Latest / Think Fast Talk Smart: Communication Techniques / 258. When Power Talks, People Walk: Why Leaders Don’t Hear What Matters Most
Transcript
- 0:03Matt Abrahams: Communication really works when people feel comfortable speaking up
- 0:08and knowing that they'll be listened to.
- 0:10I'm Matt Abrahams and I teach strategic communication at Stanford
- 0:13Graduate School of Business.
- 0:15Welcome to Think Fast Talk Smart, the podcast.
- 0:18Today I look forward to speaking with Megan Reitz.
- 0:20Megan is an associate fellow at the University of Oxford Business
- 0:24School and an adjunct professor of leadership and dialogue at Hult
- 0:27International Business School.
- 0:29Her work focuses on creating workplaces where all voices are heard
- 0:32and valued, especially in the face of employee activism and change.
- 0:37She has written several books, the most recent of which is "Speak Out, Listen Up".
- 0:41Welcome, Megan.
- 0:42I am really excited to learn from you today.
- 0:45Megan Reitz: Lovely to be here.
- 0:46I've been looking forward to this conversation.
- 0:49Matt Abrahams: Great.
- 0:49Shall we get started?
- 0:50Megan Reitz: Let's go.
- 0:51Matt Abrahams: In your work, you talk about our conversational habits.
- 0:55I'm curious what are these and why do we have them and can you
- 0:58share what your truth framework is?
- 1:01Megan Reitz: I can.
- 1:02So Matt, you and I and everybody listening right now have habits, lots of habits,
- 1:09but the habits I'm interested in are the habits that we have around when
- 1:13we speak up and when we stay silent.
- 1:16And also, definitely, the habits that we have around when we listen
- 1:22and who we listen to and what we listen to and when we don't.
- 1:27And those conversational habits, what we hear and what we say, they define
- 1:33our lives when you think about it.
- 1:35And they certainly define the lives of the people that are
- 1:37around us at work and also at home.
- 1:40Now, in a organizational settings, conversational habits
- 1:44define organizational success and our capacity to flourish.
- 1:48Ethical conduct depends on what we're able to say and what we aren't,
- 1:51and whether we're heard or not.
- 1:53Innovation depends on our capacity to speak up and challenge, and disrupt,
- 1:58and whether that is heard or not.
- 2:00And of course, our engagement and our ability to perform depends
- 2:04on a feeling that our opinion is valued and that we're respected.
- 2:08So that's the territory that I'm most interested in terms of our habits
- 2:13and what our habits mean, and of course, how we disrupt our habits.
- 2:16And in our research, we've asked thousands and thousands of
- 2:20people, why don't they speak up?
- 2:22So I'll just ask again, the people that are listening, think about something
- 2:25right now that you feel you could or should speak up about, but you haven't.
- 2:31And then think about why haven't you spoken up about them?
- 2:35And I've asked lots and lots of people that question and come up with what we
- 2:39call the TRUTH framework, which is five factors that affect our choice around
- 2:43whether we speak up or stay silent.
- 2:45And whether we choose to listen or not.
- 2:48And very briefly, the T stands for trust.
- 2:51So to speak up, I have to trust in the value of my opinion.
- 2:55And to listen, I have to trust the value of other people's opinions.
- 2:59R stands for risk.
- 3:01So when I'm speaking, I tend to think about what the consequences are and
- 3:06of course we can catastrophize about that, but we're often worried about
- 3:10our relationship, we're worried about being perceived negatively.
- 3:13If we are listening, we need to understand how those speaking to us experience risk.
- 3:20U stands for understanding.
- 3:22And it's understanding power and politics because speaking up and
- 3:25listening is political, a political act.
- 3:28The second T is for titles and labels, 'cause if there's one thing
- 3:32that affects what gets said and who gets heard, it's our construction of
- 3:36status and authority within a system.
- 3:39And the H is the how to.
- 3:41I, I may have something to say, but unless I have the words and the person and the
- 3:45time and the place, I'll stay silent.
- 3:48And similarly, I may want to invite other people to speak, but unless
- 3:52I know how to do that skillfully, I'm not gonna hear a thing.
- 3:55So that's the TRUTH framework.
- 3:57We really use it to help people to understand why they do what they do
- 4:00and how to disrupt it if they need to.
- 4:02Matt Abrahams: Everybody knows I love a good acronym and I want to dive deeper
- 4:06into it, but the broader point here, our willingness to share our opinions,
- 4:11to speak up, as you say, is inhibited and restricted due to a lot of things
- 4:18beyond our control, some in our control.
- 4:20And if we really want to be functional in an organization and in our relationships,
- 4:26we have to really work on this.
- 4:27And I appreciate you highlighting the problem.
- 4:30I'd like to dive into the truth, the whole truth, nothing but the truth.
- 4:33A couple things stand out to me that I'd love for you to just to dive deeper into.
- 4:37So you talk about understanding, you talk about titles and labels,
- 4:40so there's a political status, performative nature in this.
- 4:44I'd love for you to share a little bit more about how we can be
- 4:46sensitive to this, and what we can do when we feel that we are being
- 4:50restricted in our communication and not listened to, as a result of the
- 4:54politics and status that are at play.
- 4:57Megan Reitz: Yes.
- 4:57As I said, if there is one thing that affects the conversations that we have
- 5:01at work and outside of work, it's how we are busy constructing our status and
- 5:06authority in relation to other people.
- 5:08So a kind of practical way to think about this is, think about all the
- 5:11titles and labels that we throw around in an organizational system.
- 5:15So we've got things like hierarchy, of course, hierarchical labels.
- 5:20We have things like gender.
- 5:22We have things like expertise, department, the number of years you've been in an
- 5:28organization, we've got reputational labels, you name it, we label, it
- 5:33inside an organizational system.
- 5:35And depending on organizational culture, fascinating thing is that
- 5:39these labels and titles convey relative levels of status and authority.
- 5:44Depending on the context, so you can't really generalize about them.
- 5:48So I often in my work ask, people which titles and labels affect
- 5:53voice in your organization.
- 5:56For example, people might say, if you're in the executive management board,
- 6:00obviously everybody listens to you, but not if you are further down the hierarchy.
- 6:05Or they might say, if you are in commercial, you lucky person, you
- 6:10kind of rule, everybody listens to you, but if you're in HR, you have
- 6:14a more tricky time, or vice versa.
- 6:16Yeah, there, there isn't really any patterns here.
- 6:19So these titles and labels and our understanding of power, in particular
- 6:24help, not only when we're speaking up, but also really when we are listening up.
- 6:29So this brings me just to something that we have in our research
- 6:33called advantage blindness.
- 6:34So when we have the in inverted commas "right" labels in a system, in other
- 6:40words, the high status labels, we are actually very unlikely to notice the
- 6:46impact that they have on other people.
- 6:48If we have the wrong labels, or the underdog labels, the less
- 6:52status labels, it's actually really obvious to us the impact that has.
- 6:58And advantage blindness is the fact that when we're, I don't know, chief
- 7:02executive, and we come from commercial and we've been in the organization
- 7:06for 10 years and we have a good reputation, our experience is that we
- 7:10can speak up and everybody listens.
- 7:13And we tend to then assume that's everybody else's experience too.
- 7:17So what it means, particularly, as you go up the hierarchy, is you are very
- 7:21likely to overestimate the degree to which other people are speaking up around you.
- 7:26You'll probably overestimate as well how approachable you are, and you're
- 7:31almost certainly overestimating your listening skills as well.
- 7:34So this means that we can have this what I call an optimism bubble going
- 7:39on, and that's ever so important, particularly if you're in positions of
- 7:43power and your leaders and managers, and frankly, to do your job well, you
- 7:48need to hear what you need to hear.
- 7:51Matt Abrahams: I think you hit the nail on the head there
- 7:52with this notion of awareness.
- 7:54Everything I'm hearing you say certainly rings true, in terms of
- 7:58where you are in the hierarchy, your experience, your title, that all
- 8:02influences how much you perceive others listen to you and understand.
- 8:07And we carry that idea that others have that same experience, even though their
- 8:12rank status experience is different.
- 8:15So it's about awareness.
- 8:16So I'm curious, how do we build awareness?
- 8:19How do we burst that opportunity bubble and really leverage advantage blindness?
- 8:24What do we do?
- 8:26Megan Reitz: Yes, it's a good question.
- 8:27The first thing is that, as I said, power probably affects our
- 8:31conversations more than anything else, and wonderfully, ironically, if there
- 8:36is a conversation we are least likely to have at work, it's about power.
- 8:40It's this capacity to open up an understanding of how this is
- 8:44influencing our conversations at work in a way that sparks curiosity and
- 8:50interest as opposed to defensiveness.
- 8:52And a lot of my research is about doing exactly that.
- 8:55But I talk about three traps in particular, that people in positions
- 8:59of power need to be aware of.
- 9:00And the first trap is around knowing that you're probably more
- 9:04intimidating than you realize.
- 9:07So, as I said, we tend to think we're lovely and approachable, but
- 9:10because of the titles and labels we wear, actually, it's not so much.
- 9:15Our first article in Harvard Business Review, which is about probably nearly
- 9:1810 years ago now on this research was called "The Problem with Saying My Door
- 9:23Is Always Open." And it's not a problem to say that, it's a problem if you think
- 9:27anybody's actually gonna walk into your office and tell you what you need to hear.
- 9:30So first thing is just be aware of power and be aware about how those
- 9:36labels mean you might be intimidating.
- 9:39And then you need to put the other person at their ease.
- 9:41Choosing environments, choosing your moments, choosing your questions, we might
- 9:46come onto that, there's lots to say there.
- 9:48But how can you reduce the risk for the other person?
- 9:51The second trap is around echo chambers, essentially.
- 9:55So we often go to the same people for opinions and advice.
- 9:59Of course we do, because we trust them, but we need to question that list of
- 10:03people that we tend to go to all the time.
- 10:05And even more so, you know, cast our attention a little bit wider and ask
- 10:10ourselves, actually, who am I not hearing from right now that in order to be a
- 10:16brilliant manager, leader, whatever, I really need to know what they're thinking?
- 10:21So who aren't I including?
- 10:23An echo chamber is a very dangerous place for a leader to be, but it
- 10:27can be all too common, especially as you go up the hierarchy.
- 10:30And the third trap I refer to, very pragmatically, is
- 10:34the signals that we send.
- 10:37I, I often say we send what I call shut up signals rather than speak up signals.
- 10:42And I'll give you one example, and I'll use myself as an example here.
- 10:46I have this rather unfortunate habit, and maybe some of the people
- 10:50listening can relate to this, when I happen to be very thoughtful and
- 10:54interested in what somebody's saying, I can on occasion have, what is
- 10:58politely known as, a thinking face.
- 11:02And I frown and I can look a little bit intimidating, actually.
- 11:07And I know that that's one sort of signal.
- 11:10You know, another signal, a classic signal, is when we are meeting virtually.
- 11:15We can absolutely tell, can't we, who's doing their emails, trying to be subtle
- 11:20about them, but failing miserably.
- 11:21I don't know why we all think we can do our emails without anybody else noticing,
- 11:25but of course, it's always noticeable.
- 11:28And if you have somebody around you that is trying to build up the confidence
- 11:33to say something important, and then they look at you and you either
- 11:37look really intimidating or clearly, completely distracted by something else.
- 11:42Guess what?
- 11:43They're gonna stay silent.
- 11:44Knowing our signals, as Nancy Kleiner, past colleague of mine,
- 11:48beautifully said, know your face.
- 11:51Do you know what signals you are sending?
- 11:54Particularly, and I'll, let me underline this one, Matt, particularly
- 11:58when somebody has spoken up.
- 12:00And you know what, maybe they've not done it very well because
- 12:03they've been really nervous.
- 12:04The signals we send in the next couple of seconds determine whether
- 12:09that person's gonna speak up again.
- 12:11So that bit of self-awareness is utterly vital.
- 12:16And actually, we can train it.
- 12:18A lot of my research is on mindful leadership.
- 12:21I know we can train our attention, we can train our levels of self-awareness.
- 12:25We can also make sure that there are people around us that can dig us in the
- 12:28ribs at the right opportunity to make sure that we keep altering our habits and let
- 12:34us know about the impact that they have.
- 12:36Matt Abrahams: I really appreciate you identifying the traps that we all
- 12:40fall into that that really accentuate and bring, in some cases, adversity
- 12:45to our communication around the ideas of status and power and politics.
- 12:50So this idea that we are often perceived as more intimidating than we are.
- 12:54I have had that experience in my own life where people have told me, or I've
- 12:58learned that people find me intimidating and I feel that's not the case.
- 13:01The notion of echo chambers, who we're actually seeking information from.
- 13:05And then how we show up and what we show people.
- 13:08All of these can work against inviting others to speak up.
- 13:11I like the term of shut up signals, and it's important,
- 13:15again, that self-awareness.
- 13:16And it strikes me that having trusted others who can give you genuine feedback
- 13:21about how you're showing up and perhaps even digitally recording yourself and
- 13:25watching and seeing it would be two key ways to enhance your own self-awareness.
- 13:30I'm curious if the mindfulness work that you do fits into how we can
- 13:35better set up psychological safety and be present in those moments.
- 13:40Do you have some thoughts?
- 13:41I, I was curious about this mindful leadership idea
- 13:45that you mentioned earlier.
- 13:47Megan Reitz: I'll actually just get people listening to pause at that moment
- 13:50and notice their response to the word mindful and mindfulness, because it
- 13:57carries quite a lot of baggage, sometimes incredibly positive and sometimes less.
- 14:03And there's quite a lot of misunderstanding around what
- 14:05it means, similar actually, to the word psychological safety.
- 14:08I am interested in habit change, right?
- 14:11Now, to change your habits, you have to have the capacity, when you are
- 14:18about to do what you've always done, to notice that in the moment and
- 14:24then choose to do something else.
- 14:27So that is at the heart of all habit change.
- 14:30And we know from our research, from wide selection of research now, that it is
- 14:36possible with practice to train our brain to be more aware in that present moment.
- 14:44So to have that, what we might call metacognition, that notices our thoughts,
- 14:50our feelings, our sensations, our actions in the moment when we're doing it.
- 14:55And the research that we did, I did with Michael Chaskalson, examined
- 15:00whether we can train leaders in that.
- 15:02And our research found that with 10 minutes or more, preferably, practice
- 15:08a day with certain sorts of practices with the brain, you can indeed build
- 15:13that level of in the moment awareness.
- 15:15So that you open up actually a very small space where you can choose your
- 15:22response rather than being on autopilot.
- 15:26Now, we'll never do that all the time, but if we could do it just 10%
- 15:30more of the time, of course, that would have potentially quite profound
- 15:34impact on ourselves and on others.
- 15:37The very interesting thing is that we could argue that attention is the
- 15:41most valuable thing that we feasibly have, and nearly all of us don't train.
- 15:48How crazy is that if you ask me?
- 15:51Matt Abrahams: Absolutely.
- 15:51I really like the way you define mindfulness.
- 15:53I have been somebody who has been attempting to practice mindfulness
- 15:57for many years now, and a few things that you've mentioned that
- 16:00I think are critical is really, it's where you put that attention.
- 16:04And giving yourself that little bit of space to distance yourself from
- 16:08the interaction from the emotion you're feeling, from whatever, to then
- 16:11make a choice is really important.
- 16:13When I coach people who have extreme anxiety in speaking in front of
- 16:17others or communicating with others, a really powerful mindfulness
- 16:21tool is simply to say, this is me feeling nervous in this moment.
- 16:24And that distance that gives you that opportunity.
- 16:27And I can see as leaders or as people who are really trying to be in the
- 16:31moment, just reminding yourself, this is me doing this, gives you
- 16:35that perception and that opportunity.
- 16:38So I very much appreciate you highlighting the fact that we
- 16:41need to train that attention.
- 16:42What I have found in my own life is finding physical activities, help me
- 16:47train my attention, that I can then bring that learning into my interaction.
- 16:50So many people listening know I've done martial arts for a long time.
- 16:54Sometimes people do a sport, sometimes they play music,
- 16:57sometimes they walk in nature.
- 16:58All of those are ways of training your attention and you can then
- 17:01bring that to the communication and the interactions we have.
- 17:05You know, Megan, this has been a fascinating conversation.
- 17:07I think what you study is really interesting and really, really helpful.
- 17:12Before we end, I'd like to ask you three questions.
- 17:14One I make up just for you and the other two I've been asking
- 17:17everyone as long as this podcast has existed, are you up for that?
- 17:20Megan Reitz: Yes.
- 17:21Go for it, Matt.
- 17:22Matt Abrahams: So you had mentioned that one of the things you have become
- 17:25aware of is how you appear, your face if you will, in interactions.
- 17:31I'm curious, how did you learn about that in hopes that others can follow the
- 17:36process so we can learn how we come off?
- 17:38And what have you done to change that?
- 17:40Megan Reitz: Yeah, that's a lovely question and I'm grinning from ear to
- 17:43ear because do you know, I think 'cause there is an irony with this, okay.
- 17:47Because if you are in a position of power or you're a little bit intimidating,
- 17:52nobody's going to tell you that you've got a thinking face because they're too
- 17:55intimidated to tell you, and you are none the wiser, and so you can just stay in
- 17:59this beautiful bubble without a clue.
- 18:01And I do come across many people that discover it for the first time in an
- 18:04anonymous 360, and they go, what the hell?
- 18:07I would say that the person that really landed that
- 18:11feedback with me was my husband.
- 18:13I remember particularly, we were on a train journey and I can't, I think
- 18:17there was somebody in the carriage obviously that was either having a
- 18:20very loud conversation or behaving in a way that I didn't agree with, and I
- 18:23clearly had it written all over my face.
- 18:27And I remember my husband just saying, honestly, it's like a loud
- 18:31speaker coming from you at the moment.
- 18:33Do you know how much you are communicating?
- 18:35And so it got me quite interested and I think I have practiced
- 18:40mindfulness 25 years, I think.
- 18:43And as you will see videos of me in various places, goodness me, I
- 18:48don't get this right all of the time, but I'm better than I used to be.
- 18:51So, I do have a little bit of that awareness that just says,
- 18:55hang on, Megan, what are you doing with your face right now?
- 18:59And so I have built that practice through my husband and my mindfulness work.
- 19:04Matt Abrahams: So the take home message there is that trusted others can give
- 19:07us this feedback, and perhaps sometimes we have to solicit it to learn about it.
- 19:11And I can certainly tell you as somebody who has had the pleasure of being able to
- 19:14see you and not just listen to you, many of folks listen to this without watching
- 19:18the videos, I do not see that face at all.
- 19:20You have been very engaged, so well done on you.
- 19:23But the notion that we have to hear from others external to us, and
- 19:27then consciously work on it and give ourselves a little bit of grace that
- 19:30we're not gonna get it right every time.
- 19:31Megan Reitz: Absolutely.
- 19:32And a little bit of humor helps, a bit of lightness and curiosity helps rather
- 19:37than taking it all a bit too seriously.
- 19:39Matt Abrahams: Yes.
- 19:39A little dash of levity in all interactions can make things better.
- 19:43Question number two, who is a communicator that you admire and why?
- 19:48Megan Reitz: So there are so many people I could list here, but my mind went straight
- 19:52to my co-researcher and co-author, John Higgins, and I'll tell you why.
- 19:58Not only is he, he's absolutely superb communicator himself in terms of how he
- 20:03describes our research and advocates, but the reason why he comes straight
- 20:07to my mind as a amazing communicator is because of his capacity and
- 20:14skill in helping me to communicate.
- 20:17So when we walk, we have a practice where every couple of weeks we go for long walks
- 20:23together without a particular agenda.
- 20:26And John, through his capacity to utterly turn his attention to me, his
- 20:33curiosity and his amazing questions he helps me to then discover stuff that he
- 20:42then responds to, and then together we can create some really amazing things.
- 20:48So John is the person that comes to mind.
- 20:51Matt Abrahams: I love that you answered that question not because
- 20:54he's a good communicator, although you say he is, but that he brings
- 20:57out good communication in you.
- 21:00And what a treasure to have people like that in our lives.
- 21:03And I hope all of us can find people who can help us in that capacity.
- 21:07So my final question for you, what are the first three ingredients that go
- 21:12into a successful communication recipe?
- 21:15Megan Reitz: So I would say number one is genuine curiosity that requires our
- 21:23ability to turn our attention and also to something I call mutuality, to really
- 21:30see and value the other person in that.
- 21:34And to be honest, I don't think you can do that via techniques.
- 21:37I think that's something that's more of a kind of orientation and a value.
- 21:42The second thing in a recipe would be a, an understanding awareness and a
- 21:48deep fascination with power dynamics because of the way that that affects
- 21:55what gets said and who gets heard.
- 21:57And the third thing I would say is creating the space to have
- 22:02different sorts of conversation.
- 22:04Having the courage within systems that are tight and busy and in the doing
- 22:09mode, how do you create that space for yourself and others to have those really
- 22:16meaningful and important conversations.
- 22:18So those are my three ingredients.
- 22:21Matt Abrahams: I love them.
- 22:21Curiosity, I like this notion of mutuality, appreciation of the
- 22:26power and status that's at play in the moment, and then thinking about
- 22:29ways to allow for spaciousness so the connection can really occur.
- 22:34Megan, this has been a really insightful and fascinating
- 22:39conversation in so many ways.
- 22:41You've helped us understand the truth.
- 22:43I love the acronym T.R.U.T.H., and you really helped us think through
- 22:48how we can truly allow ourselves to speak up and speak out and help others.
- 22:54And I wish you well with your book, "Speak Out, Listen Up".
- 22:57Thank you so much for your time and for your insight.
- 23:00Megan Reitz: Thank you, Matt.
- 23:01I've really enjoyed it.
- 23:04Matt Abrahams: Thank you for joining us for another episode of
- 23:06Think Fast Talk Smart, the podcast.
- 23:09To learn more about psychological safety, listen to our episode 132
- 23:13with Amy Edmondson and to learn more about leadership, listen to
- 23:16episode 148 with Irv Grousbeck.
- 23:19This episode was produced by Katherine Reed, Ryan Campos, and me, Matt Abrahams.
- 23:24Our music is from Floyd Wonder.
- 23:25With special thanks to Podium Podcast Company.
- 23:28Please find us on YouTube and wherever you get your podcasts.
- 23:32Be sure to subscribe and rate us.
- 23:34Also follow us on LinkedIn, TikTok, and Instagram.
- 23:37And check out fastersmarter.io for deep dive videos, English language
- 23:41learning content, and our newsletter.
- 23:44Please consider our premium offering for extended Deep Thinks episodes,
- 23:48AMAs, Ask Matt Anything, and much more at fastersmarter.io/premium.