Latest / Success Story with Scott Clary / Lessons - Dedicated CISO Teams & Sophisticated Security Threats | John Downey, CISO at GoFundMe
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome to Lessons episodes of Success Story, part of the HubSpot podcast network.
- 0:14These lessons episodes will be shorter conversations with past guests, valued members of the success
- 0:20story community, and myself.
- 0:23They'll be focused on teaching you actionable, insightful takeaways that you can use to
- 0:28upskill your personal and professional life.
- 0:31You start to see more and more prevalent security threats and more complicated security
- 0:35threats.
- 0:36And there's always been threats, right?
- 0:37But do you notice that more companies are creating dedicated teams?
- 0:42Is this more of a like a 2023, is this like a you have to have like a CISO in your organization
- 0:48as soon as you can get one because there's just so many bad actors and they're so sophisticated?
- 0:52Is this like the norm now?
- 0:55I think it's been kind of developing as the norm for a number of years.
- 0:58And so I kind of like in my career, I kind of see a few of miles.
- 1:02So there's 2013.
- 1:04There's a couple of major retail of breaches, so you saw like Target and a few others.
- 1:07And that was kind of the point at which it became clear that a security incident was not
- 1:12just going to affect the chief security officer.
- 1:15It was also going to affect other sea level executives at the company.
- 1:19So that that was an interesting kind of development.
- 1:21And then, you know, fast forward a couple of years, you had 2016.
- 1:23You had the election interference and the hack of the DNC.
- 1:27That kind of, you know, was another big aspect.
- 1:29Fast forward to 2020, everybody went to work from home.
- 1:33There's the, you know, the joke of like which C word major, you know, drove the technology
- 1:38innovation at your company.
- 1:39Was it the CTO, the CEO or the COVID-19?
- 1:42Because everybody overnight went work from home and that brings, you know, radically
- 1:46changed the security landscape.
- 1:48And then, you know, kind of, you know, fast forward to today, you know, these inflection points
- 1:51keep hitting.
- 1:52And then we have a big one for at least for public companies with the SEC rules that,
- 1:56you know, are currently a proposal, most likely going to pass that are going to require
- 2:01that you start to report on the cybersecurity expertise of your board that the board has
- 2:06to acknowledge that they have cybersecurity oversight responsibility, kind of setting
- 2:09out rules and requirements for reporting of cybersecurity incidents.
- 2:13And then just even a couple of days ago, the Biden administration putting out the national
- 2:17cyber security strategy from the, from Sissa, the critical infrastructure security administration
- 2:22as part of DHS, they set out kind of like, here's how, you know, technology is critical.
- 2:28Security issues and technology are, you know, kind of affect the entire American people.
- 2:32And here's what we're going to do to make sure that companies are taking responsibility
- 2:35for this because there's really an underlying current of, you know, kind of so what?
- 2:40Like we have a security issue, the stock price rebounds, you know, maybe someone loses their
- 2:44job, but it's like not that big of a deal, except for it has, you know, started to become
- 2:49a big deal and companies are starting to realize it, but I think politically the regulators
- 2:52are starting to say, look, we have to get involved in push companies harder and faster.
- 2:56When you look at what the SEC is doing, is it enough?
- 2:59Does the SEC know what good looks like or is there more that has to be done?
- 3:04So I think that's a, that's a great question.
- 3:05I think where the SEC is largely, in my opinion, catching up with where highly regulated
- 3:11organizations, right? So like financial services, health care, places like that, had already
- 3:16had a lot of these kind of requirements in place, where the SEC is kind of coming in as
- 3:21it's clarifying that this isn't just those industries, it's all industries.
- 3:26And also clearly, you know, clarifying wise at, you know, SEC's goal is always, we need
- 3:30to empower investors and protect investors.
- 3:33And so what requirements are there, you know, if you have an incident, but the incident
- 3:37maybe doesn't reach this, you know, this kind of mythical material level, what does that
- 3:41even mean?
- 3:42Like, it's the SEC's kind of laying out, like, well, no, here's what that means, here,
- 3:44you know, here's we have to put into your 8K, which is the form that you have to file
- 3:48when there's a, you know, material incidents, and here's like specifically how long it's
- 3:53been going on, kind of like the criteria of it, you know, are they going far enough?
- 3:57I think that's, that's a great thing we'll kind of see over the next few, you know,
- 4:01over the next few years, if, you know, companies really start to increase the reporting and
- 4:05the visibility, if the sunlight actually, if the sunlight actually kind of acts as a,
- 4:10you know, acts as an agent of change, but I don't know, you know, I think the, a lot
- 4:15of the, a lot of the regulated issues were already this, or already this way, especially
- 4:18if you are regulated out of states like New York, where they already had very stringent
- 4:23requirements for financial services companies, you know, you're seeing a lot of these things
- 4:27are things that you had to do already.
- 4:30I've always found that on average, nonprofits do not have the expertise that the for-profit
- 4:37business world has, and I'm interested as to you as like a case study is to what made
- 4:44you want to move into the nonprofit world, because somebody with the information security
- 4:49background from PayPal, I would say there's unlimited career opportunities, potential, money
- 4:54out there that you could go chase after, and I think that's actually a problem that a lot
- 4:57of nonprofits have.
- 4:59I think that they do not know either how to or cannot afford to pay because the business
- 5:03model is suffering to some degree, to pay the salaries of the people that can move
- 5:09the organization forward and not even just information security like sales, marketing,
- 5:13everything.
- 5:14But you made that conscious decision and I think that like that's remarkable.
- 5:17So I feel safe with, with GoFundMe, I feel safe with Classy, but I think a lot of nonprofits
- 5:21suffer from this, which is why you see trust in nonprofits start to be great, to be quite
- 5:25honest.
- 5:26But what was that thought process for you?
- 5:28How did you make that jump?
- 5:30Why were you able to do that?
- 5:31Why did GoFundMe look towards somebody who was highly capable to bring into the organization?
- 5:36Yeah, so I spent, as you mentioned, I spent a number of years at PayPal, and I knew
- 5:43my next steps.
- 5:44I wanted to stay in financial services, so I actually went to and spent a little bit of
- 5:47time and insurance just to try my hat on another financial services sector.
- 5:54My passion is for payments, and it's weird to say, but like I kind of got really good
- 5:57at it.
- 5:58I learned a lot about how the banking system works, how messy it can be, but how functional,
- 6:03and in a lot of ways it isn't, how important it is, you look at a lot of the last couple
- 6:07of weeks here with the Fed and the banks in the U.S., and so that I wanted to kind of stick
- 6:14to that.
- 6:15So GoFundMe and Classy offer a way to kind of like, for me, stay in payments, but also
- 6:19feel a lot better about what I was doing on a day to day.
- 6:22And now that, obviously, I hold no animus towards any of my prior employers, we were doing
- 6:27great work, but it helps day to day, I feel they impact a lot more at GoFundMe and Classy.
- 6:33In terms of, you know, you've raised a great point around nonprofits, and you know, the
- 6:38whole kind of government in PO sector, you know, NGO sector has a real deficit of talent
- 6:45in a lot of cases.
- 6:46There's recently been a case where, you know, the NSA and others have been like, hey,
- 6:51we want to do a talent swap with industry where they want to go to like Google and Facebook
- 6:56and others and say, hey, well, we'll swap people with you, like you can kind of send your
- 7:00best security engineers to us and we'll train them to help us in our fight against, you
- 7:04know, whatever it is.
- 7:05And then they'll work for us for a few years and then we'll swap them back and you know,
- 7:08kind of like, you know, as a way to like maybe get talent, that's something they've kind
- 7:12of floated recently.
- 7:13I think this is, you know, it just goes to show you that there's a real issue here and
- 7:17a lot of that kind of stems back to, just, you know, start, you know, nonprofits have
- 7:22a lot of the, my experience have a lot of the issues startups do.
- 7:26You know, they're small, they usually have very limited resources, scrappy team, everybody's,
- 7:30the thing I love about being a startup is everybody did everything, right?
- 7:32Like my job, which I want to join brain tree, said that I maybe asked to take the trash
- 7:36out.
- 7:37I thought that was awesome because I was, it was something I was really passionate about.
- 7:40I think the people who work at small nonprofits, small to medium sized nonprofits have the
- 7:43same passion, but you know, maybe a little bit different mission alignment, right?
- 7:47They're very philanthropic, like kind of looking to the, do, you know, do the most good.
- 7:53And the key thing I see is sort of the funding, right?
- 7:56So in a startup, you know, another dollar going towards AWS or some, or GitHub or some developer
- 8:02tool, you know, it kind of makes sense.
- 8:04It's, you know, an investment that you're kind of making towards the future.
- 8:08When you're in a nonprofit, a lot of these dollars, like you want to maximize your dollars
- 8:11going to programs.
- 8:13How can I deliver whatever help my nonprofit is trying to deliver?
- 8:16I want to maximize that, which means, you know, paying less on salaries, investing less
- 8:20on training, investing less on, you know, other things.
- 8:23Until you get bigger and you hit this kind of inflection point at which, you know, you
- 8:26kind of have to make that risk based decision, but smaller organizations, community organizations,
- 8:30they're really trying to maximize the program, though how much they can put into the program,
- 8:34which means they have to minimize a lot of other stuff.