Latest / Coffee and Crime with Mom / Who Killed 5-Year-Old Paitin Fields? | The Uncle on Trial
Transcript
- Nicholle: Two little sisters were sleeping on a couch in the living room of their grandparents' North Carolina home. One was seven, the other was just five. It was November 13, 2017, and in the early hours of that morning, according to the prosecution's account, the older sister woke up and noticed someone near the couch, someone familiar, her uncle. She later described watching him walk toward his bedroom. When she looked at her little sister, something was wrong. Her eyes looked strange. She wasn't responding normally. The older girl tried to wake the adults. They did not yet understand what was happening. She was sent back toward the living room, back to the couch, back to her sister. Before the morning was over, the younger child would be fighting for her life. Doctors would find injuries that suggested this was no medical accident, and it would take nearly five years before an arrest. Her name was Paitin Fields, she was five years old, and this is her story. Zalle: see, let's to you. This is another one of those cases where I don't know the story. Nicholle: Welcome back to Coffee and Crime with Mom. I'm Nicholle. And I'm Facebook. Zalle: And I'm Zalle. Today's case is especially difficult because it involves a little girl, her family, and a trial that is happening right now. We're going to discuss a child's death and evidence of sexual violence. Nicholle: We will distinguish what witnesses testify to, what prosecutors allege, and what the defense disputes. If this subject is too much today, please take care of yourself and choose another episode. Zalle: And before we begin, if you appreciate carefully researched conversations like this one, please follow or subscribe to Coughing Crime with Mom, leave a rating or review where you listen, and share the episode with someone who values thoughtful true crime coverage. We'd also love to hear your perspective after you've heard the evidence, but please remember that a real family is at the center of this case. Nicholle: One more thing. We are recording on Monday, October 12th for release on Thursday. We'll tell you where the proceedings stood at the time of recording. Please check the episode description for any later verified update. Now let's go back to Pender County, North Carolina in November of 2017. Paitin and her older sister, Savannah, were living with their maternal grandparents, Lisa and Del Hunt. Lisa later told the court that the arrangement was a family decision, not a court ordered placement. The girls had been there for more than two years. It is important to start here because a courtroom can reduce a child to a name on a medical chart. Paitin was a little girl with a sister and a household routine. We do not have to invent favorite foods or childhood memories to recognize the life that was lost. Zalle: The girls often slept in the living room on a large couch. Their uncle David Wesley Private, was Lisa's son and Dell's stepson. He was nineteen. According to the family testimony, he moved between relatives' homes and had returned after a disagreement with his girlfriend. His presence in the house was not, by itself, unusual. The prosecution would later focus on where everyone was sleeping, who was awake and who had access to the living room. Nicholle: The weekend before the emergency, Paitin had been coughing and seemed more tired than usual. Her grandmother remembered her falling asleep in a recliner, something that stood out because she was normally active. We need to be careful not to turn that into an explanation for what happened next. It is simply part of the family's recollection of the last ordinary days before the emergency. Zalle: On Sunday night, Lisa said she carried Paitin from the grandparents' bedroom to the couch where Savannah was already sleeping. David came home later and Lisa let him in before going back to bed. By the family's account, the grandparents, David, and the two girls were all inside the home. It is a small group of people, but a small group does not make the answer obvious. That distinction becomes crucial when we get to the trial. Nicholle: in the early morning of November 13th, Savannah noticed that something was wrong with her younger sister. Years later, she described seeing her uncle near the couch before he went back to his bedroom. That detail is part of the prosecution's case and we will return to when it first appeared in her interview. For now, immediate reality is that a seven-year-old was trying to communicate that her sister was not acting normally. Zalle: When Lisa eventually went into the living room and saw Paitin, she screamed. Dell and David responded Rather than wait for an ambulance, the family drove the child to Pinder Memorial Hospital Nicholle: The defense has different size both including rest of the sense of addresses. Prosecutors have a different interpretation of evidence about the same thing that the defense decides life second process later than those things. Zalle: In Burgal, the defense has emphasized David's efforts to help, including attempts at rescue breathing. Prosecutors have a different interpretation of the evidence surrounding him. The same emergency that the defense describes as a life saving contact would later matter when jurors heard about DNA on clothing. Nicholle: Paitin arrived unconscious in the early morning. Medical workers began emergency treatment and saw injuries that raised immediate concerns about strangulation and sexual trauma. She was transferred to a larger hospital in Wilmington. Her condition did not improve. Paitin died on November 16, three days after she was brought to the first hospital. It is worth sitting with that for a moment. A family went from putting two sisters to bed to an intensive care emergency and then to the death of a five year old child. Zalle: The medical findings made clear that investigators could not treat this simply as an unexplained illness. But medicine could answer a different question from the one police and the jury ultimately faced. Doctors could assess injuries and cause of death. They could not, from those findings alone, identify the person who inflicted them. Nicholle: The autopsy concluded that Paitin died from a lack of oxygen caused by ligature strangulation. A ligature is an object such as a cord tightened around the neck. The forensic pathologist described marks and other physical findings consistent with that mechanism. Medical testimony also addressed injuries raising concerns about sexual assault. We will not narrate those injuries graphically. What matters for understanding the trial is that the medical findings established a violent injury. Not merely a child becoming ill overnight. Yeah, that's that's heavy. Mm-hmm. Zalle: Makes my blood boil. It makes my blood just boil. It makes me Nicholle: I know. Zalle: Feed to the pigs. That's how I feel. Nicholle: Yes. When you Zalle: One detail that caught the attention of investigators was a U-shaped mark on Peyton's neck. The pathologist said it was consistent with a red earbud cord collected from the home. But consistent with does not mean proven to be. Other cords were Nicholle: That's consistently spread. Early collects and Consistent width does not smooth. Other particles. Zalle: also possibilities, and the pathologist could not identify Nicholle: Not exactly. Zalle: the exact object. The limitation is not a technicality. It is part of what Nicholle: The limitation is not with the challenge. It is part of Zalle: the jury Nicholle: the Zalle: must weigh. Nicholle: agreement. Those red earbuds became a recurring object in this case, not because we know exactly what they did, but because the state believed they could connect the physical findings to an item associated with David. The defense argued there were innocent reasons for DNA to be present on an item used around a family home. When we hear the phrase DNA match, it is tempting to treat it as the end of the story. In a shared household, it can be the beginning of a much harder question. How did the DNA get there and when? Zalle: Investigators searched the home shortly after Paitin was taken to the hospital and returned for additional evidence collection. They gathered clothing, cords, bedding, and other possible evidence. Some items were moved or collected later, and the defense has questioned how some material was packaged and preserved. Those concerns do not automatically invalidate every result. They do require the jury to evaluate how reliably the evidence links a particular person to a particular act. Nicholle: Investigators also examined David. A detective later testified about the appearance of his fingernails on one day and that they looked cut and cleaner the next. it is the sort of observation that can sound ominous in a courtroom, but without proof of why someone cut their nails, we should not tell our audience that the act itself proves guilt. David denied harming Paitin. He maintained that he responded to the emergency and tried to save her. Zalle: David was publicly identified as a suspect in 2018 in reporting about a separate charge involving a threat against the lead investigator. Still, the murder arrests did not come that year. Investigators continued working the case, including later evidence collection at the house. In November 2022, David was arrested in Louisiana and brought back to North Carolina to face charges. Why was he in Louisiana? How do you get down? Nicholle: I don't know. That nearly five year gap is one of the biggest questions in this case. What did investigators learn? What evidence was reexamined? And how much of the eventual prosecution rests on testimony or testing that came years after the night itself? Those are fair questions to ask without deciding in advance what the answers must be. In 2026, the case finally reached a jury. David pleaded not guilty to first degree murder and two first-degree sexual offense charges involving a child. There is one witness whose perspective is impossible to ignore, Savannah, the sister sleeping near Paitin. She was seven in 2017. Jurors heard forensic interviews from 2017, 2018, and 2022. Her later description of seeing David near the couch was not reported. Zalle: There is one with us whose perspective is impossible to inform, Savannah, the sister Sidney near Pavy. She was seven in 2017. Jurors heard forensic interviews from 2017, 2018, and 2022. Her later description of seeing David near the college was not reported Nicholle: in the same way in the earliest interviews. Zalle: in the same way in 1915. Nicholle: That matters. It also matters that we're discussing a child trying to describe a traumatic night Zalle: That matters. It also matters that we're discussing a child trying to describe a dramatic night Nicholle: years before she could have imagined herself at the center of a murder trial. Zalle: years before she left imagining herself at the center of America's life. That poor baby. Poor child. He he's a monster. If that's what happened Nicholle: Poor child. That's what happened. Zalle: and like her recollection is correct, and it was her uncle and not somebody else. Whoever did it. Monster. Yes. Monster. Nicholle: Yes, definitely. Zalle: The prosecution presented her later account as evidence that David was near Paitin at a critical moment. Nicholle: The bins put the five characters. Zalle: defense questioned why that recollection emerged later and whether time, repeated interviews, or outside information could have affected her memory. Neither side's interpretation should be substituted for the interview recordings themselves. An inconsistency does not automatically mean a witness is lying, and a sincere recollection is not automatically accurate. Nicholle: Think about the burden that places on jurors. They are asked to listen carefully to a child's words across several years and decide how much weight to give them. It would be irresponsible for us to dramatize Savannah's thoughts or put dialogue in her mouth. What we can say is that her testimony became a major point of disagreement, and the difference between the early interviews and the 2002 account is essential. Zalle: essential to the case. And that leads to a question for listeners. If you were evaluating a memory that became more specific years later, what cooperation would you want to see? That is not an invitation to attack Savannah. Let's start there. It is a reminder that witness accounts, especially from children, need to be assessed carefully and compassionately because it's not a like her brain didn't block that out at the beginning and she got that memory back later. Nicholle: Right. Yeah. Zalle: We're not just gonna be like, she's lying because trauma affects the brain in in a lot of different ways and I'm beyond yeah, Nicholle: And she's so young. Zalle: and I'm beyond sure that was traumatic. And then she was sent back to the couch where her sister was at. Nicholle: Right, when she tried to tell people. Zalle: Yeah. Nicholle: On October eighth, forensic scientists described results from the state crime lab. The test of sexual assault kit material did not yield a positive result for semen, And a DNA analyst said no usable male DNA was recovered from the tested kit items or other swabs. That does not erase the medical findings. It does mean the biological testing did not provide a straightforward identification of the attacker from those samples. Zalle: A genital squaw squab squab Nicholle: Well, we are struggling. We are s we are both struggling. We are both struggling. It's on both sides. It is ridiculous. That we cannot say normal words. Normal words. I think Johanzen can come say that five times fast. Zalle: Whoa, okay. A genital swab Nicholle: Whoa. Whoa. Zalle: collected from David produced a mixed DNA profile from three people, but Paitin was not identified as a Contributor. Other items produced different results, including material associated with the red earbuds. According to the testimony reported from court, DNA consisted with Paitin and David appeared in the evidence that prosecutors considered significant. But DNA on an object cannot by itself show precisely when it was deposited or whether the object was used in an assault. Nicholle: The defense also argued that contact during the effort to get Paitin to the hospital could explain some DNA on David's clothing. That is an alternate explanation jurors must assess against the complete record, and the evidence collection process itself drew scrutiny. Questions about packaging, items collected years later, and material that was unavailable for testing. It would be a mistake to call this case a DNA slam dunk. Zalle: Argued that prospecting the effort to get paid into the hospital could explain some DNA on the exposed. That is an ultimate explanation jurist must assess against the public record. And the evidence packaging process itself is true. Questions about packaging, items collected years later, and material that was unavailable for testing. It would be a mistake to call this case a DNA spent out. It would be just as mistaken to say a negative statement test. Nicholle: It would be just as mistaken to say a negative semen test proves no assault occurred. The forensic evidence has to be read together with the medical and witness testimony. Zalle: For to know a self-operative. The forensic evidence has to be read together, and that's why discussed. This is why courtroom cases are rarely as neat as a 30-second video makes them seem. Different kinds of evidence answers different questions. Medical findings can describe an injury. DNA can identify possible contributors to a sample. Witnesses can describe what they recall. None of those sources should be made to say more than it actually says. Nicholle: Here's the prosecution's case in its broadest form. Paitin suffered fatal strangulation and sexual injuries in a house with a limited number of people present. Prosecutors point to Savannah's later recollection, the medical findings, and selected forensic results as a pattern they believe implicates David. They do not need one piece of evidence to tell the whole story if the combined evidence proves the charges beyond a reasonable doubt. Zalle: And here's the defense's broad response. David denied the attack and says he helped when Paitin was found unresponsive. His attorneys have challenged the timing and reliability of Savannah's later recollection, disputed how DNA is being interpreted, and raised concerns about evidence handling and the direction of the investigation. The defense does not have to prove who else committed the crime. The prosecution carries the burden of proving its allegations. Nicholle: And that is a difficult but necessary distinction. It is possible to be certain that a child was violently harmed while remaining careful about the separate question of who is criminally responsible. Our job on coffee and crime is not to manufacture certainty. It is to help listeners understand what is known, what is contested, and what remains for the jury. And I just want to say something real quick. I think it's crazy how, say ten years ago, if you had DNA and DNA said this certain thing, that was it. That was the end of the story that person was going down. We have since learned that while DNA is a great tool to use, it is not the end all be all of evidence. We have to look at everything. Zalle: The trial began with jury selection in late September 2026. Testimony began October 1st. By Thursday, October 8th jurors had heard medical evidence, investigators, interviews involving Savannah, and testimony from forensic scientists. Court was not scheduled for Friday, October 9th, and proceedings were set to resume Monday, October 12th, which is today. Nicholle: Presume proper time is the day we were recording. Zalle: Yeah. Nicholle: Because our episode is releasing Thursday and any significant development after we record will be added to the description or a clearly dated update. David Prevate remains presumed innocent unless an until the jury finds him guilty. I keep returning to the image we began with. Two little sisters on a couch. One seven, one five. Whatever jurors ultimately decide about David Prevate, there's no dispute that Paitin died after a violent injury. The trial is an attempt to answer who was responsible using evidence collected across many years. Paitin deserves a story told with accuracy and dignity, not speculation dressed up. As a fact. And so that's what I do. Zalle: And Savannah deserves care too. She was a child when this happened, and the details she has been asked to revisit are deeply painful. I mean, we could not imagine. So we Nicholle: No. So we Zalle: hope the legal process treats everyone involved with the seriousness this case requires. Nicholle: Thank you for spending time with us on Coffee and Crime with Mom If you found this episode informative, follow or subscribe. Leave a review and share it. Tell us what questions the evidence raised for you, but please keep your comments respectful of Paitin, Savannah, and the people involved. We'll continue following verified developments and update you as the case progresses. Until next time, take care of yourselves and each other. Bye! Zalle: Bye.