Latest / International Flavor: Where the Truth Tastes Better / Brest to Grozny: History, Music, and the Unfinished Divorce of the Post-Soviet World Across Belarus, Georgia, Chechnya, and Russia
Transcript
- 0:00Hello, how's the family?
- 0:01I am Samuel Trapp.
- 0:02This is International Flavor.
- 0:04We're coming to you live from damradio.com
- 0:07forward slash live.
- 0:08You can listen to all the past shows
- 0:10by going to internationalflavor.com or should you
- 0:15feel the urge, you can go out to
- 0:16damradio.com forward slash podcast and listen to
- 0:21not only my wonderful international flavor show that
- 0:25comes to you every morning from 7 30
- 0:27to 9 a.m. Monday through Thursday, but
- 0:30you can also listen to the additional show
- 0:34offerings like on Fridays, I do civic outlaws
- 0:37and that is a more of a civil
- 0:45and civic actions and interesting legal themes that
- 0:49need to take place.
- 0:51I run a, I run a an organization
- 0:53called the modern law ecosystem.
- 0:58And it is, uh, it's progressing quite well.
- 1:02I'm, I'm feeling pretty good about it.
- 1:04I like it a lot.
- 1:05And so we do research for law firms.
- 1:07We do stuff like that.
- 1:08And then I'm also, uh, one of the,
- 1:11uh, uh, uh, founding members of civic outlaws
- 1:14and MOLAG Missouri licensing, um, advocacy group where
- 1:21we talk about Missouri licensing and, uh, it's
- 1:25a, uh, that's a five Oh one C
- 1:27six.
- 1:28Civic outlaws five Oh one C three.
- 1:30And so we're growing and we're looking for,
- 1:32uh, people to join in the effort, uh,
- 1:35and in all of those things, sorry to
- 1:37do some personal advertising, but it's my damn
- 1:39show.
- 1:40So there you have it.
- 1:41I wanted to talk a little bit about
- 1:43his story and history and memory and stuff
- 1:47like that because, um, and I, and it's
- 1:50kind of, I travel a lot and I
- 1:54was, I was, I tried to get a
- 1:56new Russian visa and, uh, I sent off
- 1:59my passport, uh, which you have to do.
- 2:02And it goes to the Russian consulate.
- 2:04I've gone twice to the Russian consulate one
- 2:06in Washington, DC.
- 2:08Now, I was there years and years ago.
- 2:10I used to drop off all the Russians
- 2:11over there.
- 2:12That's where they would get their support.
- 2:13So when I worked at, uh, uh, onsite
- 2:16inspection agency, pretty funny.
- 2:19I'd have like a 15 passenger van full
- 2:22of Russians and I'd drive them all over
- 2:23the place, wherever they wanted to go.
- 2:25And all I was was a glorified chauffeur.
- 2:28You're a chauffeur.
- 2:29Now show is chauffeur noun.
- 2:32We wonder anyway.
- 2:33Um, the fact is, is that, uh, I've
- 2:36been to the Russian, uh, consulate, uh, years
- 2:39ago and it hasn't changed a whole lot.
- 2:42And, uh, I went there, uh, 2021.
- 2:46Oh, you know what?
- 2:46It was during COVID.
- 2:47I went there in 2020 and I went
- 2:49to the Russian consulate and the frigging capital
- 2:52building in, in the Supreme court, we're all
- 2:56chained off with a razor wire fence on
- 3:00the top with military guards standing there, frigging
- 3:03nonsense.
- 3:04And the whole mall area where I had
- 3:06lived, basically, I like to run around there.
- 3:10Um, you know, if you watch, uh, captain
- 3:13America, they show him running around that, that
- 3:16space.
- 3:16That was a popular space to go.
- 3:18If you were stationed at, um, uh, Fort
- 3:22Belvoir, I think it is, is where all
- 3:24the generals houses are in the, in the
- 3:26Arlington national cemetery.
- 3:28And I worked on Fort Belvoir for a
- 3:31period, about six, eight months.
- 3:32And, um, it was a pretty cool little
- 3:34program.
- 3:34And I would go there in the morning
- 3:36at, and at six o'clock, I would
- 3:38do a run around the mall, just like
- 3:41those other people.
- 3:41I don't know why I'm telling these stories
- 3:43kind of a history story today.
- 3:44And you would run around there.
- 3:46And, uh, that was, that was, uh, uh,
- 3:48um, a beautiful way to start the day
- 3:52is running on the mall and you go
- 3:54down there and the, and the, the mall
- 3:56is in 2020.
- 3:57Anyway, it was covered with razor wire and
- 4:00nobody was there and it was frigging empty,
- 4:02you know, and you remember that place like
- 4:05from when a Forrest Gump was standing in
- 4:07front of the, uh, the Lincoln Memorial on
- 4:10the, on the one end, or was it
- 4:12to Washington Memorial?
- 4:13He was, no, he was standing in front
- 4:14of the Lincoln Memorial and, uh, uh, you
- 4:17know, where they had that big stage where
- 4:19a Forrest, Forrest Gump was, uh, given his,
- 4:22uh, speech.
- 4:23And that's all I have to say about
- 4:25the war in Vietnam, you know, and then
- 4:28he met his little girlfriend.
- 4:29Anyway, I don't know why I'm quoting movies
- 4:30and crap like that, but I wanted to
- 4:32talk about history and I wanted to talk
- 4:34about travel.
- 4:35And I wanted to talk about all of
- 4:37the things when you go to the consulate
- 4:39and, uh, the consulate has not changed.
- 4:41And it was, uh, um, you drop off
- 4:43your passport there.
- 4:45You get an interview by a Russian guy
- 4:48down there.
- 4:48That was kind of cool.
- 4:49And, um, you go through that entire process
- 4:52and they give you a visa.
- 4:53They mail it back to you a couple
- 4:56of weeks later.
- 4:57And then another time I went to the
- 4:59Houston consulate to get a Russian, um, uh,
- 5:04visa as well.
- 5:05And then the last time I, which was
- 5:09several years ago, 2023 it had to be
- 5:13because I had a three year visa.
- 5:14I went through a process where you do
- 5:18the interview, you do the paperwork and you
- 5:20give it to a facilitator and you pay
- 5:24that facilitator to take your passport through the
- 5:28process and they mail it off.
- 5:30Well, I did that.
- 5:31My passport or my visa, I mean expired
- 5:33in February.
- 5:35And so my visa to Russia expired in
- 5:38February and I still have plenty to go
- 5:41see and do in Russia.
- 5:42So I want another three year visa because
- 5:45every other one had only been granted to
- 5:47me for one year.
- 5:48So you got to get all the paperwork
- 5:49right.
- 5:50You got to have everything just so, or
- 5:52you won't get the visa that you want
- 5:54to get.
- 5:54And anybody who's been through this process, going
- 5:56to a country that isn't on, uh, uh,
- 6:00when it's not, uh, a friendly country, when
- 6:07you're not friendly, you know, these, uh, friends
- 6:10of Russia, well, you got a problem and
- 6:13the same is in reverse for them.
- 6:15This is what they go through to try
- 6:16to get to the United States and it's
- 6:18difficult for them.
- 6:20And so it's not as difficult anymore because
- 6:24I've had one, but before I had a
- 6:25diplomatic passport and my diplomatic passport, I had
- 6:28a diplomatic visa and they, they cocked that
- 6:31up one time for me and I went
- 6:33to Russia without a visa.
- 6:34That's a story in and of itself, which
- 6:36I won't share again here.
- 6:37But, uh, I could tell some stories about
- 6:40that.
- 6:41Anyway, the, the process of getting your visa.
- 6:46I sent my, my passport away several weeks
- 6:50ago, a month or two ago, two months
- 6:52ago, I sent it away in March because
- 6:55I have some travel plans for, uh, uh,
- 6:58this summer to go to Russia.
- 6:59And I certainly want to be there for
- 7:01new years in, um, St. Petersburg is where
- 7:06I want to go to spend Christmas.
- 7:07I want to go see the new year
- 7:10in St. Petersburg, something I've always wanted to
- 7:13do.
- 7:14And, uh, at any rate, the process of
- 7:19getting a visa, I mailed it away.
- 7:21They mailed it back and my passport had
- 7:24no empty pages to, to stamp the Russians.
- 7:29They put a full page sticker in your
- 7:31passport every time you get a visa.
- 7:33And I've got three of those, however many
- 7:35pages your passport has.
- 7:36It's like 30 pages or whatever.
- 7:38And I never thought about it, but you
- 7:40know, you just go through and people stamp
- 7:42it in.
- 7:42Mine is completely full.
- 7:44And so I sent it in.
- 7:46I just figured they'd cover it up.
- 7:47And now somebody told me you could add
- 7:49more pages or whatever, but I I've never
- 7:51done that.
- 7:52And I thought I still had a couple
- 7:53of pages left.
- 7:54It's not something you really pay attention to
- 7:56when you travel and get stamps as much
- 7:57as I have.
- 7:58And so, uh, I sent it off and
- 8:02it came back.
- 8:04The lady had to send it back.
- 8:06She sent it in to the Russian consulate
- 8:08and the consulate sent it back.
- 8:10I still have three years left on my,
- 8:11on my passport.
- 8:13Right.
- 8:13And they say, you can, you know, here's
- 8:15your passport, you know, here, she mailed the
- 8:17passport back and said, you know, everything is
- 8:20correct in here.
- 8:20Everything looks good, but there's no space to
- 8:23put your sticker, your visa without, uh, now
- 8:27sometimes you go to countries and they give
- 8:28you a paper visa and they put it
- 8:30in there and you got to carry it
- 8:31with your passport at the same time.
- 8:34If you go to, you know, another country,
- 8:36that's not totally friendly with you that has
- 8:39visa requirements for the U S and most
- 8:42countries, you don't have to do that, but
- 8:44there are some like you have to, I
- 8:46hear that in China, uh, now I had,
- 8:48you have to get one in Turkey on
- 8:50and off.
- 8:50And so I had to get one in
- 8:51Turkey, but in Turkey they give you a
- 8:53paper, you fold it up and you take
- 8:54it with you and you apply online two
- 8:56weeks before and you get a, you pay
- 8:5875 bucks and you get a visa.
- 9:00Right.
- 9:01And, uh, uh, so a lot of countries
- 9:03were like that, but Turkey is on again,
- 9:06off again.
- 9:07Sometimes you need a visa.
- 9:08Sometimes you don't.
- 9:09The last several times I've gone to Turkey,
- 9:11you don't need a visa.
- 9:12You just get a stamp when you come
- 9:13in.
- 9:13If you go to Qatar or somewhere, they
- 9:16just stamp your visa, read your eyeballs, you
- 9:18know, and check you out and keep you
- 9:20in the database and move on down the
- 9:23line.
- 9:23It's pretty smooth and decent process.
- 9:25Some places are not.
- 9:26When I went to Sri Lanka, uh, many
- 9:28years ago, had not many, 10 years ago,
- 9:30I had to get, uh, you know, something
- 9:32there.
- 9:32Anyway, um, getting the visa, they sent my
- 9:36passport back and I was like, well, crap.
- 9:38Now what?
- 9:39Get a new passport.
- 9:41So I signed up and, uh, uh, went
- 9:45to get a new passport.
- 9:49And so now, and you can order a
- 9:51big fat passport.
- 9:52No, you know, and so I ordered a
- 9:54big fat passport.
- 9:55So now I have a new passport.
- 9:57I got to send it away again to
- 9:58get some of this stuff.
- 9:59And then, so some of the troubles that
- 10:01you get and what I really wanted to
- 10:03get to was, uh, some history today and
- 10:06why history is so important.
- 10:08And I started out from the point of
- 10:10view of, uh, so I started my international
- 10:13flavor show in Russian in, um, uh, it
- 10:18had to be 2024.
- 10:20Four.
- 10:22When did, uh, maybe it might've been 2023.
- 10:26Um, we're going to find out for sure
- 10:30by asking a question to the computer.
- 10:39And I am asking when, what, when it
- 10:43was, it was a February and, uh, Tucker
- 10:47Carlson.
- 10:48Yep.
- 10:48I was right.
- 10:49It was February the 6th of 2024, two
- 10:54years after the start of the war in
- 10:56Ukraine.
- 10:57Now we're going to get to the meat
- 10:58of what I wanted to talk about without
- 11:01Sam stupid stories in the beginning and cocking
- 11:04up the entrance into his show.
- 11:06So when we're, and I got some music
- 11:07for you and I'm going to play some
- 11:09music just because I have a lot of
- 11:10songs that I liked that I wanted to
- 11:12play.
- 11:12And I can't find Lubitschka and I got
- 11:15to find Lubitschka, uh, because that's a good
- 11:17song.
- 11:17And, uh, anyway, Tucker Carlson interviewed, uh, president
- 11:21Vladimir Vladimirovich Putin in Moscow on February 6th
- 11:25of 2024.
- 11:25And it was released on February 8th of
- 11:282024.
- 11:28Well after that interview took place is when
- 11:31I started my international flavor show in Russian,
- 11:35not a Ruscom yes he kept and I
- 11:37did it in Russian.
- 11:38And I talked about how Tucker Carlson interviewed
- 11:42Vladimir Putin and what I believed he missed
- 11:45and opportunities and, and, and, and I, you
- 11:49know, I understand, I get it.
- 11:50It's a, you know, I don't know what
- 11:52I would do in the same situation.
- 11:53And Tucker's a professional journalist.
- 11:55I'm just some hack with a, with a
- 11:58radio show.
- 11:58Right.
- 11:59And Tucker's a good guy.
- 12:02Quick coffee sip there.
- 12:04And, uh, uh, at any rate, I, I
- 12:08didn't criticize, I think, but I thought he
- 12:10missed something.
- 12:10It was an awesome interview and he did
- 12:12very, very well, but he missed some things
- 12:13cause he doesn't speak Russian and he missed
- 12:16a couple of points and somebody is whispering
- 12:18in his ear and translating it for him
- 12:21on the fly.
- 12:22And that's the trouble with doing things in
- 12:24different languages.
- 12:25You don't get the absolute translation or you're
- 12:28so busy worrying about the translation.
- 12:30You don't necessarily get what the person is
- 12:33saying.
- 12:34And Vladimir Putin spent a lot of time
- 12:37in the first 20, 30 minutes of this
- 12:39hour plus hour and a half plus, I
- 12:41think interview and he spent a good 15
- 12:45to 20 minutes talking about history.
- 12:48And he was talking about the two years
- 12:50into the, to the war in Ukraine and
- 12:53well, many, it's actually 10 years into the
- 12:56war in Ukraine cause it really started in
- 12:582014 when the Ukrainians were slaughtering Russians on
- 13:02the other side in the Donbass and nobody
- 13:04in the West paid any attention to that.
- 13:06And they didn't pay any pay any attention
- 13:08to the farce of the Minsk Accords and
- 13:11the, the, uh, the, uh, uh, what do
- 13:15you, what do you call it?
- 13:16Budapest agreements and all of that.
- 13:19All was wiped out by, by us funding
- 13:22and supporting Ukraine in an effort to take
- 13:26Russia.
- 13:26Okay.
- 13:27Now my point is that these things have
- 13:30gone along forever before there was Russia, before
- 13:35there was a Ukraine, before there was Poland,
- 13:39Lithuania, Belarus, Georgia, Chechnya, Azerbaijan, uh, Armenia, all
- 13:46of these places that I talk about it.
- 13:49The fact is the human struggle for land,
- 13:55food, shelter, water, survival goes back and back
- 14:00in bath.
- 14:00And, and, and I am a, I don't
- 14:04know how to say it.
- 14:06A citizen of world history.
- 14:08I suppose you would say before I am
- 14:11a politic, uh, a political, uh, hack or,
- 14:16or reviewer of what's going on politically because
- 14:20history is what bases it all and makes
- 14:23it all so damned interesting of where we
- 14:28go.
- 14:28And so when we talk about this region
- 14:31as if it began with NATO or with
- 14:35Putin or with the Green Goblin or with
- 14:38Khrushchev or with Lukashenko or with anybody else
- 14:42in the area, we're already committing intellectual malpractice
- 14:47because it's not correct to attack it in
- 14:52that way.
- 14:53And so sometimes you feel like the Lone
- 14:55Ranger when you're talking about this stuff and
- 14:58people don't get it.
- 14:59People only care about what's happening today.
- 15:02But deep back in time we have the
- 15:04history of the Bashkortostan and the human memory
- 15:08of the step.
- 15:09That place was called the step, the vast
- 15:12plains.
- 15:12These areas were overrun by the Turkish hordes,
- 15:17by the Mongols, by, by, by Russian, uh,
- 15:20from the North, by, by Polish and Lithuanian
- 15:23forces from the Northwest.
- 15:25And it's been overrun for forever.
- 15:31From the earliest days of humanity, these places
- 15:35have been run over and you feel like
- 15:38the Lone Ranger when you say that.
- 15:40So I have some music choices for you
- 15:42and I hope you enjoy at the beginning
- 15:44of this, I'm going to play for you.
- 15:47Um, this is called, uh, and I have
- 15:50a couple of songs like these and they're
- 15:52great songs, but they're just, they're foolish and
- 15:55they're a foolish look into how Sam thinks,
- 15:58which could be a problem in and of
- 16:00itself.
- 16:00But we're going to play Mr. Lonely by
- 16:04a guy named Frankie B when we get
- 16:09into it.
- 16:10And this is a, it's a somewhat, Oh,
- 16:13it's a pretty long song, but we're going
- 16:14to go ahead and play it.
- 16:16And then we'll get to the meat and
- 16:18we're going to talk about the history and
- 16:19breast and where Vladimir Putin was going and
- 16:22why it was important and why people have
- 16:24ignored it all the way back then and
- 16:27are still ignoring the culture of it all
- 16:30right now, all over Europe, all over the
- 16:33West.
- 16:34I mean you could put this same function
- 16:36into Iran because Iran is the same connection
- 16:40that is connected to Azerbaijan, Armenia, uh, you
- 16:44know, on the, on into the Turkish areas,
- 16:47into Syria, all of those places over there.
- 16:50This is massively important and people don't understand
- 16:53it.
- 16:53And I feel very lonely when I talk
- 16:55about it.
- 16:56So I'm going to play Mr. Lonely for
- 16:58you.
- 20:40Oh yes.
- 20:42That's Mr. Lonely.
- 20:44And uh, well that sometimes is, sometimes it's
- 20:47about me.
- 20:48I feel like the lone freaking ranger.
- 20:50sometimes and talking about some of this stuff
- 20:54because people don't understand how important history is
- 20:58to you and we're gonna tie in another
- 21:01kind of techno-ish song as well later
- 21:04on and that'll be a little bit of
- 21:06fun too I just like sometimes and then
- 21:08I got a couple of Ruski as well
- 21:10you heard the German in there the guy
- 21:12talking about you know you're you're you're you're
- 21:15not the only lonely I'm also lonely and
- 21:18he started talking about is lonely and how
- 21:21he has no body for my own and
- 21:24so mental madness is what what we're talking
- 21:28about here but the working theme of my
- 21:30show is from you know talking about all
- 21:34the way from breast to the Caucasus all
- 21:36the southern the southern border of Russia where
- 21:39all the stands are where Georgia is I've
- 21:42told you some of these I don't want
- 21:45to just make it a travel diary because
- 21:48you know for some of the places that
- 21:49I went but I but I want to
- 21:51connect what I have discovered and what people
- 21:55need to discover in order to understand what's
- 21:58going on about connecting Eastern Europe Belarus Russia
- 22:04Georgia northern Ossetia Chechnya think about this Latvia
- 22:11Lithuania Estonia all of those can go in
- 22:16there as well and it you need to
- 22:23understand it when you can get there I'm
- 22:26gonna talk about breast first which is in
- 22:33Belarus no no think about this breast is
- 22:37one of the oldest cities in Belarus and
- 22:41it was first mentioned in a thousand nineteen
- 22:44as better Estia and its geography explains everything
- 22:50about its history it sits in the southwestern
- 22:53Belarus near the Polish border at the meeting
- 22:56of the Western boog and the Mukha Viet's
- 22:58rivers that location made it a trading point
- 23:02a military point a religious point and very
- 23:04political it was never just a city it
- 23:08is a hinge between different worlds Britannica summarizes
- 23:13this core history breast passed to Lithuania in
- 23:171319 later to Poland then to Russia in
- 23:221795 returned to Poland from 1919 to 1939
- 23:27and became part of Soviet Belarus after World
- 23:31War two the deeper point is that breast
- 23:35shows how artificial modern national borders and territories
- 23:41become when you're studying actual history of specially
- 23:46of Eastern Europe and anywhere connected to the
- 23:51complicated history a history of Russia this city
- 23:55breast has been connected to Kievan Rus the
- 23:59Poles the Grand Duchy of Lithuania the Polish
- 24:03Lithuanian Commonwealth the Russian Empire interwar Poland the
- 24:08Soviet Union and now Belarus you know Poland
- 24:12in Lithuania influence is huge in that area
- 24:15and you know you can't say it was
- 24:18Polish the Polish of course want to claim
- 24:20it's theirs it's been there's because they had
- 24:23it when 1919 to 1939 and the Soviets
- 24:27took it after that it became part of
- 24:29part of Soviet Belarus after World War two
- 24:32and so and then became part of stayed
- 24:34part of Belarus when the collapses Soviet Union
- 24:37these are just borders these are just political
- 24:41influences but the place has never changed it's
- 24:44the same people living there just different people
- 24:47controlling it and I'm telling you the that
- 24:50place you felt the history I didn't want
- 24:53to leave that place I swear to God
- 24:55it took it took three hours to get
- 24:58there two and a half to get there
- 25:01on a on a bus a great big
- 25:02bus from where was I oh I was
- 25:06in breast not breast Minsk I was in
- 25:09Minsk and we took the bus to to
- 25:12breast and spent the entire day on this
- 25:16little fortress island in between there talking about
- 25:18the history going back over some of the
- 25:20cool fortress that is built around there some
- 25:23of the best Soviet monuments that I have
- 25:26ever seen are inside that crepus the the
- 25:32fort they were inside of it and it
- 25:35was friggin awesome who toured that place in
- 25:38every room where they had the cells underneath
- 25:41and this was I mean it went back
- 25:43there's a huge church crepus crepus naya I
- 25:49don't know what you would call it the
- 25:50the the place where it's all walled in
- 25:53like a compound I guess it would be
- 25:55and and that in the compound they had
- 25:58all of these places for people to stay
- 26:00and the main protectorate was like the Lord
- 26:03of the land same as they did in
- 26:05England and so the Lord of the land
- 26:07had this big beautiful house church with all
- 26:12the cupolas on it like the top of
- 26:14the Russian churches you see those upside down
- 26:16onions is what I always call them that
- 26:18are on top of their coated with gold
- 26:20or coated with other fine materials or jewels
- 26:23or whatever to show the power of the
- 26:25guy in the region and that place passed
- 26:27back and forth between the Poles Lithuanians to
- 26:30Belarus the Ruskies the Kievan Rus because Ukraine
- 26:35took that place over a couple of times
- 26:37came or people from Ukraine came up and
- 26:40took that place so you can talk about
- 26:42all of these influences and pretend that it
- 26:44was Polish or pretend that it was Russian
- 26:46and Soviet Empire you know pretending that all
- 26:49the earlier history disappeared and this is what
- 26:52makes this place in particular interesting it's layered
- 26:56it's not simple the simple history is to
- 26:59say wow Soviet Union on that and then
- 27:01and then then the Belarus they're they're fans
- 27:04of Russia so they took it over and
- 27:06it's part of that well who knows if
- 27:08they're gonna remain fans of Russia when Lukashenko
- 27:11has gone who knows what's gonna happen and
- 27:14I mean same thing could happen there that's
- 27:18happening in Ukraine and it's nonsense you know
- 27:21even in Ukraine and in the history of
- 27:23Ukraine is even worse because the only time
- 27:26Ukraine existed is anything separate other than the
- 27:29crepus naya an exterior fortress part of Kievan
- 27:35Rus which started in Kiev and then moved
- 27:39to Moscow is before that history but it
- 27:42was all part of the Russian Empire and
- 27:45those guys were not on the edges Ukraine
- 27:48means edge means frontier you I mean it
- 27:51doesn't really but but that's not cry cry
- 27:54who cry is a cry is the edge
- 27:56is the the in and who means next
- 27:59to who cry it is is it's in
- 28:02their freaking word and they were part of
- 28:04the borders the borderlands which stretched all the
- 28:07way through Poland it sometimes and when it
- 28:09was part of the Lithuanian Polish Empire which
- 28:12which was based in Lithuania up in what
- 28:17was the name of that city hell I
- 28:19can't remember but it but it was it
- 28:21was when I went last year to that
- 28:23place I liked I was checking out the
- 28:25history okay and so well think about this
- 28:29breast matters from the religion of the area
- 28:33as well because of the Union of breast
- 28:36which came about in 1596 that agreement United
- 28:41several million Russian Ukrainian Kiev Bruce Bella Russian
- 28:48Orthodox Christians that lived under Polish rule in
- 28:54Lithuania with the Roman Catholic Church and preserved
- 28:58elements of Eastern rights practice with people further
- 29:02east the the people from the religion the
- 29:06more more more Greek and Eastern Russian Orthodox
- 29:09and all of that was tied together in
- 29:12this one big Union of breast in a
- 29:15religious pact that agreement united all of these
- 29:19people to the Orthodox Christians under Polish and
- 29:23Lithuanian rule with the Roman Catholic Church while
- 29:27preserving elements of all the other religions and
- 29:30so this is because the struggle in this
- 29:33region has never been about language or about
- 29:35the army it's about churches it's about loyalty
- 29:38it's about bishops it's about Rome it's about
- 29:41who's which religion is correct among them all
- 29:44the way ordinary people get pulled into grand
- 29:47political religious projects historically it happens everywhere and
- 29:53that area in particular so then comes the
- 29:56breast Litovsk that that name still rings but
- 30:01you know in 1918 the Treaty of Brest
- 30:04Litovsk was signed in breast and the Central
- 30:07Powers signed one treaty with the Ukrainian Republic
- 30:11well Russian Ukrainian Republic on February 9 of
- 30:141918 and another with Soviet Russia on March
- 30:17the 3rd of 1918 ending the hostilities in
- 30:21the Eastern Front in World War one same
- 30:25old crap going on in World War one
- 30:27the Russian side accepted the harsh terms because
- 30:31of the new Bolshevik government that went into
- 30:33place in 2017 that they needed to get
- 30:38out of the war so breast wasn't just
- 30:40a city where history happened it was a
- 30:42city where empires clashed historically forever and you
- 30:47know the breast fortress the crepus is that's
- 30:51the emotional center of all of it that
- 30:55place was unassailable would be the best word
- 31:00because it's basically on an island it's surrounded
- 31:04by river right and not not a big
- 31:06island but you got to get a bridge
- 31:08to come across you can't just wander across
- 31:10a low-lying patch of water you got
- 31:13to get there and that's where all the
- 31:15power was housed and so it was very
- 31:17hard to to get in there and so
- 31:20the fortress was built in the 1830s and
- 31:251840s and it was the meeting point of
- 31:29the of the Boog and the Mukhavets rivers
- 31:32and during construction the town was relocated to
- 31:35about two kilometers away the fortress occupied more
- 31:39than four square kilometers in a central citadel
- 31:42multiple artificial island fortifications and that's what matters
- 31:47because when you walk through and you see
- 31:49the barracks the walls the gates and the
- 31:51ruins you're not just looking at a monument
- 31:54you're looking at an imperial an empire military
- 31:58machine turned into historic memory of the entire
- 32:03area and in 1941 the defense is what
- 32:07made the Brest Fortress a sacred element of
- 32:11Soviet and Belarus memory in June 1941 when
- 32:17Nazi Germany launched Operation Barbarossa Brest was immediately
- 32:22hit Belarus talks about the Brest Fortress as
- 32:26a key symbol of Soviet resistance in World
- 32:29War two and it was the town of
- 32:31Brest was devastated you know outside of it
- 32:34soldiers inside the fortress resisted and the fortress
- 32:38later received the title of the hero fortress
- 32:41the equivalent symbolic category to this you know
- 32:45Soviet hero city ideas so the barracks the
- 32:49sculptures and the memorial scale is it's just
- 32:53enormous and there's a guy laying on a
- 32:57stone dude that is laying on his side
- 33:01crawling while laying on his belly basically crawling
- 33:05through and he's a you know tatters his
- 33:10rags he's aware you know as he's going
- 33:12through and that structure if you can I
- 33:17mean get on get on the internet and
- 33:19look at the Brest monuments and it is
- 33:21freaking amazing and it goes all the way
- 33:23back to the to the you know the
- 33:251400s and they have a history in that
- 33:29area and so Brest isn't just I don't
- 33:36know a history point it's a cultural point
- 33:39right it didn't so it this memorial wasn't
- 33:43rebuilt as a normal historic restoration it was
- 33:46a shrine and the entrance is this huge
- 33:49star cut into concrete right there's a thirst
- 33:53monument that's the one I'm telling you about
- 33:56that talks about this injured soldier reaching for
- 34:00water trying to get to water and the
- 34:02bayonet obelisk is huge it's a hundred meters
- 34:06high and there's a courage monument that stands
- 34:0933 meters high Belarus dot BY Belarus notes
- 34:15that only 216 of 850 defenders buried there
- 34:21are known by their names they I mean
- 34:25they defended that place in in that crepus
- 34:29that fortress by in 1941 against the so
- 34:35the Nazi aggression on that spot so you
- 34:39know the they don't even know who that
- 34:44is and there's a famous war song that
- 34:47I have to look up that I'm gonna
- 34:49play for you and I think I think
- 34:58it is it's a very good song anyway
- 35:01but even if you watch satirical comedies like
- 35:06the show Patriot in Russian which I think
- 35:08is friggin hilarious that is funny and I
- 35:13watch it all the time even in there
- 35:15the Patriot this kid this kid who is
- 35:17good well he's a young man who's gonna
- 35:19be part of the KGB and or the
- 35:22Security Service it's you know whatever remains of
- 35:25the FSB that he's gonna be a part
- 35:28of he he he sings it and I
- 35:33think the version I'm gonna play I'm gonna
- 35:36put the Red Army Orchestra is one of
- 35:39my favorites is one I'm gonna play for
- 35:42you that tells you the one it is
- 35:46and this song is something that in wartime
- 35:49is this is the true Russian version of
- 35:55this and it's the shorter version that'll that'll
- 35:58play for you but it's called Katyusha and
- 36:01so these have been around for decades certainly
- 36:05since World War two then that they have
- 36:08been playing this and this is the one
- 36:10paid by the red played by the Red
- 36:11Army Orchestra and it's a historic it truly
- 36:15is a historic song and if you ever
- 36:17hear Russian things you know on the radio
- 36:20or in anything they always play stuff like
- 36:23this it's almost as big as Vysotsky over
- 36:26there and this song is a is a
- 36:28basically a war song it's a song of
- 36:32a of a soldier and his love who's
- 36:36Katyusha Katya and Katerina that would be for
- 36:41for real and it's a Katya and then
- 36:43Katyushka it would be what it is and
- 36:46this is a song about Katyusha and she's
- 36:48a young girl and her love is going
- 36:50off to war and blah blah blah but
- 36:52it's a I shouldn't say blah blah blah
- 36:54it's a good song but we're gonna play
- 36:56it for you and you may have heard
- 36:57it before it might sound familiar to you
- 37:32Oh
- 38:05It's a song for the girls You're flying
- 38:11behind the bright sun And you're a soldier,
- 38:15let's go to the bar Say hello to
- 38:18Katyusha And you're a soldier, let's go to
- 38:24the bar Say hello to Katyusha Let her
- 38:30remember a girl as simple as she used
- 38:32to and hear how she sings.
- 38:37Let the sun protect you, and love will
- 38:42save Katyusha.
- 38:44Let the sun protect you, and love will
- 38:50save Katyusha.
- 38:58Let the sun protect you, and love will
- 39:06save
- 39:06Katyusha.
- 39:25Oh yeah, Katyusha.
- 39:27And that was one of the oldest versions.
- 39:31There's a little girl in there.
- 39:32She's got to be, what, 12, 13?
- 39:34That did the singing in there.
- 39:36Her name was on the screen.
- 39:41Valeria Kornushkina and the Red Army Orchestra.
- 39:45And that was, geez, ages ago that they
- 39:48have done that because the Red Army Orchestra
- 39:50obviously hasn't been around for years.
- 39:54The Red Army doesn't exist anymore.
- 39:57Well, it does, but it's now the Russian
- 39:58Army.
- 39:59And at any rate, that is a historic
- 40:02song.
- 40:03And it talks about a girl who's on
- 40:05the banks of the river singing and her
- 40:08soldier goes off to war and he fights
- 40:12for everybody's right to survive in this country.
- 40:17Now, this is a cultural song.
- 40:19But that song, even today, is extremely important.
- 40:25And there's some more that have jumped in
- 40:26there.
- 40:26But that, when you talk about it, and
- 40:29culturally, you know what you're talking about.
- 40:32You're talking about defending your homeland and those
- 40:37that you love.
- 40:38And your loved ones are being strong about
- 40:41it.
- 40:41Katyusha keeps her songs to herself.
- 40:43And she holds the love of her soldier
- 40:45who is taking care of the fighting in
- 40:48the war.
- 40:49So when you talk about war, and you
- 40:51talk about especially that area of the world,
- 40:54you can't talk about it without bringing in
- 40:57all of the enormous cultural influence.
- 41:01My culture influence, of course, is slanted because
- 41:03I had a Russian Studies degree from the
- 41:06University of Illinois.
- 41:07I went to the Russian Language School in
- 41:10Monterey, California.
- 41:11And so I learned the history from a
- 41:14Russian perspective.
- 41:16And all of the history that goes back
- 41:18into it.
- 41:19So, of course, I'm slanted toward that bit.
- 41:22But I also understand history from a much
- 41:25larger point anyway.
- 41:28Just because I'm a macro kind of guy
- 41:31and not these little micro battles that are
- 41:34going on between Ukraine and Russia.
- 41:36I see something that is like, Jesus, here
- 41:39we go again.
- 41:41And 100 years from now, here we go
- 41:43again.
- 41:44100 years ago, here we go again.
- 41:47Kiev, the collapse of the Soviet Union, the
- 41:52Polish Empire giving up its space because it
- 41:56had been overrun by the Nazis anyway.
- 42:01Russia defending against those Nazis.
- 42:03The Polish people have been through hell since
- 42:07their Polish-Lithuanian Empire, which I reviewed in
- 42:10Lithuania last year.
- 42:12And it's all of these historic things, depending
- 42:15on what period of history you're looking at,
- 42:18you're looking at who's in charge.
- 42:20And when you talk about those things, you
- 42:22talk about what is going on now in
- 42:24Iran, Azerbaijan, Armenia, Russian borders along the north
- 42:31of there, Turkey off to the west, Syria
- 42:33off to the southwest, or maybe straight west.
- 42:37And Turkey is a little bit more northwest.
- 42:39But either way, you can talk about this
- 42:44from when I took a trip over to
- 42:45Georgia, went over to Tbilisi.
- 42:48And Tbilisi, I traveled through Vladikavkaz and into
- 42:52Chechnya, okay?
- 42:54And Chechnya, there's a city called Grozny.
- 42:56The same thing happened after the collapse of
- 42:59the Soviet Union.
- 43:01The western influence, and it's still going on
- 43:05today.
- 43:06Armenia, I talk about.
- 43:07I talk about Georgia and all of the
- 43:10influences of trying to turn these people into
- 43:12NATO as if they're part of Europe.
- 43:15They're not part of Europe.
- 43:17And NATO is the North Atlantic.
- 43:20And these places do not touch the North
- 43:23Atlantic.
- 43:24So why are they part of the North
- 43:26Atlantic Treaty Organization?
- 43:28This is nonsense.
- 43:30Oh, here now, Venezuela.
- 43:32Trump is floating Venezuela now as the 51st
- 43:36state.
- 43:36Ah, that's pretty comical.
- 43:39Anyway, I gotta get back to my point.
- 43:41And there's a mountain town that I'm telling
- 43:44you about that is Stepansminda.
- 43:52Stepansminda.
- 43:53And it's the town, it used to be
- 43:56known as Kazbegi.
- 43:57And it's near the Russian border on the
- 43:59Georgian military highway, okay?
- 44:01And it's a mountainous town.
- 44:03Freaking beautiful.
- 44:04And I stayed in a little A-frame
- 44:06loft.
- 44:09The only bedroom was in a loft up
- 44:11there.
- 44:12And it was a tiny A-frame.
- 44:14Like, think of your tiny home stuff.
- 44:16And there's a kitchen and bath down below
- 44:18with a small sitting area.
- 44:20And up above, there's a loft with a
- 44:22king-size bed.
- 44:23I mean, it was a good-size loft
- 44:25up there.
- 44:26But very small structure.
- 44:30And there were three or four of these
- 44:31built on a back street in this town
- 44:35called Kazbegi, which is now Stepansminda.
- 44:38And you can stay there.
- 44:40And you have to cross through Abkhazia, okay?
- 44:46And so it's, you know, I told you
- 44:48about Brest and why Brest was important on
- 44:51the Western Front.
- 44:52When you talk about the Georgian borders to
- 44:56Vladikavkaz and Karmaden, the mountain town is, it's
- 45:01very mountainous.
- 45:01It's very beautiful.
- 45:03And I took some tours to see these.
- 45:06The green and the depth of it all
- 45:09is just unbelievable.
- 45:11And talk about this Caucasus scenery.
- 45:14Tell you what, Georgia's official tourism materials places
- 45:19Stepansminda in the province.
- 45:22There's a Gergeti Trinity Church, which is on
- 45:25top of a hill.
- 45:26And it's a 14th-century church above the
- 45:30town.
- 45:302,200 meters above the town.
- 45:34That's 3,000, 4,000 feet, if I
- 45:38remember correctly, somewhere in there.
- 45:40And so I crossed from Georgia into Russia.
- 45:45And this, you know, people there were so
- 45:49kind and so nice.
- 45:50But those two areas, there's an area in
- 45:54between.
- 45:55I believe it's Abkhazia.
- 45:57And that area is part of a neutral
- 46:02zone between Georgia and Russia.
- 46:05And you have to cross the border twice.
- 46:07I've told that story of crossing the border
- 46:09there.
- 46:10Started this show with telling you a little
- 46:12bit about the passport and visa issues.
- 46:17And I had, now Georgia, with an American
- 46:20passport, you can fly, or U.S. passport,
- 46:23you can fly into Grozny.
- 46:24I think we, I'm sorry, not Grozny, Tbilisi.
- 46:29And I think the flight went from Miami
- 46:32to Istanbul to Tbilisi.
- 46:35And then by car up through Vladikavkaz into,
- 46:41which is across the Georgian border, stayed a
- 46:43few days, four or five days, in this
- 46:47northern Georgia town of Stepansminda, took some tours
- 46:52up in the mountains and saw some really
- 46:53cool stuff, and then crossed the border into
- 46:55Russia and to Vladikavkaz.
- 46:58And that place, historically, is the same, and
- 47:02it's been overrun too, that entire area.
- 47:05Think Mongolian horde.
- 47:08Think China.
- 47:10You know, all of that stuff.
- 47:12This area is very close to Russia and
- 47:18Georgia.
- 47:19Grozny, I think Stalin was from Georgia.
- 47:23Grozny, from Tbilisi, I believe.
- 47:27And that was an interesting, people in these
- 47:31places don't think like a political think tank
- 47:36group would from Washington, D.C. or New
- 47:39York.
- 47:39They experienced it through roads, through the weather,
- 47:42through family, food, water, religion.
- 47:45There were some fantastic churches with little fortresses
- 47:49around them up on top of hills.
- 47:51And remember, the church was a symbol back
- 47:53then that would save these people in the
- 47:56event of confrontation.
- 47:58They would come into the church walls, which
- 48:01were walled off, you know, huge places for
- 48:03them where they could stay for several weeks
- 48:06while the town was ravaged outside.
- 48:09So when you cross into Russia, and the
- 48:11horror story of crossing the border took me
- 48:15forever, and all the people that I was
- 48:16with actually got a little grumpy about it
- 48:18because they had to wait for me for
- 48:21like an hour and a half because I
- 48:23was being really checked out when I crossed
- 48:26the border by car into Russia from Georgia
- 48:31through, I forget the name of the place,
- 48:34and I want to say Abkhazia, but I
- 48:36don't think that's it.
- 48:37I think Abkhazia is a little bit further
- 48:39west.
- 48:40But it doesn't matter.
- 48:41I crossed two borders to get there, and
- 48:45there's a neutral zone in between them, and
- 48:47a cool tunnel.
- 48:48I mean, it's really neat to go into
- 48:50that area, and the history just takes you
- 48:53over.
- 48:54So these are very cultural points.
- 48:59When you get into the Vladikavkaz area, that
- 49:02place too, even though it's inside of Russia,
- 49:05has also been part of influences and different
- 49:08border changes for centuries.
- 49:11And the same all the way through Kazakhstan,
- 49:16Kyrgyzstan, Uzbekistan, Mongolia, and all of those places
- 49:21along the Chinese border.
- 49:22I think it was Kazakhstan that came up
- 49:25right next to the Chinese border, and it
- 49:27was very, very interesting to hear the history
- 49:34from those perspectives and who came across.
- 49:38There's still border disputes between China and India
- 49:41on some of their borders.
- 49:42Well, imagine some of the...
- 49:43And that's been going on for decades and
- 49:46centuries.
- 49:46And the same thing goes with these others.
- 49:48And in the Soviet Union times, they just
- 49:50said, no, you know what?
- 49:52Doesn't matter anymore.
- 49:53These will be the borders.
- 49:54And we're enforcing them.
- 49:56Poland didn't like it on the Brest side.
- 49:58Ukraine never liked it, you know.
- 50:00But Ukraine was part of Soviet Rus'.
- 50:03And so anyway, when you come through that
- 50:06area, all of the history...
- 50:08I'm a cultural fan too, and so I
- 50:10tell you about Brat and Brat 2, which
- 50:13is Brat as brother, Brother and Brother 2,
- 50:17the series I've told you about.
- 50:19There's a young man in there whose name
- 50:23is Daniel...
- 50:26His brother, they call him the Tatar, because
- 50:29he's a Tatar.
- 50:31And he's...
- 50:34They lump them all together as culturally.
- 50:37When you talk about people from Georgia, you
- 50:41know what they're talking about, you know.
- 50:43And it's the same thing when they talked
- 50:47about, you know, Bodrov and...
- 50:51Sergei Bodrov was the young man who was
- 50:53a film person.
- 50:55And I went to...
- 50:56He was young.
- 50:57He's direct.
- 50:58He was searching for morality after the collapse
- 51:02of the Soviet Union when he was involved
- 51:04in those movies, Brother and Brother 2, which
- 51:07are cultural changes in the history, even from
- 51:10back then.
- 51:11He's skeptical of the approach to the West,
- 51:15of Europe, of all of that.
- 51:17And all of them were, including Ukrainians, Polish,
- 51:21Lithuanians.
- 51:22Now they've bought completely in and have decided
- 51:26to hate their prior culture.
- 51:28And that is a sad reality.
- 51:32Very sad.
- 51:33And they have taken on more of the...
- 51:37What is that guy's name?
- 51:42Bandera, Stepan Bandera, and taken more of this
- 51:45nationalist, these harsh nationalist position as if Ukraine
- 51:50was always Ukraine and as if Poland was
- 51:54always Poland.
- 51:56Never the twain shall meet.
- 51:58That's not true.
- 51:59There was such a mix of all of
- 52:02these places that it's ridiculous for today to
- 52:06fight a war over stuff that occurred because
- 52:10your language is different or your religion is
- 52:12marginally different and you're destroying your own culture.
- 52:16I don't like that in America and I
- 52:18don't like it anywhere else.
- 52:20And this Bodrov guy, the themes of his
- 52:23shows, Brother, Brother 2, the first one that
- 52:28he did, which was Sisters, the first three,
- 52:29the Sisters, that's his first effort at being
- 52:34a director of his own and that was
- 52:36some cultural...
- 52:38And it wasn't cynical in the dead corporate
- 52:41Western sense.
- 52:44He was...
- 52:45They were searching and he was doing it
- 52:47through art, right?
- 52:49And through movies and through stuff like that.
- 52:51All through the fake 1990s, especially in post
- 52:55-Soviet Russia and Georgia and Armenia and all
- 53:00of those areas.
- 53:02And he died in an avalanche in the
- 53:05mountains in Southwest outside of Vladikavkaz, less than
- 53:11an hour.
- 53:12And his entire film crew was buried through
- 53:16a huge avalanche that came and took them
- 53:19all out.
- 53:20So his death, talk about the fate of
- 53:23the entire Caucasus and this relationship with the
- 53:29tragedy of this young man, this young artist,
- 53:33and trying to portray some of the things
- 53:36of that area, the history of it all
- 53:39through harsh, real stories.
- 53:42And real in the point of view that
- 53:47they display the time period of the 90s
- 53:49in unbelievable format.
- 53:52And it's really pretty cool.
- 53:55And I want to get into, where am
- 53:58I with...
- 54:02I think I want to, if I could
- 54:04find it, I want to find, because then
- 54:08I want to switch into Grozny and Chechnya.
- 54:12And, but I have to, I haven't found
- 54:15a good version of this song.
- 54:20And I hope it's the right one because
- 54:23I have a fairly good search on it.
- 54:28And I want to take this same sort
- 54:32of more artistic, and it's Lyuba Lyubonka.
- 54:38And this one is performed, who is this
- 54:42lady?
- 54:44This is Tatyana Kurtukova.
- 54:48And Matushka's, no, no, that's the next song.
- 54:51Damn it.
- 54:52I knew that wasn't her.
- 54:53This is the prior song on that, but
- 54:55we'll get to it.
- 54:56This one is Lyuba, Lyubov Uspenskaya, Lyubov Lyubochka.
- 55:03And you may have heard this one too,
- 55:05just like the one that I played for
- 55:07you previously.
- 55:09But we're going to jump right into this
- 55:12and hope that it is correct.
- 55:14I'm 90%, 99% sure that I got
- 55:18it right.
- 55:19Oops.
- 55:20Of course, I can't run my own damn
- 55:22board here.
- 55:25Dear friends!
- 55:55Lyuba
- 56:22Lyubonka
- 56:25Lyubov
- 56:55Uspenskaya My dear, dear Russians And my foreign,
- 57:02cheerful friends For so many years you have
- 57:06not become strangers to me You also need
- 57:10my song, my ringing song And I will
- 57:14pamper and delight you with songs Without a
- 57:18song, you can't live without water Without a
- 57:20song, you can't live without water Until my
- 57:23heart stops beating in my chest And I
- 57:27will sing for you, my friends Lyuba Lyubonka
- 57:32I kiss you on the lips Because you
- 57:36sing like a nightingale Today you shine like
- 57:42a paradise Today you shine like a paradise
- 57:43And tomorrow you can go to Broadway Today
- 57:50you shine like a paradise And tomorrow you
- 57:55can go to Broadway And
- 58:13that is Lyubochka.
- 58:17Lyuba Lyubochka.
- 58:18And that is...
- 58:20Who is this lady?
- 58:22Next is one that I'm gonna play for
- 58:26you toward the end.
- 58:28That is...
- 58:30This one's very, very famous.
- 58:32And this is today's song.
- 58:34This one came about like three, four years
- 58:36ago.
- 58:36And this one took over the entire eastern...
- 58:43everywhere in Russia.
- 58:44You would hear this song everywhere you went.
- 58:47Imagine a song here in America.
- 58:49You know, pick a...
- 58:52There were a couple that went, especially after
- 58:54the start of the war, and all of
- 58:56this cultural stuff.
- 58:58And it's like, hey, man, they're taking the
- 59:00entire Russian culture and destroying it everywhere around
- 59:05the world.
- 59:05And they're destroying this culture.
- 59:08And we can't...
- 59:10There's the...
- 59:11What do they call it?
- 59:12Eurovision.
- 59:13Eurovision.
- 59:14In fact, it's going on right now, the
- 59:15final 15 countries in Eurovision.
- 59:18And this has been a European song thing
- 59:20forever.
- 59:22And one of the ones they put out
- 59:24in Eurovision was...
- 59:27Think about the clogging dancer.
- 59:29I forget his name from...
- 59:33Was it Ireland?
- 59:34Ireland, Scotland?
- 59:35Can't remember which.
- 59:36But they had the dancers, the clogging, that
- 59:39took it over by storm.
- 59:42And they won Eurovision way back when.
- 59:44And there's a Swedish...
- 59:46There's always very famous songs that come out
- 59:49of Eurovision.
- 59:50And they cut Russia off.
- 59:53You know, Russia can't participate.
- 59:55Russia can't participate in sports.
- 59:57Russia...
- 59:58I mean, it's all foolish idiocy that they
- 1:00:01can't participate in these things as if their
- 1:00:04culture is guilty of all of this.
- 1:00:07Nuts!
- 1:00:08Just friggin' crazy that your culture has to
- 1:00:10be destroyed.
- 1:00:11You know, in America, we've taken to cancelling
- 1:00:14things.
- 1:00:16We cancel our history.
- 1:00:18We cancel any president who owned a slave.
- 1:00:21We burn their homes down.
- 1:00:24We push over all of their statues as
- 1:00:27if the world wasn't very, very different at
- 1:00:31that time.
- 1:00:32This is what's going on.
- 1:00:33This is why Ukraine and Russia are in
- 1:00:36a war and America was trying to take
- 1:00:38over and got involved in something that we
- 1:00:41never should have gotten involved in.
- 1:00:44And so, I tell you what.
- 1:00:47It's...
- 1:00:47When you ease out of there...
- 1:00:50I don't mean to be morbid about talking
- 1:00:52about this kid, Bodrov, who represented the post
- 1:00:55-Soviet culture.
- 1:00:57But it's important to understand where they came
- 1:01:00from to understand why we are where we
- 1:01:03are right now.
- 1:01:05And these type of places that you see,
- 1:01:09history, it kills.
- 1:01:14I mean, the death that surrounds all of
- 1:01:17this for the foolish present visions.
- 1:01:21Fortresses.
- 1:01:22Invasions.
- 1:01:23Religion.
- 1:01:24Artillery.
- 1:01:26And then, you think about history and a
- 1:01:30kid like Bodrov dying in an avalanche.
- 1:01:35Killed quietly by everybody.
- 1:01:38I mean, they never found any of them.
- 1:01:39They were buried by a mountain.
- 1:01:41The whole mountain slid down upon them.
- 1:01:43You know, a mountain, a glacier, a valley,
- 1:01:46a film crew that never came home.
- 1:01:48That's part of a serious history.
- 1:01:51And there's a shrine over there that you
- 1:01:53wouldn't believe.
- 1:01:54I was very lucky to know that.
- 1:01:55I knew that he had died that way.
- 1:01:58And I knew about his history.
- 1:02:00And it was depressing because the movies that
- 1:02:02he was part of and, you know, Brat
- 1:02:05and Brat 2 and he was a young,
- 1:02:07just coming out.
- 1:02:08And he was gonna be a massive movie
- 1:02:13director star.
- 1:02:15His first ever effort was that movie Siostri,
- 1:02:19which is a real look at the harsh
- 1:02:23life that was, for some, a reality in
- 1:02:28the post-Soviet world.
- 1:02:31And the critique of the West in Brat
- 1:02:332 when you come in and all of
- 1:02:36this history tied together.
- 1:02:38This is a kid who knew where he
- 1:02:39was from.
- 1:02:40You know, he knew that.
- 1:02:42And when you talk about, you know, slide
- 1:02:44into a little bit east of Vladikavkaz and
- 1:02:47east of Georgia, where I was and the
- 1:02:49very real interference that we put both in
- 1:02:58Grozny, that we put into Chechnya, that we
- 1:03:01wanted to take the post-Soviet world.
- 1:03:05And that we, when I say we, I
- 1:03:06mean the West, the way that we think,
- 1:03:09this global empire, we need to dominate the
- 1:03:12rest of the world.
- 1:03:13And so what do we do?
- 1:03:14We insert our thoughts, our beliefs, our democracy,
- 1:03:19and our success story.
- 1:03:22All of the stuff that they want about
- 1:03:25the West is the dream of living in
- 1:03:28a free place that isn't going to be
- 1:03:32overrun by war.
- 1:03:35That's what they're looking for.
- 1:03:37They're looking for what we have.
- 1:03:39When's the last time we worried about war
- 1:03:41coming to the United States?
- 1:03:43Coming to your homeland?
- 1:03:45I mean, I imagine your life would be
- 1:03:48different or your thought process would be very
- 1:03:52different if you had to worry about a
- 1:03:55drone flying over and destroying your home or
- 1:03:58attacking you and your personal things because you
- 1:04:04maintain a certain religion.
- 1:04:06Think about Iran.
- 1:04:08What are those people thinking of?
- 1:04:10The same crap that's been going on for
- 1:04:133,000 years.
- 1:04:16And we're getting involved in it.
- 1:04:18Think about Grozny, Chechnya.
- 1:04:19I went there on this same trip when
- 1:04:21I went up through, so I spent maybe
- 1:04:24five, six days, four or five days.
- 1:04:29So Tbilisi, I was only there for a
- 1:04:31day.
- 1:04:31Then I went up, which is a really
- 1:04:33cool city in Georgia.
- 1:04:34And then I went up to these Stepna,
- 1:04:37Stepan, I can't remember the name of it,
- 1:04:40but northern Grozny in the mountainous village stayed
- 1:04:42there three, four days.
- 1:04:43It was really cool.
- 1:04:44And then crossed into Russia across the border
- 1:04:49and went into Vladikavkaz.
- 1:04:53Saw the mountainous regions.
- 1:04:55Saw where Sergei Bodrov died.
- 1:04:58Spent the day and went across to Chechnya
- 1:05:01and Grozny.
- 1:05:02And this is important as well because Grozny
- 1:05:06was a Russian fortress in 1818 on the
- 1:05:11Sunja River Leo Tolstoy, Lev Tolstoy and Mikhail
- 1:05:17Lermontov served in both of those places.
- 1:05:20And when I was in school in Russia,
- 1:05:22Lermontov is famous for writing some of the
- 1:05:27stories about the Kavkazi and the mountainous steppe
- 1:05:32and the wars.
- 1:05:33And Tolstoy, of course, everybody knows about Tolstoy.
- 1:05:36And going through, and they served in Grozny
- 1:05:39at this Russian fortress that was built in
- 1:05:431818.
- 1:05:45And so I think Lermontov, who was the
- 1:05:48one that died?
- 1:05:49A couple of them died in duels.
- 1:05:52Very young.
- 1:05:54Very young.
- 1:05:55And they would go to Moscow and the
- 1:05:58politics of it all.
- 1:05:59People were dying in duels back then.
- 1:06:03There are oil deposits in Grozny that were
- 1:06:06commercially very decisive.
- 1:06:08Large-scale production of that began in 1893
- 1:06:12when the railways reached that town.
- 1:06:14And by the time of the Russian Revolution
- 1:06:16in 1917, Grozny was one of Russia's major
- 1:06:22oil centers, second only to Baku.
- 1:06:25And this matters because Grozny's history isn't just
- 1:06:28about Chechnya and the war and, you know,
- 1:06:32Ramazan Kadyrov or whatever his name is, that
- 1:06:35has built a great country.
- 1:06:38In Chechnya.
- 1:06:40And this is a lazy Western headline version
- 1:06:44when you talk about Chechnya just equaling war.
- 1:06:48It's not.
- 1:06:49Grozny was a military, imperial, literary, industrial, Islamic,
- 1:06:55and Soviet oil-rich, destroyed country rebuilt, politically
- 1:06:59transformed over and over in Chechnya.
- 1:07:03The wars of the 1990s and early 2000s
- 1:07:07are central now.
- 1:07:08But they don't equal the whole identity of
- 1:07:11that historic place.
- 1:07:12It just doesn't.
- 1:07:14The Russian invasion of Chechnya in December of
- 1:07:171994 and the taking of Grozny in March
- 1:07:20of 1995 and continued guerrilla resistance by the
- 1:07:24Muslim Chechnyans and their resistance and the unresolved
- 1:07:28peace of 1997 and the return of Russian
- 1:07:32forces in 1999 and then there's a guy
- 1:07:35named Ahmad Kadyrov who was killed in 2004
- 1:07:39and now, I believe it's his son, Ramzan
- 1:07:43Kadyrov, who is the Chechen president who's very
- 1:07:46loyal to Vladimir Putin and he came to
- 1:07:53power in 2007.
- 1:07:55They've been solid for 20 years in their
- 1:07:58support and their anti-war and the growth.
- 1:08:01And there's, think about these guys who, Chechen
- 1:08:05generals, Chechen forces are helping the Russians in
- 1:08:09Ukraine right now.
- 1:08:11There's a guy named Opti Aloudinov who is
- 1:08:13a general appointed by Ramzan Kadyrov to be
- 1:08:17a general, to lead the forces in there.
- 1:08:20They're the people that defended Kursk and sent
- 1:08:24them back.
- 1:08:26Sent the Ukrainians back, destroyed them all.
- 1:08:29And they're harsh.
- 1:08:30These are some tough dudes.
- 1:08:33You think about some, I mean, this is
- 1:08:36a tough army force that comes from Chechnya,
- 1:08:38let me tell you.
- 1:08:40And under Ramzan Kadyrov, they're very loyal to
- 1:08:45Russia right now.
- 1:08:46And all of this, and I'm trying to
- 1:08:48talk about stuff that isn't necessarily Sam's political
- 1:08:51talk about how BS the entire Ukraine deal
- 1:08:55is and I hope if you get anything
- 1:08:57out of today's show, you get the fact
- 1:08:59that we shouldn't be there.
- 1:09:02And it's nothing to do with America and
- 1:09:05nothing we do is gonna change what goes
- 1:09:09on there.
- 1:09:10And in 50 and 100 years, you're gonna
- 1:09:12have the same old crap come up again
- 1:09:15because people are people.
- 1:09:17This has gone on for centuries.
- 1:09:20I mean, think about this.
- 1:09:21This is crap.
- 1:09:23This is crap.
- 1:09:24I mean, when you go to the heart
- 1:09:25of Chechnya, there's a mosque and it's Ahmad
- 1:09:29Kadyrov in his mosque.
- 1:09:31It's called the Heart of Chechnya and it
- 1:09:33opened in Grozny in 2008 and it can
- 1:09:36hold 10,000 worshippers.
- 1:09:39It is one of the visible symbols of
- 1:09:42post-war Grozny, not just religious, but reconstructionist,
- 1:09:47authoritarian.
- 1:09:48It's the identity and the declaration that that
- 1:09:51city is not rubble.
- 1:09:54It isn't gone.
- 1:09:55That city is a historic place and the
- 1:09:59mosques, there's a woman's mosque that was built
- 1:10:02for Aiman Kadyrov, which is the wife of,
- 1:10:11what's his name?
- 1:10:13The other, Ramzan Kadyrov's mother, right?
- 1:10:17And so it talks about it all and
- 1:10:20it's the mother's heart.
- 1:10:21It's a female, a woman's, and I couldn't
- 1:10:24go in it.
- 1:10:26I couldn't actually, I could go through the
- 1:10:28main portion of it, but you couldn't get
- 1:10:29into the part where only women can go
- 1:10:31and worship.
- 1:10:32You can't get in there.
- 1:10:33Lana went in there.
- 1:10:35She's a Muslim and she's very formal about
- 1:10:38it.
- 1:10:38You have to put a shawl on every
- 1:10:41time you have to cover your hair and
- 1:10:42I got in trouble at one in, where
- 1:10:45was that one?
- 1:10:47I went into one of the huge mosques.
- 1:10:49I believe that one was in, geez, Kazakhstan
- 1:10:54maybe, but it was on the bank of
- 1:10:55a huge river and it was freaking amazing.
- 1:10:58I wish I could remember the name of
- 1:10:59that place, but I went in there and
- 1:11:02I was taking pictures and the prayer symbols
- 1:11:05went off and I was escorted out of
- 1:11:09there quick.
- 1:11:11They grabbed me and took me out and
- 1:11:14some Western idiot in there taking pictures while
- 1:11:18the men are worshiping and that was, I
- 1:11:21didn't understand.
- 1:11:22I thought it was individual.
- 1:11:25It wasn't part of a tour or anything,
- 1:11:26but you have to understand these things and
- 1:11:28when you go into the place, the Aiman
- 1:11:30Kadirova Mosque in Argun, it's called the Mother's
- 1:11:33Heart and it's named for Miss Aiman Kadirova,
- 1:11:36the widow of Ahmad Kadirova, the mother of
- 1:11:39Ramzan Kadirova and it opened in 2014 and
- 1:11:42it's very modern and cool architecture and its
- 1:11:46capacity can hold around 15,000 worshipers and
- 1:11:51I tell you what, the Chechen religion, the
- 1:11:55maternal symbolism, the public architecture, you ought to
- 1:11:58see all the brand new apartment buildings going
- 1:12:01up in Grozny and everywhere modern, everywhere women
- 1:12:05pushing buggies, everywhere very modern cars and the
- 1:12:09money was a surprise to me.
- 1:12:13You think, and in America, it's always third
- 1:12:16world.
- 1:12:16We're supposed to go over and all it
- 1:12:17reads is these are third world countries.
- 1:12:19My ass.
- 1:12:20They're very modern and they're very cool and
- 1:12:24when you go through there, I mean everywhere
- 1:12:26they're building.
- 1:12:27There was a kind of a, and this
- 1:12:31was in Grozny and Grozny was destroyed basically
- 1:12:35during the wars of the 90s between Chechnya
- 1:12:38and Russia and there was another country involved
- 1:12:40as well that came, I forget which one,
- 1:12:44but it was a massively overrun place in
- 1:12:47the 90s, post-Soviet, you know, and we've
- 1:12:50always tried to influence and Ramzan Kadyrov, we
- 1:12:54ain't putting up with that.
- 1:12:56You know what I mean?
- 1:12:58He understands that NATO's not the answer.
- 1:13:01Georgia, I don't know, but you got these
- 1:13:03young kids and these young kids, they want
- 1:13:05all the crap that Westerners have.
- 1:13:07They want the, you know, where's my Obama
- 1:13:09phone?
- 1:13:09They want the same crap that everybody wants,
- 1:13:12you know, just to live a good life
- 1:13:14and this Apti Aloudinov, and it's A-P
- 1:13:18-T-I-O-P-T-I is his
- 1:13:20name, Aloudinov, he's currently a lieutenant general.
- 1:13:23He's the deputy head of the main military
- 1:13:25political directorate of the Russian armed forces and
- 1:13:28he's the commander of the Chechen volunteer formation
- 1:13:32which is called Akhmat and he's very visible
- 1:13:36as the public military commentator during the Ukraine
- 1:13:39conflict because especially around the Kursk region because
- 1:13:43they're the ones that drove back the Ukrainian
- 1:13:46attempt to take over Kursk and killed about
- 1:13:4970,000 Ukrainian soldiers trying to take over
- 1:13:53Kursk and Kursk was very important in World
- 1:13:57War II also, one of the major defense
- 1:14:01forces that pushed back Nazi Germany tank divisions
- 1:14:05in the Kursk region of Russia, massive victory
- 1:14:11and held off, the Russians held back the
- 1:14:16onslaught of the Third Reich tank forces.
- 1:14:20So, you know, all of these, it's crazy
- 1:14:26because all of these mix into where we
- 1:14:30go today.
- 1:14:30On this show, I always talk quite a
- 1:14:33bit about the realities of today and the
- 1:14:37focus on the wrong thinking of politics and
- 1:14:42political people of today that ignore history or
- 1:14:47just act like all that counts is today.
- 1:14:5150 years from now, nobody's going to give
- 1:14:53a crap about the fact that Ukraine either
- 1:14:57wanted or didn't want to be part of
- 1:14:59NATO, part of the EU, part of anything.
- 1:15:02They're going to care that a million young
- 1:15:05men and women died in Ukraine, far more
- 1:15:10than that when you include the Russian side
- 1:15:12too and tell you what, by the time
- 1:15:16this is done, does it really matter?
- 1:15:20Do the wars that I talked about that
- 1:15:22the overrunning of Brest or the wars that
- 1:15:25took place in Grozny take, matter?
- 1:15:29What matters, and this is selfish, what matters
- 1:15:32is me being able to go over and
- 1:15:35see, just like I did in the southern
- 1:15:39parts of Tatarstan, that place has been overrun
- 1:15:43since the Mongol hordes and the Turkish Empire,
- 1:15:48the Ottoman Empire.
- 1:15:49I mean, think about all of this.
- 1:15:51When you go there and you get to
- 1:15:53see the history, it kind of levels the
- 1:15:58playing field and you sit there and you
- 1:16:00go, all right, what do any one of
- 1:16:03us, Donald Trump included, you know, Opti Aloudinov
- 1:16:07included, Vladimir Putin, Ramzan Kadyrov, all of that,
- 1:16:14does it matter?
- 1:16:15And I think that with that, I'm going
- 1:16:18to take, you know, it's pretty sad, and
- 1:16:22this is a tie-in, I'm trying to
- 1:16:23get into this song because I love this
- 1:16:25one too, is to, and it'll be the
- 1:16:28final song for today, and then we'll wrap
- 1:16:30it up, but, you know, life is sad
- 1:16:32because you talk about all these history and,
- 1:16:36you know, it's, I mean, frankly, I want
- 1:16:39to play, Frankie Goes to Hollywood, Two Tribes
- 1:16:42Go to War, would have fit in here
- 1:16:44somewhere because this is all we're doing.
- 1:16:46It's the same old crap all the way
- 1:16:48around the line.
- 1:16:50And so I think people need to understand
- 1:16:52the history of all of this entire area
- 1:16:55in the post-Soviet world.
- 1:16:57And I've taken you from northern Brest and
- 1:17:01Belarus on the sides down through Ukraine into
- 1:17:04Tatarstan in the Bashkir down there in that
- 1:17:08area.
- 1:17:08And I also went over to the eastern
- 1:17:10half over by Ufa and went through Ufa
- 1:17:13and through, you know, stayed over there for
- 1:17:1610, 15 days.
- 1:17:17That was pretty cool.
- 1:17:18But on the Grozny side was this war,
- 1:17:20and all of this has been post-collapse
- 1:17:24Soviet Union, horror story of reality for these
- 1:17:29people who all they want to do is
- 1:17:32have what we have.
- 1:17:34A place to live, what we generally have,
- 1:17:37I think, where you don't have to worry
- 1:17:39about war coming to your home.
- 1:17:45And I'm not saying we don't have to
- 1:17:47worry, but that worry is a pretty far
- 1:17:49-fetched reality here in America.
- 1:17:52The rest of the world, especially post-Soviet,
- 1:17:56has that worry constantly.
- 1:17:59And so I want to play for you
- 1:18:02a very fitting song, in my humble opinion,
- 1:18:05called, and I like techno music anyway, rave
- 1:18:08music, and this one is called Life Is
- 1:18:11So Sad.
- 1:18:12And life sometimes is sad, and so I'm
- 1:18:15going to play this for you.
- 1:18:16And this one's the single edit, so it's
- 1:18:19only three, four minutes long.
- 1:18:26Life is so sad I have no one
- 1:18:35to kiss Love is not easy
- 1:18:45But I don't want to miss Life
- 1:18:54is so sad I have no one to
- 1:19:03kiss Love is not easy
- 1:19:12But I don't want to miss But
- 1:19:57I don't want to miss Love
- 1:20:36is not easy I have no one to
- 1:20:46kiss Love is not easy But
- 1:20:56I don't want to miss Here
- 1:21:28we go again Love
- 1:21:43is not easy But I don't want to
- 1:21:53miss Life is so sad Isn't it?
- 1:22:02Well, life is sad if you always got
- 1:22:04to worry about war coming after you.
- 1:22:07I like some techno.
- 1:22:10I like all kinds of music, and I
- 1:22:13tell you what, I went to, and I'm
- 1:22:16going to wrap up the show by telling
- 1:22:17you this little, little again, former Soviet Republic
- 1:22:26in Kyrgyzstan, and I went, two, three years
- 1:22:31ago, I went to Kyrgyzstan, Uzbekistan, Kazakhstan, and
- 1:22:37spent like six weeks over there, and toured
- 1:22:40around in that place, all post-Soviet, you
- 1:22:44know, former Soviet republics, and there's, I spent
- 1:22:50ten days or so in a Russian, well,
- 1:22:57a Kyrgyzian, but everybody speaks Russian there, and
- 1:23:00you know, there's whatever the language is, the
- 1:23:04derivative of the Southeast, which a lot of
- 1:23:07the countries down there all speak, that each
- 1:23:11one of them is similar, but not the
- 1:23:13same, and so the common language, like English
- 1:23:15would be in the western half of the
- 1:23:17world over there, the common language is Russian,
- 1:23:19and so because they've been dominated by the
- 1:23:22Russian Empire for two, three hundred years, and
- 1:23:25whether it's Soviet, Russian, or whatever, and so
- 1:23:29when you go around there, they've gone through
- 1:23:31some of the same stuff.
- 1:23:32Kazakhstan has had troubles, and Kazakhstan, the U
- 1:23:35.S., and the West, and NATO are all
- 1:23:38trying to influence every country down there to
- 1:23:41separate from Russia.
- 1:23:43Why?
- 1:23:44The continual war for resources.
- 1:23:47Kazakhstan is where the nuclear power of the
- 1:23:51Soviet Union took place, and I forget the
- 1:23:54name of the test site, but their test
- 1:23:56site was over there, and like I talk
- 1:24:00about me touring around with Soviet and Russian
- 1:24:03nuclear scientists over here, and they had something
- 1:24:11similar in Kazakhstan, so Kazakhstan, Uzbekistan, I went
- 1:24:15to a lake down there, and if you
- 1:24:17don't understand the history, that was a huge
- 1:24:19resort area for the Soviet Empire, and they
- 1:24:23had one of the, what do you call
- 1:24:26it, sanatorium that I went to for ten
- 1:24:28days, medical treatment, mud baths, salt baths, I
- 1:24:33don't know, swimming in mineral waters, it was
- 1:24:38freaking awesome, and if you can go and
- 1:24:40do something like that once in life, it
- 1:24:42would be fantastic for you to enjoy what
- 1:24:45I've enjoyed three times in three different areas
- 1:24:48of former, one inside of Russia, actually two
- 1:24:53inside of Russia, Ufa was still inside of
- 1:24:55Russia, and I went to Bakirov in Tatarstan,
- 1:24:59which is still part of, that republic is
- 1:25:01part of Russia, it's just a Russian region,
- 1:25:04and that place was fantastic, and Bakirov, but
- 1:25:07the one on Lake Issyk-Kul, which is
- 1:25:09now Kyrgyzstan, is being rebuilt, and so I
- 1:25:13hope that what my, I don't know what,
- 1:25:17my rambling roundabout way of talking about all
- 1:25:21of these cultural things and mixing music, movies,
- 1:25:25history, travel, reality, Vladimir Putin and being interviewed
- 1:25:30by Tucker Carlson talking about the history, it's
- 1:25:34similar to the, if you don't understand history,
- 1:25:36you're doomed to repeat it, well, it's gonna
- 1:25:38repeat all over, and so the thought process
- 1:25:42needs to be a little bit different, and
- 1:25:44that can be stretched all the way into
- 1:25:46the Middle East as well, and everywhere, you
- 1:25:50know, why should you, just because you don't
- 1:25:53live in America, why should you have to
- 1:25:55worry about bombs coming in over your head
- 1:25:57at any given time, because somebody wants to
- 1:26:00enforce their power over you, it's been going
- 1:26:03on for generations, and it's always the same,
- 1:26:07we're fighting over resources, and I think the
- 1:26:10better move is 99.9% of the
- 1:26:15time, diplomacy as, you know, if you want
- 1:26:20to take anything from this show, learn your
- 1:26:23culture, learn your history, value the cultures of
- 1:26:26others, value the opinions of others, and how
- 1:26:29other people think, and remember that they're all
- 1:26:32after the exact same thing at the level
- 1:26:36of us, middle class, or low class, if
- 1:26:41you want to call it that, in my
- 1:26:43case, that all we want is the same
- 1:26:46thing.
- 1:26:47We want to be able to travel, to
- 1:26:49see things, to live in a way that
- 1:26:53we like.
- 1:26:54You don't have to like my music, you
- 1:26:56don't have to like my words, you don't
- 1:26:57have to like anything, but you should appreciate
- 1:27:00them, and appreciate the fact that I'm willing
- 1:27:02to let you have your own.
- 1:27:04So if you take anything from today's program,
- 1:27:07take it as Sam's dissertation on history versus
- 1:27:12diplomacy and reality, and how both mix, regardless
- 1:27:17of whether you're a diplomat, or whether you're
- 1:27:20leaders, you're fearless leaders, believe it or not.
- 1:27:23I'm Samuel Trapp.
- 1:27:25This is International Flavor.
- 1:27:27Thanks for listening.
- 1:27:28You can join me every morning, 730-298
- 1:27:32-M on damradio.com forward slash live.
- 1:27:37Tomorrow's the biggest day in radio history.
- 1:27:41Tomorrow, here on damradio.com forward slash live
- 1:27:45starts with me, 730-A-M.
- 1:27:48I look forward to you hearing me then.
- 1:27:53Have a very nice day.