Latest / Deep Values: Value Investing Deep Dives / Intel Q3 2025 Financial Analysis: A High-Stakes Wager
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome back to the Deep Dive. Today we're tackling well what
- 0:03might just be one of the most ambitious, maybe even make or
- 0:06break corporate turnarounds we've seen in tech for a long
- 0:09time. Intel Corporation, ticker INTC.
- 0:14Yeah, ambitious is definitely the word.
- 0:15I mean, this isn't just a minor course correction.
- 0:18Intel's basically trying to rebuild its core identity, its
- 0:20whole engine, while the industry landscape is shifting under its
- 0:24feet. Right O our mission today is
- 0:26really to unpack this huge bet they're making the IDM 20
- 0:30strategy. It's incredibly capital
- 0:33intensive integrated device manufacturing 20.
- 0:36We need to figure out if the massive financial risk they're
- 0:38taking on lines up with the potential payoff of, you know,
- 0:42actually reclaiming leadership in semiconductors.
- 0:44It feels like a massive question, is Intel still that
- 0:46dominant giant just hitting a rough patch or has it
- 0:49fundamentally changed? You know, maybe become more of a
- 0:52deep value play, something needing a really high tolerance
- 0:54for risk. Let's try and get into it.
- 0:56So IDM 2 point O. The sheer scale of it is kind of
- 0:59mind boggling for listeners. Maybe not grew to the chip
- 1:02sector day-to-day. Can you break down what this
- 1:04strategy actually involves? What's it mean for Intel to
- 1:10effectively split itself? It's a fundamental break from
- 1:12their past, really. For decades, Intel designed its
- 1:15own chips and manufactured only its own chips.
- 1:19That was the model IDM 2 point O basically decouples those two.
- 1:22OK. The idea is to create Intel
- 1:24Foundry Services IFS as a separate business unit, a world
- 1:28class cutting edge foundry that can build chips not just for
- 1:31Intel's product groups, but for external customers too,
- 1:34competing head to head with the big guys like TSMC.
- 1:36So hold on. They're asking their own
- 1:39manufacturing arm to not only catch up to the world leaders
- 1:42which they fell behind, but to potentially leapfrog them and
- 1:45then convince their competitors to become customers.
- 1:47That's the plan. It sounds audacious, I know.
- 1:50And maybe the most eye popping part is the timeline.
- 1:52They've set 5 nodes in four. Years 5 nodes 4 years.
- 1:56Yeah, that's their benchmark for success.
- 1:58They're trying to cram maybe a decades worth of process
- 2:01technology catch up into just four years.
- 2:03The goal is manufacturing leadership again by 2025.
- 2:07It demands well near perfect engineering execution and just
- 2:10billions upon billions in capital.
- 2:12OK, that context really frames the recent Q32024 earnings.
- 2:16Then it was seen as maybe the first real sign that this
- 2:19incredibly expensive ship might be studying.
- 2:22What did we actually see in those numbers?
- 2:24It definitely brought some relief.
- 2:25Yeah, sign of stabilization. Revenue is pretty solid $13.7
- 2:29billion, but the the real headline grabber was profit.
- 2:33Non jap EPS came in at 0, all around $0.23. $0.23 and the
- 2:38expectation was? Way lower.
- 2:39Some analysts were down around like a penny per share, so $0.23
- 2:44was a huge beat. Understandably, the market
- 2:46reacted pretty strongly. Stock jumped what, 7.7% right
- 2:49after? OK, so on the surface a clear
- 2:50win, but you mentioned this idea of A2 speed recovery.
- 2:53Where's the catch if the long term Moat is still shaky?
- 2:56What were analysts picking apart under that positive headline?
- 2:59Well, the recovery, if you can call it that yet is definitely
- 3:03lopsided. Almost all the strength came
- 3:05from their traditional business, the client computing group CCG.
- 3:08That's PC chips. Right, the old reliable.
- 3:11Exactly. It was up 5% year over year.
- 3:13It's providing this vital kind of predictable financial cushion
- 3:17while they try to execute the big strategy.
- 3:20But the problem area, the strategically critical part for
- 3:22the future is data center and AI or DCAI.
- 3:26And how did that do? That actually lagged.
- 3:28It was down to 1%, not a huge drop, but it shows that in the
- 3:32really high margin server market where the future growth is
- 3:35supposed to be, they're still feeling intense competitive
- 3:37pressure. That 1% decline, even if small,
- 3:41really underscores the challenge from competitors like AMD in
- 3:44that space. It does.
- 3:46But, and this is crucial, what makes this whole turn around
- 3:48attempt even possible is the enormous amount of external
- 3:51support and frankly, de risking that happened.
- 3:54Intel isn't going it alone here. You mean the government funding?
- 3:57That's a huge piece of it, Yeah. They landed $5.7 billion from
- 4:01the USCIFES Act. That's a massive government
- 4:04investment helping to foot the bill for these new fabs.
- 4:07And then there are those really interesting private investments
- 4:10too, right from some surprising name.
- 4:12Absolutely fascinating. You've got $5.0 billion coming
- 4:15in from NVIDIA. Their competitor?
- 4:17Technically. Well, yeah, competitor in some
- 4:19areas, potential massive customer and others now, right?
- 4:22And another $2.0 billion from SoftBank Group.
- 4:25These aren't small checks. These players wouldn't put that
- 4:27kind of capital down unless they saw two things.
- 4:30One, Intel becoming a necessary part of the global supply chain
- 4:34again, maybe diversification from TSMC.
- 4:37And two, that IFS, the founder business has a credible shot at
- 4:41being competitive. It provides a significant safety
- 4:44net for this whole effort. And to steer this massive ship,
- 4:47we saw some pretty decisive moves at the top too.
- 4:50A real sense of urgency, maybe new CEO Le Batan came in and
- 4:54there was big executive shake up.
- 4:55Yeah, former CEO out, products chief out.
- 4:59That's what happens when a company hits an existential
- 5:01crisis, essentially. It's not just about tweaking
- 5:03things. You have to break down the old
- 5:05ways of thinking, the institutional inertia that
- 5:08frankly allowed their main competitive advantage, their
- 5:10economic mode, to crumble in the first place.
- 5:12OK, let's talk about that Moat. Right, the economic mode.
- 5:15It's the core reason for all this upheaval.
- 5:18As you know, Warren Buffett famously described it.
- 5:20It's that durable competitive advantage, the thing that
- 5:23Shields a company's profits from competitors over the long haul.
- 5:27And Intel's Moat used to be legendary, like a fortress.
- 5:31What were the main walls of that fortress?
- 5:33What made them seem so unbeatable for so long?
- 5:36It really rested on three huge pillars.
- 5:38First was just massive economies of scale.
- 5:41Being a vertically integrated IDM, designing and making
- 5:44everything in house gave them enormous production volumes that
- 5:48drove their cost per chip down to levels rivals just couldn't
- 5:50touch. Makes sense?
- 5:512nd intangible assets. Think Intel inside that brand
- 5:56was incredibly powerful. Plus they had this iron grip on
- 5:59the BI 86 processor architecture through patents.
- 6:02Very hard for others to compete directly.
- 6:03And the third. High switching costs, the whole
- 6:06Wintel duopoly. Windows and Intel created this
- 6:08incredibly sticky ecosystem, especially for businesses.
- 6:12Once you were in, it was expensive and difficult to
- 6:14switch away. So if that Moat was so
- 6:16formidable, how did it get breached?
- 6:19It feels like it happened relatively quickly from the
- 6:21outside looking in. Well, it.
- 6:22Probably felt quick at the end, but the cracks were forming for
- 6:26a while. It really boils down to a
- 6:28catastrophic internal failure manufacturing.
- 6:31They just stumbled badly on successive generations of their
- 6:35chip technology. The 10 nanometer process, then
- 6:37the seven nanometer years of delays.
- 6:40And that created an opening. A huge opening.
- 6:42Competitors, especially AMD who didn't have their own fabs but
- 6:46used TSMC who wasn't stumbling, just seize the opportunity.
- 6:50They suddenly had chips that were technologically ahead of
- 6:52Intel's. And that hit Intel where it hurt
- 6:54most, right? The data center and the server
- 6:56market. Exactly.
- 6:57That's where the really high margins are, and the market
- 7:00share losses there are just staggering.
- 7:02Think about it, back in 2017 Intel had something like close
- 7:05to 100% of the server CPU market.
- 7:07Basically monopoly. Pretty much today that shares
- 7:10crater to around 63%, maybe even a bit lower.
- 7:13And AMD is still gaining ground with really strong products.
- 7:17But there's another threat too. What's that?
- 7:18The architectural threat. It's not just about AMD using
- 7:22the same by 86 architecture better.
- 7:24It's the rise of ARM based chips you see in Apple's M series
- 7:29chips for laptops, which are incredibly powerful.
- 7:32And now you're seeing it big time in data centers with chips
- 7:35like Amazon's Graviton. To the very foundation the by 86
- 7:39architecture itself is under attack.
- 7:41Potentially, yes. It threatens to shrink Intel
- 7:44score market permanently even if they fix their manufacturing.
- 7:48It's a fundamental challenge to their whole playground.
- 7:50OK, so putting it all together, investing in Intel today isn't
- 7:54like buy into that old secure monopoly anymore.
- 7:57It really is, like you said, a high stakes bet, a wager that
- 8:00they can rebuild that entire Moat starting with the
- 8:03manufacturing foundation basically from the ground up.
- 8:05That's the essence of the investment thesis right now.
- 8:08Right. If that's the story of the
- 8:09competitive decline, let's look at the financial consequences.
- 8:12The numbers don't lie, right? We ran Intel through a kind of
- 8:15classic Buffett style investment checklist.
- 8:18Looking at its track record, how does this former tech giant
- 8:22stack up now against the metrics you'd look for in a truly
- 8:25wonderful company? The. 10 year financial picture
- 8:28is pretty sobering actually. Kind of shocking for a company
- 8:31of Intel's historical stature. It really lays bare how deep the
- 8:34damage has been. OK, hit us with the highlights
- 8:36or maybe the low lights. Let's start with profitability,
- 8:39gross margin, which used to be consistently up around 60%,
- 8:42sometimes higher. Well, on a trailing 12 month
- 8:45basis TTM, it's down to 32.66%. Wow, almost halved.
- 8:51Yeah, and it gets worse. Net margin, what's left after
- 8:54all costs is actually negative right now -8.28% TTM.
- 9:00So fundamentally, they're losing money overall on the chips they
- 9:02sell when you factor everything in.
- 9:04And that's reflected on how they're using shareholder money
- 9:06too, right, the returns on capital.
- 9:07Absolutely. You see clear signs of value
- 9:09destruction trailing 12 months return on retained earnings.
- 9:12Basically, how much value they create from profits they keep in
- 9:15the business is -4.37% and return on invested capital.
- 9:19ROIC, a key measure of efficiency.
- 9:21Also negative -2.70% TTM. So negative ROIC means they're
- 9:26essentially spending money on investments that are losing
- 9:28value. That's the quantitative signal,
- 9:30yes. The investments they're making,
- 9:32primarily these huge fab constructions, are currently
- 9:36costing more than the returns they generate.
- 9:38It shows the business in its current state is destroying
- 9:42capital. And this ties directly back to
- 9:44what you said earlier about the IDM model, those huge fixed
- 9:47costs. It's the double edged sword of
- 9:49being an IDM. When things are good and your
- 9:52fabs are full, the scale is amazing, right?
- 9:55But when you're investing billions in new fabs that aren't
- 9:58running at full capacity yet, or your products aren't competitive
- 10:01enough to fill them, the cost structure is brutal.
- 10:04How brutal? Is there a metric that shows
- 10:05that? Yeah.
- 10:06Look at the ratio of depreciation to gross profit.
- 10:09Depreciation is that non cash expense reflecting the cost of
- 10:12building and equipping those giant factories over time.
- 10:15That ratio has just exploded. It's at 98.18% TTM. 98% What
- 10:20does that mean in plain English? It means that almost all the
- 10:23gross profit Intel makes from selling chips is immediately
- 10:26being eaten up just by the accounting cost of their massive
- 10:29investments in fabs. The fixed cost burden from
- 10:32underutilized, hyper expensive factories is just overwhelming
- 10:36their current profitability. OK, that paints a stark picture,
- 10:40and it explains why management has shifted to what you called a
- 10:43wartime footing, right? They had to make some really
- 10:45tough calls on returning cash to shareholders.
- 10:48Exactly 2 really big flashing signals there.
- 10:51First, they slammed the brakes on share buybacks halted
- 10:54completely back in Q12021, even though they had plenty of
- 10:57authorization left that cash was needed for CapEx for building
- 11:01those fabs. And the dividend that was almost
- 11:03sacred for Intel investors for a long time it.
- 11:06Was but in early 2023 they cut it drastically but about 66%
- 11:11down from .3655 per quarter to few .125 cents.
- 11:15You don't do that unless you absolutely have to preserve
- 11:17cash. These aren't moves a comfortable
- 11:19market leader makes, it's about survival and funding the IDM 2
- 11:23point O turn around above everything else.
- 11:25Understanding that financial pressure is key because it means
- 11:27the stop's value is incredibly leveraged to whether IDM 2 point
- 11:30O actually works. How sensitive is the valuation
- 11:34to them hitting those really ambitious tech goals?
- 11:37Extremely sensitive. We ran a discounted cash flow
- 11:41ADCF analysis and because the risk is so high, we used a
- 11:44pretty high discount rate, a 9.5% weighted average cost of
- 11:47capital or WACC. Even so, the range of potential
- 11:51outcomes, the potential intrinsic values is enormous.
- 11:55OK, layout the scenarios for us. What's the spread look like?
- 11:57Alright, scenario one is the conservative case.
- 12:00Let's see, the turn around only sort of works.
- 12:02They stabilize, maybe stop the bleeding, but they don't really
- 12:05regain clear leadership. Yeah.
- 12:07Our estimate there puts the intrinsic value around $28.50
- 12:10per share. OK, below where it's trading
- 12:12now, right? Then there's the nominal
- 12:13scenario. This assumes IDM 2 point O is
- 12:16largely successful. They hit their manufacturing
- 12:18goals. IFS becomes a real player.
- 12:20They regain significant market share stability.
- 12:22In that case the value jumps quite a bit, up to $45.75.
- 12:26And the best case, the home run. That's the optimistic scenario.
- 12:30This is the Grand Slam. They nail the five nodes in four
- 12:32years. IFS becomes a world leading
- 12:34foundry. They recapture tech leadership
- 12:36across the board. If that happens, the model
- 12:39suggests the value closer to 72 dollars.
- 12:42So with the stock around $38 currently, it looks like the
- 12:45market is pricing in something well, better than outright
- 12:48failure, but nowhere near guaranteed success.
- 12:51Maybe somewhere between conservative and nominal?
- 12:55That seems about right. It suggests the market sees the
- 12:58potential upside of the plan works, but it's heavily
- 13:01discounting for the very real execution risk involved.
- 13:04Which brings us to the actions of some very smart, very risk
- 13:07averse investors. Their trading history in Intel
- 13:09can be a really powerful signal about that underlying risk,
- 13:12can't it? Absolutely.
- 13:14Looking at how people known for deep diligence and avoiding
- 13:16losses have behaved is often quite telling.
- 13:18Let's start with the most famous 1.
- 13:20Warren Buffett. Berkshire Hathaway owned Intel,
- 13:22but not for long. Right Background to the Eleven,
- 13:252012. Yeah, it was a relative actively
- 13:27brief holding. They got in, took a closer look
- 13:29and got out fairly quickly. The strong implication is that
- 13:33Buffett and his team, after doing their homework, didn't see
- 13:37the kind of durable, predictable economic Moat they absolutely
- 13:40require for long term investment.
- 13:42Even back then, a decade ago, they likely saw underlying
- 13:45instability or competitive threats that made them
- 13:47uncomfortable. OK, not stable enough for
- 13:49Buffett. Then more recently, you have
- 13:52Seth Klarman at Bowpost Group. He's famous for his focus on
- 13:55margin of safety. Right Klarman is arguably the
- 13:58archetypal value investor focused on downside protection.
- 14:02Bowpost took a pretty big stake in Intel in late 2020.
- 14:05The bets seem to be on new leadership turning things
- 14:08around. But they didn't stick around
- 14:09either, no. Yeah, Over the next six
- 14:11quarters, they systematically sold off the entire position,
- 14:14finishing the exit in late 2022. And reports suggest they likely
- 14:18sold at a loss. Yeah, for an investor like
- 14:21Klarman to take a loss and completely exit implies A
- 14:25fundamental reassessment. It suggests that as the
- 14:28manufacturing delays continued and the turn around challenges
- 14:31became clearer, whatever margin of safety he initially saw
- 14:35completely evaporated. The execution risk became just
- 14:38too high. So when you see investors like
- 14:41Buffett and Klarman heading for the exits, it really highlights
- 14:43just how deep and persistent these business risks are for
- 14:47Intel, even with the recent positive Q3 results and all that
- 14:51external funding it's. A powerful cautionary tale for
- 14:53sure. OK, so let's try to wrap this
- 14:55up. Intel is clearly one heck of a
- 14:58complex situation right now, based on everything we've dug
- 15:01into our analysis lands where well.
- 15:03Putting it all together, we see Intel as really only a
- 15:06speculative buy and that's only for investors with a genuinely
- 15:10high tolerance for risk, a very long time horizon, think years,
- 15:13not quarters, and frankly a strong belief that management
- 15:17can actually pull off this incredibly difficult IDM, 2
- 15:20point O strategy against some pretty long odds.
- 15:23And for everyone else? For most investors, given the
- 15:25financial damage we discussed, the ongoing competitive threats
- 15:29and the execution uncertainty, it probably remains a hold at
- 15:32best right now. The next say two to three years
- 15:36are absolutely critical. They have to deliver on that
- 15:38aggressive technology road map. They have to land major high
- 15:41volume customers for the foundry business.
- 15:43If they stumble there, the financial pain could become much
- 15:46more permanent. Which leaves us with a final
- 15:48thought, maybe a key question for listeners to ponder going
- 15:51back to that external money. Yeah, The big question is this,
- 15:55does that $5 billion investment from NVIDIA really signal that
- 15:59Intel is now a truly viable long term foundry alternative?
- 16:04Or are the headwinds just too strong?
- 16:06You know, the relentless competition from AMD, the
- 16:08fundamental shift towards AR member architecture.
- 16:10Could those factors overwhelm Intel's efforts even with all
- 16:12the government support and strategic investment?
- 16:14A multi billion dollar question indeed.
- 16:18Only time and near flawless execution will tell.
- 16:22Now, if you're tracking these kinds of major market shifts and
- 16:24want a way to gauge the overall market temperature, you might
- 16:27check out the iOS app Buffett Indicator.
- 16:30You can search for it and download it from the Apple App
- 16:33Store. Right.
- 16:34Thanks for joining us and sharing your sources for this
- 16:36deep dive. Just a reminder, all this
- 16:38analysis is based on public information and it's purely for
- 16:41educational discussion. It's definitely not investment
- 16:44advice. Always do your own thorough
- 16:46research before making any investment decisions.