Latest / Ensombl Advice Australia / Insurance Podcast #12 - Christine Cupitt
Transcript
- 0:00The Ensemble podcast is intended for professional financial advisors.
- 0:03This content is created in partnership with our sponsor, Zurich Australia Limited, ABN 9200 010 195 AFSL 232 510 and is limited to publicly available information.
- 0:14Before acting on any general advice, you should consider whether appropriate and obtain financial advice from a qualified financial advisor.
- 0:20Ensemble does not hold an AFS license and does not provide any financial advice or services or endorse any general advice.
- 0:30Thank you.
- 0:50Each episode features real conversations with the people who live and breathe this work every day, uncovering the lessons, processes, and the stories that help advisors lift confidence, capability, and client outcomes.
- 1:01Whether you write two policies a year or 200, this podcast is here to help you deliver better protection, build stronger businesses, and ultimately serve more Australians.
- 1:10Let's jump in.
- 1:13Zurich is proud to be supporting this episode.
- 1:16Experience Zurich and OnePath advisor portals with new and improved digital capabilities and an enhanced range of self-service functionality, helping make your business more efficient, saving you time and removing complexity.
- 1:30It's everything you need in one place.
- 1:32Partner with us today.
- 1:36Hi everybody and welcome with me today.
- 1:39Very, very privileged to have the CEO of Cali, Miss Christine Cupid.
- 1:43Hello and welcome.
- 1:44Hi, Ben.
- 1:45Hey.
- 1:45So thank you so much for coming in.
- 1:47I know you're extremely busy, especially with the code review that's just occurred.
- 1:51So I want to jump straight into it.
- 1:54Callie's role is with the life insurers rather than with the advisors or other components of the market.
- 2:00So I'd like to just get to know you and let everybody get to know you.
- 2:03Can I just ask for a little bit of your history there?
- 2:06Because I know that you're involved in the banking industry.
- 2:08There was a couple of debt or counselling roles that you've got as well.
- 2:11Yeah.
- 2:11Can we just wind back a couple of years?
- 2:13Oh, thank you, Ben.
- 2:15I think the best way to describe me is somebody who is really interested in making sure that there are good customer-consumer outcomes in the finance sector.
- 2:25And that is so that people can enjoy financial resilience so that they have peace of mind and so that they can get on with living their lives with a higher degree of financial security.
- 2:35So that's really defined the work that I've done initially in superannuation, then advice licensees.
- 2:42Went into public policy at the Australian Banking Association and then CEO of Cali.
- 2:47And all of those have been terrific opportunities and real privileges to contribute to making sure that we have a more financially resilient system and more financially resilient Australians.
- 2:59Yeah.
- 2:59Can I ask, so when I did the research quickly looking through your LinkedIn history, there's also, it's WayForward Debt Solutions, I think, and then you're also a director of Mortgage Stress Victoria?
- 3:09Yes.
- 3:09Yeah, what are those two, sorry?
- 3:11Yeah, so those I'm actually very proud to be involved in.
- 3:14So WayForward Debt Solutions was started when I was at the Australian Banking Association.
- 3:20And I led the formation of that together with a number of community representatives and Financial Counselling Australia.
- 3:27And the premise of that organisation is that there are many thousands of Australians who are struggling with multiple unsecured debts.
- 3:35So generally multiple credit cards, but now we've got buy now, pay later, wage advance, other unsecured debts coming into the market.
- 3:42And the observation was that when people needed financial difficulty support, they had to go around and negotiate that with each of their lenders.
- 3:51Yeah.
- 3:52and then manage the payments themselves.
- 3:54So what WayForward does is we work with the client to understand all their unsecured debts.
- 3:59We then work with them on a budget in terms of what they can afford for debt repayment.
- 4:04Then we go around and negotiate the financial difficulty relief with the creditors, and then we take one payment and distribute it on their behalf.
- 4:13And those settings mean that that person has the best chance of working off or working through paying down that debt.
- 4:20It often involves a fair degree of debt waiver as well and a fixed timeframe.
- 4:25So people can see the light at the end of the tunnel.
- 4:29But what we see is quite extraordinary in terms of people coming in with $70,000, $80,000, $90,000 of credit card debt.
- 4:37And the link to the work that I do every day is that a lot of that is driven by illness, injury, not being in the workforce.
- 4:46Right.
- 4:48It can be sick children.
- 4:49It's also when people have had accidents in or outside of work and they're not able to work and they lean on the credit cards to manage day-to-day living expenses and health bills.
- 4:59That's awesome.
- 4:59So I wasn't going to mention this, but I got permission from Earthside, a client from maybe two years ago from a domestic violence situation where –
- 5:07Again, lots and lots of debts that were racked up in the situation that was sort of out of her control.
- 5:12And the first thing that I'd sort of recommended to her was to contact this particular financial counselling service.
- 5:17I got a message from her maybe three weeks ago, just with tears in her voice, basically saying, hey, because of the introduction, this is what I've been able to do.
- 5:23And it was everything from Harvey Norman purchases all sorts of stuff.
- 5:26So that's absolutely brilliant.
- 5:28Well done.
- 5:28Thank you.
- 5:28It's a great outcome.
- 5:29Yeah.
- 5:31All right.
- 5:31So then moving on to Cali itself, right?
- 5:33So Cali is relatively new.
- 5:35When did they start?
- 5:36Yeah.
- 5:37Three and a half years.
- 5:37Yep.
- 5:38Actually, the company was formed at the end of 2022, but we really started in earnest in February 2023.
- 5:44Right.
- 5:46And in that time, we managed the transition of the life code.
- 5:50We've worked on a number of really important regulatory reforms like advice reform and genetic testing.
- 5:54Yep.
- 5:55But it seems like five minutes in five years.
- 6:00Yeah.
- 6:01Okay.
- 6:01Time flies when you're having fun, right?
- 6:02Yeah.
- 6:02Not stressed at all.
- 6:03It's amazing.
- 6:04Yeah.
- 6:05can I ask why the separation out of the FSC so the FSC was the first one to write the code and up until that long ago it was all one body what happened why
- 6:15The biggest shift was in the market profile.
- 6:19So as you were aware, after the Royal Commission, the major banks spun out the life insurance businesses.
- 6:25They wanted to be simpler, better banks, which meant that we had a lot of global capital come into the market to acquire those businesses.
- 6:34And over time, with the acquisitions and the integrations, what we ended up with was a group of specialist life insurers
- 6:43So not part of big integrated banking and wealth groups anymore, but businesses where people come to work every day thinking about life insurance and come to work thinking every day about health and disability rather than kind of wealth protection or those traditional notions.
- 6:59So in light of all of that, in light of the focus on health and disability, in light of the change in the ownership and the funding, it made sense for life insurers to have their own voice, hence the creation of Cali.
- 7:11Okay.
- 7:12And is Cali made up of all the insurers?
- 7:14We represent all the life insurers and reinsurers in Australia.
- 7:18Yeah.
- 7:18Okay.
- 7:18And so in the market, there's what, 18, I think off the top of my head, but 80% of the market is sort of Tal Zerich, AIA and Ascender.
- 7:28How does that sit within the environment where you're representing the industry?
- 7:31If you've got these four major stakeholders?
- 7:33Yeah.
- 7:33Yeah.
- 7:34Well, a huge priority at Cali from the chair, the board, from me, is an equal share of voice for our members.
- 7:40Right.
- 7:41So we do a lot of work.
- 7:43My team does a lot of work making sure that all members are engaged through our working group processes, processes,
- 7:49We particularly look to like the reinsurers, for example, for their expertise and input.
- 7:55And the perspectives of the insurers that are outside, that four, is really important in terms of providing a perspective on how the market operates as a whole.
- 8:06And that's, as I said, something that's supported by the board.
- 8:10We really want everyone to have that equal share of voice.
- 8:12Yeah.
- 8:12So from a financial advice point of view, we're seeing the creation of the large corporatized businesses in not just in life insurance, but across all of the financial advice, everything from aged care to fund management, all that sort of jazz.
- 8:25As an advisor, I've sort of mixed feelings about that because I like the idea of the cottage cheese industry where…
- 8:31A financial advisor owns the relationship with 200 clients within 20 kilometers of their radius sort of thing.
- 8:38But is your view that the life insurance is better served by scalability?
- 8:43So having those four large members and then a couple of smaller members, is that, do you think the best way forward?
- 8:49Or if there was further consolidation, would you think that was a bad thing or a good thing?
- 8:53I think we just have to give customers choice about where they buy their life insurance.
- 8:58So we need to give them choice in terms of the advice business that they work with, whether it's more a kind of a smaller professional firm or if it's a larger corporate business, they need to have choice.
- 9:12Similarly, with the insurer that they work with, there are a range of
- 9:17different options, different priorities in terms of things like early intervention, different brands.
- 9:23I think all of those things are important to enable choice.
- 9:27And that's really, I think, what we're all here to do is to best meet the needs of our customers and clients.
- 9:31Okay.
- 9:31And I guess shout out to Zerup for actually keeping Clearview open and committing to that.
- 9:35That's good.
- 9:37All right.
- 9:37So moving to the life code review, this was obviously massive and it's only a couple of weeks old now.
- 9:45Can I just ask you to summarise Callie's position?
- 9:47I know that's a really open-ended question, but can you just talk to it and then can we pick apart your response and try and understand certain parts?
- 9:53Yeah, absolutely.
- 9:54So I'll go a little bit to the history of the code and a bit about the way it operates.
- 10:00So this is why I gave you room to answer.
- 10:01It's great.
- 10:01Yeah, okay.
- 10:03So there had been a life insurance code that was in operation before the Royal Commission.
- 10:10But what the industry did subsequent to the Royal Commission was rewrite it, like root and branch review.
- 10:15Makes sense, right?
- 10:17Yes.
- 10:18Yeah.
- 10:18Respond to the conduct in the case studies that we saw in the Royal Commission, respond to the commissioner's recommendations and respond to the change in community expectations.
- 10:29So there was a root and branch review of the code.
- 10:31It was rewritten.
- 10:33And that came into effect in July 2023.
- 10:36Yep.
- 10:37Within two years, we thought it was important to commission an independent review of the code, given that there had been so much change, both in the commitments in the code, but also in the industry and community expectations.
- 10:50We think that that was important to have a regular review.
- 10:52Before we keep going with the review, can I just ask, sorry, quickly, so we have the law and then we have the code which sits not above but in addition to?
- 11:00Yes.
- 11:00Is that the way it currently operates?
- 11:02Yeah.
- 11:03That's right.
- 11:03So the code will operate above and beyond the law.
- 11:07That's a good way to put it.
- 11:08Yeah.
- 11:08Okay.
- 11:10And particularly in life insurance, it has the opportunity to respond to very specific customer and client needs.
- 11:17So if you think about things like claims handling, where you might need things like an independent medical report,
- 11:23There are commitments in the code around how we will do that, how we will manage the experience of the customer, offering the choice of gender of the doctor, for instance.
- 11:33Those are things that the government's never going to step in on that are really important for us to have in the industry code.
- 11:39And how enforceable are those?
- 11:41So the law, obviously, governed by ASIC.
- 11:43What happens if an insurer steps out of line on the code?
- 11:46So we have a very robust independent life code compliance committee.
- 11:51So it is separately funded, separately operated.
- 11:54The secretariat for that committee is provided by AFCA.
- 11:59And what it does is a couple of things.
- 12:01It's a bit of independence there.
- 12:02Yep.
- 12:03Well, and that's exactly what we need, right?
- 12:05Like we stand by the code and we stand by consumer trust and confidence in it.
- 12:11And enforceability is a really important part of that.
- 12:14Yeah.
- 12:15So our code committee does three things.
- 12:18It can receive allegations of breaches of the code.
- 12:20And that can be from customers, consumer advocates, advisors, and it will make determinations on those.
- 12:26Okay.
- 12:27It can apply sanctions for breaches.
- 12:28Yeah.
- 12:30It conducts an annual compliance check, so a big data collection, where it'll analyse the compliance of the industry, themes in breaches, themes in reporting, and they report publicly on that.
- 12:43Sure.
- 12:43And the committee also does thematic inquiries, a bit like ASIC or APRA do, where they'll look at a particular part of the code and do a deep dive around industry compliance.
- 12:53One of the questions I wanted to ask on that specifically, I've seen the reports come out in the press around, you know, this many breaches or whatever of the life code.
- 13:01We're not naming the insurers.
- 13:02Is that changing anytime soon or not?
- 13:04Well, the code currently provides the LCCC with a number of different sanctions that they can apply.
- 13:10And one of those sanctions is naming an insurer who's been found to have breached the code.
- 13:15Right.
- 13:16And they can publish on their own website as well as require the insurer to publish their determination on their website as well.
- 13:24So there is good transparency around insurers that are found to have breached the code.
- 13:29And then the other transparency measure that we're going to bring in subsequent to the review is that where there's a thematic review, like on planes handling or First Nations engagement, mental health, we're able to name the insurers who are involved in those thematic inquiries as well.
- 13:46Okay.
- 13:47So when there's a breach, one of the sanctions can be naming.
- 13:50Yes.
- 13:51But it's not mandatory in every breach.
- 13:53Okay.
- 13:54No, it's at the discretion of the LCCC.
- 13:56Right.
- 13:57So depending on the significance of the breach, the steps that the insurer has taken to remedy the breach, how early they reported, all of those things are taken into account.
- 14:07But they have other sanctions beyond naming, so they can require the insurer to take corrective action.
- 14:14They can also impose what's called a community benefit payment, which is like a fine.
- 14:19So there is a financial lever there that they have in their toolkit.
- 14:23Okay, so can I just ask, sorry, apologies because I cut you off earlier.
- 14:26I wanted to ask a couple of specific questions.
- 14:28Reviewing the code.
- 14:29So initially created by the FSC, then there was root and branch review post the Royal Commission, and now there's a commitment every two years, I think you said, or...
- 14:40So we thought given the extent of the change in this current code, it was important to review it quite quickly.
- 14:47So after two years of operation, we are thinking about what a more sustainable period for review is going forward.
- 14:54I don't think two years is the right cadence.
- 14:57Well, it's also, you've got to give the opportunity for the code to settle and embed and test or monitor the outcomes.
- 15:03I completely agree.
- 15:03Yeah, yeah.
- 15:04So we'll think about the appropriate cadence as probably like five years.
- 15:09But this two-year review was really important and we took it very seriously in terms of ensuring that it was well-resourced, fully independent.
- 15:19We appointed quite an eminent consumer and regulatory policy expert in Peter Kell and it was staffed separately, separate secretariat.
- 15:30Yeah.
- 15:30Really, we wanted to make sure that we had a credible, robust, independent review.
- 15:34Yeah.
- 15:35And I think given that we got 85 recommendations, we've probably...
- 15:39We'll crack into those.
- 15:40Yeah, and we can come to those.
- 15:42Okay.
- 15:43So did Peter and that team have access to more data than what was otherwise publicly available?
- 15:49In terms of, so we talked before about the breach reporting of the code, for example.
- 15:55So what might not make it to the public sphere?
- 15:57Did Peter and that team get to see more of that or not?
- 16:01So the review received submissions from all kinds of interested stakeholders, including CALI and some members.
- 16:09But in terms of the data they have access to, the Life Code Compliance Committee's data is all very public.
- 16:16The annual compliance review that they publish is very comprehensive, comprehensively.
- 16:21And then there's all of the APRA and ASIC data, the claims and complaints and dispute statistics, for instance.
- 16:27Yeah.
- 16:28So all of that is in public domain, and he certainly took all of that into account.
- 16:33Yeah.
- 16:34But the other really useful input were those stakeholder submissions.
- 16:38Consumer groups.
- 16:39So consumer groups, advisors, and such a broad group of stakeholders.
- 16:44Because it's life insurance, we had medical stakeholders, academics.
- 16:50Yeah.
- 16:50very broad.
- 16:51It is kind of cool when you think about our industry, the fact that it touches basically everybody in Australia, right?
- 16:56Not just the fact that I think there's 22 million insured Australians out of 26.
- 17:00But you think about, again, everything from the NDIS, like it touches every aspect.
- 17:05All right, can we go to the specifics of the 85 recommendations?
- 17:09And we can't go more than 30 centimetres in life insurance without talking about mental health, which I think was the first 13 of the 85.
- 17:16Yeah.
- 17:17Would you be able to summarise those 13 positions or those 13 recommendations?
- 17:21Sorry.
- 17:22So the recommendations touched on a couple of themes.
- 17:26So the theme that I think is most significant for the industry is the application of full exclusions as part of the standard form contract.
- 17:36Yeah.
- 17:37So this is something that the industry thought very deeply about and the review received a number of submissions on this particular issue.
- 17:44I'm hoping from doctors as well on that.
- 17:46Yeah.
- 17:46Like there would have been mental health advocates that were heavily involved in this?
- 17:50Mental health advocates, consumer representatives.
- 17:52Absolutely.
- 17:54And the reviewer has recommended that the standard form contract should not fully exclude mental health.
- 18:01So we have accepted that recommendation.
- 18:04So no insurer's standard form contract will start with a full exclusion of mental health.
- 18:09But we are very conscious of affordability and sustainability, and we think that insurers should have some sustainable design features that they can choose to apply if they want to.
- 18:21And that would include being able to opt out of cover.
- 18:24It would be able to include things like choosing different features that are in the market now, things like installments, caps, longer waiting periods.
- 18:33Yes, okay.
- 18:35And also, of course, non-standard terms after underwriting.
- 18:39Yeah.
- 18:39Can I ask, so there's heaps to unpack there, and it's, I think, actually really, really positive for the industry.
- 18:45So going back again, so actually one thing, shout out, well done, the KPMG review, mental health, stunning, stunning research, absolutely brilliant.
- 18:54Thank you so much for putting that together.
- 18:55And for those that don't know, I think the biggest standout statistic for me, and the importance of mental health was there was a 730% increase in mental health, sorry, in TPD claims for mental health
- 19:06for blokes 30 to 40 years old, I think.
- 19:08I've got that right.
- 19:10Yeah.
- 19:10So, it's great having our research out there because it can empower the right decisions, especially as we go through these reviews.
- 19:16So, with the position of Kelly and the recommendation, so we have to offer cover.
- 19:22I was speaking the Royal way here.
- 19:23So, we have to offer cover, but now there's optionalities with the insurers to offer a six-month cap or I guess the TAL five-year delayed payment, that sort of thing.
- 19:32Yeah.
- 19:33Yeah.
- 19:34Do you think that's the end of it or are we going to see more from the insurers in trying to move that or this will be where we sit for five years, see how it goes and then change again?
- 19:43So I should be very clear, Ben, when something's in the code, it's about what the insurer is able to do as opposed to prescribing what they must do.
- 19:54So each of those product design choices still sits with the insurer.
- 19:58The code is just there to enable that flexibility so that they can enable that sort of customer choice and tailoring.
- 20:05And again, it's just going to need to be a matter of the market evolving and innovating.
- 20:11And we've already seen that in the last 18 months, the introduction of four very innovative retail products.
- 20:18Yeah.
- 20:19So I can't really sort of talk to what the individual choices of the insurers are.
- 20:23Yeah.
- 20:24But we're very pleased to see that level of innovation happening in such a short period of time.
- 20:28Yeah.
- 20:29With TPD, and that's the sort of the big issue at the moment with the insurers and especially around mental health.
- 20:35APRA stepped in on income protection.
- 20:38I've heard from all the people that I know that APRA is not looking to intervene at all with the TPD component.
- 20:44So these new four products, do you think that's going to move the dial fast enough on the back books of the insurers and where the product's going?
- 20:53Well, I think we can jump ahead, actually, because you very kindly set out some themes you want to cover in the podcast.
- 21:00And I think we might jump ahead, actually, to the work with advisors.
- 21:04So our priority at Cali, you know, that's been set by the board is to work with advisors so that there's a higher degree of comfort in being able to provide advice on the newer, more contemporary products.
- 21:17Yeah.
- 21:17Because we understand the challenges that advisors face in terms of meeting the best interest duty, being across the products, all the things.
- 21:26So that is our priority and it's something that we want to continue to work with advisors on through the Risk Advice Forum.
- 21:32So for us, that's the work at industry level is understanding what advisors need in order to be able to provide advice and recommend those more contemporary and innovative products.
- 21:43Yeah.
- 21:44Okay.
- 21:45Before we go on, I just want to say a personal thank you and a thank you to Kelly as well for the risk advice forum.
- 21:50So for those that aren't aware, we started the Life Peer Group, which I think you were involved in some of those early conversations where we got about, I think there were a couple of hundred risk advisors with about a billion of premium behind us.
- 22:01And we went and spoke to all the individual insurers.
- 22:02And then it was you, Chris, that said, all right, well, there's enough bandwidth here.
- 22:06There's enough support.
- 22:07Why don't we get everybody together?
- 22:09And so the last risk advice forum, we had the Actuaries Institute.
- 22:14We've got quite a few reinsurers, pretty much every life insurer, the FAAA.
- 22:18So yeah, I'm really confident that that'll be a good body.
- 22:21So again, thank you so much for your support there because that will see, I think, advisors and clients have better access to life insurance.
- 22:28Yes, and I don't think we should gloss over your contribution to that either.
- 22:33You know what?
- 22:33We should talk about it more.
- 22:35Let's expand the podcast for five more minutes.
- 22:38Okay, that's cool.
- 22:39Now, all right, so that's one to 13 on the recommendations.
- 22:43And sorry, I will just touch on those a little bit more.
- 22:47That recommendation about full exclusions I think is one of the most meaningful recommendations, but there are some other recommendations on mental health.
- 22:55So some of them relate to tidying up the code.
- 22:59We've got some duplication in the code or some commitments that don't quite align.
- 23:03So the reviewers recommended that tidy up.
- 23:06And we're also taking steps to see what other tailored support we can provide to people who are experiencing mental ill health.
- 23:14when they make a claim or interacting with their insurer generally.
- 23:18So really thinking about what the tailoring of support might look like so that customers feel well supported through the claim with the insurer as well as understanding if there's any other support they need.
- 23:31Okay.
- 23:32And what was next on the review?
- 23:33So we hit mental health straight away.
- 23:35And again, it's the biggest one to talk about.
- 23:37So thank you for being so open about it.
- 23:39I know there was a bit on there about First Nations and claims as well.
- 23:42Yes, yes.
- 23:43So lots on claims, as you would expect.
- 23:47Yes.
- 23:48Some of the recommendations, sorry, are again about tidying up.
- 23:52So we do have some duplication.
- 23:53We've got some clause commitments that don't quite sit neatly with each other.
- 23:58So we've got those tidy up recommendations.
- 24:01But we've also got recommendations that are really targeted to clarifying and firming the timing of insurer communications through the claims assessment process.
- 24:13So, you know, that's important for advisors to understand what they can hold.
- 24:18insurers accountable to in terms of communicating with customers and communicating with them.
- 24:23Do you know what that day turnaround time is or not off the top of your head?
- 24:28There's a couple of different timeframes.
- 24:29Yeah.
- 24:30So in terms of communication, it's sort of testing me now, but there's a few on just when communications need to be made for the purposes of an update.
- 24:41Yeah.
- 24:42When communication needs to be made once the insurer's got all of the information they need or if, in fact, they need to request more.
- 24:48Sure.
- 24:49And then there are other claims handling timeframes, which are specified in the code already.
- 24:54Yeah.
- 24:54relate to when the insurer needs to make the claims decision.
- 24:58Yeah, I think a shout out to advisors there.
- 25:00It's always good to know what those timeframes are so that if you're talking to a claim assessor, maybe you can remind them of the expectations.
- 25:05Yeah, yeah.
- 25:06The code is the standard of service that life insurers have committed to.
- 25:10Yep.
- 25:11So to encourage advisors to understand what the commitments are that are in the code.
- 25:16Yeah.
- 25:16And yeah, absolutely.
- 25:17Yeah.
- 25:18Okay.
- 25:18And what were the other major themes then through the recommendations?
- 25:21So vulnerability and financial difficulty.
- 25:25So, you know, people come to their life insurer to make a claim on one of the worst days of their life or to their advisor to help them make the claim.
- 25:35So we really need to think about...
- 25:37how we can respond to the individual circumstances of the person making the claim.
- 25:43The language that is used in the financial sector is vulnerability.
- 25:47So just thinking about how we identify and respond to vulnerability.
- 25:51Yep.
- 25:52Also making information about our financial difficulty support options more readily available.
- 25:58Premiums come out of the household budget, as you know.
- 26:00So we want to make sure...
- 26:03I'm going to ask about that.
- 26:04Thank you for the reminder.
- 26:05We want to make sure that people understand what they're covered for and how much it costs.
- 26:09But we also understand that when people are experiencing financial difficulty, they're making choices about their household budget.
- 26:18And the research that we've done at Cali indicates that when people are under financial pressure, they value their life insurance more.
- 26:25So we want to be able to help them maintain their cover and get through that financially difficult period.
- 26:31So the code commitments are about making sure that information is more readily available.
- 26:35All right.
- 26:36Now, we can't touch on that without talking about the new class of advisor.
- 26:39Mm-hmm.
- 26:40First question, and I'm going to hold you to this.
- 26:43Does Kelly support the idea of new class of advisors becoming available to advisors or should they be available to advice practices now?
- 26:50Yes.
- 26:50We support.
- 26:51Sorry.
- 26:52I just heard yes.
- 26:53All right.
- 26:54There.
- 26:54Done.
- 26:54Excellent.
- 26:57We have always felt that there should be a level playing field with the new class of advisor.
- 27:03We understand why the ministers made the decision to stage this, but it's always been our view that there should be a level playing field and that advice practices should be able to utilise a new class of advisor.
- 27:15Yeah.
- 27:16And, you know, at the end of the day, what we want is for more Australians to have more access to advice.
- 27:21Yeah.
- 27:21particularly advice about life insurance.
- 27:23So anything that's going to do that is something that we support.
- 27:28And, you know, at the three-year review that the government will undertake on the NCA will make that same point.
- 27:33Yeah.
- 27:34Okay.
- 27:34And it's worth noting as well, I think most of the insurers that I've spoken to
- 27:38are big fans of the ideas of building up that new class of advisor team, and then they're really happy for the advice practices to go in and poach the good staff and turn them into real advisors.
- 27:46So just, that's, okay, that's good.
- 27:48Well, the insurers will embrace that.
- 27:49Yeah.
- 27:50The insurers want to see more potential advisors in the pipeline.
- 27:54Yeah, distribution.
- 27:55Yep.
- 27:55And, you know, if you think about the national mutual models, the AMP models from 20 years ago, that's how many holistic advisors got their start, right?
- 28:05Yeah.
- 28:05Is learning to engage with clients.
- 28:08The existing tight agent.
- 28:09Yeah, supporting life insurance.
- 28:11And then they evolved their careers into being a holistic advisor.
- 28:15And we see that exact career path for NCAs if that's what people choose to do.
- 28:19Yeah, it's funny.
- 28:20So it's the same parallel in life insurance where a lot of PYs will cut their teeth in life insurance and then move across the holistic.
- 28:26But the goal here is obviously to keep them in life insurance because it's way cooler than fun.
- 28:32Premiums, you mentioned before about making insurance more affordable.
- 28:35Now, APRA and ASIC have been quite vocally engaging with the life insurers about premium volatility.
- 28:43Again, I think we're going to come into some statements that we've had at the risk advice forum around competition.
- 28:48But there seem to be practices within the industry that are good at the immediate term, but ultimately poor for the longer term.
- 28:57Does Cali have a role to play in building a more sustainable outcome for the industry, looking at things like upfront discounts, not accurately pricing risk for a client, etc.
- 29:11?
- 29:12Does Cali involve themselves in any of that component or not?
- 29:15So Cali has a very clear role in supporting customers to be informed and have access to the information they need to make choices about life insurance.
- 29:26So the code does already, but will expand the commitments around the information that insurers need to provide on health.
- 29:34how premiums operate, that they may go up over time, and the effect of any upfront discounts.
- 29:41So the role at industry level is very much around communication, getting customers the information that they need at the right time to make an informed choice.
- 29:49But the other issues that you've talked about in terms of pricing, they are definitely within the remit of the individual insurers.
- 29:57Yeah.
- 29:57Okay.
- 29:58What feedback or do you have any feedback from the advice bodies at all?
- 30:02Or is the engagement of the life insurers, do you talk directly to consumers?
- 30:06Just curious about the moving forward, right?
- 30:09We talked about this review, having stakeholders from mental health advocates, support groups, like everybody was able to take a part in this day to day with Cali, is your engagement just with the insurers or is it going to broaden out in any way?
- 30:22So on the code review, for example, the FAAA made two submissions to the code review and they did touch on information about premiums, upfront discounts.
- 30:34So the FAAA and the Life Reviews,
- 30:38I may have been part of that committee saying, hey, we need to get rid of these.
- 30:42Yeah, yeah.
- 30:43I had a very clear voice in the review and the reviewer took that on in terms of that very clear recommendation to provide more information about the effect of upfront discounts.
- 30:53Sure.
- 30:53Sure.
- 30:54So, advisors have had a great voice through the review.
- 30:56We also engage regularly, monthly, with the FAAA on a sort of regular cadence as well as, you know, from time to time on different submissions and certainly through the Risk Advice Forum.
- 31:09Yeah.
- 31:09Okay.
- 31:10Awesome.
- 31:11All right.
- 31:11So talking about consumer engagement, and again, I want to go circle back.
- 31:16I can't help but talk about it lots because it seems like the biggest issue.
- 31:20The KPMG report into mental health.
- 31:22So again, absolutely wonderful that you've done that industry research at that level.
- 31:26TPD is changing.
- 31:27The review's got some really clear recommendations.
- 31:31We can't ignore what's happening, I guess, politically with the budget and the NDIS, massive costs and whatnot.
- 31:38What role do you see life insurance playing inside that government ecosystem and looking after the average Australian?
- 31:45Well, you're absolutely right in that this is a cross-ecosystem, cross-community, cross-economy issue.
- 31:52In our view, it's one of the biggest productivity challenges that the country faces.
- 31:58And if you think about where life insurance steps in, life insurance steps in when people are too unwell to work.
- 32:05And if we've got this many people increasingly being so unwell that they can't work either temporarily or permanently, that's a symptom of a broader issue.
- 32:16So we have been thinking more about what our industry can do to contribute to responding to that national problem.
- 32:23So you mentioned the KPMG research on the 10-year lookback of claims experience.
- 32:29Yeah.
- 32:29It identified the 732% increase in the rate of claim like you referred to.
- 32:34But just in terms of the dollars, in 2019, the industry paid $1.2 billion in mental health claims for income protection and TPD.
- 32:45In 2024, we paid $2.4 billion.
- 32:48So that's... Slightly above inflation.
- 32:50That's a lot of premium, though, to collect from everybody else.
- 32:53Yeah.
- 32:53Right?
- 32:53The claims experience has really flowed through to premiums, as we've already discussed.
- 32:58And those are the numbers that sit behind that.
- 33:01Yeah.
- 33:01So if we've got this many more people so mentally unwell that they can't work, then we've really got a national problem that we need to lean into.
- 33:10So we will be doing some more research this year on a 10-year forward plan.
- 33:15Like what happens to life insurance claims experience if these trends continue?
- 33:20We'll be releasing that at the beginning of next year.
- 33:23We've also done some research on the income protection system more broadly.
- 33:28So not just us, but government safety nets, workers' compensation, insurance.
- 33:34Sick leave, and sick leave is actually a really important issue to draw out, particularly for small and medium business owners.
- 33:42Sick leave takes up the lion's share of income support in the country.
- 33:46And when it's increasingly for mental health, there is a real productivity and business expense challenge there.
- 33:53But we've seen it across every system.
- 33:55So pressure in workers' compensation, pressure on the disability support pension, pressure on us.
- 34:00If you think about the disability support pension, 40% of disability support pension payments are made for psychosocial disability.
- 34:09I don't think anybody can.
- 34:11would guess that that's the case.
- 34:14So every system is under real pressure due to mental health.
- 34:19So we do need to think about what can be done from a preventive perspective.
- 34:24Workplace-based solutions, I think are going to be really important.
- 34:28Things like mental health first aiders.
- 34:30There's some very good research on the role that well-trained managers can play.
- 34:35in supporting people experiencing mental ill health before they become so unwell that they stop working.
- 34:43So we've really got to be thinking creatively as a country about how we deal with this, and life insurers are very keen to contribute to that conversation.
- 34:52Okay.
- 34:52And would that be in the form of like, I guess, thinking about it directly and how you go about that is that so you've got your existing clients, what you engage with, but it would be maybe through the superannuation funds that would have maybe a broader reach or through employment groups.
- 35:04How do you think Cali will go about that?
- 35:07So we've spoken to the government about how this could be done.
- 35:13Some of it, I think, is an opportunity to talk to the funds more.
- 35:16They increasingly have a primary financial relationship with somebody over their lifetime and would be well-placed to...
- 35:24provide more communication and support potentially around mental health.
- 35:28Definitely workplace-based interventions that sort of manage a training and support.
- 35:33It's going to be really important.
- 35:34And then even just playing a role in helping the entire health and disability system come to grips with mental health claims assessments.
- 35:43for instance.
- 35:44One of the reasons that our systems are all under pressure is that they weren't built for mental health.
- 35:50They weren't built for conditions that are episodic and relapsing.
- 35:57So, working through how to best respond to that from a claims assessment perspective is also something that we can contribute to and we're actively doing that with the Department of Health.
- 36:06Okay.
- 36:06Australia seems to be an outlier in this, right?
- 36:09When we look at other jurisdictions like New Zealand, the UK, Canada, that sort of stuff, we aren't seeing the, I guess, the impact from mental health like we are in Australia.
- 36:18Any idea why?
- 36:20So I think that's true in relation to life insurance claims experience.
- 36:25The claims experience in Australia is higher than other markets.
- 36:28Sorry, that's the only point I'm talking from.
- 36:30I only know about life insurance.
- 36:31Yeah.
- 36:32Wouldn't have a clue about the government.
- 36:33But at community level, yeah, it's something that many other countries are facing.
- 36:40And many other countries are facing the same challenge in terms of participating in work.
- 36:45The United Kingdom has a really deep productivity challenge.
- 36:50It's partly related to mental ill health.
- 36:53We've got 20% of their working age Britons who are not working, either due to lack of engagement, disability or unemployment, 20%.
- 37:04Wow.
- 37:05So the UK is looking quite deeply at how to...
- 37:08keep those connections with workplace when people are unwell or disabled, and that includes mental health.
- 37:14Yep.
- 37:15Through that review in the UK, they've also identified that the fastest growing group of people who are out of the workforce due to illness and disability are people between 30 and 40 with mental health conditions.
- 37:27Yeah, right.
- 37:27So unfortunately, for better or worse, it's not just us.
- 37:31It's a phenomenon that's seen in other markets, but definitely the life insurance claimed experience is unique and it goes to the design of our products, right?
- 37:40Because they have historically had a very comprehensive approach to mental health cover.
- 37:46Yeah, I was talking to Adam at Zurich Marshall at Ascender and it's interesting, they kept trying to, I guess, educate me, stop talking about the product and look at the need behind it.
- 37:57So do you think there'll be further evolution with income protection and potentially not the removal of TPD, but it might not exist today like it will in 10 years time?
- 38:07Well, the purpose of life insurance is something that we should keep coming back to.
- 38:11So for temporary and permanent disability, it's really got to kick in when somebody is too unwell or disabled to work.
- 38:19That's really got to be the test as opposed to a diagnosis, for instance.
- 38:23So I think the more that we can set that expectation with the community, with customers, and then have products that align more closely to supporting people when they come in and out of work due to episodic conditions.
- 38:36Yeah.
- 38:37That's something that's going to go a long way in terms of meeting the new need in the community as well as hopefully stabilizing affordability over the long term.
- 38:47Yeah, okay.
- 38:47So, if I look at the, again, the Australian jurisdiction versus the world from a life insurance lens, because it's the only one I've got, our products genuinely, generally have better features than what you would find elsewhere.
- 39:00So, agreed value, for example, for income protection didn't really exist many places.
- 39:03We've pared that back.
- 39:05The specific injury benefits built into income protection, I'm not sure if you...
- 39:09Just fancy things like you break your arm, you get three months payment, all that sort of stuff seems to have pared back.
- 39:14So if we're looking at a more affordable, more sustainable life insurance industry and we're facing into the mental health headwinds, could we expect then the products to continue on the path that they are at the moment, which is less features, less benefits?
- 39:31Well, I think what we can expect is for life insurers to continue to think about what the changing need is in the community.
- 39:39And that's increasingly solutions that deal with episodic conditions and conditions that relapse.
- 39:47and that give people the right support so that they can have earlier financial support, get back on their feet and get back to work.
- 39:55We've really got to have products and settings that encourage people to get better and to go back to work or rejoin the workforce.
- 40:04And so that is going to require some innovation in product.
- 40:07And I know that my members are thinking about that quite deeply.
- 40:10Okay.
- 40:11It'll be, I guess, the hard part from an advice point of view.
- 40:14with the best interest duty in its current format, we more often... Well, sorry, there is a very heavy focus on the immediate solution for the client.
- 40:21So looking at a one-year timeframe versus a five-year or a 10-year timeframe.
- 40:25Is there anything you think that Callie could do towards helping...
- 40:29I guess prevent another arms race.
- 40:31So, you know, with income protection, right, it was chase the features, who's offering the best product, who's offering the cheapest rate.
- 40:36And it was year one cheapest rate.
- 40:38And invariably, we all traced each other downwards to the point where APRA needed to step in.
- 40:42Is there anything that you think Callie could get involved in to help advisors look at a long-term solution for a client?
- 40:49So, give advice not for now, but for now and also the next five years.
- 40:53So, I don't know, maybe some sort of sustainability.
- 40:56Coming back to one of the board priorities, the strategic priorities for Cali, and that is around working with advisors to make sure that you have the information that you need to be more comfortable advising on the newer, more contemporary products.
- 41:13and making those assessments around complying with the best interest duty, for example.
- 41:18So there's a number of ways to skin that cat.
- 41:20Certainly looking at sustainability and premium sustainability is one way to look at it.
- 41:26But I think at the end of the day, we've just got to keep coming back to, as advisors do, what's the need of the customer or the client?
- 41:35What solution do they actually need to have that peace of mind or have that financial support when the worst is to happen?
- 41:41So we've just got to keep innovating product against the customer need.
- 41:45And as I said, in the last 18 months, we've seen four really strong examples of that coming to the market.
- 41:51Yeah.
- 41:51I guess that's not a bad viewpoint, right?
- 41:53Where you go, Cali's North Star is effectively the client and you go, what's the best thing for the individual client, but then society as a whole with life insurance.
- 42:00So that's pretty cool.
- 42:01I like that.
- 42:02All right.
- 42:03Well, thank you so much.
- 42:04Is there anything else that you wanted to touch on with the conversation at all?
- 42:09I think this has been a great opportunity to understand what's on your mind and talk to some of our work that we're doing at Cali.
- 42:18Certainly, you know, for the next two years, the big focus is going to be mental health and the review of the life code.
- 42:27And so we look forward to engaging with a range of stakeholders and in particular advisors on both of those.
- 42:32So on that, can I ask a favour?
- 42:33So I think you came to the Risk Info conference a little while ago.
- 42:38Could I ask, again, not really a personal favour, but it would be great if Callie could have more of a forward-facing role with advisors.
- 42:45So it would be brilliant to see you out there more often.
- 42:48Can you come to the Risk Info one, please?
- 42:50And potentially maybe, I don't know, the Acumen or other large licensee groups.
- 42:55We would be very pleased to continue to engage.
- 42:58Yeah.
- 42:59And we have engaged through those Risk Info series.
- 43:03I'm also mindful of complementing the work that our members do individually because obviously the insurers themselves put a lot of time and resource into that sort of engagement.
- 43:14Yeah.
- 43:14So we just have to be clear that what we're doing is complementing that.
- 43:18Yeah.
- 43:18But, yeah, very pleased to continue the engagement.
- 43:20Absolutely.
- 43:20Ashley, sorry, I will ask this.
- 43:23Where can Cali, again, sorry, quite rude of me.
- 43:27So, complementing the insurers and the work that they do, right?
- 43:30If I take that to the nth degree, I think about things like underwriting application forms.
- 43:34Every insurer has got their own underwriting application form and they view it as a point of difference.
- 43:40As an advisor, I can almost guarantee that of the 15,000 advisors, 4,999 would agree with me that that's not necessarily a point of difference.
- 43:48So what steps can Callie do to improve the approach from the industry to the advice group?
- 43:57Oh, I think insurers are considering every day how they can make it more efficient for advisors to engage with them and making significant investments in terms of portals and processes and other things.
- 44:11That's a top priority for all Cali members.
- 44:13Is there any standardisation though?
- 44:15So ANZIF, I think, they standardise the codes for occupations, I think.
- 44:22Or like there was broad agreement from all the industry.
- 44:25You know what I'm trying to get to?
- 44:26Yeah.
- 44:27Sorry for being vague.
- 44:28No, no.
- 44:28No, no.
- 44:28I understand.
- 44:30Look, one of the things that I would add is that where there is that difference, particularly around underwriting, it's not so much a competitive issue, but it's a risk issue.
- 44:40So each insurer will have their own risk appetite.
- 44:43They'll have their own approach to underwriting.
- 44:45It'll be informed by the reinsurer that they work with.
- 44:48So it's very much driven by collecting the information that they need to make a really good underwriting assessment as opposed to being like a point of competition.
- 44:59So I think we'll just need to be mindful of that in terms of insurers having the information that they need.
- 45:05to do your underwriting and manage their own risk.
- 45:08But if I think of other examples like occupation codes, right?
- 45:11So simplifying and standardizing occupation of codes across the industry, I don't think would represent any lack of competition.
- 45:17It would just make life easier for financial advisors.
- 45:21What else would it be?
- 45:21Like standardizing lapse within reinstatement timeframes.
- 45:25So if a policy is 30 days overdue, then we can put it back into force with only paying a minor premium.
- 45:31All right.
- 45:31This has been absolutely brilliant, Chris.
- 45:32And again, I appreciate you taking your time.
- 45:34Just a real generic question.
- 45:36So what can we expect from Kelly in the next five years?
- 45:39Where is all this going?
- 45:40Well, Kelly's mission is to ensure we have a trusted, understandable and accessible life insurance industry.
- 45:47And that's not going to change.
- 45:48We're going to continue to work towards all three of those objectives, but particularly accessibility.
- 45:55You know, we're really challenged in terms of getting people the information that they need to understand their life insurance options and what suits them.
- 46:03So certainly working closely with advisors for the advice profession to understand how we can support you better, thinking about the implementation of that new class of advisor to deal with very simple questions and inquiries, and then thinking about long-term sustainability of the products so that they continue to be affordable and accessible.
- 46:24Because ultimately we want
- 46:26Australians to have peace of mind about their financial resilience.
- 46:30And going back to the conversation that we had at the start of this podcast, which is why do I do what I do?
- 46:37And I do what I do to ensure that people have financial resilience so that they can get on with their lives through peace of mind.
- 46:45So working towards that, working towards Kelly's mission, that's what we'll be doing for the next five years.
- 46:50Brilliant.
- 46:50Okay.
- 46:51Well, thank you again for coming on and best of luck.
- 46:54Thanks, Ben.