Latest / SHULCHAN ARUCH YOMI: Own the Halacha in 25 minutes a day! / Yoreh De’ah 246:4-6. Learning Torah: Secular Studies, Payment, Women

Transcript

Yoreh De’ah 246:4-6. Learning Torah: Secular Studies, Payment, Women · SHULCHAN ARUCH YOMI: Own the Halacha in 25 minutes a day!

• 0:00
  Say hello, good morning. We are innovation involved with
• 0:02
  this Tom Mutoya. We're in the middle of the
• 0:06
  Siddala. We're in the middle of the
• 0:07
  Ramah. Just to recap the Ramah
• 0:12
  Sushita's about how you split up the you know, how you split up
• 0:17
  your learning. Just one interesting point I
• 0:20
  didn't like. I think stand on the touch is is
• 0:23
  Gumara is you know, that's what I think, but I don't know is
• 0:28
  that you know, the Mahabir says he should split it up into
• 0:32
  Tershevic S Tershabalpet and and Talmud.
• 0:36
  So Talmud doesn't specifically according to them around only it
• 0:40
  doesn't specifically mean Gemara.
• 0:42
  It means Eun. You know, it says it says
• 0:45
  Tershabalpet is, you know, is Mishnaeus.
• 0:49
  But you know, nowadays it could also include Gemara.
• 0:53
  But the point of Talmud, the third of the day is this thing
• 0:56
  Madame Nilsson also to think about what you're learning and,
• 0:59
  and and and compare things and, and divine into it and, and
• 1:03
  think about it. And that's, and that's, you
• 1:05
  know, it's a big failure of the, you know, of the, of the Lemood.
• 1:08
  I mean, that's the famous base of Levy.
• 1:11
  This is NASA. There's two types of NASA and
• 1:14
  Ishmael. One of is there's and one one of
• 1:17
  them is the, is the Icarus, you know, the the thinking and the
• 1:19
  EU and the, and the that's, you know, Lemud, I'm sorry, that's
• 1:23
  also a Shanghai's match. But like that.
• 1:26
  So it's not just, you know, reading the words, it's it's
• 1:29
  understanding and and and and making condition and things or
• 1:32
  on your however, at your level is fine.
• 1:35
  You're in the Ramov in the autumn Limoid Ki mikra mishna
• 1:39
  the Gomorrah. But please give me shakima Akrem
• 1:43
  the Ramos says the Hampshire. You know that the the random
• 1:46
  time says nowadays we rely on learning Gomorrah includes
• 1:49
  everything right learning more Taka If you learn Gomorrah and
• 1:52
  you learn and you and you go through you also there's a lot
• 1:55
  of even if you can't think of things yourself, but you see the
• 1:58
  process of how to be shown in thought and all that running
• 2:01
  thought it was that Yeah in right, but the Mikra Mikra
• 2:09
  mission of Gomoro police skin hunting Shaka Maka.
• 2:11
  I am it was there you can have oil on answer.
• 2:14
  This is how you get schmuck. This is how you enjoy oil and
• 2:17
  hazard of all the harbour. I know oil and harbour of a low
• 2:21
  believable char Hoffmas, but learning other Hoffman's are not
• 2:27
  that's not how you that that's not how you get oil and hazard
• 2:31
  and oil and harbour and what are these?
• 2:34
  What are these char char Hochmas?
• 2:37
  So the well, let's just finish the Ramon and the talk about a
• 2:41
  couple things outside, because welcome Moto Lumo back cry.
• 2:45
  Bashar Hochmas Ramos says you can you can learn how the
• 2:48
  Hochmas back cry. That's how I remember sitting in
• 2:51
  shiver Victor Miller and he said he said he said he had a stack.
• 2:55
  He had a stack of it's like his Peter Botanica outside his
• 2:58
  bathroom. He would he would read in the
• 3:01
  bathroom. Vivant should only use sifry
• 3:04
  meaning as long as these aren't sifry meaning there's fear in
• 3:08
  them. Zelnicker the zelnickerbeneche
• 3:13
  and learning other hochmaz is what's called teel Bapartis.
• 3:17
  The ain't no other tile Bapartis raffle after Shimali creates a
• 3:21
  bust of the eye and he shouldn't go into parties until after he
• 3:26
  who leader is ever had there didn't mitzvah.
• 3:29
  He shouldn't go into these things until he has a good
• 3:31
  grounding. This is the sheet of sarabam.
• 3:33
  Now other shark Hochmas, the shaft says, and this is the
• 3:37
  point of the that that includes philosophy, philosophy math.
• 3:44
  You know, obviously it's not talking about learning for a
• 3:46
  job. We're talking about like higher
• 3:48
  level math and or, you know, and higher engineering sciences,
• 3:53
  things like that. Hafosakabola and also
• 3:56
  Hafosakabola is included in this point of the Ramallah at least
• 4:01
  included in this thing. Now the shock says that the
• 4:04
  passion of the Ramallah doesn't make is the shock and you'll see
• 4:07
  the bra also the Hulk on the Ramallah and they say that
• 4:10
  doesn't what he says is not even not according to the round bomb
• 4:13
  is not is not correct, because his definition of of pardes is
• 4:22
  different than the pastas, because the remote says that the
• 4:26
  acre. The thing about the problem with
• 4:28
  Pardes, the way the grog explains it is that you know the
• 4:33
  according to the Kumar and taiga that that is that we see our
• 4:36
  ridiculous on the paradise and their Bikiva emerged, you know,
• 4:40
  unscathed and Binzoma went crazy because he was behind too much.
• 4:45
  He couldn't miash of everything. But as I died and after became
• 4:52
  it was and so the Ramon learns the reason why Akra became a
• 4:58
  kaifer. Zagora says that he used to go
• 5:01
  out from the bass manager. She had sifry meaning or
• 5:03
  whatever it was fell out of his jacket meaning that he was icing
• 5:07
  and sifry meaning. So the Ramon understands the
• 5:10
  problem with learning other hokumas is that if you Start
• 5:14
  learning sifry, meaning this career mixed in, it's that's
• 5:17
  what's going to knock you off otherwise, otherwise you
• 5:20
  otherwise you're going to be otherwise it's OK, bad cry of
• 5:25
  the Shah and the famous lotion of the girl over here is the
• 5:29
  famous girl who says he says Lashon Arab any Masuka and the
• 5:33
  lotion of Arab is not correct in Zoe partes hate Amar Volo.
• 5:39
  Whatever he's understand, you know, he he he said his
• 5:44
  understands his low of a low row as a as a paradise low over
• 5:49
  lower Rambam. The famous lotion of the Gras is
• 5:52
  that he didn't see paradise and nor did nor did the Rambam that
• 5:56
  their understanding of paradise is it was philosophy or other
• 6:01
  Hakkos. If the Shah even says even
• 6:02
  Hakkosaka Bolo the Rama puts into parties the the gross says
• 6:06
  that. What do you mean?
• 6:07
  The shack is also much more like this that Kabbalah is Sisya.
• 6:11
  It's not a separate side Hoffman it's Sisya.
• 6:15
  The weather, you know, the the lotion of parties is shot is
• 6:20
  shot. R.E.M. is drush and sold.
• 6:22
  I mean the the Grahal that that that everything that's how all
• 6:28
  the mode is based on everything in this world is based on those
• 6:31
  44 levels. And even any, even any, any, any
• 6:35
  lotion of Khazar, any, anything has these four different levels
• 6:40
  and you get deeper. And then Even so even they get
• 6:42
  the song, there's chat, there's whatever there's a there's
• 6:49
  actually very interesting. First thing goes through that.
• 6:50
  There's automata around the on the was it on the software that
• 6:57
  see you. So you also have the graduated
• 6:59
  very interesting. You know, so at some point in
• 7:02
  his life the grass the grass said, Oh, he he was Miyashi the
• 7:06
  grass Miyashi all of Torshibaal pair Torshiba Benigla Torshiba
• 7:11
  Cesar through Pardes. He was put everything together
• 7:14
  and everything fit at some point.
• 7:16
  OK, that was the girl of Akhopanim.
• 7:19
  So the girl understands that that that this is a acre hills
• 7:22
  of the Toyota Piska Chuva brings.
• 7:26
  He asks, are you high swung Kabala?
• 7:30
  Is there a huge swung Kabala? So the there's a lot of there's
• 7:38
  interesting Truva and he, you know, talks about he says, he
• 7:41
  says there's an inherent danger in learning Kabbalah that he
• 7:47
  says that unless, you know, unless you have a rebbe who can
• 7:50
  keep you straight, it could come to it could easily come to to
• 7:53
  fear. And the Rambad says by the eagle
• 7:57
  Azov was because they understood Kabbalah wrong, meaning he says
• 8:00
  the the eagle Azov, the whole if you look at the Rambad, he says
• 8:03
  because they're that they were trying to Mahavin to to meet a
• 8:07
  sardine or whatever, you know, you mean steeper stuff there,
• 8:11
  but whatever, you know, and the and because of that, you know,
• 8:15
  they came to it like it came to the sort of a physical identity.
• 8:18
  And the, the Hamzier says people who don't, who don't have a
• 8:21
  proper, you know, Han the Shah also says the, you know, proper
• 8:25
  muna proper the kiosks and all these things, whatever it can
• 8:30
  easily the, the, the you know, the caballos falls remosly of
• 8:34
  understanding, understanding Khoshbar, who in Michelle and
• 8:38
  Michelle and all done different things.
• 8:40
  And the person can easily come to, to to, to, to make, you
• 8:44
  know, mistakes. And the you know, and the
• 8:48
  there's no such thing as in Caballo is what he says can't
• 8:52
  just say that was a Burkina of this a Burkina of that.
• 8:55
  Another thing is smarter. If you start making smarters up,
• 8:58
  you end up you can end up Kira. So you said there's an inherent
• 9:02
  danger in in learning Kabbalah. So therefore, he says there's no
• 9:06
  therefore some kind of Patrick. Oh, then the truth is Ramon, the
• 9:11
  Ramon self has our goals on on the Zoar and even the dark
• 9:14
  emotional Arrock and even the cosier called torso or even from
• 9:16
  the Rama Rama, right that the learning Kabbalah is he said
• 9:21
  he'd to have pale pair and the people who just stop up and
• 9:23
  swarm and stop, you know, and stop say, you know, think
• 9:27
  they're learning Kabbalah. It's it's it's it's it's a
• 9:29
  danger. It could be.
• 9:30
  That's why Baskin's here like you shouldn't get into it.
• 9:33
  Oh, so I'll tell you what, I'll tell you what.
• 9:35
  So I but I, what I did, what I did understand is that from
• 9:38
  where the grot, what the Cavalo general rights and whatever is
• 9:41
  that is that the, is that I think, you know, the grot was
• 9:45
  the Sadr, you know, and you see the Shahaim, you see, whatever
• 9:49
  he was, he took what was Kabali, Kabala sari.
• 9:52
  And then what this is what led to him shop, say 3:00 and all
• 9:54
  these things was that people were just learning it and just
• 9:57
  throwing stuff around without really understanding the growth.
• 10:00
  I think sort of took it and and and like filtered everything and
• 10:04
  he set it up, you know, and according to like a Sligas and
• 10:07
  things or whatever Hasidim took, you know, and they said it took
• 10:12
  the Kabbalah and pushed it towards the voter sashem, not
• 10:15
  just stop. Lima would also get into
• 10:17
  Kabbalah, Mysids and all these things.
• 10:19
  You think of him a Kabul. He's like a magician.
• 10:22
  OK, that's already that's not according to you know, that
• 10:26
  there is a helical that it could be that shark Hach was and
• 10:28
  kamehas and all these things, but at the time, leave it, leave
• 10:32
  it at Tara. So the that this seems to be the
• 10:34
  I think the the you know, the way the girl understand that the
• 10:37
  person should the way you know, should try to learn it.
• 10:39
  That's how the show says a person should learn it.
• 10:43
  So how far he can before it gets too much for him, you know, and
• 10:49
  there and there. And so there are plenty of smart
• 10:50
  and they go and person goes definition high and 1st it opens
• 10:53
  up the Das Trunos and how things like that.
• 10:56
  That's all based on Kabbalah. But it's something which is, you
• 10:59
  know, given over to that people can understand on their on their
• 11:03
  on their level. You know, you get into, you
• 11:05
  know, not if you get into all the but that's where the danger
• 11:08
  is. But taking taking out the
• 11:09
  lessons from it. That's that could be there's
• 11:12
  there's some sort of maybe there's some sort of here to it
• 11:15
  or not. That's that's what seems to
• 11:17
  that's what seems to me to come out.
• 11:19
  Hey, if you lost, but you're not going to understand.
• 11:22
  Listen, there's a lot of midrush.
• 11:23
  Zora Batson is Midrushan and it's a lot of but a lot, a lot
• 11:26
  of it is stuff which unless you unless from Roshira wants and
• 11:30
  said like he tried learning through, you know, he tried
• 11:32
  learning. He learned through Zora.
• 11:34
  He said unless he's sitting, he's not gonna stand a thing.
• 11:36
  Like you just went through it. Now there's OK, there's people
• 11:38
  who say hockey sell you learn and Zora's retired.
• 11:41
  If you don't understand, you do understand.
• 11:43
  I'm not getting into all those all those things, you know, you
• 11:47
  know, but the shaft does also bring that the the Benabrine
• 11:51
  Shano, that Labina, that person shouldn't learn it until Malik
• 11:54
  Risa was also means 40 years until he's, you know, he's a
• 11:57
  certain level of maturity and dust and he's learned enough,
• 12:01
  you know, Gamora and stuff that he can really understand.
• 12:05
  You know, just the general, like skimming the surface is not
• 12:07
  really learning Kabbalah. It's Kabbalah in your name.
• 12:09
  And like it's hot people talking about the sphere of the sphere
• 12:12
  as you look in the in the sitter.
• 12:16
  Yeah, that's just scratching the surface.
• 12:18
  That's not really with Cabala. But I mean, I'm saying a copy of
• 12:21
  you to learn that something. Hey, Maham Shenagar Lalami
• 12:25
  Tershevik Sav Biskar mutter Lalami Biskar in the place,
• 12:29
  which is knowing to learn to teach Tershevik sav for to get
• 12:35
  paid. It's mutter to teach about
• 12:38
  Tersheva pere also the Lalami Biskar Tersheva is also based on
• 12:41
  more than daring doesn't and Horace is Manny Bikinam after 10
• 12:47
  Bikinam. And of course, work was just
• 12:49
  like it's a draw show that just like I thought for free, you
• 12:52
  should teach for free low amounts of mission of Dena
• 12:56
  Bukino. If you can't find someone to
• 12:57
  teach to learn who want to teach Tershavale Pekina Yuma Biskar,
• 13:02
  they should teach then. Then you can then fine.
• 13:04
  You pay him. I have to pay, so I'm also going
• 13:12
  to get paid what he should teach others.
• 13:20
  Is he a bolovera? No, it's a it's Bolivira.
• 13:25
  I don't think so. It's it's not recommended.
• 13:30
  We're going to get into the remote at the end of the simony
• 13:34
  goes into it a lot more, but the it's a little bit the the the
• 13:40
  the the Carver finishes about Shinogu Indianolami, Hakoba Star
• 13:44
  everyone, everyone gets paid to teach.
• 13:48
  This is the person. He doesn't have any other
• 13:54
  profession on the side. So then it's motors affiliation
• 13:57
  log. Even if he's wealthy.
• 13:59
  Who's scar Patolo? It's what's called scar patolo.
• 14:02
  He gets minimum wage or he gets, you know, he just, he gets the
• 14:07
  the Muhakshmi, Akala, Sakov, Umassom Matano Shari, the proper
• 14:13
  Paskins negative durambam in class of Misha.
• 14:16
  He's marriage negative. He's very not.
• 14:18
  He's not marriage negative durambam.
• 14:21
  Here's 100 Paskins negative durambam that you're allowed to
• 14:24
  go ahead and take you know, even you know, as long as it's it's
• 14:28
  clear that you're not, you're OK.
• 14:31
  You need people to teach. So this is the thing that you
• 14:33
  need people to do. You know, so someone who leaves
• 14:35
  doesn't go out, doesn't leave other rooms and teachers.
• 14:38
  You need to pay. He needs to be able to live.
• 14:39
  So that's what the the Mitig and then it's also be shiny and the
• 14:45
  Tashbits is going back whatever other definitely other be
• 14:49
  showing everybody I know that the rush argues argues straight
• 14:53
  on the Rambam that that you're you know that you're allowed
• 14:58
  you're allowed to take if if this is if this is an angle
• 15:01
  Mamanis Barnis the call Heduche the the call Heduche is safe for
• 15:08
  him. Hainu masha niska MI derabona
• 15:10
  multi lethal Scarlando. So emphasis is that the only
• 15:15
  problem is teaching Mikro or we have or Michelin maybe, but but
• 15:23
  all Hindu. She is sorry for him.
• 15:24
  All they'll be sharing him all these things.
• 15:26
  Whatever. It's not included in the it's
• 15:28
  not included in the puzzle of an Ibakinum and the the the Linux
• 15:33
  him is only only Torsovic Saab whatever, but other stuff, but
• 15:38
  which is Rover we learned is there's no there's not even
• 15:41
  underneath that. OK, I'm I'm expanding and this
• 15:47
  can be what you just I mean, I don't know.
• 15:54
  I don't know. I don't know.
• 15:55
  We'll see the Rambo at length in there.
• 15:57
  The Ramak quotes the Ram on the length.
• 15:58
  We'll get into it at the end of the end of the simian.
• 16:01
  But the Mahabir, he's clear. He's clear because he's mission
• 16:05
  of that that we don't pass it like the Rambo.
• 16:07
  We'll get to the you know, whatever above Isha Shalom, the
• 16:11
  Tara Ishala scar, a woman who learns she does get scar of a
• 16:16
  low kiss. Cara Ish Visha, any Mitsubaisa,
• 16:20
  she's not Mitsuva voice. She you know, she gets some sort
• 16:23
  of scar, you know, you know, but but it's not it's not the same
• 16:27
  scar that we talk about Inhaba and this and whatever.
• 16:30
  It's not the same level of scar. It says, it says in the Warren
• 16:34
  Saita, it says that the you know, it's close to Tyler.
• 16:38
  It says by a site that says she would live longer, you know, if
• 16:41
  she the school's Tyler, that if she would, you know, help her
• 16:44
  husband learn or help the kids learn, you know, So you know, it
• 16:48
  doesn't say that if she if she if she, you know, was learning
• 16:51
  herself. You know, that's not as close
• 16:54
  Toiler as close Toiler is, is the hell.
• 16:56
  She could learn herself. But you know, but the but the
• 17:00
  but it's more acre to be sure that she runs the fat.
• 17:03
  You know, you know that she you know that she puts her
• 17:07
  correctness into, you know, into the system.
• 17:10
  Savo Khazal Shmali Lamid Odom is Beta Taira.
• 17:14
  They should even Hanochi indict them.
• 17:16
  If you've honestly summit. They should not.
• 17:19
  The person should not teach his daughter Taira, because most
• 17:22
  women they don't have you know, the diet on or not because they
• 17:27
  don't have it, they're not able to get get the learning clear,
• 17:30
  but CSD Victoria DVFI and they're going to take the what
• 17:34
  they learn and and and use it for the wrong things.
• 17:38
  The Phoenix Dieton is real. No shame that they will be.
• 17:42
  They're going to use it for things which they you know,
• 17:45
  which aren't. They misuse it and nowadays are
• 17:47
  probably a lot of men who do the same thing, but I'll component
• 17:50
  I'm a khame khame alame. This is the harvest child.
• 17:54
  I think Khal is saying I'm a khame Khame Alame is Vito Turkey
• 17:57
  Lambda Tifus Piyush Devara Veyor that they're going to use or
• 18:01
  actually says they're good that that that women might use are
• 18:04
  memos like they use the they might use the the Sarasan things
• 18:08
  to to do to do things to to to you know to be what's the word
• 18:15
  to you know, to be, you know, user shrewdness to go ahead and
• 18:19
  do things which are wrong bedroom removing Tershaba pet
• 18:24
  Well, tershaba, but this is time to cherish about pet.
• 18:27
  But Tershaba Khalila in Malanda in Malanda Tiflous.
• 18:32
  However, it's you shouldn't teach in the Khalila, but it's
• 18:35
  not Malanda Tiflous Hagar Miko Marco Aisha Lumo.
• 18:42
  She has to go to dining class and you know, and you know, and
• 18:48
  learn the things, which is shy to a woman and my daughter, it
• 18:51
  happens to be today she's learning.
• 18:53
  She's taking a Mikhan RT on Sagim and ya'll do it.
• 18:58
  And then here it's actually where they know these are things
• 19:00
  they should know, but they're all things and it's fine.
• 19:03
  The, the, the, the right that now that like you know, from
• 19:09
  Sarah Shnehra, she came to the public time.
• 19:11
  Nowadays in Besiakov, they do teach Tereshibik Saab and a lot
• 19:15
  of Besiakovs even teach so Morales and this and whatever.
• 19:18
  It's because that people girls being pulled off by Haskala and
• 19:23
  things or whatever. And they needed to have the
• 19:25
  intellectual stimulation and said, there's no, it's no, it's
• 19:28
  tequila and the person shouldn't worry.
• 19:31
  Now, the thing about what women learning themselves is, you
• 19:35
  know, is a couple of things. First of all, they say that,
• 19:37
  listen, the women can learn themselves, but it's not
• 19:39
  something that should be, you know, set up in a structure.
• 19:43
  They want to learn themselves. They're they're you know, and
• 19:46
  they quote the the the here quote the like the Marshall, the
• 19:50
  I quote the Marshall that there is, I'm sure showing that there
• 19:53
  was a woman who sat behind the pizza and and gave a sheer to
• 19:57
  Bakker. There are there were Yukidi
• 20:00
  school. There were there were women who
• 20:02
  who, who, who, who were able to even nowadays.
• 20:04
  I mean, whatever they they say that the they say Papa Jutsu was
• 20:09
  written by the footman's daughter.
• 20:11
  But I don't know. I don't know if that's true or
• 20:15
  not. I'm just saying that's the
• 20:16
  rumor. But but there's you know, there
• 20:20
  are no, I'm saying there are there are there are there are
• 20:25
  things. The point is if they make it
• 20:26
  into a. If they make it into a a big
• 20:31
  thing in MC Kiora, then whatever, that's that's where
• 20:34
  the horror that's negative this, this thing.
• 20:36
  And if they're not mode, the if the women aren't mode to this,
• 20:39
  to this Myra Khazal to this, how can you learn?
• 20:46
  If you want to say so the Gemara, OK, I don't know.
• 20:54
  OK, they can learn. They can learn.
• 20:55
  But the point is is right. There is a there is a there is a
• 20:58
  thing. I mean, you have the famous
• 21:00
  going through a lot of the you know, the Maisa Brewery.
• 21:02
  I brought in the voter the sentence of voter actually in
• 21:04
  the voter Zara that she said, you know, she was very learning
• 21:07
  and she said I think college doesn't apply to me.
• 21:09
  And that's a very whole sad story there, whether they're
• 21:13
  trying to prove prove her wrong. But I thought EIN Sham and Doff
• 21:17
  his test, I think. But Uncle Panim, you know Uncle
• 21:20
  Panim, it's it's a complicated issue and every person should
• 21:24
  have Shilohs, you know personal Shilohs and things the issue and
• 21:27
  if he have his Lalam. It has been Ontario.
• 21:29
  However, a woman is definitely a high.
• 21:31
  There's a heave to teach herself Ontario become welcome e-mail
• 21:34
  Zarus Lubnau the Baila. She asked you, but tell you let
• 21:37
  this scar about her diet. It's like you can suffer as food
• 21:40
  like we had before and that if she you know that if she does
• 21:44
  help help her husband and whatever supportive and you know
• 21:49
  men in all different ways, then she gets a hail it just like he
• 21:53
  suffers fool and she gets vomit or sutras and in his Li mode.