Latest / Dark Murder: True Crime Cases / Episode 72
Transcript
- 0:06Dark murder true crime cases five four, three two one. Welcome back.
- 0:28I'm your host, Jordan Lee. I'm sure you are all ready to dive
- 0:32into some dark, creepy stories, so let's get started. He possessed charm,
- 0:42murderous charm. The dead Lady Patrick Mahon. Most people who ever met
- 0:50Patrick Mahon would tell you that not only was he handsome, but he possessed
- 0:55a certain charm. Both of these characteristics he used unabashed in his constant pursuit
- 1:00of women, despite having been married for thirteen years in the year nineteen twenty
- 1:07three, considering his wife had stuck with him during two terms in prison,
- 1:11once for a year after he wrote a bad check so he could have an
- 1:15affair with another woman shortly after his marriage. The second time came after he
- 1:21robbed a bank and he hid an employee with a hammer that got him five
- 1:26years behind bars. Despite his poor record as a husband, his wife gave
- 1:30birth to two children, a boy and a girl. However, his son
- 1:34would later die during one of Pat's prison terms. While he was locked up,
- 1:40missus Bahan moved to London to start work with an air raider company to
- 1:45make sure her children had food and a home. She was a hard worker
- 1:49and continued to be promoted until she found herself as a secretary. The time
- 1:53she spent there allowed her to get Pat a job once he was released from
- 1:57prison. As a member of this team, his charms and good looks helped
- 2:02him to see success there as well, and he eventually found himself as a
- 2:07sales manager. To missus Mahon, it seemed like things were going very well,
- 2:13except Pat was engaging in an affair with a woman named Emily Kay.
- 2:19She was a woman who worked for a firm of accounts that his company had
- 2:23dealings with. Emily knew her younger, handsome boyfriend was a married man,
- 2:28but he'd kept the affair going with vague promises that one day he would leave
- 2:32his wife for her. Eventually, Emily began to tire the words that she
- 2:38was being fed by Pat, and so she began telling others around her that
- 2:42the two of them were engaged and would soon be moving to South Africa,
- 2:46where Pat would be an executive. He had other plans for the future,
- 2:51however, he continued to come up with excuses why they couldn't leave, in
- 2:55hopes of stringing Emily out as long as he could so. He had taken
- 3:00control of her savings and started investing the money and allowing her to quit her
- 3:05job. What she didn't know was Pat had a gambling problem, and he
- 3:09would borrow money from this account to blow out the racetrack. Pat's two woman
- 3:15life came to a head when Emily told him that she was pregnant. She
- 3:20believed they were meant for one another and suggested that they try out living together
- 3:24for a few days as an experiment. Though hesitant, Emily had a trump
- 3:30card. At one point, she accidentally happened upon a newspaper article in a
- 3:35desk drawer that told of Pat's bank robbery and the five year prison term.
- 3:39She threatened to expose this past, which would get him fired if he didn't
- 3:44go along with the plan. In the end, he relented. The location
- 3:49that Pat chose was on an isolated two mile strip of Sussex speech. He
- 3:53rented the cottage under the fake name mister Waller and paid for a week in
- 3:59advance. Emily traveled to the area and checked into a hotel on April seventh,
- 4:04nineteen twenty four, expecting him to arrive soon after. Despite all he
- 4:11had riding on this on April tenth, he was still in London and by
- 4:15chance met a young woman named Ethel Duncan. When he offered to share his
- 4:19umbrella with her. The meeting ended up with the two of them making a
- 4:24dinner date for the following week. It was the following day that Pat and
- 4:29Emily walked into the cottage together for what Emily hoped was a love filled weekend.
- 4:34The first night, he didn't stay with her, but returned the following
- 4:38day to begin the experiment. Three days later, on April fifteenth, nineteen
- 4:44twenty four, Pat murdered Emily before returning to London the following day to keep
- 4:49his dinner plans with Ethel, but not before buying a new butcher knife.
- 4:56During their date, Pat offered lonely Duncan the option of spending the following weekend
- 5:01at his seaside cottage. She was enamored with her handsome, smooth talking companion,
- 5:08and she gratefully accepted his invitation. When she arrived, most women might
- 5:14have thought the place to be rather plain or out of date, but she
- 5:16loved it, and more importantly, she was already in love with Pat.
- 5:21During the two days, they spent their time making love and moving about the
- 5:26house as if they were really together. Ethel had access to the entire place
- 5:31except for a single room that had been locked. Little did the love struck
- 5:36Duncan. No. Behind this door was the body of Emily Kay. Meanwhile,
- 5:43back in London, Missus Mahan was starting to wonder about her husband's comings
- 5:47and goings. She knew his job necessitated some travel, but he'd been gone
- 5:53every weekend in several days during the week recently. When a friend told her
- 5:58she'd seen Pat at the racetrack recently, she knew her fears were justified,
- 6:01thinking he'd fallen back into his old gambling habits. Little did she know that
- 6:08was the least of his sins. She began searching through his things and discovered
- 6:13a cloak room ticket for one of the local train stations. One of her
- 6:16friends was a former railroad police officer, and she asked him to look into
- 6:21it for her. When he presented the ticket, he was given a bag,
- 6:26and upon looking inside, he immediately informed Scotland Yard. He told Missus
- 6:30Mahon to return the ticket where she'd found it, and despite her prodding,
- 6:35all they would tell her it had nothing to do with gambling. The following
- 6:41day, pat showed up with a ticket in hand to claim the bag as
- 6:45if nothing were wrong. Police took him into custody and he was escorted back
- 6:49to the station. Inside the bag, authorities had found the butcher knife,
- 6:55blood stained clothing, and a tennis case with the initials E b K on
- 7:00it. All of these items had been covered extensively with a disinfectant. He
- 7:06tried claiming that he'd been using the case to transport dog meat, but that
- 7:11lie was quickly abandoned when they informed him they'd already tested the blood and knew
- 7:15it was human. That is when his confession came out. Although his statement
- 7:21was tainted with lies in hopes of covering up that he was guilty of premeditated
- 7:27murder. He told police that the two of them had an argument that turned
- 7:31physical. He claimed they had fallen together and she'd hit her head on the
- 7:36head of a coal shuttle. The blow had apparently killed her instantly. He
- 7:42then said he took her body to the spare room so he and Ethel could
- 7:46have their week end together. Afterward, he then cut up her body into
- 7:50small pieces in order to dispose of it. When the detectives went to the
- 7:55cottage on sussex speech. They had no idea what they were walking into.
- 8:01As they went through the home, they discovered all the evidence they needed to
- 8:05confirm a human had been systematically sliced and butchered to pieces. In a trunk
- 8:11that had, like the tennis case, the initials E B K embossed on
- 8:16it. Bloody pieces of woman's clothing and large sections of a human body were
- 8:20found inside. There were dirty saucepans all over the cottage that contained human fat,
- 8:26and one large pan in particular had a broiled piece of human flesh.
- 8:31In a hat box, they found thirty seven pieces of human flesh and an
- 8:35obiscuitin human organs. There was also a bloody saw, likely used by Pat
- 8:41to dismember Emily, a broken axe that was suspected to be the murder weapon.
- 8:48Their final discovery was bits of partially burnt bone that were located in the
- 8:52fireplace, two things that were discovered missing after doctors attempted to reconstruct the body
- 9:00where Emily's head in part of a leg. The discovery led Pat mahon to
- 9:03be arrested. During his trial, he attempted to persuade the jury that he'd
- 9:09purchased the knife in the aftermath of Emily's death, but that was disproven when
- 9:16the prosecution presented receipts showing that Emily had been alive when he purchased the knife,
- 9:22and thus had intended on dismembering her. They also showed jurors that the
- 9:28coal shuttle was of such poor quality it would be nearly impossible for her to
- 9:33have died by falling on it. Pat accounted for the missing head by telling
- 9:39a story that one day he had built a huge fire in the fireplace and
- 9:43placed it on the flames. At the time, a storm was blowing through
- 9:48the area, and a flash of lightning, followed closely by the thundercap coincided
- 9:52with Emily's eyelids opening on their own as the flames of the fire licked at
- 9:58the dead skin. A doctor would later verify that the heat of the fire
- 10:03could in fact cause this to happen. In the end, the jury was
- 10:07convinced of Patrick Mahan's guilt. The judge, given the ghastly crime, sentenced
- 10:15him to be hung. He attempted to appeal the verdict, but his pleas
- 10:18amounted to nothing. Pat met his end on September ninth, nineteen twenty four,
- 10:24at the end of a rope