Latest / On the Path / Reflections on 9/11 - How Missions Changed
Transcript
- Steven: Federal Aviation Administration. We have a problem here. We have a hijacked aircraft headed towards New York. Northeast Air Defense Sector. Is this real world or exercise? FAA No, this is not an exercise, not a test. Needs. United ninety three. Have you got information on that yet? FAA. Yeah, he's he's down. Needs. He's down. FAA. Yes. Needs. When did he land? FAA. He did not land. Needs. he's he's down down. FA Yes. Those lines are direct quotes from twenty five years ago, today, when the world changed. On this twenty-fifth anniversary of those attacks, we thought we would spend some time reflecting on that day and specifically how it changed the way churches and ministries send people around the world. September 11th is one of those dates which very few people are unaware. There are certain moments in history where people who live through them can tell you exactly where they were when they heard the news. December 7, 1941, the Japanese attack on Pearl Harbor was a pivot point in history that is remembered. Similarly, if not more so, September 11, 2001 is a date that seared itself into the conscience of everyone who lived through it and changed the trajectory of the world. It most certainly changed far more than airport security. It reshaped international travel, national security, foreign policy, and even the way Americans were perceived around the world, and not just in the immediate aftermath, but throughout the decades that followed. For churches and missions organizations, it also marked the beginning of a very different era of global ministry. The Great Commission hadn't changed, the gospel hadn't changed But the environment in which gospel workers traveled and served had become significantly more complex. Now, twenty five years later, we have an entire generation of gospel workers who were either young children on september eleventh or weren't even born yet. They're serving in a post nine eleven world without necessarily knowing what ministry and international travel looked like before it. So that's what we're going to explore today. I want to go back in time and talk about what international ministry for American gospel workers looked like before September 11th and changed afterward. And maybe most importantly, what we've learned or still need to learn many years later. And Scott, and for those of you who may be listening for the first time, Scott is president of Concilium. I think you're uniquely positioned to help us have this conversation. You had already been traveling internationally and involved in ministry well before two thousand one and you've obviously spent a tremendous amount of time traveling, serving, training, and working with ministries around the world in the years since. So you've really experienced both worlds. So Scott, welcome to the podcast and and why don't you we start with maybe a personal reflection point of where were you on September eleventh, two thousand one? What were you doing when you first heard America had been attacked in this way. I had just returned from Russia on a mission trip in the Caucasus Mountains and was preparing our next team that was going to be leaving for southwest China when the when the Twin Towers were hit, when the Pentagon was attacked. I was thinking back, I was at SBU, I was a freshman at Southwest Baptist University and I remember walking through the our coffee shop and just saw the smoking tower just on the screen that an airplane hit. I had no idea that it was a bunch of passenger jets that were going and what was unfolding at that time. And I remember our whole school just came to a standstill. So quite the day. Well before we move forward from that day, let's let's let's go backward in time. Yeah, you'd already been traveling internationally, like we we mentioned for ministry for years. For someone who has never known the pre nine eleven world, what was international ministry travel like before September eleventh happened? It's a good question. I would I would frame it this way. The the pre nine eleven world was not necessarily safer for missionaries. It it was differently dangerous. Okay, the the the missions community understood and managed that danger differently than than they than they did post nine eleven. in in some important respects, I think nine eleven and the wars and political changes that followed r really did alter the threat environment, but the threat environment was already there prior to nine eleven. I I remember Being in Sudan just a few months after the US bombed Sudan in in order to launch a reprisal against the the first World Trade Center bombing. And remembering the you know they they were also looking for Osama bin Laden back in in the late nineties. I mean it's not like this brand new problem arose in in 2001. In fact, I was in Khartoum just a few months after the bombing of of of the aspirin factory there. That's a whole whole other story. But just remembering we don't want to romanticize this pre-nine eleven period as being safer. look by by nineteen eighty seven the Christianity today had reports on terrorism and threats to missionaries. sending agencies by the by the 1990s were developing contingency plans. missionaries who had been you held captive in Colombia, in in Mozambique, Af Afghanistan before before 9-11, right? Yemen. and and other places. So there there were there were issues out there prior to the the the attacks on on on the Pentagon and on the Twin Towers. So I just I I want to really try to to drive that home. I I think before 9-11 much of missionary security thinking was localized and event driven You know, I mentioned Columbia, you know, you you've got the FARC and guerrillas and the kidnapping and the number of missionaries who were had been taken there. And there's there's some amazing stories of of survival. there's heartbreaking stories of missionaries being murdered. But a missionary going somewhere dangerous needed to understand that particular danger, not necessarily the broader complex or complexities of traveling there and the threats that you could face along the way. after 9-11, I think the threats became more understood, or maybe increasingly understood, as transnational. interconnected, even identity-based, based on your nationality, you know, being an American traveling to some of these places, but but also very systemic. And when when when people began to learn about Al-Qaeda and that Al-Qaeda was bigger than just you know, a a a a f a few guys in Afghanistan. And there's Al Qaeda in Yemen. And you've got Al Qaeda franchises in the Philippines. And you know, peop people were were were pledging their their allegiance, right, to to Al Qaeda. all of these began all these issues began to arise, forcing mission agencies to reevaluate risk after after 9-11. That's a lot of good stuff in that to to reflect on. Do you remember your first international ministry trip after September eleventh? I do. It was it was taking that trip into southwest China. How did that go? Were was there anything on that where you know you you realized well things are different now? Yeah. Well, yes. It was going through security obviously changed and what you could carry in your in in your carry-on versus not carry in your carry-on. But I think for me, we we we flew from k from Kansas City to Salt Lake City, and getting off the plane No, just changing planes and seeing the number of police standing in the airport, in the secured areas of the airport with M4 carbines and body armor. I think that was the the the biggest visible change that that you could see and and trying to ignore that as you're, you know, going from from one plane to another. But but especially in Asia, I think once once we got out of the United States and I think our next flight, we we landed in Tokyo and from there got on a an another airline. any of those big changes when I got to got to Asia. It's more on the American side, yeah. Now Europe it was probably different at that time, but my first trip was to was to Southwest China. So it was at post nine eleven with Southwest China. Yeah. So looking back then, twenty five years later, where do you think the mission community adapted well? And I guess probably a more important question, where d where do you think we might still have work to do? Obviously when nine eleven happened. unforeseen, unplanned event, no unanticipated it. Those type of things obviously have consequences and cause all sorts of quick reactions, quick responses. You know, everybody's going different directions, different thoughts. you know, how how how did the missions community adapt and and again, where where do where do you think we might still have work to do? I think 9-11 was an inflection point for the missions community, but but the the institutional transformation was not instantaneous. It it took time. Remember, at that time in 2001, I was the president of a small discipleship and mobilization ministry, taking high school and college students around the world on short-term missions. So we were partnering with with larger mission agencies, but doing the work on the ground of preparation and sending, we were we were fielding many more questions of concern from parents prior to 9-11. But but the actual number of of people who were going overseas did not decrease. If anything, it actually started to increase within the the the the the evangelical church. post 911. So yeah, the the So you might have observed some more fervency, more of a drive even. Yeah, no, I I I think we did see more more of a drive because the the need to go became more apparent. And in in many of these places, you know, post post 911, A year later, I'm I'm leading student teams into Afghanistan. That's pretty pretty quick after. I mean really, yeah, yeah. So you know, basically you've got you've got September 2001, and then by October, you've you've got the invasion, and then by by the end of 2002, we're we're we're preparing to bring students in. And within a year of that, by the fall of 2003, is the invasion of Iraq. And I I I was in Baghdad the night they caught Saddam Hussein on a mission trip. I mean you know, I mean to go from being an army ranger in in the Gulf War to being on a mission trip in in in in northern Iraq. We we we just gotten to Baghdad and we're we're driving up north. But yeah, we we s that that night the green zone is when they caught Saddam Hussein. And so you know you you sort of reflect on these these things. Yeah. But but I'd say the 9-11, what it really did was to change the scale and perception and and and the the strategic context of of ministry. You know, mentioned earlier that security concerns didn't begin with nine-eleven because there were security concerns back in the nineteen eighties and and and and nineteen nineties. so they were already there. again, geographically speaking, we often looked at that security. concern within the country that we were entering, you know, civil war, coups, banditry, kidnapping, you know, on the physical side, like the health side of disease and things like that. and the risk was geographically located. Yeah. But after nine eleven, the next realization comes of the fact that your nationality, your organizational affiliation, religion, relationships, communications could get you into trouble. And and and even more than that, I think there was a symbolic value to harming Americans in particular, maybe Westerners in general, especially for kidnapping purposes. and so that was a significant conceptual shift. You know, a a missionary didn't simply happen to be working in a dangerous environment. And in some environments that were relatively safe environments, the missionaries' identity could increase their threats simply because of the color of their passport and and and where they were from. And and so yeah, I'd I'd say by 2002, 2003, that's that's when we we began to see the shift in mission agencies. But the initial shift, i it might have been reactionary. You know, and because for for again looking back from from from 2001 to 2007, because I didn't get into vocational security. you know, management, professional security management until two thousand seven. And prior to that, it was all focused on helping young people decrease their vulner vulnerability to threats so that they wouldn't become victims. Right. I mean I mean keep in mind, I I I tell this story of, you know, one of the first young people I sent overseas went to Bosnia. This is what, nineteen ninety eight? And the the the the threat there was unexploded ordinance. And, you know run into a minefield chasing a soccer ball. No no one's no one's actively trying to kill him, but you know, situational awareness needs situational understanding so that you don't run into the minefield chasing a soccer ball. Not being able to read a sign that says warning minefield. Yeah, yeah, essentially. And and so that was already high on my mind sending young people to these hard places. I mean keep in mind it from Bosnia it's to Sudan. And from Sudan it's to to to to to threatening locations i across the Middle East and and North Africa. and and into south southwest china and south asia and and so security and and risk management was already high on our mind because we saw the the connection between Decreasing vulnerability to threat, which increases opportunity for obedience. But I didn't see that in the mission agencies because what I saw in the agencies was much more focused on reactionary measures. For example, a higher focus on crisis management, which is a response to something bad happening. Security training at that time was highly focused on captivity survival. Although 99.9% of missionaries, and maybe even higher. Will never be kidnapped. But there was this intentional focus on captivity survival. Now I'm I'm glad that these focuses were made and they were very useful. But but again, 25 years ago, looking at where security management was then to where it has come to today, it is two different worlds. when I got into full-time security management, the question never was, how do we keep missionaries safe? It's how do we sustain legitimate Christian presence in these environments where all of these things that prior to 9-11 you know didn't work against us, but today they do. Not just in in restricted access countries, but even in some of the open countries or traditionally open countries. And and and that is a much more sophisticated problem to solve than just how do we keep missionaries safe? Right. Because Gospel workers are both coming from and going to a entirely different mindset than just trying to avoid risk. They're coming from a completely different perspective. I think that's a really important thing to point out that you highlighted there. So if I was if I was to try to s simplify this, pre-9-11, the the the the philosophy was dangerous countries require precautions. Post nine eleven, two thousand one to two thousand three, it was more akin to The world has changed. We need more security, sort of reactionary. And sort of understandably so almost, right? I mean the the level of that event, right? Sort of sends you re reeling a bit. But by 2003 to 2006, seven, eight, that's where you see it change from we need security to we need organizational systems for managing security and crisis. Because by 2009, that's where you get. The risk management network. Gotcha. Is because those who are managing security in their organizations are starting to ask these questions about how do we design and develop systems for managing security in crisis. And right now the focus is really reactionary, crisis management versus security management, and in particular, security risk management. But later the the maturation process, we'll see security cannot be separated from strategy. See that that's what becomes important. You can't just build a box around the organization's mission and say, you know, go crazy in the box and because inside the box is safe and outside the box is unsafe. Because that's a lot of what you were getting when when a lot of these security guys, military, law enforcement, first jumped in headfirst into security for mission agencies. Well, the problem with building a box of security policies and procedures is that sometimes God works outside the box. Yeah. What if he calls you out? What if he calls you out? And and and now at minimum you've got this friction between the organization who's still who's being bought into this philosophy we keep people safe versus helping people to go to the ends of the earth. by managing their risk well. Look, let's be really clear. Toda using today as an example, hey, back in tw two thousand one. An unreached people in the 21st century unreached and unengaged for a reason. It's it's hard to get to them, which means that sentiment alone is not going to get you there. And by the way, safety programs alone are not going to get you there. It's about learning to manage risk and understanding that managing risk and the security risk management programs that should come as a part of that should be laying that security strategy on top of the mission instead of building a box around the mission. And that's how we find out that we don't separate security from strategy or identity, legitimacy, tying it to duty of care, the need for information. Information security, InfoSec, Communication Security, ComSec, but also the need for member care. And driving all of that are the theological underpinnings that give the rationality for why, and then the mission objectives that give it the how. And that's really, I think, the benefit since 9-11. I'd say post-2000. I'll just call it ten. About two thousand ten. Yeah. And going forward. Cause by two thousand fourteen, when when concilium started, my whole focus and and and and stand was look, crisis management training is important, but the ounce of prevention is worth a pound of cure. Well hey, if we could put more focus on security risk management and training people to decrease their vulnerability to threat on the field, then that's one less time we're gonna have to activate the crisis team in the first place. Mm-hmm. So if I can train people to keep from from succumbing to risk, that's one less time I have to activate the the crisis team. And so what we began doing through those that we were training in in this, you know, what we call our CAS program and our race program was helping organizations look at, okay, through this training, how many times in the last five years did you have to activate your crisis management team? Okay. Five years ago, I'm just throwing out numbers here, it was it was five times. And now after having this training two or three years in, it's it's once a year. So what you've seen with with wisdom is individuals learning how to decrease their vulnerability to threat, increase the opportunity towards obedience by managing their risk well, because now their vulnerability isn't being overwhelmed by the threat. Why? Because how how do we quantify risk? It's where threat and vulnerability meet, right? And that's where you quantify the risk. Well if the threat never meets the vulnerabil I'm sorry, if the if the vulnerability never meets the threat, we don't have a risk. That's the win. That's the win. Yeah. And that's been the big shift really post two thousand ten, twelve, thirteen, fourteen, and what brings us to today. That's the shift. It's a really important paradigm change. But more reactive, more it seems much more intentional, much more organized, much more just being better stewards with the resources in general as you're approaching this subject. Well i i it's it's a two-way street. Okay. If if you're trusting in your security plan, then you're not trusting in God. These were the the the the cultural pushbacks. Well the problem is, and even today, it's it's a pro problem prior to 9-11, it's a problem today, is is you have people who are stepping out in what what I call blind faith. In other words, they're stepping out in ways that God never called and then expecting his protection in ways that he never promised. Yeah. And and and what what does that blind faith lead to? Tragedy. Yeah. What's the tragedy lead to? Disillusionment. People deconstructing their faith. And at minimum saying, well, if this is what it's like to serve the Lord, I'll never do it again. Because they they said, But Lord, I trusted you, I stepped out for you, I risked for you. But come to find out the risks that they're taking were in clear violation of his word. Which which brings us to, you know, the the difference between say blind faith versus subjective faith, which which is basically I can do all things through a verse taken out of context. And where does that lead? Right? To tragedy, to disillusionment, to people deconstructing their faith. so that's that's one side of trying to balance this beam. But but the other side of the beam was that that security management had to had to modify. In in other words, you you can't bring that value system from the military or from law enforcement directly into missions because because in law enforcement and military, you typically hold safety as the highest value versus the gospel. In fact, we have a term for it today. We call it those guys that come in from the military and law enforcement, they need to demil or or they need to unblue. And Really what you're talking about is those men and women coming from professional law enforcement or military, they have to be discipled. Yeah. Because it's a paradigm shift for them. It it sure is. Yeah. Yeah. Absolutely. And and what's come out of this is that there's been a more mature vocabulary that's that's developed in which prudence and faithfulness are not opposites. Prudence and faithfulness are not opposites. Flesh that out little more. Well, the the prudence. Let's take Matthew 11. Or sorry, Matthew chapter 10 and Luke chapter 10. Okay. Okay. Jesus is sending out his disciples for the first time. Very interesting. You get Luke, the physician. Uh-huh. He's he's philosophical. What does he focus on with with Jesus' sermon or guidance? It it's it's the harvest is plentiful, but the workers are few. Okay. And how many times has that been quoted? Every missions conference, at least. Right? Yeah. And and and then but then you go to Matthew, who's a tax collector, Matthew chapter 10. He's gonna focus on Jesus' safety briefing. Hmm. Yeah, he he he begins by warning them that you know not to be sheep to the wolves. And in order not to be sheep to the woods, because this is a metaphor, he says to be as shrewd as serpents, yet innocent as doves. And that word shrewdness. It's wisdom, but it's wisdom to your advantage. Jesus is saying, use this wisdom to your advantage. But as you do that, be innocent as you do so. He he's telling them not to go out alone. He's he's gonna send them two by two. He he he he teaches them that if you come to a village and they don't receive you, he doesn't say come up with creative ways to access the village. Actually says the opposite is knock the dust off of your feet. It'll be worse for that village on the day of judgment than it is for Sodom and Gomorrah. Yeah, right. But if you're if you're welcomed into the village, ask a blessing on the village or into a home, ask a blessing upon the home. Well, what is what do we call this today? We think we've discovered this all of a sudden. We call it acceptance strategy. And that's not our acceptance of the risk, it's it's it's the local community's acceptance of us. That's the foundation, the building blocks for for for risk for security risk management, is having acceptance in in the community. That's where you start to build on your principles of safety. on that security triangle and and deterrence which is the other arm of that of that triangle but it's all built on the foundation of of acceptance so this this then because it goes back to that idea of prudence and faithfulness are not are not opposites it means that the Lord wants me to be prudent because security watch this is rooted in stewardship It's the stewardship of time, resources, and lives. Yeah. Stewardship is an act of worship. But it's typically not an emotional act of worship. Just like giving your tithe. You typically don't have people going, woo, when they when they put their money in the plate. Or or for most of us today, we we it comes out of our our bank account because we've set it as as a as an EFT and it just comes out automatically and we we set it and forget it. Right. And yet it's still just as as important of an act of worship as that emotional feeling of singing, you know, or or hearing the sermon. Because it's what happens when we leave the sermon and things start being applied. Well, that's that's the prudence. It's not just emotional. So yeah, it's our Our security, security management's rooted in stewardship. Stewardship is an act of worship. And throughout the New Testament, Jesus is going to make it clear that we need to manage our risk well, not because we're faithless, but because we're faithful and good stewards of what God has given us. Yeah. Yeah. And so important with this whole subject that we're talking about here. It's it's interwoven all the way throughout It's I I like how you unpack that there. you got a few minutes for some true or false questions, Scott, as we kind of close out our time together. Okay. As it's S. Here we go. All right. This is where there's only one right answer. You can also say it it's complicated if you need to. We'll allow a third answer. So true or false. International ministry was safer before nine eleven. False. Anything to tag on or just go go go No, no, no, no. You go through See all the above. See all the above. Yeah, yeah. Everything that I just said. No, it it's false. Yeah, absolutely. True or false. Technology has made international ministry significantly safer than it was twenty-five years ago. Hmm. No, false. Technol technology is very helpful, but it doesn't make you safer necessarily. It helps with communication, for sure, but not necessarily safer by decreasing vulnerability to threat. No, just an additional tool for us in the in the toolbox. That's right. True or false, most churches sending short term mission teams today are adequately prepared for a serious crisis. false. Okay. As evidenced by a lot of stories we could probably share if we had a just in twenty twenty six alone, the number of short term mission teams that we've had trouble with, my goodness, yes. The list continues to grow. And I'm glad they go. Don't get me wrong. I'm glad they're going. Right. True or false, Americans generally underestimate how much US foreign policy affects how they're perceived overseas. True. Hmm. I found that out in Nairobi this year when USAID was cut. And I was staying in a Nairobi n well in the Kenyan hotel. It wasn't a Western hotel. And they knew that we were there and they literally put a newspaper. They didn't give out the newspaper. They put the newspaper there for us to see. Like just not that they're gonna hurt us, yeah. But they were very disappointed and it impacted our relationships as a result. my goodness. Yeah, very interesting. That would have been interesting. All right, last one. True or false. twenty five years after nine eleven, the world is more dangerous. for gospel workers than it was in 2001. I don't think it is more dangerous. I I I think it's false. But I I would say that get given the calling that God has entrusted to us. We we have to continually ask the question: what constitutes faithful, wise, non-negligent stewardship of people in ministry? And I say that as a leader, especially for those that we have a duty of care towards. What what what constitutes this faithful, wise, and non-negligent stewardship of the people that are entrusted to our care? Good thoughts to close on. Well, Scott, you unpacked a lot of things in there. You shared a lot of good wisdom, a lot of insight, a lot of perspective. And twenty-five years is a long time. Yeah. Long enough that September eleventh has moved from something that we all watched unfold in real time to something an entire generation now knows really only in history, pictures and videos. But as we've talked about today, it's its impact didn't end on that day. It it helped shape the world that churches, mission organizations, and the gospel workers are are still navigating today. And maybe that's one of the reasons conversations like this are helpful And we want to thank our guests for stopping in and reflecting with us. Many of us live through those events while others have only seen it pictures and video. it's been a quarter of a century. it's an event that we'll probably never forget. At the end of the day, though, it is a history-breaking moment that reminds us of the the world is in deep need of Jesus. If any of you have any questions that you would like to send our way, feel free to send them to info at concilium.us. We'd love to hear from you and would be delighted to share any thoughts we may have regarding your questions. Also, as a reminder, you can find us on Facebook and LinkedIn as well if you are into the social media realm. Well, we hope to see you all further down on the path, and may your ministry be faithful, resilient, and effective.