Latest / Sobering Stories / CAN YOU NAME THE CASE BEFORE I DO???
Transcript
- 0:00You know, and you have to understand LA was a very corrupt
- 0:02department back then. It was a real life LA,
- 0:05confidential, if you will. And so a lot of the cops were on
- 0:09the take. And dad had a lot of money and a
- 0:11lot of power and a lot of influence.
- 0:13And he was performing abortions for Police Department and the
- 0:17politicos of the day. And he was about to be arrested
- 0:21by the DA's office who had actually taken over the
- 0:24investigation. And we're literally days away
- 0:27from arresting him. And he splits, leaves the
- 0:29country. And they thought, well, wait a
- 0:31minute, he's in the wind, He's gone, he's left the country.
- 0:35Maybe it's best if we just lock this away for now and, you know,
- 0:40keep it under wraps. We'll come back to it.
- 0:41But let's clean up, dodge, get rid of all the corruption.
- 0:46If we if we expose this now, we won't be able to assume power
- 0:49and do what we want to do. Of course they were happy that
- 0:52he was gone in the sense that, you know, he could reveal a a
- 0:55hell of a lot about a hell of a lot of people.
- 0:58Raw or sobers, It's January of 1947.
- 1:02The city of Los Angeles is buzzing with energy, with hope,
- 1:07with New Year's resolutions, with the feeling of a new fresh
- 1:13start with the turn of the new year.
- 1:15A chance for you to work on all those things you've been saying
- 1:17you'd work on for the entirety of last year and probably the
- 1:20year before. But that would quickly fade away
- 1:23when Los Angeles would experience its most brutal and
- 1:27gruesome cold case ever documented.
- 1:29We're not exactly sure the events that took place between
- 1:32January 9th and January 15th. And we're not sure if maybe this
- 1:3722 year old waitress and aspiring actress was just
- 1:40walking home from work one day, suddenly hearing the sound of
- 1:44footsteps matching hers, getting closer and closer.
- 1:47But she's too scared to turn around, and she's too scared to
- 1:50run. But suddenly the footsteps stop,
- 1:53and before she can even realize it, she's scooped up and
- 1:56disappears into the fog of the night.
- 1:58Perhaps she was making her way to the local bar, or leaving the
- 2:02bar after hanging out with some friends.
- 2:04Maybe she bumped into a familiar face offering a ride, maybe just
- 2:08company, and then disappeared end of the night.
- 2:11Some have even speculated that she was offering St. side
- 2:14services, putting herself in one of the most risky and dangerous
- 2:17positions she could be in. But what we do know is that a
- 2:21female's body was found on January 15th in the Leimert Park
- 2:25area of Los Angeles in front of an empty lot, in a scene that's
- 2:29described as being so brutal, so gruesome, that even the most
- 2:34hardened police officers and detectives had to look away.
- 2:38Let's go. All right, OK, Happy Halloween.
- 2:59Welcome back to Sobering Stories with me, unnamed teddy bear.
- 3:03If this is your first time here, I really appreciate you joining
- 3:06me and trying to figure out what's even going on with this
- 3:10case. If you're a returning
- 3:12subscriber, Sub sobers. Before we dive in, I just wanted
- 3:15to give a huge shout out to Sean Atwood's channel for bringing me
- 3:19on as a special guest featuring me on their channel.
- 3:23They had me on doing a live stream conversation couple days
- 3:26ago. I felt like things went really
- 3:28well. We were talking about the Silent
- 3:30Children project, Anthony Bourdain, Chris Cornell, Chester
- 3:34Bennington, and Avicii, but I had a lot of fun talking with
- 3:36Ron. I feel like we talked about some
- 3:38really interesting points and I'll go ahead and link the video
- 3:41in the description of this video.
- 3:44If you haven't seen it, go check it out.
- 3:46We plan on doing future conversations, future collabs.
- 3:50They've already invited me back for November.
- 3:52So keep your eyes peeled for more of that.
- 3:55Check back every single day to see what's going on on the
- 3:59Sobering Stories YouTube page every day.
- 4:01And I'm going to try and get better about posting more shorts
- 4:04and giving you guys some more content so you have more of a
- 4:06reason to come back every day. But anyways, I really appreciate
- 4:10you guys and I just really want you to know that.
- 4:13And I really appreciate all of the folks that came over from
- 4:17the Sean Atwood channel and gave me a chance.
- 4:20That was super cool. But even more so, I want to give
- 4:23a huge shout out to all of the sobers that were in the comments
- 4:27just literally hyping me up so hard.
- 4:29I went through and read so many of those comments and I can't
- 4:34tell you how much love was in there and I am just truly
- 4:37grateful from the bottom of my heart for the love and support
- 4:40and just for hyping me up the way you guys do.
- 4:43Really, really appreciate you guys.
- 4:44I wanted to try something a little bit different this week.
- 4:48Well, first of all, because it's very rare that my episode
- 4:51actually lands on in an actual holiday, so it's landing on
- 4:56Halloween. So I figured I should do
- 4:58something cool, maybe a ghost story or I couldn't really
- 5:01figure it out. I was trying to do something
- 5:03that other people haven't really done before.
- 5:05And then I was just kind of divinely inspired and I had the
- 5:08idea to do a Halloween murder mystery mystery.
- 5:14So the whole mystery is also a mystery because you don't even
- 5:17know what it is. I'm sure there's some of you
- 5:19that have already figured out what it is.
- 5:21If that is you, make sure you've dropped it in the comments that
- 5:24you figured it out already. But if that's not you, drop it
- 5:28in the comments when you do finally figure it out, or if you
- 5:31think you've figured it out, and let me know exactly what it was
- 5:34that gave it away. This beautiful young lady was
- 5:36born on July 29th, 1924 in a small suburb of Boston, MA
- 5:42called Hyde Park. It was an area mostly filled
- 5:46with mill workers. Her mom was a bookkeeper and her
- 5:49dad was a retired Navy veteran who had taken a hard change of
- 5:54direction and started building miniature golf courses with his
- 5:58own business. Now, money was already tight for
- 6:00the family. They were eating canned beans
- 6:03and really rationing things. That was all leading up to the
- 6:06Great Depression. Things would take a real dark
- 6:08turn for the family once the Depression hit in 1929.
- 6:12Unfortunately, the business would collapse.
- 6:15There's not really a need for people to build miniature golf
- 6:18courses if there's nobody playing miniature golf because,
- 6:22well, they don't have money. Though things were tough, this
- 6:25young lady and her four sisters said that they came from a
- 6:28loving home, lots of laughter, where they had dreams of
- 6:32eventually doing something great and getting themselves out of
- 6:36the situation they were in. Which is what makes it even more
- 6:38tragic when a telegram arrives at the family's front door which
- 6:42says that their father's car was found unoccupied on the
- 6:45Charlestown Bridge. No note, no sign of him, and
- 6:49from what they could deduce, he either slipped into the Charles
- 6:51River or decided to go in himself.
- 6:54His body was never recovered. Mom burns this telegram up in
- 6:58the sink, never to speak his name again.
- 7:01The sisters all left without a father, heartbroken and sad with
- 7:05the thought that their dad just swept away in this Charles River
- 7:09a wound that would last for the rest of their lives.
- 7:12And unfortunately for this young lady, the first of many
- 7:15tragedies that would occur in her lifetime.
- 7:18Seven years later, at the age of 13, she's checking the mail and
- 7:23finds a postcard unmarked from California.
- 7:28And all it says is I couldn't face the war, but I didn't die.
- 7:32Immediately, her mom grabs this postcard, shreds it into a bunch
- 7:36of pieces and throws it in the sink and lights a bunch of those
- 7:40pieces on fire. Once her mom goes away, she
- 7:43grabs all those little pieces that are leftover and she pieces
- 7:46them all back together with tape and she holds on to it.
- 7:50This is hope. Her dad's still out there.
- 7:53Either that or somebody's playing some sort of sick game
- 7:55on her, because that's crazy. It's messed up.
- 7:57Days, months, years even go by before another communication is
- 8:01sent, this time an apology letter to the entire family, but
- 8:06especially to the mom for just completely bailing.
- 8:09He mentions he's working at the Mare Island Naval Shipyard, says
- 8:13that he has amazing regret and wants to make things right.
- 8:17Now you might expect the family to have said no, we don't want
- 8:21anything to do with you. But this young lady, at the age
- 8:24of 18 years old, sets off to Viejo, California to try and
- 8:28find her father. Her supposedly dead father.
- 8:32And I mean, if this dude can fake his death, then why can't
- 8:36any of the other people we talk about fake their deaths?
- 8:39This dude was just a dude, and he was a poor dude at that.
- 8:42Her main goal was to re spark and rekindle a relationship with
- 8:46her dad who she thought was dead.
- 8:48But she also had dreams of becoming an actress so getting
- 8:52her closer to Hollywood didn't seem like a bad thing.
- 8:55Now this young lady was absolutely stunning.
- 8:57She certainly had the looks to be an actress, but she did not
- 9:00have any talent in that industry, and she didn't have
- 9:04any connections either. So it's really hard to break
- 9:06into Hollywood when you don't have acting skills or
- 9:10connections to help get you some sort of role or get you in front
- 9:14of the right people. Rejection letters are piling up.
- 9:17Her hope of becoming an actress is slowly dwindling.
- 9:20She's working as a waitress at these dime a dozen diners,
- 9:24really not going anywhere and not seeing the success that she
- 9:28thought she was going to see. She had moved to California with
- 9:31such promise, such hope for the future, and yet all of those
- 9:36dreams were seeming to crumble around her.
- 9:38And to make things even worse, her relationship with her dad
- 9:42never improved. Things were distant and things
- 9:45got sour real fast to the point where she ended up moving out
- 9:49very quickly within the same year.
- 9:51So she hopped on a Greyhound bus, made her way down to Santa
- 9:54Barbara. While she was down there, she
- 9:56met a United States Army Sergeant.
- 9:58The two of them hit it off and ended up living together for a
- 10:01little while. But dude was abusive so she
- 10:04ended up leaving that relationship.
- 10:06Good for her. Unfortunately, that left her
- 10:07with nowhere to go. She was kind of a transient,
- 10:10staying in hotels and motels pretty much anywhere she could
- 10:14and she was also self medicating by drinking quite a bit.
- 10:17But that's until 1943 when she would get busted for underage
- 10:20drinking which would get her thrown in the slammer and
- 10:24unfortunately this would stay on her record.
- 10:25This theme of tragedy just seems to be following her each and
- 10:29every step of the way. So when she dealt with all this
- 10:32underage drinking stuff, she was looking for a fresh start and
- 10:35she decided to move to Miami, FL.
- 10:37While she was down there she met AUS Air Force officer and they
- 10:42eventually got engaged in 1945. But tragedy would strike again
- 10:47when she'd receive a letter saying that her fiance, soon to
- 10:51be husband, died in a tragic plane crash.
- 10:54She just can't catch a break. After about a year in Florida,
- 10:58things seem to be getting even worse.
- 11:00She ends up packing up her things, heading back to
- 11:03California. This time she heads down to San
- 11:06Diego. She's got some girlfriends down
- 11:08there and she links up with them while couch surfing with all of
- 11:11her friends. She is continuously letting them
- 11:14know. Like there's this boyfriend,
- 11:16this ex-boyfriend from back east.
- 11:19He has been stalking me and following me and the whole
- 11:22reason I came back to California was to get away from him.
- 11:25She was constantly looking over her shoulder.
- 11:28She seemed very freaked out, so much that it really bothered and
- 11:32worried all of her girlfriends. She stayed in San Diego with her
- 11:35friends for roughly a month, and while she was down there she
- 11:38ended up meeting a real smooth salesman.
- 11:41The two of them hit it off and I wouldn't say that they were
- 11:44necessarily dating, but it was definitely a situation ship.
- 11:47Unfortunately the guy was in fact married.
- 11:50After couch surfing for like a month, she'd pretty much worn
- 11:53out her welcome at her friends houses, so she was looking for a
- 11:58new place to go. Where is she going to stay?
- 12:00So she decided if she's going to continue pursuing her dreams,
- 12:03she should go back to LA. And everything's better in LA.
- 12:07And it just so happens that this new situation, ship, boyfriend,
- 12:12whoever this guy is, he actually lives in Los Angeles and he's
- 12:16going to be headed back from his business trip soon.
- 12:18And he offers to give her a ride.
- 12:20So on January 9th, he drives her from San Diego, CA back up to
- 12:25Los Angeles. He drops her off at the Biltmore
- 12:28Hotel where she says she's meeting up with her sister.
- 12:31This was all a lie. She wasn't meeting up with
- 12:32anybody, but that was just a nice place that he could drop
- 12:35her off, I guess. Now, here's a little fun fact
- 12:38for you guys, because I know that most of you, pretty much
- 12:42all of you guys love fun facts. He drops off on January 9th.
- 12:46The dude died January 9th in 1986.
- 12:51Might mean something, probably means nothing, but I thought it
- 12:54was interesting. Now of course at the time he
- 12:57didn't realize this, but this would be the last known
- 13:00documented sighting of this young lady for six days.
- 13:04On January 15th, a young mother with her daughter just out
- 13:08taking a stroll in the neighborhood, walking along
- 13:11Norton St. when she sees randomly A mannequin just laying
- 13:17in the grass along the sidewalk. As she gets closer and closer,
- 13:21she realizes that this mannequin is in two different pieces, the
- 13:24torso half and the leg half. As she gets even closer, she
- 13:29realizes this isn't a mannequin at all.
- 13:31This is a young woman who experienced clearly one of the
- 13:35most traumatic, unfortunate, brutal deaths that one could
- 13:39ever imagine. Also, I always forget to mention
- 13:42this, but if you guys do want to support the channel, if you want
- 13:46access to uncensored early released videos, then think
- 13:51about becoming a super sober member.
- 13:54Or you can join me on my Patreon where I usually upload videos as
- 13:59soon as I finish them. No edits, no censorship,
- 14:02nothing. And of course, that is a really
- 14:05good way to support the channel as well as me and my little
- 14:08family. Since I'm trying to make this a
- 14:11full time thing, I also upload on Spotify, Rumble, Apple
- 14:14Podcasts, pretty much anywhere you can get podcasts, so I'm out
- 14:19there. Despite this being a pretty high
- 14:22traffic area in the middle of a neighborhood with lots of
- 14:25possible witnesses, the killer decided to display this young
- 14:28girl's body, and we're not sure what it really means.
- 14:31Her arms were lifted above her head, both of them angled at
- 14:35about a 90° angle inwards, and her legs were placed about a
- 14:40foot and a half to two feet away from her and her legs were
- 14:43spread open. A game of Tic tac toe was carved
- 14:47into her body, as well as the initials BD.
- 14:50Her skin was pale pale white, and there was no blood in her
- 14:55body at all. No blood at all.
- 14:58None. No blood.
- 15:00There wasn't any blood. A wristwatch was found at the
- 15:04scene, and by at the scene they mean inside of her chest cavity.
- 15:08It was obvious that her hands and her legs had been tied
- 15:11together. Her underwear was stuffed into
- 15:13her mouth. Her head and face had been so
- 15:16brutally beaten. Her face was so brutally beaten
- 15:20that her head, her whole cranium, it was cracked like a
- 15:23spider web. The precision with which her
- 15:26body was bisected LED investigators to realize that
- 15:30this must be someone with extreme medical training because
- 15:33the technique that he used to do this was something that was
- 15:36being taught fairly recently during that time period.
- 15:40To most surgeons and medical professionals at the time, it's
- 15:44what's known as a hemicorporectomy.
- 15:47Hemicorporectomy. Hemicorporectomy.
- 15:52I think there were signs that she had been severely taken
- 15:55advantage of, essayed. And the weirdest part in my
- 16:00opinion was that when they did the autopsy, the only thing that
- 16:04they really found in her stomach was human poop.
- 16:09But unfortunately, guys, it gets worse.
- 16:13She had a tattoo of a rose and that tattoo was neatly sliced
- 16:19off and it was used as a tampon is I guess the best way I can
- 16:25say it and probably the piece that will give it away for most
- 16:28of you guys is the Glasgow grin that was carved into her cheeks.
- 16:33She had a three inch cut on one side and a 2 1/2 inch cut on the
- 16:37other side, going from the corners of her mouth all the way
- 16:41to her ears. And the brutality of this is bad
- 16:44enough, but at the time, reporters relied on listening to
- 16:48police scanner radios to figure out what the next story or where
- 16:51the next story was going to be. And because they were a lot
- 16:54closer to where this all happened, tons of reporters
- 16:58showed up before any police showed up.
- 17:00They trampled through this crime scene, destroying tons of
- 17:03evidence, and then they took some of the most graphic,
- 17:06terrifying photos that were then released and shown to the public
- 17:10in the newspaper. If you can believe that, police
- 17:13finally arrive and are doing their best to not throw up and
- 17:16begin the investigation. Just down the street, near one
- 17:20of those little gutter areas where the water goes in, a purse
- 17:24is found. They pick up the purse.
- 17:27They find some smaller items like a bus pass and some
- 17:30lipstick, but they don't find any wallet or identification of
- 17:34any kind. There's no money.
- 17:36There's really nothing in this purse.
- 17:37Luckily, because of her arrest for underage drinking in 1943,
- 17:41her fingerprints were in the system, so they were able to
- 17:44identify her from her fingerprints.
- 17:46But if they would have just waited until January 26th, they
- 17:49would have received a letter in the mail inside of which
- 17:53contained her birth certificate, Social Security card, her ID,
- 17:58tons of personal letters and notes, different, I don't know,
- 18:02things that she's planning on working on with her acting
- 18:04career, all kinds of different stuff.
- 18:06Unfortunately, this envelope, just like her body, was wiped
- 18:10clean using gasoline. So lifting any prints became
- 18:13very difficult. But they were able to lift a
- 18:17couple of partial prints. But because these cops
- 18:20apparently suck at their jobs, they sent it into the lab and
- 18:25something went wrong and these partial prints were destroyed
- 18:28and couldn't be used. But this investigation brought
- 18:31in the help of hundreds of officers from around California,
- 18:36the FBI, just tons of police were on this case.
- 18:39And the investigation obviously eventually led to the last
- 18:43person who was known to have seen her alive.
- 18:45And that would be this salesman that had brought her back from
- 18:49San Diego. His story is that he dropped her
- 18:51off at the Biltmore Hotel. Everything seemed fine.
- 18:55She seemed a little bit city jaded, like she was a little bit
- 18:58anxious, but she got out. She said she was meeting her
- 19:01sister and he felt fine about everything.
- 19:03And then he took off, headed back home to be with his wife.
- 19:07Now the cops think this dude is definitely involved, so they
- 19:10grill him for 12 plus hours. Things get physical and it
- 19:15eventually gets to the point where they asked him if he'll
- 19:17agree to do a lie detector test. He agrees, and though he's
- 19:21extremely drowsy from 12 plus hours of interrogation, he
- 19:25passes with flying colors. So he's released and the
- 19:29investigation continues, adding an extra layer of WTF to this
- 19:34thing. Six months after he's
- 19:36interrogated and released, this guy is found unresponsive in a
- 19:41bathtub at a motel, unfortunately by his own hand.
- 19:46Things with his marriage seemed like they were going to be fine,
- 19:48but he said he couldn't stand the intense guilt that he felt
- 19:52just having been the last person to see this young lady alive.
- 19:56The only reason we really know this is because there was a
- 19:59letter left behind. This letter was released to the
- 20:02public, but then the letter was completely destroyed, never to
- 20:06be seen again, which is a bit peculiar now.
- 20:09To this day, over 500 people have claimed responsibility for
- 20:14this horrific brutal. Attack.
- 20:18Obviously none of them were credible enough or believable at
- 20:21all, to the point where they still don't have a suspect.
- 20:24But there are two main suspects who have only gotten more
- 20:29suspicious as time has passed. The first of which was actually
- 20:33a bellhop from the Biltmore Hotel where she was last seen
- 20:36at. This bellhop was actually
- 20:38freshly released from prison for money laundering and some other,
- 20:43I don't know, white collar crime stuff.
- 20:44And he also had trained underneath a mortician as a
- 20:48mortician's assistant, so he would have had the necessary
- 20:51medical training to have bisected this young girl the way
- 20:56that he did. One of the most puzzling pieces
- 20:58of this investigation was the fact that there was no blood
- 21:01found. No blood whatsoever, which led
- 21:04investigators to believe that this was actually carried out at
- 21:09a second location. Where was the second location?
- 21:12Who really knows? Was it a private residence?
- 21:15Was it a public location? Was it some back alleyway?
- 21:18Well, police would catch a break when a motel owner actually
- 21:21realizes that one of their rooms is completely covered in blood
- 21:27and feces, which is a pretty good indication that these two
- 21:30things might be related. But the LAPD dismisses this
- 21:34information and says the two are not related.
- 21:37So that begs the question, what else happened that there's blood
- 21:41and poop all over this motel room?
- 21:43Like, if it didn't happen from that, what caused it?
- 21:47Another big lead for investigators actually came from
- 21:50that envelope that was mailed to the Los Angeles Examiner.
- 21:54Within this envelope, there was a notebook.
- 21:56And this notebook was actually a notebook.
- 21:58They came from a local club that was owned by a pretty well known
- 22:02Hollywood socialite nightclub owner.
- 22:05Now, this bellhop not only was working for this owner of the
- 22:09nightclub, he also was seen in the area of the Astor Motel
- 22:15around the same time period when this young lady had disappeared.
- 22:19This guy had also come in to the police station and offered up
- 22:23his assistance, basically just volunteering to do anything he
- 22:26could help with the case. But this dude's just a random
- 22:29bellhop at the hotel that she was staying at.
- 22:32What investment does he have in this case?
- 22:34So that was pretty suspicious. The one thing that really tipped
- 22:37them off and really zeroed them in on this guy as a main suspect
- 22:41was the fact that they had not released the information about
- 22:44the Rose tattoo being cut off of her and then put back inside of
- 22:49her. But this guy, this bellhop, was
- 22:52able to tell them that information.
- 22:54So how else would he know that information if he didn't have
- 22:57something to do with it? This bellhop was obviously
- 22:59elevated to #1 suspect because of this information, but they
- 23:04didn't have enough to actually put the charges on him because
- 23:08they didn't have any evidence. But then police receive another
- 23:11letter on January 26th of 1947. It's a handwritten letter
- 23:16instead of the little cut up newspaper clippings.
- 23:19And this letter basically says that is planning to turn himself
- 23:23in on the 29th of January. So the police are elated.
- 23:27They're like, I'm sick. We don't have to do anything.
- 23:29He's just going to turn himself in.
- 23:30So cops get ready. They set up this huge operation
- 23:33to take this guy into custody and he doesn't show.
- 23:37Days turn to weeks, weeks to months, months to years, and
- 23:41eventually the case, it goes cold.
- 23:44They don't have enough evidence to put this crime on literally
- 23:47anybody, but they have a massive list of suspects.
- 23:50They've taken in hundreds of thousands of tips.
- 23:53They've been given over 500 false confessions that they've
- 23:56had to sift through. And it just seems like no matter
- 23:59how much information comes in about this case, they still
- 24:03can't figure out who did this because of the precision of the
- 24:06cuts and just the way that this body was completely drained,
- 24:10this person had to have some medical knowledge.
- 24:13So the police start sifting through everyone in the Los
- 24:16Angeles area that is medically certified and would have
- 24:20received this kind of training. So doctors, surgeons,
- 24:24morticians, everybody, they subpoena all these different
- 24:27documents and then they start looking for any sort of
- 24:30connections to this young lady. Eventually they do come across a
- 24:35pretty decent connection and this guy is a very well known,
- 24:39very wealthy surgeon, known to mingle with the wealthy elites.
- 24:43He's a very well respected member of the Los Angeles
- 24:46community. What makes this doctor so
- 24:48interesting to police is that he is a venereal specialist.
- 24:53He has an IQ of 187. He's like a super genius and he
- 24:57obviously has the medical training and knowledge to carry
- 25:01something like this out. He also was either dating or
- 25:05friends with this young lady. He became one of LAPD's top
- 25:09suspects in 1949 after his daughter Tamar comes out and
- 25:15says that he was engaging in incest.
- 25:18He was experimenting with her with these different tools and
- 25:21devices and she claims that he abused her for most of her life
- 25:27as well as got her pregnant, which is so weird.
- 25:30She files official charges and in 1949 he's going through a
- 25:35trial for these charges and during that trial, his daughter
- 25:40claims that she overheard him talking about being responsible
- 25:44for this brutal, awful incident. Police immediately take this
- 25:49seriously and then begin to 0 in on this doctor.
- 25:53But it's not just his daughter that thinks this.
- 25:56His son as well also believes that he had something to do with
- 26:00this awful incident. The reason he believes this is
- 26:03he was eventually given after his father passed away, this
- 26:07little photo album of pictures he had.
- 26:10And in that photo album, he found two photos of this woman
- 26:14that looked so familiar he couldn't put his finger on it
- 26:18until he did. He realized it's the victim from
- 26:21our story. So why would his father have
- 26:24pictures of this young lady? Why did he have them in this
- 26:28special album? There were pictures of other
- 26:30young ladies in there as well. And there was no explanation
- 26:33ever given to him as to why these pictures were in here, who
- 26:36they were, what this means, nothing.
- 26:39But these photos led him to suspect his dad of being the
- 26:42killer. Police are also becoming
- 26:44convinced that this might be their prime suspect, so they
- 26:48decide to wiretap his house, hoping that maybe he'll let
- 26:51something slip while he's talking to a homie.
- 26:53And sure enough, he does. Eventually they have it recorded
- 26:57that he says even if I am this young girl's killer, they can't
- 27:02prove it now. He also goes on to talk about
- 27:04how he's been performing illegal abortions, and he also talks
- 27:10about paying off police for something, but they're not
- 27:12really sure what they. Had bugged the house right 18
- 27:16detectives 24/7 for six weeks they bug put live microphones in
- 27:21the walls ran a hard line to Hollywood station 4 miles away
- 27:26the station. I would work for 17 years in
- 27:28homicide when I grew up and they would sit there recording these
- 27:31recordings 24/7 around the clock for six weeks and.
- 27:35Then eerily they hear a woman who is talking conversing with
- 27:40him. Eventually they hear 2 screams.
- 27:46Eventually they hear two woman's.
- 27:49Eventually they hear 2 screams from this woman.
- 27:56They don't know who it is, but after these two screams, there
- 28:00is no female voices heard after that at all.
- 28:04And in a completely separate recording, this doctor also
- 28:08mentions that his secretary had died and the official report on
- 28:12that says that she chose to leave on her own accord.
- 28:16Many years later, this doctor's son, while doing his
- 28:19investigation, he comes to the conclusion that not only does he
- 28:23think that his dad was the killer of this young lady, but
- 28:27he was also involved with multiple other slayings.
- 28:31One in particular would be one that happened just a month after
- 28:36the young lady we're talking about.
- 28:38It happened on February 10th of 1947, Very similar
- 28:42circumstances, body dumped along the side of the road and on the
- 28:47body written in red lipstick was the words FU and then the
- 28:51letters BD, just like the carvings that were on our
- 28:57current victim's body. Now during his investigation, he
- 29:00decides that he's going to do a handwriting analysis because in
- 29:041947, the Los Angeles Examiner had received a handwritten note
- 29:10from the supposed killer. So he wanted to take that
- 29:15handwriting sample and compare it with some notes from a
- 29:18journal that he had gotten from his dad after his dad had passed
- 29:22away. He sends it off to an official
- 29:24handwriting expert, and they come back saying that the two
- 29:27handwritings are identical. Even more convincing is that the
- 29:31way that his dad writes his letter D, it's like overshooting
- 29:35the little bar going way around it.
- 29:38It's very Pacific, very unique, and it's not typically how
- 29:42people write their DS. But if we look at the D on this
- 29:46body written in lipstick, and then we look at the D in these
- 29:50letters, it's identical. Identical.
- 29:55The other piece that's fairly interesting about this is that
- 29:58his secretary also passed away within the same time period.
- 30:03So there's now three separate slayings that all seem to be
- 30:08connected through this doctor. This doctor's secretary would
- 30:12have been Privy to some very crucial information, very
- 30:15incriminating information. She was not only a witness in
- 30:18the 1949 incest case, but she was also Privy to some of the
- 30:22conversations that this doctor was having in which he
- 30:26implicated himself in this murder.
- 30:28Then, conveniently, she turns up unresponsive and it's ruled that
- 30:33she did this to herself. The same exact story as the
- 30:36salesman that brought our victim back from San Diego to LA.
- 30:40He also did this to himself and then our other suspect that we
- 30:45were talking about, the bellhop. He also in 1958, is found in a
- 30:51bathtub. Unfortunately, he had chosen to
- 30:54leave this world on his own terms.
- 30:57Did he do this out of guilt? Did he do this because he just
- 31:00couldn't handle it anymore, keeping this deep, dark secret?
- 31:03We may never know, but this suspected doctor's son is
- 31:07thoroughly convinced that his dad was the killer.
- 31:11And one of his biggest pieces of evidence to support that is that
- 31:15in 1950, his dad completely left the country.
- 31:19He lived in Puerto Rico for 40 years, not returning until 1990.
- 31:25He. Thinks they're on to him about
- 31:27that case. Absolutely.
- 31:28I mean, actually my mother had been interviewed a few days
- 31:30before and he left the country a few days later.
- 31:33Yeah, she goes, tells him, hey, the police have got photos of
- 31:36you and and the girl and stuff and that they mentioned they
- 31:39interviewed me and he splits. He leaves the country at that
- 31:42point he. Says that he was leaving to
- 31:44escape the bad reputation he had gotten from the incest trial
- 31:49because even though he was acquitted, that reputation is
- 31:53not going away. Couple that with the allegations
- 31:55of him being involved in this murder.
- 31:58Yeah, he doesn't have any reason to stay.
- 31:59But he blazes out, and not just out of the state, out of the
- 32:03country, which is pretty suspicious.
- 32:05After starting a new family and basically a new life as a
- 32:09physician in Puerto Rico, he returns in 1990 back to San
- 32:13Francisco. He's about 80 years old at this
- 32:16point. And then he eventually passes
- 32:19away at the ripe old age of 91 years old in San Francisco.
- 32:25And that's when his son is given all these things and the case
- 32:29starts to unravel a little bit. To this day, both the bellhop
- 32:33and this surgeon remain the number one and #2 suspects in
- 32:37the case. But unfortunately, the case has
- 32:40remained unsolved since 1947. But this doctor's son, with all
- 32:45this new information, this new motivation to see if his dad
- 32:48really was responsible for this, they decide to take a look at
- 32:52the soil in the backyard of the home that he would have lived in
- 32:56at the time. Not only did this home have a
- 32:58basement with a drain in it, think about that, but police
- 33:02canines were brought onto the property to sniff out any
- 33:06indication that human remains were ever there on the property.
- 33:10And the dogs indicate that there was in fact human remains at
- 33:14some point or currently at that property.
- 33:17And it isn't until a couple years later they're actually
- 33:20able to forensically analyze the soil to determine if there is
- 33:24proof there is human decomposed bodies in this soil.
- 33:30Basically, come to find out there is in fact proof that
- 33:35human Pacific decomposed remains were found on this property.
- 33:40Great work. That's fine.
- 33:42Buster indicated finding the scent of human remains in the
- 33:44alley behind the house. Now we know from cutting edge
- 33:47lab analysis of soil samples, Buster was right.
- 33:51Soil was actually came up positive for human remains and
- 33:54we know that because there are a number of human specific
- 33:57markers. This doctor was also known to
- 34:00have real close friendships and ties with the local Police
- 34:03Department because he ran around in elite circles and likely
- 34:07donated to the Police Department was at different functions where
- 34:11they were supporting the police. He was just buddy buddy with
- 34:14different officers on the force. In fact, the week of this young
- 34:18lady's disappearance he was seen at a party like a police get
- 34:22together party hanging out with all of these officers.
- 34:26So was there some sort of cover up involved, especially taking
- 34:29into consideration how poor this investigation was, how much
- 34:33evidence was tainted by all of the reporters coming in before
- 34:36the police made it? And they didn't even make the
- 34:38link between these three murders slash unalivings that happened
- 34:43within months of each other. And yet the evidence that they
- 34:47were linked seems pretty obvious and pretty clear.
- 34:50But I want to know what you guys think.
- 34:52I want to know if you figured out who we're talking about yet.
- 34:55And I also want to know, do you think it was the surgeon or do
- 34:58you think it was the bellhop? Or maybe it was somebody
- 35:01completely different outside of anyone we talked about?
- 35:04Drop it in the comments. At 78 years old, this is one of
- 35:09the oldest and most brutal cold cases in American history.
- 35:13And I think the reason that this case has never died, people have
- 35:17not lost interest in what happened is because they want to
- 35:20know who could be so deranged, so depraved, who could be such a
- 35:25monster to do the insane, unthinkable things that were
- 35:30done in not only the red lipstick murder, but also the
- 35:34murder of the Black Dahlia. Elizabeth Short.
- 35:38That's the stuff nightmares are made of, you guys, literally.
- 35:41But that's all I got for you guys this week.
- 35:43I really appreciate you guys chilling, hanging out with me.
- 35:46I look forward to doing this again with you guys next week
- 35:48for another one. But until then, I hope you guys
- 35:52sleep safe. I hope you stay sober.
- 35:55And remember, only you can prevent forest fires later
- 35:59Sobers.