:18to home and connecting it with the reason for, let's say, particular, the movement of
- 43:27migrants and asylum seekers in and around Europe.
- 43:33So in the UK, particularly in the past week, we've been witnessing the most horrific scenes
- 43:41on the streets involving essentially modern racists and right wing fascists, young idiots
- 43:56doing Nazi salutes who can barely hold a coherent sentence together.
- 44:04And the, the, the origin of these, these people and their lack of coherent thought is with
- 44:17the media, I think.
- 44:20We have with recently up until about maybe 10 years ago, we've had terrible tabloid,
- 44:31a culture of tabloid journalism.
- 44:36And it's extremely lazy.
- 44:42And yeah, they've done that.
- 44:45I'd say that it's the media in general, which is lacking and has a fundamental part to play.
- 44:53And most notably, it needs to translate or communicate the science of the climate closer
- 45:04to home and explain to people that the reason that they hate people from Pakistan is not
- 45:12because of their skin colour and these terrible, ridiculous, morally reprehensible attributes
- 45:21that they subscribe to particular skin tones, but it's because of the climate crisis.
- 45:29It's the climate crisis that has caused people to, to move around.
- 45:38And yeah, I would suggest that journalists, they have a part to play.
- 45:46So yeah, going back to these scenes of forest fires, it's a curious situation because I
- 45:54would have thought that showing particular animals in horrible situations, that is good
- 46:02to use the modern terminology click baits.
- 46:06But yeah, no, if they're not using that, then I'm not sure why not, because I'm sure that
- 46:14would grab headlines.
- 46:16And it's a great shame that they don't bring that to the public's attention wherever they
- 46:21are in the world.
- 46:23Well I looked up the numbers.
- 46:25Do you remember the Australian wildfires that happened, I think in 2019 or 2020?
- 46:35I think they were big, like it, and every news outlets was covering that.
- 46:43Would you want to guess, you know, how many animals lost their lives in those wildfires?
- 46:51Like if you had a number in mind?
- 46:55I mean, depending on the types of animals, it would have to be beyond, I mean, it would
- 47:02have to be close to a million or beyond a million.
- 47:05Well, I looked it up and according to various, you know, wildlife nonprofits and all of that,
- 47:12the number is three billions.
- 47:16Academy fellow Chris Dickman first estimated that half a billion animals had been killed.
- 47:21But as the fires continued to rage, he now puts that figure at over a billion.
- 47:27And that number doesn't include frogs, bats, fish or insects.
- 47:32So a lot of species that have small populations or small geographical distributions, if the
- 47:37fire affects the entire habitat where they occur, then they're at risk of imminent extinction.
- 47:43And even if they survive the fires, they still must deal with the loss of habitat and food
- 47:48and the threat from feral animals such as foxes and cats.
- 47:52Wow.
- 47:53Which is, this is astonishing.
- 47:56This is just the number that just, and again, even as us vegans are not truly aware of the
- 48:07depth of that disaster.
- 48:10But yeah, we don't talk about them, the three billion lives lost in those gigantic wildfires.
- 48:19I think that there's an old saying that an individual person can be highly intelligent,
- 48:28whereas people en masse are stupid and behave accordingly.
- 48:37So I think that's absolutely right.
- 48:40When I see these people voting in right wing fascists into modern 21st century government
- 48:49buildings, the explanation I have for that is that we have to remember that despite our
- 48:56modern technology, the ability for us to travel from our home planet to our nearest moon,
- 49:02and us walking around with essentially computers in our pockets, we are still animals.
- 49:09We are still saddled with the same evolutionary, biological, basic impulses.
- 49:20And so on that basis, we can be stupid and dangerous.
- 49:26And I think that in order for us, if we're interested in surviving as a species, we do
- 49:32have to think about things more long term.
- 49:35We have to continually, constantly place the grand scheme, the largest macro scale at the
- 49:46forefront of our minds, whether it's the conversations about the climate or voting in political leaders.
- 49:59It's amazing that people are more interested in asylum seekers than the climate.
- 50:07Other than believing that the earth is flat, it's got to be one of the most stupid beliefs
- 50:15that you can have in the 21st century.
- 50:19And so, yeah, we need to be continually reminded of the grand scheme of things.
- 50:29Yeah, so I just think it would be important to add to that.
- 50:34Well, given that right-wing people are usually the furthest away from our position and are
- 50:45playing against the interest of animals the most, given that, and given the fact that
- 50:52there are plenty of right-wing solid arguments that we could present them, my question, which
- 51:05always frustrates me and is always in the back of my mind, is why are we not making
- 51:11those arguments?
- 51:12Why are we satisfied with staying in this left-wing vegan echo chamber?
- 51:21Why are we not welcoming right-wing people?
- 51:27Why are we not putting more efforts where they need to be?
- 51:32What is this lack of flexibility from our part?
- 51:37And I have to say, I tried with this podcast, I tried to play with daring ideas, and I invited
- 51:46two wonderful people who identify as being right-wing to Americans, and the barrage of
- 51:56just hostility I got from everyday vegans from that initiative, accusing me of the worst,
- 52:05because what?
- 52:06We had a conversation with two right-wing people.
- 52:08Those are your neighbors.
- 52:09Those are half of your country population, and those are the people you should be making
- 52:16the vegan arguments to.
- 52:18And those right-wing people were vegans.
- 52:24They were.
- 52:25And why not?
- 52:27Why not invite them?
- 52:28Why not put shed light on them and show that it is possible for the next person who identifies
- 52:38as being conservative?
- 52:40So can you explain that to me?
- 52:43Yeah, I would say that the best chance of persuading someone, I should say it around
- 52:59the other way, young people offer the best chance of considering our views, whether they're
- 53:08politically, they come from a politically left household, or a politically right conservative
- 53:17household, because young people, there's debate about whether this is specific to the post-war
- 53:28side of human history, but young people are innately revolutionary, compassionate, idealistic.
- 53:45And that is why I, with my book, I'm carefully and cautiously being divisive.
- 53:54I am not interested.
- 53:56I have a limited lifetime.
- 54:01I want to spend that time focusing on the people who present the best chance of listening
- 54:10to compassionate approach to the world.
- 54:15And those people are our youth.
- 54:18There is a lot of hope with our youth, and I don't see it with the older generation.
- 54:27Of course, these are great, grand sweeping stereotypes.
- 54:32But I am more focused on our extraordinary, brilliant young people.
- 54:45And yeah, I'm not interested.
- 54:52When I do street activism, for example, I'll talk to someone, and I can see that they will
- 55:00tell me that I'm not making any impact whatsoever, and they walk away.
- 55:04And it's very frustrating.
- 55:06And I'll speak to some other members of the group, and they'll say to me, Joel, don't
- 55:11do that, because if you weren't here, he's now just behaving and carrying on with his
- 55:20life regardless.
- 55:22You shouldn't focus on him because he was going to do that, whether I was here or not.
- 55:28It's the people that I do make an impact with.
- 55:34And I would suggest that it's with our young people that offer the most hope.
- 55:43There's evidence to show that young people are the more, as I said, liberal and more
- 55:52left-wing.
- 55:53There is an old adage, which is that we are born liberal and die conservative.
- 55:58There's various reasons for that.
- 56:01But I think I recognise the potential in young people in taking up moral consideration of
- 56:13non-human animals.
- 56:14And I want to make this presentation as exciting and engaging as possible.
- 56:24Young people stereotypically like to rebel against their parents.
- 56:30And so I want to incite and encourage a compassionate and rational revolution.
- 56:41And parents are perfectly entitled to get angry at me and to say that I am being irresponsible
- 56:50and divisive.
- 56:53I'm certainly being divisive, but you're more than welcome to join the side of compassion.
- 57:00And not harm animals.
- 57:03Yeah.
- 57:04And so basically, to answer your question, is I would say that the way I see it is that
- 57:11I'm aiming my conversation towards the people that statistically offer the best chance of
- 57:21consideration of our viewpoint.
- 57:24But how would we know since there are no initiatives targeting right-wing people?
- 57:33You talked about how some arguments don't resonate with people.
- 57:37Well, if we're not talking their language, if we're not talking about governmental subsidies,
- 57:44and even there is a pro anti-abortion argument for veganism, I'm sure you're aware of it.
- 57:54But if we're not talking, if not using this language, then how can we even hope to resonate
- 58:03with people on the right wing of the political spectrum?
- 58:09Yeah, that's a good point.
- 58:13I think, yeah, I'm not sure.
- 58:19I would suggest that there is evidence.
- 58:24Did you say that there isn't a great deal of data or initiatives in the first place on
- 58:35vegan outreach towards right-wing people?
- 58:39Yeah.
- 58:40I mean, who is doing the outreach right now?
- 58:44I know of one group, I think they're called Vegan Conservatives UK.
- 58:52And I think they're the only one.
- 58:53I tried to contact them, get them on the show, no answer.
- 58:57I don't even know if they are active.
- 59:00I know of a few Facebook groups of conservatives out there, but that is grassroot and mostly
- 59:08not really, it's not an outreach effort.
- 59:12It's mostly a way for conservatives to try to find community and support because they
- 59:20don't find it in the vegan community since vegan community is mostly left-wing.
- 59:27So where are the initiatives targeting right-wing people?
- 59:34I think, yeah, it's a really good question.
- 59:37I don't know.
- 59:42I haven't actually looked into it.
- 59:49I would still suggest that, again, to use another philosophical quote, you'll never
- 59:56jump into the same river twice.
- 1:00:02In other words, a river is constantly flowing and changing.
- 1:00:08It's not a static entity.
- 1:00:11And that is the same for the human race.
- 1:00:14And to be perfectly blunt, the older generation or the...
- 1:00:21I'm now aware that I'm equating or conflating the political right with the older generation.
- 1:00:28But yeah, maybe I should stick to the political right.
- 1:00:32I would say going back to the older generation that to be blunt, these people, these ideas
- 1:00:38are going to die away, pass away with them.
- 1:00:47And those ideas are stereotypically uncompassionate.
- 1:00:57And so I would suggest that that's not a bad thing in the interests of the welfare of existing
- 1:01:05people in the world.
- 1:01:07But no, yeah, so for the people on the right, yeah, I absolutely take your point.
- 1:01:18I think the people, the political, the subgroup of humanity that are, that do identify as
- 1:01:28being on the right is far more potent in North America.
- 1:01:32And it's not something that we have seriously considered in Europe.
- 1:01:37And I think you're absolutely right to actually consider and pursue.
- 1:01:47And with the aspects of the vegan movement, which is climate change and maintaining our
- 1:02:03species, but maybe when it comes to the political right, focusing on maintaining their particular
- 1:02:12society and their particular class of people, people who look like them, speak like them,
- 1:02:20have the same skin colour.
- 1:02:25And yeah, that is a really good, sophisticated ambition, I would say.
- 1:02:34Yeah, fortunately, in Europe, we don't quite have that sort of stretch in our political
- 1:02:43bandwidth.
- 1:02:44The our, certainly English, politically right, my politically right, voting people are not
- 1:02:56as far away from the left as they are in the United States.
- 1:02:59If that makes sense.
- 1:03:02It makes sense, and I agree with you that older people tend to be more conservative.
- 1:03:10But that words me because all of those young people who we're targeting and we want them
- 1:03:17to become vegan, first of all, they don't have purchasing power.
- 1:03:21And then once they grow up, chances are they'll go to become more right wing.
- 1:03:30That's what we see in terms of studies that have been done on the topic.
- 1:03:35Once you start paying your taxes and look at the role of the government, and I guess
- 1:03:42psychologically, you become more and more attracted to the right to conservatism.
- 1:03:50So there is a big problem there.
- 1:03:53I mean, we should also be present in that stage of their lives.
- 1:03:58Yeah, you're absolutely right.
- 1:04:01It's not something that I can, I've considered as someone from the UK and Western Europe.
- 1:04:08There is a, well, I mean, I think France has just voted in or there is a rise on the right
- 1:04:15in France and there certainly is in countries more East like Hungary.
- 1:04:24But no, you're absolutely right.
- 1:04:28And I think that is an important initiative for the vegan movement to pursue.
- 1:04:37Yeah, it's not something that I've particularly considered because of the kind of relatively
- 1:04:46smaller bandwidth.
- 1:04:52Maybe that's not the right terminology, but the political spectrum, I should say.
- 1:04:58And so it isn't as a significant issue here.
- 1:05:06But no, these things should be pursued.
- 1:05:11And yeah, this is, yeah, I mean, arguably, this is more important than the discussion
- 1:05:20in the UK because the North America is larger with a much greater population.
- 1:05:26Yeah, it's a really, really good point.
- 1:05:30The origin of my book was with my background in philosophy and theology.
- 1:05:39It's not so much with politics.
- 1:05:42And so yeah, I may have to leave that to someone else to pursue because it's very difficult
- 1:05:50for us all to advance the moral consideration of non-human animals in all directions simultaneously.
- 1:06:03So we're back.
- 1:06:05We had to stop the recording and start again.
- 1:06:10This time, I think one day has passed since we stopped.
- 1:06:18That's the wonders of podcasting.
- 1:06:20You always have some unforeseen circumstances that lead you to do things.
- 1:06:28But yeah, that's also the magic of editing.
- 1:06:33You don't have to listen to an entire day of silence before getting to this.
- 1:06:41OK, so Joel, before we end this conversation, I have two punchy questions for you.
- 1:06:49Here's the first one.
- 1:06:55We talked about the philosophy of left versus right and how there is this place for veganism
- 1:07:03wherever we go on the political spectrum.
- 1:07:07That's one thing.
- 1:07:09But then when we think about the politicians and the political parties, I see lots of vegans
- 1:07:16who again tend to be liberal or on the left find that leftist parties and leftist politicians
- 1:07:30are more on their side.
- 1:07:33And that is something I haven't seen, maybe on the margins.
- 1:07:38But I feel like every political party and every politician, wherever they are on the
- 1:07:45political spectrum, are speciesist and are against animal liberation and are alien to
- 1:07:53veganism.
- 1:07:54And let me give you a quick example from American politics again.
- 1:07:59So recently, you know, Kamala Harris has, you know, true, chose a new VP.
- 1:08:08I think his name is Tim Walz.
- 1:08:11And interesting how Tim Walz, this person considered a radical left by the right, is
- 1:08:21a hunter.
- 1:08:23He's a weapon carrying hunter.
- 1:08:26And in a time honored Minnesota tradition of deer hunting, Governor Tim Walz teamed
- 1:08:31up with hunters from across the state, officially launching the gun deer hunting season.
- 1:08:35I grew up hunting.
- 1:08:36I said I'm a big pheasant hunter was my thing.
- 1:08:38But we hunted deer and things growing up.
- 1:08:40And picking this up as the governor in this was just incredible.
- 1:08:44My host, Jim Vots, had me out in one of the most beautiful piece of property you could
- 1:08:48see.
- 1:08:49We watched deer for an hour and a half.
- 1:08:51Turkeys passed up a shot on a doe waiting for the big deer, the big buck.
- 1:08:55But that's the way it goes.
- 1:08:56And then they revealed they published the first Tim Walz ad, I think on TikTok.
- 1:09:06And what do you see?
- 1:09:07I think in the second or third picture frame of the video they released of him promoting
- 1:09:15him.
- 1:09:16You see him feeding milk to a poor calf in a dairy farm.
- 1:09:26Governor Walz visited a dairy farm in Lesour to highlight the state's work on agriculture.
- 1:09:30Earlier this year, the governor signed an agriculture bill that provided new support
- 1:09:34for the ag industry, includes new investments for dairy farms, grain and livestock producers,
- 1:09:39broadband, farm safety and emerging farmers.
- 1:09:42Twenty, thirty years ago, the price of milk was still the same.
- 1:09:45So that tractor cost a heck of a lot less than it costs today.
- 1:09:49Diesel fuel is 80 cents.
- 1:09:50Not what it was.
- 1:09:51The agriculture and broadband bill provides four million dollars for the Dairy Assistance
- 1:09:55Investment Relief Initiative, along with 10 million dollars to establish the state's first
- 1:09:59grain indemnity fund.
- 1:10:01So there you have it.
- 1:10:04That's the typical leftist politician.
- 1:10:10That's how sympathetic they are to the vegan cause, in my opinion.
- 1:10:14That is a great illustration of it.
- 1:10:17And then you have the political activists who love to preach about compassion and inclusivity
- 1:10:27and how we should be mindful of the environment.
- 1:10:35And then they stuff their mouth with steak and dairy and that hypocrisy is just it angers
- 1:10:45me.
- 1:10:46It angers me so much.
- 1:10:47It's so shocking because at least the right will proudly talk about hunting and all of
- 1:10:53that.
- 1:10:54But then the left has this opposite discourse versus their actions.
- 1:10:59So I'll let you first comment on that because I know you've and I encourage people to visit
- 1:11:07your social media.
- 1:11:08You post a lot about that hypocrisy.
- 1:11:13I mean, I would say that politicians are they just reflect and they themselves are part
- 1:11:22of society.
- 1:11:26They are human beings, too, despite some of that strange behavior.
- 1:11:36And we talk about one of the pioneers of the animal rights movement.
- 1:11:45Peter Singer wrote a book entitled The Moral Circle or he would refer to our expanding
- 1:11:54moral circle, beginning with the rights of women, people of color, different sexualities.
- 1:12:06Sorry about that.
- 1:12:09Turn that off.
- 1:12:13And yeah, it's now we now see it seriously for the first time, spreading to the moral
- 1:12:21consideration of other species.
- 1:12:23And I think it will it may just take a few more generations to impact the political class.
- 1:12:39So as we were talking about before we started recording that the you know, we've got we've
- 1:12:48got to come from somewhere and there is always progression and advancement.
- 1:12:55That's what we see throughout history.
- 1:12:58And so, yeah, I have great faith that in future decades to come, we will have politicians
- 1:13:08who who will be who will identify as vegetarian and vegan.
- 1:13:13And a quick follow up question, do you think it is even possible for politicians because
- 1:13:20we talk of them as our representative, but can they even and I'm getting philosophical
- 1:13:26here in your lane, is it even possible for them to embody the interests of millions of
- 1:13:35voters and of nuanced and complex philosophies?
- 1:13:43And we talked about how relative the left and right was.
- 1:13:48So you know, what do you think of that?
- 1:13:54I think it's just a case of education and putting investment into education to seriously
- 1:14:05adhere to a commitment to raise the level of awareness amongst the majority of people.
- 1:14:17I think that we have you can compare the consideration of animals to other rights that we see within
- 1:14:32humanity.
- 1:14:35We don't despair and worry that we are going to that we're going to just walk around or
- 1:14:51we don't kill each other.
- 1:14:53We've put in place some legality surrounding the murder of other human beings.
- 1:15:02So and that's we now take that for granted.
- 1:15:06Of course, it does happen, but it's not acceptable to kill someone on the high street because
- 1:15:14they've bumped into you.
- 1:15:17And so it's just a case of shifting the dial a little bit further along.
- 1:15:23And we have done that.
- 1:15:26And yeah, I just I see that as something that is in a way kind of inevitable, I think.
- 1:15:38I love your optimism.
- 1:15:40I hope your vibe.
- 1:15:42Okay, as a last question, Joel, and again, thank you for your time.
- 1:15:51What made you want to write this book?
- 1:15:55And I'm saying that with the understanding of how from having talked to other writers,
- 1:16:06it's such a big commitment of time, of efforts of brainpower.
- 1:16:12So why why did you decide to write this book?
- 1:16:17So I studied philosophy aspects of theology and cosmology.
- 1:16:28And I worked with a theologian and cosmologist.
- 1:16:33And it was 20 years later or so after realizing what we do to animals, that the consideration
- 1:16:45of animals was not once mentioned by my by the theologian I worked with, who happens
- 1:16:54to be a wonderful, kind and caring man.
- 1:17:00And I just considered that a catastrophic moral oversight.
- 1:17:09And so I decided that this needs to be rectified, corrected.
- 1:17:15I see what I'm doing as comparable to the moral consideration of women and the gay community
- 1:17:26with the church's view of same sex marriage.
- 1:17:31In other words, they've incorporated these things to a certain degree.
- 1:17:35And I want for the church to for them to incorporate the moral consideration of other life on earth.
- 1:17:48And what keeps me going is that I just cannot bear the witnessing, violence, cruelty and
- 1:17:57suffering.
- 1:17:58And I just astounded when I hear people suggest that there's anything other than other anything
- 1:18:08other more, anything more important than trying to alleviate the suffering of others in the
- 1:18:14world.
- 1:18:17It just seems so obvious to me.
- 1:18:19It might I may be fortunate if I can say it like this in the I kind of experienced bits
- 1:18:27of anxiety myself in the past and having that first hand experience.
- 1:18:37It gave me an insight into the experience of suffering to some degree.
- 1:18:43And when you are experiencing that, it's the most terrible thing, but it's the most important
- 1:18:49thing.
- 1:18:53And so I just have this innate commitment to alleviate these things for others, because
- 1:19:03I wouldn't want to be in that situation myself.
- 1:19:06And so, yeah, if I can help correct this, then I'm going to because I don't know of
- 1:19:14anything else that's more important with the finite time we have on earth.
- 1:19:21I want you to comment on something that came to my newsfeed.
- 1:19:30And that is what happened to Robert Sheik.
- 1:19:33I don't know if you're familiar.
- 1:19:36He wrote a book called The Impactful Vegan.
- 1:19:40And I welcomed him on the show, you know, a couple of times.
- 1:19:47And I read the book.
- 1:19:49It's a great book and I encourage people to get the book.
- 1:19:56And then later on, he wrote a newsletter in which he describes how he was not able to
- 1:20:06yes, he was able to publish the book, but he was not able to sell the book.
- 1:20:12And that made him incredibly depressed and he wrote a whole newsletter.
- 1:20:19He has a personal newsletter about this.
- 1:20:24It's heartbreaking.
- 1:20:25Let me read just a few lines.
- 1:20:27You know, he says, I didn't have a plan B. I went all in on the best book I have ever
- 1:20:33written hoping that it would resonate with readers, have a strong performance and help
- 1:20:38take my writing career in a positive direction.
- 1:20:42I gave it everything I had.
- 1:20:43I bet on myself and I was wrong.
- 1:20:48And he goes on and on on the just depressing, just realization of that.
- 1:20:58And then I thought maybe it's just because we're talking to a niche of readership.
- 1:21:06Maybe his expectations were just too great.
- 1:21:09You know, how many people are vegans?
- 1:21:11And then how many people who are vegans are interested in doing activism?
- 1:21:16And then then you go down the.
- 1:21:20Yeah.
- 1:21:22And I was thinking, you know, what would you say to Robert Sheik and how would you react
- 1:21:29to what happened to him?
- 1:21:31Yeah, I mean, I completely sympathize.
- 1:21:35And with that experience, it's absolutely awful to end up in that.
- 1:21:43Not that it's not a realization, but feelings that you're in that temporary space that the
- 1:21:48world and other the majority of people aren't listening.
- 1:21:54I mean, there is something to be said that, you know, the phrase being ahead of your time
- 1:22:02comes to mind.
- 1:22:04I mean, that literally.
- 1:22:06Maybe maybe the case.
- 1:22:10What I would say is that and something that I I talk about online and is part of my book
- 1:22:19is that with any rights movement, as we've seen in history, they are rights activists
- 1:22:29are demonized.
- 1:22:32Veganism is methodically distributed out in order to keep them at the periphery, in order
- 1:22:38to maintain status quo.
- 1:22:43And this is happening.
- 1:22:44This happens with the vegan movement.
- 1:22:49So much so that the negative connotations which are conjured in the minds of people
- 1:22:59who eat animals arrives with the just the word vegan alone, which is why I don't I rarely
- 1:23:09use that word.
- 1:23:10And I rarely use that word because I feel that I'm using the language of people who
- 1:23:18eat animals.
- 1:23:20I feel that it's a it's a box that we are encouraged to climb into and we are moved
- 1:23:29to the periphery of the discussion.
- 1:23:34I'm in the future.
- 1:23:37People won't use the word vegan in the same way that there is no word for not racist or
- 1:23:45not homophobic.
- 1:23:46It would be strange to introduce to someone at policy your friend and say, oh, this is
- 1:23:53my friend.
- 1:23:54He's not homophobic.
- 1:23:57If someone said that, you'd think, well, OK, well, I didn't think that they were.
- 1:24:02And that's because the majority of people are not homophobic to a certain degree.
- 1:24:07And it depends on where you are in the in the world and in the country.
- 1:24:11But fortunately, there are lots of spaces where it's unacceptable.
- 1:24:18And so I want to represent and I want to occupy the normal, compassionate, rational middle
- 1:24:27ground.
- 1:24:28I'm not a vegan.
- 1:24:30I don't eat vegan food.
- 1:24:33I'm a normal, compassionate person that eats food.
- 1:24:37And it is you that eats and pays for animals to be killed.
- 1:24:45I want to occupy the normal middle ground.
- 1:24:49And so the reason I mentioned that is that with my book is that I'm trying to not talk
- 1:24:57about vegans and veganism or even animals as such.
- 1:25:03I'm talking about violence, violence or moral exclusion and oppression and then subsequent
- 1:25:11violence.
- 1:25:12And this is violence towards the gay community, trans community, women, people of color and
- 1:25:17animals.
- 1:25:18And if I can encourage Robert to connect all these things together to because I feel that
- 1:25:26that will have the best he will have the best chance in communicating the message by by
- 1:25:32talking specifically about animals.
- 1:25:36People switch off.
- 1:25:37Yeah, so that's my my response, I think.
- 1:25:45Amazing.
- 1:25:46That's an yeah, I never thought about it this way.
- 1:25:52I'm glad I asked this question.
- 1:25:57So Joel, I don't want to take more of your time.
- 1:26:03Did you have anything to add before we stop the recording?
- 1:26:06No, not really.
- 1:26:07I just wanted to thank you, Ryan, for the opportunity inviting me on the show.
- 1:26:12And yeah, it's just been an absolute pleasure talking to you.
- 1:26:16And I've learned a lot, particularly about what's happening in North America, it's things
- 1:26:21that I haven't considered myself.
- 1:26:23So I just wanted to thank you, and I'm just so impressed with the podcast that you have
- 1:26:30and if I can support it in any way I can, I'd love to.
- 1:26:36Thank you so much, Joel.
- 1:26:38This was truly, truly a pleasure.
- 1:26:41Like I said, you know, before I was looking forward to this conversation, and I had the
- 1:26:47great privilege of reading already some of the chapters you wrote.
- 1:26:54And I am just excited for people to discover this book, to just get stimulated by the nuggets
- 1:27:03of wisdom that are there.
- 1:27:07So looking forward to the book getting published.
- 1:27:11Yeah, thank you.
- 1:27:14Thank you so much, Joel.
- 1:27:15Thanks, Ryan.
- 1:27:16Thank you.
- 1:27:17Thank you, everyone, for listening.
- 1:27:20I kindly invite you to share this podcast with the vegans you know.
- 1:27:24Let's encourage more people to take action.
- 1:27:27Again, thank you so much for caring, and I will see you next Tuesday for a new episode.