Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / Ethics and Misuse of Social Media in Court with Claude E. Ducloux of LawPay
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome to ethics and misuse of social media in court.
- 0:12I'm Rachel Kogan, Chair of the Litigation Section of the Beverly Hills Bar Association.
- 0:18I'm happy to introduce our speaker for today's program, Claude DeClo.
- 0:25Claude E. DeClo is a highly accomplished attorney with over 45 years of experience in Texas.
- 0:33He is also licensed in California and Colorado.
- 0:36And he's the recipient of the prestigious Gene Kavan Award for Lifetime Contributions
- 0:42to Continuing Legal Education.
- 0:46We were just chatting and Claude just told me he has delivered over 800 acclaimed presentations
- 0:53nationwide since 2010.
- 0:56He really loves educating lawyers and he has a lot of great information to share.
- 1:04Claude is board certified in civil trial law and civil appellate law.
- 1:09And he has held leadership roles in numerous bar associations, including serving as president
- 1:15of the Austin Bar and chair of the Texas Center for Legal Ethics.
- 1:20Currently, Claude is the national director of education, ethics and state compliance from
- 1:25Lafay with a career marked by awards for his writing, pro bono service and contributions
- 1:31to law and the field of litigation and legal ethics.
- 1:35We can't wait to see what he has prepared to share with us today.
- 1:39And Claude, the floor is yours.
- 1:42Thanks very much, Rachel.
- 1:43Hi everybody.
- 1:44Gee, I feel like since it's Beverly Hills and I grew up out there, I should have been
- 1:48handled a little trophy of some sort, maybe one of Arne Becker or something like that.
- 1:53Again, I've been a lawyer.
- 1:55I was licensed first time in 77.
- 1:58I was licensed here.
- 1:59I took the whole bar exam in 78 in California and I've been a working lawyer.
- 2:04I was a prosecutor for two and a half years and I joined a small law firm in the 80s where
- 2:09a civil trial firm where we all did things like car accident cases.
- 2:12We were all defense counsel in the course.
- 2:14Then I crossed from the dark side to and then was recruited by a big New York firm.
- 2:21And I did that for two years and I really didn't enjoy being part of a firm that was
- 2:26in 10 different cities.
- 2:27So I started my own firm, Hilda Clue, Carnes and Deligarza and that's the way we practice
- 2:31for the next 27 years.
- 2:33Lafay asked me to create a program for them because I was a pretty well known speaker.
- 2:38And that has been the greatest joy that in fact, that I get to share this stuff and try
- 2:42to help lawyers across the country to be better.
- 2:45Now for those of you in Beverly Hills, welcome.
- 2:48I grew up in Los Angeles.
- 2:49I grew up right off, you know, Crenshaw Boulevard at Vernon Avenue, which was the
- 2:57Lamert Park and Vernon Avenue turned into Mount Vernon Drive, went up into Windsor
- 3:02Hills and that's where I grew up all the way till I was a senior in high school.
- 3:07We moved to Austin because my father took over the music department, the University
- 3:11of Texas, where he was in charge of it in Los Angeles at USC.
- 3:15The University of Southern California spent a lot of time there.
- 3:18So but let's go back to what we're talking about.
- 3:21Lawyers like the rest of the population often make big mistakes on social media and one
- 3:25of the things, of course, nowadays, if you're doing any sort of work, you need to add a
- 3:31social media clause to your attorney fee agreement.
- 3:34I have so many presentations and so many forms if you want that agreement.
- 3:39I hope I have sent that to you as a downloadable form.
- 3:44I have a packet of attorney fee agreements for every type of practice, whether it's,
- 3:49you know, personal injury or state planning or regular things and all sorts of additional
- 3:58forms for various things.
- 4:00So anyway, we get ourselves in trouble by using social media.
- 4:04We want to help you avoid those situations, could result in malpractice because you revealed
- 4:10something you shouldn't have in social media.
- 4:12Isn't it amazing how people, if you ask someone how old they are, they say, how rude of you,
- 4:17but then they'll post it on Facebook.
- 4:19Today's my 85th birthday, whatever.
- 4:22Ethical breaches, subject to discipline, breach of fiduciary duty by revealing things that
- 4:26your client told you you shouldn't have or making fun of your own client, which happens
- 4:31and you'll see a lot.
- 4:32So I have lots of types of cases to show you and then of course you can get monetary damages
- 4:37by misusing it and get sanctions and things like that.
- 4:40So what we're going to cover today in today's session, I have lots of things to cover and
- 4:44I try to keep this really upbeat for you so we talk about it.
- 4:47But I do want to tell you, because I have so much that we're going to cover, if you
- 4:51have a question for me, I get all of my CLE email across the country and in Canada and
- 4:56Puerto Rico at simplyclawedatlawpay.com, CLAUD at lawpay.com.
- 5:04So feel free to email me and if you have a question and you want to get on the phone,
- 5:09I do that a lot with lawyers.
- 5:11Just talk through an ethical situation where they're just in a quandary because that's
- 5:14a real specialty of mine.
- 5:16I've probably handled grievance complaints against 300 lawyers and law firms and guide
- 5:23them on how to avoid that area in the future.
- 5:25So first, disregarding confidentiality and posting things on social media then.
- 5:32Unethical information gathering, using social media as you're somebody else to get information
- 5:36you shouldn't have been entitled to get.
- 5:38Fail to assert client control and letting your client know that you're going to lose
- 5:42your case on social media because you're an idiot and what you're posting on social
- 5:46media is going to hurt our case.
- 5:49Danger area number four, evidence preservation.
- 5:52We'll talk about a couple of cases where people say, take down your Facebook page and
- 5:57in interrogatories will say you never had Facebook page.
- 6:00Now isn't that the stupidest thing in the entire world?
- 6:03Well no, there is more stupid things that we've seen in the last year.
- 6:07Ethical conduct involving jurors, looking up jurors and actually contacting them.
- 6:12And then of course with the impact of what you share in your social media posts and things
- 6:19like that and then reacting to online reviews or critics and what is the proper way for
- 6:25you to react to online views.
- 6:27Now I will say this at the beginning because you all know this is true.
- 6:32If you are going to post on social media, you will only be known by your very worst post.
- 6:39People are trolling you for bad posts and I just give you so many examples of that.
- 6:45You might have 413 beautiful, intelligent, articulate posts but then one night about
- 6:549.30 you've had a little too much Zinfandel and you post something that you think sounds
- 7:00funny and it comes off as racist, homophobic, something like that.
- 7:04Guess what?
- 7:05That's your post for the rest of your life.
- 7:06You could lose your job and everything like that.
- 7:08So the internet is written in ink and no matter how much you think you can get rid of it,
- 7:14you're wrong.
- 7:15It's going to be there someplace.
- 7:17Alright, now why do you need this?
- 7:19Well let's go through a little bit of a background.
- 7:22Remember the word social media wasn't even invented until 2004 in those old disciplinary
- 7:28rules we used to call advertising, internet based advertising because there was no word
- 7:33for social media.
- 7:35By the way I just finished 6 years on the disciplinary rules committee where we passed
- 7:39about 19 new rules and I think I had a great hand and probably about 16 of those 19 rules
- 7:46because I get to teach all over the country.
- 7:49I see like in Texas there's a lot better rules.
- 7:52Some of your rules in California are way better than the ones we have here.
- 7:55In fact I used your rule 1.8 to fix our rule 1.8.
- 7:58I used another rule from the Minnesota bar to look at how to improve our disciplinary
- 8:04rules.
- 8:05I don't remember but let's talk about social media and it was defined as forms of electronic
- 8:10communication through which users create online communicates, shared information ideas, etc.
- 8:15And as a form of communication it's a tool but it's not really subject to regulation.
- 8:20So it's the manner that you use it which may be subject to restriction or regulation or
- 8:27punishment.
- 8:28So the problem of course is the ease, the speed of access and the vast reach of social
- 8:34media.
- 8:35You know when we used to get mad in the olden days when I was a young lawyer, we'd write
- 8:40one of these barn burning letters and say you're a son of a...
- 8:44And then of course we'd put it in our desk drawer overnight and we'd get up the next
- 8:48morning and say oh my thank God I didn't mail that.
- 8:50Well now we just push send and then you get those odd things.
- 8:53Clodd to Clea would like to recall that last email where he called you an idiot.
- 8:58Okay well so you have to watch out what you're doing all the time.
- 9:03Alright so and it's ubiquitous and I try to keep these up to date you know as August
- 9:10to YouTube 2.3 billion monthly active users, 2.3 billion right 500 hours of video.
- 9:18Can you imagine this?
- 9:19Since I've been talking over a thousand hours of videos have been uploaded to YouTube.
- 9:24It's just amazing 2.9 billion monthly active users of Facebook, 1 billion registered users
- 9:31of what used to be Twitter 396.5 million monthly active users.
- 9:36Now I'll bet that's gone down ever since Mr. Musk who lives right here in Austin Texas
- 9:40has taken that over.
- 9:42LinkedIn 706 million, Instagram over 800 million monthly users and 500 million daily active
- 9:51users of Instagram.
- 9:53Now you ask Clodd what do you use?
- 9:54I use very little.
- 9:55I do have a Facebook page but I have minimal attention to it because frankly I don't have
- 10:00time to keep and I don't care about commenting on everything.
- 10:03I'd rather write a letter to the editor.
- 10:05And then TikTok 1,398 million monthly active users.
- 10:12So it is simply everywhere.
- 10:13I love YouTube though because if you talk to like my kids they're you know in their late
- 10:1930s early 40s they'll if I say how are you going to fix your toilet and they'll go I
- 10:22don't know I'll go to YouTube and that's exactly right just about anything you need
- 10:27to fix.
- 10:28So I had an old 2012 Mercedes that had a dead battery and I thought I don't want to take
- 10:33it as a dealer they're going to charge me 300 bucks to tell me oh your battery is dead.
- 10:36Yeah I already know my battery is dead.
- 10:38So there it was.
- 10:39How do you change a battery in a 2000 Mercedes whatever it was a C230 whatever it was and
- 10:43there is a seven minute video on how to change my own battery so YouTube is just wonderful.
- 10:48Alright social media by the numbers in May of 2018 Facebook and YouTube dominate 5.16
- 10:56billion accounts worldwide and 80% of all adult Americans have at least one social networking
- 11:01account and 58% of us have two or more.
- 11:0616 minutes of every hour spent online is spent on Facebook and there are more Facebook profiles
- 11:12five created every second than there are people born.
- 11:15So there are more Facebook profiles than people born and more than 1 billion tweets
- 11:20are sent every 48 hours.
- 11:23So now because of all this we have this new duty of competence and I give this around
- 11:28the country and I try to put in your rule but all of us within the comments of our rules
- 11:34usually it's our rule 1.1 if we are following the general pattern of the ABA is that we
- 11:38have to maintain the requisite knowledge and changes in the law and technology and all
- 11:44that kind of stuff and we have a duty to do that which means you know if you are going
- 11:49to continue practicing the law for a long time we know this and you are hiding from
- 11:53it if you say well I will just get someone else to do it.
- 11:56You need to learn how to do it.
- 11:57You need to learn how to file your own pleadings even though lawyers generally hate learning
- 12:03new stuff.
- 12:04You younger lawyers God bless you.
- 12:06You learn stuff more easily and more quickly and we need for you to mentor us and we can
- 12:12help you with other things but I know myself.
- 12:16You know that I just don't like having to learn new stuff especially as old as I am
- 12:24and of course we are going to have to hold you to a higher standard right now.
- 12:29For example if you are picking juries and you have at least and you had the time to
- 12:34Google some of the jurors you could find out a whole lot more about them simply with publicly
- 12:41available information.
- 12:42So now some courts have said you have a duty if you have time to do that you should.
- 12:46In fact there was a case in Texas where the old lawyer even older than I am you know picked
- 12:52a man for his jury who actually ran a group that was against the insurance company that
- 12:59the old lawyer was representing.
- 13:01You know I won't name the company I'll just call it Never Pay Insurance which is covers
- 13:05most of them.
- 13:06At any rate he said but the guy is a never he has a never pay auntie never pay and you
- 13:11put him on the jury and you lost that case with a hung jury.
- 13:15You should have found out about that and it was malpractice for you not to do that.
- 13:20See in Missouri affirmative duty to research jurors online in the 9th circuit they said
- 13:25the failure to investigate social media in Kennedy versus Adam and the media recantation
- 13:31of a sexual abuse victim held to be an echo.
- 13:34In other words the victim said well you know it didn't really happen.
- 13:38Just like that remember the alleged victim came clean she was the attacks by that was
- 13:45a lacrosse team it do never really happened well that doesn't help but that's 12 years
- 13:50ago.
- 13:51Womack you're says Yeoman the dangers of not being a conversant with technology.
- 13:56There the plaintiff's lawyer wrongly accused the defense lawyer of hacking the plaintiff's
- 14:00social media account wrong.
- 14:02All the information is publicly available and he got sanctions.
- 14:05Okay what about privacy?
- 14:09If you haven't been following the wonderful tale of our attorney general Ken Paxton oh
- 14:15you've missed a really bad telenovela soap opera because we have somebody that's wow
- 14:24as our Paxton got sued by his own personally picked assistance right and for whistleblowing
- 14:32with this they reported him his top aides reported the FBI and with the protection of the Supreme
- 14:39Court he never even had to sit for a deposition he wouldn't be put under oath.
- 14:43So but this was the Austin Court of Appeals which is much more enlightened than most of
- 14:49the judges and they said no you have a right to a disclosure privacy in zones of privacy
- 14:56that you have a right to expect and that would include you know matters relating to marriage
- 15:01procreation contraceptions family relationships and child rearing and education well of course
- 15:07that that's all being changed quickly by our courts here in Texas.
- 15:15So let's just go directly to danger area number one disregarding confidentiality and people
- 15:21who love to post you can be sure of one thing they love to post so here's one thing here's
- 15:26how you shape safely shoot someone this out of Tennessee this lawyer put on on is a story
- 15:35of here's how you can shoot someone and get away with it turnies about some gauge and
- 15:40criminal conduct and void arrest violated the disciplinary rules and following a hearing
- 15:44the Tennessee Supreme Court raised his punishment to four years of suspension with one to do
- 15:50and three probated and they said it was ample evidence support the court's conclusion that
- 15:55the attorney violated the rules of professional conduct should be subject to discipline required
- 16:01lawyers to complete nine hours CLA focused on ethical use of social media by attorneys
- 16:06they found the attorney in fact offered advice on how to use deadly force and concoct of
- 16:12false defense yeah I think that's probably not what you ought to be doing okay now this
- 16:18was out of Florida a public defender took a picture of her clients underwear because
- 16:26this is how tough this is going to be a tough trial that needed to wear that you know leopard
- 16:31underwear was written by public defender and you sitron was stern where she shared information
- 16:36her male clients choice of underwear most infamous trial was granted and the lawyer
- 16:41was fired look before you tweet oh tweets of course a series she became famous Sarah
- 16:49Paris Peterson her research attorney with the Kansas Court of Appeals tweeted she was watching
- 16:54a legal proceeding and it was against a another court official and she's tweeting to her friends
- 17:01who is a naughty naughty boy and this wise Phil Klein smiling there's not the smile amount
- 17:08you I think there was something about being from a Deutschland but something some sort
- 17:13of D bag anyway so what happened to her she had to come on the carpet say I'm so sorry
- 17:21I didn't think that in addition to communicating with my friends on Twitter I was also communicating
- 17:25with the public at large is not appropriate for somebody who works for the court of appeals
- 17:30I apologize because the comments were made on Twitter and thus public received as a reflection
- 17:33on Kansas Court she was fired information admonishment which was the only thing now
- 17:38what about another lawyer's incendiary post with the Paul Treywick of South Carolina
- 17:42suspended for six months when he writes on Facebook about the George Floyd's women's
- 17:47tattoos that are explicitly incendiary here's how much that s stains life actually matter
- 17:53referred to George Floyd stock futures are up markets move higher Monday and Tuesday and
- 17:58he says to anybody who doesn't agree with that F you you can just unfriend me so his
- 18:04he got a six month suspension diversity education which of course is a no no now in the state
- 18:09of Texas anger management and comply with treatment recommended by lawyers helping lawyers
- 18:14so you know again you're always going to be known by your absolutely worse point here
- 18:20is another I would say probably poor Mr. Peshack was burned out he was a public defender and
- 18:26he's texting his to his friends look this stupid kid is taking the rap for his drug
- 18:32dealing dirt bag and an older brother because he's no snitch and they say Mike another one
- 18:37he said my clients in college just go to show that higher education doesn't imply you have
- 18:41any sense and then he and then he and his third client he goes he's standing there in court
- 18:46stoned right in front of the judge and the probation officer and prosecutor and swearing
- 18:51he was clean so here he's clearly texting something against his clients best interest
- 18:57and what happened to that he was suspended for the practice and fired after 19 years
- 19:02of the public defender's office and again and only for his mental health sounds like he
- 19:08was burned out anyway you shall not reveal information writing the representation of
- 19:12the client that the client gets informed that the disclosure is authorized to carry the
- 19:15representation or the disclosure is permitted by a paragraph B. Alright let's go on to
- 19:21danger area number two unethical information gathering. Ethics opinions about contacting
- 19:28witnesses via Facebook we have all these you know I look at so many of these because I
- 19:33I give speeches live in Philadelphia and I give speeches live every year in New York
- 19:37City and all over the place but the basic thing that you need I do a whole hour on can
- 19:45we talk that's the name of it and when if you're a litigator when can you call and talk
- 19:50to employees of the defendant corporation without having to notify the attorney and I'll
- 19:55cut you to the chase the general answer is if that employee that you're trying to contact
- 20:04of a corporation you're suing if you're trying to hold the corporation vicariously liable
- 20:12by what that employee did you must assume that the company will provide counsel to him
- 20:18because there if that if they're that high up on the food chain of the officers you can't
- 20:25talk to them without notifying the the other attorney but you can if you're just trying
- 20:29to get facts from somebody that's generally now again case law is very dynamic could be
- 20:34moving you can't face a friend a witness of course under false pretenses remember you
- 20:43can't make a false statement of material fact or law to a third person now we we know that
- 20:49under under our fiduciary duties which is the highest duty imposed relationship imposed
- 20:58by law that we can't lie to our clients and we can't do this and but you might think well
- 21:03I can lie to the opposing party it's advocacy it's just abs its puffery it's everything
- 21:09we're kick your ass well that's not it let's here's what they mean you can't make a deliberate
- 21:15misstatement about a law or or fact if you know that that person is relying on that
- 21:22I try to use this example let's say you're collecting a debt and it's a the guy owes
- 21:26five thousand dollars so you assume five thousand dollars but you send him he's a pro say and
- 21:30you say look if he'll pay us three thousand dollars we'll settle the case what do you
- 21:35say and he thinks about it and he calls you back in two weeks okay okay I'll pay the three
- 21:39thousand dollars you go oh dang it you know you only had ten days to respond to that under
- 21:44law you know so now that it's over ten days I can't settle for less than thirty three
- 21:49hundred I have to charge you ten percent more which is a lie now that would be a lie that
- 21:54would be a grievous because you're lying about the law to him you can say anything you want
- 21:59but you can't make a material lie that a person is relying on and believing you in making
- 22:04a decision and then you can't engage in conduct involving dishonesty fraud deceit or misrepresentation
- 22:10boy that's that's certainly imposed a lot isn't it case the false friending in May 2012
- 22:17Ohio civil suit filed against an insurance defense firm right for impersonation to gain
- 22:22access to this minors Facebook page of minor plaintiff and a dog so they say hey you want
- 22:29to join your Facebook and the claims of invasion of privacy and why violation of the wiretapping
- 22:35statute and in June 2013 a Gleven assistant prosecutor was posing as a fictional baby
- 22:42mama of a murder defendant in order to say the two female alibi witnesses not to testify
- 22:49I say oh no don't do that you know don't give it you know because he's a bad person you
- 22:54know and I'm the baby well that's a lie you didn't that one year's suspension from the
- 22:58practice of law but it was probate because you'd never had another complaint this barred
- 23:03for ghosting this one is really interesting you know every year I I am the course director
- 23:08of the state bars most expensive trial course it's called advanced trial strategies it's
- 23:12always in February in New Orleans and it's going to be in February 13th 14th this year
- 23:17again but and so everybody kind of thinks in New Orleans oh it's it's a lovely place
- 23:22to visit but so backwards you know and that no it's not it's there they have some really
- 23:27good ethics opinions there but here this guy Salvadori Pericone was a you assistant US
- 23:33attorney and he filed 2600 comments under assumed names and I mean he bitched about everything
- 23:41and he commented on various defendants and cases he insulted politicians lawyers police
- 23:47officers and other citizens and the Supreme Court of Louisiana disbarred him saying you
- 23:54know you're a prosecutor working with the US attorney and you're that was a breach of
- 23:57public trust you inflicted harm on individuals you insulted the prosecutor's office and legal
- 24:05profession as a whole so it was a really good opinion and I refer to it later don't communicate
- 24:14with represented parties we talked about that a second ago if you know that they are represented
- 24:19you can't talk to them without now again I do this longer thing about what what if the
- 24:28client calls you right and but you know he's represented by Joe Doe and I said well I got
- 24:33a notify Mr. Doe so you notify said that you know Mr. Doe your client wants to talk to
- 24:39me do you want to be there Mr. Doe most cases you give it a good college try if the attorney
- 24:46doesn't you know respond then I think you can assume he's not representing them anymore
- 24:52under most times so anyway but do your due diligence and try to make sure that you go
- 24:57through the attorney and you can't and you can't use social media for that to get around
- 25:04it and don't sweet snapchat message a represented party you can't friend request former co-employees
- 25:10of the plaintiff in a labor case are considered represented parties because they were high
- 25:15enough up on that food chain and the famous Robert Telly Adamo case in New Jersey the
- 25:20allegedly directed the paralegal a friend request a young male plaintiff in a personal
- 25:24injury case even though he was represented by counsel they got only an admonishment because
- 25:29nothing happened but it was later appealed and dismissed because the judge said well
- 25:33we really don't understand how Facebook really works it was too novel at the time that they
- 25:38did that okay so what is the appropriate standard and that's what I just talked about they they
- 25:45recommended that New Jersey join Massachusetts Colorado in this standard an attorney any attempt
- 25:50by an attorney or the attorney's subordinates or agents or proxies including the client
- 25:57itself to gain access to a represented parties otherwise private social media is an improper
- 26:02communication in violation of rule pressure content 4.2 furthermore any attempt to gain
- 26:07access in other words that don't cost means including going through their social media
- 26:15and any attempt to gain access to the social media whether he's represented by counselor
- 26:20not without explicitly disclosing who is making the request and the specific purpose of the
- 26:25crest constitutes context involving dishonesty prodigy misrepresentation accessing and viewing
- 26:31publicly in public information out there is completely all right even though they might
- 26:36see that you're looking at it you put it out there you can they can see it inappropriate
- 26:42friend request from a judge this is an interesting floor some of these of course are Florida
- 26:46always the most important crazy things happen in Florida Judge Linda schoonover presiding
- 26:53over Florida divorce case while she's the judge and the wife and the husband are sitting
- 26:59and she sends an ex party friend request to the litigant wife she wants to be friends
- 27:04with the litigant wife she was you know attractive and everything when the litigant declines
- 27:09the request and tells her lawyers the judge is sending me a friend request the judge
- 27:14retired you know you know the judge has to the judge then retaliated awarding most of
- 27:21the marital debt to the wife and ordering the husband the wife to pay excessive alimony
- 27:26the husband well the result of course was overturned and the judge resigned while they're
- 27:32investigating her and the complaints against her now I always said what would I do if that
- 27:37happened my client comes to me and says hey judge Scott sends me a request I think I've
- 27:44got to have a conference with the judge and the other lawyer I would say judge may me
- 27:50and the other poor police presence you know my client has indicated I you know that you
- 27:55have sent a friend request to her and I don't think that we need to discuss that and certainly
- 28:02Mr. Jones the other counsel needs to know anyway so danger area three failure to assert
- 28:10client control having that conversation with your client saying I will not lose your case
- 28:16on social media during this case you will not post about anything you will tell your
- 28:21children your grandchildren your grandparents your grandmother you know your brothers and
- 28:25sisters and friends do not post anything on social media about this case because I am
- 28:30not going to lose your case on social media in Gulliver schools versus Snae Florida court
- 28:37of appeals the daughter winning they they sued the school to got an $80,000 confidential
- 28:43settlement so she posts a whoa ho mom and papa Snae won the case against Gulliver they're
- 28:49now officially paying for my vacation to Europe suck it the whole settlement went out the
- 28:54window the violated the plaintiffs violated the Facebook post and violates the release
- 28:58confidentiality provisions so take that seriously if your client has a confidentiality clause
- 29:03when I'm mediating case where they they've agreed to that I actually write out for the
- 29:08party what you're from this point on you're only allowed to tell your lawyer and your
- 29:14accountant as required by law or government institution who's required to know that otherwise
- 29:19anybody who asks you you say the case was resolved to the satisfaction of the parties
- 29:24and that's all I can say about it I write that out for them so they do that all right
- 29:28West Virginia criminal defense lawyer was ordered to show cause why he shouldn't be held
- 29:32in front for allegedly giving his client a copy of the confidential in a packet containing
- 29:38the identity confidential employment so the client's roommate then posts several photos
- 29:43of the packet on Facebook showing the name of the dress and bragging about I'm going
- 29:47to expose the rat result of a imp imposition of a monetary fine I think he should have
- 29:55been disbarred if he did that and now here this is the rapper 50 cent and he's going
- 30:02through a bankruptcy and I love these pictures can you imagine the bankruptcy lawyer seeing
- 30:06this because here here he is spreading out the on the left things he's he's spelling
- 30:12out the word broke in hundred dollar packets a hundred dollar bills and there he is on
- 30:17the second and third picture he's on a private plane with piles of money behind him so he
- 30:23is ordered to come to court say explain to me why we're here at bankruptcy court with
- 30:28all that money behind you all right be aware of what the prosecutor is posting as well
- 30:35in people versus Armstrong 2014 the prosecutor posted Facebook about a plot to kidnap the
- 30:40key prosecution witness in Missouri versus Pope the DA tweeted before during an after
- 30:47trial called troubling and concerning by the Pelican there was a judge here in Texas who
- 30:53loved to post during trial who I think the defense is really doing a good job in the
- 30:57plaintiffs the lawyers no slouch either and the you know commissioners just kind of going
- 31:02he doing oh I'm not allowed to know you're not allowed to do that danger area number
- 31:08four evidence preservation and spoliation all right social media posts are evidence
- 31:15right 3.1 a lawyer you may not unlawfully alter or destroy evidence and cannot direct or
- 31:20assist others to do that that's rule 3.1 right Ali concrete versus Lester the wrongful death
- 31:27case is surviving husband was told to clean up his Facebook page and then answers sworn
- 31:33interrogatories that he didn't have a Facebook page $722,000 in sanctions and the plaintiffs
- 31:40counsel resigned from the practice of law and had his license suspended for five years
- 31:46by the Virginia bar where he was also licensed now spoliation of course is defined as the
- 31:52intentional reckless or negligent withholding hiding altering fabricating or destroying
- 31:56the evidence relevant to legal proceedings so I'm going to tell you this very quick story
- 32:00I think I'm one of the only lawyers I've ever known who got I actually got the judge
- 32:04to give a spoliation instruction to the jury I was trying I had jury of 12 and it was a
- 32:10case involving damage by a speeding what I said was a speeding locomotive to hitting
- 32:17trucks across an overpass luckily no one was killed so I'm trying this case and I know
- 32:23that these locomotives had at the time what they called speed tape sonnet that shows 24
- 32:27hour period it was like a graph that went around for 24 hours and how fast the train
- 32:31was going and I alleged it was speeding so that would prove what if I was right or wrong
- 32:36that speed tape would show it so when I requested that speed tape in in the discovery they said
- 32:42no we didn't have it there wasn't what wasn't on it the last witness at trial was the the
- 32:48breakman who was in the caboose and he said yes he walked up and I said well now these
- 32:53tell me about this you know you talk to the where you up up in the cabin and you know
- 32:57when we have those don't they is that where they put those speed tape right in the middle
- 33:00of on a pedestal yeah yeah and did this one have it in there yeah yeah yeah was it working
- 33:06yeah I think oh my god so I got the judge to give the jury an instruction saying if you
- 33:12find that a specific piece of evidence which would have been determinative of an issue
- 33:17was peculiarly within the control of one party and that party refused to produce it you may
- 33:24assume that that piece of evidence would not support their case so once I got that
- 33:29spoilation instruction I was home free in one that case actually one more than I asked
- 33:33for because they don't like people that lie Gato versus United Airlines personal injury
- 33:39plaintiff deactivated his Facebook account during the midst of discovery I've been honest
- 33:43to his lawyer spoilation Plamus and in premises liability case lists his witnesses to change
- 33:49their stories on Facebook then deletes the Facebook message I once was in a case of a
- 33:57high dollar case it was a very well-known family where the husband left the wife a voicemail
- 34:05on the old tape machine saying I'm gonna come over there and mess you up and no one will
- 34:11ever find out about it beep so there was a tape who leaves a message like that in the
- 34:16tape Patel versus Vannebar plaintiff premises lie solicits witnesses to change their stories
- 34:23by via Facebook Yikes so know what your client is up to can you advise your client to clean
- 34:30up the Facebook page is okay there's a bunch of good ethics opinions but I will boil them
- 34:36all down to this that you can do this you can say you can up your privacy settings you
- 34:43can take things off your Facebook page you know if you claim your back is hurting you
- 34:48might not want to have that picture of you doing you know five twirly tumbles on there
- 34:54anymore but you cannot pretend they didn't exist and you can be asked about those so
- 34:59you cannot destroy anything and you can up your and then you can just not respond is
- 35:05cleaning up your Facebook's polliation all the ethics opinion this is kind of what I said
- 35:09said it's okay to provide advice on what privacy settings to implement as well as to counsel
- 35:14them on the content that they post and its potential ramifications its permissible advice
- 35:18clients to remove or take down content as long as no spoliation you don't destroy that
- 35:23content and all evidence preservation obligations are adhered to and of course those of you who
- 35:28are much more adept at this technical stuff will tell you we have what's called or what
- 35:33the engineers for to the way back machine and that'll show what your Facebook page or what
- 35:38your website look like in nineteen ninety two if you had one so there's always ways
- 35:44it's that internet is written in ink right now I know you're not reading this this is
- 35:50I'm just showing you about the first page of my social media addendum that on the rules
- 35:57of social media meaning will you will come up you will look at all your social media
- 36:01your websites your pros your LinkedIn and everything like that we're going to turn this
- 36:05up and then on saying pay you will not post anything at all about this case you will tell
- 36:12everyone around you not to post you will not respond to any posts around that if you have
- 36:16to respond say I am not you know it's inappropriate to post about an ongoing matter period nothing
- 36:21else so they know why you're that you're there but you're not doing it all right can a governmental
- 36:27entity delete citizens post this is spoliation isn't just for citizens it's for government
- 36:32who doesn't like what citizens are posting on the public website the starting point to
- 36:37determine whether social media post can be deleted is understanding what type of forum
- 36:43is created by that page we're going to go through the different types of fora forums
- 36:48what the effort is not just limited to physical forms the courts in United States Supreme
- 36:55Court said the courts recognize three types of governmental forms first the traditional
- 37:00public forum you're out on the street corner you're standing in front of the the city hall
- 37:05blah blah blah a government designated or limited public form a meeting committee meeting
- 37:11city council meeting and the non public forum right so let's talk about traditional public
- 37:17form is the streets designated public form yes we want to hear from you in your comments
- 37:22here you can leave them in writing or give them or a non public form is what the government
- 37:26says no there you cannot hold public communication like an airport or a jail or a and confined
- 37:34or circumstance which is under police surveillance or things like that but the courts haven't
- 37:41definitely said where social media is but here's a notable case whether or not putting
- 37:48things on social media should be considered a public forum or a violation of law first
- 37:55law case law and social media is public speech in this Hawaii foundation the city of Honolulu
- 38:02to prepare the website and allowed people to post on it well a lot of people posted stuff
- 38:07that were negative to the city of Honolulu they weren't doing it right they weren't doing
- 38:11it fast enough they were wasting money blah blah blah and so what the city did is they
- 38:15just deleted those posts and the people are going to know you designated as pace and you
- 38:20have to leave it up and they said the court said you're right if you deleted that censorship
- 38:26and in quick city beach grove that's a Indiana case police department banned two women for
- 38:33posting because they posted negative things about the city of beach grove and the settlement
- 38:39before resulting the claims being able to post again and a new rules on warning other
- 38:44posters before they banned posts and then the supreme court waited in 2017 this is packing
- 38:51hand versus North Carolina now this is back when good old justice Kennedy was on the bench
- 38:57and he was always that swing vote so a sex offender was banned from doing any social
- 39:02media posts but he posted because he said I got a speeding ticket I wasn't speeding
- 39:08and so I accepted the information where it was and they made me come all the way into
- 39:12Durham for the hearing anyway and then they dismissed it as soon as I got there well that
- 39:17was my big waste of time so we just kind of venting that they wasted a couple of hours
- 39:21of his time going down when they were intending to dismiss the ticket but the Durham police
- 39:26were checking on social media posts by sex offenders and they saw that post about the
- 39:30speeding ticket said aha they brought him in and they prosecuted him and they convicted
- 39:34him for making a social media post but and the North Carolina Supreme Court upheld the
- 39:43ban on it but the United States Supreme Court said no Facebook is tantamount to a public
- 39:52forum you know the dicta now Roberts then and Thomas and Alito they wrote a separate
- 39:59opinion they concurred the result that he shouldn't have gotten in criminal trouble for posting
- 40:04about what happened in this public forum but they refused say well the whole internet is
- 40:10not the same as city park or city street so we're going to have to develop new laws it
- 40:18goes along what about censoring terms on public websites pita the ethical treatment of annuals
- 40:25right versus Texas A&M now Texas A&M which is just north of Houston has one of the best
- 40:31veterinary schools but pita was alleging that they were you know torturing these animals
- 40:36and their experiments and things like that they were abused and torture and so they wanted
- 40:42it they took down pita's posts and then pita sued and Texas saying it would prevent significant
- 40:47interference with university business ultimately the case settled with a change to the Texas
- 40:52A&M University posting policy in favor of pita and now this is during his first term what
- 40:58about at the real Donald Trump well is are his tweets a public forum because he's president
- 41:05and in night versus first amendment institute at Columbia at Al versus Donald Trump they
- 41:11said well this is Twitter but and he started that Twitter account 2009 but he did use it
- 41:18for political purposes he identified himself as the president of the United States he touted
- 41:23his let's say of agenda he defended his policy so he said well yeah you're using it as a
- 41:27political place and so it was designated a public forum let's go on to number five ethical
- 41:34conduct involving jurors using social media research jurors ethics opinion say yes you
- 41:40can and in fact some things say you ought to if you have time but both stress using
- 41:45caution so as not to inadvertently communicate with a juror sites like LinkedIn and Twitter
- 41:50inform them I think LinkedIn cost still cost you ten bucks extra a month but they'll tell
- 41:55you hey these people looked at your site but if they're just looking at your site it's
- 42:00still not impermissible communication in the 2013 and the hustle mortgage fraud trial
- 42:05maybe that was the movie with Bradley Cooper and Amy Adams about you know the the banking
- 42:12mergers anyway they complained about a first year associate on the defense fiend peaking
- 42:17at his LinkedIn profile anyway subsequent ruling we just on April 2014 it's okay to review
- 42:26a juror's internet so long as no contact is initiated and the fact that the jury finds
- 42:31out that your ruror finds out as long as you don't go exceed the bounds of what he that
- 42:37juror has purposely put up there for you to look at it's fair game you can look at it
- 42:42alright danger area and it says forgetting the impact of what you share here this is
- 42:48a picture by the assistant district attorney Julie Jones and the police officer she's
- 42:54holding a shotgun and he's holding an assault rifle and the post says you should take the
- 43:01plea take the plea the DA was not amused saying Jones's contact was contrary to office protocol
- 43:09and respect had with respect to handling of evidence and see these are just things we're
- 43:13learning to do along the way here's a fairly recent one that I found out as I was getting
- 43:20ready for this I dug up some more for you this is judge Erica Ballew in Las Vegas she
- 43:27posted a Facebook of a photo of herself and hot tub with two of the public defenders who
- 43:33worked in their courtroom one man and one woman and referring to the male public defender
- 43:38Ballew said he was surrounded by great whatever that word was it involved two T's in an S
- 43:46at any rate so her ethics charges were filed against her in January 2024 at the time I
- 43:53did this about a month ago they still hadn't resolved okay then of course you have these
- 43:57wonderful guys that encourage political violence I'm hunting rhinos which you know of course
- 44:02are Republican and name only and so it encourages violence you're holding a gun saying if I find
- 44:12you rhinos I'll shoot you that's not very good town judge shared his views in Brunswick
- 44:19New York town judge Robert Schmidt in his Facebook page applies that Bill Clinton had
- 44:24Jeffrey M. Ceddon killed and he mocks gun control laws and compared Facebook censorship
- 44:29to Nats Nazi book burning of course somebody got to him and said you sound like an idiot
- 44:34and so he he groveled he said I'm so sorry I'm so so he just got it admonished you know
- 44:43I think they ought to be a little harder on these people and the risks of advocating for
- 44:48clients on social media this happened I think right at an Ellis County which is the county
- 44:54writes out the Dallas Texas where this guy was you know trying a case and he posted I
- 45:01was in the court yesterday cross examining the witness who accused my innocent client
- 45:05I got stuck for a second was lost for the right so I said a prayer it was answered immediately
- 45:08we got to the truth with this hostile witness for those who say prayer won't work you never
- 45:15really played with the knowledge that it will be answered yeah I guess that's all of us
- 45:19because we really never know if we answered rocks on Collins the judge didn't like that
- 45:25anyway and his Facebook prayers are met with gag orders from the Ellis County Texas judges
- 45:31don't do that some courtroom victory selfies in September 2015 some caught Wisconsin order
- 45:38lot Anthony cotton there shown on the right snaps a victory selfie with an acquitted murder
- 45:42client in the courtroom that posted on Facebook and the judge didn't like it and ordered caught
- 45:48to return to court to explain himself okay zealous advocacy if you ever just want to
- 45:54Google this case in the matter of James Hansen and see the vile thing that Mr. Hansen said it
- 46:01reads like a scripted you know the guy who writes you know family I would say Indiana
- 46:08attorney sends his clients ex-husband a profanity lace Facebook poetry says I'm going to gather all
- 46:13the red relevant evidence and I'm gonna you so hard your teeth are gonna come loose I've got you in
- 46:20my sights and he was charged with felony intimidation he really said a lot of really bad things I'm
- 46:26surprised he only got a 30-day suspension from the practice of law but that's pretty funny case to
- 46:32read maybe not for to mr. Hansen and now this this is Joyce McCool Joyce McCool is there there's a
- 46:39technical name in in I think in medicine for her she's a nutball and she was walking the court she
- 46:47didn't even have a client she was walking the courthouses and you know she puts out all these
- 46:54inflammatory and misleading statements about cases and child custody contains that had sealed
- 46:59information and she's disbarred for her social media blitz but she didn't she didn't have a client
- 47:06in those cases she was just a snoop and she was posting stuff and maybe think she was going to save
- 47:12the world or something December 14 an Air Force lawyer post comments on Facebook critical to the
- 47:18military's policy on sexual assault resulting in criminal investigation of that lawyer now the
- 47:24interesting thing on that case that I looked up I'm going what she was actually complaining that
- 47:30that officers male officers having dating female unlisted personnel were treated quite differently
- 47:40than female officers dating enlisted personnel it was a really a two two tiered system one that
- 47:51favored the males and she was doing that well she had got criminally investigated other as
- 47:58example of lawyers behaving badly in the matter of gamble that we talked about that suspension
- 48:03of lawyer egregious over the past she was one says you you de bag you know to oh this was the other
- 48:09one yeah poses lawyer for egregious over the top messages on face unrepresented unwind mother while
- 48:15representing the baby's biological father in an adoption proceeding so he's he is say he's the
- 48:27lawyer and he's saying terrible things how dare you try to you know give that baby away you're
- 48:32you're a dirt ball everything like that so no that's to the other side court held the lawyer
- 48:36of messages trying to make the mother feel guilty about consenting to give the child up for adoption
- 48:40consistent violations of rule 8.4 and 8.4 g conduct reflecting adversely on that person's
- 48:47fitness to practice law here tweeting from the courtroom chicago lawyer vincen schmelz is at
- 48:52a spoofing trial the spoofing is the high frequency trading using algorithms and he sends nine tweets
- 48:58with pictures of the evidence despite prominent courtroom signs saying photographs recording
- 49:03or broadcasting is prohibited right in front of them and he's taking pictures of the evidence
- 49:08he got a $5,000 fine in order to do 50 hours of pro bono work in order to attend a seminar
- 49:14in social media and legal ethics maybe mr schmelz is with us today if you are hello victor all right
- 49:21more examples of what not to do jason maris a brooklyn assistant district attorney has his
- 49:26facebook page posted on a national media outlet there he is in blackface he's this tall white guy
- 49:33in blackface holding a confederate flag in simulating prison rape the brooklyn da isn't
- 49:39amused by the abhorrent stupid and childish behavior and of course uh in 2011 indiana dipi ag
- 49:46is fired after tweeting about using live ammo on pro labor protesters in madison wisconsin
- 49:54and i like the second case here we're going to talk about it for a second wane michigan prosciutto
- 49:59walls is fired after suggesting on facebook that rioters should be shot and a usa a distinct
- 50:06u.s attorney john craft and bowmont that's in eastern texas comes under fire for inflammatory
- 50:11posts on facebook about the trevon martin case interrogatory statements about president obama
- 50:16including referring to him as the dali bama and the u.s attorney east for the east indus john bails
- 50:21calls the comments reprehace reprehensible so defense attorneys then of course use those comments
- 50:28to say i wanted a new trial this guy's sentencing recommendations were all off and it's because he's
- 50:34a racist so then of course you do us a favor here's these for florida prosecutor kenteth luis
- 50:41posts controversial comments after your london nightclub mass shooting um uh i can't believe
- 50:47this seven years ago says nightclubs are utter cesspools of debauchery and our lander should
- 50:52be leveled as a melting pot of third world miscreants and ghetto thugs and he lost his job
- 51:00as he probably should and then of course what we talked about uh before the salvatore perocana he
- 51:09in in new orleans he did his 2600 comments with five identities one to 200 posts related to the
- 51:17matters being handled by his office and he is barred because his actions betrayed and caused
- 51:23actual armed pending prosecutions what about online reviews do not ask your client to post
- 51:29reviews that everybody does it and it's not an unethical anymore in most states but i would say
- 51:35your good review is the fact you got paid it's a confidential communication if you're going to
- 51:39ask your client to post on what a great lawyer you were make sure you tell that client you don't
- 51:44have to do this because i'm asking you to breach the attorney client privilege you have a right to
- 51:49expect from me if you're going to post for me so you don't have to do that unless you want to
- 51:54because there's a lot of lawyers there's a lot of clients out there that i'm sure i just talked to
- 52:00one today would never want anybody to know that he even had to have a lawyer high up uh you know
- 52:05a politician and so if i say oh yeah why don't you tell everybody how great i was in your criminal
- 52:12case no i don't like that um what about i i say good clients pay you consider that your good
- 52:20and once you start soliciting reviews you encourage those displeased with your wife to post negative
- 52:27reviews as i always say maybe you think this is too but you know who who knows how to post
- 52:34crazy people they'll post all day long they don't care what you you know they don't pay any attention
- 52:39to that you know injunction you got against them further saying anything because they got nothing
- 52:44to lose they got nothing and they're going to make it even because by the way you were the third
- 52:49lawyer that couldn't do their unreasonable demands so watch it once you start doing that uh doctors
- 52:56i got a few doctors here who lost their license a dr kathryn growa dr ossey locks lost her medical
- 53:02license for harming patients while live streaming their surgery she'd do surgery and talking and
- 53:07then she harmed a patient during the social media dr jason cambell the tick-tock doc gained fame first
- 53:14by dancing on camera but then it was said wait a minute that's the guy who's guilty of sexual
- 53:18harassment he ended up paying five hundred eighty five thousand dollars dr colab was a cleveland
- 53:23clinic resident career ended for anti-semitic tweets years ago surfed in an it's written in
- 53:28ink and dr dalia carrese said the australian pretended to be a doctor online and uh treated
- 53:36gave advice to over 100 000 she had to plead guilty to that all right finally don't here's a funny
- 53:44case and comes out of north texas this is north of dalis this van dyke says i'm a lawyer and i'll
- 53:48show you mr retzlap attorney van dyke sues his online critic retzlap who had referred to van dyke
- 53:54as a nazi and a white supremacist he sues in the eastern district of texas and they both
- 53:59exchanged bitter emails and messages and then finally prompting van dyke to declare in his
- 54:03december 2nd message this guy's cost me damn near two full years of my life and i'm not going to
- 54:08spend another minute of my time in the fbi and the courts and state bar can do what they what
- 54:13but friendly i do not give a solitary i think it was fish is the word he was looking for
- 54:18said i'm out and as far as i'm concerned thomas retzlap no longer existed which just plays into
- 54:23retzlap hands and he says my position is this van dyke can go fish for himself i ain't dismissing
- 54:30shots if he wants to quit fine but i'm winning so fish him all right the danger of engaging so
- 54:38then van dyke files a motion for court order dismissal any basic laws says the plaintiffs
- 54:44would dismiss this lawsuit he is of the opinion that short of the locking the fenton a prison
- 54:47self the rest of this knife there is nothing that any other court can do to stop defendant from
- 54:52continuing harassment and there's no resolution of this case stop defendants behavior and the
- 54:57pen is already placed plaintive and dire financial straits simply put plaintiff lacks the time
- 55:01resources continue letting see that's what you had when you poke the bear you sometimes get bit
- 55:07and revealing conferences isn't helpful when your client says a bad thing about you you know
- 55:13you can't say yeah well he was a dirt bag and he's a liar and everything like that the best thing i've
- 55:18ever seen was that that the paragraph see the very bottom that was a pennsylvania bar association
- 55:23of formal ethics opinion that says a lawyer when you're getting bad review a lawyer's duty to keep
- 55:29client confidence it has a few exceptions and an abundance of caution i do not feel a little
- 55:32the particular respond in a point by point fashion in this form suffice to say that i do not believe
- 55:36the post affairs affair an accurate picture of events now i gave this to a friend of mine who
- 55:42had it was a plaintiff's attorney and the woman was complaining didn't get enough money and the
- 55:46other thing he added on this which i thought was brilliant because it made him look said we have
- 55:50invited mrs. jones to come to our office and review her file with us and we're glad to do that
- 55:56no cost to her and so far she has refused to come all right that shows look we're being good guys
- 56:01she's the dirt bag here anyway so practice caveats for you refrain from posting during trials
- 56:07refrain from any commentary about your client's period remain the adult you have to do sherry
- 56:13duties the essence of this profession is confidentiality and discretion you're going to be
- 56:18judged by your worst post remember the woman who posted she was in a big um you know advertising
- 56:24firm in new york and she was on her first trip to cape town south africa and she posted gosh this
- 56:29is already about seven or eight years ago said hey i'm get to go to africa oh hope i don't get aids
- 56:35don't worry i'm white uh just and by time she arrived there she had been fired from her job
- 56:42and of course her tweets let a million people to say the most vile things about her so the the
- 56:50punishment for bib the bad tweet is like 10 times worse than what you ever intended uh to do so you're
- 56:56going to be judged by your worst post don't ask for online interviews never tweet or post anything
- 57:01you wouldn't say to a person's face so again review your client's social media uh if at all
- 57:07before signing on because you might be in a big problem every post is permanent you'll be judged
- 57:12by your worst legal representation tells a willingness to refrain from posting and never reveal
- 57:17anything strategies evidence attitudes or opinions never post or tweet anything you wouldn't say to
- 57:21the person's face and don't try to destroy or permanently evidence and if you can't say it to
- 57:26their face you're probably using it wrong right uh you rarely need to use it you're a trusted confident
- 57:34if you do tell the truth it's a truth will get you in trouble you're likely using it
- 57:38inappropriately and before posting social media consider every single negative connotation and
- 57:43do not ask clients to post anything about you now i will end with this guy have just a couple of
- 57:49minutes left i strongly believe this to the core of my existence we are the most important profession
- 57:55in the united states of america we are that guardians of the rule of law that is our social
- 58:00compact to to handle disputes with the laws and within rules and if the rules aren't good enough
- 58:06we'll make better rules but we'll always do that and part of that is our duty of civility our civility
- 58:12means we are going to create a safe space to hear and consider and have people who have can do something
- 58:19about it all opinions that doesn't mean our opinions are always right but our the opinions we have
- 58:24might be influenced on the some of the opinions of others even if they're not right so we the whole
- 58:31point of the rule of law is for us to listen to create a space where we can exchange opinions
- 58:35and you have something something wonderful in your pocket and that's a law license you can
- 58:40reduce people's suffering you can solve their problems you can remove their strength you can
- 58:45make their lives better and we need to use that and always remember how gifted we are that we have
- 58:51that access in this society at this moment in time we are here to support the fair administration
- 58:57of justice so there you have it there you have my email claud at lawpay.com i'm delighted to
- 59:04do been invited today i've got many more presentations and i'm happy to present to the
- 59:10Beverly Hills Bar Association and i'm thinking of you out there right now as i'm sitting in
- 59:14Austin Texas and we'll think about my very very happy childhood growing up there in California
- 59:21and so i'm going to turn it back over and see if uh any questions if not i'll let you all go
- 59:30are you there jose? yes i am and we do if you click on the q&a you will see the questions
- 59:35all right let me see if i can find that you might want to stop your screen share okay here we go
- 59:40hi everybody okay i had Beverly Hills questions yeah claud at law pay um let's see do i did you
- 59:48say there's more questions yeah there's some that if you click on the q&a that we have oh okay i'm
- 59:53sorry no worries all right thank you very much please share your shows from me to claud's use
- 59:57for engagement absolutely i will send that to the Beverly Hills Bar or you can send me if you want
- 1:00:03again claud at law pay and i'll send it to you immediately i'll send you a whole packet um it's
- 1:00:08part of the reluctance to categorize facebook and social media as private forums uh due to the
- 1:00:13first amendment implications yes um the courts found social media would that prevent facebook
- 1:00:18private well this is a longer thing that i'll have time to do is there a line between posts made
- 1:00:23in the course of business and attorneys private speech when not on the clock or lawyers just not
- 1:00:27able to engage in offensive speech generally boy i wish i could answer that question you you ask great
- 1:00:34questions i think that the wiser thing is to avoid uh offensive speech now clearly i'm not
- 1:00:41you know immune to that either there's times that i've been uh you know wish i hadn't said things
- 1:00:48because it's hard to take them back uh but let's see if there's a couple of other things don't
- 1:00:54thank you very much i hope it's okay for me so that i love claud oh well thank you donna and
- 1:01:00again there are so many presentations that i have that you would love like a how to prepare witnesses
- 1:01:06you know so one of some of that i do i on contract construction are people's favorite on how to improve
- 1:01:12your your contracts because anyway thank you very much uh uh judge aposic thank you very much cathleen
- 1:01:20all of you thank you very much i know you're probably willing to get back into your day and get
- 1:01:25back to work and you all have a wonderful holiday season and i'm told by all of my wonderful jewish
- 1:01:31friends that we have this really unusual thing we're both christmas and the first day of hanukkah
- 1:01:36on the great day so everyone please enjoy it and try to get a little rest too and do something you
- 1:01:42really want to do thanks everyone you may be eligible for c le credit in your state visit
- 1:01:49bhba.org slash podcasts for more information