Latest / Deep Values: Value Investing Deep Dives / Four hidden shocks shaking the US economy
Transcript
- 0:00Right now, the US economy looks, you know, incredibly robust on
- 0:03paper, Like if you just glance at the headline metrics, you
- 0:06think we're standing on solid bedrock.
- 0:07Oh absolutely, the surface numbers look great.
- 0:09Yeah, but under the surface there are four massive shocks
- 0:14vibrating the foundation all at once, and anyone of them could
- 0:18trigger a systemic crisis. Right, which is why today we're
- 0:21taking a deep dive into a stack of incredibly revealing internal
- 0:25policy notes. Exactly.
- 0:27We've got notes from the Fed, private credit sector analysis,
- 0:30and even real time transaction data from Bank of America.
- 0:33We are diving into the systemic risks currently hiding in plain
- 0:37sight. Yeah, the mission here is really
- 0:39to cut straight through the surface level, kind of Econ 101
- 0:42panic. We want to decode what actually
- 0:44happens to you when these overlapping macroeconomic shocks
- 0:48collide. OK, let's unpack this, because
- 0:50the sources point out something fascinating right at the outset.
- 0:53The best way to visualize what we're looking at is it's like a
- 0:56massive, incredibly unstable game of Jenga.
- 0:59I love that analogy from the notes.
- 1:01It's so accurate. Right, You've got these 4
- 1:04structural blocks being pushed and pulled at the exact same
- 1:08time. You've got lingering trade
- 1:10tariffs, a massive private credit boom operating entirely
- 1:13in the shadows, the sudden reality of AI driven job
- 1:18displacement, and of course, surging oil prices.
- 1:21And every time you pull one block, like tariffs or AI, the
- 1:24whole structure just wobbles. Yeah, it vibrates, but the core
- 1:27tension here is whether the system can absorb these
- 1:30simultaneous pressures, or if pulling just one more block
- 1:35brings the whole architecture down.
- 1:37Well, and that brings up a crucial concept from the
- 1:39sources. Despite these massive shocks,
- 1:41the US economy possesses this dynamic that the analysts call
- 1:46unforecastable resilience. Unforecastable resilience it
- 1:49could constantly defies traditional modeling doesn't.
- 1:51It exactly Every time there's a major geopolitical disruption,
- 1:54the models predict a severe contraction, and yet the broader
- 1:57economy somehow, just, well, absorbs the blow.
- 2:00There's an analogy in the notes about the US oil industry that I
- 2:02think is perfect for understanding this scale.
- 2:04Oh, the Tampa analogy. Yeah, the Tampa one.
- 2:06So the domestic oil sector is essentially the size of the
- 2:09entire Saudi Arabian economy, right?
- 2:12Right. But because it operates within
- 2:14the massive, diversified U.S. market, it's like picking up the
- 2:17entire city of Tampa and dropping it into the middle of
- 2:20New York City. That's such a wild visual.
- 2:22It's massive, but it just gets swallowed by the sheer scale of
- 2:25the broader economy. Right.
- 2:27And since we have this massive internal oil economy, we need to
- 2:30understand exactly how global oil disruption impacts the
- 2:34system today. Because that scale completely
- 2:37changes the macroeconomic math. Historically, a massive spike in
- 2:41crude oil almost guaranteed a domestic recession.
- 2:44But today, because that camp is so robust, a global oil shock
- 2:48acts more like a massive internal wealth transfer than a
- 2:51pure economic drain, right? Exactly.
- 2:54Let's look at the math from the latest energy sector data.
- 2:57If oil goes up $35 a barrel and you multiply that across the
- 3:00roughly 20 million barrels consumed daily?
- 3:03That equates to what, hundreds of billions of dollars?
- 3:06Yes, hundreds of billions. And it's effectively migrating
- 3:10from the discretionary spending of everyday consumers directly
- 3:13onto the balance sheets of domestic oil.
- 3:16To put that in perspective, contrast that with the 1973 oil
- 3:19crisis. For a true 1973 impact today,
- 3:23oil would need to hit something like $550 a.
- 3:26Barrel, right, Which is just unthinkable.
- 3:28But I want to push back on this a little bit.
- 3:30If the money stays in the US, like does it really matter who
- 3:33holds it? Oh, it absolutely matters.
- 3:35It matters entirely what the oil companies do with that sudden
- 3:38windfall. Like will they drill pay
- 3:41dividends? Or make bizarre pivots.
- 3:44I mean, look at the historical parallels.
- 3:46During the windfalls of the 1970s, Exxon didn't just pour
- 3:49that cash back into aggressive drilling, they notoriously
- 3:52pivoted into manufacturing word processors and fact machines.
- 3:57Wait, really? Exxon made fax machines.
- 3:59It was a staggering misallocation of capital.
- 4:02So assuming this current windfall will just perfectly
- 4:04recycle into the broader economy ignores how inefficiently these
- 4:08corporations behave when they're suddenly flush with cash.
- 4:10Wow. OK, so that historical the
- 4:13context is crucial. Corporate behavior during a
- 4:16windfall is rarely optimal, but we also have to contextualize
- 4:20the threshold of the current shock.
- 4:22Right. And the analysts stress a very
- 4:24specific distinction here, the difference between a flow
- 4:27disruption and a stock crisis. And we are currently managing a
- 4:31flow problem, right? Tankers might be taking longer
- 4:34routes around conflict zones. Insurance premiums are spiking.
- 4:37Supply chains are delayed. But the physical commodity is
- 4:40still moving. That's the key.
- 4:42The market mechanism still functions even if it requires a
- 4:46premium. Right now, a stock problem, on
- 4:47the other hand, is when the underlying inventory actually
- 4:51vanishes, like the straights are physically closed or reserves
- 4:54are fundamentally depleted. Which is a whole different ball
- 4:57game. Yeah, the notes use a very clean
- 4:59Econ one O 2 illustration for this.
- 5:01It's the desert analogy. If you have 10 people wandering
- 5:04in a desert and only 9 bottles of water, the price of that
- 5:07ninth bottle doesn't just increase by 10%.
- 5:09No, it goes to Infinity. Exactly.
- 5:11It triggers an asymptote reaction because the buyer will
- 5:14pay literally anything to survive.
- 5:15And when a market perceives that we are crossing that threshold
- 5:20from an expensive delayed flow into a dwindling unavailable
- 5:25stock, that is when you see tremendous unmanageable spikes.
- 5:28That's the environment where crude jumps to 150 or $200 a
- 5:32barrel in a matter of days. It ceases to be an issue of
- 5:35pricing and becomes a panic of absolute scarcity.
- 5:39But if that panic sets in, you know, and oil hits $150.00, the
- 5:43market instantly expects the Federal Reserve to step in and
- 5:46fix the chaos. Which is crazy because they are
- 5:48completely unequipped for this specific type of crisis.
- 5:52Isn't raising interest rates to fight an oil shortage like
- 5:55treating a broken arm with cough syrup?
- 5:57That is the perfect way to put it.
- 5:58There is literally no monetary policy mechanism, no matter how
- 6:01high they hike rates, that can clear a shipping lane or pull a
- 6:04single extra barrel of oil out of the ground.
- 6:07And the central bank is acutely aware of that limitation.
- 6:10Chair Powell and the core of the Fed board, they understand they
- 6:13cannot control supply side shocks.
- 6:15Right Powell believes policy is currently in a good place,
- 6:18right? Slightly tight to fight
- 6:20inflation. Yeah, but what he is terrified
- 6:22of is the psychology of the consumer.
- 6:24He's obsessed with these three to five year inflation
- 6:27expectations becoming unanchored.
- 6:30Let's drill into the mechanics of that psychology.
- 6:32Because it's the invisible engine of inflation.
- 6:35If you, as a listener, believe that energy prices and grocery
- 6:38bills are going to be significantly higher three years
- 6:41from now, you fundamentally alter your behavior today.
- 6:45Exactly. You go to your employer and
- 6:47demand a massive raise to preemptively cover those future
- 6:50costs. And then the employer,
- 6:52anticipating a higher payroll, instantly raises the prices of
- 6:55their goods. the Fed isn't holding rates high to make gas
- 6:59cheaper. They are aggressively trying to
- 7:01break that self fulfilling psychological loop.
- 7:03They have to break it before it becomes permanently anchored in
- 7:06the labor market. But that imperative has created
- 7:09a profound internal fracture within the Federal Reserve
- 7:12itself. Right.
- 7:12The policy notes detail an intense, ongoing debate about
- 7:16how to respond. You've got a deep divide.
- 7:19Yeah, on the dovish end of the spectrum, you have figures like
- 7:22Stephen Myron. He basically argues that any
- 7:25exogenous shock to the economy should be met with immediate
- 7:28liquidity. So his camp always pushes for
- 7:31pre emptive 50 basis point cuts. Exactly, to cushion the broader
- 7:35market from the negative impacts of high energy costs because
- 7:39they fear a rapid contraction in employment.
- 7:41But dropping rates by 50 basis points when the market is
- 7:44already terrified of an inflation spiral, I mean, that
- 7:47could easily be interpreted as panic.
- 7:49Which is exactly why the historic Hawks are fiercely
- 7:52opposing that strategy, especially the block out of the
- 7:55Kansas City Fed like Jeff Schmidt.
- 7:57They point to a labor market that is fundamentally balanced
- 8:00right, with unemployment hovering around historically
- 8:03manageable levels. Right.
- 8:04And they argue that cutting rates now would signal total
- 8:07surrender. They genuinely believe that
- 8:10rates must rise further, strictly as a signaling
- 8:12mechanism. Just to prove to the bond market
- 8:14that they're still serious about their 2% target.
- 8:17Yes, and into this deeply divided arena steps a highly
- 8:21experimental framework. Oh the Kevin Warsh experiment.
- 8:24This is fascinating. The sources describe his
- 8:27strategy as a stock and flow approach to the Feds own balance
- 8:31sheet. Historically, the Fed has
- 8:32utilized its balance sheet and its benchmark interest rate in
- 8:36tandem, but Warsh is floating the idea of totally decoupling
- 8:41them. He looks at the Feds $6.7
- 8:44trillion balance sheet as a burdensome stock that needs to
- 8:48be aggressively burned off. Yeah, all those assets bought
- 8:51during the quantitative easing eras of the financial crisis and
- 8:54the pandemic. And mechanics of that are wild,
- 8:57because shrinking the balance sheet inherently tightens the
- 9:00economy. When the Fed lets those bonds
- 9:02roll off without reinvesting, they're literally draining
- 9:05liquidity out of the financial system.
- 9:07Which puts immense upward pressure on long term yields.
- 9:10But to counteract the severe economic drag of that
- 9:13quantitative tightening, Warsh proposes simultaneously lowering
- 9:16the flow, meaning aggressively cutting the short term benchmark
- 9:20interest rates. It's an attempt to actively
- 9:22manipulate the yield curve from both ends.
- 9:25You shrink the balance sheet to drain the excess liquidity,
- 9:27suppressing the long end while cutting rates to provide
- 9:30breathing room on the short end. But the internal debate centers
- 9:34on whether holding that 6.7 trillion actually does any
- 9:38functional work in the market, or if the market only reacts to
- 9:41the act of buying and selling of those assets.
- 9:44Right. And while the Fed is publicly
- 9:46wrestling with these visible metrics, balance sheets,
- 9:49benchmark rates, crude oil, the true systemic risk might be
- 9:53migrating elsewhere. Here's where it gets really
- 9:55interesting. The risk isn't in the heavily
- 9:58regulated banking sector anymore.
- 10:00No, not since 2008. Post 2008 Dodd Frank regulations
- 10:04effectively put major banks into a soft receivership.
- 10:07They demanded massive capital buffers and slashed their
- 10:09leverage ratios. Going from like 40 to 1 down to
- 10:12a fraction of that. Right.
- 10:13But the demand for capital didn't just evaporate, it simply
- 10:17shifted into the shadows, into the intensely opaque world of
- 10:21private credit. And this is where the
- 10:23institutional analysis becomes absolutely critical.
- 10:26The sources present a theorem for financial contagion that is
- 10:29incredibly elegant, really Nobel worthy.
- 10:32The systemic risk equals value at risk multiplied by opacity.
- 10:37Exactly. The danger to the financial
- 10:39system isn't strictly determined by the absolute dollar amount
- 10:43that might be lost. The danger is determined by
- 10:45whether the market can accurately identify who is
- 10:48holding those losses. That is the core mechanism of a
- 10:51panic. If there's a $50 billion loss
- 10:54and everyone knows exactly who holds it, nobody panics.
- 10:57The risk is priced in, right? But if a highly leveraged shadow
- 11:02entity takes a comparatively minor $1 billion hit and the
- 11:06exposure is entirely opaque. Nobody knows which pension fund,
- 11:09which endowment, or which counterparty is secretly holding
- 11:12the bad. So everyone indiscriminately
- 11:14sells all their liquid assets just to ensure they aren't the
- 11:17one caught holding the contagion.
- 11:18Opacity is the ultimate accelerant for a liquidity
- 11:20crisis, and the private credit market is fundamentally defined
- 11:24by that opacity. No.
- 11:26Proponents of the space constantly defend their risk
- 11:29profile. They point out that private
- 11:30credit funds are generally only levered at a 2 to one ratio.
- 11:34They argue there's a thick cushion of equity protecting the
- 11:37debt. But the sector analysis reveal A
- 11:39structural vulnerability. The real danger is the
- 11:43incestuous nature of the business.
- 11:45Because roughly 80% of direct lending from private credit
- 11:48funds go straight to private equity firms engaged aged in
- 11:52leveraged buyouts. Which brings up the terrifying
- 11:54unknown. This is the hidden leverage
- 11:57behind the equity. The private credit fund might
- 12:00only be levered 2 to one, but what is the actual nature of the
- 12:04equity that the private equity firm is putting down?
- 12:06Right. Are they using pure unencumbered
- 12:09capital or are they utilizing net asset value loans borrowing
- 12:13against their other portfolio companies to fund the equity
- 12:16stake in this new acquisition? If they are stacking
- 12:19subscription lines of credit on top of NAV loans on top of
- 12:23direct debt, the actual systemic leverage is vastly higher than
- 12:26what is printed on the initial term sheet.
- 12:29We just can't see it because the reporting requirements simply
- 12:31don't exist in the private markets.
- 12:33Which brings us to the most alarming intersection of data in
- 12:36these sources. Where exactly is all this
- 12:39opaque, potentially hyper leveraged capital concentrated?
- 12:43The answer links back to the AI threat we mentioned at the very
- 12:46beginning of this deep dive. Over 25 to 30% of the entire
- 12:52private credit ecosystem is dangerously exposed to a single
- 12:57vertical the enterprise software industry.
- 13:00And private equity didn't flood into software because they were
- 13:03passionate about the underlying code.
- 13:05No, they fell in love of it because of the shift to sauce
- 13:07software as a service. It turned these companies into
- 13:11highly modelable pseudo banks. It was all about the Excel
- 13:13spreadsheet. Before the subscription model,
- 13:15software revenue was lumpy and unpredictable.
- 13:17You couldn't underwrite a massive loan against it.
- 13:20But once you shifted to recurring annual revenue, the
- 13:23cash flow became a mathematical certainty.
- 13:25You knew your churn rate, your customer acquisition cost, your
- 13:28lifetime value. It was the absolute Nirvana for
- 13:31cash flow, allowing private equity to load these companies
- 13:34up with unprecedented amounts of debt.
- 13:35But wait, I have to ask, isn't AI supposed to make coding
- 13:39faster and software companies more efficient?
- 13:42Why is it suddenly a threat to their survival?
- 13:44That is the 60 day old realization that is currently
- 13:47sweeping the market. That entire underwriting model
- 13:51relied on the software company maintaining A formidable
- 13:54economic Moat. Right.
- 13:55Historically, the barrier to entry was the immense cost of
- 13:58development. You needed an army of
- 14:00specialized engineers to build and maintain the product.
- 14:03But AI is systematically dismantling that mode.
- 14:06It is not simply a productivity tool.
- 14:08It fundamentally erases the line between designer, developer and
- 14:12marketer. When 0 marginal cost software
- 14:14reproduction meet 0 marginal cost software creation, the
- 14:18entire pricing dynamic collapses.
- 14:20Exactly. If anyone can prompt an AI to
- 14:23build a competing software suite in a fraction of the time and
- 14:26cost, the incumbent legacy software companies completely
- 14:30lose their pricing power. They can no longer force their
- 14:32clients to accept 15% annual subscription hikes.
- 14:35The Moat evaporates and with it the predictable cash flows that
- 14:38the private credit loans were underwritten against.
- 14:41And the timing of this disruption is what makes it a
- 14:44systemic threat. The vast majority of these
- 14:47software buyouts occurred between 2018 and 2022, right?
- 14:51An era defined by zero interest rate policy.
- 14:54So these companies are carrying massive debt loads that were
- 14:57perfectly serviceable at 0%. But now growth will slow and
- 15:02critically, they face a massive refinancing wall next year.
- 15:06They have to roll over that debt into a macroeconomic environment
- 15:09where rates are drastically higher.
- 15:11At the exact moment AI is actively compressing their
- 15:14margins, it is a perfect storm for covenant breaches.
- 15:17If those cash flows deteriorate just slightly, the highly
- 15:20leveraged software companies default.
- 15:22The opaque private credit funds that issued the loans have to
- 15:26mark those assets market taking massive write downs.
- 15:28And because of the structural opacity we discussed earlier,
- 15:31the broad financial system will suddenly realize it doesn't know
- 15:34who is actually bearing the brunt of those losses.
- 15:37And it isn't just software companies facing a squeeze.
- 15:40While the institutional markets try to calculate the fallout of
- 15:43this tech disruption, the real time private data shows us that
- 15:47the everyday consumer is already starting to crack under the
- 15:50pressure. Right.
- 15:51To understand the consumer, we have to bypass the lagging
- 15:54government data. The Census Bureau surveys take
- 15:57months to revise and compile. By the time they signal a
- 16:00recession, the damage is done. That's why the anonymized real
- 16:05time private sector data from institutions like Bank of
- 16:08America is so invaluable. They can literally track real
- 16:11paychecks, direct deposit trends, and daily spending
- 16:14velocity across specific income brackets.
- 16:17And the picture that real time data paints completely shatters
- 16:20the narrative of a uniform, resilient consumer.
- 16:23It reveals the severe reality of AK shaped economy.
- 16:26In the immediate aftermath of the pandemic, lower and middle
- 16:29income households experienced a temporary surge in savings and
- 16:32real wage growth. Right.
- 16:33They were the upward leg of the K, yes.
- 16:35But the current transaction data illustrates acute, immediate
- 16:39distress returning to those exact demographics.
- 16:42The cumulative weight of persistent inflation over the
- 16:44last three years has entirely eroded those buffers.
- 16:49Then you layer on the exact oil shock we discussed at the
- 16:51beginning. Talk about insult to injury.
- 16:53Yeah, for a highly leveraged household with 0 discretionary
- 16:57buffer, an extra $35 per barrel of crude isn't a theoretical
- 17:01macroeconomic flow. Problem No.
- 17:03It's an immediate, regressive tax that filters directly into
- 17:07their commuting costs and their grocery bills.
- 17:09And when the bottom leg of that K shaped economy cracks, the
- 17:12foundation of total consumer spending, which drives 70% of
- 17:16the USGDP, begins to vibrate violently.
- 17:18It forces a massive recalibration of risk across the
- 17:21board. We are watching the real time
- 17:23collision of relentless technological disruption, deeply
- 17:26divided monetary policy, geopolitical resource
- 17:29constraints and an over leveraged shadow banking sector.
- 17:33So what does this all mean for you, the listener?
- 17:36Well before we get to our final thought, a quick note to access
- 17:39more advanced researches, applications and our latest
- 17:43published personal intelligent multi agent Deep Value
- 17:45Intelligence. Welcome to explore and join Deep
- 17:48Values dot AI community. Track total market temperature.
- 17:52Welcome to search and download iOS app Buffett indicator from
- 17:55Apple App Store. Disclaimer All analysis is based
- 17:58on publicly available sources and may be subject to revisions
- 18:02or differing interpretations. All contents from this channel
- 18:05is for educational and research purposes only and does not
- 18:07constitute investment advice. Conduct your own due diligence
- 18:11before making investment decisions.
- 18:13If you'd like to access wider topics, including life and
- 18:15investing philosophy, please subscribe to our sister channel,
- 18:18Deep Values. Don't forget to like this video.
- 18:20Much appreciated. So as we monitor these
- 18:22converging forces, there's a fundamental rotation of capital
- 18:25that we have to consider. If the predictable cash flows of
- 18:28the software sector, the very engine that powered the private
- 18:31credit broom, are truly being destroyed by AI, that capital
- 18:34has to find a new home. Right.
- 18:36Trillions of dollars in shadow liquidity won't just sit idle.
- 18:39Exactly. Which leaves you with a
- 18:41fascinating unmapped implication to think if the software mode is
- 18:45permanently breached, does that massive, highly leveraged
- 18:49private credit apparatus suddenly pivot away from digital
- 18:53assets entirely? Do we see all of that opaque
- 18:55capital flood into hard physical constraints instead?
- 19:00Yeah, like aggressively monopolizing residential real
- 19:02estate, industrial power grids, or even agricultural water
- 19:06rights. It's a huge question.
- 19:07If AI successfully destroys the predictable subscription models
- 19:11that private equity has relied on for years years, it might
- 19:14force shadow banking to seek safety in the physical world.
- 19:16Meaning the next asset bubble won't be in the cloud, it will
- 19:19be in our own backyards. Keep questioning the consensus,
- 19:22keep an eye on the actual data flows, and we'll see you next
- 19:25time.