Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / The Rule Follower: How Legal Culture Drives Mental Health Crises in the Profession
Transcript
- 0:03Good morning, everyone. Excuse me. Good afternoon,
- 0:06everyone. My name's Dean Sirwin. I'm the chair
- 0:09of the Beverly Hills Bar Association's wellness
- 0:12section. Very excited that we have this section.
- 0:15As many of you may or may not know, when you
- 0:18have your MCLE requirement, there are those certain
- 0:21hard to get specialty items, one of which is
- 0:25competency. And that usually deals a lot with
- 0:29mental health and substance abuse issues, but
- 0:33the bar in its wisdom has allowed that one of
- 0:36those two hours can be in wellness, which is
- 0:39a more rounded concept that involves emotional
- 0:45well -being as well. We have a lot of programs
- 0:49on breath technique, meditation, tapping, meditation,
- 0:54things like that. I encourage you to check them
- 0:57out. As you may also know, we have the BHBA on
- 1:00demand, which is sort of like a YouTube for MCLE.
- 1:05By the way, I don't know if any of you are coming
- 1:07in from out of state, but the BHBA is authorized
- 1:12and empowered to provide a CLE for every state
- 1:16in the country that requires CLE. There's still
- 1:18one or two, I think, that don't. So if you have
- 1:22colleagues in other states, they can join. They
- 1:24can come and check out these panels. and get
- 1:28their MCLE requirements met. The one thing I
- 1:31really love about the MCLE, the way we do it
- 1:34is you have a locker. So when you watch this,
- 1:37you'll get a certificate, but you'll also, if
- 1:40you're a BHBA member, have it logged in your
- 1:43MCLE locker. So when it comes time to do that
- 1:47every three -year compliance, it's a couple of
- 1:50clicks. And you can also see, how many hours
- 1:53you have of each required competency so that
- 1:57you can go, oh, I need another one on competency.
- 2:00I need another one on, oh, I forget what the
- 2:04required ones are. But it's really easy to do.
- 2:08And there's great programs there like this one
- 2:11that are timely, up to the minute. When a new
- 2:14case comes down or some administrative rulings
- 2:17or things like that, we're going to usually have
- 2:19a program up within a week. We've got one or
- 2:22two a day, and I won't go into all the stats,
- 2:26but that's basically it. Your certificate will
- 2:30come to you automatically. The materials for
- 2:32this, if you didn't receive them by email, they're
- 2:35in the chat. This is a webinar, so you can't
- 2:40use the chat, but you can use the Q &A, and questions
- 2:45will be answered at the end. So with that, I'm
- 2:47gonna introduce our speaker. Bo Baez, and for
- 2:53his program, The Rule Follower, How Legal Culture
- 2:56Drives Mental Health Crisis in the Profession.
- 2:59Very excited about this program. Bo Baez is a
- 3:03professor at Ohio Northern University College
- 3:05of Law. He spent his career in legal education,
- 3:10teaching at law schools across the country and
- 3:13covering 15 different courses. along the way.
- 3:16That's very impressive, which gives him a wide
- 3:19angle view of the profession that he's going
- 3:22to be examining in this program. So with that,
- 3:24I'm going to say thank you again, Beau, for being
- 3:27here. Thank you to all our participants. And
- 3:30again, this will be in that locker. You can go
- 3:33look at the BHB On Demand. You can watch it again.
- 3:36You can send your friends and colleagues to it.
- 3:40Thank you, Beau. Thank you, Dean. Let me now
- 3:43share my screen. You don't want to see a talking
- 3:45head for the next hour. And make sure I've got
- 3:49the right one open. I think here we go, application
- 3:52window. And I think we're up and running. I'll
- 3:58rely on them to tell me if I were not. So again,
- 4:01good afternoon. Welcome again to the CLE. So
- 4:08what I want to start off with is a little bit
- 4:09about my how this presentation came about. It
- 4:13draws upon my recent published scholarship. I
- 4:17have an article that's published in the Capital
- 4:19University Law Review, which explores the intersection
- 4:22between legal pedagogy, professional conditioning,
- 4:26and depth psychology. So for the next hour or
- 4:30so, we're gonna bypass the comfortable platitudes
- 4:34that dominate typical discussions of attorney
- 4:37well -being. We're not going to talk about the
- 4:39generic lifestyle advice instead. We're going
- 4:43to focus on the psyche. And we're going to look
- 4:48at our institutions, how our profession venerates
- 4:52the rule follower and ultimately helps in a negative
- 4:59way to detach our psyche from our humanity, which
- 5:06creates mental health and substance abuse. problems
- 5:09in our profession. So I want to begin by addressing
- 5:14an uncomfortable reality regarding how our profession
- 5:18talks to itself about mental health. Seems like
- 5:22every year the bar journals run special editions
- 5:25related to wellness, every year law firms host
- 5:30seminars during National Wellbeing Week, and
- 5:33without fail, they'll ask everybody to download
- 5:38an app. and the app helps us with breathing,
- 5:42suggests yoga meditation at 6 .30 before we go
- 5:45to the office, drink more water, take a brisk
- 5:4910 -minute walk. And by the way, those are all
- 5:51good things. I don't want to disparage healthy
- 5:54habits, but we must be intellectually candid,
- 5:59offering an attorney who is suffering from clinical
- 6:02depression, chronic sleep deprivation, or chemical
- 6:06dependency, offering them an app It's like giving
- 6:10a bandage to somebody who is bleeding out of
- 6:13an artery. It does not simply fail to cure the
- 6:17underlying injury, but it insults the intelligence
- 6:20of the person who is bleeding. And more perniciously,
- 6:25these interventions subtly shift the moral burden
- 6:27entirely to the lawyer. The implicit institutional
- 6:31message is unmistakable. The economic model is
- 6:35sound. Billable targets are reasonable. the adversarial
- 6:39culture is healthy, you simply need to breathe
- 6:42more efficiently. Well, I'm here today to present
- 6:46a radically different thesis. The mental health
- 6:49crisis in the legal profession is not an aggregate
- 6:54failure of individual resilience. It's an inevitable
- 6:59structural outcome. It's the direct consequence
- 7:03of a specific psychological conditioning that
- 7:06begins on the first day of law school. solidifies
- 7:09during bar prep and calcifies over decades of
- 7:13practice. The profession selects for, grooms,
- 7:17and relies upon a specific character pattern,
- 7:21the rule follower. Now, to solve this crisis,
- 7:24we have to look past the superficial symptoms
- 7:27and examine its foundational psychic roots. Now
- 7:34to appreciate why this inquiry is urgent, we
- 7:37have to anchor ourselves in empirical data. which
- 7:40demonstrates that psychological distress in our
- 7:43profession is not an isolated occupational hazard.
- 7:48It's an industry baseline. So in 2016, Patrick
- 7:53Krill, Ryan Johnson, and Linda Albert published
- 7:56a landmark empirical study in the Journal of
- 7:59Addiction Medicine. They examined 13 ,000 practicing
- 8:03attorneys across the country. Their findings
- 8:07remain the empirical benchmark for our field.
- 8:10And you can see the data, 20 .6 % of licensed
- 8:14practicing attorneys screen positive for hazardous,
- 8:19harmful, and potentially alcohol -dependent drinking.
- 8:23And when you look at younger lawyers, those under
- 8:2630, that percentage goes up to almost 32%. 28
- 8:33% of practitioners reported clinically significant
- 8:36active symptoms of depression. 19 % struggle
- 8:40with severe chronic anxiety, 23 % suffer from
- 8:45profound debilitating occupational stress. Now,
- 8:49let's pause on those numbers for a second. Nearly
- 8:52one out of every three junior attorneys sitting
- 8:56in our law firms and corporate legal departments
- 8:59is engaging in hazardous drinking simply to cope
- 9:03with the reality of their daily practice. I mean,
- 9:07in no other licensed profession do we accept
- 9:09a 30 % chemical dependency rate as the cost of
- 9:13doing business. When pathology reaches a scale,
- 9:16it causes systemic and not personal. So now,
- 9:24what psychological mechanisms drive these alarming
- 9:29numbers? A pivotal survey emerged that was conducted
- 9:34by NALP and Krill Strategies called the Survey
- 9:37on Lawyer Perfectionists. perfectionism, and
- 9:40well -being. The researchers investigated the
- 9:43phenomenon known as the perfectionist paradox,
- 9:46and they established a vital distinction between
- 9:50two fundamentally different patterns. First,
- 9:54adaptive striving. This is the healthy pursuit
- 9:57of professional excellence characterized by pride
- 10:01in craftsmanship, diligence, and resilient recovery
- 10:05when outcomes don't go as planned. On the flip
- 10:09side, we have the maladaptive perfectionism,
- 10:13an obsessive terror -driven avoidance of mistake,
- 10:19characterized by rigid external compliance, catastrophic
- 10:23fear of error, and harsh punitive self -judgment.
- 10:27Now, the empirical data reveals that attorneys
- 10:31exhibiting high maladaptive perfectionism experience
- 10:34twice the occupational stress four times the
- 10:38anxiety and more than seven times the rate of
- 10:41depression compared to peers who scored low on
- 10:44that metric. So notice who's being destroyed
- 10:48by our culture. It's not the slacker. It's not
- 10:51the careless attorney who cuts corners or ignores
- 10:54court rules. The crisis consumes the most hyper
- 10:59conscientious rule bound practitioners. It strikes
- 11:03the star associate who checks every citation
- 11:06three times, stays till the office till three
- 11:10in the morning, and ruminates obsessively over
- 11:13a single ambiguous clause in an email. The crisis
- 11:17belongs to the ultimate rule followers. So what
- 11:26exactly is the rule follower archetype? So in
- 11:31our culture, the rule follower is not merely
- 11:33someone who stops at red lights, or files court
- 11:36documents on time, so they certainly do those
- 11:38things. The rule follower is an individual who
- 11:41has constructed their entire psychological identity,
- 11:46their sense of personal safety, and their fundamental
- 11:49self -worth around external rules, procedural
- 11:53conformity, and rigorous avoidance of external
- 11:57censure. Now, this development trajectory begins
- 12:01long before legal training, from childhood. This
- 12:05individual discovered that the safest path through
- 12:09an unpredictable world is deference to authority.
- 12:13When parents, teachers, or administrators set
- 12:17down a boundary, the rule follower doesn't push
- 12:20back. They master it. They don't challenge the
- 12:24rubric. They memorize. When they get to college,
- 12:29they do not read a syllabus to discover intellectual
- 12:33passion. They read it to identify the grading
- 12:36scale, asking, and this is one I get on a regular
- 12:38basis, will this specific concept be on the final
- 12:41exam? The one question all professors hate to
- 12:46hear. Now, eventually, this candidate arrives
- 12:49at the law school admissions office. To the admissions
- 12:53committee, the individual is ideal raw material,
- 12:563 .9 undergraduate GPA, a high LSAT score, pristine
- 13:02character and fitness disclosures. Perfect, admitted.
- 13:08Now the legal profession actively selects for
- 13:10this archetype because the machinery of modern
- 13:13law is an extraordinarily complex bureaucratic
- 13:17system that demands rigorous procedural fidelity.
- 13:22Our courts, regulatory agencies, and our transactional
- 13:26closing checklists cannot function without technicians
- 13:30who will scrupulously adhere to detailed procedural
- 13:34rules. However, when a human being organizes
- 13:40their entire psyche around external compliance,
- 13:43they make a devastating Faustian bargain. They
- 13:48trade away their internal guidance system, their
- 13:52emotional compass, and their personal autonomy.
- 13:56And for what? Well, they replace their authentic
- 14:00internal conscience with an external rule book.
- 14:03In doing so, they become a brilliant legal technician
- 14:06who is completely severed from their own living
- 14:09soul. They believe that as long as they follow
- 14:12the rules with absolute precision, they're safe.
- 14:17And that illusion is precisely what the practice
- 14:20of law will shatter. So how does this latent
- 14:26psychological tendency transform into a calcified
- 14:31pathology? It occurs through the neurogenetic
- 14:36machinery of American legal education. This term
- 14:40was coined by legal scholars to describe how
- 14:43the pedagogical process of legal training itself
- 14:47manufactures psychological illness. In their
- 14:52landmark multi -year empirical study published
- 14:54by the George Washington Law Review in 2015,
- 14:58professors Kriger and Sheldon track thousands
- 15:01of law students from their initial orientation
- 15:04through several years into practice. And what
- 15:08they discovered should trouble every law professor
- 15:11and legal employer in this country. So when students
- 15:16matriculate into law school in August, guess
- 15:19what? Their psychological profiles are virtually
- 15:23indistinguishable from the general public. In
- 15:27fact, their baseline measures of life satisfaction
- 15:32self -esteem and positive effect are slightly
- 15:36higher than average. Within five months, by the
- 15:41end of their first semester of their 1L year,
- 15:45those metrics collapse. Rates of clinical depression
- 15:49spike dramatically. Subjective life satisfaction
- 15:53drops precipitously. Generalized anxiety becomes
- 15:57an endemic feature of daily existence. More critically,
- 16:03Krieger and Sheldon tracked a profound motivational
- 16:06shift. They documented that over the course of
- 16:10the first year, students systematically abandoned
- 16:14what psychologists classify as intrinsic values,
- 16:19the organic desire for community, personal moral
- 16:23purpose, emotional authenticity, and human connection.
- 16:27In their place, students value extrinsic values.
- 16:31What's your class rank under the mandatory grading
- 16:35curve, right? Law review selection, starting
- 16:38salaries and rigid external validation. Oh, I
- 16:42got into this law firm versus that law firm.
- 16:47So in less than 150 days, the law school classroom
- 16:50systematically strips away the internal anchors
- 16:54that keep a human being healthy, replacing them
- 16:57with a relentless drive for external complaints.
- 17:01Now, this is on me as a law professor and my
- 17:04cast, and I am doing some things in my classroom
- 17:08to try to minimize this. More, if you want to
- 17:11read my article, I kind of talk about what law
- 17:13professors can do. But today, we're going to
- 17:15talk about our profession as a whole. So the
- 17:20pedagogical shift was not an accident of history.
- 17:23It traces directly back to Christopher Columbus
- 17:26Langdell, who introduced the formalistic Socratic
- 17:30casebook method at Harvard Law School in the
- 17:321870s. Langdell conceived of law as an inductive
- 17:39empirical science. He famously asserted that
- 17:43all the relevant raw materials of the science,
- 17:48the legal science, are contained within the bound
- 17:53pages of printed appellate opinions. Now consider
- 17:58what that pedagogical revolution accomplished.
- 18:03It took human conflict, the grief of an injured
- 18:07laborer, devastation of a fractured family found
- 18:12in family law cases, the visceral terror of a
- 18:15criminal defendant, and stripped it of all flesh,
- 18:20blood, and moral reality. It transformed profound
- 18:25human suffering into sterile geometric line drawings
- 18:30suitable for academic dissection. In the modern
- 18:361L classroom, when an unconditioned student reacts
- 18:39to an unjust fact pattern by stating, well, professor,
- 18:43that outcome feels fundamentally unfair to the
- 18:45plaintiff. What is the standard pedagogical response?
- 18:51The professor smiles, maybe doesn't even smile,
- 18:54and replies, that's very touching, counsel, but
- 18:57what is the rule? What is the procedural posture?
- 19:01What are the elements in the case? Ignoring the
- 19:05emotional aspect of the case. So we systematically
- 19:11teach incoming students that their visceral feelings,
- 19:15their moral intuitions, and their natural human
- 19:19empathy are childish impurities that must be
- 19:22purged from their minds. We condition them, though
- 19:26not maliciously, to believe that the only thing
- 19:29in the universe Possessing validity is the cold
- 19:33dispassionate rule. And we do it for a number
- 19:36of reasons. One significant reason, again, it's
- 19:39not malicious, is coverage. You have so much
- 19:43time with this student, there is this much material,
- 19:46and you're trying to get all that information
- 19:49within the constraints of the number of hours
- 19:53you've been given to teach them. All right, let's
- 20:04keep moving. Simultaneously, legal education
- 20:11conditions the nervous human system into a chronic
- 20:13state of hypervigilance. Consider the pedagogical
- 20:18culture of the traditional law school issue spotter
- 20:21exam. A student is given a four -page narrative
- 20:25sequencing some everyday event, well, maybe not
- 20:29every day, the way law school exams work. The
- 20:32student's sole objective is to scan every sentence,
- 20:36every clause, every comma, hunting for latent
- 20:39liabilities, hidden torts, a breach contract
- 20:43or breach multiple contracts, and prospective
- 20:46disasters. So if a character on an exam says
- 20:50good morning to an acquaintance, the conditioned
- 20:53student does not see a polite reading. They immediately
- 20:57wonder, did that statement induce justifiable
- 21:01reliance? Did it create an oral warranty? did
- 21:06it constitute intentional infliction of emotional
- 21:09distress? So in the context of the bar exam or
- 21:13when redlining a high stakes commercial agreement,
- 21:18issue spotting is necessary. But cognitive neuroscience
- 21:24reveals that when a human brain is subjected
- 21:27to this training for three intense years, and
- 21:31then 40 to 80 hours a week in active practice,
- 21:35that neural pathway becomes the default lens
- 21:38through which the individual perceives all reality.
- 21:43Psychologists call this the cognitive priming
- 21:47of negativity. When you train your brain to hunt
- 21:51for catastrophe in every document, guess what?
- 21:55Your brain automatically hunts for catastrophe
- 21:59in every human being, every relationship, every
- 22:03conversation. I mean, go back if you can. Think
- 22:07about that first semester of law school when
- 22:09you took torts. Do you remember within a week
- 22:13or two, you started seeing torts everywhere?
- 22:18Somebody touches your shoulder. Oh, you committed
- 22:20a battery. You see a rug in the law school area
- 22:25that's maybe a little bit wavy, hasn't been matted
- 22:28down, potential negligence action, right? Your
- 22:32mind just starts, I mean, I do this to this day
- 22:35too. I see torts everywhere, because one of the
- 22:38classes I teach is torts. But now it gets worse,
- 22:42right? You're now a practicing lawyer. You go
- 22:45home to dinner with your spouse, and you spot
- 22:48issues in how they describe their day. You speak
- 22:51with your kids, and you cross -examine them on
- 22:54their answers. You sit down to rest on a Sunday
- 22:57afternoon, and your nervous system remains locked
- 23:01in a state of fight or flight. scanning the horizon
- 23:06for the hidden trap that must be waiting to spring.
- 23:11You have transformed yourself into a radar dish
- 23:13that can register only threat. Rest becomes physiologically
- 23:19impossible because the brain has been conditioned
- 23:23to believe that letting down your guard is an
- 23:27invitation to malpractice. This psychological
- 23:33conditioning creates a profound intellectual
- 23:36arrogance paired with an acute emotional fragility.
- 23:40Nearly a century ago, the great legal realist,
- 23:43Jerome Frank, published his masterwork, Law and
- 23:45the Modern Mind. He observed that lawyers have
- 23:49inherited an almost medieval cognitive habit.
- 23:53We treat concepts, transactions, and general
- 23:56names as if they are more real than the physical
- 23:59world itself. We convince ourselves that reality
- 24:03is governed by our legal definitions. we believe
- 24:06that if we draft an agreement with enough clauses,
- 24:13indemnification clauses, indemnification provisions,
- 24:17warranty disclaimers, we can banish commercial
- 24:21uncertainty. We convince ourselves that if an
- 24:25appellate court articulates a multi -factor balancing
- 24:28test, human conduct will neatly fall behind that
- 24:32test. We see this tendency clearly in substantive
- 24:36doctrine. Consider the law of products liability
- 24:40and defective food, an area of scholarship I
- 24:43have examined in depth. Over the past century,
- 24:46courts tied themselves into analytical knots,
- 24:50developing the foreign natural test to determine
- 24:54whether a food supplier is liable for consumer
- 24:58injuries. In cases like Micks versus Ingersoll
- 25:02Candy, and more recently in the Ohio Supreme
- 25:05Court's decision in Berkheimer versus R .E .K
- 25:09.M., court declared that because a chicken bone
- 25:13is natural to chicken, a consumer who suffers
- 25:17a tornosophicus from a dish advertised as boneless
- 25:22wings has no cause of action. Why? Because the
- 25:27court determined as a matter of law that the
- 25:30word boneless does not mean without bones. It
- 25:34merely describes a cooking style. And consider
- 25:39the sheer detachment of that legal fiction. When
- 25:42the law reaches that level of scholastic abstraction,
- 25:46it has severed all ties with common sense and
- 25:50lived human experience. The doctrine operates
- 25:54in the stratosphere, while real people, consumers,
- 25:59choke in restaurants below. For the rule follower,
- 26:03this dynamic is seductive. Rule follower retreats
- 26:07into the sterile world of abstract doctrine because
- 26:11that world feels tidy, orderly, and controllable.
- 26:15You can master the rules, but you can't master
- 26:19life. The crisis arrives when that lawyer must
- 26:22leave the library and step into the reality of
- 26:25practice. In actual practice, judges make erratic
- 26:28rulings, disregard clear precedent, opposing
- 26:32counsel acts in bad faith, key witnesses collapse
- 26:35on cross -examination, and juries evaluate cases
- 26:41based on visceral human instinct rather than
- 26:45refined legal theories. When the messy, uncontrollable
- 26:50reality of the world breaks through the tidy
- 26:53perimeter of the rules, the rule -follower's
- 26:56cognitive framework collapses because they relied
- 26:59on rules to provide illusion of control. Their
- 27:03failure leaves the attorney feeling helpless
- 27:06and defenseless. All right, now to understand
- 27:12why this cognitive failure generates such profound
- 27:16despair, we must turn to depth psychology, specifically
- 27:20the structural model of the psyche developed
- 27:22by Carl Gustav Jung. Jung spent decades mapping
- 27:26the terrain of the human mind. His analytical
- 27:29psychology provides the exact diagnostic vocabulary
- 27:33needed to decode the mental health crisis in
- 27:36our profession. He posited the human psyche consists
- 27:40of three distinct layers, the conscious ego.
- 27:44This is the center of our waking awareness. This
- 27:46is who we refer to when we say I. It processes
- 27:50information, makes conscious decisions, analyzes
- 27:53case law, and organizes our daily calendars.
- 27:57Second is the personal unconscious. Now this
- 27:59is positioned right below the consciousness,
- 28:03it's the repository of our unique personal history,
- 28:06our forgotten experiences, our repressed emotions,
- 28:10our vulnerabilities, and our early life wounds.
- 28:14And it belongs to each of us individually. And
- 28:18then finally, we have the collective unconscious.
- 28:20This is the deepest, most foundational layer
- 28:23of the human mind. Jung demonstrated that just
- 28:27as our bodies inherit and anatomy, heart, lungs,
- 28:32a central nervous system. Our psyches inherit
- 28:36universal psychological structures and behavioral
- 28:40patterns that have evolved across millennia.
- 28:44Jung termed these inherited archaic patterns
- 28:48as archetypes. Now for Jung, the overarching
- 28:52purpose of life is individuation. Now that doesn't
- 28:56mean selfishness or individualism, it is the
- 29:01lifelong process of psychological integration.
- 29:04It is bringing the conscious ego into an ongoing
- 29:08dynamic dialogue with the deeper unconscious
- 29:12layers of the mind. And when you start integrating
- 29:16this into yourself, we get to creativity, reliance,
- 29:22and genuine moral grounding. Now when the Dialogue
- 29:27is severed when the conscious ego represses,
- 29:31outlaws, or denies contents of the unconscious,
- 29:35the psychic fractures. That's when we have neuroses,
- 29:38depression, addiction. These are the inevitable
- 29:42results of that psychic split. And that psychic
- 29:46fracture is precisely what legal education and
- 29:49firm culture demand of the practicing turning.
- 29:55Now, the word persona derives from the Latin
- 30:00term for the mask, worn by actors. We've seen
- 30:02these maybe in movies, in old movies, they put
- 30:05a mask on. In analytical psychology, the persona
- 30:10is the social face an individual presents to
- 30:13the collective world. It is the functional uniform
- 30:17we put on to navigate through society. Now, a
- 30:20persona is not inherently bad. Every profession
- 30:25requires one. A trauma surgeon cannot collapse
- 30:28in horror when they see a catastrophic wound
- 30:32in the operating room. A commercial airline pilot
- 30:36cannot broadcast panic over the intercom when
- 30:39encountering severe turbulence. And an attorney
- 30:42must possess a functional, professional persona.
- 30:47When you are representing a criminal defendant
- 30:49facing decades in prison, you can't sit at the
- 30:52council table weeping with anxiety. When an adversary
- 30:56makes a fraudulent representation during oral
- 30:59argument, you just can't leap up and scream in
- 31:02uncontrolled rage. I mean, you shouldn't. I guess
- 31:05you could, but you're not supposed to, right?
- 31:07That's our persona. And you must channel your
- 31:10intellect through procedural decorum. The persona
- 31:15of the calm, detached, articulate, objective
- 31:17counselor is an absolute professional necessity.
- 31:22The astrophe occurs when an attorney undergoes
- 31:25what Jung called persona identification. This
- 31:30is when your conscious ego forgets you're wearing
- 31:33a mask, and you actually think the mask is who
- 31:37you are as an individual. Our profession does
- 31:41not merely tolerate persona identification, it
- 31:44actively worships it. We venerate the lawyer
- 31:47who never shows sorrow, who never admits doubt,
- 31:50who bills through personal tragedy, and who approaches
- 31:53every human situation with cold, detached calculation.
- 31:59We reward this total identification with equity
- 32:03partnerships, appointments to the bench, academic
- 32:06chairs. The lawyer internalizes the delusion.
- 32:11I am not a human being who happens to practice
- 32:14law. I am the law itself. I am the detached,
- 32:20objective intellect. Now when this happens, the
- 32:24attorney's authentic humanity is effectively
- 32:27decapitated. The living person is swallowed whole
- 32:31by the professional mass. Now what happens to
- 32:37everything within the human being that does not
- 32:40fit into the sterile, unyielding persona? In
- 32:44Jungian psychology, the rule is absolute. What
- 32:47the persona rejects, the shadow collects. Now
- 32:51the shadow is That sector of the unconscious
- 32:54mind that holds everything an individual refuses
- 32:58to acknowledge about themselves. In the legal
- 33:01profession, the shadow becomes an overcrowded,
- 33:04highly pressurized prison cell. Now, what's locked
- 33:10away in the attorney's shadow? Vulnerability.
- 33:15The natural fear that we might not have an answer,
- 33:17that our legal strategy might fail or that we
- 33:19are outmatched. Vicarious grief. The emotional
- 33:23trauma of handling a child custody dispute, moral
- 33:30distress, the profound internal friction of advancing
- 33:34legal arguments that clash with your own personal
- 33:38conscience, fundamental human needs, the biological
- 33:42demand for rest, human intimacy, creative play,
- 33:45and authentic human connection. So under the
- 33:48rule follower archetype, the attorney acts as
- 33:51a ruthless prison warden, locking the cell door
- 33:55of the shadow, tighter with each passing year.
- 33:58The attorney tells themselves, at least subconsciously,
- 34:01I must not feel this. I must remain objective.
- 34:05I must hit my billing quota. I must draft the
- 34:09next motion. And again, it started in the academy,
- 34:12the legal academy, because we don't let students
- 34:15express their emotions. We just go from case
- 34:18to case. Great, we got the rule. Let's move on
- 34:21to the next case. The message that students get
- 34:24is, That's what we have to do. We just have to
- 34:26kind of hide our emotions, not feel them, and
- 34:30we stay at the higher rational level. But you
- 34:33can't exile core dimensions of human nature without
- 34:36paying an enormous psychic ransom. The unconscious
- 34:40cannot be permanently silenced. When an authentic
- 34:44human emotion is denied conscious expression,
- 34:47they don't disappear. They turn toxic in the
- 34:51dark. the pressure of the shadow builds continuously
- 34:55behind the conscious ego. And eventually, the
- 34:58repressed psychic energy erupts into active practice
- 35:01through destructive pathological pathways. Let's
- 35:08talk about a couple of them. First, chemical
- 35:11numbing. The first and most rampant in our profession
- 35:16is chemical dependency. Remember, the Krill study
- 35:19found more than one in five practicing lawyers
- 35:23struggle with hazardous alcohol dependent drinking.
- 35:28Why? Is it because lawyers have an inherent affinity
- 35:31for alcohol? No. For the rule follower, alcohol
- 35:35is not a recreational beverage. It's anesthesia.
- 35:42It's a chemical sledgehammer used to knock out
- 35:45the hypervigilant persona at the end of the day.
- 35:48And consider the daily psychological reality
- 35:51of an active practitioner. You spend 12 consecutive
- 35:54hours locked in a state of sustained nervous
- 35:57system arousal. Your brain has been scanning
- 36:01for threats, reviewing discovery files, battling
- 36:06opposing counsel, and suppressing every personal
- 36:09feeling. Your body is saturated with cortisol
- 36:13and adrenaline. You walk in at home at 8 30 p
- 36:18.m. The culture of the law has given you zero
- 36:21tools to decompress. You have been conditioned
- 36:24to believe that acknowledging fear, sorrow, or
- 36:27exhaustion is an ethical and professional failure.
- 36:31You can't quiet your mind because your issue
- 36:34-spotting machinery continues to spin at full
- 36:37speed. So what do you do? You go grab some scotch,
- 36:41maybe some wine. And this artificially silences
- 36:46the relentless internal critic. It forces your
- 36:49agitated nervous system into sedation. Substance
- 36:53abuse in our profession is rarely about seeking
- 36:56pleasure. It's a desperate, maladaptive attempt
- 36:59at self -regulation by attorneys who have been
- 37:02denied any legitimate emotional release valve.
- 37:06Now the irony, of course, is that alcohol is
- 37:10a depressant. It destroys REM sleep. It amplifies
- 37:15baseline anxiety. It erodes the executive cognitive
- 37:18functions necessary to practice law. So the attorney
- 37:20wakes up the next morning, feeling more anxious,
- 37:23more depleted, requiring more psychic effort
- 37:25to maintain the persona, accelerating a devastating
- 37:29downward spiral. All right, the second major
- 37:34pathway of eruption is clinical depression. Lawyers
- 37:38frequently misunderstand the clinical presentation
- 37:42of depression. They imagine that depression looks
- 37:45like weeping or acute outbursts, but with lawyers,
- 37:50depression rarely manifests itself as sadness.
- 37:53It manifests itself as anhedonia, which is the
- 37:57profound inability to experience joy, enthusiasm,
- 38:02or meaning. It presents as a gray, black, emotional
- 38:06numbness. Now, why does this happen? Because
- 38:10human beings cannot selectively numb emotion.
- 38:14When you use the rule follower persona to suppress
- 38:17fear, vulnerability, grief, and moral distress,
- 38:20You simultaneously extinguish your capacity to
- 38:23feel joy, love, wonder, and passion. You flatten
- 38:28the entire emotional register. This is where
- 38:31the Krieger and Sheldon research intersects directly
- 38:34with Jungian theory. When an attorney spends
- 38:37decades serving only external rules, external
- 38:41metrics, and external demands, the internal self
- 38:45atrophies from neglect. Remember had a former
- 38:50colleague of mine who practiced in San Francisco,
- 38:53large law firm, and one day her boss says, you've
- 38:56been working six, seven days a week. You need
- 38:58to go take a day off. And this was after about
- 39:00two years of not taking a day off. And she said,
- 39:04it was a Monday. She wakes up. She says, I don't
- 39:08know what to do. And she realized at that point,
- 39:13I've got a problem. I don't know what to do.
- 39:15I haven't had a day off. She becomes so acclimated
- 39:19to the grind. Lawyers, we look at our desk, we
- 39:24look out a window and completely refill that
- 39:27inside. We're an empty shell inhabiting an expensive
- 39:31suit. That is the depression of the rule follower,
- 39:35the horrifying realization that you have sacrificed
- 39:39your living soul in the service of an external
- 39:42script that never cared about more humanity.
- 39:47All right, let's move from theory to practical
- 39:49diagnosis. How? Do you recognize when the rule
- 39:53follower archetype has turned pathological in
- 39:55yourself or in a colleague? So watch for these
- 39:58four markers. Number one, persona self -fusion.
- 40:03This is where the attorney who can't take off
- 40:05their armor, they cross -examine their spouse
- 40:08over household chores, treat a disagreement with
- 40:12a friend as an evidentiary dispute requiring
- 40:15impeachment. They can't participate in normal
- 40:18human conversation without framing it. as an
- 40:21adversarial contest. The theatrical mass has
- 40:26fused to their face. If you try to pull it off,
- 40:29it would bleed. Second, severe somatization.
- 40:34When the conscious mind refuses to acknowledge
- 40:36psychological agony, the physical body acts it
- 40:40out, incapacitating migraines, chronic severe
- 40:46stomach disorders, grinding your teeth until
- 40:49your dental crowns fracture. Terrifying panic
- 40:54attacks. Something that sends a healthy 35 -year
- 40:58-old to an emergency room convinced that they're
- 41:00having a heart attack. Perfect coronary arteries,
- 41:04but the body is screaming what the mind has suppressed.
- 41:09Third marker is the tyranny of the minor infraction.
- 41:12Because the rule follower derives their entire
- 41:15sense of safety from absolute compliance, any
- 41:19deviation from perfection feels like total annihilation.
- 41:23The junior associate misses a routine filing
- 41:26deadline by two hours, a procedural error that
- 41:29can be easily remedied with an unopposed motion
- 41:32under the rules of civil procedure. Yet they
- 41:35experience suicidal despair or paralyzing panic.
- 41:40The senior partner who receives a routine evidentiary
- 41:44inquiry from a trial judge and spends the next
- 41:4648 hours rewriting the brief that was already
- 41:50thoroughly complete. the psychological reaction
- 41:54is disproportionate to the actual legal risk.
- 41:59A marker for contempt and shadow projection.
- 42:03Now, pay close attention to how an attorney reacts
- 42:05to conversations about wellbeing or colleagues
- 42:08who show vulnerability. When a lawyer sneers
- 42:11at an associate who takes parental leave or decides
- 42:14a mental health initiative at work is, oh, it's
- 42:17just that touchy -feely nonsense for the week,
- 42:20This is classic Jungian shadow projection. They
- 42:24are projecting outward with rage the exact vulnerabilities
- 42:29that they have violently suppressed within their
- 42:32own psyche. They can't tolerate vulnerability
- 42:35in others because they live in terror of the
- 42:39repressed vulnerability lurking in their own
- 42:42shadow, except they don't even know that that's
- 42:45what's going on, right? It's repressed. So let's
- 42:50now ground this discussion in the professional
- 42:53ethics of our profession. So as attorneys, we
- 42:58don't operate in a vacuum. We are bound by the
- 43:00rules of professional conduct. Now there's a
- 43:03pervasive myth in our profession that suppressing
- 43:05all emotion makes an attorney more competent.
- 43:08It does not. Let's start off with rule 1 .1.
- 43:13A lawyer shall provide competence. Representation
- 43:17to a client, competent representation requires
- 43:19the legal knowledge, skill, thoroughness, and
- 43:22preparation reasonably necessary for that representation.
- 43:28Now, while comment 8 to rule 1 .1 reminds us
- 43:31of our duty to keep oppressive changes in the
- 43:34law and technology, the American Bar Association
- 43:37made clear in formal opinions 3 .429 and 3 .431
- 43:43that mental fitness is an indispensable foundation
- 43:47for this rule. Furthermore, under Rule 1 .16A2,
- 43:53an attorney is mandated to withdraw from representation
- 43:58if their physical or mental condition materially
- 44:02impairs their ability to represent a client.
- 44:06Now consider the neurobiology. When an attorney
- 44:09operates in a state of chronic exhaustion, self
- 44:13-medicating with alcohol, and repressing their
- 44:16shadow, their prefrontal cortex degrades. Working
- 44:23memory capacity contracts. Cognitive flexibility,
- 44:28the ability to pivot when there are unexpected
- 44:31facts, is compromised. A psychologically fractured
- 44:36lawyer is an impaired lawyer. If you examine
- 44:40state disciplinary records, you will find that
- 44:42the vast majority of complaints under Rule 1
- 44:45.1 and 1 .3 don't involve malicious attorneys,
- 44:49plotting fraud. They involve terrified rule followers
- 44:53who made a mistake. They felt overwhelming shame.
- 44:58They hid the case in a drawer. They lied to the
- 45:01client out of panic and spiraled into professional
- 45:06ruin. Now let's consider another foundational
- 45:12ethic mandate, ABA Model Rule 2 .1. In representing
- 45:17a client, a lawyer shall exercise independent
- 45:20professional judgment, and render candid advice.
- 45:24In rendering advice, a lawyer may refer not only
- 45:28to law, but to other considerations such as moral,
- 45:31economic, social, and political factors that
- 45:33may be relevant to the client's situation. Notice
- 45:37the title to this rule, advisor. We are counselors
- 45:42at law, not automated case retrieval engines.
- 45:47A lawyer who is completely fused with the rule
- 45:50follower archetype cannot fulfill this rule.
- 45:55When a corporate client consults you regarding
- 45:57a contentious executive termination or an individual
- 46:01seeks counsel during a bitter estate dispute,
- 46:04they do not merely need a mechanical recitation
- 46:07of statutory elements. They need an advisor who
- 46:11understands human dynamics, psychological motivations,
- 46:15and moral consequences. If you are emotionally
- 46:18deadened, you cannot perceive the human emotional
- 46:23landscape of the dispute. You cannot recognize
- 46:26when your client is acting out of destructive
- 46:28spite rather than sound business judgment. You
- 46:33can't anticipate how a jury will react to your
- 46:36witness because you have replaced human empathy
- 46:38with sterile legal abstractions. True legal counsel
- 46:43requires a whole human being. All right, let's
- 46:50move to ABA Model Rule 5 .1, which establishes
- 46:55the ethical responsibilities of partners, managing
- 46:58attorneys, and supervisory lawyers. The rule
- 47:01mandates that partners and managers must establish
- 47:04internal measures giving reasonable assurance
- 47:07that all lawyers in the firm conform to the rules
- 47:11of professional conduct. Consider the structural
- 47:15inconsistency. Firm leadership cannot enforce
- 47:202400 billable hour quotas, treat associates as
- 47:25disposable units of production, and cultivate
- 47:27an atmosphere where admitting distress results
- 47:31in career termination while claiming compliance
- 47:35with Rule 5 .1. When firm leadership creates
- 47:39an environment of fear that forces attorneys
- 47:42to conceal impairment, Firm leadership is systematically
- 47:46manufacturing conditions that violate rules 1
- 47:49.1 and 1 .3. You can't demand your attorneys
- 47:54to maintain professional competence while maintaining
- 47:57structural working conditions that make human
- 48:00competence neurologically impossible. Creating
- 48:04an environment that terrorizes lawyers into hiding
- 48:06mistakes is an institutional failure. So how
- 48:11do we heal? How do we break the destructive grip
- 48:17of the rule follower archetype without sacrificing
- 48:20our analytical rigor. The answer lies in what
- 48:24Jung called shadow integration. We do not abandon
- 48:28procedural rules. We do not abandon professional
- 48:31craftsmanship. Instead, we reclaim our authentic
- 48:35human self from behind the persona. Now, on an
- 48:39individual level, we must implement four intentional
- 48:42practices. Differentiate role from identity.
- 48:47Your bar license describes your trade. It does
- 48:51not define your human worth. When asked who you
- 48:55are, stop answering exclusively with your law
- 48:58firm title. Reclaim personal boundaries outside
- 49:02the law. Second, implement de -rolling rituals.
- 49:08The human mind responds to physical boundaries.
- 49:11When you leave your office, change your clothes
- 49:15before greeting your family. Sit in your car
- 49:18in the driveway for five minutes in silence before
- 49:20entering the home. Mentally declare, the counselor
- 49:24is stepping down and the human being is stepping
- 49:27in. Take off the armor. Three, bring the shadow
- 49:32into the light. When you experience fear, professional
- 49:37grief, or imposter feelings, stop stuffing them
- 49:40into your unconscious. Speak them aloud to a
- 49:43trusted colleague, a therapist, a spouse, Naming
- 49:47an emotion drains it of its toxic unconscious
- 49:51power. I mean, in my case, I joined one of these
- 49:5612 -step programs. I didn't have an alcohol issue
- 49:58or substance problem. Going through a messy divorce,
- 50:01and I thought it would be useful to talk to others.
- 50:05And there's something eye -opening about talking
- 50:10to another human being, all experiencing different
- 50:13issues, but in a shared, confidential setting,
- 50:16being able to Well, let your hair down to the
- 50:18extent you have hair to let down. Or a therapist,
- 50:23also very useful, right? Helping to identify
- 50:25the real you if you've lost yourself over the
- 50:28decades. Utilize your state's lawyer assistance
- 50:32program. Now these programs are confidential,
- 50:35they're privileged, and independent from disciplinary
- 50:38counsel. Reaching out to them, it's not an ethical
- 50:41failure, it's an act of professional self -preservation.
- 50:48Now, for those who lead law firms, corporate
- 50:50legal departments, public agencies, the obligation
- 50:53is systemic. Dismantle the myth of infallibility.
- 50:58Senior partners must openly discuss their professional
- 51:01scars. Talk about the motion you lost. Talk about
- 51:06the mistake you made early in your career and
- 51:08how you corrected it. When leadership pretends
- 51:11it has never experienced doubt or error, it forces
- 51:15junior attorneys to conceal their mistakes. setting
- 51:18up catastrophic malpractice disasters. Two, institute
- 51:23blameless debriefs. When a trial goes poorly,
- 51:26a motion's denied, conduct an analysis of the
- 51:30process, not a prosecution of the individual.
- 51:34Create an environment where an associate can
- 51:36say, you know, I felt overwhelmed and did not
- 51:38understand the assignment without fear of being
- 51:41terminated. Three, decouple value from volume.
- 51:47Recognize that human beings are not industrial
- 51:50machines. Evaluate attorneys on judgment, craftsmanship,
- 51:55and client outcomes rather than raw seat time.
- 51:59Four, protect off hours boundaries. Stop rewarding
- 52:03performative workaholism. Establish communication
- 52:06blackouts for non -emergencies so that the human
- 52:10nervous system can downshift and recover. So,
- 52:19the rule of law I want to be clear, the rule
- 52:22of law is one of humanity's greatest accomplishments.
- 52:26It preserves liberty, restrains tyranny, and
- 52:30creates commercial order. It demands dedication,
- 52:35intellect, and profound discipline. But we must
- 52:39never forget, the rules were made for humans,
- 52:43not humans for the rules. Don't have to annihilate
- 52:49your soul to be a brilliant attorney. In fact,
- 52:52your capacity to feel, your capacity to listen
- 52:56to your moral intuition, and your capacity to
- 53:00honor your own human limits are the very qualities
- 53:04that make you a wise counselor, a formidable
- 53:07advocate, and a whole human being. Step out of
- 53:10the prison of the rule follower, remove your
- 53:14mask, and bring your whole self to the law. All
- 53:21right. So thank you for your time and attention.
- 53:25If you'd like to explore the theoretical grounding
- 53:27of today's presentation further, please consult
- 53:30my article, Legal Education and the Rule -Follower
- 53:33Archetype. We have some additional time remaining,
- 53:36so I will see if we have any questions. If not,
- 53:39I will give you a couple of strategies I employ
- 53:42to keep myself grounded. So do we have any questions?
- 53:49It actually looks like we have one question so
- 53:51far. course get another as we um wait this question
- 53:54is a little bit um on the longer end so i'll
- 53:57try to um let's see okay so uh professor bias
- 54:03thank you for your provocative presentation it's
- 54:05been I've been educated entirely in Roman Catholic
- 54:08institutions through law school, and I've witnessed
- 54:10first -hand on modern secularist trends and regulatory
- 54:13structures, specifically those in the American
- 54:14Bar Association can dilute a religious mission
- 54:17and strip legal education of its moral and human
- 54:20anchor. I therefore find myself questioning your
- 54:22premise on two fronts. First, isn't the detachment
- 54:25we see today less about the 1870s case method
- 54:27and more about this modern top -down bureaucratic
- 54:30standardization, which forces institutions like
- 54:33my own University of San Francisco to secularize
- 54:36why, well, rare exceptions like Ave Maria University
- 54:40must fight to resist it. And second, if American
- 54:43common law, constitutional law, and criminal
- 54:46law are fundamentally the crystallization of
- 54:48organic human experience seeking to correct deviations
- 54:52from an inherent right to order, isn't the study
- 54:55of law inherently attached to human feeling rather
- 54:57than detached from it? Oh. Yeah, so it is, you're
- 55:02absolutely correct. Now I would say that it is
- 55:04not by chance or maybe by providence if you prefer
- 55:08to use the religious language. I began my teaching
- 55:11career at an explicitly religious law school.
- 55:14And I would suggest that the rule follower archetype
- 55:16was very strong there as well. In fact, I noticed
- 55:19commonalities with people who are very religious.
- 55:24because they also wanna follow rules. Okay, what
- 55:26are the rule? How short do I have to keep my
- 55:28hair? Can I wear a beard? The rules that apply
- 55:32in religious settings. So I don't think this
- 55:35is anything modern. I think though at least my
- 55:40study really through my own self healing as well
- 55:44came to realize that I think that is that we
- 55:48are reinforcing something that is. basically
- 55:50in everyone. So Jung basically taught that these
- 55:53archetypes are present in everyone to some degree,
- 55:56but it's when they get out of balance. So I would
- 55:58suggest everybody has a little bit of the rule
- 56:01follower archetype, and then are we doing things?
- 56:05Now, I'm not suggesting that, I mean, maybe it
- 56:07is the bureaucracies as well, but in life, when
- 56:11we encounter things that reinforce a particular
- 56:15archetype, if we don't do things to to keep the
- 56:20archetype in balance, right? That archetype can
- 56:26start taking over, right? And predominating.
- 56:30And we see multiple archetypes and people who
- 56:33seem to be dominated. Another common archetype
- 56:36is that of the jester or the fool, right? The
- 56:39person who always has to be the final laugh.
- 56:43And he's just, or she has let that archetype
- 56:46sort of influence them. But I do believe that
- 56:50legal education through the Socratic method is
- 56:52a significant factor in our profession, especially
- 57:00basing it on the empirical data. It's that we
- 57:04see the data at the beginning of law school.
- 57:06Law students are fine, or at least about the
- 57:08same as the general population. And by the time
- 57:11of their first final exams, they're a mess. that
- 57:18data informs me to think we're doing something
- 57:21in law school. It got me to reevaluate how I
- 57:24teach. One other thing I mentioned, I was going
- 57:28to give one technique that I used to stay grounded
- 57:30because I would say I was very strong in the
- 57:33rule follower archetype until my own recovery,
- 57:35my own process of individuation. And I realized
- 57:42six, seven years ago, I don't know that I feel
- 57:45things. And I knew that wasn't healthy. I mean,
- 57:48I felt some things, but I would say a very far
- 57:51level. And so I remember seeing an emotional
- 57:55wheel. If you Google emotional wheel, you'll
- 57:57probably find one. And I keep it right here on
- 57:59my... Hold this out very quickly. And you see
- 58:04whenever... I'm pretty good about feeling emotions
- 58:07now, but the key is how do we get back to feelings?
- 58:11And on this chart, you see there are broad categories,
- 58:14right? There's... fearful, angry, disgusted,
- 58:18sad, happy, surprised, in the center. And most
- 58:21of us are pretty good about feeling these basic
- 58:23feelings. But as we go further out, I realized,
- 58:26how exactly do I feel? And when I use this chart
- 58:30more actively six, seven years ago, as I was
- 58:34going through the process of individuation, I
- 58:35think it's a lifelong journey. We're always going
- 58:37through the process of individuation. I said,
- 58:40oh, wait a second, I feel sad. Wait a second,
- 58:42it's lonely and actually go beyond lonely. So
- 58:45the secondary is lonely and then third, oh, I'm
- 58:48feeling isolated. But a way of trying to recapture
- 58:52that emotion, one that not everyone loses in
- 58:55law school, but I would suggest a significant
- 58:58portion. And I don't mean to say that the rule
- 59:00follower archetype is the sole cause for the
- 59:05problems in our profession, but I would suggest
- 59:06it is a very significant cause. I hope I answered
- 59:11the question. If not, please feel free to follow
- 59:14up with another email or text. I'll stay on for
- 59:17a few minutes if you have a follow -up question,
- 59:21or if anyone else does. All right. It looks like
- 59:26we actually have, well, one of them's positive
- 59:28feedback. Thank you so much for this talk and
- 59:31insights. So it looks like we have a couple or
- 59:34a couple more. One from Peter asking, can the
- 59:37dynamic you described not be linked to the trend
- 59:40in recent decades of the legal profession transitioning
- 59:42from a quote unquote profession to a bottom line
- 59:45driven business? Well, I think that exacerbates
- 59:50the problem. I think you have, and early on I
- 59:53said something about law firm, not all law firms,
- 59:56but some law firms grooming, right? You're trying
- 59:58to identify people who are willing to tolerate,
- 1:00:02you know, the 24 hundred hour a week billable
- 1:00:05hours. So, you know, it's kind of sort of a chicken
- 1:00:09and an egg. Do I think it's the law firm culture
- 1:00:12that has created that? The bottom line, I don't
- 1:00:15think so. I think is in law, we've had this issue
- 1:00:18for many, many years. I think that predates the
- 1:00:22big law and the bottom line mindset. But if you
- 1:00:28have people who are willing to follow these rules
- 1:00:32and willing to be taken advantage of, well, then
- 1:00:36there will be people who will fill that void.
- 1:00:39But I don't think it's the firms creating it.
- 1:00:42I think it maybe just takes advantage of the
- 1:00:46rule follower archetype. What else? So there
- 1:00:51was one more. Looks like we do have one more
- 1:00:54question. All right, so it looks like we have
- 1:00:57another question from Okay, Christopher with
- 1:01:02respect professor the classical Socratic method
- 1:01:04was never intended to produce clinical rule followers
- 1:01:07was designed as a tool of deep inquiry to discover
- 1:01:09virtual injustice. Okay I believe it's actually
- 1:01:13a byproduct of secularized modern legal education
- 1:01:16system that has been stripped of its morel anchor
- 1:01:18by top -down bureaucratic mandates. Let's see,
- 1:01:21is there a question? Yes. Even a faith -based
- 1:01:23institution film like Liberty struggles with
- 1:01:25this. Does that prove my point? Do you have any
- 1:01:30more thoughts on this argument? Sure, right.
- 1:01:35So again, it was not designed to show feelings
- 1:01:40down into the psyche. I mean, I think Christopher
- 1:01:42Columbus Langdell, great innovator, made American
- 1:01:46legal education what it is today. I think probably
- 1:01:49the premier type of education system in the world
- 1:01:52because of the Langdellian method. I think it
- 1:01:54is a good method. But here's what I am doing
- 1:01:57a little bit more often. And this is gonna be,
- 1:01:59sound a little bit odd. It's odd to me. It's
- 1:02:01going to seem odd to some of you. So let's say
- 1:02:03we're dealing with a case. I remember one pretty
- 1:02:05brutal case when I was teaching criminal law
- 1:02:07involved a person being strangled with a telephone
- 1:02:10cord. So you can tell the case was a little bit
- 1:02:12older and we talked about it. Okay, here's the
- 1:02:15legal issue was a premeditation and we moved
- 1:02:17on. But now what I'm more apt to do is, well,
- 1:02:20that was a horrible set of facts. What do you
- 1:02:22all think about that? I mean, let's stop for
- 1:02:25a moment. Let's process our feelings, right?
- 1:02:28It's the need for an emotional outlet. We still
- 1:02:32need the Socratic method. I think it's a great
- 1:02:34method, but when you deal with a particularly
- 1:02:37gruesome set of facts, and I also teach tax,
- 1:02:40so we don't generally deal with gruesome sets
- 1:02:42of facts in a federal income tax class, but when
- 1:02:45we're dealing in torts, we do. And just stopping
- 1:02:50and letting students recognize that having a
- 1:02:54feeling about this set of facts, a disturbing
- 1:02:57set of facts where somebody's been raped, somebody's
- 1:02:59been attacked, somebody's been murdered. It's
- 1:03:03okay to think about that and to recognize the
- 1:03:06wrongness of it. I think that has been the failure
- 1:03:10of the academy is not stopping because you say,
- 1:03:13I've got a one -hour time slot. I have three
- 1:03:15cases I need to cover today. I've got these four
- 1:03:17problems. We don't have time for this mushy,
- 1:03:20feely kind of stuff, right? And I would suggest
- 1:03:23that we absolutely need to make I'm not saying
- 1:03:27that we get around and stand in a circle and
- 1:03:30sing kumbaya. I'm not saying that. But at least
- 1:03:33recognizing this is an issue and that we need
- 1:03:37to take some steps, at least in the profession.
- 1:03:40I'm really talking to myself and my colleagues.
- 1:03:43And then also, once those of you who are members
- 1:03:46of the bar, saying, okay, how do I reattach to
- 1:03:48my feelings? I've elevated my psyche, my rational
- 1:03:53thought. I need to get back in touch with my
- 1:04:00emotions. Because I think the opposite side is
- 1:04:04emotions, right? So basically they're out of
- 1:04:06balance, right? So you've elevated one, the flip
- 1:04:09side are emotions. By helping to bring that back
- 1:04:12into balance, the individuation process, we become
- 1:04:16a whole person. Other questions? It looks like
- 1:04:23we just have one last question here. Let's see
- 1:04:26from Christine. I enjoyed your presentation.
- 1:04:28I'm taking away that mentoring younger lawyers
- 1:04:32about healthy handling of less than complete
- 1:04:34wins is something I'd like to learn more about.
- 1:04:36Do you have any articles that you'd like to suggest?
- 1:04:41Ah, you know, you think I would have come prepared
- 1:04:46with something like that. No, I guess I don't
- 1:04:52have any articles right off the bat that I would
- 1:04:55recommend. And I'll tell you, one of the challenges
- 1:05:02that we have is the process of individuation.
- 1:05:06So Jung also taught that life is a two -part
- 1:05:09journey. And for young people, they are in the
- 1:05:12first half of that journey. They're in the process
- 1:05:15of building a career. They're making money. They're
- 1:05:23trying to meet those external criteria that we
- 1:05:27talked about. when they hear things like what
- 1:05:31we're talking about now, it's very hard for them
- 1:05:34because this is more, the process of individuation
- 1:05:37really is a second half of life journey. So I
- 1:05:43think what, for those of us who are a little
- 1:05:45bit older and we are mentoring younger people,
- 1:05:48I think we give them advice, make sure you take
- 1:05:50time off, sort of the basic things. I'm not sure
- 1:05:54they understand it at a deep psychological level.
- 1:05:58Jung himself taught, you know, there has to be
- 1:06:00basically some catastrophic event, some moment
- 1:06:05where a person starts recognizing their own mortality
- 1:06:09before the individuation process begins. He said,
- 1:06:13for men, that generally occurs when your father
- 1:06:17dies. And that was my experience. After my father
- 1:06:21died, That's when all of this started making
- 1:06:24sense. That is when my own journey of healing,
- 1:06:26my process of individuation began. But can also
- 1:06:29per, I mean, those are people who went to war,
- 1:06:31right? Seeing a close friend die next to you
- 1:06:34in another, right, when you're in battle. Some
- 1:06:39horrible event, maybe surviving an airplane crash.
- 1:06:42Those kind of events are the time when you are
- 1:06:45able to see your own mortality and you start
- 1:06:48working on yourself. I don't know if that quite
- 1:06:50answers the question, but yeah, I don't have
- 1:06:53a good resource. I will need to think of that
- 1:06:56for the next time I give this presentation. Anything
- 1:07:00else? All righty, that does look like that's
- 1:07:05it for questions. Thank you again, Professor
- 1:07:08Bias, for an excellent presentation today. We'd
- 1:07:10also love to extend a warm thanks to our audience
- 1:07:13for joining us. Have a great day, everyone. Take
- 1:07:16care.