Latest / Onramp Bitcoin Media / Final Settlement E010: A Nuclear Powered Bitcoin Standard with Ryan MacLeod
Transcript
- 0:02It all comes down to computers communicating.
- 0:06The information superhighway can be a confusing mix of on ramps
- 0:09and off ramps. Bitcoin is worthless artificial
- 0:14gold. Is it still rat poison?
- 0:17Probably rat poison squared. We need to get into the world of
- 0:21OK, this is actually foundational technology.
- 0:24What the Internet of Money does is it creates a single network
- 0:28which can do a microtransaction to a giga transaction.
- 0:36The Internet is going to be one of the major forces for reducing
- 0:41the role of government. The one thing that's missing,
- 0:44but that will soon be developed is a reliable E cash.
- 0:51Thank you for joining us for this week's episode of Final
- 0:53Settlement, a podcast from On Ramp Media.
- 0:56On today's show, we're joined by Ryan McLeod, a chemical
- 0:59technologist and Bitcoin enthusiast who works in the
- 1:02nuclear industry. We discuss the potential of
- 1:04nuclear power, the utility of Bitcoin mining, and the
- 1:08synergistic relationship between the two industries.
- 1:11Ryan explains the challenges and misconceptions surrounding
- 1:14nuclear power, including cost and safety concerns,
- 1:17highlighting the benefits of small modular reactors, which
- 1:19can be factory built and commissioned in shorter time
- 1:22frames. The conversation touches on the
- 1:24global interest in nuclear power and the technological
- 1:27competition between different countries.
- 1:29We explore how Bitcoin mining can complement the build out of
- 1:32nuclear power plants and contribute to energy
- 1:34independence. Nuclear power provides a
- 1:37reliable and efficient source of energy, while Bitcoin mining
- 1:40offers a way to utilize excess energy and bootstrap the build
- 1:43out of energy capacity. The integration of Bitcoin
- 1:46mining with nuclear power can create a more stable and
- 1:49resilient grid, providing a path towards energy independence and
- 1:52abundant future. And now, time for the show.
- 1:55And we're live. Welcome back to Final
- 1:58Settlement. Very excited for for this week's
- 2:01episode. On the show today we have Ryan
- 2:05McLeod, who is a chemical technologist by trade and for
- 2:12the past decade or so has worked at Canadian nuclear laboratories
- 2:16and he also happens to be a Bitcoiner.
- 2:19But the reason I'm, I'm really excited for this combo is
- 2:22because you know, thinking about sort of the purpose of this
- 2:26podcast in many ways is to show Bitcoin as a technology, as a,
- 2:31as a protocol that people are are leveraging in the real world
- 2:34and, and using for various forms of utility.
- 2:37And, and one thing that we haven't really touched on thus
- 2:39far throughout the episodes is, is the Bitcoin mining space.
- 2:43And why that is really in my mind, one of the greatest
- 2:46examples of bitcoins utility in the real world in the sense
- 2:50that, you know, we now as as a human species have the ability
- 2:53to monetize energy in a location agnostic way, which was never
- 2:58previously possible. And I think that itself is a is
- 3:01a form of utility for, for Bitcoin mining that is
- 3:04completely outside in the realm of of price or number go up or,
- 3:08you know, the digital gold thesis, if you will.
- 3:11And so very excited to talk not only about Bitcoin mining, but
- 3:14about the nuclear space, which Ryan is a domain expert on.
- 3:19And and so welcome to the show, Ryan.
- 3:21Glad to have. You thanks for the introduction,
- 3:23Brian. I, I certainly wouldn't call
- 3:25myself too much of an expert. Just like with Bitcoin, it's
- 3:28this is an endless rabbit hole and you can immerse yourself in
- 3:31it for as long as you want and you will never see the end of
- 3:34it. I am lucky in my position that I
- 3:37have exposure to many nuclear scientists, so I can always pick
- 3:40their brains on many of these topics.
- 3:43And my interest is predominantly on the economic side of these
- 3:46things. Like we've got many great
- 3:47scientists trying to solve all of the the new challenges with
- 3:51fuels and materials and getting the SMRS to commercial stage and
- 3:56also supporting the existing reactor fleet like Canada's.
- 4:00I've got where I'm from in Ontario, we have 20 operating
- 4:03nuclear reactors at three sites and that's provides 60% of the
- 4:07power for the entire province of Ontario.
- 4:09And we often export a lot of that to the states in the
- 4:12Northeast corridor along with Quebec often.
- 4:16But yeah, mining is really what got me attracted to Bitcoin in
- 4:20the 1st place. Like I was already kind of
- 4:23primed to understand Bitcoin. Like I'd watched the the
- 4:26Zeitgeist movies back in the day.
- 4:28I was following with Ron Paul in the end of the Fed movement.
- 4:31Max Keiser came up every once in a while in the alternative media
- 4:33that I was paying attention to at the time, and then never
- 4:36pulled the trigger. And then or years later, I
- 4:39cashed out some Bitcoin from an online poker site.
- 4:42And then it was 21, the, the run up in Christmas 21.
- 4:46That was really grabbed my attention.
- 4:48And then I quickly went, went off the deep end with Max's
- 4:50podcast. And then it was when I was
- 4:53introduced to Steve Barber and Adam Oh, did two consecutive
- 4:56podcasts around them at that time talking about what they're
- 4:59doing with stranded power. And then that just got me really
- 5:02interested in mining. I'm telling my wife all about it
- 5:04and she's it's like, oh, that's great.
- 5:06You found a new hobby. That's very interesting.
- 5:08Hopefully you can find some friends to talk about it because
- 5:11you've talked about it a lot and it can get annoying.
- 5:14But then I, but it was good though, because I, I gave her
- 5:19enough of an education on this that when Elon Musk started
- 5:22crapping on Bitcoin's energy usage on the, the backside of
- 5:24that spring run up, she just threw out the idea of just, if
- 5:29the type of energy that Bitcoin mining is using is a problem,
- 5:33why don't we focus more attention on mining Bitcoin with
- 5:36nuclear power? And at the time, I was kind of
- 5:41paying attention, like I wasn't super immersed in it like I was
- 5:43now with like nuclear advocacy and learning everything I can
- 5:46about the industry. But I was aware that we had a
- 5:50plan to develop small modular reactors that we're currently
- 5:53refurbishing our entire fleet to, to extend it well into the
- 5:5660s. That around America, many of
- 5:59their reactors were being chosen to retire them instead of making
- 6:03the effort to try and refurbish them and extend their lives like
- 6:07Indian Point, Palisades, Pilgrim, Vermont, Yankee, San
- 6:10Onofre. And then they seemed to draw a
- 6:14line at Diablo Canyon in California.
- 6:17And that's where they kind of said, no, no more of these
- 6:19reactors being shut down. But around that time, me paying
- 6:22attention to Bitcoin, it seemed like whenever nuclear power got
- 6:26brought up in the context of Bitcoin mining, like at the
- 6:28conference or just the mining panels or whatever, it was
- 6:30always with the perspective that nuclear's kind of on its
- 6:34downturn, the reactors are being shut down.
- 6:37There's not any anything invigorating the industry.
- 6:41And then all of the sudden world events started to happen and now
- 6:46all eyes are on nuclear over the last two or three years.
- 6:48And everybody is very aggressively looking at it as a
- 6:52critical piece of the infrastructure architecture for
- 6:56many nations to secure their energy futures.
- 7:00Because it's just, it's a superior form of energy
- 7:04generation. It takes a lot of capital to
- 7:06pull it off and it takes a lot of a lot of alignment across a
- 7:09lot of stakeholders. But when it is operational, it
- 7:11provides so much value to the the countries that it is that
- 7:17hosted that they they can see massive increases in their GDP
- 7:22from using it. And then you can see the
- 7:23countries that have had strange relationships with nuclear
- 7:27power, like Germany's an interesting one, retiring their
- 7:29fleet. Meanwhile, the accident happened
- 7:31in Japan and Japan is now actively trying to return their
- 7:35fleet to service as fast as they possibly can because the cost of
- 7:38importing natural gas is killing their population.
- 7:41And it's not a fun experience for an aging demographic when
- 7:45they have to start choosing between rent and heat and food
- 7:48when in these trying times, especially when you guys are
- 7:50familiar with the the financial situation over there.
- 7:53Like their currency is a complete basket case.
- 7:55So it's going to be interesting to see how they can pull this
- 7:57off. But I, I would actually like to
- 7:59see more about them. There was talk that somebody in
- 8:04TEPCO, Tokyo Electric Power Company, was investigating
- 8:07Bitcoin mining. So I haven't seen anything else
- 8:09about that since then. That was just like one, like
- 8:12little news report about two years ago, but I don't know,
- 8:14maybe something's bubbling behind the scenes.
- 8:17At On Ramp, we believe that Bitcoin will be the most
- 8:19important asset to own in the 21st century.
- 8:21Our multi institution custody solution is the safest and most
- 8:24secure way to ensure that your Bitcoin remains in your in your
- 8:27family's possession for decades to come.
- 8:30Multi institution custody maximizes security and minimizes
- 8:33counterparty risk. Leveraging Bitcoin's native
- 8:35properties to eliminate single points of failure that have
- 8:38historically complicated Bitcoin ownership on Ramp provides Peace
- 8:41of Mind for your Bitcoin journey.
- 8:43For more information. Check us out at on
- 8:45rampbitcoin.com. You brought up a lot of good
- 8:48points in there. I think one for me, it's been
- 8:50very interesting to sort of observe nuclear from afar over
- 8:55the past few years. And to your point, I think the
- 8:57Overton window is shifting a little bit with respect to
- 9:01recognizing that this is, you know, a viable path towards
- 9:07creating energy independence. And and the notion of energy
- 9:10independence has become more and more of a hot button issue as
- 9:13we've seen all the issues sort of with fossil fuels and having
- 9:16to rely on on other countries for the, you know, vast, vast
- 9:22majority of your energy. I think it's becoming more and
- 9:25more top of mind. But I think the reason why
- 9:28that's so interesting is because for so long it was, you know,
- 9:32nuclear as a whole was sort of demonized.
- 9:34And for various reasons that I would love you to go through in
- 9:38terms of, you know, why, why were we in a place prior to the
- 9:41past couple years where people effectively dismiss this as not
- 9:46a viable solution? And I guess what has changed
- 9:49over the past couple years that have, you know, in your mind
- 9:52open, open people's eyes to the the merits of a nuclear
- 9:57strategy? Yeah, there's there's many
- 10:01factors that go into play to explain why why nuclear has been
- 10:04having a tough go of things like bureaucracies.
- 10:07Definitely one of them. There's very well funded
- 10:10opposition to nuclear power, whether that's coming from like
- 10:14the oil and gas industry or like other competing industries that
- 10:17don't want to see as much nuclear power on the grid
- 10:20because it cuts into their market share.
- 10:22Even though like you talk to a lot of people in these
- 10:25industries and they're very supportive of like, yeah, all we
- 10:28we need the power. But the incentives and how all
- 10:32of these these interests financially interact starts to
- 10:36create interesting, interesting feedback that results in nuclear
- 10:42power getting demonized disproportionately to compare to
- 10:45other technologies. And there's a lot of lot of
- 10:48scrutiny like radiation. It is it is an industrial hazard
- 10:52like many other industrial hazards.
- 10:53Like we know how to handle it. We know how to to safely manage
- 10:57fuel and radiation products. But because of that, like
- 11:03radiation is a contentious topic in the public.
- 11:07Many people raised watching Simpsons are familiar with with
- 11:11how they portray nuclear power, which is not the most accurate
- 11:15depiction. There's like many instances in
- 11:18just in popular media that they just, they do not accurately
- 11:22portray it. And then it creates an anchoring
- 11:24bias in a lot of people's minds. And then there's also the fact
- 11:27that like the Cold War happened. So there's an entire generation
- 11:30of people that have that trauma to affect their their decision
- 11:35making and their perspective on nuclear power.
- 11:38But there's a whole new generation that sees it as an
- 11:42opportunity to build for the future.
- 11:44So that is very, very refreshing to see that that the youth are
- 11:50taking an interest in a technology that can be greatly
- 11:52beneficial to them because especially since they don't get
- 11:56exposed to much nuclear power unless they actually seek it out
- 12:00in school. So much like when, when you're
- 12:03familiar with how many people go through an economics class and
- 12:06never learn anything about Austrian economics, like you can
- 12:09go through entire environmentalist courses, entire
- 12:12like energy infrastructure courses and you'll have like
- 12:14just a brief little talk about nuclear power and like, oh, it's
- 12:17there. And but let's focus on windmills
- 12:19and solar panel because it's free when it's generating
- 12:21electricity. And like there's a whole host of
- 12:23reasons why I disagree with a lot of the assertion that we can
- 12:28power a high tech society on wind solar and mostly has to do
- 12:31with like it. It's very challenging to get
- 12:36power to where it needs to be when, when it needs to be there.
- 12:40That is where the costs of wind and solar start to to ramp up.
- 12:44But if you just look at them stand alone, they they can look
- 12:47great if it's just a windmill in the middle of nowhere with
- 12:50batteries to back it up and you and they they can definitely
- 12:53look like they've got good economics.
- 12:54But as soon as you start having tie that into the grid, things
- 12:58get a lot more complicated. And one of those reasons, it's
- 13:01something that I was reading up recently.
- 13:02It's inertia is an interesting concept on the grid that most
- 13:06people aren't familiar with. And it't provided by thousands
- 13:11and thousands of spinning machines synchronized at the
- 13:14exact same frequency. So that's the the 60 Hertz that
- 13:17most people hear about when that when someone's talking about the
- 13:20grid frequency that they try to maintain.
- 13:22So that's all of these spinning machines, whether it's your,
- 13:25your hydro generators, your, your coal plants, gas plants,
- 13:29nuclear power plants, they all spin at 60 Hertz and they all
- 13:33synchronize with each other. And so if you're bringing new
- 13:34generation onto the grid, it has to synchronize with that 60
- 13:37Hertz. The type of electricity that's
- 13:41generated from the windmills and from solar panels doesn't
- 13:43synchronize with that. So then that's another added
- 13:46cost that they have to bring into this this equation in order
- 13:50to like properly synchronize with the rest of the system.
- 13:53So then it creates this dynamic where some of their advocates
- 13:57are just like, well, if we just do away with the old system and
- 14:00we create a new system, we can create a better system.
- 14:03But it it doesn't quite work like that when you're trying to
- 14:09adapt something that was built over many, many decades and is
- 14:14very, very complex, like a grid that serves like hundreds of
- 14:18millions of people, especially in North America.
- 14:21It doesn't just, you can't just change it with a visionary new
- 14:26technology. It has to have a period of
- 14:30adaptation. And what is being seen a lot
- 14:32right now is as they more aggressively push these like non
- 14:37synchronous generation sources onto the grid, the they are
- 14:42seeing that the the diminishing returns are like that would
- 14:46naturally be. There aren't really manifesting
- 14:48because there is so much subsidies, so much tax credits,
- 14:51so much revenue that they can collect that is unrelated to
- 14:54actually selling power on the grid that it starts creating a
- 14:56lot of distortions in the pricing market.
- 14:58So then it doesn't give proper signals to when new generation
- 15:01should be built. It doesn't it's, it just creates
- 15:04a lot of disruption in the markets and it makes it very
- 15:07challenging for the engineers that are actually responsible
- 15:09for taking care of these systems and making sure that they
- 15:11operate in a reliable fashion is incredibly like it's an
- 15:19increasing challenge for them, which then just increases more
- 15:22costs. So it's.
- 15:23Sorry, that was a. Little bit there.
- 15:25No, that that's helpful, helpful context.
- 15:27I'm curious if you could drill down a little bit more into the
- 15:30cost, right, because I think there's general misconceptions
- 15:34around the cost of some of things like wind and solar
- 15:38because they have been heavily subsidized to your point.
- 15:41So if the if in the absence of that, you know, how would you
- 15:45sort of compare and contrast the cost of building out capacity
- 15:49in, you know, wind and solar versus building out capacity in
- 15:53in nuclear? Because I would also imagine and
- 15:55I would, I would curious your insights on this as well as like
- 15:59over the past few decades, like I would imagine the cost of
- 16:03building out nuclear capacity have also come down and improved
- 16:06and technology as as advanced in that sense that it is more
- 16:10realistic to build out this, you know, much more efficient and
- 16:16dense version of of energy capacity.
- 16:19So curious, any thoughts on just like you know, if in the absence
- 16:22of subsidies for for wind and solar, like what would that sort
- 16:25of cost benefit analysis look like relative to something like
- 16:28nuclear? Like, I wish it was the case
- 16:31that the cost of nuclear is coming down and in some ways it
- 16:35kind of is. But the one big failure in the
- 16:39West was not sustaining the capabilities as well as they
- 16:43should have. So that's like Vogel is a pretty
- 16:46good example of trying to restart a program that was kind
- 16:52of allowed to atrophy. So like, like the US had lots of
- 16:57experience building nuclear reactors and in, in my opinion,
- 17:00one of the, one of the flaws of that system is building bespoke
- 17:03reactors that don't all match with each other.
- 17:05Whereas like in Ontario and France, they just picked 1
- 17:08reactor design and then just evolutions of that design.
- 17:10Whereas in the United States, you've got reactor sites where
- 17:13there's two different reactors on the same site.
- 17:16So you can't even take the same operator out of one reactor to
- 17:18operate the other one. Whereas you can take an operator
- 17:21out of a Bruce reactor and put them into a Darlington reactor
- 17:24and it it wouldn't even make a difference.
- 17:26They'd be able they'd be like 90% up to speed.
- 17:28Whereas it would be a considerably different situation
- 17:31in in AUS reactor like Three mile Island is a perfect
- 17:34example. They couldn't they couldn't peel
- 17:36operators from the other reactors to respond to the issue
- 17:40that they were having in the run reactor that had that was having
- 17:42issues back in the 70s. But that that separate topic.
- 17:48But yeah, the thing about the cost of nuclear is it's so front
- 17:52loaded. There's the licensing, there's
- 17:54the engineering, everything gets packed up front.
- 17:57And then they also have to be able to account for their entire
- 17:59life cycle, like what they're going to do with the waste, what
- 18:01they're going to do with the decommissioning.
- 18:03So a lot of the capital in building nuclear is very heavily
- 18:06front loaded. So then that makes it
- 18:09disproportionately more challenging them for them to
- 18:11recover those capital costs in the same sort of time frame.
- 18:14So if investors just trying to to turn around their capital
- 18:18within 510 years and then you can just see like well we'll
- 18:20just build these windmills and solar panels, we'll take the
- 18:22protection production tax credits, just harvest those for
- 18:2510 years and then you, yeah, you move on to a new project.
- 18:29Whereas with nuclear it requires a much longer time horizon
- 18:33thinking in like multi generational, like 40 year year
- 18:37periods that these systems are going to be operational like
- 18:40Canada, like our reactors, full life will probably be about 80
- 18:44to 90 years for the ones that we're refurbishing right now.
- 18:48So like we can get almost a century out of these things.
- 18:50It's basically the same idea of doing like a resto mod.
- 18:54Are you guys familiar with that concept where they take like an
- 18:56old car, replace, replace all the old insides and and give it
- 19:00give it new brakes, new transmission, new yeah, new new
- 19:04components. So it's basically on the outside
- 19:06it still looks like the same old machine, but on the inside it's
- 19:10got brand new, everything's been refreshed and it should be able
- 19:13to remain operating for another 40 plus years if it's maintained
- 19:18well, which we have a very robust program here in Ontario
- 19:21that we, we, we take good care of these machines because they
- 19:25provide a lot of value to us and we need to build more of them in
- 19:32order to drive those costs down. But like a lot, a lot of that
- 19:35comes to like the way that they're financed with, with,
- 19:38yeah, like with subsidies and stuff.
- 19:40Because that creates all these distortions in the markets.
- 19:43Because now that subsidies are a thing, everyone's competing for
- 19:47the subsidies instead of trying to compete for like actual
- 19:50market share. Because that's basically what
- 19:53Fiat has done to this entire system.
- 19:55It's it's rewards those who are better at ingratiating
- 19:58themselves with politics rather than who can actually provide a
- 20:03better service to the market. Like luckily like we're we're
- 20:06seeing. Alignment in politics, like
- 20:09Senator Granholm just came out the other day and saying that we
- 20:11need 98 more Vogels, which is like a very, very positive for
- 20:16the industry. But like that's also going to
- 20:18require a lot of capital. That's going to require a lot of
- 20:21alignment. And I and it's a very good thing
- 20:25for them to do that because now that Vogel's been done, they've
- 20:28learned from the experience of building Vogel, which had a lot
- 20:31of trials and tribulations. If anyone wants to do a deep
- 20:35dive on that, the Decoupled podcast did a four part series
- 20:38that explains the whole Vogel saga from start to finish and
- 20:41all of the the reasons why it was challenged, whether it's
- 20:44regulatory bureaucracy, just trying to start a project
- 20:48without a finished plan and then parts move on when you're when
- 20:56things start moving and then stakeholders start getting upset
- 20:59with each other because timelines aren't being met.
- 21:01And it it got to be a bit of a mess.
- 21:03Like Westinghouse almost went bankrupt and now they're
- 21:06partially owned by uranium mining company Kamiko's.
- 21:09It's one of our companies up here in Canada that provides a
- 21:12lot of high quality uranium for our fleet and for the a lot of
- 21:16the American fleet. And they're actually hoping
- 21:19they're planning on expanding our extraction capabilities for
- 21:23uranium because they're is clearly a lot of demand for it.
- 21:26So we are aggressively trying to ramp up our fuel production
- 21:30capabilities, especially now that Russia is being cut off
- 21:33from the rest of the world. So Russia was the primary
- 21:36enriched uranium provider for most of the world's fleet until
- 21:41two years ago. And so now everyone is
- 21:44frantically trying to recalibrate their, their fuel
- 21:47cycles so that we can produce as much as what we can in America
- 21:52and Europe and, and Canada. But like luckily in Canada, that
- 21:56is our unique feature of our reactors that is we don't
- 21:58actually need to enrich the fuel.
- 22:00We can, we just have to refine it into the fuel rods.
- 22:04But the, the natural isotopic ratio that it's found in, in
- 22:10when it's extracted from the ground can be used in our
- 22:13reactors because of the way that we use heavy water, which is a
- 22:16unique feature that gives us an, an, an advantage in that we can
- 22:21use our own fuel without having to rely on external parties.
- 22:25So we can have our entire cycle from cradle to grave contained
- 22:29within Canada. So that is one of our, the
- 22:32things that we we proudly like to brag about every once in a
- 22:35while. And but yeah, it's just learning
- 22:38from the mistakes, putting it into action, getting a supply
- 22:41chain and a labor force back in line and getting people, getting
- 22:45more people interested in being a part of this technology.
- 22:47Like we need labourers, we need engineers, we need trades
- 22:50people, we need we need management, we need sales
- 22:53people. We need like more than anything,
- 22:55we need a lot of people that are really good at public
- 22:57communications because that has been one of nuclear power's
- 23:00biggest challenges is that the only time you ever hear about it
- 23:03is when something goes wrong. So public relations needs to be
- 23:07a lot more aggressive getting the message that the pro nuclear
- 23:10message out there. And all of the great things we
- 23:12can do beyond even just power generation, like because like
- 23:16radio, we do tons of radio isotope research here at our
- 23:20site at Canadian nuclear labs for medical applications, for
- 23:26sterilization, for different agriculture applications.
- 23:30There's dozens of different isotopes that can only be
- 23:33created in the environment that a nuclear reactor provides.
- 23:37So it's there's, there's a lot more to this industry than just
- 23:42generating power. So that and that that makes an
- 23:45interesting argument when you do start getting into like what
- 23:48what's superior and energy generating system, the nuclear
- 23:53or wind and solar or, or like all the other competitors.
- 23:57But it's not an even match because nuclear flick, for one
- 24:00thing, the power density is so outrageously superior.
- 24:04And then the fact that there's all kinds of other peripheral
- 24:06things that nuclear power can do that wind and solar can't even
- 24:09touch. And, and the other fact that you
- 24:12can just drop them, you can just replace a coal plant with a
- 24:14nuclear power plant because the transmission infrastructure is
- 24:17better aligned for a like a large thermal plant rather than
- 24:21building out large, large fields of hundreds of thousands of
- 24:25acres of windmills and solar panels.
- 24:27And then even once you have all of that installed, like you need
- 24:29five times of it at least, probably even more to compare to
- 24:33what the output you get from a nuclear power plant.
- 24:36And just, and then it's just the when that power needs to be
- 24:40consumed, because then you run into nuclear power's biggest
- 24:43economic flaw is that they generate so much power that if
- 24:46you're not capturing value from those electrons, then you're
- 24:51leading potential revenue. So if you can find a clever way
- 24:54to make sure that your price floor is set above 0, you can
- 25:00very significantly change the like the economic case for how
- 25:04nuclear power is generated and how, how it interacts with the
- 25:07grid. Because now we can have a new
- 25:09option where we can sell to the grid or we can sell through a
- 25:13digital conduit that it can extract that value and to make
- 25:16it available to anywhere in the world very, very quickly.
- 25:20Because a lot of the other technologies that they're
- 25:22talking about for doing that and they're like great technologies,
- 25:25but they, they don't go to the same places that the Bitcoin
- 25:28miners can go. Like there's going to be lots of
- 25:30attention on hydrogen electrolyzers.
- 25:32There's lots of attention on desalina tion.
- 25:35There's a lot of excitement about the potential of doing
- 25:40synthetic fuels. So basically you can do if you
- 25:42can capture the molecules from the air, if you can capture
- 25:45carbon, nitrogen, oxygen, if you've got methane available to
- 25:49you, you can combine those into anything if you have the power
- 25:54to do it, which at the moment it is way too more costly than it's
- 25:59worth. It's more economical to just
- 26:02extract those hydrocarbons from the ground, but there is a time
- 26:05in the not too distant future when we have so much power
- 26:08available to us that we will be able to just synthetically
- 26:11create whatever hydrocarbons we want just from.
- 26:15Yeah, extracting the resources from the atmosphere.
- 26:20And I think that we are going to get there because Bitcoin mining
- 26:24is going to amplify the deployment of nuclear power much
- 26:28faster than we could have anticipated.
- 26:30That the. Really the only thing that's
- 26:31going to limit it are the deployment of these things is
- 26:35how quickly they can get built and and configured.
- 26:38Like once they get to their commercial state and they start
- 26:41getting momentum, like Bitcoin mining is going to allow their
- 26:44order books to get a lot more filled up.
- 26:46They're going to have a lot more investor confidence because they
- 26:48know they're going to be getting those RO is regardless of where
- 26:51we start deploying these things, but probably getting a little
- 26:54ahead of myself because. And we can.
- 26:56Yeah, we. Expose that was a that was a
- 26:59nice a nice natural segue to sort of the the synergies
- 27:02between nuclear and Bitcoin that we certainly want want to touch
- 27:06on. Just going back to something you
- 27:08said earlier, though, I'm curious, you know, to me, like
- 27:13observing from afar, the big push back to nuclear has been
- 27:17won the cost and then to the safety and you sort of alluded
- 27:19to the safety component there and how, you know, for the most
- 27:23part that might be more narrative driven and reality.
- 27:27So like, how do you yourself sort of handicap the, you know,
- 27:31the obvious benefits of this, you know, super dense form of
- 27:35energy versus the theoretical safety concerns or risks around,
- 27:40you know, something going wrong. And that's to your point, what
- 27:43everyone always sort of Harkins back to is like, that's why
- 27:46we've sort of ignored this nuclear thing for so long is
- 27:48because, you know, something could go terribly wrong and and
- 27:51make it all not worth it. So I guess maybe a little bit
- 27:54more color on on the safety side of things and then we can dive
- 27:59into the the synergies with Bitcoin mining.
- 28:03Yeah, like there's no denying like working with radiation
- 28:06hazards, hazards and and can be dangerous under the the right
- 28:09circumstances. But like I mentioned earlier,
- 28:12it's it's an industrial hazard that we know how to manage, we
- 28:15know how to protect ourselves from time, distance and
- 28:18shielding are the the main three things that get stressed to
- 28:21everybody that works here. So if you are going to be
- 28:23exposed to any radiation whatsoever, you first want to
- 28:26limit the amount of time and then the distance and put as
- 28:31much shielding as you can between you and that object.
- 28:33And sometimes you don't always have the option to have
- 28:36shielding. So you have to limit the other
- 28:38factors. And it it really depends on the
- 28:40job that you're doing. So like like I get exposed to
- 28:44like in my job, maybe one millisievert of radiation a
- 28:49year, which is a modest amount for somebody that works in the
- 28:52industry. But then you, you guys, if you,
- 28:55if you're travelling and flying, you probably get exposed to more
- 28:58radiation than I do. And I work with this stuff like
- 29:01someone actually didn't experience experiment recently
- 29:03where they wore a dosimeter. They travelled all the way from
- 29:07America to Japan to go and tour and see the the blown out
- 29:11reactor. And they flew all the way there,
- 29:14read their their radiation readings while they were flying.
- 29:18And then it went back down and then they got to the reactor.
- 29:20You'd see the radiation readings come back up.
- 29:22But in comparison, I got far more exposure to radiation from
- 29:26flying than they were standing 50 meters from a blown out
- 29:29nuclear reactor. So it's the the hazard is just
- 29:33because of the poor understanding of radiation in
- 29:36the technology. It it gets overly
- 29:39sensationalized when it happens because Fukushima itself it it
- 29:43was actually a hydrogen explosion.
- 29:45Like it technically wasn't a nuclear explosion.
- 29:47Like what happened was they weren't able to cool it.
- 29:50Then they created a lot of heat within their, their pressure
- 29:53tubes. And then those pressure tubes,
- 29:55they release hydrogen and then the hydrogen created the, the
- 29:59explosion once it, once it, the, the pressure had exceeded what
- 30:02the containment Dome could could handle.
- 30:05And then it just did blew, blew up the roof.
- 30:06And then that, that carries with it of small amounts of radio
- 30:11radiological material. So that, that was the, the
- 30:14major, major hazard that everyone was concerned with,
- 30:17which when people go back and revisit that incident, there was
- 30:22far more casualties related to the evacuation than the actual
- 30:27event itself. And there's like there's people
- 30:29that live within 100 meters of that, that site there, there's a
- 30:33711 like right around the corner.
- 30:35Like they, they give tour. It's a, it's a tourist site now
- 30:38more than anything. And they're, and I actually had
- 30:40the opportunity to tour one of the other reactor sites in Japan
- 30:45where they showed us that they're turning those sites into
- 30:48fortresses. They've built 20m tall, 3M thick
- 30:51concrete walls around the entire facility.
- 30:54And they've put their backup generators on floating
- 30:56platforms. So if they ever get hit with
- 30:58another tsunami, those reactor sites will probably be the
- 31:01safest locations on the entire island.
- 31:03So they're, they're not screwing around, they're putting a lot of
- 31:05money into this and they are determined to get their nuclear
- 31:09reactor fleet back operating because it's going to be greatly
- 31:12beneficial to their, to the economics of their country
- 31:15that's already struggling and in in enough ways already.
- 31:19I yeah. And then just like can do like
- 31:23the reactor type that I'm most familiar with, that's the
- 31:25Canadian one. Like it was designed in such a
- 31:28way that it can't even meltdown. Like if there was an incident
- 31:31that that would happen, there's a multiple redundancy layers
- 31:36where it would just completely kill the reaction.
- 31:38It would drop the fuel rods, it would poison the reactor and it
- 31:40would completely eliminate any reaction whatsoever if it
- 31:43started to get out of control, which it would be a costly
- 31:45incident, but it would also prevent any any unintentional
- 31:50release of radiological materials should there ever be
- 31:53like an event at a in a candy reactor.
- 31:56So they're actually touted as the these safest reactor design
- 32:02on the market and which is disappointing that we haven't
- 32:04continued to build anymore. But that may turn around in the
- 32:08not too distant future because there's a contract with Romania
- 32:12to complete two of their reactors because Romania
- 32:15actually owns two can do reactors and they're planning on
- 32:18building another two that were started 20 something years ago.
- 32:22But then they kind of got put on the back burner during the the
- 32:25contentiousness of the overthrow of the Ceausescu government.
- 32:29So they that's kind of been set aside for a while, but now it's
- 32:32being financed and revisited. And there's at least a dozen
- 32:36other countries in Europe that are very eager to get into
- 32:38nuclear power, like despite what the Germany's objections to it
- 32:43might be. And then Germany's even an
- 32:44interesting case because it turned out that the German
- 32:48Greens recently fraudulently submitted a, they, they
- 32:53manipulated the data in a report that they had submitted to a
- 32:57panel that was exploring whether or not Germany should should
- 33:00keep or retire their nuclear reactor fleet.
- 33:02And it only just came out like two months ago that that they
- 33:07had kind of played the shenanigans.
- 33:11But it also like it, it also shows like being bitcoiners,
- 33:15like did nobody like verify this?
- 33:17Like you, you, you know that these people have a vehement
- 33:19opposition to this technology. They came in with a report that
- 33:23says, yes, tech, this technology, nuclear power bad
- 33:26shut it down and nobody bought bothered to check their work.
- 33:29And then two like 3-4 years later, someone checks their work
- 33:32And it's like, you know, they, they kind of lied here guys.
- 33:36And we shouldn't have listened to them and shouldn't have
- 33:39What's the what's? The response?
- 33:41Been there. Now that that has come out.
- 33:44There's a lot more politicians that are eagerly fighting to
- 33:47bring them back online, but part of their problem is there was
- 33:52such an eagerness to retire them that some have been brought to a
- 33:56decommissioned to a state where it's going to take minimum 2-3
- 34:00years to bring them back operational.
- 34:02Like they might be lucky and the last ones that they brought down
- 34:05might be able to come back, but most of their fleet is pretty
- 34:10much mothballed and it's not, it's going to take a lot of work
- 34:13to bring them back to life, which I'm sure most of Europe
- 34:16would be very happy if they did because like France is having to
- 34:22pick up the slack for basically everybody because they're the
- 34:25ones with all the nuclear capacity.
- 34:26They, they, they had the foresight decades ago to make
- 34:31sure that they had everything that they needed to ensure their
- 34:36energy security in the future. But even then, France is having
- 34:39an interesting situation with some of their uranium mining
- 34:44sites throughout Africa, as many African nations at the moment
- 34:48are kind of trying to throw off that French boots that's been on
- 34:53them for many, many decades. So that is creating an
- 34:56interesting dynamic with with French, with France and their
- 35:01their resources that they're typically used to having access
- 35:04to. So it's going to be interesting
- 35:06to see how that plays out going forward because Africa is also
- 35:08very eager to get nuclear power. Like I was just in Ghana for the
- 35:12conference the day that the the COP conference was happening in
- 35:1620 countries pledged to expand nuclear power by 3X by the 20
- 35:21fifties. And Ghana was one of the
- 35:22countries that had signed on to that.
- 35:24But then the other part that I see is that if America and
- 35:30Europe and Canada want to participate in the African
- 35:34markets, they're going to have to get their act together
- 35:36because the Chinese and Russians are already eating our lunch.
- 35:38They're they've already been forming relationships.
- 35:40They've already got a lot of, lot of big plans.
- 35:43I just saw like something like Rosa Tom is going to be working
- 35:47with Vietnam in to help them. They've got plans for floating
- 35:51nuclear barges for, for Guinea. There's Yeah, Rosa, Tom has been
- 35:57very, very busy building relationships throughout the
- 35:59world with nations that aren't, aren't overly concerned about
- 36:04what's happening in Ukraine. They just want a quality product
- 36:06they can to help them sustain themselves and give them a
- 36:11robust infrastructure that they can build their futures upon.
- 36:13So it's going to be it's going to be interesting seeing how all
- 36:16of these, these dynamics play out as as this market starts to
- 36:20mature. Because like once, once the SMRS
- 36:22start coming onto the market, we're going to see a lot more, a
- 36:25lot more aggressive competition in, in getting these, these out
- 36:29there. Because especially if you've got
- 36:30multiple different designs that are kind of competing in the
- 36:32same markets, there's going, there's going to be a few that
- 36:36probably don't ever even make it to that commercial state because
- 36:39you, you don't, we won't need 4 different types of reactors that
- 36:43all are applying to the same like application, whether it's
- 36:47heat or like small off grid scenarios.
- 36:49Like we definitely want a few options, but we don't need, we
- 36:52don't need 4-5 MW reactors. We need like 15 MW reactor.
- 36:56We don't need, we don't need to explore too much of the, the
- 37:00molten salt reactors beyond just one design that's really, really
- 37:05capable of reprocessing like spent fuel and using recycled
- 37:09fuel as its primary fuel like, But there's that that goes
- 37:14beyond like the American markets, the Russian markets,
- 37:16Chinese markets, everyone's trying to build these, these
- 37:18reactors and get them out on to the world market.
- 37:20So it is very, very exciting time and nuclear power right
- 37:23now. And like some of these, these
- 37:25these companies are very aggressive to aggressively
- 37:29trying to have something for the market by the 30s.
- 37:33And that's, that's pretty optimistic at this point.
- 37:37But I, I think with the alignment of stakeholders and
- 37:41like policy makers right now that getting behind this, we've
- 37:44got a real chance to have some of these, these technologies
- 37:48ready, ready for prime time by yeah, within the next 5-6 years.
- 37:53So that. That leads perfectly into what I
- 37:56was about to ask mentioned SMR is a few times you mind defining
- 38:01you know what an SMR is how how it changes you know speed to
- 38:05build and you know where these might be able to be these
- 38:08reactors be able to be located maybe just dive in a bit over
- 38:13there yeah the. SMR stands for the Small Modular
- 38:16Reactor. It's basically a catch all for
- 38:20any reactor design that's under 300 megawatts.
- 38:23And the main idea is they want to be able to factory build the
- 38:27major components so that they can just quickly ship them to
- 38:30site and then have them commissioned in a very short
- 38:33time frame. Like the very, very small ones
- 38:35down in the 510 MW range. They're hoping that those can
- 38:38just be transported on a truck bed dropped off on site,
- 38:41operating within six months. The as they start getting
- 38:44bigger, that timeline starts expanding.
- 38:46But they're like hoping, like the idea is a 300 MW reactor
- 38:49will take about two years to, from, from shovels in the ground
- 38:53to commissioning like, and you'll, you'll have to have
- 38:56licensing and your site preparation that will all be
- 38:59done long before shovels are in the ground.
- 39:02But that's all preliminary work. But once, once the sites are,
- 39:06have been approved and all the environmental assessments are
- 39:08done, they, yeah, they're, they're hoping that these
- 39:11reactors can be stood up within like two, 2-3 years Max compared
- 39:14to the traditional reactors that we've, we've seen come up like
- 39:17Vogel took like 15 years and the, the one that they just
- 39:20finished in Norway took like 15 years or something.
- 39:23The one in, in the UK is plus 10 years.
- 39:27So they've been a lot of challenges getting these things
- 39:30built on time. So that is one of the appeals
- 39:32of, of the SMRS and, and the, the modularity component.
- 39:35And then the other appeal of the SMRS is that they're going to be
- 39:39using more novel fuel techniques.
- 39:42It's not stuff that hasn't been researched before, but they were
- 39:45kind of fuels and coolants that were put on the shelf decades
- 39:50ago when the whole industry as a whole kind of decided, like
- 39:54we're familiar with these boiled water reactors.
- 39:56We're really good at the boiled water reactors and the
- 39:58pressurized water reactors. That's what most of the the
- 40:02submarine fleet is based off of that technology as well.
- 40:05So they were very familiar with it.
- 40:07So they went with that kind of standard design and then that's
- 40:11what got built out. So like 90% of the reactors
- 40:13operating in the world are all based off of just boiling water
- 40:17under a pressurized condition. And then that just creates
- 40:20steam, turns a turbine. But these new reactors, they're
- 40:23getting into using molten salts as their coolants, sodium as
- 40:26their coolants, having like solid like graphite coolants and
- 40:31lead coolants. So they're exploring a lot of
- 40:34that that have different passive features that they like.
- 40:38If the reaction does start overheating, they've got
- 40:40features that will, it will start to reduce the, the how
- 40:45aggressive the reaction is. So it will actually slow itself
- 40:47down if it starts getting hot. So it has like a self regulating
- 40:50mechanism in some of these reactors.
- 40:52So they, so they'll require a lot less safety barriers like
- 40:58they're, they're still going to need to be like like an
- 41:02exclusion zone to varying degrees.
- 41:05But compared to like the, the many acres that the, the large
- 41:08reactors require, these small reactors are only going to need
- 41:11like a very small footprint of, of extra space around them to
- 41:16compensate for, for an accident, because they also have much
- 41:19smaller fuel loads. So they're going to have less of
- 41:22an impact should anything happen with them.
- 41:24But that the whole point of building these things is so that
- 41:27they have passive features so that they can basically be walk
- 41:29away safe. If they lose power, they'll fail
- 41:31into a safe state. If they lose cooling, they'll
- 41:33fail into a safe state. So there's a lot of those cool
- 41:35features that they they want to take advantage of.
- 41:38And then the other aspect of the SMRS that they want to use is
- 41:41because of these different fuel types is they can approach
- 41:44different temperatures. Because if you're only boiling
- 41:45water, your temperature outlet is limited to like boiled water
- 41:51100°C. If you pressurize that, you can
- 41:53push it up like to almost like 200°C.
- 41:56But these new reactors are hoping that some of them can
- 42:00have outlet temperatures as high as 800°C.
- 42:02So that can allow them to apply to a lot more industries and
- 42:06displace hydrocarbons in a lot of a lot of heat and steam
- 42:10applications for like even just doing oil refining textiles,
- 42:14like you name it, Like there's hundreds of different industries
- 42:17that you could probably think of that can use heat of that
- 42:21temperature. And like there's still a range
- 42:23above there that it's going to be tough for nuclear to approach
- 42:26just yet saying like when we start getting up to 1000°C where
- 42:30it's still going to need things like like coke coal that can
- 42:33really achieve those temperatures or like very, very
- 42:38like high intensity, like induction furnaces is another
- 42:41way to do that. But it's, there's, it just
- 42:44requires a lot of power to get there.
- 42:46And yeah, nuclear powers is, is going to, it's going, going to
- 42:52provide a, a new tool for a lot of these industries that have
- 42:57been pretty much dependent on on hydrocarbons as as their primary
- 43:01fuel source. And then the other thing I was
- 43:03thinking about beyond that is like you start displacing those
- 43:06hydrocarbons. They don't go away.
- 43:08They just start finding higher order uses for them.
- 43:11We start using methane more for for fertilizer.
- 43:14We start using, yeah, we start doing like, what the heck's the
- 43:19word like the cracking process where you can just recombine
- 43:23hydrocarbons and create longer chain hydrocarbons.
- 43:25You can do, we can do all kinds of stuff like that.
- 43:27We just, we, we just primarily use a lot of that for our heat
- 43:33and and electricity right now. So the idea was that would be
- 43:37less cost, they would cost less for those other uses if they're
- 43:41not being used for electricity and heat, whether you've been
- 43:44buying Bitcoin for. Years or just getting started on
- 43:46your journey, our multi institution custody solution is
- 43:49the safest and easiest way to custody your Bitcoin.
- 43:51With On Ramp and our partners at Bitco and Coincover, you can
- 43:55sleep soundly at night knowing that your Bitcoin is safe from
- 43:57exchange failures, the loss of seed phrases and broken hardware
- 44:00devices. On ramps Multi institution
- 44:03Custody solution eliminates any single point of failure,
- 44:06distributes counterparty risk and minimizes required trust all
- 44:09while providing. Greater.
- 44:10Assurances that a client's Bitcoin is secure and auditable
- 44:13on chain. As a client of On Ramp, your
- 44:16assets live in a multi save vault controlled by three
- 44:18distinct entities, none of which have unilateral control.
- 44:22On Ramp provides products and services that honor our clients
- 44:24ownership and control of the underlying asset.
- 44:27To learn more about multi institution custody, check us
- 44:30out at on rampbitcoin.com right right now that.
- 44:33That's. That's all super helpful,
- 44:35helpful context. And and I think it's, you know,
- 44:38at least if I'm on becoming clearer and clearer that people
- 44:42are having more of an open mind to nuclear.
- 44:44And I think it's, you know, it in in large part a result of
- 44:50realizing that energy independence is actually vital
- 44:53going forward, particularly if you think about, you know, the
- 44:57build out of AI compute, you want to be able to service that
- 45:01in a way that is not reliant on on other nations.
- 45:05And so I think people are coming around to the idea that energy
- 45:08independence is going to be extremely important going
- 45:11forward. And, you know, in a parallel
- 45:15sort of narrative, I think people are realizing that
- 45:18Bitcoin is very important to become financially independent
- 45:21from the Fiat system. And what I think less people are
- 45:25tuned to is that there's actually some synergies within
- 45:28both of those sort of parallel narratives that are that are
- 45:31emerging. So I would love to pull on that
- 45:33thread of why, you know, Bitcoin mining is is a really perfect
- 45:38complement to the build out of these nuclear sites.
- 45:42And you know, I think people have heard this concept with
- 45:46with respect to the build out of wind and solar, but I think it's
- 45:49been less talked about in the in the scope of the build out of
- 45:53nuclear. So would love to love for you to
- 45:55drill down into why it's such a a match made in heaven, if you
- 45:58will. Well, I.
- 45:59Like to reference the pioneer species idea for stuff like
- 46:03this, because that's, that's basically like Brandon created a
- 46:06brilliant analogy to to like view this through.
- 46:10Like you start, you want to build power where you know
- 46:14you're going to need power in the future, but you know that
- 46:16you're not going to have sufficient demand for that power
- 46:19now. So Bitcoin miners allow you to
- 46:22plant that seed, build out that energy long before it's going to
- 46:25be needed, act as a placeholder until that market matures and
- 46:30invites more sophisticated energy buyers to come and
- 46:33participate in that market. Like we kind of are already
- 46:36seeing inklings of it with what happened at the the Susquehanna
- 46:39power plant where Terra Wolf is. They built their little 48 MW
- 46:43mining load center and then they started building a giant data
- 46:47centre on the side. And then it got scooped up by
- 46:50AWS just a few weeks ago. And like, that's kind of like,
- 46:54yeah, that wouldn't have been there.
- 46:56That wouldn't have been already under construction had Terra
- 46:58Wolf not already had the foresight to get in there and
- 47:01start doing that. And then we're like starting to
- 47:03see many of the other miners are starting to lean into it.
- 47:06And then there's also like many of the other nuclear reactor
- 47:09operators like Dominion Energy and Constellation, they're
- 47:12starting to have these thoughts too.
- 47:13They're like they, they see these opportunities to bring in
- 47:17these large loads. They can ensure that they're
- 47:20going to get a return on their product regardless of what's
- 47:25happening on the grid. Because like I had kind of
- 47:27mentioned earlier, like when nuclear reactors primarily
- 47:31generate the revenue by selling power onto the grid, most of the
- 47:33time they'll they'll they'll sell it in in like large
- 47:37tranches or but if they're exposed to like the day ahead
- 47:40market, they have to compete with like when like many of
- 47:44these other sources that get the production track credits or just
- 47:48the renewable energy credits that the nuclear isn't as that
- 47:54aren't offered the same to nuclear.
- 47:55Like, like there are definitely some subsidies that come from
- 47:58nuclear, but not the same. Same way of like basically these
- 48:01windmills are paid to operate inefficiently and generate power
- 48:05when nobody needs it and the price is negative.
- 48:08But if they want to collect the, the PTC, they have to be on and
- 48:11pushing power onto the grid, even though the grid doesn't
- 48:14want it at the time. And it creates all these
- 48:15negative feedback dynamics where then your nuclear reactor is
- 48:19exposed to -6 cents a kWh. And they're like, well, we
- 48:23either now have to eat that loss or curtail their load.
- 48:29Or the other option is like a policy decision where it's just
- 48:32like they just get a guaranteed 6 cents a kWh regardless.
- 48:36Essentially that's what we do in Ontario is because often when
- 48:39when we're at full capacity, we're paying the Lake MI and New
- 48:44York to take our our surplus because it is a liability on the
- 48:47grid. If you start generating more
- 48:49than what your grid is capable of handling and it, and it
- 48:52creates these just these situations where the economics
- 48:57are not, it's not natural. The prices that we're seeing are
- 49:01so distorted by money that is not part of this market that it,
- 49:06it creates, it just, it creates so much more challenges for the
- 49:11base load generators to be able to be economic and actually sell
- 49:16their product and be good stewards of, of the grid.
- 49:20And then on the other side, like when we have the peaker plants,
- 49:22because they're only coming on for a short period of time
- 49:26during the year, they have to take advantage of like the worst
- 49:30grid prices of the year. So they're hoping for solar to
- 49:33just drop off so they can turn on for 10 minutes and scoop up
- 49:36like $3000 per MW hour for, for an hour.
- 49:40And then that's, that's their bread and butter.
- 49:42That was that, that, that's, that's, that's their World
- 49:45Series that they show up for just a few hours a year.
- 49:48And then that's how they make all the, but it's, it's such an
- 49:50inefficient way to run a grid, but they need to be available
- 49:53because sometimes if you're heavily reliant on wind and
- 49:57solar, they could just go to zero.
- 50:00And now you, you have to have something available to fill that
- 50:02space. You can't just retire all of
- 50:05your, your spinning reserves and just say like, oh, we can handle
- 50:08it with batteries. Like I'm really not impressed
- 50:11with what they're capable of just yet until there's a major
- 50:14bat breakthrough in energy storage.
- 50:16Like what what is available to the market right now is not
- 50:19capable of doing what is what what they are saying that they
- 50:23want to do with like 20 hours, like 30 hours of a battery
- 50:27backup. Like that's a lot of resources.
- 50:32It's it's going to be very. Challenging, I know.
- 50:37You know, as Bitcoiners we see, you know, the how Bitcoin can
- 50:42and the Bitcoin Bitcoin miners can help facilitate some of
- 50:46these these build outs of nuclear power plants.
- 50:50The curious, because you operate in both both worlds, you know,
- 50:54Bitcoin and the nuclear space, like in nuclear circles, does
- 51:00Bitcoin mining get talked about? Is there excitement there?
- 51:03As you know, they, they absolutely have a vested
- 51:05interest in building up, you know, some of these facilities.
- 51:10Does Bitcoin mining get talked about or do we sort of get
- 51:12lumped in with with AI, you know, as far as a, you know,
- 51:16potential source for for energy? How are we talked about over
- 51:20there? It depends on what they've been
- 51:23exposed to. I, I deal with a lot of people
- 51:26that have seen the Fuds like, but, but you're enabling
- 51:28criminals, but it, it uses, it uses bad energy.
- 51:32And then I look at them and it's like, you're in the nuclear
- 51:33sector, like we, we are the solution to that problem.
- 51:36And it's just all, all the typical FUD that, that we hear
- 51:38about. It is it's hard to, to overcome
- 51:40that anchoring bias. And then on top of that, I'm
- 51:43dealing with engineers. They're very smart people in in
- 51:46their field, but they also went to university and as you are
- 51:50aware, they were taught in economic framework that they
- 51:53were taught is economics. And so they have this complex
- 51:58where you start coming at them with Austrian ideas and it's
- 52:01very off putting for them. And so they there's a bit of a
- 52:04challenge just getting getting this idea fully embraced by the
- 52:09people that need to hear it the most.
- 52:11Like I'm getting some traction at in, in some places where it's
- 52:15not as impactful, but then I'm starting to make some ground in
- 52:19other ways. But I, I also don't want to come
- 52:21off as being like so pushy. Then you come off as the crazy
- 52:24guy. But then, but then things come
- 52:26around later and then it's like, Oh, the crazy guy was on to
- 52:28something. Because like, I, I know how it
- 52:31can get, you get very excited about learning about this
- 52:33technology and you're just like, you can fix this and you can fix
- 52:35this. And it's like, here's this very
- 52:36specific problem that we are working on and that it was
- 52:40identified in a study that we did what it was just like,
- 52:42because we're, we did, they collaborated with the, the
- 52:46Ontario Power Generation and the mining company Morarco to build
- 52:50a hybrid, hybrid energy study. And they have the, they've got a
- 52:55model that they use. They just pump in all, the, all
- 52:57the variables. But the one piece that I, I, I,
- 53:01I noticed that stood out to me was in the scenario where they
- 53:05wanted to deploy just nuclear, it clearly stated we cannot
- 53:08deploy just nuclear because of the high capital expenditures
- 53:11and the risk of leaving power stranded.
- 53:12I saw that. I was like, I have a solution
- 53:15for that. I, I will narrowly focus on just
- 53:18that one problem and offer a solution for just that singular
- 53:22focus. And they are very intent on
- 53:26yeah, there there's a very intent on hydrogen.
- 53:29There's a lot of interest on in batteries.
- 53:31Like, I just saw that my company's building a, a battery
- 53:33farm that we want to absorb from the grid during the the low
- 53:37power times and then distribute it back during the higher
- 53:41priority times. It's like, and I get that and I
- 53:43get the logic to it, but I, I've got a much better solution than
- 53:49trying to to arbitrage like power prices at different times
- 53:54of day. Just you plug in the computer
- 53:57and you turn it into money and then you do whatever you want
- 54:00with it. Yeah, let's.
- 54:02I, I'd be curious like if you could sort of paint a picture
- 54:06for folks and like, you know, Fast forward a decade and you
- 54:11know, we more fully embrace nuclear, we more fully embrace
- 54:15Bitcoin. What could, you know, a hybrid
- 54:17power system on a Bitcoin standard look like?
- 54:21And what would be, you know, the sort of key takeaways in your
- 54:25mind if you're, if you're sort of painting that picture 10
- 54:28years out, let's say, or I don't even know if that's the right
- 54:30time frame. But into the future, if, if you
- 54:32know, these, these sort of trends and trajectories continue
- 54:36in the way that we think they should just from sort of like a,
- 54:40you know, economic reality perspective, what could that
- 54:43world look like in in 10 or so years?
- 54:46Well, like we're already. Starting to see the puzzle
- 54:48pieces come together like the, the lightning architecture is,
- 54:52is an amazing payments channel and seeing companies like Sonoda
- 54:56starting to pop up that are going to enable consumers to pay
- 55:00their electricity, like literally stream in real time
- 55:02payments and settle that in real time.
- 55:05And then a friend of mine is working on a project that's kind
- 55:09of the opposite of Sonoda. So if you're familiar with the
- 55:11programs where they have where they'll offer you like a rebate,
- 55:15but then they'll take control of your smart thermostat for the
- 55:19period of time when the grid's stressed.
- 55:22His idea is more along the lines of creating like, a bounty out
- 55:25of it and having a lightning channel open between the utility
- 55:28and the consumer. And instead of just having
- 55:30unilateral control over their thermostat, they have to push a
- 55:35transaction like a lightning transaction, kind of like, if
- 55:38you're familiar with lane bits and how that, like, Ben Arc uses
- 55:41that to, like, turn on lights and gumball machines and
- 55:43electrocute Peter McCormick on stage.
- 55:46Yeah. But yeah, OV had this idea just
- 55:49like, well, if you can turn things on, you can also turn
- 55:51things off. So he was like, well, if the
- 55:53utility were to pay consumers a bounty when they want them to
- 55:58curtail their energy consumption, that can almost
- 56:01create like a gamified structure where where it creates a unique
- 56:05incentive for people to participate in these programs
- 56:07instead of just like opting in. And then your thermostat just
- 56:11turns down on the hottest day of the year.
- 56:13And you're like, OK, that's fine for one day and then two days
- 56:17and then three days. And then you start getting very
- 56:19irritable when you can't turn your thermostat before like 70
- 56:22lower than 75. And yeah, people will not be
- 56:25impressed if when that starts becoming involuntary.
- 56:29So he, he has an interesting idea of how to, to tie that
- 56:32together. And then you start thinking
- 56:33about how like the lightning architecture it, it's, it's not
- 56:39a perfect map, but it does, it does have similarities to how
- 56:45the electrical grid is managed because it's just just your,
- 56:48your generators, your substations, your consumers,
- 56:50there's just, there's nodes and channels.
- 56:52You got outbound nodes and inbound nodes.
- 56:53Similar idea except you have to the the flow is constant as
- 56:57opposed to just having liquidity that can just be moved as
- 57:01needed. But I wouldn't put it past me if
- 57:05as these generators start becoming Bitcoin miners
- 57:08themselves, then they'll start having Bitcoin mining on their
- 57:10balance sheet. They're going to have to start
- 57:11thinking about things like, well, could they provide
- 57:14lightning liquidity and work with like lightning service
- 57:17providers like voltage to, to actually have have these
- 57:20channels and actually put it to work for themselves.
- 57:22And then we've all, we're already seeing different ways
- 57:24like like sailors got his treasury strategy.
- 57:27It wouldn't be unfeasible if some of these companies start
- 57:29adopting similar ideas to to keep just Bitcoin in their
- 57:33treasury. And like, even if they just want
- 57:35to just flip it for whatever currency they want as they're
- 57:38generating it like that's going to give them, they just, they
- 57:43can just turn that into money right away.
- 57:45And then we are starting to see other products like the Luxor's
- 57:49hash price futures. So that's going to be an
- 57:51interesting one to overlay. So then they can just, they can,
- 57:54they can just be like, OK, well, for, for two years, we're just
- 57:57going to sell our whatever, like 1X hash for whatever.
- 58:02And just, and then they have that confidence that they're
- 58:05going to have their locked in prices.
- 58:06So that's going to be a lot more a lot more effective for
- 58:10utilities that are typically very risk averse when if for
- 58:13them to engage in Bitcoin. So if they can, if they can
- 58:16stabilize the revenue with something like like a forwards
- 58:18product, then that's going to give them a lot more confidence.
- 58:20And then you start seeing how all this fits together and like
- 58:23we could have like utilities in a micro grid essentially having
- 58:26like a fetiment with all of their customers.
- 58:28And then you can have these channels that have like the, the
- 58:31consumer pays through like Sonoda's software back end.
- 58:35And then ways that yeah, they then they can receive money if
- 58:38they opt into curtailment programs.
- 58:40And then they can, they can also have like if, if surplus revenue
- 58:45is being generated in these micro grids, they having a, a
- 58:48mint with all of their like local ratepayers, they can
- 58:52actually like send out like bonuses and very easily and
- 58:56quickly in, in that regard. And then it's all pretty much
- 58:59just going to get cycled into just building more
- 59:01infrastructure and just improving the systems and making
- 59:03them more robust and adding more equipment to them.
- 59:06And then like as the Bitcoin miners, they plant the seeds.
- 59:10And then you see more you, you now have the option as higher
- 59:14order energy consumers come into those markets now that they're
- 59:17more amenable to those larger consumers because the Bitcoin
- 59:22miners go in where, where you need someone a little bit more
- 59:25robust and tolerant of, of tough conditions.
- 59:28So they'll set the stage so that the consumers that require a lot
- 59:33more like redundancies into a nicer, cleaner operations to to
- 59:39be in these markets. So they'll start bringing them
- 59:42in. And then you have the option
- 59:44that you can then add more power or you can take away Bitcoin
- 59:47mining or you can add or you can do like a combination of the
- 59:50both. It's just it's going to start
- 59:52giving them so much more optionality in how they engage
- 59:57with the financial markets. Like was Bob Burnett was saying
- 1:00:01something like he expects like these Bitcoin miners and power
- 1:00:04companies and financial institutions to essentially kind
- 1:00:07of like all merge into singular entities.
- 1:00:10And based on the tools that we're seeing maturing and
- 1:00:14becoming available, it's really not out of the realm of
- 1:00:17possibility that that these these like power generating
- 1:00:21utilities will become like core. Components of the new financial
- 1:00:26rails on Bitcoin. So they're going to need to
- 1:00:29start having relationships with these financial institutions
- 1:00:31that are they're a little bit more familiar with with that
- 1:00:34type of work because there's going to be a lot of crossover
- 1:00:37in the in the coming years as these two start maturing into
- 1:00:40each other. Because I think we're only just
- 1:00:42getting started now that we're starting to see like the miners
- 1:00:45that the ASICS that are being built are being custom built to
- 1:00:49the needs and wants of the actual like people in the
- 1:00:52industry doing this. Instead of just having a six
- 1:00:55that are just zero and one on and off.
- 1:00:57Now we've got like power throttling from anywhere from
- 1:01:00zero to one and then over clocking if you've got them an
- 1:01:03immersion. So you can really push the
- 1:01:06limits on what like how fine of control we can, we can play
- 1:01:11these curtailment games like that's like, if you can wield
- 1:01:15megawatts within seconds, like that gets down to like frequency
- 1:01:19management and like, so that provides a lot of value to the
- 1:01:23grid beyond just being a like a, a consistent consumer of power.
- 1:01:28And it's going to give them a lot more, a lot more certainty,
- 1:01:32a lot more stability, just a lot more confidence when we're
- 1:01:34trying to build out these projects.
- 1:01:36And it's just, yeah. And then yeah, more, more
- 1:01:40projects, more orders. And then we just keep that
- 1:01:43feedback loop going and just, and then everybody, everybody's
- 1:01:46going to benefit in the long run if we can amplify these
- 1:01:49technologies. Yeah, that's it's fascinating
- 1:01:52stuff. And, and to me, it's, it's just
- 1:01:55becoming clearer and clearer the more I've learned about it.
- 1:01:59And, and speaking with you, it's like, you know, building out
- 1:02:03nuclear capacity is vital, I think to, you know, our sort of
- 1:02:09energy independence going forward as a, as a country.
- 1:02:12And I think, you know, we mentioned this a couple times,
- 1:02:15but like I, you know, I've heard quotes over the past few weeks
- 1:02:18of like, you know, the basically the energy capacity required for
- 1:02:24us to, you know, remain competitive on the AI side of
- 1:02:27things, you know, relative to the trials of the world, Like we
- 1:02:31are going to need to build out immensely more capacity than we
- 1:02:34have in the US today. And so, you know, if you believe
- 1:02:38that to be true, then like we have to lean into nuclear more
- 1:02:41than we already are. And as we've mentioned, like,
- 1:02:46you know, Bitcoin mining is a great way to do that in the most
- 1:02:48efficient way possible. And so, yeah, to me, it's it,
- 1:02:52it's all lining up. And I think you know it, it will
- 1:02:54take. Yeah, the biggest, I guess
- 1:02:56question mark is, is the political will to get it there
- 1:02:59and for those regulatory hurdles to be softened at least to the
- 1:03:04point where people can start putting meaningful capital
- 1:03:08behind the build out of these things.
- 1:03:11Is, is that, am I correct in that line of thinking?
- 1:03:14Like, is it, is it the political will that's like the biggest
- 1:03:17impediment at this point in time?
- 1:03:20Oh, political will. Is definitely on our side now,
- 1:03:23like Canada, both conservatives and liberals are pro nuclear.
- 1:03:28It seems like in the US, like if you got Senator Granholm coming
- 1:03:31out, very, very pro nuclear. And like I listened to that
- 1:03:36recent podcast that Trump did with the all in guys and he
- 1:03:39sounded very positive on nuclear.
- 1:03:40He was just like, we just got to figure out a better way to get
- 1:03:43these things financed, guys, let's go.
- 1:03:45And, and like a lot of that is there, there is the, the
- 1:03:49bureaucratic momentum that needs to kind of be refined so that
- 1:03:53that is a challenge. Like it just gets built up over
- 1:03:56the decades. And, and it's specifically
- 1:03:58designed for a, a unique type of reactor that doesn't align well
- 1:04:03with this whole new fleet that we're trying to bring into the
- 1:04:05world. So that's got it going to need
- 1:04:09some significant updates. And that's where I think some of
- 1:04:12these newcomers to getting into nuclear power are going to have
- 1:04:15an advantage because they're not going to be bogged down by
- 1:04:18decades of bureaucracy that's just been piled on top of
- 1:04:20itself. And it's and becomes more like
- 1:04:24of a kind of a suck for for the money that comes into the
- 1:04:27industry. It all gets sucked into the
- 1:04:29licensing and the regulatory and it becomes very challenging to
- 1:04:31actually do engineering and build these things because
- 1:04:35there's just so much like extra cost burdens on them.
- 1:04:40Yeah. What was I going with that?
- 1:04:44I think you know we're. Cognitive time and we're, we're
- 1:04:48over an hour here and want to be want to be respectful of your
- 1:04:50time, Ryan, But you know, any other sort of just further
- 1:04:55thoughts on on cause for me, this has been fascinating in the
- 1:04:57sense that, you know, I think the, the sort of nuclear side of
- 1:05:03things is its own rabbit hole that I've begun, just begun to
- 1:05:06go down. And once you start to realize
- 1:05:09that there are some similarities to the to the Bitcoin rabbit
- 1:05:12hole and that those holes actually potentially converge at
- 1:05:15a certain point and there's a lot of interesting synergies
- 1:05:18there, it becomes, you know, that much more fascinating.
- 1:05:22So, you know, any, any sort of final thoughts or final words on
- 1:05:26how people can learn more about this, where they can follow you?
- 1:05:29Any of that would be helpful. Well, the the world nuclear.
- 1:05:32Association has a really, really good library of information for
- 1:05:36anybody that wants to dig in on learning about nuclear power.
- 1:05:39There's also the NEASMR dashboard that was put out a few
- 1:05:45months ago. It's it covers the technological
- 1:05:49readiness, readiness on 6 different categories for 42 SMRS
- 1:05:53that are currently vying for to get into the market.
- 1:05:57And so there, that's, that's an interesting one that it, it
- 1:06:00explains a lot about the SMRS before getting into what the
- 1:06:05what, what is available on the market.
- 1:06:06And then just another, another one.
- 1:06:07While I do still have you guys here, because I've been looking
- 1:06:10at these ideas like, because I, I think about, I see the
- 1:06:14Bitcoin, I see the nuclear physics and there's a few
- 1:06:17interesting similarities just with the principles of like
- 1:06:21radiation and, and and nuclear physics.
- 1:06:23And like Bitcoin because like we're all familiar with the, the
- 1:06:28issuance formula and having cycle like that is exactly comes
- 1:06:32out of, of like radionuclides is they decay.
- 1:06:35The way that we measure how they decay over time is through their
- 1:06:39half life. So how, how long does it take
- 1:06:41for half of that material to decay and become a new element?
- 1:06:45So it, it is interesting just kind of seeing that like,
- 1:06:48because Satoshi seemed to be such a polymath in many
- 1:06:51different things. Like it would not surprise me if
- 1:06:53if he was familiar with nuclear physics and he was like, well,
- 1:06:56that seems like a pretty reasonable rate to, to model
- 1:07:00this, this issuance off. And then the other cool thing
- 1:07:02that I was even digging deeper into is when these atoms decay,
- 1:07:07there's a degree of like it's completely random.
- 1:07:09So no singular event affects the other, another atom from
- 1:07:14decaying. And I got to thinking how that
- 1:07:16is kind of similar for how the Bitcoin miners are searching for
- 1:07:19a nonce. And just like every single hash
- 1:07:21is independent from every other single hash, but it's all
- 1:07:24completely random. But you can infer a pattern from
- 1:07:29it if you like kind of pull yourself back and observe it
- 1:07:32over time. So it's it's very interesting to
- 1:07:33see those those relations that that Bitcoin has to like the
- 1:07:38natural principles of of nuclear radiation and the how
- 1:07:43radionuclides work if I found that one kind of interesting.
- 1:07:46So I've been looking for an opportunity to share it
- 1:07:49somewhere and just no, it's fascinating.
- 1:07:51Like, yeah. And like I know like the.
- 1:07:52Bitcoin the. Bitcoiners definitely like to
- 1:07:54see where where our technology starts to cross over with with
- 1:07:58other technologies and see where these possible like like where
- 1:08:03where the hell did this guy think of all of these commonly
- 1:08:06like and the other like the crazy one.
- 1:08:08I was just thinking about this the other day, like the the 20,
- 1:08:11the 2016 for the difficulty adjustment.
- 1:08:14And we all know that's 61O2 in reverse.
- 1:08:16Like that was such like what came first because that actually
- 1:08:20at 10 minutes a block that works out to be perfectly 14 days.
- 1:08:24So was it intentional or was it just a complete coincidence?
- 1:08:28Because it's it's beautiful. It's beautiful.
- 1:08:33It is beautiful. Bitcoin touches everything.
- 1:08:35And, you know, I think the, the themes and concept we've we've
- 1:08:39discussed today really give me give me hope and optimism for an
- 1:08:44abundant future and, and ideally one that's on a Bitcoin
- 1:08:46standard. So really want to want to thank
- 1:08:50you Ryan, for for coming on the pod and, and sharing your
- 1:08:52insight on on these, these very interesting topics.
- 1:08:56Mitch, do you have anything else?
- 1:08:57No, I just appreciate the time. It's it's.
- 1:08:59I agree. It's fascinating watching
- 1:09:03Bitcoin sort of submerse itself into every say, every industry
- 1:09:10and this power and particularly the build outs of you know, and
- 1:09:16the progress that we can make and in the nuclear space, you
- 1:09:19know, I I learned a lot over here to to seeing how how both
- 1:09:25those two worlds can can help each other.
- 1:09:28It's inevitable. I'm.
- 1:09:29Just trying to help it along any way I can because I don't know.
- 1:09:32I see, I saw something that I think can help, but it's just
- 1:09:35educating everyone else is is the challenge that I now find
- 1:09:39myself in which no, and that's that's the key.
- 1:09:41It's it's people like you. Who have, you know, are sitting
- 1:09:44in the you know, the the other industry, whatever it may be
- 1:09:49that see the light, see the vision of Bitcoin and and start
- 1:09:51making those connections. So we need more people like you.
- 1:09:54Ryan, where where can people follow you on Twitter?
- 1:09:58Yeah, just nuclear bitcoiner on Twitter I.
- 1:10:00Have Noster as well. I should probably use it more
- 1:10:02often. But yeah, it's been a weird
- 1:10:03experience. Like I went from guy just
- 1:10:05sitting in a lab and now I'm talking on podcast and just
- 1:10:08reach out cold calling to just random people that I think would
- 1:10:10like this idea. Like it all started with Foss of
- 1:10:12all people. Like he was the first one that I
- 1:10:14poked with this idea. And he's like, that's a great
- 1:10:16idea. Here's another guy that's
- 1:10:17working on it. You guys should talk to each
- 1:10:19other. And then we submitted it to a
- 1:10:20contest and then we won. And now I'm the nuclear
- 1:10:23bitcoiner talking about this stuff with everybody.
- 1:10:25Like the first big podcast I got invited on was McCormick invited
- 1:10:29me. He flew me all the way to to
- 1:10:32Bedford, for God's sakes. I'm just like, there's much
- 1:10:36better people. But I was very honored to have
- 1:10:39have been invited. Oh, Speaking of McCormick.
- 1:10:42Yeah. Because I know we we have time
- 1:10:44like him taking over Bedford right now.
- 1:10:46I don't know if you've been watching this story with him
- 1:10:48fighting with mayor and slowly taking over the city.
- 1:10:51Yeah, I think one day he's going to need a good solid power
- 1:10:55source to keep that football empire he's going to be
- 1:10:58sustaining over there one day. So, so 100% wouldn't, wouldn't
- 1:11:03put it past them to get some nuclear power in Bedford once
- 1:11:05he's once we got Mayor Pete in in the seat.
- 1:11:08Yep. No, I, I see the vision.
- 1:11:10I see the vision. Well, thank you.
- 1:11:12Thank you again, Ryan, This is this has been awesome.
- 1:11:14And yes, yeah, thanks everyone for for tuning into this episode
- 1:11:18of Final Settlement and we'll see you guys in a couple weeks
- 1:11:21later. Thanks.
- 1:11:23Thanks for listening to this week.
- 1:11:24'S episode of the show. If you found the information
- 1:11:26valuable, please share the episode with a friend or leave a
- 1:11:29rating on your favorite podcast app.
- 1:11:31All the links we discussed in today's show will be in the show
- 1:11:33notes inside your podcast app. Before we finish, a quick
- 1:11:36reminder that On Ramp Media is for informational and
- 1:11:38entertainment purposes only, and nothing should be construed as
- 1:11:41investment or legal advice. Regardless of where you are on
- 1:11:44your Bitcoin journey, we'd love to hear from you.
- 1:11:47Visit onrampbitcoin.com/contact. Schedule a consultation with one
- 1:11:51of our private client advisors.