Latest / Bloomberg Law / SCOTUS Takes Death Penalty Case & Crypto Face-off
Transcript
- 0:03Speaker 1: This is Bloomberg Law with June Brusso from Bloomberg Radio.
- 0:10Speaker 2: Richard Glossop has been just hours away from being executed
- 0:14Speaker 2: three times. He's maintained his innocence through more than a
- 0:18Speaker 2: quarter century on Oklahoma's death row, telling news outlets like
- 0:22Speaker 2: Sky News that he's not guilty of hiring a coworker
- 0:26Speaker 2: to kill the owner of the motel where he worked
- 0:29Speaker 2: in nineteen ninety seven.
- 0:30Speaker 3: I didn't commit this crime, and there's no down in
- 0:34Speaker 3: my line that I may die because of this. I'm
- 0:39Speaker 3: truly sorry for what happened to Arry. I am, but
- 0:42Speaker 3: I had nothing to do with it.
- 0:44Speaker 2: Glossop's case has garnered international attention.
- 0:47Speaker 4: You never done this before. Yeah, it's close to a
- 0:50Speaker 4: murder before.
- 0:52Speaker 5: What is it doing in a place like it?
- 0:55Speaker 2: Sister Helen Prejahn, the death penalty opponent portrayed in the
- 0:59Speaker 2: nineteen ninety one five movie Dead Man Walking, has taken
- 1:02Speaker 2: up his cause, as have celebrities like Kim Kardashian and
- 1:06Speaker 2: Susan Sarandon.
- 1:07Speaker 4: Richard's case is so typical, you know, bad representation to
- 1:14Speaker 4: trials that were ridiculous, no physical evidence. You know, he's
- 1:18Speaker 4: put there by a snitch who actually did kill the person,
- 1:21Speaker 4: and then the snitches has life, and this guy is
- 1:26Speaker 4: being put to death.
- 1:27Speaker 2: And now Glossop has support from an unprecedented place. Oklahoma's
- 1:32Speaker 2: Republican Attorney General, Gentner Drummond, the state's top prosecutor, has
- 1:37Speaker 2: been urging the courts to undo his conviction, saying he
- 1:40Speaker 2: didn't get a fair trial due to critical errors, including
- 1:44Speaker 2: the destruction and suppression of evidence. The state has set
- 1:47Speaker 2: nine execution dates for Glossip, and just days before he
- 1:51Speaker 2: was again scheduled to be executed in May, the Supreme
- 1:55Speaker 2: Court blocked his execution and this Monday decided to review
- 1:59Speaker 2: his case. My guest is John Bloom, the director of
- 2:02Speaker 2: the Cornell Law Death Penalty Project. How unusual is it
- 2:07Speaker 2: for this Supreme Court to grant a stay of execution?
- 2:12Speaker 6: Well, this is a court that has been in general
- 2:15Speaker 6: hostile to inmates. So they've been reluctant to grant review
- 2:19Speaker 6: in capital cases and have been hesitant to interstags of execution.
- 2:24Speaker 6: And most of their work has been vacating stays of
- 2:26Speaker 6: execution which you've been entered by lower courts.
- 2:29Speaker 1: So why do you think they took this case?
- 2:31Speaker 6: Most likely the court took Gossop's case because it had
- 2:35Speaker 6: the extremely unusual feature of the Attorney General of the
- 2:40Speaker 6: relevant state here Oklahoma, agreeing with Gossip that he was
- 2:44Speaker 6: denied the right to a fair trial, and the Supreme
- 2:46Speaker 6: Court should intercede.
- 2:47Speaker 2: Explain the circumstances and why the Attorney general came to
- 2:53Speaker 2: that conclusion and independent investigations came to that conclusion.
- 2:59Speaker 6: Yes, For years been a number of questions raised about
- 3:01Speaker 6: colossups in his innocence, and new evidences resurface casting light
- 3:05Speaker 6: on the credibility of the main person that testified against
- 3:09Speaker 6: him in this particular case. And then there was some
- 3:12Speaker 6: additional evidence discovered by the prosecution and disclosed to the defense,
- 3:16Speaker 6: which has formed the basis of this most recent appeal,
- 3:19Speaker 6: and been several independent commissions, both of which have found
- 3:22Speaker 6: serious problems with the fairness and the constitutionality of his trial.
- 3:28Speaker 6: And so after reviewing all that evidence, the Attorney General
- 3:31Speaker 6: concluded that he should get a new trial.
- 3:33Speaker 2: Did prosecutors withhold a box of documents this whole time
- 3:39Speaker 2: and just turned it over to the defense recently, Yes.
- 3:43Speaker 6: Been referred to in the press as Box eight, But yes,
- 3:46Speaker 6: they found a box of materials which cast furthered out
- 3:50Speaker 6: and corroborated some of the suspicions that people had about
- 3:53Speaker 6: the main witness, a person named Sneedge's credibility in this
- 3:56Speaker 6: particular case, indicating that he'd been significantly coached testimony that
- 4:00Speaker 6: he was under the influence of some powerful drugs that
- 4:03Speaker 6: had psychiatric problems. And so after reviewing all that, the
- 4:07Speaker 6: Attorney General in Oklahoma said, yes, I think this person
- 4:10Speaker 6: should get a fair trial. The Oklahoma Court of Criminal
- 4:13Speaker 6: Opiles said no. But I think the unique feature of
- 4:16Speaker 6: this is that the judgment is not being defended by
- 4:19Speaker 6: the attorney General of the state of Oklahoma. They are
- 4:21Speaker 6: confessing that there was constitutional error in Glossop's case.
- 4:24Speaker 2: As you mentioned, the Oklahoma appeals Court upheld his conviction,
- 4:28Speaker 2: and the court ruling noted that the attorney General said
- 4:32Speaker 2: he was not suggesting Glossop is innocent, but only that
- 4:36Speaker 2: justice would not be served by executing him. Was that
- 4:41Speaker 2: the main reason they didn't overturn the case.
- 4:44Speaker 6: I mean, I think the main reason they didn't overturn
- 4:46Speaker 6: the case, at least according to what they said, is
- 4:49Speaker 6: they didn't feel like this a new evidence met the
- 4:52Speaker 6: legal standard in Oklahoma to file a second petition. I
- 4:55Speaker 6: don't really understand that under their own rules, it would
- 4:58Speaker 6: seem that this type of perspesive showing of innocence would
- 5:01Speaker 6: satisfy the standard to have a second post conviction relief
- 5:05Speaker 6: hearing in mister Glossop's case. But the Oaks Homeless Corkorne opils,
- 5:10Speaker 6: you know, said no, and that again is unusual, and
- 5:14Speaker 6: that's probably why the Supreme Court took it.
- 5:16Speaker 2: And the state's pardoned parole board deadlocked in a vote
- 5:20Speaker 2: to even grant him clemency.
- 5:22Speaker 6: Yes, I understand they didn't have the full panel, but
- 5:24Speaker 6: the people that were there deadlocked on whether to grant
- 5:27Speaker 6: clemency or not.
- 5:28Speaker 2: Do you understand why the Attorney General thinks that this
- 5:34Speaker 2: was a miscarriage of justice and yet he still believes
- 5:38Speaker 2: in Glossop's guilt.
- 5:40Speaker 6: I think that's really a mischaracterization of what he said.
- 5:44Speaker 6: I think what he has that is, I'm not persuaded
- 5:48Speaker 6: that Glossop is innocent, but I am persuaded that the
- 5:52Speaker 6: trial itself, which produced his convictions and death sentences, was
- 5:57Speaker 6: not reliable because of the fact if the jury didn't
- 6:01Speaker 6: hear all the other And that's a little different from
- 6:03Speaker 6: saying I don't think he's endoctent. I think he's saying no,
- 6:05Speaker 6: I don't know whether he's innocent or not, and there's
- 6:07Speaker 6: been questions raised about his inisence. I'm not saying that
- 6:10Speaker 6: he is, but I am saying this trial wasn't sufficiently
- 6:13Speaker 6: reliable to produce an outcome which I'm comfortable allowing his
- 6:17Speaker 6: person to be executed.
- 6:19Speaker 1: Okay, I accept that distinction.
- 6:21Speaker 2: So now Oklahoma set nine execution dates for him, and
- 6:25Speaker 2: he's been just hours away from being executed three times.
- 6:29Speaker 2: How do you think he's managed to survive through all
- 6:32Speaker 2: those execution dates when you know other inmates on death
- 6:36Speaker 2: row are not so able.
- 6:39Speaker 6: I think the two primary reasons, which aren't necessarily mutually exclusive,
- 6:43Speaker 6: One is that he's had a lot of very good
- 6:46Speaker 6: lawyers working very hard to save his life over the years.
- 6:50Speaker 6: And two, he's been fortunate, been lucky in some respects
- 6:53Speaker 6: that this has been stayed. And often that's what it takes, right,
- 6:57Speaker 6: people working really hard and a little bit of luck
- 6:59Speaker 6: thrown in.
- 7:00Speaker 2: The Supreme Court did consider his case once before, although
- 7:03Speaker 2: not the merits of it explain why one of his
- 7:06Speaker 2: execution dates was set aside by the Justices in twenty fifteen.
- 7:11Speaker 6: Yes, there was previously a challenge to the execution methods
- 7:14Speaker 6: in this case, and part of that and whether he
- 7:16Speaker 6: could be executed humanly under lethal injection. So it didn't
- 7:20Speaker 6: deal with this question of whether there's a pervasive showing
- 7:23Speaker 6: events and sufficient to warrant a new evidentiary hearing or
- 7:26Speaker 6: some new proceedings, So they look at different issues.
- 7:28Speaker 2: The Supreme Court had been weighing his appeal since late September.
- 7:33Speaker 2: Do you have any indication or do you have any
- 7:35Speaker 2: suspicions about why the delay in acting.
- 7:39Speaker 6: It's not that I don't want to say it's that typical,
- 7:41Speaker 6: but it's not uncommon for a case to be the
- 7:44Speaker 6: technical term is relisted a conference and relisted and those
- 7:47Speaker 6: of the court talks about it, and then they don't
- 7:50Speaker 6: do anything, and then it comes back and relisted. Sometimes
- 7:52Speaker 6: that means that they are trying to look more deeply
- 7:56Speaker 6: at the record. Sometimes it means someone is going to
- 7:58Speaker 6: dissent or write an opinion. Sometimes it means there's going
- 8:02Speaker 6: to be a procureum reversal. In other words, they are
- 8:04Speaker 6: going to just go ahead and reverse it on the
- 8:05Speaker 6: pleadings without doing it and in this case, they just
- 8:08Speaker 6: sat on it and decided to look at the meyristocket. So,
- 8:11Speaker 6: I mean, there's a lot to go through in this case,
- 8:14Speaker 6: and I think it just is a further indication that
- 8:17Speaker 6: the court was troubled by this, and I think it's
- 8:20Speaker 6: unlikely they took it to say, yeah, we're going to
- 8:23Speaker 6: let you execute it. And usually when they take a
- 8:25Speaker 6: case in this posture, they're taking it to reverse it.
- 8:28Speaker 2: Wasn't there a similar situation to Glossups a year ago
- 8:32Speaker 2: and the justices ordered Texas Appeals Court to look at
- 8:35Speaker 2: the case again and it was a death row inmate
- 8:38Speaker 2: who had the backing of prosecutors as well.
- 8:41Speaker 6: Yes, I mean, this is not a completely unique situation,
- 8:44Speaker 6: but it's virtually unprecedented in many ways. And in this case,
- 8:47Speaker 6: you have not only the attorney general, a lot of
- 8:49Speaker 6: very conservative lawmakers in Oklahoma are also coming forward supporting
- 8:52Speaker 6: gloss Up and just saying we shouldn't execute him at
- 8:55Speaker 6: this time. So it's a very I think the fact
- 8:57Speaker 6: that he has a lot of people supporting him who
- 8:59Speaker 6: are not what you would generally call the usual suspects
- 9:03Speaker 6: is part of what makes this case stand out and
- 9:06Speaker 6: probably explain the Supreme Court decision to review it.
- 9:09Speaker 2: It's gotten national attention. There's been a documentary and Susan
- 9:13Speaker 2: Sarandon brought a tangent to it. Kim Kardashian urged her
- 9:17Speaker 2: social media followers to contact the parole board. So he's
- 9:21Speaker 2: gotten more attention than most death row inmates.
- 9:24Speaker 6: That is true, and credible showings of innocence tend to
- 9:27Speaker 6: do that.
- 9:27Speaker 2: What is the question the High Court is actually going
- 9:30Speaker 2: to decide, Well.
- 9:31Speaker 6: Basically they've been asked to decide whether the prosecution's failure
- 9:35Speaker 6: to disclose this evidence the prime glossip of a fair trial.
- 9:39Speaker 6: This information was with hell. There's a Supreme Court decision
- 9:42Speaker 6: called Brady versus Maryland who says prosecutors have a duty
- 9:46Speaker 6: under the due Process clause to disclose material exculpatory information.
- 9:50Speaker 6: And the Oklahoma Court Criminal Appeal said this didn't fall
- 9:53Speaker 6: into that category, and the cirt Peedition says, we think
- 9:56Speaker 6: it does. We won't use Supreme Court to rule on that.
- 10:00Speaker 6: What they're going to rule upon.
- 10:01Speaker 2: If the Supreme Court reverses his conviction, could he be
- 10:04Speaker 2: tried again.
- 10:05Speaker 4: For the murder?
- 10:06Speaker 6: Yes, I mean theoretically yes. The Court isn't in the
- 10:10Speaker 6: business as saying, no, you can't retry this person again.
- 10:13Speaker 6: Normally what they do as they say, there was a
- 10:15Speaker 6: problem this trial. We remanded back for proceedings consistent with
- 10:18Speaker 6: his opinion. I do think, given all the evidence which
- 10:21Speaker 6: points towards CLASSPS innocence here at the Supreme Court reverses
- 10:25Speaker 6: extremely unlikely there will ever be another trial.
- 10:29Speaker 2: I'd also like to get your reaction to Attorney General
- 10:32Speaker 2: Merrick Garland's decision this month to seek the death penalty
- 10:37Speaker 2: for the massacre that occurred at a Buffalo supermarket last year.
- 10:42Speaker 2: After he took office, Garland had issued a moratorium on
- 10:46Speaker 2: federal executions, and this is his first approval of a
- 10:50Speaker 2: new capital prosecution.
- 10:52Speaker 6: Very disappointing. I mean, president did run on an anti
- 10:55Speaker 6: Deathtony campaign. I relized. This isn't the president himself, This
- 10:58Speaker 6: is the president's attorney general, so there is some independence
- 11:02Speaker 6: and what the attorney general does versus what the president does.
- 11:06Speaker 6: But you know, for whatever reason they felt compelled to
- 11:08Speaker 6: do this, maybe because they did it in Pittsburgh, you know,
- 11:12Speaker 6: I don't know.
- 11:14Speaker 2: Do you think that even bringing one capital case diminishes
- 11:18Speaker 2: their protestations against the death penalty?
- 11:22Speaker 6: That's true. I mean, I think the main lesson one
- 11:25Speaker 6: of the reasons the presidents that he opposed it was
- 11:28Speaker 6: wasn't persuaded that it could be done fairly in the
- 11:30Speaker 6: majority of cases. And there's lots of evidence to support that,
- 11:33Speaker 6: and it can't be done anymore fairly in the case.
- 11:36Speaker 6: I mean, And of course I would never say that
- 11:38Speaker 6: what happened in Buffalo wasn't anything but horrific. You know
- 11:41Speaker 6: it clearly was. But still the death only is not
- 11:44Speaker 6: going to solve what created that crime, what caused that crime,
- 11:48Speaker 6: and in the end, isn't going to bring anyone's.
- 11:51Speaker 4: Love them back.
- 11:52Speaker 2: It's such a difficult topic. Thanks so much for sharing
- 11:54Speaker 2: your insights with me. That's John bloom director of the
- 11:58Speaker 2: Cornell Death Penalty Project. Coming up next, another face off
- 12:02Speaker 2: in federal court over crypto. I'm June Grossow, and you're
- 12:05Speaker 2: listening to Bloomberg. A hearing in federal court in DC
- 12:09Speaker 2: is being closely watched by the crypto industry because it
- 12:13Speaker 2: could help determine the extent of the SEC's jurisdiction over
- 12:17Speaker 2: digital assets. If that sounds familiar to you, it's because
- 12:21Speaker 2: the same issues were the subject of a hearing in
- 12:23Speaker 2: another case last week in Manhattan Federal Court that was
- 12:27Speaker 2: the legal battle between the SEC and Coinbase. This is
- 12:31Speaker 2: the legal battle between the SEC and Binance. These two
- 12:34Speaker 2: hearings are about the threshold issue of the definition of
- 12:38Speaker 2: a security. The SEC's actual case against Binance differs from
- 12:43Speaker 2: the case against its rival Coinbase because it includes allegations
- 12:47Speaker 2: of fraud and market manipulation. In fact, last November, Attorney
- 12:51Speaker 2: General Merrick Garlott announced that Binance was paying one of
- 12:54Speaker 2: the largest corporate penalties in US history four point three
- 12:59Speaker 2: billion dollars for money laundering.
- 13:01Speaker 7: Finance facilitated billions of dollars of unregulated cryptocurrency transactions. It
- 13:08Speaker 7: willfully enabled hundreds of millions of dollars in transactions between
- 13:13Speaker 7: American users and users subject to US sanctions, and its
- 13:18Speaker 7: platform accommodated criminals across the world who use finance to
- 13:23Speaker 7: move their stolen funds and other criminal proceeds.
- 13:27Speaker 2: Joining me is securities law expert James Park, a professor
- 13:30Speaker 2: at UCLA Law School. Jim. The SEC has argued that
- 13:34Speaker 2: most crypto assets fall under its jurisdiction and are subject
- 13:38Speaker 2: to its rules. Is it taking too broad an approach?
- 13:43Speaker 5: And I think that the SEC has to think about
- 13:48Speaker 5: the limits of its arguments. What are the limits of
- 13:51Speaker 5: its ability to regulate crypto assets? And in fairness to
- 13:56Speaker 5: the SEC in litigation, you are, you know, trying to
- 14:01Speaker 5: advance the position and trying to advance as broad of
- 14:04Speaker 5: a position as possible. And I think that is to
- 14:09Speaker 5: some extent reflected in the positions the SEC has taken.
- 14:14Speaker 5: At the same time, as a regulator, you have to
- 14:17Speaker 5: understand that at some point you have to define standards
- 14:21Speaker 5: that will give some guidance as to the limits of
- 14:24Speaker 5: your authority. And I think that's what the SEC has
- 14:27Speaker 5: to continue to think about now.
- 14:28Speaker 2: They have to.
- 14:29Speaker 5: Find some limits, right For example, they have concluded that
- 14:33Speaker 5: bitcoin is not a security, and bitcoin is the most
- 14:38Speaker 5: valuable crypto asset that's out there, worth you know, almost
- 14:42Speaker 5: a trillion dollars if you believe the valuation, and the
- 14:46Speaker 5: SEC is saying we're not regulating bitcoin. So, you know,
- 14:49Speaker 5: I think that the SEC has set some limits, and
- 14:53Speaker 5: the question is whether the courts are going to require
- 14:56Speaker 5: or define further limits for the SEC regulation of crypto assets.
- 15:02Speaker 2: Does the SEC's case against Binance differ from its case
- 15:06Speaker 2: against coinbase because it includes allegations of fraud and market manipulation.
- 15:13Speaker 5: It is different, and I think that the case against
- 15:16Speaker 5: Finance is more compelling because of those allegations relating to
- 15:22Speaker 5: a lack of compliance by the exchange in regulating questionable transactions,
- 15:29Speaker 5: and I think that that is ultimately going to make
- 15:32Speaker 5: Finance an easier case for the SEC. Having said that,
- 15:36Speaker 5: these initial motions to dismiss that have been argued are
- 15:40Speaker 5: about certain threshold issues with respect to the definition of
- 15:44Speaker 5: the security that are pretty much the same in both
- 15:47Speaker 5: the Binance and the coin based cases. So there are
- 15:51Speaker 5: some fundamental similarities about the initial stages of these cases.
- 15:57Speaker 5: I expect though, that as the litigation moves forward, assuming
- 16:01Speaker 5: that it does move forward, that the SEC will have
- 16:04Speaker 5: an easier time in the Binance case than the coinbas case.
- 16:09Speaker 2: So where does this piece fit in Binance and its
- 16:12Speaker 2: CEO pleaded guilty to Justice Department charges and settle with
- 16:16Speaker 2: the CFTC and the Treasury Department in November, with Binance
- 16:20Speaker 2: paying four point three billion dollars and shangpen Jao agreeing
- 16:25Speaker 2: to step down as CEO?
- 16:27Speaker 1: Does that fit anywhere?
- 16:28Speaker 2: Into this case?
- 16:30Speaker 5: Fits in? But indirectly, I think my understanding of those
- 16:33Speaker 5: charges as they related to compliance with various money laundering
- 16:38Speaker 5: statutes that require financial institutions to monitor suspicious transaction, and
- 16:46Speaker 5: Finance did not do that. Now there's a separate question
- 16:50Speaker 5: as to whether or not the Binance exchanges are they
- 16:54Speaker 5: securities exchanges, and that's an entirely separate issue that is
- 17:00Speaker 5: being litigated with the sec Then I expect that the
- 17:03Speaker 5: fact that Finances litigating this case seems to indicate that
- 17:08Speaker 5: they think that they can continue to do business even
- 17:12Speaker 5: with a substantial settlement like the one with the Department
- 17:17Speaker 5: of Justice, and that they believe that if they can
- 17:20Speaker 5: win I'm against the sec that they have a viable
- 17:24Speaker 5: business going forward. And it also speaks to the amount
- 17:27Speaker 5: of revenue these exchanges have generated that they're able to
- 17:32Speaker 5: afford such a large monetary penalty and still continue doing business.
- 17:39Speaker 2: So, as you mentioned, the case hinges on whether the
- 17:42Speaker 2: tokens fit within the definition of an investment contract. So
- 17:46Speaker 2: for those who have not been following this crypto debate,
- 17:51Speaker 2: explain what that means.
- 17:53Speaker 5: The term. The phrase investment contract is listed in the
- 17:58Speaker 5: definition of a security in the major federal securities laws.
- 18:03Speaker 5: At the very beginning of the Statute. They have definitions, right,
- 18:06Speaker 5: and one of the key definitions is that of a security,
- 18:09Speaker 5: and there is a long list. I mean, if you
- 18:11Speaker 5: ever get a chance to read the definition of a
- 18:14Speaker 5: security in the Federal Securities Acts of nineteen thirty three,
- 18:18Speaker 5: or or security is a Change Act in nineteen thirty four,
- 18:21Speaker 5: you won't really be able to make heads or tails
- 18:24Speaker 5: of it. It's a long laundry list. And I think
- 18:27Speaker 5: that the fact that you have this long list of
- 18:30Speaker 5: different types of things that could be securities evidence is
- 18:34Speaker 5: an intense by Congress that the definition of security is
- 18:38Speaker 5: fairly brought. So you have included in the definition of
- 18:41Speaker 5: a security some standard securities like a stock, a bond,
- 18:46Speaker 5: securities we're all familiar with. And then there is this
- 18:49Speaker 5: category of investment contract. And the meaning of investment contract
- 18:53Speaker 5: is not self evident. It's been defined though in a
- 18:57Speaker 5: Supreme Court case, the Howie case, and the big essence
- 19:01Speaker 5: of it, it's an investment in a common enterprise where
- 19:05Speaker 5: there is an expectation of profits through the efforts of others.
- 19:10Speaker 5: That's a mouthful, but it is a broad definition that
- 19:14Speaker 5: is meant to capture those financial arrangements that do not
- 19:19Speaker 5: quite fit into the category of stock or bonds, but
- 19:22Speaker 5: we think of as having the fundamental attributes of a
- 19:25Speaker 5: security and to try to translate that legal definition into
- 19:31Speaker 5: sort of common concepts. I think the basic idea is
- 19:34Speaker 5: you're investing in a business, a common enterprise that is
- 19:38Speaker 5: expected to generate profits, and you are not the one
- 19:43Speaker 5: running the business. You are somebody who has invested with
- 19:46Speaker 5: the expectation that the folks who are running the business
- 19:50Speaker 5: are going to generate profits. And that is the fundamental
- 19:55Speaker 5: essence of a security. And the sec has maintained that
- 19:59Speaker 5: some crypto assets are essentially like an investment in a
- 20:04Speaker 5: type of business that is expected or hopes to generate profits,
- 20:09Speaker 5: and that's why investors are buying these crypto assets.
- 20:14Speaker 2: Let's look at the arguments from both sides in the case.
- 20:17Speaker 2: So an attorney for Binance said that the company had
- 20:20Speaker 2: no obligations to investors after selling certain tokens, which would
- 20:25Speaker 2: need to be the case if the assets were to
- 20:27Speaker 2: be considered securities.
- 20:29Speaker 5: That's essentially trying to say it's not a contract, and
- 20:33Speaker 5: they are really focusing in on the plain meaning of
- 20:37Speaker 5: investment contract. We need some sort of a contract between
- 20:41Speaker 5: the investor and the common enterprise and they maintain that
- 20:46Speaker 5: there is no such contract. I think there are a
- 20:49Speaker 5: couple of responses one can make to that argument.
- 20:52Speaker 2: The first is.
- 20:53Speaker 5: That you know, to have a contract, it's an agreement.
- 20:56Speaker 5: It's an agreement, and it doesn't have to be written down.
- 20:59Speaker 5: So long as there is a expectation between the investor
- 21:04Speaker 5: and the enterprise that the enterprise is working to increase
- 21:08Speaker 5: the value of the crypto asset. Wants to argue that
- 21:11Speaker 5: that element of an agreement has been satisfied. Now, I
- 21:16Speaker 5: think Binance would say, well, you need something more than that,
- 21:19Speaker 5: because you know, there's nothing that says if I'm an
- 21:23Speaker 5: investor in crypto assets and the founder of the project,
- 21:28Speaker 5: they basically just take the money and don't do anything
- 21:31Speaker 5: with it. They don't make any efforts to create a
- 21:34Speaker 5: network that is valuable. If that happens, the person who
- 21:38Speaker 5: buys the crypto asset has no recourse. They have no
- 21:41Speaker 5: ability to sort of sue and enforce some obligation that
- 21:46Speaker 5: may or may not be technically true. It's a dangerous argument,
- 21:49Speaker 5: I think for Binance and the crypto industry, though, because
- 21:53Speaker 5: you know, why would I buy a crypto asset if
- 21:56Speaker 5: the people who raise money by selling tokens take the
- 22:00Speaker 5: money and do whatever they want with it. They don't
- 22:02Speaker 5: use the money to build a valuable system that's going
- 22:05Speaker 5: to increase the value of my crypto asset. I think
- 22:08Speaker 5: there is an understanding there, or there should be, that
- 22:12Speaker 5: if I buy a crypto asset from a venture where
- 22:15Speaker 5: they represent that they're going to use the funds to
- 22:19Speaker 5: build a valuable decentralized network, that's going to increase the
- 22:22Speaker 5: value of my crypto asset, I believe most investors, knowledgeable
- 22:27Speaker 5: investors would have an expectation that they will use that
- 22:32Speaker 5: money and use it in a way that potentially results
- 22:35Speaker 5: in profits. And so I think that's essentially what the
- 22:39Speaker 5: SEC has concluded.
- 22:41Speaker 2: I was going to say that sounds like the argument
- 22:44Speaker 2: from the attorney for the SEC that marketing efforts by
- 22:48Speaker 2: Binance to promote its tokens suggests that investors expect a
- 22:52Speaker 2: profit as they would when investing in securities. Is that
- 22:55Speaker 2: about the same argument it is?
- 22:57Speaker 7: It is.
- 22:58Speaker 5: I think the fact that they are representing to the
- 23:00Speaker 5: crypto accet holders that they are going to do this,
- 23:04Speaker 5: they are making these sorts of statements and representations. Whether
- 23:08Speaker 5: you think that creates the formal contract or not. There
- 23:12Speaker 5: is some understanding there. There is some understanding there. Whether
- 23:16Speaker 5: it rises to the level of a contract, I think
- 23:19Speaker 5: is a complicated issue, but there's an expectation and because
- 23:24Speaker 5: the Supreme Court has read how we fairly broadly in
- 23:28Speaker 5: the past that I think that even if there is
- 23:31Speaker 5: not a formal enforceable contract there, the sec has an
- 23:37Speaker 5: argument that you know, it's not crazy for the investor
- 23:40Speaker 5: to think that there is an obligation on the part
- 23:45Speaker 5: of those who have sold the tokens to use that
- 23:48Speaker 5: to build something that is valuable and Jim.
- 23:51Speaker 2: Are these arguments similar to the arguments that coinbase made
- 23:56Speaker 2: last week and other crypto platforms have made in the pasts.
- 24:01Speaker 5: They are very similar. They're very similar. The same argument
- 24:04Speaker 5: essentially has been made by both coinbase and Finance, and
- 24:09Speaker 5: even in prior cases Ripple and Terrorform, the major arguments
- 24:14Speaker 5: have been the same, which indicates to me that some
- 24:18Speaker 5: of the best legal minds in the country has come
- 24:21Speaker 5: to the conclusion that this is the best hope for
- 24:24Speaker 5: the crypto industry to avoid classification as a security.
- 24:29Speaker 2: Coming up next on the Bloomberg Law Show, I'll continue
- 24:32Speaker 2: this conversation with UCLA law professor James Park, and we'll
- 24:36Speaker 2: talk about the confusion in the courts over crypto. I'm
- 24:39Speaker 2: June Grosso and you're listening to Bloomberg. Finance and the
- 24:43Speaker 2: Securities and Exchange Commission faced off in federal court in DC.
- 24:48Speaker 2: It's the second closely watched courtroom battle in less than
- 24:51Speaker 2: a week that could help define the SEC's jurisdiction over
- 24:55Speaker 2: the crypto sector. I've been talking to UCLA law professor
- 24:59Speaker 2: James Park. Judge Amy Berman Jackson said the SEC seems
- 25:04Speaker 2: to be saying that all digital assets are securities. She asked,
- 25:08Speaker 2: how are the issuers supposed to know when they crossed
- 25:10Speaker 2: the line but hasn't. The SEC said it doesn't have
- 25:14Speaker 2: jurisdiction over bitcoin.
- 25:16Speaker 5: Bitcoin is not a security. And I think that she's
- 25:20Speaker 5: probing the SEC and trying to get it to take
- 25:24Speaker 5: a firmer position on what the limit thought. And I
- 25:27Speaker 5: think part of what she would like to do as
- 25:29Speaker 5: a judge, in her opinion, is to give litigant some
- 25:36Speaker 5: indication of where the limits of how we might be.
- 25:39Speaker 5: It might be troubling to have a test that is
- 25:42Speaker 5: so undefined that the only way we know whether something
- 25:46Speaker 5: is a security is because the SEC takes the position
- 25:49Speaker 5: that it is a security that is not ideal. At
- 25:54Speaker 5: the same time, it may not be possible to define
- 25:58Speaker 5: clearly what the limit of how we are and so
- 26:02Speaker 5: I'm not sure exactly what Judge Jackson is getting it.
- 26:05Speaker 5: There are a number of possibilities. One possibility is that
- 26:08Speaker 5: she is really skeptical of the SEC's position and thinks
- 26:11Speaker 5: that is really broad. The other possibility is he recognizes
- 26:15Speaker 5: that this is a vague test, but is really trying
- 26:18Speaker 5: to get the SEC's assistance in thinking about how we
- 26:23Speaker 5: could be limited in some way to what extent can
- 26:27Speaker 5: we provide the industry with some notice as to where
- 26:30Speaker 5: the line is. Where is the line between something that's
- 26:33Speaker 5: the security that is an investment contract in something that
- 26:36Speaker 5: is not. You know, the SEC has tried to give
- 26:39Speaker 5: some guidance, but I think that in the closer cases
- 26:43Speaker 5: the line is very blurry. The line is very blurry
- 26:46Speaker 5: if you are getting into digital assets that are close
- 26:50Speaker 5: to the line between something that is an investment contract
- 26:53Speaker 5: and something that is not.
- 26:55Speaker 2: Yeah, the judge wanted the SEC to define a boundary
- 26:59Speaker 2: for what it can considered a security in regard to
- 27:02Speaker 2: virtual tokens, and lawyers for the SEC said the test
- 27:06Speaker 2: is designed to be flexible and that there is no
- 27:08Speaker 2: bright line to make the distinction. And that's true of
- 27:11Speaker 2: a lot of tests in the law, right, that there's
- 27:13Speaker 2: no bright line.
- 27:15Speaker 5: That is true. That is something true in many areas
- 27:18Speaker 5: of the law when you're trying to define something like
- 27:21Speaker 5: negligence or intent, it really depends on a close examination
- 27:28Speaker 5: of the fact. I think the reason why the crypto
- 27:32Speaker 5: asset industry is frustrated though, by this approach, is that
- 27:37Speaker 5: if you're going to build an industry, if you're going
- 27:40Speaker 5: to create an ecosystem of digital assets, the entrepreneurs who
- 27:47Speaker 5: are starting these projects, they want a certain amount of certainty.
- 27:51Speaker 5: They want a certain amount of certainty as to when
- 27:53Speaker 5: they will be regulated, when they will not be Unfortunately,
- 27:57Speaker 5: I'm not sure that that certainty is possible. I'm not
- 28:01Speaker 5: sure that it is possible. And that is something that
- 28:05Speaker 5: you know, we'll see what the judges say, whether or
- 28:08Speaker 5: not that it is permissible to leave the state of
- 28:11Speaker 5: affairs as it is, or whether some judges may feel
- 28:15Speaker 5: like maybe we should rule against the SEC in some
- 28:18Speaker 5: of these cases and define the limits for them. And
- 28:22Speaker 5: you know, I think that's certainly a possible outcome in
- 28:24Speaker 5: some of these cases.
- 28:26Speaker 2: And Finance was pushing that this implicates the Major Questions doctrine,
- 28:32Speaker 2: which involves agency interpretation in matters of great economic or
- 28:37Speaker 2: political significance, just as Coinbase did last week, and this judge,
- 28:44Speaker 2: like Judge Polk last week, seemed to dismiss that.
- 28:48Speaker 5: Yeah, I think that's that's interesting, maybe not entirely unexpected.
- 28:53Speaker 5: You know, it is a doctrine that has some potential,
- 28:55Speaker 5: but the sort of application of it is unclear, and
- 28:59Speaker 5: I think both judges may have concluded that, you know,
- 29:04Speaker 5: the crypto asset industry is not large enough to implicate
- 29:07Speaker 5: the Major Questions doctrine. And it's interesting that both judges
- 29:12Speaker 5: seem to have come to that conclusion independently. And this
- 29:18Speaker 5: may also be a significant decision in that it begins
- 29:22Speaker 5: to set some limits to that Major Questions doctrine. And
- 29:26Speaker 5: I think that, you know, that's something that is notable,
- 29:30Speaker 5: but in my view, maybe not all that surprising.
- 29:34Speaker 2: As we've discussed before, courts have been divided on this
- 29:36Speaker 2: issue of whether digital tokens are security subject to SEC oversight.
- 29:41Speaker 2: And I've mentioned this before, but two Manhattan federal judges
- 29:44Speaker 2: whose courtrooms are just one floor apart in the federal courthouse,
- 29:48Speaker 2: here came to different conclusions. Now this case is in DC,
- 29:53Speaker 2: and the three other cases over cryptocurrency, we're in Manhattan,
- 29:57Speaker 2: the second circuit, which Justice has Marry Blackman called the
- 30:01Speaker 2: mother Court of securities law. Is there more weight put
- 30:06Speaker 2: on Manhattan Federal Court judges decisions.
- 30:09Speaker 1: As opposed to a DC federal court.
- 30:12Speaker 2: I mean, if there are conflicting decisions, where would the
- 30:16Speaker 2: greatest reliance be placed.
- 30:18Speaker 5: It's a great question. They're both very good courts, very
- 30:23Speaker 5: good judges, strong traditions, and I think it's good that
- 30:30Speaker 5: we are getting some decisions outside of the Southern District
- 30:33Speaker 5: of New York the Mother Court, because I think that
- 30:36Speaker 5: it's good for as many judges as possible to weigh
- 30:40Speaker 5: in on these issues, because if we begin to see
- 30:43Speaker 5: certain patterns in their decision making, then that can indicate
- 30:46Speaker 5: there's a consensus about what the law is. I think
- 30:50Speaker 5: that the advantage the Southern District of New York has
- 30:54Speaker 5: is the volume of cases relating to securities that the
- 30:58Speaker 5: judge is here, and that gives them an ability to
- 31:04Speaker 5: build up some expertise. I think that because of the
- 31:08Speaker 5: location of the Southern District of New York, the pool
- 31:12Speaker 5: of attorneys who end up becoming federal district court judges
- 31:16Speaker 5: include many individuals who have experience working with securities or
- 31:22Speaker 5: corporate law types of issues. So they are very knowledgeable,
- 31:26Speaker 5: and I think that, you know, the advantage the Southern
- 31:29Speaker 5: District of New York may have is that if you
- 31:32Speaker 5: have multiple cases in the district, then you will have
- 31:36Speaker 5: multiple decisions that can provide some guidance as to what
- 31:42Speaker 5: the parameters of the law is. And then eventually some
- 31:46Speaker 5: of these cases will go up to the US Court
- 31:48Speaker 5: of Appeals for the Second Circuit, which is also arguably
- 31:52Speaker 5: the pre eminent appellet court for deciding securities law issues,
- 31:58Speaker 5: and so there is a developed body of law in
- 32:01Speaker 5: the Second Circuit that district court judges are both using
- 32:06Speaker 5: to guide their decisions and also influencing through their own decisions.
- 32:10Speaker 5: There may be a little bit less of that in
- 32:13Speaker 5: the DC Circuit simply because of the makeup of cases
- 32:17Speaker 5: may be more relating to government agencies and administrative law,
- 32:23Speaker 5: but they still do get a good number of significant
- 32:26Speaker 5: securities law cases as well. So I think that that
- 32:30Speaker 5: decision will also be influential.
- 32:33Speaker 2: So Binance is the second courtroom battle over the same
- 32:36Speaker 2: issue in less than a week. How many more of
- 32:39Speaker 2: these cases are in the offing?
- 32:41Speaker 5: You know, these are probably going to be the major ones.
- 32:44Speaker 5: I think that you have other cases pending terre reform
- 32:48Speaker 5: and ripple. I think these four cases are probably going
- 32:52Speaker 5: to define the scope of what is a security You
- 32:56Speaker 5: could potentially see some other cases rise up as well
- 33:01Speaker 5: as we see additional enforcement. The question is whether or
- 33:04Speaker 5: not there will be incentives to litigate those cases and
- 33:09Speaker 5: whether they'll be resources. Will there be resources to fully
- 33:12Speaker 5: litigate cases involving, say, individual defendants who are charged with
- 33:18Speaker 5: insider trading on crypto assets. There may be, there may
- 33:21Speaker 5: not be. I think the thing that distinguishes this group
- 33:25Speaker 5: of four cases is that these defendants have the resources
- 33:29Speaker 5: to hire top notch attorneys who can make very sophisticated,
- 33:34Speaker 5: well developed arguments and litigate potentially all the way up
- 33:39Speaker 5: to the US Supreme Court. And I don't really see
- 33:44Speaker 5: all that many other cases having that sort of staying power.
- 33:48Speaker 5: But I could be wrong.
- 33:49Speaker 2: Are any of these cases close to the appellate.
- 33:52Speaker 1: Court level yet?
- 33:53Speaker 6: Not yet?
- 33:54Speaker 5: And I think you know, if I had to bet.
- 33:56Speaker 5: I think the one that may make it up first
- 33:59Speaker 5: may be the terraform case. I believe Judge Raycop granted
- 34:03Speaker 5: some rejudgment back in December, and so I think that
- 34:07Speaker 5: could fairly soon be in a stage where it's in
- 34:10Speaker 5: a final judgment that could be appealed to the Second
- 34:14Speaker 5: Circuit and Jim.
- 34:15Speaker 2: One thing I want to mention is these oral arguments
- 34:18Speaker 2: were incredibly long.
- 34:20Speaker 5: Four hours, you know, these oral arguments were very long
- 34:24Speaker 5: the financing coinbase and I commend both judges for taking
- 34:29Speaker 5: the time to give both sides the time to argue extensively.
- 34:35Speaker 5: These are judges that are trying to get things right
- 34:38Speaker 5: on a very complicated issue. They're also very busy judges.
- 34:42Speaker 5: They may have hundreds of other cases on their docket.
- 34:45Speaker 5: It's very unusual to give you a block of four
- 34:49Speaker 5: hours to oral arguments, but I think the fact that
- 34:52Speaker 5: they did will lend some additional legitimacy to the decisions
- 34:58Speaker 5: they end up making. Think it's great to have these
- 35:02Speaker 5: very talented judges, you know, listening to the arguments of
- 35:05Speaker 5: what are some very talented attorneys to try to get
- 35:08Speaker 5: things right.
- 35:09Speaker 2: It's going to be interesting to compare the conclusions these
- 35:11Speaker 2: judges come to on this question that's so important to
- 35:15Speaker 2: the crypto industry and to the SEC. And we discussed
- 35:18Speaker 2: before the record penalty that Finance paid, and its chief
- 35:22Speaker 2: executive shangpeng Xiao, had pleaded guilty as well and agreed
- 35:27Speaker 2: to step down as CEO. His sentencing is coming up
- 35:31Speaker 2: in February, and for the second time, a judge denied
- 35:35Speaker 2: his request for permission to travel back home to the
- 35:39Speaker 2: UAE while he awaits sentencing, even though he offered a
- 35:43Speaker 2: post a bond of one hundred and seventy five million
- 35:45Speaker 2: dollars secured by fifteen million in cash. Of course, he
- 35:49Speaker 2: has a net worth of more than thirty seven billions,
- 35:52Speaker 2: so maybe the judge was taking that into consideration.
- 35:55Speaker 5: The thing that may concern the judge is that there
- 35:58Speaker 5: are some allegations that Finance was somewhat intentional in trying
- 36:04Speaker 5: to evade US law. And to the extent that that's
- 36:08Speaker 5: the case, you have, you know, a person who may
- 36:12Speaker 5: be able to go pretty much anywhere and may have
- 36:17Speaker 5: a mentality that you know, as long as I can
- 36:20Speaker 5: avoid US law, I have no moral obligation to come
- 36:25Speaker 5: back and comply with it. I think that that's what
- 36:28Speaker 5: makes the judge a little bit uncomfortable. In addition to
- 36:31Speaker 5: the vast resources that the CEO has.
- 36:35Speaker 1: It is crazy money. It is.
- 36:37Speaker 5: That's what makes it so unprecedented and interesting because you know,
- 36:41Speaker 5: typically the investment contract cases that seen in the past,
- 36:45Speaker 5: they involved fairly small time schemes, maybe involving a few
- 36:50Speaker 5: million dollars here and there. When you're getting into you know,
- 36:54Speaker 5: digital assets worth billions potentially, that really changes.
- 36:59Speaker 2: The nature of the It certainly seems to. Thanks so much, Jim.
- 37:03Speaker 2: That's Professor James Park of UCLA Law School. And that's
- 37:07Speaker 2: it for this edition of the Bloomberg Law Podcast. Remember
- 37:10Speaker 2: you can always get the latest legal news by subscribing
- 37:12Speaker 2: and listening to the show on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, and
- 37:16Speaker 2: at Bloomberg dot com, slash podcast, Slash Law. I'm June
- 37:20Speaker 2: Grosso and this is Bloomberg