Latest / eMotors: Electric Revolution / Solid-State Battery Comparison: Rimac, CATL, QuantumScape
Transcript
- 0:09Welcome back to the Deep Dive where we take your stack of
- 0:12research, the dense articles, the technical papers, all those
- 0:15corporate announcements, and we boil it all down.
- 0:17We find the essential, fascinating insights you really
- 0:20need to know. Today we're looking at the power
- 0:23source of the future. I mean, this is the battery tech
- 0:25that's really set to end the internal combustion era for good
- 0:28for what, the better part of a decade?
- 0:30The whole conversation around EVs was just one thing.
- 0:33Range anxiety, you know, will I make it to the next charger?
- 0:37But your analysis confirms that this whole psychological
- 0:39barrier, it's pretty much history.
- 0:42That is pretty clear. Back in 2011, the median EV
- 0:44range was a tiny 73 miles. By 2025, that's jumped to 283
- 0:50miles. We've largely solved that
- 0:52initial range problem. We have and that shows how fast
- 0:54the chemistry has evolved, but it also, you know, it reveals a
- 0:57new challenge. We've sort of reached a
- 0:59temporary ceiling with the current high performance lithium
- 1:01ion cells. They generally top out around
- 1:032:50, maybe 280 Watt hours per kilogram.
- 1:06So if EVs are going to go from just being a strong alternative
- 1:09to, well, true Rd. dominance, they need another big leap.
- 1:12A chemical and architectural leap.
- 1:14And that leap, according to all the search you shared with us,
- 1:17is solid-state batteries or s s BS.
- 1:20So our mission today is to focus completely on this race to get
- 1:24them to market. We're looking past the current
- 1:26stuff, the high density of lithium ion, and straight into
- 1:29what's next. We're going to examine the key
- 1:31players, Quantum Scapes, CATL and REMAC, to see who is really
- 1:35ahead. And you know what metrics prove
- 1:38they're fundamentally changing the game before this decade is
- 1:41out. OK, so let's unpack that shift.
- 1:43Early lithium ion cells had some really clear limitations.
- 1:46The liquid electrolyte, for one, was a safety risk.
- 1:48Everyone worried about flammability.
- 1:50And then you had lower energy density and charging times that,
- 1:53well, they still took a while, 30 minutes, maybe more.
- 1:55The data suggests these new S S BS are about to just completely
- 1:58wipe out all those issues at once.
- 2:00And what's really transformative here is understanding why the
- 2:03solid electrolyte is so much better in today's batteries, the
- 2:06liquid ones. Charging too fast causes these
- 2:08little metallic spikes, they're called dendrites, to grow, and
- 2:11they grow right through the separator.
- 2:13They cause short circuits, which, you know, reduces the
- 2:15battery's lifespan. And in the worst case scenarios,
- 2:18that's what leads to thermal runaway, to fires.
- 2:20That's why current batteries have to charge more slowly.
- 2:23So the liquid is the actual weak point here, it's forcing all the
- 2:27other limitations. Precisely, you replace that
- 2:29flammable liquid with a a robust solid medium.
- 2:33It could be a polymer, A sulfide, an oxide and you just
- 2:37stop the dendrites cold. This unlocks 2 massive
- 2:40advantages that are linked together.
- 2:41First, you get vastly improved safety and 2nd, you can now
- 2:45safely handle these ultra high energy densities.
- 2:47I mean the prototypes are targeting specific energy
- 2:49densities well above 400 Watt hours per kilogram.
- 2:52That jump is the key number we have to track.
- 2:55Just to give you some context for that, early lithium ion
- 2:57cells were around what, 100 Weir MHQ ROMs?
- 3:01Today's very best is about 250, so jumping to over 400, that
- 3:05isn't just a small range boost, it means a car maker could build
- 3:08a battery pack that's maybe 40% lighter or 40% smaller and still
- 3:12have the exact same range. And that energy density, when
- 3:15you combine it with the safety, it enables the other key metric,
- 3:19ultra fast charging without that risk of dendrites, SSPS are
- 3:23being engineered to go from say 10% to 80% state of charge in
- 3:27five to 10 minutes. And that is the crucial
- 3:29benchmark for mass adoption because behaviorally it feels
- 3:32just like pumping gas. The last friction point is just
- 3:35gone. OK.
- 3:36We should probably pause here on the 2 core metrics we're going
- 3:38to hear about. There's gravimetric density,
- 3:40which is Watt hours per kilogram, and volume metric
- 3:43density, which is Watt hours per liter.
- 3:45Yeah. Why do both of them matter?
- 3:46Are they for different engineering goals?
- 3:48That's a really key distinction. So gravimetric density, the
- 3:51weight, HKG, that's all about energy versus weight.
- 3:54It's critical for maximizing range, right?
- 3:56And for improving efficiency, say in trucks.
- 3:59It also helps reduce material costs.
- 4:01But volumetric density, the WHL, that's energy versus volume, how
- 4:05much space it takes up. This is essential for packaging.
- 4:09If you're designing A sleek sports car or a compact city EV,
- 4:13every single cubic centimeter counts.
- 4:15High WHL just means you can pack more energy into a smaller space
- 4:19it changes everything for vehicle design right so to get
- 4:23our heads around the global competition, the research
- 4:25material really points to three players who show the different
- 4:28strategies if quantum scape they're focused on technical
- 4:31validation ATL, which is all about volume and scale and then
- 4:34there's remac technology targeting that ultra premium
- 4:37high end niche let's. Start with Quantum Scape or QS.
- 4:41They seem to be the leader right now in getting independent high
- 4:44profile validation for their tech, especially to that big
- 4:47collaboration they have with Powerco.
- 4:49That's the Volkswagen Group's battery.
- 4:50CUP, their credibility is really built on being transparent and
- 4:53showing long term performance. The data they've put out shows
- 4:57their cells going past 1000 cycles while still retaining an
- 5:02incredible 95% of their original capacity.
- 5:04And that's critical because for you as a consumer, that speaks
- 5:07directly to longevity, to the total cost of ownership.
- 5:10If a battery lasts that long it just de risks the whole long
- 5:14term investment in the vehicle. And their biggest public demo
- 5:16was that one in September 2025 at IAA Mobility.
- 5:20They showed off the QSE 5 cells with their own proprietary Cobra
- 5:24separator process and didn't just show it in a lab, they
- 5:27actually put it into a modified Ducati V21L race motorcycle.
- 5:32Yes, and that was a crucial move.
- 5:33It demonstrated real world integration.
- 5:35The key numbers from that debut were all about high volumetric
- 5:38energy density, 804, four WHL and crucially a fast charge time
- 5:43of 10% to 80% in just over 12 minutes.
- 5:45It's not the five minute dream yet, but it's a huge step
- 5:48forward. And you can see the conviction
- 5:51in the investment. The following Volkswagen
- 5:53expanded their collaboration. They put up another way, up to
- 5:54$131 million in milestone payments.
- 5:58That kind of commitment from a global auto giant?
- 6:01It says a lot about their belief in the timeline for
- 6:03industrialization by the end of the decade.
- 6:05Absolute. So now we can pivot from that
- 6:07technical validation to just sheer scale.
- 6:09And that brings us to CATL, the global behemoth of battery
- 6:13manufacturing. Their strategy is fundamentally
- 6:16different. It's about pure volume and
- 6:18really aggressive density targets.
- 6:20Right as the world's production heavyweight, CATL is all about
- 6:23maximizing specific energy density for the mass market.
- 6:27The research says they're already testing 20 amp hour
- 6:29cells, aiming for a really aggressive 500 weight kilograms.
- 6:33I mean, that's an aspirational, what, 40% jump over what's even
- 6:36available today? And their timeline is just as
- 6:39aggressive. They're aiming for high volume
- 6:41production as early as 2027. And when they talk about
- 6:45development level 7-8, that means the process is very
- 6:48mature. It's past the pilot stage, it's
- 6:51almost ready to be dropped into full scale assembly lines around
- 6:54the world. CATL is just leveraging their
- 6:57massive experience in Celta pack architecture to make sure that
- 7:00once the chemistry is locked, they can flood the market.
- 7:03OK. So if QS has the demonstrated
- 7:05performance and CATL is going from Max density, our third
- 7:08player REMAC technology, they seem to be taking a totally
- 7:12different path. They're focusing on the ultra
- 7:14premium, high end hypercar niche.
- 7:17Think Bugatti. That's right, Rimac is at a more
- 7:19intermediate development level and their production target is
- 7:22further out around 20-30. But they are all about bespoke
- 7:25performance. Their current 100 kilowatt
- 7:27prototype gets about 260 weight age kilograms and this is
- 7:30important. That density is comparable to
- 7:33today's best liquid lithium ion cells, not those 400 plus
- 7:37targets. Wait a minute, if their density
- 7:39is basically the same as what we have now, how are they even a
- 7:42solid-state contender? Are they just showing off some
- 7:44kind of charging trick? That's a great question and it's
- 7:47because they are using that non flammable solid electrolyte to
- 7:50just push the charging envelope regardless of the starting
- 7:53density. Their unique selling point is
- 7:55speed and ultra fast charge from 10% to 80% in just 6 1/2
- 8:00minutes. They do this by pairing the
- 8:03safety benefit of the SSB with extremely sophisticated
- 8:06lightweight axles and advanced cooling.
- 8:09It just maximizes how much power the battery can accept.
- 8:13So their strategy is all about volumetric density and insane
- 8:16speed for that high end market, The market where cost isn't an
- 8:19issue and packaging is everything.
- 8:21So they're proving that S S BS can deliver performance metrics,
- 8:24specifically charging speed, that are just impossible with
- 8:27today's liquid tech, even if their gravimetric density needs
- 8:30to catch up later. So we've established the
- 8:32technology is maturing. We have multiple major players,
- 8:34Toyota, QSCATL, all targeting volume production before 20-30.
- 8:38If we connect that back to the bigger picture, the implications
- 8:41for the mass market are, well, they're enormous.
- 8:43So what does this tech shift mean for EV development?
- 8:46It's more than just adding a few miles of range, right?
- 8:49How do SSB's really change the entire value proposition of an
- 8:53electric car? Well, they essentially eliminate
- 8:55the 2 remaining non cost barriers to mass EV adoption.
- 8:59That's charging time, parity and sustained battery health.
- 9:02The five to 10 minute charge time we talked about, that's
- 9:05basically indistinguishable from a stop at the gas station.
- 9:07And that level of convenience just removes the last major
- 9:10psychological hurdle for consumers.
- 9:12And the better cycle lifelike quantum escapes 1000 cycles with
- 9:1695% capacity. That dramatically lowers the
- 9:19total cost of ownership, the TCO.
- 9:21Exactly, for commercial fleets or anyone who drives a lot,
- 9:24battery replacement is a huge potential expense.
- 9:27S S BS promise a durability and longevity that just far exceeds
- 9:31current batteries and makes them ideal for heavy use.
- 9:34Extending the vehicles economic life and this combination of
- 9:37convenience and lower TCO, it's going to combine powerfully with
- 9:41policy drivers. We're already seeing those.
- 9:43You've got major mandates like in the EU, in California,
- 9:46targeting a phase out of new internal combustion engine sales
- 9:49by 2035. This technological leap just
- 9:52cements that trajectory. We look at the numbers.
- 9:55Global EV sales went from 120,000 in 2012 to 14 million in
- 9:592023. S, S, BS are going to accelerate
- 10:02that dominance exponentially, especially when you think about
- 10:05things like autonomous driving and grid stabilization.
- 10:08And that's where the ecosystem synergy becomes so critical
- 10:11because SSBS are safer, more energy dense and charge faster.
- 10:14They are the perfect power platform for all these advanced
- 10:17mobility services. You know, they enable much
- 10:19better synergy with autonomous driving platforms, the ones
- 10:21being piloted by Waymo, Cruise, Baidu.
- 10:24Those services require consistent high density,
- 10:27reliable power. Basically 247.
- 10:29And crucially, SSBS really boost the viability of vehicle to grid
- 10:32V2G adoption. Yes, you think about the high
- 10:35safety, the long cycle life and the rapid power transfer of s s
- 10:39BS. They transform the EV into a
- 10:42really reliable distributed energy storage asset.
- 10:46Millions of V2G enabled EVs could feed power back into the
- 10:49grid during peak demand. That stabilizes our energy
- 10:52infrastructure, especially in a future with more intermittent
- 10:55renewables like solar and wind. That's a true game changer for
- 10:59grid resilience. OK, so the technological
- 11:01forecast looks pretty sunny. High density fast charging
- 11:04batteries are on the horizon. But we know the EV transition is
- 11:08structurally really complex. If the technology is being
- 11:12solved, what stops us from just swapping every gas car with an
- 11:15EV next year? Even with S, S PS coming, what
- 11:18are the major structural issues still on the table in 2025?
- 11:21The main barriers that remain are geopolitical and
- 11:25infrastructural, and they both feed into the core issue of
- 11:28global affordability. First, the entire transition, S
- 11:31S, PS included, is still hostage to critical material.
- 11:34And those supply chains are still so heavily concentrated in
- 11:37just a few places, which means geopolitical risk and price
- 11:39volatility are just baked into the system.
- 11:41That's the vulnerability right there.
- 11:43The raw materials, the lithium, cobalt, nickel, they're all
- 11:47sourced from a very narrow set of places.
- 11:49For instance, 70% of the world's cobalt comes from the Democratic
- 11:53Republic of Congo, and even after you dig it up, the
- 11:56processing is centralized. China controls over 60% of
- 12:00global lithium refining. So even if CATL or Quantum Scape
- 12:05completely perfects the chemistry, any instability or
- 12:08trade tension in one of those key regions could create a
- 12:11massive bottleneck. It would drive up the cost of
- 12:14the final SSB cell and just make it that much harder for the tech
- 12:17to become democratized globally. Exactly.
- 12:19And the second major hurdle, which links directly to cost, is
- 12:22infrastructure inequality. This technological leak to
- 12:25solid-state is fantastic for mature markets, but it doesn't
- 12:29solve the fundamental problem of unequal access to electricity
- 12:32and charging in emerging economies.
- 12:33Yeah, the sources layout this contrast so starkly.
- 12:36Western Europe, in China, they've invested heavily.
- 12:39They have, what, 12 to 16 public charges for every 100 EVs on the
- 12:42road? That density supports mass
- 12:44adoption. It completely gets rid of range
- 12:46anxiety. But then you look at the global
- 12:48S 40% of the world's population, especially in rural regions and
- 12:52emerging markets, still lacks reliable public charging.
- 12:55Sub-Saharan Africa, for example, has fewer than one public
- 12:58charger for every 100 EVs. That is just a staggering gap,
- 13:02and it's not just the number of chargers.
- 13:04The affordability barrier makes it even worse.
- 13:07EVs, even with cheaper SSBS, eventually have a really high
- 13:11initial price compared to local incomes in these markets.
- 13:15So if you can't afford the car and you can't rely on the
- 13:17infrastructure, this whole amazing technological leap is
- 13:21essentially irrelevant to you. In until we address that
- 13:24infrastructure gap and couple it with policies and financial
- 13:27support that bring down that initial sticker price in low
- 13:29income countries, the EV transition just won't be truly
- 13:32global. We risk creating a 2 tiered
- 13:34system where the developed world gets 5 minute charging and the
- 13:37global S gets left behind. Hashtag how?
- 13:39Trout. What a monumental journey we've
- 13:41covered today. I mean, we've gone from that
- 13:43meager 73 mile median range back in 2011 all the way to
- 13:48prototypes hitting 400 plus HKG and charging in under 7 minutes.
- 13:53The key take away for you is this.
- 13:55The impending shift from liquid lithium ion to solid-state is
- 13:58not just some incremental improvement, it's a
- 14:00technological chasm being crossed and fundamentally
- 14:03changes the EV value proposition from a viable alternative to,
- 14:08well, the inevitable market default.
- 14:10And that technological leap creates a really interesting
- 14:12strategic tension going forward. So given that affordability in
- 14:15emerging markets is still a huge structural barrier, will the
- 14:18race for super premium SSB performance, you know, like
- 14:21RE/MAX focus on 6.5 5 minute charges for hyper cars?
- 14:24Will that actually delay the availability of lower cost, more
- 14:27democratizing SSB tech? Or will the sheer scale, the
- 14:30volume focus, and the global supply chain mastery of a player
- 14:33like CATL win that battle 1st and force the technology to
- 14:37become affordable for true global adoption?
- 14:39That is the. Pivotal question we'll all be
- 14:41tracking as those production timelines get closer to the end
- 14:44of the decade. Thank you so much for sharing
- 14:46your sources and joining us for this deep dive into the battery
- 14:49revolution that's really set to redefine transportation.
- 14:53You can follow our channel for more curated exlorations into
- 14:55complex topics. We'll see you next time.