Latest / Politics with Paul / Politics With Paul #30: How Should We Compensate Our Elected Officials?
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome back to the politics with Paul podcast.
- 0:03I am your host, Paul Reiter.
- 0:06Today, we're gonna talk about how should we compensate our elected government officials.
- 0:13Every so often, somewhere in The US, a politician or a group of them is going to bring
- 0:20up raising their pay.
- 0:22In fact, they're doing it right now.
- 0:24How much government officials, especially elected officials, should be getting paid and
- 0:29otherwise compensated for their work can be a bit of a touchy subject.
- 0:33That's especially the case when you account for the wealthiest government officials from
- 0:38president to Congress to state and local level politicians.
- 0:43It certainly doesn't help when one of these officials is making money on the side in a
- 0:48definitively or potentially illegal way, or even when it is legal.
- 0:54And then when a politician proposes a pay raise, whoo boy, look out because many voters
- 1:01probably aren't going to be happy to hear that.
- 1:04There's a lot that must go into deciding how we should compensate our elected officials.
- 1:10Many of these same considerations also apply to appointed government officials, but for the
- 1:15most part, we're gonna focus on elected officials today since they're more directly
- 1:19accountable to voters.
- 1:21So what factors go into how much we compensate officials?
- 1:26What are some examples of compensation we already see for federal, state and local
- 1:31officials?
- 1:33How should we decide how to compensate the politicians we elect?
- 1:38Well, that's what we're talking about today.
- 1:40So let's begin.
- 1:42What factors do we consider when compensating our government officials?
- 1:48Now keep in mind, these are not perfect correlations to how we determine salaries,
- 1:54benefits, like health care, and so on for these elected officials, but these are some basic
- 1:59guidelines.
- 2:00So specialized versus generalized expertise.
- 2:04Do we pay more for a specialized job that few people will have the knowledge and capability
- 2:10to do?
- 2:11For example, local offices, there are some special districts like water districts that are
- 2:17very narrow and specific in what they do?
- 2:21Or do we pay more for the generalized job like most elected officials you see?
- 2:26Because they are handling a bunch of different things and they have to have their hands in
- 2:31multiple jars.
- 2:33What do we consider a specialized job?
- 2:36A specialized job again, that might include those special districts or specific court.
- 2:43So how exactly do we determine how to pay those officials based on whether they're specialized
- 2:50or generalized?
- 2:52How often is their job performed?
- 2:54Because not every elected position is considered full time.
- 2:58In fact, there's a lot of state legislatures that are considered part time where they only
- 3:03meet for a few months or so in the year, at least in an official capacity.
- 3:09And do we only pay them for days where they show up to work, or do we still give them a
- 3:15full salary?
- 3:16Is it wages versus a salary?
- 3:19Several different things to consider there.
- 3:22What level of government are we talking about?
- 3:24So federal versus state versus local.
- 3:27Generally, we would expect the highest to lowest pay to be federal to state to local.
- 3:34However, there can be a lot of variation within each of those levels.
- 3:39For example, one state legislature could be paid massively more than another state's
- 3:44legislature.
- 3:45And because of this variation, some state officials might get more pay than federal
- 3:51officials in that same state, or even a local level politician might get more or get a higher
- 3:59salary than a state or a federal official in that state, depending on what the local office
- 4:07is.
- 4:07But generally speaking, you'll see.
- 4:10I'm gonna pay for federal level officials, then goes down to state level, and then it goes down
- 4:17to local level.
- 4:18And in a similar vein, the prestige of the position.
- 4:22So the more well known high ranking offices will generally get higher pay, probably more
- 4:30benefits like health care.
- 4:32For example, if you're the chief justice of a state supreme court or of the US supreme court,
- 4:38you'll probably get a higher salary.
- 4:40Maybe not necessarily a whole lot more, but you will get a higher salary than your associate
- 4:46justices on the bench.
- 4:48Big city mayors probably are gonna get more pay than smaller city mayors, partly because
- 4:54there's a bigger taxpayer base there.
- 4:57So there is going to be more tax revenue and just the, again, the prestige of the city to
- 5:05place like New York City or Los Angeles, Chicago, Tampa, Miami, are a lot more than a
- 5:13small rural town out in Nebraska, for example.
- 5:18Not trying to pick on you, Nebraska.
- 5:19It's just an example.
- 5:23Congressional leaders versus the rank and file members of Congress, they'll generally get, the
- 5:29the congressional leaders will generally get more money.
- 5:33So comes it's a bit more commensurate with what your ranking is in your respective, level of
- 5:41office.
- 5:42And sometimes depending on what state and locality you're in, how many people are
- 5:48directly affected by that official's decisions.
- 5:52So we might expect officials whose decisions in government impact more citizens to be
- 5:58compensated more than officials whose decisions impact fewer citizens.
- 6:03So if you are the mayor of a city that has a Maryland residence, you're probably gonna get,
- 6:11higher pay than a mayor who only has 10,000 citizens or even a hundred thousand citizens.
- 6:19And then if you consider officials for the whole nation versus just parts of the nation or
- 6:26statewide officials like a governor versus the state legislature.
- 6:29So for a districted versus nondistricted counterparts, because being a districted
- 6:37official like a state legislature or a city council by default, you're gonna have a smaller
- 6:43constituency to directly answer to than if you were the mayor for a city, or even those
- 6:52counties that have also have mayors or a governor of a state or the president of The
- 6:57United States.
- 7:00There's also the compensation forms beyond just a simple salary or wage.
- 7:06There are, there's a type of compensation called a per diem, which is Latin for by the
- 7:12day, which refers to costs related to travel.
- 7:16So the actual travel, if you're going by car or by airplane, lodging and accommodations, food
- 7:23related to that travel, so on and so forth.
- 7:26You might also have privileges such as subsidized health care and what's called the
- 7:31flanking privilege, which basically means when you're sending out official correspondence, you
- 7:37don't have to pay for stamps.
- 7:38You can use your official signature at sort of in place of those stamps so you don't have to
- 7:44pay for the stamps.
- 7:47Whether there is an ability to receive outside income.
- 7:51And this is where things get a little bit dicey and how much outside income you can receive if
- 7:58you can receive some outside income.
- 8:00So we're talking, for example, speaking engagements, book deals, stocks.
- 8:07Is there a difference between the income from works made before you entered office versus
- 8:13works during office?
- 8:15Can you make a book deal while you're in office versus, you know, obviously before office,
- 8:23there wasn't a whole lot you can really regulate there, but when you're in office, are
- 8:27you still allowed to have book deals and speaking engagements?
- 8:31Because those can be very lucrative things.
- 8:34How much your compensation is tied to inflation.
- 8:37So as inflation goes up, does your compensation also go up for a lot of places?
- 8:42That is the case.
- 8:43Some places it's not.
- 8:47Do so does the salary or do other forms of compensation you get go up as the prices of
- 8:54goods and services rise and your purchasing power decreases?
- 8:59Again, depends on the office.
- 9:01And then there's also just these other unique differences between the states because every
- 9:06state has its own realities to consider.
- 9:09Where is money already being spent?
- 9:12All these other programs that are also receiving tax rev, tax revenue or taxpayer
- 9:17dollars to fund.
- 9:19How many elected officials there are in that state?
- 9:22If we take state legislatures, for example, there's a lot of difference in the sizes where
- 9:27if you're talking about Alaska's legislature, it's a lot smaller than New York's legislature
- 9:33or New Hampshire's legislature.
- 9:37And then obviously the total tax revenue, which is in part due to population size.
- 9:43If you have a larger population, you're probably going to have a larger taxpayer base.
- 9:49So all sorts of things here, and this is not necessarily a comprehensive list.
- 9:53There might be some other factors to consider in compensation for officials that I haven't
- 9:57covered here, but this is just some of the really, general basic things to consider when
- 10:04we're talking about compensation for government officials, especially the elected officials.
- 10:10Now let's take a bit of a deeper dive into each level of government.
- 10:14So federal versus state versus local level, officials compensation, and we'll go with
- 10:21federal level first.
- 10:23So, obviously, we have the president.
- 10:25The president's pay is covered by US code title three section one zero two, which stipulates
- 10:31that the president gets a $400,000 per year salary paid monthly, and there's also an
- 10:37allowance of up to $50,000 to, quote, unquote, to assist in defraying expenses relating to or
- 10:45resulting from the discharge of his official duties.
- 10:48A little bit vague, but that is the basic stipulation for the president.
- 10:54Now as for congress, as of 06/27/2024 from a congressional research service report, most US
- 11:02house representatives and US Senators receive a hundred $74,000 and legislative leaders get
- 11:08more referring back to earlier when I said more prestigious positions tend to get more, a
- 11:15higher salary than their regular counterparts.
- 11:19Speaker of the house gets $223,500, and then the president pro tempore of the senate and the
- 11:27majority and minority leaders of both chambers each get a hundred $93,400.
- 11:34And then you also have the twenty seventh amendment, which basically says that any law
- 11:39raising the compensation of members of Congress cannot take effect until after the next
- 11:46election.
- 11:47That was the latest amendment that we added to the constitution.
- 11:52And then for federal courts, since 1968, most years have seen an increase in compensation for
- 11:59federal judges.
- 12:00In some years, it stayed the same, but it's partly going back to the factors we talked
- 12:06about earlier, going back a little bit to, inflation.
- 12:11And for SCOTUS in 2025, the chief justice's salary is gonna be $317,500, and then associate
- 12:18justices get a little bit under $304,000.
- 12:22And so taking all these federal officials, together, some of the factors you see
- 12:28contributing to their compensation is they're in the highest ranks of US government because
- 12:33they're on the federal level.
- 12:34They their decisions affect the widest range of people, not necessarily directly, some of it
- 12:41indirectly, but they represent the entire nation.
- 12:46They're in office for a considerable portion of the year to and their decisions have a wide
- 12:52ranging impact on a lot of people.
- 12:54Because of these considerations, these are some of the biggest reasons why you see federal
- 13:00level officials get the compensation that they do.
- 13:05Now whether they should get more or less, well, we're gonna get a little bit into that, debate,
- 13:12later on in this episode.
- 13:15But aren't you the state government officials now?
- 13:17So talking about state executives, there may, many different kinds of those.
- 13:22Some of which aren't found in every state.
- 13:25Governor is obviously in every state.
- 13:27Attorney generals in every state.
- 13:29Lieutenant governors in almost every state.
- 13:31But then you've also got things like treasurer, insurance commissioner, agriculture
- 13:35commissioner, superintendent of schools, or might also be called education commissioner,
- 13:40all these other different offices that states may or may not have.
- 13:45Governor salaries in 2023 range from $90,000 in Colorado to $250,000 in New York.
- 13:53So there's quite a big disparity depending on the state.
- 13:57And Arizona, Colorado, and Oregon were the only states below a hundred thousand dollars for,
- 14:03per year for their, governors as of 2023.
- 14:09And some of the biggest jumps you saw from twenty twenty two's salary to 2023 included
- 14:14Wyoming, where there there was a 33.3% increase.
- 14:18Massachusetts was a 20.1% increase, and South Dakota was a 14.5% increase from 2022 to 2023.
- 14:27So a decent variety of states that saw big jumps in salary for their governors.
- 14:36And then another state executive offices as well, you see lots of variations in salary.
- 14:40But perhaps surprisingly, not every state makes its governor the most well paid state
- 14:46executive.
- 14:46You might expect that because they're the most prestigious in their state government, but not
- 14:52that's not always the case.
- 14:55So we have data from the book of the states, which is from the council of state governments
- 14:59that gives us an in-depth look at compensation for these state executive offices.
- 15:05Again, this is 2023.
- 15:06Not necessarily gonna be a huge difference for if if we had the data for 2024 and 2025, but
- 15:14there might be a little bit of difference.
- 15:15But still, not every state's governor is that state's most well compensated state executive.
- 15:23So states and, again, 2023 salaries where the attorney general actually earned more money
- 15:30than the governor include Alabama, Colorado, Maine, Montana, South Carolina, and some states
- 15:38where the treasurer actually earned more money were Alaska, Massachusetts, Michigan,
- 15:44Tennessee, Virginia.
- 15:46So pretty big variety, pretty decent variety of states there, some that we would consider red,
- 15:52some that we would consider blue, so it's not necessarily tied to partisanship either.
- 15:58Now as for state legislators, ballot pedia lists four main ways that the salaries of state
- 16:04legislators are determined.
- 16:06Some states have a commission that determines the salary.
- 16:12Some states stipulate that any recommendation to change legislator pay must be approved by
- 16:17voters before going into effect.
- 16:20Some states tie their legislative salaries to those of other state employees, and then other
- 16:26states allow legislators themselves to set their own salaries.
- 16:29And later on, we're gonna talk a little bit about the reasons some people may support or
- 16:35oppose each of those specific ways of determining, compensation for, gov governor or
- 16:46compensation for government officials in general.
- 16:50But for for this particular part, we're just talking about state legislators.
- 16:54So, pay is partially based on whether these legislature in that state is part time, hybrid,
- 17:02or full time, which basically denotes how much state legislators in a given state spend their
- 17:09time on their official legislative duties.
- 17:12Now just because they work part time doesn't mean that they don't actually work all that
- 17:18often in their legislative capacity.
- 17:21Some legislators would tell you that even though they're nominally part time, it's still
- 17:26a full time job.
- 17:27But according to the National Conference of State Legislatures last report in 2021, '10
- 17:34states were considered full time legislatures, 26 states were considered hybrids, and then 14
- 17:40states were considered part time.
- 17:42So generally speaking, the salary, the comp the the compensation strictly based on salary
- 17:50typically goes from highest to lowest with full time to hybrid to part time, although you'll
- 17:57see a little bit of difference there.
- 18:00For example, there are a few part time legislatures where the legislator actually
- 18:05earned more than some of the hybrid legislatures.
- 18:10But there's also a thing called a per diem, which we mentioned earlier on, which is Latin
- 18:15for by the day.
- 18:16So some most states give their legislators a per diem regardless of whether they provide a
- 18:22salary.
- 18:23So that refers to costs associated with travel, like lodging, food while traveling, gas.
- 18:31Basically, anything that's related to the costs of travel.
- 18:35And in some states, it might either be the same way for every legislator where each of them get
- 18:42the same per diem, or there might be states where legislators further from the capital get
- 18:48a higher per diem because they have to travel further.
- 18:50Alaska is one of those.
- 18:52So a little bit even a little bit of difference even for within the state legislature,
- 19:00depending or depending on where that state legislator resides in the state.
- 19:07And then for state courts, and this data is gonna come from Ballopedia, who in turn cited
- 19:13the National Center for State Courts Judicial Salary Tracker for 2024.
- 19:19For state supreme court justices, West Virginia was the lowest that was just under a hundred
- 19:24$50,000 all the way to California, which was just over $291,000.
- 19:31So honest, California, state supreme court justices made almost double what West
- 19:39Virginia's state supreme court justices made.
- 19:42And some of these states, there's potential for the chief justice to make even more money in
- 19:47terms of salary.
- 19:49And then intermediate appellate court justice, intermediate appellate court being the rank
- 19:54just under state supreme court.
- 19:57And not every state has an intermediate appellate court, And this is for where data was
- 20:02available, but West Virginia, again, was at the bottom with a hundred $42,500, and then
- 20:09California was once again at the top with just under $273,000.
- 20:16And these salaries are not necessarily tied to court budgets.
- 20:20So we talk about earlier where sometimes a a government official's salary is in part due to
- 20:30the availability of tax revenue.
- 20:32So there's a little bit of that here, but it's not entirely the case because salaries are not
- 20:37necessarily tied to the core budgets.
- 20:40We have six states with $1,000,000,000 plus budgets.
- 20:45California and New York by far have the highest budgets for their state court systems at
- 20:515,100,000,000.0 and $3,700,000,000 respectively, and their justices are at or near
- 20:57the top of pay for state court justices.
- 20:59So that's not surprising.
- 21:01But Oregon, Minnesota, and Colorado also have over a billion dollar budgets, yet they rank
- 21:09roughly middle of the pack in terms of salaries for their state supreme court and intermediate
- 21:15appellate court justices.
- 21:18And so taking all these state government officials together, some of the factors
- 21:23contributing to their compensation, statewide officials getting higher salaries than
- 21:29districted state officials.
- 21:31So for a Tampa state legislature, didn't really rarely, if ever gets the same kind of
- 21:37compensation as a governor or attorney general or a treasurer, and the statewide officials are
- 21:46usually gonna get more than most local level officials as well.
- 21:50Although, with some exceptions, however, just because there is more tax revenue available and
- 21:57just having a higher population state and therefore more citizens to affect with their
- 22:02decisions, that did not always correlate with officials' compensation.
- 22:06That was that is to say, just because you had more tax revenue available, a higher budget,
- 22:13having a higher population state affects it more citizens to affect with your decisions,
- 22:19that did not always translate to a higher compensation for those state level officials.
- 22:24A lot of times it does, but it's certainly not a perfect correlation in that regard.
- 22:30And now for the last group, local government officials, this is a pretty tricky group to
- 22:38analyze because it's much harder, if not impossible, to find info on various local
- 22:44government officials' compensation.
- 22:46There are a lot of them to account for.
- 22:48There's over 90,000 local governments of some form.
- 22:53So cities, special districts, counties, any sort of substate unit, there's a lot of those
- 23:04to account for, And it tends to be more difficult to find info on these governments,
- 23:10especially when it comes to governments that have jurisdiction over smaller populations.
- 23:16So small towns that might still have a mayor and city council, those can be very hard to
- 23:22find information on information on their government in general, let alone how much
- 23:26their, government officials get compensated for their job.
- 23:33Because local government in general gets less media coverage, and it has fewer resources to
- 23:40make info about them known than their state and federal government counterparts do.
- 23:48And as a result, I couldn't find a verifiable source that gives a fully accurate picture of
- 23:55the range of salaries and other forms of compensation that mayors, county commissioners,
- 24:00city councilors, and so on receive.
- 24:03I'm not gonna quite say that that doesn't exist, but I find it very hard to believe it
- 24:09does exist just because there's so many local government officials to account for.
- 24:17So that being said, though, some of the more populous localities have some information
- 24:22available because, again, they're more prestigious.
- 24:26They have a lot more people they affect.
- 24:28They're they have more resources available, so you're gonna typically find more information on
- 24:32them.
- 24:33So a few examples we can point to.
- 24:37San Francisco seems to have perhaps the highest mayoral salary.
- 24:43So their new mayor, Daniel Lurie, he was elected in 2024.
- 24:49He actually decided to make his salary a dollar per year, but he otherwise would have made just
- 24:56on a little bit under $365,000.
- 25:01New York City seems to be second place.
- 25:04I don't wanna say definitively that it is second place, but it seems to be the second
- 25:08highest compensation for its mayor.
- 25:10Currently, that's Eric Adams with a lot of the legal troubles that he's having.
- 25:14We'll see how long he lasts in there, although he is, at least right now, running for
- 25:19reelection to the mayoral office in New York City, but he right now makes $258,750.
- 25:28Oh, excuse me.
- 25:29New York City is not second place in that regard.
- 25:32I believe it's actually Los Angeles because Los Angeles Mayor Karen Bass, who was recently in
- 25:37Congress, she makes a little bit under $305,000 a year.
- 25:43So even though the info on them is limited, certain local government officials, whether
- 25:49it's a mayor of a big city or a county commissioner in a big county, if the city is
- 25:55big enough, they may actually make a higher salary than a state level or federal level
- 26:02government official in that same state.
- 26:05And you you see that there with San Francisco's Mayor, Daniel Lohrey and Los Angeles Mayor,
- 26:10Karen Bass, and New York City Mayor, Eric Adams.
- 26:13They're not necessarily the only ones, but they're some of the most prominent examples
- 26:17where they actually get compensated more than a lot of federal and state level officials do in
- 26:24their same states.
- 26:26Now that we're done with federal, state, and local officials, let's talk about well, let's
- 26:32just talk about officials in general.
- 26:34Should officials be able to receive outside income, especially elected officials?
- 26:40And this is a trickier question than one might assume.
- 26:43There are already some regulations on outside income depending on the office.
- 26:47Insider trading is a big no no for anyone, especially for politicians.
- 26:52And for members of congress, outside earned earned income, according to the Congressional
- 26:58Research Service, is limited to 15% of the annual rate of basic pay.
- 27:02So in 2024, that was a little bit under $32,000.
- 27:081 of the overarching, debates, I guess, you would say, about how much we can limit these
- 27:19officials' ability to receive outside income is you're kind of balancing the freedoms of
- 27:23speech, particularly of speech, versus the potential for corruption.
- 27:29Is there a potential first amendment or other constitutional issue with preventing outside
- 27:35income?
- 27:35Now, obviously, there should be some hindrance on where elected officials receive outside
- 27:41income from, but where do we draw the line?
- 27:45They shouldn't be able to take money from the nefarious actors, ones who have a clearly
- 27:50vested interest against The United States.
- 27:54But what exactly can we ban and how far should we ban these things?
- 28:02So a few of the debates that you'll hear about, one in particular, should they be able to hold
- 28:08stocks in companies while they're in office?
- 28:11There is the potential for insider trading that can and has happened already.
- 28:16But what if officials move those stocks into someone else's control while that official is
- 28:22in office?
- 28:23So if Joe Schmo has however many shares in Tesla or Google or you know, whatever the case
- 28:32may be.
- 28:33What if he moves it to somebody else's control?
- 28:38Is that okay, or is that not quite removed enough from Joe Schmo and he needs to sell his
- 28:46stocks before he gets into office?
- 28:49Some citizens and even some elected officials already have been pushing for requiring members
- 28:55of congress to sell their stocks when they get elected, so before they get into office.
- 29:02Another debate is, should they be able to receive speaking fees while in office?
- 29:08Because speaking fees, especially for a prominent current or former government
- 29:12official, can be very lucrative.
- 29:16So do we make it so that they can only re receive speaking fees after they leave office?
- 29:22Where exactly do we draw that line?
- 29:25Or is is is their ability to if we hinder their ability to receive speaking fees while they're
- 29:32in office, is that infringement on their first amendment rights?
- 29:37Is there the potential for corruption there to to allow them to have these speaking fees and
- 29:44to just rack up all this money in a way that's maybe not necessarily illegal, but potentially
- 29:51unethical, you using and abusing their their office?
- 29:55Is it even an abuse of their office?
- 29:58Not exactly straightforward straightforward debates about that kind of thing.
- 30:05And in a similar vein, should they be able to make book writing deals?
- 30:10Similar situation to speaking engagements.
- 30:13If they they are able to have book writing deals, obviously, you need to have some
- 30:18guardrails as to what resources they put towards book promotion.
- 30:22I believe it was Baltimore's previous mayor that she wrote a book.
- 30:29I can't remember her name off the top of my head, but she wrote a book, and she used
- 30:34government resources to try to promote that book, which was illegal, and she had to resign.
- 30:42I don't know if she actually went to jail.
- 30:44I can't remember if she actually went to jail or was fine or what exactly happened, but she
- 30:49had to leave office.
- 30:50So would it just be easier to ban book deals when in off office altogether, or is that also
- 30:57an infringement on certain freedoms like freedom of speech?
- 31:04Or if we get to a little bit more of not just accumulating wealth while in they're in office,
- 31:13but wealth before they got into office.
- 31:15If a politician is wealthy enough outside of their government job, should they have to
- 31:20forego their salary they'd receive from that government position?
- 31:24Now you do see some politicians already decline their salary, and, partially, that's for
- 31:30political brownie points.
- 31:31But you do see regardless of their intentions, some of them do decline their government
- 31:38salary.
- 31:39We just mentioned the San Francisco Mayor.
- 31:41He went with just a a dollar a year salary when he could have had over $360,000.
- 31:48Now whether that's out of the goodness of his own heart or or not, that's for you to decide.
- 31:53But in general, there are politicians that do it for those political brownie points.
- 31:59So you do see some politicians already decline their salary, but should there be a rule that
- 32:05says, okay.
- 32:06You've earned you your regular job earns you three times the amount that this government
- 32:14position would, get you in terms of salary.
- 32:19So do you have to forego your salary that way?
- 32:23And that kind of ties back into, should they have to sell all their stocks and other
- 32:28companies, all their shares, any sort of is are there other assets they should have to sell so
- 32:35that there's as little potential for corruption or abusing their station as possible?
- 32:43So if we compare specific legislatures, New Mexico, their state legislature has no salary.
- 32:51They only earn a per diem.
- 32:53So should New Mexico's legislators have fewer regulations on outside income compared to New
- 33:00York legislators who are the most well paid state legislators in the country.
- 33:05Is that considered fair?
- 33:09There's I mean, e e even if we did decide, okay, if they if if they're wealthy enough,
- 33:16they they should have to forego their government salary.
- 33:20Okay.
- 33:20Even if we all decided that that was what they should do, what exactly is that threshold?
- 33:27Do they it doesn't have to be that they earn a hundred thousand dollars, more than they would
- 33:33if they so if their government salary was gonna be a hundred thousand dollars, if they had
- 33:37another job that earned them $200,000, do they have to give up their government salary?
- 33:42Or does it have to be if their outside job is $300,000 or $400,000?
- 33:48Where exactly do we draw that line?
- 33:50It's not a it's not an obvious answer.
- 33:55And then lastly, when it comes to outside income, how much do these bans on outside
- 34:01income or potential bans on outside income, how much does this depend on what the office is?
- 34:07So, for example, should state supreme court justices have even more restrictions on outside
- 34:14income than a state governor or a state attorney general?
- 34:19State supreme court justices deal with the law, so there's arguably even more of an emphasis on
- 34:28making sure that they're not corrupt.
- 34:29But we also have state legislators who write laws.
- 34:32We have state executives who execute the laws.
- 34:36So should they have different rules to abide by than people who rule on the legality of things?
- 34:46Some might say yes.
- 34:47Some might say no.
- 34:49There's not a there's not a clear answer on that.
- 34:53Some people can argue one way and some people can argue another.
- 34:57But these are just some of the questions to think about when it comes to bans on outside
- 35:02income, because it's very easy to say, oh, yeah.
- 35:04They shouldn't be able to to earn too much money because it's it's too much of an
- 35:10accumulation of power and they are and and things like that.
- 35:15But you need to have more concrete guardrails.
- 35:20And how exactly those guardrails look is not it's not an easy thing to come up with even
- 35:27though some people may wanna make it think or make it seem like it's an obvious thing.
- 35:33You it's there's there's little nooks and crannies that you really have to consider.
- 35:38And speaking of nooks and crannies and nuances, I know talking about nuance is not, the hot
- 35:45thing to do in politics, but let's just talk about the general debate on how much we should
- 35:51pay officials.
- 35:52So I'm not talking about outside income or the ability to we're we're not talking about
- 35:58outside income in general.
- 35:59Now we're just talking specifically about their compensation, Specific amounts of compensation
- 36:07aside.
- 36:08So forget about whether it's they're getting $80,000 a year or a hundred thousand dollars a
- 36:12year or whatever.
- 36:13What are some general arguments you hear made for and against raising how much we pay elected
- 36:20officials.
- 36:22So some of the most common arguments you'll hear for paying government officials more is it
- 36:30gives officials more resources to do their job.
- 36:32They can hire more staff to help with the job.
- 36:35It's very easy to look at executive, legislative, and judicial elected officials.
- 36:41It's very easy to look at them and and just assume that they're doing the entire job, but
- 36:45they have staff that help them out.
- 36:48And how much how big their staffs are, how well versed and seasoned and experienced their
- 36:57staffs are their staffs are, that can depend on states.
- 37:02So some state legislatures, their staff sizes are a lot bigger than in other states.
- 37:07A state governor, one state may have a lot more staff under him or her than in another state.
- 37:14And it's the same thing with state court justices.
- 37:19So the idea is that if they get paid more money, you are giving them the ability to hire
- 37:25more staff so they are more efficient to do their in doing their job.
- 37:30Another argument that you might hear for paying these government officials more is that it
- 37:36gives them less incentive to look for outside sources of income, making corruption less
- 37:40enticing.
- 37:41So the idea is an official who is getting $25,000 a year, for example, They might be more
- 37:50enticed to look for shady, maybe not necessarily illegal, but legally ambiguous,
- 37:59sources of outside income to supplement what they're making versus a a government official
- 38:06of the same capacity in another state that's making, like, a hundred thousand dollars a
- 38:09year, so they're making four times the amount.
- 38:11So the idea is that if you increase this government official's salary by x amount of
- 38:20dollars, they're less likely to wanna find outside sources of income.
- 38:25And even if those aren't illegal sources of outside income, there's still a potential for
- 38:31corruption there.
- 38:32At least that's how the idea goes.
- 38:34And then one more common argument you hear for arguing for more pay for these government
- 38:42officials is that it gives regular people a chance to pursue becoming elected officials
- 38:47because they don't have to rely on that outside income.
- 38:51So it's not just rich people.
- 38:53There is a lot more variety in class backgrounds as to who can run for office and
- 39:00win office.
- 39:01So if you have New Mexico, for example, which doesn't have a salary, they have a per diem.
- 39:09The idea is that it's harder for regular people who are not as well resourced.
- 39:16It or personally, if they don't they don't have a whole lot of money to their name, whereas
- 39:21somebody who's a small business owner, for example, might have more money, and they are
- 39:26more able to be able to do that job because they already have outside income from the
- 39:34beginning.
- 39:36So the idea is they won't have to maybe take out loans to try to help them through cost of
- 39:47for through cost of living, through being fed.
- 39:51So that's another thing to consider.
- 39:53And then on the flip side, some of the art common arguments you hear against paying these
- 39:59government officials more money is that it costs taxpayers more money because more of
- 40:05their dollars are going to paying these officials.
- 40:09So you might have to raise taxpayer dollars, or they, you might have to take tax revenue that
- 40:15is already going towards one program, pull it from that and then put it towards compensating
- 40:23these elected officials.
- 40:27And then you also sometimes hear that elected officials already have ways that they are
- 40:32compensated beyond simple salaries.
- 40:34And they're not just talking about earlier with, like, speaking engagements at book deals,
- 40:39but they are compensated through not necessarily clearly monetized means.
- 40:45So they already have the prestige of being in office.
- 40:51So maybe after office, they can go out on the speak, public speaking trail.
- 40:56They can make book deals.
- 40:58They can become a lobbyist.
- 41:00They can work in a nonprofit that deals with government relations, for example, or they can
- 41:08parlay it to, federal government job or try to run for federal office.
- 41:14So it's the prestige and future opportunities that come from being a a a government official
- 41:22that may not be as well salaried now, but you'll get more opportunities in the future.
- 41:28So you hear some comp so these are just some of the common arguments you hear for and against
- 41:35increasing compensation for these elected government officials.
- 41:38Again, regardless of what they're actually making right now, don't wanna don't wanna make
- 41:42this more simplified.
- 41:43So just whether we should pay them more in general or we should pay them less in general
- 41:49or at least not increase how much we pay them now.
- 41:54But to end things off, types of offices aside, what are the ways we what are the methods we
- 42:03should use to determine compensation of elected officials?
- 42:06So I'm not talking about the actual level of compensation, whether they're getting 60,000,
- 42:1380 thousand, hundred thousand dollars a year.
- 42:15They're getting subsidized health care.
- 42:17They're getting freaking privileges.
- 42:19They're getting per diems.
- 42:20Not talking about any of that.
- 42:21I'm talking about the specific way the specific method we use to say, okay.
- 42:28They're they're getting paid The way we're determining how they get paid is this, and we
- 42:33just highlighted a few of those were specifically for the state legislatures, but
- 42:37now let's take it and apply it to elected government officials in general.
- 42:45So should we use a special commission that determines their salary like some states do for
- 42:52their state legislators?
- 42:53So some people, the way they the arguments they would use to support that is that if you use a
- 42:59special commission, you're not leaving it in the hands of politicians who would have a
- 43:03vested interest in raising their pay because who doesn't wanna get paid more to do their
- 43:08job?
- 43:09And this commission is probably more in tune with the needs of officials and their staff
- 43:13versus, say, the voters.
- 43:16But then also, of course, you have people who would be against it.
- 43:22So some of the people or some of the arguments that you would hear for people opposing a
- 43:26special commission determining government official salary is that there might be the
- 43:32potential for closed room deals and political agendas if commission members can run for
- 43:37office or interact with politicians.
- 43:39So even if they're not necessarily in office now, they might run for it later, or they can
- 43:43still be influenced by those who are in office.
- 43:46And then they might they they might have the, what's the word I'm looking for?
- 43:55Protest is not the word I'm looking for, but they might protest about, well, who should
- 44:00choose the commission.
- 44:01It's easy to say that, oh, we'll have a an outside commission determine the salary, but
- 44:06who picks that commission?
- 44:08Do politicians do that?
- 44:09Do voters do that?
- 44:11Do voters and politicians jointly pick people?
- 44:15Is there a specific office already a specific person who's already in office like a governor?
- 44:21Do they pick the people on that special commission?
- 44:28Things to consider both for those who support having that special commission and for those
- 44:33who oppose that special commission.
- 44:36What about if we determined government salary by approval from voters?
- 44:42So the way some of the arguments from people who would support that, they'll say that voters
- 44:48will have a more direct say over where their taxpayer dollars are being devoted to.
- 44:55Obviously, taxpayers should have some say over where their tax dollars are going.
- 45:02But how how much of that is feasible?
- 45:05And then if you have voters doing it, it's a potential for a more open air process as
- 45:10opposed to if you just had a special commission doing it.
- 45:14But some people who would oppose approval by the legislators would say, well, there's a
- 45:18potential for manipulation of voters, and especially with how rampant misinformation and
- 45:23completely false information is, you might see that become a problem for voters in
- 45:28determining, oh, how much should these, politicians get compensated?
- 45:35And voters aren't often are often aren't going to be as privy to the financial needs of these
- 45:40government officials because, typically, there and this could be a pro or a con.
- 45:48There's often a political risk, and elected government officials try to get voters to
- 45:52support a pay increase for them.
- 45:55Your taxpayer dollars are going to again, let's just use Joe Schmoe as an example.
- 46:00You say, hey, you know what?
- 46:01You should support this ballot measure that increases my pay in office.
- 46:07You think that's going to go over well with with these voters?
- 46:11Generally speaking, probably not.
- 46:13Now he might have all these reasons that he wants you to do that, and he might put forth
- 46:19those those reasons to you, but then there might be somebody who opposes him and says, oh,
- 46:24no.
- 46:24He's full of it because of these reasons.
- 46:27Who's right.
- 46:29Obviously, that's a lot of that is up to your point of view, but it's voters generally aren't
- 46:36gonna be as privy to whether or not Joe Schmo was actually telling the truth on there.
- 46:42There's a lot of BS that they gotta sift through to see if, okay, we do need to up the
- 46:48compensation for these officials.
- 46:51Should we tie the salaries of these government officials to other state employees?
- 46:56So arguments in support of that would include that if you do so, the there's more equal
- 47:04ground with other state employees.
- 47:06So the state these other, or or for federal employees, if if you tied let's just use the
- 47:15state level.
- 47:16If you tied the state legislators' employee, salary or state governors or states, supreme
- 47:23court salaries to other state level government employees, it it puts them on more equal
- 47:30ground.
- 47:31So if you increase the pay of these state legislators or governors or other state
- 47:37executives or state supreme court justices, then that means the state government employees
- 47:43are also going to get a boost in pay.
- 47:47And it inherently takes the needs of state employees more into consideration since it also
- 47:54involves elected officials.
- 47:56What is good for the elected officials, a lot of times, will then be good for those state
- 48:03employees.
- 48:03Or if or if it was for federal government officials, if you were tying their salaries to
- 48:10federal employees, their vested interest would be similar as well.
- 48:16But some of the opposition arguments to tying salaries to those of of employees other
- 48:22employees in that level of government, they might say that, well, if you increase the pay
- 48:28for elected officials, that means more overall taxpayer dollars are being spent on that
- 48:34government because then you have to raise other employees' pay as well.
- 48:38So if it's stay employees or federal employees or local employees, that taxpayer base, you
- 48:45either have to raise taxes on them or you have to take tax revenue from other programs and put
- 48:50it towards raising those employees' pay as well.
- 48:54And then because of that, you might see possible cuts to government employee workforces
- 49:00if there's not enough tax revenue for all those salaries.
- 49:03So if there's, I don't know, a hundred, local government employees for whatever county you
- 49:12want to, you wanna use as an example, and the the mayor and the and the county commission,
- 49:24their their salary is tied to the salary of the local government employees.
- 49:33So you raise the county officials, salary.
- 49:37That means you you raise the local level employ, government employees salary.
- 49:43But then more if there's not enough tax revenue to go around, then that hundred person
- 49:49workforce might have to get trimmed down to 92 or something like that.
- 49:56So another case where some things might sound good in some respects and some things might not
- 50:04be as good.
- 50:06But one last one is, do you allow officials to set their salary themselves?
- 50:12So some people who would support this argument is these legislators, governors, state court
- 50:23justices, they're gonna be more in tune with their specific financial needs for compensation
- 50:29and staff help.
- 50:30And it inherently makes it a simpler process if you just let them decide what their salary is
- 50:38gonna be.
- 50:39But then on the flip side, you have the obvious issue of letting an elected official set their
- 50:43own pay.
- 50:43Of course, these elected officials are gonna wanna give themselves more pay, and it could
- 50:49also pave the way for a closed door process to set compensation so the public is not gonna
- 50:56necessarily be privy to what's going on there.
- 51:01So do we use a combination of these above ways?
- 51:04Maybe we have a commission that says, okay.
- 51:08We're gonna raise the compensation of these government officials that we elected by 5%.
- 51:17And then we also say that the voters have to approve that.
- 51:21So the commission has already done it, and then the voters have to approve of it.
- 51:27Or what if you did both of those things and also tied that salary to other government
- 51:34employees of that same level?
- 51:38Is there another way that has not been listed here that you could potentially, do it?
- 51:45All sorts of things to really consider here.
- 51:48So it's it's very easy to say that, you know, government officials, they get plenty of money.
- 51:55They they they don't need anymore.
- 51:56They get prestige and all that.
- 51:58There's you know?
- 52:00You know, there's there's a lot of politicians that undoubtedly are corrupt or abuse their
- 52:05station or whatever, but can you you can't just apply that to every single, government
- 52:11official.
- 52:11And then even so, how do you you can't just not compensate them.
- 52:17There has to be some level of compensation there, but what is that level of compensation?
- 52:23It's like many things in politics.
- 52:25Sometimes it can be made out to be much simpler than it actually is when it's a lot more
- 52:34complicated.
- 52:35So I just wanted to give you a sense of some of the, factors to think about when it comes to
- 52:41determining compensation and hopefully giving you more or having you feel more empowered in
- 52:50discussing these things?
- 52:52How exactly we need to compensate these elected officials and what limits we place on them so
- 52:58that they can find other ways to compensate themselves when they're in office?
- 53:02Because there aren't there's not really an easy answer in that regard.
- 53:05And each state, each locality, federal level office even, they all have their own realities
- 53:12to contend with and to think about.
- 53:14So just, hopefully, that gave you a clear idea of how this all works.
- 53:20But that is gonna be the end of today's podcast episode.
- 53:25As always, thank you so much for listening.
- 53:27Please like, comment, subscribe, share.
- 53:31Do what you can to get this podcast out there, whether it's YouTube, Spotify, Apple Podcasts.
- 53:38Share with all your networks and your friends.
- 53:40Really appreciate all of you listening, and please make this, you know, help increase the
- 53:47reach of this podcast.
- 53:49Links in the show notes with Facebook, LinkedIn, my break, why independents really
- 53:54rarely win elections and how they give it could become more competitive.
- 53:59My free educational email course about some of the ways we unintentionally can enhance
- 54:06polarization when we're meaning to lessen it, why we make those mistakes and how we can
- 54:12rectify those mistakes, and, several of, other, things I'm I'm forgetting off the top of my
- 54:19head right now.
- 54:20But, again, as always, thank you so much for listening.
- 54:23And until next time, take care.