Latest / Five Games for Doomsday / 5G4D News-The Honey Mushroom Episode
Transcript
- 0:07From the kitchen of the cabin. It's the five Games for Doomsday news with
- 0:11Ben and Steve. It's the New Show, Stevie. So thank you for
- 0:18telling me that upfront. Good news. We're doing okay, this section.
- 0:22The news is not very good these days. It's not good at the moment.
- 0:25So this section is usually where we have some banter. And we gave
- 0:29the new patron backers their nicknames. Yeah, yeah, but you said that
- 0:33you have to watch menu or something on the on the tele age exactly.
- 0:36That's not the reason it's going to be quick. The reason it's going to
- 0:38be quick is because tell them the bad news, Stevie. Well, it
- 0:42turns out since the last time we did the New show, which was when
- 0:46last month, because it's a monthly show, are we actually on schedule?
- 0:49Yeah, we haven't missed one. No, oh well since then, no
- 0:52new backers, unfortunately no, so nope, no new backers, not a
- 0:57one, not one new backer, new backers. Where are where are you?
- 1:03That? Crickets? That's crickets? Noise? Ki ki ki ki.
- 1:07So what we're gonna turn this section in. It's going to be very short.
- 1:11I'm not sure I feel like being funny with no new backers, So
- 1:14why am I entertaining? No, this is why if you let me,
- 1:15if you'd let me fucking speak for five fuck you know, you know,
- 1:19can we just like have a fucking can we have like a like a decent
- 1:25conversation for once on this podcast? Like the yelling, the shouting, the
- 1:29recriminations, imputations. I don't appreciate them, Like seriously, I listen to
- 1:34loads of podcasts, and people are able to have civil conversations, in civil
- 1:41discourse on these podcasts. You know, they chat, they talk about interesting
- 1:44topics. You think they just yeah, yeah, there's a little bit of
- 1:48interruption, right, there's a little bit of interruption, But they don't.
- 1:51They don't yell at each other. They don't they don't insult each other.
- 1:53They don't fucking have a go all right, Like fucking Tony Boydell is listening
- 1:57to this podcast right now, and fucking every time you yell at me,
- 2:01he comes that closer to fucking pissing himself and running his car off the road.
- 2:06I am not gonna fucking have an injured, possibly possibly killed in an
- 2:10automobile accident, Tony Boydell on I'm not having that happen on my watch.
- 2:15Ben, I'm not having an incontinent Tony Boydell whose life is in our hands,
- 2:20is all I'm trying to say. Can you please keep it together here?
- 2:22All right? See? So what I'd like you to do in lie
- 2:24of new people, what I'd like you to do is give an impassioned two
- 2:30wish minute speech on why if you were thinking about backing the Patreon to five
- 2:35Games for Doomsday, why you should and go. Thank you for giving me
- 2:39time to prepare my speech. I've been working on this for quite some time.
- 2:43Five Games for Doomsday is, in my estimation, the number one board
- 2:49game podcast on the Internet. And it's not not just a podcast. Ben
- 2:52does videos, he does original content, he's doing interviews. I mean,
- 2:57he is basically producing in I'd like to say he's like one man. I
- 3:02don't want to say content factory. Content is a derogatory term for the kind
- 3:07of work that he's doing. Nobody else is doing this. I listened to
- 3:10a few other board game podcasts, and I can learn a lot from them,
- 3:15but I think Ben's original, idiosyncratic take on things is unequaled, unrivaled,
- 3:21And if you consider yourself a board game fan, then you owe it
- 3:25to yourself to do your part to make sure that Ben can continue creating for
- 3:30you and for me. I myself am a patron as Ben can attest,
- 3:36and I've been so since I've known him since the beginning, because I actually
- 3:39get a lot out of this work. I find it helps me have a
- 3:43greater connection to the hobby to think more about games. And I don't think
- 3:47before I met Ben and encountered his work, I actually thought of board games
- 3:53as objects you could think with the way you would a text or some other
- 3:59work of art. In fact, thought of board games as works of art
- 4:01before Ben, with creators, with designers, with I don't know all of
- 4:06the various facets of interest that art comes with. So I mean, that's
- 4:11what it has meant to me. And you know, contributing a little bit
- 4:15to make sure that this kind of commentary and discourse continues is not much to
- 4:18ask. I'm glad to be part of it. We would love to have
- 4:20you part of it too. That was brilliant, all right, So we'll
- 4:23move off the cuff. So we'll move on to Elizabeth Hargrave. Let's go
- 4:29new So I'm delighted to welcome to the new show, the designer of Wingspan,
- 4:38Tussy Mussy, the upcoming Fox Experiment, and Undergrove Elizabeth Hargrave. Elizabeth,
- 4:43Welcome to the new show. Hi Ben, thanks for having me.
- 4:46So, just to start off, uh, how is it now in the
- 4:53world of being a professional game designer? So, I guess you've been a
- 4:58full time professional game designer now for well knocking on five years or so.
- 5:01How is it? I don't think it's been five years yet, not quite.
- 5:08I quit my day job at the end of twenty nineteen is when I
- 5:11really had nothing else by games. So is then ish? Yeah, get
- 5:16getting close? How is it? I don't know, it's it's kind of
- 5:24sweet. I mean, I feel like my experience as a full time game
- 5:28designer is really unusual because I can actually rely on my royalties as a fairly
- 5:36steady stream of livable income, and my other friends who are trying to do
- 5:43it. It's it's much more of a grind, and I feel so lucky
- 5:47that Wingspan is at the point where I don't feel obligated to grind. And
- 5:55do you have a number of how many how many copies it's sold at this
- 5:58point? The last I heard was one point seven million, but that was
- 6:01months ago. So I interviewed Donald X Vaccarino recently and he said to me,
- 6:09I designed games as a hobby and I cash dominion royalty checks as a
- 6:13job. To what degree is that your life is a game designer? Obviously
- 6:18not dominion. I like that. I mean, I do feel like the
- 6:25process of getting a game through the last stages feels less like a fun hommy
- 6:32and more like a job. Like there are parts of it that are work,
- 6:35but yeah, a good part of it. I don't need to do
- 6:42it for the income anymore, and I do it because I enjoy it.
- 6:46And so I guess not since Matt Leecock in two thousand and eight, really,
- 6:50if we had a designer that's just come from sort of not being present
- 6:56in the industry at all to being, you know, a foremost aim in
- 7:00the industry. To what effect does the wingspan effect? How does it facilitate
- 7:05your ability to get your design seen and you know your foot in the door
- 7:13in the industry. Oh, my foot's definitely in the door. I mean,
- 7:17I think I could probably get a pitch meeting with just about any publisher
- 7:23that I wanted to. I get emails often before the major convention saying are
- 7:28you coming, do you have anything to pitch to us, which is very
- 7:31different from my experience in twenty sixteen when I was called emailing a bunch of
- 7:36publishers trying to set up appointments and some of them just didn't even reply.
- 7:43So, yeah, that's definitely a big change. And you know, you've
- 7:47been sort of intimately involved in the industry for the last sort of three four
- 7:51years. Have you seen any significant changes in the time that you've sort of
- 7:57been a professional game designer. That's a good question. I mean, trends
- 8:05come and go. We're definitely seeing a I don't know, are we going
- 8:09to keep seeing the nature games coming out there have definitely been a bunch in
- 8:13the last few years, but changes sort of more industry wide. I think
- 8:18people are thinking harder about diversity and inclusion, which I can maybe take a
- 8:24slice of credit for, but I think there are larger societal things going on
- 8:28that would probably have made that happen as well. And I think we're just
- 8:33seeing like new generations of gamers, new generations of designers come through, and
- 8:41both of those groups are getting more and more diverse. I think we're seeing
- 8:48it a little bit at the publisher level that as publishers are hiring staff,
- 8:52they're thinking more about diversifying their staff. But I think, yeah, it
- 8:58all starts with needing to get get the population of people who play games to
- 9:05look more like the general public, and then it has to filter through,
- 9:09like designers come from the people who've been playing games a while, and then
- 9:15a lot of publishing people come from people who either have been playing games and
- 9:20you know, volunteering and doing things like that for a while, or just
- 9:24coming from the design world. So that's like can be even more lagged behind.
- 9:30But I do think it's improving, and I think there it's I get
- 9:37less pushback now sometimes if I say something about diversity, then I did back
- 9:41in twenty eighteen, twenty nineteen. So on this, on this sort of
- 9:46question of diversity, it's a conversation I have often with people just sort of,
- 9:50you know, not on microphone, you know, when we're talking about
- 9:54things and my and while I'm not of the opinion that die diversity is a
- 10:00bad thing, and I think the term force diversity of is something of an
- 10:05auxiemoron I don't I don't think, I don't think diversity is a bad thing,
- 10:11so putting the word forced on it doesn't really doesn't really mean anything.
- 10:15But my fundamental criticism, and I think this is a this is because this
- 10:20is a by and large and American led movement, is that I see the
- 10:26diversity question focused solely on aspects of identity, and it's around color, sexual
- 10:33orientation, sexual gender, and all of these sorts of things. And yet
- 10:39I rarely see in the debate aspects of class addressed, and there's very little
- 10:46talk about people who are people who are financially at a disadvantage and campaigning for
- 10:56more diversity across the sort of class divide. And I guess, because I'm
- 11:01a wary old Marxist that I see this gaming still seems to me a very
- 11:05very middle class Dare I say bourgeois hobby? Am I am? I completely
- 11:11off base here? Well? Single game costs sixty or seventy bucks now,
- 11:16right, So right, yeah, sort of by definition, although here in
- 11:18the States, I don't know if this is happening. In Europe, there
- 11:20are a lot of libraries that are starting to have board game collections alongside their
- 11:26books, so you can check out games. You can go to the library
- 11:30and play games for free. So I think people are getting creative about how
- 11:35to get around some of that. And obviously, you know, good game
- 11:39stores will have a good library of games that you can go and play on
- 11:43site for free on game night without having to purchase your own collections. So
- 11:48in that sense, it's except getting more accessible. But yeah, and I
- 11:54would say the same for a game design. It's an expensive hobby if you're
- 11:58going to be going to conventions, if you're going to be even just taking
- 12:03the time, if you have a low paying job, like the chances that
- 12:11you have the time and energy outside of that job to be designing, you
- 12:18know, really can vary from person to personally, I guess. But but
- 12:24yeah, and just like protetyping, things costs money sometimes, right And also
- 12:28also it seems to me that especially pre COVID, but I think this is
- 12:33returning a large part of getting yourself published, getting your foot in the door
- 12:37in the game industry is being able to attend game conventions. And it's not
- 12:41just buying the ticket to the convention, right, it's buying the hotel room
- 12:45for four days, and the transport and the food and all of that sort
- 12:48of stuff. Right, It's a lot and I think COVID might have changed
- 12:52that because a lot of publishers developed the ability to pitch on tabletop, simulator
- 12:56or whatever platform they want to use. I'm not sure that it's necessary to
- 13:05go to a convention anymore. I'll be curious to see how many of them
- 13:09go back to using conventions as their primary pitching platform, because I know for
- 13:16some of them it's an exhausting, grueling process to get half our pitches back
- 13:20to back for three days straight. Like they're not necessarily getting the best of
- 13:28the best that way because they're so exhausted. And I got to that age
- 13:33now where you know, I've started to repeat things, and when i'm when
- 13:37i'm when i'm being particularly self reflective, I see myself saying things like,
- 13:41oh, well, it's not as good as it was ten years ago in
- 13:46terms of quality and things, and thinking, oh my god, you've become
- 13:48that old now. I mean, what do you think in terms of the
- 13:52quality of games that are regardless of who's behind the pen, What do you
- 13:56think generally of the quality of game that have been coming out in the last
- 14:01few years. I think there have been fantastic games that have come out,
- 14:05but there's just so many it can be hard to filter through and find the
- 14:11ones that are right for you. All right, so let's let's move on
- 14:16to while you're actually he having and this is this is the upcoming games you
- 14:20got. So first of all, we'll talk about Undergrove. And this is
- 14:24a game you've designed with someone else. How did that? How did that
- 14:30relationship happen? So Mark is a developer at AEG and he was the developer
- 14:41for Mariposa's, which they published, and we were like two piece it apart.
- 14:48He's a former park ranger. He spent like twenty years being a park
- 14:52ranger in Scotland, and while being a park ranger, he was a huge
- 14:56gamer and got very involved with Legend of the Five Rings, which was published
- 15:03by AEG, and started doing some freelance design for them on the side,
- 15:09and then eventually switched over to being a full time employee at AEG, which
- 15:18is where I met him. So yeah, like he just got what I
- 15:22was trying to do with Mariposa's right away, and we really enjoyed working together.
- 15:30So the head of AG Johnson's, hit us both up and was like,
- 15:35you guys should just design something from scratch together and you know, you
- 15:39can use your worktime to do it, Mark, and so we were like,
- 15:43awesome, let's do it. And then we threw a bunch of ideas
- 15:48around and we were kind of playing around with ideas of like other big migrations,
- 15:54So Mariposa's is about the migration of modern butterflies, what about the wildebeest
- 16:00or other things? But then I also mentioned that I had always wanted to
- 16:04do a game about the fact that mushrooms trade resources with trees, and Mark
- 16:10was like, Oh, that's that's better than anything else we've been talking about.
- 16:14And so here we are. So I've been reading the description of this
- 16:19before we before we met up on it's his undergrove. Is a three X
- 16:25game? Would I be right in assuming that extermination is the x that he
- 16:30is not present? Yes, I'm not sure that that description is actually going
- 16:36to survive. There's a there's a totally different write up on the Age website
- 16:40and they haven't gone back and changed it on Board game Geek yet. But
- 16:44but yeah, one of our playtesters use that term, and we were like,
- 16:47he's not wrong, because you're kind of now I'm gonna forget what the
- 16:49three the other three are you're exploring in the sense that you're building a shared
- 16:56board throughout the game, kind of like uh, you know, a dungeon
- 17:00collar where you'd be flipping over tiles, but you're building out different mushroom tiles
- 17:06on the board and everyone has access to them explore, exploit, and then
- 17:11you're using those mushroom tiles as one of the main actions in the game.
- 17:18You can trade resources with them. So trees you're playing from the point of
- 17:22view, have a tree, you make carbon just as a free action,
- 17:26and then you can trade that carbon to different mushrooms in different ways for resources.
- 17:32What's the less sand oh, expanding. Yes, you're you're playing new
- 17:38little tree seedlings out on that set of mushrooms on the intersections of the tiles,
- 17:47and that's what gives you access to the powers on the tiles. You
- 17:52can't use them until you have built your pieces in the right locations. And
- 17:57so this is the first game you've have published that you designed for someone else.
- 18:03How did you just split up the duties between you? It's not exactly
- 18:07the first one. So the fact experiment. By the end of it,
- 18:12I had added Jeff Frazier to the box because he was a developer on that
- 18:18and sort of came up with a way to fix a problem I was having
- 18:22with the dice that felt so fundamental of the game that he ended up being
- 18:26a code designer. But this is the first one I've start started from scratch
- 18:30with a code designer. How did we I don't feel like we ever sat
- 18:33down and split up the responsibilities. We met pretty much once a week and
- 18:42talked about the game, and we play tested almost once it got to a
- 18:47certain point. We were play testing every week together on table test simulator,
- 18:52often with other developers at AEG, and we also were going off and play
- 18:56testing with our own people in person. And so I do think we have
- 19:06different strengths. Mark likes to plan everything out in his head and I'm very
- 19:10much like, just make the damn thing and see what happens. And I
- 19:15think that that's actually a really good mix, because he can think things out
- 19:21in his head in a way that I can't sometimes, which can save time
- 19:26sometimes, but also if you spend too much time in your head, like
- 19:27you can waste time by not realizing that it's not gonna work. Yeah,
- 19:33So it was a good mix that way, but it was just very collaborative
- 19:37throughout, and we did everything, you know, like all the card information
- 19:42was in a big Google sheets document and the rules were in a Google Deck.
- 19:48So we were just always working in the same document together. We'd have
- 19:52it up while we were talking. Yeah, it was great. I was
- 19:56the nandic person. I was the person that made the files that trans slid
- 20:00the spreadsheet into the mushrooms. That's one of my skills, into the into
- 20:03the tiles. So I'm an absolute nightmare. This is why I don't do
- 20:07creative work with other people, because I'm I find it basically impossible to work
- 20:12with other people because I'm I'm I'm terrible at compromise. I mean, were
- 20:17there ever any moments when working with Mark that you came to any points of
- 20:22contention? And if so, were they difficult to overcome? I think most
- 20:27points of contention are solvable by play testing. I think there's usually a correct
- 20:33answer. And so what are the what are the vital statistics for this?
- 20:40When's it? I believe it's comes to crowdfunding. When's that happening? What's
- 20:47it going to cost? What can we expect to come in the box all
- 20:49of that good stuff? Yeah, it's going to be on Kickstarter. No,
- 20:55the latest date is November seventh, hopefully that won't slip too much.
- 21:00And I do not know the price yet, but it will be a game
- 21:11for one to four players with a bunch of I think fifty something mushroom tiles
- 21:18with beautiful art by Beth Sobol And then you have a set of player pieces
- 21:22that are little tree standees and little discs that are your ceilings, and little
- 21:30bits that are roots that you put around those ceilings. What else some ballcards
- 21:37and sort of what weight are we looking at? Are we looking at sort
- 21:41of Mariposa's wingspan kind of weight? You know, it's interesting. For a
- 21:47while we were asking our playtesters at every playtest how they thought it compared in
- 21:51weight to Wingspan, and we got both that like, some people would think
- 21:56it was heavier and some people would think it was lighter, which is so
- 21:59fascinating to me, and I think it has to do maybe with people's comfort
- 22:06level with different types of games. This game has a spatial component to it
- 22:11that doesn't exist in Wingspan. There's a there's a little more player interaction.
- 22:19You can really suck up carbon that's on the board that other people were hoping
- 22:25to get to you can grab a corner of you know, I really point
- 22:30heavy or good powered corner of the mushroom tiles that someone else would like,
- 22:37those sorts of things that there's no way to really beat up on anyone or
- 22:41take something away from them. But there's there's some more spatial competition than in
- 22:48any of my other games, really, and so I don't know if that's
- 22:51part of what feels easier or harder to people, depending on their their comfort
- 22:56level. And you know, but it is super interesting. So somewhere in
- 22:59that ballpark probably heavier than than Mariposa's. Mariposa's is definitely a little lighter than
- 23:06we expand. And you know, this is another project you've done with AG
- 23:11Why is working with them good? I really like all the staff that I've
- 23:17worked with there, some Mark and some of the other development team, and
- 23:22then our project manager managers Adelheid Zimmerman, who's great. They just they do
- 23:30a lot of advanced planning and are very organized. They put a lot of
- 23:36resources into this game, Like they have this process where they do online play
- 23:40testing for all of their games. Basically, the staff, just like the
- 23:44development stuff, block out their Wednesday every week and they play all of the
- 23:48games that they have in development, and I just think that's a really great
- 23:55process. And then they do outside playtesting as well too course, but yeah,
- 24:02I just I really like the team and I like the way they work.
- 24:06So let's move on then to a game that's already been crowdfunded and he's
- 24:10coming out soon, and this is the Fox Experiment. So firstly, what's
- 24:14the situation with the Fox Experiment? When can people expect to get into the
- 24:17hands? Uh, they're hoping to have some copies at essen, which I
- 24:22am assuming means that it's going to deliver sometime in September or October. I
- 24:30don't know. I don't know if anyone knows the exact date because it all
- 24:33depends on shipping and things. But soon people can have the Fox Experience seen
- 24:40and then it'll be in retail soon as well. And so how has the
- 24:48process been for this one? Going through the process of crowdfunding and then doing
- 24:53development after the project, and then and then getting the game out there?
- 24:57Is this has this been? Was this a first time experience for you or
- 25:03had you gone through it before? Oh? The kickstarter process? Buttonshet used
- 25:10Kickstarter for Tussy Massy, but that's a tiny, light utuine card game,
- 25:15and I ass was done by the time the crowdfunding was was started, right,
- 25:22Yeah, yeah, I mean, so was the Fox Experiment, except
- 25:26they fired the graphic designer in the middle of the kickstarter and the rule book
- 25:32wasn't done, so that was kind of chaos. It was definitely a chaotic
- 25:37process all around, a lot of stuff. Turnover a pantosaurus And to what
- 25:44degree do you do you think that had an effect on the game or did
- 25:47the game come out of that unscathed? Yeah, I mean the game was
- 25:51done at that point, and they ended up hiring Matt Piquette to finish the
- 25:56rulebook, and so it looks fantastic because Matt does great work. And no,
- 25:59I think we'll be fine. I don't know. I don't have my
- 26:02copy yet, but I think it's going to be great. And so for
- 26:07us that haven't played the Fox Experiment yet, give us a brief overview of
- 26:12what the game is. Yeah. So the Facts Experiment is inspired by an
- 26:18actual experiment that is ongoing in Russia that started in the fifties where they took
- 26:27already captive foxes and they started selecting them sort of based on a theory about
- 26:33how dogs might originally have been domesticated, which is that the dogs that were
- 26:40the wolves in that case that were the most curious about humans, the least
- 26:45scared of humans, might have over time sort of self selected to be friendly
- 26:52around humans and domesticated dogs. And so they started doing that with foxes,
- 26:56where they would pick the friendly foxes of each generation and only they would be
- 27:03bred for the next generation the experiment, and over time they started getting all
- 27:07of these physical traits that we associate with dogs. So their ears got floppy,
- 27:11their tails started curling up and wagging, they got spots, and so
- 27:18I'm just always I've known about this experiment for a long time. I think
- 27:22it's really fascinating. It is like a textbook thing that you learn about in
- 27:26genetics. And I really wanted to figure out a way to have generations passed
- 27:37down traits in a board game. And so you're rolling dice to figure out
- 27:41what traits your baby foxes get, and then you actually write on dry erase
- 27:48cards what the traits are that they got because of the because of the dice,
- 27:52and you get to name your fox because it's dry erase. You can
- 27:56do things like that, and then those fox cards that you wrote on with
- 28:02Mark or become the parents for the next generation. And you do that five
- 28:06times, and it's really cool to see that traits emerge over time through the
- 28:11way that the dice sort of build up. There's some sort of engine building
- 28:15to it. And yeah, the person who breaths the friendliest foxes with the
- 28:22most of these traits wins the game. And so you say the experiment.
- 28:26I'd heard about this experiment before I heard about your game, but I had
- 28:30no kind of idea about the results. You say, it's ongoing. Do
- 28:36people have now pet foxes in Russia? There was a time after Glass Noos
- 28:45that they ran out of money and were selling some of the foxes as pets,
- 28:49but apparently they were not really great pets yet, like kind of hard
- 28:56to house train. And I think, So, there's a woman with Nilla
- 29:03Truth, who is still going, who was a very young scientist when the
- 29:07experiment started. She is still associated with the experiment, and she really believes
- 29:15that they will get to the point that foxes could be pets. So we'll
- 29:22see. So I was listening to a podcast on I was listening to a
- 29:27paleontology podcast and they did an episode on They did two episodes, separate episodes
- 29:33on cats and on dogs, and they implied an origin of domestication that essentially
- 29:41human beings didn't domesticate cats and dogs, they kind of domesticated themselves right in
- 29:48that it was beneficial for them to live with humans, and we find it
- 29:51beneficial for them to live with us. To what degree do you think this
- 29:53is plausible? I mean, that's sort of what this experiment was also based.
- 30:00Don was this theory that like the animals that would have hung around the
- 30:04campfire and approached to get food or whatever, you know, those sorts of
- 30:11things would have been the ones that were sort of biochemically predisposed to be let
- 30:17to have less of a stress response around humans. And they think that that's
- 30:23linked to these physical traits that like having sort of more serotonin and less of
- 30:30the stress chemicals in the mother's body when that baby fox is forming actually affects
- 30:37the physical development of the embryo and causes some of these physical traits. It's
- 30:41wild, it's really cool. It's literally not wild, it's domesticating and so
- 30:48and so, when when is the fox experiment going to be in chops?
- 30:55This fall. I don't know exactly when, but you know they got to
- 30:59get it off the boat and through customs and all that. But but definitely
- 31:03followed twenty twenty three, and so you're known as the nature game designer.
- 31:08Essentially, is that for the foreseeable the area that you're going to travel with
- 31:15in game design? Or are you branching out and thinking about doing games with
- 31:19other kind of things. I could see myself doing other themes. I mean,
- 31:25these are ones that are near and dear to my heart because I am
- 31:30you know, I've been collecting mushrooms for twenty years. I've been burning for
- 31:33a long time. So those were sort of passions that I really wanted to
- 31:41work on in a game. But so I'm running out of hobbies to do
- 31:45games about, and now I just have to do cool stuff Like the Fox
- 31:48experiment is one where like that. It's something that I find interesting, but
- 31:52it's not like something I spend time on in my spare time. And so
- 31:59you know, they're there could be subjects like that that are really interesting to
- 32:01me that are not necessarily nature. We'll see. I don't know, I
- 32:06don't know what I'm doing next right now. I'm just working on the next
- 32:07wingspan expansions, So more nature for now. And so finally, how good
- 32:14are chanterrel mushrooms? Oh, they're good, but they're not my favorite,
- 32:21so because because I live in Germany and they call them fiffling a here,
- 32:25and it's a very special thing. There's a flifling a season and every restaurant
- 32:30you go to, every meal comes with them. That's great. Yeah,
- 32:36So what is your hot tip? Just to finish your hot tip for mushrooms
- 32:42for people to try that they probably haven't. Oh, I mean, it
- 32:47depends on what you can get your hands on. Here in the States.
- 32:52It's not that common to see like, well, if you go to a
- 32:54farmer's market, there will probably be someone that's raising oyster mushrooms, which are
- 33:00actually one of my favorites. A lot of people think they're sort of,
- 33:07you know, run of the mill, but I don't know, there's something
- 33:07about them that I really enjoy. It could be that. Also, they're
- 33:13fairly easy to find, and they're pretty good beginner mushroom. It's hard to
- 33:16go too far wrong with them if you, you know, as long as
- 33:20you get someone who knows what they're doing to show you and double check what
- 33:25you're doing before you eat mushrooms from a while, but you can almost always
- 33:29get them at a farmer's market or and grow kits are pretty common now to
- 33:35They're one that's really easy to cultivate because they're just a decomposer, and so
- 33:43you can grow them in sawdust or newspaper, all kinds of different substrates,
- 33:46whereas Chantorell's, as far as I know, are not cultivated because they are
- 33:52one of the mushrooms that has this micro rhizole relationship with trees that undergrove is
- 33:57all about, and like you mature oak trees to form a relationship with the
- 34:04Chanderell's for the Chanderell's to get their carbon from their carbohydrates, and so like,
- 34:13how do you do that as a commercial enterprise? You need one hundred
- 34:17year old oak trees, you know. But I guess though it's kind of
- 34:22nice that not everything is a commercial enterprise, right right, Yeah, excellent,
- 34:29Well, Elizabeth Hargrave, thank you very much for your time, Thanks
- 34:32for having me Ben News. So I am honored to welcome to the new
- 34:42show the designer of the New Stone Maya Hotness Apury, Connie Vogelman. Connie
- 34:49welcome to the new show. Hi. Well, thanks so much for having
- 34:52me. I really appreciate it. I'm excited to be here, and I'm
- 34:54excited to talk a bit about Apiary. Excellent. So to begin, though,
- 34:58because you're a your sort of new face on the scene, can you
- 35:01give us a sort of a potted history. What's your history with games and
- 35:06sort of what your history with designing? Yeah, yeah, absolutely, I
- 35:10know that it's sort of probably not the you know, it's a little bit
- 35:14of an unusual path to go from you know, unsigned to having a you
- 35:15know, Stone Mayer published game. So I'm absolutely happy to talk about,
- 35:19you know, my background in history a little bit. So I started playing
- 35:22games in a fairly serious way, probably almost fifteen years ago. Somewhere ten
- 35:27eleven years ago, oh my gosh, I'm sorry, somewhere around twenty ten
- 35:30or twenty eleven. I was in law school at the time, and I
- 35:34had a friend who invited us over to play a game, and I gave
- 35:37him a lot of side eye because at that point, you know, board
- 35:38games were very much not something that we did. And he's like, don't
- 35:42worry, I promise you'll love this game. And it was Settlers of Catan,
- 35:46and I absolutely did, and that really just sort of kicked off the
- 35:51next few years of my life. That became kind of more and more around
- 35:53board games. After I graduated from law school, I moved to Washington,
- 35:58d C. And really I didn't know a lot of people in DC.
- 36:00So I started joining all of these meetup groups and ended up just in one
- 36:04games group after another after another, and then really kind of building a social
- 36:07life around board games. You know, I tend to be a very introverted
- 36:10person. I don't, you know, see or speak to you people very
- 36:14well, and so having that, you know, eric exercise that way of
- 36:20talking with people was just absolutely wonderful. So then a few years ago,
- 36:24somewhere somewhere around twenty seventeen twenty eighteen, my partner David actually had an idea
- 36:30for a board game and I sort of offered to help in a very kind
- 36:34of secondary capacity. I was like, Oh, I'll hope I can do
- 36:36some of the graphic design stuff. Not that I'm very good at that,
- 36:38but I'm happy to learn and to try. And that was a very short
- 36:42lived effort. I mean that lasted maybe two or three months. We learned
- 36:45a couple of things. One is that we don't design games very well together.
- 36:50We have completely opposite strategies and opposite philosophies. He tends to be very
- 36:53scientific and methodical, and I'm trying to like throw everything at the wall and
- 36:57see what sticks. And I think what we learned at that exercise was that
- 37:00I just absolutely caught the design bug. You know, it's sort of silly,
- 37:04and maybe you can make all these comments about, you know, gender
- 37:07and kind of what we think we can do and how we think of ourselves.
- 37:10But I had never really thought of designing board games until then, and
- 37:13then just absolutely caught the bug. And then a few years later was having
- 37:17a discussion with some friends and we were talking specifically about work replacement and how
- 37:22I think we were talking about the Lords of Water Deep quest. I think
- 37:24it's called Recruit to the Lieutenant or something like that, where you can get
- 37:28another worker for the entire game, and how it's not as interesting as it
- 37:31should be because you basically get if you get the quest at the very beginning
- 37:37of the game, you just kind of do it. If it pops up
- 37:38in the middle or the end of the game, you just don't. It's
- 37:40it's not really a very interesting decision because it's really expensive, so you have
- 37:44to really invest at the beginning of the game, and how that ultimately just
- 37:47wasn't that interesting of a decision. And so we were kind of talking about
- 37:52dynamic work pools, you know what about this idea of workers aging and dying
- 37:55and you know, being added to your pool and leaving your pool. And
- 38:00then from there it just really really clicked that that would be perfect with bees.
- 38:05And then that was kind of the conversation that started Apiary and then I
- 38:07never never really looked back. So that was sort of my origin. That
- 38:10was a little bit long winded, but that was sort of my origins as
- 38:14a gamer and then as a game designer. So the reason we're talking today
- 38:17is because Elizabeth Hargrave put us in touch. And you know, you said
- 38:22you moved to Washington Cheese from around that area, and were you sort of
- 38:27interfacing with her at that time? Were you asking her advice and getting tips
- 38:32on how to enter the world of design and all that sort of stuff.
- 38:36Yes, absolutely, And Elizabeth has been absolutely wonderful throughout this process. I
- 38:42had actually met Elizabeth before Wingspan was even released as part of this our very
- 38:47short lived game design attempt with my partner, and we had met her through
- 38:53that and then started play testing with her and some of the other local designers.
- 38:58There's a lot of really really great local designers in the in the area.
- 39:00You know, Matthew and Melly Dominic Gramfuschett's, you know, Talia Rosen
- 39:05has a new game with fort Circle coming out soon. I'm in Korean Yager.
- 39:08I mean, there's just tons of tons of really great designers in the
- 39:12area, and so we started absolutely interfacing with them, and that really really
- 39:15jump started any kind of design attempts that I was making. It's very much
- 39:21a learned skill, as are a lot of other things, and being able
- 39:23to work directly with those designers and get direct feedback and input from them really
- 39:29accelerated the process. And then this is jumping forward a little bit ahead of
- 39:32time, but I ultimately took Apery to the Stonemayer Design Day in twenty twenty
- 39:37one, and before then, I, you know, emailed Elizabeth and I
- 39:39was like, all right, can you you know, you've obviously worked with
- 39:42Stonemyer, what kind of tips and tricks do you have? And she really
- 39:45kind of pointed me in the right direction. To get those conversations started as
- 39:49well, and so why did you choose Stonelare Is it because just Jamie offered
- 39:53the design day or did you think, you know, this is a nature
- 39:57game stone Meyer have got you know, Wingspan. It was a massive success
- 40:02and it was sort of kickstarted the renaissance of nature games. Or was it
- 40:07a bit of both. It was a bit of It was a bit of
- 40:09everything. Because you know, APII did start out as a be themed game.
- 40:13It was not originally Bees in Space, it was just regular honeybees,
- 40:15and so there certainly seemed to be a natural fit there. At that point
- 40:19in time, I was also one of Stonemyer's playtesters. I was the lead
- 40:22playtester at one point. I had this goes back a few years now,
- 40:27but I got really frustrated with some of the discussions about tapestry and the civilization
- 40:30balance, and for some reason I just messaged Jamie on board game Peek and
- 40:35I was like, I'm so frustrated by this conversation. I have all these
- 40:37thoughts, and he basically responded back. He was very polite and sort of
- 40:40said, Okay, well I don't know about any of this, but would
- 40:43you want to playtest for us. So I had been playtesting for them for
- 40:45a couple of years and really really liked the process and also figured two that
- 40:51there was some kind of vague name recognition there. I mean, you know,
- 40:53it wasn't a total stranger, and then that was actually the reason why
- 40:57I had signed up for the design day. But you know, I'll also
- 41:00mentioned too that you know, Apera uses a work replacement kind of a bumping
- 41:05mechanism, and that's something that was heavily inspired by both Euphoria and Turderstone,
- 41:08which are Stone Myer games as well. So you know, from the beginning
- 41:12they were definitely my number one publisher, kind of like the Dream, just
- 41:16because I thought the fit, you know, the fit was so good.
- 41:19And so how did you then get the game signed? Was it was it?
- 41:25Did it just blow Jamie away the design day? No? Absolutely not.
- 41:31So what ended up happening is, you know, I took it to
- 41:34design day. I had email Jamie ahead of time saying, hey, I
- 41:37have this game. I think it's a really good fit. You know,
- 41:38is there any way you'd consider it? He basically said he'll take a look
- 41:40at design day. As you would imagine, he's very busy at these events
- 41:45saw maybe two or three minutes of the game, but he did send I
- 41:49think a friend to sit in and play through the game. And then after
- 41:52that Jamie had talked with that friend and sort of said, Okay, maybe
- 41:54there's something here. So then after design day, Jamie and I got sort
- 41:59of messaging to messaging back and forth, and one of the very first things
- 42:01that Jamie said was I think this is interesting, but honey you know,
- 42:06but he was aware of Honeybus. I think Honeybus had just come out at
- 42:07that point, and he's like, I think the midweight worker placement B themed
- 42:14market is somewhat saturated. Would you consider moving the game to outer space?
- 42:17And I just remember getting this email. I just remember it vividly and being
- 42:22like, oh my god, Yes, I didn't even think about it.
- 42:23I absolutely love science fiction. I love, you know, some of these
- 42:29kind of alternative futures, alternative pathways. It also solved some design problems.
- 42:32I mean, why are bees developing technologies? I don't know, but it
- 42:36makes a lot more sense if they're much more advanced. And so that once
- 42:39I said yes, I'd consider moving it to space, Jamie and I probably
- 42:44messaged back and forth for another about two months after that. You know,
- 42:47he had some concerns. There were some rough edges. I mean, you
- 42:51know, again, this was my first design. I didn't don't think I
- 42:53had streamlined it super well. There were still a few things that were a
- 42:55little bit awkward. So we actually emailed back and forth quite a bit,
- 43:00and how he really helped me workshop and troubleshoot some of the issues. And
- 43:04so at one point I recorded a playthrough with some friends, you know,
- 43:07and sent that to him, and then ultimately he asked for, you know,
- 43:10a prototype, which I submitted and then that's that was sort of my
- 43:15formal submission and then it was signed from there. And so what was the
- 43:19development process then? And you know, so I'd imagine if I submitted my
- 43:24first design because I haven't designed anything. If I had, I would feel
- 43:32not expert in the room, and so I would defer a lot of decision
- 43:37making to the developer. Was that the case or were there certain sort of
- 43:40things in which you said, no, no, no, this has to
- 43:43remain like this. So that's an interesting question. I think it was actually
- 43:47a very collaborative process for the most part, you know, and I will
- 43:51give Jamie all of the credit in the world for this, but he kept
- 43:53me very involved throughout every single step of the process. You know, they
- 43:59obviously had final say on things, but it was obviously very much a collaborative
- 44:02back and forth. And so, you know, the way playtesting, a
- 44:07lot of the playtesting and development works is once you have a game signed with
- 44:09stone Meyer, they send it out for different waves of playtesting. In each
- 44:13wave of playtesting, they have you know, five or six lead playtesters,
- 44:16each of whom agrees to play the game several times, and then they submit
- 44:20written reports. And so after we got every single written report, Jamie would
- 44:24you know, bundle it all together. He'd send it all to me.
- 44:27He'd send me all of his thoughts and he'd say, all right, these
- 44:30are the comments that we received that I think are the most meritorious. What
- 44:32do you think? And then that would sort of trigger a back and forth
- 44:36of him, you know, saying his thoughts and then me kind of responding
- 44:39and back and forth. And I think almost all of the time we could
- 44:44kind of ultimately come up with something that I think we were both very very
- 44:47happy with. There were I don't think there were any times where we had
- 44:50something where we just absolutely couldn't see eye to eye on which was really an
- 44:54amazing process, and I think again a lot of the way Jamie acted around
- 44:59it really kind of helped me feel empowered to actually give my opinion and be
- 45:04a really active part of the process, because you know, at every step
- 45:06it's this is what I think? What do you think? How do you
- 45:08feel about this? Remember, this is your game and your vision. You
- 45:12know, even though we are the publisher, what do you know? We
- 45:14want to hear from you. And so I've played prototypes, and when I
- 45:23play prototypes, I'm very cognizant that it kind of doesn't feel like a game.
- 45:28It feels like a collection of intellectual concepts. And it's only when it's
- 45:34produced that I play it and I think, oh, here we are,
- 45:37this is the game. The thing with you, has there been a point
- 45:43where you realized, oh, criche, here we are. This is actually
- 45:47a game. I'm going to in some unspecified points of time in the future,
- 45:52have this thing that is so far removed from my initial conception. I
- 46:00mean, honestly, I'm not one hundred percent sure it feels real. I
- 46:02don't think it feels real now. I don't think it ever feels real.
- 46:06I will also comment that I think in some ways I'm my own harshest critic,
- 46:09and so I don't know for me, and maybe it'll be a little
- 46:13bit different. I don't have a final as we're recording this, I don't
- 46:16have a copy of the game yet, but we'll be getting one shortly.
- 46:21It's still never quite felt real to me, to be completely honest, and
- 46:23I think that whenever I play my own game, all I can see are
- 46:28the flaws, and all I can see are all of the decision making that
- 46:30went into the different pieces, some of which I'm happier than others, you
- 46:34know, with how it turned out. I think for me, a lot
- 46:36of it's external validation from other people. You know. When I took the
- 46:38game to that Stonemare design day, that was really a hot and AHA moment
- 46:43for me because I could see people really enjoying the game, and all of
- 46:46a sudden, I'm like, oh my god, I made this thing,
- 46:50and people are excited and they're invested and they're enjoying themselves, and to them
- 46:54it feels like a real game, even though to me it's still, as
- 46:57you said, feels like kind of a collection of mechanisms, and how different
- 47:05is the game you took to the stone my design day from the game that
- 47:09people can receive in the box in a couple of months. Yeah, that's
- 47:16so, that's a really good question. I think the game that they're going
- 47:21to be receiving, is the final version, is certainly much better than the
- 47:22version that I took to design day. I think that during the development we
- 47:28really fleshed out a lot of really interesting elements of the game that were not
- 47:31originally in the prototype, you know, sort of interesting. I think in
- 47:34this case, the game actually got a fair bit more complicated during development to
- 47:37some of these additional things were added. At the same time, though,
- 47:40I think a lot of the core core mechanisms have stayed the same. I
- 47:45mean, the very first idea for this game was what if you had workers
- 47:49that age, aged and died. Well, now that age and hibernate,
- 47:52but for all practical intents and purposes, that's very much the same mechanism.
- 47:57You know. Similarly, fundamental to the core of the game is this new
- 48:00that as the workers age, they get stronger. As they get stronger,
- 48:02they are able to do more actions. You know, they're able to take
- 48:06more powerful versions of the actions. I mean sort of like these dice playsment
- 48:08you know, a lot of the dice placement games, and that is all
- 48:13stayed very very constant. You know, most of the actions are fundamentally the
- 48:15same actions as they used to be, although your workers interact with them differently.
- 48:21You know. The other big kind of core core concept that stayed the
- 48:23same throat is there are these three types of tiles. They're sort of you're
- 48:27you know, you're building your hive out over the course of the game,
- 48:30and there are tiles that trigger instantaneously, there are tiles that give you an
- 48:34ongoing benefit, and then there are tiles that give you kind of powerful end
- 48:37game scoring. And so that framework stayed very much the same. And then
- 48:40a lot of things changed around the edges. I mean, we changed how
- 48:45exploration is done, so your primary collection of resources this became a shared ship
- 48:51that moves around the galaxy. That was nothing that was ever in the prototype.
- 48:53We added kind of extra strong actions that you can take with your strength
- 48:58for bees, those are your maximum strength bees on all of the action spaces.
- 49:02Things like that were new. We added a Queen's Favor track that deals
- 49:06with basically excess resources. You know, what if you have too many resources
- 49:09in your hive. And we added you know mats as well, hive mats
- 49:14that are basically sort of like the player boards in Arknova that you're building and
- 49:17you're covering specific spaces. I'm sure I'm forgetting a few things, but you
- 49:22know, I think the core is very recognizable. I mean, I think
- 49:23if somebody played the game at design day, they would say, aha,
- 49:27I see. But again, this version is much more rich, it's much
- 49:30more deep strategically, and it's much more refined. So the game comes in
- 49:35the box with twenty factions. How how do you how do you balance those?
- 49:44And how long does that take? Yeah, so, and this is
- 49:47this is a really common question, and I know that, you know,
- 49:50especially with a lot of the Tapestry Sis, there's been a lot of concern
- 49:53about the balance. And the thing that I would say with this is the
- 50:00factions are sort of nudges, so they're not incredibly strong or incredibly powerful.
- 50:05You know. A big part of the concept behind the factions was that not
- 50:08everyone would be doing the same actions all the time. You know, you
- 50:13don't want somebody to be able to have the first five or six or seven
- 50:15turns of the game planned out before the game even starts. And you also
- 50:19don't want all of the players to be competing for the same couple of actions.
- 50:22So a big part of the concept behind the factions were was just to
- 50:27kind of push folks in different directions. And so I would say probably fifty
- 50:30percent of the power or the difference of each faction is just their starting resources
- 50:35and their starting workers. You know, they do have some player powers,
- 50:40you know, and we certainly did our best. I mean, you know,
- 50:44one thing I should mention with the factions too, is that most of
- 50:46the factions actually came in the box at design day. These are things that
- 50:50I had been working on in kind of troubleshooting and play testing even before I
- 50:53brought the game there. We added the basic factions, the sort of starter
- 50:59factions during Stonemayer development, but most of the others had been around sort of
- 51:01since the beginning and just collected a lot of data. You know, Stonemayer
- 51:06now has some data analysts that are pulling in numbers from all of the play
- 51:09tests, and then we were collecting subjective feedback from the playtesters as well,
- 51:13like this feels good, this feels bad? You know, and the other
- 51:15thing too, is there is sort of some amount of underlying math in the
- 51:19game, and so you're trying to estimate, Okay, if this ability is
- 51:22worth two points and it's used five to six times, this is how much
- 51:25it's worth. And so we did really kind of do kind of a multi
- 51:29pronged approach to try to do as much as we can to keep all of
- 51:31the factions balanced, but you know, it's never going to be perfect.
- 51:36The last comment I'll mentioned too, I know I'm sort of droning on,
- 51:38but about balance is it's you know, everyone thinks of it kind of as
- 51:40a single metric, and it's oftentimes not just in the sense that different factions
- 51:45can interact differently, and also different levels of expertise can handle the same faction
- 51:50very differently. I mean, you can have a faction that has a very
- 51:52low floor and a high ceiling versus a faction that has a much smaller swing.
- 51:57And it's hard to really say definitively whether or not those are balanced because
- 52:00so much of it is subjective. And the game is illustrated by Quanchai Mourria,
- 52:07who's something of a rock star in the board game artist world. How
- 52:15cool was it when you saw the ants for the game? Oh my god,
- 52:19it was amazing. I mean, this just is better than anything I
- 52:22could have ever imagined. I mean, he's really brought it to life in
- 52:24a way that's truly phenomenal, you know. And I'll mention too that it's
- 52:29it's bright and it's colorful, and so you have this wonderful starkness of the
- 52:34black. So like the hive matts, for instance, have this kind of
- 52:36black, starry sky around them and then these bright colors, and it's absolutely
- 52:40absolutely stunning, sort of funny. Quanchai actually used to be a beekeeper himself,
- 52:45or I think he did some beekeeping research in college or in grad school,
- 52:50and so he was I think almost just the perfect person to bring this
- 52:52to life too, because he had kind of all of the background and all
- 52:54of this like creativity of like, oh, okay, let's take what we
- 52:58know about current bees, let's expand it extended to the future and really be
- 53:01really imaginedive imaginative about it. Oh, I think it's absolutely perfect. So
- 53:08I'm in the process of designing a game at the moment, and whether it
- 53:14will ever go past you know, a couple of zoom calls with my co
- 53:17designer or art. I'm not sure, but one of the one of one
- 53:22of my sort of goals in designing a game is I want that day where
- 53:28the postman rings the bell and I get the box and open the box and
- 53:32the game box is there with the art and my name across the top.
- 53:37And I speak to a lot of I speak to a lot of grizzled old
- 53:40designers who've designed a lot of stuff, and I tend to ask them these
- 53:44questions, this this upcoming question, and they tend to be quite sort of
- 53:47blase about it. But how excited are you about getting the finished game in
- 53:53your hands? Oh? My god, I am incredibly excited. I am
- 53:57not at all going to pretend to be. I mean have to say that
- 54:00they're pretending. I'm sure where is af after you've published, you know,
- 54:04however many games, But for me, no, I am so excited.
- 54:07I absolutely cannot wait. I know there's a copy on the way to me
- 54:10now. I think I'll have it by the time this episode's released. But
- 54:14no, it's the whole thing has honestly been very very surreal. I mean,
- 54:17as I mentioned at the beginning, I'm very much an introvert, I
- 54:20don't have much of a social media presence, and so going from basically a
- 54:23complete unknown to your name is on the box of the next stone Marrier game
- 54:28has been a completely surreal experience from start to end, and I think it
- 54:31probably will be for quite some time. So can you give us the vital
- 54:36statistics then, so when the game's coming out, how many players it goes
- 54:40up to, how long it takes, and how much it costs, all
- 54:46of that sort of stuff. Yeah, absolutely, So the pricing details should
- 54:51be up by the time this is released, but they're a little bit unknown
- 54:54right now. I think they've said from their web store will be somewhere between
- 54:58seventy and eighty dollars, a little bit less obviously if you're a stone Meyer
- 55:01Champion. The game plays from one to five players, and it is about
- 55:07sixty to ninety minutes. I would say you might be a little hard pressed
- 55:09to get a ninety minute five player game in but I think that should be
- 55:13pretty good at the two, three and four player count. And so,
- 55:19just in terms of dates, it will be available for ordering from October fourth
- 55:23on the stone Meyer site and then it will hit retail in late November.
- 55:28I know they're also working with a few different localization partners for different languages as
- 55:30well, but I'm not one hundred percent sure on the timing on the timing
- 55:35of those, and I know this is going to be rather presumptuous, as
- 55:39this current game is an out yet. But are you working on anything for
- 55:44the future. Yeah, I actually do have a couple of pretty cool projects,
- 55:49not things that I can talk about or anything, but I do think
- 55:51one of them should be announced within the next couple of months, so I'm
- 55:54hoping that that will that will be out soontastic. Well, Colie Vogelman,
- 56:00thank you very much. Well, thank you so much for having me.
- 56:04I really appreciate it. All right, Steve, so because I wrote a
- 56:13brilliant bumper with fucking great music. How was the chat with Elizabeth Hargrave?
- 56:16By the way, it was great? Did you say HI for me?
- 56:21Yeah? Of course I always say hig for me. Okay, good off
- 56:22off off Mike, though why not I'm Mike because I'm not doing admin on
- 56:27air. We do enough of that between us. Okay, you can you
- 56:30can reach out to her. I mean I I did a little, a
- 56:35little, a little text chat with her while I was essen, so some
- 56:37of us. She warned me that they only had a few limited copies of
- 56:40Fox Experience. So some of our friends played Fox Experiment last night and said
- 56:44it was great. They gave it a rapturous report. So I'm interested to
- 56:50play your copy of All right, let's do it. All right, so
- 56:52we'll go to the A M. A. I can't use the great Bumper
- 56:54which random number generation, because you threw your bloody dummy out of the pram,
- 56:59so there's no random I'm a generation? No, No, is it
- 57:00because there's only like one fucking question or something. No. I've just decided
- 57:05to do and you're blaming No. I've decided to do it a different way
- 57:07now. So what I do is before we record the news show, I
- 57:09just go on the discord and then I say to them, you know,
- 57:13any questions for the news Ama, and then I use them. So is
- 57:16this like not the way I always suggested you should do it? I don't
- 57:19know whether you was just that, but every single people want to join the
- 57:22discord, Steve, how would they go about doing that? For fuck's sake?
- 57:25Can you just like record me doing this once? No? Come on,
- 57:29like if you just record it you can just insert it in as a
- 57:31drop. Yeah it drops right, Yeah, but it's less it's less uh
- 57:36spontaneous. You you want the frejon of my desperation having to say the same
- 57:40fucking thing over and over again every episode. Five games are doomsday dot com
- 57:45pinned, post click it invite in patron nickname, five stars, like and
- 57:52subscribe lovely. So doctor asks doctor we met him at as we did?
- 57:59We didn't. He's taken over the hashtag channel threat. Yeah, he thinks
- 58:01he's in charge of now apparently. So, which places, place or places
- 58:07you've so far only ever encountered in or through a board game? Do you
- 58:10want to visit the most? I actually read this question in advance and I
- 58:15thought of two different responses. First of all, dagda, I've been everywhere,
- 58:21so there is no such place. Second I and this is the real
- 58:25answer. I don't know if I'm actually going to do this, but I've
- 58:29mentioned it to you once before. I thought it would be kind of a
- 58:30kind of a lark, kind of a laugh to travel around Germany visiting every
- 58:35town that is featured in Hansa Tutanica. Yeah, that would be great,
- 58:37just as like a thing to do. Have you been to cux Harvard,
- 58:43like Minden and Stada and all these like fucking towns that were important during the
- 58:49Hanseatic period, but like you wouldn't even have heard of them today. Yeah.
- 58:52So there's so many, right, there's so many, and you know,
- 58:55especially now with the Scheffenfeld city things. But I don't know Minge and
- 59:00Cuxhaven and Fuckton. So I can't think of a that was very good,
- 59:07by the way, I can't think of a place that I haven't visited.
- 59:13But I when I visited Bruges for the first time after having played the game,
- 59:21I recognized, shit. I went, oh, though, the buildings
- 59:23they look like that because it's Bruges in that and I thought I was cool,
- 59:28and I think it's a wonderful thing. I think it's a wonderful thing.
- 59:30With board games, yeah, I mean, I definitely. I don't
- 59:34know, like board games make me interested in places and visiting places and history.
- 59:39I've been to Carcassone and I remember going, really, oh no,
- 59:43that's my answer. It's Carcasson. I've never been. I really want to
- 59:45get a Carcasson. That's where I bought my hat, by the way,
- 59:47the floppy hat that you mentioned in a previous episode. So I went to
- 59:52the Carcasson Castle and I went to the gift shop, and I was stunned
- 59:54that they didn't sell the game there, and I asked them about it and
- 59:58they'd never heard of it. Crazy, like, how could you not saying
- 1:00:00you must do it now? Though I don't know, I mean this was
- 1:00:02fifteen years ago, right, like, how can you not sell the carcasso
- 1:00:07on the board game in the gift shop of the Castle's mind blowing? Isn't
- 1:00:09it? All? Right? Well we have our next road trip then,
- 1:00:12yeah, absolutely, Coxon would be amazing. So before we move on to
- 1:00:15the next question, did you realize Steve or you know Caten? Yeah,
- 1:00:20that's not a real play Steve, isn't it? No? Anyway, So
- 1:00:24did you know Steve that this week this is the week of Ben and Steve?
- 1:00:30Why is that? Because beauty sort of scheduling issues and me working and
- 1:00:35and Essen and all that sort of stuff not planning ahead. The hashtag channel
- 1:00:42show came out on Monday, this new show on this Friday. What is
- 1:00:46today? It's Friday? Right now? Yeah, right now, it's Friday.
- 1:00:51De Oh god, I fucking love Friday. Think that fucking what a
- 1:00:53week. I mean, you should be at work as you recorded the show,
- 1:00:57but it's the week of Ben and Steve. What do you think about
- 1:00:59that? Like Ben and Steve in your ears all the time? I mean,
- 1:01:04I expect to see another zero appear after the monthly Patreon contribution. Actually
- 1:01:09is what I expect to see because the week of Ben and Steve. Anyway,
- 1:01:12So the last question is how do you feel about semi co op?
- 1:01:16I think it's one of the most underutilized mechanisms. But I've heard others say
- 1:01:20it doesn't even exist. So who who's asking it is? Steve Elicious ask
- 1:01:27asker Chris. He's a game designer, right, is he? I thought
- 1:01:31so no that I don't know either. Are you a game designer? Let
- 1:01:35us know. I can't keep track anymore. You have so many game designers
- 1:01:38in the discord, in the coolest discord in the Internet. It's so interesting
- 1:01:44question. I just played a semi co op the other night. It was
- 1:01:47Martin Wallace's Chaos co was not a semi co op. It is a semi
- 1:01:51co op. So maybe you have more insight into the question than I do.
- 1:01:53Why do some people say it doesn't exist well, because it's still competitive
- 1:01:58even if it's a right semi So what if, like you're playing Pandemic with
- 1:02:02a bunch of really attractive people. Yeah, I mean I used to drive
- 1:02:07a truck as a younger kid, so I've always I've always got a semi
- 1:02:10on. So but so it's interesting, isn't it that? So people say
- 1:02:16it either doesn't exist or it doesn't work, but I can think of I
- 1:02:21think I could think of a game in which semi copp works wonderfully. Weather
- 1:02:23Machine. No, and it is a game that is I think criminally underrated
- 1:02:30and a game that within our canon is very important. Yes, and that
- 1:02:38is the game of New Angelis from Fantasy Flight game Wow, the er game
- 1:02:44in the Saga of Beninstein, exactly the first game we played together, which
- 1:02:46will never be able to play again because you sold it. No, I
- 1:02:50don't. It wasn't my copy, but I do think Misha has it so
- 1:02:52we can always play it, so that it was good. Actually, yeah,
- 1:02:55it's a really good game, and it's a semi cop in which you
- 1:02:58have to work together. But the thing is, you may say that the
- 1:03:01semi co op doesn't exist because fundamentally, at the end you kind of have
- 1:03:05to break away. Game of Thrones is like this diplomacy is like this right
- 1:03:09the semi I'm just thinking, like depending on how you define it, Like
- 1:03:14a lot of games require some amount of group effort, Like Carcasson could be
- 1:03:16called semi co op. Do you have a betrayal betrayal? Yeah, definitely
- 1:03:22semi co op, right because you like because it's there are phases in what
- 1:03:25you're cooperating phases and what you aren't. You definitely break off in betrayal.
- 1:03:30So but there are moments when you must cooperate. There are moments until until
- 1:03:36until you're not the haunts, right, So I guess chaos Cove by the
- 1:03:42way, it's it's I mean, if you want to call it semi co
- 1:03:45op, I guess you can. It's more like there's a would you call
- 1:03:49it like sort of like a press press your luck kind of thing where there
- 1:03:52there's an external pressure like if you if you don't deal with external threats together
- 1:03:59somehow, like everybody suffers, So somebody has to do it. But it's
- 1:04:02sort of like you'd rather someone else do it, right, and you have
- 1:04:04to like take a gamble or take a chance that like I'm going to do
- 1:04:08it this time, you do it next time. But there's no like over
- 1:04:10the table negotiation. And it's not zero sum. No, I think it.
- 1:04:16I think we can we define semi co op as something that is I
- 1:04:19think it wants zero Yeah, I mean in this case it is because you
- 1:04:21would end the game sooner if you let it happen. And then I think
- 1:04:27it even says in the rules anyone who does this on purpose is an asshole
- 1:04:30and you shouldn't play with them again. And so with semi co op,
- 1:04:32if you can is a game where you only have one winner semi co op.
- 1:04:39Do you think is semi co op a type of game or is it
- 1:04:43like a mechanism question? Well, it's an idea that there is an idea
- 1:04:48that you have to work together to ensure that something happens, right, yeah,
- 1:04:54let me refer back to the what do you call it, the magic
- 1:04:56circle, the golden circle, the golden magic triangle, golden Yeah. Yeah,
- 1:05:00there's like a social contract at play in any given game. But that's
- 1:05:04not that's not that's a different thing. Yeah, I know, but it's
- 1:05:06not about it. So you could so this game Chaos Cove, you could
- 1:05:11deliberately scupper it, and maybe that would be a way to win, but
- 1:05:15it would actually like ruin the game. And this is why the rules literally
- 1:05:18say don't do that. But but there's nothing to prevent you from doing it
- 1:05:23except you're like the social contract that you won't. Yeah, but that's that
- 1:05:28I don't see as semi co op. That I see as pandemic as well.
- 1:05:32You can do whatever you want on your turn. You can just like
- 1:05:33discard all your cars. Yeah, it's pandemic. Is absolutely a co op
- 1:05:39game. It's it's something where you have to work together, yeah, to
- 1:05:44achieve victory. But so maybe so, I think I think the problems semi
- 1:05:49co op games often find is that is it satisfying when you have in a
- 1:06:00sensibly competitive game, which is what semi co ops are, Is it unsatisfying?
- 1:06:04I barely remember, just to just have to have more than one winner?
- 1:06:09Is that unsatisfying? Do we are we just completely obsessed with having one
- 1:06:13winner? We played team games once in a while, that's fine. Sure,
- 1:06:16we play co op games and we love them and everybody wins, and
- 1:06:19I don't know why is this particular permutation not okay? But in a PvP
- 1:06:24game, we expect one winner, do we not? Yeah? So what's
- 1:06:27another example besides New Anglees Because I haven't played that one in years barely.
- 1:06:30Ar Capelago is the one that everyone uses. Oh, I really want to
- 1:06:33play that, it haven't. Well. The thing I can't talk about it
- 1:06:36because I played it ten years ago and I loved it, But I can't
- 1:06:40remember another game Mischa has. Do you know what really knocks me off?
- 1:06:43Everything? Ar Capelago? Who says that? Lots of people say it.
- 1:06:47I mean that sounds like the kind of way. It's like the way a
- 1:06:50British person who's deliberately trying to mispronounce a word would say it. But it's
- 1:06:55archipelago. It's always been archipelago as far as I know. People say archipelago.
- 1:06:58Who the fuck says archaeola for instances archipelago? Maybe he doesn't know how
- 1:07:02to read this may be it. So yeah, the thing is I think
- 1:07:09I think New Angelis is a great semi co op game in which you do
- 1:07:12have to work together, but essentially you're working together to achieve a singular victory,
- 1:07:19and I think that really works. So I think depends how much you
- 1:07:23think victory is the point. I think in Archipelago, Well, some games,
- 1:07:25victory is clearly the point, right, And I think it's interesting that
- 1:07:28there are some games that attempt so RPGs, it's not about victory really,
- 1:07:34it is about experience. But I think in board games so much is about
- 1:07:40reaching that endpoint and having a winner. It feels deeply, deeply unsatisfying if
- 1:07:45you don't have a winner at the end. Right, Well, if all
- 1:07:47board games eventually derive from very simple two player games like chess, which themselves
- 1:07:51are meant to be abstractions of war games, which are typically one side versus
- 1:07:56another, and there has to be a winner, and it is zero sum
- 1:08:00thing in a time where we have really like stretched and bent and explored these
- 1:08:03boundaries and questioned them and you know, sometimes they work, sometimes they don't.
- 1:08:08We're trying lots of things. If we have a good time, we
- 1:08:11walk away satisfied. That's more important. Then maybe there's one winner or who
- 1:08:15wins, because I think you and I both played plenty of games where there
- 1:08:18was one winner, but it's and it was a horrible experience. For the
- 1:08:21point, is it the thing? Right? What it's that classic? Well?
- 1:08:26Yeah, you should, you should, you should asp to win,
- 1:08:28don't make winning. But if if the game sets up conditions that require you
- 1:08:31to cooperate in certain moments and not others, and it ends up and it
- 1:08:34works you and you enjoy the experience. Like this is where the heavy duty
- 1:08:39board gamers will hate me, right, Like, you can't talk about enjoyment
- 1:08:42in games, right It's got to be about who wins and how to win
- 1:08:45and what's optimal, what makes sense what doesn't. I mean the same thing
- 1:08:46with the memory conversation that's going on in the discord right now as well.
- 1:08:49It's all about like what makes sense within the context of the game, not
- 1:08:54ever going beyond these sort of like logical boundaries to simply like the human element
- 1:09:00of the game, where you may or may not remember some things, you
- 1:09:02may or may not enjoy what you're doing. It's got to be like,
- 1:09:04no, I'm I'm going through a fucking like algorithm maze, and I want
- 1:09:09to make sure it is as fair as possible, and let's like sort of
- 1:09:13eliminate as much as possible the differences that we all have as people. This
- 1:09:15to me is a bit boring and a bit limited in thinking, and so
- 1:09:18also it comes down to that sort of basically definition of what is a game?
- 1:09:21Right, is telestrations a game? I mean, good question, it
- 1:09:29can be the way it does come with rules, the way we pay play
- 1:09:32telestrations, is it a game? Well, do you need per do you
- 1:09:36need victory conditions for a game to be a game, because the way we
- 1:09:41play telestrations is simply for the lolls, And people would say, well,
- 1:09:44that's not a game, it's an activity. Easy the game, I mean
- 1:09:47the stuff that little kids do, we often call it games, and the
- 1:09:50only thing that distinguishes them from other type like adult games, is like the
- 1:09:54kid games have rules because the kids just invent rules. Everything is Calvin Ball
- 1:09:58when you're a kid, right, right, But there's no like winner necessarily,
- 1:10:00or there's not even like a conclusion. You go out and you pretend
- 1:10:02to be someone else for a while and it's a game until it's over,
- 1:10:05and it's like maybe the same thing. And even the way we play telestrations,
- 1:10:10it has rules and there's no winner, right, there's no person that
- 1:10:14the game will say is a winner, but maybe in particular moments it's like,
- 1:10:17well that was fucking funny and bah. So with teleistrations is a great
- 1:10:21example, right, you don't. We don't all win bend. But sometimes
- 1:10:25when you draw a penis on just the right image, you're the winner.
- 1:10:29That's very true. But Telestrations is dessert, right, Yeah, you can't
- 1:10:32live on dessert, right, can't live on dessert. But you can't live
- 1:10:36on like primary eul there, Yeah, but you can live on You cannot
- 1:10:42have desserts and just have nice main meals and be perfectly fine. Right.
- 1:10:45So I think it's interesting that I think when we step out of that competitive
- 1:10:50millieure, it is great. It is a enjoyable temporary trip. But I
- 1:10:59don't think I could live there in the way that I could live with just
- 1:11:03playing good, challenging competitive games. Right. I don't think I can generalize
- 1:11:08here. It It's got to be like case by case depending you left Tenanties,
- 1:11:12it's got to be case by case, field martialised. It's got to
- 1:11:15be case by case, depending on the game. Can't think of any more
- 1:11:17army ranks. I would keep going until you fucking right out because fuck you
- 1:11:21know, Colonelize, fuck you do you actually have a take on this?
- 1:11:25Like, do you think that semi co op is a thing? Yes?
- 1:11:28I think New Angelus is. I think so, but you seem to think
- 1:11:30it can work, then I think Archipelago is, and I think when it
- 1:11:34come down on it, when implemented well, it can work brilliantly. And
- 1:11:38case by case, it's just really fucking hard to make semi co op not
- 1:11:44devolve into either co op or just I have to do this otherwise the game
- 1:11:50crashes, which is just simply not fun. Is a really difficult balance to
- 1:11:56strike. And so the reason there aren't loads of semi coomes, and especially
- 1:12:00there aren't loads of successful ones is it's bloody heart. I mean, it's
- 1:12:04another case where this like rigid Aristotelian desire to categorize, kind of doesn't work
- 1:12:10exactly anyway. So thank you for the questions. Please go to the discord
- 1:12:14if you want to give us more questions, And thank you Steve. This
- 1:12:17is the week of Ben and Steve. How has it been. It's been
- 1:12:21a great week. I mean as much time as I can possibly spend with
- 1:12:24you, Ben, I mean, actually even pretty busy lately. I haven't
- 1:12:27yet, I haven't played anything, but we have a very special weekend coming
- 1:12:30up. We certainly do. It's hot and steamy stuff. Join the Patreon
- 1:12:34and you'll get the goss. Thank you for listening to the Five Games for
- 1:12:41Doomsday News. To listen to past episodes, you can go to five Games
- 1:12:45for Doomsday dot com, or to back the show, you can go to
- 1:12:47Patreon dot com forward slash five g for d So join us again next month
- 1:12:54for some hot and spicy Five Games for Doomsday News