Latest / "Isn't That Interesting?!": Breast Cancer Survivor Stories + Remarkable Research / Episode 7: Karen Powell
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome to Isn't That Interesting, where we will
- 0:04highlight the innovative work supportedbyearlier.org Friends
- 0:08for an earlier breast cancer test.
- 0:10This series features conversations with researchers,
- 0:14medical professionals, survivors, caregivers, and
- 0:17dedicated supporters all involved in advancing early
- 0:21detection for breast cancer. Each discussion reveals new
- 0:25approaches and rapid progress in science, showcasing the diverse
- 0:29efforts that are underway. These conversations are designed
- 0:33to give a broad perspective on emerging methods of early breast
- 0:37cancer detection and the people driving this important mission.
- 0:40They will truly have you thinking.
- 0:42Isn't that interesting? All right folks, so here we are
- 0:48with Karen Powell and she has agreed to talk with us.
- 0:51She is a genetic counselor with Cone Hospital in Greensboro, NC.
- 0:57And I have lots of questions for her.
- 1:00And I just wanted, I wanted Karen to be able to use this
- 1:03platform to help people understand what genetic
- 1:09counseling would do for them and how it might be able to help.
- 1:12And so, Karen, why don't you just give a bird's eye view of
- 1:18what it does and then we'll talk about how we bring people to, to
- 1:24that to seeing what feeling comfortable about doing that
- 1:28with you. So go ahead and and just talk
- 1:30about who, who would you suggest that do that to?
- 1:37To who would we suggest to do genetic testing?
- 1:40Yes, OK. So I think that anybody who is
- 1:47who has a family history of breast and ovarian cancer,
- 1:53pancreatic cancer, prostate cancer or combination of those
- 1:58those cancers might want to consider genetic testing.
- 2:03Having one individual in the family may not be enough family
- 2:08history in order to do testing unless that person is under 50
- 2:12at that diagnosis or has a particular form of breast cancer
- 2:18called a triple negative form of breast cancer.
- 2:21But if you have a combination of several family members with
- 2:26breast or ovarian or prostate or pancreatic cancer, then you may
- 2:31qualify for genetic testing. And the important thing in
- 2:36finding that information out is that we can follow individuals
- 2:42differently, meaning I we would manage their care differently to
- 2:47either prevent a cancer from happening or hopefully identify
- 2:51it early when it's more trouble in individuals who do test
- 2:56positive, it also lets us know if there are other cancers that
- 2:59they may be at risk for that maybe they didn't realize just
- 3:03based on family history. So what would be the age that
- 3:07you would recommend looking at that?
- 3:09Would it differ as to whether what their family history is?
- 3:16So we receive referrals of for families of all ages or
- 3:23individuals of all ages, women in their 20s to women in their
- 3:2760s and 70s. It really just determines when
- 3:32they come to attention that there's a family history that is
- 3:38strong enough to consider genetic testing.
- 3:41There are some families where you know, there may not be
- 3:45enough information either because the person coming in to
- 3:49see us may not have that they either people have passed away
- 3:54or maybe there just isn't communication within the family.
- 3:59But we really do see individuals of all ages coming in for
- 4:05testing. We typically want to test people
- 4:09over the age of 18. So we don't tend to test
- 4:13children simply because the majority of the genetic
- 4:18conditions of testing for don't affect children.
- 4:22There are some outliers there, but for the for the most part,
- 4:26individuals who are over 18 are the ones that we're looking to
- 4:31undergo testing. So like for me as an example,
- 4:36having had breast cancer, would I encourage my granddaughters,
- 4:40one is 19 and 1 is like 15? Would I?
- 4:44Would I encourage them to get tested or to discuss it with
- 4:50should? Should we monitor that?
- 4:53So when it comes to your granddaughters, they're they're
- 4:57young. So we would not encourage your
- 4:5915 year old to undergo testing and your 19 year old mayor, you
- 5:04know, may or may not be interested.
- 5:06She's still pretty young and has, you know, maybe other
- 5:09things on her mind than than her risk for breast cancer.
- 5:13But understanding that they are currently unaffected, but you
- 5:18personally have had a diagnosis of breast cancer, you're a
- 5:21better person to test. Individuals who are affected
- 5:26with cancer are more informative for families to understand if
- 5:31there is a hereditary condition simply because their diagnosis
- 5:35of cancer is already possibly, you know, suggested that maybe
- 5:39there could be something going on there.
- 5:42You know, I think that's very interesting and I think we need
- 5:47to encourage folks to think about doing it for our our next
- 5:54generations that if if nothing else just for their information.
- 5:59But we, you know, we don't usually have those kind of
- 6:03discussions, but I think to be able to say here's some
- 6:06information for you that you might want to evaluate.
- 6:11So I think it's just it's asking a lot out of a 19 year old to go
- 6:16have. So what does the testing
- 6:18include? I mean like it's like lots of
- 6:21different things or not. Yeah, that's a really good
- 6:24question. You we typically like to draw
- 6:27blood. We like to get a blood sample
- 6:30from individuals to do the testing.
- 6:32But you really can do it in multiple different ways.
- 6:34You could do a saliva sample where you spit in a tube and
- 6:38send that in. You can do what we call a buckle
- 6:41where you you rub a a little brush against the inside of your
- 6:47cheek and it gets some cells there and you can do blood very
- 6:54rarely in certain circumstances. Sometimes we do skin biopsies in
- 6:58order to obtain this information, but those tend to
- 7:03be infrequent. But sometimes we have to do it
- 7:05that way, depending on the situation.
- 7:09So you would encourage probably the older adults, not not old
- 7:15like me, but young adults that maybe if they have encountered
- 7:22breast cancer particularly which we're focusing on, but any of
- 7:27those in the family that if they've experienced it, then
- 7:31they might want to sign up to do the, the hereditary, the genetic
- 7:36counseling. Yeah, I, I think that it, I
- 7:39think that having the genetic counseling is really important
- 7:42because you can go through information, gather information
- 7:47about the family and then talk with the individual about
- 7:51whether or not their family history is truly strong enough
- 7:55to warrant genetic testing. You know, when we think about
- 8:01cancer in general, only about 5 to 10% of people with a
- 8:06diagnosis of cancer will have an inherited cause for their
- 8:09cancer. So it's really a small
- 8:11proportion. Most people develop cancer by
- 8:14chance. Maybe there is, you know,
- 8:19multiple things going on that could increase somebody's risk.
- 8:23For instance, if there, you know, are maybe one or two
- 8:26people in the family with cancer and then there's maybe an
- 8:29exposure or a lifestyle that might increase the chance for
- 8:35developing that type of cancer. So when thinking about genetic
- 8:39testing, it's only a small proportion of folks that are
- 8:43going to qualify for testing or or at least need need to have
- 8:49that testing. There's many people that come
- 8:52through that. When once we take a family
- 8:55history, we realize that their family is not their family
- 8:59history is not strong enough to warrant genetic testing.
- 9:03They don't quite meet that that medical criteria.
- 9:07And it's important to look at that because insurance companies
- 9:12follow the the medical guidelines pretty closely and
- 9:18they determine whether or not they're going to cover the
- 9:20testing. So certainly there we can do
- 9:25testing, we can order testing on individuals who don't fully
- 9:29qualify based on medical guidelines, but then it could be
- 9:33an out of pocket cost. Some of our laboratories keep
- 9:37that out of pocket cost relatively low at around A249
- 9:42price point, but other laboratories might not have
- 9:46that, that cap or that patient pay price that that could keep
- 9:51that cost a little on the on the lower end.
- 9:53So it, you know, kind of cost is, is an idea of how, how that
- 9:59could be a barrier for for testing at least in individuals
- 10:03who may not meet that medical criteria.
- 10:06It could be a barrier for people who who do meet that medical
- 10:09criteria, you know, especially if you have a high deductible
- 10:12plan or things like that. But overall, when thinking about
- 10:15the cost of genetic testing, you know, it has come down
- 10:18dramatically over the years. And I think that if we average
- 10:22it out amongst all of our patients, most people pay $100
- 10:27out of pocket or less for their genetic testing.
- 10:30Great information. Do you, is there a way of how
- 10:37can I say this that it won't the results won't impact insurance
- 10:43or employment or various things. How do how do we circumvent
- 10:48that? Yeah, so there is a federal law
- 10:51called the Genetic Information Non Discrimination Act.
- 10:55We shorten it up and call it Gina.
- 10:58That law protects individuals from having their health
- 11:03insurance company raise their premiums or raise their rates.
- 11:09It protects them from their health insurance companies
- 11:12kicking them off their policy or forcing them to take the test in
- 11:17order to insure them. For employers, as long as an
- 11:23employer has 15 or more people, they are not able to use this
- 11:28information for hiring, firing or promoting reasons.
- 11:33Now, I think a lot of my patients when they hear about
- 11:36employment, they're like, well, how would my employer get this
- 11:39information? They can get this information
- 11:42maybe if it's provided through Wellness programs or if the
- 11:47individual turns it over for some reason, provides that
- 11:51information. But most employers are not going
- 11:53to have that information. My impression is that that part
- 11:59of the law really was covering the fact that most individuals
- 12:05get their insurance company through their employer.
- 12:07And so people were really worried about that combination
- 12:10of not only their their medical insurance, but then what could
- 12:16they be used against them in their employment so that they
- 12:20would lose their medical insurance.
- 12:23So when it comes to medical insurance and employment, there
- 12:27are those protections against the federal law with the federal
- 12:30law, that federal law does not protect any of the supplemental
- 12:33insurances like long term care, life insurance, disability
- 12:38insurance. So having a positive test,
- 12:42meaning that you are identified as having a hereditary
- 12:46predisposition or mutation it it could make getting those types
- 12:52of insurances either more difficult or more expensive to
- 12:56obtain. So it would be important to have
- 13:00all your ducks in a row before you would decide to do the
- 13:04genetic testing, right? I mean if you want to do long
- 13:08term care insurance that that you.
- 13:12Need to get that ahead of time, yes, yeah.
- 13:15So do you need to have a referral in order to do this or
- 13:20could I just walk in and say hi, I'd like to get this genetic
- 13:23testing? I think that really depends on
- 13:26the site. So at Cone Cancer, we do not
- 13:31need a referral and so patients can call in and just say that
- 13:37they are interested in genetic testing.
- 13:40Most of the people that we see who do not have referrals are
- 13:46coming in to get tested because they had a relative who tested
- 13:50positive and then they reach out to us and ask for an
- 13:53appointment. So that's how we receive most of
- 13:57our non referred patients. Other patients tend to be
- 14:01referred to us either from internally within the Cancer
- 14:05Center or within the community from community providers who we
- 14:10work closely with. So this is not a trick question.
- 14:14I'm just trying to figure out how you encourage.
- 14:17How would we best encourage people to have this in their
- 14:22mindset? Contemplate if that would be
- 14:25something that they would feel comfortable doing.
- 14:28I would think that there will be a little bit of hesitancy to do
- 14:33that. It's almost like, do I really
- 14:36want to know? I mean, is that just it?
- 14:39It's difficult and I don't know how to get over that, that big
- 14:42leap, Yeah. You know, I think that's a,
- 14:46that's a good question. And I probably have a very
- 14:49skewed idea of things simply because the people who make an
- 14:55appointment and show up are probably more motivated in
- 14:59getting testing than the people who have been referred and, and
- 15:03cancel their appointment and don't, don't come in.
- 15:06But every once in a while we do have individuals who, you know,
- 15:11make their appointment, they come in and, and they just are
- 15:15worried. They don't know if this is
- 15:17information that they want to know.
- 15:19Maybe, maybe they don't want to burden their family with this,
- 15:25with this information. One of the things that I I try
- 15:29to emphasize is that this is one way to help with prevention
- 15:36because one, once we identify people who have these hereditary
- 15:43mutations running in their family, we can change medical
- 15:47management and in some cases offer preventive surgery.
- 15:53While that is kind of a radical idea of having, you know, maybe
- 15:59ovaries and fallopian tubes out when you don't have cancer or
- 16:02having your breasts removed when you know, before you have
- 16:05cancer, it is one way to be preventive.
- 16:10But not every, every condition that we can test for warrants
- 16:16that preventive surgery. So we may have screening that is
- 16:21being performed that will identify people, hopefully early
- 16:25when it's when a cancer might be more treatable or at least
- 16:29identify high risk lesions that can be watched and and
- 16:34monitored. So really our goal is to try to
- 16:38identify people either early when things are more more
- 16:43treatable, or possibly prevent a cancer from happening.
- 16:48And you know, a good example of not necessarily having to
- 16:52undergo like a preventive surgery.
- 16:54But in the case of colon cancer, there are some colon cancer
- 16:59syndromes where we might recommend having colonoscopies,
- 17:03you know, every one to two years.
- 17:05And, you know, so that's not a preventive surgery, but it is
- 17:09having, you know, monitoring much more frequently than than
- 17:13what you would typically anticipate.
- 17:16And that certainly would identify, you know, any polyps
- 17:22that could become cancerous or even, you know, maybe a very
- 17:27early cancer that's contained in a polyp.
- 17:29And once you remove the polyp, there's no treatment that's
- 17:31needed. I just think that we are so
- 17:36blessed to have this available because we can go merely on our
- 17:44way. But once you have this
- 17:46information, then you can make a decision.
- 17:50And it sounds as if the medical community is working hand in
- 17:55hand with what this is. You're just giving them more
- 18:01ammunition for being alert to you as a patient, to what your
- 18:07situation is as a patient, right?
- 18:10Right. It allows, allows for more
- 18:11personalized care. So that way we can target how we
- 18:16want to follow individuals based on their own personal genetic
- 18:20information. You know, we, we currently have
- 18:23these population guidelines. Well, how often do you have
- 18:27mammograms? How often do you have
- 18:28colonoscopies? But once you have genetic
- 18:33testing and are identified as somebody who may be at higher
- 18:36risk for cancer, then we can tweak that and personalize that
- 18:42screening to the individual. And we can do it within families
- 18:47because there might be some family members that need to be
- 18:50screened more frequently and other family members that might
- 18:53not be, might not need that. Right.
- 18:56So how do you think that the medical community is excited
- 19:03about this opportunity to have that information?
- 19:06And I love the fact that it can redesign what your general
- 19:13treatment or observation might be.
- 19:16So I, I think in general, the providers that we work most
- 19:19closely with find it incredibly beneficial.
- 19:23You know, we work very closely with our oncologists, we work
- 19:28closely with our oncology surgeons and radiation
- 19:32oncologists. And I think all of that, that
- 19:36whole group of individuals finds this information very helpful.
- 19:40You know, when it comes to surgical management, they, you
- 19:43know, individuals can have discussions about what kind of
- 19:46surgeries might be best for their particular case.
- 19:51When it comes to oncology, sometimes we have extra tools in
- 19:55our tool belt based on this genetic information.
- 19:59So as an example, I think some of the more.
- 20:04Common genes that people are familiar with are the BRCA 1 and
- 20:08BRCA 2 genes that you know are sometimes called the BRCA genes.
- 20:13Individuals who test positive for the BRCA genes if they have
- 20:19like a breast cancer, colon not colon cancer, breast cancer,
- 20:23ovarian cancer or any of the cancers that are typical for
- 20:26that particular gene might be able to be given PARP inhibitors
- 20:31under certain circumstances that allow, you know, in the PARP
- 20:36inhibitor will provide what we call progression free symptoms.
- 20:41So if for instance, they're at stage 4 and are given a a PARP
- 20:47inhibitor, it may keep their symptoms exactly where they are
- 20:50and keep it from spreading for a period of time.
- 20:54There is a a time frame when that usually works and then
- 20:57after that time frame you know it it might stop working, but it
- 21:02does provide some progression free symptoms for a period of
- 21:06time. Great.
- 21:08So what is if someone is interested in being a genetic
- 21:12counselor, what do they need to do?
- 21:14What is there? What's the path, the study path
- 21:17for that? Yeah.
- 21:19So genetic counseling programs are masters are generally
- 21:23masters trained. You would apply for a genetic
- 21:28edit, one of the genetic counseling programs just as a
- 21:31time out. I can look to see how many there
- 21:33are. I don't there feels they're
- 21:35constantly being added on to, but I can I can provide that
- 21:40information if that's helpful. But it is a master's program.
- 21:46You, you apply to the program and interview and then you have
- 21:49a match for what program you get into.
- 21:52It's similar to the medical school match where if you apply
- 21:56to multiple programs, you rank them and then all those programs
- 22:01rank the students and then they're matched to the program
- 22:06and then that's the program that they go to.
- 22:08And once you go through your training program, you graduate
- 22:14and you're eligible to start working at that point in time.
- 22:19There are some states that have licensure laws, so you might
- 22:23have to apply for a license. In order to obtain that license,
- 22:27you have to be certified. So there is a certification exam
- 22:31that's administered twice a year, in August and in February.
- 22:36And so you pass that exam and then you can go ahead and apply
- 22:40for your license. Well, I am really appreciative
- 22:44of your work and what you were doing and what Cone is being
- 22:48able to provide and all of our providers in this particular
- 22:53community. But is there anything else that
- 22:55is of interest to you to be able to share is your time if you
- 23:00would like to share something or encourage people to do it or
- 23:04whatever? I encourage people to make
- 23:08appointments with genetic count with, with a genetic counselor
- 23:10if you have any questions on whether or not your personal or
- 23:16your family history might qualify you for genetic testing.
- 23:20The appointment with the genetic counselor is just a conversation
- 23:23where we discuss family history. We go through the information
- 23:29about what what results might might occur from that testing.
- 23:34So you can get one of three results.
- 23:37Most commonly it's negative, but sometimes if it's positive, then
- 23:41we would need to react to it, which not only is changing an
- 23:45individual's medical management, but we also would then offer
- 23:50testing through the family. Sometimes you can get
- 23:53essentially inconclusive results.
- 23:55We identify genetic variations in the genes that are uncertain,
- 24:02our experiences that the majority of those uncertain
- 24:05results are truly normal results once we gather enough
- 24:10information about them. So we do not change medical
- 24:14management based on an uncertain result, but those are the three
- 24:18results that most commonly come through.
- 24:20And when you get your results back, then the genetic counselor
- 24:25can can walk you through that information as well.
- 24:29So it's just it's really gathering more information for
- 24:34you about your health and what may be the.
- 24:39Cancers in the family? Yeah, So, well, Karen, I really
- 24:43appreciate your spending time with us.
- 24:45I think it's just been very helpful.
- 24:47It's a it's an area of study that I hadn't been familiar with
- 24:53and I think it's very fascinating and I'm so excited
- 24:56that we in this lifetime have that opportunity.
- 25:00It'll be interesting to see the development of this particular
- 25:03science. Absolutely, absolutely.
- 25:07I think every year we we gain more and more information.
- 25:11Right. Well, keep, keep up the good
- 25:13work. And we thank you so much for
- 25:14sharing with us today. Thank you so much, Karen.
- 25:18Bye. Oh, and just one more thing.
- 25:20I mean, I don't know, I, I, I don't know if you end up like
- 25:23kind of talking about other things in the meantime.
- 25:26But one thing about if people are coming in for a genetic
- 25:30counseling appointment and they know family members have a
- 25:34genetic mutation, try to bring a copy of that report with them.
- 25:38OK all. Right.
- 25:40Good. I don't understand.
- 25:42Yeah, it is because then that allows us to know exactly what's
- 25:45going on in the family and tailor everything.
- 25:47But but anyway, that could be like an aside or something that
- 25:52you just mentioned, but that would be.
- 25:55All right. Thank you so much.
- 25:57All right. Thank you.
- 25:59Bye, bye. Thank you for joining us for
- 26:02Isn't That Interesting? We hope you've been inspired by
- 26:05these remarkable individuals as well as I have.
- 26:08You can support our progress with a donation at earlier.org
- 26:12or by hosting a fundraising event.
- 26:15Follow us on the Instagram or Facebook and visit us at
- 26:19www.earlier.org. Let's change the picture of
- 26:23breast cancer together.