Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / The Nevada Advantage in Context: Comparing Today’s Top Trust Jurisdictions
Transcript
- 0:03Welcome to the Nevada Advantage in Context comparing
- 0:05today's top trust jurisdictions. My name is Teal
- 0:08Schoonover and I'm a co -chair of the Beverly
- 0:10Hills Bar Association's Trust in a State's law
- 0:12section. We are thrilled to have you join us
- 0:14today. Before we begin, I'd like to take a moment
- 0:16to acknowledge Nancy Sanborn and Brian Joy of
- 0:18the Sanborn team. Nancy and Brian have been the
- 0:21official sponsor of the Trust in a State section
- 0:22since 2006. In addition to the Sanborn team,
- 0:26the Trust and Estate section is also sponsored
- 0:28by Bond Services of California, Liberty Mutual
- 0:30Surety, California Title Company, and Pickford
- 0:32Asker Company. Now I'd like to turn things over
- 0:35to Leah Momsius to provide this month's legal
- 0:37updates. Thank you very much, Teal. Her Executive
- 0:42Order 14247, effective September 30th, 2025,
- 0:47Paper checks are being phased out for all payments
- 0:50from and to the IRS. There's no exception for
- 0:53trust in estates. So that includes the state
- 0:55and gift tax payments, which must now be made,
- 0:58quote, as soon as practicable. Either one electronically
- 1:02using the electronic federal tax payment system,
- 1:06EFTPS, or two via same day wire directly from
- 1:10a financial institution to the IRS. Unfortunately,
- 1:13both options require advanced planning. The same
- 1:16-day wire payment option may involve additional
- 1:18costs such as wire fees, has a cut -off time
- 1:21of 5 p .m. Eastern, and requires that you provide
- 1:24your bank with a completed same -day wire taxpayer
- 1:27worksheet which calls for various codes depending
- 1:29on the type of payment you're making. Meanwhile,
- 1:32the EFTPS option is free but requires an enrollment
- 1:36process that takes a couple of weeks to complete,
- 1:38including having the trustee or executor register
- 1:41for EFTPS online, then waiting to receive a PIN
- 1:45from the IRS via snail mail and thereafter returning
- 1:48to the EFTPS website to activate the account.
- 1:52Now it does appear that there is a ramp up period
- 1:54for making electronic estate tax payments because
- 1:57there is still information regarding paying by
- 2:00check on the IRS's website, but we recommend
- 2:03practitioners begin acquainting themselves with
- 2:05the electronic payment options sooner rather
- 2:08than later. And that's your legal update for
- 2:11February 2026. Over to you, Aubrey. Thanks, Leah.
- 2:15Now onto the program. Today's speakers are Kristin
- 2:19Madioni and Robert Rankin. Kristin D. Madioni
- 2:23is Vice President, Associate Counsel at Whittier
- 2:26Trust, where she assists with the firm's legal
- 2:28affairs, advising on trust fiduciary corporate
- 2:31regulatory and business matters. She brings nearly
- 2:34a decade of experience in trust and estate law,
- 2:37having previously practiced with Snell and Wilmer
- 2:40LLP and Mopping Cox and Legoy, advising high
- 2:44enough worth individuals on estate planning,
- 2:46administration, and business succession. Kristen
- 2:49earned her BA in International Affairs and her
- 2:52JD, both Magna Cum Laude, and is actively involved
- 2:56in professional and community organizations in
- 2:58Nevada. Robert W. Rankin is Executive Vice President,
- 3:03General Counsel at Whittier Trust, where he oversees
- 3:06the legal affairs of the firm and its affiliated
- 3:09entities. He brings more than 20 years of experience
- 3:12advising closely held businesses and high net
- 3:15worth individuals on business succession. estate
- 3:17planning, tax strategies, nonprofit matters,
- 3:21and trust administration, and previously served
- 3:23as a shareholder at Clark and Trevithick and
- 3:27as senior vice president trust counsel at Fiduciary
- 3:30Trust International of California. Bob holds
- 3:33a JD from Loyola Law School, a master of business
- 3:37taxation from USC, and is recognized as a recognized
- 3:41Southern California super lawyer and frequent
- 3:43speaker on tax and trust related topics. Please
- 3:46welcome Kristen Madioni and Robert Rankin. Thank
- 3:51you guys so much. I'm going to try to get this
- 3:54up on the screen. Okay. Hopefully that is now
- 4:01working. Thank you so much for that introduction,
- 4:05Aubrey. We really appreciate it. And thank you
- 4:07to all of you who are tuning in and giving us
- 4:10the opportunity to speak with you all today.
- 4:12I think is our I guess short bios indicated Bob
- 4:17and I are acutely aware of how valuable all of
- 4:21your time is as both of us were in private practice
- 4:24before we moved in house with Whittier. So with
- 4:29that, let's make the most of our time together
- 4:32today and dive into this. So today we are going
- 4:38to cover a topic that is very near and dear to
- 4:41my heart and potentially to many of you who operate
- 4:44in the realm of advanced estate and tax planning,
- 4:48although we probably call it something very different.
- 4:53call it the Nevada Advantage. And I always preface
- 4:57when I talk about this topic by saying that I
- 5:00am entirely and completely biased in everything
- 5:03that I am going to tell you today. And that is
- 5:06because I am a fifth generation Nevadan. I'm
- 5:09obviously a Nevada licensed attorney. And so,
- 5:13you know, I say all of that through that lens
- 5:15and through that context. But I hope that all
- 5:19of you will agree with me that despite my own
- 5:22internal biases about Nevada law and Nevada principles
- 5:26of estate and tax planning. It is really undisputed
- 5:31that Nevada has garnered a reputation for being
- 5:34one of the top trust jurisdictions in the nation.
- 5:37Specifically, Nevada has always been considered
- 5:40one of the big three, which is Delaware, Alaska,
- 5:44and Nevada. Although now, I very much think that
- 5:47we have the big five, which includes Wyoming
- 5:49and South Dakota. Of course, there's always jurisdictions
- 5:53sort of vying for those top spots. But those
- 5:58are sort of the five that we're going to talk
- 6:00the most about today. And we will, of course,
- 6:02work some things about California into this presentation
- 6:06as well. And there are two things that Bob and
- 6:11I did want to kind of emphasize to all of you
- 6:13before we get too far into this. The one of them
- 6:18is, and I think this is particularly important
- 6:20for those of you who are the next door neighbors
- 6:22of Nevada or whatever jurisdiction you're drafting
- 6:25trusts in, and I don't want this to get lost,
- 6:28and that is you don't have to give up your clients
- 6:31just because. you know, they have trusts that
- 6:34are being prepared in one of these jurisdictions.
- 6:37You know, we have many, many clients that we
- 6:39work with, and there are many attorneys that
- 6:41we work with who part of their practice is to
- 6:43do a review of these types of trust agreements.
- 6:47And I just think that's really important to emphasize.
- 6:52And the second thing I wanted to highlight because
- 6:54I think it is really unique and I don't know
- 6:56that it fits well into anything else we're talking
- 6:58about. And that's just sort of the way that the
- 7:01legislature works in Nevada and our legislature
- 7:05meets every other year. So I do think that's
- 7:08something that's just a little bit interesting
- 7:10in Nevada and how our laws are shaped and how
- 7:13they operate. And so it's it's a little interesting.
- 7:17We have a lot of access to our lobbyists and
- 7:20many of them are practitioners. themselves. Some
- 7:22are teachers. A lot of them have other jobs,
- 7:24right? Because the legislature only meets every
- 7:26other year. So it's a really interesting way
- 7:29that our system, I guess, works. And so that's
- 7:35just something that I think is really important
- 7:36to talk about. So with that, we'll sort of talk
- 7:40about what we're going to cover with all of you
- 7:43today. So we are, of course, going to talk about
- 7:46taxes because you can't talk about any of the
- 7:49Trump top trust jurisdictions without talking
- 7:51about taxes. Then we'll talk about asset protection.
- 7:54And specifically, we're going to talk about some
- 7:56of the things, not just asset protection generally,
- 8:00but about some drafting things to keep in mind
- 8:03if you are preparing these types of trusts. Then
- 8:06we're going to talk about the flexible and favorable
- 8:09statutes that exist, right, from directed trusts
- 8:13to decantings to NJSAs and notices of proposed
- 8:17action. as well as silent trusts. Then we'll
- 8:21talk about the perpetuities period, and we'll
- 8:23wrap this up with privacy and confidentiality.
- 8:26So as we walk work through this, if you have
- 8:28questions, feel free to put them into the chat.
- 8:32So okay, taxes. So let's address the obvious
- 8:37thing first. In addition to the absence of state
- 8:42income tax on both individual and trust income,
- 8:46Nevada also does not have a gift tax and a state
- 8:49tax or other form of inheritance tax. It does
- 8:53not have a generation skipping transfer tax or
- 8:55GST tax, all of which of course make it a very
- 8:59attractive trust jurisdiction for estate planning
- 9:02and multi -generational wealth preservation purposes.
- 9:07I also just felt like I would throw this in there.
- 9:09I feel like property taxes are getting a lot
- 9:11of attention these days. So I did think that
- 9:14it was important to note that Nevada does also
- 9:17have very low property taxes. In fact, our effective
- 9:21rate is 0 .45%, which is ninth the best in the
- 9:25nation currently. But in speaking with all of
- 9:30you guys today, Bob and I did not want to leave
- 9:34anybody confused or to misrepresent that Nevada
- 9:36is the only state that of course has these beneficial
- 9:40tax laws. In fact, all of the big five that we
- 9:44just talked about, right? So all of the big five
- 9:46have these same tax benefits. There are just
- 9:50a couple things to bear in mind. So one is that
- 9:54Delaware does actually have a tax on trust income,
- 9:59but it only taxes residents. So if you don't
- 10:02have a resident beneficiary of the Delaware trust,
- 10:05you're fine. Additionally, in 2023, Alaska was
- 10:11contemplating implementing an income tax to address
- 10:14some of their very serious budget deficits that
- 10:17they're dealing with. That didn't happen at that
- 10:20time, but it is something that is being kicked
- 10:23around in Alaska. I think there was a couple
- 10:28other states that are maybe thinking about that,
- 10:30too, right, Bob? Right. Well, I'll just jump
- 10:34back a few steps. And it's great to work with
- 10:36Kristen, who's clearly passionate. about the
- 10:39Nevada piece of this. But really, all of these
- 10:42elements that we're going to get into today will
- 10:44cover key reasons why these jurisdictions have
- 10:47modified the laws the way they have, with tax
- 10:49being mostly the primary motivating force. So
- 10:54we're going to see an ever -changing tax landscape
- 10:56for the next few years. Recently, the state of
- 10:59Washington just implemented or is in the process
- 11:02of implementing a tax on a million -dollar income
- 11:06or more. if income is exceeding a million dollars
- 11:09and they're suggesting that they'll now be an
- 11:11income tax for those folks. And that's going
- 11:14to continue to change. One of the unique things
- 11:16about Nevada, and Kristin can weigh in on this
- 11:18as a generational citizen or resident, is the
- 11:23ability through their gaming and mining resources
- 11:26to continue to maintain this status. I think
- 11:30as these states, the non -tax states, these jurisdictions
- 11:33continue to attract people, the resources are
- 11:38stretched, and there's only one way to generate
- 11:42income, and that's through taxes, primarily.
- 11:45So that'll be an interesting area to watch over
- 11:48the next many years as these things grow and
- 11:51the populations grow in Florida, Texas, to some
- 11:55extent, South Dakota. People aren't rushing to
- 11:57South Dakota last time I checked, but Nevada
- 12:00is seeing some more inflow, especially the Northern
- 12:02California area. And it's going to be an interesting
- 12:06eerie to watch for sure. This is one of the key
- 12:14components. It's really less to do obviously
- 12:17with income or even a state tax. It has mostly
- 12:21to do with the ability in many of these states
- 12:25to create a trust that will go on for multiple
- 12:28generations. Many of those states have eliminated
- 12:32altogether the rule against perpetuities. And
- 12:35so what you have is an ability, as this graph
- 12:38shows, you don't have that loss in momentum in
- 12:43that 60 -year period. So a crust is created on
- 12:46a death, not necessarily rule against perpetuity,
- 12:49but on a death, you're going to see on the federal
- 12:52level, 40 % removed from the assets that are
- 12:57growing. And that's something that's highlighted
- 12:59well here. And that's primarily focused on the
- 13:02state of California. We are seeing other states,
- 13:04again, Washington state, and a few others that
- 13:06have implemented an estate tax. And that's something
- 13:08to be aware of as you plan. But the uninterrupted
- 13:12momentum of the ability of a dynasty trust to
- 13:16create wealth is pretty significant. And one
- 13:20of the things we've seen over the last 15 years
- 13:22is almost an uninterrupted growth in assets and
- 13:26creation of wealth. And while there'll be a market
- 13:30adjustment at some point, that wealth will be
- 13:33something that can be set aside, hopefully under
- 13:35the new beautiful bill and some of those aspects
- 13:38with a higher exclusion amount to take advantage
- 13:40of exactly this type of planning. Great. So with
- 13:47that, we are going to sort of slide into asset
- 13:49protection. I think everybody on this call probably
- 13:52knows, but right. Asset protection trusts are
- 13:55highly valuable for select high net worth individuals.
- 14:00A properly set up asset protection trust can
- 14:03effectively shield any type of asset from all
- 14:06kinds of legal threats. So those can range from
- 14:10lawsuits to creditor claims to divorcing spouses.
- 14:14Now, as a matter of public policy, right? Essentially
- 14:18every state recognizes in general the validity
- 14:21of spendthrift trust to protect a third party
- 14:24beneficiary's interest from creditors. But historically,
- 14:28many of those laws have been unenforceable with
- 14:30respect to a settlor who's also the beneficiary
- 14:33of the trust, right? Such as what we call a self
- 14:37-settled spendthrift trust or a self -settled
- 14:39asset protection trust. In the 1970, or excuse
- 14:45me, since 1997, many states did enact legislation
- 14:50that extended these spendthrift trust laws to
- 14:53settler beneficiaries. So what's actually easiest
- 14:57to do is as I work through the next few slides,
- 14:59I'm gonna start with self -settled asset protection
- 15:01trusts, and then we'll work our way into third
- 15:04-party asset protection trusts. and sort of talk
- 15:08about how this works. So, right, broadly, what
- 15:10is a self -settled asset protection trust? So
- 15:13ADAP, a domestic asset protection trust, is just
- 15:16an irrevocable trust that's established by the
- 15:19SETLOR for the benefit of the SETLOR and any
- 15:22other beneficiaries that they may want in one
- 15:24of the states that allows for the creation of
- 15:26these types of trusts. There's currently 19 states,
- 15:30hopefully I'm still right about that, I did check,
- 15:33that allow for self -settled spend threats. trusts.
- 15:38And DAPs generally rely on the spendthrift clause
- 15:42and state statute to protect those assets contributed
- 15:45to the DAP from the settler's creditors. And
- 15:50so sort of what's the requirement to have a DAP,
- 15:53right? So it has to be irrevocable. It cannot
- 15:57require that any part of the income or principle
- 16:00of the trust be distributed to the settler. And
- 16:03it must not be funded with the intent to hinder,
- 16:08delay, or defraud known creditors. You have to
- 16:11have a jurisdictional trustee, obviously, sort
- 16:14of your jurisdictional hook in the DAPT jurisdiction.
- 16:18And the trust has to contain a spendthrift clause
- 16:20that places a restraint on voluntary or involuntary
- 16:23transfers. I think it's really important to say
- 16:26that a primary power that cannot be retained
- 16:29is the power of the settler to make distributions
- 16:31to himself or herself without the consent of
- 16:35another person, right? Where Bob and I are often
- 16:37seeing that, probably where a lot of you are
- 16:39seeing that, but our perspective might be a little
- 16:41bit different given that we're primarily administering
- 16:44trusts here at Whittier is right, you have to
- 16:47have You have to have some, usually it's better
- 16:50if it's an independent party, but an independent
- 16:52party who is sort of in charge of that. Nevada,
- 17:00right, is largely considered to be one of the
- 17:03best, if not the best, jurisdiction in the nation
- 17:06for asset protection. We call them NAPs in Nevada,
- 17:09right, Nevada Asset Protection Trust. And a big
- 17:13reason for this is, of course, that we're one
- 17:15of only 19 states that allow it. That's great.
- 17:18These self -settled asset protection trusts.
- 17:20But really, the reasoning for Nevada being But
- 17:24truthfully, the leading jurisdiction in asset
- 17:26protection is for two reasons. And that's the
- 17:28statute of limitations period. And the second
- 17:31is the fact that we don't have any statutory
- 17:34exemption creditors. Basically, each asset protection
- 17:38jurisdiction provides a statute of limitations
- 17:41period during which a creditor can try to attach
- 17:44or make a claim on the transfer of the assets
- 17:48made to the trust by the settlor. Nevada is one
- 17:51of the only states in the nation that has a two
- 17:54-year statute of limitations for both future
- 17:57and pre -existing creditors, whereas that's usually
- 18:01like four years in the other states. I know it's
- 18:04three years in Delaware. give that a comparison
- 18:07to one of the big five. One thing that I do think
- 18:11is worth noting for anybody who really is concerned
- 18:13about this is that every self settled Spendthrift
- 18:18Trust is subject to a 10 -year statute of limitations
- 18:21period in a bankruptcy proceeding, right? That's
- 18:23federal, bankruptcy law is federal. And so that's
- 18:28because the Bankruptcy Abuse Prevention and Consumer
- 18:30Protection Act of 2005 added new language into
- 18:34the bankruptcy code. And that's what governs
- 18:36fraudulent transfers and obligations. But that's
- 18:39the first reasoning. The second reasoning, which
- 18:42I think is arguably maybe a little bit more important
- 18:45for many of our clients, And that is because
- 18:49almost every asset protection jurisdiction has
- 18:52what we call statutory exception creditors or
- 18:56super creditors super priority creditors. For
- 19:00example, a lot of other jurisdictions will allow
- 19:03for things like child support, divorcing spouses
- 19:07in alimony, maybe pre -existing tort claims.
- 19:11In Nevada, we do not have any of those. And in
- 19:16fact, the only states that do not allow for those
- 19:18are Nevada, Utah, and West Virginia, none of
- 19:23whom are, of course, in the big five except Nevada.
- 19:26So that is really the primary reason that Nevada
- 19:30takes first, I guess you could say in asset protection.
- 19:34But there are some other considerations that
- 19:37I think you have to give attention to when you're
- 19:39considering asset protection. The first is, of
- 19:42course, the fraudulent transfer standard, right?
- 19:45So a standard case of a fraudulent transfer usually
- 19:48involves a debtor who gives property or sells
- 19:52it at a fraction of its value to like your family,
- 19:55your spouse, your kids, your best friend. And
- 19:58then that person kind of tries to aid you in
- 20:00the fraud. So obviously you have to be very well
- 20:02aware of that. can't have any sort of asset protection
- 20:04for that purpose. You need to be aware of a trust
- 20:07decanting statute, which we will talk about a
- 20:11little bit later when we talk about decanting,
- 20:12but that can really matter for asset protection
- 20:15purposes. And of course, you want to think about
- 20:18things like ease of use, right? So a lot of jurisdictions
- 20:22will require an affidavit of solvency to make
- 20:25transfers to the DAP. That's not something that
- 20:29Nevada requires, just so you know, but you could
- 20:31have it if you wanted to. And there are certain
- 20:35jurisdictions like Nevada that allow the trustee
- 20:38of the DAP to distribute property to a settler
- 20:42or beneficiary for the purpose of obtaining a
- 20:45loan. So long as it's properly secured, and then
- 20:49it's reconveyed to the trust, then that doesn't
- 20:51necessarily have to be considered a new transfer.
- 20:56So these are just some things to take into consideration
- 20:58when you're looking at the big five or looking
- 21:01at asset protection jurisdictions, because it
- 21:04can really matter depending on the facts and
- 21:06circumstances of what you're dealing with with
- 21:08your clients. Something else that can be really
- 21:14important for those of you who are drafting asset
- 21:16protection trusts or considering asset protection
- 21:19trusts, and that is the types of powers that
- 21:23the settlor can retain, right? These really do
- 21:27vary by jurisdiction, but these are some that
- 21:31you can have in Nevada. I've sort of listed them
- 21:33on the screen, so I don't. necessarily need to
- 21:36go through every single one of them. But just
- 21:40know that these are these are sort of the ones
- 21:42that I highlighted because I do think they're
- 21:44important right you can remove and replace the
- 21:45trustees often that's really important or the
- 21:48investment advisors. You can also exercise discretion
- 21:51still over investment so the settler could be
- 21:54the investment advisor there's of course potentially
- 21:57some tax issues related to the ftb there depends
- 21:59on how conservative you want to be. But that's
- 22:03something to think about. The settlor can also
- 22:06be a co -trustee. Again, there could be FTB issues
- 22:09there. So we have to think about California -related
- 22:13issues for those of you drafting in California.
- 22:15But if you have non -California clients, it's
- 22:17something to consider if they wanted to be a
- 22:19co -trustee. You can also retain lifetime or
- 22:22testamentary special powers of appointment, which
- 22:25is kind of nice. So anyway, these are just some
- 22:28of the things that I think are important. and
- 22:31that we put up there for you all to think about.
- 22:34So what are a couple other things maybe to think
- 22:38about when you have non -residents? So for non
- 22:40-Nevada, non -Delaware, non -Alaska, non -South
- 22:43Dakota, non -Wyoming residents, what are some
- 22:46things that maybe you need to be thinking about
- 22:48for those types of clients? And I think it's
- 22:51pretty obvious that conflicts of law is probably
- 22:54the biggest thing. In general, the full faith
- 22:59and full faith and credit clause of the Constitution
- 23:02requires, right, that states recognize the laws
- 23:05of other states. So unless those laws are against
- 23:08the very strong public policy of the home state.
- 23:11So that's the general rule. How helpful is that
- 23:15in practice? I think that's hard, right? We see
- 23:19in particular the FTB be pretty aggressive about
- 23:23these types of things. So you do want to be very
- 23:27careful about who you're naming to have various
- 23:29roles in your trust agreements and being sure
- 23:34that you're staying on top. As Bob mentioned,
- 23:36these laws are evolving. Things are constantly
- 23:39evolving in not just at the federal level, which
- 23:43I think we're all pretty tuned into, but at each
- 23:46individual state level. All of these laws are
- 23:48evolving. Things are happening. The case law
- 23:51is constantly changing, even though there's very
- 23:53limited case law in Nevada and in all of the
- 23:56big five that addresses these things, right?
- 23:59Because our clients settle right like at the
- 24:01end of the day the clients most of the clients
- 24:03that we're dealing with don't want these cases
- 24:05heard before any type of supreme court state
- 24:09or federal and so you know there's very little
- 24:12published opinions on any of this type of work
- 24:15so those are the things to keep in mind and of
- 24:19course the uniform avoidable transactions act
- 24:21very obvious again you can't set up an asset
- 24:25protection trust for a fraudulent purpose I guess
- 24:35one of the questions that we get asked all the
- 24:37time is, can I be a non -resident though and
- 24:41take advantage of a Nevada Asset Protection Trust?
- 24:43At least that's a question that I get asked very
- 24:45regularly. And really the answer is yes. In order
- 24:50to do that, though, it is really important some
- 24:52things to think about and to consider if you
- 24:54are drafting these kinds of trusts for your clients.
- 24:58And the first, you want to name either a Nevada
- 25:00resident, a Nevada bank, or a Nevada trust company
- 25:03as your trustee. That's really how you would
- 25:07want to strengthen that nexus. A further way
- 25:11to strengthen the nexus is, of course, to set
- 25:13up a Nevada LLC or a Nevada partnership. or whatever
- 25:17it may be, depending on the type of assets. If
- 25:19you're just transferring marketables, that may
- 25:21not be as necessary, but depending on the type
- 25:23of asset, if it's like real estate or something
- 25:25like that, that is helpful to form an even stronger
- 25:29nexus to the state of Nevada. And lastly, while
- 25:36the traditional Nevada Asset Protection Trust
- 25:38is self -settled, a Nevada Asset Protection Trust
- 25:42may be specifically designed to not include the
- 25:47settlor as a beneficiary. and then they could
- 25:50potentially be added back into the later date.
- 25:53We're sort of calling those a hybrid asset protection
- 25:57trust, and I won't take credit for coining that.
- 25:59I think Steve Oshens is the one who's a Nevada
- 26:02attorney who talks about this topic pretty regularly.
- 26:05That's how he drafts his asset protection trusts.
- 26:09But really what that sort of means is that the
- 26:12trust is set up not self -settled to begin with,
- 26:15particularly for aggressive you know, clients
- 26:18in states like California where there could be
- 26:20some aggressive. laws that try to claw those
- 26:25assets back into the state of California. So
- 26:28one of the ways that we're seeing some practitioners
- 26:31go about drafting these asset protection trusts
- 26:33is that they set up the asset protection trust,
- 26:36just a third party asset protection trust, but
- 26:39with somebody, usually a trust protector, has
- 26:41the power to name the settler back in as a beneficiary.
- 26:48And then that's how, you know, so something were
- 26:50to occur later, it could become a self settled
- 26:53asset protection trust. So it's sort of just
- 26:55an additional added protection, you still get
- 26:59all the benefits of right, maybe you're locking
- 27:00an exemption, you're moving assets to Nevada,
- 27:03but you're not necessarily overdoing it. So that's
- 27:07sort of how all of that works in context. And
- 27:10again, I'm very biased, but Nevada is considered
- 27:12the best, I think, on every chart you look at.
- 27:15And it's for those sort of two initial reasons
- 27:17of the statute of limitations and the fact that
- 27:21there's no super priority creditors. Well, just
- 27:24to jump in, I think it's an interesting concept
- 27:27when you think about it. If you try and put your
- 27:31assets outside the reach of creditors, there's
- 27:34obviously an initial questioning. It's a little
- 27:38odd, to say the least, if you want to be kind.
- 27:41And then you're looking at why. So in using these,
- 27:44before we get to the third party, back to the
- 27:47self -settled, the question has to come up when
- 27:50you're meeting with folks. What is the focus
- 27:53and why is that the focus? So the threshold issues
- 27:56are, is there an existing claim? Is there a potential
- 27:59claim? Could that happen in the near term? analysis.
- 28:04Those questions need to be reviewed and answered.
- 28:07And then you get to the second question, well,
- 28:09how is it going to be funded? What is it made
- 28:11up of? What are the terms? If you see a situation
- 28:14where all of the assets are being shoved into
- 28:17the asset protection trust, it's probably not
- 28:20just a red flag. That's a sign to maybe caution
- 28:23the client and refer them to somebody else. But
- 28:27the idea behind it is so important to a lot of
- 28:31prospects that you're going to deal with. And
- 28:35it's important to understand the nuances. That's
- 28:37why Kristen went through the details. It is utilized.
- 28:41Certain professions have a higher degree of exposure
- 28:44and there is no existing or even likely claim.
- 28:49But in order to sleep at night, these are tools
- 28:51available, and these are how to do it. What we've
- 28:54seen in a couple situations is somebody appreciating
- 28:59the other benefits. They want a dynasty trust.
- 29:02They want the flexibility that the Nevada statutes
- 29:04provide, as well as Delaware and South Dakota
- 29:06and Wyoming and the others. And then the attorney
- 29:11latches on, bolts on the asset protection piece.
- 29:15And that's not a great idea. That could create
- 29:17exposure for you in a malpractice area because
- 29:20Murphy's Law, that will likely be the one that
- 29:23has some kind of creditor claim pop up. But also
- 29:27just all of these dots need to be, all these
- 29:30I's need to be dotted, the T's need to be crossed
- 29:32to make sure that this is done right. There are
- 29:34their notice requirements or nuances within the
- 29:37law that are critical that this get done. And
- 29:40then, you know, we see a variety of situations
- 29:43and many of you represent trustees and institute
- 29:46likely institutional trustees, but also in working
- 29:49with the clients, understanding what the primary
- 29:52objective is and then working with the trustees
- 29:55to understand prior to accepting that role, how
- 29:59it's going to play out, what the goal is. Are
- 30:02there distributions necessary? Are they contemplated
- 30:07at all? Is that unlikely? Look forward a little
- 30:11bit and understand how this is going to be utilized.
- 30:14And I can share with you from our standpoint,
- 30:19we're not necessarily endorsing or lobbying for
- 30:22more asset protection trusts, but it is a tool
- 30:25that is very useful and attractive to some folks.
- 30:28And it's critical that it be done correctly.
- 30:31So with that, we can move on to the third party
- 30:34aspect of this. It's a little friendlier, a little
- 30:37easier to navigate. Yeah, definitely. The third
- 30:42party aspect of this is not only easier to navigate,
- 30:46but it's the really the optimal form of protection.
- 30:49So, right, if you've got a child, I can think
- 30:53of a client who's got a child whose daughter
- 30:56is a gynecologist, right, there's a lot of, or
- 30:57excuse me, an OBGYN, and that's a high risk profession
- 31:01these days. And so, you know, it's one of those
- 31:04things. So the parents are setting up a third
- 31:07party asset protection trust in that case for
- 31:10the benefit of their daughter. And right, pretty
- 31:12straightforward, just as we talked I think most
- 31:15of you know what a third party asset protection
- 31:17trust is. It's just a trust established by the
- 31:19grantor for other beneficiaries. The grantor
- 31:21can retain quite a few powers in those trusts.
- 31:24They can fire and hire trustees. They can have
- 31:27investment control in a directed trust situation.
- 31:31If you have a complete gift, you can keep a lifetime
- 31:35or testamentary power of appointment. The trust
- 31:39is usually must be fully discretionary to get
- 31:41these maximum creditor protection benefits. And
- 31:46if you think about things like a SLAT, a SLAT
- 31:48is often an asset protection trust, right? Because
- 31:51it can benefit the grantor spouse. So something
- 31:54to keep in mind. The point sort of being that
- 31:58if a client is sued while they're a resident
- 32:01of a non -domestic asset protection trust, so
- 32:04somewhere like California, the trust should be
- 32:08designed to still provide these creditor protections
- 32:11even though it's not, because it's not self -settled.
- 32:13It should still be fine. So that's sort of the
- 32:15point. And now we did promise that we would compare.
- 32:20So upfront, sort of when you look at every comparison
- 32:23everywhere, I mean, AI Gemini and Chad GBT and
- 32:26all things will now do it for you. But I do think
- 32:29there's much more reputable places to get all
- 32:31this information. And so in general, Nevada and
- 32:34South Dakota are sort of considered the first
- 32:36tier in terms of their statutes and how they're
- 32:39written. Alaska, Tennessee, Delaware, and Wyoming
- 32:42are sort of the second tier. And I'll sort of
- 32:45tell you why. It's because Delaware does have
- 32:49statutory exemption creditors for child support
- 32:52for maintenance and for marital property and
- 32:55they also have a four -year creditor statute
- 32:57of limitations. Alaska and Wyoming have the same
- 33:02four -year look back statute of limitations for
- 33:06future and pre -existing creditors whereas Alaska
- 33:09then has an exception for marital property and
- 33:13Wyoming allows it for child support. So depending
- 33:16on where you're drafting those are some things
- 33:18to keep in mind. My understanding is that South
- 33:21Dakota, which is pretty new on the scene for
- 33:23those of you who are sort of in this game, that
- 33:26they pretty much mirrored Nevada statute when
- 33:28they were. creating their asset protection statutes.
- 33:32So really, the only real difference is that South
- 33:35Dakota does allow an exception for divorcing
- 33:40spouses in regards to transfers that were made
- 33:43prior to marriage. And then in those cases, they
- 33:47require notice to your spouse. So that's the
- 33:51small difference between South Dakota and Nevada.
- 33:57a joke, but it's not before we get into things
- 34:01that are more, I guess. more substantive. I do
- 34:03think it's really important to talk about the
- 34:05efficiency of the court system in different states.
- 34:08I cannot pretend to be well -versed in all of
- 34:11the Big Five's state court systems, but I can't
- 34:15compare Nevada to both California and Arizona,
- 34:18which I'm licensed in Arizona. I've done quite
- 34:19a bit of work in both Arizona and California,
- 34:22and neither of those are particularly efficient.
- 34:24I'm sure I'm preaching to the choir with all
- 34:28of you who do practice in in California, but
- 34:32a probate in Washoe County where I reside in
- 34:35Reno. It's timely, it's efficient, it's incredibly
- 34:39well run by our local county probate commissioner.
- 34:43And for any of you who have done work in Clark
- 34:45County, which is where Las Vegas is located,
- 34:48I will note that there used to be some pretty
- 34:50serious delays by our standards in Nevada for
- 34:54a number of years, but we have now hired a second
- 34:57probate commissioner. And so that's been really
- 34:59beneficial and helpful for the system and to
- 35:02keep things moving. Bob, do you want to talk
- 35:06about directed trusts? Sure. Yeah, I love that
- 35:10ad. I think I got a call a few years ago as the
- 35:13lawyer in the family from my nephew. And it's
- 35:15funny how he honestly for a split second in his
- 35:18current state thought there was some legal protection
- 35:22saying what happens in Vegas actually stays in
- 35:25Vegas. So that is an interesting approach. We
- 35:28see a lot of directed trusts. We think it's a
- 35:31great vehicle for a lot of families that have
- 35:34unique or concentrated positions. Unique assets
- 35:37can be the family business, can be a specific
- 35:40holding. My favorite when I started several years
- 35:43ago was a minor league baseball team. The family
- 35:47loved this team. It was part of the family kind
- 35:49of culture. or what they believed in. It stood
- 35:54for a lot of things that are really kind of just
- 35:57core fundamental, this was a Midwestern kind
- 36:00of family beliefs. Yet they agreed and we agreed
- 36:03quickly with them that we would not be ideal
- 36:05to run their minor league baseball team. So quickly
- 36:09in the planning process with the attorneys, found
- 36:13ourselves in a direct -to -trust situation, which
- 36:15seemed to be truly a win -win. They had complete
- 36:19control to do whatever they wanted. And if you
- 36:21remember some of the minor league you know, different
- 36:27things that we're trying to get people in the
- 36:29stadium, we really didn't want to be, nor did
- 36:31the trust want to be exposed to some of those
- 36:34opportunities for additional marketing. But they
- 36:38liked it. They really enjoyed it. And it was
- 36:40more of a hobby. This wasn't where they made
- 36:42their money. This wasn't where they were going
- 36:45to continue to support family and next generation.
- 36:48So it was an interesting aspect that highlighted
- 36:50in a number of ways the benefits of a directed
- 36:52trust. As Kristen has in this slide, All states
- 36:56now have some version of a Directed Trust Statute.
- 37:00California recently adopted one. a variety of
- 37:05versions, really, but the bottom line is they're
- 37:08all pretty similar. The difference, just to touch
- 37:10on it very briefly, is California does have,
- 37:14at least could be argued, a monitoring requirement,
- 37:17and Nevada's and many others are a complete exculpatory
- 37:20approach. There is complete isolation in these
- 37:24activities, which, again, for those of you representing
- 37:26trustees, those of you even explaining these
- 37:29for the clients, That's a critical piece. Do
- 37:32they want complete autonomy in the operation
- 37:35of that asset? And those are unique assets, family
- 37:38businesses. We shift to what's commonly what
- 37:41we're seeing more and more of is a block of Apple
- 37:44stock that's the majority of their wealth, Nvidia
- 37:47stock more recently, AI -related companies that
- 37:51has now moved from a minor position in the overall
- 37:54portfolio to a more prominent concentrated position
- 37:58within the portfolio. And those are things that
- 38:00can be adjusted over time to shift to a directed
- 38:03trust, to address those. They may or may not
- 38:07want to part with that or trim that exposure.
- 38:10The capital gain consequence is pretty significant,
- 38:13and they may like the holding. So a directed
- 38:16trust works well for that. We saw in the late
- 38:1980s, I'm sorry, wasn't practicing that far ago,
- 38:23despite what Kristen may say. But in the 2008,
- 38:279, 10 period, where real estate values declined
- 38:30significantly, we saw the balance of the portfolio
- 38:34shift to take some real estate assets, and now
- 38:37they were a concentrated position. This was an
- 38:40area where that could solve the problem. It could
- 38:42still function in a variety of ways, but the
- 38:45ultimate risk is then accepted and borne by the
- 38:49proper party, the family that wanted to retain
- 38:51those legacy assets. And in most of the Western
- 38:54United States, real estate is a fundamental part.
- 38:57to their net worth, to their holdings, to their
- 39:00income, to kind of the family core beliefs and
- 39:03values. So I think directed trust is really an
- 39:06area where they are being recognized as more
- 39:11useful and being utilized more effectively over
- 39:15the last half you know, half dozen years, and
- 39:18I think they're going to be more and more important
- 39:19as we kind of see this concentration of wealth
- 39:23continue. Most trustees are more than comfortable
- 39:27with marketable securities, but at some point,
- 39:29there gets a concentration level that's too high,
- 39:33and then you have a significant consequence.
- 39:35The one more story I remember vividly is a client's
- 39:40large, large position in GE. Each year, the individual
- 39:45client advisor sat down with the family. It was
- 39:48a couple of meetings a year and each meeting
- 39:50raised the issue. And the client in each case
- 39:53said, I was one of the early shareholders. I'm
- 39:56never selling this stock. And so we shifted that
- 39:59to a directed trust, moved the entire position
- 40:02over and each year again, asked him to consider,
- 40:05reconsider, trim it. And each time it was absolutely
- 40:09not. So as you can see where the story was going,
- 40:13GE is now a fraction of what it was, the children
- 40:16who were in those meetings heard their father
- 40:18take his position, immediately threatened to
- 40:20sue the trust company for letting that happen,
- 40:23letting that dramatic decline in wealth, that
- 40:27evisceration of their family wealth happen. So
- 40:31these kinds of things are tools that we all need
- 40:34to look for and continue to document and have
- 40:36the conversations. These won't act as a complete
- 40:40safeguard in many cases, but that together with
- 40:43proper communication and addressing these issues
- 40:46up front and consistently will certainly help
- 40:49should those situations arise. With that, I'll
- 40:52hand off to decanting and more exciting Nevada.
- 40:58Directed trusts are incredibly important, incredibly
- 41:01important in what we're all doing these days
- 41:03during the great wealth transfer. And I think
- 41:05that also highlights the importance of decanting.
- 41:08A lot of us are dealing with very old trusts,
- 41:11maybe not some great provisions. And many, many
- 41:15practitioners, trust companies, research groups.
- 41:18better than I have analyzed decanting statutes
- 41:22and attempted to determine who has the best one,
- 41:25usually based on things like ease of use and
- 41:27flexibility. One thing I will say is despite
- 41:30those charts, what I found in practice is that
- 41:33some of the quote unquote lower ranked decanting
- 41:36states slash statutes may actually be the better
- 41:41option for some of your clients because of the
- 41:44unique flexibility they provide. So Similarly,
- 41:48our presentation, so I'm going to give my opinion,
- 41:50is that I actually don't think that the adoption
- 41:53of the Uniform Decanting Act, it's not necessarily
- 41:55a bad thing, right? Because it does mean that
- 41:57it allows for decantings to occur. But it does
- 42:00lead to a pretty average statute, in my personal
- 42:04opinion. And so states that don't adopt the Uniform
- 42:07Decanting Act usually have some greater flexibility.
- 42:10That's a place to start if you're looking to
- 42:12do some unique decantings. Just a quick Before
- 42:17we sort of dive into the quick comparisons on
- 42:19the decanting statutes, I mean, I think. Most
- 42:21of you here joining this presentation know some
- 42:23of the common reasons for decanting. These are
- 42:25ones that we see all the time, right? Maybe you
- 42:27need to change the governing law. There's an
- 42:30ambiguous term. Are you trying to extend the
- 42:32term of a trust, meaning like from mandatory
- 42:35distributions to like dynastic, right? Changing
- 42:39the support trust into a discretionary trust,
- 42:41modifying powers of appointment, merging or separating
- 42:45trusts, right? Maybe you have a pot trust. Changing
- 42:47some of the trustee powers. potentially creating
- 42:50a special needs trust. Those are the reasons
- 42:52at least I'm commonly seeing. And this is, again,
- 42:56wasn't going to pretend, like I said, there's
- 42:58research groups and other people who have created
- 43:02analyses on state decanting charts. This is the
- 43:05Steve Wimberg and Steve Ocean's chart that's
- 43:08available on their website. Also, I think you
- 43:09guys have these materials. But what this really
- 43:12tells you is that Nevada has a very broad decanting
- 43:15statute. according to this chart, arguably the
- 43:18second most broad according to this chart. Some
- 43:21things that I think were important. And when
- 43:23you think about when you're comparing these statutes
- 43:25or things like, does the beneficiary have to
- 43:26get notice of their decanting? Can you remove
- 43:29a mandatory income interest? Can you grant a
- 43:32power of appointment to a non -beneficiary in
- 43:34the second trust? Some comparison points that
- 43:38I think are interesting is that Nevada and South
- 43:40Dakota are nearly identical in that they don't
- 43:43require this notice to the beneficiaries. But
- 43:46from a corporate trustee perspective, right,
- 43:48where Bob and I are now sitting or for any of
- 43:51your clients, if you're representing any trustees,
- 43:53individual or corporate, I think it's really
- 43:56important to know that Nevada law provides a
- 43:58protective feature to trustees who decant. So
- 44:01there's a statutory right of the trustees to
- 44:03either send a notice of proposed action, a non
- 44:05-judicial settlement agreement or to petition
- 44:07the court. So if you represent trustees to give
- 44:11notice that you're decanting or to get sign off.
- 44:13So if you're representing trustees who are maybe
- 44:16hesitant to decant, I think it can be really
- 44:18important to just emphasize that. And so that
- 44:23sort of leads to, I keep saying NJSA. So I'm
- 44:25sorry, that is such our shorthand for saying
- 44:27this, which I know is not necessarily a thing
- 44:31in California, but a non -judicial settlement
- 44:33agreement. which these are really, really important.
- 44:38So notice is a proposed action, non -judicial
- 44:40settlement agreements, both of which are very
- 44:42well established in Nevada. And we put the statutes
- 44:48on the next couple of slides. So this is the
- 44:50non -judicial settlement agreement statute. And
- 44:54I'll let Bob touch on that for a tiny bit. I'll
- 44:59just make a few comments. Similar to the directed
- 45:03trusts, non -judicial settlement agreements are
- 45:06one of the more utilized tools kind of in the
- 45:09arsenal and the available statutes for Nevada.
- 45:14And there are similar statutes in other states,
- 45:16but as is described here, and you can look at
- 45:19it later, the key is the ability to modify an
- 45:24irrevocable trust. after creation. And it's for
- 45:28a limited set of uses, but they're extremely
- 45:30broad. And a lot of times we were trying to move
- 45:33a trust from California to Nevada, add a directed
- 45:36trust provision to it, things like that that
- 45:39are staying within the principal purpose of the
- 45:43trust. But all parties agree and are available
- 45:46to sign off all indispensable parties, which
- 45:49is critical. Then you can do this very quickly,
- 45:52very easily without court involvement at all.
- 45:55And so one of the ways we see this more often
- 45:59than not is the opportunity to move it into Nevada,
- 46:03decant certain provisions, get it to Nevada,
- 46:06modify the trust to reflect the current goals
- 46:09and objectives of the family, make it a little
- 46:11more tax efficient, modify certain provisions
- 46:13for what evolved into a... you know, a concentration
- 46:18or a unique situation. And everybody's on board
- 46:21and everybody's pleased with the outcome, at
- 46:23least for the time being. It doesn't solve the
- 46:25problem forever because times change and things
- 46:28come up. But it gives you gives us the ability
- 46:31to modify the current irrevocable document. So
- 46:34we we see this and utilize this particular statute
- 46:38often. And they often, you know, if there's additional
- 46:41protections needed, it works hand in hand with
- 46:43the notice of proposed action should you know,
- 46:46that that need arise. That's very rare. But what
- 46:50we want to do is make sure that all the pieces
- 46:52fit and everybody's on the same page and all
- 46:54all transparent, all fully disclosed. And I think,
- 46:59again, putting us and your clients in the best
- 47:02position possible to move forward without any
- 47:05more attention or strain, which is something
- 47:08that's a nice I'd like to win a lottery as well.
- 47:12But certain things that are, you know, in the
- 47:14moment objectives we can help a client with.
- 47:17And this is one of the tools that has become
- 47:18very effective. Yeah, and I think it's really
- 47:22important to mention, I put this indispensable
- 47:25party slide up on the board. So if you go back,
- 47:28you can do all of these amazing things, terminate
- 47:30a trust, change how trusts are invested, add
- 47:33terms, delete terms. You can essentially do almost
- 47:36anything you want with a non -judicial settlement
- 47:37agreement. But it does require all indispensable
- 47:40parties to sign off. So when you think about
- 47:42the way we draft irrevocable trusts, What happens
- 47:45when you have minors or of course future generations
- 47:47who are not yet born? That's of course the one
- 47:49we're all dealing with on a regular basis. And
- 47:53fortunately in Nevada, we allow for what we call
- 47:56virtual representation. I call this the unsung
- 47:59hero of Nevada law because it doesn't get the
- 48:03time and attention that it should get. But it
- 48:05specifically provides that a minor incapacitated
- 48:08unborn person or person whose identity or location
- 48:11is unknown and not reasonably ascertainable may
- 48:14be represented by another person who has a substantially
- 48:17similar interest with respect to the question
- 48:20or dispute. So long as there is no material conflict
- 48:25of interest between the person and the representative
- 48:27with respect to the question at issue. So in
- 48:32very basic terms, what that means, 90 % of the
- 48:35time, 99 % of the time, if you have a minor or
- 48:38an unborn person who's not represented by another
- 48:41person, like a parent or guardian pursuant to
- 48:43this statute, then they can be represented basically
- 48:48by the person who's standing in their shoes.
- 48:50So, you know, if you've got a 25 -year -old kid,
- 48:53they can sign on behalf of themselves and all
- 48:55their heirs, successors and assigns. So, yeah,
- 48:58it's pretty great. It really allows us to not
- 49:02have to go to court all the time, basically all
- 49:05the time, unless there's really a need to go
- 49:07to court, petition the court for some sort of
- 49:09approval. So it's really the unsung hero. It's
- 49:11hard to even... downplay how important that provision
- 49:16is. Yeah, and most everybody on this call is
- 49:19very familiar, probably intimately familiar,
- 49:21with the guardian ad litem issue. And this essentially
- 49:24solves that for the appropriate cases, which
- 49:27even if you're not in court, you're stuck with
- 49:30that unborn, that minor... you're unable to move
- 49:35forward without this type of statute or getting
- 49:38a guardianal item and going to court. So it's
- 49:41hard to overemphasize how important the virtual
- 49:45representation piece has come to fit with all
- 49:47the other pieces we've covered today and why
- 49:49that makes some of these states, Nevada in particular,
- 49:53as Kristen is passionate about, extremely friendly
- 49:57to manage and accomplish the family's goals and
- 50:01objectives. So speaking of goals and objectives,
- 50:05we are going to talk about silent trust. And
- 50:07I'll move through this relatively quickly because
- 50:09I want to be cognizant of time. But basically,
- 50:12what's a silent trust, right? So a silent trust
- 50:14can really do one or more of five things. So
- 50:17it can prohibit the disclosure of the existence
- 50:19of the trust. It can prohibit or restrict the
- 50:22release of the trust agreement. It can prohibit
- 50:24the disclosure of assets or other financial information
- 50:27related to what's in the trust. It can prohibit
- 50:29the release of an accounting. or it can allow
- 50:32the trustee to redact. Those are really the reasons
- 50:35that you might have a silent trust. Something
- 50:37I think is particularly important is that just
- 50:40because a trust is secret or silent, it does
- 50:42not mean that nobody knows, right? The set law
- 50:45knows about it. The attorney who drafted it knows
- 50:47about it. The accountant may know about it, depending
- 50:50on the type of trust. The IRS may know about
- 50:52it, depending on if there's a return required.
- 50:55The Secretary of State may know about it. If
- 50:58there's a business filing, the SEC may know about
- 51:01it. The governments, both foreign and domestic
- 51:04may know. Of course, when the Corporate Transparency
- 51:06Act was being considered, that was a big concern.
- 51:11Bankers, title companies, and financial advisors
- 51:13may know, and the recorder's office may know.
- 51:16And so why are clients looking to set up silent
- 51:20trusts, right? The first one, the most obvious
- 51:22one that we see is beneficiary concern, right?
- 51:24They're unable to manage information because
- 51:26of their age or their maturity and they don't
- 51:28want to disincentivize their young children.
- 51:30That's pretty common. maybe the number one reason
- 51:32that we see. You have privacy concerns, right?
- 51:35Those are historically high profile individuals,
- 51:38but now it's also being done for identity protection
- 51:41purposes. Maybe you're giving unequal distributions
- 51:44to someone. So you don't have litigation or deal
- 51:48with that. So maybe you want a silent trust.
- 51:50Maybe you want to protect your beneficiaries
- 51:52from bad actors, so creditors or divorcing spouses.
- 51:56And of course, the last reason could of course
- 51:58be to defraud because you want to hide assets.
- 52:01That is almost never happening just transparently
- 52:04I think that's what people tell when they're
- 52:06afraid of silent trusts and I am not obviously
- 52:09a proponent sitting up here telling you that
- 52:11silent trusts are I'm actually hoping to kind
- 52:13of convince you otherwise that silent trust should
- 52:15not be your default Because they don't work for
- 52:18very for many people or they should only be silent
- 52:21for a period of time But of course defrauding
- 52:25does happen. So But what are our practical problems,
- 52:31right? When you think about silent trust, as
- 52:32I said, I'm not gonna be the person who's sitting
- 52:34up here today telling you that everything should
- 52:36be a silent trust. One is of course distributions.
- 52:40So how do you make a distribution without? disclosing
- 52:43the existence of the trust. The second is tax
- 52:46compliance, right? Do you have a K -1? Do you
- 52:48have distributable net income? Do you have flow
- 52:51through tax treatments? How are you dealing with
- 52:53that if you can't disclose the existence of the
- 52:55trust? What about crummy powers? Can't send a
- 52:58crummy notice to someone who doesn't know about
- 53:00the trust? about assets, how about titling, right?
- 53:04How do you properly title something if you can't
- 53:07disclose the information? So sometimes that's
- 53:09avoidable, sometimes it's not. And banking and
- 53:12financial transactions. So high level. can you
- 53:15continue to operate if you have a business, for
- 53:18example, your business without some form of disclosure?
- 53:21We have a client who is currently going through
- 53:24this struggle where they have some silent trust
- 53:26set up and they are looking to refinance a loan.
- 53:29And in order to refinance the loan, there has
- 53:31to be some form of disclosure. And it is an absolute
- 53:34nightmare. It's just an unforeseen nightmare
- 53:36that I don't think the client anticipated or
- 53:39was looking and was anticipating. And it's really
- 53:43been difficult to deal with. We're getting to
- 53:45the point where some form of disclosure is just
- 53:47going to have to be made to one of the beneficiaries,
- 53:49unfortunately. But it just sort of those are
- 53:52things that when you're thinking about silent
- 53:54trust, maybe that's not what you're thinking
- 53:55about. And it's definitely not what your clients
- 53:58are thinking about. So just be careful how you're
- 54:01framing a silent trust, because at the end of
- 54:03the day, excuse me, at the end of the day, you're
- 54:06the one who's going to have to answer to the
- 54:08client when they get frustrated. So the other
- 54:10norm. Yeah, go ahead. Well, yeah, you'll get
- 54:14to that in a second. Just to add on to that,
- 54:16the client in particular would be a traditional
- 54:18success story. Came to the attorney, attorney
- 54:21outlined a number of different options. And in
- 54:24this process, as Kristen said, highlighted, okay,
- 54:26you know, there are these features and of course
- 54:29we would don't want to disincent the kids. We
- 54:31don't want to alter their future, their trajectory,
- 54:36by losing momentum to actually make it for themselves.
- 54:40But like many of your clients, especially the
- 54:43family business owners, those folks have succeeded
- 54:49at what they do. And it's very relatively simple.
- 54:52They get up, they go to work, they do extremely
- 54:54well, they go home. And then they meet the estate
- 54:56planning attorney and tells them, we've got to
- 54:59deal with your estate tax issue. So now they
- 55:02had a very simple form of life where they could
- 55:05access a few different buckets to expand, to
- 55:08develop, to go into different ventures, to acquire
- 55:12more inventory, whatever it is that they needed
- 55:13to do. Now those assets are in different buckets,
- 55:18as Kristen explained. And those buckets aren't
- 55:20necessarily as easily accessible to start with.
- 55:23And then when you add a silent trust feature,
- 55:26And the children also happened to be in the business
- 55:28and were not intended to see those components.
- 55:32All of a sudden, you had a months -long emotional
- 55:37struggle to try and figure out how they can accomplish
- 55:39the financial, the business goals, yet not blow
- 55:42up the trust they created. And that is not uncommon.
- 55:46I think, you know, similar to asset protection
- 55:47trust, these need to be very carefully thought
- 55:49through. And as you work with trustees in this
- 55:54process, understand how best to deal with that,
- 55:57as you can certainly understand if there is no
- 56:02notice, if there is no knowledge of statements,
- 56:06of what the assets are, the inflow, the outflow,
- 56:08all those things that create statute limitations
- 56:10for us trustees, and put them on notice if those
- 56:14things don't exist. we really are in a tough
- 56:17position to figure out how to navigate what our
- 56:19exposure is and how best to manage that. And
- 56:22Kristen will get into some of the, you know,
- 56:24as a proxy, there are a variety of ways to mitigate
- 56:27that to some extent, but it's an interesting
- 56:29dynamic. Yeah, it's a really, really interesting
- 56:33dynamic. And I think I do want to highlight for
- 56:35those of you because, again, geographically,
- 56:37Nevada is the closest geographically to California.
- 56:39Many of you are maybe drafting Nevada Silent
- 56:41Trusts. There's a couple of things I do really
- 56:43want to highlight for those of you who are drafting
- 56:45these types of trusts. One, if you're not currently
- 56:47drafting Nevada Silent Trusts, just know it's
- 56:50not a separate statute. It's NRS 163 .004, which
- 56:55is our trust accounting statute. That's where
- 56:57Nevada Silent Trust laws sort of fit in is to
- 57:00not require the need to account. You should also
- 57:03know that the default in Nevada is silent. So
- 57:06if you don't, unless you have conflicting provisions
- 57:09requiring an accounting and requiring other types
- 57:13of things that would make it not a silent trust,
- 57:15as we just sort of talked about, that is the
- 57:17default in Nevada now is actually a silent trust.
- 57:20So again, if you're drafting Nevada trust. Please
- 57:22be particularly careful about how you're drafting.
- 57:26Our statute does not specifically mention a designated
- 57:28representative. If you are familiar with Delaware's
- 57:31silent trust laws, then there has to be a set
- 57:34period of time in Delaware. In Nevada, that's
- 57:36not the case. But I would still urge all of you
- 57:39to draft with an end. an end in mind for when
- 57:43a trust is going to be the end is not going to
- 57:45be silent, right? Because again, do you really
- 57:47want to have trusts that exist in perpetuity
- 57:50forever and ever and ever with nobody being held
- 57:52accountable? You never have to account. You never
- 57:53have to. When all of us are long dead and our
- 57:56clients and their kids, does it make sense to
- 57:59really have a silent trust continuing on? One
- 58:03thing that I do think is particularly important
- 58:04to talk about, this is a case that I've put on
- 58:07the screen. It's a Nevada case, which is a silent
- 58:10trust case without saying it's a silent trust.
- 58:13At the end of the day, the Nevada Supreme Court
- 58:14did uphold the right to silent trust in the state
- 58:18of Nevada. So there are some drafting considerations,
- 58:21but I want to be very cognizant of time. So the
- 58:23very last thing that I think, so I do think,
- 58:25look at these, if you're drafting these trusts.
- 58:27Please, please, please think about these things
- 58:29and draft in a manner that makes sense if you're
- 58:32drafting silent trusts. But the last thing I
- 58:35really want to touch on, because Bob did talk
- 58:37about the rule against perpetuities, which is
- 58:40365 years in Nevada, South Dakota and Alaska
- 58:44are perpetual. Delaware is perpetual, except
- 58:47real estate's 100 years. So in case you were
- 58:49here for all my comparisons, there you go. But
- 58:51the last thing I want to talk about really quickly
- 58:53in Nevada is privacy. It's really all the big
- 58:56five, but it's privacy and confidentiality. And
- 58:59that is that you, really, there's no public disclosure
- 59:01of trust documents or the identity of beneficiaries.
- 59:04That information is very easily sealable. But
- 59:07there is a case, which is a direct result of
- 59:10the Murdoch family dispute, which I think everybody
- 59:14who lives in this space is well versed in at
- 59:17this point. It's called New York Times Co. versus
- 59:19the district court. It's a Nevada advanced opinion,
- 59:22as we sit here right now, just came out at the
- 59:24very end, like less than two months ago, by our
- 59:28Nevada Supreme Court. We have sort of an evolving
- 59:30landscape on this. I used to just say that you
- 59:34could very easily seal anything could be filed
- 59:36under seal was very easy process. That's how
- 59:38we were handling. complex, maybe high publicity
- 59:42trust matters. Well, the very high level summary
- 59:45of this case is that the Nevada Supreme Court
- 59:48concluded that the district court erred by determining
- 59:51that the statute removes its discretion to consider
- 59:54redaction instead of sealing. And also that the
- 59:58public's interest in the case was not de minimis,
- 1:00:00and so the public has a right to access. Those
- 1:00:04of us who operate in this space are not super
- 1:00:06content with this ruling. I'm involved in a legislative
- 1:00:11board. It's actually the probate interest section
- 1:00:13of the Nevada State Bar. We hire a lobbyist.
- 1:00:16We're very active. And so are we're in session
- 1:00:20as I mentioned our legislative session only meets
- 1:00:22every other year we're in session this year and
- 1:00:25there's probably some changes coming to some
- 1:00:27of our um sealing procedures and so just some
- 1:00:30of the process for how we go about public discourse
- 1:00:32and public access to information so stay tuned
- 1:00:35these things are evolving um even in Nevada but
- 1:00:38they're evolving everywhere and so um I just
- 1:00:41felt like it was important to talk about some
- 1:00:43of that. Um, I think everyone's also aware of
- 1:00:45what's happening in Delaware. There's a lot of
- 1:00:47interesting things happening, um, in Delaware
- 1:00:49with their court system as well, particularly
- 1:00:51as it relates to corporate matters. So I think
- 1:00:55sort of on that note, I mean, I just, I want
- 1:00:57to wrap this up. Um, I think Nevada is obviously
- 1:01:00the best. I want to be very cognizant of everybody's
- 1:01:02time, but I think all of the big five are worthy
- 1:01:04of consideration. Um, when you're thinking about
- 1:01:07what's your clients, uh, what fits and what works
- 1:01:09for your clients. So. Aubrey, I can turn it back
- 1:01:13to you so you can close. Thank you, Kristin.
- 1:01:19That was wonderful, you guys. I want to extend
- 1:01:22a massive thank you to both of you for presenting.
- 1:01:25That concludes our program for today. Our next
- 1:01:28program will be on March 17th, which will be
- 1:01:31our annual updates from the probate judges. So
- 1:01:34that's a lot to look forward to. Thanks again,
- 1:01:36Kristin and Bob, and we'll see you next time.