Latest / The So What? / Of Budgets and Tariffs
Transcript
- 0:05Hello and welcome to the So What podcast, in
- 0:08which political economic analyst J .P. Landman
- 0:11discusses the issues uppermost in the minds of
- 0:13South Africans. You can find a written version
- 0:16of this content on J .P.'s website, jpluntman
- 0:19.co .za. I am Ruda Landman, and I am your host.
- 0:26Hello, and as always, a very warm welcome to
- 0:30a conversation which... goes with an extraordinary
- 0:35newsletter. Extraordinary in the sense that it
- 0:38comes only three days after the previous one.
- 0:41We recorded one for the 4th of April on the water
- 0:44situation in South Africa. This one is dated
- 0:47the 7th of April and the title is, of course,
- 0:51of Budgets and Tariffs. Why are we doing this?
- 0:56Because both those events, the approval of the
- 0:58budget in South Africa and on the same afternoon,
- 1:02The introduction of tariffs by Donald Trump are
- 1:05actually quite momentous events, each one on
- 1:07their own. And I thought it would be appropriate
- 1:10that we combine them in one newsletter and discuss
- 1:13both. So it's really two very different topics
- 1:16that are things that occurred on the same day.
- 1:19So first, tell us what exactly happened in Parliament
- 1:23on Wednesday, the 2nd of April. What happened
- 1:26in Parliament was that Parliament approved the
- 1:29fiscal framework. And what is the fiscal framework?
- 1:32It is basically the revenue, the expenditure
- 1:34and the borrowings for the coming year, financial
- 1:37year of the state, which must be set, has been
- 1:40set by Parliament. So those figures are set in
- 1:45stone? They are now set in stone. They are now
- 1:47locked. But the budget has got four approval
- 1:50processes. And the fiscal framework was the first
- 1:53approval process. And the relevance of that first
- 1:56approval process is, as you say, it sets in stone
- 1:59those three very important numbers. To what revenue
- 2:03do we commit ourselves? In other words, what
- 2:05taxes? To what expenditure do we commit ourselves
- 2:07or the so -called appropriations in the jargon?
- 2:11And then thirdly, what do we borrow? And those
- 2:14are really the critical numbers around the macro
- 2:17budget. And that was approved on Wednesday afternoon.
- 2:21And the way the approval works, just to give
- 2:23you the detail, on the previous day, the Tuesday,
- 2:25there was a committee meeting. Legislation requires
- 2:28that a parliamentary committee must meet on the
- 2:31framework, hear public representations, listen
- 2:34to people, and then make a recommendation. And
- 2:37that's what they did. And they recommended to
- 2:39Parliament that the framework be adopted. And
- 2:42that debate took place on Wednesday. And it passed,
- 2:46but only just. Yes, very interesting. The number
- 2:49was 194 in favour and 182 against, which means
- 2:54a majority of 12. Now that sounds okay until
- 2:57you realise that there were 24 members of the
- 3:00House, of the National Assembly, who did not
- 3:03vote. They were mainly members of MK and EFF,
- 3:06but they were also members from other parties
- 3:09who talked against the budget but walked out
- 3:12of the Assembly before they had to vote. So that
- 3:15number added up to 24. Now you can work out for
- 3:19yourself, if the majority was 12 and 24 people
- 3:21didn't vote, this thing could easily have gone
- 3:24a different way. So it was, as Wellington said,
- 3:28a damn close -run thing. That was of the Battle
- 3:31of Waterloo, no less. How do the approval process
- 3:35work from now on? There are a number of things
- 3:42that have to be approved. Yes, correct. As I've
- 3:46said, there are four rounds of approvals. The
- 3:47first one now was approving the fiscal framework.
- 3:50So that was done. The DA wants to go and challenge
- 3:53that in court, and we will have to see how that
- 3:55plays out. But Parliament has done that first
- 3:58approval. The second approval, which must happen
- 4:01within 35 days of the approval of the framework,
- 4:05is to approve the division of revenue. South
- 4:10Africa has got three levels of government, national,
- 4:12provincial, local. Basically, all taxes, i .e.
- 4:16all revenue, are collected by the national government.
- 4:18There's a little bit in the provinces, a little
- 4:20bit in local government, but essentially all
- 4:23revenue is collected by SARS for the national
- 4:26government. Then the constitution requires that
- 4:30that pool of money cannot just all be kept by
- 4:33the central government or the national government.
- 4:35It must divvied up to the provinces and to the
- 4:38local municipalities. That is the so -called
- 4:42equitable share. And that bill is an important
- 4:44one because it divides the money. And it must
- 4:47be adopted within 35 working days, which effectively
- 4:50takes it to about the 27th of May. By then, that
- 4:55division of revenue bill must be passed by Parliament.
- 4:58So that's the second one. The third level is
- 5:01within four months from the start of the state's
- 5:03financial year, which is 1 April, within four
- 5:06months, the appropriation bill. which is basically
- 5:10the expenditure of the state, must be approved.
- 5:12That takes us, the target date for that then
- 5:15will be, if you start on 1 April, will be 31
- 5:17July, four months later. And that's a long and
- 5:20tedious process where the budget gets scrutinized
- 5:24in detail on the expenditure side. That's where
- 5:28the various committees in Parliament for defence,
- 5:30for justice, for education, for the environment,
- 5:33where they go through their different budgets
- 5:36and screen them. and interact with the government
- 5:39and bureaucrats about them. So that's a fairly
- 5:42important and a detailed process. And then the
- 5:45last round has got no fixed date to it. That
- 5:48is the approval of the revenue bills. In other
- 5:50words, the approval of taxation laws. Traditionally,
- 5:54that is done before Parliament rises for the
- 5:56year. So there's a retrospective element. You
- 6:01approve the revenue bills, say, in September
- 6:03or October, before Parliament adjourns. But they
- 6:07apply from the beginning of the tax year, which
- 6:09is 1 March. And I suppose at some point, some
- 6:12activist lawyer will question that and say, you
- 6:14can't have a retroactive bill. But at the moment,
- 6:18that's not on the table. So those are the four
- 6:20levels of approval that are needed. But in the
- 6:23meantime, the new tax year and the new financial
- 6:26year start. So how does that? affect the whole
- 6:30process yeah a very important point the fiscal
- 6:33year starts on 1 april as i've said the tax year
- 6:36as listeners would know starts on the 1st of
- 6:40march now if you if you your fiscal year your
- 6:44financial year starts on the 1st of april but
- 6:46you have a tax increase only in may it means
- 6:50for two months you don't have you don't have
- 6:52the income from that increase If you now delay
- 6:56it from May to June, the gap becomes bigger.
- 6:58If you delay it to July, August, September, the
- 7:01gaps become very, very big. In fact, if you delay
- 7:03it to 12 months, there's no income from that
- 7:05particular tax rise. So the reality of the date
- 7:09is that you have to proceed with implementation
- 7:14of tax increases quite quickly. And that means
- 7:18that the half a percent VAT will be implemented
- 7:22on 1 May. Let's just go back and see the whole
- 7:25picture. The half a percent VAT increase is in
- 7:28your revenue number, which is approved in the
- 7:30fiscal framework. You must now give practical
- 7:33gestalt to that fiscal framework. So you've got
- 7:35to start the VAT increase to collect the money
- 7:39for the year. And that date is 1 May. And then
- 7:42what if Parliament after that says, no, we're
- 7:48not going to raise the VAT rate? Well, that'll
- 7:51come in the revenue bills towards the end of
- 7:54the year. Parliament will then have to step up
- 7:57and accept responsibility for the fact that there
- 8:00aren't enough money collected to finance the
- 8:02expenditure which they have authorized. It's
- 8:05a decision that Parliament cannot really take,
- 8:07and I think all responsible parties will cooperate
- 8:10to avoid that. Now the big question, will the
- 8:13DA leave the GNU? What's your take? As of today's
- 8:18date, that is uncertain. There's a lot of noise
- 8:22and dust. My own view is that it's not a foregone
- 8:27conclusion. It is true that there are two factions
- 8:30in ANC, but there are also two factions in the
- 8:33DA. And in both parties, there's a faction that
- 8:37wants the GNU to continue and a faction that
- 8:40wants the GNU to break up. Or at least only continue
- 8:45on their rather strenuous conditions. Will it
- 8:49play out that way? I honestly don't know. We'll
- 8:52have to see which way it goes. If they leave,
- 8:56the ANC would be able to form a government with
- 9:00about 202 votes in the National Assembly. Depending
- 9:05on who supports them, maybe 210 votes or 208
- 9:08votes rather. So it will be a very slim majority
- 9:11and the whips will have their hands full to make
- 9:14sure that every time there's a vote, all the
- 9:16members are there and they all vote. Who is included
- 9:20in that? Well, it'll be the ANC, it'll be the
- 9:23IFP, it'll be the Patriotic Alliance, it'll be
- 9:26good. The parties that have so far supported
- 9:29the process. But not the EFF? No, not the EFF
- 9:33and not the MK. I haven't included them in those
- 9:35numbers. Now, that's okay. You know, you can
- 9:38run the country if you have a majority of two
- 9:41or three, but it's not a comfortable position
- 9:43and it would, of course, be much better. If the
- 9:46government of national unity has got a stronger
- 9:48majority, if the remaining government then allows
- 9:52the EFF or MK in, they can have more numbers,
- 9:55but I'm not sure they will have more stability.
- 9:57So I don't think that's a good situation. So
- 10:02what at this point? Well, I think the first point
- 10:06is the approval of the fiscal framework was important.
- 10:09In the past, we've taken these things almost
- 10:11as automatic. Now democracy is asserting itself.
- 10:15There's no longer one party controlling parliament
- 10:18or having a majority in parliament. And it was
- 10:21kind of an experience in dealing with democratic
- 10:25forces, shaping the budget. So getting that fiscal
- 10:29framework through was an important thing. As
- 10:30I've said, it sets in stone three important numbers
- 10:33and everything else must now fit into those numbers.
- 10:36So that's something to be happy about. Secondly,
- 10:40the second so what, I think we must accept that
- 10:42the VAT increase will come in force on 1 May.
- 10:45And with that, we must accept that I do not think
- 10:48there's going to be a reduction in personal tax
- 10:51rates as proposed by Action SA. To not increase
- 10:57the VAT rate and to give the reduced tax rates
- 10:59will cost 31 billion Rand. Now, there are no
- 11:04money trees in the country where you can go and
- 11:06pluck money off. So I don't think it's possible
- 11:09to find that amount of money. So I don't think
- 11:11that income will be sacrificed. And your third,
- 11:14so what is a motion of commiseration for the
- 11:19whips for the next while? Yes, indeed. You know,
- 11:21those numbers that we had, 194 in favor, 182
- 11:26against, majority of 12, but 24 people didn't
- 11:29vote. That means that in the further rounds of
- 11:32approval, the other rounds that are still left
- 11:35over, which we discussed, the WIPs will have
- 11:37their work cut out to make sure that all the
- 11:39members are there all the time. Sometimes people
- 11:42are sick, sometimes people are on a study visit
- 11:44or they travel or whatever. Well, they'll have
- 11:47to be in the house when there's a vote. That
- 11:49is what the WIPs are there for, but they will
- 11:51have their hands full. And so it is quite possible
- 11:54that we see in the three further rounds of approvals,
- 11:57if the DA leaves the GNU, we may see in the further
- 12:02three rounds of approval that it's again a very
- 12:05damn close -run thing. That may become the hallmark
- 12:09of this year's budget. Turning to tariffs, first,
- 12:13just a summary, what has happened? Well, on the
- 12:16same day that we approved the budget, Trump announced
- 12:20what he calls Liberation Day, where he imposed
- 12:23tariffs on the whole world, friends and foes.
- 12:26A minimum tariff of 10 % on countries which did
- 12:30not particularly offend him. And then a higher
- 12:33so -called reciprocal tariff for countries with
- 12:37whom the US has got a current account deficit
- 12:39or a trade deficit. And he wants to force those
- 12:42countries to change the numbers. So for South
- 12:46Africa, he imposed a 30 % tariff of all exports
- 12:50from South Africa into the U .S., effectively
- 12:53making our products more expensive in America.
- 12:56Now, that cost will, of course, be carried by
- 12:58the American consumer. It's not carried by South
- 13:01Africans. But South Africans will carry the cost
- 13:04of fewer exports, lesser sales in the U .S. In
- 13:08that way, we will have a cost. But the cost of
- 13:11the higher products will be borne by the Americans.
- 13:14Now, it's quite interesting, Rita, that about
- 13:1650 % of our exports to the U .S. were exempt
- 13:19from this 30 % tariff. Why? Because it's minerals
- 13:23which the U .S. actually wants and need. So they've
- 13:27neatly carved out what is in their self -interest
- 13:30and said, okay, that we will not tariff. Diamonds
- 13:33and iron ore are taxed or are tariffed. They
- 13:37will carry the 30 % tariff. But then there's
- 13:40a whole host of articles like copper. Zinc, manganese,
- 13:45gold, the platinum group of metals, certain chemicals
- 13:48and certain wood and nickel products are exempt.
- 13:52As I've said, that makes up more than half of
- 13:55our exports to the US. So, yeah, they will not
- 13:59be affected. But it must be said that the sectors
- 14:02that will be affected very seriously is farmers,
- 14:05agricultural products, particularly citrus and
- 14:08wine and fruit juices. And very importantly,
- 14:11automotive exports. We've got automotive manufacturers
- 14:15in South Africa, BMW, Mercedes, the Ford bakkie,
- 14:19which is made primarily for exports to the American
- 14:23market. Those tariffs will hurt them very, very
- 14:25hard. No question. They will just not be competitive
- 14:28in the American market. No. Trump waved around
- 14:32a poster during this news conference, and it
- 14:37had certain... quote -unquote facts about South
- 14:40Africa's tariffs. Were they correct? The poster
- 14:44that he waved around showed that South Africa
- 14:46is imposing a 60 % import tariffs against American
- 14:51exports coming into South Africa. Now, that's,
- 14:56of course, completely nonsense. And there are
- 14:58two sources for me saying nonsense. The one is
- 15:00a US government agency. It is called the US Trade
- 15:04Administration. And on their website, it says
- 15:07the following. South Africa reformed and simplified
- 15:10its tariff structure in 1994. Tariff rates has
- 15:14been reduced from a simple average of more than
- 15:1620 % to an average of 7 .1 % in 2020. Tariff
- 15:22rates mostly fall within eight levels ranging
- 15:25between 0 % to 30%. This was written in January
- 15:3024 and I accessed it on the website on the 3rd
- 15:33of April 25. So that's what the US government
- 15:35agency said. mostly 0 to 30. Professor Johan
- 15:40Furry from Stellenbosch analyzed the trade data
- 15:43of trade between South Africa and the US, and
- 15:46he found that there are only four categories
- 15:48from more than 1 ,000 categories where South
- 15:52Africa levies more than 60 % tariffs on US goods,
- 15:56four out of 1 ,000. The total value of those
- 15:59imports came to $379 ,000, and the total imports
- 16:04from the U .S. were $6 billion. So you talk about
- 16:08.0063. So I think what happened in the White
- 16:12House, somebody didn't see the comma and assumed
- 16:14.0063 is 60%. That's the only explanation I can
- 16:18have for it. You know, quite frankly, the White
- 16:21House and Trump are as informed on tariffs as
- 16:25they are on the so -called land grabs. What does
- 16:28this mean for AGOA? I think it means AGOA has
- 16:31gone ruder. AGOA was supposed to expire in August
- 16:3425, five months' time, but these tariffs clearly
- 16:37overrule it. There are opinions to the contrary,
- 16:40but I think effectively AGOA is finished. So
- 16:43we can say goodbye to it. The impact? As we've
- 16:48discussed, the impact will be serious on the
- 16:50South African automotive industry. particularly
- 16:53those three companies that export to the US,
- 16:55Mercedes, BMW and Ford. It will be serious for
- 16:59citrus farmers countrywide, but particularly
- 17:03also in the Western Cape. It's serious for wine
- 17:06producers and serious for fruit juice people.
- 17:09So it will hit agriculture and it will hit automotive.
- 17:13The government is preparing to table a comprehensive
- 17:18trade and relationship agreement with the US.
- 17:21Do you see a future for that? I think it's a
- 17:24good thing that government is doing it. It's
- 17:25the right thing to do. It's the appropriate thing
- 17:27to do. I think it has a zero chance of success.
- 17:30Why do I say that? Because the gripes that Trump
- 17:34has with South Africa are of such a nature that
- 17:37I don't think there's room for a deal. He wants
- 17:40us to suspend the court case against Israel.
- 17:42Well, we're not going to do that. He wants us
- 17:45to scrap the Expropriation Act. Well, we're not
- 17:47going to do that. The Expropriation Act will
- 17:49be changed in this country by this country's
- 17:52constitutional court, not by pressure from Trump.
- 17:54And so I can go through all five of his elements
- 17:57or his gripes. So I would be very surprised.
- 18:01I don't want to be negative. I think it's the
- 18:03right thing to do. But I'll be very surprised
- 18:05if, given these gripes, we can make a deal with
- 18:08the U .S. So in your view, we should diversify.
- 18:12We should find other clients. Absolutely. There's
- 18:16no alternative. You know, people, the media makes
- 18:18a lot of the fact that America is our second
- 18:20biggest trading partner after China. And that's
- 18:24true. But it's also true that our exports to
- 18:27America is less than 10 % of our exports, sitting
- 18:30about 8 % or thereabouts. Of course, it changes
- 18:33from quarter to quarter. Now, 8 % is a lot. I'm
- 18:38not trying to minimize it, but that means you've
- 18:40got 92 % elsewhere. It also tells you that we
- 18:44have successfully, over the last 20, 30 years,
- 18:47diversified our exports, particularly to the
- 18:50East. The East takes 35 % of our exports. Europe
- 18:54takes 25%. Africa takes 25%. So that's 85%. 8
- 19:00% to 10%, 95%. The Middle East takes about 3
- 19:03% to 4%. And then Australasia and South America,
- 19:07the rest. Now, particularly in the Middle East,
- 19:10there is huge export potential. That doesn't
- 19:13mean it's easy fruit to pluck from a tree, not
- 19:15at all. But a country like Saudi Arabia has got
- 19:18something like $25 billion of agricultural exports
- 19:22every year. Of that, South Africa holds only
- 19:25about 1%. You mean that's what they import? That's
- 19:29what they import. That's what they import from
- 19:31other countries. And we only hold about 1 % of
- 19:34that. So there's chiaroscopy to that. China is
- 19:37an enormous agricultural importer. So our government,
- 19:41particularly DERCO, foreign affairs, agriculture,
- 19:45trade and industry, have got to step up our game
- 19:48of getting preferential trade agreements with
- 19:52those countries and get our agricultural products
- 19:54into their markets. In summary, so what? I think
- 19:59the biggest so what is that Trump has essentially
- 20:01launched a trade war against virtually the whole
- 20:06world, friend and foe. People that have been
- 20:10loyal friends of America and people who've been
- 20:13loyal enemies of America. Everybody got a club.
- 20:16And we will have to see how that affects international
- 20:19relations, but it can't be good for America.
- 20:22The 30 % reciprocal tariff levied on South Africa
- 20:26will hit our growth rate. Up till now, we've
- 20:29been working with a potential growth rate of
- 20:311 .8 % for 2025. That growth rate, I think, will
- 20:34come down. We will have to see by how much the
- 20:38different economists and research houses will
- 20:40tell us over the next weeks as they run their
- 20:42models. But essentially, our population growth
- 20:45is 1 .3%, so you don't want to have economic
- 20:48growth lower than that. You want to have it at
- 20:50a higher number. Our labor force is expanding
- 20:53at 1 .4%, so again, you want a growth rate higher
- 20:56than that. We'll have to see whether that can
- 20:58be achieved. The third so what is, I think the
- 21:02prospects of a deal with the United States or
- 21:04with the Trump government is very low. As I've
- 21:07said, the gripes that he has are gripes that
- 21:09we can't do much about, and that is going to
- 21:12preclude a deal. Unless, you know, the man is
- 21:14very volatile and transactional, maybe we do
- 21:17get a deal, and then nobody will be more happy
- 21:19than me. But I think we must be realistic about
- 21:21the chances. And in the meantime, we must work
- 21:24really hard to diversify our export markets.
- 21:27Absolutely. That is where people must now focus.
- 21:32Thank you very much. I hope we don't have to
- 21:34come back to a microphone in the next week. You
- 21:37know, it's a Chinese curse that you live in interesting
- 21:39times. Indeed. Thank you for listening to the
- 21:44So What Podcast. If you enjoy this content, please
- 21:47don't forget to leave a review and a rating and
- 21:50please consider subscribing so you don't miss
- 21:52any future episodes. Also, tell your friends.
- 21:56Remember, you can find a written version of all
- 21:58JP's content at jplandman.co.za.