Latest / Credit Union Exam Solutions Presents With Flying Colors / NCUA's Annual Report Highlights with Mike Macchiarola of Olden Lane
Transcript
- 0:03Do you want to maximize your success with NCUA?
- 0:06Join Mark Treichel as he shares with you the insider's view on passing
- 0:09your exam with Flying Colors.
- 0:12The With Flying Colors podcast is sponsored by Credit Union
- 0:15Exam Solutions by Mark Treichel.
- 0:17If you would like to work directly with the Credit Union Exam Solutions
- 0:20team and receive support to optimize your results with NCUA so you save time
- 0:25and money, visit us at marktreichel.
- 0:27com to find out more.
- 0:35Treichel: Hey everyone.
- 0:35This is Mark Treichel with another episode of With Flying Colors.
- 0:39I'm excited to have Mike Macchiarola from Olden Lane here today.
- 0:43Mike, how you doing?
- 0:45Mike Mac: Doing well, Mark.
- 0:45Good to be with you.
- 0:46Treichel: Yeah, glad, last year we, we had our first annual
- 0:50podcast on NCUA's annual report.
- 0:52There's a lot of annuals in there, but this is number two.
- 0:55You and I saw on LinkedIn that that you had done an article on this and
- 1:00I thought, Hey, that'd be great to do our follow up on NCUA's annual report.
- 1:03But before we get into that, why don't you describe what it is you
- 1:08and Olden Lane do for credit unions?
- 1:12Perfect.
- 1:13Mike Mac: And thanks for having me on Mark.
- 1:14Olden Lane is very technically a registered investment
- 1:18advisor and a broker dealer.
- 1:20We're also a credit union service organization.
- 1:24It's made up of a group now, 10 or 11 deep of financial professionals.
- 1:29We got together about 5 years ago or so, a little longer than that now.
- 1:34And we realized that the credit union industry was being underserved in certain
- 1:39pockets most notably in some of the delivery of capital markets expertise.
- 1:44So we set out to do a number of things through our broker dealer and our RIA.
- 1:48We've Been most notable, I would guess in our contribution to the
- 1:53subordinated debt market of the transactions that have happened.
- 1:57Olden Lane has had a pronounced role.
- 1:59We've been involved in that business all the way back to its
- 2:04early days as secondary capital.
- 2:06When we got in that business, it was about a 200Million dollar market.
- 2:10Now it's touching 4Billion.
- 2:13Olden Lane has played a significant role in helping lots of credit unions
- 2:17across the country, large and small and use sub debt for growth, for
- 2:21acquisition related growth and to repair a hiccup on the balance sheet.
- 2:26If that happens from time to time we continue to be in that business.
- 2:30More recently, we've been playing a lot in the M and a business.
- 2:34We can do anything in that area from.
- 2:37Identify targets screen for targets in particular geographies
- 2:42or across asset classes.
- 2:44And then we can advise, we can work on the negotiation between parties.
- 2:49We can do M and A between banks and credit unions and between
- 2:52credit unions and credit unions.
- 2:54We can do the valuation suite.
- 2:56We can do the negotiations and we can help in any way on
- 3:01that whole suite of services.
- 3:02That's important, and that's somewhat new to us but we think as we'll get
- 3:06into, I'm sure, in a little bit, we think that's going to be ripe for a lot of
- 3:09activity in the coming months and years.
- 3:12Treichel: Yeah, I think you're right.
- 3:13I think that's definitely going to be A lot of that going on here
- 3:17based on, what I'm seeing and what's happening in the economy etc.
- 3:20With that, let's Let's pivot to NCUA's 2023 annual report.
- 3:26I know you have several thoughts on some of the themes that you saw
- 3:30there, but I'm just going to, I'm just going to kick it over to you, Mike.
- 3:33And let's say, so what, in summary, what do you have to say about it?
- 3:37And, or, what was your first takeaway?
- 3:40Mike Mac: Okay, first of all I always look at it as a picture.
- 3:44I'm a, I'm not a good one, but a struggling artist.
- 3:46So from its artistry and its presentation and the way it's laid out.
- 3:52We give it an A or an a plus.
- 3:53And that's not surprising.
- 3:55That has been the theme consistently from the agency.
- 3:58They've won a few awards in recent years for the way it lays it out.
- 4:02That's good because honestly, it should be accessible for the industry and the
- 4:06professionals that are in the industry.
- 4:08It should be a document that the NCA is proud of because at
- 4:11the end of the day, it's really a summary of what they've done.
- 4:14But we're most interested in it here.
- 4:17Because we can glean from it and read between the lines and see
- 4:22what lens the agency seems to be looking at things through.
- 4:25And that's where, of course, it's most interesting to us because we try to pivot
- 4:30in the proper directions and respond to where we think the agency is going and to
- 4:35help advise our clients as to what we see as potential things coming down the line.
- 4:41All right.
- 4:41I would say in that regard, I think 1st and foremost.
- 4:46The biggest observation I would have is that the agency.
- 4:49Is very concerned about the macroeconomic environment.
- 4:52That is the biggest thing that I would take away from the presentation.
- 4:58Treichel: Yeah, and that's consistent.
- 5:00It seems to be a general theme.
- 5:01When NC way talks about.
- 5:04The state of the insurance fund, which happens quarterly, and I talk
- 5:07about that a little bit here and it's another document that I like to refer
- 5:11to when they do their power point on the condition of the insurance fund.
- 5:15They also include really the only public snapshot of where camel codes
- 5:20are and it's when they do that.
- 5:22I think at the last 1, they did, they said that camel code 3 dollars
- 5:26insured share said tripled in 2023.
- 5:29And then each of the board member talks about and particularly Chairman Harper
- 5:33will speak to the fact that he's worried about, is it going to be a soft landing?
- 5:37Is it not going to be a soft landing?
- 5:39Is it going to be a recession?
- 5:41You're hearing about commercial loans ballooning and empty office
- 5:44space and people working from home and how's that going to impact?
- 5:48Real estate.
- 5:49How's that going to impact credit unions?
- 5:51And they're they're definitely sending signals in many different ways.
- 5:55And they also talk about it quite a bit here in, in this in this annual report.
- 6:02Mike Mac: We watched that, that camel's code report, the NCUSIF financial
- 6:06statistics report pretty religiously.
- 6:08Now, I think I stole that habit from you.
- 6:11So thank you for that.
- 6:13I would point out last quarter, as you said, We've now got 19.
- 6:185 percent of credit unions by count are now in a three, four or five camel code.
- 6:24That's significant.
- 6:25As you said, the trend is higher.
- 6:27Almost 8 percent of the industry's assets now reside in a three,
- 6:31four or five coded institution.
- 6:34And those with more than 500 million in assets we've seen eight
- 6:39institutions and more than 20 billion in assets move into that camel
- 6:44three over the last quarter alone.
- 6:46So those are things that we watch and you're exactly right.
- 6:50The other thing I would say is that the trends are not your friend.
- 6:54We point out that there are trends in everything from cost of
- 6:57funds to delinquencies and charge offs to ROA, to OPEX that are
- 7:03trending against getting better.
- 7:06So if you look at cost of funds, for example, this is pronounced,
- 7:10and this has been the stress.
- 7:11We can call it whatever we want.
- 7:12Interest rate risk cost of funds stress.
- 7:15Here we see an industry that averaged 1.
- 7:1958 percent cost of funds in the latest quarter.
- 7:22That's not by itself so troubling.
- 7:25What's more troubling is that is a full 1 percentage point
- 7:29higher than Q4 a year ago.
- 7:32So two thirds of your cost of funds is new in the latest year
- 7:38at the average credit union.
- 7:40That is extraordinary and it's not surprising because we saw this interest
- 7:45rate hike and we saw it move with a certain rapidity and a certain
- 7:49violence that we've never seen before.
- 7:52On top of that, it comes from what we've all known was the most
- 7:55benign interest rate environment we had probably in history.
- 7:59Delinquencies is another thing we watch closest closely delinquencies
- 8:02at 83 basis points in Q4.
- 8:05That's double the bottom tick in the beginning of 2022 net charge offs 77 basis
- 8:13points in Q4 up steadily from when it low ticked in 2021 when money was abundant.
- 8:21What I saw this morning on the delinquency front on the charger front, actually
- 8:26discover credit card just reported, right?
- 8:315.
- 8:327 percent charge offering.
- 8:34You have to go all the way back to 2011 in the height of the great financial
- 8:39crisis to find that same level as concerning 256 basis points of that
- 8:46charge off level is new from a year ago.
- 8:51Those are not good trends.
- 8:54Industry wide are away 69 basis points.
- 8:58The industry was regularly hitting better than 1 percent through all
- 9:02of 2021 and has now been steadily declining since the end of 2020.
- 9:09OPEX is 2.
- 9:1195 percent and has been climbing steadily since the beginning of 2022.
- 9:15Employment related expenses are now 51 percent of what's going on at your
- 9:19credit union and those very often are the hardest to unencumber yourself.
- 9:24So it's Difficult.
- 9:26Now it is likely to persist.
- 9:28We do not think these stresses are going to abate.
- 9:32And then I would say overall, the largest concern is that we do not have a good
- 9:39picture of the macroeconomic environment.
- 9:42Yield curve remains inverted.
- 9:45We are now past 650 days of an inverted yield curve.
- 9:50That is the longest inverted yield curve in the history of the United States.
- 9:54And we are in a business.
- 9:57Which takes deposits at the short end and lends them long in an
- 10:02inverted yield curve environment that is foundationally impossible.
- 10:07So we've got tough sailing here.
- 10:10We've got choppy waters.
- 10:12Now we have to figure out how to navigate it.
- 10:14And it is appropriate for the agency to point this out in the annual report,
- 10:19the way they did respectfully, but they're signaling that it's tough.
- 10:24Treichel: As you're saying all those and again, my head always goes back to camel.
- 10:28I think it's probably six or eight quarters straight that
- 10:31the camel data has gotten worse.
- 10:34But if you go back to 0809 2010 2011, it was the bad numbers back then.
- 10:42Camel wise, we haven't come close to hitting, right?
- 10:44So when you go through and rattle off all those trends, I think the only positive
- 10:51trends statistically might be yield.
- 10:53Because loans are pricing higher and investments are pricing higher, but.
- 10:58Operating expenses going up because of inflation, cost of funds going up, charge
- 11:02offs going up, delinquency going up.
- 11:05It it ties into that, that M and a activity which could increase.
- 11:09And, one of the things I'm seeing is the pressure.
- 11:14Those credit unions who might have already got sub debt or had above average capital,
- 11:19let's say they're 12 percent capital and they have another 2 percent of sub debt.
- 11:22So they're 14%.
- 11:23Those are the credit unions that are going to be out there.
- 11:28Being able to take on merger candidates.
- 11:30You have others who thought they were fine with maybe eight and a half percent
- 11:35and well capitalized, didn't take the opportunity of the sip, or maybe didn't
- 11:40seize sub debt when rates were low, and now they're starting to get, bitten at
- 11:44the ankles by all this other statistics.
- 11:46So it's it's going to be an interesting.
- 11:492024 for sure.
- 11:51And that's what NCUA is really pointing out here.
- 11:54So yeah, great points.
- 11:55Anything that I said there that you want to comment on or you're
- 11:58ready to go to number two?
- 12:00Mike Mac: I can go to number two, but I would say something on sub debt.
- 12:02It is incredible that we're looking at today.
- 12:07Some of the largest sub debt offerings that went off only a couple of years ago,
- 12:11went off in the threes, fours or fives.
- 12:14And honestly, that's the cost of funding today.
- 12:18So you've got folks that have big pieces of sub debt to your point.
- 12:22That are inside where they would do the marginal funding trade today, which is
- 12:26just an amazing and it goes to number one.
- 12:29Those people were smart to do that.
- 12:31And in hindsight, we're all, we'd all be a lot smarter and we all should realize
- 12:35there was a sort of asymmetric risk to raising capital when interest rates were
- 12:39as low as they were historically but.
- 12:42I do think you're right.
- 12:43Those that are capital rich are going to be in a good position to be picking here.
- 12:48I will say though, I wouldn't hurry into risk.
- 12:51I had a credit union the other day very smart CEO.
- 12:55She's great.
- 12:55And she said, I am not in an asset arms race.
- 12:59And she said, it is not risky to stand Pat here as others on a
- 13:04relative basis don't perform as well.
- 13:06Very interesting.
- 13:07I thought that was pretty insightful.
- 13:09Treichel: Yeah, very much looking at the article that you did I think you had the
- 13:13next bullet you had in your article was a creeping emphasis on consumer protection.
- 13:18I like the word creeping that you, in a lot of ways that you use there, but
- 13:22what are your thoughts relative to that?
- 13:24Mike Mac: Look, I think this is somewhat driven by the NCUA and the
- 13:28internal changes that have happened there on the board composition.
- 13:33I think it's also in line with what we're seeing across a larger swath
- 13:40of sort of regulation and industry.
- 13:43People don't like overdraft.
- 13:45They don't like fees on non sufficient funds.
- 13:48We can argue about what they are or what they mean.
- 13:52Yes, some have abused them, but in many instances, they are part
- 13:55of a responsible business model.
- 13:58I would argue that as a general matter in the credit union space credit unions
- 14:02in particular are not abusers of fees.
- 14:06Our whole industry is built on going the other way there.
- 14:10But We're all going to be susceptible to a regime for the foreseeable future that is
- 14:16hyper focused on ringing a lot of this out for the benefit of consumer protection.
- 14:22What this means is certain credit unions that have this as a substantial piece of
- 14:26their business are going to have to pivot.
- 14:29And the problem is that it is a very difficult environment
- 14:33in which to replace revenue.
- 14:34We just went through all of the trends which are you against you.
- 14:38And now you're being told to substantially in many cases, pivot
- 14:43from a business that has been tried and true over a number of years.
- 14:47One of the more interesting thing is the CFPB's most recent proposed rule.
- 14:52I can't fully get my arms around it because what it does
- 14:56is it proposes to prohibit.
- 15:01banks and credit unions, among others, from charging a fee where
- 15:07there's an instant instantaneous or near instantaneous decline based
- 15:13on your balance in your account.
- 15:15That very rarely happens.
- 15:18Yes, your debit account can come up short as you swipe it at a cash register,
- 15:23but there's generally not a fee there.
- 15:26The fees in large measure are A.
- 15:28C.
- 15:28H.
- 15:28Related fees, and they come later.
- 15:30They're nowhere near instantaneous.
- 15:32They're part of a clearing fee and they wouldn't be
- 15:35captured by this proposed rule.
- 15:36So it's curious where the CFPB is going with that proposal, but it
- 15:41does highlight, at least for me, the intensity under which all of these
- 15:47fees are going to remain for some time.
- 15:49So we're seeing a lot of credit unions to their credit, abandon
- 15:52them but again, it puts substantial train, a strain on what they're doing
- 15:56from just an economic standpoint.
- 15:59Treichel: Yeah, and I commented this on one of my more recent.
- 16:04Episodes.
- 16:04But chairman Harper talked about how two of the three largest banks have
- 16:08said, no NSFs, no overdraft fees.
- 16:11We're not going to do them.
- 16:12And then trickle down effect on, on if they're going to do it,
- 16:15everybody else has to say that they're going to go away from it.
- 16:17But the reality is those three biggest institutions, they're going
- 16:20to be here 300 years from now, right?
- 16:22So they're like the Amazons.
- 16:24They have the ability to get rid of those fees and ride out the storm.
- 16:29Then you've got other institutions that are, hearing NCOA say that that fee income
- 16:34is a new type of concentration risk, which I think it's a new type of concentration
- 16:39risk because of what they're doing.
- 16:41NCOA is making it a concentration risk by deeming it such.
- 16:45So what are they going to do?
- 16:45Okay, I'll get rid of my fees.
- 16:47And then, as you said, at the same time as your delinquency is going
- 16:50up, your charge offs are going Down and then you're, you're, I don't
- 16:53know, pick a number, 100 million, 200 million, and the CEO wants to retire.
- 16:58And you're looking for someone who's going to balance all these things when
- 17:01it's in, getting harder and harder every day to do so I think it's, I
- 17:05think it's here to stay for a while.
- 17:07The focus on fees, just particularly because as you said, the makeup of the
- 17:11board but it's going to drive up it's going to drive up mergers and make
- 17:14profitability and everything else.
- 17:16More challenging going forward and just, and as you said, just at
- 17:19the wrong time when there's other issues that NCA has to deal with and
- 17:23credit unions have to deal with it.
- 17:24And I get it from an NCA perspective.
- 17:27There's finally two, two Democratic board members, and
- 17:30it's a democratic led initiative all the way from the White House.
- 17:34Therefore, they have to seize the opportunity, but it's really
- 17:36not well timed for credit unions.
- 17:40Mike Mac: Yep.
- 17:40A couple other things I would add.
- 17:41Number one is I just hate the word junk fees.
- 17:43I think it's a misnomer.
- 17:44I think it's inappropriate.
- 17:46I think it's overly hostile to what this is.
- 17:50Number two is when you compare the largest banking institutions to
- 17:54your typical credit union, what everyone leaves out of that story
- 17:58is the subsidy for too big to fail.
- 18:00Those guys can raise capital, raise deposits much cheaper
- 18:04than the smaller institutions.
- 18:06And no one has done anything to address the fact that subsidy from the federal
- 18:10government exists and I'm one of these guys that's old enough to remember
- 18:14the whole point of what we were doing after the great financial crisis was
- 18:18to take that risk and move it out of a concentrated group of institutions.
- 18:23That's an epic failure.
- 18:24Someone needs to write that story and tell it out loud.
- 18:27And what's happening is, unless and until it's done, it's going to be a disaster.
- 18:31We get honest about the fact that the smaller credit unions are the ecosystem
- 18:36by which we move capital into the smaller communities throughout this country.
- 18:42And that ecosystem has been built up over 100 years or 90 plus years of a
- 18:47federal credit union act in our case.
- 18:50We have to start valuing that because the small bar owner or the small
- 18:55restaurant owner in the rural America or urban center is not necessarily covered
- 19:01by the largest banking institutions, and nor do they want to cover him.
- 19:05So he or her need to rely on this credit union network, the community bank network
- 19:11to find that capital to find those loans to find that really big capital.
- 19:16That banking institution that cares down at his or her level.
- 19:20And we've got to value that.
- 19:21We have to understand that's absolutely important to them as a
- 19:25mechanism throughout this country.
- 19:27Treichel: Very well said, and I think it's being forgotten right now.
- 19:29Excellent point.
- 19:31So another theme I see you picked up on in, in the current 2023 annual
- 19:37report is once again, NCOA speaks to third party service providers.
- 19:41Any color you can provide to what you picked up there?
- 19:46Mike Mac: Yep.
- 19:46Some of this I get from the report and some of this I get
- 19:48from some recent conversations.
- 19:50I've done some in the field work here, Mark.
- 19:53Treichel: Very good.
- 19:53Mike Mac: You're not my only NCUA insider.
- 19:56Perfect.
- 19:58So insiders assure me that this is unlikely to happen.
- 20:02And there is enough resist from what I've heard from a lot of different corners
- 20:07that this should not or will not have.
- 20:09This is something that they've harped on for a while that they'd
- 20:12love to get their tentacles.
- 20:14The agency would love to get their tentacles into some of the QSOs and get
- 20:18more than a sort of perfunctory filing.
- 20:21They want to have some oversight over those QSOs here.
- 20:25It's interesting, right?
- 20:26So many QSOs already have a regulator.
- 20:29So take Olden Lane, for example.
- 20:31We're among the most regulated institutions you could ever have, right?
- 20:34I've got the SEC, I've got the NFA and the CFTC, and I've got FINRA.
- 20:40All review me regularly.
- 20:42I'm subject to exams.
- 20:44And those folks know our business quite well, right?
- 20:48The folks at FINRA, the folks at the SEC, when they do an exam, they
- 20:51know exactly what they're To look for and understand our business.
- 20:55So I don't know in our case, for example, what the NCUA would lend other than
- 20:59inconvenience for us and cost for them.
- 21:02I suspect this is a little bit budget creep.
- 21:04I think it's a little bit, in fairness, I get where the agency's coming from,
- 21:08because there are certain things that have happened been caused by or
- 21:12driven by what's happened at a QSO.
- 21:14There have been some high profile events tied to information or
- 21:18data loss that are QSO related.
- 21:21So I think there might be a middle ground here.
- 21:24I think if we start talking about sharing information or personal identifiable
- 21:30information of customers and members, I think that may be subject to higher
- 21:34scrutiny that may get a little bit of a different regime where the N.
- 21:38C.
- 21:38U.
- 21:39A.
- 21:39can get some additional oversight, but I think in the normal course.
- 21:44Other than budget creep.
- 21:45And frankly, I think when the NCUA looks a little harder, they're going to realize
- 21:49some of these industries, they don't want to be in, they don't have the expertise
- 21:53and there's already an existing regulator.
- 21:56So I think some of this is real.
- 21:58But some of it is overplayed and I think we're unlikely other than
- 22:01really in data to see much movement,
- 22:05Treichel: It's two things jump into my mind when I maybe two or three things.
- 22:09The It's the dog chasing the ice cream truck.
- 22:12You, you caught the truck.
- 22:13Now, what are you going to do with it?
- 22:14And I worry about that.
- 22:16I really worry about that because the NCOA everybody's having a challenge being fully
- 22:20staffed, but you take on a new arena where you don't have expertise, how's that going
- 22:24to go and how are you going to do it?
- 22:26And are you going to rob from Peter to pay Paul?
- 22:28And then when I was at NCOA, one of the thoughts, that I had when Congress
- 22:34would say, Hey, what authorities don't you have that you should have, right?
- 22:39You have to tell them that FDIC has third party service provider authority.
- 22:44You have to point it out and you have to say, yeah, in a perfect world, we
- 22:46should have that because if something blows up and you didn't ask for it.
- 22:52They're going to say why didn't you tell us you needed this authority?
- 22:55So they will ask for it forever.
- 22:59When I was there, I asked for it and I hoped I didn't get it because there
- 23:03was no way I could do it without either pretending I was doing it or
- 23:08jacking the budget up so much that, it created a burden for credit unions.
- 23:13Yeah, it'll be there.
- 23:14It'll be in the annual report.
- 23:15It'll be in every request for Congress.
- 23:18And then, every once in a while, when one really bad cyber thing happens, I
- 23:22start to think, you know what, maybe NCUA should have this authority.
- 23:26And then I kind of drift back to the dog in the ice cream truck.
- 23:30Mike Mac: It's funny.
- 23:30They've got it indirectly now in the cyber world, or they, what they've done.
- 23:35Union through the latest cyber release, right?
- 23:38You've got to do your own vendor diligence, but you'd have to do anyway.
- 23:42But I think, honestly, I think that's your insights are perfect.
- 23:46What happens is if I catch this, I've screamed truck cause
- 23:48then I don't know what to do.
- 23:50I think that's perfect.
- 23:52Treichel: So yeah, we'll see where we're next year we'll talk about their
- 23:56need to have third party due diligence.
- 23:58Mike Mac: Yeah.
- 23:58We'll put it on next year's list.
- 24:02Treichel: And a big part of, we've talked a little bit about sub debt, you guys
- 24:04do a lot in the sub debt arena and.
- 24:07The ability to do that comes from low income designated credit unions.
- 24:11Any thoughts or takeaways relative to that and the report the annual
- 24:16report and, or just in general.
- 24:19Mike Mac: I think the LICU piece of the annual report will be there every year.
- 24:22I think we can talk about it almost the same way every year.
- 24:26Like who, as you mentioned, brings you several pieces of regulatory relief.
- 24:30It gives you a lift on your member business loan cap.
- 24:36It gives you the ability to take non member deposits from any source
- 24:40instead of just from other credit unions or from municipalities.
- 24:43It allows you the case of subordinated debt to raise that subordinated
- 24:48debt, but to count it towards your PCA net worth, as and then it allows
- 24:52you access from time to community development revolving loan fund grants.
- 24:57And I believe there's a window open right now for some of that money.
- 25:01Those regulatory relief, those 4 forms of regulatory relief can be important.
- 25:07I think the best, most important in most cases is really either the member
- 25:10business loan lift or the sub debt that you get in PCA net worth but we're going
- 25:16to see people increasingly try to get to who status those numbers have been
- 25:20creeping up steadily over the years.
- 25:22It's basically 50, 50 in terms of assets at this point non
- 25:26who, and who is about a 1.
- 25:281 trillion of each.
- 25:30And there are a few more who's than non who's about 54 percent of the industry
- 25:34is now low income credit unions.
- 25:36Again, to get that status, you've got to basically meet certain thresholds
- 25:40in terms of who your membership is.
- 25:42We can help with that.
- 25:43There are several others that do that as well.
- 25:45But I think it's something that people will continue to seek
- 25:48either through strategic merger.
- 25:50Or optimizing their membership.
- 25:53The other thing I would say in that regard is anecdotally we're definitely seeing
- 25:58evidence that the NCUA is enforcing this.
- 26:01So long long respected LICUs will continue to be examined on this number.
- 26:07And if they fall below it they will be sent a letter
- 26:10from the NCUA to that effect.
- 26:13The way the reg works, I think it's 7 0 1 34.
- 26:16Under that regulation you can act if you lose your status, if the NCA says
- 26:21you, you're longer a ku, you can act as if you are a KU for five years.
- 26:26You have a period of up to five years to cure that status and
- 26:30get that, that letter back from the NCUA that you have done that.
- 26:34So not much to say other than it's gonna be here, and it's gonna be
- 26:36something that people increasingly seek.
- 26:39Treichel: Yeah, a couple of thoughts.
- 26:40So I was chatting with the credit union recently who just got one
- 26:43of those letters and has their 5 year clock that has just begun.
- 26:48And I think if I'm not mistaken, somewhere along along the way, N.
- 26:54C.
- 26:54U.
- 26:54A.
- 26:54had a proposal that would allow once a you always a like you with the concept being
- 27:00if you're so successful in your community.
- 27:04At the low income.
- 27:06Percentage is resolved for lack of another, you have so much success
- 27:12that there's so many people who move from low income to middle income.
- 27:16Is it do you really want to penalize them for being an institution at?
- 27:21As in whose collective membership has improved.
- 27:24Now that would take an act of Congress which would be like getting an act
- 27:28of Congress, so will it happen?
- 27:30Will it happen?
- 27:31I don't know, but it's a great theory.
- 27:33Mike Mac: There's two people that have told that to me.
- 27:34I used to refer to that as the Mike Kochman theory and Mike sits next to me
- 27:39here in the office because he's always been a staunch defender of that position.
- 27:43And then I believe that position is the same position that I heard repeated to
- 27:46me by a former board member Rodney Hood.
- 27:49Treichel: I think you're right.
- 27:51I think you're right.
- 27:52Mike Mac: If that's right, Mike's in pretty good company because I hold
- 27:55Rodney in some pretty high rare air.
- 27:57Treichel: You got it.
- 27:58And since you mentioned former NCOA chairman Rodney Hood,
- 28:00he was a recent guest on.
- 28:03On the podcast and to the listeners, if you missed that
- 28:06episode, I recommend I recommend you go back and give it a listen.
- 28:10And Mike, if you haven't listened to that one, go back and give it a listen.
- 28:14It's Rodney was chock full of wisdom in that one as usual.
- 28:19So we've talked at different stages of this conversation.
- 28:23We've talked about consolidation.
- 28:25Anything else we need to hammer home on consolidations and mergers.
- 28:30Couple of things here.
- 28:32Mike Mac: I now begin most of my conversations with folks on this topic
- 28:38with something to the effect of welcome to the opening ceremonies of the M.
- 28:42N.
- 28:43A.
- 28:43Olympics.
- 28:44Because I really think that's where we are.
- 28:46I think if this was a baseball game, we'd still be in batting practice
- 28:50and we've seen some movement here.
- 28:52What's very interesting if you look at the numbers and it's going to be
- 28:55the same, both on the bank acquisition side and on the credit union for credit
- 28:59union side, you have a trend line that begins in 2019 and is trending upward
- 29:06in terms of deal volume by dollar and by number turns sharply lower in 2023.
- 29:14It almost evaporates and then it starts to pick up again.
- 29:18We've had some pretty good activity in both of those fronts in 2024
- 29:22and folks say why did this happen?
- 29:23Is this a trend or what happened?
- 29:26If you remember 2023, nothing external is going to happen in 2023 because we're
- 29:31all reeling from the interest rate shock that we had internally and we're all
- 29:35fundamentally changing our business.
- 29:38In response there, too.
- 29:39So the last thing we're gonna do is entertain some inorganic growth.
- 29:45Now, fast forward to today.
- 29:47We're at a place where the cost of member acquisition is as high as any of us can
- 29:54remember the cost of member retention in terms of paying up on deposits is as high
- 30:01as anyone can remember with that As our backdrop, it is going to be hard to grow
- 30:09organically in many places in the country.
- 30:11Now, we've also got massive demographic shifts that are going on, so it's
- 30:16making it easier for some and much harder for others simply because
- 30:20your neighborhood is evaporating.
- 30:23You've also got competition on the deposit gathering side that you didn't
- 30:30even know was here when you were Stacked up with money in 2021 because stimulus
- 30:36came directly on your balance sheet.
- 30:37You didn't even realize that the chimes and the sofis of the world and the
- 30:41markets from Goldman Sachs as a world were going to come in and be able
- 30:44to sweep up deposits very quickly, simply by being competitive on price.
- 30:50And because COVID sped up the move to mobile, price becomes even
- 30:56more important as we move forward.
- 30:58So the geographic moat that you think you had, the moat that
- 31:03you had from your seg group.
- 31:05Those are all evaporating very rapidly.
- 31:08And so we're in an environment where we're going to look for
- 31:11growth in places that are inorganic.
- 31:15And so we've seen already in 2024, we've seen 7 Announced credit union purchases
- 31:21of banks that are of significant size.
- 31:24And we've seen, I think it's six credit union for credit union mergers that
- 31:30are substantial in terms of size.
- 31:32And I would call strategic instead of, to assist somebody who's in trouble.
- 31:37So we're seeing, Peer for peer credit union merger of size
- 31:41and we're seeing significant bank purchase by credit unions.
- 31:46That is likely to persist given the economic environment we have
- 31:50and in that environment capital becomes king as you said earlier.
- 31:57Treichel: And you think about COVID, the pandemic and the shift, the mobile
- 32:02ability to get your deposits mobile ability to to get, food delivered to
- 32:08your front door instead of having to go to your restaurant, mobile ability to
- 32:12work from home and not have to go into the office and all of these things have.
- 32:18Consequences or unintended consequences.
- 32:20That's all, it's as if the pandemic shrunk 20 years of progress down
- 32:26into a one year period where everybody was fighting to survive.
- 32:31And the business models of so many things changed and it's it's impacting
- 32:35mergers, it's impacting deposits, it's impacting commercial loans.
- 32:39It's impacting the fact that every, that there are restaurants that now exist
- 32:43just to deliver, and many other things that I haven't even touched on, I'm sure.
- 32:48Mike Mac: I wish I was a sociologist because you would have unbelievable
- 32:52amounts of things to study in terms of the hollowing out of the city, right?
- 32:57You first of all, you've got the Amazon, Amazonification of the retail streetscape.
- 33:03Which is already having dramatic impacts.
- 33:07Then you've got the hollowing out of the city in terms of the work from home.
- 33:12Then you've got a declining tax base in terms of tolls and pricing.
- 33:17So now you are in a potential difficult loop for the municipality itself.
- 33:24You're also in a difficult loop that we're seeing expressed in the CRE market, right?
- 33:29In terms of a redefining of what office is.
- 33:31We've seen a very significant default in the last two weeks in Brooklyn
- 33:35which is a, an interesting market.
- 33:37The largest building in Brooklyn had a default.
- 33:40You've seen a hollowing out in major cities, San Francisco.
- 33:43Of course, you've seen some difficult defaults in Baltimore.
- 33:46You've seen them in Chicago.
- 33:48And that's 1 of the things where we're not yet through the credit cycle, because
- 33:52we're seeing those difficulties happen Luckily here, not every credit union
- 33:58has commercial real estate exposure.
- 34:00Only the larger guys do.
- 34:02And the larger folks are struggling.
- 34:05We've seen some pretty pronounced write downs and charge offs in the last quarter.
- 34:09Some which were even readjusted more recently here.
- 34:12And a lot of them are related to asset classes that are Riskier or
- 34:17really honestly, we're only the biggest credit unions can play that
- 34:21has effects, too, because and some of that is alluded to in the hand.
- 34:25The interplay of big and small credit union is something that the N.
- 34:29C.
- 34:29U.
- 34:29A.
- 34:29Seems to be watching because as this consolidation happens, the
- 34:34increased bigness brings with it its own attendant risks, and the N.
- 34:39C.
- 34:40U.
- 34:40A.
- 34:40Is keenly focused on that.
- 34:42They have a quote.
- 34:43Actually, it says large credit unions tend to offer more complex
- 34:47product services and investments and increasingly complex institutions will
- 34:52pose management challenge for those institutions themselves and for the N.
- 34:57C.
- 34:57U.
- 34:57A.
- 34:58Very insightful by the agency to understand where we are in that in
- 35:03that continuum and to be looking out for what may come with it.
- 35:08Again a good grade to the agency there in terms of understanding that cycle.
- 35:12But again, I don't think we're anywhere near through the credit cycle here
- 35:17and it's going to get more difficult.
- 35:20Treichel: It's going to, yeah, it's going to get worse before it gets better.
- 35:22And, but.
- 35:24All those things are going to be solved by artificial intelligence.
- 35:28So we can maybe get to that a little bit later in the conversation.
- 35:32I'm saying that tongue in cheek, but maybe that's, that's one of the things
- 35:35maybe Nswe is alluding to, right?
- 35:36These bigger institutions are going to find themselves having to do things in
- 35:41the AI world and what does that mean for all the other complicating factors
- 35:46we just mentioned but but I digress.
- 35:48We can't talk about N.
- 35:49C.
- 35:49U.
- 35:50A.
- 35:50And we can't talk about banks and we can't talk about mobility without
- 35:54talking about cyber security.
- 35:55Certainly, they discussed this in the report.
- 35:58Any thoughts on what NCUA said in their annual report on cyber security?
- 36:04Mike Mac: When you're, when you live as exciting a life as I do, Mark, you
- 36:08do things like you take the NCUA annual report and you search the word cyber.
- 36:13And then you bet with the folks in the office to see who can
- 36:15get closest to how many times it appears across the 236 pages.
- 36:20The winner this year.
- 36:21Was it was 92.
- 36:23Tyler and our office got it right on the screws.
- 36:26He suggested that it was going to be 92 times and he was right.
- 36:29So 92 times they use the word, or if it's a partial word,
- 36:32cyber and where do they use it?
- 36:34And what do they mean?
- 36:36They're proud of their updated and scalable cyber exam procedures.
- 36:41And so good for them.
- 36:42They've got a standardized steps, a set of steps that they go through to understand
- 36:47data collection and how it's analyzed.
- 36:49And so good that they're paying attention there.
- 36:52Good.
- 36:52Great.
- 36:53The other thing that they're running a victory lap for, and
- 36:55again, rightly is that they release their cyber incident reporting.
- 36:59And what's interesting here is that they run a victory lap for the fact
- 37:05that the cyber reporting went up dramatically after the rule was passed.
- 37:10I don't know whether that's a good thing or a bad thing.
- 37:12Because here in this instance, they've caught the ice cream
- 37:15truck and it's full of ice cream.
- 37:17So it begs the question why weren't they chasing it a year
- 37:20ago or two years ago or three?
- 37:22Treichel: Sure.
- 37:23Mike Mac: But then they also have their most recent letter to credit unions,
- 37:27which is rolling out the cyber incident.
- 37:30And they require credit unions here to do a couple of things, all of
- 37:34which seem to make very good sense.
- 37:36You've got to update your response plans.
- 37:38You've got to review your third party contracts, which we alluded to earlier.
- 37:42You've got to keep your employees trained and up to date on cyber
- 37:46and all things attendant to it.
- 37:48And you've got to monitor and document any incidents very quickly
- 37:51to the NCOA, which is what a lot of folks have paid extra attention to.
- 37:56The other thing I will say here is this is a perfect place where scale matters.
- 38:01One of the places where we see scale expressing itself is the
- 38:06incidents of cyber attack are up.
- 38:09Every CEO that I talk to tells me about how difficult it is to avoid fraud,
- 38:15to avoid cyber attack, and how often they have to refresh their tech stack.
- 38:20That's a spend.
- 38:21That's a significant amount of money.
- 38:23It's a significant amount of time and energy in an environment.
- 38:27It is increasingly difficult for smaller credit unions to keep up there.
- 38:32And that is one of the one of the key drivers behind a lot of the
- 38:36consolidation that we're seeing is that the smaller credit unions just
- 38:41cannot continue to withstand that the frequency of those attacks and
- 38:48the sophistication of that fraud.
- 38:50And so they are very often looking for a more sophisticated, bigger,
- 38:54stronger partner to help them.
- 38:56And we see that in shared services.
- 38:59We also see it, honestly, in consolidation that's happening,
- 39:03Treichel: And it's going to be that it's going to be some institution
- 39:05that makes a judgment call that leaves the door with the best people.
- 39:11It's hard to, keep the wolves at bay.
- 39:14But if you are having to make dollar decisions And maybe not
- 39:18doing everything that you need.
- 39:19That's going to lead to some situations where credit unions could be subject
- 39:23to ransomware or or, Out and out fraud which, and it's those examples that
- 39:29will continue to have NCUA beating, beating the drum for needing third party
- 39:34authority, like we talked about earlier.
- 39:36The other thing that popped into my head is I love word search in NCUA documents.
- 39:41It's something that I picked up from Steve Farr formerly of NCUA, also of my team.
- 39:46And one thing I like to do is I like to, See how many words, how many times
- 39:51NCOA says safe and sound or safety and soundness and compare that to how many
- 39:55times they say consumer compliance.
- 39:57And I didn't, if I did it to this document, I don't have the data in front
- 40:01of me, but I will tell you that the use of the word safety and soundness, their
- 40:06primary responsibility is lessening compared to the amount of times they
- 40:11say the word consumer compliance.
- 40:13And is it at the right balance?
- 40:14I don't know, but there's a, but that word shit word.
- 40:18Count shift shows the shift in focus a little bit and of course, Chairman Harper
- 40:23will tell you that consumer compliance is safety and soundness and I've disagreed
- 40:28with him here on the podcast and and I, I won't go any further into that,
- 40:34but I love the word search because it tells you what their focus is, right?
- 40:37You, and cyber is always a focus.
- 40:40I mentioned AI, artificial intelligence emerging technologies any thoughts
- 40:50NCOA has been progressive in that arena from the blockchain letter where they
- 40:55made it clear that they didn't want to what's the word I want to use that they
- 40:59wanted to have an open mind to credit unions playing in the fintech arena.
- 41:05And all three board members at the time, this is when Rodney Hood was there.
- 41:09We're comfortable with being a little bit more progressive in that
- 41:13arena than what was coming up from the FFIEC, which is a good thing.
- 41:16But any thoughts on that and or emerging technology, AI is the buzzword every
- 41:22stock owned company out there has to talk about how they got AI because
- 41:25they think their stock's going to go up just because they said it.
- 41:28But any, What are your takeaways relative to the annual report,
- 41:32AI and emerging technologies?
- 41:35Mike Mac: Personally, I'm still working on acquiring the eye.
- 41:39I'm trying to get as much of the eye as I can and just try to retain it at my age.
- 41:44But anyway, this is important.
- 41:47It's also somewhat dangerous.
- 41:49Here is where you've got to weigh your business opportunity with your risk.
- 41:56And you're doing it into an uncertain environment.
- 41:59The example I use is we've gone so fast on this front that a couple of years ago, I
- 42:05remember how everyone was telling me that voice was really the state of the art.
- 42:12Way to validate an account and to be sure that a person who was who they said they
- 42:19were On a telephone call and therefore can get access to their account, etc fast
- 42:24forward two years and then you realize that the ability to do a deep fake on a
- 42:28voice is very pronounced And people were breaking through A lot of those safeguards
- 42:34that we thought were state of the art.
- 42:36So here it's It's you have to be in this game and you have to be tinkering, but
- 42:42you have to do it responsibly because you can't threaten the franchise.
- 42:46So you really have to understand what you're dealing with and what's
- 42:49coming down the pike as you use these emerging technologies and you have
- 42:53to be trying continually tinkering and playing in this field to be
- 42:58up to speed and be best in class.
- 43:01But at the same time, you got to make sure that you don't threaten the franchise.
- 43:04And so what the agency's done here, it reminds me of
- 43:06what they did in derivatives.
- 43:08They're opening it up.
- 43:09They're saying we're going to allow you to tinker.
- 43:12But they're also telling you, don't screw it up.
- 43:15And it's almost what you have to do in this type of field where it's wide open.
- 43:19I will say, we see plenty of and, maybe it's the sexiest stuff, but
- 43:24it tends to get plenty of the press.
- 43:26We see plenty of investments by credit unions into fintechs.
- 43:30We see lots of credit unions doing progressive things in fintech, whether
- 43:34it's on payments or it's on validation.
- 43:39Are tinkering into blockchain.
- 43:41We've done some of that.
- 43:43We're familiar with some of it here.
- 43:45Some of its talk more than its adoption.
- 43:48But, we'll see.
- 43:49This is something that takes time.
- 43:51It has to marinate.
- 43:53You don't make a sauce very quickly.
- 43:55It takes time and you've got to let it simmer.
- 43:57So the jury's still out.
- 44:01Treichel: All great points.
- 44:01You talk about AI and being able to imitate somebody's voice.
- 44:05I actually did a podcast based on the pod, the software I use for my podcast has, it
- 44:11has two different artificial intelligence modules, an older one and a newer one,
- 44:16which is much better, but I took the older one and did a podcast that was like
- 44:20three minutes long and it was all fake.
- 44:22It was all, Them generating my voice and I sounded even more
- 44:27monotone than I normally do.
- 44:29And that was the giveaway.
- 44:30If someone knows me, they know it's not me, but it sounds like me.
- 44:35And then you look at the newer generation version of it and it's better, and
- 44:38that was over like an 18 month period.
- 44:41And then earlier this year, I started a second podcast called
- 44:45credit union regulatory guidance.
- 44:47And that is AI, where I take a letter to credit unions, or I just did next week,
- 44:53I've got Barry Hunt's letter to NCOA saying don't disclose overdraft fees.
- 44:58And I took that letter and I turned it into AI and I had 15 female
- 45:02voices to choose from 15 male voices.
- 45:05My wife and I listened to all of them and came up with
- 45:08someone who was called Samantha.
- 45:10And I, so I named her Samantha shares because of the shared draft.
- 45:13But anyway she's far more eloquent than me she says the one kink in
- 45:18the armor is she says supervisory.
- 45:20So she says that like she's from from Australia or England, and I
- 45:23haven't been able to figure that out.
- 45:25And sometimes I have to, sometimes she says N C U A, right?
- 45:29And N C U A.
- 45:30And so I change that to agency on occasion or we change that when we're editing.
- 45:34But just the fascination that I could take, we can take a 20 page
- 45:40letter and get it into a voice that look, that sounds almost natural.
- 45:45And we're a couple of years into doing this.
- 45:47What's it going to be two years from now, four years from now, let alone,
- 45:50the Peter Gabriel guys that'll be out there making songs like they're
- 45:54Peter Gabriel and writing songs like Peter Gabriel and all of that.
- 45:57Mike Mac: I don't know if it's giving away too much, but I have listened to
- 45:59Samantha shares while I've driven across the Midwest, that's, I guess I was
- 46:05scraping the bottom of the, I had been through all of the with flying colors.
- 46:09Treichel: Exactly.
- 46:14Exactly.
- 46:15So yeah, you get up in the morning and you look at what's new in the list today.
- 46:19It's yeah, I subscribe to this one, but I don't think I've got, three months
- 46:23later, you decide to get rid of that one.
- 46:25But, it's a, it's an audio book for it it's not as popular as with
- 46:29flying colors, but it is out there.
- 46:31But the technology that, yeah.
- 46:33That was that were where my wife and I could sit down and figure
- 46:36out how to do it so easily.
- 46:39And it sound relatively good, right?
- 46:41And it's crazy where that whole arena is going to go.
- 46:45I don't pretend to understand where AI is going to take us.
- 46:49But it like you said, it's like the derivative comparison was very
- 46:54good on how NC way that you made.
- 46:56That derivatives and they want you to play in the sandbox.
- 47:00They want you to be careful, but if you don't have the opportunity
- 47:03to get into, you get into it, you could become irrelevant real quick.
- 47:06Mike Mac: But here's the thing you have to play.
- 47:08And I say to people in derivatives and I don't mean, I'm not going to.
- 47:11In derivatives, there are 1000 things you can do before you
- 47:15even get to the water's edge.
- 47:17So and they're all prescribed in those regs, right?
- 47:20You have to educate your management, your board, your staff.
- 47:24You have to have multiple people with multiple responsibilities so
- 47:27that you've got silos, but you've got cross eyes across multiple pieces
- 47:31so that not one person can get your organization in too much trouble.
- 47:36But you've also then got to stand up counter parties and counter party
- 47:39documents, and you've got to understand the products that you would trade.
- 47:42Now, all of that can be done and should be done because it's part of the learning.
- 47:48And that is just the price of admission that gets you to the
- 47:51water's edge where you can then trade.
- 47:54And the folks who just.
- 47:56Don't get started on that path because they're scared of it
- 48:00or it's not a priority, right?
- 48:02When it comes time to trade or when it comes time to put a hedge on to do
- 48:06something that's responsible, their path to affecting that transaction
- 48:11is so much longer than if they had done the work in the beginning
- 48:17and gotten themselves educated.
- 48:18And we say all the time, you've got to be engaged in the process
- 48:23of learning and standing up the undergirding of all of those
- 48:28foundational pieces that are important.
- 48:30Otherwise you're not doing what you're supposed to do.
- 48:32And then when it comes time to do the work you're too late, your process
- 48:36you're get too long of a runway before you can affect something.
- 48:39And we see it in sub debt where people take a look at it and then.
- 48:43They come back to us and say, how quickly can I get this done?
- 48:46And I said you could have, I could have made that quickly a month.
- 48:49Now that quickly is six months,
- 48:51Treichel: right?
- 48:53Great point.
- 48:53Great point on that, on derivatives on, testing your relationship with
- 48:58the federal home loan bank in the fed.
- 49:00When you need to move quick, you need to understand how the world works before
- 49:05all of a sudden you have that need and all of those arenas that you mentioned.
- 49:09Great point.
- 49:09Mike Mac: Broker deposits, any of your liquidity valves, we tell
- 49:12people all the time, have many.
- 49:15Any sources because I don't know which price is going to be in favor and I don't
- 49:18know who's going to have, that supply that you need when you need it, but test
- 49:22those pipes, put your test trade down.
- 49:24It's not going to make or break your institution, but you need to
- 49:27be able to understand that you can flow through any of those networks
- 49:30that you need to when you need it.
- 49:32Treichel: Yep.
- 49:33Great.
- 49:33Great
- 49:34Mike Mac: point.
- 49:35Treichel: Mike, is there anything we've hit a lot of the highlights.
- 49:38Is there anything that I should have brought up relative to the annual
- 49:43report or any questions I should have asked you and or any last
- 49:46thoughts that you have before we.
- 49:49Wrap up here.
- 49:50Mike Mac: I think you've got it all mark.
- 49:52You're just a tremendous questioner at this point.
- 49:54You're so savvy having done so many of these podcasts.
- 49:58So you're spot on.
- 49:59But I think we've gotten all the important points.
- 50:02I do think we're in for a little bit of a tough environment here, as I said.
- 50:06I think credit unions shouldn't hide from that.
- 50:09The most successful credit unions are going to move into that and just make
- 50:14good decisions on behalf of their members.
- 50:16And I would say if, Holden Lane can be a part of assisting in
- 50:20any way we're happy to do that.
- 50:22We have a very talented team here.
- 50:24They are.
- 50:24They're great people.
- 50:26This is what we do.
- 50:27We enjoy it.
- 50:27It's a great industry to be in.
- 50:29So if we can be helpful in any way we're here to help every credit
- 50:34union we can, large or small.
- 50:36Treichel: Yeah, Mike you do have a great team.
- 50:38This was a lot of fun today.
- 50:39And if someone's listened to this and they're going, Hey, I want to talk to
- 50:42Mike and, or the team at Olden Lane, what's the best way for them to reach you?
- 50:46Mike Mac: We're pretty prevalent on LinkedIn.
- 50:48You can find us there.
- 50:49You could.
- 50:50I'm certainly there.
- 50:51We have a website.
- 50:52It's www dot old and www dot old and lane dot com.
- 50:56And you can get us there.
- 50:58We've got an info box.
- 50:59If you fill that out, it will come to all the 4 principles over
- 51:02here and a couple of other folks.
- 51:04And we're happy to assist in any way we can, as I said and Mark
- 51:09again, thanks for having me on.
- 51:10It was it was a lot of fun.
- 51:12Treichel: Yeah, it was fun.
- 51:12Mike, as always, I wanna thank you for your time today and listeners,
- 51:16I want to thank you for listening.
- 51:18This is Mark reel, signing off with Flying Colors.
- 51:26Thank you for joining us on this episode of with flying colors, subscribe on
- 51:30your favorite podcast app to hear future episodes where subject matter experts
- 51:34of all varieties will provide tips on how to achieve success with NCUA.
- 51:38If you would like to learn more about how we assist credit unions, check
- 51:42out our services at marktreichel.
- 51:44com.