Latest / Success Story with Scott Clary / Liquidity & Liquor - Reeve Collins - Co-Founder of Smart Media Technologies & Founder of Tether | Being a Pioneer in Emerging Technologies
Transcript
- 0:00really easy thing to point to, and that is my very first job, Avenue A Media.
- 0:07So I graduated in 1997, and I got my first email address in basically 95, right, in college,
- 0:14and so the internet was just starting, and when I graduated, I lived in Seattle, and I was fortunate
- 0:20enough to get a job at a company called Avenue A Media. And I looked for, like everyone back then,
- 0:26looked for a job through the newspaper, because it's the only way to find jobs back then.
- 0:31And there was a startup, a worldwide web startup, and there's a couple of people there,
- 0:35and so I called up, and I went down and interviewed. And there's a bunch of, there's like a couple
- 0:41of young guys, and they're really smart, and they had this idea they wanted to buy and sell ad space.
- 0:47And no one was doing it, and they want to do this online. So I thought this was amazing,
- 0:51but I didn't get that job. They said that they were going to go with someone else, but I could
- 0:56call back in a few weeks. But what I enjoy about this story is that I just stuck to it. I called back
- 1:05in a couple of weeks, and they still told me, you know what, we're not hiring. You've got to call
- 1:09back in another week. I called back in another week. They said, saying, you know, call back later,
- 1:13and at this point in time, my father is like, you've got to take another job. This has been even
- 1:17chasing this for two months, and I had job offers from Boeing and like Verizon and Kellogg's,
- 1:22like I could sell cell phones or be in the finance department of Boeing. And I'm just a recent
- 1:26college grad, and I just knew that that wasn't for me. It just, it would, it would kill me.
- 1:32And the reason why I knew it wasn't for me was because prior to that, in 2000, I wish it was
- 1:39in 1991. That was 19 years old. And my mom sent me to a Tony Robbins Semino. And this Tony Robbins
- 1:54Semino, for me, I grew up in a small town while in Washington, very 30 people in my high school.
- 2:00So just, you know, 30 people. Yeah, yeah, I went to a Catholic school. Okay. So I was extra repressed.
- 2:07Um, yeah, no, unfortunately, there was seven girls in my class. Okay, a lot of options.
- 2:13A lot of options. You better make it. Yeah. Yeah. And for me to go to Tony Robbins, at the time,
- 2:20never heard of, but I got to fly to California for four days to go to the seminar. I went down
- 2:25there, and one of the things, he was like, you have to set some goals in your life. And I'm 19,
- 2:30I have no goals. And so we sit there and go through all those exercises he makes you do. I
- 2:34am like, great, I want a million dollars, you know, I'd like to make a hundred thousand dollars
- 2:39a year. And I want to read Ferrari, you know, what other, you know, it's a pretty solid goals for
- 2:44a 19 year old. And, but you go through the exercises and you envision it and you believe in it.
- 2:49And those goals really stuck with me. Um, and so when I graduated college, the reason why I kept
- 2:55calling for this job and didn't go to Boeing or to Verizon or any of these other companies
- 3:01was because I knew that they would not help me achieve my goal because the kicker in the way
- 3:05Tony Robbins makes you do it, you have to have a timeline for those goals. So I had a timeline
- 3:09when I was 25. I wanted to have a million dollars make a hundred grand a year in a red Ferrari before
- 3:1225. Um, and so I knew, and so those goals really helped me make these decisions. So very long-winded
- 3:20way to answer your question of what was the key moment of my life that set me on my path that
- 3:26gave me the success. It was, it started out with setting those goals and then sticking to them
- 3:31where I knew that I needed a job that could lead to that. And then I got that job and that job
- 3:36again was avenue way, which turned out to be the very first ever online advertising agency.
- 3:41And so I was the first media buyer at that company in the first media buyer online period.
- 3:46And when I started, there's about seven people. Um, and, you know, I kept calling, I eventually got
- 3:52that job. And that company went from seven people to five hundred employees and we went public
- 3:58within two years. Wow. Um, for six point six billion dollars. That's fast. Wow. Yeah, well,
- 4:04this was 97 to 99. That's fast. Wow. Wow. Wow. 97 tonight. What did I do wrong in my life?
- 4:10This is, this is amazing. So what was your position in the company? I was a media buyer.
- 4:14A media buyer, okay. So, but I was one of the first employees. So I got a lot of stock options.
- 4:18But in addition to that, when I was a freshman in high in college, my father gave me five thousand
- 4:23dollars because I went away to school and gave me five thousand dollars to buy a car. But I didn't
- 4:27need a car where I lived in Pullman, Washington's tiny town. I went to Washington State University.
- 4:32And I put it in, I think E-Trade just, just started right around then. So I opened up an E-Trade
- 4:38account and I put it in Microsoft and a couple of other things. But over the four years,
- 4:42that turned into quite a bit of money actually. Give us the number. How much did it turn out to?
- 4:46I ended up with about $80,000 when I graduated college. You had no trading experience?
- 4:51You just put, you just... Yeah, but does anyone college have trading experience?
- 4:54No, that's what I mean. No, that's very true. Yeah. So you made like 80,000 and now you have,
- 4:59okay, so you had some stock options. And so then I had an opportunity to invest,
- 5:04because they were doing another round of funding at this startup. And I read this quote by Warren
- 5:09Buffett. It said, you know, you need to be diversified. But if you want to put all your eggs in one basket,
- 5:14just make sure you watch that basket really closely. I'm like, well, I work here. I spend all day
- 5:20every day, you know, I live, you know, sleep and breathe this company, because it's a startup,
- 5:26but it's crazy hours back then. And so why not? I'm watching this basket closely. So I put all my
- 5:31money into that. And I got these options at about equity at a very, very low price. And we ended
- 5:35up going public at... Here's the crazy thing. We priced, so the pre IPO price was priced at $17.
- 5:43We opened at $89. Wow. So I mean, this is the peak of the bubble, like, the craziness.
- 5:50This is calm. This is, yeah. Yeah. So our, yeah, the day before, like, our friends and family shares
- 5:54that you got for everyone was $17. And then the next day was $89. Yeah. It was amazing. My equity
- 6:00was sub-a-dollar. So it really, yeah, it was a great experience to be 24 years old and go
- 6:06through that and have this front row seat to the right, this global phenomenon of euphoria,
- 6:12which is called the .com bubble, right? We got it. Like, everyone is making money over those years.
- 6:17Everyone's pouring money into these companies, and they're all going public, and really
- 6:21getting that experience was a valuable. No, I was going to say how fortunate you are to
- 6:27align up the right company, because everybody now in their 20, like, I don't think back then working
- 6:32for a startup was as sexy as it is right now. But now everybody tries to work in the startup,
- 6:37and a lot of them spend a lot of their career chasing after that early-state equity,
- 6:40really great strike price, you know, and they all fizzle out, and they waste a lot of good years.
- 6:45And it's hard to pick. I think it was about the six. I think the influence from Tony Robbins,
- 6:51when you were 19, where you said, okay, that's what other kids. I'm talking about other kids
- 6:54early on in their careers. No, yeah, absolutely, yeah. Yeah, I mean, that's why also, you know,
- 7:00Malcolm Gladwell in his book Tipping Point, he writes about a lot of the factors that
- 7:05enable people to become very successful. And a lot of it is essentially being in the right place
- 7:10at the right time. And I truly graduated in the right place at the right time. Fortunately,
- 7:15I live in Seattle, so it wasn't a tech hub, it wasn't San Francisco, but still it was a tech hub.
- 7:20But those years of 97 to 2000 is the best time still probably to date to ever graduate,
- 7:26because kids tried out of school. I mean, my job, when I started, because it was at the beginning of
- 7:31bubble, so I got paid $23,000 a year. But within a year and a half, I was making $100,000 at that
- 7:37company, because they were just paying people insane amounts of money. Like if you remember,
- 7:42they were hiring every tech company was hiring as many people as possible. It was absolutely crazy.
- 7:47What did you learn going into a startup when no one else understood what it is working over there?
- 7:54Coming out from the other side when it's already a public company moving into your next venture,
- 7:58what did you learn from the, what was your biggest takeaway? So, when we went public,
- 8:04you know, I decided I'd worked long enough, you know, I put in my whole two years.
- 8:11So hard. And I rewarded myself with the achievement of my goals. I bought a car and
- 8:18the red Ferrari on my 25th birthday. Yeah, and I moved to LA. And when I look back,
- 8:25the characteristics that I really learned there was I found that I was very opportunistic,
- 8:31overly opportunistic, and overly optimistic, because my entire professional two-year career,
- 8:37everything was a home run. Like every company you saw, every stock went up, as I moved to LA
- 8:41on top of the world. Unfortunately, the bubble burst like right after that, right? And so,
- 8:46most of my wealth at that point in time was paper money. It was in stock options. It was in
- 8:51illiquid stock, because it was still locked up. Fortunately, I still may, you know, I was able to
- 8:56cash out and still do do very well, but I lost a significant portion when the bubble burst,
- 9:01right? We went from $89, and our low after the $89, that company stock went all the way back down
- 9:07to 72 cents. Oh, okay. So that's a little bit, 72 from, from $89. It went back to, it ended up selling
- 9:18for six billion in cash. We went back to, with splits, about a $35 stock share. But the company
- 9:25ended up selling for six billion a number of years later. So it definitely, yeah, it came back.
- 9:31It sold to Microsoft. It was the largest cash transaction in history at the time. And then a
- 9:36few years later, it turns out to be the largest write-off a company did off their balance sheet.
- 9:40Wow. Yeah. It's an interesting story of having a way, razorfish, and over the years.
- 9:46But sorry, back to what I learned. Hello, the coincidence, to just consistently try to work in
- 9:51that company and having all that roller coaster. Yeah. Well, I left at the moment. It went public.
- 9:56Okay. Yeah. So I was 20. I just was about to turn 25. I left, bought the car, moved to L.A.
- 10:02And, and I was very optimistic and, and opportunistic. And so that kind of set the tone for what I did
- 10:08over the next couple of years. And I moved to L.A. and I started my own company because I had this
- 10:13experience in online advertising. I was the most experienced online media buyer there was because I
- 10:18did it longer. And, and we started my own kind of brokerage company. It's called traffic marketplace.
- 10:25And it was an ad network, like one of the very first kind of ad networks. And what we created there
- 10:30was the pop-up ad. So after that, I invented the pop-up ad. We made it more of a mainstream advertising
- 10:37unit. If you recall way back in the early 2000s, late 90s, if you ever went on an adult website and
- 10:43closed that, you get the exit traffic. That was you. Well, I didn't do that. We, we, we, we took
- 10:50that concept. It caused me a lot of problems when I was a kid. I'm just, I want to know if it was you.
- 10:54Yeah. And we took that concept and put it in the mainstream websites. And so that's how we,
- 10:59we popularized the, the pop-up and the method of media buying called arbitrage. And, you know,
- 11:05brokering ad deals with this ad. And that was your company that you built up? Yeah. Yeah.
- 11:092000. Okay. And how was it? And building your first company because, you know, you make it sound
- 11:14so simple. You just pivoted from a successful startup that IPO to just accidentally, you know,
- 11:20building a successful company. There's a lot of effort and energy and probably a lot of like
- 11:24things that didn't go right when you built your first company. So, um, walk me through some of the,
- 11:29the biggest screw ups, the biggest things, headaches, whatever, the you encounter. Because the
- 11:34first time founder, there's always stories. Yeah. Well, I'll tell you one of the most valuable
- 11:38lessons I learned from that world. Because you got to recall, this is 2000. The bubble just burst.
- 11:44All these companies that went public, uh, like home store, uh, were desperate for revenue. And so
- 11:52there was a lot of companies like traffic marketplace at that time that were, we were ad brokers
- 11:58basically, we were buying and selling ad space and pushing our revenue. And a couple of other
- 12:02companies were round tripping the revenue and, and home store being a public company, it would
- 12:09buy a ton of ad space on one site. And then they would buy it back. And then sometimes it wouldn't
- 12:14even run, but they would inflate their numbers. So we saw this happening. And why was the, the reason
- 12:18I was so valuable for me is because some other companies were doing it. And I knew the founders of
- 12:22those companies, they actually ended up going to jail. Like home store, you know, there's a big
- 12:28scandal back then. And there's a handful of companies that were, um, caught up in just
- 12:32facilitating the inflation of your revenue numbers. And obviously that's illegal when you're
- 12:36in public. Of course. But for me to witness that being another naive young guy, being like,
- 12:43oh, these are fast and loose playing deals. But then witnessing some other people that I actually
- 12:47knew, like getting real trouble at such a young age for me was really valuable because I just made
- 12:53me keep my nose very, very clean throughout the rest of my career because I sought first hand.
- 12:57And I just look at back at that. And, uh, it's, it was, it was a good lesson. Yeah, it's just, it's
- 13:02like a crossroad, it's a moral crossroad when you, when you grow your business where you can see
- 13:07things people don't seek because it's your business and you so tune into it. And you noticed
- 13:11something that's on the gray side, but you know that it's actually on the dark side and you shouldn't
- 13:16go there and you ask yourself, should I go and money can corrupt people and just very hard for
- 13:21some people to go and make the right turn instead of the left turn. So you took the right turn and
- 13:26then eventually things happen. And you look, thank God, you moved on. Yeah, for sure. And just to, to,
- 13:32because it gives you that experience that bad things can happen. Yeah, especially being at a
- 13:37young age and having your ability, exactly. And seeing that some of the people I knew was like,
- 13:42wow, that's, that's, yeah. So how did you, how did you pivot from marketing, ad buying, media
- 13:48arbitrage into crypto? What was that? Yeah. So after traffic marketplace, um, I had a handful like
- 13:57from there, what I learned. So, you know, the optimism really, the optimism was the most important
- 14:04because I believed everything was going to work. I just, I stuck, even after the bubble burst,
- 14:07I believed all these companies were going to work. And so then I was very opportunistic and I would
- 14:11chase down every single opportunity because I thought they were going to work. And so for these
- 14:15next 10 years between about 2002 and 2013, when I, before I got into crypto, um, I learned to be an
- 14:23operator because I chased down a hundred different types of business deals. And I probably started
- 14:28another 10, right? You chase them all down and you do the ones you can as you think they're all
- 14:32going to work. They're going to be great. But when I learned the skills, the foundational skills
- 14:35of being an entrepreneur, of starting a company and, and knowing enough about all of the departments
- 14:41and the divisions that it takes to start a company like from legal and HR on hiring and marketing
- 14:45and sales and then selling the company and taxes and, and everything. And so when, and I started
- 14:52a, a couple other companies, um, sold them. I had one of the very first ever, um, on, the company
- 15:00we created WebAsodes was brand funded content. So we would produce, um, short form videos for the
- 15:05internet and have them sold by brands. The other company that came out about the same time is
- 15:08Funier Die. Um, yeah. And so I had one of these coming. I sold it to a large ad network. And so
- 15:14we produced tons of content. But do I find your diet just sold? I want to say like about a year ago.
- 15:18So on day just exit. Yeah. Funier Die has been around for a while. And it's the best example of
- 15:23kind of that short form content that all started. And that was like 2006 or 2007. But, um,
- 15:30but I sold that company and I had another. And then I so, so did you sell also the ad agency
- 15:36company? Yeah. So we sold traffic and marketplace to the Vendee Universal. Okay. Um, and then I left.
- 15:41I took a couple of years off. I was 26 and I kind of just, just, I hung out in LA. How long did you
- 15:48take off from? Big two years. But I did some other things. I started a production company. We did
- 15:53150 music videos. You default to creative a lot. You do default to creative a lot. I just,
- 15:59I'm just like trying to figure out the left brain, right brain dichotomy and all the different
- 16:04ventures you take on. Because even now, like you're working on creative stuff and marketing stuff
- 16:08and you were originally ad creative. And then you want like, it's interesting. And then
- 16:12somebody who completely different from from the type of person that I would assume would take
- 16:17on a project like tether. It's a very different personality. But it's obviously used to straddle
- 16:23both very well. Well, that's where the optimism comes in like, oh, tether. Like, well, what happened
- 16:28was I learned about the internet. I sold the hand. I sold three other two other companies before.
- 16:33And then, and then my friend, you know, in 2013 started telling me about the blockchain. Because
- 16:38I'm like, look, let's do something. I'm, I'm ready to do. I wasn't, I sold the company. I was
- 16:43just ready to do the next thing. He started telling me about the blockchain. So I started buying Bitcoin.
- 16:47And, and when he told me about the, about the blockchain, I'm like, well, this is amazing.
- 16:52It's, it's got to work. It makes sense. Like, you know, we can move money in a new way and fast. And,
- 16:56you know, then I would talk to other people that knew a little bit more about finance and
- 17:00technology. And they're like, this, the blockchain is a scam. It's not going to work. I don't even
- 17:05understand where you're talking about those that did say it's the worst thing ever. But I'm like,
- 17:08huh, sounds good to me. I love it. Yeah. But entrepreneurs need that almost like
- 17:15naivety towards what they're building, right? Exactly. Especially when you layer in, then,
- 17:19then so why don't we go take the most highly regulated asset in the world? The dollar.
- 17:25And put it on a brand new technology that allows you to send any amount of it anywhere in the
- 17:32world to anybody anonymously. You know, you think we're getting any trouble for that? Oh my God.
- 17:39So, you know, we just dove in. I'm like, well, at least I'm enough of an operator to understand
- 17:44how to make all this stuff work. And I'll understand that the nuances of the technology and the
- 17:48businesses we go. And at the time, there was only Bitcoin, Litecoin Ethereum, and I'm sorry,
- 17:54there wasn't a theory. Bitcoin, Litecoin, Dogecoin, a handful of crypto currencies back in 2013, 2014.
- 18:00And so there just wasn't much awareness in this space. But we had the concept. It's like, great,
- 18:07there's a new way to move money, the blockchain. There's a new type of money being moved on the
- 18:11blockchain, crypto currencies, but that type of money, people, it's volatile. Yeah. So why don't we move
- 18:17real world currencies on this new financial infrastructure? So that was the impetus of Tether. And
- 18:22then we had to build the technology to tokenize an asset so we could put it on the blockchain.
- 18:26So we, there was a company at the time called Mastercoin, which turned into Omni, but we took that
- 18:31technology, improved upon it so we could actually tokenize the dollar. And then we rolled it out.
- 18:37And what I still say to this day is that the elegance of Tether's business model is in its simplicity.
- 18:44You give me a dollar. I put it in the bank. I issue you a token. That token works on a blockchain.
- 18:50Send me the token back. I give you the dollar. I mean, that is it. And Tether has stuck to that the
- 18:55whole time. And sticking to that as long as all that money is in reserve and it is in the bank,
- 19:02sticking to that will ensure that Tether stands the test of time and could handle anything that
- 19:09comes at it. For instance, when Tara Luna collapsed, there was a $13 billion run on the bank.
- 19:14Tether reimbursed every, you know, refund or let people withdraw $13 billion. Not many financial
- 19:20institutions in the world could withstand that. Interesting.
- 19:22With draws. And the reason why that the simplicity of Tether's business model is so important,
- 19:28especially when you think of Tara Luna and these algorithmic stable coins, those are experiments.
- 19:35People don't know if that's going to work or not, right? There's a bunch of smart people trying
- 19:39to figure out an algorithm that says, well, if you do this and that, then this will be pegged.
- 19:43Yeah, but what's the difference? So if you're saying, okay, I put my dollar, now I get a token from
- 19:47Tether, why is Tara Luna any different? Because you don't give them a dollar. Tara Luna is an
- 19:52algorithmic back token saying that we're going to buy and sell. We're going to do these different
- 19:58types of transactions to make sure our token stays right about a dollar. There is not a billion
- 20:03dollars in the bank for a billion dollars of Tara Luna. So you can just go to the bank. They're
- 20:07they're relying on a formula to pay. Interesting. Obviously did not work. Right.
- 20:12Oops. Yeah. Yeah. So, you know, that I guess the question was, how did I get into crypto and
- 20:21that's how and why did I get into crypto and dive in because I'm a believer. I'm a believer in
- 20:26opportunities that are presented to me. Can you I know a little bit about Tether and stable coins,
- 20:32but I'm not obviously as involved in it as you are. So can you even just walk through the landscape
- 20:37because it seems like something as simple as a business model as, hey, put in a dollar, get a
- 20:42token, that doesn't seem to be a business with much of a moat. It's a great point. Try to raise
- 20:48money. They're like, what do you mean? Yeah. So you can't raise money. That's why I self-funded
- 20:54it at the beginning. Then we raised a little bit of cash. Okay. Because when you go to someone and say
- 20:59well, first of all, forget about the mo, they're just they just think you're crazy when when we
- 21:04tried to roll out. This is so early on with Tether. Yeah, they're like it made no sense to anyone.
- 21:10There wasn't people trading much cryptocurrency back then. I mean, the whole market the whole
- 21:15market cap was like two to three billion dollars when we when we started of the entire market cap,
- 21:21you know, just three trillion. So it's grown a lot. So there wasn't much going on and but Tether
- 21:29provided a dollar-based trading pair. So at first, which was actually to be honest, wasn't the first
- 21:36reason why we started. We thought it'd be a better way to move money. But it turned out that if
- 21:40you trade cryptocurrency, if you're moving from Bitcoin to Litecoin, it's two volatile assets.
- 21:45You needed a stable coin, a dollar-based trading pair to trade. So that's what my very elementary
- 21:49question is going to come. If I give you a Bitcoin for Tether, you would have to exchange the
- 21:55Bitcoin to a dollar. Correct. In order to keep it as to where it was. And then the transaction fee
- 22:03has to make sense that you guys don't lose money between changing the Bitcoin to dollar.
- 22:09Well, you pay the trade. If you pay, okay. Yeah, we would only to issue Tether's,
- 22:15we would only accept cash. Now, what you would do is you would take your Bitcoin to an exchange.
- 22:21And that exchange would turn into Tether and they'd take fees for it. I understand.
- 22:25Yeah. Do you get it? It's very simple. Yeah. Okay. What's the difference between Tether and,
- 22:30like for example, USDC? So in theory, the same structure. It's a 100% asset-backed.
- 22:39And USDC, you know, circle is more heavily regulated by the US because it's a US company.
- 22:46And Tether is not based in the US. So you built this up. Walk me through like the selling of
- 22:51a company, why you chose to sell maybe the life after Tether because even funny enough before we
- 22:56jumped onto this podcast, I was like, how do you, you know, how do you want to be introduced?
- 22:59What's the person? And obviously, Tether's huge. Yeah. So it's very much tied to you,
- 23:04but you've built a ton of stuff since then. Yeah. Well, and I'm extremely proud of Tether. It's an
- 23:08amazing, I don't want to say gift, but this is an amazing creation that that laid the foundation
- 23:16for the cryptocurrency ecosystem. And so, so I am proud of that. And it, and it has standard
- 23:21with stood the test of time. And the new operators, the people who have operated and who are
- 23:25really actually responsible for its massive growth because Tether didn't really see significant growth
- 23:30until 2017 until the whole market picked up. Yeah. But they have done, in my opinion, an amazing job
- 23:38at battling all the fun to date, all the negative news, and sticking to the promise of ensuring
- 23:44anyone can redeem their Tether for a dollar at any time. So, so Tether is, yes, it was an important
- 23:50contribution to the space. But after that, the reason I sold Tether was, you have to again,
- 23:56go back to 2015, Bitcoin had a huge run. It went up to $1,100, maybe $1,200, I don't recall,
- 24:03$1,200, $1,200 from a hundred, you know, like within a number of months, so lots of enthusiasm.
- 24:09But then the market crashed and it went back down to basically $1,180. And Tether, you know,
- 24:17we were trying to build this company. It wasn't getting a lot of traction in the beginning, but what
- 24:22it was getting a lot of was heat because it's a very regulated space. If you want to move money,
- 24:27you have to money transmission licenses in every state and all of this. And so really going down
- 24:32that rabbit hole of regulation and banking and everything, and maybe in a US citizen, I held all
- 24:38of that liability on my shoulders and on my back. And when you're thinking about, okay, the only way
- 24:43this company is going to be financially successful and lucrative for us as the founders is if it's
- 24:49the biggest company in the world, because our only business model is if we have billions of dollars
- 24:52in the bank, you know, that's a big gift. Turns out there's tens of billions of dollars in the bank.
- 24:58But at the time, I'm like, you know, I have a lot of liability here. And Bipfenex was our partner,
- 25:02the principles of Bipfenex were our partners in the beginning. And they were all offshore.
- 25:07And so it was easy to, so they took it over. And it just existed as a product of the exchange for
- 25:13a while and then really, really exploded on the scene. You feel it's part of your who you are,
- 25:18identity, when you walk around and you say I'm the co-founder of Tether.
- 25:24Yes. And yeah, it is, especially in the crypto space, right? It was my first crypto company,
- 25:29and inventing this stable coin is a great contribution. But it wasn't the last one, because after
- 25:36that, after I left Tether, another brilliant visionary, a friend came to me and who's an extraordinary
- 25:42business person, but really his vision is he had the vision for this next company. And he's like,
- 25:49look, let's create something that's not going to be regulated right off the bat.
- 25:55Let's take, since now there's this technology to tokenize things, let's tokenize collectibles,
- 26:01let's tokenize tickets, let's create highly programmable digital goods. And this is in 2015,
- 26:07there was no word for NFT. This is way before. Yeah. And so we created the very first ever NFT
- 26:13platform. So after the stable coin, the next contribution was of the NFT. We called it something
- 26:21different in the beginning. We called it a vatum of virtual atom. We had to come up with
- 26:23their own word to say, what are these tokens that you actually own now? And they're highly
- 26:29programmable and can do things. And so that company started in 2015. We raised a couple million dollars,
- 26:35but it built some some really amazing tech. But then when the ICO craze hit in 2017, because
- 26:42you got to think between 2015 and 2017, the market, the crypto market crashed. And it was kind of
- 26:47a low. It was pretty dead actually for a while. Ethereum did their crowd sale in 2015. They didn't
- 26:53release a product for two years. It took until 2017 for them to actually release the product. Well,
- 26:59it might have released a little before, but then it took a while for anyone to come up with a
- 27:02use case. So there's these smart contracts. No one understood what they were or what they could
- 27:06do. And the first real use case became the ICO. And that's what drove up one the increase of
- 27:13value and tether of the money and that. But also drove the entire market. It shot Bitcoin from
- 27:19you know, one to three thousand up to $20,000 because so much time and attention and awareness and
- 27:25attention was was was on the crypto space. The reason being is because everyone was gambling.
- 27:29Yeah, it was just a big gambling gambling. It's like now you have access to all these startups
- 27:34and anybody can invest and there's no instant liquidity, right? It's a token and you can sell it
- 27:40right away. It's a new exchange. It's open 24 seven. So so we jumped on that bandwagon because we
- 27:45had some amazing technology and I did an ICO. So then I raised $22 million in October of 2017.
- 27:53So is the tail end of the ICO window, the ICO bubble because at the end of that year, you know,
- 27:59beginning of 2018, the ICO just crashed. There was only about a hundred total ICOs that raised
- 28:06over $20 million and we were one of them that I think there's about a thousand ICOs in total.
- 28:11But out of those hundred, there's only very very like very few left. And I'm proud to say and I
- 28:19do say this a lot that that block V has delivered on all of its ICO promises. The technology is still in
- 28:25use and the token still is in use. But here's the interesting thing. What we got wrong was marketing.
- 28:31We didn't market it. We didn't pump the token because now as we all in retrospect, we all know
- 28:36that that's all that matters. And here's the best example of why marketing is the only thing it
- 28:40matters when it comes to token value. And this is that's a big statement. That's a generalization. But
- 28:44the reason I say that is look at the meme coins. Look at Doge. These coins are worth tens of
- 28:49billions of dollars. But it's all garbage, though. That's the thing. That's what I'm saying. Yeah,
- 28:52it's all marketing. There's no tech. Yeah, I know. I built extraordinary tech. Didn't do the
- 28:57marketing. So our token. It did go up 20 X. But that wasn't anything I did. That was the that was
- 29:02the hype cycle of the ICO. Yeah, you know, something this is this is something I was I was thinking
- 29:07when is the spot one been asked you about that because I think that anything related to crypto
- 29:12from NFT, uh, if it's metaverse, if it's any kind of crypto, it was all the winners are marketers.
- 29:19Even if it's for a short period of time, because then there's going to be a miserable collapse,
- 29:22like Shiba Uno and and Dodge, right? It really comes down to organized marketing where they had
- 29:28organized groups on Reddit and they would pump it and maybe telegram and this or very, very
- 29:35organized eventually everyone were doing that and and so on and today, it's it's much different,
- 29:40right? People want to see faces. So that opportunity disappeared. So then
- 29:45Tether really stood the test of time. But blocked the two, I guess. Well, yeah, that's true.
- 29:51Not as big as Tether, but I mean, but I mean, how did Tether promote himself eventually? I mean,
- 29:56was it just organic? No, pure utility. Beautiful. There's no need to promote like people like,
- 30:01oh, should I invest in Tether? I'm like, well, if you need to ask, if you're asking that question,
- 30:05the answer is absolutely not because Tether's not something you invest in. Tether is a dollar,
- 30:10and it stays a dollar. You can invest in Bitcoin and Ethereum and other crypto you'd like,
- 30:13but you don't invest in Tether. You use Tether. It's just a utility for the, for the ecosystem.
- 30:18So it didn't need to promote itself. It just was so useful. And for the first
- 30:23five years, it was the only stable coin. There, there weren't any others and then they started coming
- 30:29out. I think maybe 2017, 18, a couple of others started trying to do it. So, so, so, so there's
- 30:35that the answer to that. And and that block fee, we didn't promote the token enough, but we built
- 30:41some amazing tech. And so you built a, you built a company. Yeah, you should. But that's the thing.
- 30:45A lot of people don't build companies, right? That's the issue with Doge and she, but you know,
- 30:49all that it's a market. What's the difference between between you and say Dodge? Because
- 30:56that's that's a token and that's a token, right? So, what's the difference? So there's no utility
- 31:01other than it being a token. Okay. And it traded on a blockchain. What Doge did was they forked
- 31:06the copied Bitcoin like within, you know, but I don't even know when Doge came out probably
- 31:122010 or 11 or 12 or very long time ago. They forked Bitcoin and all they changed was instead of 21
- 31:18million. It's, it's endless, right? So it's, it's nothing. But they just had this community and
- 31:24people believe and they buy and then Elon pumps it. And, and that's all, that's what, that's what
- 31:29takes to raise prices. People just, there's demand, supply and demand. And, but we built some
- 31:34extraordinary technology at block fee. And so then what happened was my partner there, the,
- 31:39the visionary behind block fee went and started company called Vatem Inc. And I started to come
- 31:43back called smart media technologies. So we both built new companies on top of this technology
- 31:49to deliver NFTs to the world. So smart media technologies today is one of the largest enterprise
- 31:55Web3 platforms that there is. We deal with some of the biggest enterprises in the world. And we
- 32:00provide the wallet infrastructure that ability to create NFTs and metaverse environments. So we
- 32:07are leading the charge in the Web3.0 movement for large brands and organizations to connect to their
- 32:13consumer on a one-to-one level through the wallet. Because when we get to Web3, the killer app,
- 32:20unlike Web1 and 2, the killer app has been email forever. In Web3, it's going to be the wallet.
- 32:26The reason being is, if all you have is an email, the only thing you can receive from brands and
- 32:31anyone else is information and spam and a lot of annoyance. Like, like, especially when they're
- 32:36marketing to you, very, not very often is it very valuable. Yeah. They now have the tools to
- 32:42actually give you value. Because now you're going to have your email address and you're going to
- 32:47log into a website. But there's going to be a wallet attached to that email address. And now that
- 32:52the brand has a wallet attached to it, he can actually send you cryptocurrency or NFTs.
- 32:58So let's touch on NFTs a little bit and then I'll dive more into it.
- 33:01I think that's important. So you're delivering the platform to communicate between the business
- 33:04and the consumer. But then the question comes up, okay, so great. I'm a business enterprise
- 33:09deliverant NFT and you're probably going to go into this. Okay. So what next? Right. Because
- 33:14especially when we talk about NFTs and the hype that you guys just, or that we all just experience,
- 33:19the hype from 2020. Again, that was just like ICOs, the NFT hype, pure gambling. People like,
- 33:25I don't understand NFTs. It's like, because you're overthinking it. These guys are degenerates for
- 33:30reason. They are gambling. They are just, it's just the frenzy. They're having a great time.
- 33:35Hopefully make it money and hopefully not losing too much. But it drove a ton of awareness into
- 33:40this space and it changed consumer behavior. It enabled people to understand what a wallet is
- 33:45and place value on it and also place value on digital objects within that wallet. Because before
- 33:50the last few years, no one, no one cared unless you were a gamer and had like inventory in the game
- 33:55and you place value on that. But other than that, no one cared about digital wallets or digital goods.
- 33:59But now the world cares. And so now brands can use this shift in consumer behavior
- 34:05to deliver them value to the wallet. And here's the best way to explain that. Think about to date
- 34:12how much brands spend an online advertising. So this year it's about 250 billion in the US,
- 34:18571 billion worldwide. That's what's spent by brands on digital advertising.
- 34:25Guess where all that money goes? It goes to the middleman, the planners and the buyers of
- 34:29the technology. It goes to the agencies and it goes to the websites to Apple and to Facebook
- 34:35and to Google and to all the websites. Everyone has a data. All 571 billion dollars goes to everyone
- 34:42except the consumer. The consumer. That's all the brand wants to reach. Web 3 and the wallet
- 34:50gives the brands the tools to actually give that value to the consumer. So you can go and say,
- 34:56I'm enabling ads and I will get paid for the ads that I'm displaying on Web 3 or the wallet.
- 35:03Why? Why even have an ad? If this brand wants to market to you,
- 35:08and why would he spend five dollars to get that ad in front of you? Why does he just give you five dollars?
- 35:14Look we're fine. It's actually coupons, loyalty, all that. So when you think about loyalty programs
- 35:21to the past, they're kind of lame and maybe some people really enjoy it. And sometimes you get
- 35:25some points and sometimes there are a lot of value and sometimes it's just entertainment to get
- 35:29points. But loyalty programs are important but they're about to get 100 times more important in
- 35:36the future through Web 3. So what you think of your loyalty program of the past where you get some
- 35:42points, now the loyalty programs of the future with Web 3 wallets are going to provide you the
- 35:47consumer real value because the brand now has a tool to put that money in your wallet.
- 35:55Never been done before. The brand will have a one-to-one relationship to the consumer,
- 35:59to market to them into their wallet. And they're not going to just give you five dollars.
- 36:04They're going to give you a smart coupon that says, well, if you buy these two things,
- 36:09it's third one's free. And if you send it to five of your friends and they buy,
- 36:12you're going to get a free pair of shoes. Each coupon is going to be highly programmable
- 36:17because that's what programmable NFTs are. So back to what I was starting with,
- 36:22when people say they don't understand NFTs, are NFTs dead because they collapse? No,
- 36:26that's NFT 1.0. That was gambling. That was the buying and selling digital images. That's
- 36:31trying to create a community around an ape. NFT 2.0 and beyond are NFTs with actual utility.
- 36:39They do things like loyalty. And so now you're going to get this stuff from a brand that's really
- 36:45valuable because let's say the brand, let's say it's Nike and they give you this digital
- 36:49pair of tennis shoes that turns into a free pair of Jordans. But let's say you hate Michael Jordan
- 36:53or don't like tennis shoes. It's still valuable. In the past, you couldn't trade out your loyalty
- 36:59points. But now you have this digital good. You can put on a marketplace and sell it for something
- 37:03that you do care about. So now all the brand communications, when it is an NFT in your wallet,
- 37:10can become valuable to you because you can trade it for something else. Well, it's going to really be
- 37:13a reality because Web 3 obviously came out after, I mean, mostly for the masses during the NFT time.
- 37:23And there's a lot of excitement because they said it's decentralized internet. No one can shut
- 37:27you down. You can speak freely. No one can. There's a lot of reasons. A lot of, I would say,
- 37:32emotional reason for some, but but only again, just decentralized. Just let's just go and continue
- 37:37the philosophy. But, but yet, when do you think we're going to actually see a shift or majority of the
- 37:44young generation, Gen Z or younger than them? I don't know what the term is for younger Gen Gen.
- 37:50I don't know the general. Gen Z Gen Z. We're going to say, no, I'm not going on this one. That's
- 37:56centralized. I don't want to go into centralized. And really we're going to be able to see
- 38:00the mass adoption. Yeah, well, once you have critical mass that it's worth it for you to invest
- 38:04your time into it. So there's two things you're touching on. One is decentralization versus centralization.
- 38:10The other is Web 3. And the problem is, how do you define Web 3? Everyone defines it differently
- 38:15because one, one definition is a decentralized internet. I believe that's way much farther
- 38:22in the future. Okay. Because the easy use for decentralized technology isn't there for the
- 38:27average consumer. It's hard to set up a web wallet, especially if you don't use a system like
- 38:33Coinbase or three months ago FTX. Centralization offers a ton of value. Now, the drawback is,
- 38:46you know, it can be corrupt and fraudulent, et cetera, et cetera. But it does offer ease of
- 38:52use value. Now, that's slightly different than what I like to call Web 3.1.0. What's the first
- 39:00version that we're going to experience Web 3? How is the, like people have heard about it,
- 39:05and no one's experienced it yet. It's not tangible. And that's kind of your question. When's it
- 39:09going to happen? The decentralized version of it, I think, is much further out. But what we're going
- 39:14to experience soon, I think everyone else, the majority of people will start experiencing in some
- 39:20sense throughout 2023, is that you'll now have a wallet. You might not need to go set up a
- 39:26wallet anywhere. But the next, but soon you'll go to a website. And if you log in or sign up,
- 39:32you'll get a wallet and they'll give you an object because they'll give you an incentive. They'll
- 39:35say, enter the sweepstakes to win a free backpack. You're like, great, I love Fyall Raven. It's
- 39:40cool, funky brand. I want their, their, their, their conkin backpack. So you'll enter a sweepstakes.
- 39:45You'll get a digital backpack in your wallet. You send it to do friends. You get, you get two more
- 39:50entrance into the sweepstakes and they'll do a drawing every week. So it'll be a more gamified
- 39:54loyalty experience. So you're, so you're basically saying Web 3 1.0 is centralized companies deploying
- 40:00decentralized technology for, well, deploying. Let's get away from, because I'm trying to understand
- 40:06also the internet part behind us. How is it different? I mean, you, you, well, no, because I do
- 40:10understand, I do understand the added value of a loyalty program. So if I, yeah, that's a marketing.
- 40:16My point is that, okay, so if it sits on Amazon web servers, how is it different? Just because
- 40:22you download a wallet like Metamask that doesn't sit on a very slow, not very. It's not necessarily
- 40:28different. We're, we're talking about a couple of different things here, because I agree with
- 40:32exactly what you're saying. A lot of this quote unquote Web 3 stuff that I'm speaking about,
- 40:37like loyalty programs and ticketing and all this stuff. It does not need to be decentralized in any
- 40:42way, shape. Of course not. Yes. So it's a new, but, but consumer behaviors shifted because now we
- 40:48understand wallets. Look, COVID, one of the things that was beneficial from it is it
- 40:52introduced the US to QR codes. People now know how to use QR codes, which is a great thing for
- 40:58NFTs and digital objects, because now you can just scan something and instead of going to a website
- 41:03to read information, you're going to get an object of value. So if that brand wants to give you
- 41:07this NFT that's actually valuable, it's really easy to get now. And so consumer behavior has changed.
- 41:12You know what QR codes are? You place value on wallets and the digital goods within those wallets.
- 41:17And so the first version of what people are going to start experiencing is they're going to have
- 41:23a wallet and it's going to be filled with stuff and that stuff's valuable. And most of it's going
- 41:28to come from brands because those are the people that want to give consumer value. Why did you
- 41:33want to stay away from the word deploying? Because with finding that decentralized? No, no, in
- 41:37centralized. Look, I said your version of Web 3 1.0 is centralized companies. Like your company
- 41:42is centralized. You have an org chart, your centralized org, but you're creating decentralized
- 41:48widgets for people. Oh, decentralized. Yes, I say you're spot on. Sorry, yes. Now the NFTs that
- 41:56those people have in their wallets, they can work on any blockchain or centralized blockchain,
- 42:01you know, a closed loop blockchain if you want. But yes, they have the objects interoperable.
- 42:06And this is this is a slide I just showed earlier today, which is from or I will describe the
- 42:11slide I showed earlier today, which is we can find it in second in the video. Yeah, is one that I
- 42:16created in 2017 when I was doing my my ICO road show to describe how big of an opportunity we
- 42:24have in front of us about these interoperable digital objects. And I called it the trillion object
- 42:29opportunity because there are millions of apps and a billion websites, but there will be a trillion
- 42:37objects. And think about how much value has been created through apps and through websites.
- 42:43No value to date until well, when I was pitching this in 2017, there was no value in objects.
- 42:49And now the first year that NFTs hit the scene, they went from zero to 27 billion dollars
- 42:55of sales in NFT revenue in I think in 2020, right? And explode on the scene. That's the
- 43:00trillion object opportunity. That's what I'm sharing with people now. It's like NFTs, it's not over.
- 43:05We've just scratched the surface on the use case. Everything you do in your digital life moving
- 43:12forward is going to be an NFT. All the objects of value in that life will be NFTs, they'll be in your
- 43:18wallet and you'll get value. Again, not a very elementary question again. We're not we're not
- 43:22equipped to people over here. You got to take everything in your brain. And again, when you want
- 43:28to bring people into the industry, it is very important that you take all these concepts because
- 43:32it's going to affect your day to day. So in years from now, that information is going to be valuable
- 43:37for, but people would look back and say there was all that information that we didn't want to
- 43:43process and really understand. So I'm going to try to like with a little bit lame strum for myself,
- 43:47actually. So if you're saying it doesn't have to be decentralized. If you're telling me here is
- 43:53a digital wallet and I'm giving you this image and it's registered as your as our image in which
- 43:59we're giving to you and maybe in the future, it's going to be worth something and I'm handing it over
- 44:03to you. The currently on the blockchain, that's where you can all verify. There is just one centralized
- 44:09place where you can verify who owns what, what was the entire trail, all that Picasso. Okay, that is a
- 44:14digital Picasso type picture work. But if it's centralized and it's not sitting on the blockchain,
- 44:21then it's not web 3.0, 3.0. It's just a utility that's moved into 2.0. Am I wrong about that?
- 44:32It depends on what your definition of web 2.0 or web 3.0. It sounds like you're defining web 3 as
- 44:38a decentralized internet. And necessarily in this case, I understand the point that you're saying,
- 44:42look, it's going to be centralized. My point is if you're saying it's going to sit on Amazon
- 44:47web servers. Right now, if you're looking at it. Let me rephrase it. It can sit on Amazon web servers.
- 44:53It can sit on a blockchain. That's the beauty of these objects. It depends on the creator. So we
- 44:58provide tools. You're the creator. You're like, I want this on the Polkadot blockchain. I want this
- 45:05on Solan. I want this on Cardano. I want this on Ethereum. Or I don't want any of those
- 45:10blockchains. I want it on this database because I don't need to pay the extra amount of money or
- 45:14the time and cost to put it on those blockchains because it doesn't need to be publicly verified
- 45:18blockchain. So it all boils down to the use case for that object. And to date, right now,
- 45:25the majority of these use cases can all sit on a database. We don't need the blockchain for the
- 45:29majority of the use cases that brands need that when they want to provide value to their consumers.
- 45:37There'll be lots more use cases in the future. And I am a huge believer in decentralization.
- 45:42It is where we're going, but it's going to take a while to get there.
- 45:48I have a question for you. So you mentioned this is sort of going back to one of the points you made
- 45:52about the 570 or some billion dollars in ad spend that whatever that was. Now, you mentioned that
- 45:59companies will have that revenue because they want to communicate directly with their customer.
- 46:03But the the action that you're describing is basically last mile of the marketing funnel,
- 46:08right? Like you're talking about if I have already the connection with the customer,
- 46:12then I can exchange some sort of lowly program. So have you seen, because that's a huge
- 46:18budget of ad dollars, have you seen other emerging disruptive texts that can solve for awareness
- 46:26or general top of funnel stuff that you could that you don't have to go through Facebook for
- 46:30or agencies for. But it's a great question and and various student observation. But that is why
- 46:37first party data is so valuable to the brands because they get the first party data essentially
- 46:41your email address and permission to market to you. And this is what my company does. It's an
- 46:47enterprise great platform that that enables these brands to do this legally and appropriately,
- 46:53because you know, when you have to follow all of the different. Castle and GDPR. Exactly.
- 46:58CCA or whatever. Yeah, to get all of those licenses or
- 47:02approvals, I should say, is very challenging. But once you have all that and then you can collect
- 47:08that first party data and then you can market to these people right in their wallet. That is what
- 47:12the brand wants. But how do they get that first party day in the first place? They use the traditional
- 47:16methods and smart media actually does it across the board. We do all television media behind as well
- 47:22as full suite of digital. I love how you're like it's like coming full circle. Yeah, all your
- 47:26career is 100% and yes, and they all build on to one another. And that's why when we created the
- 47:33NFT, like to me, the use my use case that I was really passionate about is specifically this
- 47:39is enabling brands to connect on a one-to-one level with their consumer and provide them value
- 47:42because being in digital marketing since the advent of, you know, internet marketing,
- 47:48seeing all of the money being sucked out by middlemen, you know, and the consumer getting nothing,
- 47:53it's like we can finally solve that. And so that's something worthwhile.
- 47:56And that would be a major disruption. This is one of those disruption that happens once
- 48:01every couple of decades sometimes in certain industries. And that's a multi-industry
- 48:06disruption, right? It's going to be a, well, I guess that's when you short meta.
- 48:11Yeah. I mean, it's not like they need any more shorting. But that's going to be a major
- 48:18disruption for everybody. Yeah. Absolutely. And you know, you mentioned meta.
- 48:25Do you have a question you want me to ask? No, go ahead. No, I was looking at, I had some
- 48:28questions about the metaverse, but yeah, well, I can tell you the metaverse now. Yeah. So,
- 48:33you know, Mark Zuckerberg gets so much grief for putting so much money into the metaverse
- 48:39and investing so heavily on that and betting the future of Facebook on it. Well, if you didn't
- 48:44bet on that, what was he going to bet on? Because the future of Facebook is in a dire shape.
- 48:50Yeah. Because of the age of the cookie is over. The way we would track ads forever is over.
- 48:55Like, look at the upgrades with the new iOS platform. You have to like opt in everywhere. And
- 49:00people just say, no, I don't want to be tracked. Every website you go to now, you have to allow
- 49:05cookies. Most people say no. That's where I think that he might do it right. Maybe it is
- 49:10the future. The thing is it's a very long road for him. I think that his bet was supposed to go
- 49:17against Amazon by acquiring Shopify saying, all right. So Shopify is the largest platform for websites.
- 49:26If we acquire them and not just doing a partnership like we're doing right now, I can track them
- 49:31throughout. I can own that part where I understand that this is the person that came over. We have
- 49:37everything in the one roof. And then as soon as I, as soon as you come into Facebook, you already
- 49:43have your wallet or say Facebook, it's more Instagram, right? No, but your wallet is there just
- 49:49like an Amazon. And it would be probably more convenient to work to buy on Instagram, then later on
- 49:55on, then what it is today on an Amazon, right? Because you'll buy an Amazon. And then part of what
- 50:02Shopify would try to do. And I'm not sure what stage they are. They're trying to acquire a lot of
- 50:08a three three PL shipping companies where they process everything. So they can try to fully
- 50:15compete more effectively with Amazon with with the shipping process. Probably Facebook has a little
- 50:20bit of a better chance. And if they were going in doubt route, that would probably be introducing
- 50:28cash flow fairly fast just from the integration and then adding a layer of shipping parts where you
- 50:34can actually have the products in you can create a certain control. You can really go in and
- 50:39compete with the strategy they're deploying right now. No, they're not. They have not. And that is
- 50:43where I say he should have done this because it would have produced revenue fairly early. Right now
- 50:51Shopify is not a profitable company because of investments that are making in acquiring all those
- 50:56shipments types companies right where they could have been acquiring them. They're not big enough
- 51:03they can acquire them for stocks. And then on the entire flow from from seeing an image all the way
- 51:10to the thank you page all the way through the email everything else and you can just create a wallet.
- 51:16You would probably see yourself using Amazon much less. Yeah. And then eventually competing also
- 51:22that would have been my move to go and satisfy me term and then still invest but give myself
- 51:29a couple of years because that would have been a tough competition going after he's not wrong about
- 51:34that but it wasn't his only option. That's my yeah. Yeah. I mean, I can't comment on the inner
- 51:41workings of his mind. I agree with you. There's probably a lot of roads that he went down but
- 51:44but he went all in here and good or bad business decision or not. It's great for the rest of us.
- 51:49The reason why it's because no other company to spend 10 billion dollars in trying to make
- 51:54extraordinary technology for virtual reality and in great software for the metaverse. They may
- 52:00fail in the software because today they haven't we haven't seen much but the hardware is great for
- 52:06the entire industry. Absolutely. Yeah. I think this is actually going to be quite the fact that they're
- 52:10putting so much cash into it where we're going to see that we're going to bear those fruits if
- 52:15even if they're going to collapse that that investment was made and someone's going to bear those
- 52:19fruits. It's kind of like similar to me where the dot com created so much hype around the internet
- 52:27a little bit too early so they started putting fiber optics in Antarctica. Yeah. And you said,
- 52:32okay, now you get internet everywhere because of the results of all that money that was put in
- 52:36and now we enjoy that. Yeah, 100%. And but speaking of the metaverse which I think is really
- 52:41interesting because just because of my like NFT 1.0 was the gambling on these images and it's
- 52:48collapsed. And at the peak about a year ago, we started hearing about the metaverse a lot and
- 52:54everyone got really excited. And the metaverse isn't new. It's like an immersive video game that's
- 52:59been playing for 20 years. But what's new is consumer behavior and these tools where the average
- 53:05consumer will now have a wallet and a digital good. And so when NFTs became popular, they're like,
- 53:11well, why don't we have a more immersive environment to view and interact with this digital good
- 53:15that I just purchased? I need to put it on a wall and showcase it, you know, if it's a piece of art.
- 53:20And so then companies like Decentraland and Sandbox, they exploded in popularity even though it's
- 53:27a very lackluster experience. It's kind of lame in there. And then Facebook does it's big.
- 53:35So then Decentraland and Sandbox, they're basically building an environment to support NFT 1.0.
- 53:42So I bought my art nice. Now I can hang it on my virtual wall, my virtual house, in my metaverse.
- 53:50But ultimately, I still think you're building a product for a problem that shouldn't even exist
- 53:54in the first place. Yeah. And it's this virtual world that people don't really, it's not all that
- 54:00great to hang out in. Now, we've all seen the movie Ready Player One. And for the listeners
- 54:04who haven't seen it, please watch it. It's great film. And it is what I believe will be the future.
- 54:10It is, you know, it's a very dystopian future. But I believe that the metaverse will be super
- 54:15immersive and people will live in it. Is that good or bad? I'm not placing judgment on two things.
- 54:20What do you think that, do I lay down the road? What do you think it's going to be a 2.0.3D for
- 54:23everybody? I think it's going to be 3D, but that could be a decade away. But all that stuff just
- 54:28doesn't matter right now. What matters right now is what is the metaverse in the next few months?
- 54:34My opinion on metaverse 1.0 and the technology and software we're pushing out there is just
- 54:40a small enhancement to websites. Why don't we go from 2D to 3D? Yeah. Why don't we go click a button,
- 54:48the website all the sudden expands? Yes. You're in there, you can talk to a sales guy,
- 54:52the merchandise is way better because now it's 3D, it spins around. And guess what? Your buddy can
- 54:57meet you there. You're like, I'm going to REI to buy a kayak, so you go to REI.com. You both
- 55:01log in at the same time, you get to walk around, look at five kayaks, talk to the sales guy,
- 55:06and then maybe there's a professional athlete in there that's one of the best kayakers in the world,
- 55:11right? And you can talk to him or watch a film of him talking about this stuff, right? It's just
- 55:16much more immersive engaging. So all it is is a simple upgrade to your website. And it's also
- 55:21an e-com buying experience problem. Exactly. Now you got your wallet and your NFTs, you can get a
- 55:27little digital kayak and put it in there. And if you click five of them, maybe you get $10 off,
- 55:31right? They gamify the experience. It becomes more engaging and more fun. So it's a much better
- 55:35buying experience. You can shoot zombies and hunt for treasure with all of your friends for the
- 55:41last 20 years on video games, right? You can run around and kill each other. But you've never
- 55:45been able to go online shopping with your friend. Now you can. That's Metaverse 1.0. You're going to
- 55:50log in and almost be like a video game and walk around the store with your buddies. And it's just a
- 55:56much more engaging immersive and ultimately valuable experience. You bother like even like
- 56:00personally investing in any Metaverse anything right now? Well, for me. So it's just for fun.
- 56:07I am not a. The land, the big hype around Metaverse, especially in Decentral and Sandbox. It
- 56:15didn't make sense to me. I kind of get it like you might as well buy a piece if it's like this
- 56:21fully built out space that you want to hang out in. And so it's like buying a website off the
- 56:25shelf that's already built. But land, I'm not sold on that in the Metaverse. But as far as how do I
- 56:30invest and get involved in Metaverse? There's a stock called Meta not Facebook, but it's Meta ball
- 56:36and it is a ETF for all the companies that are public that are involved in Metaverse technologies.
- 56:44There's a small piece of portfolio there. You know, yeah, so I just bought some of that stuff.
- 56:48This is this is where I can relate because when you tell me and you need to buy a land, but then
- 56:53Metaverse is just a website, not a website. You'll have endless websites like why would they go
- 56:58and spend so much money in Decentral and the Facebook is going to come and take over or maybe Apple.
- 57:04Decentral and it's going to be a thing and it's going to be just like FTX, right? It's going to
- 57:08disappear all the money. No one's going to care all this buying land for a million dollar right next
- 57:13to Snoop Dogg and so on. It doesn't, I don't know. It's like, it's like, you know, now you have
- 57:19a couple different projects. You can go down like anything else. I know, but I mean, at least nobody
- 57:24needs to hold them high. DeRest slightly, I find. But then the stocks that are traded in this ETF
- 57:30are like Nvidia, Nvidia and that's different. This is just publicly traded companies that provide
- 57:39the technologies for companies to build Metaverse. If I thought it would be a good place to,
- 57:43if I was going to get out of crypto a little bit, what stocks would I invest in and some stocks that
- 57:47actually will participate in the future of the Metaverse. When you build out, I'm just still curious
- 57:55about sorry, I'm going back to your actual company. When you build this out, the mechanics of building
- 58:00a company, call it whatever you want. Web 3, I don't care. We can just come up with a fake name for
- 58:05this iteration of what you're trying to build out. But the mechanics of building out a company,
- 58:10is it difficult to build out a traditional enterprise sales force, what's the revenue like,
- 58:16onboarding cost like all the metrics and KPIs you would normally look to when I'm trying to take
- 58:21a software company, B2C, B2B to market. How does that play over when you're building out something
- 58:26like this? It is, I'm sure Tam is, I don't know how you figure it out. Blue Ocean probably,
- 58:32like it's messy, it's not easy. Yeah, it's extraordinarily difficult.
- 58:37Fortunately, I have an amazing partner. Sky Tyler, maybe, this is the CEO and the real brains behind
- 58:49all of the execution of everything and a lot of the vision of what smart media technology is.
- 58:55And a long time entrepreneur himself. So yes, it's really hard to build an enterprise sales software,
- 59:02both to build the software and then build the sales team. But the real interesting nugget there is,
- 59:11since we've been pushing NFTs since in this iteration through smart media technology since the
- 59:16beginning of 2018, well before anyone was buying them at all, there's no revenue, there's no money,
- 59:22there's no profit. I know it's an issue. It is a lost leader. So we were super fortunate that
- 59:28Tyler already had an ongoing business and we kind of rolled all these companies together,
- 59:32we rolled three companies together. So I started at the time, it was called Vatum Labs with him
- 59:38and that was the pure play, NFTs for brands, right, and it was built on top of BlockVee.
- 59:45And then he had another company that was a digital, it was a digital ad agency that really supported
- 59:57outdoor lifestyle brands, but he built a full stack of technology, a good demand side ad platform
- 1:00:04and all the analytics software and everything. And then we bought a television media buying company as
- 1:00:10well. So we combined a TV media buying company, his traditional digital media company,
- 1:00:15and then this new company that was going to take NFTs to brands. Those two other companies were
- 1:00:19highly profitable. So we had the foresight and the vision to say, okay, we'll roll in a lost leader
- 1:00:26because we believe that the ad landscapes changing and we believe in this vision of, I mean there
- 1:00:32wasn't anything called Web 3 back then or even NFTs, but what we believed is that through this
- 1:00:37new technology, through smart media objects, through these smart NFTs, we could shift how brands
- 1:00:45engage with their consumers on a one-to-one level, enable brands to provide value to consumers.
- 1:00:50But it took a long time for that to take off and we didn't actually participate, even though I've
- 1:00:55been in the NFTs space since the beginning, since before the beginning, we did not participate in
- 1:01:001.0, because never in our wild... I didn't buy any board apes. I didn't buy any board apes.
- 1:01:07Never in my wildest dreams did I think that gambling was going to be the first use case,
- 1:01:11and then buying and selling all these images was going to be the first use case. But at what,
- 1:01:14as we thought, is it going to be utility like ticketing or loyalty? And ticketing still hasn't come
- 1:01:19yet, but that's more politics versus technology. The technology is there, but
- 1:01:23ticket master and lighting nation have such a monopoly. It's funny because even it's a great point
- 1:01:28because all these ideas of different NFT style projects, they were floating around way
- 1:01:34before NFTs became a thing. Look, and every time someone came up with a new, oh, this NFT
- 1:01:41can do this or that, I'm like, would you like to see my deck from five years ago?
- 1:01:45The thing is, it goes back to marketing, right? If it wasn't
- 1:01:50Logan Paul and Gary Vee promoting every day from the top of their lines NFT,
- 1:01:56most people wouldn't know what it is. Then luring in any celebrity talking very sealed on anyone
- 1:02:02goes talks about NFT and wider boring, buying board apen, just just creating all that
- 1:02:07that hype over just buying digital images instead of understanding the utility behind NFT.
- 1:02:14And to instead look, it's just a utility, but you really need to buy a computer generated image
- 1:02:19that 10,000 other ones were created equally just because other people that are celebrities are
- 1:02:25buying it, that suddenly decide to be art collectors, digital art. So it was that hype that we
- 1:02:32I guess forgot what it was all about. You started about the utility behind this and then it was
- 1:02:38kind of like forget that. Let's just buy art. It's digital this time. Yeah, it can be used by an
- 1:02:43NFT. Yeah. Yeah, it's a great point. Like the frenzy happened. People were making money,
- 1:02:49so everyone went into it. So it did a great service and disservice at the same time,
- 1:02:54the services that it brought a ton of new entrance into the crypto space because before NFTs,
- 1:03:00the only people buying crypto were people that were into finance, into stocks, into cryptos,
- 1:03:05right? Like they they were somewhat finance people. Now it's much more gamers and artists and
- 1:03:11collectors and people that don't care about finance, but want to participate. So that was a great
- 1:03:16thing it did. You know, the negative thing was a lot of people have lost a lot of money.
- 1:03:21When you when you mentioned that it was tough to take this company to market, but how is it
- 1:03:26doing now? Like is it doing is it profitable yet? Or are you? Yeah, it's doing extremely well.
- 1:03:31Okay. We're we're about to announce one of the you know largest credit card companies in the
- 1:03:38world, you know, announce a handful of partnerships with a bunch of big companies where they're going
- 1:03:43to utilize our technology platform for for for their wallet. So you're seeing shifts like you
- 1:03:50see shifts because now you have big brand names that are onboarding your tech like yeah absolutely
- 1:03:56massive shifts. Huge brands and enterprises that and even the agency holding companies that
- 1:04:02they're all diving in because they know web3s the future and how do you participate in web3 if
- 1:04:09you're an agency you have to have a wallet you have to be able to provide those services so
- 1:04:13they're using our technology and the way this gets all tied back is our technology smart media
- 1:04:18has built a massive proprietary stack, but it has built it on top of the block V protocol.
- 1:04:23So smart media still uses V our token that we issue in the ICO to power it. And so
- 1:04:31again, there's just a ton of utility in the token that we created because we're a massive company
- 1:04:36utilizing it. So you've done this obviously a few times. So I'm curious about lessons for entrepreneurs
- 1:04:42that are trying to build in the web3 space. So raising money right now I'm sure it's probably
- 1:04:46pretty hard, but what advice would you give an entrepreneur who wants to build a company from scratch?
- 1:04:50Do they raise money? Do they try and bootstrap it? Do they get a technical co-founder? What's the
- 1:04:54what's the game plan for somebody? Well back to being opportunistic. So it's an individual answer
- 1:04:58for that individual. So what is that person's experience like? So look at your close circle of
- 1:05:04influence in friends and lean in. Lean in. Is there a benefactor that's actually going to help
- 1:05:10support you? Can you support yourself for a while? What's your level of experience and expertise?
- 1:05:15How certain are you that you can make it 12 months without like going broke? So all those things
- 1:05:22weigh in on the strategy of how do you move forward? And especially in the beginning those are
- 1:05:28the most important aspects. Because any generic answer, I mean it's generic. Well build a great
- 1:05:35plan. Do your research, find money, talk to angels, go network. It's like okay, but you know you
- 1:05:39got to dig a little deeper and look at your own strengths and weaknesses and and plan to those.
- 1:05:44So I have a question so pretty much every business you had eventually you exit. You build them for
- 1:05:49exit. You do it just like you sell it just like I sold black boxes would make up in it. Well
- 1:05:55eventually I sold that business but but eventually you look at a business just like this in
- 1:05:59the same way I look at black boxes we wrap them up and we ship it. Is there going to be a point
- 1:06:05you think in your life that you're going to just keep a lifestyle business that you want to move
- 1:06:08on to your kids? Or there's always an exit strategy? Yeah I mean right now I would probably for
- 1:06:16me say more it's the exit strategy because my creative outlet the way I'm artistic is in business.
- 1:06:23Like I enjoy the deal. I enjoy seeing these new opportunities and and get excited about them.
- 1:06:30I get excited about tons of opportunities. Very few of them are worthwhile but I get excited
- 1:06:34about all of them. So that's actually what makes it fun. I get more excited about the ones that I
- 1:06:37can push even farther forward. I'm most excited about what's about to come. I'm about to launch
- 1:06:44a web 3 a handful of companies in the web 3 space that all that revolve around entertainment,
- 1:06:50media, gaming and and I'm really really excited about this next chapter because it builds upon
- 1:06:57all of the technologies that have built in the past and partners with a lot of those companies
- 1:07:02to lay the foundation to be able to take it to the next level and I believe that this next suite
- 1:07:08of companies which all announced probably in January will be one of the ways that a lot of people
- 1:07:14get to experience my definition of web 3 for the first time and my definition is simply that you
- 1:07:19have a wallet and you get digital goods in that wallet that are valuable to you and and then
- 1:07:24you have a sense of community. And so I'm really excited to actually roll that out and so
- 1:07:32your question is do I want to have a lifestyle business? I don't know. We'll see what this turns
- 1:07:35into. I feel this is this is this next chapter for me will be a really big chapter and and I could
- 1:07:42be in it for a while but it's a handful of companies. I know I will sell a number of them hopefully
- 1:07:47that they're successful and I sell them in the short term. Makes sense. Yeah. I just had one more
- 1:07:54point that I wanted to go into and I want to understand your perspective on this because it's very
- 1:07:58topical right now and I guess it's about central bank digital currencies. Yeah, CEDC. I want to
- 1:08:05understand more about those because it's a trending topic but that's technically what Tether originally
- 1:08:12did but without a central bank. So what is your opinion? There's a lot of concern about them
- 1:08:20because now you've digitized your dollars right and now the government's digitized their dollar
- 1:08:25and you're doing a test run in Japan if I'm not mistaken. So what's your opinion on those? Are those
- 1:08:30going to be a replacement for Tether for USDC? Is this something that's good bad? Well good or bad
- 1:08:38is in the eye of the beholder for the government's best thing that's ever happened. For the citizen
- 1:08:43it's potentially one of the worst things that's ever happened especially for citizens in countries
- 1:08:47like China and countries where the government really exerts its power doesn't care about the
- 1:08:53the citizen so much. The reason it's so bad for them is because it it provides technology for the
- 1:09:00perfect surveillance state right because with a CEDC with a digital dollar with a dollar that's
- 1:09:07on a type of blockchain the government will know every penny of every dollar you spent and where
- 1:09:14you spent it and can track it perfectly on an individual basis and can program that money because
- 1:09:20you've all heard that Bitcoin is programmable money a CEDC can be programmable money. Guess what the
- 1:09:25first thing they're going to program is well I'm going to take 30% of every transaction for my taxes
- 1:09:30right off the top right so the reason why people are concerned is because the technology is there
- 1:09:38for the government to do extraordinarily intrusive things to its citizens with this technology
- 1:09:46were somewhat protected in the United States more than a lot of these other countries
- 1:09:50and the reason why I wouldn't be so concerned is a U.S. citizen of a CEDC in Fringian
- 1:09:56Prongian privacy the best analogy an example is just surf the internet you now have to click allow
- 1:10:03cookies on every single website right you get a warning and pop up everywhere you go and that's
- 1:10:08just to get permission to track anonymous web surfing data not where you spend every penny of
- 1:10:14every dollar right so think about the level of bureaucracy and legalities that the government
- 1:10:20would have to do to be able to successfully do that in the U.S. so I'm not so concerned about it
- 1:10:24but they do they will have the tools to do it it's a bigger concern in other countries because
- 1:10:30that's like if I if I just you know I wrote down a whole bunch of like trending crypto web 3 topics
- 1:10:35I mean we've already spoken about FTX to death with other people before so we don't have to
- 1:10:39belabor that point again it's like it's all it's in the news like unless there's something
- 1:10:43revolution there that you want to speak about but CBDC is one thing that's obviously very top of
- 1:10:47mine for people I'll throw it to you is there any other things that are circulating in crypto
- 1:10:53web 3d5 that are just trending things that people should know about your opinion on it that I'm
- 1:10:58probably not smart enough to research well you know the the thing I since you asked and since you
- 1:11:04did mention FTX and block fire and and you know this crypto crash is much more significant than any
- 1:11:11to date because in the past all the crypto crashes were simply because people were getting out of
- 1:11:15Bitcoin they're like something's going on I'm selling Bitcoin or I'm selling my crypto I'm
- 1:11:20selling the sidelines that's not what happened here this is a new industry d5 decentralized finance
- 1:11:27all these exotic financial products built on blockchains so all these centralized companies now using
- 1:11:32blockchain technology to offer financial products to their users was created over the last two years
- 1:11:37and it exploded in value and what's taken place is these centralized companies on top of decentralized
- 1:11:43technology are failing and so this is systemic failure of a new industry that's on top of blockchain
- 1:11:49that's what's caused this crash it started with Terra Luna so the failure of it experiment of an
- 1:11:55experiment of an algorithmic stablecoin and that had a cascading effect because like block fire
- 1:12:01had a lot of exposure and they had a lot of exposure to three arrows and two FTX and now block
- 1:12:08fire is finally in bankruptcy and block fire actually was run by some fairly sophisticated operators
- 1:12:13and they're to it right now it doesn't appear that there was any fraud or anything there is just
- 1:12:18some some bad decisions but they got swept up in this and there's a lot of companies that are going
- 1:12:23bankrupt in this space causing this massive crash were experiencing it is not also because the
- 1:12:29market just went down and traders or traders and the mostly doer traders but the market went down
- 1:12:36but that's not what necessarily caused the the whole crash of the market went down and it's
- 1:12:42well well Terra Luna was a big part of it and then fraud was it was a big part of it mismanagement.
- 1:12:48Absolutely it was bad but I mean the market started declining and on the same day the same
- 1:12:53minute the same second so was the crypto market right so if we if we take the point or the
- 1:12:59bear market start I would say it's the day where Netflix reported their earning the bitter earning
- 1:13:05but because of one word that their CFO said it they lost 20% and at the time I think they're
- 1:13:10200 billion dollar market cup and for that reason at the same second so did the the crypto market
- 1:13:17right so it went down with the stock market and then obviously those didn't have right
- 1:13:22right so it had this cascading effect but what I was sharing is it's not just people selling crypto
- 1:13:27which is causing this massive decline it's these companies in DeFi failing but what I wanted to
- 1:13:33bring up and leave the audience with don't blame DeFi right DeFi is an amazing advancement in kind
- 1:13:42of this ecosystem in the technology that the the the financial services that these decentralized
- 1:13:48financial companies are going to start creating and delivering really will transform how people
- 1:13:56do banking it will create much more global inclusion for people to use financial services for
- 1:14:02people that don't have access to good financial services now they will so let's call it DeFi 1.0
- 1:14:09it just had its spectacular inclusion but DeFi 2.0 all those things will be improved upon
- 1:14:15and ideally they'll offer better safer products in the future because look at the banking look
- 1:14:20at traditional finance banks and they're still massive meltdowns in the most highly regulated
- 1:14:26industries so you can't just blame it on crypto so I do want to make sure that people don't think
- 1:14:31that DeFi is dead and that these financial products are dead just because some companies failed
- 1:14:36do you think how long do you think it's going to take to restore confidence for the average
- 1:14:40maybe see non industry person yeah it might be a little while but this is the beauty at least of
- 1:14:48my focus yes which is a non-financial kind of blockchain based businesses a lot of web 3s
- 1:14:54stuff juicy trickle over but there's a lot of a triple go like without all the financial stuff we
- 1:15:00wouldn't have had the idea of cryptocurrencies and wallets and then it turned into NFTs which
- 1:15:04brought in other people and now it's turned into web 3 which is bringing in the brands and that
- 1:15:09they can use all this technology to better engage with their consumers and then throughout this next
- 1:15:15year I think that what's going to drive the next big bull run will be recognizable web 3 projects
- 1:15:23that have actually delivered on the promise and then people will start believing again and pouring
- 1:15:28more money in the next five I don't know do you think in next five ten years we're going to start
- 1:15:33seeing young people start buying again with with ease and each other with each five or ten months
- 1:15:40or years no no years years I think in months well so right now the trade around crypto is decline right
- 1:15:47because majorities are investors but then when will come the time where a lot of the trader know
- 1:15:54if I want to say the majority or not but but just say a lot for a percentage of the trade is going
- 1:16:00to be around just day-to-day transactions yeah retail some I'm paying you to do to cut my my
- 1:16:07grass or something like this this way you don't pay taxes a lot of people were doing it already
- 1:16:12and and it's gonna it's gonna start coming back right now they don't want to touch it because it's
- 1:16:16too volatile but how when do you think it's gonna be stable in terms of volatility when they'll use
- 1:16:22a stable coin for that like okay big coin isn't meant to replace cash right it is too volatile all
- 1:16:28these cryptocurrencies are too volatile anything that you know you need a stable coin and and what's
- 1:16:33gonna happen is there will be CBDC so while I said people should be scared of the amount of control
- 1:16:39that a CBC can offer it will also offer a ton of benefits and the ease of use you'll be able to
- 1:16:44send money globally instantly and for free you know and so CBDCs will have a huge use as well
- 1:16:51but there is a lot of concern for them and so something like what you're saying is when are they
- 1:16:55going to use kind of cryptos they'll probably use this a digital dollar so you're saying you're saying
- 1:17:00they're not gonna use ease they're probably gonna use stator or some stable coin this way they
- 1:17:04don't have to worry about volatility unless eventually it became stable because that's also the
- 1:17:10by the way people are already doing that like USDC but not enough as a volume no no no most of it was
- 1:17:16if you were if you were to buy an NFT or anything it was all east because it was the only option at
- 1:17:21the time yes that's why the layer 2s exploded in popularity because it was too slow and too
- 1:17:26expensive so yeah cardan and solana and polka dot and everyone else and and polygon you know
- 1:17:31came out yeah no I just find it fascinating like building in this basis so it's like it's
- 1:17:37tumultuous but it's exciting but that's not disruptive right some massive roller coaster it is
- 1:17:42okay um where do you want to leave the audience with um final thoughts on the industry and then
- 1:17:47also working they like reach out to you check out all this after working on yeah now you can find
- 1:17:52me on instagram and twitter and linked in at rive underscore callons on twitter at rive callons on
- 1:17:58everywhere else um but my final thoughts are look we all experienced a lot of pain right like
- 1:18:06especially in the crypto space this last uh six months and it's really sad but it doesn't take
- 1:18:11away from the the massive potential of the technology and for where we're going so just you know
- 1:18:19when people say NFTs are dead and the metaverse is dead and defies that and bitcoins that
- 1:18:24is just it's just not true so the quote I will leave everyone with is a quote by victor Hugo
- 1:18:29and it says that the only thing stronger than all of the armies in the world is an idea whose time
- 1:18:35has come so when you think about that what bitcoin is it's a new type of money and this is the
- 1:18:43first time in history that anyone other than kings and governments could create not only their own
- 1:18:48money but their own monetary system this was never possible before and so that quote is so
- 1:18:55so perfect for for for this industry because this is the most coveted things that governments
- 1:19:01protect and all the armies in the world will fight to protect their their money but guess what
- 1:19:06now the average user now the citizens have the ability to build their own money and their own
- 1:19:11monetary systems and that's what's happening that's why cryptocurrency is so important I love it
- 1:19:16thank you man yeah absolutely thank you yeah pleasure my pleasure