Latest / Sleepy Facts About History / Why Did Pippin the Short Need the Pope to Become King? - The Carolingian Takeover and the Papal Alliance | Sleepy Facts About History
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome to Sleepy Facts About History. For nearly
- 0:13three generations, a powerful aristocratic family
- 0:16ruled the Frankish army, treasury, and church,
- 0:19while a powerless king sat on the throne. This
- 0:22episode explores how the Pippinid family, later
- 0:26known as the Carolingians, converted generations
- 0:29of accumulated practical power into the sacred
- 0:33dignity of kingship. It traces their rise from
- 0:37regional mayors of the palace in Austrasia to
- 0:40the undisputed rulers of the Frankish realm,
- 0:43examining the military campaigns, monastic patronage,
- 0:47and political maneuvering that made their dominance
- 0:50possible. The narrative follows the pivotal moments
- 0:54that allowed this dynastic takeover to succeed.
- 0:58From Charles Martel's consolidation of military
- 1:01power without royal title, to Pippin the Short's
- 1:04decisive political act of tunchering the last
- 1:07Merovingian king, the episode explains why force
- 1:11alone was not enough to claim the throne. It
- 1:14details the crucial alliance with the papacy,
- 1:17the anointing with holy oil that transformed
- 1:20a political coup into a divinely sanctioned kingship,
- 1:24and the resulting Frankish military campaigns
- 1:27in Italy that laid the foundation for the papal
- 1:29states. I kept returning to one central question
- 1:33while working on this episode. Why did a family
- 1:36that already commanded the army and controlled
- 1:39the government go to such lengths to seek religious
- 1:41approval for a title they had effectively already
- 1:45taken? Understanding this transition requires
- 1:48looking beyond the simple idea of do -nothing
- 1:51kings and examining how legitimacy actually functioned
- 1:55in the early medieval world. It is a story about
- 1:59the limits of rule power, and the enduring necessity
- 2:02of sacred ritual. For nearly three generations,
- 2:09the most powerful family in the Frankish kingdom
- 2:11ruled the army, the treasury, and the church.
- 2:14A powerless king sat on the throne. His only
- 2:18function was the growing absurdity of his presence.
- 2:22This is the story of how they finally removed
- 2:25him, and why they needed God to approve it first.
- 2:29In the early 8th century, A powerful aristocratic
- 2:33family in the Frankish kingdom controlled the
- 2:36army, the treasury, the royal estates, and the
- 2:39network of monasteries and bishops that made
- 2:41government possible. Yet the throne itself remained
- 2:45occupied by a dynasty that had ruled the Franks
- 2:48for nearly two and a half centuries. The family
- 2:51in question was not royal. They held the office
- 2:55of mayor of the palace. This had originally been
- 2:59a household manager. Now it was the effective
- 3:03head of government. For generations they had
- 3:06accumulated land, military followers, monastic
- 3:10alliances and regional influence. The question
- 3:14this episode addresses is how such a family converted
- 3:19that practical power into the sacred dignity
- 3:22of kingship and why they needed to do so at all.
- 3:27The Frankish world of the 7th and early 8th centuries
- 3:30was not a centralized state in any modern sense.
- 3:33It was a patchwork of regional aristocracies,
- 3:37royal lands, church institutions, and personal
- 3:40followings bound by loyalty to successful war
- 3:43leaders. The Merovingian dynasty, descended from
- 3:47Clovis who had united the Franks in the late
- 3:505th and early 6th centuries, still supplied the
- 3:54kings. But real power had shifted. The kingdom
- 3:58was often divided among sub -kingdoms. Austrasia
- 4:02lay in the northeast. Neustria lay in the northwest.
- 4:07Burgundy lay in the east. Royal authority was
- 4:12contested, fragmented, and increasingly mediated
- 4:15by aristocratic factions who controlled the great
- 4:18offices. The office of mayor of the palace, the
- 4:22mayor domus, had emerged as the most powerful
- 4:25secular position in each sub -kingdom. The mayor
- 4:29commanded the royal household troops, he managed
- 4:33the royal estates, he presided over the palace
- 4:37court, and he increasingly directed military
- 4:40campaigns. By the 7th century, the mayor was
- 4:44often more powerful than the king he served.
- 4:47The separation between the title of kingship
- 4:50and the substance of rule had become a structural
- 4:53feature of Frankish politics. The family that
- 4:57would become known as the Carolingians, but who
- 5:01in their own time were called Pippinids after
- 5:04their most successful members, came from the
- 5:07Austrasian aristocracy. Their power base lay
- 5:11in the Moers -Moersel region. This was a zone
- 5:14of fertile land, Roman roads, and strategic position
- 5:19between the Rhine frontier and the Frankish heartland.
- 5:23They were not unique in their wealth or connections.
- 5:26What distinguished them was their success over
- 5:29several generations in converting regional prominence
- 5:32into institutional control. The first Pippin
- 5:36of note, Pippin of Landon, served as mayor of
- 5:39the palace in Austrasia in the early 7th century.
- 5:43He was a powerful figure. allied with the church
- 5:46through his daughter Gertrude. She became abbess
- 5:50of the monastery of Nivelles, a house founded
- 5:53on family land in the rolling country south of
- 5:56Brussels. But he also experienced the dangers
- 5:59of aristocratic politics. He fell from favour
- 6:03and was exiled. Though he returned to power,
- 6:06his career demonstrated that even great Frankish
- 6:09nobles could be brought low by royal or factional
- 6:12hostility. Exile in this world meant more than
- 6:15distance from court. It meant severance from
- 6:19the network of estates and followings that sustained
- 6:21aristocratic life. It meant removal from the
- 6:25monastic houses that preserved family memory
- 6:27and prayed for the dead. It meant exclusion from
- 6:32the gift -giving and alliance -building that
- 6:34made political survival possible. His son Grimald
- 6:38attempted something more ambitious. As mayor,
- 6:42He tried to place his own son on the Austrasian
- 6:45throne. The attempt failed and Grimald was killed.
- 6:50The lesson was clear enough. Royal blood still
- 6:54mattered. The mayoral office could not simply
- 6:57be converted into kingship by force or by will.
- 7:01The family's fortunes revived with Pippin of
- 7:05Hestel, the grandson of Pippin of Landon, through
- 7:09a combination of military success. strategic
- 7:12marriages, monastic patronage, and careful management
- 7:16of the mayoral office, Pippin of Herstal became
- 7:20the dominant figure in Austrasia. Then, decisively,
- 7:24he became the dominant figure in the Frankish
- 7:27kingdom as a whole. In 687, at the Battle of
- 7:32Tertri in Picardy, Pippin defeated the Neustrian
- 7:35mayor and established Austrasian dominance over
- 7:39the other Frankish sub -kingdoms. The merity
- 7:42of a single sub -kingdom became, in effect, the
- 7:46headship of the Frankish realm. This victory
- 7:49at Tertri is worth pausing over because it illustrates
- 7:53how Frankish politics worked. The battle was
- 7:57not simply a military encounter. It was the culmination
- 8:01of years of alliance building, gift -giving,
- 8:03and the cultivation of military followings. Pippin
- 8:08had persuaded or compelled enough Frankish nobles
- 8:11to support him. that he could field an army capable
- 8:14of defeating the Neustrian establishment. A 7th
- 8:18century Frankish battle involved the mustering
- 8:21of armed followings from across a noble's network.
- 8:24It involved the movement of cavalry and infantry
- 8:27across open country. It involved the importance
- 8:31of terrain and morale. Victory at Tertiary confirmed
- 8:34Pippin's dominance, but it did not automatically
- 8:38make his position secure. He spent the remaining
- 8:41years of his life, He died in 714, consolidating
- 8:46his control, rewarding followers with land and
- 8:49office, and deepening the family's connections
- 8:52to monastic houses that could pray for his soul,
- 8:56manage his estates, and preserve his memory.
- 8:59The monastic dimension of Pippinid power is easy
- 9:03to overlook, but essential to understanding how
- 9:06this family operated. Consider the monastery
- 9:10of Stevalot Malmedy in the Ardennes. or later
- 9:13Echternach on the Sour River. Both houses were
- 9:17founded or re -founded by the Pippinids. These
- 9:21were not merely religious retreats. They were
- 9:24walled complexes containing a church, a scriptorium
- 9:28where records were kept and charters drawn up,
- 9:31agricultural lands worked by dependents, and
- 9:34storehouses for grain and wine. Monks prayed
- 9:38in regular cycles for the families dead. They
- 9:41commemorated their names in written lists that
- 9:44preserved memory across generations. They managed
- 9:48the scattered estates that sustained aristocratic
- 9:50wealth. A daughter like Gertrude at Nivelles,
- 9:54or a family member buried within the monastery
- 9:56walls, created a permanent physical presence
- 9:59that tied sacred space to dynastic identity.
- 10:03The Pippinids understood something that would
- 10:05serve them well for generations. Power in the
- 10:09Frankish world required not merely military force,
- 10:12but the accumulation of sacred and social capital
- 10:14that made that force legitimate and sustainable.
- 10:18Pippin of Herstal's death in 714 brought a period
- 10:23of instability. His designated heir was a grandson,
- 10:27still a minor, and several factions contested
- 10:30control. The eventual victor was Pippin's illegitimate
- 10:34son, Charles, later known as Charles Martel,
- 10:38the Hammer. Charles spent his early years in
- 10:42conflict, defeating rival claimants, rebellious
- 10:45nobles, and external enemies. By 718, he had
- 10:50established himself as undisputed mayor of the
- 10:52palace. He would hold that position until his
- 10:56death in 741. Charles Martel's reign as mayor
- 11:01represents the high point of practical Pippinid
- 11:04power, exercised without royal title. He ruled
- 11:08the Frankish kingdom from the Meuse -Moselle
- 11:11heartland, campaigning against threats on every
- 11:14frontier. To the north along the north sea coast,
- 11:18the Frisians raided and resisted Frankish control.
- 11:21To the northeast, beyond the lower Rhine, the
- 11:25Saxons threatened. To the east, across the upper
- 11:29Rhine, the Alamans maintained their independence.
- 11:32And to the southwest, beyond the Loire in Aquitaine,
- 11:36Muslim forces had crossed the Pyrenees and established
- 11:39a presence that challenged Frankish authority.
- 11:42His victory at Tours or Poitiers in 732 or 733.
- 11:47The dating is uncertain in our sources. Over
- 11:51a Muslim raiding force has become one of the
- 11:54most celebrated battles in European historiography.
- 11:57For our purposes what matters is not whether
- 12:01this battle saved Europe. That claim owes more
- 12:05to later nationalist imagination than to 8th
- 12:08century realities. What matters is what it did
- 12:12for Charles' position within the Frankish kingdom.
- 12:15The victory enhanced his prestige. It demonstrated
- 12:19his capacity to protect the Franks from external
- 12:22threat, and it confirmed that the mayor could
- 12:25perform the primary function of kingship, military
- 12:29leadership, more effectively than the Merovingian
- 12:32who nominally held the throne. Yet Charles Martel
- 12:36did not become king. This is a crucial point,
- 12:40and one that requires careful explanation. He
- 12:44had the power. He had the prestige. He had effectively
- 12:48eliminated the Merovingian king from active government.
- 12:52In his last years, he ruled without even the
- 12:55pretense of a royal figurehead. But he did not
- 12:59take the title. The sources do not tell us directly
- 13:02why. We can infer that the obstacles were substantial.
- 13:08Kingship in the Frankish world was not merely
- 13:10an office. It was tied to blood, to the sacred
- 13:14lineage of Clovis, to rituals of inauguration
- 13:18and long hair that marked the king as set apart
- 13:21from ordinary men. To claim kingship without
- 13:25that blood was to claim something that could
- 13:27not be seized by mere force. It required legitimacy.
- 13:32and legitimacy in this world required more than
- 13:35military success. Charles Martel's solution,
- 13:40or perhaps his acceptance of limitation, was
- 13:43to rule as mayor while systematically strengthening
- 13:46the material foundations of his family's power.
- 13:49One of the most controversial aspects of his
- 13:52reign was his treatment of church lands. Facing
- 13:56the need to reward his military followers and
- 13:59maintain an effective mounted force, Charles
- 14:03confiscated or reallocated lands belonging to
- 14:06monasteries and bishoprics. He granted them to
- 14:10his warriors as precaria, temporary holdings
- 14:13that became in practice permanent. This policy,
- 14:17sometimes called secularization, has been interpreted
- 14:21in various ways by historians. Some see it as
- 14:25a deliberate assault on the church to build a
- 14:27secular military machine. Others emphasized the
- 14:31pragmatic pressures of constant warfare and the
- 14:34expectation that church lands would eventually
- 14:36be restored. What is clear is that Charles was
- 14:40willing to override ecclesiastical privilege
- 14:43to maintain his following. This created tensions
- 14:46with some church leaders that his successors
- 14:49would have to address. Charles Martel died in
- 14:53741, leaving his power divided between his two
- 14:57legitimate sons, Carloman. and Pippin. The brothers
- 15:01continued their father's practice of ruling as
- 15:04mayors. They briefly restored a Merovingian king,
- 15:08Childeric III, to serve as a figurehead. This
- 15:12restoration is itself revealing. Even after decades
- 15:15of Pippinid dominance, the Merovingian name retained
- 15:19a legitimacy that the mayors could not simply
- 15:22dispense with. The brothers ruled, but the king
- 15:25was present, however passively. in the political
- 15:28theatre of the realm. In 747, Carloman retired
- 15:33to a monastery, leaving his brother Pippin, later
- 15:37called Pippin the Short, as sole mayor. Pippin
- 15:41now faced the question that his father had avoided.
- 15:44He ruled alone, with no check on his authority
- 15:47but the lingering presence of a Merovingian king
- 15:50who did nothing and commanded nothing. The gap
- 15:54between power and title between the reality of
- 15:57government and the symbolism of kingship, had
- 16:00become acute. Pippin decided to close it. Childeric
- 16:06III was the last Merovingian king. In 751, Pippin
- 16:11had him tonsured. The shears cut the long hair
- 16:14that had been the visible bodily marker of Merovingian
- 16:18royalty. This was hair that distinguished the
- 16:21king from ordinary men. and marked him as belonging
- 16:24to the sacred lineage of Clovis. The cutting
- 16:28was not mere humiliation. It was a ritual unmaking
- 16:32of kingship. It was the removal of the physical
- 16:36sign that separated the royal body from all others.
- 16:41Chalderic was then confined to a monastery. His
- 16:44royal identity was severed as cleanly as his
- 16:47hair. A king became a monk, sacred in a different
- 16:51way. Removed from the world of politics by the
- 16:54shears that severed his royal identity, this
- 16:58deposition was accomplished through elite consensus,
- 17:01not popular revolution or constitutional process.
- 17:05Pippin convened the Frankish nobles and bishops,
- 17:08presumably at a royal assembly, and presented
- 17:12them with a situation that was already obvious.
- 17:15He held the power. Childrick held only the name.
- 17:20The sources suggest that the assembly agreed
- 17:22to the deposition, though what pressure or persuasion
- 17:26Pippin applied, we cannot know in detail. The
- 17:29bodily transformation was precise and deliberate.
- 17:32The political process that produced it was more
- 17:35opaque. But Pippin did not simply declare himself
- 17:39king by acclamation. He sought something more,
- 17:43something that would transform a political coup
- 17:45into legitimate succession. He sent to Pope Zacharias
- 17:49in Rome with a question that has become famous
- 17:52in the historiography of this period. He asked
- 17:56whether the one who held the power, or the one
- 17:59who held the title, should be king. The Pope's
- 18:02reply, as reported in later Carolingian sources,
- 18:06was that the one who actually held the power
- 18:08should be king, for the good of the kingdom.
- 18:11This exchange, whether it occurred exactly as
- 18:14described or was shaped by later retelling, served
- 18:17a crucial function. It supplied a moral and religious
- 18:21justification for what had been accomplished
- 18:24by political means. The anointing of Pippin as
- 18:28king was the ritual mechanism that converted
- 18:31practical power into sacred kingship. In the
- 18:348th century understanding, anointing involved
- 18:37the physical application of holy oil. The oil
- 18:41was typically poured or smeared upon the head,
- 18:43perhaps the hands or shoulders. of the one being
- 18:47consecrated the oil was not merely symbolic it
- 18:52was understood to mark the body itself as set
- 18:54apart transformed by tangible contact with the
- 18:57sacred the ritual drew on old testament models
- 19:01that would have been familiar to any educated
- 19:04church man the prophet samuel poured oil upon
- 19:07the head of saul then of david marking them as
- 19:11chosen by god for rule over israel This was not
- 19:15entirely new in Christian practice, but its application
- 19:19to a new dynasty and by the Pope himself gave
- 19:22it extraordinary significance. The precise details
- 19:26are debated by historians. Some sources suggest
- 19:30an initial anointing by Frankish bishops in 751,
- 19:34perhaps at Soissons. A more elaborate ceremony
- 19:38occurred in 754, when Pope Stephen II travelled
- 19:42north to meet Pippin. At St. Denis or perhaps
- 19:46at Pomtheon in Champagne, the Pope anointed Pippin
- 19:50with holy oil and probably his sons as well.
- 19:54Their bodies were marked to set apart for royal
- 19:57office. The anointing did not create Pippin's
- 20:01power. He already had that. What it did was transform
- 20:06the character of that power. A mayor ruled by
- 20:09delegation, by office, by the accumulation of
- 20:13personal following. A king ruled by divine sanction,
- 20:17by sacred unction, by a status that transcended
- 20:20individual capacity and tied the ruler to the
- 20:23cosmic order of Christian society. The anointing
- 20:27made Pippin not merely the most powerful man
- 20:30in the Frankish kingdom, but a king in a new
- 20:33and potent sense. It also bound the new dynasty
- 20:37to the papacy in relationship of mutual obligation
- 20:41that would shape both Frankish and Papal politics
- 20:44for generations. The alliance with the Papacy
- 20:47was not merely symbolic. The Papacy in the mid
- 20:51-8th century faced a pressing military threat.
- 20:54The Lombard Kingdom in northern Italy was expanding,
- 20:57pressing against the territories around Rome
- 21:00that the Popes claimed. The Byzantine Emperor,
- 21:03theoretically the protector of Italy, was too
- 21:06distant and too weak to defend them. Pope Stephen
- 21:10II came north not merely to anoint a king, but
- 21:14to secure a protector. The negotiations between
- 21:17pope and mayor, now king, were detailed and consequential.
- 21:23Pippin promised to defend the papacy and to restore
- 21:26the territories that the Lombards had seized.
- 21:29In 754 and again in 756, Pippin led Frankish
- 21:34armies across the Alps into Italy. The crossing
- 21:38was a significant military undertaking. The Frankish
- 21:42army had to move through mountain passes where
- 21:45supply was difficult. The army could not live
- 21:48off the land as easily as in the Frankish heartland.
- 21:52The Lombards controlled the approaches to the
- 21:55Italian peninsula. The Lombard king, Aistulf,
- 21:59who had refused to fulfill his promises to the
- 22:02Pope, found himself facing a military force he
- 22:05could not match. Pippin's campaigns were not
- 22:09effortless triumphs. The pressure was sufficient.
- 22:13Eistorf submitted, at least nominally. Pippin
- 22:17was able to grant to the papacy territories in
- 22:20central Italy that had been held by the Lombards
- 22:23or claimed by the Byzantines. This grant, known
- 22:28as the Donation of Pippin, created the territorial
- 22:31foundation of what would become the Papal States.
- 22:35This was a distinct political entity that would
- 22:37endure in various forms until the 19th century.
- 22:41The precise character of this donation is debated.
- 22:45The sources describe a grant of rights and territories,
- 22:49but the legal language is not that of a modern
- 22:51treaty or constitution. The Lombards did not
- 22:55simply disappear. They remained a power in Italy,
- 22:59and Byzantine claims were not formally extinguished.
- 23:03What Pippin provided was Frankish military protection
- 23:06and a practical allocation of territories that
- 23:09the papacy could attempt to govern. The long
- 23:12-term significance was nevertheless profound.
- 23:15The papacy acquired a territorial base independent
- 23:18of both Lombard and Byzantine control. The Frankish
- 23:22king acquired a sacred obligation that tied his
- 23:25prestige to the defense of the Roman Church.
- 23:28The relationship between Pippin and the papacy
- 23:31was reciprocal. not one -sided. The Pope needed
- 23:35a protector. Pippin needed legitimacy. Each supplied
- 23:40what the other lacked. The papal endorsement
- 23:44was a powerful moral and spiritual argument that
- 23:47Pippin could deploy to persuade or overawe Frankish
- 23:50nobles who might otherwise resist the new dynasty.
- 23:53It sacralized a political act, making it appear
- 23:57as the will of God rather than merely the ambition
- 24:00of a powerful family. But the Pope did not simply
- 24:04make Pippin king in the sense of conferring a
- 24:07title that the Franks were bound to recognize,
- 24:09regardless of their own politics. The papal blessing
- 24:13was necessary but not sufficient. It had to be
- 24:17accepted and enacted within the Frankish political
- 24:20world. The continuity of Frankish institutions
- 24:23under the new dynasty is a point that requires
- 24:27emphasis. The Carolingians did not sweep away
- 24:31the Merovingian system and design government
- 24:33anew. They inherited the same assemblies of nobles
- 24:37and bishops. They inherited the same county structure
- 24:41of local administration. They inherited the same
- 24:44network of royal estates and revenues. They inherited
- 24:48the same church organization and legal traditions.
- 24:52Pippin held court of the same palaces, issued
- 24:55charters in similar forms, and presided over
- 24:58the same kind of military and judicial gatherings
- 25:01that his predecessors had done. What changed
- 25:04was the dynasty, the sacred legitimation of its
- 25:08rule, and the increasingly explicit Christian
- 25:11framing of royal activity. The substance of power
- 25:15had long been Pippinid. The form became so as
- 25:19well. But the form was not invented. It was adapted
- 25:24and sacralized. The construction of Merovingian
- 25:29decline in our sources deserves attention, because
- 25:32it has shaped how this transition has been understood.
- 25:36Carolingian and later writers developed a narrative
- 25:39of the later Merovingians as do -nothing kings
- 25:42Roy Fainanes in the French historiographical
- 25:45tradition. They sat on the throne accomplishing
- 25:49nothing while the mayors ruled. There is some
- 25:53basis for this image. The later Merovingians
- 25:56were often young, short -lived or passive. But
- 26:00the image of complete uselessness is partly a
- 26:03construction, a way of making the Carolingian
- 26:07takeover appear natural and necessary. The Merovingians
- 26:11had not simply failed as kings. They had been
- 26:14systematically excluded from power by a family
- 26:17that had learned to operate the machinery of
- 26:19government without them. The decline was not
- 26:23organic. It was produced by political competition
- 26:27that the Pippinids eventually won. The uncertainty
- 26:31that remains in our understanding of these events
- 26:34is considerable. The exact sequence of Pippin's
- 26:38anointing, whether in 751 by bishops, or in 754
- 26:43by the Pope, or both, cannot be established with
- 26:47certainty. The sources are fragmentary. and were
- 26:50revised by later Carolingian writers with an
- 26:53interest in presenting the most impressive version
- 26:56of events. The precise wording of the exchange
- 26:59with Pope Zacharias is not directly preserved.
- 27:03We have only the account in the royal Frankish
- 27:06annals and related texts composed after the fact.
- 27:10The motives of individual Frankish nobles in
- 27:13accepting the dynastic change are largely inaccessible
- 27:16to us. We know that Pippin faced some resistance.
- 27:20including a revolt in 753 that may have been
- 27:24connected to the deposition. But the details
- 27:26are sparse. The exact territorial extent and
- 27:30legal character of the donation of Pippin are
- 27:33debated. Some historians emphasize the practical
- 27:37grant of revenues and protection. Others emphasize
- 27:40the more ambitious claims of papal sovereignty
- 27:43that developed in later centuries. What can be
- 27:46said with confidence? is that the carolingian
- 27:49accession to the frankish throne was a deliberate
- 27:52political act it was prepared by generations
- 27:56of aristocratic accumulation and accomplished
- 27:59through a combination of elite control military
- 28:02prestige and sacred ritual it was not a peaceful
- 28:07constitutional succession in any modern sense
- 28:10it involved the deposition of a reigning dynasty
- 28:14It involved the physical transformation of its
- 28:17last representative through tonsure and confinement,
- 28:20and it involved the deployment of papal authority
- 28:23to legitimize what force and negotiation had
- 28:27already made probable. It was not proof that
- 28:30Merovingian rule had naturally ended, as if dynasties
- 28:35simply expire when they become ineffective. The
- 28:38Merovingians were removed, actively and politically.
- 28:42by a family that had learned to rule without
- 28:44them, and then sought the title that would make
- 28:47its rule complete. The mechanism at work is one
- 28:51that recurs in various forms across history.
- 28:54Long accumulated practical power, whether economic,
- 28:58military, or institutional, requires legitimation
- 29:02to become stable and heritable. Force alone is
- 29:06insufficient for durable rule. The Pippinids
- 29:09understood this. Charles Martel could have attempted
- 29:14to seize the throne by main strength, and perhaps
- 29:17failed or succeeded only to see his dynasty quickly
- 29:20reversed. Pippin the Short chose a different
- 29:24path. He chose a path that acknowledged the sacred
- 29:27and ritual dimensions of kingship and sought
- 29:31to harness them for a new dynasty. The papal
- 29:34alliance supplied the necessary legitimation.
- 29:38In return, the papacy acquired a protector and
- 29:41a territorial foundation that would shape the
- 29:43political geography of Italy for centuries. The
- 29:47Carolingians captured the Frankish throne by
- 29:50converting generations of accumulated aristocratic
- 29:53power into sacred kingship. They used papal recognition
- 29:58to make dynastic displacement appear legitimate.
- 30:00They inherited the institutions of the Merovingian
- 30:04world, rather than designing government from
- 30:07scratch. The anointing did not create their power,
- 30:11but it transformed its character. It bound the
- 30:14new dynasty to the church and to a developing
- 30:17ideology of Christian kingship that would have
- 30:20profound consequences for the political culture
- 30:23of medieval Europe. The last Merovingian was
- 30:27tonsured and sent to a monastery. The first Carolingian
- 30:31king was anointed with holy oil and pledged to
- 30:35defend the Roman church. Between those two acts,
- 30:39performed within a few years of each other, lies
- 30:41the story of how practical power became sacred
- 30:44title, and how a family of Austrasian mayors
- 30:48became the royal dynasty that would shape the
- 30:51early medieval West.