Latest / Psychology In Seattle Podcast / Diagnosing Game of Thrones (2017 Rerun)
Transcript
- 0:07Hey, deserving listeners, It's just me. Let me tell you something.
- 0:11When it comes to diagnosing people, the Internet is stupid. The Internet is
- 0:16just plain stupid when it comes to diagnosing people. And let me explain.
- 0:21Someone from a magazine asked me to provide some opinion because they are writing a
- 0:28piece on diagnosing characters from Game of Thrones, and I gave them a few
- 0:33of my opinions, a few quotes. But then I went online to see
- 0:38what others are saying, and I was astonished at all the bad information out
- 0:42there. To some of you, you might wonder you might be astonished at
- 0:45my astonishment. But I thought I would find at least, I don't know,
- 0:50a few articles with accurate information written by clinicians. But the first page
- 0:57of Google searches brought up a bunch of bad articles written by people who clearly
- 1:00have no idea what they're doing, even clinicians, by the way. So
- 1:04I tried the second page of Google hits, and the same thing, a
- 1:07bunch of bad articles written by people who clearly have no idea what they're doing.
- 1:11So I tried the third page, and same thing. So in this
- 1:15episode, I'm going to provide a critique of these popular websites and what they're
- 1:21saying. And I'm also going to provide a diagnosis for several Game of Thrones
- 1:26characters. From my opinion, this episode is going to take a while.
- 1:32I'm guessing at least a couple hours, So get ready for a lot of
- 1:36Game of Thrones talk. This is the Psychology Against YadA podcast. I'm your
- 1:40host, Doctor Kirkonda. I am a professor and a therapist. Just so
- 1:45you know before we get going, I'm going to spoil everything up until early
- 1:49twenty seventeen, so I'm going to spoil everything and up and up through season
- 1:53six of the TV show and up through book five in a Song of Ice
- 1:57and Fire. So just know everything's going to be spoiled, So go out
- 2:01and watch this. So read the books if you don't want things to be
- 2:05spoiled. Okay, so let's get into it. I'm going to do it
- 2:07by alphabetical order from first name, and we have Aris, the Mad King
- 2:13Targerian. He is not in the TV show very much. He's a historical
- 2:19figure. He happens before the first book happens. He's the mad King that
- 2:27Robert and ed Ard and the Lanisters overthrew and put Robert Brathian on the iron
- 2:35throne. So what does So I'm gonna with each of these characters from Game
- 2:43of Thrones, I'm gonna give some quotes from different websites and then I'll provide
- 2:47my opinion. So with Aries the Mad King Targerian, the popular website that
- 2:53I found was a blog Ofthrones dot com, a blog of Thrones, and
- 3:00they identified Aris the Mad King Targerian, you know, the one who wanted
- 3:04to set King's landing on fire. He identified the mad King as suffering from
- 3:09pyromania. And in this instance there he's actually whoever was writing this article was
- 3:15actually correct. It's one of the I know I was going to talk about.
- 3:19I knew I was going to talk a lot of crap about our websites.
- 3:22But in this instance, the blog Ofthrones dot com, actually they were
- 3:25correct. So but let me go into Aries Targerian a little further beyond pyromania.
- 3:35So, yeah, yeah, he suffered from pyromania. Let's go through
- 3:38the DSM five criteria for that. A repeated deliberate fire setting. Yes,
- 3:46he had repeated deliberate fire setting. For instance, he burned Rickards Stark alive.
- 3:52This was Edard's father tension or affective arousal before the act. Yes,
- 4:00according to the books, it made him a horny to think about starting things
- 4:06on fire, fascination with fire. Yes. Did he derive pleasure from fire?
- 4:14Yes? Was the fire not for any particular gain, you know,
- 4:18like arson that for insurance purposes or something. Yes, he often shot himself
- 4:25in the foot to see things burn. He loved the burned things so much
- 4:30that it actually got him killed in the end in some ways, I mean
- 4:34in a you know, in addition to a bunch of other bad leadership skills
- 4:39that he presented. Also, is it not attributable to some other disorder?
- 4:45And I would say, yeah, it's not attributable. So he really fits
- 4:50the full criteria. Although he's not a classic case because if you actually read
- 4:57case studies with classic Kates of piro maniacs as we might call them, he's
- 5:02not. I wouldn't say pyromania was his primary disorder. His primary disorder is
- 5:10schizophrenia and or some other psychotic disorder. It could have been bipolar with psychosis
- 5:17or something. It's hard to tell because it's not like the books give us
- 5:24a full, you know, course of his mental illness, but I would
- 5:28say that the most likely diagnosis that we would land upon is schizophrenia. Oh,
- 5:33by the way, before going forward, I just want to say something
- 5:36upfront, and people who've listened to this podcast know this. The issue of
- 5:44or the the practice of diagnosing mental illness from the d s M five is
- 5:53a complicated one in that if you have a medical condition like a broken bone,
- 5:59you fall off a ladder, you break a bone in your arm,
- 6:02you go to the emergency room, they take an X ray, they see
- 6:09a broken bone, you know, they actually see the bone is broken.
- 6:14They send it to a radiologist. The radiologists looks at it and says,
- 6:18yep, broken bone. They send you to a bone person or someone else
- 6:24in and they diagnose whatever their diagnosis is, broken bone, of the of
- 6:28the blah blah blah bone treatment plan, you know, set the bone and
- 6:33you know, put a cast on, physical therapy, that kind of stuff.
- 6:38So that's in the medical profession. In the psychological professions of mental health
- 6:43professions, it is not like that. Not usually anyway, someone comes into
- 6:49my office and I can't scan them with an X ray, I can't take
- 6:56their blood and look for biomarkers that suggests a particular syndrome or condition or disorder.
- 7:03I have to usually just ask the client to tell me what their experience
- 7:11is, or what they feel, or what they typically do on a typical
- 7:17day, and then I use the DSM five to guide me toward a likely
- 7:24construct is what we call them. We don't call them things. We don't
- 7:28because a broken bone is a thing. When you have a broken bone,
- 7:31there's no there's no subjective reality to that you have a broken bone. But
- 7:36when you have depression or anxiety or PTSD or schizophrenia, these are things that
- 7:44as a profession in mental health we construct. For instance, we have different
- 7:49types of schizophrenia for instance, well we could if we wanted to, if
- 7:55we just got together and decided to, we could say that all those different
- 7:59types of schizophrenia are actually different disorders. We could, you know, have
- 8:03four different disorders that under and you know, we could split them all up.
- 8:09And we do this actually in our field. The DSM will take disorders
- 8:13and split them up and combine them and move them around and change them over
- 8:18the years. And so whereas broken bone, you know, it's been that's
- 8:22been the broken bones since the beginning of time. I'm guessing the ancient Greeks,
- 8:26and the ancient Chinese cultures and the ancient American cultures, they all knew
- 8:31what a broken bone was, and so I'm just guessing. But the idea
- 8:35of mental illness has changed as culture has changed, and in one hundred years,
- 8:41I guarantee you our construct of mental illness will change along with it.
- 8:48Now, some things will probably remain stable, schizophrenia probably being one of them,
- 8:52but it's hard to tell because they have changed over time. So as
- 8:56I provide my opinion on applying labels and constructs to these fictional characters in these
- 9:05books, keep all that in mind that this is not a hard science.
- 9:09This is not something that I can even if I had a real human being
- 9:13that I was assessing, I couldn't take a reading and mark a number into
- 9:20a you know, the file, the client file, and determine whether or
- 9:24not it means this or that. In reality, it's just things that we
- 9:30construct as a guide for treatment. You know, when someone seems to fit
- 9:35these criteria, we apply this label of schizophrenia because that helps us to treat
- 9:41them and to understand what will likely be the course of their issue. As
- 9:48they present. Someone comes in with schizophrenia, well, in all likelihood,
- 9:52in five years they're probably still going to be suffering from that. And these
- 9:56are the medications that are going to work. And these are the psycho therapies
- 10:00that might soothe the client. These are the family systems issues that might help.
- 10:05These are the other things you know. There's there's all these just guidelines
- 10:09really, and they're very squishy. For some people it'll work in for some
- 10:13people it won't work. So's it's an imprecise science. And so as I
- 10:18provide my opinion, although I'll probably sound a little pompous because when I read
- 10:24these other websites and what they're saying, it's laughable. And to any clinician,
- 10:28honestly, it would be laughable, or any clinician knows who we're talking
- 10:31about, because some of these are actually clinicians that are writing. But understand
- 10:35that you could argue with me, anyone could argue with me, and and
- 10:39that would be legitimate. You know, every there there are, particularly when
- 10:41we get into personality disorders. My god, the people argue about those kinds
- 10:46of things all the time, mostly because we don't really know what it is.
- 10:50And everyone is sort of describing a different thing that while I'm on this
- 10:56jag, I just kind of want to do this. One of the things
- 11:00that I will lecture about to my students is the definition of rap. Okay.
- 11:05You know, everyone understands what rap is, right. Well, when
- 11:09I was growing up in the eighties, Beastie Boys or a rap band or
- 11:16a rap group or rap outfit or rap whatever. Hip hop. The term
- 11:20hip hop didn't really emerge as a popular term until the early nineties. But
- 11:26in the eighties, you know, you had Beastie Boys, and you had
- 11:30run DMC and Vanilla Ice and MC hammer or wait, mc hammer, ice
- 11:39Cube iced Tea, these mwa, these people public m this was this was
- 11:43referred to me as rap music. Well, I don't know, I'm dating
- 11:50myself, but probably like ten years ago or something, I was talking with
- 11:54some clients who were teenagers and one of them said, I said, oh,
- 12:00yeah, rap, you know, like Beastie Boys or something. And
- 12:01then they're like, oh, Beastie Boys, that's not rap, that's rock.
- 12:05So they said that Beastie Boys are rock. Okay, So at the
- 12:09time, I thought, well, that's ridiculous. Of course Beastie Boys are
- 12:11rap. But really, it's all a matter of classification. What do you
- 12:15define as rap? Do you define rap as being you know, as having
- 12:18these criteria or a different set of criteria according to my criteria that I absorbed
- 12:24or you know, sort of solidified in the in the mid eighties during mainly
- 12:28during the run DMC popularity times, whatever criteria I have for rap. The
- 12:35beasts, particularly your early early Beastie boys, they qualified, they qualify as
- 12:41rap to me then, and they still do to someone else. They have
- 12:43a different set of criteria for what rap is. So but neither one is
- 12:48right, you understand, Like, no one can say what rap is.
- 12:52It all just depends on how you define it. Well, mental disorders are
- 12:56exactly the same way. All the disorders all, you know, a group
- 13:01of people get together and decide this is how we're this is the label,
- 13:03and this is how we're going to define it. And it and the criteria
- 13:11are also in the eye of the beholder. Right, So let's say,
- 13:15you know, with rap, we say, well, you have to talk
- 13:18instead of sing. You know, you're not singing like law, And how
- 13:22do you define singing? You know, extended vowels with a tonality to you
- 13:26know, like la la la. That's singing whereas rap is. But you
- 13:31know, hello, my name is Kirk, and I'm here to say I
- 13:35like to work and I like to play my God. So that's one criteria.
- 13:41Well, what about certain kinds of hip hop where it's sort of like
- 13:48singing but it's also kind of rhythmically talking. I mean, in some ways
- 13:52you could say Bob Dylan in a lot of his songs wasn't singing. He
- 13:56was just talking. You know, It's not really tonality, it's just so
- 14:01was he rapping. So the criteria are in the eye of the beholder.
- 14:05And again it's just different individuals making different decisions about different criteria that are for
- 14:13different labels that we call diagnoses. And the term diagnosis is confusing because again,
- 14:18in the medical field, when you have a broken bone, the diagnosis
- 14:22is pretty is you know, is you probably universally accepted among physicians. You
- 14:28know, everyone looks at, oh, broken bone, disorder of the blah
- 14:33blah blah bone. I'm guessing, or at least i'd hope that if you
- 14:37know, everyone looked at an X ray, they'd all say, yep,
- 14:39that's the diagnosis. Well, in my field, you present someone with what
- 14:45some people consider a narcissistic personality disorder to one hundred different mental health commissions and
- 14:50even ones that know what they're talking about, I guarantee you're going to get
- 14:54a lot of different opinions. Well, that's that's why it's a construct,
- 14:58and it's cultural, and it's in the ivy beholder. So take everything that
- 15:03I'm about to say with that in mind. Having said that, there are
- 15:07certain conventions that I know are are you know, established in my field that
- 15:11a lot of these websites that I'm going to critique are are going against.
- 15:16They're not they're not following the normal convention and they're not using the normal criteria,
- 15:22and they're not there the eye of their beholder is not anything close to
- 15:28what the the typical bell curve of clinicians would would exhibit. So anyway,
- 15:37all right, so Arias the Mad King Targerian a Blog of Thrones to is
- 15:41pyromania and I agree. Uh. And the second diagnosis for aries targarian schizophrenia.
- 15:48And let's go through the criteria here, all right, So you need
- 15:50two or more are the following to qualify for schizophrenia. First, you need
- 15:56delusions, that's you know, one out of the five things that you need,
- 16:00so you need two or more delusions. Yes, he had several grandiose
- 16:06paranoid health related persecatory delusions. He thought he was going to be the best
- 16:11king in history when he became king, which is you call it a grandiose
- 16:14delusion. He didn't let anyone touch him, which is a delusion of that
- 16:18touch equaled harm. He was highly suspicious of everyone, most notably Taiwan Lanister
- 16:26and Prince Regar, which is an example of paranoid delusions. So we got
- 16:33that one. Hallucinations. There's no evidence of hallucinations that I can remember from
- 16:37the books. Disorganized speech again, no evidence that I remember. Disorganized behavior.
- 16:45Yes, he had mood swings. He had strange behavior that was seemingly
- 16:49unrelated to the situations, bouts of crying, bouts of you know, getting
- 16:53super angry and explosive outbursts, and severe joy without any reason. And so
- 17:00that's what we might call disorganized behavior. Any negative symptoms, No, no
- 17:06evidence of that. So he meets two of he got two of those he
- 17:11got, So he just met the threshold of schizophrenia. There a level of
- 17:17functioning has suffered. Yes, he's not a good king at all. So
- 17:22and did it persist for six months? Uh, it's I don't remember that
- 17:27specific in the books, but I'm pretty sure it did. So. Really,
- 17:32when it comes to schizophrenia, Aris Targerian is actually a mild case.
- 17:38He does meet criteria in my opinion, and but it's it's a it's a
- 17:45mild case because he only meets the criteria somewhat. The problem is that he
- 17:52was king and could do a lot of damage with his problems, right,
- 17:56So there's that. The other diagnosis is psychopathy or antisocial personality, sir.
- 18:06In this talk that is already super long, and I'm only one character into
- 18:11this. Oh my god, how long is this going to take? I'm
- 18:15going to use psychopathy and any social personality disorder for the most part, interchangeably,
- 18:19although they are slightly different. Some people consider them to be the same
- 18:23thing in my world, and some people in my world consider them to be
- 18:26slightly different. But I'm just going to use them interchangeably because that's my preference,
- 18:30because basically, the core of psychopathy or psychopathic personality disorder in the core
- 18:37of any social personality sort or basically the same. You could argue with me
- 18:41if you want, and that's fine, but Aries Tigerian show definite signs of
- 18:47psychopathy and any social personality because just because you have paranoid delusions doesn't mean that
- 18:53you kill a bunch of people without any remorse and without any thought or any
- 19:00empathy. People with schizophrenia with paranoid delusions, they have empathy. You know,
- 19:04There's there's nothing barring someone with schizophrenia from having empathy or remorse. So
- 19:11we have to add, because Aris was just so sadistic and terrible, we
- 19:15have to probably acknowledge some level of psychopathy in any social personality sort. The
- 19:22other possibility here is paranoid personality disorder, which is you know, I've talked
- 19:29in other episodes about about personality disorders and I just have to say another caveat
- 19:36from the start is if you're not a clinician who who has expertise in personality
- 19:44disorders, I can almost guarantee you you do not know what a personality distorder
- 19:48is. Personality disorders are so confusing. It took me years to understand how
- 19:55what the authors and what all the researchers were talking about when they were talking
- 20:00about the different personality sorters. I remember taking you know, a couple years
- 20:06of school in my Masters studying different personality sorders and just really like going huh,
- 20:11And really, it wasn't until I encountered people with particular personality disorders.
- 20:18It wasn't until then that I really was like, Oh, I get it.
- 20:22And there's no YouTube video that's gonna help you, and there's no definitely
- 20:26no text that's going to help you. You have to experience these human beings
- 20:32in all of their full the full breadth of their personality, not only the
- 20:37full breath of the personality, but the way it feels to you when you
- 20:41interact with them, which is actually a pretty pretty good set of data.
- 20:47I always use the way someone makes me feel as a guide regarding personality disorders.
- 20:56So I'm going to say that as a caveat, as a BeO forward
- 20:59to that, because we're gonna because a lot of people talk about personality sorders
- 21:03on the internet, about Game of Thrones characters, and I'm gonna as well.
- 21:06But just know that in this talk I'm not going to be able to
- 21:10convey to you what that means, what personality sort does exactly mean. I
- 21:14can convey to you what schizophrenia is for the most part, I can convey
- 21:18to you what PTSD is, I can convey to you what pyramanias, I
- 21:22can convey to you what depression is. But I but personality sorders just just
- 21:26just people out there, please, for the love of God, just understand
- 21:30that unless you are an expert in that area, you don't know what it
- 21:33is. And there's no way you're gonna be able to find out. And
- 21:36there's no YouTube video and there's no article, there's nothing other than experiencing people
- 21:41in a clinical setting with clinical guidance about what you're looking at. You were
- 21:45just never going to know what that is. And the reason why I'm saying
- 21:48this is because I see a lot of people throwing on personality sort of labels.
- 21:52You know, Trump has a narcistic personality disorder, was a big one
- 21:56that has been happening a lot lately. In the past. It was well
- 21:59Bomb that had a narcissistic personality store and I just, you know, people
- 22:03just need to stop. They just need to stop that. There are things
- 22:07in the medical field, like like again getting back to the midical field,
- 22:11when when I have a broken bone and my bone is sticking out through my
- 22:15skin, I don't need to be a genius, or I don't need I
- 22:18needed, I don't need to go through a bunch of medical education to understand
- 22:22that my my bone has broken in my arm. So there are some medical
- 22:26conditions that are you know, easier to diagnose than others, whereas other kinds
- 22:33of things like I don't know, an autoimmune disorder of the you know that
- 22:37affects the lining of your intestines or something. My guess is that it's it's
- 22:44harder to you know, understand what that is, or MS or something I
- 22:51don't know. There's probably certain medical disorders that medical professionals pull their hair out
- 22:56when they look on the internet and see everyone die ignosing people with it,
- 23:00when medical professionals fully know that that's a very complicated disorder that requires an expert
- 23:07to really understand and to really look at an individual in their entirety to even
- 23:12begin to guess that they might have that medical condition. Well, personality stores
- 23:18are the same way anyway. So Harry's the mad King Targarian, you know
- 23:23you could have one could argue he suffered from paranoid personality store since he didn't
- 23:30exhibit hallucinations or disorganized speech speech or the negative symptoms that are associated with schizophrenia.
- 23:36It's possible that he had paranoid personality store instead of schizophrenia. He was
- 23:41highly paranoid. It seemed to be a persistent personality trait in him. He
- 23:45was obsessed with who was loyal and who was not, and his mood swings
- 23:51could have been a result of him feeling as though everyone was out to get
- 23:53him. So we could be seeing a paranoid personality and we're mistaking it it
- 24:00schizophrenia because it just happens to kind of look like that. Now again in
- 24:04my caveat, I said that there's no biomarker between schizophrenia and person and paranoid
- 24:11personality disorder. It's it's in the eye the beholder to some extent, and
- 24:15so so just know that, all right. So that's that's so conclusion for
- 24:21Aris the Mad King. I would say, either schizophrenia or some other psychotic
- 24:26disorder, some other disorder that of all psychosis, or paranoid personality sorder kind
- 24:30of like paranoid personality sort or some extent pyramania, definitely, but it's but
- 24:36it's a kind of a typical case to some extent, and a dash of
- 24:41antisocial personality and psychopathy, maybe traits of of it, if not, if
- 24:48the if not the full blown disorder. All right, let's go on to
- 24:52Alisir Thorn. You remember Alisair Thorn, Good old Alisair. He's the guy
- 24:56who always hated John Snow at the wall, all right. A blog of
- 25:00Thorn a blog of Thrones dot com says narcissism and quote when a person has
- 25:07an inflated sense of their own importance and complete disregard towards others, often seeing
- 25:11them as inferior to them. His speech to the Knight's Watch when announcing the
- 25:17death of John Snow confirms it as he centers most of it around himself.
- 25:22Unquote. Uh yeah, well me, What I would say is, narcissism
- 25:26is not a diagnosis. So without a standard definition, anyone can call anyone
- 25:33a narcissist. So I don't know exactly what to say to a blog of
- 25:38thrones in that way, because narcissism is these articles were all saying these are
- 25:45mental illnesses, and so just even the terminology they use just indicates it's like
- 25:49you don't even know the terms. But anyway, so narcissism is not diagnosis.
- 25:56What I would say is Alisha Thorne, there's no evidence mental illness.
- 26:00I read other articles from clinicians even that we're saying that he had a narcissistic
- 26:04personality. Stir. I mean, you know, again, with different eyes
- 26:08of beholders, you could absolutely Whenever I say that eyes of beholder, I
- 26:14think of because I'm a D and D player, the beholder I think.
- 26:18But anyway, Alisa Thorne, in my opinion, has no there's no evidence
- 26:22presented in the books that he has any mental illness at all. He's just
- 26:26massively insecure. In my opinion, he is frequently trying to humiliate and put
- 26:33down John Snow, which we see, but that's just a classic sign of
- 26:37massive insecurity. I'm guessing his father humiliated him a lot, or he was
- 26:42bullied a lot as a kid, because he bullies John Snow all the time.
- 26:48It's just a defensive projection. He's projecting his internal sense of his own
- 26:53incompetence and his own weakness onto John Snow and then attacking John. This is
- 26:59what we can call making the internal conflict external. It's a it's a it's
- 27:03a defense mechanism that that people do all the time. But that's not a
- 27:07mental illness. It's just a common defense mechanism that everyone uses. So in
- 27:11conclusion, Alisha Thorne no evidence of mental illness, and I wouldn't say narcissistic
- 27:17personality store. For whatever reason, on the Internet, everyone loves to apply
- 27:21narcissistic personality store. It's it's a very trendy thing. And I think part
- 27:27of the reason is because everyone, maybe particularly Americans, I don't know,
- 27:33everyone hates someone who brags. You know, everyone everyone hates someone who tries
- 27:38to get power, and and every and everyone hates Alers Thrown. I don't
- 27:42know. I mean it's funny, I get. I've done a lot of
- 27:45episodes on Game of Thrones for this podcast, and if you want to search
- 27:51for it, I'm putting them all, all the Game of Thrones episodes on
- 27:53Psychology and Seattle dot com. So if you go to see Psychology and Seattle
- 27:57dot com, there's a button under episodes. I believe that says like Game
- 28:03of Thrones episodes, and so they're all going to be there, because if
- 28:06you just search a form on YouTube, it might be kind of hard to
- 28:07find them or on your phone. But the point I'm making here is that
- 28:17when it comes to like evil characters like Ramsey Bolton, Ramsey Snow. People
- 28:21will email me and say, like, oh, I love Ramsey, He's
- 28:23like sexy, He's my favorite character. Well, no one ever says that
- 28:26about Ali Chathorne. Everyone hates that guy. And so when you hate someone,
- 28:33you just don't you just want to apply a mental disorder to them,
- 28:37right, You just have this kind of like, well, clearly there's something
- 28:40wrong with that guy. And there's also this massive misconception that if someone is
- 28:47being a dick, or if someone is presenting bad behavior, then they have
- 28:52to have some mental illness that causes that bad behavior. You know, some
- 29:00one goes on a killing spree, for instance, and kills a bunch of
- 29:03people. Well, it's it's it's hard for non clinicians. It's hard for
- 29:07the public to accept that that person might not have suffered from any mental illness.
- 29:14Some people will say, well, the fact that they did that,
- 29:17it means they have to have suffered from a mental illness. Well, I'm
- 29:19here to tell you no, people make all sorts of weird decisions all the
- 29:23time. And I'm not saying going on a killing spree is good. I'm
- 29:29not I'm saying, you know, in the term in terms of morality and
- 29:33evil and social good. This is an extremely terrible, terrible act done by
- 29:38a human being. Is there something different about them? Is there a psychological
- 29:45reason for why they did what they did? Yeah? Probably, But do
- 29:48they suffer from a mental illness as designated by the various mental Illnesses in the
- 29:52Diagnostic Statistical Manual, fifth Edition. No, this is it's it's possible,
- 29:59but it's also possible they don't suffer. In fact, a lot of people
- 30:02who go on these killing spreez have you know, when people actually look at
- 30:04them, there's no evidence of any disorder at all. And so Alisair Thorne
- 30:10is someone that everyone hates and he was massively, massively insecure, and he's
- 30:14a total dick to John Snow. But honestly he had his reasons, right.
- 30:17He he wanted to uphold the rule of law and the rule of tradition,
- 30:22which is to keep the wildlings out of the Southlands. Right, that's
- 30:27their mission. Their mission is to keep the wildlings, and John Snow is
- 30:32like wanting to bring all the wild things over. And so, you know,
- 30:34there was alisair Thorne wasn't alone. He had he had compatriots who hated
- 30:41John snow dead too, so it's there's there's reasons for it, and applying
- 30:48a disorder to him, I think is is short sighted. Okay, next
- 30:52character, but before we do that, let's take a break. All right,
- 31:00we're back from the break. For those of you who are not a
- 31:03patron. Become a patron now by going to patreon dot com, that's Patreon
- 31:07dot com. Become a patron of the podcast, and you get access to
- 31:11hundreds of premium episodes, including one episode, one Game of Thrones episode that
- 31:17is only available to patrons in which I in which I analyze Sandra Cligan the
- 31:23Hound. So go there, do that. Become a patron of the podcast
- 31:27to it. Now. If you are a patron of the podcast, we
- 31:30love you so much because you are an awesome person and you obviously have great
- 31:36tastes in podcasts. All right, Aria Stark, let's talk about So we've
- 31:41talked about Aris the Mad King, We've talked about Alisha Thorne, Aria Stark.
- 31:45We're not even out of the a's and we're already a half an hour
- 31:48another this podcast. My god, this is going to take forever, but
- 31:51it's so fun to talk about, you know, all right, Aria Stark.
- 31:53WhatCulture dot com? What culture dot com? A lot of people had
- 31:59a lot of things to say about Aria Stark, so and and what culture
- 32:02had a lot of things say What culture dot com? What culture said that
- 32:07Aria Stark suffers from PTSD and the symptoms that they say are regular outbursts of
- 32:15anger, difficulty controlling her aggression and emotions, difficulty falling asleep, She has
- 32:20intrusive thoughts and dreams, and she maintains a hypervigilance to danger. All right,
- 32:24well let's look at PTSD. Let's look at the specific criteria for PTSD.
- 32:32All right, first criteria A Criterion A is exposure to a threat?
- 32:38Did Was she exposed to a threat or to some kind of trauma? Yes?
- 32:43Absolutely, She's been exposed to several several horrible traumas. Okay, B.
- 32:49What is the second criteria one or more of the following? Does she
- 32:53have intrusive distressing memories as you know, as as PTSD often does. Does
- 33:01she have an intrusive distressing memories? No? I don't remember any evidence of
- 33:06her having just you know, essentially like flashbacks, right like it remembering something
- 33:12bad is not a flashback. It has to be intrusive and distressing, like
- 33:16you're a war veteran from Afghanistan and you're walking down the street and then and
- 33:22you hear a loud noise and suddenly you're transported back to a moment where your
- 33:28friend got killed and there was blood everywhere, and it's like just stuck in
- 33:31your head and you can't get and it's you know, it's it's very distressing.
- 33:36You have lots of anxiety. It feels horrible. You know. There's
- 33:39no evidence that Aria had that experience. If you've saw, if you've seen
- 33:45that in the books, then let me know about I see, all right,
- 33:47two nightmares? Was there any evidence of nightmares? I don't remember.
- 33:52Maybe maybe she did have nightmares, but I don't remember nightmares. Dissociation No,
- 33:57I'm not even going to get into explaining to association. That's kind of
- 34:00like personality stories. Association is extremely difficult to explain to people. But no,
- 34:06I didn't see any evidence of dissociation. Psychological distress from triggers. No,
- 34:12I didn't see any Does she have triggers? I didn't see any triggers
- 34:16to any kind of trauma, you know, physiological distress from triggers. No,
- 34:22I don't remember any evidence in the books of physiological distress. Physiological distress
- 34:27is like something triggers, something reminds you of a traumatic event that you've been
- 34:32through, and your body completely becomes dysregulated and you can't breathe or think or
- 34:39talk or function in those moments. And there's no evidence that she had physiological
- 34:45distress from triggers. Okay, avoidance of triggers, there's no evidence of that.
- 34:54Two of them are the following can't remember the trauma. No evidence of
- 34:58that low selvis theme, no evidence of that. In fact, she seems
- 35:02she seems to have high self esteem, as she's like ten or eleven years
- 35:07old by the end of the fifth book, and she's out there killing people
- 35:15and joining the you know, the no face people, and you know she's
- 35:22for someone that's been through so much, I would say she has very high
- 35:24self esteem, self blame, no evidence for that in an excessive manner,
- 35:31persistent negative emotional state, no evidence of that, diminished interest in things,
- 35:37no evidence of that feeling detached from others. Maybe maybe detachment from others.
- 35:43But she's around people who don't really care about her, I mean, think
- 35:45about the people as she's been around since King's landing. There's really no one
- 35:49even at King's Landing, right. I guess Edward would have been the last
- 35:52person that she would have been around. Who and that, you know,
- 35:55the water dancer, the sword dancer guy aside what was his name, like
- 36:01Curio or these people were the last people she ever was with who actually cared
- 36:07about her, you know. The hound was you know, not super warm,
- 36:10right, and the no face people, they're they're not warm at all.
- 36:15So the fact that she's detached from others might just be a product of
- 36:20the fact that she's just never been around someone that she could be close to.
- 36:23So if she were around say John Snow, maybe she would be really
- 36:28close. And so therefore she wouldn't meet this criteria. Can't experience positive emotions
- 36:34maybe, but she seemingly had fun, you know with Sandrad cook Gain,
- 36:39so it's hard to say. So she might have met a couple of those,
- 36:45but again not in a quintessential PTSD manner. Two or more the following
- 36:51irritable. I mean, she gets angry at times, but I wouldn't say
- 36:55she's like pathologically irritable, reckless or self destructed kind of. You could kind
- 37:01of make a case for that, but she's on a mission, right she
- 37:05she wants revenge. She's highly motivated, so I wouldn't call it. I
- 37:08mean, the classic kind of self destructive in reckless things one does is like
- 37:13in our modern society, is driving too fast, or drinking and driving,
- 37:17or sexual behavior with people that you don't know very well, or spending money
- 37:24faster, you know, just things like that, the things that are Ari
- 37:28is on a mission and she everything she's doing is heading in a particular direction,
- 37:32and she is succeeding. So I wouldn't say that's reckless or self destructive.
- 37:40Is she hyper vigilant? No, Again, with hyper vigilant, it's
- 37:45sort of hard to explain what that means, and this episode is already long,
- 37:47so I'm not going to explain it. But her, you know,
- 37:51she's vigilant, for sure, She's she's vigilant, but it's just not it's
- 37:53not hyper vigilant. She's she's vigilant because she is being literally hunted and tried
- 38:02to be killed by people. You know, her vigilance is totally justified.
- 38:07So that's that's not what we're talking about in the DSM. When we're talking
- 38:12about PTSD hypervigilance. The hypervigilance we're talking about from in the PTSD DSM diagnosis
- 38:19is something that is not justified usually anyway exaggerated start response, see any evidence
- 38:25of that. Problems concentrating, definitely not sleep disturbance. Maybe maybe a sleep
- 38:30disturbance. But again we're not talking about a lot of endorsed criteria for PTSD.
- 38:36So in conclusion, she does not suffered from PTSD. If you know
- 38:38what PTSD looks like, you know Aria does not present those symptoms. Now
- 38:44being affected by trauma. This is there's gonna be a lot of soapboxes.
- 38:49I'm gonna get on, get on right now. Just because you've been traumatized
- 38:53as Aria has. She's been obviously traumatized. Just because you've been traumatized does
- 38:59not mean you develop PTSD. PTSD is a very specific reaction to trauma.
- 39:05There are many reactions to trauma, most of which are not in the DSM.
- 39:10Let me think if I can come up with a good analogy that involves
- 39:14the bone breaking thing. Okay, so let's say you're on your roof and
- 39:17you fall off your roof. Well, one of the possible results of falling
- 39:22off your roof is breaking the bone in your arm right, But there's also
- 39:27a lot of other kinds of things that could happen to you that would be
- 39:31in addition to breaking your arm, or instead of breaking arm, you could
- 39:36break your leg, or you could break your back, or you could have
- 39:39a brain hemorrhage, or you could sprain something, or you could have a
- 39:45contusion or a laceration or what other kind of random medical terminology can I make
- 39:52up here? So, when someone goes through a trauma, a psychological trauma
- 40:00PTSD is but one reaction, and there are many reactions to trauma, most
- 40:06of which are not described in the DSM. And that's a problem in my
- 40:08opinion. I think because the DSM is such a widely used instrument for understanding
- 40:17the human nature, which is a travesty. But because it's used as a
- 40:22way to understand human nature, it should include other kinds of traumatic traumatic reactions
- 40:29because there's so many kinds. Anyway, getting back to what culture, So,
- 40:35what culture dot com says PTSD? I say no, what culture dot
- 40:38com also says obsessive compulsive disorder or OCD, And to this is one of
- 40:45my very first so PTSD. When someone applies that to Aria, I'm just
- 40:50like I can imagine clinicians who don't know what they're doing doing that. In
- 40:53fact, I have supervises who will diagnose people with PTSD and then I'm like,
- 41:00so tell me which criteria they meet, and they're like, well,
- 41:04you know, they've been traumatized and they're kind of anxious, and I'm like
- 41:07that PTSD is a very long disorder, has a lot of crimes. It's
- 41:12one of the longest lists of criteria in the DSM. And you can't just
- 41:17say they were traumatized and they're anxious. That's not enough to justify a label
- 41:22of PTSD. You're going to have to go back to the client and assess
- 41:25that person if that's what you want to do. So clinicians will do this,
- 41:30especially nom as clinicians, But when it comes to OCD, I feel
- 41:34like most people understand what that is. And in this article, they're basically
- 41:39saying, well, because she has this obsessive death list that she says every
- 41:44night before she falls asleep, that justifies OCD. And I just have to
- 41:46say, like, that is just the dumbest thing I've ever heard. Well,
- 41:50I've heard a lot of dumb things. It's one of the dumbest things
- 41:52I've ever heard obsessions? Let me explain what obsessions are. Obsessions are This
- 41:58is D sign language. Recurrent and persistent thoughts, urges or images that are
- 42:02experienced as intrusive and unwanted, and that in most individuals cause distress and the
- 42:08individual attempts to ignore or suppress those thoughts and urges or images. So again,
- 42:15recurrent and persistent thoughts, thoughts, urges or images that are experienced as
- 42:22intrusive and unwanted. So as she goes to bed at night, when she
- 42:25is reciting her death list, is that a intrusive thought? No? Is
- 42:32that an intrusive or unwanted urge? No, she wants that urge. It's
- 42:38justified. These people have done horrible things to her, and she has reasons
- 42:44to get revenge. In fact, I would say most of us reading the
- 42:46books and watching the TV show are hoping that Aria actually succeeds in doing this
- 42:52sort of thing. So in some ways it's a justifiable revenge motivation. How
- 42:59is that? How that related to OCD? Like if you woke up in
- 43:02the morning and said today I'm going to have a good day, and every
- 43:07day you said that, or every night before you went to bed, you
- 43:10thanked God for all the good things that are happening in your life. Is
- 43:15that OCD? No, that's just something you do before you go to bed.
- 43:19It's stupid that someone would think that's OCD. It's just dumb. Okay.
- 43:22The next label that WhatCulture dot com says is codependent with the hound.
- 43:28So they think that Ariostark is codependent with the hound. Okay, Yeah,
- 43:35another stupid thing. Codependent is not a diagnosis, So why are they presenting
- 43:39it as such? I think what if they're trying to use a diagnosis,
- 43:43they would want to use. Dependent personality disor codependent is a word from alcoholics
- 43:47anonymous that usually refers to the spouse of a dependent person, hence the word
- 43:52codependent, as in copilot. So you have an alcohol, you have an
- 43:58alcohol, you have someone who's the pendent on alcohol, and the spouse is
- 44:02the codependent, like copilot. Just because she found a friend, just because
- 44:07Aria Stark found a friend, they have to pathologize that. But we all
- 44:14need people. Imagine that you're ten years old and everyone is out to kill
- 44:17you, wouldn't you latch on to someone, anyone who was at least partially
- 44:22on your side, like the hound was. This is just another example of
- 44:27how Westerners pathologize healthy attachment. Aria is reaching out to someone who is literally
- 44:34going to save her life and bring her back to her family, and she
- 44:38kind of likes the guy, and so how do you call that fucking codependence?
- 44:43So dumb? Okay, WhatCulture dot com continuing to diagnose Aria Stark dissociative
- 44:51identity disorder otherwise known as in the past multiple personalities sir quote let's not even
- 44:58get into dissociative identity disorder thing in her latest storyline with the Faceless Men unquote.
- 45:07Okay, just more stupidity here. Let's look at the criteria four dissociative
- 45:12identity disorder disruption of identity by two or more distinct personality states with discontinuity and
- 45:19sensive self. Does she have that No? Does she have recurrent gaps of
- 45:22memory? No? Does she have significant distress from these memory gaps or from
- 45:29disruption of identity No. Dissociative identity similar to personality disorders, similar to just
- 45:36general dissociation, is extremely difficult for me to explain probably best. Well,
- 45:39actually, I do have another podcast episode in which we talk about Actually there's
- 45:45two episodes, one in which we talk about associateive identity disorder in the movie
- 45:49Split, and one in which you talk about dissociative idity disorder in the movie
- 45:53Fight Club. So go out and listen to those if you want to.
- 45:58But dissociative ident disorder is a you know, it's a legit thing that happens
- 46:01to people. And to call Aria stark as suffering from dissociative ideita disorder because
- 46:06she disguises herself as different people, it's just the dumbest thing ever heard.
- 46:09I mean, my godpeople. Okay, MTV dot com thinks that she has
- 46:15PTSD because she's stuck in survival mode. And this so the MTV quotes are
- 46:22front the MTV actually reached out to an actual clinician, I think a mental
- 46:24health counselor and a licensement health counselor actually like provide. I'm not going to
- 46:29call out these people's names because I don't see the point of that. But
- 46:32MTV quotes just remember actual clinician being stuck PTSD because she's stuck in survival mode.
- 46:40She's recited, she's reciting that list, she's replaying all those traumas that
- 46:45have happened to her. Her brain isn't being rational. It's stuck in an
- 46:49emotional hemisphere. It's stuck in an emotional hemisphere. What the frick does that
- 46:52mean? It's all anger and fear all the time. Okay, so that's
- 46:57what they're saying. Again, just because someone has been through a trauma and
- 47:00just because they're angry, that doesn't mean they have PTSD is just the stupidest
- 47:05thing. I mean, my god, people, someone someone you know,
- 47:07they encounter a trauma and they get angry, that means they have PTSD.
- 47:12This just so stupid. What you remember all the criteria that I listed off,
- 47:15and I'll just again, I'm just gonna rattle them off real really fast.
- 47:21Intrusive distressing memories like flashbacks, nightmares, dissociation, psychological distress from triggers,
- 47:27physiological distress from triggers, avoidance of triggers, can't remember the trauma,
- 47:31low self esteem, self blame, persistent negative emotional states, diminished interest in
- 47:37things, feeling detached from others, can't experience positive emotions, irritability, reckless,
- 47:42self destructive, hypervigilance, exaggerated starter response problems, concentrating sleep disturbances.
- 47:49Now you don't have to meet all those criteria, but you have to meet
- 47:51a number of them, and she doesn't have any of those things. She's
- 47:54she's been through a trauma and she's angry, and therefore she has PTSD.
- 48:00Good boy, Okay, A blog of Thrones, what do they say?
- 48:06Okay, get this? Get this a blog of thrones. A blog of
- 48:10Thrones says that Aria Stark has schizophrenia slash multiple personality sort. In the article
- 48:19there's they're saying that schizophrenia and multiple personality sort are the same thing. Quote
- 48:27Aria stark struggle with her own identity versus the one the faces man want her
- 48:31to take creates this personality conflict within her unquote my god, dumb to dumb
- 48:38dumb dumb idiots. These are completely different disorders. One. Two. We
- 48:43don't use the term multiple personality sorder anymore, but I'll forgive that. It's
- 48:45fine you can utilize that term. I still use Munchausen by proxy because I
- 48:51like it. It's now called factitious disorder imposed on another. But anyway,
- 48:58uh so a blog A blog of Throne thinks that schizophrenia and multi personality sort
- 49:01of same thing. They're not. One and two. She doesn't suffer from
- 49:06either. One of those things is they're extremely specific disorders. And I just
- 49:10wonder what this author did. Did they just go on Wikipedia and just like
- 49:15glance at the criteria and go like, yeah, it looks about right,
- 49:19you know, you know, it'd be like be like be as a non
- 49:23physician. You know, like someone's kind of sick and they they're sniffling,
- 49:29and I'm like, I go on the Internet and I'm like, yeah,
- 49:30it looks like HIV. You know you have HIV. Like oh, okay,
- 49:37So again, what do I say Aria has? I would say she
- 49:42has nothing. She doesn't suffer from any mental disorder at all. She is
- 49:47actually highly adaptive to her situation. She is actually quite resilient to the traumas
- 49:55that she's been that she's been through. She is she's she gets disheartened at
- 50:01times, and she gets angry at times, and she is suffering at times.
- 50:07But that's life, you know, that's grief. That's reacting to life.
- 50:13You know, if if someone steps on your toe and you get angry,
- 50:16is that a mental illness that you have? No, you're getting angry
- 50:20because someone stepped on your toe. You know, it's it's a it's it's
- 50:23normal life. You don't have to pathologize that. And Aria Stark, in
- 50:28my opinion, does not suffer from schizophrenia. My god, how stupid.
- 50:31She doesn't suffer from multiple personality disorder PTSD, associate of identity disorder, codependency,
- 50:37which is in a thing, obsessive compulsive disorder. My god, No,
- 50:42she doesn't suffer from many of these things. She's she's got a clean
- 50:45bill of mental health. Now is she a healthy individual? Is she living
- 50:49a healthy life? That is debatable is does she have issues? Clearly that
- 50:55girl is going to need therapy for a long time after this is all over.
- 51:00But that doesn't mean she has a mental illness. I guess you could
- 51:05make the argument she has an adjustment disorder. Maybe, I guess a lot
- 51:07of these people you could, because adjustment disorders kind of have low criteria at
- 51:10times, depending on your point of view. But I'm gonna not go down
- 51:15that road. Okay, next character Brand Stark brand, you know brand good
- 51:20old brand. There goes a loud, very loud motorcycle that annoys me outside
- 51:25my window. Okay, Brand Stark, a blog of Thrones dot Com says,
- 51:30psychoticism quote a generic psychiatric term in which a person starts losing contact with
- 51:38reality. Brand is training is Brand is training to have visions through the warewood
- 51:44trees with the three eyed Raven unquote. So psychoticism is what a Blog of
- 51:52Thrones says, Brand Stark is suffering from, uh, just stupid beyond belief.
- 52:00The term psychoticism has a number of different old definitions, and most people
- 52:04don't even use this term anymore. So, I given the track record of
- 52:07Blog of Thrones has presented so far, I'm really trying to figure out where
- 52:10they even got that term from. I would guess that most clinicians don't even
- 52:15know what psychoticism means or have never even heard it before. One definition of
- 52:22psychoticism is psychopathic traits to some degree, even small, you know, like
- 52:29a degree of psych of psychopathy. And Brand is definitely not psychopathic. He's
- 52:36one of the most empathetic carrying people in Westros. But what I think A
- 52:39Blog of Thrones meant was psychotic. They confuse psychotic or psychosis with psychoticism.
- 52:49Since they said that he's quote unquote losing touch with reality, losing contact with
- 52:53reality, this is additionally stupid. He's actually tapping into his powers, which
- 53:00helps him to see far away and across time. He's not He's not psychotic.
- 53:04He he literally has magical powers. So how how is he losing touch
- 53:09with reality when he you know, this is a magical world and they have
- 53:13magical things. Uh. If Brand came into a and you know, to
- 53:17what they live on some other planet literally, So if Brand somehow transported himself
- 53:23to our galaxy and came to our one of our mental hospitals and reported that
- 53:29he could see through time and you know, he could meld with a tree
- 53:32and blah blah blah, yeah, people would think potential psychosis. But he
- 53:39he has those powers, so he doesn't have that issue. So in conclusion,
- 53:45Brand Stark, no diagnosis. Don't be stupid, okay. Brian of
- 53:47Tarth, Brianne of Tarth. Oh boy, let's get into this one.
- 53:53A blog of Thrones says, masculinity complex slash tomboyism. Masculinity complex slash tomboyism
- 54:05quote, or, as Sigmund Freud worded it, penis envy when a girl
- 54:08addresses and behaves like a boy to find significance in her life. Unquote.
- 54:15Uh, this this is you know, this is stupid too, but there
- 54:19is actually some merit to what they're saying if they are utilizing some definitions of
- 54:27classical Fredian talk. So but again there's no DSM diagnosis. I think a
- 54:35Blog of Thrones even on their website, they were talking about how these were
- 54:37actually medical conditions. I don't even think they were referring to them as mental
- 54:42health issues. So there's that. So if we're looking at if we're if
- 54:46we're looking at Brian as uh, you know, as having a mental illness
- 54:52called masculinity complex or tomboyism, then that's completely stupid. But if we're looking
- 54:58at Brian it bring and saying she's got issues like uh a, Matt,
- 55:04she has a complex with with gender, she is a tomboy, and she
- 55:08has penis envy, then then let's get into that. So first off,
- 55:14penis envy is not dressing up as a boy. That's not what that means.
- 55:17It's way more complicated than that. Uh. I'm not super into the
- 55:22psychosexual stages of classic psychoanalysis, so I couldn't even go on for a long
- 55:30time about it if I wanted to. But the the the bit I do
- 55:34know about it, it's it's not just simply dressing up as a boy.
- 55:37Plus almost no one uses the construct of penis NV, even psychoanalysts anymore.
- 55:45So and I'm a psychodynamic person, and so penis env it just isn't used
- 55:51anymore. But you know, if you wanted to use that then and and
- 55:53you uh, your your right up on blog of Thrones dot com is not
- 55:59sufficient to convince me that you understand what what penis entity is. But if
- 56:05you provided one, it'd you know, be open to reading that. Let's
- 56:07move on to masculinity complex. I've never even heard of this before. I've
- 56:12heard of masculinity and femininity inferiority complex, which refers to women who be you
- 56:19know, so femininity inferiority complex is you know, an obvious term that refers
- 56:24to when women become masculine because they have been made to feel as though femininity
- 56:30is inferior. So is does she have a masculinity complex? Yeah? Maybe
- 56:35you know? Or does she have a sorry, a femininity inferior inferiority complex?
- 56:40Yeah, I mean you could. You can make an argument for that.
- 56:43Tomboyism. I'd never even heard that term before I looked it up.
- 56:47It actually is kind of a term that some people use. Again, not
- 56:51a disorder as any of these things are. It's it's not a mental illness
- 56:55to dress and act like a culture really different gender than you are or what
- 57:04people say you are. And so I don't know why we have to label
- 57:07someone as a tomboy. As a child, she tried to conform to female
- 57:13norms. She as a child, she was actually very much trying to be
- 57:16a proper lady. She was ridiculed though, because everyone thought she was too
- 57:23tall and too ugly. In the books, they describe her as much more
- 57:28ugly as they portray her on the TV show. In the TV show,
- 57:30she's actually attractive, you know. Gwendolyn Christi is a you know, she's
- 57:35a pretty lady. But in the books she In fact, when I saw
- 57:39the actress who was going to play Brienne, I was like, oh no,
- 57:44I mean she's tall and she seems fierce, but she's not ugly enough.
- 57:49I mean the vision I had in my mind when I was reading the
- 57:52books, I was like, boy, this woman must be, you know,
- 57:54pretty ugly. And I think, you know, if they cast an
- 57:59ugly character, I think it would have been more compelling. But of course
- 58:04it's a TV show, and so, you know, in the same way
- 58:06that theon Gray Joy in the books after being tortured, is a disgusting human
- 58:13being. I mean, he's lost most of his teeth, lost most of
- 58:16his fingers, most of his toes, his hair has gone white, he's
- 58:21lost, you know, thirty pounds. He doesn't walk right, he doesn't
- 58:25look right. He looks sixty years he looks forty years older. Well,
- 58:30in the TV show, he looks exactly the same, because if you deformed
- 58:36him, it'd be hard to look at him, you know, and so
- 58:38TV shows usually do that. But anyway, so as a child, she
- 58:43tried to conform to female norms, but everyone made fun of her because she
- 58:47was ugly and tall. So she started to fight people, and she found
- 58:51that she was good at fighting people, and so she tried to fight in
- 58:54tournaments and stuff, and she was good. So she stuck with that and
- 58:58she became perhaps the best knight in all of Ustros. So that's her progression
- 59:04into that. It has nothing to do with her psychology or you know,
- 59:07any mental illness or what we might call tomboyism or something. It's just,
- 59:13you know, she deep down probably wants to fit into society, but they
- 59:17didn't let her fit in, so she decided to do something else. You
- 59:22know. Now, some might say that she has gender dysphoria, which is
- 59:28in the DSM five. But if you know what that looks like, you
- 59:31know that she doesn't have gender dysphoria. She's a heterosexual, cisgender woman who
- 59:37decided to become a knight because that gave her self esteem because everyone was making
- 59:40fun of how tall and ugly she was. It'd be like if a woman
- 59:45decided to join the NFL and she was one of the best linebackers in the
- 59:49league. Is that a mental illness? No? Is that gender dysphoria?
- 59:52No? Is it tomboyism or a femininity inferiority complex? I wouldn't say.
- 59:59Is it p this envy? I mean, I don't know why we have
- 1:00:01to apply any of these labels to it. So, in conclusion, Brian
- 1:00:06does not have any evidence of mental illness. She she's been traumatized a lot
- 1:00:12at being bullied and whatnot. Does she have issues? Does she have self
- 1:00:15esteem issues? Does she have I don't know, self worth issues. You
- 1:00:20know, maybe, but that's not mental illness. Those all of us have
- 1:00:23self esteem issues to some extent. All Right, Let's take a break,
- 1:00:28and when we get back, let's go to Circe. Lanister, my god,
- 1:00:30this episode is going to take forever. I'm only on the letter C.
- 1:00:34Oh my god, let's take a break. Okay, we're back on
- 1:00:42the From the break, we're going to talk about Circe. We're only on
- 1:00:45the letter C. And this episode, I have now decided, is probably
- 1:00:49going to take five hours. So, oh boy. I hate doing part
- 1:00:53episodes. I don't know why I hate doing episodes and parts, but because
- 1:00:59you know, when you find part two and you're like, wait, where's
- 1:01:00part one? I don't like that. As a consumer of podcasts, I'd
- 1:01:05rather just like have it all in one file, I guess, and so
- 1:01:08I've always done just one files anyway. Also, before talking about Circe,
- 1:01:15the answer again, become a patron. Please go to patreon dot com.
- 1:01:17Support the podcast, support art, support your stuff. I'm not calling this
- 1:01:22art, by the way, but a lot of people doing art on Patreon,
- 1:01:24but support podcasts. You know, I do this. It takes me
- 1:01:29hours and hours and hours too, especially for an episode like this to prep.
- 1:01:31And so the only reason why I'm doing this and the only reason why
- 1:01:36I'm dedicating all this time is because about five hundred of you or four hundred
- 1:01:39of you have become patrons of this podcast, and so that justifies me taking
- 1:01:46time away from my practice essentially to dedicate all this time to you. All
- 1:01:52right, circelanister, WhatCulture dot com? Let's see what they say. What
- 1:01:57culture dot com says about see narcissistic personality disorder with Macavilion tendencies. They write,
- 1:02:07It's a textbook case of narcissistic personality disorder. She is almost completely consumed
- 1:02:12by a pathological need for power, success and status and has precisely zero problems
- 1:02:15stepping on whomever she needs to in order to get it. She has a
- 1:02:20complete lack of empathy. She has cruel, self obsessed, controlling, haughty,
- 1:02:23power hungry, exploitative, and ruthless. Okay, so let's look into
- 1:02:29this. What do I say, Well, sort of, but I would
- 1:02:31say not really. But you know, one could make the argument for narcissistic
- 1:02:37personality sort but let's look at the criteria here, A grandiose sense of self
- 1:02:43importance. Again, as I said earlier, when we talk about personality disorders,
- 1:02:49these are hard things for clinicians to understand, let alone someone who's looking
- 1:02:53it up on the Internet or listening to a podcast about it. So what
- 1:02:59different centiates grandiose sense of self importance from, you know, someone who does
- 1:03:06not have narcissistic personality disorders to someone who does. This is a very difficult
- 1:03:10thing to describe and understand. But does Circe anister have a grandiose self sense
- 1:03:19of self importance like exaggerating achievements, exaggerating counts? You know, like I
- 1:03:27invented the Internet for instance. You know that's one exaggerated achievement. You know,
- 1:03:30you did not invent the internet or expects to be recognized as superior without
- 1:03:38the commensurate achievements. So you know, you're I don't know, let's see,
- 1:03:45you're you're not a very fast runner, but you expect people to think
- 1:03:51of you as the fastest runner of the planet. Okay, that's that's there's
- 1:03:53something wrong with you if if that's how it is, you know, does
- 1:03:59Circe exhibit this behavior. No, she is the effing Queen of Westros.
- 1:04:04The society worships her, and she doesn't exaggerate anything, So she has no
- 1:04:11grandiose sense that she you know, she is self important. She's the queen
- 1:04:15so and Before she was the queen, she was a princess or a you
- 1:04:20know, a lady or whatever they call it, you know in the house
- 1:04:25Lanister. She was, you know, a daughter of Taiwan Lanister, one
- 1:04:30of the most powerful men in the known world. So does she have a
- 1:04:33grandiose sense of some self importance. No, she's queen. She everyone says
- 1:04:39she's important. She does have importance. Okay, number two preoccupied with fantasies
- 1:04:45of unlimited success, power, brilliance, beauty or ideal love. Again,
- 1:04:50in my opinion, we're talking about either beholder. But no, she doesn't
- 1:04:54meet this criteria. Again, she's the efing Queen of Westros. She already
- 1:04:59has power. She didn't want any more power than that. Everything started to
- 1:05:03go downhill for her when she was forced to marry Robert, who didn't even
- 1:05:08like her, and he also beat her, so she turned to Jamie for
- 1:05:14comfort and they had three kids, maybe by accident, I'm not sure.
- 1:05:17And when John Aaron and Edward threatened to out her secrets, which would have
- 1:05:25resulted in her death and the death of her children because King Robert would have
- 1:05:28killed her and killed the children. When John Aaron and Edward Stark threatened to
- 1:05:33out her. She did what would she at least considered what people would consider
- 1:05:41to do, which is to kill John Aaron and kill Edward Stark, which
- 1:05:44is what she did to protect her protect herself. She was ruthless, and
- 1:05:48she exhibited several degrees of lack of empathy and remorse. But if you understand
- 1:05:56her circumstances, you see that her back was up against the wall. Now,
- 1:06:00later she kills all those people with wild fire, not in the books
- 1:06:04but in the TV show, but again she was facing the likelihood of imprisonment
- 1:06:09or death. Again, her back was up against the wall. If anything,
- 1:06:14she has antisocial personality disorder because she doesn't seem to care about the people
- 1:06:17that she harms. But in my opinion, she's just trying to preserve her
- 1:06:20own life and the lives of her children, which is what everyone would do,
- 1:06:27and particularly in this world. I mean, this world is a brutal,
- 1:06:30ruthless place and a lot of people in her shoes would have done the
- 1:06:34same. So does this mean she has narcissistic personality disorder? In my opinion,
- 1:06:41no, although a lot of people thought she had narcissistic personality stort.
- 1:06:45If you want to call her narcissistic, then fine. You know, if
- 1:06:50you want to call her mean and unkind and self centered, then fine,
- 1:06:55But that's not narcissistic personality disorder. Although you could argue that she had traits
- 1:07:00of narcissistic personality sort because she lacked empathy, she was arrogant, she did
- 1:07:06look down on other people, and she did consider Jamie to be the only
- 1:07:11one worthy of her love. And in the books he looks exactly like her.
- 1:07:15When they were kids, no one could tell the difference between them.
- 1:07:17So she's, you know, self centered enough that she only thinks that Jamie
- 1:07:23is worthy of her love, although she did actually love Robert before he became
- 1:07:28a dick to her. So yeah, you could make the argument for narcissism.
- 1:07:34You could even make the argument for narcissist the personality. But honestly,
- 1:07:39when you clinically encounter people with narcissistic personnaity S order, they don't present the
- 1:07:44way Sirce does. And again that's just one of those things you're just gonna
- 1:07:47have to believe me on because again, persona I disorders are extremely complex and
- 1:07:53hard to describe. I guarantee you've probably run across someone with narcissistic personality disorder,
- 1:07:59but you probably didn't know that that's what it was. It's a very
- 1:08:01particular presentation. Maybe I'll do an episode on that. In fact, I
- 1:08:06know I will at some point because it's a hot topic in today's media.
- 1:08:11All right, let's see what MTV dot com says about Circe Lanister again,
- 1:08:16actual cindition being interviewed. The clinician diagnosed her with borderline, not borderline personality
- 1:08:24sort or just the word borderline. She overidentifies with her children, This is
- 1:08:29what they're saying. She overidentifies with her children, especially Jeoffrey, and is
- 1:08:32complicit in helping him stay in power because it helps her stay important. But
- 1:08:36you can see it most clearly in her relationship with Jamie. It's an I
- 1:08:41hate you, don't leave me. They push, pull, back and forth,
- 1:08:44and of course their sexual relationship. Borderlines gravitate toward risky behavior, anything
- 1:08:49that releases endorphins, risky sex, gambling, drugs. The brain registered these
- 1:08:55registers these things as solutions rather than risks. End of quote. What would
- 1:09:00I say about borderline? You know, maybe, but if you understand the
- 1:09:04history of Circe, you would know that her reasons for being like this is
- 1:09:12there are reasons, you know, you should listen to my long episode in
- 1:09:15which I did I don't know, a couple hours on Circe. She was
- 1:09:21very close to Jamie for some very justifiable reasons. Also, she wasn't overly
- 1:09:29emotional when betrayed. She never decompensated. You know, she gets revenge like
- 1:09:33the way Aria does, but that's not borderline. Getting revenge, you know,
- 1:09:39isn't necessarily borderline. When people with borderline person I sort of when they're
- 1:09:45betrayed, they become emotionally unhinged because they've been traumatized. Remember how I said
- 1:09:53you fall off her roof. There's a lot of different diagnoses that can happen.
- 1:09:57Well, when you become traumatized, one of the things that can happen
- 1:09:59is you can developed borderline personnel. You saw so and I consider it at
- 1:10:06its base a traumatic reaction. And so when you are rejected, even even
- 1:10:15the hint of a possible rejection as an adult, it triggers those childhood,
- 1:10:19deep deep childhood traumas regarding being rejected and abandoned or abused as a child.
- 1:10:26Over time and you start to re experience all those feelings of just being empty
- 1:10:31and alone and not good enough and angry and hurt and afraid and just all
- 1:10:36those things. And then you decompensate emotionally, and you know, your personality
- 1:10:42becomes unhinged and you become extremely emotionally erratic and upset, and you might get
- 1:10:48angry and stuff. Sirce never did that. There was no decompensation from Circe.
- 1:10:55She was very calm and cool and collected well being. Having borderline personality
- 1:11:01disorder is not typically associated with being calm and cool and collected. It's really
- 1:11:08the opposite. So so again, a borderline personality disorder doesn't really fit the
- 1:11:15bill. But in the books she is much more paranoid than she exhibits in
- 1:11:23the TV show, particularly when Tommin was king. She's totally convinced that many
- 1:11:27people are out to betray her, which is, you know, it's a
- 1:11:30minor sign of borderline personality. But really, if you have any experience of
- 1:11:33borderline you would know that she doesn't fit the profile. So MTV dot com
- 1:11:38borderline conclusion stupid. So so what's the what's the the final thing? Oh
- 1:11:48no, there's a couple other There's there's another website here, a blog of
- 1:11:51Thrones. What does the blog of Thrones say? They say alcoholism because of
- 1:11:57excessive and compulsive drinking that leads to psychological and physical addiction unquote me the sort
- 1:12:02of old language, but you know, the psychological and physical addiction bit.
- 1:12:06But you know it's fine. Also, it's it's not called alcoholism in the
- 1:12:12DSM, it's called alcohol use disorder. But we don't really know if she
- 1:12:18was actually addicted. It's hard to say, but I'll get more into that
- 1:12:23in a second. I think, what do so in conclusion about Circe.
- 1:12:29Circe suffers from antisocial personality sort, or what we might call that's not in
- 1:12:34the DSM psychopathic personality sort. However, her diagnosis presentation, her diagnostic presentation
- 1:12:42is complicated by the fact that she's a woman who has been continually marginalized and
- 1:12:45abused, most notably by her father and her husband, and kind of by
- 1:12:50society. Also, she is surrounded by a context that values power, specifically
- 1:12:57royal power, so her psycho pathic antisocial behavior could be a result of circumstances
- 1:13:02and culture rather than her personality. Most of her major antisocial acts have been
- 1:13:09instrumental in gaining power and could be considered acts of survival. From her perspective,
- 1:13:15she also suffered from alcohol use disorder since she appeared to drink every day
- 1:13:20throughout the day. But it's hard to say if she had any ill effects
- 1:13:25from her drinking, which is a criterion for the disorder of alcohol use disorder.
- 1:13:30But that's really common to fictional depictions of alcohol use. They really show
- 1:13:34any negative effects. You know, people like Tyrian. Is there one time
- 1:13:40you show they showed a negative effect is when he vomited That one time when
- 1:13:45he was when he landed in you know, across the Narrow Sea Ravosi,
- 1:13:49I think they were in anyway. The rest of the time, they just
- 1:13:53never show any ill effects. You know, Tyrian and Circe are drinking wine
- 1:13:58all the time, and that they see to get a little bit more lush.
- 1:14:01They seem to get a little bit more bold and cynical when they drink,
- 1:14:08which you know might be something that people do when they drink. But
- 1:14:12in the movies they rarely show like the reality of alcoholism. You know that
- 1:14:18it actually produces slurred speech, bad choices, difficulty thinking, massive hangovers,
- 1:14:30just compulsive drinking in the face of consequences, not making any sense. Losing
- 1:14:35your temper. You know, there's a lot of things that you see in
- 1:14:39the real world with persistent alcohol use that you just don't see in depictions and
- 1:14:45fictional depictions, probably because it's just not fun to see that, I guess,
- 1:14:47I don't know. The way they portray drinking in the in the movies
- 1:14:51and TV shows, it always just seems so glamorous, you know, it's
- 1:14:54like, oh, that sounds fun. I'm gonna be Tearyan and I'm going
- 1:14:57to be you know, king of Wine or what does he call himself,
- 1:15:00King of wine and tits or something. So getting back to Circe, some
- 1:15:04might label Circe as suffering from borderline or narcissistic personal disorder or some other personality,
- 1:15:12but in my opinion, she is, you know, for the most
- 1:15:15part, below the threshold that is required for those labels. So in conclusion,
- 1:15:20Circe, there's really not any evidence, not enough at evidence, for
- 1:15:26any mental disorder, antisocial, borderline, narcissistic personality traits, but not the
- 1:15:32full order full disorders. You know, she certainly exhibited a lack of empathy
- 1:15:36and harmed other people. She exhibited some sensitivity to rejection and some push pull
- 1:15:45with Jamie. She exhibits some self centeredness, but she, in my opinion,
- 1:15:50does not fit the full criteria for those disorders. Again, it's particularly
- 1:15:56that the one you could say is anti social. But again when you look
- 1:15:59at her spec choices, and I didn't go through the books again, but
- 1:16:03from my memory in the books and her decisions, she made a lot of
- 1:16:08decisions that made sense to her survival. And again sometimes she was being threatened
- 1:16:16with death or at the very least a life of servitude or being a poor
- 1:16:23person somewhere, you know. So I wouldn't say she has any sort of
- 1:16:29personality sort. Does she have alcohol use disorder? Probably, but the books
- 1:16:34just don't give us enough data to make that decision, you know, could
- 1:16:38she stop at any time? Does she actually drink all day every day?
- 1:16:43Is it presenting any negative effects for her? It's just, you know,
- 1:16:46they don't give us enough data. So in conclusion, circe no diagnosis,
- 1:16:53but antisocial, borderline narcissistic traits and a very good possibility for alcohol use disorder.
- 1:17:00Okay, let's going on to Denaries finally at the letter D. How
- 1:17:02long is this episode going to? WhatCulture dot Com says that Denaries is sane,
- 1:17:09they say, despite her gene pool being as shallow as a bird bath.
- 1:17:14I like that line. She is as well adjusted as she is,
- 1:17:16as well adjusted as you could hope for a woman who has been sold by
- 1:17:23her brother, gave birth to a deformed dead baby, and owns a trio
- 1:17:28of dragons. As a powerful queen, she is inevitably she is inevitably a
- 1:17:32bit forceful, but not mentally ill. MTV also said she's sane, she's
- 1:17:38not narcissistic, and she's very empathy empathic they say. Psychology today also gives
- 1:17:46no diagnosis to Denaries. They say she's one of the most stable, well
- 1:17:50adjusted characters in the Game of Thrones universe. She isn't overly anxious, doesn't
- 1:17:56have multiple personalities, and doesn't suffer too much from her past trauma. So
- 1:18:00I have a confession to make. Try as I might, the DSM five
- 1:18:03doesn't give me anything to work with. I find that so unquote. I
- 1:18:09find that that line is sort of telling right the So psychology today presumably a
- 1:18:14clinician is writing this one. I'm pretty sure on that and this writer,
- 1:18:18they say, try as I might, I can't diagnose Denaries with anything.
- 1:18:24I find that interesting. Try as I might, Why are you trying so
- 1:18:28hard to diagnize? I think that's one of the things about these websites.
- 1:18:30It's like you ask someone, Okay, what you know, what mental illness
- 1:18:33does Denari suffer from? Like there's this compulsion to like just come up with
- 1:18:36something. You know. How how about be a clinician and say she it's
- 1:18:42fine, she doesn't have anything, you know, Like, why why do
- 1:18:45you have to do that? If anything, you should be extremely conservative when
- 1:18:50doling out complicated labels, like you know, personality stores. So what's my
- 1:18:57opinion? Yeah, I agree, there's no evidence of mental illness. I
- 1:19:00suspect that everyone is being very careful about diagnosing Denaries because they like her.
- 1:19:08That's that, and because the Jesus doesn't show any of the kind of triggers
- 1:19:11that would cause people to diagnose. But I find it interesting that no one
- 1:19:15on the internet that I was looking at all these various sites, that no
- 1:19:18one is disgusting that she might have narcissistic personality. If Circe and Alisair are
- 1:19:27so clearly narcissistic to people, then why not Denaries. Denaries is just as
- 1:19:31power hungry as Circe. If not more. Denaries kills a lot of people
- 1:19:36to gain power. Now she also frees a lot of slaves and does a
- 1:19:41lot of what we would consider to be morally good things. But you know,
- 1:19:44she's done. She's killed a lot of people, all because she wants
- 1:19:46to rule Westros. You know, she is hell bent on killing people so
- 1:19:54that she can go back to Westros to kill a bunch more people so that
- 1:19:58she can sit because she wants to sit in the iron throne, you know,
- 1:20:00because she deserves it. And that no one is talking about narcissism and
- 1:20:05that I mean, I wouldn't say she's narcissistic, But with all the loose
- 1:20:09talk on the internet about narcissism, why is there zero talk about Denaris being
- 1:20:14narcissistic? It is just interesting. I think it's because people like her,
- 1:20:16you know. And again it shows that when you don't like someone, you
- 1:20:21want to diagnose him, all right, Grand Measter, Piscell, Grand Mester,
- 1:20:28Piscel. He is the sort of asshole, maister. A Blog of
- 1:20:35Thrones says, malingerer quote a person that fakes illness or exaggerates symptoms for personal
- 1:20:43gain or to avoid work and duty. Unquote. What would I say,
- 1:20:47yes, he is mallingering, but mallingerer is not a diagnosis. The term
- 1:20:55in the DSM is factitious disorder imposed on self. And as I was preparing
- 1:21:03to talk about Grand Master Piscel, I realized that I screwed up the Munchausen
- 1:21:09by Proxy episode in which I talked about Munchausen by Proxy and I also talked
- 1:21:13about that documentary Mommy Dead and Dearest, because I kept saying, I kept
- 1:21:20saying factitious disorder imposed by another, and I didn't like that, and I
- 1:21:25even, I think I even said once, I was like, why isn't
- 1:21:27it called imposed on another? And it is impose on another, because of
- 1:21:33course it's called that, because that's what makes sense. And I'm an idiot
- 1:21:39because I kept railing on a name that I didn't realize it was. I
- 1:21:45was guilty of one of the things that I am blasting people for, which
- 1:21:48is, you know, not accurately reading the DSM. And you know,
- 1:21:54I just want to face palm and do that Napoleon Dynamite line it or you
- 1:22:00know, anyway, but yeah, uh so the technical term DSM factitious sort
- 1:22:08of imposed on the self. Grand Master pie Sell, but he doesn't seem
- 1:22:12to have factitious disorder because he's not presenting as such. And if you want
- 1:22:16to know more, listen to my Munchausen by Proxy episode for more information about
- 1:22:21that. It's just because you're faking an illness doesn't mean that you qualify for
- 1:22:28factitious. Factitious is kind of a specific thing. Is it's usually factitious is
- 1:22:32usually reserved for people who are doing it compulsively and strangely, and there's not
- 1:22:36really any run They might get some gain from it, but it's not doesn't
- 1:22:41really make a lot of sense as to why they do it. Grand Master
- 1:22:45Pieceel acts like he is old and rickety because I think, you know,
- 1:22:50he wants to manipulate other people to uh, to go easy on him,
- 1:22:56think of you know, to think of him as this frail, you know,
- 1:23:00simple old man and therefore worthy of you know, other people's compassion.
- 1:23:05And at least that's what I think, and I might there's some things I
- 1:23:11could be getting the books and TV shows mixed up on. I know that
- 1:23:15they portray this in the TV show, but uh, and I'm pretty sure
- 1:23:18they portray it in the book too. But anyway, so diagnosis for a
- 1:23:23Grand Master Paisel, Uh, there's there's no evidence for any mental illness.
- 1:23:27But is he faking an illness aka malingering? We would say yes, sir
- 1:23:33Gregor Clagane the Mountain. A Blog of Thrones calls him sadism, a person
- 1:23:42who enjoys inflicting pain on others. Uh and what do I say? Yes,
- 1:23:46a Blog of Thrones, you are correct Sadism. We know that he
- 1:23:51was abusive to his little brother, Sandark Klagane the Hound, and he and
- 1:23:56his men repeat it. So this isn't the books, by the way,
- 1:23:59so and the TV show they don't show this, but at least I don't
- 1:24:01think they did. But in the books, he and his men the Mountain
- 1:24:06Men, I think they were called. He and his men repeatedly and brutally
- 1:24:11raped several innocent girls and women in the books, which is again not depicted
- 1:24:16in the TV show. And he killed Prince Ragar and his baby by dashing
- 1:24:20the baby's head against the wall. And it's rumored that he killed his father,
- 1:24:26and it's rumored that he killed his first two wives, and it's rumored
- 1:24:30that he killed many of his servants. And he didn't seem to have any
- 1:24:33hesitation or remorse about these actions. So I would say definitely the label of
- 1:24:40any social personality disorder would be justified. Sadistic personality disorder, which is not
- 1:24:45in the DSM, would also be justified, and sexual sadism disorder would also
- 1:24:48be justified. Sexual sadism disorder which is a on the paraphilias. But again
- 1:24:56it's hard to tell if he's just following orders and purposely being scared, because
- 1:25:00that's part of his job is to be scary and violent. But I think
- 1:25:05given what we understand about, you know, at least the rumored, if
- 1:25:09the rumors are true then and even some of the things that we absolutely know,
- 1:25:14I mean, you know, randomly finding girls, little girls, like
- 1:25:17thirteen year old girls and you know, young women and just gang raping them.
- 1:25:23That's you know, that's sick. That's disturbed behavior. Definitely, any
- 1:25:27social definitely sadistic, and definitely sexual sadistic. The Mountain is one of the
- 1:25:32most He's one of the worst people in the books, up there with Ramsey.
- 1:25:36He is. He has a horrible, horrible human being, all right,
- 1:25:41Jamie Lanister. A lot of people have opinions about what he is suffering
- 1:25:45from. What culture dot Com claims him to be sane again, we don't
- 1:25:50use or not again, but we don't use the term sane or insane.
- 1:25:55That there's some legal turns about sanity, but that's not that's not a term
- 1:26:00we tend to use. In mental health. We would say that he doesn't
- 1:26:04meet criteria for any mental illness or a diagnosis in the DSM. So what
- 1:26:10culture says no diagnosis? MTV dot com says narcissist and doesn't really provide any
- 1:26:16justification. They just say he comes from a family of narcissists. A Blog
- 1:26:20of Thrones dot com. Narcissism when a person has an inflated sense of their
- 1:26:26own importance and complete disregard towards others, often seeing them as inferior to them.
- 1:26:30Okay, what do I say about Jamie Lanister, Well, these other
- 1:26:34websites MTV dot com on Blog of Thrones dot com, they're not saying narcissistic
- 1:26:39personality disorder, they're not using that entire phrase. They're just saying narcissist or
- 1:26:44narcissism. So it's fine for them to use those terms since they're not technical
- 1:26:47diagnoses. You know, anyone can call someone narcissistic, for instance, if
- 1:26:54that's what they think makes sense to them. But that's and I as a
- 1:26:59clinician, I'm not gonna you know, wag my finger at that because that's
- 1:27:03not a technical term and there's no clear, standardized definition of what that means.
- 1:27:09So you know, anyone can do that. You know, it's like
- 1:27:11calling someone a jerk. You know you're a jerk. Well, as a
- 1:27:15diagnostician, I'm not going to say, you know, what's the criteria for
- 1:27:17jerk? It's just like, fine, it's a word. Whatever. So
- 1:27:20these these now these websites are claiming to be diagnosing and they're they're just saying
- 1:27:27narcissists. He's I'm going to diagnose him as a narcissist, so you know,
- 1:27:32my god, it's so dumb. But but does he have narcissistic personality
- 1:27:38or which I think is what these people are trying to say. Again,
- 1:27:40context is everything. He was raised in a society that worshiped him, so
- 1:27:44when he exhibits his self importance, he's just doing what society taught him to
- 1:27:47do and what and what society kind of wants him to do. Also,
- 1:27:51he wasn't obsessed with with bragging about himself and making everyone admire him, so
- 1:27:59at least from my memory for the books, he wasn't like super obsessed with
- 1:28:01making everyone admire him all the time. So and again, if you understand
- 1:28:08actual presentations full blown narcissistic personality story, you know that Jamie Lanister does not
- 1:28:14fit that those criteria. Is he self centered like Circe? Yeah? Is?
- 1:28:19Could he? Would we all like him, particularly in the beginning of
- 1:28:24the books, to take it down a notch for sure? Would we all
- 1:28:28like him to have empathy? Absolutely? But you know, he's raised in
- 1:28:31a world, in a family, and in a context in which you know,
- 1:28:34there's there's there's the people who matter, and there's the people who don't.
- 1:28:39And he was just following those protocols. You know. In some ways
- 1:28:45you could say that he was quite noble and chivalrous when he decided to kill
- 1:28:54the mad king, you know. But anyway, so in conclusion, I
- 1:28:58would say, Jamie Lanister no evidence of mental Disorder's let's not let's not overdiagnose
- 1:29:03everybody. All right, Let's take a break and when we get back,
- 1:29:08we'll get to the letter. We'll continue with the letter j stept Okay,
- 1:29:17we're back from the break. Continuing after talking about Jamie Lanister, let's talk
- 1:29:23about Jackanhagar, ThoughtCatalog dot com. This is a new, a new player
- 1:29:29in our field here, ThoughtCatalog dot com. They say, Jack Jack Jack
- 1:29:33and Agar has dissociative identity disorder, and this this site actually provides treatment plans,
- 1:29:41treatment plan twenty five appointments with a psychologist allowing multiple identities to be consolidated.
- 1:29:46They said, Okay, to you clinicshes out there, I just want
- 1:29:50to read this because it's so so dumb. Okay, so thought catalog dot
- 1:29:55com diagnosis Jack and Agar with the associative attent disorder and a treatment plan of
- 1:30:04twenty five appointments with a psychologist allowing multiple identities to be consolidated. Again,
- 1:30:13this episode is already too long. I'm not going to go into dissociate identity
- 1:30:17disort that that much, but and treat the planets. But I just have
- 1:30:24to say it, like my god, that's that's so stupid. Twenty five
- 1:30:28appointments is way not enough for dissociated identity disorder if you truly thought someone had
- 1:30:34that. And then the twenty five appointments with a psychologist, well, what
- 1:30:39about all the other mental health professionals who are qualified to treat associated identity stor
- 1:30:45and then and then just applying that the labeled associative identity disorder to Jack and
- 1:30:49Agar just you know, just dumb, just just stupid, Okay. Jeffrey
- 1:30:56Barrathian WhatCulture dot com? What is what culture? What culture dot com have
- 1:31:02to say about Jeoffrey brathy And they say sociopath with sadistic tendencies. They say
- 1:31:09Jeoffrey is completely devoid of empathy and takes active enjoyment in the violation harm of
- 1:31:14others. What do I say, Well, sociopath is not a preferred term.
- 1:31:19People don't use the term. In the mental health world. Antisocial personality
- 1:31:26disorder is used, and sometimes we use psychopathy or psychopathic personality disorder. But
- 1:31:31yes, if if what culture dot com is saying antisocial with sadism, absolutely
- 1:31:39anti he is. Jeoffrey Brathian is super antisocial and super sadistic. But you
- 1:31:45know, we wouldn't apply that label because he's not eighteen. I think he
- 1:31:49dies at the age of thirteen, and so in the field we would label
- 1:31:54him as conduct disorder because that's the childhood version of antisocial for the most part.
- 1:32:01A blog of Thrones dot com, they say antisocial personality sort. So
- 1:32:05what culture dot com and a blog of Thrones dot com they get it right.
- 1:32:10MTV dot com, what do they say the clinical sociopath? They say
- 1:32:15clinical sociopath. I love it when people use the term clinical as if other
- 1:32:21diagnoses are unclinical, you know, like clinical depression. It just shows that
- 1:32:28they're ignorant of our lingo ANTV dot com clinical the clinical sociopath. So not
- 1:32:33only are they using that stupid term clinical, but they're also using the term
- 1:32:36sociopath. It's like, I mean whatever, but you know, in essence
- 1:32:42they're right. So psychology today says antisocial personality sort. But realistically Joffrely would
- 1:32:49have been diagnosed with conduct disorder. So psychology today was the most accurate,
- 1:32:56although they weren't always accurate. What would I say? Yeah, Jeoffrey suffered
- 1:33:01from any social personality disorder as well as sadistic personality disorder, which is not
- 1:33:05the DSM five, specifically tyrannical sadism in that he relished inverbally and physically harming
- 1:33:13and abusing others with his power. However, since personality disorders are commonly relegated
- 1:33:17to only adults and not miners, most current clinicians would apply the label of
- 1:33:23conduct disorder because he exhibited a pattern of violating the rights of others as a
- 1:33:27young person. His disorder may have developed from the abuse that he experienced from
- 1:33:32his father, Robert Brathian. He also had a distant mother guessing, you
- 1:33:39know, we could imagine Sirce, he wasn't all that close and warm.
- 1:33:43Jeoffrey also experienced trauma from his parents fighting all the time. It's something obviously
- 1:33:47they didn't show the TV show, but they refer to it in the books
- 1:33:50that you know Jeoffrey experience as a young child. His parents, Robert Brathian
- 1:33:57and Circe were fighting all the time. It was violent, it got ugly,
- 1:34:01and Robert was very violent with Circe. Also, that something that's not
- 1:34:10really portrayed in the TV show is Jeoffrey looked like a girl and he was
- 1:34:15being teased because he looked like a girl. Also, inbreeding might have an
- 1:34:20effect on the development of sadism and antisocial Also, his mother drank while she
- 1:34:30was pregnant in all likelihood, and that might have had an effect. You
- 1:34:34know, there's not a real there's not a ton of solid research on that,
- 1:34:36but you know, you never know. Also, growing up, he
- 1:34:42was heir to the throne of Westros, and he's being told he's better than
- 1:34:45other people. And you know, we know real cases where children are spoiled
- 1:34:51in this way and can develop anti social least traits. Also, we can
- 1:34:59imagine that his parents conditions were also great. So there are a lot of
- 1:35:01reasons why Jeffrey developed his issues, his conduct disorder, which makes me believe
- 1:35:09that if given enough time and enough love and enough attention, enough good enough,
- 1:35:17good environment, he could have pulled himself out of it. It's just
- 1:35:20a guess. But who knows. Ramsey, on the other hand, in
- 1:35:24the Mountain, they're far gone. There's nothing that could be done. So
- 1:35:28in conclusion, Jeffrey Barrathian, Yeah, anti social personality sor sadistic personnaity sort
- 1:35:34and sexual sadism disorder. And if you want to hear my full analysis,
- 1:35:39listen to the full episode on Jeffrey Barrathian. That was my very first Game
- 1:35:43of Thrones episode. I don't know why I did it, but I just
- 1:35:46wanted to do Jeoffrey. And as soon as I posted it, everyone was
- 1:35:51like, oh, you got to do Ramsey and you got to do this
- 1:35:54person. So this episode is kind of in response to everyone wanting me to
- 1:35:59do all the all the characters. Okay, John Snow, let's go to
- 1:36:03John Snow. WhatCulture dot com says seasonal effective disorder and let me quote that
- 1:36:12here. Depression run. Depression runs in John's family, with a strong tendency
- 1:36:16for melancholy running through the Stark DNA. He has a depressive affect and it's
- 1:36:24only been getting worse since heading north. The seasonal effective disorder is a type
- 1:36:29of depression that worsens during the winter months with reduced sunlight and colder weather.
- 1:36:33Early on, he can be found laughing and joking with his family in the
- 1:36:38comparatively temperate environment of winter Fell, but as winter draws in and the nights
- 1:36:44get darker, so does his outlook. Unquote all right, what do I
- 1:36:49say? This is stupid? There's no evidence of this disorder. The technical
- 1:36:55term is major depressive disorder with seasonal pattern. And let's go over at the
- 1:37:00criteria here. Okay, first off, for a major depression, depressed mood
- 1:37:06meaning feeling sad, feeling empty, feeling hopeless, appearing like you're down.
- 1:37:15There's no evidence that John Snow had a depressed mood. Diminished interest and pleasure
- 1:37:23in things that you were normally interested in. No, he's he is highly
- 1:37:28motivated in his work. He is one of the most non depressed people in
- 1:37:31the books. I mean, look at all the things he does. Depressed
- 1:37:34people have a hard time getting out of bed in the morning, let alone
- 1:37:41taking on the world the way John Snow is so. No, he is.
- 1:37:45He is definitely interested in getting his job done and saving the world.
- 1:37:51So I wouldn't say he has diminished interest. If anything, he has an
- 1:37:55increased interest in taking action on things. Weight change, no evidence of that,
- 1:38:00sleep problems. I don't see any evidence of that. Psychomotor agitation or
- 1:38:05retardation. Absolutely, no evidence of that. Fatigue. I don't see any
- 1:38:10evidence of that. Feelings of worthlessness, no evidence difficulty concentrating. No evidence
- 1:38:16suicidality, you know, actual suicidality, not you know, the kind of
- 1:38:21stuff that you just do in the course of war. No. No evidence
- 1:38:26of wanting to kill himself. Significant distress from all these things. No,
- 1:38:32Okay, seasonal pattern depressive episodes that coincide with seasons. No, since he
- 1:38:39doesn't have any depressive episodes. Full remission for part of the year. No.
- 1:38:45In the last two years, two major depressive episodes. No, So
- 1:38:47even if he did have major depression, which he doesn't. Even if he
- 1:38:53did, you couldn't give him a seasonal effective disorder otherwise known as a seasonal
- 1:38:57pattern to major depressive disorder because he he hasn't exhibited enough cycles back and forth
- 1:39:02to know what's happening. If you just want to if you wanted to say
- 1:39:06major depression, then fine, it's still wrong. But there's no if even
- 1:39:12if he did have major depression, you would have no idea if it's if
- 1:39:16his depression is going to go away once it becomes summer again, because you
- 1:39:20haven't seen him in the next summer, so that you would know if he
- 1:39:26has a seasonal pattern to his depression. If he was depressed, maybe this
- 1:39:30is just the beginning of his depression and then he just stays depressed for the
- 1:39:32rest of his life, regardless of the seasons, or the seasons have nothing
- 1:39:38to do with his cycles. So I just have to say, you know,
- 1:39:42seasonal effective sorder is up. There is one of the dumbest things I
- 1:39:45saw on the internet. His life has been really tough. You know,
- 1:39:49his adoptive mother and father, Caitlin and Edward. They're dead. His beloved
- 1:39:56brother rob dead, beloved sister presumed dead, beloved, you know, younger
- 1:40:02brothers Brandon, Rickon presumed killed by Theon, who was supposed to be a
- 1:40:06friend, beloved girlfriend killed by his friends. You know, John Snow,
- 1:40:12you know nothing. He's betrayed by Theon. Winter Fell is burned by Ramsey,
- 1:40:18and so many people are killed. There's a huge army of White Walkers
- 1:40:23that are coming to kill everyone, and no one is trying to stop it.
- 1:40:28And many of his brothers in arms are killed by various different people,
- 1:40:32and so on and so on. These are terrible, demoralizing, depressing things.
- 1:40:40And in spite of that, he has persisted. He's the opposite of
- 1:40:44depressed. He's highly motivated. He must be at least, you know,
- 1:40:48partially optimistic, because otherwise why would he fight. If I was John Snow,
- 1:40:55I would have gave up long ago. I would have become depressed and
- 1:40:59just been like, what's the point. You know, We're all gonna die
- 1:41:03and no one's helping, and my own men are trying to kill me and
- 1:41:10did kill me, and now I'm back to life. So yeah, is
- 1:41:14he depressed? Does he have major depressive disorder. I would say no,
- 1:41:17and you know, don't be stupid. Okay, MTV dot com, guess
- 1:41:23what empty you know? So far, MTV dot com has been the dumbest
- 1:41:26of all, even though they're talking to a clinician. So what can we
- 1:41:29imagine a MTV dot com Let's say, well again, seasonal effective, not
- 1:41:32seasonal effective disorder. Just the phrase seasonal effective, seasonal effective? What seasonal
- 1:41:39effective joy? Seasonal effective happiness? You know, it's like what they say,
- 1:41:45if anyone in West Ros has brain based, biology based mental health issues,
- 1:41:50I'd say that depression runs in the Stark family. It's a weird it's
- 1:41:56a weird phrase. If anyone in Westros has brain based, biological, biology
- 1:42:00based mental health issues, I'd say that depression runs in Stark in the Stark
- 1:42:03family, Santsa is clearly depressed. She has a depressed affect. Caitlin had
- 1:42:11that too at times, and John snow he's experienced a lot of loss,
- 1:42:15which is a trigger for depression. And it's also common for people displaced from
- 1:42:18home to experience depressive episodes. It might even be seasonally effective living that far
- 1:42:25north. Okay, end of quote me, Yeah, stupid, this is
- 1:42:29a clinician talking. Sure, he's been through a lot and he's grieving and
- 1:42:33that's made him sad. You know, that's that's grief. But that does
- 1:42:36not mean he has major depressive disorder. And it definitely doesn't effing mean he
- 1:42:43has major depressive disorder with seasonal pattern. I mean, don't be stupid people.
- 1:42:46You're just thrown around these these terms as if you know you know what
- 1:42:53they mean, and you don't. You know, stop it. You don't
- 1:42:56know these things. So get out of my kitchen if you want to.
- 1:43:00If you want to talk about John Snow's personality and he's like, oh,
- 1:43:03he seems kind of down or seems kind of uh, you know, forlorn,
- 1:43:08or his motivations are funny or you know whatever. Fine, great,
- 1:43:12you're you're you're just as good at that as any clinician is. You can
- 1:43:15you can wax and Wayne or what do you call it. You can,
- 1:43:19you can you can talk as much as you want about personality and motivation and
- 1:43:25character arc and what what you know, what's deep down in him and if
- 1:43:28you can relate to that, yes, go for it. I love that
- 1:43:32stuff. In fact, I watched that TV show that's right after Game of
- 1:43:38Thrones. You know, there's a there's a TV show that comes out,
- 1:43:41So if you know when you when a new Game of Thrones episode comes out,
- 1:43:44immediately after there's this there's there's this TV show and I think it's HBO
- 1:43:48that talks about the episode. These people and I love all that stuff.
- 1:43:53But if you're going to come into my world, the mental health world,
- 1:43:56and you're gonna start throwing around these terms, stop it, because you clearly
- 1:44:01do not know what you're doing. Internet. You just don't know what you're
- 1:44:05doing. Okay, Okay, Uh, what is a blog of Throne?
- 1:44:10Okay? So what culture dot com seasonal effective Disorder? Just dumb? MTV
- 1:44:15seasonal effective dot dot dot also dumb a blog of Thrones. Martyr complex martyr
- 1:44:23complex it goes on, also known as victim complex when a person exaggerates his
- 1:44:29own suffering or persecutions, wanting to become a martyr for his own sake,
- 1:44:33in some cases attributing their persecution to the exceptional ability of their own John being
- 1:44:40skillful John, John being a skillful, Castle trained, high born bastard puts
- 1:44:45him at odds with the rest of the night's watch when he first takes the
- 1:44:48black period. End of quote. All right, yeah, this is not
- 1:44:53a DSM label martyr complex or victim complex, but you know, it's an
- 1:44:57interesting analysis. There are a number of times that John Snow actually puts himself
- 1:45:01in harm's way in a very public manner, and we might call this a
- 1:45:06martyr complex, or we might call this masochism. He's always volunteering for these
- 1:45:12extremely risky jobs. He went by himself to the Wildlings when they were about
- 1:45:16to attack the wall, which was very risky and very public. He had
- 1:45:20been treated somewhat badly by the people growing up in his life. I mean,
- 1:45:25you know, he's sort of a second rate citizen at you know,
- 1:45:28at winter Fell, particularly when it came to Caitlin, his adoptive mother.
- 1:45:32And you know, when you have those kinds of experiences in early in life
- 1:45:36and you're treated badly, you internalize that relationship and it becomes a difficult,
- 1:45:41internalized representational relationship inside your psyche. And so you sometimes to cope with that
- 1:45:47as an offense, you end up abusing yourself through society or sort of making
- 1:45:51other people know that you're being abused in some way. I could go on
- 1:45:57and on and on, but anyway a blog of Thrones, because a martyr
- 1:46:00complex is not a DSM thing, you know, and because if I'm understanding
- 1:46:10what a blog of Thrones writer is saying, sure you could say that,
- 1:46:14and there's no criteria. It's all in the either beholder in that one.
- 1:46:18So and I can even sort of agree with it all, right, Next
- 1:46:23person, Jora Mormont, Jura Mormont. What does a blog of Thrones say?
- 1:46:27They say, obsessive love. That's the diagnosis. That's his mental illness.
- 1:46:31Obsessive love, they say, a state of mind in which a person
- 1:46:34feels an obsessive desire to possess a person to whom they feel strong attraction,
- 1:46:40with the inability to accept rejection from that very same person. Jura has proved
- 1:46:45it many times that he is obsessed with the Naries Targarian, even saving her
- 1:46:48in the fighting pits of Marine unquote. What do I say about this?
- 1:46:55Stupid? This is not a diagnosis. Obsessive love is not a dignote.
- 1:47:00It is not a mental illness as it's presented in this article. Jora Mormont
- 1:47:03just merely loves her. That's not an obsession. If you understand what obsessions
- 1:47:09are you understand, this is not obsession, is just he just loves her.
- 1:47:13He's fond of her, he's dedicated to her, and for a time
- 1:47:15he's her night, and he's trying to do his job, and he feels
- 1:47:18bad about being excommunicated from his homeland, so he's, you know, he's
- 1:47:23trying to be a dutiful guy. And yeah, he loves he loves draw.
- 1:47:28So that's not a mental illness. If if that is, then ninety
- 1:47:32nine percent of the people on the planet have a mental illness called obsessive love,
- 1:47:35because everyone has that experience in life. All right, So in conclusion,
- 1:47:42Jora Marmont, any mental illness, No, of course not. You
- 1:47:45know, don't be stupid, okay. Lisa Aaron, Lisa Aaron. A
- 1:47:48lot of people have a lot to say about Lisa. WhatCulture dot com says
- 1:47:54borderline personality disorder. And what I would say is, yes, this time
- 1:47:59they're right. She is actually a good example of one particular presentation of borderline
- 1:48:04personatosaur. But to be clear, most people with borderline personnaitosaur do not look
- 1:48:10Likelysa Aaron. She she's an example of it, but she's not an all
- 1:48:15encompassing example of it. What does MTV dot com say paranoid personnality sorder and
- 1:48:20Munchausen by proxy? And what I would say is, yeah, you know,
- 1:48:26I actually people are getting this right. You know, Paranoid personnality sorder,
- 1:48:32I would say, is a possible differential when it comes to borderline personality
- 1:48:38sorter and Lisa Aaron, You know, could be, but I think borderline
- 1:48:41is a better diagnosis. But you know, one can make the argument for
- 1:48:44paranoid personality saur And then Munchausen by proxy is possible. Again, we call
- 1:48:47that fictitious disorder and pose another you know, the way she treated her son,
- 1:48:53you know it's possible, But I wouldn't say it's a strong presentation of
- 1:48:59Munchausen by product scene. All right, what does a blog of thrones say?
- 1:49:01They say, delusional jealousy or Othello syndrome. Uh so, delusional jealousy
- 1:49:11and athello syndrome. What do I have to say about that? That's stupid.
- 1:49:16Those aren't mental illnesses. I've never even heard of them. I guess
- 1:49:20I could imagine what othello syndrome is. I guess that's referring to Othello in
- 1:49:25the Shakespearean play Delusional jealousy. No, Lisa Aaron is not delusional. She's
- 1:49:31jealous, but she's not delusional. She's justifiably jealous and athello syndrome, I
- 1:49:39mean, come on, So conclusion about Lisa Aaron, Yeah, I would
- 1:49:44say, you know, a good a good candidate for borline per se or
- 1:49:48is she a typical boorline personality? No, because she's I don't know,
- 1:49:55she's she's quite aggressive and she's quite mean to people. But but yeah,
- 1:50:02if if I were to diagnose her, I would say, you know,
- 1:50:05that's a good candidate. And clearly it's so so Actually in relation to this
- 1:50:12other talk that I'm trying to help people understand personality source, you never get
- 1:50:16the sense that Lisa Aaron is okay, Like, even when she is,
- 1:50:21you know, even when things are going well, she doesn't seem happy.
- 1:50:26Right. The actress that plays her is just brilliant because there's always something off
- 1:50:31kilt her about her. There's always something she seems to be suffering all the
- 1:50:36time. She's not. She doesn't seem to be happy with herself. She
- 1:50:42you know, she reacts very strongly to rejection. She becomes very emotionally dysregulated
- 1:50:47when she's threatened by people in a relationship way, and that's what people with
- 1:50:57personal disorders will do aly borderline personality. Well, you know, again,
- 1:51:02as I said earlier, when you are traumatized relationally and rejected, then you
- 1:51:08are very very sensitive to rejection. And when someone rejects you, it brings
- 1:51:15back all those old feelings from when you were a very young child, and
- 1:51:18you essentially have a temper tantrum that is justified given how how bad you feel,
- 1:51:26you know, And so I shouldn't say temper tantrum. I should say
- 1:51:30melt down. That's a better term, you know. Temper tantrums are things
- 1:51:34that I guess we do on purpose at times, or at least sometimes.
- 1:51:38But a child, when they melt down, you know they're they're coming on
- 1:51:42glued, their emotions are taking over and they're melting down. And so when
- 1:51:48you have when you've been traumatized in a way that makes you develop borderline personality
- 1:51:54sort and someone even hints at rejecting you, you melt down because you can't
- 1:51:59turn to internal resources to help you get through those moments, to to reassure
- 1:52:04you that you're still a good person, to reassure you that you'll be okay.
- 1:52:09Without that person, you don't have that in the same way that a
- 1:52:13four year old can't turn to himself and say, I'll probably be okay if
- 1:52:17my parents reject me. You know, if my parents dropping off in the
- 1:52:20curve, you know, I'll be okay. You know, no four year
- 1:52:23old can do that well when you're traumatized at in those ages, and you
- 1:52:27know when as a young child you retain that structure of personality and as an
- 1:52:33adult, even though you're walking and talking like an adult, you feel like
- 1:52:38a four year old does. And so Lisa Aaron exhibited that that way of
- 1:52:44feeling. Now, the thing that that's different about Lisa Aaron in terms of
- 1:52:48the typical you know, the vast majority of people of boorline personnelity, so
- 1:52:53is that Lisa Aaron was an extremely mean individual. I mean, she had
- 1:52:56no problem, you know, trying to kill Tyrian and just doing all and
- 1:53:00she's very strange with her son. And I actually know borderline personality disordered people
- 1:53:04who are actually great parents. So Elisa Aaron was a particular kind of borderline
- 1:53:11personality. Okay, what about Melissandra Melisanda? WhatCulture dot com says histrionic personality
- 1:53:18disorder. Blah blah blah, We'll see what they say. Affecting four times
- 1:53:24as many women as men. Histrionic personality disorder is characterized by excessive attention seeking
- 1:53:29behavior through the use of high drama and extravagant displays of sexuality. They crave
- 1:53:33stimulation, attention, and admiration, and will use persistently manipulative means to achieve
- 1:53:38their own needs. Histrionic people will be overly emotional, theatrical, prone to
- 1:53:43rash decision making, and likely to blame personal failures or disappointments on others.
- 1:53:47Unquote, what would I say about this is stupid. It's a complete misunderstanding
- 1:53:54of historionic personality disorder. I did I think at least a two hour episode
- 1:53:58on histrionic, So go listen to that I want if you want to.
- 1:54:01I think it's a patron only episode. Though she's not histrionic. She's a
- 1:54:05religious priest, melisand is a She's a religious priest or priestess, so everything
- 1:54:13she does is in line with her religion and her job as a priest,
- 1:54:16So to call her histrionic is completely missing the point of historionic personalite or.
- 1:54:24And again, if you've experienced someone with historionic personalite or you know that,
- 1:54:27Melian Melissandra, she does not present like that. What is MTV dot comment
- 1:54:33to say? And again, with MTV's track record, we could only imagine
- 1:54:38how stupid they're going to be and guess what. Yeah, totally stupid.
- 1:54:41Delusional again, not not a diagnosis, just delusional, they say. If
- 1:54:47we put magic aside, Melissandra has serious delusions of grandeur in terms of what
- 1:54:53she believes she's capable of. Okay, stupid. Yes, if she did
- 1:55:00have magical powers, then yeah, maybe something's wrong there. But she does
- 1:55:04have magical powers, so there's no evidence of delusions or psychosis. Don't be
- 1:55:10dumb. So conclusion Melissandra, no evidence of mental diagnoses. She's a priest
- 1:55:16who is trying to serve for God and her king who happens to be Stanus,
- 1:55:20which is you know, completely normal for religious leaders in this world.
- 1:55:26So there's no mental illness for Melissan. She's she's fine. Over in Martel
- 1:55:32the Viper, a blog of Throne, says sex addiction blah blah blah,
- 1:55:39constant craving for the flesh that can distract a person from his tasks and duties.
- 1:55:44What do I say about that? Again? Stupid people love to use
- 1:55:48sex addiction as a label, and I'm getting tired of it, frankly.
- 1:55:53Over In Martel, he likes sex. You know, many people like sex.
- 1:55:57That doesn't mean that he's a sex addict. In our world, many
- 1:56:00people like to watch football, right in our world, right in our American
- 1:56:05football, A lot of people like to watch American football. But that doesn't
- 1:56:09mean that they're football addicts, you know. And just because he likes to
- 1:56:15have sex, I mean, we don't even know how much he how much
- 1:56:17sex he was having. I mean, I suppose if he was having sex
- 1:56:21sixteen hours a day, then you know, maybe, but we don't.
- 1:56:27He just you know, he likes sex. He's from Dorin. They seem
- 1:56:30like a very sensual people. You know, of the things that these royals
- 1:56:36were getting involved in, I would say sex is you know, one of
- 1:56:41the least harmful things that people were getting involved in. So is he an
- 1:56:45addict because he liked to have sex? No, that's dumb, So don't
- 1:56:49be stupid. In conclusion, Ober and Martell, no evidence of diagnosis,
- 1:56:56okay, Peter little Finger Bailish, Peter Bailish, little Finger throne says myth
- 1:57:00omania, myth omania or pathological lying? What do I say about that?
- 1:57:08Stupid? The term pathological lying usually refers to people who lie for seemingly no
- 1:57:14reason or who you know, it's almost a compulsion to them, and it's
- 1:57:19usually, in my experience, the result of major attachment injuries and or child
- 1:57:25abuse. Little Finger is playing the game of thrones right, just like everyone
- 1:57:30else is. But he's playing to a strengths. He's using his intellect and
- 1:57:33his guile, just like Robert Brathian played to a strengths as a fierce warrior
- 1:57:39to become king. Right. So Robert Brathian played to a strengths with this
- 1:57:44huge hammer, and little Finger is playing to a strengths by using his intellect.
- 1:57:49So to call him, to call him a pathological liar is totally misunderstanding
- 1:57:58what pathological lying actually is. Pathological lying is a legit thing. Uh believe
- 1:58:02me, I I've come across it. So uh so you know it's legit.
- 1:58:09It's not a thing that's in the DSM. But but it's a legit.
- 1:58:13Anyway, what does ThoughtCatalog dot com I have to say? They say
- 1:58:16antisocial personality sort they say, he slithers his way into advantageous situations, manipulating
- 1:58:25everyone around him to get what he desires. They have a treatment plant because
- 1:58:29remember thought thought catalog has treutm plan, treating plan, extended psychotherapy, and
- 1:58:32a regimen of prozac and zoloft. Uh, what would I have to say
- 1:58:39about what ThoughtCatalog dot com is saying that stupid prozac and zoloft? I mean,
- 1:58:44are you just pulling out random pills out of your head? And that's
- 1:58:47you know, like names you've seen on TV, and that's and for for
- 1:58:53anti social personality story, your treatment plan is prozac and zoloft. That's that's
- 1:58:57your treating plan. Like why are you even trying to Why if you don't
- 1:59:00know what you're talking about, why do you even talk about it? Why
- 1:59:02don't you just say regimen of meds I've heard before, like hey, good
- 1:59:10boy, Well now extended psychotherapy. You know it's there's it's debatable whether or
- 1:59:15not you can even help someone with anti social but but there are some therapies
- 1:59:18that seem to work anyway, depending on the goal. But little Finger clearly
- 1:59:26doesn't care about human life and he's willing to harm others for his own gain,
- 1:59:30So he does in my opinion, so that that kind of log is
- 1:59:33saying anti social and I'm saying, yeah, you could make a case for
- 1:59:38that, But again, he is The question is is he actually psychopathic?
- 1:59:44Is he actually anti social personality or is he just playing the game of thrones
- 1:59:48that everyone else is trying to play. It's hard to tell. Also,
- 1:59:51another data point here is he didn't seem to exhibit any psychopathic, you know,
- 1:59:59mean trait prior to Jeoffrey becoming queen king. You know, so when
- 2:00:04Jeoffrey became king, that's when Little Fingers started to kind of engage in a
- 2:00:09lot of these shady behaviors which would eventually lead to uh, little Finger participating
- 2:00:15in the death of King Jeoffrey. So maybe Little Fingers anti social behavior is
- 2:00:21just the manifestation of his intelligent efforts to establish a good leader on the throne.
- 2:00:28You know. It's hard to tell, But similar to Circi, he
- 2:00:33does show he does show a lack of empathy, and he does show a
- 2:00:39lack of remorse at the things that he has done. So at the very
- 2:00:43least he has anti social personality traits. So the conclusion for Little Finger is
- 2:00:48antisocial personality disorder traits, but I don't think he has a full disorder and
- 2:00:55definitely doesn't have mythomania. You know, don't be silly. Okay, we
- 2:01:00are all the way to Ramsey, but before we go to him, let's
- 2:01:04take a break. All right, Welcome back. We're back from the break,
- 2:01:14and we're talking about Ramsey on this marathon episode in which I talk about
- 2:01:18the various stupid stuff that's been said on the Internet and I provide my own
- 2:01:21opinion. Again, as I said at the very beginning of this episode,
- 2:01:27diagnosing is a art form. It is not a science as a lot of
- 2:01:31people would like it to be. It is highly in the eye of the
- 2:01:35beholder. It is. It is, you know, subject to subjectivity and
- 2:01:41to opinion, and so I am providing mine. But as I also said
- 2:01:45at the beginning of this episode, there are things that the vast majority of
- 2:01:50clinicians would laugh at, and I'm trying to exhibit that laughing in this episode.
- 2:01:56Okay, Ramsey, A blog of Throne says anti social personality sorder,
- 2:02:00and Thought catalog says sexual sadism disorder. And I will say that these guys
- 2:02:06are getting it right. It appears that when someone is off the charts problematic,
- 2:02:13then the Internet actually manages to get it right. I don't know why
- 2:02:16that is, but that seems to be the pattern. So a blog of
- 2:02:19Throne, A blog of thrones, anti social personality sort thought catalog sexual sadism
- 2:02:26disorder. So yeah. In my opinion, Ramsey had sexual sadism disorder along
- 2:02:32with sadistic personality disorder, which is in the DSM, but sexual sadism disorder
- 2:02:36is since Ramsey demonstrated market pleasure and complete lack of remorse from the suffering of
- 2:02:45others. He also suffered from anti social personality disorder which is in the DSM
- 2:02:49five, or psychopathic personality disorder which is not, which are both related to
- 2:02:54sadism and sexual sadism. He's the most problemat a character in the show,
- 2:03:00along with the Mountain in my opinion, since he clearly demonstrates tremendous pleasure in
- 2:03:04harming others in a variety of ways, and he engaged in frequent statistic behavior
- 2:03:11even though it would harm him in the end. For example, he raped
- 2:03:16and killed many many people, many young women, and one time when he
- 2:03:23did this it almost got him killed by Sir Roger Cassel, So he enjoyed
- 2:03:29raping and killing women even when it didn't help him, you know, in
- 2:03:33contrast to sircees antisocial behavior, in which, at least from my memory at
- 2:03:39least most of it over antisocial behavior was actually self preserving. That's the thing
- 2:03:45about these personality sorts. It's another sort of to add to the nuance of
- 2:03:49personality source. A lot of times the sort of behavior that people engage in
- 2:03:56as a as motivated by their personality disorder, you know issues, it actually
- 2:04:02is shooting themselves in the foot. People with borderline personality disorder frequently shoot themselves
- 2:04:08in the foot deep down. They are desperate, as most people are,
- 2:04:12but borderline percentage sort of people are even more desperate for a strong, secure
- 2:04:17attachment. But because they react so strongly to even the slightest hint of rejection,
- 2:04:24they end up pushing a lot of people away in this tragic recreation of
- 2:04:28their original rejection when they are children. And so so Ramsey exhibits this and
- 2:04:33that he is, you know, he's sadistic. He's antisocially psychopathic, you
- 2:04:40know, sexual sadism, which is just another way of saying you enjoy raping
- 2:04:44people. And his disorder gets in the way, almost gets them killed.
- 2:04:49So you know, that's just one thing to think about. Okay. So
- 2:04:53conclusion about Ramsey, he you know, was he had a difficult childhood.
- 2:05:00I did a whole episode on Ramsey, so listen to that episode. He
- 2:05:03has a fat Ramsey Bolton has a fascinating history, fascinating childhood, and he
- 2:05:11had a lot of biological you know, Ruce Bolton was also a psychopathic and
- 2:05:17was also a sexual a sadis he would rape and kill people. Ruth Bolton
- 2:05:21would when he was young. So Ramsey may have gotten that set of genes
- 2:05:28that sort of set up an epigenetic situation to create that sort of personality.
- 2:05:33Plus he experienced, you know, a lot of difficulties as a child,
- 2:05:36so which is common for people with these kinds of disorders. So the conclusion
- 2:05:42is Ramsey has antisocial personality disorder and sexual sadism disorder in a big way.
- 2:05:47It's one of the more obvious cases in the Game of Thrones or a song
- 2:05:51of Viseumpier all right, Robin Aaron Lysa Aaron's young Boy, Robin Aaron Sweet
- 2:05:59Robin a blog of Thrones dot com, says Oedipus complex Oedipus complex quote when
- 2:06:05a child has too much affection towards the parent of the opposite sex, and
- 2:06:12resentment even jealousy towards the parent of the same one. All right, what
- 2:06:16I have to say about it? Sure, it's not an actual mental illness
- 2:06:20Oedipus complex, it's not. It's never been in the DSM. So you
- 2:06:26know, it's one of those psychobabble terms that can mean a lot of different
- 2:06:30things. And a Blog of Thrones is not using this term in a bad
- 2:06:35way. Actually, it's it's you know, it's a little close to the
- 2:06:39marker. I wouldn't be surprised that some classic psychoanalysts wouldn't use this term to
- 2:06:47explore Robin Aaron's personality. So you know, the idea is that because his
- 2:06:55mother is disturbed, he's he becomes stuck in this early stage of development,
- 2:07:00this this oedipal development stage, and he is he remains as an older boy,
- 2:07:10he remains very dependent on his mother as if he still was an infant.
- 2:07:15So Oedipus complex you could apply, so a Blog of Thrones again every
- 2:07:20once in a while, or a broken clock is right twice a day anyway,
- 2:07:25Blog of Thrones got it right, Oedipus, I mean not right right,
- 2:07:28but because a blog of Thrones, if I remember right, is trying
- 2:07:30to present what they called, I think medical conditions, and Oedipus complex is
- 2:07:36definitely not a medical condition and it's actually also not a mental illness. Okay,
- 2:07:43Sansa. What do we say about Sansa? Well, what culture dot
- 2:07:47com? WhatCulture dot com says, note is that she's sane. A blog
- 2:07:53of Thrones says, masochism quote when a person obtains any sort of game through
- 2:08:00tolerating mental or physical abuse from someone close to them. I just want to
- 2:08:05read this again because this is one of the this is this is so dumb,
- 2:08:11but in a different way that I won't laugh at it. I'm just
- 2:08:16going to it makes me angry. Actually, So A blog of Throne says
- 2:08:22masochism. Sansa suffers from masochism because she's a person who gains, who gets
- 2:08:31a gain, who gets something out of mental or physical abuse from someone close
- 2:08:35to them. Uh, I'm sure you understand how utterly stupid and offensive this
- 2:08:43is masochism. Sansa being raped by Ramsey is you know she gets it,
- 2:08:50she gets something out of this? What sort of effing gain did Sansa get
- 2:08:56from being repeatedly raped and abused by Ramsey? This is idiotic, offensive,
- 2:09:01victim blaming, terrible, dumb. What masochistic Santa is masochistic? She gets?
- 2:09:11I mean she's being abused, that's true, she's being traumatized, that's
- 2:09:18true. But you're you're you're gonna claim that sants is getting something out of
- 2:09:24being. It sounds like a sounds like a projection from whoever's writing this,
- 2:09:28like like you have some sick thing where you want Santsa to get a get
- 2:09:33something out of Uh, there's there's just gross. Let's move on. Well,
- 2:09:37no, let me conclude, Sansa. No, no mental illness.
- 2:09:41Don't be stupid. Okay, sand Or the hound clagain, Sandor clagain,
- 2:09:45the hound again. I did a whole episode on him. Go listen to
- 2:09:50that if you want. A Blog of Throne says post traumatic stress disorder.
- 2:09:54Psychology today says post traumatic stress disorder and alcohol use disorder. What do I
- 2:10:01say? Uh? Yeah, they actually got this right, Blog of Thrones
- 2:10:03and Psychology, They actually got this straight. Sandor clearly suffered from PTSD related
- 2:10:09to the ongoing extreme abuse he received from his older brother, Gregor Cogain,
- 2:10:16when he encountered the threat of fire, he consistently showed signs of PTSD,
- 2:10:22actual signs of PTSD. So that's remember I was talking about people talking about
- 2:10:28Aria has PTSD. If you want, you know, now, Sandor doesn't
- 2:10:33have a He doesn't. We don't have a full assessment on Sandor. But
- 2:10:39the reaction that Sander has when when he when he encounters fire, when King's
- 2:10:46landing is being attacked by Stanis and all his people and there's there's a burning
- 2:10:50fire or there's all the wild fire. Anyway, sand Or, even though
- 2:10:56he's a brave, courageous feel warrior, he freaked out and ran and not
- 2:11:03and where did he run? He ran? He ran a Sansa. He
- 2:11:05ran to Sansa and he said, Sansa, let's get out of here,
- 2:11:09and Sansa's like no, and then he left. He just got out of
- 2:11:13town. I mean, that's how that's how distressful that was for him.
- 2:11:16He was, he was it was so distressful to him seeing all that fire
- 2:11:22that he just he needed to escape, you know, as like a clauster
- 2:11:26phobia feeling. So yeah, that that that's an example of physiological, likely
- 2:11:33physiological, but at least psychological distress as a result of the memory of the
- 2:11:39trauma being triggered. You know, his his older brother smashed his face into
- 2:11:45a burning fire, which resulted in massive disfiguring of his face. And so
- 2:11:50from that point forward, whenever he sees fire, now he that that deep
- 2:11:54trauma is triggered in him and he has a reaction. So uh so,
- 2:11:58yeah, we don't have the full all the criteria necessary endorsed for PTSD,
- 2:12:05but we have, I think enough to say probably PTSD. Sandor does not
- 2:12:13fit criteria for psychopathy or sadism since he demonstrated empathy and remorse mainly for sansan
- 2:12:18aria, and he didn't seem to harm others for pleasure. However, other
- 2:12:24clinicians could apply the label of antisocial personality disorder or psychopathy or sadism because he
- 2:12:30exhibited callousness and some pleasure upon harming others, But in my opinion, that
- 2:12:35attitude was likely part of his job, similar to someone in the military during
- 2:12:41wartime. And also, Sandor used alcohol to cope with stress, which would
- 2:12:48likely justify the label of alcohol use disorder. But we don't really know because
- 2:12:54we don't have all the data. So in conclusion, the hound suffers from
- 2:13:00likely PTSD. Showed you know, definite signs of that, and one could
- 2:13:05make the argument of antisocial personality disorder and sadism, not sexual sadism, but
- 2:13:11just general sadism. And there's likely a case of alcohol use disorder. All
- 2:13:18right. Moving on to Stanis Barathian, A blog of Thrones diagnoses him with
- 2:13:24stubbornness. Stubbornness is a mental illness. No, it's not sure he's stubborn,
- 2:13:33but so is everyone else in this story. If anyone, if anyone
- 2:13:37in this story deserves to be stubborn, it's him. He was the rightful
- 2:13:41king since Robert died, and Robert didn't have any legitimate heirs, so the
- 2:13:46crown was supposed to pass to him, and if anyone was supposed to be
- 2:13:52quote unquote stubborn, it's him. Plus he almost won. His stubbornness,
- 2:13:56you know, what you were labeling stubborn was actually instrumental in helping him almost
- 2:14:03win. If Winter had been a little slower, or if he had managed
- 2:14:05to beat Ramsey, he might have kept marching south and gaining more power,
- 2:14:09and you know, everything might have worked out for him, So you know,
- 2:14:15one one person stubborn is another person's determination, you know, And I
- 2:14:20was I was kind of pulling for Stantus until he killed his daughter, right
- 2:14:24But and of course George Martin loves to make people suffer, so of course
- 2:14:30Stanis had to lose to Ramsey. All right, smooved a Theon Grade Joy
- 2:14:35again. I did a full episode on theon so go check that out.
- 2:14:39What does MTV dot com have to say about Theon Grade Joy? They say,
- 2:14:43quote unquote complete break with Reality unquote, So that's their diagnosis again,
- 2:14:48a clinician was helping them write this complete break with Reality. What in the
- 2:14:54world does that mean? Does that mean psychosis? Does that mean delusional?
- 2:14:58I don't know. It's not a diagnosis. Not complete break with Reality is
- 2:15:03not in the DSM, So that's that's stupid. Plus the basis of it
- 2:15:07is also done, which I'll get into in a second. A blog of
- 2:15:11Thrones they diagnose with catalepsy, and it's even spelled wrong. Presumably since you
- 2:15:18own a website you can google things and catalepsy is spelled with an S,
- 2:15:22not a C. But anyway, catalep c is what A blog of Thrones
- 2:15:28is diagnosed them with which is not a mental disorder. It's not a it's
- 2:15:33not a d s M disorder. It is muscular rigidity or a fixed posture.
- 2:15:41So it's it's like catatonic in a certain sense. It's it you're you
- 2:15:45can't move, You're stuck in a in a position. And what Thean Gray
- 2:15:52Joy was was was had rigid muscles and a fixed posture. What are you
- 2:15:58been talking about out? Psychology today diagnosis theon Gray Joy with narcissistic personality disorder,
- 2:16:05Stockholm syndrome, and associative disorder. You could make a case for a
- 2:16:11narcisstic person I sort given the way that he was acting when he was younger.
- 2:16:16I wouldn't say he meets the full criteria, but you know you could
- 2:16:20you could make a case, depending on your definition of that personalite or Stockholm
- 2:16:24syndrome. Absolutely, I'll get into more than a second dissociative disorder. No,
- 2:16:30and I'll get it into that. So psychology today got I think one
- 2:16:33and a half out of three. WhatCulture dot com? They diagnose theon Gray
- 2:16:39Joy with psychotic break, which isn't a diagnosis. They diagnosed theon Grade Joy
- 2:16:48with associative identity disorder. They diagnosed the on grade Joy with PTSD and Stockholm
- 2:16:54syndrome. Okay, so let's get into this. Yes, he clearly effered
- 2:17:00from a tremendous amount of physical and emotional trauma, but it's hard to tell
- 2:17:03if he meets criteria for PTSD. We don't see him getting triggered, we
- 2:17:09see him anxious, we see him scared, but that's not enough for us
- 2:17:13to apply the label of PTSD. Really, his syndrome is more akin to
- 2:17:22Stockholm syndrome. You know, the experience of that abuse spouses will sometimes go
- 2:17:28through, and that he became submissive to the abusive person to save his life
- 2:17:33again, not in the DSM Stockholm syndrome. He also lost his identity as
- 2:17:41a result of the trauma, not as a result of well anyway, he
- 2:17:46lost his identity as a result of being tortured by Ramsey, which can happen
- 2:17:50when an abuser punishes identity congruent thoughts and behavior. So whenever theon said you
- 2:17:56know, I'm theon, he would get punished, and when he said I'm
- 2:17:58reek he was awarded. This was exacerbated I think by the pressure theon experience
- 2:18:05from his father, sister, and other people, you know, other ironborn
- 2:18:09to be ruthless and psychopathic, which was counter to a sense of morality.
- 2:18:13So he had to do all these like atrocities which were not really his thing,
- 2:18:18and this resulted in immense guilt and shame that contributed to him believing that
- 2:18:22he deserved to be punished by losing his identity. However, this was mainly
- 2:18:28what was presented to us in the TV show. In the books, it's
- 2:18:31less clear that he was remorseful. So so again getting in a narcissistic personality
- 2:18:37disorder sure traits maybe, but I wouldn't say the full blown disorder. Again,
- 2:18:45if you have seen full blown narcissistic personnality disorder, you would definitely not
- 2:18:48think young. Theon exhibited that that presentation. Also, Psychology Today said dissociative
- 2:18:56disorder, and what culture dot Com said dissociative identity disorder And just have to
- 2:19:01say, that's like so dumb. Clearly you do not understand associative identity disorder.
- 2:19:09And what culture dot com says psychotic break MTV dot com says complete break
- 2:19:16with reality. No, it's not psychotic. If someone abuses you to the
- 2:19:22point where you have to adopt a mindset that you that you are now Reek
- 2:19:30and that you deserve to be punished. And this is day in and day
- 2:19:33out. If you adopt that, that's not dissociative identity disorder. And again
- 2:19:39this is just another example of how the Internet is stupid, and frankly,
- 2:19:43how some clinicians writing on the Internet are stupid. I mean, you clearly
- 2:19:48just don't know what you're talking about. Dissociative identity disorder is it's a rare
- 2:19:52thing, but it happens. And when you are traumatized, usually as a
- 2:19:58young person repeat sort of like every day for a number of years, your
- 2:20:05personality splits into these different identities that sometimes don't even know each other. So
- 2:20:13the fact that Theon basically just probably made a calculation, as mine said,
- 2:20:18look, i got to become Greek because that's the only way I'm going to
- 2:20:20avoid getting tortured. So become Greek, act like Greek, even think like
- 2:20:26Greek, and that will save my life. And it did. And then
- 2:20:31when the time came that he could become Theon, he went back to he
- 2:20:35went back to thinking he was the On, But he was probably always Theon,
- 2:20:41he just was internally sort of adopting a character to survive, and that's
- 2:20:46not associated with Dennis don't be dumb and catileepsi. I don't even know where
- 2:20:52that comes from. I don't know how a blog of Thrones even got there.
- 2:20:56Is there something in the TV show or the books in which he becomes
- 2:20:58rigid in terms of his muscles? If so, then maybe I guess so.
- 2:21:05I would say, you know, if you want to be narcissistic,
- 2:21:09if you want to apply the narcissistic label, then sure, traits of narcisstic
- 2:21:13personal I disorder, but definitely not the full blown disorder. Definite Stockholm syndrome,
- 2:21:16not a DSM diagnosis, but you know, a human phenomenon and maybe
- 2:21:22PTSD, but definitely more assessment would be needed. It's hard to say,
- 2:21:28all right, we have two more people. Oh my god, we have
- 2:21:31Tyrian and we have taiwand Lanister. Let's talk about Tyrian first. What culture
- 2:21:35dot com calls him alcoholic? MTV dot com calls him alcoholic narcissist. That's
- 2:21:43the diagnosis, alcoholic narcissist. A blog of Thrones dot com says, Napoleon
- 2:21:48slash small man syndrome. Napoleon syndrome slash small man syndrome, which I will
- 2:21:58quote a known term to describe the inferiority complex that short men tend to possess.
- 2:22:03This causes them to overcompensate by putting more effort than men of regular heightwood
- 2:22:11end quote. What in the world are you talking about? Blog of Thrones.
- 2:22:15That is the dumbest thing. Napole It's not a known term to who
- 2:22:20the internet. Napoleon syndrome, small man syndrome. Uh, this is one
- 2:22:24of those, you know, offensive stereotypes. You're you're short, you're little,
- 2:22:31and that automatically makes you have this Napoleon syndrome. Plus, you know,
- 2:22:41Tyrian is a legit dude, Like he has legit powers. You know,
- 2:22:46he's smart, and he's diplomatic, and he cares about people, and
- 2:22:52you know he's trying to be bigger than I don't know, I don't even
- 2:22:56know what you're saying, Napoleon complex, Like this is dumb thought atalog dot
- 2:23:00com alcoholism And again, since this site provides treatment plans ninety days of alcohol
- 2:23:05rehab, ninety days of alcohol rehab, all right, what do I think?
- 2:23:11Well, as with Circe, it's hard to tell what his drinking is
- 2:23:16really like in real life. You know, yeah, he drinks a lot,
- 2:23:20just like Circe, But more assessment would be needed to see if he
- 2:23:24fit criteria. I mean, let's look at the actual criteria for alcohol use
- 2:23:28disorder. So there are different degrees. So if so, you can,
- 2:23:33but you need at least two of the following taken in larger amounts than intended?
- 2:23:41Has has Tyrian ever taken larger amounts of wine than intended? You know,
- 2:23:46I don't know if we know that. I don't know if you know
- 2:23:48the answer that persistent desire to use or unsuccessful efforts to cut back. So
- 2:23:54has he ever tried to cut back and failed at cutting back? Hard to
- 2:23:58say, but you know, possible, lots of time spent getting alcohol,
- 2:24:03using it, and being hungover again unknown, a lot of craving. Probably
- 2:24:11there were times when in at least the TV show that I remember that he
- 2:24:16was like, where's the wine? I need the wine? Interference with work
- 2:24:22and with home life hard to say. He uses in the face of consequences
- 2:24:30that's unknown to me. Gives up on activities in order to use alcohol,
- 2:24:35that's unknown. Does he use when it's dangerous to do so? Hard to
- 2:24:41say. Does he use even when he knows that it's harming him? Maybe
- 2:24:48he seems to know that wine isn't the best thing and he uses it anyway.
- 2:24:52Does he have tolerance? You know? Does he need more to get
- 2:24:56drunk? I would say probably. Does he experience with draw all symptoms when
- 2:25:00he doesn't, you know, get alcohol? Yeah, I think they exhibited
- 2:25:03that at least in the TV show. So he seems to qualify for a
- 2:25:07few of these, now I would not so. Uh. The the d
- 2:25:13s M five, the new d s M five, Uh, the criteria
- 2:25:18for substance disorders. They have a very low threshold. So in order to
- 2:25:24qualify for the mild version of alcohol use disorder, you only need two of
- 2:25:28these criteria to be met. Moderate is four to five and six plus is
- 2:25:33severe. So again, I just I just want to say this to you
- 2:25:35out there. If you, if you drink alcohol and you and you qualify
- 2:25:43for two of these eleven criteria, then you have a mental illness. So
- 2:25:48again I just want to which which I don't agree with, by the way,
- 2:25:50I think d s M five set the criteria way too fucking low.
- 2:25:54But anyway, so out of the eleven criteria. If you say yes or
- 2:26:00even you know, kind of and maybe to these, then you have to
- 2:26:03admit to yourself that, according to US five you have you have alcohol use
- 2:26:09disorder one? Do you take in larger amounts than intended? You know?
- 2:26:15Do you ever say tonight, I'll have two drinks and instead you take three?
- 2:26:18Has that happened to you? Number two? Persistent desire to use or
- 2:26:24unsuccessful efforts to cut back? Have you ever tried to cut back like,
- 2:26:28Okay, I'm not going to drink as much for the next you know,
- 2:26:31few months, and then you you don't succeed at that goal. Has that
- 2:26:33ever happened to you? Number three? Lots of time spent getting alcohol,
- 2:26:39lots of time spent using it, and lots lots of time being spent hungover
- 2:26:43that sort of a higher threshold thing, so you know. Number four craving
- 2:26:50Have you ever craved alcohol like, boy, I need a drink, or
- 2:26:54you know, you're just like, oh man, I can't wait to go
- 2:26:56off my friends and have a drink, or you know, I need to
- 2:26:58be here, you know? Has that ever happened to you? Number five?
- 2:27:01Interference with work and home? Has your drinking ever made it difficult to
- 2:27:07be in your relationship or difficult to work, or difficult for your home life.
- 2:27:13Number six, have you ever used, in the face of consequences drinking
- 2:27:18more than one or two drinks? Most of us understand that's not good for
- 2:27:22our health, right, So have you done that? Number seven? Give
- 2:27:28up on activities to use? So this is sort of a higher level threat
- 2:27:31criteria criterion to you know, have you ever, for instance, not gone
- 2:27:37to a birthday party because you wanted to stay home and drink or something?
- 2:27:41Number eight? Do you ever drink alcohol when it's dangerous to do so?
- 2:27:46Like have you ever driven drunk or drink when you knew you had to drive
- 2:27:52home? Has that rappened to you? Number nine? Do you ever drink
- 2:27:54alcohol when you know it's harming you? So it's similar to the one I
- 2:27:58was saying before. Number ten, do you have a tolerance? And do
- 2:28:01you do you need to drink more now than you used to to feel a
- 2:28:09buzz? You know? Number eleven, have you ever experienced withdrawal symptoms which
- 2:28:13is basically a hangover? So if you have said so, I don't know
- 2:28:18how if you counted how many said yes, But if you said yes,
- 2:28:22two or three times, then you have mild alcohol use disorder. If you
- 2:28:26said yes four to five, then you have moderate and said if he said
- 2:28:30yes the six plus, you have severe alcohol use disorder. So the threshold
- 2:28:37is you know, anyway, it's hard to know if Tyrian had it,
- 2:28:39but he probably did, so we could probably apply either a mild or moderate
- 2:28:45alcohol use disorder to Tyrian. But he doesn't suffer from a narcissistic person disorder
- 2:28:52or Napoleon small man syndrome. You know, as with Circe, and as
- 2:28:58with Jamie, and as with you know a lot of these people. They
- 2:29:03are legitimately important people. And lu Tyrian Lanister thinking that he is smart,
- 2:29:09thinking that he's important. It's true, he is important and he is smart,
- 2:29:13and so I wouldn't say he has a narcissistic personality disorder. Again,
- 2:29:20don't be dumb, okay, Taiwin Lanister. Taiwin Lanister, a blog of
- 2:29:26Throne says, megalomania megalomania because quote ruthless, a moral, high ambitious,
- 2:29:35ruthless a moral highly ambitious, but with a thirst and lust for power unquote
- 2:29:41what do I ask saying about that? Megalomania is not a diagnosis. And
- 2:29:46it's really true for many of the people in gaber thrones that they're ruthless and
- 2:29:52ambitious and they lust for power. I mean, so why would you apply
- 2:29:58that Taiwin isn't acting really any different than anyone else would in his positions.
- 2:30:01It's it's everyone has their job, you know what that this is all based
- 2:30:07on medieval Europe, right, And for those houses, when you are in
- 2:30:13charge of a major house, it's your job to sustain the house, and
- 2:30:18if that means being ruthless, then that's what it means. And if you
- 2:30:20aren't ruthless, then someone else is going to take you over. With Taiwan,
- 2:30:24you know specifically, just you know his story when he was a kid,
- 2:30:28his dad, so you know, s Tyrian's grandfather. So Taiwan when
- 2:30:33Taiwan was a kid and his father almost lost their seat of power because Taiwan's
- 2:30:41father was weak and not ruthless, and a bunch of other houses, minor
- 2:30:46houses rose up against Taiwan's father and almost eliminated Taiwan and his family from power
- 2:30:54even from their lives. And Taiwan, as a young person, actually stepped
- 2:30:58in and to go over and fought back these smaller houses and sustained house lanister.
- 2:31:07So if Taiwan had not been ruthless as a young person, house slanister
- 2:31:11wouldn't exist anymore. That's what the world that they live in the reason why
- 2:31:16Taiwan is ruthless is because he has to be ruthless, because this society made
- 2:31:22him into a ruthless person. So to call him a megalami maniac, like
- 2:31:28there's something wrong with him just completely misunderstands the context. It's similar to when
- 2:31:33people will label an inner city kid who his only means of making a living
- 2:31:41and paying for food for his family is to sell cocaine on the corner and
- 2:31:48sell meth on the corner. Well, he's breaking the law, and you
- 2:31:54know maybe that involves being violent with rival drug people or something. Well,
- 2:32:01he has anti social personality sore, you know, he's breaking the law.
- 2:32:05He doesn't have a regard for you know, other people's lives. What's wrong
- 2:32:09with this kid? He has he has a mental illness. But if you
- 2:32:13understand the context that this person lives, and then you understand, oh,
- 2:32:16it's his environment, that's that's he this is his life. He for whatever
- 2:32:22reason feels as though and and may be true that this is his way to
- 2:32:26survive. And if he doesn't become ruthless and if he doesn't sell drugs and
- 2:32:31if he doesn't break the law, then him and his family will not survive
- 2:32:35in this environment. And so it's it's not a mental illness to survive,
- 2:32:41is the point. And Taiwan lanister as well as people, and he does
- 2:32:46not qualify for a diagnosis, So I would say Taiwan does not qualify for
- 2:32:50any DSM diagnosis. So wow, how long? How long was that was
- 2:32:56that? Three hours? My god? Let me know what you think,
- 2:32:58and I'll probably we talk more in depth about other people. People want me
- 2:33:03to talk about Drara, people want me to talk about Tyrian and it's fun,
- 2:33:09so I probably will. But anyway, let me know what you think
- 2:33:13about all this stuff. And again, if you haven't already, please become
- 2:33:16a patron of the podcast by going to patreon dot com. When you become
- 2:33:20a patron, you get access to all these really super interesting deep dives that
- 2:33:24we've done over the years. So please, please, please, if you
- 2:33:28can, if you haven't already, become a patron. If you're already a
- 2:33:31patron, and you up and you up, your situation to twenty dollars,
- 2:33:37then you will get a mug. I'm about to send out a bunch of
- 2:33:39mugs in a couple of days to some people who are in this category.
- 2:33:46I have to say this mug is awesome. I use it every day,
- 2:33:48not narcissistically, not only because of narcissism because my face is on it,
- 2:33:52but also because the cup is the perfect coffee cup, the perfect handle,
- 2:33:56the perfect size that it's kind of thinner and taller, but not too thin
- 2:34:01and too tall, if that makes any sense. Also, if you can
- 2:34:05tell a friend or our colleague about the podcast. I think a lot of
- 2:34:09people hear about us through word of mouth. So if you're in a graduate
- 2:34:11training program, you know, tell tell others around you that's you know,
- 2:34:16spread the word. That's cool if you can do that. Also, if
- 2:34:18you can rate us on iTunes, that'd be cool. And let me know
- 2:34:22if you rate us on iTunes and I'll send you some swag. Also join
- 2:34:26the Facebook fan group Face Psychology and Seattle Facebook or Psychology and Seattle fan group.
- 2:34:33I think it's cool and it has a lively group of individuals. There.
- 2:34:37Also, you can join our Instagram, of which I post a picture
- 2:34:41about once every two months, so there's that. Also, you can like
- 2:34:48the regular Psychology and Seattle page on Facebook, in which I post tougher bluffs
- 2:34:52every Tuesday. Yeah, out there people. I know that there are people
- 2:34:56that probably don't know about this, but every Tuesday morning I post a Tougher
- 2:35:01bluff on the Facebook page, not the Facebook fan page, but the regular
- 2:35:05Facebook page, and it's always a lively participation situation, and people in my
- 2:35:13family, including my parents, often participate. So anyway, that is that
- 2:35:20for that episode. Thanks for sticking with it, and please take care of
- 2:35:24yourself and take care of others because we all deserve it,