Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / LA's Child Custody Recommending Counseling CCRC Pilot Program: What You Need to Know
Transcript
- 0:03I am Ryan Wetteking, the outgoing co -chair of
- 0:08the Beverly Hills Bar Association's Family Law
- 0:10section. Today we have a very important program
- 0:15on the LA Superior Court's pilot CCRC program
- 0:22and sort of getting everybody up to speed on
- 0:25that, what you need to know, what is it, what
- 0:28it is not. And to discuss the CCRC palette program.
- 0:35We have, I think, the most important people we
- 0:39could have to discuss it. We have presiding judge
- 0:42Shelly Kaufman and Judge Ferdus Doherty with
- 0:47us today to discuss. I think everyone is familiar
- 0:53with Judge Kaufman and Judge Doherty, so we will
- 0:57forgo a lengthy intro. Given how much subject
- 1:03matter we have to address, Judge Kaufman and
- 1:06Judge Dory, I think we can get right into it.
- 1:09Okay. Thank you, Ryan, just for the record, since
- 1:13we are on the record. It's supervising judge,
- 1:19presiding judge is presiding judge, Sergio Tapia
- 1:22of the court. But just to make it clear. So thank
- 1:27you for the opportunity to speak with members
- 1:32today. Thank you to the Beverly Hills Bar Association
- 1:34for organizing this forum, creating the forum
- 1:39for us to be able to speak to all of you out
- 1:41there who we can't see. So I will get started.
- 1:46The Spirit Court of Los Angeles County is pleased
- 1:49to present to you information about the child
- 1:52custody recommending counseling, which we call
- 1:57CCRC because the rest is somewhat of a mouthful.
- 2:05The Spirit Court of Los Angeles County regularly
- 2:09explores how to provide the best services to
- 2:13our court users. As families and their needs
- 2:18evolve, the court wishes to stay on the forefront
- 2:21of enhancing services to our community. Next.
- 2:29What we are, do we have the right PowerPoint
- 2:32here? It was the overview. Yeah. Yes. OK, I don't.
- 2:40OK, thank you. All right. Yes, my mistake. OK,
- 2:44so what we're going to be discussing today is
- 2:46the following. What the pilot is, what the pilot
- 2:49is not, why a multi -tiered mediation model,
- 2:53why now, who are the family court service specialists,
- 2:58what's in the general order, what is the CCRC
- 3:01process, what will be the R &R or report and
- 3:07recommendation, what will be in it? What is the
- 3:10court's expectation from the pilot? And what
- 3:13is the duration of the pilot? And will the bar
- 3:15be able to provide feedback? Next. So what the
- 3:22pilot is. First, it's a pilot. And just before
- 3:27we started, Ryan asked the question, and I'm
- 3:30going to just say it instead of having you to
- 3:32ask it. is has the court ever implemented a pilot
- 3:36that they didn't then adopt? And my first reaction
- 3:41was, well, I don't know if I know that. But then
- 3:43in quick discussion, we realized the court often
- 3:47has pilots. Sometimes they're not outside facing
- 3:50to the bar because they're administrative and
- 3:53we're testing new ways of doing things to see
- 3:56if they work. And so the answer is not all pilots.
- 4:01automatically are implemented. It's a pilot because
- 4:08we're testing feasibility of a new idea in the
- 4:11real world. It's a limited scale. We've set it
- 4:16towards a universe of right now to test this
- 4:22dissolution actions filed in the central district
- 4:26on initial custody requests. limited term in
- 4:32the sense, not a defined date to end, but understanding
- 4:37at some point we have to decide, are we moving
- 4:41forward on the whole court scale, or are we not
- 4:46able to pursue this process? We will be gathering
- 4:50data to help guide future decisions. One of the
- 4:55things - Judge Cobbin and Judge Dory, one question
- 5:00that comes to mind is you just mentioned that
- 5:04this applies to initial custody determinations.
- 5:09Now, as a litigator, I can think, gosh, does
- 5:13that mean initial as defined under the UCCJA,
- 5:18Family Code Section 3402, or does that mean initial
- 5:23in terms of it is not Montenegro, not final,
- 5:28so anything but a final determination? So it
- 5:32applies to what we call an initial, meaning it's
- 5:36the first time these parties have filed an RFO
- 5:39for custody. Typically speaking, that's going
- 5:43to be a new filing and a disso case. Although
- 5:46sometimes, I mean, early on in the filing of
- 5:51the disso, sometimes disso cases are filed, people
- 5:54lead their lives, they're working it out. And
- 5:58then, you know, six months later, a year later,
- 6:00they're not working it out. and they have their
- 6:03initial request for an order on custody. So it's
- 6:05the initial, it's the first RFO filed on custody.
- 6:10It doesn't have to be in RFO. So for instance,
- 6:13if the parties had stipulated temporary orders,
- 6:17and then as you were saying, you know, six months
- 6:19down the road, things aren't working out and
- 6:22somebody files an RFO, would it apply there where
- 6:25there are already orders and somebody seeking
- 6:28to modify? No, it fits the UCC -JEA definition
- 6:32under 3402H, in the sense that it is truly a
- 6:36first custody order, including one that was previously
- 6:41existing by stipulation. And the pilot is not
- 6:49applying to DVRO requests. So while parties are
- 6:57given a mediation date when they file a request
- 7:00for DVRO, If it's only a DVRO request, it will
- 7:06not be referred to the CCRC pilot. And as noted,
- 7:13the confidential mediation remains as everybody
- 7:17knows it and is familiar with it. Nothing is
- 7:19changing in that. The only thing new is... If
- 7:24in that mediation, they don't reach a full agreement
- 7:27on all issues and it meets the other criteria,
- 7:30so initial custody and parenting order, then
- 7:34it's referred to the CCRC. Now, Judge Kaufman,
- 7:40Judge Doherty, does that mean when you say with
- 7:44no pending DV request, does that mean that if
- 7:46there's a DV request and on the DV 100, I check
- 7:51the box for custody orders? boxes for custody
- 7:55orders, does that mean that it will be referred
- 7:59to the CCRC or because it's part of the DV100
- 8:02it necessarily cannot? The latter. Very good.
- 8:08But that doesn't mean that if an allegation of
- 8:11DV comes up either in the confidential mediation
- 8:14or in the CCRC that it will be taken out of the
- 8:18process, only if there's a DV request pending
- 8:22through a DV100. Okay. So if during the CCRC
- 8:27process, there's a DBA allegation that comes
- 8:31up, that won't terminate the CCRC process. What
- 8:36would happen though if during that process, somebody
- 8:41files for DV? Would there be some mechanism to
- 8:49automatically stop the CCRC or would probably
- 8:52have to? Bring that before the court. It's a
- 8:55good question. Not if the CCRC has been completed
- 8:58and provided to the parties, it won't be that
- 9:01it would now not. But the parties are not precluded
- 9:04in any way from making the appropriate requests
- 9:08of the court that they wish to make. That's kind
- 9:11of one of the things that we want to make clear.
- 9:14There is a provision of the CRC, which is, I
- 9:19believe, 5 .210E6. that talks about suspending
- 9:24a mediation, both confidential and otherwise,
- 9:27if there's allegations of child abuse and neglect,
- 9:30and then there's, you know, because they're mandatory
- 9:32reporters. Next. So what the pilot is not. The
- 9:44pilot does not in any way abdicate the judicial
- 9:47function in custody and parenting time determinations.
- 9:50It is pretty clear. One of the things that I
- 9:53really urge everybody to do is actually read
- 9:55the general order, because there's a lot of perceptions
- 9:58that are If you've just read it, they will already
- 10:01be dispelled, which I think is really important.
- 10:04And then the pilot does not remove the reliance
- 10:06or relevant written and oral evidence that's
- 10:10being presented to a judicial officer by the
- 10:12litigant or an attorney. So your 217 hearing
- 10:16is your 217 hearing. It's not changing. This
- 10:19is just additional information that's gonna be
- 10:21provided in connection with that 217 hearing.
- 10:24I will tell you, we've started this process and
- 10:26I've seen some of the reports that have been
- 10:29prepared. There is information, even when both
- 10:31sides are represented, that is not being provided
- 10:34in the written materials that the parties are
- 10:37presenting that is helpful and useful. Just something
- 10:41simple like how far does parent one live from
- 10:44parent two in terms of distance and traffic time.
- 10:49We're having to explore that sometimes and having
- 10:53that clear just saves time in the context of
- 10:57a hearing. So that basic information is super
- 10:59useful already that we're seeing. Okay, we can
- 11:04go to the next slide. Judge Doherty, just one
- 11:08question on that last slide if we could. I think
- 11:12that there is sort of a concern at the bar that
- 11:18the recommendations are just going to be rubber
- 11:21stamped by the judges and that sure the law can
- 11:24say one thing, but the de facto situation will
- 11:27be sort of a different way. Number one, is the
- 11:33court going to be tracking how often judges are
- 11:37adopting the recommendations of the specialist?
- 11:41Number one and number two, you mentioned, you
- 11:44know, look, we're not doing away with 217 hearings
- 11:48are due process generally, but my understanding
- 11:51is the specialist cannot be cross examined at
- 11:56a 217 hearing. And so what would you say to litigators
- 12:00who might have a concern about that, that the
- 12:04report or the specialist is in some way unaccountable?
- 12:09to the extent that you can. That's about five
- 12:10questions in one, compound objection, speculation.
- 12:16I'll answer some of it. I'll take the rest. I
- 12:20think I remember most of them. Well, first of
- 12:24all, I think that we are sensitive, and we've
- 12:31heard this, to the rubber stamping claim, argument,
- 12:35fear as judicial officers. And I'm not criticizing
- 12:44you for asking the question because it's being
- 12:46asked. But I think that's underestimating what
- 12:52judicial officers in our court do and want to
- 12:57do. People are asking to come to family law because
- 13:02they want to help families. People who didn't
- 13:04ask who got a sign get deeply interested in how
- 13:09they are addressing the public and people and
- 13:13making decisions. I don't think anyone signed
- 13:17up for this job so that they could be a rubber
- 13:21stamper. And so starting with that premise, while
- 13:28the CCRC report and recommendations can be quite
- 13:34a useful tool, I find it I will find it surprising,
- 13:41if not shocking, that a judge is like, okay,
- 13:44boom, stamp, stamp, stamp, because we'd be seeing
- 13:48that happening all the time. Council, what did
- 13:51you say? All right, I'm gonna go with you. We
- 13:54listen to what you and your clients have to say,
- 13:58either in writing or orally, and we're gonna
- 14:00focus in on your biggest and most concerns in
- 14:04the short amount of time that we have. You know,
- 14:09I'm not afraid of the rubber stamping, but to
- 14:11answer your question about the tracking, I don't
- 14:15know that I want to use the word tracking. We're
- 14:17going to line up because what is accepting a
- 14:20recommendation? If the family court services
- 14:24specialist recommends that the exchange be at
- 14:27Starbucks at this location and you agree with
- 14:32that or say I'm going to make that order and
- 14:36other orders or change some of it. you've agreed,
- 14:41and some of it you haven't. So it's a little
- 14:43hard to track, but we are going to be getting
- 14:46feedback from the judicial officers, not only
- 14:48of how they found it helpful, but in their own
- 14:51opinion, you know, were they lined up 100%, were
- 14:55they lined up somewhat, you know, why and why
- 14:57not. So that's the definition of tracking, but
- 15:00I don't know that it's gonna fit into a nice...
- 15:03Excel spreadsheet with charts and numbers because
- 15:06I don't know if it's possible. I mean you can
- 15:08have orders That are three pages long including,
- 15:11you know Christmas Eve versus Christmas Day.
- 15:14That's an order And there could be 19 more orders
- 15:19And now take you answer the rest ones if you
- 15:23remember or Let's take an example where you know,
- 15:27you have a CCRC report And there are seven recommendations.
- 15:34And the bench officer takes the bench and says,
- 15:37do the parties agree to any of these? And both
- 15:40councils stand up and say, we agree to five out
- 15:44of the seven. Is that rubber stamping at that
- 15:47point? Or is that an agreement that's being articulated
- 15:50on the record? If we just tracked do. Are there
- 15:55agreements? So we'd have to then track between
- 15:57contested and non -contested. And again, you
- 16:00know, and rubber stamp is a value judgment. The
- 16:03lawyer that loses is gonna say the court rubber
- 16:05stamped. The lawyer that wins is gonna say my
- 16:08argument prevailed. And so again, the hope is
- 16:13that we will look at this and see, we're gonna
- 16:16try to get information from the bar, the bench,
- 16:20the specialist in terms of are we helping the
- 16:23people we're here to help? And that's really
- 16:25the focus of this. I understand the bar's concerns.
- 16:28I've never been in a recommending county. I've
- 16:33grown up in a non -recommending county. All of
- 16:36our bench officers have, except for the former
- 16:38family law practitioners. And to the extent that
- 16:41there are concerns, again, they might be aware
- 16:45of them through their practice. But the hope
- 16:48is that this is not going to affect your ability
- 16:50to present your case. Hopefully you'll be doing
- 16:53the same job that you've been doing and this
- 16:56will actually add more information that you might
- 16:58not have even had because some of it from what
- 17:01we're seeing is things that the lawyers haven't
- 17:02even presented such as how far you live from
- 17:05each other and other important information. So
- 17:08the hope is that that will be there. The last
- 17:11part of your question when we talk about blindly
- 17:14follow or rubber stamp. It is a bit insulting
- 17:17to not just the bench officer, but to the lawyers
- 17:21to think that your advocacy doesn't mean anything
- 17:24is insulting to think that you're submitting
- 17:27all of this work that you are. You already know
- 17:30that The bench officers are reading everything.
- 17:32They're summarizing it. They're giving it to
- 17:34you. They're showing you that they've considered
- 17:36it. And finally, to the specialist who has a
- 17:40master's degree, yours, as we're going to see,
- 17:43of counseling, you wouldn't say that with respect
- 17:47to a financial expert and say, aren't you just
- 17:50rubber stamping what my forensic thought in that
- 17:55context? So I think that we have to just wait,
- 17:59and we have to really communicate to figure out
- 18:02if the concerns that are being raised are, you
- 18:07know, warranted and then what to do about those
- 18:10when we can. Oh, go ahead. I wanted to add something
- 18:14about, you know, we have to use words. We all
- 18:18use words. We have in here, tear. Some people
- 18:20have a tear system. Some are saying, you know,
- 18:23sometimes I use the word hybrid, but then I think,
- 18:25you know, a hybrid car, and are we really within
- 18:28the definition of hybrid? I want to be careful
- 18:30of terminology, and I know that sometimes when
- 18:35we hear words, they're triggers for certain things.
- 18:38So when we say, are you recommending county,
- 18:40I think a lawyer asked me the other day, are
- 18:43we turning into a recommending county? We've
- 18:47created this pilot to test what we think is a
- 18:52good idea, a two -tier system or two layer, maybe
- 18:57layer is a better word, layer to do both to some.
- 19:02So I'm not ready for us to be saying we're no
- 19:06longer a non -recommending county or we're now,
- 19:09you know, we're non -recommending versus recommending.
- 19:12We've been a complete 100 % non -recommending
- 19:15county. That's clear. We go with that split.
- 19:18I think Judge Doherty, you have a slide that
- 19:20you're going to go over. But it's not to move
- 19:26necessarily to a 100%. We are true believers
- 19:30in the confidential mediation. I think parties
- 19:33need a forum at best to vent with somebody who's
- 19:40listening and can help guide them. And it's hard
- 19:44to imagine that we would move from that if we,
- 19:47as long as we can maintain the resources that
- 19:50we have. So. I just want to be careful that we're
- 19:53not thinking, OK, this pilot is so that we can
- 19:56become 100 % recommended. I know that Susan Thrall,
- 20:00who's head of Family Court Services, the court
- 20:03is very committed to the confidential mediation
- 20:05process. Absolutely. And this slide that we're
- 20:08in kind of tells you how we've gotten here a
- 20:10little bit. So there was a commission on the
- 20:14future of California's court systems that was
- 20:17presented in 2017 to the Chief Justice. And I've
- 20:21given you the page numbers and you can, you know,
- 20:23pull the commission's report and look at that.
- 20:27And basically the idea was that the commission
- 20:30believed that there were the number, the commission
- 20:34actually opined on every discipline of the court.
- 20:39So criminal, civil, probate, dependency, family,
- 20:43the recommendation that it made to the family
- 20:45law division of the court, the larger court for
- 20:50the state of California, was this recommendation
- 20:53that empirical research strongly supported the
- 20:56importance of confidential mediation as a first
- 20:59step, not as an only step as a first step. And
- 21:03second, that to explore through pilots, the effectiveness
- 21:07of tiered mediation to both courts and parties.
- 21:12And in that They cited a Fresno model that was
- 21:16utilized between, I believe, 2012 and 2014 where
- 21:21Fresno received some money and they were able
- 21:23to, they were a recommending county and they
- 21:25were able to institute a multi -tiered mediation
- 21:28model. And, you know, in so doing, Fresno saw
- 21:34their confidential mediation rates rise by a
- 21:38hundred percent effectively from what was happening
- 21:41through their recommending process before. They
- 21:45also saw their wait times for hearings in terms
- 21:48of CCRCs go down very substantially. And so based
- 21:54on that, of everything that the commission explored
- 21:57in family law's future, they said that was what
- 21:59we're putting forward as something to meaningfully
- 22:03consider. It's taken us a while. And again, it's
- 22:06not easy to make even a pilot sometimes with
- 22:10respect to making sure that you have resources.
- 22:12to be able to do so. Our model is not the Fresno
- 22:15model. So if you're saying, well, did we adopt
- 22:18the Fresno model? We have not adopted the Fresno
- 22:20model. Because in the Fresno model, you'd have
- 22:24to go to a judicial officer after the confidential
- 22:27mediation to see if a CCRC was recommended. And
- 22:31then there was a recommending and referral process
- 22:34specific to that. We've tried to implement it
- 22:38since we're doing this pilot in a way that it
- 22:41automatically goes from one tier or from one
- 22:44layer to the next. And that will allow us to
- 22:48allow most of the folks that are going through
- 22:51this process to have a second opportunity, two
- 22:56opportunities before they get to court. And in
- 22:59the context of the number of self -represented
- 23:01litigants that we service, which is almost as
- 23:05high as 80 % in the context of one or both, this
- 23:11allows them to be heard more than they otherwise
- 23:15would be through these two processes, one completely
- 23:18confidential and one with still confidential,
- 23:22but a recommendation that will be shared between
- 23:24the parties and the court, still confidential
- 23:26from the public. So that's kind of what the impetus
- 23:31was to get us to try something based on the commission's
- 23:34recommendation. We can go to the next slide.
- 23:39And so why now? You know, because You know, we're
- 23:44always gonna be in budget crunches and difficult
- 23:48situations. This allows for us to try to retool
- 23:52our resources that is gonna give us the opportunity
- 23:56to explore what the commission believed was the
- 24:00future for family law in California. greater
- 24:04access to justice. We're always focused on that
- 24:06in terms of litigants feeling and being heard,
- 24:09you know, by the court system in terms of custody
- 24:13determinations. And obviously we want to effectively
- 24:16utilize our resources in a way that allows for
- 24:21the maximum ability for families to get an opportunity
- 24:27to have their information presented to the court.
- 24:31What are the anticipated benefits? Obviously,
- 24:35paramount is the promoting of the best interests
- 24:38of the children. We want to encourage cooperative
- 24:41parenting, reduce the impact of prolonged litigation
- 24:45on children, improve judicial efficacy in initial
- 24:49custody orders. And again, one of the big differences
- 24:52between us and Fresno is that this is only applying
- 24:55in our county with respect to the pilot to temporary
- 24:59orders. It is not applying to final orders or
- 25:03even a secondary temporary order in that context.
- 25:06So initial orders and then to evaluate the system
- 25:10to see if there are benefits that we've potentially
- 25:13been missing out on in having a multi -tiered
- 25:16system as opposed to just a purely non -recommending
- 25:19system. So we can go to the next slide. Thank
- 25:23you. So this is a map of how the counties are
- 25:26broken down. So there are 30 counties that are
- 25:29purely recommending counties. There are 20 counties
- 25:32that are purely non recommending counties out
- 25:35of California is 58. And then there's eight that
- 25:38have some sort of a hybrid model. And, you know,
- 25:42you can kind of get a sense of A lot of the hybrid
- 25:46model counties are small counties. When Fresno
- 25:49ran its program with respect to what the commission
- 25:54based its recommendation on, Fresno is the 10th
- 25:59largest county in California. It has a million
- 26:01people. We're 10 times larger. Fresno had six
- 26:05bench officers. in terms of home courts has 20.
- 26:10So we're three times larger than their sample
- 26:12size in this context. That allows us to get a
- 26:15lot of information to be able to see if the recommendation
- 26:20that the commission made is going to be being
- 26:24able to be able to sized into a county as large
- 26:28as Los Angeles. So it's really kind of gives
- 26:30you a sense. If you look at some of the other
- 26:32multi -tiered counties, they're much smaller.
- 26:36So again, this will be really important for information
- 26:39for the court to see what the commission thought
- 26:42was the future of family law. Next slide, please.
- 26:48All right. So I know that out there in the universe,
- 26:51when this all came out, some of the questions
- 26:53asked, like, you know, well, who's doing these
- 26:55CCRCs and, you know, why are they qualified?
- 26:59And and we're just redirecting you to the code
- 27:03sections. I'm not going to. read them off to
- 27:05you. But this is sort of the same speech I give
- 27:09to litigants when I order them to mediation.
- 27:12They haven't been. And I explain to them that
- 27:14it's an amazing resource that the court provides
- 27:18at no cost to them to meet with someone who,
- 27:22of course, is not a judge, nor is that person
- 27:25a lawyer. They have a master's degree. That's
- 27:28the minimal education requirement in a behavioral
- 27:31science substantially related to marriage and
- 27:34family relationships. They have to have at least
- 27:36three years of experience in counseling or psychotherapy
- 27:39or both. The recruiting for these positions is
- 27:44tough. I mean, it's not only is it competitive,
- 27:52but how they're I mean, I'm not part of the selection
- 27:56process, but I know that it's very rigorous in
- 27:59terms of who's coming. They have to have experience
- 28:02with the court. They have to have knowledge of
- 28:06child development. They're trained in child abuse
- 28:09and clinical issues relating to children. I mean,
- 28:13their whole focus is on children. And that's
- 28:17why... And they're trained in DV, as described
- 28:22in section 1816. They're mandated reporters if
- 28:26something comes up in the hearing. And they're
- 28:29mandated to have additional regular continued
- 28:32training. They're highly qualified. That's why
- 28:36in so many ways I find this such an exciting
- 28:38program is our community, your clients, our litigants,
- 28:44our community, are now going to be able to, if
- 28:47they didn't resolve it at the confidential mediation,
- 28:50are not only going to talk to one person in this
- 28:53pilot, but two people. And getting the benefit
- 28:58of this kind of expertise in this one on one
- 29:05or three, you know, one on two. situation. So
- 29:12they're meeting with people who know what they're
- 29:14talking about and have a lot of information.
- 29:17And their only focus is on children. It's it's
- 29:20not, you know, on and family. So, you know, parents
- 29:24have to want to buy into things. But their focus
- 29:28is what's best for these kids in this situation,
- 29:32dealing with and then we as judges dealing, you
- 29:36know, take all the information we have and make
- 29:38those orders. But we're dealing with so many
- 29:41things in this big, huge county. And I know Judge
- 29:45Doherty keeps referencing, but I think it's such
- 29:47a great one. How far apart do the people live?
- 29:50I mean, this city geographically has its own
- 29:52challenge. People have work schedules that cause
- 29:56so many challenges, especially when they don't
- 29:59have a set work schedule. So how do you make
- 30:01a custody order when people work? Two days on,
- 30:06two days off. They're not the same two days.
- 30:08Sometimes they're at night. Sometimes they're
- 30:10a split schedule. There's so many things that
- 30:13go into this. All right, next slide. So what
- 30:20is in the general order? And this is, I'm not
- 30:22going through the details of the general order.
- 30:24I'm just kind of giving you an overview. It tells
- 30:26you the purpose. The preservation of judicial
- 30:29authority is very clearly laid out in there in
- 30:32terms of the judges are not giving up anything
- 30:36with respect to the CCRC report and recommendation.
- 30:41The applicability, the implementation, the effective
- 30:44date, the structure of multi -tiered mediation,
- 30:49when and which cases the CCRC applies to, that
- 30:53there is a separate mediator from the confidential
- 30:56mediation, that we currently have that is non
- 30:59-recommending to the recommending mediator. They're
- 31:02two separate individuals with the same qualifications.
- 31:07The separate mediator has, there's different
- 31:12confidentiality considerations with respect to
- 31:15the confidential mediation. Even the CCRC, as
- 31:19I mentioned before, even though that report and
- 31:22recommendation is not confidential to the parties,
- 31:26the court, the lawyers and anyone else that is
- 31:30within the scope of Family Code Section 3025
- 31:34.5. It is confidential from the public. It will
- 31:38still be a locked document in that, but you will
- 31:40have access to it. It tells you when the report
- 31:44will be revealed to the parties and to counsel
- 31:48and also the mechanism for which and how to object
- 31:52and the timeliness of objections. If any collateral
- 31:58sources or investigation to be conducted with
- 32:02respect to getting authorizations and all of
- 32:06that is outlined in there. And then if you want
- 32:09the testimony of the specialist exactly how to
- 32:12go about doing that as well. So it's all laid
- 32:15out in there. So I really urge everyone to read
- 32:18the general order. If we could have the next
- 32:21slide, please. What's involved in the CCR process?
- 32:27The time allotted by the family court service
- 32:30specialist is approximately four hours. And the
- 32:35time with the parents is about two hours. And
- 32:39I'm asking your question for you, because it
- 32:41was part of the list, Ryan, so I'm kind of pulling
- 32:44it from you. But there was a question whether
- 32:46it was actually going to be like a time clock.
- 32:49Do they each get an hour? Do they each get 45
- 32:51minutes? There is no clock. ticking, but this
- 32:55is general framework. They have about, you know,
- 32:59an hour with each parent and that's going to
- 33:02change. You know, maybe one parent kind of says
- 33:05what they need to say and all the questions are
- 33:08asked and they finish in 35 minutes and the other
- 33:10parent, you know, takes time to warm up. I mean,
- 33:13it's not an exact science, but the time frame
- 33:18is about an hour with each parent, two hours
- 33:20with the parents, and then they need time to
- 33:22just kind of you know, get all the pleadings
- 33:25together that they've had, look at that, and
- 33:27then actually prepare the report and recommendation.
- 33:30Important to know, it is not an evaluation or
- 33:34an assessment. Now, again, these are buzzwords
- 33:36and trigger words. Probably going to hear even
- 33:40Judge Doherty and I make the mistake and call
- 33:42it an evaluation or an assessment, and it's really
- 33:45not. The Family Court Services Specialist and
- 33:48their training have different tools and training
- 33:52that they use when they make evaluations and
- 33:54assessments and things that they and protocols
- 33:58they follow for evaluations and assessment. So
- 34:01they should be very clear about saying this is
- 34:04a recommendation based on the information I had
- 34:07in the time I lauded. If we, any judicial officers
- 34:11slip into the mistake of calling it an evaluation
- 34:13or assessment, this is the caveat. It is not.
- 34:17And that's not what they're doing. They're preparing
- 34:19a report and recommendation based on the time
- 34:21they had with the parties and the information
- 34:24they received in person and on paper from the
- 34:27parties in their filings. Go to the next slide.
- 34:33So what's going to be in the R &R is not relaxing
- 34:37recreation in that context. It is here as report
- 34:43and recommendation. And I kind of want to give
- 34:46you a bench officer's take on some of this as
- 34:49well. The basic history of the parent's relationship,
- 34:52we generally get that when people are represented.
- 34:55Household routines, work schedules, distance
- 34:57between homes, not always even when people are
- 35:00represented. Current parenting time arrangements,
- 35:03generally we'll get that in both represented
- 35:06and unrepresented. General concerns each parent
- 35:10wants to address. Most of the time we'll get
- 35:12that when parties are represented, not always.
- 35:16Sometimes we get a four page, you know, FL 300
- 35:18with a paragraph as to the basis for why someone's
- 35:22seeking the orders that they're seeking when
- 35:24they're not represented. So this really allows
- 35:26for a fair amount of information, any safety
- 35:29concerns identified by the parties, the children's
- 35:33needs in terms of age, school, special considerations,
- 35:37background information. only as relevant with
- 35:40proper authorization. So that goes to a little
- 35:43bit of the collateral information that the FCS
- 35:47specialist may be able to seek in certain cases.
- 35:51They have discretion under the general order
- 35:53as to whether to do that or not, but that discretion
- 35:56is still wedded to the time that they have in
- 35:58terms of the two hours with the parties and four
- 36:01hours with respect to the report being completed.
- 36:04and then any documents or collateral information
- 36:07the parents choose to provide. Many of you, when
- 36:12you're filing your initial custody request RFO,
- 36:16there might be things that the other side objects
- 36:18to, as hearsay and other things, and that will
- 36:21be made available, but the FCS specialist will
- 36:26review it, and again, they're not blindly accepting
- 36:29that either, but that is something that will
- 36:32be before them. in this context. If they're going
- 36:35to do their own investigation, or if they are
- 36:39seeking the ability to do so or interview someone,
- 36:43then they're seeking authorization from the parties
- 36:46in that context. So, Your Honor, so my understanding
- 36:52is the specialist has to, just as you said, the
- 36:56specialist has to get the party's written authorization
- 36:59to consider collateral source material, but what
- 37:02if the specialist only has one party's consent
- 37:06and not the other, how? Then they're not getting
- 37:10it. Yeah. They're not getting it. Yeah. To the
- 37:14extent that the parties do give their authorization
- 37:19to the specialist, how is it flagged within the
- 37:22report, if at all, that collateral information
- 37:26is being relied upon? There's a section of it
- 37:30that indicates that. So that's a really good
- 37:32question. when you get your first report, you'll
- 37:35be, oh, OK. So it's pretty laid out clearly as
- 37:39to what is from the parties and what is not.
- 37:42And then the outcome is a short summary of the
- 37:46information that the parties shared, summarized,
- 37:49and recommendations to support the mediation
- 37:53and assist the court. Again, our pilot is designed
- 37:57not for final orders. It's designed for initial
- 38:01orders. So that time is short, the information
- 38:05is what is going to be most helpful in the court
- 38:09having the information that it needs, that it
- 38:11may have or it may not have in some cases to
- 38:15be able to make those decisions. If we can go
- 38:18to the next slide. All right. Before you do that,
- 38:20OK. So somehow today I'm focused in on words
- 38:25and phraseology and in not getting locked in.
- 38:28So we put here recommendations to support mediation.
- 38:32Family Code Section 3183 refers to the Family
- 38:36Court Services Specialist who's conducting a
- 38:38CCRC as a mediator. And sometimes it uses the
- 38:41word mediation. I just want everyone to be clear.
- 38:46So you're gonna hear us sort of say that too,
- 38:49mediation. The confidential mediation as everyone
- 38:52already knows it is the same. So. however you
- 38:56know it or don't know it for that matter, and
- 38:59we can do another seminar on what's involved
- 39:00in confidential mediation, hasn't changed, isn't
- 39:04changing. The CCRC is new and it isn't technically
- 39:12how I think of and maybe you think of as a mediation,
- 39:16like what do you think about this, what do you
- 39:17think about that, what do you think about this.
- 39:19It is ending in a report and a recommendation.
- 39:22It is hard for me to imagine that the family
- 39:25court service specialist might not mention on
- 39:28something that seems obvious to that specialist,
- 39:31you know, parent A, what do you think about meeting
- 39:34at Starbucks as opposed to meeting at, you know,
- 39:38the police station? And, okay, I don't mind.
- 39:42So that's probably why sometimes the word mediations
- 39:46used where there'll be some things that come
- 39:49up that feel mediated. But your honor, I do think
- 39:53it is confusing that the use of the word mediator
- 39:57in those code sections. And I think the distinction
- 40:00we're drawing is between evidence code section
- 40:031119 confidentiality, which is absolute and something
- 40:08I think very different, maybe tier one on the,
- 40:11if we're going to refer to the tiers, that would
- 40:14fall under 1119. But this is also confidential,
- 40:17but not under 1119. it's privileged under 1040
- 40:21official records, so the public can't subpoena
- 40:25it, but it doesn't have that same level of 1119
- 40:30confidentiality. Am I getting that totally straight?
- 40:33Yes. That's why I just wanted to, because somebody
- 40:35is going to walk away and say mediation, but
- 40:38I wanted to point it out. It is a word that shows
- 40:40up in 3183, but I just wanted to point out that
- 40:43distinction. You know, just to add to that, a
- 40:47lot of what we're discussing now, there was a
- 40:50public comment period for the commission's submission
- 40:55to the chief justice. So almost all of what we're
- 40:59discussing, when you go to those pages that I
- 41:00cited in the commission's report, were considered
- 41:03by the commission when they made the recommendation.
- 41:06There was nothing meaningfully new that I've
- 41:09seen in terms of what I've heard that was not
- 41:12raised in 2017. The bar was vocal and did express
- 41:17its concerns, and yet the commission, which included
- 41:20Supreme Court justices from California on it,
- 41:24made the recommendation based on the information
- 41:27that they reviewed after the public comment period.
- 41:30So if we can go to the next slide, yeah. So some
- 41:32of you may be asking, am I going to get the PowerPoint?
- 41:36And we think mostly the PowerPoint is demonstrative,
- 41:39but maybe this slide has more information than
- 41:41just being demonstrative, because I'm not going
- 41:43to read the whole slide. And we will make available
- 41:46by the end of the week. Not today, but at the
- 41:49end of the week. So this just sets forth, and
- 41:54just in an interest of time, which I'm noting,
- 41:57kind of we did a chart for you of sort of comparisons
- 42:01of what's available by the court, how long, what's
- 42:05involved. And this will be something that's a
- 42:08little bit more than demonstrative, but it lays
- 42:13out what's confidential, what part isn't confidential,
- 42:18such as in the CCRC, the parties and their counsel.
- 42:22will receive the report and recommendation, but
- 42:26in a minute we'll show you how it's, well, one,
- 42:28it's going to be a locked document, so it's not
- 42:32open to the public. And that is part of our general
- 42:35order that's identifying that, even if it's in
- 42:39a disokase, of course, it's a public document.
- 42:42So I don't think I'm going to go through this
- 42:44one by one. So, Jordi, if there's somebody specific.
- 42:46No, I don't think anything on this slide. I think
- 42:48this slide will be helpful. to practitioners
- 42:51when we've made it available so that they can
- 42:53just have it as a quick reference. But Ryan,
- 42:56on your point earlier with respect to what is
- 43:00protected and what is not, the general order
- 43:03covers all those things, like you said, with
- 43:04respect to 1040 and everything else to try to
- 43:07give you all of that in one place. If you could
- 43:09please go to the next slide. Wait, wait, wait.
- 43:11Let me just, sorry. Child interview. I just saw
- 43:14that and wanted to maybe focus on that for a
- 43:17minute. So as everyone knows, I'm sure that's
- 43:19listening, that the child is not interviewed
- 43:22during a confidential mediation. In fact, we're
- 43:24very specific about, say, make sure your kid's
- 43:27not at home when we're doing this mediation.
- 43:29In the CCRC, I do not anticipate that the child
- 43:34will be interviewed very often, but it could
- 43:39happen, and it would be as needed at the discretion
- 43:42of the Family Court Services Specialist with
- 43:44consent and waivers. Logistically, it's complicated
- 43:48because you wouldn't know that was necessary
- 43:51probably until you're interviewing the parties
- 43:54and then you might not be able to logistically
- 43:56get the child involved. I'm not going to create
- 44:00hypotheticals that I don't have in front of me,
- 44:03but that is not the goal is to start interviewing
- 44:08kids ad hoc off, you know, it just, you know,
- 44:13It's going to happen infrequently, but it could
- 44:15happen. The parties have to consent to that jointly.
- 44:19A PPA is different, as you all know. The child
- 44:22is interviewed, not only are they interviewed,
- 44:24they're interviewed with each of the parents,
- 44:26and that's a requirement for the PPA to have
- 44:30the child interviewed in person with the parent,
- 44:33with the family court services specialist. And
- 44:36then, of course, this has nothing to do with
- 44:38just a child interview that's ordered separate
- 44:41and apart. and the Family Court Services Specialist
- 44:45interviews only the child and comes into court,
- 44:47and that process is still there and isn't changing.
- 44:52Okay. Next. Judge Kaufman, briefly, Family Court
- 44:55Section 3182 says that the mediator may exclude
- 45:00counsel. Okay. Is it the case that as we roll
- 45:04out this pilot program, counsel will necessarily
- 45:07be excluded from all CCRC processes, or is that
- 45:12a... up to the discretion of the mediator. How
- 45:15is that going to happen? Well, the code section
- 45:17requires that it's up to the discretion of the
- 45:20Family Court Services Specialist for mediations
- 45:22and then for CCRCs as well. And the director,
- 45:27Susan Thrall, has messaged to her specialist
- 45:34that as a reminder that 3182 is a discretion.
- 45:39There's no obligated, there's no policy saying
- 45:42automatically they're excluded. I mean, I think
- 45:45you all have the experience that you don't participate
- 45:48in confidential mediations. And I think logistically,
- 45:52it is not going to happen very often because
- 45:55of, you know, these are done remotely, don't
- 45:57forget. It's not that the court wants to exclude
- 46:01counsel. There might be a reason that counsel
- 46:04need to log in quickly and say something, but
- 46:07the Family court service specialist wants to
- 46:10conduct the process in the best interest of the
- 46:12child and make the process the most effective
- 46:18to gather as much data as possible and an opportunity
- 46:22to allow these parties to speak and give the
- 46:25pertinent information that they need to give.
- 46:29And often even in court, I'll ask a question
- 46:32and the lawyer will say, I'll just have my client
- 46:35answer directly because the client has the more
- 46:37detailed information. So 3182 is in full force
- 46:42in effect and will be followed. On this slide
- 46:46with respect to collateral contacts, I think
- 46:48we've covered everything already. It's not required.
- 46:51It's going to be rarely occurring. And with authorization,
- 46:57again, you know, there'd be very limited situations
- 47:00for children to be interviewed. And we talked
- 47:03about the CCR, I'm sorry, the California rule
- 47:08of court that talks about if there's child abuse
- 47:12or neglect in the context of a mediation to suspend
- 47:15it as being CRC 5 .210 E6, I believe. Technically,
- 47:24it would be very surprising unless something
- 47:27happened between the mediation and the CCRC,
- 47:31that child abuse or neglect would be would be
- 47:36set up mentioned in one and would have happened
- 47:38in the mediation. So it's already going to be
- 47:40suspended. And now it's not going to go forward
- 47:42to a CCRC. But, you know, I guess something could
- 47:45happen in that 10 day span. And it would come
- 47:48up in the CCRC and its California rule of court.
- 47:51Exactly. Next slide, please. So the objections
- 47:57and subpoenaing of the specialist, I know there's
- 47:59been a lot of discussion on that. So it will
- 48:02provide you that information. So once the report
- 48:05and recommendation are made available to council
- 48:08and the parties, that's gonna be at least a 10
- 48:11day. calendar day in advance of the hearing date.
- 48:15And then generally, it's going to be via email
- 48:18to the litigants and the attorneys of record.
- 48:21If you're not an attorney of record, it's not
- 48:23necessarily going to come to you if you're going
- 48:26to be appearing in a limited scope or otherwise.
- 48:28So it's really important that you communicate
- 48:31with your client if you're not attorney of record
- 48:33in terms of being able to get this. Can I just
- 48:36throw one thing in as a practice tip here? If
- 48:41you come in in the case in the beginning, then
- 48:43you'll already have your email there. But if
- 48:46you come in later, you want to make sure that
- 48:48your client gets the email. it gets the email
- 48:53to family court services so that they get it
- 48:55by email, not by mail. If we don't have the email,
- 48:59we don't have the email. And the only way we
- 49:00get the email is if you or your clients provide
- 49:03the email. I'll tell you right now, because I
- 49:05communicate by email with counsel all the time
- 49:07for settlement conferences and other things.
- 49:09And I'm forever going on the attorney California
- 49:12State Bar website to get the email, because many
- 49:15of you don't put your email on your pleadings.
- 49:17For this process, I think it's an important practice
- 49:21to make sure that email is available for the
- 49:24fastest receipt of information. Exactly. And
- 49:27also, we're going to have a cover sheet on the
- 49:30front page of the report. I'm going to show that
- 49:32to you in the next slide with respect to having
- 49:37what it's going to look like. So when the report
- 49:40comes to you, this is what the first page is
- 49:43going to be in terms of who has access to it.
- 49:45what the confidentiality provisions are, what
- 49:50you can't share, making it very clear with family
- 49:53code section 3025 .5 and 3177 up there, and then
- 49:58the prospect of monetary sanctions for being,
- 50:00you know, for reproducing or divulging the information
- 50:04in the report so that anyone receiving this is
- 50:07gonna have that on, you know, the very first
- 50:09page of it. If we can go to the next slide. So
- 50:13we created another form, just what everyone loves,
- 50:15forms, forms, forms in family law. But I think
- 50:17this is a good one. And Ryan, when you asked
- 50:21about pilots, maybe as we go along, something
- 50:24will need to be adjusted with the form. That's
- 50:26what makes part of it a pilot. We created one
- 50:30simple form to protect that confidentiality,
- 50:33so there's no mistakes with the clerk's office
- 50:36and no mistakes by you or parties. All you have
- 50:39to do is check the box and attach what you need
- 50:44to attach your objections, your statements, your
- 50:48comments, whatever you want to this form. And
- 50:50this form is what goes into the system in your
- 50:53e -filing that automatically locks it. What we
- 50:57see is literally a lock on our system and keeps
- 51:00it out of the public view. I think it's designed
- 51:03to be very simple. So there's no question of
- 51:06filing under seal and getting a motion and did
- 51:09it e -file correct? You attach what you need
- 51:11to attach to this form, and if all things are
- 51:14working right, we're in the confidential lockbox.
- 51:19Yeah, and so for both lawyers and self -represented
- 51:22litigants This is going to be really helpful
- 51:24because you're not gonna have to go through a
- 51:25number of hoops to be able to get it to the court
- 51:28with respect to objections or even if you're
- 51:31in agreement to be able to reference the report
- 51:33in a You know publicly protected Forum in that
- 51:39look for example Let's say you're to counsel
- 51:42and you both look to the report you do that wonderful
- 51:44thing that we love in a door called meet and
- 51:46confer and you say hey, you know What do you
- 51:49think? And then you realize there's really two
- 51:51points that you're, you know, bothered about,
- 51:54and you really want to argue that vociferously.
- 51:56And then you could check the box other, attach
- 52:00a joint, whether it's a stipulation or just a
- 52:03joint statement that says, this is what we're
- 52:06going to focus in on. Everything else seems like
- 52:09a good idea. We like the I'm not trying to plug
- 52:11Starbucks. I'll switch it to, I don't know, Pete's
- 52:14coffee. And we want to we want to meet at Pete's
- 52:17coffee. And we like that, but this is what we
- 52:20want to focus on. You attach, you check other,
- 52:23you attach your comments, and you're in the lock
- 52:25situation. Next slide. And Judge Kaufman and
- 52:31Judge Rory, to my earlier question about due
- 52:34process, I mean, you know, I know a number of
- 52:38attorneys have expressed those sorts of concerns
- 52:41maybe based on what they've heard about other
- 52:44counties. But it sounds like we've got processes
- 52:46for making evidentiary objections that we're
- 52:49not creating exceptions to the evidence code,
- 52:52you know, for these programs that, you know,
- 52:55hearsay is still hearsay and all those rules
- 52:59apply and the specialist can in fact be subpoenaed.
- 53:02That's right. I mean, we were very conscious.
- 53:05We actually looked at the local rules of recommending
- 53:10and hybrid or multi -tiered counties to see,
- 53:14and that's why we structured it the way we have.
- 53:16We went through a very rigorous process with
- 53:19respect to due process to make sure that we were
- 53:23feeling comfortable with respect to the ability
- 53:25to have a full 217 hearing with the evidence
- 53:29code and everything else being applicable, including
- 53:32the right to cross -examine if it was needed.
- 53:37Briefly on subpoenaing, I noted in the general
- 53:40order there's a specific provision for in -camera
- 53:42review of documents that are subpoenaed from
- 53:47the specialist. Do we have a sense of how that
- 53:51process will go down? So if I issue a deposition
- 53:53subpoena for business records and I serve it
- 53:56on counsel at the court, do we have a sense of
- 54:01how that process will go down in terms of in
- 54:04-camera review? Will both counsel be summoned?
- 54:07down to a chamber somewhere at Stanley Mosque
- 54:10to review documents before they're produced or?
- 54:12In Judge Doherty's courtroom or in general? Because
- 54:16we're all individually appointed or independently
- 54:20appointed or elected constitutional officers.
- 54:27So how that is done in each courtroom Again,
- 54:30the judicial officer has full authority. I can
- 54:33tell you how it would be done in my courtroom
- 54:34if that happened. But again, the idea is that
- 54:38we haven't made that process so formalistic so
- 54:45that lawyers actually have the ability to have
- 54:47a say in the process too. But we've outlined
- 54:49that there is the potential for that process
- 54:54when it becomes necessary. Can we go to the next
- 54:57slide? Because I'm going to tie it into your
- 54:59question to some degree. OK, so this is exactly
- 55:02on the slide what the court's expectation with
- 55:04the pilot is. But well, maybe more agreements
- 55:08between parties, especially in confidential mediations,
- 55:11and maybe more agreements even after the report
- 55:13and recommendation is submitted, more opportunities
- 55:17for litigants to be heard, more opportunities
- 55:19for co -parenting and reducing litigation, and
- 55:22more information for judicial officers to consider.
- 55:26I'm saying all those things to answer your question
- 55:29to some degree. Again, focusing that these are
- 55:32initial orders. And I know some lawyers who say,
- 55:35well, initial orders, that's what takes the case
- 55:38forever and always in the rest of this child's
- 55:41life, which I'm not sure that I agree with that
- 55:44premise. But I don't know how much you're going
- 55:49to really need. Your good lawyers, litigants
- 55:53are able to speak for themselves about what their
- 55:57needs are. I think this is going to help self
- 55:59-represented litigants focus a little bit better.
- 56:03Lawyers even focus better. Where are the real
- 56:07differences between these parties? What are the
- 56:09big issues besides I'm upset, I'm angry, I'm
- 56:13hurt? Is it where we have the exchange location?
- 56:18Is it two nights in a row versus three nights
- 56:21in a row? Is it overnights at all? I don't really
- 56:27believe that the concept of having to bring in
- 56:32the person who wrote the recommendation is really
- 56:35critical, because you can advocate and say, this
- 56:38doesn't make sense. This is what we want, and
- 56:42this is why. You don't even have to argue against
- 56:44the report. You can say, this is what we want,
- 56:46and this is why. And that's the same opportunity
- 56:49you've had already. Next slide. We've got about
- 56:55two minutes. So let's get through. So there's
- 56:58no specific duration that has been set for the
- 57:01pilot. We just need to make sure we have adequate
- 57:04information so that we can then make wise decisions
- 57:09going forward. And obviously, that's the hope.
- 57:13We didn't want to restrict it because we didn't
- 57:15know exactly how many cases. We can project,
- 57:18but until we have them, and as you can also see,
- 57:22that it might take 60 days or 40 days between
- 57:27the filing and the hearing. And therefore, we
- 57:30may not start getting data for 45 days out, theoretically.
- 57:35So we just want to make sure we have sufficient
- 57:38data that we can make our information from bench
- 57:42officers, lawyers, specialists, litigants to
- 57:45be able to consider what we've learned. And then
- 57:50the next slide. So we are anticipating to continue
- 57:55dialogue with the bar bar leaders About how you
- 58:00know anecdotal feedback? Statistically, it's
- 58:04gonna we're gonna be keeping some statistics,
- 58:06but statistically it's a little hard to keep
- 58:09that but yes, the short answer is we will be
- 58:12meeting with bar leaders and Seeing, you know
- 58:16not just scrap it or keep it but you know What
- 58:21are the pitfalls? What aren't the pitfalls? What
- 58:23are the advantages? What are the disadvantages?
- 58:25We do value your input and we will continue to
- 58:28have, this isn't exactly a dialogue, we had some
- 58:31dialogue with Ryan beforehand, but we will continue
- 58:35to have dialogue with the bar leaders and then
- 58:37presentations as you see right now. So we thank
- 58:42you. Last slide is just a thank you slide. And
- 58:46I think we're on the buzzer. Thank you for attending.
- 58:48And I think it's bad. Judge Doherty and I are
- 58:52open to have discussions and comments, but we
- 58:55will do most of our meetings with our leaders,
- 58:59as that just seems like an organized fashion.
- 59:03Thank you, everyone. Well, Judge Doherty, Judge
- 59:05Kaufman, on behalf of the HBA, we thank you so
- 59:09much for your time today. This is a very significant
- 59:15development, obviously, for the Superior Court
- 59:18and the bar. And we look forward to further discussions
- 59:27and developments as things progress. And thanks,
- 59:32everybody, for attending this afternoon. And
- 59:35we'll see you next time. See you on Wednesday.
- 59:40Yes. That's right. Thank you for running the
- 59:43PowerPoint. We so appreciate that. All right,
- 59:46bye. The State of Department 215.