Latest / CropLife Retail Week / Tariff refunds and shifts, planning strategies and glyphosate price hikes?
Transcript
- 0:05Hello, welcome to a special edition of
- 0:07CropLife Retail Week. I'm Eric Sfiligoy,
- 0:09editor of CropLife and CropLife Iron.
- 0:12Here with two guests this week, Jim
- 0:14DeLisi from Fanwood Chemical and Jeff
- 0:17Pritchard from Westlink Ag. Gentlemen,
- 0:19welcome back to the program.
- 0:22>> Nice to be here.
- 0:23>> Yep, thank you.
- 0:25>> Yeah, so hey, wanted to talk a little
- 0:27bit about what's going on in the
- 0:29in the world if you will, kind of
- 0:31current current events. And I know we
- 0:33wanted to touch on this topic, how
- 0:35tariffs and trade volatility are
- 0:37reshaping the cost of doing business in
- 0:40ag retail and more importantly, who pays
- 0:43and who's getting money out of the
- 0:45situation. So, uh I'll start with you
- 0:48Jim because I know I had you on retail
- 0:50week not too many weeks ago and we
- 0:52talked about the whole tariff refund
- 0:55situation. So, if you could give us the
- 0:57latest on that situation,
- 1:01um and then, you know, how that is
- 1:02impacting ag retailers if at all.
- 1:05>> Well, um the best
- 1:08number I can find
- 1:10is that a hundred and four billion
- 1:12dollars in refunds have been approved.
- 1:16And about seventy-five billion has been
- 1:19paid out.
- 1:20Um of course not a
- 1:23a small percentage of that went for
- 1:25agrochemicals.
- 1:26Uh Jeff can better talk about uh what
- 1:29his experience has been trying to pry
- 1:31refunds out of his suppliers.
- 1:33Uh but the the money is flowing.
- 1:37Uh the there's still no update the
- 1:40as we talked about last time the
- 1:41administration has appealed the idea to
- 1:44issue refunds for for um imports that
- 1:48have liquidated, which would be about
- 1:50half of a a half of the number. So,
- 1:53that's still working its way through the
- 1:55The system. Probably takes six months, a
- 1:57year, maybe longer for that to settle,
- 1:59Uh uh but 104 billion is supposedly been
- 2:02sent back into the economy
- 2:04uh with probably another
- 2:06uh 50, 60 billion to go for unlit for
- 2:09entries that had not liquidated. And I'd
- 2:12be interested to hear from Jeff how if
- 2:14he's having any success
- 2:16um
- 2:18getting re- getting any refunds from the
- 2:20suppliers.
- 2:22>> Good question and and uh probably the
- 2:25blunt answer to that is no.
- 2:27Uh I think a lot of suppliers are still
- 2:29trying to reconcile,
- 2:31you know, how they're able to apply that
- 2:34to a transactional level like doing
- 2:35business with a company like mine. So,
- 2:38we are talking to them about it and
- 2:40doing a little bit of our own tracking,
- 2:42but you know, we haven't seen, to be
- 2:46honest with you, a lot of impact on
- 2:48pricing
- 2:50due to rebates or due to um tariffs,
- 2:53excuse me. Um
- 2:55prices have stayed fairly low throughout
- 2:58the last uh
- 3:00two or three years
- 3:01uh on the ag chem front, at least on the
- 3:03generic side where we deal pretty uh
- 3:06pretty exclusively. So,
- 3:07um it's it's it's hard for them to
- 3:09identify which of their sales are
- 3:11associated with a tariff increase if
- 3:13they had that on their cost, but with so
- 3:15much inventory in the market the last
- 3:17two to three years, prices have pretty
- 3:19much stayed compressed across the major
- 3:22major high-volume agrochemical,
- 3:24especially on the generic side.
- 3:26>> Well, and that that confirms uh that
- 3:29that a lot of the a lot of the tariff
- 3:31increases were were eaten in the system.
- 3:34And because the other piece of this, of
- 3:35course, Eric, if you import an AI and
- 3:37you pay a tariff on it, uh by time it
- 3:40gets formulated, diluted, packaged,
- 3:43shipped, um
- 3:45the amount of the actual increase in the
- 3:48tariff is is greatly diluted. Now, I
- 3:51would not say that that would have been
- 3:52the case when the tariffs were well over
- 3:55100% for short period of time on China.
- 3:57I That's a That's a big hit. But, when
- 4:00they're 20 25%,
- 4:02it gets diluted so far down the supply
- 4:04chain
- 4:05that it's it's it's sometimes it can be
- 4:07hard to find.
- 4:11>> Okay. All right.
- 4:13Well, with all that in mind, again, what
- 4:15you know, what what's going on with the
- 4:17global supply chain situation? I know
- 4:19Jeff, you and I had you on a while back
- 4:22and we talked about how the whole
- 4:24situation in Iran and Strait of Hormuz
- 4:26was affecting the fertilizer chain
- 4:30supply chain. But, what's going on with
- 4:32crop protection? Is it being impacted by
- 4:34any of this uncertainty as well? And how
- 4:37are your members at Westling dealing
- 4:39with that?
- 4:40>> You know, it's an apropos they they were
- 4:43dealing with here July 15th, middle of
- 4:44the month, middle of the season. We're
- 4:46kind of
- 4:47regrouping and getting ready for 2027.
- 4:50Um you know, coming a lot of the product
- 4:52has moved into the channel. It's been
- 4:54applied in the field. Um
- 4:57there's I think a a lot of uncertainty
- 5:01in at the retail level right now about
- 5:03where prices are going. We're just
- 5:04starting to get some fill programs
- 5:06thrown at us from our suppliers. Um
- 5:09some of them are very aggressive in
- 5:12terms of the incentives they're
- 5:13providing. And I think that
- 5:15you know, more than anything else, I
- 5:16mentioned it earlier, inventory in the
- 5:18field.
- 5:21Some companies are driven more on cash
- 5:23flow than they are on profitability and
- 5:25they want to move that inventory. And
- 5:27then there's a tremendous amount of
- 5:28behavioral pricing activity going on and
- 5:31that's really hard to get a metrics
- 5:33around because if I'm sitting with a
- 5:35supplier and I tell him product X, we've
- 5:37just we can buy truckload volumes at say
- 5:401250 and their price at 13, they'll come
- 5:44down to 1250 immediately or they'll run
- 5:46to discounted price below that. So,
- 5:49um I think a lot of companies are trying
- 5:51to jump on 27 right away in early offer
- 5:55programs now and in an effort to try to
- 5:59gain as much revenue as they can before
- 6:02whatever's going to happen happens in
- 6:04Q4, Q1 2027.
- 6:08>> Okay.
- 6:09Uh Eric, I I I would add I would add two
- 6:11things to that.
- 6:12>> Mhm.
- 6:13>> Uh
- 6:14from the from the uh import side, the
- 6:17so-called 122 tariffs expire on July 24.
- 6:22That's uh
- 6:249 days.
- 6:25Um it was thought that the 301 so the
- 6:28new 301 investigation on forced labor
- 6:32would have a tariff rate that would kick
- 6:34in before the July 24th expiration of
- 6:37the 122. As of today, there are no
- 6:41uh conclusions to the 301 investigation
- 6:44on forced labor. There was a hearing a
- 6:46week or so ago which they have not
- 6:48completely uh digested. Uh and there are
- 6:52a whole bunch of countries that have
- 6:53come into Washington to to say to USTR,
- 6:56"We are not guilty of of uh forced
- 6:59labor." And in fact, India has passed
- 7:02within the last couple of days
- 7:04legislation to ban the importation into
- 7:07India of products produced with forced
- 7:09labor, which is one of the key goals of
- 7:12the investigation. So, if you if you
- 7:15said to me, "What's the tariff situation
- 7:17going to be on July 25?"
- 7:1910 days from now, the answer is don't
- 7:22know.
- 7:24The other thing that's going to put an
- 7:25interesting monkey wrench in all of this
- 7:27is the glyphosate case.
- 7:29And um that that will proceed and it'll
- 7:33probably take a year for it to finalize,
- 7:35but
- 7:37Bayer CropScience is said to be going to
- 7:39declare circumstances that would permit
- 7:4390-day retroactivity on the on the
- 7:46imposition of tariffs.
- 7:49We could theoretically be within that
- 7:5290-day window before the end of this
- 7:54month.
- 7:56If everything hits schedule, so
- 7:58um
- 7:59uh and you you can suspect that the that
- 8:02the tariffs on Chinese glyphosate are
- 8:04going to be significant. Whether they'll
- 8:06be as big as the tariffs on Chinese
- 8:082,4-D or not
- 8:10is unknown. A lot of it will depend upon
- 8:12how the investigation goes.
- 8:15Uh anybody that actually wants to
- 8:16participate or watch the investigation
- 8:19can go to the USITC website. There will
- 8:21be a public hearing on July 21. Um which
- 8:25I I don't think it's Zoom. It's one of
- 8:27the other
- 8:28uh
- 8:28systems that they use. Uh you can and
- 8:31you can watch the hearing just to get an
- 8:32idea what's going on yourself.
- 8:35>> Hm, interesting. Jeff, any comment on
- 8:37that?
- 8:38>> Yeah, I first, you know, we
- 8:41we're seeing
- 8:42very limited activity from our suppliers
- 8:44now that supply us with glyphosate
- 8:46uh because they're waiting for
- 8:48uh this Bayer situation to play out. Um
- 8:53as well though, you know, we're not
- 8:54going to see a lot of movement with
- 8:56other products and I truly feel that
- 8:59once this plays out, well, if if Bayer
- 9:01succeeds, we're going to see probably a
- 9:032x increase in the prices we're paying
- 9:06today for glyphosate from the generic
- 9:08suppliers we deal with.
- 9:10But, excuse me, at the same time
- 9:13we probably won't see a lot of movement
- 9:14on glufosinate, which is a very
- 9:16acceptable replacement to that. Yeah.
- 9:18And that, you know,
- 9:20my company alone has over 20 suppliers
- 9:22of the same formulation of glufosinate
- 9:25in the marketplace and that price has
- 9:27remained compressed.
- 9:29When we looked at some data earlier this
- 9:32summer
- 9:33and we looked at some of the major I
- 9:35chems that are off patent like
- 9:36glyphosate, glufosinate, dicamba, 24D,
- 9:40and then tack in there azoxystrobin,
- 9:42propiconazole on the fungicide piece,
- 9:44and bifenthrin and lambda
- 9:47on the insecticide side of it,
- 9:49we saw a decline of around 23%
- 9:53in terms of overall market value, which
- 9:55was all price.
- 9:56Um
- 9:57from say 2022, which was post-COVID when
- 10:01we had that price hike, after it
- 10:03waterfall down,
- 10:04we've seen continued compression in that
- 10:06market. And so, you're talking somewhere
- 10:08around 3/4 of a billion dollars of
- 10:10market cap that has basically
- 10:12disappeared off the market based on
- 10:15price decreases. And where are those
- 10:17margins, you know, coming from? So,
- 10:20at the retail level, there's a lot of um
- 10:23day-to-day play on this. We're We're not
- 10:25We're not looking out too far in advance
- 10:27because
- 10:28we don't need to. Um
- 10:30with prices as compressed as they are,
- 10:32we don't need to worry too much about
- 10:34say some accelerated position with the
- 10:36exception of glyphosate brought about by
- 10:39Bayer's uh Bayer's actions.
- 10:41>> Hm. Interesting. Okay.
- 10:44Well, you Jeff, you had mentioned about,
- 10:45you know, some alternative products out
- 10:48in the marketplace. And I don't know if
- 10:49the timing on this was coincidental or
- 10:51not, but it seemed just after the
- 10:54Supreme Court rendered its decision
- 10:56regarding glyphosate case, I I noticed
- 10:59EPA then approved a bunch of uh new
- 11:01active ingredients for use for the 2027
- 11:05growing season. Um you know, including
- 11:08one from Bayer, which I don't remember
- 11:10the name of it off the top of my head.
- 11:12Maybe uh Jim, you could help me on that
- 11:14one. But uh I again, there's some
- 11:16there's some new AIs coming into the
- 11:18marketplace. Are Are they going to help
- 11:20or hurt the situation that we've been
- 11:22talking about for crop protection
- 11:23products? What do you think?
- 11:25>> Well, it depends on what they are, and I
- 11:27don't I won't profess that I I followed
- 11:29that very closely in the last couple
- 11:31weeks. Um I did hear about that and I
- 11:33have to look into it, but
- 11:35um,
- 11:37I think that the, you know, a a lot of
- 11:39what we see, at least from the
- 11:40post-patent companies that we primarily
- 11:42deal with,
- 11:43is one, when some of these products come
- 11:47off patent, which makes them new on the
- 11:49generic front, like a propiconazole,
- 11:52uh, spirotetramat, products like that,
- 11:55um, the entry of the number of generic
- 11:58entrants is
- 12:00incredible and quick. Uh, in the case of
- 12:03like propiconazole, within a year of it
- 12:05coming off patent, there were 10 new
- 12:07entrants in the marketplace.
- 12:09Um, seven or eight of those we do
- 12:11business with. And what that's doing is
- 12:14that's causing a waterfall in the
- 12:15pricing. When you're talking about some
- 12:17of the new actives that are coming out,
- 12:19I probably won't see those for a couple
- 12:21years in the case of a WestLink Ag, but
- 12:24the products that we have available to
- 12:26us today are obviously covering 99% of
- 12:29the fungal, insect, and weed issues we
- 12:33face in the United States market today.
- 12:34So,
- 12:35we'll see how they fit in in terms of
- 12:37maybe they provide better resistance
- 12:39management or perhaps they provide uh,
- 12:41better stability or easy to work with on
- 12:44formulation front, mixing front. So,
- 12:47that's that's soon to be uh, we'll learn
- 12:49that, you know, as we as we work with
- 12:51those newer products.
- 12:52>> So, Jeff, I know I've done stories in
- 12:54the past, uh, 20, 30 years looking at
- 12:57the generic marketplace in the US versus
- 13:01say in Europe. And I know the numbers,
- 13:03the percentages are always much, much
- 13:04smaller here than they are in the EU
- 13:07countries. So, are are you saying that
- 13:10some of the the, uh, I guess resistance
- 13:13or hesitancy that we've seen from ag
- 13:15retailers to having these products in
- 13:18their portfolios has changed over the
- 13:20last few years? And if so, what do you
- 13:22attribute that to?
- 13:24>> Uh, you're talking about their
- 13:25resistance to generics over a branded
- 13:28>> Correct.
- 13:28>> MNC type product. Um yeah, I I think
- 13:32that that resistance has
- 13:35been uh non-evident uh for at least 10
- 13:38years, maybe longer. Um
- 13:41I think that there's a lot more
- 13:42comfortability
- 13:44with generic products today. I don't I
- 13:46actually don't think it's an issue at
- 13:47all. I think more than anything else, it
- 13:49may be driven at the farmgate where a
- 13:51farmer wants to use a brand cuz he may
- 13:53know the rep or he may just identify
- 13:55better with having the brand, meaning
- 13:57the
- 13:58uh initial product. Um
- 14:01but our in our case, we pretty much
- 14:03speak generic language all the time,
- 14:05100% and I don't see any kind of a
- 14:07issue. You know, a lot of these generic
- 14:09companies have to go through a
- 14:11tremendous amount of effort to
- 14:13get their registrations, substantial
- 14:15similarity to the branded piece. There's
- 14:18not a quality issue. There's the
- 14:20occasional packaging problems, but we
- 14:22face that with branded products, too.
- 14:23So,
- 14:25um now, I don't see any resistance at
- 14:26all to using generics. And obviously,
- 14:28Eric, you're on top of this better than
- 14:30I am, but you know, the farm economy is
- 14:32most certainly driving that as well
- 14:34because the cost of the generics are
- 14:36usually a much lower for an input-driven
- 14:39farmer than say the cost of the branded
- 14:41product.
- 14:41>> Just going to add that the first
- 14:43significant quantities of peroxy-sulfone
- 14:46tech arrived on our shores in July from
- 14:48China.
- 14:50>> Yep.
- 14:51And and just since that went off patent,
- 14:53we have five generic entrants in the
- 14:54marketplace today, including
- 14:56you know, the registrant. So, four
- 14:58generic entrants um
- 15:00since it went off patent. And we're
- 15:02already receiving pricing intel on those
- 15:04products.
- 15:05>> Well, tech tech is here now for
- 15:06formulation in the United States.
- 15:08Uh formulated product started arriving a
- 15:10couple of months ago.
- 15:13>> Okay. All right. Well, gentlemen, as we
- 15:16try to wrap up here then, uh again, I'm
- 15:18I'm going to looking forward. I know
- 15:19Jeff, you had mentioned about planning
- 15:21ahead, always a good strategy for any ag
- 15:24retailer, I know, but
- 15:26uh some advice for the ag retailers that
- 15:27may be listening to us talk today. What
- 15:30would you advise uh maybe two or three
- 15:34steps
- 15:35they can take to safeguard their
- 15:37businesses as we move into the 2027
- 15:40season when it comes to like input
- 15:43pricing and supply and demand, of
- 15:45course.
- 15:46>> I think that
- 15:48they they need to challenge their
- 15:50suppliers or have very constructive
- 15:51discussions with their suppliers about
- 15:53total supply in the market.
- 15:55Um
- 15:56they need to have a broad base of
- 15:58suppliers. You know, unlike what we face
- 16:00on the fertilizer front, on the IChem
- 16:01front, we do have a very competitive
- 16:04marketplace with a lot of suppliers
- 16:07looking for market access. So, I think
- 16:09the best move is to have as many, like
- 16:11say a glufosinate, if you know, I talk
- 16:13about 20 suppliers, that's a good
- 16:15problem. Um because we're able to to
- 16:19look at each one of them fairly and and
- 16:23make our decisions going forward. I
- 16:25think in general, with the exception of
- 16:27a few molecules, um
- 16:29there is adequate supply in the market,
- 16:31so I don't know that there's a lot of
- 16:32pressure that we have to buy product now
- 16:34because we're going to run out of it
- 16:35later. Um even though some in some
- 16:38cases, like I get Jim's reports, uh
- 16:40imports are down on some molecules like
- 16:42glyphosate, but there was a lot of
- 16:44glyphosate in the country last two or
- 16:46three years. So, that has helped keep
- 16:48things compressed. So, there's not an
- 16:49urgency to have to take a position. If
- 16:52you have an opportunity, a early pay
- 16:54program or something like that that
- 16:56comes to you, uh what we advise is we
- 16:59reach out to our other suppliers and
- 17:01see, you know, where they are in terms
- 17:03of their supply and their their
- 17:06aspirations for market access. Um
- 17:10So, I I you know, that would be my
- 17:11advice at least going into the next
- 17:13couple of quarters. The other thing is
- 17:15that I think at the retail level, we
- 17:16really have to get to know our farmer
- 17:18customers even better than we did
- 17:19before. First off, the farmer has more
- 17:21access to this intel than he had in the
- 17:23past. So, he's very intelligent about
- 17:26where prices are going just as much as
- 17:28our retailers are in a lot of cases.
- 17:31But also because of what we're seeing
- 17:32with commodity prices,
- 17:34we've had some fortunate weather.
- 17:36Um we've got Looks like we've got pretty
- 17:38good crops across the board. So, we're
- 17:39going to have good yields coming out of
- 17:41the fall. But if we don't see an
- 17:43improvement in, you know, we made it up
- 17:45to this point. Now, we're going into
- 17:472027. If we don't see an improvement in
- 17:49the farm economy, it behooves retailers
- 17:52to get to know their farmers better and
- 17:53understand where their financials are
- 17:55going forward or we're going to get in a
- 17:57backward scenario in that regard. And
- 17:58that's never good.
- 18:00>> Yeah. Jim?
- 18:02>> I would just add that that to that
- 18:04excellent summary,
- 18:06um there is a lot of geopolitical things
- 18:08that are going to impact this um
- 18:11business since the lion's share of
- 18:15molecules
- 18:17uh are either imported entirely or um
- 18:21key components are imported. And so,
- 18:23just to to to keep an eye on what's
- 18:25going on with international trade in the
- 18:27Trump administration,
- 18:29um
- 18:30because I I obviously which I said
- 18:33earlier that that we've got a big effect
- 18:35big impact on July 24th and we don't
- 18:37know what it is yet. So,
- 18:40it's only 10 days away. So, keep your
- 18:42eyes and ears open. Inventory is
- 18:44probably your friend.
- 18:46Um
- 18:47and
- 18:48just buckle up for for
- 18:50kind of a roller coaster ride,
- 18:52especially if you're heavily involved in
- 18:53glyphosate.
- 18:55>> All right.
- 18:55>> Well, any And again, I we haven't even
- 18:57touched on the whole US-Canada-Mexico
- 19:00trade agreement issue cuz I know that's
- 19:03now going to be a ongoing basis kind of
- 19:05thing versus a long-term agreement if I
- 19:09remember reading correctly about what's
- 19:11going on with that. So,
- 19:12>> Well, the the administration
- 19:14uh has a has
- 19:16their position right now is they want to
- 19:18they want it to be two bilaterals. So,
- 19:20just a US Canada, US Mexico. Canada and
- 19:24Mexico want to keep it a trilateral. It
- 19:27will take some take a while to figure
- 19:29out what's going on.
- 19:31Ambassador Greer is testifying to the
- 19:33Senate Finance Committee next week. We
- 19:35may learn something there.
- 19:37>> All right. Well, very good. Well,
- 19:39obviously we will have you gentlemen
- 19:41back on again as things develop in the
- 19:44marketplace, but it certainly sounds
- 19:45like based on what we've been talking
- 19:47about there'll be a lot to be following
- 19:49and keeping attention paying attention
- 19:51to as we move forward here into the
- 19:54planning stages for next year. So, Jim
- 19:57and Jeff, thank you so much for joining
- 19:59us for this edition of CropLife Retail
- 20:01Week. We appreciate your insights.
- 20:03Viewers, we hope you enjoyed this
- 20:05edition and we will see you again next
- 20:07week. Thank you.
- 20:09>> Thanks, Jim.