Latest / Psychology In Seattle Podcast / The Dan Brophy Murder
Transcript
- 0:00Hey, deserving listeners, It's just me today. I wanted to tell you
- 0:03about an interesting murder case that I recently did a mini deep dive on,
- 0:10but first let me give you an introduction here. So a fan of the
- 0:16podcast emailed me and she tells me that she works for Wondery, which is
- 0:21a podcast consortium. I don't know if that's the correct term, but that's
- 0:27the word I'm using, in which it has dozens of podcasts that are made
- 0:32by Wondery, including some podcasts that I've listened to, like The Shrink next
- 0:37Door, the Cold Podcast, Doctor Death, this kind of thing. And
- 0:42they don't just do true crime. They have a lot of different types of
- 0:45podcasts. But I've talked extensively on this podcast about the Shrink next Door podcast
- 0:52and also the Cold podcast, which was about Josh Powell. So when I
- 0:59received this email, it piqued my interest because of her association with Wondery.
- 1:06And she tells me that she's working on a podcast about a murder that happened
- 1:08in Portland, Oregon, which is, you know, near Seattle, and
- 1:14uh so I was like, it's interesting, sort of close to home.
- 1:17It's sort of like Josh powis both, and she wanted to interview me on
- 1:22the podcast as an expert about personality. And you know, lately, I've
- 1:26been turning down these requests because I'm trying to get my work life balance in
- 1:33order. But I love Wondery and I also since it was a fan of
- 1:38the pot because I get a lot of these requests just randomly, right or
- 1:42from people that go on YouTube and just search for certain keywords and they come
- 1:48across me and then they email me. But this was someone that's a fan,
- 1:51maybe even a patron, I'm not sure, and I agree to it
- 1:56now. Normally, what this involves for me is is that they will schedule
- 2:01an appointments where we talk remotely. They record me for thirty to sixty minutes,
- 2:08and that's that. But this was different because apparently wonder or this podcast
- 2:15anyway, has a lot of money being invested in it, because there are
- 2:20several staff members that were on the initial you know, video conference call.
- 2:29And that's another difference was that they didn't just call me to interview me.
- 2:35They called me to have a meeting about the future interview of me, you
- 2:38know, and in this initial meeting, there were like five or six people
- 2:45with really cool titles like Storyteller and you know, stuff like that, and
- 2:52also tech people people that understood how to optimize audio and this kind of thing,
- 2:58and it kind of raised my nervousness level about it. But it worked
- 3:04on me because the initial intro meeting was setting me up with the data.
- 3:10They actually sent me the full podcasts because it hadn't been published completely yet,
- 3:17and they also sent me all these outtakes that they didn't use for the podcast
- 3:23as additional data that I could pour over so that I could provide my professional
- 3:29opinion. And normally, when these outfits will contact me, I don't spend
- 3:36that much time looking into it because you know, it just seems like not
- 3:43the best use of my time. But since they gave me all the data
- 3:47and they sort of peaked my interest and I got hooked on the story,
- 3:53I spent a lot of time actually looking into it and thinking about it.
- 3:59And what that did is it made me a much better interviewee once they eventually
- 4:04interviewed me. So you know, it really worked. And I was also
- 4:10getting a little nervous about the interview because the stakes seem pretty high. Another
- 4:15detail that they told me was that the podcast was I don't know what rank,
- 4:21something like second or third most popular English speaking podcast in the world at
- 4:29the time. Maybe still I don't know, And I thought, oh,
- 4:32my goodness, you know that's saying something anyway. So let me tell you
- 4:39about the case here. This is going back to twenty eighteen, June second,
- 4:46twenty eighteen, Portland, Oregon, and we are at a culinary school
- 4:53and it's in the morning, and a student arrives at the culinary school expecting
- 4:59to find the teacher, a chef named Dan Brofy. But the student walks
- 5:05into the kitchen area, the teaching area, and he sees the teacher on
- 5:11the floor of the kitchen seemingly unconscious, and the student initially assumes that it
- 5:16must be a heart attack. Dan Brophy is in his sixties, so you
- 5:20know, that would be the assumption, and he starts administering CPR, I
- 5:27think, some sort of aid, but then he sees blood and at some
- 5:30point he realizes that Dan did not have a heart attack, but had been
- 5:35shot or injured or something. Called police medical professionals they arrive and they determine
- 5:42that Dan was murdered, shot twice by a gun. So there's an investigation.
- 5:48Police arrive and the first thing they look at is signs of forced entry,
- 5:56robbery, this kind of thing. There didn't seem to be any indication
- 6:00of that his wallet was in his pocket, that kind of thing. There
- 6:01didn't seem to be anything stolen from the facility. There didn't seem to be
- 6:08any forced injury already, kind of broken items or anything. So that's notable,
- 6:14and they start to get a list of possible suspects. They think,
- 6:20well, it's downtown Portland. There are reports of people who live on the
- 6:26streets down there, so maybe it was someone who lives on the streets,
- 6:30someone who broke in there to kill, to get money, or some other
- 6:35reason. They also wondered if it was a disgruntled student, I think,
- 6:42because workplace murders often are disgruntled associates, right, So that was another angle
- 6:51they were looking at. And they also wondered if Dan had any personal enemies,
- 6:58right, like a jealous boyfriend or you know something. So the cops
- 7:02interview that day all the students as they're arriving, and the investigator's note just
- 7:11how beloved the teacher was. The students are distraught, crying and talking about
- 7:15how much they appreciate this figure in the community because apparently Dan had been known
- 7:23in the community in Portland for a long time, and so they investigate by
- 7:30talking to it. It reminds me of a movie that came out a while
- 7:33back with Nicholas Cage. I think he plays a chef in Portland, Oregon,
- 7:39if I'm not mistaken unrelated, But anyway, the police, they interview
- 7:44the students. They also interview the people who live on the streets nearby.
- 7:48They interview the few family members that they can get a hold of, including
- 7:53Dan's wife, Nancy. Nancy tells them, you know, she's very distraught,
- 7:59but she says that she was that morning at home walking the dogs,
- 8:05taking a shower, et cetera, and it all seemed believable. The cops
- 8:09determine that the murder must have happened within a particular thirteen minute time frame.
- 8:16I think it's because they knew when Dan arrived, and they knew when the
- 8:20student arrived, and there was a thirteen minute time frame there. So it
- 8:24was a very limited timeframe in which Dan could have been killed and shot.
- 8:31But the investigation hits a dead end because they can't find any enemies, personal
- 8:37enemies, of Dan that seem viable. They can't seem to find any students
- 8:43that would have any sort of motivation to do that, and any sort of
- 8:48family member that might because Dan did have some history of estrange relationships, like
- 8:56with his own son, But all of those individuals could not have killed him
- 9:01because they weren't even nearby. They might have even been in a different state,
- 9:05that sort of thing. So the investigation pretty quickly is looking like it's
- 9:11they don't have any good leads right Well, a few days later, the
- 9:16wife, Nancy, she calls the investigator, the police officer, and this
- 9:24is recorded, by the way, and provided on the podcast, and by
- 9:30the way, the podcast is called Happily Never After, Happily Never After,
- 9:35And the recording you hear Nancy call up the police officer and the Nancy is
- 9:41very casually. You're going to remember, this is like three or four days
- 9:45after the murder. She casually asks the investigator for a statement saying that she
- 9:50is not a suspect because her insurance, the life insurance Dan's life insurance won't
- 9:56pay on a forty thousand dollars life insurance policy until it's established that Nancy is
- 10:05not a suspect, you know what I'm saying. So Nancy's like, hey,
- 10:07I'm just calling, and you have to listen to this recording because it
- 10:11is it's particular because she just comes across like she's calling a colleague at work
- 10:18about some memo that she received. You know, it just seems really casual,
- 10:24and she's like, hey, yeah, you know, I just would
- 10:26you know, I don't know if you do this sort of thing, and
- 10:28I'm really sorry about for bothering you, but I really need this note from
- 10:33you saying that I'm not a suspect, if that's possible, because this life
- 10:37insurance won't pay on the forty thousand dollars life insurance policy. I don't know
- 10:43if you do that sort of thing, but you know, if you could
- 10:43help me out. And she's being very nice. By the way, Nancy
- 10:48and Dan are in their sixties, I probably should mention that I don't know
- 10:52if this is sort of contextual, and the police officer, you hear him
- 10:58kind of a chuckle to himself and say, well, we don't really do
- 11:03that sort of thing. We don't, you know, write notes saying that
- 11:09someone is not a suspect, just particularly this early in the investigation, and
- 11:15Nancy says, oh, okay, well, you know it was worth trying,
- 11:18and then you know, they hang up, and the investigator notes that
- 11:22this is very odd. It's just a few days later. He's never received
- 11:26a phone call like this before, and he makes note of it. But
- 11:31there's not really any other reason to suspect that Nancy would have killed Dan.
- 11:37There weren't any reports from family or friends or anybody indicating that there were any
- 11:43sort of threats or violence or reason for a murder within this within this marriage.
- 11:52Also, according to everyone involved, the way it looked is that they
- 11:58looked like they were a good couple. They're in their sixties, Nancy seems
- 12:01like a sweet old lady quote unquote, and it just doesn't fit the profile,
- 12:09or at least the stereotype of what a murderer would look like. Right,
- 12:13So the cops continue to investigate throughout the rest of twenty eighteen, and
- 12:20they don't find anything useful. I'm guessing, based on what I know the
- 12:26story to be, that this case became a file that was buried underneath other
- 12:33files because there just wasn't much to go off of and they didn't have any
- 12:39leads, right, So, the rest of twenty eighteen they don't find anything
- 12:45useful, and then all of twenty nineteen they also don't find anything notable,
- 12:50and then in twenty twenty, the police they are doing a number of different
- 12:56things over the two years, but one of the things that they had to
- 13:03help them with the investigation was there was a security camera on the outside on
- 13:09the street, not inside, unfortunately, but they had a security camera outside
- 13:13and they would in a very tedious way, look over all the footage to
- 13:20see if they could figure out who pulled up to the school and see if
- 13:26they could see someone going in and out during that thirteen minute time frame,
- 13:31and they couldn't find anything notable. And the way that cops talk about it
- 13:35is it's very tedious, you know, very time consuming, and is scrolling
- 13:39through this video footage that isn't high resolution. It's pretty low resolution, but
- 13:45you know, you can make out the type of car, the color of
- 13:48the car, and they can also make out the drivers or the passengers sort
- 13:54of. You know, they can't really see the face, but they could
- 13:56see the general outline of somebody. And at some point during the investigation,
- 14:03one of the investigators notices that there's a van that he remembers seeing, and
- 14:13he says that he remembered seeing that Nancy had a very similar van, and
- 14:20you know, you can't see who's driving the car. You can't really see
- 14:22the license plate. But it's just an interesting moment in the investigation that if
- 14:30that hadn't happened, then maybe they wouldn't have gone down the road that they
- 14:33did. So the investigators like, oh, there's like I think it's like
- 14:39a gray mini van or gray van, and the investigators like, you know,
- 14:45that's that's a similar van to the one I saw Nancy arrive to the
- 14:52colon, you know, that morning when they noted where somehow Nancy was notified.
- 14:58She drives to the Culinarios school and the police officer goes over to Nancy
- 15:01and sees the van, and you know, he's putting two and two together,
- 15:07but you know, it's not a strong indication of anything, but he
- 15:09knowses his van, and then he is trying to get other security camera footage
- 15:16from around that neighborhood, and you know, there's a lot of details here
- 15:22that's in the podcast, but eventually finds that there are other video camera footage
- 15:31indicating that there was this fan similar to Nancy's driving around the neighborhood seemingly several
- 15:39times on the same street, like driving past the culinary school a number of
- 15:43times. It didn't seem to make a lot of sense. And they finally,
- 15:48after in this very tedious way, going over all this video camera footage,
- 15:52they find one camera angle from a particular storefront that you can make out
- 16:02the first three letters of the license plate and you can make out the driver
- 16:07kind of. You can't positively identify Nancy, but the driver looks like the
- 16:14way Nancy would look through a low res camera, if that makes sense.
- 16:18So not only is the van make and model and color similar to Nancy's,
- 16:23which isn't a strong indication of anything, but they actually kind of you know,
- 16:27see the license plate and make out the driver kind of. So at
- 16:33this point, and there's a lot of other details here, but at this
- 16:36point they arrest Nancy. They believe that they have enough information to start looking
- 16:44more into this. And by the way, you know, if you've listened
- 16:49to the Josh Powell Deep Diver, you know about that story. Just think
- 16:55about how little information, how little evidence they have against Nancy at this point,
- 17:02and yet they arrested or the prosecutor authorized the arrest of Nancy, whereas
- 17:07in Utah with Josh Powell, in my estimation, there was you know,
- 17:14fifty times more data, more evidence circumstantially pointing at Josh as a potential,
- 17:23you know, a person involved in the disappearance or the murder potential murder of
- 17:30of of Susan Powell. And yet they never arrested Josh, not even after
- 17:37weeks went by, you know. So yeah, it's just another indication that
- 17:42maybe there was something weird going on with that Utah prosecutor that now they have
- 17:47a lot of blood on their hands, considering that the two boys are dead.
- 17:49You know, the person responsible for killing those kids is Josh. But
- 17:52you know, you just you just have to wonder. But also in this
- 17:57case, there's a Dan's body is there, there's you know, there's the
- 18:03body and it's murdered clearly, someone shot him twice, whereas with Susan,
- 18:08powder's no body. So you know, it's a factor. But I don't
- 18:11know, it just seems like, come on, all right, let's take
- 18:14a break, we get back, I will talk about what they discovered.
- 18:22All right, we're back from the break. So again, you have Dan
- 18:25Brophy, this chef, very well known, very accomplished chef, who is
- 18:30a teacher in a culinary school, having been murdered by two gun shot wounds
- 18:37in his culinary school. And they have now arrested the wife based on the
- 18:45the evidence that they have showing that she was in that neighborhood, driving around
- 18:52that neighborhood in her van, and her story upon being interviewed the more of
- 19:00the murder was that she was not down there. In fact, she said
- 19:03she was at home. So that and some other details, They're like,
- 19:08okay, let's arrest her and let's start looking into this. So they discover
- 19:14at some point along the way that she not only had that one life insurance
- 19:18policy on DAN for forty thousand dollars, but she had ten life insurance policies
- 19:26on DAN with her as the beneficiary, amounting to one point four million dollars.
- 19:33So that's one detail, you know, circumstantial. Certainly a lot of
- 19:37people have life insurance policies. I don't know about ten, but you know
- 19:45which I suppose. I'm not an expert in this, and I don't know
- 19:48that much about this as a layperson, but I could imagine maybe a perpetrator
- 19:55would buy a bunch as a way to throw people off the scent, because
- 20:00you know, they think that if you just look at one of the life
- 20:02insurance policies, it's not enough money that people would think would motivate a murder.
- 20:07So they're just trying to spread out. I don't know, I don't
- 20:11know. Also another detail that they find is that Nancy had recently bought gun
- 20:18parts. And so I have to claim a little bit of ignorance here because
- 20:22in the reporting both on the podcast Happily Never After and also on a lot
- 20:29of online news sources, I couldn't figure out if there was one gun or
- 20:34two guns. But it doesn't really matter ultimately, but uh, there's a
- 20:41chance that she bought a gun a glock, and she also bought a bunch
- 20:47of parts of a gun. And I didn't even know this was possible until
- 20:52this case. But apparently on eBay you can buy gun parts. And I'm
- 20:59not sure about this, but my impression was that if you buy gun parts,
- 21:03you don't have to register, so you can buy all the parts of
- 21:07a gun having never registered buying the gun. But you put those parts together
- 21:12and now you have an unregistered gun. Does that make sense? I don't
- 21:15know. Or another thing that I couldn't really tell if this was what the
- 21:22plan was, was that if you buy a gun and then you buy the
- 21:27barrel, I don't know, they don't call it a barrel, but you
- 21:30know, the thing on the top of the gun, and you replace it
- 21:36with a different barrel, and you use the gun, and then you put
- 21:40the original barrel back on. It looks like you never shot the gun.
- 21:42Does that make sense? Anyway, this part I didn't understand. Apparently,
- 21:48you know, it was a big part of the story because the gun that
- 21:52was used to kill Dan Brophy was found to be a glock of some sort.
- 21:56I don't know how they knew that, maybe the the particular ammo or
- 22:02you know, I don't know how you tell the model of a or the
- 22:07make of a gun base. Anyway, they knew it was a glock.
- 22:10And they also found that Nancy had bought these gun parts and or another gun.
- 22:17So they also found that just before the murder, she went to a
- 22:23gun range that didn't require ID you know, I don't know what that means,
- 22:29but you know, it's just another detail. And by the way,
- 22:33normally like if this is the Josh Powell thing, I would look into all
- 22:37these details to kind of lock it down. You know. One thing you
- 22:41realize when you're this sort of like I don't know if I would call myself
- 22:45a secondary journalist, where I'm trying to gather a story from other people having
- 22:51gathered stories, if that makes any sense. I have learned that it's hard
- 22:56to find the facts. You know, there's a lot of reporting on facts,
- 23:00but it's worded in a way that it's not it's not concrete to me
- 23:07what is actually the fact, and it's hard. It's you know, so
- 23:11something you know, like with the Josh Powell case, I ran into that,
- 23:17what was it? It was some kind of detail. Well, there
- 23:21was that one detail of that woman who claims she heard a woman saying something
- 23:27like I don't want to go and then the man saying you will get into
- 23:30that car something like that, and a lot of people report on that as
- 23:37factually related to the case where Josh was clearly trying to coerce her into the
- 23:45van at midnight the night that she disappeared. But when Dave Cally of The
- 23:49Cold podcast looked into it and found it, well, there's a lot of
- 23:53reasons to believe that that data point is tainted by the fact that the woman
- 24:00doesn't really remember what night it was, and no one else heard it in
- 24:03the neighborhood, and she was suffering from some sort of illness, and so
- 24:07it's just little stuff like that where it's As a person myself, I'm very
- 24:12detail oriented, so I don't like to present things as if I know what
- 24:19I'm talking about. I also don't like to if I don't know what I'm
- 24:22talking about. I also don't like to present things that are possibly not supported
- 24:30by the data, even though one journalist or one YouTuber claims it was you
- 24:34know what I mean. So I'm just framing it all that way. Plus
- 24:40I didn't want to go down a rabbit hole like I did with the Josh
- 24:42Powell caase with this Nancy Brofit case, because I again work life balance.
- 24:51Plus you know, just listen to the Happily Never After podcasts they go through
- 24:53all this stuff. But I also did get additional in from it, and
- 24:59really what I'm adding eventually I'm going to get to my bit on how to
- 25:03look at this diagnosis. And the more of these cases I go over,
- 25:06the more it starts to change my conceptualization of narcissistic person, I sorder in
- 25:12general, which I'll get to in a second. But so I'm still learning.
- 25:17I'm still a learning person. And they found so they found these ten
- 25:22life of insurance policies. They find that there was this gun, and there's
- 25:30some shadiness around the purchase, you know, of the parts and that sort
- 25:33of thing. Now she will immediately claim that the gun was for legitimate reasons,
- 25:40which I'll get into you later. They also found out that Dan and
- 25:44Nancy had been fighting a lot recently, contrary to the way in which a
- 25:49lot of people were thinking that they're really a lot of people thought that their
- 25:55relationship was ideal, and Nancy would often talk about their relationship as if it
- 26:00was ideal. But there was seemingly some pretty strong evidence that they were fighting
- 26:04a lot behind the scenes, and they were struggling financially, which is one
- 26:10of the things that they fought a lot about. She I haven't talked about
- 26:12her career yet, which I'll get to in a second. This is,
- 26:15you know, arguably one of the main kind of taglines of the of the
- 26:18story is that she's an author. Later in life, she decided that she
- 26:23wanted to become an author, and she started writing writing fictional novels, and
- 26:29they were romance novels, and they were in a particular they had a particular
- 26:36theme which I'll get to you later. And she was not making much money,
- 26:41or maybe not making any money, maybe even losing money at being an
- 26:45author. I don't know the exact finances, but at really she wasn't making
- 26:49very much. And he was a very prestigious chef and had been for a
- 26:55long time, but he wasn't that interested in making a lot of money and
- 26:59having prestigious jobs so he would have a career. He built his career around
- 27:06what he liked to do, which didn't have anything to do with fanciness and
- 27:11money and prestige. He liked his life. And she wanted him to get
- 27:18a job at a fancy restaurant, get paid more, this kind of thing,
- 27:22but he didn't want to do that. Also, another detail along these
- 27:27lines is that because they were having trouble even just paying their mortgage, you
- 27:33know, it was their finances. This is reminiscent of the Josh and Susan
- 27:40Powell situation, right that the money situation was, you know, looking pretty
- 27:45dire such that Dan asked a friend if he could work for her in her
- 27:52restaurant, and the friend was like, well, Dan, you're way over
- 28:00for this cook position. You know, you working for me doesn't make any
- 28:06sense. You know, I wouldn't be paying you that much and this would
- 28:10be way below your pay grade. And Dan was like, it doesn't matter.
- 28:15I need a job. I need this extra money. And so Dan
- 28:18was working this second job. I don't know if it was part time or
- 28:22full time, but he was working this second job at a job way below
- 28:26his station. And the friend noticed that in the recent weeks leading up to
- 28:33his murder that he was often in a really foul mood. Reportedly, he
- 28:38could be in a pretty nasty foul mood often, not often, but sometimes
- 28:44he had a dark side to himself. I think he went through some shit
- 28:47growing up, and he could be quite caustic with people. And the friend
- 28:52said that he was in a bad mood and one morning or one day,
- 28:59he actually snapped at her and this was notable to the friend because that doesn't
- 29:03normally happen, and so the friend tried to talk with Dan about it.
- 29:07But Dan is a very very quiet person. So the friend called Nancy the
- 29:15wife, right, and so they talk, and Nancy talks a lot,
- 29:18so she was very disclosing. And Nancy told the friend that, yeah,
- 29:25well, you know, this is understandable because he's not really mad at you,
- 29:30he's mad at me. So Nancy's saying, when my husband snapped at
- 29:36you, he wasn't really mad at you. He's mad at me because we've
- 29:41been fighting a lot lately. I find this is interesting detail which provides some
- 29:45nuance that I can get to later. And apparently they were fighting about a
- 29:52lot of things finances. Also, Nancy really wanted to move to Portugal at
- 29:59this time. She really wanted to sell the house, and she really wanted
- 30:03to get out of Portland, and she really wanted him Dan to shed his
- 30:10lifestyle. He had a very comfy life his house, he had chickens,
- 30:14and he had all of these things that he involved himself with hobby wise that
- 30:21Nancy was really trying to get him to discard. And they were fighting and
- 30:26fighting and fighting and fighting about that. Now. I'm sure there are a
- 30:30lot of details and nuances to this conflict, but we'll never know because Dan
- 30:40has died and Nancy is not likely to come forward. About this. Plus
- 30:45Dan didn't talk about his feelings, so any of his close associates at the
- 30:52time wouldn't have heard anything from him, and he didn't write anything down,
- 30:56so we just don't really know or just peeking through a not hole in the
- 31:02fence and seeing these tiny details. So it's hard to know, but I'm
- 31:06guessing that it was quite extensive, which I'll get into you later. So
- 31:11they're fighting a lot, and Nancy really wanted to sell the house and move
- 31:17to Portugal and Dan didn't. Okay. Another detail, So again, you
- 31:23have the life and service policies, you have the gun, you have the
- 31:26marital conflict. Another detail is that Nancy's books, when they look into her
- 31:33various different books, they're mostly about a woman who is in a loveless marriage
- 31:41who has an affair with like a navy seal, you know, it's always
- 31:45a navy seal, and the woman wants to get out of her marriage,
- 31:48but her husband is this tyrant and so she kills the husband with a gun
- 31:56and then runs off with the navy seal and it happily ever after. So
- 32:00this is a theme in her books that she writes about of you know,
- 32:06with romance novels. There's a lot of different themes. It's funny, the
- 32:09only experience I have with romance novels is that my wife has been a model
- 32:15for the covers of these romance novels. And we only have like a handful
- 32:22of these books, but there's probably dozens of books that my wife, as
- 32:27a professional model, she would, you know, get a lot of types
- 32:30of gigs. It's really interesting to observe that with Stacy is just the amount
- 32:37of gigs that she's involved with. You know, sometimes she'll be doing things
- 32:42that you know that models do, like doing runway stuff for you know,
- 32:47like there was this one runway thing that Stacey did in Seattle for a famous
- 32:54renowned designer in Seattle that does addresses and it was for wedding dresses and bridesmaid's
- 33:02dresses and I can't remember her name, but so that sort of stuff.
- 33:10And when Stacey was in New York, she did a lot more of that
- 33:15kind of stuff. Seattle doesn't really have a huge market for modeling because you
- 33:22know, all the advertising agencies are mostly in New York and as you know,
- 33:24and then a lot of them in La to some except but Seattle not
- 33:28so much. But for a while Amazon actually had their main advertising wing was
- 33:35in Seattle, but they a few a number of years ago moved most of
- 33:42their modeling to New York or something anyway, but she might do that.
- 33:46She might also just operate as a living model, a living mannequin. In
- 33:53some I mean, it sounds demeaning, but Stacey actually likes this kind of
- 33:57work where designers, as they're trying to figure out the dimensions and the design
- 34:05of an outfit, they will meet in a room and they'll have actual people
- 34:12that they put the clothes on and see how they hang and see the you
- 34:16know, is the waistline right and all that kind of stuff, and they
- 34:20talk about it. And like I said, Stacey likes that kind of work.
- 34:23And that's another thing is detail is a little detail. Is that I
- 34:30have learned that the stereotype of what it's like to be a model. You
- 34:34know, certainly Stacey's been a model since she was a teenager, so she's
- 34:37had all the experiences, and she's experienced the bad side, you know,
- 34:42the exploitation and the objectification and the pressure to be thin and that kind of
- 34:52stuff. But ninety nine point nine percent of her experiences, according to her
- 34:57have been neutral or positive. You know, it's a it's a fun atmosphere,
- 35:01it's a creative atmosphere. It's interesting to do you get paid a lot
- 35:07for a relatively easy time at it. Now, I will say that I
- 35:15had Stacy has asked me to model at times. Not model model, but
- 35:19like you know, when she started to get into photography, she would practice
- 35:23on me and I would be, you know, quote unquote modeling for about
- 35:29four and a half minutes, and I'd be going out of my mind,
- 35:31be like, are we done yet? I can't stand just standing here and
- 35:37doing this, holding this position, or trying to smile under these conditions.
- 35:40And she'd be like, I haven't even set up the lighting yet. You
- 35:45you're in that, You're in this for a while. She's like, when
- 35:50I do this, I'll do it for ten hours straight, you know.
- 35:52And and that the skill level of having to keep a good attitude and to
- 36:00because you know, if you're internally just being tortured, you can't conjure the
- 36:07facial expression that they are often looking for unless they're looking for a tortured board
- 36:13individual, which is not usually the case, you know, but anyway,
- 36:15so one of the gigs that she had was these romance novels, and I
- 36:21we have copies of them and I'll sort of flip through them a little bit.
- 36:23And that's the only contact I've ever had with these. But apparently romance
- 36:28novels run the gamut, you know, there's a lot of different types.
- 36:30But her type was in a loveless marriage, kill the husband, run off
- 36:36with the navy seal. And I was just kind of notable given the allegation
- 36:40that she murdered her husband. And now there wasn't any evidence that she had
- 36:45an Avy CeAl on the side, but there was evidence that she might have
- 36:50wanted to kill him, get the insurance money, sell the house, finally
- 36:54move to Portugal, and live happily ever after. So another detail that is
- 37:04and so this detail is the main detail that is discuss you know, if
- 37:07there's a short paragraph that's written about this case, this is the detail that
- 37:09they always bring up, which is that she wrote an essay that was purportedly
- 37:15satirical a number of years before Dan died, titled how to Murder your Husband,
- 37:22and it details how you would murder your husband. And that is that's
- 37:30the tagline of this story, right, you have this this romance novelist who
- 37:36writes this piece called how to Murder Your Husband and then allegedly murders her husband.
- 37:40You know, she's just like right out there in the open with it.
- 37:44But more on that later. Also, the investigators find on her computer
- 37:49that she was researching a number of suspicious things like how to live alone as
- 37:53an expat, how to murder, how she was searching information about body decomposition
- 38:00and you know how long it takes for a body to decompose. But you
- 38:05know, she would say, and I think it's legit that this is research
- 38:08for her books, especially the body decomposition thing, because that wouldn't well unless
- 38:15she was trying to figure out what to do, maybe murder him at home
- 38:21and then bury him somewhere. You know, who knows. But it's hard
- 38:23to know if that if that's related, but you know, very well could
- 38:27be also how to live alone as an expat, That could be a result
- 38:30of her searching while she was not considering murder but considering divorce, you know.
- 38:36So you know, it's just hard to know, but it was details
- 38:38that you bring up and as an investigator, and of course, another major
- 38:45detail, if not the major detail, is that her alibi was that she
- 38:49was at home the whole time of that morning, when in fact they found
- 38:52the video of her driving around that neighborhood. Okay, so let's take a
- 38:58break a week, get back, let's go to the trial or back from
- 39:04the break. So the trial, I'm gonna provide. It's pretty complicated,
- 39:08and I only had access to bits and pieces of the trial. So this
- 39:15is, you know, my understanding of the situation. All right. So
- 39:20her narrative, her defense tried to address all of the circumstantial, all the
- 39:27evidence against her. So let's talk about the gun. She said, two
- 39:31things that I heard was that the gun was for Dan because she was Nancy
- 39:42was worried about Dan because when he went mushroom hunting, then there was worries.
- 39:46Okay, so let me explain. Mushroom hunting is something that is big
- 39:52in my family. I don't know if it's a Japanese American thing or an
- 39:55Asian American thing, or just a thing with my dad, but since an
- 40:01early age, my dad would take us on these think of like fishing trips.
- 40:07It would be kind of like that, right, It'd be a chance
- 40:12to bond. It wouldn't really be centered around the mushrooms. And my dad
- 40:16also really liked a particular kind of mushroom and I'm pretty sure it's shataki,
- 40:23but don't quote me on that. And we would drive east into the mountains,
- 40:30Cascade Mountains, and there would be all these logging roads with all these
- 40:36you know, pine and fir trees and untouched and my dad knew how to
- 40:45find these I think shataki mushrooms. He also knew how to differentiate between them.
- 40:50And there's a poisonous one that looks like it, and he would teach
- 40:52it to us, and you know, it's very bonding. And we'd bring
- 40:55our dog, Feffer off leash and she was very well trained and very well
- 41:01behaved and would run around and you know, enjoy being with us, and
- 41:07we would find these chataki mushrooms and these mushrooms. This is all just from
- 41:14memory. I don't know if any of this is accurate, but I remember
- 41:17being told that these mushrooms were very, very expensive. I don't think they
- 41:22are easily or even possibly grown in captivity, if you know what I'm saying.
- 41:27So they always had to be found somewhere. And from my understanding,
- 41:31the Pacific Northwest is a good place to find them, and they were they
- 41:38would always be right next to a tree, and I think they were often
- 41:44on the non sunny side, you know, the north side, And when
- 41:50you picked them, you had to smell them a certain way, because if
- 41:52they smelled, there was a certain smell that differentiated between the edible ones and
- 41:58the poisonous ones. It was always kind of to me, but my dad
- 42:00seemed to always know what he was doing. And when we were young,
- 42:06when I was young, we would go into the mountains and we would come
- 42:10home with like a bag full, maybe I don't know, ten or twenty
- 42:15of these mushrooms. And there's also a particular recipe that we would cook these
- 42:23up with. They're so big and meaty that you could just eat them with
- 42:28a fork and a knife with like show you or soy sauce or tariochy sauce
- 42:34or something. I don't know how they it was some sort of preparation like
- 42:36that. And as we got older, as I got older, we would
- 42:39go into the mountains and there'd be fewer and fewer of these mushrooms, and
- 42:45then eventually it was at least this is my understanding. I don't know if
- 42:51any of this is true, but it was useless to go into the mountains
- 42:55to get them because you would never find any. And the reason for that
- 42:59that I was told was because there were people who were going into the mountains
- 43:06to get these mushrooms because they were selling them, and given how valuable these
- 43:14were, you know, how valuable each one was, it was kind of
- 43:21a big deal to certain people. And I think the thought was was that
- 43:24you had people who were immigrants who were having trouble with getting ahead in life,
- 43:32you know, because of racism or lack of opportunity or something, and
- 43:38a fast track to at least getting some semblance of financial security was to get
- 43:47these mushrooms in the mountains, because not a lot of people did this sort
- 43:52of thing. But the problem was is that you had a lot of different
- 43:55groups that were competing to get these mushrooms, and occasionally I think there was
- 44:00violence, you know, sort of like gang activity of you know, this
- 44:06is my territory and how dare you come to my my hunting grounds, you
- 44:12know, and it became a dangerous activity, whereas when I was a kid,
- 44:19it seemed like no one was doing it, or very few anyway,
- 44:23I mean, occasionally we would run into people. But you know, the
- 44:27forest is big and there was so much room. And it's also hard too
- 44:34because it's there's no trail, so you're just you know, troucing, trouncing,
- 44:38trumping, you're just walking through the bushes and so you can't get very
- 44:43far. So you know, it was easy to avoid other people, it
- 44:51was, and it was easy to find an area that didn't seem like other
- 44:53people had been searching there. And my dad really loved We'd be driving,
- 44:59you know, on some country road and my dad'd be like, ooh,
- 45:02that's probably a good spot for mushroom hunting, and and you know, I
- 45:07have a lot of fun memories about that, especially when we'd come home and
- 45:10you'd like cook up your you know, what you got and and share it
- 45:20with others you know that didn't come with us. It's like it's like,
- 45:22you know, getting a fish and then you know, you clean it and
- 45:27you cook it up that kind of stuff. It always tastes better when you
- 45:30catch it yourself. And so we uh so what Nancy reported was that and
- 45:38I think another friend or something that Dan would go mushroom hunting and had once
- 45:46they were up there and they heard some noise nearby and it freaked them out.
- 45:54And I think it was based on this premise that there are gangs or
- 46:01groups that are protective of their hunting grounds and might harm you if you are
- 46:09in their territory. And so they were in the woods once, Dan and
- 46:15a friend and they heard what sounded like maybe someone moving through the bushes,
- 46:21stalking them or something, and it freaked them out. And so Nancy says
- 46:25that she bought Dan a gun, the glock, so that he could protect
- 46:30himself in the woods. Other people would say that doesn't make any sense because
- 46:36Dan hated guns and would never resort to that, you know, that sort
- 46:40of thing, you know, But this is nancy story. The other story
- 46:45in addition to this that she had was that she bought the gun and the
- 46:49gun parts for research for her book because she had a character that she wanted
- 46:54to buy a gunkit online or something like that. Now, during the trial,
- 47:00the defense brought a bunch of her author friends. She was a part
- 47:04of an author support group or group in Portland, and there's a lot of
- 47:10data from these friends because they knew her pretty well and they would testify on
- 47:17the stand that they all as writers, particularly of this genre would buy things
- 47:25that would be very strange to the outside world. Like one woman said that
- 47:30she bought a chastity belt, you know, as for research for a book.
- 47:36She didn't buy a chastity belt because she wanted to wear a chastity belt.
- 47:38She who wore. She bought a chassi belt because she wanted to research
- 47:42for the And it's totally normal for authors to buy gun parts or other kinds
- 47:49of implements or to search for decomposite, you know, the how long it
- 47:52takes for a body to decompose that It is just part of the research of
- 47:57writing these kinds of books. But the prosecutor would have a rebuttal to this
- 48:04that, Okay, sure, yeah, that's that's normal. But the authors
- 48:09who are testifying that they bought these things, these authors were actually making money
- 48:15from their books, whereas Nancy was not not enough to justify spending as much
- 48:22as she was spending on these guns and the gun parts, you know what
- 48:24I mean. It's like, how is that possible if you're basically a hobbyist
- 48:30as a writer, it doesn't seem likely that you would invest all that money
- 48:36into a minor detail that you could just make up or work around in your
- 48:42book, especially since no one's buying your book or you know, that kind
- 48:45of stuff. But anyway, that was the defense. Also, I don't
- 48:50know if I've said this yet, but I'll say it now, which is
- 48:52that that essay that Nancy wrote, how to Murder your husband. The judge
- 48:59did not allow allow this and the trial and some people think, well,
- 49:02you know, that doesn't seem right, but I agree with this because it,
- 49:07uh, you know, it's totally normal for an author to write things
- 49:12like this. And if we allow all authors, or really anyone who authors
- 49:19anything fictional, to be you know, on trial and as part of the
- 49:28data against them is cherry picked passages, you know, like you say,
- 49:36say you have an innocent person who is being charged with murder of their partner
- 49:42and they're you know, they're a fictional writer and they've written, you know,
- 49:46thousands and thousands of pages of stories, and if you cherry pick a
- 49:52few different scenes that seem to emulate the supposed narrative that the proscutor is putting
- 50:00forth, and that will have too much effect on the jury and it won't
- 50:07be fair. And I completely agree with this because you know, it looks
- 50:10bad that you have her write this essay how to murder your husband. But
- 50:15but if you're an author in this genre, then you're gonna have a lot
- 50:19of things like that. So but it also is interesting because well, I'll
- 50:24get to that more, all right. So another part of her narrative was
- 50:30trying to address the life insurance policies. And I heard bits and pieces from
- 50:36her defense and other pece she took the stand by the way once, You'll
- 50:38get to you later, but I couldn't understand what the defense was. But
- 50:46essentially, I think what she was claiming was that it was hard to find
- 50:53good deals on life insurance policies, and so whenever a good deal came up,
- 51:00she would buy a little bit more life insurance because the good deal came
- 51:06up. And that's what explains why she had ten different policies, because I
- 51:09think the implication was that she was trying to throw people off the scent by
- 51:14having several different life insurance policies. I don't know, it's hard for me
- 51:17to understand that whole storyline, but there was some kind of deal with that
- 51:22in the trial. Also. Now here's the main thing with the trial is
- 51:30the story that she was not there at the culinary school. You know,
- 51:37her claim that she was at home when they have this video showing that she
- 51:42was downtown, and she would admit that that is her, which I think
- 51:46is you know, I don't know the wisdom of that, but you know
- 51:52there from my understanding of how you can defend yourself against these claims, as
- 52:00one of the things you can do as a suspect is just not say anything.
- 52:06You know, you don't confirm or deny that it was you in the
- 52:08van that is in the video, because I don't know if the license plate
- 52:16was clear enough to clearly indicate it was her. Plus, even if it
- 52:22was her van, it could have been someone else driving the van because the
- 52:25video wasn't clear that it was her. It had the the body shape of
- 52:30someone like her, but you couldn't positively identify it was her. That kind
- 52:36of thing, and I think, you know, one of the ways you
- 52:39can get away with these kinds of murders is you just leave enough of potential
- 52:47reasonable doubt, such as maybe it wasn't even her. You know, the
- 52:52prosecution didn't even positively identy, and you just avoid answering those kinds of questions.
- 52:58But apparently pretty early on, when she was presented with the video.
- 53:01I think this is before she was arrested, she agreed that it was her.
- 53:06She's like, oh that yeah, that is that must be me.
- 53:08And she claimed that she didn't remember. When she was presented with the video,
- 53:12she was like, she would claim that it was terrifying to her that
- 53:15she didn't remember. She was like, oh my god, yeah that is
- 53:19me. What am I doing down there? I don't remember that what's happening?
- 53:22And that that was what she said initially. So on the stand and
- 53:30the narrative that the that the defense was trying to put forth was that she
- 53:37had forgot. And you know, so she agrees that she was down there,
- 53:42but she says she forgot, and she says she knows that she didn't
- 53:46murder him even though she forgot what she did that morning. It's all just
- 53:52it's a terrible defense. And let me let me go into detail here.
- 53:57So on the stand and the defense that the offense attorney would also lay out
- 54:01this narrative is that she had what she called which is a memory hole.
- 54:08She says that when she was asked upon arriving at the culinary school by the
- 54:15investigator, what she was doing that morning. She said that she had a
- 54:21memory hole, and I didn't. I don't know exactly how she presented her
- 54:28story, but I think by implication or even explicitly, she said that she
- 54:34just figured she was at home walking the dogs and taking a shower because that's
- 54:42what she always does, or she did that earlier in the morning and didn't
- 54:46remember a couple hours of time, you know, the time that she had
- 54:51driven downtown and had been in the in the area. And so she says
- 54:57that she had a memory hole, which what we would call that as a
- 55:01is retrogade am mesia, which I'll get to in a second. So that's
- 55:07one story, is that due to trauma, due to psychological trauma, upon
- 55:13learning of her husband's death, she had erased a whole segment of her memory,
- 55:20which I'll get to in a second. There's a lot to go into
- 55:22there. The second thing that she said, and I don't know if this
- 55:25was officially what she was supposed to be. There's all these questions as to
- 55:31how well she was prepared by the defense attorney, and also whether or not
- 55:37she was going off script while she was testifying. I mean, she definitely
- 55:43was going off script, which I'll get to later, but at any rate,
- 55:47she had another story along the lines of why she had a different story
- 55:52that morning, which is that she says that, look, it was a
- 55:59very month, Dane and boring mourning for me, just like all the other
- 56:04or many of the other mornings that I have where you just wake up and
- 56:07you do your morning routine, and I would do basically the same thing every
- 56:10morning, and therefore it's very forgettable. You know, people don't tend to
- 56:15remember normal, boring, routine things, right like if you think back to
- 56:22the last month. You know, for us right now, if we think
- 56:25back to the last month, the only things you're likely to remember in terms
- 56:30of specific events are the notable things, like the things that broke from the
- 56:35norm. Whereas if you you know, if you wake up in the morning
- 56:40and you tend to do the same things, you won't remember those details,
- 56:46you know what I'm saying. So that was another thing that she was claiming
- 56:51was that when she was asked what she did that morning, she had forgotten
- 56:55what she had done because she it was so it was so forgettable as a
- 57:00morning. So I think what she's saying there is that it was a normal
- 57:06part of her life to drive around downtown, you know, very close to
- 57:10the culinary school. And therefore, when asked later that day what she did,
- 57:15she didn't remember that detail because it's so boring and routine. I don't
- 57:20know, it doesn't make a lot of sense, but that was what she
- 57:23said her. The third narrative that she laid out on this stand was that
- 57:30she will, as a part of her writing technique, she will drive around
- 57:37in her car and brainstorm writing things, you know, if she has writer's
- 57:43block or whatever. She says that it's part of her creative process to drive
- 57:49around aimlessly, and when she does that, she will have moments that she
- 57:58will forget or not notice what she's doing, like the way that when you're
- 58:02driving to work and your very normal commute, and you know, most of
- 58:09us have this experience where you drive five miles and then you suddenly realize that
- 58:15you don't have a single memory of having driven those five miles because you've been
- 58:20daydreaming or listening to a podcast or something. And yet somehow you manage to
- 58:24stay in the lane and take the right turns and that kind of stuff.
- 58:30You know, Typically it's like freeway driving where you're just you know, mindlessly
- 58:35staying in one lane and driving. And this example, this experience that not
- 58:40everyone has, but I think most people have had. We point to this
- 58:45as a way to try to help people to understand what dissociation is like.
- 58:51You know what pathological association is like where you're operating normally and from the outside
- 58:59you don't see to be checked out or impaired in any way, and yet
- 59:06you're not encoding any memories. And so it's analogous to dissociation or one in
- 59:14terms of the psychoanalytic usage or the original usage of dissociation, it's actually all
- 59:19considered just you know, the word association in today's parlance, we typically are
- 59:24saying only pathological dissociation, but really dissociative experiences are varied, many of which
- 59:32are subclinical sub pathology. So anyway, so that was another thing that she
- 59:38was claiming was that she must have been downtown driving in this almost like over
- 59:46concentrated trance like state writing. And she would say that she would drive around
- 59:52and that she would pull over it because she just knows this because she does
- 59:54it so often, that she would pull over and take a few notes and
- 59:59then d I have some more and daydream and pull over and take it through.
- 1:00:02And so she claims that that must have been what she was doing,
- 1:00:07but she forgot about it because she's in this trance like state when she didn't
- 1:00:12say transke state, but she was driving out. So this all sounds very
- 1:00:16suspicious, right, because if you do this, okay, fine, but
- 1:00:22you were asked that day what you had done earlier that day. It's not
- 1:00:30like you're trying to recall something that happened last month. You're trying to recall
- 1:00:34something that happened just an hour or two earlier or something. Right, So
- 1:00:39there's that also, you would just think that those details would be remembered by
- 1:00:45you. That it's one thing to forget, Like I don't know minute by
- 1:00:52minute what you were doing. You know, at what time did you take
- 1:00:54a shower? I don't know at the time, I knew what time it
- 1:00:59was, but I don't know exactly the time I took the shower. But
- 1:01:04having driven by the culinary Institute that morning, even if you were in this
- 1:01:12state where you're brainstorming a book, you would think you would remember the broad
- 1:01:15strokes, right. You might not remember having specifically driven by the culinary Institute,
- 1:01:22but you would have remembered driving through downtown Portland, right, But she
- 1:01:28claims memory hole or retrograde amnesia in addition to these other two alibis, which
- 1:01:35also don't make sense. You can't have all three, right. You can't
- 1:01:37have a memory hole where you basically have completely erased or you know, I
- 1:01:43guess it would be erased those memories because you can also have trauma that you
- 1:01:45don't encode memories. But what she's claiming is that the memories were discarded or
- 1:01:53inaccessible or something due to trauma. You can't have that and also claim that
- 1:02:00you had a mundane and forgettable morning and therefore you don't remember, and that
- 1:02:04you were you must have been driving around in this days. Like the all
- 1:02:07three just they're they're incompatible with each other. The first two could have been
- 1:02:12or the second and the third could be compatible. You know, the mundane,
- 1:02:15forgettable morning and the driving around downtown writing those are compatible. But those
- 1:02:21two are not compatible with the retrograde amnesia. So let me talk about amnesia.
- 1:02:27And I'm not an expert in this area, so you know, just
- 1:02:30consider that, but you know, I know enough about it to say the
- 1:02:32falling, which is that Retrograde amnesia is a type of memory loss in which
- 1:02:38you forget from a particular point backward. And there's other types of amnesia,
- 1:02:44other types of memory loss, but I won't go into it. So the
- 1:02:47different causes of this type of memory loss are brain injury, like in a
- 1:02:52traumatic brain injury like being hit in the head, that kind of thing.
- 1:02:57Also, if you suffer from dementia like Alzheimer's, you can have these experiences.
- 1:03:02Also, if you have an infection in the brain like encephalitis, this
- 1:03:08is similar to brain injury. Also, if you are using substances, particularly
- 1:03:14something like alcohol, you can have retrograde amysia. I would imagine most people
- 1:03:20have had this experience, maybe in college when you drank too much and you
- 1:03:24were walking around talking, maybe slurring your words, but you were conscious and
- 1:03:29making decisions. And then the next day or even later that evening, you
- 1:03:35have no memory of what happened there, right, So retrograde amnesia. And
- 1:03:40the fifth cause is psychological trauma. During a trauma, the experiences might not
- 1:03:47be encoded, or we might I mean, one way to think about it
- 1:03:51is and there's all this science around, like neurochemicals and different centers in the
- 1:03:57brain, and we don't know precisely what's happening, but we know roughly what's
- 1:04:02happening regarding the brain science, which I won't go into, but the way
- 1:04:08to think about it is that so if we go with her story, if
- 1:04:11we go with an ansy story, that she was having a normal, boring
- 1:04:15morning, driving around downtown, taking a shower, walking the dogs, doing
- 1:04:17her routine, and then she's notified that her husband died, was murdered,
- 1:04:25and that is a massively traumatic event, right, and she has this flood
- 1:04:30of stress hormones and neurochemicals that make it so that these short term memories of
- 1:04:39earlier that morning were not adequately or even at all transformed into the type of
- 1:04:50memory that is accessible, if that makes any sense, whether we want to
- 1:04:55call that long term memory or accessible memory or something, you know, this
- 1:05:00can happen to people. One story that I'll tell that I'm not quite I
- 1:05:06don't know if this is what happened, but it's a stark example of a
- 1:05:11possibility of this happening. Was I was in college and I was driving home
- 1:05:15from Apple Cup, which is a football game between UDUB and Wazoo, and
- 1:05:20the game that year was it in Wazoo and we're driving back and this is
- 1:05:25you know, later in the fall. So the eastern Washington is pretty snowy
- 1:05:30and cold and icy, and we're there's a whole line of cars that are
- 1:05:38driving down this very country road because Washington State University is in Farmland, pretty
- 1:05:44remote area, and just outside of it are all these two lane highways,
- 1:05:49meaning you know, one lane going each way without much of a shoulder.
- 1:05:53You're not like on a major highway. And we're there's a whole bunch of
- 1:05:59cars leaving that I guess it would be that Sunday, you know, all
- 1:06:03these people from Seattle go to you know, drive six hours to Colfax and
- 1:06:09then or to pull them in and and so there's all these cars that are
- 1:06:14driving out driving back to Seattle that that, you know, that midday or
- 1:06:17something. And we're driving along and the car directly in front of us.
- 1:06:25I'm I'm sitting in the passenger seat, and I see this SUV go off
- 1:06:30the road and then you know, this is a little safety tip is that
- 1:06:38if you ever accidentally veer off of a road like into gravel or something grass,
- 1:06:45is that there's a tendency for people to jam the wheel back into the
- 1:06:51lane. The problem with that is that if you're going at fifty five miles
- 1:06:58an hour and you turn while you're in soft conditions, there will be a
- 1:07:05bit of sliding that will evolve, and then as soon as your front wheels
- 1:07:10hit the concrete or the pavement again the asphalt, you will shoot off in
- 1:07:16that direction, which is what the driver did. She I think accidentally was
- 1:07:23distracted. And she was in a car with her friend, another young woman,
- 1:07:29and then two young men were in the back seat. They were all
- 1:07:31our age, and we had seen them at the gas station heading out of
- 1:07:35town just you know, a little bit earlier. But anyway, so she,
- 1:07:42from the looks of it, was distracted in her driving and had gone
- 1:07:45off the road. And remember this is two lane highway, so if you
- 1:07:47get distracted, there's not a lot of wiggle room. And she had gone
- 1:07:50on to this very small little shoulder with some gravel and had noticed, right
- 1:07:58because it's like, oh the you know, you notice when you can just
- 1:08:01tell when you kind of go off the road, And so she jammed left,
- 1:08:05and when her wheels hit the asphalt, she shot across the highway very
- 1:08:13quickly. And then because she did that, she jammed the wheel back to
- 1:08:17the right, right, And there's a lot of crashes that involve this.
- 1:08:21So I don't know the exact advice, but the plan that I have that
- 1:08:29I don't know if this is the right plan. I don't know if this
- 1:08:30is influenced by experts, but is that one. Don't jam the wheel,
- 1:08:35allow yourself to slow down, like, but don't jam on the brakes because
- 1:08:41that can be Another problem is you might even just ride out the gravel a
- 1:08:48little bit longer than what feels like okay, because you don't have to jam
- 1:08:53yourself back onto the freeway right. You know, sure the cars behind you
- 1:08:58might have to slow down, they may hank at you, but you want
- 1:09:00to slow to a safe speed so that you can ease your way back onto
- 1:09:04the road, if that makes any sense anyway, or just allow yourself to
- 1:09:12slowly and naturally go off the road, you know, if if if you're
- 1:09:17risked, you know, especially if you're in a top heavy suv that anyway,
- 1:09:25don't listen to me, listen to experts. But so when she jammed
- 1:09:29back right, you know, she jams left and then she jams right.
- 1:09:32At that point she started to roll the car and it was rolling directly down
- 1:09:39the freeway in front of us, staying on the on the road. If
- 1:09:45that makes you know, they weren't rolling off of the road. They were
- 1:09:47rolling down the road, you know, the direction that they were heading right
- 1:09:51in front of us. And I am in the passer seat, and this
- 1:09:58is all happening so fast, and we're just like whoa, whoa, whoa,
- 1:10:00who whoa. I just remember saying that, and the driver, my
- 1:10:03friend, was also like whoa, whoa, whoa. And we pull over,
- 1:10:09and everyone else pulls over because you remember, there's this long caravan.
- 1:10:13It sort of speak of all these I think dub University of Washington students that
- 1:10:19are driving back to Seattle, and we all pull over. I remember it
- 1:10:23was kind of foggy and kind of cold, you know, like but dry,
- 1:10:28and we're sitting there and we and the car had rolled to a stop
- 1:10:35and had rolled a little bit off of the road and as it's rolling,
- 1:10:39Okay, this is I don't know, this is interesting, but it's interesting
- 1:10:42to me that the and this is this is also another part of memory,
- 1:10:47Like I remember so many details about this moment that happened thirty plus years ago.
- 1:10:54Because of how intense it was how I don't I don't know if it
- 1:10:59was traumatic for me, but it was a very intense, difficult event for
- 1:11:04me for a number of reasons, which we'll get into in a second.
- 1:11:08That made it so that my brain encoded the memories in a much higher resolution
- 1:11:15in detail than normally. Plus afterward, I would talk about this event with
- 1:11:21my friends that were there, because I there were two or three cars of
- 1:11:27my friends, full of my friends, and so we talked. We still
- 1:11:30talk about this event, you know. And it's possible that our memories have
- 1:11:36changed over time, of course, because that does happen. But it is
- 1:11:41much more likely that as a collective we remember the details accurately because of how
- 1:11:45intense it wasn't how often we've talked about it. I've also written about it
- 1:11:48in my journal back then. Anyway, So as the car is tumbling down
- 1:11:55the road, I remember noticing that the skylight was had broken, you know,
- 1:12:03the I don't know if you call it skylight, but the sunroof,
- 1:12:06I guess you call it. I just recently got a car that has a
- 1:12:13sunroof. I don't know what a moon roof is or a sunroof. It's
- 1:12:15you know, the window that's above your head in a car. I have
- 1:12:18one of those for the very first time my car has one of those,
- 1:12:23and so I feel like I've just never learned the language. But anyway,
- 1:12:27so it was too cold to have that open, so it must have broken
- 1:12:30in the rolling right, and I remember noticing that a bunch of debris was
- 1:12:36flying out of the hole that had the window as it was tumbling down the
- 1:12:43road, and I remember thinking like, it just looked weird that all this
- 1:12:47garbage and debris, and I couldn't really tell what it was. Well,
- 1:12:55at some point we're all pulled over and the dust is settled, and we're
- 1:13:00all bystanders, right, so we're all just frozen. And then I or
- 1:13:08someone in my car said we should maybe try to help or something, because
- 1:13:14because no one else was getting out of the cars. You know, there's
- 1:13:16maybe twenty cars had pulled over, and so the guys in my car we
- 1:13:25were the first to get out of the car and walk over. I think
- 1:13:27maybe because we were the car right behind them. And we're walking toward the
- 1:13:33SUV that is on its side, and I start walking through the debris field
- 1:13:42of all the glass and all the refuse that I thought had come out through
- 1:13:46the top window. But what I had seen come out the top window was
- 1:13:54one of the fellas that was in the back seat. He was coming out
- 1:13:58of that top window that was sepuelled on him, apparently in all likelihood,
- 1:14:03and playing it back through my mind went, so, we're walking across the
- 1:14:08seat and I see a body and I instantly am thinking, oh, it
- 1:14:15must not have been refuse, or maybe it was a little bit of debris
- 1:14:18in refuse or garbage or something, but it was like a human being that
- 1:14:25was just being ragdalled as they were halfway out, because that was a thing
- 1:14:30is he was only halfway out of this sun roof as it was tumbling down
- 1:14:36the asphalt, you know. And I come upon and eventually he was ejected
- 1:14:43and left there on the road, and he was the first thing I had
- 1:14:48come across. And I won't go into gory details, but it was very,
- 1:14:54very gory, and it was obvious that he was dead. There was
- 1:15:02just I won't go into details as to how I know that, but there
- 1:15:06wasn't any ambiguity about that. And my friend actually he took off his jacket
- 1:15:13and put it over his body because it was just so gruesome. And then
- 1:15:20we continue walking and we arrive, you know, me and maybe one or
- 1:15:25two other guys. We arrive at the car on its side, and the
- 1:15:29driver the driver, so it was laying on the passenger side of the car,
- 1:15:33if that makes sense. And the woman who was driving, she climbs
- 1:15:39out of the top right, you know, because her window would be at
- 1:15:43the top, and so she's climbing out and I'll just never forget this.
- 1:15:48She lands on our feet and she looks completely unscathed except for her pinky looked
- 1:15:59jammed or broke, and it was at a like a ninety degree angle off
- 1:16:02of her hand, and she wasn't tending to that. She was very very
- 1:16:10agitated and very very upset, obviously, and crying, and she was just
- 1:16:14frantically repeating, I don't remember, Like what was she saying. She's like,
- 1:16:20I don't remember crashing, something like that. I don't remember crashing.
- 1:16:24I don't remember crashing. I don't remember crashing. I don't remember crashing.
- 1:16:26She just kept saying this over and over again. And by the way,
- 1:16:30event and I remember the their radio was on, you know, tuned into
- 1:16:35a radio station, and it was eerily playing some pop song at the time,
- 1:16:42and slowly other bystanders were arriving, and there's this woman saying, I
- 1:16:50don't know, and we can kind of see into the car and see that
- 1:16:55a woman is sitting in the passenger seat who's injured, and there's a man
- 1:16:59in the back another band of the back seat who's injured. And the man
- 1:17:02in the back seat is unconscious. The woman in the passer seat is half
- 1:17:06conscious, and everyone's like, what do we do? What do we do?
- 1:17:11Well, there's the other thing, no cell phones because it's nineteen ninety
- 1:17:15one or something, and the next town is miles and miles away, so
- 1:17:24we don't know what to do. And this local drives by in their truck
- 1:17:28and we stop him and we say, you know, drive as fast as
- 1:17:31you can to the next town, next payphone and call nine to one one.
- 1:17:36Okay, So we do that, and then we're all sitting there.
- 1:17:40We're like, well, what do we do? And the woman in the
- 1:17:42passenger seat seems in distress and we can't access her. So people suggest that
- 1:17:47we push the suv up on its wheels. I don't know if that was
- 1:17:53the best thing to do. I think it is not advised because you don't
- 1:17:57know the state of the injuries of the individuals inside. You know, there
- 1:18:02wasn't any danger of a fire or anything, so it wasn't an emergency to
- 1:18:10get the you know, the other passengers out of the car. You know,
- 1:18:14if someone has like a neck injury or something, you want to especially
- 1:18:17how much jostling is involved pushing the suv back up. But anyway, people
- 1:18:23suggested that and so we put the suv on its wheels. At that point
- 1:18:30we could access the woman in the passer seat and the guy in the back
- 1:18:32seat, and it was clear that the guy in the back seat was also
- 1:18:35deceased, and the woman and the passenger seat I'll just never remember. I
- 1:18:40had eye contact with her and she I'll spare they there wasn't as many goory
- 1:18:45details with her, but she was, you know, severely injured, seemed
- 1:18:50mostly or somewhat conscious and in a very distressed emotional state and looking at me
- 1:19:00eye contact, and I just remember her. The vibe I was getting from
- 1:19:04her was that she was scared and knew and she knew just how injured she
- 1:19:12was. The driver pretty quickly, I think realized that her friends were very,
- 1:19:19very injured and she was not. And I don't know, but I
- 1:19:25think she pretty quickly might have realized that. My guess is that when the
- 1:19:30car was on its side, she turned around and she saw her friend that
- 1:19:34was very injured. She saw the guy in the back seat and knew that
- 1:19:39he was either very injured or dead. She couldn't see the other guy because
- 1:19:44the other guy gone up out through the roof. So you know, she
- 1:19:45didn't know what happened. But I think she got out of the car.
- 1:19:47I think it was so traumatic, you know, the event, that she
- 1:19:51had forgotten what had happened. I don't know that, but at least temporarily,
- 1:19:57she did not remember having gone off the road and crashed. No,
- 1:20:01maybe there was substances of all that. I don't know, but I always
- 1:20:05think about this as an example of retrogade amnesia due to psychological trauma. Now,
- 1:20:11she could have also had a head injury, but she didn't look like
- 1:20:13it, and that's you know, the nature of these kinds of psychological events
- 1:20:18is that, you know, we don't have a concrete way of figuring out
- 1:20:24what happened. She also could have been lying, right, She could have
- 1:20:26been like trying to have an alibi, like it wasn't me, I didn't
- 1:20:30know what It's not my fault, you know, who knows. But the
- 1:20:32way it looked to me was that it was such a traumatic event for her
- 1:20:36that directly afterwards she's thinking, how did I end up on my side?
- 1:20:43You know what? Am I? I obviously just gotten a crash and I'm
- 1:20:46driving what happened? You know? But because of the trauma, she had
- 1:20:50erased the previous ten seconds or five it might have even been seven seconds,
- 1:20:57you know, pretty quick event, you know, off the road, jam
- 1:21:01left and then oh my god, I'm shooting across the highway, jam right,
- 1:21:04boom, you know, roll, roll, roll, roll, roll
- 1:21:09off the road and stop. Yeah. I don't know how long that takes,
- 1:21:13but it's not very long. And anyway, so she couldn't remember.
- 1:21:15She's claiming, I don't remember what happened. I don't remember crashing. I
- 1:21:17don't remember crashing. I don't remember crushing. Okay, So that's you know,
- 1:21:20legit psychological trauma related retrogade amnesia. There are other events that, of
- 1:21:28course, we can point to, like if one is raped, people can
- 1:21:33forget that, or if one is physically abused or assaulted, or there could
- 1:21:41be war related retrogade amnesia, or if you have a loved one that has
- 1:21:48a heart attack, or you know, even if you are going into surgery
- 1:21:55or something and you're not on you know, a compound or a drug that
- 1:22:00is causing any sort of memory loss, you can also have memory loss due
- 1:22:04to the trauma. The idea is that we seemingly evolved psy psychological mechanism to
- 1:22:14protect us maybe, or it could just be the brain overloading with certain neurochemicals
- 1:22:20that result in memories having difficulty being recalled or encoded. So anyway, you
- 1:22:28know, and I could talk for a long time about memory loss and dissociation
- 1:22:32and trauma and retrograde amnesia, but you know, I hope you get the
- 1:22:38idea of what Nancy was claiming. What happened, right, And apparently many
- 1:22:45murder suspects, a disproportionate number of murder suspects will claim that they have had
- 1:22:50retrograde amnesia as a convenient excuse, a convenient defense when they are confronted with
- 1:22:58the evidence against them. So it's just suspicious whenever someone having been accused.
- 1:23:04You know, it'd be one thing if she was not implicated and she claimed
- 1:23:12to have retrogade amnesia. It's another thing for a suspect, you know,
- 1:23:16someone who was defending themselves in a trial, to suddenly claim that they have
- 1:23:21retrograde amnesia. It happens a lot, you know. And the other thing
- 1:23:27is that many of you might be thinking, is, well, having amnesia
- 1:23:32doesn't mean you didn't kill him. You know, the psychological trauma could have
- 1:23:36been that you killed him. You can't claim that you did or did not
- 1:23:43kill him because you're claiming you don't remember anything. So maybe you did kill
- 1:23:46him. You know, the gun matches and your car was down there,
- 1:23:51and you were fighting a lot, and there's no other suspect, no other
- 1:23:57reason you did have, you know. So it's not a great defense,
- 1:24:00but it's a convenient excuse when confronted with data that contradicts her alibi. Right
- 1:24:05anyway, so she claims it she had this memory hole. So is it
- 1:24:13possible what she is claiming? The answer is yes, it is possible.
- 1:24:17Anything's possible. It's hard to prove or disprove because it's all based on an
- 1:24:24individual's claim and it is something that has happened before. But the more important
- 1:24:30question is is is it likely that this happened, and the answer is no,
- 1:24:36because the nature of this type of retrograde amnesia typically looks different. Like
- 1:24:44another story that would be more believable to me is that she arrives at the
- 1:24:51investigation and is informed that her husband is dead and in the moment she is
- 1:24:59flooded with neurochemicals of distress, and maybe even she could have said that she,
- 1:25:06due to early childhood abuse, has a pattern of memory loss under psychological
- 1:25:14distress. You know, that would actually and if there was evidence that she
- 1:25:16had previously had those claims, like a therapist that could claim that they had
- 1:25:24talked about that ten fifteen years earlier than it would lend itself to that defense.
- 1:25:31But typically what happens is that over time, people will start remembering bits
- 1:25:36and pieces. They might not remember the whole thing, but they they'll remember
- 1:25:42little bits and pieces like oh yeah, I do you know something. I'll
- 1:25:44jog their memory, or once they're out of the major traumatic distress of the
- 1:25:50moment, the entire memory will come back, you know, that kind of
- 1:25:54thing. So it's not very common for someone to also so another more likely
- 1:26:01situation would be that the individual would forget having been questioned by the police,
- 1:26:08but would remember what happened that morning, you know, because if you think
- 1:26:11about the traumatic event, it's upon being informed of the husband dying, and
- 1:26:17possibly I don't know if she viewed the body or anything, but the trauma
- 1:26:23begins when she's informed. Now, can you, as a result of that
- 1:26:27trauma, forget the previous hours. Yes, but it's much more common for
- 1:26:32people to report well, yeah, I remember everything up to the moment that
- 1:26:38I was informed of his death, and I don't remember any of that.
- 1:26:44I remember. The first memory I have is that afternoon and I'm my friend
- 1:26:50is hugging me and I'm crying, But I don't remember who told me that
- 1:26:56he died. I don't remember the police officer asking me those questions. Now,
- 1:27:02later people typically with full blown retrogade AMusA, will having their memory job
- 1:27:09will go oh yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah. I have a picture
- 1:27:15in my mind of sitting on the curb while the police officer was asking me
- 1:27:19those questions. And I do remember that detail because I have a picture.
- 1:27:24It's sort of foggy, but I have a picture of that in my mind.
- 1:27:27And once they're informed, oh well, I was the one that called
- 1:27:30you to tell you that your husband had been killed, and the individual would
- 1:27:35say, oh yeah, yeah, yeah, I remember that one detail,
- 1:27:39but I you know, I don't remember ninety percent of what happened. What
- 1:27:43happened. That's way more common than someone claiming that they don't remember anything from
- 1:27:49the entire morning. They don't, and they remember everything about being questioned,
- 1:27:57you know, but they don't remember anything. They don't remember any of the
- 1:27:59before for stuff, but they remember any of it, but they remember all
- 1:28:01the during stuff. So it's just not it's not a typical situation. Can
- 1:28:08it happen? Yeah, Like I said, now, a much better story
- 1:28:14that she could have said, one that I think could have tipped the scales
- 1:28:18with at least one of the jurors so that they couldn't, you know,
- 1:28:24go beyond a reasonable doubt, was that she is having a normal morning and
- 1:28:30you know, this is this is in this world she did kill Danne.
- 1:28:34But she's smart enough to know how to get out of this detail in that
- 1:28:41she initially told investigators that she was at home and then later is presented with
- 1:28:45this video. I think for her best case scenario is as soon as she's
- 1:28:51prevented presented with the video, she says, oh my god, I don't
- 1:28:58remember that I need to talk with my lawyer, and then doesn't say anything
- 1:29:01more than that, and then on the stand she could say something like,
- 1:29:09yeah, okay, so here's what happened. I had a totally normal morning,
- 1:29:12and then I'm informed about my beloved husband having been murdered. And I,
- 1:29:19looking back now, I know that I was completely freaking out, naturally,
- 1:29:26And when the police officer asked me what I was doing that morning,
- 1:29:30he asked me again, I didn't know this at the time, but looking
- 1:29:35back, I was in a completely, you know, weird state of mind.
- 1:29:42I was in shock, and I was in a daze. I barely
- 1:29:46remember anything about that whole that whole time, you know, those couple hours
- 1:29:51when I was down there and I was seeing all the students and everything,
- 1:29:56and I just it was such a hard time for me. So when the
- 1:30:00police officer asked me what I did that morning, I remember thinking that I
- 1:30:06didn't really remember what I did that morning, but I felt like I needed
- 1:30:12to say something, and so I just assumed that I did what I normally
- 1:30:15do, which is I take a shower and I walk the dogs, and
- 1:30:17I didn't drive around downtown. I just said that and I remember feeling pretty
- 1:30:24confident that that's what I did. And I even kind of remember doing those
- 1:30:29things, you know, because I had done those things, I guess before
- 1:30:33I drove downtown. But I said that, and then the next morning,
- 1:30:41when I woke up, I just kept replaying the whole thing, and I
- 1:30:45was in a lot of distress, and I was thinking, who could have
- 1:30:48done this? And then it suddenly occurred to me that no, no,
- 1:30:54no, I had driven around downtown as a process of writing my book.
- 1:31:00But I didn't tell the investigators, and I said, and I picked up
- 1:31:03the phone to call the investigators to tell them, no, no, no.
- 1:31:08I now remember what I did that morning, I think, which is
- 1:31:11that I showered and walked dogs, and I drove around downtown. But I
- 1:31:15stopped myself because I know enough from writing these books that often the spouse is
- 1:31:24the first suspect. And I didn't want to be a suspect one. I
- 1:31:29didn't want to be a suspect because I don't want to go I don't want
- 1:31:31to be falsely investigated. But also I wanted the police to focus on the
- 1:31:35real killer. I didn't want them to be distracted. You know, there
- 1:31:39are famous cases that I've studied where a spouse is pursued as the main suspect
- 1:31:46and the investigators ignore the real killer and ignore data and they get locked in.
- 1:31:53And I didn't want that to happen. And I debated it for a
- 1:31:56long time in my mind, and I said, well, I concluded it
- 1:31:59didn't really matter that I was driving around downtown because I, you know,
- 1:32:01I certainly didn't kill my husband, and uh, you know, it doesn't
- 1:32:09really matter. I didn't knowingly lie to the police officer, but you know,
- 1:32:18it doesn't really matter. I don't need to tell them that because it's
- 1:32:20irrelevant that I did that. Do I need to tell them every detail that
- 1:32:24I remember this morning? I don't know. And I it was stupid.
- 1:32:28I looking back, I should have called the police and said that I did
- 1:32:32at that point remember driving downtown, but I was freaking out. I didn't
- 1:32:36know what to do. I didn't even want to tell anyone because I didn't
- 1:32:41want to drag anyone into my situation, and so I just said, I'm
- 1:32:45just not going to say anything. Then, when you presented the video of
- 1:32:50me driving around, I had some to some extent, I had kind of
- 1:32:57pushed that out of my mind because it was hard to deal with. But
- 1:32:59I did basically remember it, and I became so freaked out that I asked
- 1:33:03for my lawyer and I you know, so that's that's the story, you
- 1:33:12know. Okay, so end of rope play. To me as a juror,
- 1:33:17that would have given me at least a little bit more reason to not
- 1:33:26consider this beyond a reasonable doubt that she had murdered her husband. But what
- 1:33:30she did on the stand was present those three different cases. She was also
- 1:33:34pretty combative with the prosecutor, you know, with the attorneys for the prosecution,
- 1:33:42and her story didn't make a lot of sense in terms of the psychological
- 1:33:45reality of that sort of amnesia. Okay, So I want to talk about
- 1:33:49another case of retrogatee anesia that I experienced clinically with a client that I worked
- 1:33:56with for many, many years, maybe fifteen years, and one of the
- 1:34:01many things that we talked about in the course of treatment was that she didn't
- 1:34:06remember a single event prior to the age of something like twelve years old or
- 1:34:11ten years old or something, and like nothing. She had siblings who one
- 1:34:19was older when I was younger, and they remembered all sorts of details about,
- 1:34:26you know, those previous years. And it was really typified by the
- 1:34:31fact that the family had lived in a particular house earlier in her life and
- 1:34:38then had moved to another house, another place that they lived and you know,
- 1:34:45before she turned ten years old or whatever, and so she didn't she
- 1:34:48doesn't remember a single thing about that first house, whereas her younger sibling does
- 1:34:55remember a fair amount about that previous house. You know, it's one thing
- 1:34:59to not remember like a lot of details. It's nothing like look at a
- 1:35:02picture of the exterior and interior of that home and it just looks like a
- 1:35:10foreign place to you. So I don't remember anything. You know, that's
- 1:35:14pretty unusual. And I sent her to specialists and even a hypnotherapist, and
- 1:35:21we did all sorts of things regarding trauma that might be able to help her.
- 1:35:27And it wasn't a main focus. She wasn't focused on recalling those memories,
- 1:35:32but it did provide some distress for her, and so we would focus
- 1:35:38on it at times. And I basically figured that if there was something that
- 1:35:43I could do to help her with it, it would just be to help
- 1:35:45her recover from the trauma. And you know, maybe that'll help her to
- 1:35:49feel safe enough to remember those years. Well, we did everything we could
- 1:35:56and nothing ever changed regarding that memory line us. And the speculation that I
- 1:36:03had was that because we did, she did have enough memory post you know,
- 1:36:10ten or so years old that uh and enough uh you know, other
- 1:36:15stories from other people, being mainly your siblings, to piece together what her
- 1:36:18life was like prior to that memory loss, and her role in the family
- 1:36:26was to placate her father. And her father was uh, you know,
- 1:36:33suffered from alcoholis alcoholism and at times would become violent and very threatening, and
- 1:36:42it was her job at a at the age of ten and prior that she
- 1:36:46would hang out with him and get him to calm down. You know,
- 1:36:51just imagine that, just maatgine, how scary that would be. And you
- 1:36:56know, figuring that she was likely doing that prior to the memory loss,
- 1:37:01the conclusion is that she likely, due to trauma, had retrograde to amnesia
- 1:37:09at a certain point. Maybe if we asked her when she was thirteen,
- 1:37:13she would remember she would remember some things prior to ten, or maybe not.
- 1:37:15Maybe at thirteen she had just completely erased all of those memories because of
- 1:37:23how difficult those memories were for her. That does happen. That's kind of
- 1:37:28a severe case. It's also possible that she had some sort of brain injury
- 1:37:32around that time, but we didn't have any evidence of that. It seemed
- 1:37:38to me quite likely that it was such a difficult thing because her mom didn't
- 1:37:44protect her from the dad, right she, as this child, was the
- 1:37:48main companion to her father's threats and violence and danger. The mom would check
- 1:37:57out. So just imagine how stressful that would be. And that could lead
- 1:38:01to either a retrograde m amnesia event where it's so stressful that the brain basically
- 1:38:14just cuts itself off from those memories, or when those memories are recalled slightly,
- 1:38:21the brain shuts that down. Or another possibility is that as she was
- 1:38:28going through those difficult moments, individual memories were not being encoded into long term
- 1:38:33memory because they were so difficult. So it's just another example of what retrogade
- 1:38:39amnesia can look like. You know, there's a lot of different manifestations.
- 1:38:44And when I hear this from my client and there's no criminal case involved,
- 1:38:48right then it's much more believable to me. Right, she's not trying to
- 1:38:54avoid something, and plus she spent a lot of time trying to remember,
- 1:38:58and it bothered her that she didn't remember. We even spent time in therapy.
- 1:39:02She would bring in pictures of her early childhood and we would just stare
- 1:39:08at them and try to jog her memory, and nothing worked anyway. So
- 1:39:13retrogadem usa is a thing you know for trauma, of course, and it
- 1:39:16does happen, but in a murder case when you and you know you have
- 1:39:25someone that tells it in this way also has other defenses, like it was
- 1:39:33a boring morning and I was driving around writing like it just doesn't it's not
- 1:39:41very convincing. All right, let's take a break. When we get back,
- 1:39:43I'll talk about her personality and wrap this up. Okay, So let's
- 1:39:49get into my speculation about Nancy's personality. And of course I can't diagnose from
- 1:39:55afar, And honestly, I didn't have a lot of data to go off
- 1:40:00of, you know, contrary to like the Josh Powell case, with this
- 1:40:06Nancy Brophy case, there's just not a lot of stuff that I could get
- 1:40:10my hands on, even among the the podcasters who were pouring over all this
- 1:40:15data. When they would interview me, I would occasionally ask them questions like
- 1:40:19do you know any more about this detail? And so I would gather that
- 1:40:23information. It's just hard to say. But the top hypothesis I would pursue
- 1:40:30if I were to work with a case like this is the hypothesis that she
- 1:40:34did suffer from severe narcissistic person I shorder and a dash of psychopathy or any
- 1:40:41social personality, because it seems likely that she would have to have some psychopathy
- 1:40:48to have the premeditated murder and to actually pull the trigger. You know,
- 1:40:56this is a philosophical thing that I debate in my own mind and also with
- 1:41:00other people, and we've been debating this for you know, decades. But
- 1:41:05can someone without psychopathy, without antisocial personality, you know, can someone that
- 1:41:12doesn't have traits of psychopathy? Can they murder their husband, their partner under
- 1:41:19these circumstances? Is it possible for someone to pull the trigger? And you
- 1:41:26know, a lot of experts, including myself, will say yes, anybody
- 1:41:30can kill. The assumption that someone that kills has to have something different about
- 1:41:40their empathy ability is not always coherent, and we often will have that assumption
- 1:41:48because it's more comforting, right, It's more comforting to believe that murderers are
- 1:41:56different sorts of humans and therefore easily detected, or at least it's we have
- 1:42:02the ability to detect them. But you know it, behavior is it's just
- 1:42:09not that simple. But I think that it's quite likely that she did have
- 1:42:15minor to moderate psychopathy. I'm not saying severe psychopathy because she doesn't have any
- 1:42:21of the signs of a severe psychopath, which I've gone over another deep dives.
- 1:42:28But the typical profile of a severe psychopath is a chronic con artist who
- 1:42:34is exploiting everyone around them, right, and we don't see that. In
- 1:42:39fact, a lot of people would say that Nancy Brophy was a good person.
- 1:42:45You know. Recall what I said earlier when the friend called up Nancy
- 1:42:49saying, hey, Dan snapped at me and he seems upset. I don't
- 1:42:56know what's going on. Nancy, without seeming any sort of reason to do
- 1:43:01this, said something very reassuring to this woman and kind of threw herself.
- 1:43:10Nancy throws herself under the bus by saying, oh, no, Dan was
- 1:43:14snapping at you, but really he's mad at me. So a psychopath would
- 1:43:18not do that sort of thing, because the typical psychopath, even you know,
- 1:43:24sort of mid range psychopath. If there's any any possibility that they can
- 1:43:31work the narrative in their favor, they'll they'll do it even when it doesn't
- 1:43:35make any sense for them to do so. So it just doesn't sound like,
- 1:43:42it doesn't sound psychopathic, doesn't fit the profile. Plus the fact that
- 1:43:46she had all these friends and people who would claim that she was a very
- 1:43:49nice person and she was very helpful and supportive, it just doesn't jive with
- 1:43:56the psychopath jib or jibe. I never know which which one. Another one
- 1:44:00that I don't know is like down the Pike or turn Pie, I don't
- 1:44:04know, but I think that it's a strong hypothesis that she did suffer from
- 1:44:12severe narcissistic personality disorder, you know, similar to Josh Powell in a way
- 1:44:17in that it was not easily detectable because she wasn't extremely annoying to people around.
- 1:44:27So, Okay, it's like where do I begin. Well, let
- 1:44:30me just go over what I have in my notes. So the data that
- 1:44:34we have in the direction of, you know, mild psychopathy and severe narcissisic
- 1:44:40personality sort and it's a particular kind of narcissisic person disorder as well. But
- 1:44:45her friends would say that she talked a lot, that she was a talker.
- 1:44:51In fact, on the stand she would say that she's a chatter like
- 1:44:58not a chatter er, but a chatter, meaning that she talked a lot.
- 1:45:02And also friends would say that she had a lot of confidence. And
- 1:45:08also on the stand, she exhibited that she had a lot of confidence.
- 1:45:12And when she was in prison during the trial, they record all of her
- 1:45:16phone calls that she makes out of detention, and on those phone calls,
- 1:45:23the police officers would review those calls and would say that compared to other people
- 1:45:30in her situation that they have worked with, she exhibited a lot of confidence
- 1:45:35that she was going to get away with it, that she was going to
- 1:45:40win the trial. And she just seems so casual and so confident also taking
- 1:45:47the stand, just doing that to begin with, right, that's very scary
- 1:45:55situation. And she just when she was on the stand, she didn't seem
- 1:46:00to watch her phrasing or her words. She went off topics, she went
- 1:46:03down rabbit holes, she said more than what she probably should say, and
- 1:46:10it just seemed like she believed she had it in the bag. Another detail
- 1:46:16is that people would say that she was likable. So when it comes to
- 1:46:23narcissic preconise or, it is this could be two different things. One is
- 1:46:27that she was likable in the outside world. So I had a client once
- 1:46:34with full blown narcissic precise or, and people around him not only believed that
- 1:46:42he was likable and a good guy, but they thought he was one of
- 1:46:46the best human beings that have ever lived. They particularly people that were not
- 1:46:54super close to him. So outside of his family, his spouse and his
- 1:47:00kids, and outside of his close colleagues, everyone thought he was the opposite
- 1:47:05of narcissistic, that he was altruistic and a pillar of the community and all
- 1:47:11these really wonderful things. But the closer you got to him regarding relationship,
- 1:47:16like if you talk to close colleagues, but particularly if you talk to his
- 1:47:20wife and his kids, they would say, he is not a pillar of
- 1:47:26the community. He is a monster. He is abusive, he is emotionally
- 1:47:32unstable. And so what profile this fits is that you'll have an individual that
- 1:47:39will seek narcissistic supply by portraying themselves as the opposite of the way that a
- 1:47:46narcissistic person would operate. You know, if a narcissistic person is smart enough
- 1:47:51and adept enough, they can actually get narcissistic supply by coming across as being
- 1:47:58very selfless, by being very giving and very altruistic and very compassionate. And
- 1:48:04they might have those feelings. It might not be completely made up, but
- 1:48:10they're only showing a particular side of themselves. And they are working really hard
- 1:48:16all day long when they're out in the community to clamp down on their defensive
- 1:48:21structure that wants to lash out and this sort of thing. They come home
- 1:48:27or they have a meeting with a closer colleague, someone that they feel more
- 1:48:31secure with, someone that they believe isn't going to leave them. But also
- 1:48:36they just can't hold that level of concentration all day long, and so they
- 1:48:42relax at home and that's when their dark side is manifested. You could even
- 1:48:48see it as they need to make up for all of the injustices that they
- 1:48:54felt during the day. Like one profile is that they come home and you
- 1:49:00know, they get comfortable and they just start yammering at their family about all
- 1:49:06the assholes that wronged them all day long, and they just talk and talk
- 1:49:14and talk and talk, and and if the wife were to provide any kind
- 1:49:18of feedback, even if it was positive, he would just bulldoze over that
- 1:49:24because he's in this very primitive, immature way, needing the listener to just
- 1:49:30listen and particularly not call them out on their shit and so the So that's
- 1:49:36one profile, but it can get worse because if the spouse and the kids
- 1:49:44say, hey, I've got other things to do. Well, now all
- 1:49:46bets are off. The narcissistic person is really on a lay into those people
- 1:49:50because they don't have the energy to hold up the facade anymore. They depend
- 1:49:58on the family members emotional way that they don't depend on people in the outside
- 1:50:01world. The narcissistic person feels safe enough to be themselves, which involves this
- 1:50:09defensive structure around these close relationships. They believe that these people won't leave them,
- 1:50:13even though that's not necessarily true, you know. So it's possible that
- 1:50:16Nancy was doing that that in the outside world she was coming across very likable,
- 1:50:21but at home she would engage on a lot of these these behaviors that
- 1:50:29point towards massive insecurity and a need for self centeredness and attention. It's hard
- 1:50:36to know. We'll never know because Dan is dead now, but that's possible.
- 1:50:44Another thing that I said on the podcast when they interviewed me now that
- 1:50:47I remember is that we tend to cartoonize narcissistic individuals and people with psychopathy as
- 1:50:58being one hundred percent evil all the time. You know, think of like
- 1:51:02the Bill Cosby case. I think I talked about this during previous episodes that
- 1:51:10there's this question about Bill Cosby because he was very altruistic from the outside and
- 1:51:15a force for good, particularly for black actors. He would fight with the
- 1:51:20producers of The Cosby Show to have wall to wall black actors, you know,
- 1:51:29the doctor, a black person, a lawyer, you know, a
- 1:51:30black person, a neighbor, a black person, you know, and would
- 1:51:34be instrumental and jump starting or assisting in a lot of careers for people when
- 1:51:42you know, people weren't asking Bill Cosby do this, and it could have
- 1:51:45hurt him, you know, in terms of his career and that kind of
- 1:51:47thing. So he was incurring a lot of difficulty in his life to help
- 1:51:53other people. Now there's a question was he doing this for a narcissistic supply
- 1:51:58and it wasn't genuine possible? Was his way of trying to throw people off
- 1:52:02the scent of what the you know, the crimes that he was committing.
- 1:52:05You know, it's possible, but it's also possible that he actually was a
- 1:52:10good person in some ways and actually did have a good side to him.
- 1:52:15When he had enough narcissistic supply, he could relax and actually engage in some
- 1:52:21altruistic, beneficial behaviors for other people. That doesn't mean that he didn't suffer
- 1:52:29from narcissistic personality Sorer. It just means that we have to understand that humans
- 1:52:32are complex and there's a lot of nuance to it. So that's another possibility
- 1:52:39that would explain what's going on with Nancy. It's another possibility that she didn't
- 1:52:43have narcissistic personage, or she was very low on the scale, and she
- 1:52:49you know, killed, not from a place that was influenced significantly by any
- 1:52:55personnality Sore. But it's just a human variation in terms of behavior that happened.
- 1:53:01You know, you have eight billion people, You're going to see a
- 1:53:02lot there's a bell curve. You're going to see a lot of things at
- 1:53:05the edges that are odd. So it's hard to tell, but I'm going
- 1:53:13with the top hypothesis that she did suffer from pretty significant narcissism, as evidenced
- 1:53:17by the talkativeness and also by the high level of confidence that she had,
- 1:53:26like abnormal confidence that she had. Also, people say that her books are
- 1:53:31not good. I haven't read them, and I've only heard some opinions from
- 1:53:35people, but there's a possibility that her books are not very good, and
- 1:53:41yet she just kept writing. I think she started writing in around two thousand
- 1:53:45and three, so this is fifteen years of dedicating her life and time and
- 1:53:49efforts into being a successful author and completing a lot of books but not having
- 1:53:58any sort of because her books suck. And if that's true, then that's
- 1:54:05another tick in the column of narcissism where she just believes that's that she's awesome,
- 1:54:12you know. Like I had a similar experience that when I was in
- 1:54:17high school. I had a friend who was very creative and he shared with
- 1:54:24me his poems and his short stories and this kind of thing when I was
- 1:54:29in ninth grade, and I remember it sort of just being mind blowing,
- 1:54:32like oh wow, like this is really compelling, and it's this wonderful canvas
- 1:54:40that you can express yourself through, and it doesn't take anything more than an
- 1:54:45imagination. And I had occasionally, just as a hobby, written things like
- 1:54:50you know, I wrote in my journal. But I also when I was
- 1:54:54in grade school, me and my friend Tommy, we decided that we were
- 1:54:57going to write a science fiction book. And it was funny, I I
- 1:55:01it was. It was basically kind of like a Luke Skywalker character or a
- 1:55:06Neo character, you know, the chosen One kind of a thing. And
- 1:55:09I think it was this guy, a young man or a teenage boy on
- 1:55:15a on a planet that was being attacked by something, and and he was
- 1:55:19trying to get away. And we were trying to come up with a name
- 1:55:23for our protagonist. And I remember we were brainstorming various different names and we
- 1:55:29landed on we We wanted a name that was pronounceable but was not of our
- 1:55:34culture, you know. We wanted a name that that you hadn't never heard,
- 1:55:40you know. We didn't want to name like Michael or Kirk or something.
- 1:55:43We wanted a name that, you know, like Obi Wan Kenobi.
- 1:55:46It's like, that's not a name that you hear of in our culture.
- 1:55:50So we wanted it to be pronounceable, but but otherworldly and the name we
- 1:55:56came up with. The one that we brainstormed was Blaine, you know,
- 1:56:00like B l a n E. Or B l ai In. And it
- 1:56:06was years later that I discovered that that's an actual name in our culture.
- 1:56:11We just had never heard of the name, and we didn't know anyone with
- 1:56:13the name Blaine, but that was the name of our guy anyway. So
- 1:56:16when I was in high school, I we went to career day, and
- 1:56:23up until that point, I had sort of loosely been planning on becoming an
- 1:56:27astronomer because I was really into astrophysics and physics and chemistry and stars and planets
- 1:56:33and all that kind of stuff. You know, it wasn't a strong plan,
- 1:56:36but it was just kind of a loose plan. And then I discovered
- 1:56:42during career day that the job openings for astronomers were very minimal, and typically
- 1:56:49to get a job in astronomy you had to wait for someone to die,
- 1:56:54usually at a university. So there was that, and looking back, it
- 1:57:00was such a simplistic way of looking at because of course, you know,
- 1:57:03there's a lot of jobs in astronomy, but I think it was narrowly defining
- 1:57:08it as like a lead astronomer at a university anyway. So I was turned
- 1:57:15off by that. I was like, oh, that doesn't sound very promising,
- 1:57:17and I thought, maybe I'll be a writer, And so I started.
- 1:57:21I started writing in a similar manner that my friend was writing in,
- 1:57:28and I I don't know how confident I felt in my writing. I did
- 1:57:33share it with some people. I remember I had an English teacher that was
- 1:57:38very encouraging of it, and I would, you know, make a couple
- 1:57:43of my friends read some of it. But pretty quickly, I would say,
- 1:57:47within I don't know, maybe just a number of months, I realized
- 1:57:53that I wasn't any good at it. I just realized, wait, you
- 1:57:59know, this is a talent that not everyone has, and uh, it's
- 1:58:03going to take a lot of work to actually get better at this sort of
- 1:58:08thing. You have to it's a skill that you have to develop, you
- 1:58:11have to study other writers. And I just want to express my bullshit thirteen
- 1:58:18year old notions through metaphor and these dumb little stories and and they're they're not
- 1:58:25it's not a good It's good enough for me to reflect on, like I
- 1:58:29like, I liked doing it, but it's not good enough for other people
- 1:58:32to be reading it. So I realized pretty quickly that I had no talent,
- 1:58:39and you know, maybe I have a dash of narcissism enough to begin
- 1:58:44to fantasize with the idea of becoming an author. That, you know,
- 1:58:48because being an author there's a lot of prestige in that, right. It's
- 1:58:50like your your brain makes you money, you know. And so, but
- 1:58:59I didn't have enough to narcissism to overlook the data, and no one told
- 1:59:02me that I was bad. I think I just started looking as if I
- 1:59:09were an outsider on my writing and concluded that I wasn't any good like or
- 1:59:15at least I didn't have any reason to believe I was good. That's probably
- 1:59:18a better way to put it. I don't think I knew I was bad,
- 1:59:23but I didn't have any reason to believe I was actually good. I
- 1:59:26was just someone that decided to do something that anyone can decide to do.
- 1:59:30And so with Nancy, I don't know, but a top hypothesis is that
- 1:59:38she ran into data that she wasn't good or good enough, especially as a
- 1:59:42professional author, and her narcissism denied her the ability to recognize that. Or
- 1:59:49another way of putting it is that due to her traumas of in all likelihood
- 1:59:55neglect and abuse. Growing up, she was on a tread mill running away
- 2:00:00from inferiority and would deny her flaws because of the terror of acknowledging that and
- 2:00:08recognizing, you know, because it's black and white. People with narcism have
- 2:00:12black and white thinking, and if they have a tiny flaw, or another
- 2:00:16way to put it is, if they're not perfect and superior in a particular
- 2:00:20way, then they are one hundred percent inferior in one hundred percent worthless.
- 2:00:25You know. For the rest of us, like myself, I can say
- 2:00:28that I suck at writing, but I'm still a good person for the most
- 2:00:31part. But for people with narcissism, they they can't they can't have those
- 2:00:38things in the same sentence. They can't hold on to the idea that they
- 2:00:43have a flaw or they're not as good as other people, and that they're
- 2:00:47a worthy person like it. That doesn't this doesn't make sense of them.
- 2:00:50So it's possible that this, you know, this data regarding her writing,
- 2:00:57it's possible that it was related to, you know, fairly significant narcissistic personality.
- 2:01:02Another detail, similar to Josh Powell, is that she pursued a lot
- 2:01:06of different jobs throughout her career, things like real estate agent and chef and
- 2:01:14caterer and author, and I think she was a semi successful caterer later in
- 2:01:19life. But when you look at these jobs, it's at least it looks
- 2:01:26like the sort of jobs that someone suffering from narcissism would pursue as a way
- 2:01:30to try to gain narcissistic supply. You know, a real estate agent,
- 2:01:35because not all real estate agents, but and certainly I'm guessing if you just
- 2:01:43tested all the real estate agents in your community, I'm guessing there isn't a
- 2:01:47higher prevalence of narcissistic person I disorder. That's not what I'm saying. But
- 2:01:51if you are seeking, you know, data that you are superior, and
- 2:01:59you want to send information to others that you're superior, some of these jobs
- 2:02:03lend itself to that. Because to be a real estate agent, from I
- 2:02:05understand, you don't necessarily need to go back to graduate school or anything,
- 2:02:09right, so the barrier of entry is pretty low, lower than other kinds
- 2:02:14of careers. I'm sure there's some sort of barrier, right, but not
- 2:02:16significant, And you can have these delusions of grandeur that you're going to make
- 2:02:23all this money and you're going to be fantastic as a salesperson. But you
- 2:02:27know, being a real estate agent is hard. You know, you're limited
- 2:02:30by the supply of the market, and there's a lot of know how and
- 2:02:36there's a lot of sort of luck involved, you know, because the people
- 2:02:42that come your way or the properties that come your way, some are harder,
- 2:02:45some are easier. So, like Josh Powell, I wonder if the
- 2:02:51narcissism was involved in plus with Josh. Anyway, the real estate agent career
- 2:03:00allows you a lot of wiggle room regarding, especially in the beginning, how
- 2:03:03much money you make. Right so you can be very unsuccessful as a real
- 2:03:09estate agent and yet in your mind and maybe claim to others that you are
- 2:03:14building your you know, your client base or you're still getting into the industry
- 2:03:19or something, you know what I mean. So who knows, But it's
- 2:03:24just a and she wanted to be a chef, that's what That's how she
- 2:03:29met Dan. Actually I think she took one of his classes. Anyway,
- 2:03:32So other details that point towards narcissistic person I disorder is that the district attorney,
- 2:03:43the prosecutor during the trial. From my memory listening to various different reports
- 2:03:47of this, is that they were worried that they were not going to be
- 2:03:53convincing to the jury beyond a reasonable doubt based on the evidence that they had.
- 2:03:59But then Nancy took the stand, you know, because we understand it
- 2:04:04at least this is my understanding, is that if you are being if you're
- 2:04:10the defendant, then you don't have to take the stand, right and often
- 2:04:15it's it's not advised that you do because it's hard to well anyway, you
- 2:04:21know, because I won't go overall. I think people understand it. So
- 2:04:27she took the stand, and then the prosecution. Upon Nancy trying to defend
- 2:04:32herself to the jury, the prosecution was like relieved because they're like, oh,
- 2:04:41I, you know, I was thinking that the jury was not going
- 2:04:45to find her guilty, but but now I'm pretty sure that they're going to
- 2:04:51find her guilty because because the way that Nancy came across on the stand,
- 2:04:55she was combative, like I said, she you know, said to my
- 2:05:00which she was all over the place regarding her defense. And another aspect of
- 2:05:08narcissism is that people these people typically hate not being able to testify. They
- 2:05:16for you know, they want to be center of attention. Right, So
- 2:05:19if we just look at it in terms of the pros and the cons that
- 2:05:21are laid out to a defendant, you know, the cons of getting up
- 2:05:27on the stand is that, according to a lot of legal wisdom, is
- 2:05:30you're less likely to win the case. You open yourself up to cross examination,
- 2:05:36you might slip up and say the wrong thing. You know, there's
- 2:05:40a lot of pretty big cons which results in the vast majority of defendants never
- 2:05:44taking the stand. But when you are, when you suffer from narcissism,
- 2:05:48you will exaggerate the pros, right, and you'll one You'll believe because you
- 2:05:57believe you're superior and you have grandiose ideas of who you are. You believe
- 2:06:01that you will win the case and you'll convince the jury. You know,
- 2:06:06you believe you are the best person to convince the jury of these things.
- 2:06:12You also believe that you are a genius and are able to you know,
- 2:06:18out maneuver cross examination. This is a pretty classic narcissistic thing. Ted Bundy,
- 2:06:26in all likelihood, suffered from narcisism and defended himself and failed. There's
- 2:06:31all sorts of examples of this where someone with NARCISSM will shoot themselves in the
- 2:06:35foot by believing in themselves too much, so she takes a stand. Also,
- 2:06:45she was very casual in the stand, which points potentially towards narcissism.
- 2:06:48And also this notion of that she knows better than her own attorney, because
- 2:06:54in all likelihood her attorney told her to limit what she says. At the
- 2:06:59very least during the trial, her own attorney would chime in as she's being
- 2:07:04questioned by the prosecution, her own attorney would say, rabbit hole, rabbit
- 2:07:09hole as a way to remind Nancy, stop talking, just answer the question,
- 2:07:15don't elaborate your hurting yourself. Rabbit hole, rabbit hole. And yet
- 2:07:21Nancy kept rabbit holing after that, and that points to a narcissistic notion that
- 2:07:28Nancy believed that she knew better than her own attorney, you know what I
- 2:07:31mean. Another element of narcissism in the trial is that when she was being
- 2:07:39questioned by the prosecution, she would get really combative and it looked like bullying
- 2:07:45in some ways. And you know, we can think of certain politicians that
- 2:07:50are like this, where when you know at first, when you are coming
- 2:07:57at someone with narcissism and you're trying to to implicate them or something, or
- 2:08:01you're criticizing them, in all likelihood, they'll use other mechanisms, other techniques
- 2:08:07to try to evade that are not very combative. Usually not always, but
- 2:08:13you know, they'll try to argue or ignore or triangulate or something. But
- 2:08:18you push them into a corner and they almost always will come out swinging metaphorically
- 2:08:24or literally. And I think with Nancy when she was on the stand,
- 2:08:31there were times when she was being cornered and she didn't have any way to
- 2:08:37get out of that corner, and so what she would do is she would
- 2:08:41just have this attitude toward the other attorney of how dare you question me?
- 2:08:48This is a common narcissistic thing because this is the way that they believe.
- 2:08:56They have a distortion that they're right, that they're brilliant, that they're awesome,
- 2:09:00and they're ave, they're above reproach. And so if you are coming
- 2:09:05at them as if you're an equal or God forbid, you're actually above them,
- 2:09:11like in the case of cross examination, and you know what's above what's
- 2:09:16below, but you know if it just comes across like someone else is dominating
- 2:09:18you and winning something. Then you, as a narcissistic person, you must
- 2:09:24prevail, and you believe that just who you are gives you permission to prevail.
- 2:09:31You know, you don't have to convince anybody. All you have to
- 2:09:35do is just say, I prevail because I'm me. Do you know who
- 2:09:39you're talking to? You know that kind of thing, And she had that
- 2:09:41attitude. Another possibility regarding narcissism, regarding all the grandiosity and all the overconfidence,
- 2:09:48is that deep down, for people with narcisism, they believe that they're
- 2:09:54inferior. In fact, they know that they're inferior. It's not a belief,
- 2:09:58they just know that they are worthless and infergure. And one way to
- 2:10:01look at this overconfidence is a semi conscious effort to overcompensate for the fact that
- 2:10:07they feel very insecure. The closest example that most, if not everyone does
- 2:10:16in their life that I can point to is a teenager that's like whatever.
- 2:10:22Not all teenagers has stag not all teenagers, but many teenagers will, you
- 2:10:26know, stereotypically anyway, but you know, many teenagers, myself included,
- 2:10:31will enter into a phase where they come across like they're apathetic and they don't
- 2:10:37care about what other people think, and when you ask them questions, they're
- 2:10:41just like rolling their eyes like, okay, whatever, I don't know,
- 2:10:46and the persona is one the message is one of I don't care, I'm
- 2:10:54so above this, this is so dumb, I have some I've so many
- 2:11:00better things to do than sit here and talk to you. We all understand
- 2:11:03that teenagers are not super secure individuals, right. They have a lot of
- 2:11:09reasons to be insecure. They're entering a phase in their life when they very
- 2:11:13much realize and subconsciously realize that they're about to enter into the adult world and
- 2:11:18they have no idea what they're doing, and they're terrified naturally, and one
- 2:11:24of the ways to cope with that terror and that sense of inferiority is to
- 2:11:30overcompensate by coming across like you're above it all and you don't care. So
- 2:11:35we all are capable of doing that, and when you have narcissism, then
- 2:11:39that it's one of the ways that they deal with and it's one of the
- 2:11:41ways of looking at their behavior, and it can be semi conscious to them,
- 2:11:46but it can also be at costs, it's hard to tell what was
- 2:11:50going on with her. Another thing is is just to wrap up her personality,
- 2:11:56is that on the stand she had a freud and slip in which she
- 2:12:00says, I don't know how to defend myself against the truth. This was
- 2:12:03her rabbit holing, by the way. You know, she's like spitting out
- 2:12:07a bunch of things, kind of arguing with the attorney, and I think
- 2:12:11they were questioning her about the memory stuff and where she was that morning,
- 2:12:16and she's just like, look, you know, I don't know how to
- 2:12:20defend myself against the truth, meaning I don't know how to defend myself against
- 2:12:24this accusation. And it's the truth, you know, but you know,
- 2:12:28who knows. Maybe it was just a slip of the tongue, but it
- 2:12:31was. It was a notable moment. Okay, So I want to go.
- 2:12:35I want to end here. It's sticking a lot longer than I thought
- 2:12:39it would, but I want to end here with my speculation about what all
- 2:12:43happened. This is you know, there's a lot of speculator. When I
- 2:12:46speculated about Josh Powell, I had a lot more data to go off of
- 2:12:50With this one. Not much but in terms of all the things, it
- 2:12:54sometimes helps me emotionally if I can just sort of, you know, get
- 2:12:58you know, a absorb all the data that is available and try to put
- 2:13:05together some sort of narrative that explains everything. It's just a story that I'm
- 2:13:09telling myself and now telling you, So just take that with a grain,
- 2:13:15self. But I think it helps to do this sometimes to at least have
- 2:13:20an option in terms of what happened that pulls all the data together, because
- 2:13:26I think it can be helpful to do this so that you can understand human
- 2:13:31behavior in this anyway. So for Nancy, upon meeting him, she had
- 2:13:37a fantasy that they would be a fancy couple, a power couple her I
- 2:13:43don't know what point, because they met later in life, by the way,
- 2:13:46and I don't know exactly when they met. But at the very least
- 2:13:52he was a renowned chef with a very good reputation even among other chefs,
- 2:13:58you know, and so maybe she was already an author by that point.
- 2:14:03But I could see a reality in which she thought, at the very least
- 2:14:09his life will give me prestige, but maybe the two of us will be
- 2:14:15that power couple. I'm the author, the successful author, and he's the
- 2:14:20successful, high powered chef this kind of thing. So I think that that
- 2:14:24was a motivation among normal motivations like falling in love with and also I think
- 2:14:31that their relationship was highly complimentary, meaning they complimented each other's deficits in that
- 2:14:39she talked and talked and talked and talked and talked and talked and talked and
- 2:14:41talked, and took up a lot of space in the room even if it
- 2:14:45was just the two of them and he was shut down. I don't think
- 2:14:48he was listening much, but he didn't indicate he wasn't listening so and he
- 2:14:54didn't talk or fight back in those situations most of the time. So I'm
- 2:15:00guessing that to her it felt like he was listening, but he was mostly
- 2:15:05checked out. He might have also appreciated her taking up that space because he
- 2:15:09wasn't taking up the space, and if he was with someone like himself,
- 2:15:15then they would be there would be no contact because you'd have two shut down
- 2:15:18people. This is a common, you know, configuration and relationship. By
- 2:15:24the way, my other speculation is that they were never really close, even
- 2:15:28though she Nancy would claim that they had this perfect marriage, and that they
- 2:15:31were very close and they complimented each other really well. I would speculate that
- 2:15:37from the very beginning they were never really close due to their own traumas.
- 2:15:43I would imagine both of them had been through a fair amount of trauma.
- 2:15:46I don't know that, but I would just imagine, and both of them
- 2:15:50were looking to have a partner that kept their distance, and I think that
- 2:15:56they both did, you know, because some with narcissic Perconi shorders is going
- 2:15:58to be inherently emotionally distant and pathologically independent. And there are reports that the
- 2:16:05two of them did live parallel lives, reports from Nancy saying that they each
- 2:16:13had their own hobbies that they engaged in and they didn't bother each other with
- 2:16:18that. So that's my speculation is that they were just never really close.
- 2:16:26Now rewinding the clock, I would suspect that since she was young, she
- 2:16:31had been chasing narcissistic supply through a dream of fame and fortune, and by
- 2:16:37the time she got into her sixties, after being with Dan for a bit,
- 2:16:43she realized that it was kind of the end of the line, or
- 2:16:46thought it was the end of the line, and it wasn't really working.
- 2:16:50You know, she's in her sixties. The money isn't looking good. Her
- 2:16:56career as an author is you know, failing, right, and her the
- 2:17:03money situation is making it so that they can't even necessarily afford the mortgage.
- 2:17:07And she she was faced with a situation where she would, you know,
- 2:17:11the logical thing to do because he has a job, he's this teacher,
- 2:17:18and he's making some money. She is making very little money as an author
- 2:17:22and as a side job as a caterer. The logical thing is that if
- 2:17:26they're having trouble paying the mortgage, that she has to figure out a different
- 2:17:31career that is more lucrative, probably a job that wasn't very prestigious, right
- 2:17:39because she I don't know, I don't think she had a lot of skills
- 2:17:41that would lend itself to some high powered jobs. So she might even have
- 2:17:46to just enter like food service or more catering, which you know, doesn't
- 2:17:52have a lot of prestige to it. So I think this was a reckoning
- 2:17:58for her, a breaking point to Josh Powell, right, bankruptcy, two
- 2:18:03hundred thousand dollars in debt, that kind of stuff. Also, I think
- 2:18:07that there was worry for her of divorce. So I think she had pumped
- 2:18:16up because this is a common thing. It's not always the case, but
- 2:18:18people with narcisstic precise or will talk about their marriage as if it's perfect,
- 2:18:24and they might even involve themselves on Instagram along those lines these days, and
- 2:18:30when the shit hits the fan and they have to consider divorce, one of
- 2:18:35the first things that these individuals will think is, oh my god, I
- 2:18:39have to tell everyone, or at least hide, you know, without much
- 2:18:43ability to hide, that our relationship was not perfect, maybe had never been
- 2:18:50perfect, might even be flawed at its core. That's the opposite of what
- 2:18:54I've been portraying, and that makes me inferior and a failure, and that
- 2:18:58makes it very hard for me to deal with this. So I think that's
- 2:19:01another possibility. Also regarding their conflict escalating, I think that she would bulldoze
- 2:19:11with her narcissism and her taking up a lot of space, and I think
- 2:19:16that there's a good possibility that he contributed to the conflict. He's not to
- 2:19:20blame for her killing him, but I'm guessing that if I were to observe
- 2:19:24the two of them, you know, while the while he was still alive
- 2:19:28in a fight that I would conclude that each of them are contributing in their
- 2:19:33own way, and that the way that he was contributing was because he was
- 2:19:39for a fair amount of time estranged from his son from a previous marriage.
- 2:19:43And there's a little bit of reporting on this that he was the Dan was
- 2:19:50not the easiest person to get along with, So in all likelihood, regardless
- 2:19:58of who he was married to, there was going to be a problem there,
- 2:20:01and I'm thinking that that became more prevalent as their conflict escalated leading up
- 2:20:07to the murder. And I'm guessing this is all speculation that at some point,
- 2:20:13you know, probably months or years earlier than the murder, she wanted
- 2:20:16to change her life. She wanted to revamp, and she wanted maybe even
- 2:20:22to leave him, but she worried about having to come clean about the marriage,
- 2:20:26and she didn't have a way to make money on her own, and
- 2:20:31so she was in a bit of a bind, you know, because one
- 2:20:35path would be that she would divorce him if things weren't working out and just
- 2:20:41exist on her own career. But that wasn't working out. So I think
- 2:20:46that what so up until this point, there's nothing really weird about this story.
- 2:20:52There are so many people suffering from, you know, to some degree,
- 2:20:58narcissistic person I disorder, who are fighting with their spouses and having money
- 2:21:01problems. There's nothing particularly strange here, even with a dash of psychopathy.
- 2:21:07So I think what might have pushed her over the or been a major factor
- 2:21:13in the motivation to kill Dan is all of these books that she's been writing
- 2:21:20for whatever reason, and we could speculate as to why she would even begin
- 2:21:24to go down this road. Additionally, but she had been writing all these
- 2:21:28books about killing husbands and running off with the Navy seal, so it's possible
- 2:21:35that it planted a seed. And also, we tend to do what is
- 2:21:41familiar to us. I don't know why this analogy just popped in my head,
- 2:21:46but if I'm not using my GPS system on my car and I'm driving
- 2:21:52somewhere that I don't usually drive to, I will tend to take roads that
- 2:21:58I'm familiar with, even though I'm pretty sure it's not the fastest route.
- 2:22:01Because I'm familiar with those roads, I'm familiar with the intersections, and you
- 2:22:05know, I can predict what it's going to look like, so you know,
- 2:22:11this is an analogy to it. But you know, we tend to
- 2:22:13do things that require the least amount of effort and the least amount of uncertainty.
- 2:22:16And so if we have a lot of mental practice shooting people in our
- 2:22:24stories, then in a pinch, it's much more likely that we're going to
- 2:22:30consider that because you know, at least we believe that we have the ability
- 2:22:35to be more successful with something that we're familiar with. The problem is with
- 2:22:39Nancy is that given her narcissism, she would be overconfident in her plan,
- 2:22:46because when I get to it, her plan is pretty bad. Like Josh
- 2:22:52Powell. Honestly, I mean the fact that Josh Powell got away with it
- 2:22:54is you know, I think a combination of luck for him and in competence
- 2:23:01with the prosecution office in Utah. But with Nancy, I guess you could
- 2:23:07argue she almost got away with it, but she didn't, So the narcissism
- 2:23:16would convince herself. You know, take someone else that doesn't have NARCISSM and
- 2:23:22they for whatever reason are writing similar books and for whatever reason they start thinking
- 2:23:26about killing their husband. Well, someone without narcissism would eventually get to a
- 2:23:33place of us like, well, what do I know. I've never murdered
- 2:23:35anyone before. I've only written about this in a book. How I'm not
- 2:23:41confident at all in this plan of mine. Yeah, as an example from
- 2:23:48my own life, I think I've talked about this in the podcast before.
- 2:23:50It's a very notable moment, very eye opening, and pivotal moment in my
- 2:23:58life. Honestly, I'm thinking that I was a freshman or sophomore in high
- 2:24:05school and I would run for student office. I don't know how I entered
- 2:24:15student government. I think I was just voted in without even volunteering my name.
- 2:24:22I mean that sounds pompous. I think what happened was when we were
- 2:24:26I think student government when we started high school, I think so. And
- 2:24:30I think at the beginning of ninth grade, they just asked every student to
- 2:24:35vote for people to be representatives of them in student government. And if you
- 2:24:41come from an area that doesn't have student government, it might sound very weird,
- 2:24:45and I don't want to go into the details, but you know,
- 2:24:46you have a president and a treasurer, and a vice president and a secretary,
- 2:24:50and you have other positions. And for whatever reason, I was a
- 2:24:56representative. I was one of the members of student government in ninth grade,
- 2:25:01and that just persisted, I think mostly because people tended to just vote for
- 2:25:07incumbents, you know, so I was so you start by becoming just a
- 2:25:20general representative, and then from those representatives you will elect people to president and
- 2:25:26all the other roles, the sort of top roles. And so I'm a
- 2:25:31representative and I'm running for treasurer or something, and i am trying to figure
- 2:25:37out what I'm going to do for a speech. And I'm terrible on stage
- 2:25:43and I know that, and I'm terrible with public speaking, and I know
- 2:25:46that, so I'm trying to avoid it, and yet I'm running for office
- 2:25:50when I don't need to. It's like I could have just stayed a representative,
- 2:25:52which I eventually would do in later years. But because long story short,
- 2:25:58I didn't win this election, and it won't be a strange thing once
- 2:26:03I tell you what I did as my speech quote unquote. But I'm really
- 2:26:07desperately just and I'm putting it off. I'm procrastinating. I'm thinking, I
- 2:26:11don't know what to say. And you know, what a normal person would
- 2:26:15do would research what a speech should look like and and start piecing together an
- 2:26:22outline and maybe sprinkle in some jokes or have my own personality. You know
- 2:26:26that that's what everyone else did. But I didn't even have the I didn't
- 2:26:33have any idea what I was doing. I was just completely lost and clueless,
- 2:26:37and also being a little pathologically independent, I just didn't ask for any
- 2:26:43sort of help. And so at some so I go to earlier in the
- 2:26:52week before my speech is supposed to be given, there's an election for the
- 2:26:58all schools government that everyone participates in, and it's mainly upper classmen, older
- 2:27:05kids that are running for these offices. And there's this one girl, I
- 2:27:07think a cheerleader who her speech was. She had a Madonna song. What's
- 2:27:16the song? It's I think it's off the first album. And what she
- 2:27:20did is during the chorus, she dubbed in her own voice, you know,
- 2:27:26instead of the chorus being something like, uh, love me. I
- 2:27:31can't remember what song is that, but it had a had a cadence of
- 2:27:37anyway she in the you know, because this is nineteen eighty six and so
- 2:27:43the technology isn't there, So she just inserted her own singing voice, saying
- 2:27:48vote for me. My name is Anne Marie. Her name was an Marie
- 2:27:54By, and you know it was fine. It's a little goof, but
- 2:28:00I think it was entertaining to the crowd. And she's in front of the
- 2:28:03whole school in our schools, I don't know, like fourteen hundred kids or
- 2:28:07something, and she's dancing around and she's lip syncing to Madonna and to herself,
- 2:28:15overdubbing it, and she looks for some guy in the crowd to dance
- 2:28:20with, and she zeros in on one of my close friends and pulls him
- 2:28:24into, you know, to the you know it. So these species were
- 2:28:30done in the main I know, you call it the main stadium area.
- 2:28:35It's where the basketball court is and you have the bleachers and everything away,
- 2:28:37and she, out of all the fourteen hundred kids, she grabs our friend,
- 2:28:41my friend, and they dance around a little bit, and me and
- 2:28:43my friends are just cackling with laughter that she picked one of our friends.
- 2:28:50So that inspires me to do my version of her speech, partially making fun
- 2:28:56of her, which is a total dick move, but I don't know what
- 2:28:58I was thinking. So what I do is I find that same Madonna song
- 2:29:05somehow, and I overdub my voice saying something similar. But I think I
- 2:29:13might have even said vote for me. My name is Anne Marie. I
- 2:29:16might have even directly referenced her. I don't know. And then I'm like,
- 2:29:20I'm going to dance around, you know, just with my grade,
- 2:29:26and I'm going to find my friend and pull him onto the stage and dance
- 2:29:31with him the same way that Anne Marie did. And then I'm like,
- 2:29:35oh, and I have another idea is that I'm going to make fun of
- 2:29:39the fact that I'm Asian. So this is a whole other thing that you
- 2:29:43know, I grew up in a community and I went to a school that
- 2:29:46was ninety nine point ninety nine percent white people, and the fact that I
- 2:29:50was Asian was very exotic and very strange, and it was often highlighted by
- 2:29:56people. And I learned that if I just leaned into the joke, then
- 2:30:03it, you know, took away some of the sting, right, And
- 2:30:07so I thought what I would do, And you know, keep in mind,
- 2:30:13I'm like fifteen years old at this point, and I decide that I'm
- 2:30:18going to dress up in my older brother's karate outfit and I'm going to make
- 2:30:22a poster that says, like, you know, vote for Kirk for treasure
- 2:30:26or something, and then I'm going to jump I'm going to be backstage,
- 2:30:31and then just as the song starts, I'm going to jump through this this
- 2:30:37you know, big piece of paper that says vote for me, and I'm
- 2:30:41going to karate kick my way through it. And I'm going to be in
- 2:30:43this karate outfit and I'm going to be dancing to this Madonna song that's going
- 2:30:48to be a callback to this other speech we saw earlier, earlier the week.
- 2:30:52And then I'm going to do another callback by finding my friend and pulling
- 2:30:56him up on saying, so this is my idea. It's the dumbest idea
- 2:30:58that's ever been thought of. And I, you know, jump through the
- 2:31:03paper and I'm suddenly standing in front of my you know, three hundred and
- 2:31:11fifty four hundred classmates, and I instantly am terrified. They're all just staring
- 2:31:16at me, and I instantly realized this is the dumbest idea that I'd ever
- 2:31:20had. I'm like, what am I doing? This is so stupid.
- 2:31:24I don't have I didn't have anything more than what I had up until that
- 2:31:28point. It completely lacks substance. I needed something else to do like a
- 2:31:35it should have been like the beginning of my joke, Like I should have
- 2:31:37gone on you know, just thinking now, I should have you know,
- 2:31:39stopped the song and gone on stage and said like, look, running for
- 2:31:43office isn't a joke, or but that'd be still really unfair to Anne Marie,
- 2:31:48Like what am I doing? Anyway? And the Madonna song is what
- 2:31:52like four minutes long, so I have a lot of time to kill and
- 2:31:54I'm not a funny person really, So I'm I'm running around and and I'm
- 2:32:01so nervous, and I'm sort of halfway glancing through the crowd. I cannot
- 2:32:05find my friend. We did not predetermine where he would be in a crowd
- 2:32:11of four hundred students, and so I am frantically looking for him. I
- 2:32:16can't find him. And then without any punchline, and you know, certainly
- 2:32:20everyone's just waiting, Well, certain there's got to be some sort of punchline.
- 2:32:22Yeah, the initial shock of it would be a little bit of a
- 2:32:26giggle, I'm sure, but then that's it. They're just like, so
- 2:32:30we're just gonna watch this guy dance around and then the song ends and I
- 2:32:35just sort of, you know, melted back into the backstage, you know,
- 2:32:41just like God. And it was hard because for those four minutes,
- 2:32:48I'm like every microsecond regretting my decisions and realizing that just because an idea seems
- 2:32:58like it might be a good idea does not make it a good idea.
- 2:33:01And so if I have five percent narcissism that I claim that gives me the
- 2:33:09confidence and the motivation to have done the whole thing and to begin with.
- 2:33:15But since I don't have full blown narcissism, then I very quickly realize,
- 2:33:20oh, I have a limitation here, whereas someone with full blown narcissism would
- 2:33:26need to be in denial of that limitation and would distort it like, well,
- 2:33:33people don't understand what I'm doing, or everyone loved what I did.
- 2:33:39You know, I saw a lot of really happy faces or something like that,
- 2:33:41you know, because of the desperation of that. So along those lines,
- 2:33:46for Nancy Brophy, I think that she had this idea because she had
- 2:33:52written about it a lot, that she could kill her husband, get away
- 2:33:56with it, get the insurance money, go to Portugal and meet the navy
- 2:34:01seal of her life and everything would be fine. Because she had a little
- 2:34:07bit of narcissism enough to come up with the idea, and a lot of
- 2:34:11narcissism to deny her the opportunity to self reflect and conclude that her idea and
- 2:34:20her plan and her notion was not very sound, you know what I mean.
- 2:34:24Now, the other aspect of this case that I want to talk about
- 2:34:28is that it's fairly normal to fantasize about killing your partner, your spouse when
- 2:34:35you're in high conflict. And let me explain. So, I, as
- 2:34:39a therapist, will hear people tell me things that they don't tell anybody else.
- 2:34:45And I've heard a lot of people tell me about the violent fantasies that
- 2:34:50they have about their spouses as they're going through a breakup or a divorce,
- 2:34:54or post breakup, post divorce, or post infidelity or something. You know,
- 2:35:00it's common, and at first it was shocking, but as time has
- 2:35:05gone on, I'm just used to it and it's not It's not an indication
- 2:35:11that anyone is at risk. And it might be kind of scary to think
- 2:35:13about, but to me, it's not. It's not scary. A very
- 2:35:18common story that I would hear would be that, you know, say a
- 2:35:24couple goes through a really nasty divorce. And I'm talking to a woman about
- 2:35:31the divorce and there's all this anger and contention and accusation and legal actions against
- 2:35:37each other and you know, child custody issues and it's it's brutal. And
- 2:35:45in session she might say, Hey, you know, I'm a little worried
- 2:35:50because I've been having these intrusive thoughts. And I might say, what do
- 2:35:56you mean, Like, well, I've been having this vision of of you
- 2:36:01know, messing with his breaks on his car so he like drives off a
- 2:36:07cliff and dies. When I am daydreaming, I find myself daydreaming about torturing
- 2:36:18him, not just killing him, but making him suffer before he dies.
- 2:36:24Or it might be something more, or it might be something less violent.
- 2:36:28It might be something, you know. I have fantasies about making up a
- 2:36:33bunch of lies about him and telling all of his family and everyone he works
- 2:36:37with so that everyone hates him. And sometimes I might even fantasize for like
- 2:36:41forty five minutes, and I'll make plans and then I would ask, you
- 2:36:46know, a lot of questions about intent and risk, and the vast majority
- 2:36:52of time, pretty quickly i'd realize that there is no intent, there is
- 2:36:56no plan, there's no risk that they're actually going to carry this through.
- 2:37:00But it's a very satisfying emotional fantasy that people will have to make themselves feel
- 2:37:07a little better. Now, you know, we have to be careful about
- 2:37:11it entertaining these fantasies, but you know, it's common enough, and so,
- 2:37:16you know, I've heard a lot of stories like that, and I
- 2:37:20think that it's quite possible that Nancy was having that typical fantasy and you match
- 2:37:28that up with narcisism, and you know, and some site copathy and then
- 2:37:33her desperation, and you know, I think it's just possibly another factor.
- 2:37:37And another thing to think about is that given that in her books she could
- 2:37:43control the narrative and always allow the woman to get away with it, that
- 2:37:50she ended up narcissistically believing that she had you know, that she was a
- 2:37:56genius when it came to getting away with murder when she doesn't recognize that she
- 2:38:03designs the story such that they always get away with it. You know,
- 2:38:09also, she might have just fallen in love with her own writings such that
- 2:38:13she believed that it was a lot easier than it seems like it would,
- 2:38:18or a lot easier than it is, so I think due to all of
- 2:38:22these factors, she became at some point completely locked in on the Portugal fantasy.
- 2:38:31I don't have a ton of data on this, but it seems quite
- 2:38:33possible. She seemed quite desperate to move to Portugal, you know, and
- 2:38:39sell the house and get rid of the excess baggage of her husband and to
- 2:38:45get the livenstr responsey. I think that she thought that the promised land was
- 2:38:50in Portugal. And it's common for people with a narcissistic personal disorder to have
- 2:38:58this this behavior internally, even people who are just at the midpoint of the
- 2:39:07spectrum, right where they're frequently fantasizing about like Ooh, wouldn't it be awesome
- 2:39:15if this thing worked out? Or what if I just got to that point
- 2:39:18in my career, or oh, wouldn't it be awesome? If they're always
- 2:39:24looking forward to something. And this is a problem for a lot of us
- 2:39:28in our society, given the pressures on us. But for people with NARCISSM,
- 2:39:33they're almost always because they always deep down know that they're inferior, and
- 2:39:39they also aren't a constant need to run in place because they think they're running
- 2:39:45forward, but they're actually just running on a treadmill, trying to establish some
- 2:39:50sense of worth right by chasing narcissistic supply. And one of the realizations that
- 2:39:58they have potentially is that they aren't in the Promised Land yet. You know,
- 2:40:03they can't relax yet. But if they can just get to this one
- 2:40:09thing, establish this one career, or get to this one country, or
- 2:40:16have X amount of money, then I can finally relax and not have to
- 2:40:22put so much effort into establishing my superiority on other people. Of course,
- 2:40:26this ever works because the inferiority comes with them, regardless of how much they
- 2:40:31achieve. So the way it smells to me is that Nancy had had many,
- 2:40:43as had many future dreams that she had, like the dream of being
- 2:40:46a power couple with a chef, that kind of stuff, being an author,
- 2:40:50and none of that was working out, and for whatever reason, she
- 2:40:52just locked in on Portugal. I don't know what her associations with Portugal was,
- 2:40:56but in the Pacific Northwest, you know, we're pretty far from Europe,
- 2:41:01so we don't have a ton of you know, depending on the circle
- 2:41:05you run in, we don't have a ton of experience with Europe, and
- 2:41:11the common associations that I have, I'll just say from my place in my
- 2:41:16culture is that Europe is fancy and America is dumb. And I know that's
- 2:41:22stupid, but I just wanted to say. And Portugal and Spain have a
- 2:41:28particular allure to them, and maybe they're awesome, you know, I don't
- 2:41:33know, I've never been. There's an eclipse coming through Spain through Barcelona actually,
- 2:41:37or Barcelona however, you so in a couple of years it's one of
- 2:41:43one of the only places you can see the eclipse without being on a boat
- 2:41:48in the middle of the Atlantic Ocean. And it's going through Iceland. Iceland
- 2:41:52too, but it could be cloudy there anyway, So maybe I'll go to
- 2:41:58Spain for that. But the associations is that, you know, it's fancy
- 2:42:01and it's affordable, and it's you know, old world but also New World,
- 2:42:07and it's romantic, and it's good weather and there's like villas and ocean
- 2:42:16and festivals and taking naps during the day and staying up late at night and
- 2:42:24drinking, you know, sipping wine that's from a grape, you know,
- 2:42:30from a vineyard that's just across the street, and you know, nice cheese
- 2:42:35and bread that's fresh and you know, pure food, none of that fast
- 2:42:41food crap from America. Yeah, and maybe some of y'all from Spain and
- 2:42:46Portugal. Like, yeah, that's pretty much what it's like, you know,
- 2:42:48aside from the naps of the day. I don't know, but I
- 2:42:52don't know what her association was, but you know, I could see that.
- 2:42:56Like one of the one of the data points I have for this is
- 2:42:58that if you watch nine to ay Fiance, what's his face? Jesse from
- 2:43:05you know, from Darcy. One of the things that he would often say
- 2:43:09when he I think also from a narcissistic place, is trying to come across
- 2:43:13like he's this super success is that he has a villa in Portugal or Spain,
- 2:43:20one of the two. And I always just thought it was just so
- 2:43:26funny. It's like, you have a villa. I think it's Portugal,
- 2:43:30you know. He's like, yeah, I've I have houses all over you
- 2:43:33know, I have several properties all over the world, and I'm this world
- 2:43:35renowned guru of success and manliness and stuff. And I mean, I'm not
- 2:43:41even joking. It's just like it's not the exact words that he was saying,
- 2:43:45but this is what he's saying. You know, and I have a
- 2:43:48villa in por Portugal, and I'm thinking villa, Like what is there a
- 2:43:54legal definition of a villa, Like maybe you just have a house there,
- 2:43:58but house sounds so Munday, so American. You have to have a villa.
- 2:44:01And also, like, you know, good for him if he has
- 2:44:05property. But I suspected based on the little bit of investigation that I did
- 2:44:13about his life and I don't know, I guess, but I suspected that,
- 2:44:18uh, he either was in over his head regarding debt on the property,
- 2:44:22or he was renting it or something I don't know. Or it's very
- 2:44:26very cheap to have a quote unquote villa that's in the middle of nowhere,
- 2:44:30you know what I mean. Like like in Washington State, in Seattle,
- 2:44:35you know, a million dollars will get you a very average house, if
- 2:44:39not like a below average house in Seattle. But you go to central Washington
- 2:44:46just a couple hours east, and for a million dollars you could you could
- 2:44:50buy a property that was, you know, I don't know, a lot
- 2:44:56bigger, with a lot better home that has a view. But you're in
- 2:45:01the middle of nowhere, and the next town is this very small little town
- 2:45:05and it's a half hour half an hour away. This is a generalization,
- 2:45:09you know what I'm saying. But anyway, so my Portugal hypothesis is that
- 2:45:16for Nancy, she thought that if she could get to Portugal, then she
- 2:45:22will feel superior and she could finally retire. Maybe, you know, if
- 2:45:26they sell the house and they can take that money and they can sort of
- 2:45:31live, you know, reasonably within their means, they can have a really
- 2:45:35fancy villa and they could be fancy expats that claim like, oh, well,
- 2:45:41my villa in Portugal. I don't know, but I think that there's
- 2:45:45a possibility that that's what. And Dan didn't want to go. He might
- 2:45:50have thought it might be nice kind of, but he liked his life in
- 2:45:54Portland, and he liked his career, he liked teaching, he liked being
- 2:45:58a chef, and he was around some of his family and he didn't want
- 2:46:03to go. And so she bulldozed him and tried to get him to change,
- 2:46:09and she would. I think there are reports that she was starting to
- 2:46:16move ahead with the plan regardless of him consenting, like selling certain things that
- 2:46:20she wanted to get rid of so that they could move and he's like,
- 2:46:22what you sold. I don't know if it was that specific, but something
- 2:46:26like that. So I think at some point she was just like emotionally desperate
- 2:46:31to establish this new solution. It would get her away from being an author,
- 2:46:37it would get her away from having to face the music in Portland,
- 2:46:43it would in her mind, established that she was superior and that she was
- 2:46:48a success. And I think she locked in on killing Dan and she started
- 2:46:56getting all these insurance policies, and I think that what her plan was,
- 2:47:01well that she she was going to buy these guns and you know, and
- 2:47:05buy gun parts to do something to obscure the murder weapon. I'm not exactly
- 2:47:11sure. I was never really explicitly explained in a way that I understood,
- 2:47:16but you know, there's something around that was fishy. Then she did plan
- 2:47:22on shooting him when she shot him, you know, because if you think
- 2:47:26from her perspective, she's like, well, the easiest place I could shoot
- 2:47:28him would be at home, right because we're at home, this is the
- 2:47:31two of us, but you know, supposed to have the body, and
- 2:47:35if he's at home, then I'm the first person that they're going to talk
- 2:47:39to But if he dies at work, which is downtown Portland, and I'm
- 2:47:43nowhere near that, then I'm I'm in the clear, right And she thinks,
- 2:47:50well, I know that he is alone there before the students arrive,
- 2:47:54so that I have a perfect little window where I can shoot him. And
- 2:47:58so she thought that she would do that. And I wonder if she figured
- 2:48:05that they would think it was a burglary. I'm not quite sure, but
- 2:48:07she didn't do anything to make it look like a burglary, like all she
- 2:48:11had to do was take his wallet or something, but she didn't even do
- 2:48:15that. And either she didn't have a plan for that and she just figured
- 2:48:18she'd get away with it regardless, or she panicked. You know, I
- 2:48:22think that it's tempting. The common belief is that these cold hearted killers are
- 2:48:30super calm when they're doing these things. That's not likely, given that I
- 2:48:33don't think that she suffered from significant psychopathy. It's very likely that she was
- 2:48:39highly distressed leading up to and having done it. Not distressed in terms of
- 2:48:46remorse, but distressed in terms of getting caught. And whereas psychopaths often will
- 2:48:50have lack of access to their fear and will be calm as they commit these
- 2:48:56kind of crimes, not always, but often, And so there's a possibility
- 2:49:01that in the moment she did, or before she did have a plan to
- 2:49:05make it look like a burglary or something, but she panicked and just bolted.
- 2:49:07You know, you could imagine that that happening, and she planned on
- 2:49:13driving home and having the alibi, but she didn't count on she didn't count
- 2:49:20on the security cameras. And I think it's possible it's related to a few
- 2:49:26things that she didn't think about this one. I don't think even people that
- 2:49:31know about security cameras understand just how many security cameras there are in the world.
- 2:49:37You know, it's not something that is presented in a lot of like
- 2:49:41movies and TV shows. You know, there's a lot of things in movies
- 2:49:46and TV shows today that writers will write as a way of convenience, Like
- 2:49:54they not so much anymore. But but in recent pasth there would be movies
- 2:50:01where Stacey and I would suddenly ask each other why don't they just use their
- 2:50:07cell phone? And there would be no attempt to answer that question, right,
- 2:50:18or questions about security cameras. Right. So it's possible that she just
- 2:50:22had the common misunderstanding of just how many security cameras are out there. Number
- 2:50:30Two, she's older and she's in her seventies. Now, it's possible that,
- 2:50:35you know, she's just not up to date on technology and is less
- 2:50:39likely to realize that. Number Three, it's you know, quite possible that
- 2:50:43in all of her books that she would write, she kept it pretty simple
- 2:50:48and didn't involve security cameras because you know, I don't this is just a
- 2:50:56general I haven't really analyzed this, but there are certain things, things that,
- 2:51:01at least commonly it elements of a murder mystery, that can kind of
- 2:51:07ruin the story. Things like cell phones and security cameras can really simplify,
- 2:51:13you know. It's sort of like with Star Wars, right, Like,
- 2:51:16there are certain things about Star Wars movies and TV shows where you're thinking,
- 2:51:22wait, so they don't have security cam I mean, they have all this
- 2:51:26technology and they don't even have security cameras similar to the ones that we have
- 2:51:31today, you know, and they're like in the future in terms of technology,
- 2:51:39and so's there's just it's it's hard to it's harder to write a crisp
- 2:51:46story when you have to deal with these other things, you know what I
- 2:51:50mean. I don't know if that makes sense, but it's possible that in
- 2:51:54her books, which I haven't read, that she just hadn't really reckoned with
- 2:51:58the amount of security cameras that are in our lives right now. And so
- 2:52:03when she had this plan and enacted the plan, she just didn't account for
- 2:52:09the security camera problem, you know. So I don't know because she couldn't
- 2:52:15know that because if she had looked and really taken into account, she would
- 2:52:22have seen that on her route there were several security cameras and she couldn't know
- 2:52:28the resolution of those cameras. And because she almost got away with it as
- 2:52:33a thing, you know, because this the resolution was was so poor that
- 2:52:37it was hard to identify her, But she couldn't know that, right there
- 2:52:41could have been some of the cameras that had settings or the capability of taking
- 2:52:46very high resolution would have seen her face with her license plate driving at that
- 2:52:50particular time. So so I think that she just it just didn't cross her
- 2:52:56mind, is my guess. So I think due to luck, she almost
- 2:53:01got away with this. And it is kind of interesting because her plan is
- 2:53:07pretty simple, you know, especially when you compare it to Josh Powell's plan.
- 2:53:11And I mean, all she did would buy a gun just out in
- 2:53:16the open, claiming that it's a gun for him during mushroom money, or
- 2:53:18claiming that it's for her research purposes. And then she just drives down there,
- 2:53:26maybe just follows him to work, walks in there, shoots him twice.
- 2:53:28And just imagine what that would be like because he likely knew that she
- 2:53:35was shooting him, and just yeah, just horrible. And she just walks
- 2:53:41down there, walks in. She you know, she probably has the keys
- 2:53:45or it's open. She and just walks up to him and shoots him,
- 2:53:50walks off and drives home and then claims that she was home the whole time.
- 2:53:54You know, it's a very very simple plan, and she almost got
- 2:53:58away with it if it weren't for those pest kids just joking, if we're
- 2:54:01for those pesky police officers that doggedly kept reviewing these these these this video footage,
- 2:54:09which I'm a little confused by because, like you know, I have
- 2:54:11a security we have a security camera on our house and one time my neighbor
- 2:54:18actually asked me for a particular clip of my camera because well, how much
- 2:54:26do youto, do I want to go into he he wanted to establish an
- 2:54:31alibi actually that he was home because there was some sort of investigation. I
- 2:54:37don't think it was criminal, but he wanted proof that he was home,
- 2:54:45and so I just went to I just scrubbed through the recorded video until I
- 2:54:50got to that segment, and then I just pulled that segment. And so
- 2:54:54I'm I'm a little confused why when they got their hands on the video footage
- 2:55:00they didn't just scrub to the you know, if it's a thirteen hour if
- 2:55:05it's a thirteen minute window, then you know, say, you just have
- 2:55:09to search through what half an hour forty five minutes of video footage and and
- 2:55:15just watch the footage, right, I don't understand, you know, I
- 2:55:18don't know, but I mean, in the beginning, they didn't know what
- 2:55:20they were looking for, and there were a lot of cars going by and
- 2:55:22people walking around, so there's that. But but anyway, so yeah,
- 2:55:28that's my speculation. And she was convicted and she received a life sentence of
- 2:55:35imprisonment. I think the sentence was not for life, but it was like
- 2:55:41essentially life because the amount of years that she had to serve would go beyond
- 2:55:48life expectancy, something like that she's found guilty of second degree murder, which
- 2:55:54I believe second degree murder that's not premeditated, I don't know. So to
- 2:56:00conclude, there's just a couple other details that are kind of interesting. One
- 2:56:03is that, you know, when she called the investigator a few days after
- 2:56:09the murder to ask the investigator for a note saying that she was not a
- 2:56:13suspect. You know, she was like, Hey, I'm trying to get
- 2:56:18this forty thousand dollars life insurance policy, and they said that they will only
- 2:56:24give me it if I'm not a suspect, So can you write me a
- 2:56:26note? Well, there's a number of different things you can think of about
- 2:56:31this. One is that it potentially shows her obliviousness to the situation given her
- 2:56:39person disorder. Also, it might show that her primary concern was the money,
- 2:56:46again, lack of understanding the landscape, so that she should hide that
- 2:56:50given her you know, because when you're a narcissistic you just believe your idea
- 2:56:54is you also feel entitled, you know, that kind of stuff. So
- 2:56:58there's that. But when I was talking to the Wondery podcast people that happily
- 2:57:03never after folks. They one of them said that they wondered if this was
- 2:57:09a way of throwing her attempt at throwing them off the scent, even though
- 2:57:13it pointed an arrow at her. You know, there's a chance that if
- 2:57:20she hadn't a called, then the investigators might not have even really had her
- 2:57:24on the list, you know, because there didn't seem to be any motivation
- 2:57:28there. But the producer, the person that works for the podcast, what
- 2:57:35was interesting to me was that said, yeah, maybe what she was thinking
- 2:57:39was that she would claim that she only has a So here's the thinking is
- 2:57:46that she's sitting there a few days later and she's thinking, oh, crap,
- 2:57:48I don't know what the police are doing. Are they investigating me?
- 2:57:54You know, where are they? So that motivates her to check in with
- 2:57:56the investigator about her being potentially on the list of suspects, because she just
- 2:58:01she can't stand not knowing right, And criminals will often have this motivation.
- 2:58:07They will often contact the investigators as a way to try to get a lay
- 2:58:15of the land because then they believe that if they know that information, then
- 2:58:20that'll give them the ability to maneuver, you know, because they don't know
- 2:58:22which way to go, and investigators know this about guilty parties and will use
- 2:58:31it against them, you know, they'll sort of string the perpetrator along to
- 2:58:37kind of tease, like they did this to Jodi Arius if you remember anyway.
- 2:58:41So that's one motivation, But another one could have been that she wanted
- 2:58:46to throw them, you know, because she's sitting in there thinking it looks
- 2:58:50bad that I have a million one point four million dollars in life insurance that
- 2:58:56I'm going to get from this death. That looks bad, so I want
- 2:59:01to get out ahead of that. One of the ways I can get ahead
- 2:59:03of that is by telling the investigator about only one of the policies, which
- 2:59:09makes it look like I have much less motivation to kill him. So if
- 2:59:13I call him and say, oh, by the way, you know,
- 2:59:15and maybe the life insurance didn't even say this, right, she just makes
- 2:59:20it up. She's like, oh, by the way, there's this forty
- 2:59:22thousand dollars life which is policy. You know, it's a really small policy
- 2:59:26that no one would ever kill their husband over, you know, but you
- 2:59:30know, can you just write me now? I thought that was an interesting
- 2:59:33speculation. I think that, you know, it could be true. Another
- 2:59:37random detail is that last year, twenty twenty three, Lifetime made a movie
- 2:59:41about this case, because of course they did, because it's Lifetime, and
- 2:59:45it stars Sybil Shepherd as Nancy Brophy and and Daniel Brophy. Dan Brofy is
- 2:59:54played by Steve Gutenberg, because Dan Brofy kind of looks like Steve Gutenberg and
- 3:00:01Nancy Brophy I guess kind of looks like Sybil Shepherd. But it was nice
- 3:00:07to see those two still working. Honestly, I didn't know Silbil Shepherd was
- 3:00:11still working. And if you're from my generation, you know Steve Gutenberg.
- 3:00:20If you're not from my generation, you probably don't. He was in all
- 3:00:22the Police Academy movies and everything, and he was also in maybe the best
- 3:00:28movie he was in was a Ron Howard movie called Cocoon, which I think
- 3:00:33still holds up. So yeah, he was sort of like who would he
- 3:00:39be? Like? He was kind of like the Shia Lebuff of the time,
- 3:00:48like an everyman, kind of underdog, goofy guy. Yeah. Anyway,
- 3:00:56most of his movies are are panned at this point, but anyway,
- 3:01:01so there's a Lifetime movie, and then of course the Wondering podcast that came
- 3:01:05out this year So that's that episode, a lot longer than I thought it
- 3:01:09would be. But I thought, since I did all this deep diving mini
- 3:01:13deep diving into the case for the interview, I would also make my own
- 3:01:20episode on it. And so that was that episode, and everybody, Oh,
- 3:01:26let me promote a couple things. If you're not interested in this,
- 3:01:30you know, feel free to you know, stop listening. But you know,
- 3:01:35Berto and Rebecca and Bob all have cameos, So if you want to
- 3:01:39get a cameo from them, they don't get a lot of requests. So
- 3:01:46I think that's because people just don't know or remember, because I think a
- 3:01:50lot of people would like a cameo from them, and particularly Berto, because
- 3:01:54I don't think he charges very much. So if you want to give a
- 3:01:58birthday shout out, even yourself, you know, a lot of people don't
- 3:02:01get cameos for themselves. But I think that's a wonderful idea. You know,
- 3:02:03if if you're coming up on something or you just want like a pep
- 3:02:07talk or something, you know, just you know, get get a cameo
- 3:02:13from the They can't give therapy, of course, and but you know,
- 3:02:18there's a way to do a cameo within the bounds and provide so you know,
- 3:02:24cameo. Another is that our sixteenth anniversary show is coming up in September.
- 3:02:35Looking up the dates specifically, it is September fourteen and fifteen on YouTube.
- 3:02:41We're gonna start at ten am on both days Seattle time, and we're
- 3:02:46gonna live broadcast for eight hours each day, and it'll be me and Burto
- 3:02:52and we'll be doing our normal stuff that we usually do by doing swag games
- 3:02:58that y'all can participate in, an other kind of stuff and they'll be you
- 3:03:01know, antics and fun stuff that we'll talk about and Q and A.
- 3:03:05And I'm probably going to send out a survey to all the patrons and the
- 3:03:11YouTube members to provide random questions that we can answer when we get a chance
- 3:03:16on the broadcast. But another thing is that if you want to send in
- 3:03:22a card for the sixteenth anniversary, you know, you might want to send
- 3:03:26it sooner than later, because we always get like a fair amount of stuff
- 3:03:31after words. And I think it's because people scramble, particularly if you're not
- 3:03:35in the United States, you know, because mail could take longer. Also,
- 3:03:37if you want to send like a like a package or something or you
- 3:03:41know, or what I always love to get is fan art. I get
- 3:03:46a huge kick out of it. And if you do make fan art,
- 3:03:50you know, it's normal to make the fan art of yours truly, but
- 3:03:58I have a lot of fan art of yours, true, and so if
- 3:04:01it just feels narcissistic to ask for that. But also because I tend to
- 3:04:09put the art up in my office and it just looks kind of silly to
- 3:04:11have a bunch of versions of my face, and you know, but also
- 3:04:18if it's going to be in my office, I don't need to look at
- 3:04:20myself. I'd love to see you, you know, if if you want
- 3:04:22to have yourself in the fan art, or if you want to include the
- 3:04:28the co hosts in it, or just other elements in the fan art,
- 3:04:31or I don't know, just yeah, so there's that. And by the
- 3:04:37way, you know, I only have so much room in my office for
- 3:04:41fan art, so not everything can go up. You know. Sometimes it's
- 3:04:43kind of random that gets placed. You know. Sometimes I'll post a picture
- 3:04:46and people will be disappointed that their fan art isn't up. The other thing
- 3:04:48I'll say is it's not guaranteed that your fan art isn't up in my office
- 3:04:54just somewhere else, because you know, there's a fair amount of real estate
- 3:04:56on in my office for fan art. So there's that. It also could
- 3:05:03just be a function of me just saying I can't have that many pictures of
- 3:05:07me in my office, so something's got to go, I guess. So
- 3:05:13there's that. Uh what other things? If you're not a patron'd be great
- 3:05:20if you were. There's every month, Uh, there's a pretty sizable group
- 3:05:28of people that cancel their Patreon or YouTube membership. You know, I'm guessing
- 3:05:33for absolutely understandable reasons one way or the other, which means that in order
- 3:05:41for us as a as a company to survive, we have to have a
- 3:05:46constant group of people that are signing up. You know. We can never
- 3:05:54just sit back and coast like it there to stay at the same revenue level,
- 3:06:00we uh, we have to constantly be getting new people to sign up.
- 3:06:05So uh, you know, and when I stop promoting Patreon, we
- 3:06:13don't get a lot of new people, and so we're just taking a nose
- 3:06:18dive over time, you know. And I keep track of all this stuff.
- 3:06:20There's like I have graphs and spreadsheets and stuff and so because a lot
- 3:06:26depends on my ability to keep track of this stuff, because I, you
- 3:06:30know, have to pay employees and everything, and I have to pay my
- 3:06:33bills, and you know, it's the it's basically the only income for my
- 3:06:37family, and so there's a lot hinging on it, and it's it's scary
- 3:06:41to see the trends downward. Not the guilt trip you, but sometimes I
- 3:06:46feel like people might wonder if you know, we've established a certain level of
- 3:06:52success and there's no need for anyone to contribute because we're we're doing okay.
- 3:06:58And the fact of the matter is, like I said, we just need
- 3:07:00a constant new batch of people signing up all the time, you know,
- 3:07:05so only if you want to or care to, or have the the ability
- 3:07:09to, you know. But as I feel like it's I just want everyone
- 3:07:13to know the situation, and you know, I feel like I trust y'all
- 3:07:18with that stuff. What else, Oh, I want to also tell everyone
- 3:07:24that I think I've finally reached a place of work life balance. I as
- 3:07:31I won't bore you with additional details because I've already talked at length about this
- 3:07:35in previous episodes, but for the past couple of years, I've been trying
- 3:07:41and for the most part, failing at getting a work schedule that is doable.
- 3:07:48And I think I've I've finally arrived, you know, because I kept
- 3:07:52scaling back on on, you know, various different things that were really hard
- 3:07:58for me to give up. You know, like I used to make too.
- 3:08:01I used to publish two reaction videos a day, but then I scaled
- 3:08:07back to one a day, and now I'm back to Now I'm down to
- 3:08:11just for the most part, two a week, to reaction videos a week,
- 3:08:16And it's really hard to make those decisions because I like this job,
- 3:08:22I like making content, and I hate disappointing people, so every decision was
- 3:08:30hard. I've never scaled back on the audio podcast, by the way.
- 3:08:33This is the foundation of this podcast and of my life, and so that
- 3:08:39will never happen. If anything, I've just been able to have more time
- 3:08:43to dedicate to the audio podcast. So but you know, I just want
- 3:08:48to tell everyone that because if you care, because I've been talking about it
- 3:08:54for so long, I feel like I might have arrived. I don't know
- 3:08:58if it's ideal yet, but I'm hoping that it's a lot more doable because
- 3:09:07I'm still working a lot. Even though I'm working a lot less, I'm
- 3:09:11still working quite a bit. And I haven't had, you know, any
- 3:09:16sort of real vacation in a long time, which is just so weird because
- 3:09:22I'm self employed, so it just seems like I could take a vacation whenever
- 3:09:24I want. But so I don't know what that means for the future,
- 3:09:30but I'm hoping that this current sort of configuration of my career is allows for
- 3:09:41the normal allowance of maybe a weekend. I mean, I've I don't even
- 3:09:46get weekends off, really, and you know, it's fine. I love
- 3:09:50what I do. That's part of the problem is that I love it so
- 3:09:52much that I need to I need to purposely restrict myself from doing more anyway.
- 3:10:01So let me know what you think of this kind of stuff, the
- 3:10:05Nancy Brophy case, and does everyone out there please take care of yourself because
- 3:10:11you deserve it, You really really do.