Latest / Engineering Influence from ACEC / The Market Edge Podcast - The Port Report: Energy, Funding and Tariffs Energy, Funding and Tariffs
Transcript
- 0:06Hello, and welcome to another episode of the Engineering Influence Podcast.
- 0:11Diana O'Leary, ACAC National, and today's show is brought to you by The Market
- 0:14Edge, a new podcast series that was created by ACAC National members that participate
- 0:19in our new Market Intelligence Committee.
- 0:21Each episode will feature an industry expert addressing member-specific questions
- 0:26with a focus on market trends and economic insights aimed at empowering engineering
- 0:31firms to drive growth, adapt to change, and maintain their competitiveness.
- 0:35Today, we have with us two port planners and designers from member firm GHD,
- 0:40and we'll be talking about port design and the trends impacting that market.
- 0:43So a little bit about our speakers today. First, we have Victor Torado for Maritime
- 0:48and Coastal America's Market Sectorly for GHD.
- 0:52He brings over two decades of experience in managing multidisciplinary teams
- 0:57across planning, engineering, and construction.
- 1:00He specializes in delivering complex, multimodal transportation,
- 1:03as well as waterfront and marine projects ranging from substantial infrastructure
- 1:08endeavors to environmental remediation and coastal adaptation initiatives.
- 1:13Victor's project portfolio spans piers, wharves, bulkheads, dry docks,
- 1:17major navigation channels, wetland restorations, living shorelines,
- 1:21highway-grade separation, bridges, and more.
- 1:24He is also a distinguished six-year veteran of the United States Navy,
- 1:28so thank you very much for your service.
- 1:29And we also have Michael Vanderbeek, Maritime and Coastal Planning Lead for North America for GHT.
- 1:36For the past 20 years, Michael has led and or contributed to international port
- 1:41planning and development efforts for dozens of public port authorities,
- 1:48private terminal operators, cruise lines, sovereign wealth funds, and municipalities.
- 1:52He has worked throughout North America as well as in Europe,
- 1:56Asia, Australia, the Caribbean, and the Pacific Islands and Middle East on projects
- 2:01ranging from individual port master plans to transnational port investment strategies.
- 2:06As a former port executive, Michael specializes in conceptualizing new port
- 2:10infrastructure opportunities within the political, environmental,
- 2:14and community-driven context of waterfront development to help clients achieve win-win outcomes.
- 2:19Victor and Michael, thank you so much for joining us today.
- 2:23Thanks for having us. Thanks for having us. Absolutely.
- 2:26I feel like I could give a chorus song now after I've done all those very specific
- 2:32words with several syllables. I could sing an opera.
- 2:36But thank you both for being here today.
- 2:38All right. So let's get into business here. I've got to walk us through.
- 2:42Actually, I want you to help our members walk through some of the trends that
- 2:45are impacting the ports market, which is your bread and butter and where you
- 2:48guys live. So starting with the energy transition, because that's really important just to everyone.
- 2:54And so how is that impacting design elements within the port market?
- 2:58And what opportunities and challenges does this bring to the AEC industry?
- 3:03Well, I can start and then let Victor fill in the gaps here.
- 3:07But I think energy is honestly the most important single issue right now in the port space.
- 3:13And there's a number of different parameters, I would say, where it's really
- 3:18impacting port development and operations as well.
- 3:21So, you know, and the way I like to think of this is ports are not only,
- 3:24you know, they've traditionally been considered international gateways for cargo,
- 3:29but now I think increasingly they're actually energy hubs as well because of
- 3:33the synergy of different, you know,
- 3:35energy needs that ports now account for.
- 3:37So one of the major trends that we're seeing is the push to decarbonization of operations.
- 3:43And what that means basically is you're moving from traditional fossil fuels
- 3:48to primarily electrified operations.
- 3:52And that's putting a huge demand on the public utilities, on power generation,
- 3:57and a need for a lot of new infrastructure at ports.
- 4:01And so I think that's probably the primary area where we're seeing activity
- 4:06right now is new electrical infrastructure and then, you know,
- 4:09including not just the transmission,
- 4:12but actually looking at things like microgrids and other ways to supplement
- 4:16the power that's available from the utility company. So that's a very big one.
- 4:20Another one that's really important, I would say, is alternative fuels themselves.
- 4:25So when you get outside the decarbonization effort, you're looking from vessels
- 4:30to trucks, alternative fuels to replace diesel or other forms of fossil fuels.
- 4:35So methanol primarily, I would say, in the vessel space is supposed to be promising.
- 4:40Certainly LNG, but then also hydrogen.
- 4:43And I think between all of those things, when you're a planner like me and you're
- 4:47looking at port facilities.
- 4:48The question starts to become, how do you accommodate all of these energy needs
- 4:53while still, you know, conducting the traditional operations of moving containers and moving cargo?
- 4:59So I think it's really kind of like a Jenga situation where you're really trying
- 5:03to figure out where things go in a limited amount of space. And increasingly,
- 5:08the energy infrastructure is taking up some of that space, but for good reasons.
- 5:12And then the only other thing I would touch on is, you know,
- 5:14there's a unique opportunity, I think, that is kind of on pause currently.
- 5:18But the offshore wind industry has really caused a lot of ports to want to pivot
- 5:26to being, you know, not just containers,
- 5:30but actually looking at how do they accommodate that industry.
- 5:34And even though it's currently on pause because of the federal permitting issue,
- 5:38I think a lot of ports, particularly on the West Coast, are still trying to
- 5:41figure out how they can be part of that supply chain going forward.
- 5:45And that creates its own challenges because a lot of offshore wind infrastructure
- 5:48really does have to be custom built.
- 5:51So in looking at your bio, I know you've got, you know, transnational experience.
- 5:56And so are there any differences right now in the energy story versus what you're
- 6:01seeing globally and just here in North America? Thank you.
- 6:05I mean, a lot of the issues are the same. Where different ports are and maybe
- 6:11in their evolution process, depending on what country they're in, I would say matters.
- 6:14The big push a while ago had been toward automation.
- 6:18I think that's still of interest to people, but it seems to have scaled back
- 6:23a bit and decarbonization has come to the forefront.
- 6:26So it's less about automating the facilities than it is about making them zero
- 6:30emission facilities in the U.S., whereas I think automation is likely still
- 6:35something in the international space that will continue to evolve.
- 6:38So there's a little bit of a differentiation there.
- 6:40But other than that, I think it's basically everybody trying to get to zero
- 6:45emissions basically as fast as they can.
- 6:47And I don't know if maybe Victor has something to add there, but that's what I see.
- 6:51Well, I was going to add to that is, yeah, I mean, we're seeing definite increases,
- 6:55especially on the vessel design, vessel construction, right?
- 6:58There's been a significant increase in orders out there for transitioning,
- 7:02you know, shipping vessels from standard oil to, you know, to alternative oils, alternative fuels.
- 7:08And so that's definitely pushing most of the industry around the world,
- 7:12actually, or most of the ports around the world to just kind of adapt to that.
- 7:15And I know there's been a significant influx of need for Southwest Asia.
- 7:20Actually, for some of these alternative fuels, LNG and things like that.
- 7:24And the U.S. is ramping up every day their production of LNG.
- 7:27So there's definitely a dichotomy there that the whole world is shifting to the green world.
- 7:34Juan, I'm surprised you brought up offshore wind. And I was curious,
- 7:37and I've asked you this before, but I want our members to hear it too.
- 7:40I asked you before about administration priorities changing.
- 7:43And with the market you're in, it's very carbon intensive, And there's a large
- 7:48amount of emissions that come from the work that you all do and within that market.
- 7:52Are you seeing a pivot to fossil fuels and natural gas or is it an all of the above answer?
- 7:59Well, I'll take a first pass on this, and Michael, you can fill it in,
- 8:02but I think it's an all-inclusive, actually.
- 8:04It's definitely an all-inclusive shift. I mean, obviously, like you mentioned,
- 8:07Michael, California is still kind of pushing some of this wind energy stuff.
- 8:10But in general, I think our clients are seeing a shift, an overall shift, right?
- 8:16They're trying to figure out new ways to basically take over that gap that has
- 8:21been developed in the wind energy side, Michael said.
- 8:24Yeah, I mean, there's been a very clear move away from offshore wind in the
- 8:29past six months due to the change in administration.
- 8:32But the demand for energy or the push for additional energy hasn't slowed down at all.
- 8:38In fact, it's accelerated. So I think offshore wind is sort of a unique set-aside
- 8:43that I would consider not dead, but rather on pause until maybe some of the
- 8:49issues are sorted out in terms of this administration's view of it.
- 8:53But no, I don't see alternative fuels going away. I think those are very much
- 8:58being accelerated. I think the push to decarbonization is still full speed ahead.
- 9:03It's just the offshore wind industry, for whatever reason, is sort of a unique
- 9:07set aside that's been paused. But everything else, I think, is moving forward very quickly.
- 9:12Understood. Good intel there. I'm going to go on to our next question here.
- 9:15So what are the traditional funding mechanisms in the industry and how has that
- 9:20changed? And what's good and bad about those changes?
- 9:24Yeah, I'll start with this one as well, if that's okay, Victor.
- 9:26This is probably my favorite question because it's one that I think all ports are struggling with.
- 9:32And the way I like to think of this is the traditional development model for
- 9:37public port authorities usually was use their position as a public entity,
- 9:44as a government entity that can issue bonds,
- 9:45that can finance infrastructure to do that. So it's sort of a three-step process.
- 9:50The first step would be identify what your market opportunity is,
- 9:55what your unique selling proposition is as an individual port, for example.
- 9:59Step two would be find a customer. And then step three is come to terms with
- 10:03that customer and you, the public port authority,
- 10:06build infrastructure to meet their needs and then either lease it to them if
- 10:10you're a landlord port and make your return on that investment over time from their lease payments.
- 10:15Or if you're an operating port, just charge them for your services over time
- 10:18and make back your investment the same way.
- 10:20And I think what has really happened is a lot of ports have kind of hit the
- 10:26cap on their ability to issue new debt or to debt finance infrastructure.
- 10:31And this is, you know, for complicated reasons, partly because they've already
- 10:34spent a lot of their debt capacity on previous projects and partly because costs
- 10:39have accelerated so much in the past, you know, let's say 10 years,
- 10:42it's just no longer possible for a lot of ports unless they're extremely well,
- 10:47you know, really strong from a cash flow and revenue perspective to be able to go after new debt.
- 10:52They just don't have the ability to do that anymore, to finance projects that way anymore.
- 10:57And so I would say for the last 20 years or so, there's sort of been a migration
- 11:01away from that model to increasingly relying on federal and state funds as basically
- 11:08seed money for infrastructure projects.
- 11:10So the process kind of works like a port will put together a project description
- 11:14for a major infrastructure project that they want to build.
- 11:16They'll submit a grant application. And let's say it's a billion dollar project
- 11:20and they get a hundred million dollars. Okay, well, that's $100 million is a
- 11:23significant amount of money, but it's still only 10% of that project total.
- 11:26But that $100 million allows them to attract matching funds from other public
- 11:31entities and then from the private sector eventually as well.
- 11:34And I know that this is a model that has worked relatively well over the past
- 11:3720 years because public money has been available.
- 11:41And again, obviously, there's no mystery about the political landscape having
- 11:46changed in the last six months.
- 11:48The federal side of that hasn't dried up, but it has changed.
- 11:52And I think increasingly, public port authorities are going to have to look
- 11:55to new models for building infrastructure.
- 11:58And again, it's a complicated situation, but I think the private sector basically
- 12:02is going to have to step up and fill some of that gap that either state or federal
- 12:06governments were doing. in
- 12:08the past, certainly states will have to step up as well for their boards.
- 12:13All right. So I got to ask, and I don't know what the answer is.
- 12:18I got to talk about tariffs. Is it impacting anything that you do?
- 12:23You know, there's a lot of sentiment data about steers and how they think it's
- 12:28going to impact them and people pricing things ahead of schedule or buying things ahead of schedule.
- 12:32You know, is this impacting the market anyway over there, other than maybe the
- 12:36pull ahead or of, you know, imports on the rise? Anything else going on that
- 12:41might impact what you're doing?
- 12:43Yeah, I can start with that because I've been looking at a few pools and I can
- 12:46tell you that there was a lot of push early on when the first,
- 12:50the tariffs news came out and a lot of the shippers were getting ahead of things,
- 12:54trying to kind of sock warehouses and do things like that.
- 12:57I think on the back end, what's being, what we're seeing as a result,
- 13:01there's not necessarily a tremendous impact, but a shift, right?
- 13:04And this goes back to actually the China plus one era, right?
- 13:08I'm talking like several years back now where we started diversifying our supply chain, right?
- 13:14Going from China to other countries in Southwest Asia, Turkey,
- 13:18and all those other places, and India.
- 13:19So I think that shift will have already been started, which then is kind of,
- 13:25I guess, buffering a little bit of the impact on the tariffs.
- 13:28But again, I'm not an economist, right, by any means.
- 13:31But I think that's what we're seeing is that the shifts already started happening before.
- 13:35So if I change their heart to shift quickly, so I don't think that tariffs per
- 13:40se did much except for just kind of a rush at the head start and things are
- 13:46starting to come down at back. But again, I'm not an economist.
- 13:50That's just what I'm seeing on my call.
- 13:53Yeah, no, I would say this. Yeah, I would say this in saying,
- 13:57echo that sentiment, Victor, that as a non-economist, I mean,
- 14:01most of what I see or hear is anecdotal.
- 14:04But my gut tells me as someone who's been in the industry for 20 years that
- 14:09the main issue let's put it this way the long term impact of the tariffs is
- 14:15No one knows because it's going to take years for that to really,
- 14:17you know, materialize. No one really knows what the long-term impacts are.
- 14:21But in the short term, just like any other market, the supply chain,
- 14:26you know, the international shipping industry, it doesn't like when it can't
- 14:31rely on, you know, supply chains or sourcing markets.
- 14:35So it's the, I would say it's more, it's the instability and the unpredictability
- 14:40that is actually the biggest challenge for the near term, long term.
- 14:45One way or another, things will sort themselves out, you know,
- 14:47where, you know, things that now come from China, maybe they won't anymore.
- 14:51And I don't know if that's good or bad, necessarily. It's just, it just is.
- 14:54But in the near term, I think it's people not understanding how to manage inventories
- 14:59that is really the biggest challenge.
- 15:01Right good feedback there so
- 15:04i'm going to combine these next two into one i'm going
- 15:07to talk about ai right so how do you
- 15:10see artificial intelligence impacting the
- 15:13ports market and also in the
- 15:15same vein how quickly are autonomous rail cars coming to the rail market i yeah
- 15:22sure i i can't i can't speak to the autonomous rail cars i mean i think that
- 15:27that really depends i i probably prefer not to get into that issue terribly much,
- 15:33only because I think we all know that the class one railroads have an operating
- 15:38model that has worked for them for centuries.
- 15:41And I don't know to what extent they're necessarily investing in that.
- 15:46But automation in general, autonomous vehicles in general, yes,
- 15:50I think there's certainly potential for that in the near to midterm.
- 15:53As far as locomotives go and long haul rail, not really sure.
- 15:57At the port level, yes. At short haul level?
- 15:59I think so. But long haul, class one, not sure.
- 16:04And then, I apologize, what was the second part of your question?
- 16:07Any impacts on AI, aside from autonomous rail?
- 16:11Any other artificial intelligence impacting design? I mean, that's also tough to say.
- 16:17That's one of those things that I think that people aren't really sure what
- 16:22the impact of AI is going to be.
- 16:23But I think there's general agreement that there will be an impact.
- 16:26And I think how that impact really manifests is very much to be determined.
- 16:32And again, I think this will vary greatly across what part of the supply chain
- 16:37you're talking about and frankly also which country you're in because just like
- 16:42I mentioned earlier about the, you know.
- 16:44Internationally, automation is
- 16:47much more likely than in the United States because of our labor situation.
- 16:51I think the same sort of applies to AI.
- 16:54I think we have strong labor both on the West Coast and then on the East Coast
- 16:57in the Gulf and the ILWU and ILA.
- 16:59And I think their tolerance for that, their acceptance of some of those things
- 17:04is largely going to drive what gets deployed at the terminal level because they're
- 17:09still a very critical part of the supply chain.
- 17:12And I think that's obviously very different in other countries where maybe they
- 17:15don't have a strong union and they're able to deploy some of those things maybe
- 17:19more quickly or at a different level.
- 17:22So I think the jury is very much still out on what the impact of that is going to be.
- 17:27I just, again, to bring it back to the automation conversation,
- 17:30I think about 10 to 15 years ago, a lot of people would have said that by 2025,
- 17:34every single new terminal that gets built will be fully automated.
- 17:39And to date, there's only a handful.
- 17:41So, I will just have to say, I'm not sure how it's going to impact it.
- 17:47There will be an impact, but what that impact is, is very much up in the air, I would say.
- 17:52Yeah, I mean, not to say that animation is not already happening,
- 17:54right? But to your point, Michael, there's a handful of terminals already automated.
- 17:57Long Beach Helper, LA has one of them.
- 17:59So, it's already happening. It's just, yeah, the AI produces CDD.
- 18:05Understood. We've got time for probably one more question. I wanted to ask about
- 18:09trends regarding surrounding real estate at ports.
- 18:12So any insight or trends that you can provide on commercial real estate or cold
- 18:16storage or anything else that is not directly, you know, it's not at the,
- 18:20it's not the cranes, it's not the shipping containers, but that's surrounding,
- 18:24you know, CRE, any trends that you're seeing there?
- 18:28Uh yeah i would say you know
- 18:31trends are challenging because it depends on the it depends
- 18:33on where the cargo likes to move if that makes sense and what
- 18:36type of commodities get handled at different ports certain ports cold storage
- 18:41is absolutely vital because they're handling a lot of perishables so i know
- 18:45you know there are ports in south florida for example that handle a lot of that
- 18:48north south perish from the trade and they it's it's absolutely critical that
- 18:52they have cold storage Same in courts like New Orleans,
- 18:56where they handle a lot of frozen poultry, those sorts of things.
- 18:59That infrastructure is critical.
- 19:02Other courts that don't handle those sorts of commodities, it's really not even on the radar.
- 19:07And it's very interesting to sort of contrast those things. and I,
- 19:12you know, it's not as simple as if you are a, let's say you're a port in a market
- 19:17that doesn't handle refrigerated cargo or perishables currently.
- 19:21If you build a large refrigerated warehouse, speculatively, will it attract cargo?
- 19:26I don't think so. I think it's much more complicated than that.
- 19:29Could it facilitate the cargo being secured for that port?
- 19:33Perhaps, if the other dynamics work, but really it's all about the all-in costs
- 19:38of delivering that cargo, and then also, you know, is that really where the cargo wants to go?
- 19:45So, I know that's not a very good answer in terms of trends,
- 19:47but I think it's very market specific.
- 19:50The one thing I will say is that, from a general perspective.
- 19:54Ports, the primary value of ports is their waterfront access,
- 19:58the fact that a vessel can tie up and offload cargo or load cargo.
- 20:02That's their primary purpose, right, is loading and unloading cargo off of a vessel.
- 20:07Second to that is backland space, you know, the real estate that they actually
- 20:12have to serve that cargo.
- 20:14And it used to be marine terminals were good enough. But now,
- 20:18I think, you know, certainly in the larger gateways like LA Long Beach,
- 20:22for example, or Savannah,
- 20:24that upland real estate for precisely what you're saying, for the logistics
- 20:28activity, for long haul distribution or for regional distribution is increasingly important.
- 20:33And I think, you know, that that's not going to change anytime soon.
- 20:36Having the access to the logistics infrastructure is still variable.
- 20:42Victor, anything you want to add to that? No, I think Michael just covered it all.
- 20:47It's really, it's very much regional or, you know, case by case and market by
- 20:51market, for sure. But yeah, that's it.
- 20:54Understood. So that's about all the time we have for today, unfortunately.
- 20:58I will say to our listeners, please be on the lookout for our next podcast from
- 21:02the Market Edge coming soon.
- 21:03Don't forget to like and subscribe ACEC's Engineering Influence podcast and YouTube channel.
- 21:09Victor and Michael, thank you so much for joining us today. And thank you for
- 21:12joining the Market Edge. See you next time. Thank you very much. I can leave your answer.