Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / Appealing an Arbitration Award Without Going to Court
Transcript
- 0:03I am Jeff Kravitz. I am co -chair of the BHBA's
- 0:09ADR committee, and I'm very excited to be working
- 0:13this morning on the topic of appealing an arbitration
- 0:19award without going to court. We have two distinguished
- 0:23speakers, the first of whom is the honorable
- 0:27Richard Aronson, who has retired. He is a mediator
- 0:31and arbitrator and a court appointed neutral
- 0:34with jams. He was over 20 years with the Court
- 0:38of Appeals and before that was with the Orange
- 0:41County Superior Court. He in turn is joined by
- 0:46Michael Zuckerman. Michael is a mediator and
- 0:49arbitrator with jams. He handles consumer, commercial,
- 0:54employment class action and emerging technology
- 0:58matters. including data privacy disputes. Before
- 1:03joining Jams, he was a trial and appellate litigator
- 1:06at Jones Day. Without further ado, I turn it
- 1:11over to our speakers. And thank you very much
- 1:14for making the presentation today. Thank you
- 1:18very much. Good meetings. As you just heard,
- 1:24this Presentation is about, by the way, excuse
- 1:28if I sound like a frog, I'm dealing with a bit
- 1:31of a head cold, but I hope to muddle through
- 1:34and I hope you pick up everything I say. Today
- 1:38we're going to discuss the benefits of employing
- 1:41the arbitration providers internal appellate
- 1:46process. We're basing our presentation on an
- 1:50article that Mike and I did for the advocate
- 1:53and magazine that is published by the California
- 1:58or the Consumer Attorneys Association of Los
- 2:01Angeles. The article, if we manage to pique your
- 2:06interest about this topic, is loaded on the JAMS
- 2:10website. So you can have access to the article
- 2:15by getting on the JAMS website, obviously. We
- 2:21wrote this article because it's been our experience
- 2:24that The arbitration appellate the internal arbitration
- 2:30appellate process That's offered by arbitration
- 2:35providers is underutilized in large part because
- 2:42Lawyers are unfamiliar with the process or it
- 2:45seems that's our impression Or if they are aware
- 2:48of it, they're unfamiliar with the advantages
- 2:51that are available. And speaking of the advantages,
- 2:54by the way, just to to highlight that this is
- 2:59not a useless or wasted endeavor. In the winter
- 3:06of 2024, an ABA article cited AAA data from 2022
- 3:14and 2023. that showed that half of decided appeals
- 3:20were altered in whole or in part. So it can be
- 3:24a useful tool for the arbitration practitioner.
- 3:31So let's start with a hypothetical. And this
- 3:39has to do with the situation that some of you
- 3:42may have encountered. I certainly saw it on when
- 3:46I was on the Court of Appeal and in Superior
- 3:49Court. So assume that you represent a client
- 3:53in an arbitration and as you go to the arbitration
- 3:57hearing, you're pretty confident that you're
- 3:59gonna prevail. The law and the facts are on your
- 4:03side in all signs as point to you winning this
- 4:09arbitration for your client. And then you get
- 4:13the interim award and which ultimately is turned
- 4:16into a final award and you are shocked to see
- 4:20that you've experienced a devastating loss. Assume
- 4:26the arbitrator as you read the award. It's apparent
- 4:31to you that the arbitrator applied the wrong
- 4:33legal standard and made factual findings that
- 4:36just don't square with the record. This actually
- 4:41was a situation that both Mike and I encountered
- 4:43in arbitration we had several years ago. So what
- 4:50are your options at this point? Well, obviously,
- 4:55one of them is to accept defeat. This is, after
- 4:58all, what you bargained for. The fiction is that
- 5:04you anticipated this when you agreed to arbitrate.
- 5:10finality of an arbitration award is a component
- 5:14of the process of the part of the agreement.
- 5:18Another option you have is a petition to vacate
- 5:21or modify the award in Superior Court. But prevailing
- 5:27on a petition to vacate is rare because the statutory
- 5:32grounds for relief are very narrow. You're really
- 5:37pushing a rock up a hill trying to trying to
- 5:41correct this, just a few grounds that you can
- 5:44raise with the Superior Court. The other option
- 5:48is to appeal if your arbitration clause expressly
- 5:54and clearly provided for this option. Here in
- 5:59our hypothetical it says that that wasn't the
- 6:02case, that the arbitration clause is standard
- 6:04one and that it's been used for decades. Well,
- 6:08If it doesn't explicitly provide for an appeal
- 6:12to the arbitration providers appellate process,
- 6:20then you are out of luck. Can you directly appeal
- 6:26to a court? The answer to that is no. As I mentioned,
- 6:35you can file a motion to vacate or modify the
- 6:39award, the court, whether you're successful or
- 6:42not, the court will enter a judgment. And you
- 6:46may appeal from that judgment to the appellate
- 6:51court, but there's no direct appeals from the
- 6:53arbitration award. And as we'll see, the grounds
- 7:00that the appellate court will review are just
- 7:04procedural, the statutory, they're very narrow.
- 7:08Uh, and you almost, uh, it's rare to, um, prevail
- 7:14in those grounds. Mike, um, what about an error
- 7:19of fact or law? Uh, can, can you raise that in
- 7:25a judicial review of the arbitration award or
- 7:29the, of the, actually of the judgment from superior
- 7:32court? So the answer is no. and statutory review
- 7:37under the Federal Arbitration Act and California
- 7:40Arbitration Act is notoriously narrow. It is,
- 7:44let's say, near impossible. You can't appeal
- 7:47a narrow of law. You can't appeal a narrow effect,
- 7:50subject to various exceptions. Courts have said
- 7:54in the Ritchie case, which is a... a foundational
- 7:57California case, the courts cannot review arbitration
- 8:00awards for errors of factor law. Even when those
- 8:02errors appear on the face of the award or cause
- 8:05substantial injustice to the parties, there are
- 8:09unending quotes from courts saying even an award
- 8:12that is blatantly wrong, that is wrong on its
- 8:16face, where the arbitrator found, made credibility
- 8:20determinations that are unexplainable on the
- 8:23record, those are typically not reviewable, but
- 8:26it's a policy choice, right? So parties selected
- 8:29arbitration for all of the potential benefits
- 8:31that arbitration can bring. For those of you
- 8:34who have done arbitrations, you've probably experienced
- 8:37many of them. There's the potential for speed,
- 8:39for expediency, to lower cost. And sure, while
- 8:43you may have to pay for an arbitration, the efficiency
- 8:46of it could certainly lower attorney's fees,
- 8:50lower the cost of counsel to actually end up
- 8:54in cost savings to the client. There is privacy,
- 8:57confidentiality. You can select your arbitrator,
- 8:59obviously with the other side, in a way that
- 9:01you can't select your judge. And you get finality,
- 9:04that certainty to your client. And the limited
- 9:07review under these statutes preserves those advantages
- 9:10basically by not allowing for a second round
- 9:14of litigation. So the courts have tried to preserve
- 9:20that first layer without adding that second.
- 9:23And it's a trade -off. And I'm sure you saw that
- 9:26on the Court of Appeals when you were reviewing
- 9:28petitions to vacate all the time. And let's go
- 9:36on to the exclusive grounds for literature. And
- 9:42so as I mentioned, there are statutes like Dublin,
- 9:45meaning petitions to vacate an arbitration award.
- 9:48There is no direct appeal of the award. There
- 9:50is the Federal Arbitration Act. There is the
- 9:53California Arbitration Act. Whatever you can
- 9:55fit under, the Federal Arbitration Act does not
- 9:58bestow jurisdiction on a federal court. So you
- 10:01need to fit into one of these, typically during
- 10:03the arbitration. The parties will agree if it's
- 10:06not in their arbitration agreement, which one
- 10:08applies. But under the FAA, corruption, fraud,
- 10:12undue means, partiality, corruption, misconduct,
- 10:16exceeding powers, by not entering a final award,
- 10:20by refusing to hear material evidence, basically
- 10:22just excluding it without even hearing it, those
- 10:26are very narrow grounds. And they all have a
- 10:29bang towards procedural problems, not substantive.
- 10:34And courts ultimately ask, if you were to summarize
- 10:37these, was it a fundamentally fair proceeding?
- 10:40And that's how I read the cases and some have
- 10:42as well. Rich, let me throw it to you for California.
- 10:46Yeah, as you can see, 1286 .2 tends to mirror
- 10:52the federal statute, but it does add a couple
- 10:55of things. One is refusing to postpone upon a
- 11:01showing of good cause, the hearing. So it's abuse
- 11:07of discretion and denying a continuance. And
- 11:11so there is some action there. In fact, where
- 11:13the action is, if there is going to be any, is
- 11:19Numbers four and five the other ones the corruption
- 11:22failure to disclose grounds for disqualification
- 11:25that's going to be pretty rare. Over the years
- 11:31we've pellet decisions have kind of ironed out
- 11:35what's involved. I know in jams. I both Mike
- 11:41and I fill out a very involved and detailed disclosure
- 11:45report. So. You probably won't get too much traction
- 11:49looking at those sections for relief, subsections
- 11:54for relief. Exceeding powers, refusing to postpone
- 11:58the hearing or hearing material evidence. That's
- 12:00where you might have some grounds for raising
- 12:06and maybe modifying the arbitration award. But
- 12:13I want to caution you, it doesn't mean... If
- 12:18the arbitrator denies admission of what you consider
- 12:25to be material relevant evidence, that's not
- 12:29grounds for relief. That's just a mistake of
- 12:35law. And the arbitrators, the courts will not
- 12:40review, as Mike mentioned, errors of law or...
- 12:49mistaken decisions on the facts. So what does
- 12:53that mean not to hear material evidence? That's
- 12:56not a decision about whether you get to admit
- 13:02relevant evidence, whether the arbitrator rules
- 13:05it, excludes it. It only has to do with the opportunity
- 13:11to present evidence. So if an arbitrator refuses
- 13:16to hear material evidence that doesn't consider
- 13:21it at all, but just refuses to hear it for whatever
- 13:25reason, then that potentially could be grounds
- 13:33for relief. There's a very fine line here. And
- 13:36maybe there's a case that I found pretty interesting
- 13:39in preparing for today's talk. A number of years
- 13:44ago, There was a case that involved the arbitrator
- 13:53deciding in a real estate deal where the seller
- 13:55sold some property residents to the buyer and
- 14:00the buyer discovered later that the lot line
- 14:02had been incorrectly described and therefore
- 14:09sued the buyer. The arbitrator concluded that
- 14:13any damages for a lot line discrepancy stem from
- 14:21the breach at the time of the sale. And the arbitrator
- 14:24decided that he would not hear any evidence occurring
- 14:31after the breach of that sale. Well, what happened
- 14:36afterwards into the arbitration a couple years
- 14:40into the arbitration, the title company settled
- 14:43with the adjoining property owner. And essentially,
- 14:50that meant that there would be no damages. And
- 14:53as odd as it seems, the arbitrator nevertheless
- 14:56refused to consider that evidence. And the reason
- 14:59the arbitrator didn't is because it stemmed from
- 15:02his legal decision. The court of appeal overturned
- 15:06that, said the arbitrator refused to consider
- 15:09the evidence. Therefore, there were grounds to
- 15:12overturn that. The Supreme Court disapproved
- 15:16of that decision a few years later, because where
- 15:21the legal decision, even if erroneous, leads
- 15:27to the exclusion of certain evidence, and a lot
- 15:29of legal decisions result in the exclusion of
- 15:33evidence, then that's just a mistake of law.
- 15:37And there you have it. This sort of illustrates
- 15:39how difficult it is to to get over this hurdle.
- 15:47And we all talk about exceeding powers as a result,
- 15:52or a little bit later on in the presentation.
- 15:55George, before we move on to the next slide,
- 15:57I was going to add in, there is a concept floating
- 15:58around of manifest disregard for the law. You
- 16:01may have heard that as a ground to vacate. Under
- 16:04the Federal Arbitration Act, these grounds are
- 16:07exclusive. The Supreme Court has made that clear.
- 16:10Nonetheless, there are circuits where you can
- 16:11bring that argument and the court will entertain
- 16:14it. The Supreme Court has not decided the issue
- 16:18directly. It is a shaky ground. It's one that
- 16:23seems to be going away. It's where the arbitrator
- 16:25knows what the law is and decides not to apply
- 16:28it. There's an old case where the arbitrator
- 16:29says the FLSA applies, but I'm not going to apply
- 16:32it. And the court vacates. So be aware of that.
- 16:36It probably fits into exceeding powers. But nonetheless,
- 16:40it floats around. It's very difficult to show
- 16:44that. You have to show that the arbitrator knew
- 16:48and understood the law and made a conscious decision
- 16:52that he or she wasn't going to follow the law.
- 16:58There are very few opinions that find manifest
- 17:04disregard of the law. And as you pointed out,
- 17:07Mike, I know that A number of circuits don't
- 17:10even entertain this issue. So let's see, where
- 17:18are we next? So slide seven, Rich, I turn it
- 17:21to you. Did I skip that? Hang on just a second.
- 17:30Oh, well, I think I discussed slide seven, so
- 17:33we can go on to slide eight. So Mike, did you
- 17:41want to? Yeah, so I'll post it up here. So there's
- 17:44the idea of the exclusive grounds to vacate an
- 17:48arbitration award under the CAA or the FAA, and
- 17:51can you expand those by contract? Arbitration
- 17:54we'll talk about is a creature of contract. So
- 17:56can you, in effect, bind the courts or get the
- 17:59courts to enforce your notion of vacatur? No.
- 18:04Under the Federal Arbitration Act, the Supreme
- 18:07Court addressed this in the Hall Street Associates
- 18:09case. The exclusive grounds are in the statute.
- 18:13The court read the statutory text as mandatory.
- 18:16It's a limit. It's a limit on freedom of contract.
- 18:20And the court says it preserves the finality
- 18:22and efficiency of the arbitration by avoiding
- 18:26creating really a second level of litigation.
- 18:31California had a contrary decision. Rich, you
- 18:33can talk about this pretty soon after that. Right.
- 18:37Just a few months after the US Supreme Court
- 18:41said you couldn't expand the FAA's jurisdiction.
- 18:48The California Supreme Court came to the opposite
- 18:50conclusion. And the basis for the ruling was
- 18:57this, that arbitration is a matter of agreement
- 18:59between the parties. The parties can limit the
- 19:02arbitrators powers by agreement, the scope of
- 19:06the arbitrators, of how the arbitrator will conduct
- 19:10the arbitration. If they can alter the usual
- 19:14scope of review and that will be honored by the
- 19:19court. So if there is an agreement that expressly
- 19:25deprives the arbitrator of power to commit legal
- 19:28error, then if the arbitrator violates that limit
- 19:35on the arbitrator's powers, then the arbitrator
- 19:39has essentially exceeded the powers he was given
- 19:43under the arbitration contract. A violation of
- 19:46this results in the, could result in overturning
- 19:54the arbitration award. So essentially you get
- 19:59judicial review, just as if you had appealed
- 20:03from the judgment in superior court. be very
- 20:10careful about how you structure the clause essentially
- 20:18granting judicial review, appellate review of
- 20:21your arbitration. Because provisions requiring
- 20:26an arbitrator simply to apply California law,
- 20:30the Supreme Court has held that just leaves open
- 20:34the possibility that the arbitrator will apply
- 20:37the law incorrectly. the clauses have to restrict
- 20:42or limit the powers of the arbitrator. In fact,
- 20:47that word should probably be included within
- 20:51the arbitration clause. All right, so on to the
- 21:01next slide, Mike. If we don't or parties don't
- 21:08have that kind of agreement in the contract,
- 21:10what can Is there another alternative? Can they
- 21:15appeal internally to the arbitration provider?
- 21:19So the focus of our presentation here today,
- 21:20yes, there is another way. In the hypothetical
- 21:24we had, we said assume it's a standard dispute
- 21:28resolution clause. Maybe it's been cut and copied
- 21:30for decades. There is another way which is including
- 21:34in that standard contract or including in your
- 21:36new contract a provision that the parties can
- 21:39appeal inside. the arbitration itself, so you're
- 21:41still in the arbitration form. This has been
- 21:47around probably for a long time, probably since
- 21:53the early 1900s even later in trade organizations.
- 21:56It was very common for a trade organization to
- 21:58have an orbital process. You could appeal it
- 22:00up to a national committee. The large national
- 22:03EDR providers started adopting these in about
- 22:051999 into the early 2000s, and now many of them
- 22:09have these arbitration procedures to appeal the
- 22:14first level award. Ultimately, with that, arbitration
- 22:20is a creature of contract. This is a basic action
- 22:24that courts repeat all the time. The parties
- 22:27have delegated, basically, decision -making power
- 22:31to an arbitrator that they appoint. Their agreement
- 22:35defines the process, and courts will enforce
- 22:39it. Parties, courts will enforce the arbitration
- 22:47agreement. They'll also enforce, and there are
- 22:49many cases in this area, the appellate arbitration
- 22:52rules or the appellate arbitration processes.
- 22:55There is a concept, I teach a law school course
- 22:58on arbitration. And when I do that, I talk about
- 23:01this idea of arbitrate your way, that the parties
- 23:04can really design a dispute resolution process,
- 23:07an arbitration process as they wish with whatever
- 23:11procedures they want. so long as they're not
- 23:14unlawful. And that gives the parties a lot of
- 23:16autonomy to do that. Rich, if you want to start
- 23:24us off with what is an arbitration on appeal?
- 23:29Yes. As we mentioned before, this is all contractual.
- 23:33So I mean, how do you invoke this option? Well,
- 23:38there are a number of ways. If it's in the arbitration
- 23:41agreement and in language that I Just mentioned
- 23:45that is it's expressly provided for in the arbitration
- 23:48agreement. Then you have this option to appeal
- 23:52to the. Providers appellate panel. And so this
- 24:01usually involves the parties after you've given
- 24:04a notice of the appeal. The parties will get
- 24:07together and select how many arbitrators they
- 24:10want is possible to just select one appellate.
- 24:13arbitrator or to have a panel, a tripartite panel.
- 24:18We usually have three for jams. Of course, like
- 24:25the underlying arbitration that occurred, this
- 24:29also is a private endeavor conducted within the
- 24:34providers' rules. And the appellate decision
- 24:41becomes the final award, and this is for most
- 24:45providers. Judicate West has a little bit different
- 24:47take on this. We'll talk about that in a few
- 24:52minutes. Essentially, the appellate panel at
- 24:58Judicate West can remand to the original arbitrator,
- 25:02but the other providers that we mentioned in
- 25:04our article and that we'll discuss today, Make
- 25:09a final decision and the decision of the appellate
- 25:14panel becomes the final award and that is what
- 25:18you may seek to. Challenge if you prevail, you're
- 25:25going to you're going to file a petition to confirm
- 25:26with spirit court. If you're the agree party,
- 25:30you will file a petition to vacate or modify
- 25:34the appellate decision, which is the. final award.
- 25:41Just to emphasize some small language we have
- 25:44on the bottom that's important, the appellate
- 25:46process is not what we just described under the
- 25:50California Arbitration Act, where the parties
- 25:52can contract for expanded judicial review. This
- 25:55is before you ever get to court. So this is a
- 25:57separate procedure. Thanks. Yes. So how does
- 26:02an arbitration appeal work? Mike, you want to
- 26:06fill us in on that? So, the basics of an arbitration
- 26:10appeal are the mechanics. We're using four providers.
- 26:16They're the AAA, JAMS, Judica West, and NAMM,
- 26:20purely for example purposes, for exemplar purposes.
- 26:24There are other providers out there that provide
- 26:27appellate services, so we're not endorsing any
- 26:29of these. or commenting on them other than laying
- 26:33them out for what the provisions say. But start
- 26:36with finding a provider. Not all providers have
- 26:40appellate processes, but some do, as we're highlighting.
- 26:46You can be in one provider for the actual arbitration,
- 26:49the hearing, and then appeal to a different provider.
- 26:52So you could do that as well. You could have
- 26:55your own private ad hoc arbitration, presumably
- 26:58an incorporate a rule set. Each provider that
- 27:01we have on here has a rule set. And some providers
- 27:05here, interestingly, a different posture, would
- 27:08hear an appeal from a trial court decision. So
- 27:11the idea of getting a decision from a state trial
- 27:15court. And then similar to mediating an appeal,
- 27:18you can arbitrate an appeal. And there might
- 27:19be some reasons you wish to do that. I don't
- 27:22know how common that is. But some of the providers
- 27:24will also entertain your your actual appeal from
- 27:28a court judgment. When looking at these rules,
- 27:32there are a number of things you're going to
- 27:33want to take note of, and we'll go through them.
- 27:36And we list them here, standard of review, deadlines,
- 27:41arbitrator selection, which Justice Aronson went
- 27:43over, the record, new evidence, and remand authority.
- 27:53So let's look at the rules now that are involved.
- 27:59from the various providers, and you can see that
- 28:05there is some differences in how the process
- 28:09is initiated and how the agreement to appeal
- 28:16works. So as we mentioned, obviously, if you've
- 28:20contracted for it in the arbitration clause,
- 28:22then it is an option for you. You don't have
- 28:25to use it. Parties But the parties may be satisfied,
- 28:31both parties may be satisfied with the underlying
- 28:34award. But if you do choose to use it, then keep
- 28:42in mind that you can, if you don't have an agreement
- 28:46providing for an internal appeal to the provider,
- 28:50you can always agree later on to do that. And
- 28:54obviously, the time to agree is before you get
- 28:59involved in the arbitration. You want to do this
- 29:04at the outset, usually at the preliminary arbitration
- 29:12management conference. And especially so if the
- 29:18stakes are high in the litigation. So both parties
- 29:21might want to have this option. So you can agree
- 29:26anytime. You can agree also afterwards. Now,
- 29:30it's very unlikely that the winner of an arbitration
- 29:34award will agree to an appeal if it's not in
- 29:41the arbitration agreement. There might be situations
- 29:44where that happens though. For instance, if one
- 29:50side The winner is dissatisfied with the amount
- 29:53of damages that were awarded. Perhaps the winner
- 29:56feels that the arbitrator made a mistake and
- 29:59should have awarded more damages. The losing
- 30:03party, which may feel that the arbitrator never
- 30:07should have imposed liability on the client.
- 30:13And so in that limited situation, perhaps the
- 30:16parties might agree to an arbitration appeal.
- 30:20But if you've lost, and then you approach your
- 30:23opponent, and your opponent's won, don't count
- 30:27on it. I mean, it's just as likely to happen
- 30:31that there's going to be an agreement to arbitrate.
- 30:35OK, with that, then let's turn to the steps that
- 30:41are involved in an appeal. On the notice, there
- 30:47are certain time limits. Jams, for instance,
- 30:51as we'll see, has a 14 -day notice of appeal.
- 30:58The right to cross -appeal exists, and almost
- 31:03all the providers provide for that. The panel
- 31:08usually involves three by default, but the parties
- 31:13may agree to one arbitrator if they do that.
- 31:20I don't know an arbitrator that would not honor
- 31:22that agreement. And when filing the appellate
- 31:28record, hopefully, especially if the case involved
- 31:32a lot of money, a lot of issues that are important
- 31:38issues and that are very consequential to your
- 31:40clients in terms of money or other matters. hopefully
- 31:47you have a transcript that you can provide the
- 31:49appellate panel. That makes things a lot easier.
- 31:53If you don't have an appellate transcript, then
- 31:56I think that it's likely then that the panel
- 32:00will rely on any factual findings made in the
- 32:03final award by the underlying arbitrator. And
- 32:08if there's a discrepancy, if you feel that the
- 32:10arbitrator below left out some material facts
- 32:14in the Now, in the award, then you have the option,
- 32:20I think, to try to come or try to form a settled
- 32:24statement on appeal. But again, if the prevailing
- 32:32party satisfied with the is likely to be satisfied
- 32:36with the final award issued by the arbitrator,
- 32:39then getting an agreement on a settled statement
- 32:41is going to be very difficult. The best option.
- 32:46is to, especially if it's a high stakes case,
- 32:49is to have a court reporter take down the proceedings
- 32:54and create a transcript for review later on.
- 32:59The briefs, in arbitration, they're compressed
- 33:02schedules and page limits. The underlying arbitration
- 33:09procedure for these appellate providers, the
- 33:13providers are, They're designed to quickly process
- 33:16this. I know JAMS, I think, requires a decision
- 33:21after oral argument or submission on the briefs.
- 33:25I think it requires a decision within 21 days.
- 33:28Other providers, it's usually around 30 days.
- 33:32But in any event, this is designed to be a quick
- 33:35procedure, not like the procedures that you would
- 33:40face. or the delays that you would face in an
- 33:43appellate court. And usually there's oral argument.
- 33:48I have a preference for oral argument if it's
- 33:51a serious case and the issues are close. At Jams,
- 33:56in fact, if both parties request it, then the
- 33:59panel must provide oral argument. So those are
- 34:05essentially the main steps in the appeal. Mike,
- 34:11what about the deadlines that are involved? Thanks,
- 34:16Justice. So the deadlines are critically important,
- 34:19just as they are in court if you're taking an
- 34:22appeal from a trial judgment. And the dates are
- 34:27different, right? The AAA, you have a 30 -day
- 34:30window to appeal. Jams is 14, Judica West 20,
- 34:35NAM is 21. And these typically are triggered
- 34:38by service. AAA will call it submission to the
- 34:43parties. There is not a lot of case law here.
- 34:46I don't know if there's any, maybe some you can
- 34:49interpret, but these are jurisdictional in the
- 34:52sense that the arbital panel, I don't believe,
- 34:55and again, this would have to be briefed and
- 34:57decided, but from what cases there are, it doesn't
- 34:59look like the arbital panel can extend these
- 35:02deadlines. The final award, the arbitration proceedings,
- 35:09become the final award at the end of them, but
- 35:11until the arbitration panel has the case, the
- 35:16award does not open back up from the final award
- 35:18into a pending award. There are dates on the
- 35:23cross appeals, if there is a cross appeal. Judica
- 35:27West does not address the issue, so that's something
- 35:29we would want to note and perhaps take up with
- 35:32them. If you come there, as Justice Aronson mentioned,
- 35:38there are decision due dates that are pretty
- 35:40expedited. The same with oral argument. It jams,
- 35:43right? As you mentioned, the parties can ask
- 35:45for it, or you can order it. But places like
- 35:47the AAA have a presumption of oral argument on
- 35:53the papers, which could be a process to expedite.
- 35:57We've gone over the award that Mike, just before
- 36:01you leave that, I just want to mention. It might
- 36:04look like 14 days is a pretty short time to decide
- 36:07whether to appeal, especially if there's a long
- 36:11transcript to review. Even in our arbitration,
- 36:20the decision can be costly and time consuming.
- 36:28So is that enough time? 14 days should be enough
- 36:31time, because remember, the arbitrator is going
- 36:34to issue an interim award. And so you'll be familiar
- 36:39with the reasoning, the logic of the award. And
- 36:42then the arbitrator then has to issue a final
- 36:47award. And that usually involves awarding costs
- 36:50or attorney's fees or making a decision on maybe,
- 36:54for instance, who the prevailing party is. Those
- 36:57issues you can decide. pretty quickly as to whether
- 37:01it warrants an appeal or not. So again, the providers,
- 37:06and especially Jams, is interested in providing
- 37:10the benefits of arbitration to the parties. And
- 37:13that, I think, is the reason why we have a 14
- 37:16-day rule. Other outfits, other providers, as
- 37:19you can see, give you a bit more time to decide
- 37:24whether to appeal. And these are dates for the
- 37:28notice of appeal, not for the full briefing on
- 37:30the appeal, which the panel will set under the
- 37:32rules. OK, so now this becomes pretty important,
- 37:41the standard of review. And each provider that
- 37:46we looked at has a different definition of how
- 37:55the arbitration appeal is reviewed. Jams says
- 38:02that the same standard of review that a first
- 38:05level appellate court in the jurisdiction would
- 38:09apply to an appeal from the trial court decision.
- 38:13That means that you're using the standard that
- 38:18the court of appeal would apply. So let's discuss
- 38:22that. And this one standard you must be aware
- 38:25of here is the substantial evidence rule in California.
- 38:30That is a review of the facts. Remember, under
- 38:36California law, the decision on appeal, the lower
- 38:41court's decision is presumed to be correct. All
- 38:44inferences are drawn in favor of the judgment
- 38:47or in this case, the final award. The substantial
- 38:51evidence standard is applied to the factual findings
- 38:55by the arbitrator. substantial evidence is defined
- 39:02as evidence that is of ponderable legal significance.
- 39:06In other words, it's credible and it looks like
- 39:09it has some solid value. So in review, the appellate
- 39:14court and the jams appellate court will just
- 39:18search for evidence, factual evidence to support
- 39:22the underlying arbitration award. it's highly
- 39:28deferential. So once there is, or the appellate
- 39:33panel spots evidence, substantial evidence that
- 39:37supports the arbitrator's finding below, then
- 39:41that factual finding will be adopted by the appellate
- 39:45panel, even if the appellate panel would have
- 39:49come to a different conclusion. It doesn't matter
- 39:52if the weight of the evidence is more convincing
- 39:56to the appellate panel, that is, the weight of
- 39:58the evidence favored the losing party, the appealing
- 40:01party. If there's substantial evidence supporting
- 40:04the decision below, then that's it. You're stuck
- 40:08with those factual findings. It's different in
- 40:15other providers have a different rule. For instance,
- 40:19in the AAA, the error of law has to be material
- 40:24and prejudicial. and determinations of fact have
- 40:27to be clearly erroneous. That's still deferential,
- 40:32but not like the Jams Substantial Evidence Rule,
- 40:35or not the Jams Rule, it's the Appellate Rule
- 40:37in California. So despite evidence, substantial
- 40:43evidence that may support the award, the panel
- 40:46may still conclude the arbitrator's factual conclusions
- 40:49were wrong. So what they're doing, or they have
- 40:53the authority That is, under the AAA, at least
- 40:56the way I read that standard, is to weigh the
- 41:00supporting evidence versus contradictory evidence.
- 41:04And so, as you can tell, if they have the ability
- 41:08to do that, it's not nearly as deferential as
- 41:11the substantial evidence rule. And Judicate West,
- 41:19it sounds to me, and I don't know whether institutionally
- 41:23there's a different way to interpret this, but
- 41:27it sounds to me like the panel makes a de novo
- 41:30determination again. In other words, it's like
- 41:33another arbitration using the identical standard.
- 41:37Perhaps there's some deference there. I'm unfamiliar
- 41:40with how the rule works, but you should be aware
- 41:43of that, that you might be signing up if you
- 41:47have an arbitration appeal at Judica West. You
- 41:50might be signing up for another arbitration.
- 41:53That may not be very satisfactory to the prevailing
- 41:57party in the below. So keep that in mind. Mike,
- 42:02what about the remedies that are available? So
- 42:07you might think, what does the panel do if they
- 42:10disagree? At the AAA jams, there's no remand.
- 42:17So Rich, you can maybe talk about what you're
- 42:20doing in that situation. But let me go to Judith
- 42:23at West. They do send it back. The panel will
- 42:26not take evidence. Most remedies will go back
- 42:28to the original arbitrator who heard the case.
- 42:31NAMM's rules are silent, and so there might be
- 42:34some institutional process. The panel may affirm.
- 42:39They may reverse. They may modify. Rich, have
- 42:43you had the opportunity to handle a case like
- 42:46this at JAMS where there was an error, but you
- 42:51couldn't remand? Or how would you approach a
- 42:53case like that? Yeah, under the jams rules, remand
- 42:58is not an option for the appellate panel. If
- 43:01this was an appellate court, there are instances
- 43:03where we would have remanded the trial court,
- 43:05for instance, to make certain factual findings.
- 43:08The appellate court doesn't, in California, the
- 43:10appellate court has no ability to make or does
- 43:13not make factual findings on an appeal from the
- 43:18judgment below. Can't remand. So what are the
- 43:24options for the Jams appellate panel? Reopen
- 43:29the evidence. Make the decision themselves. That
- 43:31is provided for in the rules. So again, keep
- 43:39that in mind. And then the rules for the different
- 43:43providers, we have them on the bottom of the
- 43:44slide, do address new evidence on appeal. As
- 43:47Justice Anderson is saying, you can at Jams reopen
- 43:50the record at some of the other ADR firms that
- 43:54have different standards and different limitations.
- 44:08So this one, yours or mine? This would be you.
- 44:12This is me? Yes. Oh, OK. I have you written down
- 44:16here, but that's all right. I think I mentioned
- 44:20this before, but once the appellate decision
- 44:23hands down the decision, it becomes the final
- 44:27award. And so that is what you. That is what
- 44:35you challenge in the Superior Court. You can't
- 44:38go directly to the Appellate Court. You go to
- 44:40Superior Court and challenge in a motion to vacate
- 44:43or a motion to confirm if you prevail. So keep
- 44:48that in mind. And then the court will enter a
- 44:50judgment or a dismissal. And that is what you
- 44:54appeal from, not the final award in the arbitration.
- 45:02I want to talk about this case very briefly in
- 45:04the Southern District of Texas. Sure. So the
- 45:06final award becomes, as Justice Erin was saying,
- 45:11the orbital award. But the arbitration panel
- 45:14itself might introduce a new error. It could
- 45:18be something relating to the claims that was
- 45:21below. But in this province case, the claim of
- 45:25error was that the arbitration panel itself decided
- 45:29the case without a transcript. that the argument
- 45:31was required under the AAA rules. The court rejected
- 45:35the challenge, but it does show that the arbital
- 45:37panel itself might provide a new basis to make
- 45:41it. So should you use an arbitration appeal?
- 45:48There are a lot of considerations that an advocate,
- 45:51a counselor would want to consider in approaching
- 45:56the issue of including this in your arbitration
- 45:58agreement or agreeing during the arbitration
- 45:59process. And so what would you put in the clause?
- 46:12There are a lot of standard things we put in
- 46:14arbitration clauses in general. And similar to
- 46:17that, you're going to want to put the appellate
- 46:18provider's rules by name. There are some cases
- 46:22out there that say the bare right to appeal inside
- 46:26the arbitration may not be enough to actually
- 46:29invoke an appellate process. So rules by name,
- 46:32you may want to put the date of the rule, since
- 46:34rules do change sometimes to avoid any motion
- 46:37practice or defect there. Most likely, you're
- 46:41going to want to require a reasoned award called
- 46:46the trial arbitrator by the initial arbitrator
- 46:49so the appellate panel has some reasoning to
- 46:53consider. As Justice Aronson has said, a transcript
- 46:57could be incredibly important. So while the underlying
- 47:02rules may not require a stenographer, consider
- 47:05whether you want one. One of the providers in
- 47:08the absence of a transcript, will ask you to
- 47:11have a settled statement. You may want to put
- 47:13that in the clause itself to forestall any argument
- 47:16later. And as we talked about, you can have one
- 47:20arbitrator. You could have three. I suppose you
- 47:22could have more. Figure that out in your contract
- 47:26itself. Finality, while the case law may give
- 47:30you some guidance here, what happens to the deadlines?
- 47:34the court deadlines during your appeal. The case
- 47:37law seems to be that the appeal will stay your
- 47:40deadlines, but don't follow my guidance on that.
- 47:42Check the rules. And be careful. We look to California
- 47:48law specifically. There are cases that have struck
- 47:52down appellate arbitration provisions where they
- 47:55are substantively unconscionable. One was, it's
- 47:59typically when the court believes that they're
- 48:01one -sided, oftentimes in the employer -employment
- 48:05relationship and employee, excuse me, employer
- 48:08-employee relationship where only one side can
- 48:11appeal or certain dollar thresholds make the
- 48:14clause unconscionable. So be careful when you're
- 48:17writing them. Mike, before we leave this, is
- 48:21there a sentence, an essential sentence that
- 48:23you would put in an arbitration clause? Yeah,
- 48:26so I would focus on the the provider and the
- 48:32rules it the cases that are out there have some
- 48:35cases that are out there have found clauses defective
- 48:38where they don't sufficiently adopt a rule set
- 48:41so that the other party the the Non -appealing
- 48:44party has no idea what the arbitration process
- 48:47could look like And what their exposure might
- 48:50be and these are some of the cases that we have
- 49:01identified. There are many more The little case
- 49:04seems to be one case that's often cited where
- 49:08an employment agreement where the arbitration
- 49:11clause was one sided, the employer had the right
- 49:14to appeal, the employee could not. It was a $50
- 49:17,000 threshold. There's contrary case law. We
- 49:22have this Texas case. Take a look at the cases.
- 49:26They come out a variety of ways, but when you
- 49:28have a dollar threshold, be particularly cautious.
- 49:32If an appellate arbitration clause is struck,
- 49:37courts will look to severability. And they often
- 49:38will be severed where the underlying arbitration
- 49:41clause will be saved, putting on an issue to
- 49:44flag. The little case is interesting. The threshold
- 49:51award issue, there's some dispute about that.
- 49:58So in that particular case, It was an employment
- 50:02case. It was a wrongful termination action, I
- 50:06think. And so on appeal in the Supreme Court,
- 50:12the employer argued that this was not an unconscionable
- 50:18provision. It made sense. There was a rationale
- 50:21for supporting it. And that is that anything
- 50:24below the $50 ,000 threshold was just Too de
- 50:30minimis to bother with it. They should the final
- 50:33award should Should stand and that only matters
- 50:37exceeding $50 ,000 In other words where those
- 50:42stakes were raised that's when the appeals should
- 50:46be available Some courts have bought that in
- 50:50the past, but the California Supreme Court did
- 50:52not especially in the context of unemployment
- 50:54litigation because Well, that was rational way
- 51:00to view things. It was one sided. That was certainly
- 51:04would help the employer who have the employer
- 51:10that has more resources and and is likely to
- 51:17want to appeal a judgment against it that exceeded
- 51:21$50 ,000. But if the employee claimant. received
- 51:28no award, nothing at all, then that employee
- 51:33could not appeal because of the $50 ,000 threshold.
- 51:37That bar was deemed unconscionable by the court.
- 51:43So keep that in mind when you're contemplating
- 51:48or if you're drafting and going to incorporate
- 51:54the option of an internal appellate procedure
- 51:57in your arbitration clause. Okay, deciding whether
- 52:03to include an appeal in your arbitration clause.
- 52:08Mike? So these considerations cut both ways as
- 52:11we put here, right? So favoring appeal, oftentimes
- 52:15you might think a large potential exposure would
- 52:17justify the cost of an appeal, whereas a lower
- 52:20value would not. Are the legal issues important?
- 52:23Are they novel? Do they relate to an ongoing
- 52:26business relationship where you want to get some
- 52:28certainty? Or is it backbound, deference? It's
- 52:33a difficult case to vacate. You just don't want
- 52:36to go there. Think about finality and speed,
- 52:39the delay, potentially the expedited nature of
- 52:43the appeal, but the delay of having one. There
- 52:48are cost provisions in all of the rules, some
- 52:51more detailed than others. that could be a driver
- 52:54for you. And who bears the cost is also an issue
- 52:57that we're not going into, but one that would
- 53:01warrant some investigation. Again, is this an
- 53:05ongoing relationship or a one -off dispute? Are
- 53:08there many disputes like this that come about?
- 53:14So favor and appeal, you would have one arbitrator
- 53:17below, a panel on appeal. coming against and
- 53:24you're worried how they're handled. Enforceability,
- 53:32you have a negotiated contract in the commercial
- 53:34sense, but commercial employment contracts are
- 53:37sometimes excluded from, at least these providers
- 53:39would like that. Not all of them are sometimes
- 53:41excluded from the cases that they will administer.
- 53:46You do get the benefit of errors can be corrected
- 53:48before finality. As Justice Emerson said at the
- 53:50beginning, I think there's a 50 % a modification
- 53:53reversal rate here. But there could be a delay
- 53:58in leverage for the losing side. On the delay
- 54:04issue, if you're concerned about that, this is
- 54:11still a speedy process. The parties will select
- 54:17the three panel judge. And you can, in inquiring
- 54:29about who to select, you can have the case managers,
- 54:35at least at JAMS, check with the people, the
- 54:39neutrals you're thinking about selecting to see
- 54:42if they have any scheduling conflicts. A lot
- 54:46of neutrals will be too busy to immediately...
- 54:50tackle your appeal. But there are plenty of neutrals
- 54:53that will have an option or have an opening to
- 54:59get in and decide the appeal right away. So that's
- 55:02something to think about in selecting the panel.
- 55:14Okay, building the record. I can't emphasize.
- 55:20In fact, I've been on panels where the tripartite
- 55:24panels where we just order the parties to have
- 55:30a court reporter in a very complicated arbitration.
- 55:34I have one coming up that we're just going to
- 55:36tell the parties. We're not scriveners. We can't
- 55:41evaluate the demeanor of the witnesses and take
- 55:45down notes as to what's said. And I know it can
- 55:49be costly, but usually the parties will split
- 55:52the costs. And if they're more than two parties
- 55:55and it's a It might be, it's still better to
- 55:59do this. You're going to avoid a lot of headaches
- 56:01down the road by having a court reporter. It's
- 56:04just essential for us in a complicated case to
- 56:08have a transcript. So whether to, and we were
- 56:16talking about whether to employ this, the appellate
- 56:21option in arbitration. So what does that do when
- 56:28the parties know at the outset that there's a
- 56:33potential appeal? My view is that it tends to
- 56:39formalize things a little bit. It's a spur, it's
- 56:44an incentive to the parties to create a complete
- 56:47record. It's much like being in court. there's
- 56:55more formality and that's good for the arbitrator
- 56:59as well as it is for the lawyers. I've reviewed
- 57:06a transcript where the arbitration is going to
- 57:11get pretty informal. You work together, you're
- 57:14in this either a room or you're on Zoom. I reviewed
- 57:22one transcript where the arbitrator was calling
- 57:24the lawyers by their first name. Maybe I'm old
- 57:28fashioned, I don't know, but it just seemed a
- 57:31little too familiar. Knowing that there's an
- 57:37appeal, I think it's better for everyone that's
- 57:42involved to keep that in mind and ask for a reason
- 57:46record. It might remind you also to create a
- 57:51complete offer of proof. This is one of my pet
- 57:57peeves, I guess, and that is that lawyers either
- 58:01forget to make an adequate offer of proof or
- 58:04don't make one at all. If you recall, when we
- 58:09were talking about statutory grounds to challenge
- 58:12in California, to challenge a denial of request
- 58:18to continue the the hearing, one of the ways
- 58:24to get that arbitration award overturned is that
- 58:29if there was good cause, upon a showing of good
- 58:32cause is how it's phrased in the statute, and
- 58:34the arbitrator denies that, you may have a solid
- 58:40ground for obtaining, vacating that award. But
- 58:45too often I have seen where it seemed that the
- 58:50aggrieved party's lawyer failed to make an adequate
- 58:54proof. And that means specifying what the harm
- 58:59is. For instance, we had a case a few years ago
- 59:05where a material witness was unavailable. The
- 59:10witness was crucial to the defense and moved
- 59:12to continue. the hearing and the attorney specified
- 59:17what the witness would testify to. That was fine.
- 59:23That met some of the requirements for an adequate
- 59:27offer of proof. Unfortunately, there was no explanation
- 59:31as to how that would prejudice the party. And
- 59:35on appeal, it's not just that the evidence that's
- 59:42excluded or the denial of the continuance was
- 59:52in error because there was a showing of good
- 59:54cause as to materiality, it still doesn't prove
- 59:58that there was prejudice. Perhaps another witness
- 1:00:00testified to the same thing that the material
- 1:00:02witness would testify to. That is another aspect
- 1:00:07that you should keep in mind when making an offer
- 1:00:09of proof. I'm sorry to get off on that tangent,
- 1:00:11but it just is, I saw that when I was on the
- 1:00:14court and when the appellate court, and I've
- 1:00:16seen it since I joined Jams. Okay, I think that
- 1:00:23brings us to the end and we can tackle any questions
- 1:00:28if there are some. All right. It looks like we
- 1:00:38do have a couple of questions. We have one from
- 1:00:41Richard. How would you both address the following
- 1:00:44dispute regarding the arbitrator's jurisdiction?
- 1:00:47One party wants to argue sections of the CCP
- 1:00:49apply to the arbitration proceeding, while the
- 1:00:52opposing party argues the contract controls the
- 1:00:55arbitrator's jurisdiction and the CCP cannot
- 1:00:58be considered by the arbitrator. Can the losing
- 1:01:00party have this issue reviewed by the court?
- 1:01:07Yeah. If the arbitrator So as Mike mentioned
- 1:01:12earlier, arbitration is a creature of contract.
- 1:01:15If the contract has specified the scope of the
- 1:01:18arbitrator's powers, that prevails over anything
- 1:01:23else. And if the arbitrator exceeds the scope,
- 1:01:28then you're cooking with gas. You might have
- 1:01:32a solid grounds to... vacate the arbitration
- 1:01:36award. All depends on the language in the arbitration
- 1:01:39agreement. And Rich, I'll add there, in vacatur
- 1:01:46courts look at, did the arbitrator interpret
- 1:01:49the contract or did the arbitrator simply make
- 1:01:51a decision and apply their own judgment on policy?
- 1:01:55And this could be a situation where the latter
- 1:01:57occurred. All right, and it looks like we have
- 1:02:06one last question. What is your view of AI note
- 1:02:08-taking apps in lieu of a court reporter? Have
- 1:02:11you seen that approach used? Let me start off.
- 1:02:21My view of it is, it could be helpful, but always
- 1:02:25talk about it, disclose it to everyone else in
- 1:02:30the proceeding, the presiding officer, the opposing
- 1:02:33counsel, and get consent before you do it. But
- 1:02:37these programs, I haven't seen it done in an
- 1:02:39arbitration presided over. I suspect it will
- 1:02:42become more common. Yeah, I think the question
- 1:02:45is, instead of a court reporter that you use
- 1:02:48to record the proceedings. So I haven't encountered
- 1:02:54that yet. I don't know whether it's effective
- 1:02:57or not. Most of the cases that I've had involve
- 1:03:01a court reporter. Lawyers are, you know, lawyers
- 1:03:07are older, used to court reporters. But I imagine
- 1:03:13we will see more of that. All righty, this concludes
- 1:03:21today's presentation. Thank you so much, Michael
- 1:03:23and Judge Aronson for an excellent presentation
- 1:03:26today. And of course, we'd love to thank our
- 1:03:27audience for joining us. Have a great day.