Latest / Surrounded / Is Dave Rubin Living in Reality? Surrounded Follow-Up
Transcript
- 0:00OK,
- 0:00OK,
- 0:00I'm here with Kyla.
- 0:02Welcome to the surrounded follow up and thank you for being in surrounded with Dave.
- 0:07Yeah,
- 0:08thanks for hosting me and thanks for inviting me on.
- 0:09I really appreciate it,
- 0:10John.
- 0:10Of course,
- 0:11yeah,
- 0:11I know you are also in the political content space.
- 0:15Um,
- 0:15for somebody who's maybe not familiar with you,
- 0:17what would you describe as kind of your general position or
- 0:20or your mission as a political actor in these interesting times.
- 0:26Compass that came out which is always fun to do and I
- 0:28took it it's pretty accurate and I got I got progressive realist
- 0:32so I'm not quite staunch real politic if anyone knows like that philosophy,
- 0:37but I'm very pragmatic.
- 0:39I really,
- 0:40really,
- 0:40really want to see marked changes and improvements in people's lives
- 0:44and then I'm progressive by nature and then I'm
- 0:46generally left oriented probably because of my personality so
- 0:49those are probably the closest labels that you could give me.
- 0:52Um,
- 0:52you've probably,
- 0:53if you've seen me anywhere,
- 0:54would be debating feminism,
- 0:56gender issues,
- 0:57philosophy,
- 0:58religion sometimes,
- 0:59and then of course,
- 1:00politics,
- 1:01but I'm personally interested in like philosophy and stuff like that.
- 1:04Nice.
- 1:05Yeah,
- 1:05I think there's a clip.
- 1:07There's some clips going around with you debating Myron,
- 1:10who
- 1:10we all love.
- 1:13I'm just obviously being a little sarcastic,
- 1:17but yeah,
- 1:17he's been on
- 1:19I like debating Bron.
- 1:19He's like one of these weird ones that's like honest like
- 1:22when you debate people
- 1:24and they don't truly believe what they're saying,
- 1:26it's kind of like a bit
- 1:27it's actually harder because they can
- 1:30be more sneaky and they move between positions more.
- 1:33Fluidly
- 1:34Myron,
- 1:35like
- 1:35for all the problems with Myron,
- 1:37he really believes what he says and so as a result
- 1:40of it he's kind of like honest and consistent and so it's
- 1:43refreshing in that like when I pin him on ideas he'll basically go,
- 1:47I mean you got me there,
- 1:49which happens very rarely so it's weird to be like,
- 1:51man,
- 1:51I really appreciate that raging misogynist for being.
- 1:54Honest about his misogyny,
- 1:56I suppose,
- 1:56but
- 1:57that's where we're at with political discourse,
- 1:58it seems right now.
- 1:59OK,
- 2:00well,
- 2:00Myron aside,
- 2:01uh,
- 2:01you were in our surrounded episode with Dave Rubin.
- 2:04What were your takeaways after being in there?
- 2:06I feel like I got a little cranky on set.
- 2:08I might have been sleep deprived,
- 2:10but it
- 2:11I think I was frustrated because people were
- 2:14of all the episodes I've seen,
- 2:16it was really hard to follow the debates with him.
- 2:20Does it seem that way to you?
- 2:21Yeah,
- 2:21Jubilee is an odd platform because it feels like a lot
- 2:25of people go prepped with talking points they want to get out
- 2:28and less so
- 2:30I like they don't want to engage necessarily with the prompt.
- 2:32And so I think some people like they wanted to tie it back into the prompt.
- 2:35It was just taking a long time,
- 2:36which I think is tough again in this modality where you
- 2:39kind of have to get out what you want to say.
- 2:41And bring it back to the point really quickly within like 5 minutes,
- 2:45which is a really high pressure situation.
- 2:47But yet,
- 2:47I think the format just makes for those more nuanced
- 2:52conversations tough and so I think as a result,
- 2:53a lot of people go,
- 2:54well,
- 2:54I don't want to go up there and look stupid and not
- 2:56push back on somebody that my political side thinks is bad.
- 3:00So
- 3:00I need to make sure I get
- 3:02a Duncan or something that kind of trips him up or a point that proves him wrong.
- 3:08That actually,
- 3:09that feels like an accurate assessment of maybe what I was feeling.
- 3:12It felt like,
- 3:14I mean,
- 3:14Dave Rubin is a very interesting character,
- 3:16would obviously love to have him here on the follow up whenever he has time.
- 3:20But um,
- 3:21he,
- 3:21you know,
- 3:21his background's in intellectual dark web,
- 3:24which was more of a maybe left coded group.
- 3:27And then he kind of had a schism with some of those people like Sam Harris.
- 3:32And as he sort of voiced support for Trump.
- 3:34Trump,
- 3:34people became more and more critical of him and then he became more and more tied to,
- 3:38I guess,
- 3:39MAGA and
- 3:41right wing culture,
- 3:42but he's a little bit more heterodox.
- 3:44I guess that that's my read on him.
- 3:46Yeah,
- 3:47I mean,
- 3:47I don't know him super well.
- 3:48I don't watch a ton of Dave Rubin content personally.
- 3:51So I couldn't really comment much there.
- 3:53I just engaging with him as well.
- 3:55It wasn't obvious to me how honest of an interlocutor he was either.
- 4:00Yeah,
- 4:01and when I say honest,
- 4:02I mean,
- 4:03I'm not sure how much of what he says publicly is actually his
- 4:07genuinely held belief at the core of him.
- 4:10And
- 4:10just so it's clear,
- 4:11that's not like an indictment of just Dave.
- 4:12I think this is actually the case of a lot of people
- 4:14in this space.
- 4:15There's a lot of pressure to make sure that your audience is
- 4:18happy and your audience mostly wants to hear what they think through your mouth.
- 4:22And so,
- 4:23yeah,
- 4:24it was very interesting where it felt like Dave shifted.
- 4:27Halfway through the show where he was a little bit more good faith kind of
- 4:30engaging in good faith and then I think after he got really tripped up by
- 4:34Parker's question
- 4:35on economics,
- 4:36which
- 4:37was a good question,
- 4:38I felt like he came back and was a little bit more like,
- 4:41all right,
- 4:41I'm not going to get put in bad positions anymore.
- 4:44I'm not going to come away looking stupid,
- 4:45which I,
- 4:45you know,
- 4:46is one of the tough things about debate spaces is,
- 4:48you know,
- 4:48it often comes down to not wanting to look silly.
- 4:51OK,
- 4:51well,
- 4:52let's watch this first clip
- 4:54because I think that's actually really interesting
- 4:56take on him,
- 4:57you know,
- 4:57something a theme throughout the whole episode was really or
- 5:00something we kept coming back to was this contradiction between
- 5:03Dave Rubin's identity as a gay man and whether or
- 5:06not that gels with the more I guess Christian nationalist
- 5:11uh part of the
- 5:12branch of of MAGA
- 5:14you and and some of the other cast members addressed it here.
- 5:17OK,
- 5:17so Donald Trump is in the middle of his 2nd term.
- 5:20Gay marriage is here.
- 5:21It's passed.
- 5:22It's a just cause.
- 5:23I believe in individual,
- 5:24wait,
- 5:24you're friends with Michael Knowles,
- 5:25right?
- 5:26Mike,
- 5:26yeah,
- 5:26yeah.
- 5:27So what,
- 5:27what's that coalition again called?
- 5:28I think it's like less equal that's trying to
- 5:30actually get rid of Obergefell and overturn gay marriage,
- 5:33right?
- 5:34I've does that not concern you?
- 5:35I've,
- 5:35well,
- 5:35first off,
- 5:35I've never heard of that specific organization,
- 5:37but what I can tell you,
- 5:38you're friends with them.
- 5:40Michael is part of,
- 5:41I don't,
- 5:41I just don't know what you're talking about.
- 5:43What I can look it up right now,
- 5:44it's called Less Than,
- 5:45and it's Lila Rose,
- 5:46Michael Knowles.
- 5:47I think it's,
- 5:47uh,
- 5:47what's that guy's name at the Daily Wire,
- 5:49the head one?
- 5:50OK,
- 5:50but that,
- 5:50that's not Donald Trump.
- 5:51I understand that you want to go away from this.
- 5:53No,
- 5:53no,
- 5:53no,
- 5:53that's not Donald Trump.
- 5:54That's not the head of the party.
- 5:55I have friends that,
- 5:57well,
- 5:57first off,
- 5:57Michael and I are friends,
- 5:58but there is a cap on our friendship.
- 5:59There actually is friends with someone who doesn't want you to be in love,
- 6:02man.
- 6:02He,
- 6:03he doesn't want me to be in love.
- 6:04He's had dinner at my house with his wife.
- 6:06My husband cooked for him.
- 6:07Even the nicest.
- 6:09Christian nationalists,
- 6:10they do want to take your rights.
- 6:11I,
- 6:12I spend a lot of time talking to these people,
- 6:14even the really nice ones.
- 6:15So
- 6:15I just want to be
- 6:16careful and I guess I want to say like
- 6:17I remember when you posted about having your kids
- 6:20on Twitter,
- 6:20which congratulations.
- 6:23Um,
- 6:24the comments were
- 6:25horrifying.
- 6:26I don't know if you remember,
- 6:27but it was
- 6:28Christian nationalists and Republicans
- 6:30tearing you and your husband down for having a child.
- 6:33Well,
- 6:33you should also note there was a lot of love.
- 6:35There was an awful lot of love from an awful lot of
- 6:37conservatives and liberals and people across the board and everything else.
- 6:40The,
- 6:40the way the internet operates
- 6:42is people only focus on the negative.
- 6:44So
- 6:45was there a whole bunch of nasty comments?
- 6:47Was there a whole bunch of nasty,
- 6:49what?
- 6:50Honest,
- 6:50let's just be honest.
- 6:52Which side supports that,
- 6:53if you're asking me about for that specific post,
- 6:55it was no,
- 6:56for that specific post,
- 6:57it was mostly people on the right,
- 6:59for sure.
- 6:59It was attacking him.
- 7:01Yeah,
- 7:01I,
- 7:01I fully acknowledge that.
- 7:02Absolutely.
- 7:0399% of the hate that I get.
- 7:06is from people that are in this circle.
- 7:09Yeah,
- 7:09I mean,
- 7:09this is an interesting contradiction.
- 7:11He,
- 7:11Dave owns the fact that
- 7:13there is a part of his side of the political aisle that
- 7:16really doesn't want him to have the ability to be married,
- 7:19but
- 7:20that doesn't seem to bother him as much as
- 7:21the intolerance he feels coming from the left.
- 7:23What,
- 7:23what's your take of that and what was your take of his response to you?
- 7:27I mean,
- 7:27there's a reality in which obviously you can be
- 7:30Republican and conservative and Disagree with Christian nationalists,
- 7:33right,
- 7:33which I think Dave occupies that space a little bit.
- 7:35There's also something very interesting.
- 7:38I think
- 7:39hell hath no wrath like the left hate.
- 7:41There's a lot of people who
- 7:44in experiencing
- 7:46pretty strong pushback from the left have actually trundled towards the right
- 7:50and I think there's there's this interesting kind of
- 7:52pipeline that has been talked a lot about how
- 7:54in many ways for large pundits if they get.
- 7:57Like canceled even though
- 7:59canceling is,
- 7:59it's complicated,
- 8:00it's more like they just get harassed and then they go to the right,
- 8:03but they still have a platform
- 8:04is that the right is very welcoming it kind of just like wants any and everyone as
- 8:08long as they're sycophantic sufficiently to MAGA and the
- 8:11left doesn't really have like a central value,
- 8:14but definitely if you break it,
- 8:16people are going to come after you and so I'm not surprised to
- 8:18hear that a lot of Dave Rubin's hate comes from the left.
- 8:21The issue is that when.
- 8:22When it comes to like his daily
- 8:25existence like his day to day,
- 8:26he has to reconcile with the fact that he is in
- 8:29large part giving power to people who if they had their way
- 8:33would take away his rights and many other people's rights.
- 8:36He has to acknowledge
- 8:38the import of Christian nationalism to Trump's
- 8:42bind and hold
- 8:43on the Republican Party and how important Christianity is to.
- 8:47Particularly the Republican Party
- 8:49and the way that Christianity moves and shakes in politics right now.
- 8:52And I understand that if he's decided to make his bed with the right,
- 8:56that's his choice to do.
- 8:57It's one of these things where I look and I go,
- 8:59look,
- 9:00the left can be really annoying and judgy and like nasty sometimes,
- 9:04but they definitely don't want to take your rights away.
- 9:07And
- 9:08I don't know how you square these two things
- 9:10and that's a question only Dave can really answer.
- 9:13Yeah,
- 9:13and once again,
- 9:14I'd love to talk to him about it.
- 9:16What Mason brought up was it's not less than,
- 9:18I think it's,
- 9:19it's greater than is the organization.
- 9:21Michael Knowles,
- 9:22I think it's kind of like a surrogate for it.
- 9:24Also Lyla Rose,
- 9:24they've both been on the,
- 9:25on,
- 9:26uh,
- 9:26surrounded.
- 9:27And that isn't a political activist group that wants to overthrow or overturn
- 9:33the gay marriage or marriage equality decision.
- 9:36How much of a portion though,
- 9:38because Dave doesn't sound concerned about this portion of MAGA,
- 9:41and he might just be making
- 9:43a calculation and a confident one.
- 9:44It seems from my perspective that that is not
- 9:47a majority position of the party and that's.
- 9:50Not something Trump is going to take up while he's in power.
- 9:53Do you think that's a safe calculation,
- 9:55and do you think it's a big part of the party?
- 9:57I think with the stax court that we have right now,
- 9:59I mean,
- 9:59I think Thomas has been pretty open that,
- 10:02you know,
- 10:02he's open to repealing gay marriage.
- 10:04And so whether Trump would attack it or not isn't necessarily the question.
- 10:08The question is,
- 10:10when you've done institutional damage.
- 10:12And you've erected sycophants and you have to
- 10:15play the part of satisfying certain sycophants,
- 10:17a large portion of the sycophantry for Trump is born out of Christian nationalism.
- 10:21JD Vance is a Catholic,
- 10:22right?
- 10:23And
- 10:24I think acting like it's not a threat when we've seen
- 10:27so many rights get rolled back
- 10:29is
- 10:30a calculation you can certainly make.
- 10:32It's not one I think is wise.
- 10:35But the sands,
- 10:35the sands all seem to be shifting so much.
- 10:37So you mentioned JD Vance is Catholic,
- 10:39but JD Vance doesn't cross me as a Christian nationalist.
- 10:42I mean,
- 10:42he doesn't even seem to particularly like this Pope.
- 10:46liberal.
- 10:46And so.
- 10:47Yeah,
- 10:48I guess
- 10:48my,
- 10:49my thought,
- 10:50or I guess if I were to steel man Dave's position is
- 10:52sure there is a significant portion of the right that
- 10:55wants to see traditional marriage protected and they want to see
- 10:59gay marriage overturned,
- 11:00but
- 11:01it's probably not enough of a coalition to
- 11:05become a reality and I guess
- 11:07that
- 11:08having that wide of a reach or that big of a tent seems
- 11:11strategically valuable.
- 11:13So I guess what I would throw back to you is,
- 11:14do you think the left actually struggles to make
- 11:17its bed with people who it has differences with?
- 11:21Certainly
- 11:22in the name of political change.
- 11:24Certainly,
- 11:25I think the left is all full of infighting.
- 11:27That's like one of the
- 11:28true and truths.
- 11:29The main thing is that every single side has to police their own sufficiently,
- 11:32right?
- 11:33Yes,
- 11:33you have to understand if you're a liberal,
- 11:36that there are certain communists and socialists.
- 11:38You're going to work with,
- 11:39but you're going to disagree on certain areas and I think one of the issues the
- 11:42left has had is that the liberals tried
- 11:43to pretend like they were socialists and they weren't
- 11:46and the socialists were like,
- 11:47what the heck?
- 11:48You said you were just like us and then you're rolling out moderate Dem policy like
- 11:52what's happening here?
- 11:54I think though on the right,
- 11:55you also have to be careful to police your own,
- 11:57right?
- 11:58It's very easy to say like,
- 11:59uh,
- 12:00the Christian nationalists aren't that much of a threat and it's like
- 12:02why not?
- 12:04Why aren't they that much of a threat?
- 12:05It's actually concerning that JD Vance is fighting the Pope.
- 12:09That means he's a Christian nationalist in all of the ways that
- 12:12matters most,
- 12:13which is
- 12:13a Christian
- 12:14who puts their politics before their faith,
- 12:16right?
- 12:17JD Vance is fighting with the Pope because the
- 12:18Pope is too left because the Pope is telling him
- 12:20that like hate and war and violence is wrong,
- 12:23which it is by Christian standards,
- 12:25and I think one of the things you have to be concerned about
- 12:28with any.
- 12:28Side is their extremist factions and the issue is in the case of Republicans,
- 12:33their extremist factions are getting elected into power
- 12:37they're having seats.
- 12:38There are many
- 12:39Christian nationalists that are senators that are congressmen,
- 12:42whereas on the left,
- 12:43you know,
- 12:44there are concerns about extremism as well people who want to,
- 12:46for example,
- 12:46take away private property rights
- 12:48that the left does need to be thinking about,
- 12:50particularly if you're on the left and you disagree with that position.
- 12:54The issue is that almost nobody has seats that
- 12:56actually want to take away private property rights.
- 12:59Nobody has political power.
- 13:00That's like the socialist bane of existence is that they
- 13:03have a lot of political voice and they have very little political power.
- 13:06And so
- 13:06I think when you scale these things you have to go
- 13:08look,
- 13:08the media is very loud on the left in certain ways,
- 13:11but the media isn't necessarily the same as elected officials,
- 13:14and we're seeing,
- 13:15despite the fact that abortion has 80% support
- 13:18nationally,
- 13:19there are tons of states with very restrictive bans,
- 13:22bans that even their constituent.
- 13:23don't necessarily agree with
- 13:25because we have Christian nationalist
- 13:27politicians and who
- 13:29try to use the Bible to justify their preferential policy
- 13:33rather than using like logic and rationale and that's the part of Christian
- 13:36nationalism we have to be concerned about because they do have political power,
- 13:40they do have camps.
- 13:41I mean,
- 13:41I grew up
- 13:42in this world.
- 13:43I grew up as a fundamental Christian.
- 13:44I remember going to camps where they teach you how
- 13:46to be politically effective and how to get into like
- 13:49they're thinking about political efficacy in a way and have been.
- 13:52For 20 to 30 years
- 13:54in a way that
- 13:56most groups are not thinking about it and they've been effective at it.
- 13:58They are in powerful positions.
- 14:00Yeah,
- 14:00there's a dialed in shrewdness there that maybe there isn't in other places.
- 14:05And I guess,
- 14:05you know,
- 14:06maybe Nick Fuentes,
- 14:07just to plug him for a second or not to plug in
- 14:11to
- 14:11map him in this
- 14:13maze.
- 14:13You know,
- 14:14he strikes me as a as a Christian nationalist.
- 14:17Yes,
- 14:17to some degree or or motivated by that ideology.
- 14:20I would love to go down this rabbit hole.
- 14:22Further with you because I know you have a lot of insight there,
- 14:25but you mentioned,
- 14:26you know,
- 14:26the communist,
- 14:27uh,
- 14:27more socialist faction of the left
- 14:30private property
- 14:31that did come up
- 14:32and so I'm gonna play you a clip and and we'll we'll
- 14:34kind of hear that because I'm curious where you stand there.
- 14:36This is the idea,
- 14:37right,
- 14:37that
- 14:38under our current system
- 14:39we see that the majority of power as well as just like monetary control
- 14:44exists within people who own private property
- 14:46and to essentially uh
- 14:49decrease that gap progressives want to give.
- 14:51More power to those who are in the workplace.
- 14:53Do,
- 14:53do you not want people to own
- 14:55private property?
- 14:56Well,
- 14:56I'm definitely anti-capitalist,
- 14:57I would say.
- 14:58So I would say that workers should own the means of production,
- 15:00right?
- 15:00Oh,
- 15:01so you're a communist.
- 15:02Yeah.
- 15:02Oh,
- 15:03interesting.
- 15:04Yeah,
- 15:04wow.
- 15:04I don't know what is communist.
- 15:05I haven't talked to a real life communist.
- 15:07What a communist?
- 15:08Well,
- 15:08you want the you want the people to own the means of production,
- 15:12and you don't seem to believe in the people who property,
- 15:14the people who create value as in create the value of commodities should own
- 15:18the the actual value that they create from that process.
- 15:21So my answer,
- 15:22if you want the people,
- 15:25everyone in this room and everyone in this country to have more,
- 15:28what I would want is that you would take less from them.
- 15:31So you tax everybody less,
- 15:34you remove regulation,
- 15:35you create the conditions
- 15:37for competition and capitalism,
- 15:40so that more people will have more of their money.
- 15:42I want you,
- 15:43I assume you work,
- 15:44do you work?
- 15:45Do you pay taxes?
- 15:46I want you to keep more of your money.
- 15:48I don't know what you do.
- 15:49I don't know how much you earn.
- 15:50Whatever it is you earn,
- 15:51I want you to have more of that money so that you can put that money back into the.
- 15:54The majority of the wealth in the system is,
- 15:56is owned by 1% of the population.
- 15:58You understand that,
- 15:59right?
- 15:59And where does that wealth come from?
- 16:01Wait,
- 16:011% of the population.
- 16:02Do you know how much percent they pay in taxes,
- 16:03that 1%?
- 16:04Not nearly enough,
- 16:05because the majority of their,
- 16:06because the majority of their wealth comes from,
- 16:07it's 47%.
- 16:10Hold on,
- 16:10hold on.
- 16:10So 1% of the population pay 47%.
- 16:13You accept that?
- 16:14Yeah.
- 16:15So what would be their fair share of that,
- 16:17what would be their fair share their actual wealth that they own?
- 16:20That again,
- 16:21majority of these lineages of power and ownership,
- 16:24what would be their fair share?
- 16:25What would be their accumulation of what,
- 16:27what would be their fair share?
- 16:28I would say that
- 16:30the fact that they own
- 16:31so much%,
- 16:32you're not letting me finish 47% in taxes.
- 16:35Here's my problem.
- 16:35You're not letting me finish the point,
- 16:36so we can't get from point A to B.
- 16:38Do you understand that?
- 16:39OK,
- 16:39OK,
- 16:39cool.
- 16:39If you accept that 1% there's not going to be a fair share when their wealth is coming
- 16:43from the back ends of colonialism,
- 16:45so that's not going to work.
- 16:46I haven't spoken to a real life communist.
- 16:50That was great to me.
- 16:51I was like,
- 16:52you wanted to talk to the far left.
- 16:54What was your expression in that moment?
- 16:56One was disbelief.
- 16:58I basically didn't believe him,
- 16:59that he's never talked to a communist.
- 17:01He was like part of the left for a long time.
- 17:03There's lots of communists,
- 17:04but also I'm like,
- 17:05if you're telling the truth here,
- 17:07how have you not talked to a communist before?
- 17:09You like lived in LA.
- 17:11It's a pretty like rampant large like
- 17:14political philosophical group.
- 17:16Are part of a side that insists that everyone's like a far
- 17:18left commie and you've just never talked to a communist before.
- 17:21I don't know.
- 17:21That seemed very,
- 17:22I,
- 17:22I basically was gobsmacked.
- 17:23I was like,
- 17:24there's either
- 17:24no way he's telling the truth here
- 17:26and he's like trying to do a clip thing
- 17:28or he's telling the truth
- 17:29and that's like a big red flag to me because it's like how could you want
- 17:32to talk to the far left and you've just never even talked to a communist before?
- 17:36That seems,
- 17:37I don't know,
- 17:38somebody who's in politics I've talked.
- 17:39To
- 17:40almost anyone of any political ideology.
- 17:42And if I meet somebody with an ideology,
- 17:44I don't know.
- 17:44I
- 17:45talked to him extensively.
- 17:45So it's just very strange to me.
- 17:46I just don't know if I believe him that he's never talked to a communist.
- 17:49That's crazy.
- 17:50Yeah,
- 17:50there,
- 17:50there are moments where Dave does some posturing where I wonder
- 17:53if it's a little bit more for effect than it is,
- 17:56um,
- 17:57like you said,
- 17:57aligned with his real life experience.
- 17:59But,
- 17:59you know,
- 18:00he hasn't lived in in LA for some time.
- 18:02Maybe that's what he he meant by that.
- 18:04My perspective,
- 18:05though,
- 18:05is there's no,
- 18:06and let me know if you agree with this or disagree.
- 18:08There's no faster route to losing
- 18:12support for your political cause than calling
- 18:14yourself a communist in American politics.
- 18:17Um,
- 18:18do you agree with that?
- 18:19I mean,
- 18:20regardless of what we think about the idea.
- 18:22Yeah,
- 18:22why,
- 18:24why would she openly.
- 18:26I guess put that label on herself.
- 18:27It felt sort of self defeating.
- 18:29I thought.
- 18:29I think it's because it's honest and so
- 18:32so most communists will call themselves socialists because
- 18:35people accept socialism,
- 18:36but they don't accept communism.
- 18:37The issue is that the line between a socialist
- 18:40and a communist is extremely vague and unclear,
- 18:43um,
- 18:43which is why I think,
- 18:45you know,
- 18:45I've talked to Zena about it and
- 18:46she usually goes with socialist because she understands
- 18:49that people prefer that type of language,
- 18:51but the reality is that like if you're a socialist.
- 18:53And especially particularly if you don't believe in private property,
- 18:56for example,
- 18:57and you want to see a complete erasure
- 18:59of capitalism,
- 19:00like you are a communist.
- 19:01I just think it's bad that it's like a buzzword,
- 19:03honestly.
- 19:04I think if buzzwords thought terminate you,
- 19:07you probably shouldn't participate in political conversation,
- 19:09honestly.
- 19:10Um like if I hear that somebody is a communist,
- 19:12that wouldn't make me go,
- 19:13oh,
- 19:13they have nothing to offer here because
- 19:14communism has excellent critiques of capitalism.
- 19:17I don't think that it offers a better system,
- 19:19but the critiques that it brings forward are legitimate.
- 19:21And things that capitalists need to consider because they,
- 19:25there are major problems.
- 19:26Capitalism is just the worst,
- 19:28best system we've
- 19:29invented so far,
- 19:30right?
- 19:31So,
- 19:32you know,
- 19:32we talked about kind of does,
- 19:34does the right have termites
- 19:36with their Christian nationalists?
- 19:38Do you think the left has termites with
- 19:41communists?
- 19:42Because I mean,
- 19:42there's a lot of chatter after
- 19:44Hassan posts a book of him.
- 19:46He's reading on the train.
- 19:47What was he reading Karl Marx.
- 19:49Do you think this is a bad
- 19:52path to go down for the left's own political goals?
- 19:55I think communism is the way that it's been built out by the thought
- 19:58leaders in it doesn't work and that's why it's a really bad idea.
- 20:02The issue is that communism as a principle
- 20:05isn't built
- 20:06on keeping other people away from accessing things necessarily.
- 20:10It's built on this principle of trying to
- 20:13bring about as much egalitarianism as possible,
- 20:15which is a hard thing to look at on its face and go,
- 20:17well.
- 20:17That's terrible,
- 20:18right?
- 20:19What's bad about communism is that when it gets put into practice,
- 20:22it leads to authoritarianism,
- 20:24tyranny and like
- 20:26mass problems
- 20:27just like most authoritarian groups
- 20:30and so
- 20:31does the left need to be aware of communism?
- 20:33Absolutely,
- 20:33but the left needs to be aware of communism in large part because
- 20:37communists are very self aware that Democrats are not their political
- 20:42friends necessarily they understand that they are working in many.
- 20:46Ways in opposition.
- 20:46This is why you'll hear communists say things
- 20:49like cut a liberal and a fascist bleeds,
- 20:51right?
- 20:51And I disagree with this,
- 20:52but
- 20:53there is this reality that when we're talking about
- 20:55competing for political power I've never heard that.
- 20:58Oh really?
- 20:58Yeah,
- 20:59welcome to the internally online,
- 21:01I suppose.
- 21:01I apologize
- 21:03to interrupt you.
- 21:04No,
- 21:04you're good.
- 21:05The only places where communists can compete for political
- 21:08power is in states and areas already blue one,
- 21:11which is why
- 21:13people further left.
- 21:14Democrats are mostly going to fight with Democrats
- 21:17and
- 21:18I think there's something good
- 21:20about the fact that communists recognize that they're separate from
- 21:23Democrats and I think it's bad that Democrats don't recognize
- 21:26that we're different from communists.
- 21:27I think that is a bad thing.
- 21:28I don't really want to call them termites.
- 21:30It's really dehumanizing.
- 21:31I don't even think Christian nationalists are termites.
- 21:34I think their ideology
- 21:35is
- 21:36destructive to the faith,
- 21:38most importantly to me,
- 21:39and destructive to the state,
- 21:40right?
- 21:40In the case of communism,
- 21:42I think it's.
- 21:42Destructive to the state,
- 21:43but I think that there are certain communist
- 21:45arguments that have led to really good policy.
- 21:47I'm very for market regulation,
- 21:50increasing market regulation.
- 21:51We tried the neo-lib
- 21:53thing in the 2000s and we got the 2008 crash.
- 21:56So,
- 21:56there's a lot to be valued there as long as it can be argued with
- 21:59like logic and rationale and my issue
- 22:01with Christian nationalism is they usually harken back
- 22:04to the Bible for their arguments for why their policy ought to be some way,
- 22:07and that's just not a policy I'm open to.
- 22:10That's what I mean by termites.
- 22:11I don't mean the people themselves are termites.
- 22:13I guess I mean the,
- 22:14does the coalition sort of have a stability problem?
- 22:18And something you mentioned earlier is like
- 22:19Christian nationalists are just much more politically mobilized
- 22:23and have been,
- 22:25you know,
- 22:25building momentum for some time.
- 22:27I also would argue that
- 22:28it just rhymes
- 22:29Christianity and Christian nationalism rhymes with American culture much more.
- 22:34And so I think there's more of an advantage there.
- 22:36They can find alliances.
- 22:39Culturally with very moderate American voters,
- 22:42I guess my,
- 22:42my take would be that Democrats don't have that advantage,
- 22:45you know,
- 22:46pairing yourself with,
- 22:47I don't know,
- 22:47it'll be interesting to see how Mom Donnie does,
- 22:50but you see it such an immediate rapid dog pile on DSA candidates
- 22:55once they're kind of in the mainstream of politics,
- 22:58and I think mainstream or average Americans,
- 23:00they hear socialists,
- 23:01they hear communists and
- 23:03something sort of rises in their,
- 23:05their gut,
- 23:05whereas if they hear Christian nationalists.
- 23:07I think there's that same reaction,
- 23:08even though they might be very comparable in terms of their their radicalness.
- 23:13Sure,
- 23:13yeah,
- 23:13and and to this,
- 23:14I would basically say to the American,
- 23:16this is like where buzzwords are causing thought termination,
- 23:19like a theocracy is just as tyrannical and destructive and awful.
- 23:23Like look at the theocracies that exist historically or now.
- 23:26Nobody wants to live there.
- 23:27It's not great.
- 23:28So like you can be afraid of communism and be afraid of the
- 23:31tyranny that happened out of like the Soviet Russia and whatnot like that's,
- 23:35that's fine.
- 23:35The Soviet Union was a failure of a of a of an experiment.
- 23:39The issue is that like
- 23:40we need to
- 23:42like Mamdani is doing
- 23:44cool stuff.
- 23:45He's just doing cool stuff and this is why I'm very big on like the practical side,
- 23:49right?
- 23:49Like
- 23:50the reason I'm not a communist is I really value private property.
- 23:53That's why I'm not a communist because I think taking away private property rights
- 23:56only leads to
- 23:58tyranny and the destruction of the lower class.
- 24:00I think it like is
- 24:01the worst thing that we can do for people's access to.
- 24:04Like tangible fungible
- 24:06rights.
- 24:07That's why I'm against communism.
- 24:08That's why I'm not a communist,
- 24:09right?
- 24:10But I think there's a lot of communist arguments that are pointed.
- 24:13I think that we do have a wealth disparity issue in this country.
- 24:16I think it's
- 24:17as somebody who comes from Canada,
- 24:18it's insane
- 24:19to know that people are choosing between
- 24:22going into debt or their bodily integrity.
- 24:25Like it's just,
- 24:26you know,
- 24:27my friend has an abscess and he's a,
- 24:29you know,
- 24:29a dad of 3 kids and he's got this huge abscess in his.
- 24:32And he's just
- 24:33hoping it clears because he can't afford to go and get medical care for it.
- 24:37That's
- 24:38insane to me
- 24:39and so this will all get labeled as communism
- 24:41and it's just like there's this thing that the Republicans
- 24:45and I think Democrats did too where they kind of gave over Americanism to the right
- 24:50when it's like Americanism is not a right thing it's not a left thing like it's its
- 24:54own kind of rugged individuality and liberty and
- 24:57you know these balances of power and and.
- 25:01And rights for the common man like that's Americanism.
- 25:03It's not a left or right issue and it's it's actually sad to me to see that
- 25:07Christian nationalists can co-opt it so strongly when
- 25:09I would say that they're both defying the faith
- 25:11as a Christian like I think Christian nationalists are destroying our faith
- 25:15are creating a false version of a past version of America.
- 25:18That's idealized that never existed
- 25:21and that nobody wants to go back to.
- 25:22I think I got
- 25:24sidetracked from our original conversation,
- 25:25but yeah,
- 25:25no,
- 25:26no,
- 25:26I appreciate it.
- 25:26Well,
- 25:26yeah,
- 25:27maybe that's the that's a running option for
- 25:29the third party's name is the Americanist.
- 25:34Maybe they'll finally get off the ground.
- 25:36Yeah,
- 25:37because that's something I do wonder is if,
- 25:38you know,
- 25:39as the party sort of widen or the delta widens,
- 25:42you know,
- 25:42every once in a while parties do sort of cycle through and,
- 25:45and you do wonder if it would happen in our lifetime.
- 25:47Earlier you mentioned Parker.
- 25:49Parker kind of had a gotcha,
- 25:50a big gotcha moment with Dave.
- 25:52Although how big is,
- 25:53is debatable.
- 25:54I think depending on who.
- 25:55Watching it,
- 25:56but at at the core of,
- 25:57you know,
- 25:58the socialist or even communist argument is really economics
- 26:02and so Dave is a defender of Trump and his economic policies and so Parker really went
- 26:08for him
- 26:09with this.
- 26:09So I'm gonna play that clip and then hear your thoughts.
- 26:12Also,
- 26:12Parker
- 26:13emailed me back.
- 26:15I've been trying to get him to do one of these for a minute.
- 26:18All right,
- 26:18so this is
- 26:19Parker asking Dave about key metrics.
- 26:22Nice to meet you.
- 26:22Hi,
- 26:22how are you?
- 26:23All right,
- 26:23good.
- 26:24What is one main metric that Donald Trump has made better off since he got in office?
- 26:27Like an example would be GDP,
- 26:29unemployment,
- 26:30inflation,
- 26:30etc.
- 26:31Well,
- 26:31right now,
- 26:32first off,
- 26:32the big beautiful bill was just passed last year and it's kicking in now,
- 26:36right?
- 26:36It's kicking in now.
- 26:38OK,
- 26:39so we are,
- 26:39see,
- 26:39we're going to now see results of that,
- 26:41like even the tariffs.
- 26:42All right,
- 26:42so let's do tariffs.
- 26:43Are you for or against tariffs?
- 26:45I'm against the universal tariffs.
- 26:46So what's the main metric that he made better off?
- 26:49What?
- 26:49What's the main metric that he made better off?
- 26:50GDP,
- 26:50unemployment,
- 26:51inflation?
- 26:52Do you have an idea?
- 26:54Listen,
- 26:57I don't think you do.
- 26:58Do you think,
- 26:59hold on.
- 26:59So
- 27:00you're arguing that things economically were better under
- 27:03Joe Biden at the end of his administration.
- 27:05Absolutely.
- 27:05So can you give me an example of how?
- 27:07Yeah,
- 27:07GDP growth was better off,
- 27:08real median wage growth is better off.
- 27:09Inflation was better off at the end of his administration,
- 27:11unemployment was better off at the end of his administration.
- 27:13With the worst year of job growth in the past four years,
- 27:15just this last year under Trump's administration,
- 27:17the inflation 3.8% year over year since Trump got in office.
- 27:21We're seeing all of those economic indicators become worse off.
- 27:24Can you tell me anything that he's done to make it better off?
- 27:26You say it's broken for Democrats.
- 27:27It sounds like it's broken right now under Trump.
- 27:28Have you looked at the stock market?
- 27:30It's worse off in terms of growth in 2025 as compared to 2024.
- 27:33If you look at Dow Jones and S&P 500.
- 27:36They're both up quite a bit right now,
- 27:38but lower rate and doing quite well.
- 27:40You know,
- 27:40things don't happen overnight.
- 27:42So Donald Trump,
- 27:42for example,
- 27:43things don't,
- 27:44that's true.
- 27:44That's true.
- 27:45Is that how you remember it happening on set?
- 27:47Obviously it gets edited a bit.
- 27:49Basically,
- 27:50yeah,
- 27:50I think,
- 27:50I think Parker just kept cycling.
- 27:52What's a metric?
- 27:52What's a metric?
- 27:53What's a metric?
- 27:54Um,
- 27:54and we just didn't really get a firm answer until
- 27:57kind of the end with the Dow and the S&P.
- 27:59The
- 28:00Dow,
- 28:00look at the Dow right now.
- 28:01I mean,
- 28:02OK,
- 28:02so I'm gonna,
- 28:03I
- 28:05I gotta defend Dave a little bit.
- 28:06So when it was tariff time when we were approaching,
- 28:09you know,
- 28:10the,
- 28:10the stock market was crashing big time because everybody was freaked out about
- 28:14what the impacts were going to be of of the tariffs that Trump
- 28:17wanted to implement.
- 28:18And he went even further than pretty much everybody thought.
- 28:21However,
- 28:22the aftermath of that,
- 28:24and I guess at least reflected in in the stock market.
- 28:27The inflation hasn't gone up as aggressively as I think a lot of people
- 28:32feared.
- 28:33It has gone up,
- 28:34but it,
- 28:34you know,
- 28:35compared to the inflation that happened under Joe Biden,
- 28:37it still is much tamer,
- 28:39and
- 28:40the market did recover and essentially baked
- 28:42in the risk that they were calculating.
- 28:45And as far as we've seen,
- 28:46you know,
- 28:47the stock market has continued to,
- 28:48to steadily go up.
- 28:49Now,
- 28:50sure,
- 28:50you can compare it to the last few years of Joe Biden's administration,
- 28:53but I,
- 28:54I guess the only thing I would say to Steelman Dave is,
- 28:57the darkest predictions,
- 28:58which were very common,
- 29:01did not come true.
- 29:03And I,
- 29:03I don't,
- 29:04let's factor that Iran,
- 29:05you know,
- 29:06wore out a little bit at the moment.
- 29:09Just pure economic policy and less foreign policy.
- 29:13What,
- 29:13what is your take?
- 29:14It's interesting when people talk about economics under presidents because
- 29:17the president has almost nothing to do with the economy.
- 29:19By and large,
- 29:20there are certain things,
- 29:21so Trump is actually a unique one in that he's done things to affect the economy.
- 29:25Usually,
- 29:25the economy is managed by the Federal Reserve,
- 29:28right?
- 29:28And Jerome Powell,
- 29:29the GOAT,
- 29:30OK,
- 29:31anyone in economics knows that he was just an absolute
- 29:34king.
- 29:34He,
- 29:35he,
- 29:35I mean,
- 29:35the fact that America came out of COVID so well
- 29:38is exclusively Jerome Powell's.
- 29:40Thanks.
- 29:41He managed the country
- 29:42so well,
- 29:43which is why it is absurd that Trump is now weaponizing the DOJ against him,
- 29:48but there's really few ways that presidents can impact
- 29:50economics and it's through war and through tariffs which.
- 29:54It's funny that uh you know we have this so
- 29:56yeah there's this interesting thing where I
- 29:58actually follow a lot of economic channels.
- 30:00I'm really interested in economics
- 30:01and most modern economists go
- 30:04this AI bubble
- 30:05is getting us through everything right now.
- 30:07Like yes,
- 30:08the stock market has continued to trendle up,
- 30:10not as much as we would expect with how much of an AI
- 30:12bubble we're in and we know some of that slowing and cooling is from
- 30:17frankly,
- 30:17the lack of stability.
- 30:18We have seen some pretty large
- 30:20US Treasury liquidations.
- 30:23I'm not sure.
- 30:23I'm sure if you're familiar with that,
- 30:24but
- 30:24that's a really concerning sign.
- 30:26Do you know what US Treasuries are?
- 30:28Educate me and the listener.
- 30:29I mean,
- 30:30I would embarrass myself if I tried to,
- 30:32it's super esoteric.
- 30:33This is something most people don't need to know,
- 30:34but it's essentially debt.
- 30:36It's US debt that gets like
- 30:37packaged up and people buy the debt and people
- 30:40like to buy US Treasuries because America's really stable.
- 30:43It pays its debts
- 30:44and so you're guaranteed a certain amount of of
- 30:47of basically interest and paybacks when you own treasuries,
- 30:50which is why
- 30:51American treasuries.
- 30:52Really highly valued.
- 30:53Most countries and most super rich people own
- 30:56lots of American treasuries.
- 30:57So China and these countries,
- 30:58they own a lot of American debt.
- 30:59When we say China owns American debt,
- 31:01we mean that they own
- 31:02American treasuries.
- 31:03When people start liquidating off,
- 31:06they're saying,
- 31:06I don't want to touch American debt anymore.
- 31:08What that means is people don't trust America to be stable over the next
- 31:1210 to 15 years,
- 31:13that it will pay back its debts,
- 31:15so they don't want to own it anymore.
- 31:17That is really concerning and so I agree
- 31:19that none of the doomsday predictions happened,
- 31:21but That's mostly because
- 31:23most journalists and analysts don't understand economics well enough
- 31:27to report accurately and they have to sell like
- 31:29bait
- 31:30clipping stuff,
- 31:31so they have to be like,
- 31:31oh my gosh,
- 31:32it's the end of the world and it's like that's not how
- 31:35inflation and economics work.
- 31:37Like what we're seeing and feeling now
- 31:40is the beginning grumblings of it,
- 31:42where we're trundling towards some potential explosion,
- 31:46whether that be the US dollar suddenly becoming
- 31:49massively deflated,
- 31:50that would be terrible.
- 31:51Right?
- 31:52So you're right,
- 31:53the
- 31:54stock market has continued to go up under Trump.
- 31:56The issue is if it stops going up,
- 31:59that's like red alert.
- 32:01That's like very scary.
- 32:02If the American stock market doesn't continue to rise,
- 32:05if the Dow and the S&P 500,
- 32:07a lot of people don't know this,
- 32:08it sets new records like
- 32:10every week
- 32:11like that.
- 32:11We want it trundling up.
- 32:13We want 2 to 4% inflation for a healthy country.
- 32:17If we start seeing
- 32:19those numbers stagnate.
- 32:21Or dropping that is a code red
- 32:23and so I think a lot of people like well it's not that bad
- 32:25like things are mostly the same it's like sort of but like your electronics,
- 32:30this camera I bought it for $250
- 32:32it's worth $800 right now.
- 32:34We are seeing the growth we are seeing the collapse of,
- 32:38you know,
- 32:38unemployment rate is 5.2%. The new
- 32:41Fed report came out today.
- 32:42People who have graduated have a 5.2% unemployment rate,
- 32:45which is higher than the national average.
- 32:47That's
- 32:48really not good.
- 32:49That means.
- 32:49New sectors of educated sectors don't have jobs for new graduates.
- 32:54That doesn't bode well for the future,
- 32:55especially for the future with a really aging populace
- 32:58that is increasingly relying on
- 33:00Medicare and all these social insurance and these social welfare networks.
- 33:04That's very spooky with an aging populace.
- 33:07I'm glad you kind of brought up the deficit because that
- 33:10actually probably is the easiest attack on Trump economically speaking,
- 33:14it has gone up.
- 33:15I think what was it like 25% since he's become president.
- 33:19And that was something he did definitely run on,
- 33:22you know,
- 33:22Doge was all about trying to take care of that.
- 33:24So
- 33:25it's not a good look.
- 33:26And I do think isn't the just the interest on our debt eclipses GDP.
- 33:30Is,
- 33:30is that true?
- 33:31Yeah,
- 33:31it is,
- 33:32which is really scary to think about really bad.
- 33:35So,
- 33:36I mean,
- 33:37we're coming up on our time here,
- 33:38I guess,
- 33:39um.
- 33:40What are your predictions?
- 33:41How bad,
- 33:42how bad is this going to get?
- 33:43Are we looking at like a pitchforks,
- 33:46storm,
- 33:46the best steel,
- 33:48you know,
- 33:48let's pull billionaires out of their houses moment.
- 33:51I would not obviously advocate for that.
- 33:53But
- 33:54you got to wonder,
- 33:56does history repeat itself?
- 33:57And and is that something that's that's coming for us?
- 34:00I think it's really important to remember
- 34:02that history is not linear and neither is the future.
- 34:05So I kind of,
- 34:06I always tell people I am an optimist by tactical necessity,
- 34:09which is a quote from
- 34:11my favorite movie,
- 34:11Everything,
- 34:12Everywhere all at once.
- 34:13The future is not set.
- 34:14The future is made by the choices that we as individuals and people
- 34:18make every single day.
- 34:20And so is there a future timeline
- 34:22that ends in like
- 34:24civil war and violence and like death of the bourgeois?
- 34:27I probably there's probably one multiverse where that's happening.
- 34:30I certainly hope it's not this one
- 34:32and the reality is that like
- 34:35yeah exactly
- 34:36and I I hope that that future isn't the one that we see.
- 34:39I want a future
- 34:41where Republicans wake up
- 34:43and they go,
- 34:43you know what?
- 34:44We did usher in a corrupt president.
- 34:47Like there isn't a way that you get away from the fact
- 34:49that he is like the slush fund and his personal wealth growth
- 34:53despite,
- 34:54you know,
- 34:54despite the country being 25% increase in in in debt,
- 34:57he's made $4 billion in a year,
- 35:00him and his family.
- 35:00You can't run away from that.
- 35:02You can't run away from the fact that
- 35:03you got
- 35:04Ponzi.
- 35:05Schemed by a president who used his presidency to
- 35:08weaponize it to line his and his friends' pockets,
- 35:11and he's open,
- 35:12he's open about how he wants the DOJ to attack his political enemies enough.
- 35:16Just today he released something
- 35:18against the woman who won a lawsuit against him for sexual assault.
- 35:23He said we need to weaponize the DOJ more against her.
- 35:26And
- 35:27I don't know how we fix this until both sides do a little bit of reckoning,
- 35:31and the issue is that I'm really willing to do reckoning on the left.
- 35:34I'm probably
- 35:35one of the people on the left that is popular for this,
- 35:38but the left has a really good point,
- 35:39which is that it takes two to tango.
- 35:41And if Republicans don't own the fact that they have been usurped by
- 35:45corrupted politicians,
- 35:47and it is not the same
- 35:49as like Biden being old
- 35:51or like having his son work in Ukraine.
- 35:54If we can't get to the same reality,
- 35:56I don't know what we do.
- 35:58And so.
- 36:00We just need a little bit of accountability in the country.
- 36:02I think we need a little bit of bipartisan
- 36:04work where it's possible to try to rebuild things,
- 36:07and
- 36:09we need politicians who will do actionable
- 36:11changes to get housing and zoning improved so
- 36:14people can own and afford houses and fix some of these really simple stuff.
- 36:18I mean war happens less on the back of.
- 36:21ideological divide and oftentimes more on the back of economic
- 36:25crisis.
- 36:26Right?
- 36:26I think I,
- 36:27I mean,
- 36:27a lot of what you say is music to my ears.
- 36:29I mean,
- 36:29I,
- 36:30the,
- 36:30the mission of Jubilee,
- 36:31and I'm somebody who's been heavily involved in Jubilee has always been to kind of
- 36:35find um unlikely
- 36:37points of alignment between
- 36:39both sides of the political aisle.
- 36:41And like you said,
- 36:41that kind of pragmatism.
- 36:43Um,
- 36:44in politics,
- 36:44sort of fueling that.
- 36:46But
- 36:47something that I wonder is if
- 36:49to the Trump corruption point,
- 36:51just to kind of respond to that.
- 36:52I agree with you.
- 36:53It's
- 36:54and and this came up in the Glenn Greenwald episode,
- 36:56you know,
- 36:57it's naked corruption.
- 36:58It's kind of hard to argue against,
- 37:01um,
- 37:02because it's just so obvious,
- 37:03but yet people don't really seem to care.
- 37:05Trump's political brand,
- 37:07his,
- 37:07his.
- 37:08Um,
- 37:08effectiveness as a leader and as a populist is just so
- 37:12strong that it doesn't seem like those who voted for him,
- 37:15or at least a significant portion of them are really willing to hold him accountable
- 37:19or push back on that.
- 37:20Um,
- 37:21and I have family members who
- 37:23support him and I've I've had conversations with them.
- 37:25And,
- 37:25and again,
- 37:25they just are kind of like,
- 37:26I don't,
- 37:27I don't really care.
- 37:28So that makes me wonder if,
- 37:30you know,
- 37:31the,
- 37:31the move.
- 37:32the left that that pragmatic move is really to focus on governance
- 37:36rather than I think justice for for this injustice that is happening.
- 37:41Like I I I wonder if that is the wrong way to go,
- 37:44but that doesn't seem
- 37:45to be a pill that most people on the left
- 37:48who hold power really want to swallow.
- 37:50Yeah,
- 37:50I mean,
- 37:51we are seeing touches of it.
- 37:53We've got,
- 37:53you know,
- 37:54um,
- 37:55AOC has become like.
- 37:57An increasing ultimate pragmatist.
- 37:59um I've been really impressed with her career.
- 38:01We have Josh Shapiro,
- 38:03a highly pragmatic politician.
- 38:04I think the issue that we see in the Democrat space is we don't know who we are yet.
- 38:09There's a war
- 38:10we're trying to decide it right now and so I agree with you that.
- 38:14a facelift of effective policy could go miles,
- 38:17right?
- 38:18I think one of the things that's going to do Mamdani so well
- 38:20is that he is getting stuff done
- 38:22quickly and measurably,
- 38:23and people are seeing it and people
- 38:26really need to see it.
- 38:27People are really frustrated by the lack of movement that I think we're.
- 38:31Experiencing in this country.
- 38:33I think the other thing that has to happen is a face lift for the Democrats.
- 38:36I think the reality is that like if I told most people you're going
- 38:39to go to a party and all of them are really staunch Democrats,
- 38:43most people,
- 38:44including people who are like
- 38:45socially left leaning,
- 38:47would be like,
- 38:47oh,
- 38:48you know,
- 38:49that sounds like a bad time.
- 38:51So we when did Democrats become so uncool
- 38:54in my childhood it was the total.
- 38:56Yeah they're like smoking weed.
- 38:57I don't know they just all became lawyers and got like
- 39:00afraid of liability,
- 39:01I think
- 39:02um so they're like also has to be this like media cultural
- 39:05revamp
- 39:06that I think
- 39:07for example socialists and communists have always been really good at.
- 39:10They're very populist they're very good at being chill and showing that they
- 39:14care about like the little guy whereas
- 39:16you know the liberals are more like,
- 39:18look,
- 39:18I care,
- 39:19but like you have to understand.
- 39:21Why liability is an issue.
- 39:22It's like nobody wants to hear about liability and
- 39:25like bureaucracy and balance of power when 50% of
- 39:28their income goes to paying for rent for some
- 39:29like shit apartment that they don't even like.
- 39:31Like nobody wants to hear it.
- 39:32So yeah,
- 39:33I think
- 39:33governance that's affecting change
- 39:35will do a lot
- 39:36for Democrats if they can like
- 39:38figure out how to do it,
- 39:39but part of I think how to do that is to get enough momentum and
- 39:43coalition behind them that they can get stuff done,
- 39:45um,
- 39:45which is just
- 39:47increasingly difficult in our.
- 39:50modern political landscape right now.
- 39:51Well,
- 39:52Kyla,
- 39:52I appreciate you so much for coming on.
- 39:53My very,
- 39:54very last.
- 39:54I heard AOC.
- 39:55I heard Josh Shapiro.
- 39:58Those would be your top two
- 40:00if you had to choose
- 40:02the face of the party in a couple of years.
- 40:03I don't know.
- 40:04Josh is not very charismatic.
- 40:07I think he's a great politician,
- 40:08but he's definitely not charismatic.
- 40:10VP material maybe.
- 40:11Yeah,
- 40:11I'm not sure.
- 40:12I honestly,
- 40:12I don't really care who's the face.
- 40:14I'm not going to lie.
- 40:15I just want effective policy.
- 40:17You must care though.
- 40:18You must it's such a huge,
- 40:20it's such a huge variable.
- 40:22Yeah,
- 40:22but politicians are like uh hired grifters.
- 40:25I want a politician that reflects the populace.
- 40:27So like at a media level,
- 40:28I want the populace
- 40:30to get educated sufficiently
- 40:32that the politicians who represent us is good policy
- 40:34and whoever will grift to that the most effectively,
- 40:36I think would be great.
- 40:37I think Gavin Newsom's been doing a lot of bidding to try to
- 40:40show that he's more moderate now while still having his progressive background.
- 40:44I think Pete Buttigieg is really trying to be like.
- 40:47I know I'm gay,
- 40:47but forget about that.
- 40:48Think about how good I am at rhetoric and stuff like that,
- 40:51you know,
- 40:51and how good I am at policy.
- 40:53So I,
- 40:54I'd be,
- 40:54I'd be open to a lot of people.
- 40:55I don't even know if I have a favorite.
- 40:57I like a lot of people.
- 40:58AOC I think has been clear she's not going to run
- 41:01anytime soon.
- 41:02Yeah,
- 41:02I think she's been,
- 41:03people have asked her about it a bunch and she's been pretty like,
- 41:05uh,
- 41:05probably not.
- 41:06She's pretty young.
- 41:08I think she really wants to build up a bit more of her record,
- 41:10particularly with her bipartisan work.
- 41:12I think she wants to get a couple more years of bipartisan work under the belt.
- 41:15Or she makes a run for
- 41:17federal office because she's obviously kind of got that communist back like
- 41:21people accuse her of being a communist in her younger years.
- 41:24So that's my suspicion of what's going on with her.
- 41:26But I like her policy a lot.
- 41:27I like Bernie.
- 41:28I've always been a Bernie bro.
- 41:29So my personal preference is like a Bernie type,
- 41:31but really,
- 41:31I'll take any politician that grifts to the right policy.
- 41:34I don't really care.
- 41:34All right,
- 41:35well,
- 41:35may the best grifter win.
- 41:38Um,
- 41:38Kylie,
- 41:38I'm sure this won't be the last time we cross paths in this political space,
- 41:43but thank you so much for.
- 41:44Coming onto Surrounded and for doing a follow up.
- 41:47Thanks for hosting me and letting me up.
- 41:48I appreciate it.
- 41:49If you want to see more follow-up episodes of Surrounded,
- 41:52be sure to like,
- 41:53leave us a positive review,
- 41:54comment if you're watching the video on YouTube.
- 41:57Uh,
- 41:57you can subscribe to Tubbili,
- 41:59Jubilee's second channel.
- 42:00You can also subscribe to Jubilee to see full
- 42:03surrounded episodes.
- 42:05But however you want to support us,
- 42:06just thank you so much for listening.
- 42:08Remember,
- 42:09you could be wrong,
- 42:10so could I.
- 42:11Keep your mind open
- 42:12until next time.